255320 . ' . , : Y ;: _K_ ,. :w • 5 .. ,
. �
. , .. , .,, . ,
* - -� , .:. �. r .
� � • - '-_�,
� �FINAL ORDER � �OUNCIL FILE NO
By
File No �
In the Matter of saM�Ilt� tlMt ��lt sa iiMr �rLiM t� il�E ittwt ftls
�rrir� �elrri ts i�a i�r�� aM i� 1� s� a�tYne w�d�e �I�Lsi�!� w�s� �i
lasii�a� Iw► o�r� trsLt t,���t�,
� ..
�.
under Preliminary Order i�i�w► approv� ���1
Intermediaiy Order approve� ,
A public hearing having been had upon the above improvement upon due notice, and the Council
having heard all persons, objections and recommendations relative thereto, and having fully considered
the same; therefore, be it
I�tESOLVED, By the Council of the City of St. Paul that the precise nature, extent and kind of im-
provement to be made by the said City is
�i s+�wsts�wat !� �iw�t w �M sl�Ys ot liM�st i�C tt+w �el� �w t�
3.#�in #w�s a�t � �o3,a� a� �r ws# i�i f� �s� ai L�■�Cal !�
�+�l�b af� i��wt, �i �+� �i aM ss�!lei�t �s+M si�rs�los �wr
�*
:W
and the Council hereby orders said improvement to be made.
" BESOLVED FURTHER, That the Commissioner of Public Works be and is hereby instructed and
directed to prepare plans and specifications for said improvement, and submit same to the Council for
approval; that upon said approval, the proper city officials are hereby authorized and directed to pro-
ceed with the making of said improvement in accordance therewith:
couivcir�x AU G 1 ? 1971
Adopted by the Council
Yeas ��„-, .-.. Nays
u� � �-cr�--,
CGN Wqy Approve
t�—_ '
MEREDITH
SF??A FKA Favor
T�DESCO /r r
McCART1( (� Aro��t
�UBLISHED AUG 2 1 197a
�� _.___
� , . ,..
� , _ Dist. No. 2�
� 9� �' ` ' B.S. Albert St. - Goodrich Ave. to Liacoln Ave. ^4 g9
� s _ 9 ��� �
OFFICE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF PUBLIC WORKS
REPORT TO COMMISSIONER OF FINANCE
July 12th. 19 71
To the Commissioner of Ftnance o� the City of St. Paul :
The Commissioner of Public Works, having had under consideration the preliminary
order of the Council known as Council File No. 254864 approved
July 8th. 19��,,,�_ relative to to reconstrLCtina the sidevalk on hoth
s�aps of Albert St. from Goodrich Ave. to Lincola Ane. and hv doin�_�11 other
work Which is necessarv and incidental to complete said imvrovement.
and havin9 investigated the matters and things referred to therein, hereby reports:
1 . The estimated cost thereof is $ 4.40 per lin. ft. for standard sidewalk
5 ft. vide and $5.30 per lin. ft. for standard sidewalk 6 ft. wide�
2. A plan, profile or sketch of said improvement is hereto attached and
made a part hereof.
3. Initiated by the Commissioner of Public Works X
4. Improvement is asked for upon petition X
�,� i>>er�
�� �
� � � � � �
� �J��J�� �,N. is oner of Pubi ic WorScs �
cf� '?i�4� Q'�'��i �
�� p���P '�,
S� � ��
F�� �
.� �
I �p � . . . - .. . . . . . .
JOHNSON, ESSLING. WILLIAMS AND ESSLING
: ATTORNEYS AND COUNSELORS AT LAW /���
(AN A890CIATION) � � (
SUITE 780 MINN680TA BUILDING J
SAINT PAUL. MINN. S!l101
J08HPH P. JOHN80N . . . . . p n (]�'7 � � CHARLEB H.WILLIAMB.JR. .
WILLIAM W. EBBLIN6 _ .. AUgUS{� G� ��7/ � . � PHONFi 22Q•0715 �
DAVID ESBLINO � . � . . ' � . � �
PHON6�S 224•4819 . �- �. � . � �� � . � �
�224•0778
Mrs. Rosalie L. Butler
Commissioner of Finance �
� City of Saint Paul
113 Court House
St. Paut , Minnesata SS102
Re: Fi1e S9468, Page t
Dear Mrs. Butler:
i am enclosing a copy of Notice which your department has mailed to me,
concerhing Che proposed sidewalk impravements on Albart Street from Goodrich -
to Lincoln Avenue,
Our hame is located at the Southwest corner of l.incoln and Albert. Our
address is 1404 Lincoln Avenue. Uur tot is a corner iot and there is
appraximately 150 feet of proposed sidewaik along the side of our property.
