Loading...
258861 OR161NAL TO CITY CL6RK 258 8 s1 � t CITY OF ST. PAUL HOENCIL NO. ' *` OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK � ` ' COU IL OLUTIO ENERAL FORM PRESENTED BY COMMISSIONE � AT� RESOLVED, That Mary-Casey Realty Corporation .be and hereby is granted a permit to install a 48-car parking lot for use in conjunction with a =estaurant on the north side of Ford Parkway between Cretin Avenue and Mt. Curve Boule- vard, more particularly described as follows: Lots 22-26, Block 7, St. Catherine Park Addition; all in accordance with plans dated Received February 11, 19'72; subject to the condition that applicant meet all the design standards; further subject to the condition that a 6-foot high screen board fen¢� be constructed at the alley line of the prop- erty, said fenae �to be constructed within 60 days of the date of the resolution approving the application; and further subject to the condition that said applicant-permittee, and its successors � � and assigns, shall make due coaipliance with all applrcable pro- C] �'`� visfons of municipal ordinances, state statutes and rules and � ` a regulations of public authorities having cognizance. � � � MAY 31 1972 � COUNCILMEN Adopted by the Counci� 19— Yeas Naya Butler JUN 1 �� � .�Y—� 1s— �� ,!ln Favor Meredith ' Sprafka Tedesco A E'�inst • Mr. President, McCarty PUBLiSHED JUN 101972 °�� , � ' S . . � . � � w � ' BOARD flF ZONING, CITY OF ST. PAUL 1010 COMMERCE BUILDING • ST. PAUL,MINNESOTA 55101 • PHONE: 223-4151 May 1, 1972 ti���86 � Mr. Harry E. Marshall City Clerk Room 386, City Hall St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 Dear Sir: This is written in response to the application of Mary-Casey Realty Corporation for a permit to install a 48-car parking lot for use in conjunction with a restaurant on the north side of Ford Parkway be- tween Cretin and Mt. Curve Boulevard. This property is further described as Lots 22-26, Block 7, St. Catherine Park Addition. This matter was heard by the Board of Zoning at their April 6, 1972, public hearing, at which time the staff report on file wasread. Noting that the striping existing on the parking lot is different from that shown on the plan, the staff said that the plan meets design standards but it is not known whether or not the existing layout is adequate. A copy of a letter from a resident north of the subject site was read. This letter concerned itself with another parking area owned by the appli- cant located across the alley north of the subject site on property zoned "B" Residential. It complained that this facility was not being maintained and requested that the zoning laws be enforced regarding it. The staff pointed out that even though this area was not part of the present appli- cation, they thought the letter should be read since it was written in response to the present application. Mr. Tedesco commented on this matter, saying the Board should have an iron-clad a�reement witi� the applicant before permitting this parking lot. MY. James Litman, President of the Highland Park Community Council expressed concern about the on-street parking situation in the area if this permit were denied. He also concurred that there should be a barrier between the lot and the alley. It was explained that in the absense of a permit, the Building Department would notify the applicant to discontinue use and that he would be called into court if he continued to use it. Subsequently, the Board heard a motion to recommend denial until the applicant shows good faith in observing the standards since the applicant has not ob- served agreements in the past. The motion was seconded. As the Board ��� �.3 �" . :�,�>.S�-�7 r°,/'� t G � � � �� f • . � ' • e ` ' ' Mr.•Harry E. Marshall City Clerk Room 386, City Hall St. Paul, Minnesota Page 2 discussed the motion, it was argued that the plan for the subject lot meets design standards and enforcement of them is someone else's responsibility. The motion carried by a vote of 4 to 1. Very truly yours, . a �� ��-�� ��� Peter J. Maietta Secretary, Board of Zoning PLR/br Z. F. 7322 ,r . • � � � . , BOARD OF ZONING REPORT AND ACTION April 6, 1972 • , , . Plat Map 17 , Acting under Legislative Code Chapter 60 thru 64 passed August 22, 1922, as amended to January 27, 1971. 7322 1. APPLICANT'S NAME : Mary Casey Realty Corporation 2213 2. CLASSIFICATION . � Amendment � Appeal � PermiC � Other X-1b84 3. PURPOSE ; 48-car parking lot for use in conjunction with restaurant 4. LOCATION � North side of Ford Parkway between Cretin and Mt. Curve Blvd. 5. LEGAL DESCRIPTION : Lots 22-26, Block 7, St. Catherine Park Addition 6. PRESENT ZONING: Heavy Industry 7 . PURSUANT TO Zoning Code Chapter: 60 Section: .23 Paragraph: 4,b 8. STAFF INVESTIGATION & REPORT: Date: March 27, 1972 By: ATB A, HISTORY: In 1950 a permit was granted for a parking lot on lots 25 and 26 to be used in conjunction with a tavern which existed on the site. B. AREA ZONING: The frontage along Ford Parkway is zoned heavy industry, north of this frontage the zoning is mixed "A", "B", and "C" residential. C. DESIGN STANDARDS: The plan meets existing deaign standards for this type facility. The plan indicatea that a wond fence exists along the alley line. This fence does not exiet, but there ia a ateel post and cable barrier along ; the alley line. A decorative board fence along the alley line