253945 Orislnal to City Clezk
� ORDINANCE 25�945
COUNCIL FILE NO
PRESENTED BY �� ORDINANCE NO �
An ordinance amending the Zoning Code,
Chapters 60 to 64, inclusive, of the
Saint Paul Legislative Code, pertaining
to Use Districts, I3eight Di�tricts and
Rezoning of crert�in properties in the
City of Saint Paul, as amended.
THE COUNCI� OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAiTL DOES DIt�ASN:
3ection 1. That the Zoning Code, Chapters 6� to 64,
inelusive, of the 3aint Paul Legislative Code, pertaining to
Use Districts, Hei�ht Districts and Rezoning of certain prop-
ertie� in the City of Saint Paul, as ataended, be and the same
ia hereby further amend�d so as to r�zone the following described
property from "C" Residence nis�trict to Commercial Diatrict,
to-wit: �
Pa�1.
Lot 2, Bloek 76, West St.�properp
situate on property located on the east side of Humboldt Avenue
between East Winifred and Ea�t Robie Streets in the City of
Sai�t Paul.
Section 2. Thi� ordinance shall take effect and be in
�orce thirty (30) days from and after its passage, approval
� and publieation.
. ' . -� .= i
����
�
��� � ���
�� �,�,z
.� ,
,�.;
# � � .�� _
�� � . � . ,
��: ��: _ ��;
, a, ����
� . � -
�+m �: � ��� f�:1� �;�rf.,�.�.,� . ...v•.�4: �
���.ao'�� -: " �; ; � ' i
' ����` .
���,, ;r�s�w�u � �>
Yeas Councilmen Nays Pasaed by the Council
MAY 21 1971
Butler
Carlson
Levine n Favor
Meredith C� � Against
Sprafka
Tecles�° MpY 21 1911
Mr. President (McCarty) Approv •
test:
ity Cler Mayor
��
Form approved Corpor�tion Counsel By
��tisr��n MAY 2 �19�
a+�.a r�
� ORDINAN � E
r
���� � No 25�9�5
'�, PRESENTFA BY `ORDINANCE NO
,
1 �lu ordinance a�eaedi.aq the Zoninq Code.
` Chagt.�rs 60 to 64, inclusive, of the
,'i Saiat Panl Legialative Code. pertaiainq
to t�s� Districts, Hefght �istric�ts a�d
� &ezouinq of eertair� properties ia ths
Cit�► og Saint Paul� aa aa�endocl.
'P8t QOi�IS. QF '1� CITY t}F' SAI�iT F1tA'. Dt3FS oli�I�t:
8sctioa 1. T2ut the �o�a� Coc't�, Chaptsts 60 to 64,
incluacive� of the Saint Paul I.eqislativQ Cod�, p�rtainisq to
II�e �iatriata, �eight Districts an�d xszaniaq of certs�t p�tp-
�rt�� iu the C�ty of Saiat Paul, as a�ad�d, be aad th� sa�e
ia hereby fnrth�er aaead�d so ase to r�son� ths fQllt�tiag �irarib�d
�ape=ty fsbm "C" Reaidencs Di.etrict to Com�rcial Dfst�cict,�
to-�rit:
l�tl
Lo� 3, slvck 76, 1�Ttat 8t.�psoger=
sitaato oa:proparty located on tha �t side of Hn�boltlt �►w6aue
b4t�sep 8ast W3;nifred and �iast �obie StreQta ia t&� City o!
! Sai�t Pan]..
,
Soction 2« �his ordinaa�e ahall take effact aad be in
l5or� thfrty {30) days fro�u aad aftar its pass�qs, appzorral
an�t pnbli�ation.
MpY Z 1 1911
Yeaa Councilmen Nays Pa�eed by► the Council
Butler
��OII n Favor
Levine
��i� � Aoainu�:
�. T��t a� MI1Y �� 1�i1
� ���') APProved:
Atteat:
City Clerk Mayor
�� Form ap�ro�d Co�qars�ian Couneel BY _ ._�
✓�� > � �//a
� � �
` ° � -��- �
• •� � CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA
.
` PETITION TO AMEND CHAPTERS 60 thru 64 OF THE LEGISLATIVE (ZONING) CODE
� Note: The signer should appraise himself of the uses permitted under the new classi-
fication before signing this petition. For further information about the
rezoning of property, call the Board of Zoning Office at 223-4151.