We object to the proposed improvement as being completely unnecessary and
excessively expensive. We offer the following suggestions:
l . The existing sidewalk is generally in good cond�tion. 1t
could be made tnto perfecC condition by simply resetting approximately
24 existing sidewalk blocks.
2. There is very little pedestrian travel on this walk and
if a new walk were to be constructed, or�e 13 x 24 inches wide woutd be
more than suffi,cient, as there are no entrances to 'homes on our side of
the street.
3, 7he cost estimate in your letter of July 30 indicates an
assessabte charge to us of approximateiy $600.00. For the reasons indicated
above, we feal `that the proposed improvemc:nt is unnecessary.
rs very trul
\ L,��¢y
� . _ �
- William W. Essling
WWE:vb
Enc.
�
_. �, .E >
... ;; ,� , . ; ,,. � , :, .� - :
�. ,� �;�� ., �. ;. ,.,�„�,o �� �r : � . ;;.� ;:'
� ��'°":"`�. � A �; . .. .. . t� �t �����t 2fx�x,, $R*�:.
� '� G G�Y �� . � . . �'�# x .''�'h'J�s #,A. �SJ y•
,
a. ,'
.
. - � . ._ - . ' . � .4ty 7�k -. � . .
�, _ .. _.: ' �_ �. .e
, c:;.�' r a=;i ^
� � '.
_ ♦ _ �
� �
. � r
�
� r :y _�,'t� {'+� Y �
, .
, � ,
�
�. � k . ,. . . . . . � .. �'.. ... -
' ;�,. . � 1TY C.� F � �l, It� T : �" �A1� �. �; �
, _ � . � � -� � ��
�v�9t�E�v�afJ7�'o
-; :. �
C��6'�`a��'�,��'::G�9�� t��' �1�1Ai��� , ` '.
111 Ca�-_,v HcD:no 551p'� .
,�cyl�' :3C1, �.''.3�� . ' '
W111iQti1 W«` ns1ld X'�ir�x''�;�7C�:� C„ I:';r,� �r,�; _
��'�t14 I.i,atra�ln ,A.ve�ai.�r�
s�, rAU�, z��.mr���,o�:z; �►axt��
�'i�la S9�SC�i�; �'��a 1
tlo��.ce �.s� he�reby givetx �a�at e-;,,� �:�»an.ciA aP tttc Ciky' �� �3iC+ ��ta� wil�. hp�d
� publi,� kac�ce�in� �.n th� Ca�..�F��.l (�h;�E��a�E.r�z o� t��� C�.�y H�X� a�c1 Cduxt; l�o�:s�
a� lO:Qp :�.et�. on t1u�;
u^�: �.7, �.K37 r c,�;. �:'bQ? a�°vi.n:zbil.ity �� �iz`�ic����-n�; c�ie:4i
��aQ�im�.nrtry Uxdc�x 2S�FCiCf4, ��;t,��ilLri ica"�.� �, 1t.�71, whi.�tx p�apo��:� ��
s-eccaee��xu�ct t[ic t�ic�cL•1�;�.1e on bo�ia n',.6��:€, o� Ali�a�g� S�xcet ��`oCd C�o��t�����.
.���,,^�ue +�a lLineola� Avc�.�� �n�1 Uy do;.F�E �11 c��hcr ��rk w�ti�t� l.ti �t�ac:c.,:, -=y
:�n� ire����=ca�z�1 9�ax cnrwf�l.�t� r,aic� iR�,>sc,vc��rnc�d:, cxccpt �at�cr�a i.t; ie dE;�:c��^f��,•.9
�t�xat �ucd �md a�a£ficicne �SC�a��'�c4 c�i<�^canllct� c�ci�t.
Tlac� �e�L'Amr��d co�s� therco� �.s ;r�..t.� �S�r �.ir�c.;�]! £aat &ca�c a at�n.d�a�r� n#,cl�i�r�i�,4c
a �'�.�� 4rse�v renei f5.3() por la.nc*.�:� S;e,at £or r9 a.�nrtdat�d a�dc��tal,k G k�^�:�: ��.u�c.
