252536 � ������
OR161NAL TO CITY CL6RK
CITY OF ST. PAUL q�UNCIL NO.
� OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK
UNCIL RESOLUTION—GENERAL FORM
PRESENTED BY
COMMISSIONE ATF
R�SOLVED, Thm Mid�� eorporatio� be and hereby is granted
� pexmit to install m 41-�ar parkir�g lot on property lc�cated
on the southeast�sly corner of M�in and West �finth Streets,
more particularly describ�d as follows:
i�este=ly 1/2 of Lot 5, and Lot 6,
Block 4, Ric� and Irvine's Addition
to Sairit Paul=
all in accordanc� with plans d�ted Received �a�nary 25, 1971f
subject to the condition th�t amid applicant-permittee, and
its successors and �ssigns, shall make d�e co�apliance with �11
appli�able prcvisio�s of mtu�icipal ordinanceffi, state st�tntes
a�d rules axid regul�tions ot p�blic a�thorities haeing cogaizamce.
.
�
N
C
�
O
b U
t�.1 c
� o
b "
� �
� a
¢ o
U
� � �Eg 1 � 19.7�1
�
COUNCILMEN Adopted by the Counci� 19—
Yeas Nays �EB 1 � ��7�
Butler
Caxlson 19—
Levine
n Favor
Meredith
or
Sprafka � Against
Tedesco 2 0 19
Mr. President, McCarty PUBLISHED F
��
BOARD OF ZONING, CITY OF ST. PAUL �`�`�`��
1010 COMMERCE BUILDING • ST. PAUL,MINNESOTA 55101 • PHONE: 223-4151
January 26, 1971
Mr. Harry E. Marshall
City Clerk
Room 386 City Hal1
Dear Sir:
This is written in response to the application of Midas
Corporation for a permit to install a 41-car parking lot on
property located on the southeasterly corner of Main and West
Ninth Streets. This property is further described as:
Westerly 1/2 of Lot 5, and
Lot 6, Block 4, Rice and
Irvine's Addition.
This matter was before a public hearing of the Board of
Zoning on September 3, 1970, at which time the staff reported
that a different parking lot plan had already been approved
for this site. The matter was subsequently laid over
indefinitely in order to obtain a legal opinion from the
Corporation Counsel as to whether the Board could act on this
application in these circumstances and whether the appellant
can simply take over the formerly-approved p1an.
The matter again came before the Board of Zoning on
December 17, 1970, when it was laid over due to illness in
the family of the applicant.
This matter was heard again at the January 7, 1971, meeting
at which time the staff summarized the history of this case,
stating that the Corporation Counsel disclosed the opinion that
the Zoning Board may act on an application under these circumstances
but that a different party may not assume the authorization of a
permit granted to another party. The staff displayed the plan
submitted by the applicant which showed suggested revisions by
the staff to make it conform to standards. The staff indicated
that the suggested revisions have not been reviewed with the
applicant.
,,�� �
� „���
-1- �� `'� °�
(
O
Mr. Harry E. Marshall (continued) January 26, 1971
Mr. Michaelsen, representing the application, indicated
approval of the revisions.
The Board heard a motion to recommend approval of the
application subject to staff recommendations. The motion was
seconded and carried by a 5-0 vote.
Plans dated Received January 25, 1971, meet design
standards.
Very truly yours,
,
PETER J. IETTA
Secretary, Board of Zoning
PJM:gaf
PLR
Z. F. ��7018
-2-
� ' City of Sa#nt Paul, Minnesota
, APPLICATION FOR SPECIAL COUNCIL USE PERMIT
(Please print or type)
TO THE HONORABLE A�AYOR AND CITY (70UNCIL
yb the City Clerk
. City of Saint Paui, Minnesota
Application is hereb made to remodel or reconstruct an euisting
y install and operate a new (cross one out)
� FILLING STATION
No. of islands and pumps :
1
No. of tanks and capacity: ,
��� HN
� PARKING LOT for (customers) (employees) (private use) (pnblic use) (other)
(indicate type)
Capacity of parking lot ;�y,�,,,� gi,� g��
To be used in coanection with: �„��,,, �� � �� � � � �, � � �
� 1RISCEI�i.ANEOtiS:
' (indicate type such as Drive-ln Refreehment Stand, Used Car
Lot, Dry Cleaning Pick-up Station, Ice Vendor, etc.,)
Capacity of parking area:_T ��
*Location � y f� !� � � lla�
Legal Description : Lot Block Addition
�4 �! �� +�N � �►f a+!"� d �N a� la'!la�s A�i1�3�wt
Applicant's Name . � �
Home or Office Address: �� �� � � ���� ��� � � � ��
Phoae Number ; j���;j� � J U L � j,���
FOR✓BY TI� APPLICANT, �11Y YLANniNG 130Ahti
;�aunc P�wl► Miw�tot�
� ignature —7��� �
Address : �� j,�w �� �d�p,� � �Q!j
Phone No.: �� 9��
When completed: file three copies of tbis application forna and three priats o�
t8e preliminary lay-out pians of the proposed facility with the City Clerk,
Room 386, City Hall and Court House, Saint Paul, Minnesota
Z-3 6/11/56
*EXA�PLE: 1. S.E. corner of I�ain St. and First St.
2. South side of Main St. between First aad Second St.
ZONING FtLE '���
.t
_ , � ,� � �,� .
i J. SFE
e .. � MAa A{. A,. .,
s � ,� K�", .f_IN J. 4�� n b �K
, �>, f-. �S_f'' i:f R.