would provide an effective screen for the residences fronting on Pinehurst Avenue to the north. D. FRONTAGE AND AREA: This property has a frontage of 200 feet along Ford Park- way with a depth of 125.4b feet, resulting in an area of 25 ,092 square feet. E. TRAFFIC INGINEER: The Traffic Engineer reports he will recomm�end approval if the fence is constructed as shown. Access to the alley should not be permitted. F. SITE CONDITI�TS: The site is developed and used as a parking lot for the customers of Kelley' s Restaurant, but the existing atripping ia different from that shown on the plan. G. AREA CONDITIONS: South across Ford Parkway is the Ford Motor Company Assembly Plant, east is a commercial use and a filling station, west is a restaurant that suffered fire damage and has not reopened. North are single family residences fronting on Pinehurst Avenue. �ao vacant lots north across the - alley from the restaurant structure are divided by a 6 foot high basket weave fence that is not being maintained, The rear area adjoining the alley �s used to park cars. These two lots are under the same ownership as Kelley's Restaurant. 9. BOARD ACTION: To Recommend � Approval � Denial Council Letter Dated: Moved by . McPartlin Yeas Nays 5-1-72 X Ames - X�b. Date of Seconded by: Benshoof X Cochrane - Ch. Hearing: � McPartlin Secretary's remarks: Maietta g 5-4-72 Mansur Council Action: X Benahoof Dooley Date: Prifrel � • , � � . � , ' , � . . City of Saint Paul, Minnesota APPLICATION FOB SPECIAL COUI�CIL uS� PERI�IT , (Please print or type) TO THE HDNORABLE MAYOR AND CITY QOUNCIL � tbe City Clerk City of 3sint Paul, Mianesota Application is hereb made to remodel or recoustruct an exietiag y instali and operate a new (croas one out) Q FILLIPAGG STATION No. of islands and pumps : No. of tanks aad capacity: � PARKIl� IAT for (customers) (emplo�es� ( .�.�...�.�.:...+�..�....r�,w�� .... (iadi,cate type) Capacity of parkiag lot �` . , �To be used in cqx►nection with; ��` MISCBI,LAI�OU3: ra . (indicste type sucb as Drive-in ltefreshsent Stand, Uaed Car Lot, Dry Cleaning Pick-up 3tstioa, Ice Vendor, etc.) Capacity of parkin� ares: � *Location . ��.'�,� ��"` �. �! i�' � � � . � � � �d �. � �'�. Le�al Descriptioa : Lot � ,��,�j � Block Addition APp li caat's Nsa�e : NiN�+�p� � 1�„ Home or Office Address: $Q�i �� �� ' Pboae Number : �4$.;�Q�� FO TRB AP I , _8_ Z . (Siga ture date Address ,� Phone No.: 8�� 1Vben c�pleted: file three copies of this applicatioa lorm and three prints of � tbe preliminary lay-out plans of tbe proposed facility arfth the City Clerk, Room 386, City Hall aad Court House, 3afat Paul, Miaassota Z-3 6/11/56 *EXA1�P�,E: 1. 5.8. corner of Main 3t. asid First St. � � � 2. 3outb side of Main St. between First and 3ecoad :� � � � � �E8 9 • �97� ZONING FIL� `�� r��,,,,�' ��� , ..� _ . .._ — � � • • . , ' ' - 2215 Pinehuret St. Paul, r�inn. 55116 Kelly �e 2221 Ford Parkway St. Pa.ul , �inn, 55116 /�ttentlon �dr. Bud Trivieki Dear Mr. Trivieki; I am aure you r�call the gentle�aen �e agreement that wse a+ade at the Fbrd Road Library 1n Lhe preeence o� Leonard Levine and other city offiolale betaeen youraelf rapre�enting Kelly�e and the reaidente living on P3nehuret Svenua between Cretin ezid �dount Curve Boulevard, in which it was agreed th�t �rs Would not ob�eat to your uee o� the b8ak part of tha empLy lota sornas the alley from the back of your building, for parking, 1t you woula erect � decent, good lookin.g fence on the same line as the previous fence wae, (that you tore doAn) msi.ntain it well, and keep the front part of the lot alesn and frae Prom weede and debris. ;e� It le true thdt you purchaaed new fenaing msteri�l but the `r inefficient temporary maulner in r►hich you hsd it ereota� le not " at all sa�tisfaatory from e�n a�ppearanoe etandpoint. It le not s $ durable enough type of conetruaxion to withst�,nd the wind end � weather aonditions that prev�il here, and as a reeult the fence ie many times either wholly or partly on the ground resulting in the entire lot being an eyegore and r� degrad�tion ta the antire neiRhborhood. In view of the above 2'aate, and your failure to live up to your part of the agreement, I atn notifying you herewith thgt all agreements relating to this matter are caneelled, and that a request will be made to the proper city officiele and departments to eee to it tha.t all parking be prahibited on the lot in queation, and that all �oning lea►e be etrlatly enYorced. Youra truly, ��,� �� ._� ��' �✓�/...��i� �� , �� J'�� y;; �� �.f;� � � � � �� Robert D6. Groeby ,� , Chairman ot Neighborhood roup � ����� � � ���z dealing with probleme relating to - �, ��� lots owned or Qontrolled by �..�.��� ���.����� �+�,� =����3 b��F��t ;<-�.���-�s� K el1 y�a ; _.._. . __. .� ..T.�...........�,.�.�..� �ember ot e�eecutive committee, e. g � ;� ;� �'',� � ; Highland Park Qommunity Oounoil ,; ` , . . .���� �:.�.,�.... �. , _ ._. '-; ..�e c �2;��T1'a7r�""'�� , ty Couno 11man 3 R1.ch�,rd L. Amey, Building Inapeator " h�� Beter J. Maiett�, $earetary, Board ot Zoning Y Jamee Litmen, Pree. Highl.and Park Commnn7.ty Counoil �':4 � � •-"--�1'---- �' �_ - E L E� A N 0 R � !� Q �� o 0000 � o00 - � � 0000000 ooc _ o --.--, o . , o o p c� o � n a.�. --o --� �� � . � � _ _. � �, __ - - _ i � � � , ,r ;� „,. �, , i i i i a � � i � � � i � ' ' �� a o ooaa 000� d b �o ib oo � a � m � iooc : o b ; � , ---- ' — _ �'� j T-T�TT�7-�7v-17 — p— (5? �f��' i O �?6 2� ____ Ui00 � O 000 d 00�� 0 0000 OiO� K� 101 � O t I� (.