�.n a�c3clit q.a� tn ChU r�d3ove, c����'�;ece �,r��l bc: m:icle far t�xtxt� 'wrorl� wt��cli i.a a
pe�4:�ce��.�-r. bz�n�,t��D� �:a E:h� :4P3i�t�in� �,6n���rt:Y� rsuc'� ��� xrc�e romovra�, �mu���
r:u�r��.��c� ��^:,aovnl, clr�ve_�se�e .�aic� t3eXC�i�9e:eta+al ��xdth o� Wa1{tc�`, bttfa�*r� rssr i:h�
ar.�.�a<��. ci�i�v���.!: co�a�rar_t: Zax�r,�^: mjs .��.�c� i.n s��l►e ll��»tc4:tnec�� o£ �'cx9��.ic ti7t�xftn.
I¢ ;ntx e�yi�:ka uc4;�i�ed �.nfor�7i�H:�.e,zz r���;:�rd�►�r; th�n prop0�o� �.mprOv�rn�nt, yor�
�:x� �.rde�;�;,�1 �� g::^�t ori�ix �Ez� t:ech�i�.c�1 �aciv3.�:csr� �r�1 Che Couticil (:Y��x=,i':�es�a ��
�): "3� °.'o �t1:f�C) u.rra. ;t�€ ., �::�e� e!rzj� .3{i �,hc: k�eR�r�.n�;. Xou m.:�y �.lso talc����oz� .
;
223-�a2�5 �or cc�z-�:;a,:�t�c&:�,�>re f�ai:or.r,,:::in.atx ox ?_23-y2/+1 fax' nu�:��c��.n��� iea' orr�;?:$.n,:�.
'tt�L*► �>rc��c::szd i.r�pr.e�vc�a��r�t sa:.�,*. in�.����r�d by n l,eti�ion �iled by thC prop�z���i
oFiytc�'� �n tta�: L�a;ax�r��m�s�ze�: of PRal�l�c L]or6cc7.
�'o cornp�� �:����:1� �:�;e �:f�:y �i�.nr�:cr, �tic �3c�rartrncnt o� 1?inunce 1e+ ct�a.r�;ed w�.�t►
�nf�irm�.�a�; �aE.� c�i: �paila public Itet�x'in�,. '
�� ycu hrruc� <�ny c�uc3�3,on�, �t is rc:comsr.c*.r�d�c� Chnt yau �ttt�nd �hxo puis],i�
}ac�ar�r��; �o a��agct yaa L�iU o�po�Cutl�.ty to m�;:e your vf.ew�, �o�ti �yxv anc� ea:t,
:��
k:�.��an Y:cs rda�� C.:+.�:;� C:ot7.�acfa..
i
;:'i
Lf(y:�,l�e�..I�`. X.. {3lI'CI.C:'�
�;omini.e��ionar o� ri,�n�ncc�
��i..Y ' � . . . � . . �
._.-:` . . . . . .
''r..�. � . . .
, ' • ���i'�'/ . � . .:.� .
, . . . � .. ,... . ..��.. . .... F ... . � � �
� �
���--��.��
Au�ust 17, ].97�.
Hon. Roger �. Cr���,
�o�ssr. c�f PublAc �;�rl�.
�ax Sir:
Attac�d �'c��° � i�f�a�.t�.c3ra �.s� �, capv e�i` a lett�r
n�' �di7.�.3.a�a�� w'. �s:��.:i..� ���°i:��..��..-�� to �"5.za.a"9. C}�� C. i'. 255�'��
� thQ matt�:� m�' re�an��ru��ir� �t�a�: ��.c�rrr�,,.�. c�xi. ba�3a� ��r�z� r�f
1�.�3+'�'�`�. +:'u• :L"7C�L` d,"C(5�ti.'�3."v.'d� �i�'E:. �;�' �:.:"J.�"�9'�1 �'iiF�°.� 1�.').C�.��m s'. �}.
y��y �r� �e � ,°r w��r,,�..
'"t'�`Y'� �.�'�:.�i./�Y;:d.i. L^6A.�y�.` i.'�' .�,i.,,.i'j..i.s
�ti l`+»�}I v1�.d� �"6�1�:i��J�
�id.4y v��`V'.F.`J:�
�
�
^ ' ` DEPABIMEI�T OF FINANCE
� �iE:�iO
r '
DATE: August 9, 1971
T�� A1 Olson - City Clerk's office
FROM: Commissioner Rosalie L. Butler
COMh1ENT: We are attaching hereto letter from
William W. Essling concerning proposed sidewalk im-
provements on Albert Street from Goodrich to
Lincoln Avenue.
Will you please see that this is read
at the August 17, 1971 hearing.