_ - .d',, i�6�6.i�t;1. �':+IC:�+tl
����,�'� ��' � ., �, -,���(,�-� ry �T ,� ��, a,�
rn�u.,J�.lN'J4±t! '"' " ' �_� :�, �_.L�i .;' ,R�".� p i'� . . N. Ri� P
�r�'! I. F'c;
� �o'>�+ri�l.ril �8G1 , , uES'<'�t�'�'Psi ���7`� 1'.'-""� CTN A S_� Er�
3'�� ���^y No3�, ^4 �'c3o6, hNS�� �euo4a B3'i���:
^3,� [;��� A. 'rl.,^ ,
�� ..
rt)�:�'.�Irl� ' �: 1� � ��� i��
� ! I F
. ''� "1[; Z. H�.�'lt�� Il
, r� ,_ i.r�r .
� , }' ; i� ,;��F1T'eTl:l ,lr� `;�J3 C''� � �
`>1-�j r,';.�;, E°ce :�,:zi i .i�_�� �
��
�' . �'ri1��� , '9i rtn��S��t a
,
:,.t
� �
. �, , r�a�, ,5 C,��-�r,�� ��Ciot� , ."�,��l:ic.�%. i��ii �o:
.t :� ��C�r T'�� icin� � �,t, ,.
i., �� r Dre ��eic�c�n;
� ,� y����;r !E*tf�.r. o� Sep+ : ���>� a� i��, 1�7�, xf . ,�rflin:< i ?�ic
';����c ,�,�� �:i ,��:�;1 e ,:�t.��:m 1�, a. �i p�,,,-ic:� n�, l.c�' �ie�cat���l �e�.� thc� ���,t�s_h—
� �r ��,- i�,� � ' ' t11 c �
�, � .�i-n� �i- c M�� z.7 ,�� �i Wc�s ^�%ri _n �' .��• .s -i r� ;,? . '�� � !
' � ;.�' 1 � �� � �c:.r:� 1?� �j is . '
[���s , r.i3° � /. of I,=,' � , <<;tc; L,oi� 6, , � :�-�k
l+� !'LG'c` <tii:! ��'VJ.TI•_ � .ti �,�C�it. i(:T'i.
-,u :�sk ' � qu���r.i �ns :
' . Whe� ��a-�r_ i_t���� ���r.d :'�•,xi��., �,i���r�ul� : _ _ c�r�
�,�7 - ���1_i.c��t i .�� for � �-�.r�t,r.ir, �� 1� :e �E�a �..� L
�.11'l,. UP.�' O�3 ;'}�'lE' S� ��;,'f �3'Cj3E t,�' �.+Ir��; �'+°,)�)t"E)V�.?CI
1)}11_ !laDL. i„i( � C�";? Q�j :'�11t
_' . ��}'l�`n }lt?�' ��jt� 1)i:'F'9CI'lt 'tj)p� �(`.ii�i�� e.�i11 �U`;t �.Ell�f
ov���- t,he p.�•���.�iousi�� ��n���°ovc � " �er�mit�
1 r i S c,t�.� un�ler�Y�:�ndirxs: i�11�� CE' �?:r31 �llt n Rr3f�1�� ��'i ii1C;. � ,
> ;
�� �-�ii:t:.c ci �� �e rmi� .:o �ns�..�a� � e 5�.���,- �,- �_�� lo� `'
� - �_ a� r_c!r Cus� = r������s aa.�!
� �F��]����t�F��, ��n th� �arop�rty> l.oeate�t�� c�n �he ���*re pr��e��er�y d� .,�•:.l,cd � ��
�` � raF;r�;�i� c�ne �f_ t..h�s ���t- �:r. (�ee t�tfi.a �h��? co;� oi r�su j ut ; �n �,i��.� � .l
2`
�'� � li 1� ��� �, �i,; �
1 - � �
.� ,.
.�
��r. N��!��n�� R. H�a r��n :� �ovemt���r 18, 1 ���;t�,
.I,�T"�Uc19'y' � ' ' ��.�7��� . Su}��;��c��,enti',�� I7n e'3C�: �"[1 WcIS C 1�C�`ti �)g7 �f r11'1"8L 1_it�;
,.�rj_+ �7t.1��1"� �21C:. � 1l(i� W��S' 'lI?�I LlC�tls�Tll L���r�F'T� �!e�' £3I��'�� (??8E: $ �:) �>�.'.?_�C� 'iL.��i
�i � ,'ii��'. iflr �7t .
.
�� � .,��p�.�. �,�T 3 � � `� 0� ��xe tktc� Iio. ��•d o£ �c: aa t��; m��� ' i i���;, tli�.
t�r; ;� ic (`�)7•R'()1'�� 1.0�1 :;'�I�ili�.�:1'.t ;� ei°1E.' 1�1Z1� ?.C.iiL ?;1 F�b��/e' ilUt:LC�o ,L `.311 I �'.'.:('�
�.� 1'f 1C1 '"�' `?�'T.'/?t. t-�S �:�1f? l;EN: c.:YS�'l�p.� l�� t.t3h� ;'i)��'7't�7 :10tC(i ct�;;�liE' �1Tc'jS .''"�Cj
:� n r.h;� �wne�-sti, ' a�� af r.�i� same ��r•�•c�.is ;f�:�/or c��-pc:ratior�s (Scl-►•�i '>,
� r��� . � :d ��ne Sch� � ��nger) ,
'�'he �;Cr���r il. e :.-�bli�g Sta'_9it� r � r:ing t^�, iicipaltt.ic�s t���
<;;ii.li�rity "�o ;:onn , M�.nr���sc"a St�Lii'.��a ��1 . 3_�7, Sut ,_l. 1, st �.�c:�; , it�
i-; � I f�.r�.rlt�. �;�I't o
`���nr the ��tr��oses �f ��.-am,��• � s�s� th�: jnablic
hQ�ril t.}�, .��:�t:f� :.•�� [n �r�] �; ,�Y�ca fyfraera� �,rc�l�are ,
<7 c�3;�a.i��i�:,'t!. ty �1j' !��}° c��cli ��ncf� rfy�,°�l��te. . , .
