02-716ORIGI(�A.L
Presented By
Referred To
Council File # � �. � � l (�
Committee: Date
.._ _,�
WHEREAS, Chapter 293 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code was
enacted to regulate the subject of noise in the City of Saint
Paul; and
WHEREAS, §293.11 provides for the granting of variances from
the sound level limitations contained in §293.09, upon a finding
by the City Council that fu11 compliance with Chapter 293 would
constitute an unreasonable hardship on an applicant, other
persons or on the community; and
WHEREAS, Rolling River Music and Film Festival, represented
by Mick Sterling, co-founder, who has been designated as the
responsible person on the application, has applied for a variance
to allow sound for live music at Harriet Island and Raspberry
Island between September 18 and 22, 2002; and
WHEREAS, applicant is seeking a variance for various hours
on each of these dates; and
WHEREAS, if applicant is not granted a variance it will not
be able to present the event; and
WHEREAS, the Office of License, Inspections, and
Environmental Protection has reviewed the application and has
made recommendations regarding conditions for the variance; now,
therefore, be it
RESOLVED, that the Council of the City of Saint Paul hereby
grants a variance for September 18, 19, 20, 21 and 22, 2002 to
Rolling River Music and Fi1m Festival, subject to the following
conditions:
1) The variance for music at Raspberry Island
shall be for the hours of 6:00 p.m. to 10:00
p.m.on September 18, 2002; from 6:00 p.m. to
10:00 p.m. on September 19, 2002; from 6:00
p.m. to 10:30 p.m. on September 20, 2002;
from 6:00 p.m. to 10:30 p.m. on September 21,
2002; and from 7:00 p.m. to 10:00 p.m. on
September 22, 2002.
2) The variance for music at Harriet Island
shall be for the hours of 5:00 p.m. to 9:00
p.m. on September 19, 2002; from 3:00 p.m. to
10:30 p.m. on September 20, 2002; from 1:00
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
��°r�� �
_... .:. f��
2002.
to 10:30 p.m. on September 21, 2002; and
1:00 p.m. to 7:00 p.m. on September 22, d �' 1 "
3) All electronically powered equipment used in
conjunction with the events at Raspberry
Island and on the Great Stairs on Harriet
Island shall not exceed 95 dBA as measured at
50 feet from the noise source. All
electronically powered equipment used in
conjunction with the events at HarrietIsland-
Target Stage shall not exceed 100 dBA as
measured at 100 feet from the noise source
5) The applicant shall provide personnel and
equipment who shall provide continuous sound
level monitoring for the times during which
the variances have been granted on each of
the dates to ensure compliance with Condition
#3.
6) All electronically powered equipment, PA
systems, loudspeakers or similar devices
shall be turned off no later than 10:00 p.m.
on September 18 and 19, 2002; 10:30 p.m. on
September 20 and 21, 2002; and 10:00 p.m. on
September 22, 2002 at Raspberrry Island and
no later than 9:00 p.m. on September 19,
2002; 10:30 on September 20 and 21, 2002 and
7:00 p.m. on September 22, 2002.
FURTHER RESOLVED, that any violation of the conditions set
forth above on any of the dates may result in revocation of the
grant of a variance for the later dates, in addition to any
criminal citation which might issue.
�
OFFICE OF LIEP Date:
xoger curtis, Director July 22 aooz GREEN SHEE o�
266-9013 No . 4 0 3 3 81
1 EPARTHL+NT DIRECIOR ` ITY C09NCZL
� ITY ATtvJRN%Y� ITY CLERR
w�arn
ust be on Council Agenda: � uncam nx IN. & MGT. SVG DIR.
ugust 7, 2002 Public Hearing 3 sox (OR ASSISTANl)
TAI, # OF SIGNATURE PAGES 1 (CLIP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE)
CTION REQUESTED:
hat the Saint Paul City Council grant a noise level variance for September 18,
19, 20, 21 and 22 to the Rolling River Music Film Festival subject to
conditions at Harriet Island and Raspberry Island locations.
COSffgNDATIONS: APPROVE (A) OR REJECT (R) NAL SERVSCE CONTRACT3 MOST ANSNSR THE FOLLOWING:
PLnNNING CO[�IIaISSION CIVIL SERVICE Has the person/fixm ever worked undes' a contract for this departrnent?