(Please type or print)
Date: �,� / l� l�/ 7 i
TO THE HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL
c/o the City Clerk, Room 386 City Hall
City of Saint Paul, Minnesota
Pursuant to Section 64.06 af the Legislative Code, we, the undersigned owners of
two-thirds of the several descriptions of real estate situated within 100 feet of
the real estate affected, hereby acquiesce; and we, the owners of 50%a or more of
the frontage to be reclassified, petition your Honorable Body to rezone the follow-
ing described property; (legal description and street address) �t 2 Block 76 West St.
Proper '
from C residential District to Commercial District, for the
purpose of installing, constructing and/or operating the following:
(describe briefly the proposed facility) Constructin� an addition to present fUneral home
located on Lot 1 Block 76 West St. Pa3t1 Proper (I�Sg Humboldt Ave)
RECORD OWNER 5IGNATURE LOT BLOCK ADDITION
Subject Property:
_ M ,�
� ` � " "- �e Ts3 - !o � .�T �f/ L �,�
m/►ws� !� la �I eY �-'� 3 0. t a,��s-�
J � S'a�o — G ��� ,,c
o.+�a �t�T� � � <o — V�'�.-°St.s/ !s r
��t�`,�.. Br� ��-- a e ..� > � ( cs7��Pg/�'L ,o �e
� -7-8
(� . /'1�tt -�a ld T L ��
-T" �l'� � �}' l� L-�. tr�� �� �� �Q�'6' ,�_z-°� _a- �
�
`- �
.�
u7 �
�� �
.�,r
'. ..,-� TY1
�y,^,; O
�-^ S!
^
. � � � � -
I J . 2, t7
_ � .,
{.
�
State of Minnesota (
County of Ramsey � ss � � �
�r�'D Nd r o� �: .L d iY'q being f irst duly sworn, deposes and states that he
is the person who circulated the within petition consisting of �' pages;
that the parties described above are the owners respectively of the lots placed
immediately following each name; that this petition was signed by each of said
owners in the presence of this affiant, and that the signatures above are the true
and correct signatures of each and all of the parties so described.
Subscribed and sworn to before me �
this j�j day of , � q 7/
� • ddress: ��� �, �(���
,[,�C� Telephone No. � yZ_���3
Notary Public, Ramsey County, Minn.
My commission expires Approved as to form 1/4/65
Office of the Corporation Counsel
FGI 1/5/65
ERIC G. DULKA -
Notary Public, Ramsey County, Minn�
My Commission Expires May 28, 1977.
�
. � City Clerk
386 City Hall
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
MINNESOTA
DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE
113 Court House 55102
April 9, 1971
File R1019, Page
You are hereby notified that a public hearing will be held in the
Council Chambers of the City Rall and Court House in the City of
St. Paul at 10:00 a.m. on April 22, 1971 on Che petition of Devlia,
Bradshaw and Hauge, Iac. to re�one from a "C" Residential District
to a d1Caaimercial" District the property described as folloas: Lot
2, Block 76, West St. Paul. The property is located on the $aet
side of �iutnboldt Ave. betweea Robie Street and vacated Winifred
S tree t.
l�or further infonmstion, contact the Plaaning Board, 8oan 1010
Ccmmerce Building, or telephone 223-4151.
To co�ly with the City Charter, the Department of Finaace ie
charged with informing you of this public hearing.
If you have any questions. it ia reco�mnended that you attend thia
public hearing to afford you the opportunity to make yaur vie�s,
both pro and cou, known to the City Council.
ROSALIS L. BUTLBR
Comaiesicmer of Pinance
O
� BOARD OF ZONING, CITY OF ST. PAUL
1010 COMMERCE BUILDING • ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA 55101 • PHONE: 223-4151
April 20, 1971
2���45
Mr. Harry E. Marshall
City Clerk
Room 386 City Hall
Dear Sir:
This is written in response to the petition of Leonard G. Lang
to rezone from "C" Residence to Commercial to construct an addition
to the present funeral home, property located on the east side of
Humboldt Avenue between East Winifred and East Robie Streets. This
property is further described as:
Lot 2, Block 76, West St. Paul Proper.
