257684 ORIGi1iAL TO CtTY CL6RK � ��J h j��
� 4 CITY OF ST. PAUL FOENCIL NO. v��
j . � OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK
� U IL OLU ON--GENERAL FORM
PRESENTED !Y
COMMISSIONE ATF
RES�L�BD, That Land Ho, Inc. , b� aad hereby is granted
a per�it to constrnct a 254-car parking lot to be nsed in
conjnnction with apartmentss on property located on the ea�t
side of Westminster Stre�t between Cottage and Hyacinth
Streets, more particalarly described as �ollows:
Lots 34, ��, 42, and 43, and the �orth
75 ft. of $ot 27, d. W. Baas Acre Lots=
all in aecordance with plans dated Received February 12, 1971f
subject to the condition that said applicant-permittee, aad
its s�ccessors and assigns, shall make dne conpliance with all
applicable prowiaions of m�tnicipal ordinanecs, state st�t�tes
and rnles and regnlatio�s of public a�thorities h�ning
cog�iza.nce.
.�
�
�
_
0
0
w
> �.
.._._._ .
�
¢
� MAR 14 1972
c� a
� COUNCILMEN Adopted by the Council 19—
. Yeas Nays
�: MAR 14 1972
�[ Conway App 19—
�
Levine � Tn Favor
Me�eed�r
Sprafka v Mayor
�►g'81I18t
Tedeaco
Mr. Vice President Meredith PItBUSHEO MAR 181972
��
, e
. ' .
�'BOARD OF ZONING, CITY OF ST. PAUL
1010 COMMERCE BUILDING • ST. PAUL,MINNESOTA 55101 • PHONE: 223-4151
February 8, 1972
��� R
Mr. Harry E. Marshall
�v�
City Clerk
Room 386 City Ha11
St. Paul, Minnesota 55102
Dear Sir:
This is written in response to the appeal and application for a permit
by Land Ho, Inc. for a setback variance and a permit to construct a 254-
car parking lot to be used in conjunction with apartments on property
located on the east side of Westminster Street between Cottage and Hyacinth
Streets. This property is further described as follows:
Lots 34, 35, 42, and 43, and the north 75 ft. of Lot 27, J. W.
Bass Acre Lots.
This matter was heard at the January 20, 1972, Board of Zoning public
hearing, at which time the staff reports were summarized for both the
appeal and the permit application. A letter from the Traffic Engineer
was read and is quoted in the minutes.
The staff commented on the appeal by noting that the variances requested
affect unimproved Edgemont Street frontage and that if the several parcels
across Edgemont not owned by the appellant are developed residentially,
this setback variance of 88.88% may affect these properties.
Mr. 0'Toole, attorney for the appellant, said that Land Ho, Inc. would
never petition to improve Edgemont because the cost would be prohibitive;
and, since Land Ho, Inc. owns most of the property, other ownerships along
Edgemont Street do not represent enough signatures to petition for the
improvement of Edgemont Street. He oontinued by explaining that a vari-
ance would allow more of the site to be used as open space.
Subsequently, a motion to recommend approval was seconded and carried by
a vote of 3 to 1.
Very truly yours,
/��C�(�-���/"wt
./�%��
Peter J. Maietta
Secretary, Board of Zoning
PLR/br
�y
Z. F. 7121 and 7295 �� -�--
�i
� (/�
C�
i
,
. • ,' . .� y�
� �
� �� �� ��
�� � � " r�� v
� TERRANCE S. O'TOOLE �. � �
ATTORNEY AT LAW � � �
COMMERCE BUILDING �
SAINT PAUL. MINNESOTA 55101
222-5539
December 2, 19'71
The Honorable Mayor and
City Council
c�o City Clerk
Room 386 City Hall and Courthouse
Saint Paul, Minnesota ,5,5102
Gentlemen:
a. The name of the Applicant is LAND-HO INC .
b . The telephone number is 646-3158 .
c. The legal description of the property is as follows :
Lots 34, 35, 42, � 43 of J. W. Bass Acre Lots
d. Two blocks North of Maryland Avenue and two blocks
East of Highway 35W.
e . The property is empty at the present time.
f. The proposed us of the property is the contructing
of an apartment building consisting of 135 units .