� -0- _� � ; �, � I � I I I I �-IF N- ----- - _ — -Q ;_ � -� I -----�}-- � O I � ! � t I I � � ' � ; I~�� _ �,- � � o a!a� b �o! b ! o� b o 0 0 0 0�o 0 0 0 � � ( -_-- �� I t�g"��- �::� � � � ! �J � F� lJRS �' � � � � � /�/� -7�ES,- �� � ,� '� '��I1If/� i �y � � �.�-� o .r � �'���� � � '.; ���..��� ��_ O p � OOp �JQOO " O OOC�' ' OOOC r � — - ( �: `� ,, C- � �- I I� � �,�. I��, I S � E � E � I I � � � � � w - � `1�...L w �L.�L �. ...��_..� �:�. ..�� r �. .� � � �rl � � .� �� _ ��� , � � . �e f..�`s r...�S_ � �_.._ �r; � p � G Q �F �a I 1 r.�,,...,.,--il �,:.�,.-f � ✓ � •� �`.�.,�,.._r .�2� �..,,. v �� � � r 1 t I ---------- yF y yr � �? � �'A A KV�IAyP v �, /�r/O vs T� APPL�CANTMARY - CASEY REALTY C0. LEGEND" PURPOSE Install 48 car parking lot to be used in L�AND USE conjunction with Kelly's Resturant. � O ONE-FAMILY P�ZESENT ZONING Light Industry �' 1�V'�0-FAMILY �'l THREE- FAMILY PETITION SIGNERS . -��- FOUR-FAMiLY _ �(� MULTI- FAMILY s wnCOM[qAERCIAL FILE No. 7322 MQRTM n n INDUSTRIAL � VACANT St. Paul Planning Board, Date� Mar. 2�, i9�2 � Property under considerotion �. .. ' , , r��r�s c,� �� ���;:c ����ur ���a�� � sa� o� za�n�c V:.Y l.l'4Vi1L31i.�E�T�. �f!-i3.1! LT':. �r's7Gf �8 Li��o ��riY PR� Mrs� Ccch�.�Q; �I�E�r�. 2�IcL��rt3.��, �ts�naof, t�m�e a�d riafett� a� t�e Baard; Mr. Lo��g�� �rd �. R}.i.tt�� o� th� staff. ��kY�CASLY P.�'.�LT°Y C(?RP(�t�,°.��G��, {����:;: Az� appllcatiaa �or a pet�.x Lo zn���iZ a 4���ca� patiki.�� f o� f�� e.s��. i�x cor�,jasne�?.OA TA��I3 a retttau��t on the :oz�h sid� �af i�or3 P��l��ap �e�a-t�.::�a� �retin a�d Mt. ��ve Ba��.evard. Y�. ktosetter sua�xri��d th� ::t�a::� E:::_oa�::, � pa�t o� tt��a fi1�, not�it�.� �h�t ?�. 195i3 � ���uai� �aa ����ec3 ?:j L � �sr:�:'�i�x.� �.ot os Lots� 2S axtd Zb Co i�� used i�a cc�ju:��t:i�t �sgi�k� �:, s;a+xe�w.: �h�.;:?� �a�•i eCed oxx �,�e aire. �e £�.tage a�c��� Y�a:cd ��rr���;� �.s �o�?�-'. �e�e��;���� iaduas:�, ��rt�a a� �his frc�t�gs t►t�e wo�irA� is �ei�;�� "r�"', ":.", a�;.� :�C" B�sid�zL•ia�. The �it�tt �eeto e�isti�F� desx�� �t���ctAa:r�W �c�:. ahis x:ypa f.�ci�iL-y� x'�e plmt in- dic��eo �h�z� a �oac� fence ��.:..sw� �a� �3:g t�:�� �1�4y lia�. �'his feac� doea �o� e�is�, th�xe is a st��r�. ;,;:ost �.�^k,: �a?�?e �a�ricr �Ic�g ttt� al.Iey �ia�. R drr�ax�ti�v� �aaarc� £euce .��e�:�; �� :.::?�.e;y �xz�e ��auZd prz�vid+s ��a effcecti�te ac�eeu �ar t���z r�sxu�nc�s ��:��za�ir�� �:y Ptraet:urst ��es�c ta �ht� nor�h. Z`�m Traffic E��immc�e� �c��a:,Lfa �� �r�.;.", r��ctns�.�t�d apprawra�. i� the f�tce �:s ca�s�z�taed r�s �hct��. ������� �a i:�;. 83?�� �itou2d awt "� pe�i.Cted �d cfoe� uat shc�m o� ��.� g3�aa:. ":P�� s�.u;� i� i�e��lopec� aad ;s�ed as a park3ng 9.0� for �he custa:4�ra of �:e�:.�r's �•�:�ta���.t, but th� €�xiatiag st�ripiag is di�fnsm�t z�o�� th�� sl�r*:�z �� ��:w a3.��. xh� pian tb-at shat�rs ou pape� 1�3 ��eq�3a�� £a� d�si� sta�:'..n�.��, a��: �f�. ��;a�ttc,z eai�3 t�� otZ�P�B �uicix eaciats "os� �Es� g�c�d" tt�„� ���': be �ct���at�. ao+aCh �c�oss Fo�d �?��i��,� �.� �.�a 3<��:;� ��£sY..t)r: Cr�an� A�s���y P�apt�, �ast �g a Ca�rcf.a� �e ���z� � �i.�.�.�,�;g ����;-crnp 4:+;r�r. is a �est�czraca� �har scat£e�ed fi�e da���e amd Y�� �x�,t r.r=o�.-�.:�;�c3. :<r�stli a�x�. auag�.� f�:ui�y r�aide�ee� :Exoa�ti�xg rr�, �fu�t�t?��t a�+��t��� `��a °:�c��. :c�tis �a��r�h c�:xass t�e algay trcan �h� �:r���ae�L��� �t�t;.c:rzz�.�• �dr� �_'�siciar'� ix3 � 6 faot �igh Usek,�C oieatie �ersee that is �aar� �ain� ��xi�+.a'.�,�a�. T�a� :��-.az a�:9.� ad�a3uit�� �h2 a18�y it� �ae�d to par�. �ara. �"rn�s. s.-�w�� �o�:;� ,,;.�r� ^a::�iet� eh� sa�e ��+e.�hip as IC�E��y's Btst.�carant. ���. Ras��r�r co�t3cs��d, ��,�>a_�; ��•� �ho�c�;i� �he p�arkis�� lot �l�t is raortb o£ �I�� �31�y i� �a� i.aa�Is:d�c� i�a r��,w ,-s�a-y�ica�it:-�., 3.t �aas c�;� �o th� at�e�ia� Q£ th�a �trof� �scu�,zs� a cs��� crf ���� ::��1��3�.;.� �,�t�ex v�a� received �rema xobe�t M. Grcabp, �c:d����ed to 1�i�.�a `.A:� ��.::�";-.. ��I am a�=r� gc��a :.ec�l� �iU� ��:;�.:_��'� =��ce�tt ��as� �as m�e a� t3�e Fs�sd Ra��3 �iDsr�z,t i:: r��.� g::�sea+:.�r� ��' Lc�casa�r�! ;aevi�� a�d oth� Gity of�iCisa:� 7�ot�c� °:�r-�,R�,-;� ' r�p:;�:�,-���'s�F; K�i�.�y's �w�3 the re� sid�.ts 3ivin� c� T��t�a.�I:s;:r:;� ,°��r:�,c� �a�rN.:z;�e�, �r�tiL: �sc3 �Ys�at Cux've Ba�l�ard, Yu ��icb it �?a� a�;w,.�c� ts�¢ �+e �ao�ld r�nt ab�e�� Co gc�r eae of t�ie ��1c �L �: C:�� �-�,.;:�,:tp �a�� acto:�s � a�Ze� fxo� �h� beck o&' g*�� �ui3dias�;, ::v.: g��.:"�:utg, i: pou t�ass�.d �rec� sx d�ce�„ gor9d loo�iag �ea�ea oza �:�L� �,z;� �ifz� :aL:: �he �3rs�v!ie.�3$ f�nc� �as {that you to�e dc�) aa�d ra3it;��::�:�� ;.�: ..er�q. :.�a:d tc��� �bc ��a�.t gra�t o� th� 2at ciean a� +�xa� �acsa �Q:d� �.:.�d c?�;�.�is. It is x� �aat yrar� ��.b�ee� .:�� ����Qg �taari�a3:, ba�s: �he �N e£fici�t� �ea�4�sz? s��z>_�� i.�n ��i�ic� �a� bad i� ea:�e� is st�t at . �. • . • MA1tY�CASEY BEAI.TY COIt]ty��i]:GIu t�ge � Ap�iZ b, 9,9i2 a11 satis�ac�a�y �r� as� :���'�u::�-�uc� �eaudpaix�t. It is uot a durab3� �rao�gh eq�,4 0� co�x��rea��3.a�► �a withatarid �he �iad a�! �r�ati�e� comditias�s t�� �S���ai�.. theseo aQd �a a result, tbe �erecc: is mm�r t�s r:it2aea� c��ho:�sly ox part�,p on ehs groand se- scal�iag ir� tbE e�ftixe Io� beia��; � ey�svre aad a �iegradat�.on to t�e �r�t3.re ae;gh�a�.