This matter was heard at the April 1, 1971, Board of Zoning
meeting. The staff summarized the staff report noting the lot
dimensions and area zoning. The staff inentioned considerations
both in favor and opposed to the rezoning. In favor is the fact
that it would be simply an extension of the Commercial district
immediately adjacent to this site, and could definitely not be
termed spot zoning. A possible consideration opposing the proposed
amendment is the fact that residential structures closely adjoin
the site.
Mr. Lang, the petitioner, noted that in the immediate block
there is only one "B" Residential lot. He said his funeral home
adjoining this site was built in 1929.
As the Board considered this matter, it was noted that the
existing funeral home has been there for some time. There was an
expression of concern that any parking lot built there would meet
design standards. With a motion to recommend approval, the feeling
was expressed that this proposal would not be a detriment to the
Wilder Residences or to St. Matthew's School which is across the
street. The motion was seconded and carried by a 5-0 vote.
Very truly yours
/ � L%�iC�����
�
✓��L'�;/�-�C .
�
PETER J. IET A
Secretary, Board of Zoning
�' �'���
PJM:ga f °"�. �°'J�
PLR (J (� �
V
Z. F. ��7131 Cj
� ' Harry E. Ma�shaQ ��'''' ��F� Albert E. Olson
' City Clerk and °� R %� Counci,l Recorder
Commissioner of Repistration � �� ^
� �e
�
�S% h'
OFFICE OF TNE CITY CLERK
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
BUREAU OF RECORDS
�86 City Hall
St.Paul,Minnesota 55102
�'. 5, 19'Tl
�ning Board
Commerce Bld�.
St. Paul
Gentlemen:
The City Oauncil today ref�rred to yau for recommendation the
attached petition to rezone Lot 2� Block 76� West St. Pa.ul�
located between Huarboldt and Gorms,n Aves. and south of vacated
Winifred St.� to Commercial District.
V�ry truly yours�
�
'C�ty erk
n� G
��_..s,_r.�,� `' .... ..,.Y a � -. . = .. �..I��� •- I
: �
�_' ,... .,� . .....-..e... , ........ .. _ .�#
�......_; ...
� � {�
��"( E�.�
��I�"Y E'L��� �y
,?;n} �2�t �.�.�'k [.1�,',j���ii
: ''�c -�
/�'��` � � S
�
. � y
� DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE
� CITY OF SAINT PAUL
MINNESOTA
I13 Court House,Sb102
ROSAUE L. BUTLER, Commissioner Phone:223-�4646
March 5, 1971
Ta the Co�acil
City of St. Paul
6entlese�:
I have check�d the attached petition of Devli�, Brads�iaw �
Hagae, Iac. , filed ia the matter of rezAaing,
Lot 2, Block 76, West St. Panl. The propertq i� located
betWeen $�boldt aad Gc�rsaa Avenues and sontli of vacated
iiinifred Street,
fro�a a Class "C" gesidestial District to a "Co�ercial" District,
sud fiad that said petiti0a is sufficient.
Yoars rery traly,
� Q�''Z�""`'`� � �CG ����
Roaslie L. Bntler
Cc�eissiomer af Finance
Re: X-1019
c.c. Hr. Axes
p. �. Seidea
�!!ra. B�Cler
Froatage: 100�:
Parcels l�ligible - 15 ; �
Parcels Sigaed - 15 or 100Z I r
�+�.......�. M
Needed - 10 er 66-2/3� - . - � v - �/ �� �
;
,`- ` . _-�,..f
�. �� if :i
�r�:. � �� � �f � 1�
, .''` �- ���1
�/5,��,}��'"�'tii�i;ti': ° :�;..
� ' _ `�. �"-'����ij�
�
^�O
BGARD OF ZONING REPORT AND ACTION April 1, 1971
- - "Lat '-1aP ��45
- Actin� under Legislative Code Chapter 60 thru 64 �� ��^_,__��+
passed Au�ust 22, 1922, as amended to January 27, 1971. I
7131 __
- � , . . . _ "!A'���,;. . Leonard G. Lang
_:.r.,;,'�;; '� ",'':a ; �';;; , �._X� Amendment � APpeal ❑ Pe�mit � Other
�
X-1019 I
,��
, Rezone from "C" Residence to Commercial to
,i-: �=�i: ,
construct an addition to present funeral home
� ' j"`i` ` i*' East side of Humboldt Avenue between
/1 East Winifred and East Robie Streets
� �. A.Fa�,A.,, U1,��.,�,..i fy��i-J.r .