g. Variance on the set back on Edgemont Avenue so that
the garage may be 3 ft , from the line on Edgemont and
that the building may be 22 ft, instead of 2'7 ft , The
open parking may be 82 ft, �in stead of 132 ft ,
�
h. That because of the design of the building and the
amount of clear space afforded, this variance is necessary
in order to meet the full set back requirements on
Westminster Street, which the front side of the build ing is
facing, and Edgemont Street, which is non-platted.
i. Cite section of Ordinance appealing under : Legislative
o e a� Section , D 3 Paragraph � -
,ZO�i���� ����: ���-
Yours very truly, ;
.�-,•rz�.�--�'�, D "T��_�_
Terrance S. O � Toole
. _ ,
�� A
Y CITY OF SAINT PAUL
MINNESOTA
DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE
113 CouA Nouse 55102
January 28, 1972
.
City Clerk
386 City Hall
File X1165, Page
You are hereby notified that a public hearing will be held in the Council
Chambers of the City Hall and Court House in the City of St. Paul at 10:00
a.m. on February 9, 1972 on the application of Land-Ho, Inc. for
1) a permit to install a 254-car parking lot for apartments, and
2) an appeal of the above to vary the• set back requirements of the
Legislative �oning Code, both of the above on the property
described as follows;
Lots 34, 35, 42 and 43 and the North 75 feet of Lot 27, J. W. Bass Acre
Lots. The property is located East of Westminster Street between East
Cottage and East Hyacinth Avenues.
For further information, contact the Planning Board, Room 1010 Coc�snerce
Building or telephone 223-4151.
To comply w.ith the City Charter, the Department of Finance is charged
with informing you of this public hearing.
If you have any questions, it is recommended that you attend this public
hearing to afford you the oppartunity to make your views, both pro and
con, known to the City Council.
ROSALIE L. BUTLER
Commissioner of Finance
• � f
. . � ��.. q���_ . .
�a�'��
�"'
:�Iotice ven that a pub2lc
11�aring �� before Ci�y
C»uncil O' -�I'34'ebxµarY� },p7$,
C��f bes iu x�e
mattei+ �: �ot�ve� dn-T�e
te+ I�a�d-Ho. inc„
St P�aul � �Cl
,for � '�y
m ;�� 8nd��
���. � �::i�, ��fasa,Acte
I Aven�, �,� : and R. BY�ciuth
� 9 " � �
I Ds ,�;.,�,w � �
,��- �Y����;,
��._'��
�
, •
. , � � � City of Saint Paul, �innesota � ��i I
APPLICATION FOR SPECIAL COUNCIL USE PERMIT I �I�
(Please print or type) i� 1� D
I d'�
TO THE I�NORABLE MAYOft AND CITY COUNCIL � 1��'�
% the City Clerk �
City of Saint Paul, Minnesota
Application is hereb made to remodel or reconstruct an existing
y install and operate a new (cross one out)
� FILLING STATION
No. of islands and pumps :
No. of tanks and capacity:
� PARKING LOT for (customers) (employees) (private use) (public use) (other)
�apartment tenants) (indicate type)
Capacity of parking lot 254 Parking spaces
To be used in connection with: construction of an apartment building
wi uni s .
� MISCELI,ANEOUS:
(indicate type such as Drive-in Refreshment Stand, Used Car
Lot, Dry Cleaning Pick-up Station, Ice Vendor, etc.)
Capacity of parking area:
*Location : 2 blocks north of Maryland, on the east side
of the Street.
Legal Description : Lot s 34, 35, 42, � 43 Block Addition
J. W. Bass Acre Lots.
Applicant's Name : LAND-HO INC.
Home or Office Address: 186'7 Carroll Avenue, Saint Paul, Minnesota
Phone Number : 64b-315$
FOR/�THE APPLICANT,
��
I �� �-�O_�� � ..
(Signature) (date
Address . 511 Commerce Building
Phone No.: 222-5539
When completed: file three copies of this application form and three prints oY
the preliminarq lay-out plans of the proposed facility with tbe City Clerk,
Room 386, City Hall and Court House, Saint Paul, Minnesota
Z-3 6/11/56
*EXAMPLE: 1. S.E. corner of Main St. and First St.
2. South side of Main St. between First and Second St.
, � ,
. .