CO�IISSION YES NO
Has this person/firm ever been a City employee?�
CIB COMMITTEE BUSINESS REVIEW YES NO
COUNCIL Does this person/firm possess a skill not normally possessed by any
Current City employee?
Boai'd of 2oning _ DISTRICT COONCIL YES NO
laia all YES aaswers on a separate aheet and aYtach.
Appeals
UPPORTS WFIICA COUNCIL OBJECTIVE?
INITIATING pROBLEM, ISSUE, OPPORTUNITY (Who, What, When, Where, Why):
ouncil action necessary to grant noise level variances.
VANTAGES IF APPROVED: Event will be held.
ISADVANTAGES IF APPROVED:
ISADVANTAGES IF NOT APPROVED: Event will not be held.
OTAL AMOUNT OF TRANSACTIOIV $ COST/REVENUE BUDGETED YES N
UNDING SOURCE ACTIVITY NUMBER
INANCIAL INFORMATION: (EXPLAIN)
�g�1C1� ���
��� ����
SUN-20-2002 16�31 57P PARKS & RECRERT?ON
CTTY C}F SATNT PALJL
Rmidy 4 Ke[fy, Ma�wr
612 292 7405 P.01/03
OFFICF QF LiCENSF, MSPECfIDNS wtuo
GNVIRLINMEN'CAL PROTECTfON O�, 1�
RvgerG Gurfk, Direuor
LOWRYPROFESStIINALSUILDING Pe7epAone: 65/-266-90qp
330SFPtlrrSYrceCSv1te300 Facsiisile: 651-ISG912i
SpinlPaul,M(ryqpspfa55102-l570 Web: wwv.ccistpov].mn.lu/4ep
App�ication f�r Sound Level Variance
City of Saint Paul Noise Ordinance
Chapter 293 oFthe Saiut Paul Legislative Code
1. Qr�anization or person seeking variance:�LL/it(� /r/�Z �%�S�C �- r7Gt�
Z. Address: 3 ��� Si �jiir Gl-/LL Sr. Davz ,.ti/f,/ $
3. Responsible person: /�/G� ���Rti�tt�
4. Title or position__ �r1
5. Telephone: ) 852' h3�3
6. BrieQy describ� the noise source and equipment involved; MVS�c j,aLt gE pe�t're+2�c� o,./ � jSySnp
9n n,�r ��s�i-5.,�iQS uv �r /S - z2, ir .��zy T.,� e.� Sta �S z2 �ro �r �9o��2s Qm,�
ON �?DT �✓ f Z �9L7l1C{!�!/ 2L �orGi,�n 4v,hi .t ii�, v l.c.�.,, r�.,..-n.� ...... ..._. .. .. n....r.�
7. Address or legal description of noise
8. Noise source time of operation SCNE�jt4E tiN �lc- 6 �t/et7 �'cV�-izSirG-ir
9. Sriefly describe the steps that wiIl be taken to minimize the noise levets: dc� bt� /i %'7) ii5n� �,� �ry/,�./
��ESs h.�s'�'Sirv.d �ifi, cQ�Ati.r is.�r �t i '-�s�t/� %ts�t�vn. �mGc u�/u7c �riut
1�. Briefly state reason for seekiug va.rianCe; .�__��L1j� � '—
11. I?ates dtu�ing which the wariance is
Signature of respansib[e
�4��ir�
Return coraapleted Applicat' n an $15�4.06 fee t�:
CYT'Y OF SATIYT PAUL
OFFICE 4)F LIEP
350 ST. P�'C'1ER 5'�'REET, 5T77'I'E 300
SA�7VT PAUI.,1�E.�T �53 02-15I9
�6si} 26�-4090
Xlate 6 �.J'� � 2-
noisevar-app R¢viced7l2002
Office Use pnly
Da±e Rce' d.