��cac�, Ia viQaa a� Che uaove ��ets, ar�.w: yo�r �ai3s�re to Zi.u� up to yosur p3�'t OF ��tC A$��@�t.�tit."� :t um ��.:3.�yia� yon t�se�rit� that SxY agr�e�aez��� rel�tit�$ �o th�?s �sa.:�er ax� c�acelled, and t�at a r�quest t3ii$. � �ad� to t�ne p:rc.�per C�.�y aff'�ci83s aad depart- r.�e�ts to s�e Co i� ��.a� A2� �ra:�°�ic�g be prahibited ou tbe lot i�a questiia�,, �nd �ha� a�.�. za�i:.:g l�rr� l�e at�i.ctl.y �forced." Mr. Ras�tter sa,id this pe��ir�n�a� ��:��a wa� �ot iuctesded 3a tbe appllcat=oo ; tni� he thougl:t it proper to �3g�s�.t it �o �he Bo�d since the 2etter eas ; s�riCten ia r�spaa�e ta the e�.z�e�ec� .�pp��e�tio�. , riz. Tedcsaco said �y d�ati�a�a �ix�y ��sve F.�� oritb Mr. Trivisdci have aaot '6eea tta� bs�t aaaci he sa��ste� �ha w>flescd deay t�ts ps=king p�s�ait tai�ees t�� ha�e a� iros�-clad a��e:.�t�� t��f:�:h bim �at hr� �il�. abid8 by theiz recoo�uda�icrres. Mr. 3ac�se Li�.x, :'�^ec�•sde�t� I�i���°�d �ux�c Ca�nity �+�emeiY. 8slced hrtsat �prou].d hap� i£ �hc Eaard e�c�ai.�d �Taf: p�a�rnit siaac� a p��king �at a�ready e�ists t�erc. M�s. Cc�chraiae �aid U� co��.d �c�x �� it �it�out n p��.r. �ir. Lit�na� asi�d ��'�:�� ��.�c�:�rs �c:�,:� �:�r�. i� t�i� Lo9� ��rc nc� p�rmikted aztd safd i�s �as Chinki�tg ��o�a� �a�� �::.c���b�a�a ts�to live ao Pi��st et� the oa-atreet cus3to�r �xkia� tY��� �a�stld oce�r �hares He said he eat- curred �ith �ae Qr�:��oss oE �l �er�::��� �a�riear teo pzc�eect the pa�lcing I.at frc�a � �11� mr,d Ct�a� :�.�re ���a��cr.�td �s no �xit o� es►t�raace fPOm t1� aYl�g+. � p�i.nti�ci oc�t k:tz�t cz�:ig�'o�c:.�.� �c! x�quas�ed cc�ttaio C�ta�'fit �igos b� p�c�i in �he s���r tv ����at� :z�� fc+r,� th� protn�tiaa of cbildseo, i+9�:. Ca�chxat�� as1�d if the �ig�a a�c��:ld � Asctas.�sy ;�: a fi�ee r� thers a�d tt�y �e�a� raot a�7,r,�d to ur�e tI:� s��.�°y. lSs. Lieman said h� vovld ��ilY 3i1r.� �a 3�� �+ si�a plac:ed in tho ail,ay be- r.+ause o£ hea�r9 tre�cic c�ee �or �h� ��;;��ac�an�. Se eaid delivery truckt� arrive a�� �he bacic oi R�Zi�ry's cn �:a� enr�:�a si��. Tho main eatr�ace 3.s Yight ai�f t�ae aide o� �h� �ui�.d�.ng �i�c��tly� �;.::3 t�s� g�:lcisag lot r:o trt�cics awst So aP aaB daie3u tb� s3l�y. Ift. M+cPartiia eacv►ed thst �he �e�i.: '�� ��iad bee�+s� the app3ic�t has aot obaer�zed agx�:�nCs he m�.d� i.� �� ���� �asl ttze�a ie �o sasursac� he will obsa�ve tia� tbis tisao. � ��eo��::��ci d�n3at tuztil '}u appliesnt e1'iot�8 �cad f.�it� i� ohses�ing �1�e ww�d��:,�s. �Iis'. F3�abrio� sc��d�d �T�e �ars��.c��t� l�s. Lit�sa� eske8 �it ��� ��p�s �a t� +e�ciatiamg Eo} i! �e �AC is d�niad. 1'SClL1i�4[�S� 1V:t31L1 i NVi1S VlUll.��! F�a�,e 3 Apxi 1 6 a S7�L 1K�c. Ames exp2ai�ed that, shonYc� �he permit be deaied b3r t6e Co�uteil, his department a�nuld iu<otify the ap�Iiea�t to discoat=ana ctse and if he 3Li12 eontiinesea to nse it, he wouAri be ca:tled fato eourt. Mr. ?taietta noted Chat the sc�it�e� plaa meets desigee steadards aa�d s�r ffierked that tlse matter of 1o�zdia� f:,°am the alley is a qe�estion of lmgality atad ia aot a ivactic� of thi� Boa�d, He aaid ttsat taforacmeat af approved parking lots �.s a7.so aot the t�ucei�� of t�he Ze�iag Seard and aaid pesbaps same othcr dapart�es�s of th� Cit�r ;3ave 1e� this matter got out of l�ad. If the appiicaat has becn doira� s�uthiag �11ega2, he sho4aild have be�n stopped before. The vote on Mr. M��'art�ia's u�o�ioa Y:as � to 1 r�ith Hr. Maietts disse�atiog beceuse of the rease�►s Ize sta�ed a£�.�� th� motioa e�as made. Snbmitted by: �.pp�oveel by: Paul I.. &oseeter ��s. Caralpn Cocbr��e PP _ -. . M3�It�TES UF T� �'UB��IC I3F;�Zt�t� B�s�R� TgE BQARD OF Z�TIIQG �I ��5�l.��', d!�:�:I, fi� I972s AT 2z0A P.Mo I�tESE�dT: �Sxsv Ceschrax�e; x3essr�. Mcr-�lrtlit�, Beashoaf, Ames s�ci Maietta o� tli�Boa�d; Mr. Ros�tt�� ��d B. Itr.�.ttaz of the stafF. MARYNc�s� x�a�,� c��cm��ac�? (?��2`; : 11t� appliCation aos a permit to install a k6pca� p���Cia.g �.o� fa� c���:: in co�juaction �a��b e reatauxaat on t6e e�or�h side af �'oxd Earlrz��� bet�c�<~e:L� Cretia �ad Mt. C�ve Sa�levaxd. rir. �.oa�tte�c sum��iz�c3 th� :t.�fi �.:�or�, a part of tt� �i��, not'�ng t�at '_a 3954 a p�ra+it ctas g��,��ed �c;� a parkiag Iot ara Lots 25 aod Z6 to b� used in �o��u�ctiirz� �ai�b .� �a�r�s�:f�. �hich �s�s�ed aaa �he site. 't� E�e�t�ag� a�oa�� �'oa:d �artcrn�� i.s �cn:e.: he�try iudu3try, u�xtte ot this fraata�� tl�e �aain� is oai.z�d t'�i�'; ":':'�� �d ;�C'� &esid�a�ia�. The p3att �e�te existiug desi�n atandardz� s"•ox shis type faci3ity� Tbe plan � s3icatee ttna� a �oc�d fe�ce �::�sts ��a::��g ��: alley ].iae. This feace does t�ot exis�. C3��xe is a st��l ��ost � csia�e :sarzier alo�g th� aL�.ey li.ne. � dacora�ive uo�rd £�uce alc�*�g t�ae� �°:�3.ey aiue �nZd provide ara effeerive sc�seu for th� xe�Ld��eces fkt�rz�i�a� ,:,�;� Fi�aenurst Aaen�e ta eE�e c�o�ctb. Tho Traffie E����ecr nepa�.ts �xe ��i�.:; r�co�.m�eaad a�aprova� i� the fct�ca ie �os:►:atr�et�s1 a� �i�c::�x. Ac��aa� :o k:L=:= ����y sbat�2d oot "� perssieted aad do�a s�oe rs�ts�ta us� t�s p�.a!�o :�°�e ��:.�:.:.w is a�vu�Iop�d aad as�ed as a pa�kipg �fl� far the custacs�xs af Kes;.e�°s ��:sCaux�t, bu� th+e c�isting stripiag is di�fer�nc►t ;roa� ���t aiinz� oa� �Y�n al��e. mY�e p�:an tla�t shca�s �t papear is ad�quate �or �e�ign se�uc�s.xr3s, ia-.L t��. Ras�tt�x sai� the eLriP3.a$ ��ifc� ��is�s "o�t th�z g�ra2t�2d" t�} �zcs:: b� �:c3e:qt�stt�. So�th across T'ord �'�x�la,iy ic �La 7a::•c� Pi��.oM Caa�any Asse.mbly Ptaat, east �.s a Car�zcial e�se �:z�t � �i:��ih;g B��as:�c�� �.