� City of Saint Paul, l�innesota•
. �
' APPLICATION FOR SPECIAL COUNCIL USE PERMIT
'�, (Please print or type)
,. TO THE I�ONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY (70UNCIL
96 the City Clerk
C1ty of Saint Paul, Minnesota
Application is hereb made to remodel or reconstruct an existing
y install and operate a new (cross one out)
� FILLING STATION
No. of islands and pumps :
No. of tanks and capacity:
� PARKING LOT for (customers) (emplo e s) (private use) (public use) (other)
��� ����� (indicate t�pe)
Capacity of parking lot $$� Pi�� �t�',►it'�Om
To be used in connection with: ��t��i@� Qr � ap��tt bu�.ld�qg
6.
� MISCELI,ANEOtJS:
(indicate type such as Drive-in Bef reshment Stand, Used Car
Lot, Dry Cleaning Pick-up 3tation, Ice Vendor, etc.)
Capacity o� parking area:
*Location : � b2c►�c,pi t��tth o�," �apyl�mdi 4�; ttts ��s side
+�P th�r �trae�t.
Lega1 Description : Lot�t $4���s �$� �r 4,� Block Addition
3. i�. �� �,ora I�o��e.
Applicant's Name : L�D�� j1�C.
Home or Office Address: 1�5� �#t'rtall 11V�qilil* 3�It3�� Pst�l.� �tg��ltll�pti
Phone Number : bdb—�1$$
FOIt/�TRE APPLICANT,
� �I". � �%6�e ��28— 1
(Signature (date
Address : ,�1�. CC�t�Ctm $ti�1t�,�,ts�
Phone No.: Z�:$��5�9
INhen completed: file three copies of this application form and three prints of
the prelimiaary lay-out plans of the proposed facility with tbe City Clerk,
Room 386, City Hall and Court House, Safnt Paul, Minnesota
Z-3 6/11/56
*EXAMPLE: 1. S.E. corner of Main St. and First St.
2. South side of Main St. between First and Second St.
zoNi�� ��iE �
�.� �
__-�� _ I ! � c'
"� � 1 �
� . I
___ _. __.
� __;�A � _�'
i
,q _ �, , ,
k 1 r! ` �
__:('' _:..._ . ' .. i....
I
�,► � _- - :_ --_ __..� �+{-
-
; ,
� S 0 0� , ;
_. 9 __-_r -�.9£ . _ ..% , ,
�
. i � i
� � ;
i .� �
, :._ _.�_ _ .�_. __ � . __. , ;
. _,..� ;
_ T �.____._____�_ ,
� � �,
� � `� � ; 1
�
.
. .
� � ;
' _.�_. a ;
__......_,._ .____� ____.._ � � ,
� ,Otd � i i
' � �
� , '� � ,i�
Z � : � � ' !
� , i
. G �
� � � ' '�a
' ,,�i
. � � � +, i;
� � '
� . �;
=,�, i °i
� �__�� ! / � `N` j ' �
. . � - , �
;� � • , :
� � � � - ; � ;
� ,o � o ; � � �
, . �
i P ' �,,�i ';
� s�.s_L:,..W-a�..�. ..._��.�..�..Y.-.- a � . ; . ,{
� ¢ ' 4 �
' � Q _ �. � � i
_-�_ . � �,
_� _ � «� . � �'° M,n i (
' Z • __ � -�; (� �. �� � �
� _._ yG ._ r . ! ! F"i" ; `+�c � +! j ��
1 � � " • .. ; � � i �
. -__ •C) . I � , O
' :�---_ oQ.. _. '" o; '' � W � ' ,' a i �
� � � i �; � � f ,t ��
; ; i ,p. :___.. �.._ ._ , � ; � �{ I!
� ' + � � ; � ; � �` ;� � �� ��-
��_.. .. _ W .. . .
� ' .� � v5 ' � �.y� � �1 �j
� t
, � _ � ,� 41 ,
d , �� - , � I
� � �„ a
� ��.�.;�:� ,
. � �, , . i ,i
� ��... I., _�__u-°-�'p ' � r _ a � ��.y � r.� ; �1
� �n �n d' O +! �
� 4n �n � { „�
�N � �.� _ �. �ic ,� � W
.�._ �.._�.. � � �. ; uu : ` �I � d
j � �o � _ ,� � �- ' �, a— �
� � , ��
,
� � � _ � � � � • �, �� �,
� _ �
j _ � . �
: , . � � � � .._
. _ �
� . ,
,_... �y, , � i
; 7� N _ ' ' _ � �� � ��
� �, � ; � � ,
~ 1 �
' -- � m r . __ �� - ' �.