Reviewed
Da[a ,PUblia Notice Sent
Rcfcaed to Cnuncil
� � � � �,
�
�" `�� — : j�g =r � �: _
.f
�.� P �E
�
o�
�
w
�J� O rLEASAPJT
`� � Rd�ERT
fl � C
A�1C�
� �O �� }
� �G� � � GORMAN Q
O
Q
J
a
�'�b�
,
G � HUMBOLDT �
C9 �
W o p HALL � Y Q w
� p � U STRYKER � m O W r U
F—
a� � m WINSLOW Y � �O � Z�
p U
W o� BI�'JVELL p r
O
�BELLOWS � � Z BELLECREST �
� � � WASECA WASE
z � }
�' w �
d� � �' z
� J � ��'
���� � �`'
�' � �������
�d, S
� ���
���� we�.aa� � wiLK
LEECH �
��i
�o �� y�`, v�'��
� � G �
f9 p O � �DQ�'�!�}IAP�
2 ���� � � � � AI�N
� �, g u� C�
r
� w
z
w � �
> �
C9 F' LIVINGSTON
w
�
O
C�
�����`;
v �
, ;a�,;
�c� O � 1;�J�ST��'�
��, s '� � �
�1� J � � fY e�?
C
Q
' �tS� � � p U g .S, �"
LAWTON �2 m O c�.� � �� � ��J��Q�tNE
-- �G � � � �s� ��'�
° z
OHIO in p
z
Z S WMINOLE �
� � � Q MANOMIN
Y m � °° SMITH z
OTTAWA O
CHEROKEE �
DELAWARE
CHIPPEWA
S1H�13y 33�f0�3H�
RAS�H Q RASH
U �
� Z
� � �
_$, ��� �� ���- „
��,�'�{s: � � ` �
,TM
` #�. ,� ,
b �-'►lk Z
O
�
w Z �
o O
> z
m � c�
z
O
�
�
�
g ��
`� /� .
I - �
L ""
� �I
,���sG S�� S��
�
�
o�._���
b.��r1 �-� - �� �v,� �r /� _ �
�lur� Cl�/nb .�ilr?J S%S�Z�S Br✓ ��fi J��as t�i"J/�r� 1.Si�F�VJ .SiYl�c
� ��3Ei7izy 15G� .S�de t el�!//E S�
o?'DIl �,3-'OV t'- �`� � SOu Ci�� v:✓ �/��y �
5c�►� G�-� � ,M�} P�
.�-��� - l�`OU �? ^� flzAdi��s �✓ Qr�:�y Is�o r-Ma�zs /��
�pUip�c�z nt?dies t MUSrL�
/�/t)(IN : .�JU. �J C�/�-,L� �'✓ N✓lJLEi " �.S(� S�'1'b�
a't�! v. •� : �vu✓J C�uc v�/ �-� �.Yto�� ,S�
�'� �K
��� �Mr
�:d�1 Q n ,
Mus 6�✓ c�G�9'r �� ��1sc`
M!/5iL drv /�gy��i � .�Ytb�
jiU�1 4.i/ /�ls?,�y 25i,s�
/d; 34 ' /�fUSlr t f�UY Eibs
g'�0 ��. '. �uro C� r�� .�x� Zs�
OFFICE OF LICENSE, INSPECTIONS AND ��„ �'1�.V
ENVII20NMENTAL PROTECTION
Rager C. Curtis, Director
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
Rmuly C. xetTy, Mayor
J,�y 1�, aooa
TO
FROM:
SUBJECT:
LOWRYPROFESSlONAL BUILDING Telephone: 651-2669090
350 SL Peter Sireet, Suite 300 Farsimfle: 651-266-9/24
Saint Paul. Minnesota �5102-l510 GYeb: w�w�.cistpauLmn.us/liep
Nancy Anderson, Council Invesrigarion & Research
Room 310, City Hall
Mark Kaisersatt, R.S. �/��
Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection
Sound Level Variance
Roiling River Music and Film Festival --Harriet Island & Raspberry Island
Attached is a sound level variance application from Mick SterIing, representing Rolling
River Music and Film Fesrival, 332 Minnesota St., Suite #W-122, Saint Paul, 55101, to
allow live music and soi:,nd for film projection at Harried Island & Raspberry Island. A
variance for music is requested at Harriet Island for the hours of 5:00 p.m. to 10:00 p.m.
on September 19, 2002; frem 3:OQ p.m. to 1030 pm. on September 20, 2002; from
1:00 p.m. to 10:30 p.m. on September 21, 2002; and from 1:00 p.m. to 10:00 p.m. on
September 22, 20Q2. The variance for music if requested at Raspberry Island for the
hours of S:QO p.m. to 10:00 p.m. on September 18, 2002; from 5:00 p.m, to 10:00 p.m. on
September 19, 2002; from 3:00 p.m. to 1030 p.m. on September 20, 2002; from 1:00 p.m.
to 10:30 p.m. on September 21, 2002; and from 1:00 p.m. to 10:00 p.m. on September 22,
2002.
