257681 ORIOINAL TO CITY CLBRK /� /�R�
CITY OF ST. PAUL couNCi< <'r� � u
. OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK N�E NO.
. ` OU RESO TION—GENERAL FORM
PRESENTED BY .
COMMISSIQNE A*F
RESOLVED, Thit Phillip ICaercher be and hereby is
,:
permi���ed to remodel an existing ear wash fseility by
. S
iastallatiou of an additional car w�sh bay aad three gas
p�np islands on property located on the northwest corner
of Frosperity and 6eraaium Streets, Bnore particularly
described as follows:
bots 22 thru 28, Block 2, Kiefer
l�ark Additioa;
all in accordance with plans dated �teceived �aaaarp 18, 1972f
subject to the coadition that said applicant-permittee, and
his suecessors and assiga�, shall make due complianc� with
all applicable provisions of m�nicip�l ordinance:, state
statntes and rules and reg�lations of public anthorities
� � having cognizance.
0
c
> ;.
a �
a o
Q
..:
o a MAR 14 1972
�
COUNCILMEN Adopted by the Council 19—
Yeas Naya
��� vea MAR 14 1972=
� Conway 19—
Levine `� Tn Favor
-�fei�
Sprafka (� Mayor
A gainst
Tedesco
d
•, �i�o President Meredith PUBUSHED MAR 18 1972
�
,:� :
BOARD OF ZONING REPORT AN� ACTI,ON January 20, 1972
� Plat Map 33 � '�";:°
. Acting under Legislative Code Chapter 60 thru 64
-4 ' p�ssed August 22, 1922, as amended to January 27, 1971.
� 7288
.. 1. APPLICANT'S AIAME . Phillip Kaercher 5693 •,
,, 2. CLASSIFICATION . � Amendment � Appeal a PermiC � Other `m
, X-1159
3. PURPOSE , Remodel an existing carwash facility by install- .
ation of an additional car wash bay and three gas pump islands
4. LOCATION . Northwest corner Prosperity and Geranium �
';�,; 5. LEGAL DESCRIPTION : Lots 22 thru 28, Block 2, Kiefer Park
��-:.. �
�; .
6. PRESENT ZONING: Heavy Industry ;�
�:'
� 7. PURSUANT TO Zoning Code Chapter: 60 Section: .23 PBrggraph; 6,b
�
`.` g, STAFF INVESTIGATION & REPORT: Date: 1-10-72 By; ATB �
a, . , ��
• °i�
�;, A. HISTORY: A permit for a coin-operated carwash was granted for this property on
January 23, 1965.
B. AREA ZONING: The area south of Maryland Avenue and west of Clarence Street is '�!;4
+ zoned Industrial. East of Clarence Street the zoning Commercial. '��
�r �.:
� .
;�: C. DESIGN STANDARDS: Revised plans meet design standards.
�.�j D. 1�FONTAGE AND AREA: The aite has a frontage of 122.6 feet on the westerly side .'`
�_
���.: of Prosperity Avenue and 203.55 feet along the north side of Geranium Avenue "'�
,::";', resulting in an area of 29,800 square feet. ��
>
� .;
��:` E. TRAFFIC ENGINEER: The Traffic Engineer notes that the present operation has a %:�
'` traffic flow which is the reverse of that shown on the present plan. He ;
<<. ' �
;�;� recommends approval of the submitted plan.
�,' �: .
" ' , F. SITE CONDITIONS: A four-bay coin operated carwash occupies the property. The
: required parking area was not fully plowed.
�' G. AREA CONDITIONS: Clarence Street intersects Prosperity Avenue at this point. `
`-��i: The Phalen Shopping Center is located east of this intersection. Four filling
stations are located within a three-block area from the site.
�;
� 9. BOARD ACTION: To Recommend � Approval � Denial Council Letter
Dated:
Yeas Na 2-7-72
Moved by : McPartlin ys •
� Ames - Ch. Date of
;y. Seconded by: Benshoof X Cochrane Hearing:
�'.` � X McPartlin 2-10-72
�'� Secretary's remarks: X Maietta
�"�'
-;�;i Mansur Council Action: �
a` X Quast -
X genshoof
Dooley Date:
`� Prifrel .