t;t�i� aise8 raf 'E�c�G. . .��r�cj rk� F�:;±�.ab.�. :h
st^�e��a�:ds ,���7,�� proc � ���-c�5 r� ,�ul�t�.in�; �;ueh u5��_; � ��
�I '�r ti1�t�l:t� ntg UL1��2't'ii1@ C711�'l:� �.11LE'!'�1��'.�7_P1`, Gt1�: 8�?i���'C? f�lIC/tE' ? �Ca�:llf r
�.L���l xl� ttle c�s�� c�f ��i,-.� v C:: e.:v at (.r ;tf�1 �� i r� D.�3� �fi7 N.t�:. ��'.
, . ......� �. �. � � a
�� :�, ��� ,�� ;196a� : _
"G��`hile our ��rt�r� c:nebiin� sta�u�e:� do not
�x-�ressl,� cc;Flfer u�.a�n rnuni� �pa�.�.tic� the
��w� Y tn �r��^.�°�d� .���. s�t�C; ��-LSc� p�: �°mi t�,
^uc'; pa�«���1• :�s cle4��ly �m�1 �it in �� �,�n.
cr.� . C;�,f?.:s �?� S�.s� :?. l . oe
� x1d�.� �.i� �� �trit�i� o�y ���ac�•, thc �ity of ;���nt i'����1 a�3opt� ��
( - �,i �1.�t� i � Coc�e � Ca0. 23 ��.,.�i w�iic�h �s�-�iz�� � �hed ��-t�cc�dur�,; ����.• the
. � ��ll� �; t � : ):� n��� ��3e�C�,EaI�.^l1Sa �,1@I'[ti3 6,:i .iOT �� i,}"�C�T?g ��i<�.'l. 1 :�.t1.C'�� , �I��11S
�a : �li.r���ni•� reac�s, � r� rc��:�v: rii: Qgi�.o
�°�b .': �"r :ti ?v, Fer���1�, �irtr�, f�r. co�n� r-at.i�n�
��h�`? 1 ��� r�b4i9'� , �t�f���-- +n, a1t- r, ;�r
()��:'xciL�. Z !�v>:�'�' t:il�ci"� g;'' ";�1T7r� P�' "'� :+.�
ii�°LG� Pc'i, ° 7.]'ld �'i i�i�;'_ �2t3 � �..O�C3
�a��c.,_r.- ofi' t���a��tv�on�� �'_'� �� or ,E�re
ve�ti�.�c�= . e a .3•?. '_�»���� f a •�,�: �,��ta ,i���s��
:1 �'�('.C.:�. 1.'� L�vE? '<�.- �1� t_�'.e i l '�Q'l' : r-��T�1-
��te C�� t��� (;fluticl 1 � 'Ckz�� ���-��:n_clt�rc� ��or
���E' ::�51:,3t1C8 U1 �_l1�.S S�'�'C'�'+ ?1� tT ;,, Pe2'[it�L
'�311 U�� a3 f��.? +,��as : �
�1`� F'i��i Qr�I.Lcatic�i� for �e��-1 pc�rmit
;:h�3.1 .;c�t f.or� i t?a� nat�-_ o�' the
��P�1ic;3nt , thc:� ?c�cati.on af L-t�e
��retn��,: s to Ue ��sed� a7 .i tite n:�� �� ,
�?�.tu�g� ay�� l�c;���:a c�n o� t I�e us� ,
�� � am:�, ��� �•���,�.,� �he pF���°1:i�g
� iacil:� ' y : I�all t�p sccc��:�or1�.
I he e� ,�l i, ��nt: �;Y�f��l sui ii t cop.: �
��: a �� �� �-i, �-drr���� ; � sc�:� ;��� :�i�owi��
;�� �� ,,1, �,�d ,, �, �f.
. �
,r , rJr, l�a . ; ,�. �?E �►E�n __ ;.. �;c�vern', _ ; �'�, ;� 7��
s fsE, ��xCl�Cl;.. �? t c?r:lr '�fl�' �.'eB:L"�� ?.i?E;
}?a �.i�;;E� . . . . .. ..
� ,�� iT7i:�1� 2.'E'C4 a _ iii� �7. iE'p'�Z° C3i.
s rlc� `'',=:,��3X�'+!� �s�� d'r_ ;�,-j_ � ���E? �'FS:ll�it;tl
:lE. j �O'f: :2� ;i r?'. ! `� '�'. t1C'3 '1 tl},.',. . . ��
T�'�•o,�i �� -F� ,�di�?��. c��. tk�a =��. s,����. _ nia� .t-�3 stat:�_!t E� and �;:-c�'_�i��nc�� �� �
. :�. . �
„ . , . � �.at
-i , �.� E'�1l _ , '��;�. _ c'����I ] �_ �!�C�[1 � �� ' e� ��� . s�7�5�.C�E,�'i �� �;c?j)�17L�:i_r ��7� :i �, ��.�:� .�.El
1�iT�i lG(it: i ��tl lE�?�li� 'r?� ...-1'i '13Y� �E.I3._ f1'."'lil'�'�C:: I?:ZL`:.�Lit�l7?�:' 1_�"lC 1.'�! ,!'_� (�i �Q;�
.t i°�'>�� f�i 1 f i� ;1 r(� �,�-�� '?/1 E a� � , d M �, a c � t :�
� ��ro� � a �snn= . �_ s �1ci zl 4 �-°;� ��otc ,i �t.��t t �
� �;iL'!' t � � �•, �..�'l�� ,`i�311'!07' 't1.�� �e.,0 � a� ��'s�.�? 1Ce�� _�i�:l�)�f �;t?e�1�:!.C9�7:_ �a t.Q t�:<
. • - - .