Enclosed is the copy of the Public I�earing Notice sent to property owners within 200 feet
of Harriet Island and Raspberry Fsiand.
Please have this item placed on the Council agenda for August 7, 2002. If you have any
questions, feel free to contact me at 266-9147.
Resolution to follow.
MRK/il
Attachm�nts
c: file
!�-?.�^A-EEO Emp(oyer
�
z
�
W
}14
�
t7
�
�
�
W
iTa
�
H
Z
c
O T
y
�
d
�
C'
V
U
G
9
4
G
.�
O
.£
m
�
cv
� p
N �
t >
y
o .�
w �
��
c �
m �
A a.
> •
A�
o r
r
�.
y O
� rn
��
� �.'
� d
`' i�.
o �
7s
�J
�+ U
40 "'
5b
O O
N �
N .�
H 2
C
0
�
N
�
3
m
�
P
A
�
0
c
0
U
i
U
.s.
:?
�°«
�
G
.�
U
d
R �
C O
G �
Q 0
y L
Y �W
CJ
� w
Q �
O �'
�, s
w �
G W
U �
y Ro
y Y
�
43 L ° ~
? � y e
U
< U �E�PI
��. G�
U � rr te
U w y y
� � �
� Z � F
V a a
m .. `� �
N rTi .� � 7
� � GLCy
c U;�O a
��o'� T•�
y ¢ , o E �m
o �ao
dvi:%w �
�, ° 7
a y �. V�
9
ei '� V d
o �y w
d � •� C �
V �i V � S �
Q E"� 1� � N
w-�w
� y a.+
sw`�'
� � �
oa� t�
y
C
�° a
U �
1�l
� �
j O
y �
� Q
= O
y �
� O
L V
+ N
d�
� N
d
N
� N
��
>
" s
�
R y ,
£ u �
[i, N d:
� O T
U 'O y
� .0 ¢
�a�
>-dd
� qb
C G y
0
a��
V d � A
� ��x
. a , �
> a�i a�i «
W ^ y V
� rZ U ra
.�
N
Q
N
O
N
n
� O
� �
v �
.�
� v
fT
�
N
�
N
N
�
i
�
0
�i
>
.°�.
�
L
O
�
v
W
N
�
a.
0
.�
�
�
a
F
T
�
T
F.
W
�
w
A
6
6
� ���
OFFICE OF LICENSE, INSPECTIONS AND
ENVIltONMENTAL PROTECTION
Roger G Cur[is, Director
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
Randy C. Kelly, Mayor
7Uly 17� 2,��2
Mick Sterling
Rolling River Music and Film Festival
332 Minnesota Street Suite #W-122
Saint Paul, MN 55101
beaz Mr. Sterling:
LOWRYPROFESSIONAL BU77.DING Telephone: 651-2669090
350 St PeterStreet, Suite 300 Facsimile: 651-166-9I24
Sain[Pm�I,M'vv:esota55102-ISIO Web: mvw.ctstpaul.micus/[iep
Your application for variance from the noise source limitarions as indicated in the St. Paul Noise
Ordinance (Chapter 293 of the St. Paul Legislative Code) has been received and is being
processed.
A public hearing before the City Council will be held on August 7, 2002 at 5:30 p.m., 3rd floor
City Hall Council Chambers, at Yhe Saint Paui City Hall/Ramsey County Courthouse, 15 West
Kellogg Boulevard, Saint Paul, MN 55102.
You shouid be present at the hearing to respond to questions that the City Council may have.
After the public hearing the Council may by resolurion �axit, deny, or modify the variance
request.
If you haue any questions, please feel free to call me at �651) 266-9147.
Yours trulY
���G��/Z ����1�""�, V
Mazk R. Kaisersatt, R_S.