Lot 2, Block 76, West St. Paul Proper
r "C" Residence
. ��.L,l,:. 1 . e��r1..AV11,
� ''.i:''> ,,'� ,''' ','onin� i�ode r:hapter: 64 Section: .06 Parat?raph:
���I'�: ;�` 7�;�'�;";"I�:,A'II�tJ & RE�'ORT; Date; 3/23/71 3y; ATB
A. SUFFICIENCY: The petition was declared sufficient by the Commissioner of Finance
on March 5, 1971, with the owners of 15 of a possible 15 (100%) tracts having
signed the petition.
i3. HISTORY: None for this property.
C. YROPOSF.D USE: The petitioner proposes to construct an addition to an exi5ting
funeral home.
D. FRONTAGE AND AREA: The property has a frontage of 50 feet alon�; Htimboldt Avenue
with a depth of 150 feet, resulting in an area of 7,500 square feet.
�. AREA ZONING: The area north on Wabasha and Humboldt is zoned Commercial. The
area to the east is zoned "C" Residence. "B" Residence is the predominant zoning
in the rest of the area.
F. COMPREHENSIVE PLAN: The Comprehensive Plan recommended that the Wilder Homes site
be expanded to include the adjoining properties.
G. SITE CONDITIONS : The site is vacant and level, terraced S-8 feet above the sloping
grade of Humboldt Avenue.
H. AREA CONDITIONS : Humboldt Avenue in the vicinity has approximately a 5% grade
sloping down from the south to the north. East of the site is the Wi.lder Homes,
and west across Humboldt Avenue is St. Matthew's Church and School. Nortli alon�
liumholdt Avenue and Wabasha Street is commercial development.
9. BOARD ACTION: To Recommend X� Approval � Denial Council Letter
Dated :
Moved by . Mansur Yeas Nays 4/20/71
X Ames - Ch. Date of
Seconded by: Mrs . Cochrane x Cochrane Hearing:
X McPex'tlin
Secretary's remarks: Maietta 4/22/71
x Mansur Council Action:
X Benshoof
llooley Date:
Prifrel
� Y �' � ==-�- - — =f; � � � � � Q O m � '�
�
� 0 � � _— -- v I � �] a �
..a
i � o u �
, O � � ----- l 1 `V ' � O1 � � �� Q -C
- o . � , o o ��� � o � ,�o � do o , c.� .F
,::
co,vsRE�s�' ,�Q' � ' C 0 N G R
� '
� � - � � � ¢ -- T �`' � �'" �
_ ° � , � � P� �, • 'c
- , � , y� . �
� — , -�- .��c' i
� -� -�-� �
¢ � � . � b � o - oo
� � a • a� �
� .
r �t aO • �dM�+��e�►4� � �! i `
vJ� /FRE,4 ;� vV �
� ~ a �C •
� - _
_ O , . �, �
_ � � v — 'q , '
� � lDE __� � • i �I G �
� O � 'P.S. � � �
�. . � 1 �Si �
� w�
� rr w .� � �� t
1�
�_ _----o- .�_ e _p _ 10 �-. � �
-_ - - o- .o.._ � ' � �_�,._ _ 5 t c�, - _ �
� �� -- _ �
O ° Q � � - ,
� � t� .;� � � � �;, ;v � - - � - -6 t
� . :F ��`. �o,� E � � . GEOR G E-.
0 - - - - o�.�' � '� O e p p �_ -9 O
- - � � 0 9 � � ;
— 9- � v - — u W � W W W v - � -
• �— -o- > ..�,- � p.s.q � �� >
� - .R cn � � _, ��t o � � o � � a -` -;
.. _ _ _ �
° sT���'�s � . E, STEVEN�
e� �. � � � � ' t �
AP�����N� Leonard G. Lang L�� °���
P������ Commercialmto�c��nstructcant� L�-"ed�iLJ �a��1��
addition to Pre ent funeral home
C) 0(UE-��N91LY
P�ESEfVT ZO�BfUG "�'" xe�iden��e -��- Tti^JO-�A��ILY
� THRE';- F,��r�lLY
PETITIOf�J SIG(VERS �' �f a possible 1.5 (100%) -� - FOl3R-FQlUfiLY
� AiiULT B- P°A��I L�'
FILE No. �1"31 _ niaRr�� � �nCO�"�Ifl��RCIAL '
� n INDUSTR6,4L
� ,
l,eA�:F�����1T �
St. Paul Plann�ng �oard, Date� 3/z���l � Pro��rtu �Rr,�ar ,.,,.,��a�..,..:,...