"? i�:;> i: ��11Ct! � j;cY'�n ^ �:: . 791 a_�cat�r :i�., �.�'`,;, ('�a„ ,i ' tQ �,_^ '^ 3i� f1�
L� '�t:'t "2;_C1Y.'':'si i �;;� __ ,:: xe��'�.E'. (� �.i?�:*I� �7 (?XE'x.�" "..�;J.a14� �c _._ �.11)t..�ii; 1L'•,% t
, p � � � ' l-
+ 'i�'[)d�'�;i " �'ll �:T'�1_11.' 1YO1sM_"i a����'+.'�'. 1.��) ., i?t.'A ,_ :�flC.�1 ,"1IJ��.1C.�_1° '..f;7i .
�Gtli' SE:�:.i.�1"](j t�t;�_�.'�}.d4X1 �.`� ., :�lt?X'C� ;?I'�.' s f3Yi.^� �C'c:'Ci 1±3 i:.i'.t' i1(.'P;`.1? Ly' �
�r�1 F3�,1� �s�na, y,-e'.',��: �Q� � r;, �:�1� �?:°��:F'aU2, :; 'C'�: �e� . �'1 1.II � i.,,7 t����
��.1_�� 1. �t� , 'ra '�,C3')�. � VaJm�� '; �� e
' 4l.1$. � � }'�t. P.�l�?�?_1Q1� ��1 �''31T1r'iti'�?t'E'ii :�Tl ��'12 y.f-1.ICTlf3r J:? 9 C'J�t.EI �.�`l': `
± ,l l cn���i r?; ��,_�.�� � �; ,����:=o� a E�efor: t�3r:� $o��:�i c�i' Gu. a g��, x�c.c� .:cE:�.ids Fj) s)T'Q)Va1
„ �- �1� � � - - �
����- �� �d�l� , , i �f' i Q��� l��)7'e"t;t"Ci'�.��C'�'�1 " r � o-z�a� , C�s �� ' 1?nf3�"CI r;��0 �CiTil.11 `7 tp �
���7 ! lf �1_E' �>i?�.'�;, .;�C't_j ..j�. ���'�'(�i F1e��.ia�a� ..111� ���.'� �,,1'�+�.�1Cg "1� �.�1'_� � '1�_�_
I �►,�1. °'.r ��� , ril �?�.�L�� I:a���.,��_ , �fl�.., t� .; r���� ���� c�xes� ;� :. the r- ,.� . .
i����L t:,� 1��� �� 3d
� ���:� � a. �� �� t�a2�:�. . . t�.�. `.;'?_ � F�,t��� ���a.i���� � :���►� xeqta� ��t� t:Y�at �:i�ic C:out�� � �
''(?I! ' �)C .:'�T�1. l �i i�1� Ci �.;1 C.f?`,.�t. � .� ��i��: Z`i�1C�.�.�{r�.'. 3 .�._�'bCi• ;i7"ill�:ll� t�
. ,- , q ' `
. � � - , �
'�LTl� la".� � L�`f��f� � �3�.�.V(� ,e „a(� �3 i?i.�- ...� i �, �E � ; �_�� � �'7'I� f.�� St.c3z.:_'S9 -L11 T"�. �_t .'.3I'lt
jD����r �
�er,�,- r �'Se' r ti , �� '�
�t � ���ia;� i,_ 1C' �'�..�fJ'1 �� S_;l�s. � : 2d C�i� C)�1 t:,a�iE?
�-��,' � 1.Ce1"� �'>. ^�1�1�.� `3� "'�c:G a ':� �7� �.` ;` �3.9Sc�, t,
C��" ri'c�J � . �.�,�$'� Fv� , t.�`, ._ Sty� 1 �3s`�: �(3 �� �lil"
�;�,? ��� i ';_ t:n�ar�,� , �v ^��: . � �.Y�.�tt� , t E�checi
t:.c� � �.�e� ;' ��• � °�,� n`' ��,�' �'� .�, :i t_ ��nci � i.�.h s? � 1 1
.er -t1 : ", � ��r,t��� " . <_�,�rr� -,� � : tzct �:> te� l.�
��l.)i 'fl'('t � . e6'�t� O�t !�i } �� -.�.ft. : . 53�� t.� ' <� �_L��I13 �. .
;; �,Q::iz ., . i �:�rr .. ra ., r. .•ill � ; ��:
<)t�tt ��.its��;I'd . �:t(� �:^ � � �,11:; �� i �OC�;��° . � , t:}t'
�i '(1.` 5�+� � i�:d L+�' 4..�) �.�1��.` �`�� �>� � Cif'1�..�a(�S! , s •Z�`P..LE;
��ti.. .R 4. . .. ' 4�� ...�. } l.,__ � u � L� 111� .
7 �, . !!� !; � ���1 ° ^ �- �12��.'
� � �'.�t i'. �' e�l"�3. �r1ET 'i ?:�'(;t'.� . � �t.`�'i .._..
:i�f.. �'j�,'7, � o' ._ �_��`�r� �, `�;'� !1 i� o� �.?.�.�' �.j .-I� �(j'��� .