�� , ; . ' - '� ,' �`, ,�' I � ; �� � i I I ; � I t � � � ��, _ ' � ' �
��, - r , . ` � � � � � f F J � -,', .k,�
�� �� , ! j� i l �2 , �� �� t - �'�
?; , ;;. . - :,, _ ` �� ,� :>,� 1 R S N� rZks �� � :�
; �, � � ' . . � � W � �. � �� y `�
� i . E {� � (� " . �� ��-k� ��
., �` � . . i . . � ' / I � � ',O `'� � �� l � .� �y
r�.. � � i . �� � 1
� � . � .. �.. _ � s �; ,
\ .'`\ . ( � ' , ' 2 4 ?L v i 4 :�
. . � \ , ` (,�• • .:z
, •-
. , ► � � � ; � eoM4 � �
\ � , ' , i J � � � (� �
. �
� � , � � _ �'� O � ,
. � � , . , , �
..
� �
fs: . �� i��1 �R Y L A (� D ��;
� —--- �---�---, --- , � -, � �t �' � � ; ��'' � �7 � " �
� ' � �-., �', �-''� � , i �
„ f` � a!�uT ,nr�uS� y � �
�� , � `, '`
1 �----..`
. ,
- ', ; , ,• �, f., •,
. , � ------ . ,
. .. f . . . f � � � - .
.
`� �. , . �1 . � .......�. . .. � , y . _. r . . ��� ��
♦ �� � �
E� ' . , t`' � ,r, `' �{ � , � . � � � �.a
.
, .� � . �
-. . . �. ; � � � , � ;�
.,.� . , . . . ., �� � 1 ' ,i�' . • � . `/ � � , �,���r, . _ . . �S(+1 .•1
v�
�
y,-. � �". �l\• �..,_. r
- �,(���,� � ,l(' ,� � ._..._...__l. 'Q. , A R �. ;y
��' . `V' � ` � � � � ::�
��..A� ��� � .�. , r"�i �•� �,.�` ! ` � � � � � � ,Z, - --- � `( ___._ �'`i
= �� --� � / ' ��-, � � � �
\ . „ � I., y �,�
, , � �.,, � _� ./ ;
� . {/-�.� �, . � -.�� ; � ` . , � ♦ 2 ( Q, _"` ;
��' � � � �'`t ��" - �'� ��� �� rn ��� � _ � !�� �_ � � ��. � � ��
, `� . 1,. f' . , t� _--__� �G
e , _ �� � V�� ___.____,—__1�l_._ _ _ r� �v�;r;
� , ,'' ; � ,,, , , � r • �
� .
� "' ' ° f" � f(` �; 'I � 1 ' � . `� V V ` �-�,
' .. � � '� �� , � I � '.,:`
'� ( � .� � . ,^, �J; '; ` ,,I � �;�
� \ � ` , .'� ;- �:� r., ��.� � :: C � F; �� R; ! U ,, + ,`1, , �
4�. � � � ' i . �,.�` r �' �•� ( I `/ • /\\ / ' 0 '�
� � � ,��
''-� � � . ���. � � `� E... .,� � " �� �/ ♦(� � 1�,, � � V � '-�
��, , . � ... ' `� ,.. "'� . . . � � ���,
�h' , . + ; �, ' . � 1 . + _ .._ � ��} � J ( �
�,. . .. . �`; \�+ � ' �i G,� � ��Q'` ,�
�_ �� � , , r. � ,} � f� �' J � � ��,
� , . . f.. '', �. , ,n. , 1 O O '� � P o ,.
� ;. ,. , , �' " �. ; I� i_ � �,i a ( ��,.
, .� F' �• � � � I 1 '"`. � � � \
'', . ` 1 � - _,� // � �,
� . .
, At—�l�,����� 1 YliilliF� Kaercher �,t,'j��� �' � ���
.��` �lnst�all and operaCe a coin-operated car ����� 1 ���
�•� PUf�C��.��
�.'��. w�ish and fillin�; station with 3 ��ump islands . « ��
` o o�v�-r�r��i�Y ��
,�d
;;�t �
���.Pr�E��f�T Z0�"��f��lG »�<��y i„<����tr-y -U- TI��Jn-Fl-1f�.�1[_`�
�
, Tf-�f�EE- ��r��.ilLY i
� PE 1 I'1"(���! �(Ci'��i��S -�-. � ��
�;
FC�U @-f"r.�:���:�E.,Y '��
�; T� ����1!_.°i I-� �� ".:�t��r �
� 1 �RT4� � a n C�►�'�rd'�.�;C,!�=;L `.�
�`FILC f�!a �?��
�;,�A � � If�[�J�TEYl�it�
_ � u \/faC��i �,
'', St. Pa� I t'lanni�c� Board Dat�� i-�o-�� ��'`� r �: � "�
, ��� Prop�r�y Uncf�r Cc�sic���a�io� .:'�
,
, MINU�'ES OF THE PfJBLIC HBARING BEF'ORE THE RQA12D OF ZON�
� �N TIiURSL�AY, .I.FlbliIfi� Z0, 147�, AT 2:G0 P"eMe
pRESENT: Mrs. Cocbrane and Mrs. Qnast, aad Messrs. McPext�.�.n, Mafetta and BeQShoof
of the Board; snd Mro �tisettex �nd Be Reitter of the staff.