�x�t is a. �ceata�traae that snx£es'ec1 fire dama�e axxd I�� s�ot xrop::uec�. <:'orth as� s3.�t�;la fa:uilg ra�idencee tzaa�i�g ata Piaets�.t�st A�acz�:�c�e< '!°s�o •,�ac�� �.c��s nc�rth a�sass the alleq fr�on �he rese�.urenr. �trts��.rz�:�� ��:e ��.taid�� L;� a 6 faat iai$h baeket aea't �raee thst is �at �x�is�� �ii.�z�:a'.r��s3. 1'h� �c�r sr��.a ad�oi�iog th� a1Re�y is ta��d to paz1c casa. �''nesc� .Ct�a ?aC� ,,-.re �.�^adr-:� tlae same �arship as It���'o'9�s 8e�tsuraat. I�. Sogetter �oo�tatr�t��sd, �a�ir�g ev� �.hor��� �b� pa�kiag 1ot that i$ noYt� of che �tl�.ey is zzot �c�r3sl�d in �xi� ��;rxica�ia�., 3.t bae c+x�e ta the att�tioa �t the Bta�'� $eacgur� c� co�y f��¢ th4ry .�:v13es��i�� iet�er saea �eceivecl fram 8obert M. Grosbq, sddt�sQ�ed �o a'�a `>'� ��z��.'.: "Z am sure qau secsl�. tt�,e �e��:'.�e:�°a e,��t �?aat vas a�ade $t Che k'crc� Ro2�� Libr�rr�* ac� �3�,� �::�se�c;e af Lc�c,arx�r� �..evist� �d other City officf.,��.� be�a�� �.�o�,sx��:�': xe�w�:,�sst�i�; Ke31ey's ra�� �h� re- afdea�s iivisa� a� �w�tt�.��:�t ���.�tes �Se���o t:reeti� �d Mouat �t�Ztr'e Bo+alevsrd, iu ��ich 3.e C�as a�;°:-:�d �har. � �ax1�i u�t ob���t to yo�c esss og t3ae �'.tit�3c gsY� o:: tnw �*w,:�y �o�� arroas the e��ey fzam th� b�ck o£ yass buildisn�, :'oa pa�:-�.u�, �� yoa i�3d �r�ct a dsc�t, �ood loo&,iag feoce oa �:i.� 3a� �.ist+� �.� the �s�e�tia:ae f�ace t�as (that �rflu �o�e do�� aad �ai�a::�I� 7.� �e�'�, ��si kePp th� froa.t part of the io2 cisaa 8�ad fre� f�c� ���d� r:�d d�'�is. It is ta�s tLe; ya� ���assd .:� �+��teg �z+ACi�'�, be�t t1� i� efficieat C�g+osaEZjr ma��e� �^� �<�ic� ya�� bad it er�ered is �ot at , � w � 1�ARY=CASEY BEALTY CdR��TI� Page 2 April 6, g972 al� satiefac�ory frc�i a� �ppe�F:anc.e standpai�tt. It is aot a durable e�oa�t� typ� a� C0124$�'C�:��.OA t0 withstaeui the �ri.�d and �ea�b,e�c conditious that pse�ei� there, aod ae a resalC, rbe faxtce is �asnp ti�s �ithem osho r.ly o� partZyr on the gronad re- sultiag i�a the eatire 2a� beiu� $a eyeeore aa�1 a deg�cadat:oa to the er�tire u���hbo�hocad. In► v3.� af the above face�, aur;� yaur �ailusa to live up to your part o¢ the ggre�aent, T am no x:i£y ixt� yon here�ri th tha t all agreemsats raleti�g zo th�?s �a'��er sR� cancelled, and tlsat a reQuest ta�il� be made to the pxE;ger C�.ty officl.sln aad depast- ments tc s�e ta it that a33: pa��Kia� be psahibi�ed on t.2u tot in qaaestio�n, end thasc a�.� xou►i�::g �rs b� st�cieely en£orced,'t Pir. ltosetter sai.d �his partie�a�aa a::�ea �as aot iacleided 3n the applieation ; btst be �ho�aglat it �propes to �r�ses�t i� to �h� Board siaee the IetCsr was � m�rittea in rc��pomaa to t� sz�'ect :�pplicatian. ! Zir. Tec3eaco �aid �ay dealir�gs �h�gt :.:.ave �ad witb Mt. TriviBki have aot be�r� ti�e best at�d be st�ges�c�� thQ "yoard 3eay tbe paskiag pesmit unlese they 6ave a� i�ozt»�lad agfi�c�ic ��i..h him CLat 1� �ii.11 abide by theil� Z@CO��Ltd8��.08t8. Mr. Jamaa Li.t�ax►, Yre��d��t, �ig,�ila:-<.d Park Coa�nuaity �o�acil, aek�d rdsat �oa2d hap� if Ctec Eoa�d ds�i.�d �hc: permit sf,a�� a pt�ieiag Zot axroadq exists ebcre. Mrs. Gochraae eaid h� �o�ld uot use it t�i'thattt a piermit. Ms. I.itxnaa asbced a��er�e ceisto�rs :�c���.d �ar�C if the loY: t�eze not permitted amd esid he was thix�.kiag aixout t� ;,��18bba�s e�o live on Pi�lwret aod tbe oo-street cuatao-�r parki�g t1a3� cauld occar tbere� Re said � eat- carred sitb the ea�ec�ian of a parr�s;we�t baxtier to pzatect the partiog Iat fram tbc a11�y a�d tha� �s�r� �rt.e�Rd �a ao e�tit o� entzauce fxom tbe alley. 8e poi.�ted au� �itat �eighi�ca;s ir�� r�quested ccjrtaio tzaffic sigus b�a placed iu tve a1i�y ta �:�u�ate ,>�eed for ths protc�ction of childsea. i�a. Coehrsc� ask�d t£ the eigr�� a�cT.��,d ba �sa.�s� ±.c a f� rer� t.fiare �d they �e�� xao� a��o�d �c� �ssa t&�w a�.lcrq. �z. Litx�a said h� atauld s�il?► lit�� to s�e a siga plac:ed in the a12ey be� ca�a ot heavy ts�ack nss �og �he re:�r.a�zsat. H� aaid 8eliv�sy tr�cics arriva a� �he baetc of �Q�.La�r's aa ��s ocr�::� si�e. Ths �oaia c�atrsz�e is �i�tt off tls� aide of the �S�.�ding dir�ctly ��:, r.�c patkiog lot :�o tsvcics muat go tip a�d da�sn ehe� algaq. P�. McFertlixa mav�ad ths� the p�rtiii: be dtnisd tueanse the epplie8at has aot obaerved agr�a�ts �e m���e i� the �ast aa� t.here ie ao aeswcaa�ce 1ae wil2 o�bea�ree th�mn this tS.�ao. 8e r�com��dad deaiai t�LiZ th� applicmt a1w�s gcod f�tith ia obs�swiag the sta�adsa_•�3s. BSr. BeashooF secozzd�d the motivae lYr. Litra� asked �hat ��.d happ� �o tlae a�isti.o,� Io� if the p�nit ia a�ai�d. MARY-GASEY BB�L�'Y CORPOItATIdPT �age 3 April b, 1972 Mx. Ames expl.ai�ed that, shoUld the permi� be deaied by the Co�tcil, his depa�ctm�nt woc�ld notilEy Che agp�ica�.0 to diacoatiaue case sad if he 8Li12 coatinaes to use it, ha �ou�d be ca�.3ed iato court. Myt. Mai+�tta noted that the sc:l�mitt�� piaa cceets dasigc a�andards aa�d ra� ec�rked that thc3 matter of 1oAding f;:om ttc� a21eg ia a question af I�gality aa�d is aot a fu�actio►� of this Boaacda fle said that ea£orcemeat of approved parking iota is also aot the �unceic�n af the Zoaing Board sod said perhaps sa�e othcr d�p8rtments of the City Yta�e le� this a�tt�z get os�t of haad. If t�ce applieaat has beca doiug so��thing illegal. be should liave been sCopped before. The note on Mr. McPart�fa's �o�i� �:;as 