�Ii1L1� � �i�, �;.}°'a� �."i���',;�v"�.1 �fi?.'il�i i.}�Q� �'l�? ��13?1F t:�.'rC'. T? �t o'}iGCt�� E`Ci
�
, itlC� r�1C' �y1�,11 � '_!�..i , Q��.C.�.Y^ `� �.() '��lC' '�SF`:."tI1a , vv'!:��.' 11`. L !+1r'w9 � '-1L' �.OLITIC' ! 1
ao '
`„ , �� . `, ,� � � � ..
:� . ,.
, . . � , / � , � �; � �.
/ , . ' ``� 4� � � �\�� \ / `�f \
� ��Y ,/�F' � _ \ � � r� "�_'\
� � � 5p \ - �-_ j_ ,� / ��•
\� • �'6 ..� _ �� � }--� .!� � `�
� - � 1 , � `'�
,
'`,� _ _ .;__ � ;
\ \ `-----� � \ � /
.� �� � ���� � ��
� U���
� �, , ' r ' � ;
' J' � � ^ �
� �'\\ ,� . . f i ..
' �.\\ `�... � "_'.�_., i '•..\
� �.��
' � r � ' � � � / �
. ,•'\ ''�`� 1 �Q � ,'-' /, �
i �.J ��1,�P1, / ` '�
� 5P / � �
�1� --
�� � � �
\ ' ' ,,a� '���,� ,,� � .,-
,\\ , , N���ry �: ;,-� ,.�:, �, ,
a , S
� � ��` � _ W N�_�, � ��
!_ ` F—: ,S�
:, . f
� ,, -: � ,
� � � ���� � :
��:., 'i• � �'� ' T'-'"-- ' � � '_ ., � "----- � F
.� , A � .,._�� �/_ � � � �,�• �
�" r , ,�' ,., "' < _
,�" / �� � � « '_. I' I ` `�
k
c� J t,� �
� '. . .. p �c _
��� V' �� t�,"` J� .. �Mi -
� 7 ���
�' 'l:VL� L�1 � ='j i
�� � � � t �� �_� --- , -
P ��� r� � �� � �; , �
�.
�� P�� � � �, �f�'�"c � � � c-�~�-;; =_����i_r�_ _
�P�' �-� - C t v � ..�_; _ C
v � c�F � --�._ C��
Z ; ��
�`•a � � ,
/�� ;_,
.:�� � � YC. � � �1i "~ _
_ `
`. _ � ��. �'�r '`----�._.. � i`�^ �,
�� ��. ��:..__.�� ,.. �, � � .;�. �-- �,�. .
_""--, �� � a `-� °" � -
� '��os •---1_ ��, ''� ,,` '```►�+
� �' ~ � �� W � +�' 1 ,
� ' , 8�t � � '`� `�" ,`' ,
� � � � � � Q �- ;�. � , �, � _
� � i .��
\� � , i ., , l �� . �``�-
. / 1 Y , �
APPLICANT Mldas Corporation L���N�
_.
PURPO�E Tnstall a 41-car parking lot LA�1D USG
Q ON E-F�{��I l�Y
PRESENT ZONING Commercial °{}' T1r!/0-F'AP�+!LY
PETITION SIGt�CRS �� Th�RE�:-F�R�il Y
� F�l1i,- F�,�'iILY
� Ml�LT6-Ft`�1�ILY
FILE No. ��18 �QRTa � � ��CO��ti����r�CIAL
INDl1S`��lAL
V VAC,�^.�!7'
St. P�ui Planr�i,�g Boa;d, Date: s/��,��o ��� �w�oR�r?y ►�nd�r cc���i��;ra�ic�n
I�LI.NTES OF �E �[JBLIC HEARIrtG P�FOitE THE P�vARD OF ZONZNG
ott �'huxsday, Segtember 3, 1970, at 2:00 PaM, -
\
phi.�CEN`I': Messrs. Ames, Doody, Gad�.er, McPartLin, and plansur of the Board,
� an�] �;r� Sar.en��n and r�lrs . I�r�n.tzen of the staff,
MIl?AS CORP'0[iATI�3N: �n app?.ication fa� a pern�it :o ans�al�. a 36-csr parking
lot on proper.ty lacated c�r the saut�a�asterLy corner of Main €�nd West Ninth
5��:eets.
Mr, Sorens�an sununa�-iz�d tlie s�a�� rep�rt, a part of the fi1e, st•at�.ng that
rx 34-car parking Lat -•��s appr.c�vecl f_ox L-his propLr€:yr and �h� a�joi�razng 40
fezt to the sou[h on .7anuar� 3�, 197U, �he �arking h�:� not been itistal?ed
zn accord�nce witlt t"ra.at permi?�. `Th� c�rigi�al suhanitted plans with theix
spplication did ��.ot meeL r��uired desi�n s�an�ards; r�viseci plz�r�� do no�
��UVi��e far hituminou� �urf�c�n� and wil.t require a,ttendaza� �pexation. Tne
s��ff fee�s the Zoning Bc�.�rd and City Coeancil mre being asked �o approve a
n��a permi�. to aileviate �:k�c. neces^zcy ef fclLowz��R angrov�c� plan.s. Tiae
gxoposed lot has less de:�;.ra�,�.e ��cter� �h�n tize o�ciginal app�aved one.