PHILI.TP KAERGHSR (7'288ys An application far e perm3t to iastiall a coiu-operated
carwash with a filli.ag stat�on with �h�ce� gump islauds.
`The �pplicaat wes nat present se the heerin�«
Mra Rasetter g�mri�ed the ataff repart, a p�rt of the fil�, bq noting that the
carwash is preseatly opersting �ritho�t aa attend�nt on dutp. The applicant 'has indi-
c�ted that after �asCellatioa of th� antomatic washiag ma�chinery aad the gasoline
service f�ciLity, an eteendant will b� reqtxired, not omly fos pumping gs�s, but for
operating [he w�shiug machit�erp. �e proposed lacation of the gasoline pnmps did
not germit smooth ope�ation of the facili�y�. The plans were returnsd to the appli-
caat with suggested relocaCion of the p�ps amd ath�r changes. Mro Boeetter said
revised pls�s h�ve aow been received which provide the changes requeeted. Se poin�ed
out on tiie map the tzaffic flow an.d s:�id th� �ataff'a concerr► was that ehe traffic
flaw had been reverB�d from thst stiawe on Che pl�n for th� originsl carwash develop-
m�nic wit1� the cars mow drivin� directly 3nto the b�ys. He noted that the reviafone
to this pl�rt call for au "out oniy" drive and a�a "in only" drive which directs txaffic
to the rear of �he b�ailding wher� at�cking space ia provided �nd where gas pumgs are
proposed to be ias��lled. �e said he thought �tiat wi�h the g$�s pe�mp� where they* ares
the psoposed �raf£ic flow c�oe�ld be observed.
Mro Maietta poiated o�t thnt ther� was snother carwash 8cross the street and two fill-
ing atatioas, He �aid the C�ty shouLd do some reseerch on th� filling statfa�n-carwash
buaine�e ssd make sa�me xestrict�ons rla.�t �muld a�a�d up 3.�a court.
It was pointed out ths� �he ar�s wss pre�eustly soned to r�llc�wr Che sabject cerwas�i end
filiing staticme
Mr, McparLl£n moved th�t the permfit be �pprov�d, �ubject to the a�ww planso Mro Beashoof
s�coaded ehe moCion. � motiau carried by a vote of 5 to 0.
Submitted by: Appsoved bq:
Psul Lo Boaetter Mrs. Carolyn Cochr�tne
br
' . ,
• City of Saint Paul, �innesota
� . APPLICATION FOR SPECIAL COUI�CIL USE PERMIT
� (Please print or type)
TO THE HONORABLE 11�AYOIt AND CITY COUNCIL
96 the City Clerk
Citq of Saint Paul, Minnesota
Application is hereby made to remodel or reconstruct an existing
(crosa one out)
� FILLING STATION
No. of islands and pumps :
No. of tanks and capacity:
QPARKING LOT for (customera) (employees) (private use) (public use) (other)
(indicate type)
Capacity of parking lot
To be used in connection with:
� MISCELI.ANEOUS: (:O� O�U� Oi� WOO�1
(indicate type sucb as Drive-in Refresbment Stand, Used Car
Lot, Dry Cleaning Pick-up 3tation, Ice Vendor, etc.)
Capacity oP parking area: �0 f,lal�
*Locatioa . NOtth W�1tt Ct�t�c O� pe�p�tlEl► aud G��[aYtiWID
Lega1 Descriptioa : Lot ZY � ZS Block � Addition ���
Patk
Applicant's Name . p� ��K
Home or Office Address: 15�b E. IVX
Phone Number ; �Z$"7���
FOR✓BY APPLI
(Si re (date
Address : 9 w'apsata Slvd., A�plt. , Ml�. 55�05
Phone No.: 377-0216
When completed: file tbree copies of this application �orm and tbree prints of
the preliminarq lay-out pians of tHe proposed facility with the City Clerk,
ftoom 386, Citq Hall and Court House, Saint Paul, Minnesota
Z-3 6/11/56
*EXAMPLE: 1. S.E. corner of l�ain St. and First St.