4 to 1 witb l�tr. Maietts disseotiag be�:aase of the r�asoans 6e sta�ad a�zet tbe motio� i►ae made. Se�bmitted by: �ppraved by: Paul Le 800etter ��ra. Caroipn Cochrsae 1►P Citq Clerk ' , , � � ' CITY OF SAINT PAUL MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE 113 CouA Hous� 55102 April 21, 1972 File X1184, Page You are hereby notified that a public hearing will be held in the Council Chambers of the City Hall and Court House in the City of St. Paul at 10;00 a.m. on May 4, 19�? on the application of Mary-Casey Realty Corporation for a permit to install a 48-car parking lot for use in conjunction with a restaurant on the property described as follows: Lots 22, 23, 24, 25 and 2�, Block 7, S:t. Catherine Park Addition. The property is located on the North aide of Ford Parkway between Cretin Aven;ue and Mount Curve •Boulevard. For further information, contact the planning Board, Room 1010 Co�erce Building or telephone 223-4151. _ To comply with the City Charter, the Department of Finance is charged with informing you of this public hearing. If you have any questions, it is recommended that you attend this public hearing to afford you the opportunity. ,to make your views, both pro and con, knawc► ta the City Council. � ROSALIE L. BUTLER Coagaissioner.. of Finance • ��� . . Cit of Saint Paul � �� , Y , l�innesota APPLICATION FOR SPECIAL COUNCIL USE PERMIT (Please print or type) TO THE HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL 96 the City Clerk _� ���j City of Saint Paul, Minnesota � Application is hereby made to remodel or reconstruct an existing install and operate a new �cross one out) � FILLING STATION No. of islands and pumps : No. of tanks and capacity; � PARKING LOT for (customers) (employees) (��€�������€����€ (indicate type) Capacity of parking lot 48 To be used in connection with: �STAUR�NT � MISCELL�ANEOUS: (iadicate type such as Drive-in Refreshment Stand, Used Car Lot, Dry Cleani.ng Pick-up Station, Ice Vendor, etc.) Capacity of parking area: *Location 2019 Ford Parkway- North side of Ford Parkway between ' Cretin Avenue and Mt. Curve Boulevard. Legal Description : Lot See attached sheet Block Addition Applicant's Name : Ma.ry-Casey Realty Corp. Home or Office Address: 2019 Fprd Parkway Phone Number : 698-4031 . , FO TI� �P IC , J. w: ' � (Signature) (date Address : 2019 Ford Parkway Pbone No.: 698-4031 When completed: file three copies of this application form and three prints of tbe preliminary lay-out plans of the proposed facility with tbe City Clerk, Room 386, Citq Hall and Court House, Saint Paul, Minnesota Z-3 6/11/56 *EXAMPLE; 1. S.E. corner of A�aia St. and First St. 2. South side of Main St. between First and Second St� � � � � � � � �ES � • i9?� �`'�t���M�Axu � �. �97°2 Mary-Ca�ay Reslty Corporatic�n 20I� Ford Park�aay St. F�.'.z]L� iKinuesnta C=en�lenen: The City Couti�ii tod�r heid a public hearing on the application c,�' P�ry-C�sey Realty �rporation far a percn�t to instal]. a �+8-Gar parking lat �n the nox�h �tici� o�' Fa�rd �arkw�,}r between Creti.n A�re, arad i�it. Curve Hlv3. �ter h,ea�3.ng ab,�ectiona and diacussing �he matt�r at same len�,th� the Goeuzcil a$reed that the m�..tter should �ie laid over one •�reek ta 1�y 11, 1972 at the x•egul,ar Couacil meeting at 10:00 .�.M.� and the Cs�unc�.t ftiirther reqtte�ta that you be pres�n�t �t tha� mseting to diBeuss th� m�ttsr witYa them or b� sub��c� tc� the di�eontinuance o�' operation o�' this park3n�g lc�t and to the parking lot north or" this locatior� on P3ztehur�t Ave. Very truly Yott�i C3.ty Glerk AO/ng �Y' �+, 1972 Zoning Board Co�erce Bld�. Ger�tl�ra t The City Caunci], today laid ov�er aue �r��k tc� May l..l.th, 19`7� �the ;�p,plication of' Mary-��e�y 1�es�3,.�Cy Carporation for a permi� to 3n�ta11 a �8-car paacl� lot fQr us� in con�uriction wi�h �► restaurant on the �noa�th side of Ford Pkwy. between Cretit� and �+it. Curve Blvd., on Lota 22 - 26, �lnck 7� St. GBtherine Park Ac3dition, Very truly yours, City C],erk n� '`i2EC T FAR CERTIFIED MAIL-305� (plus pastage); • • SENT TO' �y1� � r ,�j POSTMARK • ry�/��Y_ CnSG i� 1\El�l,l j CO p ORDATE STREET AND N0. �- a o� 9 ���A � v� as� �9� C7 P.O., STATE AND ZIP CODE ry cV Sr, �r��._ rn �l�}�1 �S1 j ,��� � � OPTIONAL SERVICES FO ADDITIONAI FEES � (� RETURN 1. Shows to whom and date delivered ............ 1 . �� � RECEIPT W�th delivery to addressee only............6 2. Shows to whom,date and where delirered.. 35 O SERVICES _ With delivery to addressee only............85d �ijf�jd n a� DELIVER TO ADDRESSEE ONLY ...................................................... 50d �� z --- SPECIAL DELIVERY (2 pounds or less) . ................................... 45e POD Farm 3800 NO IHSURANCE"COVERAGE PNOVIDED— (Sse ofher sid�) July 1969 NOT FOR INTERNATIONAL MAII AppOs �o�oo...�..e. �� a � � '�inbui a�ew no�f;i;i�uasa]d•pu�`�diaaa� si�µaneS 'S . � ' " "` r �pa�sanba�si a3in�as ;ey� �i p�e� }diaaa� wnla� ay; ;o Z aui� ui luawas�opua awes ay} eaeld 'AlNO•33SS3a00tl " Ol b3A113a lua; ay� uo �i as�opua 'aassa�ppe a43 0} F�uo paaani�ap �ai��e ay3 ;ueM no6;� •y '031S3f1D3a ldl3�3b NNf113a a��i�e ;o �ua} as�opu3 •spua pawwn8 ay;;o sueaw �tq a�i;�e ay; Jo �aeq ay� o; li y�eue pue 'IT8£ w�o� 'p�e� �diaaa� wn�a� e uo ssa�ppe pue aweu �no� pue �aqwnu �iew-pagii�a� ay� all�nn '�diaaa� u�n�a� e �ueM no�( ;I '£ •a��i�ie ayl �rew pue ';diaaa� ay� ui�ai pue yae}ap 'a��i}�e ay; ;o apis ssa�ppe ay� ;o uoi��od �;a� ay; uo qn}s pawwn8 ay� �a�3s 'pa��ew;sod �diaaa� siy; �ueM ;ou op nod �I 'Z • � (a8�¢ya e��xa ou� •�ai��e� �e�ru �no6 0l �i puey �o nnopwM a�uuas aai}�o}sod e�e a�ai}�e ay}�uasa�d pua�poy�e�diaaa�ay�8uieea� 'a�ai;�e ayl;o apis ss�ppe ay;;o uGi��od;�a�ayl uo qn;s pawwn8 ay}�ai�s 'pa��ew;sod �diaaa� siy�;ueM no6�I 'T puo��ees)'S3�IA83S 1tlN011d0 031�313S ANV tl0�S39dUH� ONV'33d 11tlW 031d11839 '(IIB�u�le �o sse�a ig�!