Th.e Traffic Engineer �oted that the dri�ae���ny th�t is existing shoiald Ue
rPloca�ed about 10 fe�t ��ie��. af the pres��.� xocation. Tt�e curb cut� in
place aflung M��n Stx:�e� sta��zl.d be elxmin�Led. Tl�e ,�ernsit drac,r�.azg is
poo�r, a�.d th.e exisa:in; sic�nw:�Ik ca�.dths ;3o noe conform to those s�:�wza an
ths� p�.ar�. The rada.us a� .:he inLers�c"iorc i� inacc�a���te. In respcnse to
a qi�estion Pir, Sax+�nson nc�teu t�aat C;aptain Anderson. was sent �oi.ice of
today`s public hearinb, but has nc�t z°€�plf.ec.t,
Icz co�c�.us�on, Mx�� Scsrd•:�.,on xiv�.:ed tha*r �he `�rai'�ic Eragineer h�� nat �pproved
th�.s fac�.tity. T�ie pAe�.*i�Qa�s ��r�rtii.i: h�xc� b�r_�F�-� d�,.7i�;n t:eate.ires �xn� �oas
�atisizin� al�. �he property--�izis one �.�a ct�.ly pa��tial parking witt� the rest
of 4�h;= �rea foz s�5��'iY"a�� `° th� sta£f fear_5 tiais soil? �:v�ntual�iy end up as
1iTiLOY�78:. parking. Tf this pia�. iU �p�ra�ed, standards wiZx tae rel�xed.
He r�c��:ed thaF� ifi ti�i� zs r�=_c�-s�:�m�nde�1 far apprc�vral, i� shoal.d be a�t�enda:i�-
Gp��8t�a, Etavc v�.i:uz��Inc��.c5 ��.:r��ci.n� with striping, b1x�+i�er fences �.iast�ad of
�ahe�Ist�g�s, t�;ain 5i�reet ruts sF�.oul.d b� closed and havFa ne�a curbing, an� the
cut on. Na.ntlz St,-�e� sho�xicl '°�p r�?UCa�ed �ccoadir¢, �o i:��e "Txaffic Et�gineer.
Mro Gadler asked :C` th�.s i.s on the stree� that cam�s off the �reeway, sa�d
Nr. Sorenson answered that i'�: is the str�et �hai- uI.timately leac�s �o the
freews�y.
Representin.g ttap ap�ll.ca�t eaa� ��r. G. �,> A4ichaelsPny l�x�esic�ent af Mid�s
�Corparation. I-Ie nQt+�d he didr�'t know a�e+ut t�ae a�prov�d pern�f.t since he
jus� �i?�s�d the pr�perty. x�Ir. :oren��±x not•ac' tha9� r_hr� �e�rm3.'t was ��Sproved
'�:ecter �hF, na�ie of �entxal Rac3t.�tor.
�.c�_
MiDAS CORPt�.2ATI�1 (9/�/70) (Coatiuued)
Mre Ames sta�ed that the prev�.ou� germit had bette�r fea�ures, aad shauld
be adhered to, Thati paxkiag Iati was nevex iastalled, hawevere Mro Ames
su�gested tha� the applicant woxk with the pl�iag staff on co�nplyiu�
x�ith the approved applicatiocz, aud tche s�aff caa repor� back to the
Zonia�g Board ��ethe� this r�ew app�ica�ia� can be raithdrawno
Mr, McP�rtlin maved for aa inde£ixcite Yayover of this �pplfcation9
su�ges��.ng tbat a legal apinio�t be obtafned froaa ehe Corporation Covxtsel
as to whether �he Zo�aix�g Bearcl �hould act on �his �ezmi� since one on th�
same �rope�ty was app�'o�ed lsaa� �tever in�stal.2�do Pethaps the app3icaut
can just tak� ouer the previa�s�y apgro�ed perm�.t, The motion was secanded
bg Mxo Gadlsr, and ca�"xied aaxAanimouslyo
Submi�eed by: Colc�.e�. Lo So�ez�sgsa P.o3�e�t L. Ames a Chaiz°maa
e�pe
. 1
..
�1INUT�S OF THE E�(TBLIC IiF�R�.adC Ii�:�(3R� `�� �t3R�}} OF Z�NII'�G
on `Thursd�y, Dec�m��ea° Z7, b970,, ae 2:00 �'oM�
PRESENT: Messrs. .Am�s, Daody, Gadl.er, a�ad Ru�z�c�� asf thc Boar�d; �'te:�srs. Brcowci,
Roset�er, Ry�n, and S�r��ison, F�1rs e Fxantz�n, and rirs o I�an�orowicz of.
eh� st�ff; and M�, Ite�e 51�rierc ai ttte �o�g�r�raticn. Ccztisnse�°s off�ce.
1�IiDAS CORPORATiON; An �pplica�3.on for � �e�x-f�it �o ic�s�all a 45-car parking lot
on p�o�aerty l.ocst�d oa �he s�utheaste;:�� c��rr.er of ;�faixt z�a�d West t3in�l1 Streets e
Tinis maeter was ff.rst heard at the Sep�:embPr 3, 1970, Board o£ Zonix�g meetingo
AC that time, it was laid over �nd�f�.nirely.
Mr. Rasette� aotec3 that the appii.can� txad reques�ed s further 1�yover because
his wife is in the hospit�3,
Mro Gadler mov�d for 8 Iayover of this m�t2:er ta tt�e Jan�zary 7, 1971, Board o£
Zoning meeti�ag. The mat£c�n was secanded b�r rir. R�tzicit, and earripd nnanimou.slya
S�abmitLed by: Przul Lo P.as��ter Robert L� Ames, Ch�irm��
.,
MINUTES OF THE PUBLIG HEARING BEFORE THE BOARD OF 20NZNG
on Thursday, January 7, 197i, gt 2:00 FaM,
PRESENT: Mrs. Cochrane, Mes�rs. Ames, Benshoof, McPartl3.n, and Mafetta
of the Board; and Messrsa �rown and Rosetter, Mr�, Frantzen,
and Mrs. Kantorowicz of the staff,
MIDAS CORPORATION: An application for a permit to install a 41-car parking
lot on property located on the southeasterly carner of Main and West Ninth
Streets.