2. South side oP Main St. between First and Second 5t.
���'�
zo��N,� � :�-=
_�....�
F�� :...��., ,..
. ' �1't
� City of Saint Paul, l�innesota f � I
, APPLICATION FOR SPECIAL COUNCIL USE PERMIT � 1
� (Please print or type) ��' � C �
TO'THE I�DNORABLE MAY08 AND CITY OOUNCIL ��
96 the City Clerk
City of Saint Paul, Minnesota
Application is hereby made to re��°�econstruct an existing
(cross one out)
� FILLING STATION
No. of islands and pumps :
No. of tanks and capacity:
� PARKING LOT for (customers) (employees) (private use) (public use) (other)
(indicate type)
Capacity of parking lot
To be used in connection witb:
� MISCELLANEOUS: Coin operated car wash
(indicate type sucb as Drive-ia Befreshment Stand, Used Car
Lot, Dry Cleaning Pick-up Station, Ice Vendor, etc.)
Capacity of parking area: 40 Cars
*Locatioa . North West corner of Prosperity and Geranium
Legal Description : Lot 22 th.ru 28 Block 2 Addition Kiefer
Park
Applicant's Name � phillip Kaercher
Home or Office Address: 1525 E. Ivy
Phone Number : 725-7238
FOR,C� APPLICANT,
�
�.� � /Z- - (-
(Si ture) (date
Address : 809 Wayzata Blvd. , Mpls. , Minn. 55405
Pboae No.: 377-0216
When completed: file three copies of this application form and three prints of
the preliminary lay-out plaas of the proposed facility with the City Clerk,
ftoom 386, City Hall and Court House, Saint Paul, Minnesota
Z-3 6/11/56
*EXAMPLE: 1. S.E. corner of Main St. and First St.
2. South side of Main St. between First and Second St.
,
S - '
. � CITY OF SAINT PAUL
.
. r MINNESOTA
DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE
113 CouA House 55102
.1aau+ary 28, 19�2
City Clerk
386 City Hall
File X1159, Page
You are hereby notified that a public hearing �aill be held in the Council
Chamber8 of the City liall and Court House in the City of St. paul at 10:00
a.m. on February 10, 1972 on the application of Phfllip Raercher for a
permit to instali and operate a coin-operated car wash and filliAg station
with 3 pump islands on the property described as follows: Lots 22, 23
24, 25, 26, 27 and 28, Block 2, Riefer Park. The property is locat�d
on the Northwest corner of ProsperiCy Avenue and East Gerani�a Avenue.
For further information, coatact the Planaing Boerd, Roaa 1010 Ccmtnerae
Building or telephone 223•4151.
To coonply with the City Charter, the Deparanent of Finance is charged
with iAforming you of this public hearing.
If you have any questians, it is reconmended that you attend thi� public
hearing to afford you the opportunity to make your views, both pro and
ccm, k�awn to the City Couacil.
xOSALIE L. BUTLSR
Caamissioner of Finance
' I � � �� :�� ; �
:� , �
I: �� � .� � �i i I �
;; ; j :'� � ` � !
;; _ � ; � � � �� �A � �
,, � �
, ;_.__._._ _,_-� �-
,; , t� �
' : -� �
�i � -+� ' t-`�l � � ' �'
�
�' �---- ,--��--- . � _ '"' � (
r� � � �� � F�� i i � i
`� � ' ; o- N � :� � '1 � y, � :�
,� � � i ; _ _ a ��
.
`.f � �1J � t>: ' � �1 �� �F r`` � � ��: � �
! , t �c, c.1 N , c' � "`. I
-. ;
I . ' -
�
„ ,
; � � , . _ ; t
.
�_
, , �
� �
: M r i • ti N � � �
� I i ' ' ; � � Lu U � ; ,°� J'� ' _
i { i � �' � ;,., _<�,. � r� , � -� � ,� ' � r�' i
L � 'i � �.- .�.. , 1 .�.- � �� ��� L''� I
, _ r � : � b ; (
; -��— �
�. �" `�'
! i � "N _ � ' x � �
� � � � '�� . � �� � � � � �_ ,�
j I 1' � (►.� ' --- - �.�� k . �,,•
ti' I I, � /o' � , 2 ;:',. ..,: a,- �
U � � � � ; �
� � �
;� � � N �� _
�4,� ` } „� � � ,v � � 1
i �' ' "' '�
� io' ';� �.