{) 39tl1SOd 83A0� Ol 31�ti8tl Ol SdWtl1S 39V1SOd A�I1S __.�_._....__. � . _. .,.U9PObTAGE V-�.. _ � � L�.. A Office of the City Clerk _ - . ! �°�� ' ..���_. . r � i � �� , HARRY E. MARSHALL �--°---.,.,,_ : ""_ � =� � 386 City Hall and Court House �� -+��i n�j�.` ��� � � "`^+� ' ' ' � ` ��"" � � �� R r . �L , , Y. ST. PAUL, MINN. 55102 s'"_.�1 ���'�rv ? ,' ; ;:., �� : �� " . ,, �R.�KUN.o.noo �E.b� 7s • . B��,C� � � , �,.�_ � �,.;;• -• I, , � "�' --_-- �"'°�^Y. , '- �.�� i �- - - _ _ _ - - - - - ( � �'� _ ����;��` "'�G.���.� �£�'1��T� Ma►ry-Casey ealty Corporation � � 2019 F'or Parkway No. ������ St. Pa� , Minnesota 55116 i , i ,' , . . �~�dL.L�Y�► o - _ ::. . o � � , , r_ — - — —�OWtifA�. _ ,�.... �X7.�'1`: WD13.� �'£i�l�'� ,� . _T � �. �6. ' � � � f ��� � � E � � � t: fi,. �r �.1� ; / � �t�_ ___ __ _ _f �� �-_ _�- .� -- ._ _._ __�� � 1 � `. �,.�• � � � � i _� � G1�N C..tlV+ldE�G �?"Q/� ! � i � � , ' � ( � � '. , '`� t � -l- -,.—r/.�.�� ! _, �. � r- { . ? � _— - --- t t� , t_?�,,�-✓ rt 1. 17.5'' �4 � ,. , " � ' � 7� i ,� � � ____' � �-` �-, . — �' _. � � � ��� � � � � ' � � �' �� � � � � � � � � � � � C�1 � : � � -�.� ,,,., ___i C� r — �.._ -� � , �"� � � � 1 .j� � �_ � t° � ' � ► �, .� � � _ � s a � , . . � v. -� _� _ _� � �f ��� �,.. � �:. j,� �ftt � ' - m . ► � �` � l . j � I j EX►ST`ING' ci-.. . , _ _ i . ..., � � B U 1 L D.1 N.G ,�'^ t .g�..__ _-� �. � �Y t` ,�-- ! cn � I � w' :�,. � � YZ � °' 4 �,�•;t� � i '1�• . � �`;;."{� ��.� _ i °� . !.� � - - -;-- - -�- - i � � � �� , , f i � Z v ` . .. �1 1 Z ; � :� tC j i�- t. � �� � � � �..t � � �! �'f.�w � J .r ..» .�� . �. ✓... rr.,� . ' ��.- `_I�.... . __J . � 41 I � �';j { j ;� ,.-�—, ! � .� � � i • ,O� .t% ' � �,;, . � �11 � � c[1 � � � � :� -- - -�-� �,, , r _` _�_ '�. - � �:, - � ► N� ' . '�, �. ��r>�` i ,� � � � , � _� , � 4 t ; .1 � w y �-- — �---��- -+- ._.._� w. _+. { `' .�-'--� ... .� c/ . �. �1-.g.�' � 9.�.A.:. _ 2 Q.'p"�� 'Z S'.Q, � 2l��� - t �.+D::4' � 2_�'. � 53 3S' _,_ __ _ _ _--� --____-. --- -�t�_ ---�.r_._�..�� ' �--�-----. --- ...._� - t i_ _ _ -- _j �- �� - - - _. �.. _" t. � � :� I ' ` � ;yl� _ _ _� J �� �� �, t. 4 �� � �. .. ,,,,� � � �: .. t,:. G'rsy�:`1�,NCBL:. S7ap5�� � �� COlIMC. , � - � • i .. i -_ . , �-- � � � k � 4 � r i y ` � `� . . # � i . � .. � . _ _ ... -__�� r.. _ __ � T N � ` / ` �1(I s � G C oNG. W�11.K �-----�► � _ — " �.� __. � �✓"� `� _ ,_ 2Q� 0 r. ` I �:'' � � • �.! ' �S��. � /' �'Xf$'T'iKb B�ULEVApID � � f� � f/�uR$ �u�s ' �. �� Cf ✓LL`�� �`./ `�Xi�'1`i . 6,- Gl � �--- : � J � ( Zlo.D' � ' �����_� O ' O�� �*1, f � 4 '�-. ..�.ORD PARKVy�Y _ - - 11f Kenneth G . l� ordby asz.d Associates , inc . ,. ,,,: ,,. . ,.. ,. , .4 '�� ' � Y � v :fi�e � � � " 4 e � ' � , , t..� fy ��-.; � . � � . . . . . -.� . . ... ... . . � . . :�'. ... . .'. - . . . . . . .�... .. . . . . � • �. . .. . , , ;� .. . .. -'. , . . . ., . .. . :: . _ .. � ' �� M' ...� .,. � . . � . , � ' .�' .. . . . .' •. , .. .. . . ...,, . . +t . � , . . .� �'�" . Y x `1. �.,�. .:. .� . ..- , . ,. . �� . . . . .. "' . � . .�� . �. . . ,.. . :.�. �. . , � _, • . :.. .�� :.. �-. . ',. , , .. ,. . ..�.. .. . .... -:� .. � . -.,� . . ..., �,. �;,� :� . �. . . �, - . . . .. , . � .. ,.. . . �. � ' .. . �. , .' . . � �.. .. . . . ��.�� ,.:;. . � . , _. .. ,�., .. .. , �, , �. , � _ .. ,. ;,.� . . .. r '. � ;. . � .� . , . '�. , .... . . _. � ' . ... , .. ��� �- , �.� . � .� . � .. . ..� .. .- .. - ... , . � . � ��. ���..�. �, ,: ._ , r � .... , .� :. „ .. - . . �. . : . . _ . ��_. ,� , . _', ...-� .. �r' e � . • � , . . : _ , . ,..�� . a r= � ,, .. , . . ... , .. .� . , . : .'� . . : .� ,.", .. "r u..�. . .. , . �... .., . . . . . �� . - . - . ,� . '. ' . '.,- ` .. � . . . . .� .: .. . - ..♦� i" :tr;:�. . . .. . . ... , .. , ..... , f � v i. ," . ; . `. ,"` S ' -' '� � � , � , - .. . 7 � . . . . . .., �. . . . . 1..,_� 6. . - .... . . .., .. _ � , , . . , .- . . ' ',.. _ . . ., . . .�,�. i. . . , , , , . ',� .:,- � ..� -,� . , . - ;� •E` . . : . . - : .� . � . . ,` . . .. : . ,_ ��. , . - � .� . .�;� . '�, , : .. . ' , c.r =, .. � -.. ; . .- .. ...-., _ . . . .. . . . , �� . . . .. � � .�, � •:. :�.. '-'�� . . . - . .,. '.:. .:, ,', � : . . . �.. .:..�, ,. ..: j;. . , .". .. ��. ., �,: . . �. • .. ' .. . . �' . �,@:; .. - , .,. � �� ,� , .� . . . ._ . . . ? � . . . ,' ..� . ..�� _ . . . . ., .,-: '��„� . , ��� '' _ , . '. . .. , ,. .�. � . , . � . . �-� . ,�. .�. -�, ,� • �. . ,� . . , � � � '� . . . _� . . . . . . '� . '. . : �. .' , . . . ..r: . . . . . .... . .. ... .; . . . . . . . . � . �.: S . . ... , . ��. .�� . . . �: '. . . . . . . . ',. . ..� . . . . _ .`. ... ... _ . , , .:� i � •, ... �. . . ..: , . .. . ..- .� , . , . . • , . . . : . . . . � ... . ,... :, , .� �.... ..� � `.:. . , �,� � . , s '.y� .. . .. .. ... . . ..�... . . . . ' . ' ' . .. . t } 'ry. , . , ... . . . � , , . � . . , i� . ..� . '�.: . . ,. :� .. � '�. . .. �. . � ..� .:�, i ,. . , � , .. . ': . • .�. � . . � - � .. :=.