This matter was laid over from the September 3, 1970, and December 17, 1970,
Board of Zoning meetings.
Mr, Rosetter su�narized the staff report, a part of the file, stating that
a 34-car parking Lot was apy�roved for the entire �rea covered by the
accompanying Iegal descripti�n on January 31Q 1970, 7'his applicatioa was
laid over by the Zoning Board in order to obtain a 1ega1 opiaion as to
whether the Board should act on an appiication involvic�g �he same aite as
a previously-approved permit and whether the pxesen� applicant could take
over the previously-approved pe�cmit. The Corporation Counsel disclosed
the opinion that ttae Zoniag �oard may act on an app�.ication under these
circumstancesa The Corporstion Counsel's Lctter aiso expressec3 the opinion
that each applicaat must forlow appZication procedures ands therefore, thia
applicant may not t1take over" the prev�ously-approved permit, Mr, RosetCer
presented the sfte plan to the Board, He noted it is staff policy to be
certain all land included in the legal descrf.ption is covered fn the plan.
Therefore, the staff has revised the submitted plan to include the entire
area for parking, making it conform to design standardse TExe building
awner nexC door for whom the previously no�-included part of this site
had been reserved for hi� pgrking, has expressed his approval of this
arrangemento
Upon a question by Mr, McPartlin, Mre Rosetter said ttie applicant has
experienced difficulty in gctting together with the staff £�x consulta�ion
on this parkin� lot sppl.icatione
Mro Go Eo Michaelsen, representing the applic�tion, noted he is wiiling to
cooperate fully with staff recoffin�ndations.
Sub3ect fio staf£ recommeadations, Mr, 1�Iaietta moved L-or approvs�. o£ tb.e
parking 2ot application. The motion wss second�d by Mro �3enshaof, and
carried unanimously,
Submitted by; Paul Lo Rosetter Robert La Ames, Chairman
_6_
� City Clerk
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
MINNESOTA
DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE
113 Court House 55102
January 15, 1971
File X936, Page
You are hereby notified that a public hearing will be held ia
the Council Chambers of the City Hall and Court House in the
City of St. Paul aC 10:00 a.m. on January 28, 1971 on the
applicatfon of the Midas Corporation for s permft to install
a 41-car parking lot on the property described as follows:
The Westerly 1/2 of Lot 5 and Lot 6, Block 4, Rice and Irvine's
Addition. The property is located on the Southeasterly corner
of Maia and West Ninth Streets.
For further information, contact the Planning $oard, Room 1010
Commerce Buildiag, or telephone 223-4151.
This notice of a public hearing has been senC out from the
Department of Finance in compliance with the City Charter.
ROSALIE L. BUTLEx
Cmznnissioner of Finance
O
- � �- �`�° �
� - zq- 7 �.
� � City of Saint Paul, l�innesota
APPLICATION FOR SPECIAL COUNCIL USE PERMIT c� ��ao
(Please print or type)
TO THE I�'ONORABLE bIAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL
� the City Clerk
City of Saint Paul, Minnesota
Application is hereb made to remodel or reconstruct an existing
y install and operate a new (cross one,out)
� FILLING STATION
No. of islands and pumps :
No. of tanks and capacity:
Public Use
� PARKING LOT for (customers) (employees) (private use) (public use) (other)
(indicate type)
Capacity of parking lot tr;rt� S;Y Cara
To be used in connection with: �nn+hrar nf mr 7ots '�Q feet to the south on 9th
� MISCELI,ANEOUS:
(indicate type such as Drive-in Refreshment Stand, Used Car
Lot, Dry Cleaning Pick-up Station, Ice Vendor, etc.)
Capacity of parking area: ��
—�. Cars
*Location g W Co'rner of gth and Main
Legal Description : Lot Block Addition
'�z of lot5 and 2/3 of lot 6 �3.ce and Irvines Addition
Applicant's Name
' Mid�sEC��ra�.�se°n Pres
Home or Office Address: 2403 I�ake E3aCe � Minrseapolis Minn 55�+05
Phone Number : Franklin 7-0306 .
FOR/BY THE APPLICANT,
" v' ' (signature) —���+i97�
Address . 2403 Lake �.ace� Minnespol3.s Minn 55405
Phone No.: Fr�� 7-(J106
When completed: file three copies of this applicatioa form and three prints of
the preliminary lay-out plans of the proposed facility with the City Clerk,
Room 386, City Hall and Court House, Saint Paul, Minnesota
Z-3 6/11/56
*EXAMPLE: 1. S.E. corner of Main St. and First St.
2. South side of Main St. between First and Second St.
September 3, 1970
December 17, 1970
301�RD OF ZONING REPORT AND ACTION January 7� 1971 nl�t Map ��4
. -�- . .�_,..�.