` � ' �� � �
f a ` � � - � �
* �.
, -
� !
, , t� I
� �
� _ . _ c� ,' .��, ; ,� � �
� � . _ _- ..
�, 1_ Z �: • _ ._ , i � { I
�
. Y � __ � � ; � �
j ` � ._..._. � ; i
' , -q1 , i
� ._ __ _ �
� �'' t�t� � � �i
:...,.. ry ;
r - -+ � \,/ ti � � ���
7� � � 0 "L� _-"` _ �
rSl� 0 00�' ,Sl ` � ! ;
� , I
r �t.�...._4x�.�-.� � ��,
�` ��.. _ . � {.
% �l�,' ��..�� �� r � {;
'' �� c�°' � � ���I I
� �i�
\ jt ��,_� � � D
, , ,
� � � I ���-� �?
; � � j � �
''i ; f� i � \r ��
,1 li � � ' � � S i
�
�
��
'� i4. t �' � O
. � � , , �
: : � _ �� � � � 'z
�
� a��,�,o'oL ��� ,�� � � � ��
'F ir � ! �
� � ! �
__ _-_ --_ _. . F I f
+ ~ -t� r' `..r..-_°+ i j
--y- --� � ��--r----� �`jk '- ""`� � i . j ,
. � � . � � + t , � i
< + �
� �
' ; i .�'-}, r'�: +� 1 � . . : �
.__�..-�.�. ... .__.._ ...- ; . ., . :
. ... , . � . . j .
r. , t� �y `
,.
�. � " ,
� i
..._.._.. . . ,_ . _. t 3-ean�..��',.�ID.pk'�,
,'� - . ,.,.. ,_..,�mg..+.vaa exa._er s-...a..�...s,..._> w. �
.., � _ . i .i. .. ,.y. •:,;�, ,s .� ..tu..�„e .,.m.c"4w�„aar I2 u.«.k.av.r,;,.
! , ::�.n�,< .p.....__ � ,y1, .
. ;.., .;. ...
r .. :,
-�-- 'fr— \_'. � . . � .. �.. , '
� � �� � � �
3�.�r,1�j1J # ;` �; ' �
5 _ _,_ �__�...�.. ---t- ' �, , ; � ' , � �— �
��y _ � 1 ; � ' ,� �
; � + ; ; ; �
' ' ' � ' + ;
; { � �
i j j �� r� � � ,
� � „� .._ ,��_...__.. � ,G�
. ,,__.� !
�y _� __ `'h�� � � �,� ' ? ��` -
�' �)'OF: �'�� . °' ;
����� �.. � �� �i � � �'� �
�I' � �
z "' � {
1 ' '
_.__.�,._ �CJ; E �
_ _ _ �,
__ , _,. ____ �-.�`...—��'w, ' � �
.
j s � �
<
� . .... _.. . _ . _ ,._.... ,_.J._ .�,
�
, 't..! _ .
{ ,
y � � ;� � ,.:.. ��, �
' , ; � � � � .��,. �
! �' `� �;' �
}"" � N7 C� �.� �:
� �.
W � � � irf i �
� � f� � i � ,5�.
�
� ; � ° � ' ,� �
vy ' '� , � ,+ " �
� � � ; �
� � � � � � �
t��f ' �� � a
� ; �� � �
r.. � �
� �
� � !
{ ,
� � . � ,
1 � �
; �
i I � ,
I � � �
� � � �
� � � ; �
;
; �
� �
� � � `�:�� �
� ►: �
_ ; ' _;j; �
.,� ; t D
i
� �
? � ? /� F.4
� a �' ±A
� . �� �
� , �r �� ��
� ` s � �
,
� ; �' i;
� ��� ��
i i
i ` c�� � �
; ��
i j �
;;;
i ��:
� , :�:
; �
;
;
a
;
x ��
,
_ _. _. _ . , _ , , �:
—,�'
�
; � , � � ,r
; � � �
� ; c� �
� �
; � � �
� _ �
+ , ` �.
� � �
� ;
� ' '
� � � ;♦
I � �
� , ��y� �
- -- _._____._____�_...�.----
�---- ------� `
+ ' ' _ .._..�...�..__,� ....._.____�______..__�y .4
� I !
� I
f
I
i
i
`t
i � :�
i
]
1 �
i j
1 i
f �
� � �
�
i