- : � � � . . _ .�. . , , ���.:, �� . .. _.� .. . V , '_ . � � '. . . , . .. � _ ..��,.. ,. . . r , . , . .• . . ... , .. . . , .� ,.: . ...�.. ��"� . . . . . .��. � . . .,. . . . , .. . � . _. � .: r _ _'_ � , .. ' " _ " ' ., . .. . . . , � , �, , � . . . �, , , ,. �.� .' . , . . , I ' .. � ., ... , .. ' � '1 X t � E � � . ' � ' =J�. , . . - � , ..r r k" � �� . . ,_ . L+. ;i - • .. . . ,. .�.... . . . ... . . , . , :- . . : . f .i � _. �� Y� roj' �. .. - � J }y.� - �i Y . ;... R fA � f ti,.r r �,_� .. .. a . .;r � . ' � � . � . . • . ' .. ,' * ri:: .. n '�'�� �s - t 1 F ,� .;n..�, • �,;; `^�.i w ��y�' _ � • . i Y^{ h � �` •' . _ ' . .. . , , ; � '. , � . . .°. .. ,.'; ..: {,. �.... . ..� .�. : .,4 °..�. Y t.,� h s , . t .. � x 4 ,� s � "R 4`!} ( c � �n - { ��, �». �`� _ . , �.r " r,'., �, B � . , : ) •.A e ..� . . ::. . , . . �„ _' , _ ?�r �. h. �. .' " t . . . . . . �;.: '', : .�. . .. . . � , �$�!' . . . � . • . , .. .. . ..� r,,� . . , . F � - t i,. ��. �� � . .. `� �� s �° �"�.� '� �.. . .�. ... . . .... . � � . . .. ,. .. . . . : . ,,'; . . . . . _ , , .� ��'� ,:`,: . .�. = , ,r. . '� a �y��ar �t a . . � �' � � fi�,A �x �m _ !��: . ' � ' " _ ,p,.'t,�.a-' -�`c- �'.i _ _ . � � . � . . �- �. . . , . ,_.._ .. . ...� , s .:.� ,.�� ... .�. �w �.: ' � '��-� - ' q i ... ,.�.. . .. . . �� - -.., . .• .�.. . ,' ... ' ' , , , . _., . .. . . .-:., • � . . - � , �� � �� . - - . � ,. . . . - ..� .. . . . .. a . . . . � . • : . . . �...' ,. �.;' . . �� . , , , y , .. - , ... � ,. . . . . . � .. .., , , .�. - �`x. ..., ,. ... . � . . , . . . .. � , . .. . �:. „ . .. � . .� ..,. � . , . .. �.. . „ - , � . :. ; , , .: _. . '. .�.. . „ � . ., . ,�;. . �. ,. v . , 4' � . � .-.. ;. : . _ . � .; ` .� . . . , . . � . � . .��. ,... . ' , : � .� . �• . �'� .,. . .��. .. +� , , . , . � . . .. .:; . .. :, . . . . . � ,..., ,.,. . . �; .. � '. _ . ,"�� .� , : . , � '���... . ; �` .� .. :�. �. .�: . . . . . : ..� . . . �., • ;� .w' . ' _ . � . . � . .�� .. :.-. . ;., .., ,.. . . ' .l^ . " ;� ,. , ._ . . .. � , ... . ,. .. . . .a ,. , , . �. .,�.:. ' . ,. �.. . . .. . , .. , � .. . .���. . . ., ,. -, � y� � , . .'. , , . , : ..':.,. , � , . . ,. . :.: - _ . :. - ` ;. r ' . .... .� . �:,_ . . �. . � � ' �.. . .. i . . , -.� . . .� ... r � ��: . ... ,.. . . ,. .. ._ . . , . . .;, -.: - . , , .�. J , , , , ; . _ , . , . � � � , .. ; . . � . , ; .." 4 , . . . .. . � . � . . '. i . : a : : . .. �'. �:. . � .. � . ... . � �. , . . .. . - _ . � � ��y *t* `� �: � ��•�1l'� � . ' . � . a .. . �. .� . , � � ' , ; . � '� ,. . . , . . .� _ . , . � .y � ^� ' _ . . .�.�..�.+�. a� • :..� " ........ . . .; , .� ...' � �� ' :�� > , . ��. .. ,<:..� . . , j . , ;�.: . . . ... � �:.:�Qi.=:f�.. . , .. . _ . .. . . , . � . . - , . ..- . . > . ,,_.. , : .,. .. _ ,. . , , _ ...,. � , . .. . , : , . , ; . , . . ;. : . . .. . : ... . . _.... . ; "t R-�d _ .?�' - ;�, . ,.. .� ,. , -- . - , . . ,. . . .- � - . . . ' . � , �. . . .. •, , �:: � , Q .�.. - . . _ . . � � . .. . � j. r 'y . . - . , . , . .- _ . . . . . .. ..; ' . . , ' . . . . � .� ; , �. , .. . . �.> t '�' �� ' i . s � ,-�.. . �: , � _:�: . , -, . � . , , . ,. ... i � ... „ . . .. . .�� � . '.. , . �. . .`_. ...� , �,:: � . . .: v . . _� >:.� ,�„ , r �: . :: , . ....�. � � t �*� ��'� .� ,� . .:����� sr.i^,��4.iiY Y�'�« '�• ,.twa�' > � �,e�. "j��' .�:}�.$�"7'+'i �r,•�t"�, ��'I}��+'4�.1���.`�!A'�,,�C« , . �C�x ' ` � t�C1�-�:��'S'��..,.'1`9��'t��ft+ ..' . �t�t��; ��I�t��? `{���, ri - - , , >�,. �"��.�ar'; �1�K�--,�? 5"1'�.�.�:�?'�.lii3"�3.��t1� :. ' ��Jt't.'� "�`�t" � � �t�tirl�.�''i�"�t �";p��.: � .�— -- : � ..�PA '� �"��*'� �C�11�i�`�#��y� � , . �. , ,, . � , �- ,., .�, , .. .. .. - - _, � ,. . , . . , - ; ,,. , _ , _ - ..: � �. � � , . ... . , , ,� , �� �,. � � �: � . � - � �, �� -� ,. ^ _ '�..'T-:""-_"' " �' � ` . . � � �. � o . .�r� . � . : . a � � : .F�B9 =19T2 . � _ . ; � � �rY ��v�v�r►c� �u�►t�w �"n . S�i�nt Pa+�1. N1iar�cr�► : _ ; �� � � � ,� .��. � � � � _ "�` '�+�.�+�f��e d�� :����� � :w : �`�. - . , -� :: , . � _ _ ...y� . .. , ^� ..-. �. y . �M "�' `t` M �' .� � ra 4 4 h"-.: 2 _ � rr 3 �.�� � � �`.�.•c.^ �.`�«r � �L7�� 'S b � .�r 1�* � y „.«F '�^"" � •�,C y ,�^«i� �� rv M�Y � ,�,�j,��*.a+ � '3�,.� ��� »+7^x-ine�>"�a j n�', � I I �i" � a a�� � ,�, ° '1� 's '"�."x ,�',�'y:�w:°�. ��^ "'��"�,""`�"T�' i ���; .�a.r 'F� Y..0 r:-�+� y: �*`�,i� �^' "`,.���4'?'a� i..�:, j.�e� 1 �i:"�'-•w�- �j -'�� ,., .. � ,.,-,e. +.�-a` �" �: p'�.wP�e, rb».R+,xe y} ?��.lE�. ., �h '��, �����""! � •- r r c^ � v,sn* � �,.' "�•� ��`i� ^;t.u k��i��''�:t +..."-� ir _ ,� . . t� .. .-� * T * ��_.t"",y" ��.�• � s�'"' �:a�a^m�u.*'...�e�e r�-:r�s}w .. �Z„���3 ��~� ._Y.. �;�� i�,-�:"-f�.T4+ z��''' _ �:.n x' -a�„�:' '°� ;.,, Y a ,,, = P I •. i 4 .� � 'd � I ... i � + f '. �.? � � � 'Y �-�.d `k6 �1 . �-.M }{�'n+'� i ,:•t , ; �. �, 4` � ! ,�.yt'k ,j �k h�' �',�' '� h �'.� � .. � � '� .. ' . . .. , .; � .. _ �y _ , � �. ,a � � � `�tiJ. ,. . �e..,s4.a. , .. , . . : . , _�' . . _ „_, . .,.... ... ...._.._ v . .. . . i„�' .< .,,W. �� :: . �- ;. . � . _. .�.W.�� ...,�u. ,-.� n .»_ ,. . . _ _ . . . ... ,: � , .- ti+ ; ��. .,. .. r ,';� �_,......mi�.,.�r..+x�- ..._ff';v—...a_a� , ..... _.. . ... . . �; �. ;�x; .��� '.1ew#�a*�:'-�i,.�:, �. .:• '.'ri '4 .Ae 1� E"'I� �`��.�ae�iSa._..d..�"1� {�� . i f F.M , .. ..,'+ •. .s�P `1�. ' .d5.f" . .�._ _ .,, . . ....r. _<. ,, ,.. .. .__ ..� < _. , . _ y" •}x 'r� '.�,. � •'.y'