- • �.: ,.�
rr �
: ;; �,� �
;._ _ � � :� I
t :� � ��
- - --- -__.. , +� � !
� -- - -- � �
-� �� .:.,�..,,�,, - � 1� -,,t
, � , i !o^ ,
,
I r; � � � ` � �
-�. �
� �i i
� i-, o I. �
�, - W :..� �
' � � �- � , �� ? �
f � . if ,
,�
,
_ h !
� � � '
� � � �� � � �
I� '! i
t; �
�� � t
�' �__�_ ; . �' - � � � i �
r � �
�
�, � �. .
! , ;j '
i � � + � � � � �
� �` i �I ^ �
.,\\ � �!;1 � ,i'l �1 � � �t
\.� u '. � . ,b � �� /,�,, I.
�' �:� X ,l � - I" I
� -i '\, , 4 +
� d � � � �
« \ � \ • � ? ! �
V�, � 1
� .
..•. _ . . ` � i
��.
, � a f
.,.. ..� �� f� � �
'-\ ,, . � �_ __
� ' '
� ` �
.:�� � ��� �
_�_ ��-, �� , � ' � �
�� � ,:. � � �
� Q � < �
�( �_� �� � - � � �' �
; ,��� � � ;. �,� /' \ �� � ;
�a:� � � � ���.� \ � ` � 4' $ '�� 1
� ,� � � /C 1
� ��� ,.�� ,/' �1i �� �
� 4
�� �..
�, �-' �� � ?� �
��' � �-�,� � � '° � �; ��
w� " �` '`,�, � ,
��„ ��/.
�".-�'� � . \
, � �,.� � �' � i, '�.._.____ -
� ,�� � �, ��,.,:` �
.� •��
1"°° s�� �- �=, �-�
� ` =� �� ___.�. ' --�.-.—
'7 ��J � �"t'��_.. %
?`1
� G� � �
l�s `" � ►� G—il
°t' �, � o — .
-____
�¢�
l► `"'�
,; � >..,
c:�e :: .,r..._.�, _._._
�,n � ��._._..__.__ __ __._�._
z� "O
� � �
/� L�C .E'_�_
� 7�.____----__.-______--__----- .__ -- -- ---- �-�- ---_ �... _._._ _ �:.. __
_ _ . . .
l__.._,.._.'_J L:_ _=-1 t_:_I t=_-_-� r- r�--,-� 'l �.;_:i G_.---t ( ._J � _._.._J ' ,.. i --- . --
� �.i� ��;{ , - _ . ._..
. ..�_ l 1 ! � . 1 c:�..
;�.- r---- -__-, -�
� f�4",�'rr .� �a�r w+e�►'� vt� rs 1 -- .;3'�.n , .
�, �7 ; i_ C
9 " ��
• , 6 ,�' q
; '� " + �,.�. .Y.....
� -� � "` f � _ -+��:,
, , :�__, .,,;_ -
, j ; - .,� • . -�
! t � � .• ' .. � i� .
� �'`- ��l..�i=; : . /o ; �� • ' -.o" .r
' ry _ � _._.__
,
� �� .�.._. �� i,f" - � !
, a� . . �6 ,�, # 7
� _
�I '� �r 2 0 � � �¢�v ��' �
f !i _.__ ; � � '� ' i
I '� " � `
� l+ ,
i � ��
` ' n �z z� � ����+ � i �2.5
M{ :�
� � _ ` ? +
�i r� 2� � �? � � � 2�,' � � �y _---z�,
N� � �
„
� . �, �
,
� _._._._..._.L_____ ` _.
� r
�
4 �
� _ .�� 3 2 �'./_ _ a °
1 -----__,_ _ � .
.
� . . . .. . ___. .___. .. _.... .._.._.. _ ._._. . . 3:+,+.. ,
I ; � i �� <��� � y� �. �
�
_ ,
.
� 7 . ' '
_. _ __ �
; _ _ _ _ __ _.___ _____.----___...____�
� - � �� �`� � � �_____
� r ►.._._ __ _._ ____ ._.____..__.__.
,
; y
� ____ ___
�--- , r , i � - _ _
_ .
_. _._L _.__ t ._":.__:J 1'. _ t i_"" --�1 L.__----� ' --_] L._ __: .IS ' __l 1: ,--_I � _ , �-._
----- — ___._ ____`_.��..
__� � _
�.. ^-i S..,,.
_i--,. U��_�i1-�r,.���.__.t�_�'..�.;L�.;��r--, ..
REVISION DATE