MII�PU°rES OF THE PUBLIC HEARIAiG BEF'ORE TfIE BQARA OF ZONING
on Thursday, April 1, 1971, at 2:00 P�M�
PRESEN°f: Mrso Cochrane, Messrso Ames, Benshoof, McPartlin, and
Ma�sur of the Bo�ard; and Messrs. Brown and Rosetter,
and Mrs, Frantzen of the staff.
LEONARD G� LANG: A petition to rezone from "C" Residence to Cvmmercial
to construct an addition to the pxesent funeral home, property Located
on the east side of Humboldt Avenue between East Winifred �nd Test
Robi.e 5treets.
Mr, Rosetter summarized the staff report, a part of the file, stating
Chat the property has � frontage of 50 feet along Iiumboldt Avenue with
a depth of 150 feet, resulting in an area of 7,500 square feete The
area north on Wabasha and �iumboldt is zoned Coa�ercfal, and the area
ta the east is zoned "�" Residence. ":i" Res�dence is the predorninant
zoning in the rest of ehe area. Mr, Rosetter presented pictures to the
Board. iie �.c�ted that �h�e Wilde� Residences is shown in the background.
In conclusion, Mr. Rosetter stated that ia favor of the proposal is the
fact ttaat i.t is an �xtenaion of the zaning i�ediately to the north of
the site and would �.ot be termecl "spor zoning"� Against the propos8l,
it could be s�id th�t � single-fsmily home zoned "B" �esidence adjoins
the subject property on the §auth. Also, some units of the Wilder
Reaidences would face �he rPar of the subject site.
The petitioner, Mr. Leon�rd G, T„sng, asked how large an area was Caken
fnto consideration when the sraff noted the predominant zoning w�s "B"
Reaidence. Mr, Rosetter said he meant several blocks west of the site�
Mr. Lang replied that in tne ic�edi.ate surrounding bloc�C there is only
one "'B" Residential lot.
Mr� A�iansur noted that the Devlin Funeral Home has been at that location
for abouC 40 years. Mro I,�ng confirmed that the structure was b�ilt �.n
1929. Mr. Mansur sa�.d he �eels this extension is needed and wa�1d not
be a det:riment to the Wilder Resid�nces or to Sto Matthew°s Schoal�
2herefore, he moved for approval of the peti�ian to r���neo
As a matter o� info�mati.on, Mrs, Cochrane asked if this wou�.d ctrtaform to
�auffer requirements, s�Lnce there is a single-fami�.y house d�.rectly s�c�tho
Mr. Ames r�eplied that sideyarcl requirements would have t� bp me�. .A
repres�ntative of the peti�ior� s�td there would be a d�iveway ax�c3 �
buffer strxp.
At this poir�t, Mrse Cochr�ne seconded the motion for approvaL, Tt��
motion cA�ried unsnimouslye
-5-
f
♦
LEONARD Go LANG (4/1/71) (Continued):
Mr� Ames noted that i� this sddition will eveatually need a parking
lot, plaas would have to be submitted; however, if the proposal is
merely for a building, he said that building plans could be presented
at a later Cime.
When the representative said it would have about e 15-car parking lot,
Mr., Ames suggested that the petitioner meet with the zoning staff to
facilitate an administrative parking Lot pextnit.
Submitted by: Paul L, Rosetter Robert La Ames, Chairman
-6-
��� 5
Is� 2nd -�
Laid over to
3rd and app �' —Adopted � �j
Yeas Nays as Nays
Butler utler
Carlson 2��94� arlson
Levine �evine
Meredi+h � ��eredith
Sprafka � ,T*5prafka / )
�J
Tedesco desco
Mr. President McCarFy �r. President McCarty
O