Environanental Health Specialist II
�� {
c: file
AA-ADA-EEO Employer
� LIEP RECEIPT
Date: 07N'I/2002
Received From: ROLUNG RIVER MUSIC & FILM FESTIVAL
PO BOX 270057 GOLDEN VALLEY MN 55427
Description:
Invoice Detaits
3193�2
Noise Variance
TOTAL AMOUNT PAID:
Paid By:
j Type Check # � Received Date i Amount
K:heck � 1085 07/11/2002 $150.00
Invoice Amount
$150.00
aa-���
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
Office of License, Inspedions
antl Environmental Protection
350 SL Peter SL Suife 300
$3int Paui, Minneso�a 55102-7510
(65t)2fi6-9090 F�- (657)2665t24
wrnv.ci.stpaul.mn.us/liep
Amount Paid
3150.00
$150.00
Page 1 of ?
, :: � , i �, � ��
`.
GEORGE C ALBERS
2�0 PLA70 BLV� W
ST PAUL MN 55107-2045
JAMES E PEL7lER
111 BELLE ST
ST PAUL MN 55107-20i2
CITY OF ST PAUL
15 KELLOGG BL.VD W RM 140
ST PAUL MN 55102-1613
JAMES P GARONER
1 WATEft ST W
ST PAUL MN 55107-2U25
WEST SIDE NGHBRHD HSNG SVCS
35 WATER ST W SUITE 201
ST PAUL MN 55107-2096
CHICAGO ST PAUL MPLS OMAHA C/O CHICAGO
NORTHWESTERN TRANS
1416 DODGE ST
OMAHA NE 68179-0002
LSNB INC GROSS GIVEN MANUFACTU C/O BIL�.
COLFORD
7S BIDWELL ST SUITE 10t
ST PAUL MN 55907-2014
LARSON LEASING INC
PO BOX 20087
BLOOMlNGTON MN 55420-0087
C ST P M AND O RY CO ATTN JEF2FtY
WILDHABER
1416 DODGE ST R�OM 325
OMAHA NE 68179-0002
RUTZICtC PROPERTfES
485 PLATO BLVD W
ST PAUL MN 55107-20Q7
Use temptete #or 5lbm�
Oo2-7lrp
DUGGAN PROPERTIES INC
111 BELLE ST
ST PAUL MN 55107 20'12 .
J AN� L WIRE CLOTH CO INC
111 BE11E ST
ST PAUL MN 55107-2012
HOUSING AND REDEV AUfHORITY
25 4TH ST W 12TH FLR
ST PAUL MN 55102-1634
ONE WEST WATER STREET LLC CO JAMES
MILLER INVESTMENT
PO BOX 1769 REALTY CO
ST PAUL MN 55101-0769
WESCHCKE FAMILY LP C/O LLEWELLYN
WORlDWIDE LTD
84 WRBASHA ST S
ST PAUL MN 55107-1803
LYLE V BUSCH
33472 GOVERN TRAlL
RICHYILLE MN 56b76-9637
PJRT AUTHORITY OF ST PAUL
�15 ST PETER ST SUITE 1900
ST PA�1L IuiN 55102-1661
PtiALEM BANK
1425 MARYLAND AVE E
ST PAUL MN 55106-7152
R F2 L HARDENBERGti CO INC
174 WATEF2 ST W
ST PAUL Mfd 5b107-2014
GEORGE C ALBERS
200 PLATO BLVD W
ST PAUL MN 55107-2045
�wa --_ _a. Arttl�.�..al �..l+..lsv 11.�.e.... IDMIQ21�
�91fl�r������lte�s�M ��i4�� �� u�����s�1���i�3��
Oc�-7/Qo
AMEFtlCAN CRANE NA"FIONAL INC
75 BIDWELL ST STE 109
ST PAUL MN 55107-2001
BIDWELL tNVESTMENTS INC
75 81D4VELL ST STE 101
ST PAUL MN 55107-200i
TWIN CI'FY REFUSE RECYCLE INC