Acting under Legislative Code Chapter 60 thru 64
pasged August 22, 1922, ae �mended to Apz31 $, 1970. 7018
1� RP��LICAK'�''S PiAML , Midas Corporation 2169
� I—� 1192
i o Ci.,ASSIFIC::ITI�JN ; � Amandment CI Ap�eal CC°J Permit I� �ther g_936
3• P(JRPOSE , Inatall a 41-car parking lot
4 , LOCATION ; Southeasterly corner of Main and West Ninth Streets
5. LE(',AL DE�CRIPTIOii ; Westerly 1/2 of Lot 5, and Lot 6, B1ock 4,
Rice and Irvine's Addition.
o� P�tE5F,tJT i.�NIN„ Copanercial
% . ?URSUANT 't'� 7cn�n� Code Chapter: 60 Section: .23 Farac?raph: 4, 2
3 , S'1'AFF INV�STICATION � REP�RT; Date: 8/27/70 & 12/11/70 �y; CLS & PLR
A. HISTORY: A 34-car parking lot was approved for the entire area covered by the
accompanying 1ega1 description on 1/31/70. This application was laid over by
the Zoning Board in order to obtain a legal opinion as to whether the Board
should act on an application involving the same site as a previously-approved
permit and whether the present applicant could take over the previously-
approved permi.t.
B. CORPORATION COUNSEL: In a letter dated 11/18/70, the Corporation Counsel
disclosed the opinion that the Zoning Board may act on an application under
these circumstances, but advised that the Board apprise the City Council of
the fact that the previously-approved permit has not been exercised according
to agreement, and further that the Board may wish to recommend to the Council
that the previous peYtnit be revoked. Counsel's letter also expressed the
opinion that each applicant must follow application procedures and, therefore,
this applicant may not "take over" the previously-approved pe nnit.
C. AREA ZONING: Commercial.
D. DESIGN STANDARDS: PZans dated Received January 25, 1971, meet design standards.
E. FRONTAGE ANA AREA: The site has a frontage of 90 feet on West Ninth Street and
150 feet on Main Street, resulting in an area of 13,500 square feet.
F. TRAFFIC ENGINEER: The Traffic Engineer has viewed the plen and gives his
approval on the condition that the lot be serviced by an attendant.
_.. __ _._._
G. SITE CONDITIONS: The site is 1eve1 and at the grade of ad�oining streets. It
is presently-used for parking in a manner similar to that proposed, but the
southerly curb cut on Main Street remains open and accessible.
H. AREA CONDITIONS: Thie aite and the surrounding area is included in the Housing
and Redevelopment Authority's Seven Corners Redevelopment Area. It is also
included in the Planning Board'8 Central Business Dietrict-�Weatern Area report
which recommenda a medical complex for this site and the surrounding area.
9. BOARD ACTION: To RecouQnend �X Approval � Deniel
� Moved by ; Maietta Yeas Nays Council Letter
Dated:
Seconded by: Benshoof X Ames - Ch. 1/26/71
X Cochrane
X McPartlin Date of
Secretary'a Remarks: x Maiette
Mansur Hearing:
1/28/71
x Benshoof (Alt.) Council Action
Dooley (Alt.)
- Prifrel (Alt.)
Date
_ .
�- H... '� r �` .n�,ti •,. -:r^*�.� �r
��y..y a�,,.�+� ! ,d.y:�a. 4,y4 h . i'f°��'�rn `t:.T�},� 94 � � / _ - ,. , ., .... . .
. , �
�7 :' • �, .'.. y }..+ti �,� ,d�bc ..p ��t. Y . . . ��i�� . . _
. � �
..'_. _
, . . )
. : . ,
, . . . � n �.;. � . .. ,.r. � � , . ` . , .- , .
/t
,`�
.
. . . .. 1- . : •- - .. .: . � .. . _ ...
. �. , .
�. .. �� . . . - •,.�, - . � ... -, ,.�..n: ... _ . .:,. . . , .
.:.. . ., _ . ., . . .: . �.. . . .
, . .
, ..
, . .. , . ', s .... .. � . ., . ' . � 't
. ,. . � '� � � � .. . � .. . ' . . . .
.. . :�. .. � :.�.. .. . , . , . ..� . . ,
. .r---, �/ . , h 8
: _
� _ � .
. _
- � �c�bM �n� aa � - _ - ,
I ; . � N I1. SlX� .
. . _:
-, , � � -
. ; ,
1 ' � ,9z ,9/
� .:.
� ` , . , � , � , ; . — - ,
r _ w �
� :
� o N Z � � a .
� �
; � � � :� T
���
a �- o Q ¢ Q �
` � � � � o
; _ p Q � �,.� _ �
; _ o - J :o a �
. � ,
� ' � ` 4-- � � Z . �
-
_ . LL1 � � L� � � -
; � Z �,,i � �-�-
Y
� � ,� � d -J .
CL = Cp U d q '
, . . _ t,L1 � '
, _ - Ci u. O :
E-�-- � � � o a .
� _ , � �
. o� ,.
� Cl :t
_
, :.
O .
� � -�
, -. _
� _
i � .
, _ -
, .
� ,
_
� �
,
�
y , �j
, �
�
O > � �.
w �
� o � c �
:� .� z � Q �� z
�. — J � :d
� �
1 � - : . � � � _ - �
. I�_- � � �
l!� � tI�
, .
, �
� , : . � . :
�' Z . �
_
� � J ..� . � . . .. . . . . ; . ... � �. �.
� . . . . . � . ' � . . � . ..� � .
�. � .. . . . ' . . . . ' - . . . . . . . �. .. , .
. ' � . . . . � . . . � � , . . . . . . . . � .
� - W
�
� � _ ' . _ O
J
; . ' + , , �
. , W
�
' �: , . O �
" : , , � �
� 1�-
� v
. Z -
. - _ ,,,
� _ Q LL
" � :�
. �
_ Z %
, : Q
` �
_ -:� � � � � a
� � ,
v .
ca 4
� a
_ � -
. .
� . . � �
_ N '�
,.
.
_ - . :_
. - O
` O� _ .
! - , _ .