3'18 WATER ST W
ST PAUL MN 55907-20'f 1
JOSEPH KARAS
7a5 ROBERT ST S
ST PAUL MN 55107-2947
KATHLEEN M MORAN MARY C SELANDE32
1280 OTTAWA AVE
WEST ST PAUL MN 55118-2018
ROSE KARAS
705 ROBERT S7 S
ST PAUL MN 55107-2947
STATE OF MN DOT BLDG 509
395 JOHIV IRELAND BLW
ST PAUL: MN 55155-1801
GEORGE GUBASH SARAH GUBASH
7Q5 ROBERT ST S
ST PAUL MN 55107-2947
BEFORT ROOFiNG INC
336 WATER ST W
ST PAUL MN 55107-2011
LOIS V WYLIE
2556 SPRUCE ST
LIITLE CANADA MN 55117-1419
STATE OF MN TRUST EXEMPT
50 KE�LOGG BLVD W SUITE 6206
ST PAt1L MN 55102-i 557
CSP CHEROKEE PARK PR33061
15 KELLOGG BLVD W 140
ST PAUL MN 55102-1613
�iLCaSi(Q� d�A�IVQGG..� Rjt�1�.4 A Ci3ACr �YAR'�'�
S�t�t��!$E►��"' ��f?�p�� .�''�� U�s�p�EdP5i86�°
r � Chl
MINNESOTA BOAT CLUB CO ROLLIN AND MINNESOTA BOAT CLUB CO THOMAS E
ASSOCIATES INC KLECATSKY TREASURE
101 STH ST E NO 1810 2078 TFIERESA ST
ST PAUL MN 55101-1808 MENDOTA HEIGHTS MN 55920-1306
CITY OF ST PAUL
15 KELLOGG BLVD W RM 140
ST PAUL MN 55102-i 613
1�d..�_..� o.�.�._ -° -°- - --'-�`
I.owertown Redevel�pment Com
apitolRiver CounciU Dist 17 Weiming Lu, Esec President
Cs. Mary Nelson, C.O. Galtier Plaza, Suite 750 �
32 Minnesota St, Suite W-1250 175 E Sth Street
imt Paul, MN 55101-1305 Saint Paul, MN 55201-2905
istrict 17 �
pdated 8/13/99 �•�- ' -a `�' =` =- ��� 4 s ;..�_
li.�.ry , f r
_.'__.�i-�
oa-���
Capitol River CoimciUDist. #17
Rev. William England, CHair
First Saptist Church
9 & Wacouta Streets
Saint Paul, MN 55101
i
s
�
a
a
0
tn
O
�
�o
�
�
�
$
N
�
�3
�
c
�
�
L
w
m
A
�
�
�
o'
�
<
0
�
w
�'
w
.�.
.�
�
�
N
�
�o
� o
w �
m e
�' A
O v
V
O
N
0
�
�
4
ogz�
� s, o
.�v ry N �
,-��, `.�' o �
m T" �
Y � � �
R O �
3 �
� N
'}' y �
a �
� £ i
���
m
� m m
� 6 C�
^ � �
�. v� �?
3 Rs 3
a � „�
y
� �
r �
�
y
N
O�
�
N �
i
� �
^. �
oa
O
� <
9 m,
O y
o w'
w�
o �,
� -�i
�
G
O
w a �
o " -•
en
� c '�
A�-��,ryd
.�'! �, 2 � � 9i
� A A
� _
s � � o .
A n� _
� `G � .
�, O y
�
� � � W U 9
�• �. P.w❑
O � fp ..-i � �
cn e o '� �,
ms'�°��
T � (� N
� 0�.2 0
=�°�x N
�„
�C�O "
� w ^* c
to � .'�' p
Q � N (�
p � r�.+
0
Vi � ^: �
r.�+ A m
O t� �
N � � �
�+ � .�.. ^ y
N y e!
H �
O � a
y n
7 �
C �
. A
CS
5 �
� �
� o
m �
� �
b �
O O
N y
T �
'3 �
�
o �
�-
6 �
5 �
N ^
� 3
�
s c
.j o
^A
n �
� 4
W C
0
y
M�
S R
��
<
� �
E °'
O
r �,
w z
=°
� �
< T
� �
D �
6 3
� a
��
�
�
3
y
5
a
w
o.
0
>'
�
�
V
G
� Q
� �
C '
b J
�
� �
O
m
�
Q
�
n
�
O
�
"b
�
r
P�9
n
lJ
�
