257803 ORIGINAL TO CITY CLERK 25'���3
CITY OF ST. PAUL �EN�� NO.
. OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK
• .
C S TION—GENERAL FORM
COMM19810NE CO��ss ioner Cornvay �TF
RESOLVED, That the proper City officers are hereby authorized a�d
directed to execute Agreement between the City of Saint Paul and Barton-
Aschman Associates, Inc. , pertatning to providing consulting services for
the "St. Paul Core Area and State Capitol Complex Circulation and Distribation
Study," which Agreement was prepared u�der the authority of C.F. No. 256866,
dated December 28, 1g71 , a copy of which Agreement Is attached hereto and
incorporated herein by reference.
:s.
��� �� �� ou� �'
�
'v
�°'..<.�
Cl� r
� �,ss'��
Mp,R 2 3 1972
COUNCILMEN Adopted by the Council 19_.
Yeas Nays
��- � MAR 2 4 1972
�1'eb�i/ Conway Approved 19—
Levine _�� Favor z�i�o(.
1V�e�edit�
":7 Mayor
Sprafka (� A�ing
A$'AlI18t
Tedesco
Mr. Vice President Meredith PUBUSHED APR 1 197�
��
, • � � D� a
� ��(J�7
�
AGR�E�iENT 3E"iWEEiV
Cityo uf St. Paul , Minnesota
Name o f Ci tz�
AN 0
Barton-Aschman Associates, Inc.
Name of ConsuZtant
FOR
T;;e Dev�lopment of a People Circulation and Distribution Plan
ror the St. Paul Core Area and the State Capitol Complex.
THIS AGREEMENT, made this day of ,
�:�72 by and between the City of St. Paul , a municipal corporation of �ne
State of Minnesota, acting in the premises by and through its Cor�missicner
of Pu�l �c I�'orks and other proper officers, under the authority of a
resolution of its Council , C.F. No. , approved ,
i9_, :�ereinafter referred to as "City" and Barton-Aschman Associates,
�:�c. , a Delaware Corporation, hereinafter named the "Consultant", whose
CG'rporate address is 1771 West Howard Street, Chicago, Illinois 60626
and whose local address is 1821 University Avenue, St. Paul , Minnesota
5�iO4.
Ld�;�:REAS, the City desires to conduct the "St. Paul Core Area and
State Capitol Complex Circulation and Distribution Study" directed
-�e�,�ard solving the downtown, people circulation and distribution
proa7ems of the City, and,
� -2-
��HEREAS, the City has determined a need for professional con-
sulting services in carrying out this circulation and distribution
study, and,
WHEREAS, the Consultant has considerable experience in the
field of transportation planning, economics, engineering, and
development, and in the preparation of people circulation and
distribution planning and design studies ,
NOW, THEREFORE, the City and the Consultant, for the considera-
tion hereinafter named, do hereby mutually agree as follows:
I GENERAL CONDITIONS
A. COMPLETION DATES
Starting times and completion times for the various phases
of the project are specified in Section P, Time of Performance.
B. CONTRACT TERMINATION
The City reserves the right to terminate this Agreement at
any time by giving the Consultant thirty (30) days written
notice of such termination. In the event of said termination,
the City shall be liable only for the value of the services
rendered to the date of termination based upon fees described
herein. It is understood that all completed or partially
completed drawings , records, computations, surveys and survey
information and other material the Consultant has collected
shall become the exclusive property of the City.
C. MAJOR CONSULTANT PERSONNEL .
For the purpose of dealing with the City, the Consultant
' -3-
snall assign as Project Manager, Mr. Michael Powills. He
snall be in full charge and responsible for the Consultant's
conduct of �he study. The Consultant shall also assign as
Assistant Project Managers, Mr. S. 0. Edman for Administration,
and Mr. P. A. Fausch for Technical Activities. These men are
based in St. Paul and Mr. Edman will act as liaison with the
City Project Director. The Consultant may replace said Project
Manager subject to the approval of the City. The Consultant
shall replace the Project Manager when requested by the City.
D. DISPOSITION OF PLANS AND COMPUTATIONS �
l . All reports , drawings, designs, and specifications pre-
pared by the Consultant in the performance of this
Agreement shall become the property of the City on
payment for services performed as specified in this
Agreement, and a71 such reports , drawings , designs ,
and specifications shall be delivered to the City as
specified in this Agreement, or upon any termination
thereof. Any risk of loss , destruction or damage of
or to said reports, drawings, designs, and specifica-
tions shall be borne by the Consultant prior to the
time when the same are delivered to the City, nor
shall any such loss, destruction, or damage excuse
performance of the Consultant under this Agreement.
. I
� ' -4-
2. Any patentable result arising out of this agreement, as well
as all information, desi�ns , specifications, know-how, data,
and findings shall be made available to the Gover.nment of the
United States of America for public use, unless the Department
of Transportation shall , in a specific case where it is legally
permiss�ble, determine that it is in the public interest that
it not be so made available.
3. The final report shall describe the techniques used and
alternatives considered in the various phases of the study
as well as the basis for its conclusion upon each of these
work items.
4. One Hunared Eighty (180) copies of the fina7 technical report
will be printed toge�her with five nundred (500) copies of a
"popular" type summary report, and will be delivered with the
originals of both repor�ts to the City's Project Director upor
their cor�pletion for distribution by the City.
E. CLAIMS , INDEMNITY, AND INSURANCE
Claims
The Consultant indemnifies , saves, and holds harmless the City and
all of its agents and employees of and from any and all claims ,
demands , ac�ions, or causes of action of whatsoever nature or
charac��r arising out of or by reason of the work to be performed
by the Consultant hereunder, and further agrees to defend at its
own sole cost and expense any action or proceeding comr�enced for
the purpose of asserting any such claim of whatsoever
' - -5-
cl�aracter arising as a result of the action taken hereunder
by tne Consultant. It is further agreed that any an� all
employees of the Consultant and all other employees excspt
employees of the City while engaged in the performa�ce of
any work or services required or provided for herein to be
performed by the Consultant,shall not be considered employees
of the City, and that any and all claims that may or might
arise under the Workmen's Compensation Act of the State� of
Minnesota on behalf o-f said employees while so engaged,and
at�y and all claims made by any third parties as a consequence
of a�y act or omission on the part of said employees while
so engaged in any of the work or services to. be rendered
herein sha71 in no way be the obligation or responsibility
of the City.
Insurance
The Consultant agrees to procure and maintain for the
services covered by this Agreement, insurance of the
kinds and in tne amounts nereafter provided by insurance
companies authorized to do such business in the State
of Minnesota, covering all operations under this
Agreement, whether performed by the Consultant or by
their subcontractors. Before commencing the work,
the Consultant shall furnish to the City a certificate
or certificates in a form satisfactory to. the City
� -6-
showing that it has complied with this paragraph, which certi-
ficate or certificates shall provide that the policies shall
not be changed or cancelled until ten (10) days written notice
has been given to the City. The kinds and amount of insurance
required are as follows :
A. Po7icy covering the obligations of the Consultant in
accordance with the provisions of the Workmen's Com-
pensation Law. This Agreement shall be void and of
no effect unless the Consultant procures such policy
and maintains it until acceptance of the work.
B. Policies of Bodi7y Injury Liability and Property
Damage Liability Insurance each with limits of
liability of not less than $100,000 for any one
person and $300,000 for any one accident with
damages arising out of bodi7y injury, including
death at any time, and not less than $25,000 for
each accident resulting in injury to or destruction
of property.
F. COMPLIANCE WITH LAWS
The Consultant shall comply with all Federal , State and Local
Laws together with all ordinances and regulations applicable
to the work. He shall procure all licenses , permits, or other
rights necessary for the fulfillment of his obligations under
this Agreement.
-�-
G. EQUAL Ef�1PL0YMENT OPPORTUNI?Y
In connection with the execution of this contract, the con-
tractor shall not discriminate against any employee or
applicant for employment because of race, religion, color,
sex or national origin. The contractor shall take affirmative
actions to insure that applicants are employed, and that
employees are treated during their employment, without regard
to their race, religion, color, sex, or national origin. Such
ac�ions shall include, but not be limited to, the following :
employment, upgrading, demotion, or transfer; recruitment, or
recruitment advertising; layoff, or termination; rates of pay,
or other forms of compensation; and selection for training,
including apprenticeship. The Consultant shall insert a
similar provision in all sub-contracts for services covered
by this Agreement.
H. CONTINGENT FEE
The Consultant warrants that he has not employed or
retained any company or person, other than a bona fide
employee working solely for the Consultant, to solicit
or secure td�is Agreement, anci that he has not paid
or agreed to pay any company or person, other than a
bona fide �mployee working solely for the Consultant, any
fees commission, percentage, brokerage fee, gifts, or
-8-
any otl�er consideration, contingent upon or resulting from
the award or making of this Agreement. For breach or
violation of this warranty, the City shall have the right
to annul this Agreement without liability, or in its
discretion to deduct from the contract prior or consid-
eration, or otherwise recover, the full amount of such
fee, commission, percentage, brokerage fee, gift or
contingent fee.
I . INTEREST OF MEMBERS OF OR DELEGATES TO CONGRESS
No member of or delegate to the Congress of the United
States shall be admitted to any share or part of this
Grant Contract or to any benefit arising therefrom.
J. INTEREST OF CITY EMPLOYEES
The Consultant shall not engage on a fu71 or part-time
or other basis during the period of this Agreement any
professiona] or technical personnel Who are, or have
been at any time during the period of this Agreement,
in the employ of the City, except regularly retired
employ�es , without the written consent of the public
employer of such person.
K. INTEREST OF PUBLIC OFFICIALS
No member, officer, or employee of the City, or of a
local public body, during his tenure or for one year
thereafter shall have any interest, direct or indirect,
in this contract or the proceeds thereof.
-9-
L. SU3LETTIfdG
It is anticipated that �:he Consultant will sub-contract with the
firm of Toltz, King, Duvall and An�erson, Architects and Engineers ,
1408 Pioneer Building, St. Pau] , Minnesota 55101 . Such sub-contrac-
ting shall not exceed 15% of the total contract cost, and shall be
primarily related to physical impact analysis. The City will reimburse
the Consultant for th� sub-contracted services provided by Toltz, King,
Duvall and Anderson, Architects and Engineers, for this study subject
to the review and approval by the City of the sub-contract relative to
cost and scope of work. No additional sub-contractor shall be engaged
wi�hout tne specific approval of the City in writing.
M. SUCCESSORS AND ASSIGiVS
The City and the Consultant each binds himself, his partners, successors,
executors, administrators, and assigns to the other party of this
Agreement and to the partners, successors, executors, administrators ,
and assigns of such other party, in respect to all covenants of this
Agreement; except as above, the Consultant shall not assign, sublet,
or transfer his interest in this Agreement without the written
consent of the City. Nothing herein shall be construed as creating
any personal liability on the part of any officer or agent of any
public body which may be a party hereto.
iV. AUDIT AND INSPECTION OF RECORDS
Ti�e Consultant sha17 permit the authorized representatives of the
City, the U.S. Department of Transportation, and the Comptroller
General of the Unit�d States to inspect and aud'it all data and records
of the Consultant relating to his performance under the contract.
-10-
0. MAINTENANCE OF DOCUMENTS AND RECORDS
The Consultant shall maintain all books, documents, papers,
accounting records and other evidence pertaining to cost
incurred in connection with work and services performed
hereunder. He shall make such materials available at his
office at all reasonable times during the contract period
and for three years from the date of final payment under
this Agreement, for inspection by the City or any authorized
representatives of the Federal Government and copies thereof
shal7 be furnished upon request.
P. TI(�E OF PERFORMANCE
The Consultant shall begin the work defined in Section II ,
Scope of Services , within 10 days of contract execution.
Total duration of the contract sha71 be nine (9) months
from the time of contract execution. Information necessary
to provide input to the Metropolitan Council 's Development
Guide sha]1 be developed by the fifth (5th) month and prior
to the publication of the final recommendations and report.
Q. COMPENSATION TO THE CONSULTANT
1 . Payment
Payment for a71 work done under this Agreement shall
not exceed $72,000.00. Payment to the Consul�tant for
its services shall be made on the following basis :
A. Fixed fee in the amount of $7,200.00 (Exhibit A) .
� -i�-
PAYMENT continued
G. Direct salary cost to the Consultant at the actual rate of
the personnel as set forth in Exhibit A.
C. A payroll burden at the rate of 23 percent of direct
salary costs under Exhibit a, Item 1 and overhead
cost at the rate of 103 percent of the direct salary
cost under Exhibit B, Item 2.
�• The Consultant will be reimbursed for direct expenses
which will include but not be limited to the following:
Telephone
Film and Printing
Special Material and Rental Equipment
Reproduction
Printing and Binding Report
Travel and Subsistence
� - 11a -
�
EXHIBIT A
COST aREAKDOWN
BARTON-ASCHMAN ASSOCIATES , INC.
PERSONNEL SALARIES, PAYROLL BURDEN AND OVERHEAD
Hourly Payroll Billing
Classification Rate* Burden Overhead Rate/Hr.
Principal Associate 13.25 23% 103% 29.95
Senior Associate 9.25 23% 103% 20•90
Associate 6.50 2 3% 103% 14.70
Senior Technician 5.00 23% 103% 11 .30
Draftsman 4.00 2 3% 103% 9 .05
Technician 3.25 23% 103% 7.35
Typist 3.25 23% 103% 7.35
�Tnese rates are average values for the sa7ary range of each
classification.
ESTIMATE OF COSTS BY MAJOR PHASE
Phase I Project Inauguration $ 4,800
Phase II Problem Definition 10,000
Phase III Evaluation Measures 5,000
,
Phase IV Deve7op Alternate Plans � 20,000
Phase V Test Alternate Plans 15,000
Phase VI Recommendatians and Final Report 10,000
Total Consultant Cost $ 64,800
Fixed Fee (Profit) 7,200
Total Contract Cost . $ 72,000
- llb -
, EXHTBIT B
Percent of Dir�ct
6reakdown of Payroll Burden and Overhead Cost Salary Costs
l . Payroll Burden
a. Vacation, holidays , s;ck and personal leave 13. 38
b. Federal and state payroll tax 5 . 85
c. Workmen's compensation insurance 0 . 26
d. Group insurance 1 • �9
e. Pension plan 1 . 57
f . Employee incentive payment 0 . 11
Total Payroll Burden 23. 16
2. Overhead Cost
a. 7axes (except state and federal income) 0 . 32
b. General insurance 3 . 35
c. Salaries , administrative office and clerical 51 . 82
d. Office expense �postage, supplies and printing) 7. 82
e. Accounting and legal 2 . 56
f. Inter-office travel & pre-contract negotiations 4. 0 0
g. Telephone and telegraph 5 . 5 6
h. Personnel procurement 2 • 1�
i . Dues,subscriptions , meetings & conventions 3. 0 6
j. Depreciation and amortization 2 . 35
k. Rent, uti 1 i ti es and mai ntenance 13.. 57
1 . Equi pment rental 0 . 51
m. Data processing 3. 21
n. Management consulting fees 1 . 7 3
o. Automobi 1 e expense 0 . 5 2
Total Overhead Cost 10 2 . 5 5
. -12-
2. Progress Payments
As the work progresses, progress payments covering salary
costs, reimbursables, payro? 1 burden, overhead, and a ,
prorata portion of the fixed fee, shall be payable
monthly, all in accordance with progress reports sub-
mitted to and approved by the City. Ten percent (10%)
. of each progress payment shall be retained by the City
until 50 percent of the work is complete, at which time
the retainage shall be reduced to five percent (5%) for
the balance of the work. The retainage shall be released
at the time of final payment.
3. Sub-contract Costs
The costs of any sub-contract will be included in the
Consultant's cost and will be paid through the Consultant.
R. CHANGES
The City may, from time to time, require changes in the scope
of services of the Consultant to be performed hereunder. Such
changes, including any increase or decrease in the amount of
the Consultant's compensation and schedule of performance, which
are mutually agreed upon by and between the City and Consultant
shall be incorporated by written addendums to this Agreement.
� -13-
II SCOPE OF SERVICES
The Consultant shall do, perform and carry out, in a satisfactory
and proper manner, the services described in the following sections :
PHASE I - PROJECT INAUGURATION
1 . Detail Procedure - The Consultant will refine and expand
the work program detailed in the Request for Proposal ,
to identify work schedules , procedures, and responsibilities
for all subsequent work items. The work program will de-
scribe the purpose of each work item, the activity that
will be accomplished, the responsibility for the work,
the end product of the activities , and an estimate of
the time required to accor�p7ish the individual items.
Also included will be a work sequence diagram and a man-
power budget estimate for accomplishing each work item
including a tentative schedule of ineetings to be approved
by the Management Board.
2. Organization-Administration - The City will organize the
committee structures (see Exhibit C) which are designed
to provide the management review, coordination, and
advisory functions to' the study.
At the initial meeting, the Consultant will present the
detailed work program developed in Item 1 above. This
work program will identify a committee meeting schedule
including those which the Consultant will attend, for the
concurrence of the Management Board.
c� c� � � -
--� -v -�1 _. _. -• c� r�
- co o -, rt r+ � r* r*
n "� N ^G `G � _t "t
S -• � c� O O
. � C1 N � � Q cn 'l7 '(J
n0 . � n '� � -h -h0 O O
C� � d �. -t 7•7 N -rN _. _ N , •
'L3 G -� LZ r'► C� • � _ rr rr —1 ,
< 4� '�
O 7� A N rt O ' � j -• � 7 �
-r N G O O '� (D CO C'� -G
CJ _. -t 7 -1 G`� G �' C� "'� pr �
O _* Q �G � � � -� � � c� z ^
3 O � � � J U K � � c� �
"'J � -G O m t� c�� v� - m
� � c� � � o N ° ° �* ro
X N � r! 7 C'� � O N .
� 3. � ° r- 3 ,
. �
_ • �-r t� v -
n � . Pf '1 � � - . �J1 .
r* � O N
C (p p _
� � Q
, � n 3 �
O
-'1
r�
JA
`+ . •
�� ^
�/� � . . �� � ` ' ? � .
1 r J� � � T�� � � y� Cj �
� . � �• �. � V• '- � � 3� � � . .
� � . l^v �/� W � �{ �1 s ��,� • � .
� � ^ � \I \• .7 O � � ? � �� ' .
o `; : -ti �r rr � " v�i .'�} z ��� c'� --1
O -
m o�o -�
'� v7i -C � 3 ? v 7 D-o �n � � , c
. ` �. cj _•tp -t O -• � � � O .
G � C!f � � C.7 tD f7 � � rt !Tt � �. -p C) "'1
� ' rr r* �C � to !) O • p � O j �p- -�1c/� .
� . r► -h '� f � -t O � � -J < -"� � � � �.� ,
- N J .Z _• n CJ n
� N T. �.c^,��.N �• � O O � � { �
� � cn c/' p � -• e-r • ^J D • ' p C
=� � � O C� � � -s r'
fi N � n � � o
� ^!� � v rt -1 7 �i
ry � O r-*
. r'! "1 �
O . � -t
� �
N � � � t
rt
' C
CL
� ' .
rt
O ���.. •
-t n ,
c� w � .
�'
� � � -o v � c� -v �v 0� . �
� c� a. v' v � a" r+ � v N � .
. .,n _. � � � c� �
' r+ c) � -• < rr -r �• • 7 -h _ . .
-s tA (� C� 0 � r�r' ' O t� N D
-O • C 9 --1 O � -�+ o � '"^ �., ;� < .
G � j � � � n -1 CA 'b "' . ' .
.r (D 7 c� O � O G � '�D �^
' -, w a ro � c� � c?' a � °
o � �' � ?. � °- � < � �
� �' � o � � ' � o
_? N f3 t17 (D rt � -,
� r� rr 3 •• _,.� 3
-ti � - -• G"' � _ •
tD a O r+ _{
G� ' . tf� � �-r �r D "� .
Cu � _, C m
fr -t c� (� �,j rr r*i
� u' � tn ?
c�. D 3 p
N v+ '?�
rt v� �
oi O .�
rf ll
. (D • •
' � lIflIHX3
• ' . ..
_r£ �_ , ; . :
-14-
3. Established Public Liaison - The City will establish a
public liaison structure to provide inputs from affected
citizens, civic groups, and other interested organizations.
4. Data Furnished by City - The City shall make available to
the Consu7tant all available data from past studies , other
governmenta.l agencies , and known private development plans.
Transparencies of availa le maps, to an appropriate scale,
will also be furnished the Consultant by the City.
PHASE II - PROBLEM DEFINTION
1 . Inventory Land-Use - The Consultant shall evaluate existing
ard forecast land-use inventory data furnished by the City
and determine additional needs, if any.
2. Inventory Transportation - The Consultant shall evaluate
existing and forecast transportation data furnished by the
City and determine additional needs , if any.
3. Establish Growth Dynamics - The Consultant shall , based on
availab7e data, trends , and forecasts determine growth dynamics
and opportunities and constraints which can provide high and
low forecasts of activity within the study area established
in the Request for Proposal .
4. Analyze Person Movement - The City shall conduct and summarize
data on a mail-out, telephone, or business location inter-
view survey to develop attitude and preference profiles.
The exact type of survey will be based on a review by the
Consultant of previously collected data to determine where
additional information will be required. The Consultant
shall provide technical guidance for this survey.
� -15-
5. Physical Constraints and Opportunities - The Consultant
snall identify, map and analyze physical constraints and
opportunities. Tf�e City shall provide whatever assistance
is necessary in identifying these constraints and oppor-
tunities.
6. Enunciate Local Concepts - The City will , through the
committee structure iden�ified in the study design,
organize a session for local groups to provide a forum
for the presentation of conceptual plans that should be
considered. The Consultant shall attend up to two meetings
for this purpose and summarize these plans graphically to
determine their implications to the study.
7. Evaluate Data Validity - The Consu7tant shall evaluate all
data with regard to its sufficiency and validity by per-
forming spot checks and comparisons with documented study
area statistics.
8. Assemb7e Additional Data - The City wi71 collect any additional
data required to fulfill data requirements of the study. The
Consultant will provide g�idance in all these additional cases.
-16-
PHASE III - EVALUATION MEASURES
1 . Develop Objectives and Standards - The Consultant shall
develop objectives and standards for evaluating alternate
plans. This work will be based on a review of existing
local and regional policies , objectives and design standards ,
witn particular emphasis on :
a. Transportation policies.
b. Physical and aesthetic design standards.
c. Environmental impact.
d. Social impact.
e. Economic impact.
f. Development policies and objectives.
The Consultant will define and propose additional standards
and objectives as necessary. The City will organize a meeting
with the committees outlined in the Request for Proposal to
discuss the objectives and standards to be used in the
evaluation of alternate plans to be developed in the
study. The Consultant will attend the meeting and provide
guidance in the selection and approval of the final objec-
tives and standards to be used in the evaluation.
PHASE IV - DEVELOP ALTERNATE PLANS
1 . Develop Concepts - The Consultant will review existing
conceptual plans for providing circulation and distribution
needs in the St. Paul core area and the State Capitol
Complex developed in Phase II . The City and the Con-
sultant will screen all the concepts which are available
from previous work. 7his screening will result in a
-17-
number of concepts to be further detailed including but
not limited to:
a. Continuation of -�resent transit service using,
1 ) local and express bus services with capital
and service improvements in accordance with the
Metropolitan Transit Commission's 13 point impr-ove-
ment program; and, 2) with expanded parking in close
proximity to employment.
b. Development of a shuttle bus program to augment
current local and express bus service plans.
c. Development of an advanced urban transportation
system (people-mover) to augment local and
express bus service.
d. A combination of the previous concepts (a,b, or
c) plus a transportation center. The transpor-
tation center concept shall include the conceptual
development of possible interchanges between;
(1 ) Skyway Concourses and other pedestrian move-
ments , (2) fixed guideway fast link transit,
(3) local bus service, (4) express bus service,
(5) �huttle bus service , or (6 ) advanced urban
transportation systems (people-mover) .
2. Detail Alternate Plans - Based on the inventories of 7and
use and transportation characteristics, and established
growth dynamics, the Consultant will further detail each
of the alternate plans with respect to its impa��� on
current and forecasted land use, current and forecasted
-18-
traffic and transportation characteristics , and other
existing physical constraints,
3. Review of ?echnology - The Gonsultant shall review
. existing technology as it affects the various alternate
concepts. The Consultant will meet with the P�etropolitan
Transit Commission staff to determine where coordination '
with ti�eir activities should be accomplished.
4. Develop Da�a Processina 7echniques for Testing Purposes -
The Consultant shall develop whatever data processing
techniques are necessary to detail alternate plans.
These techniques may include but not be limited to:
a. Building test networks for distribution and
assignment of person and vehicular movements.
b. Deve7opment of simulation models.
PHASE V - TEST ALTERNATE PL.4NS
l . Test Functional Ca�a�'lit,� of Alternate Plans - The
Consultant will summarize the various functional
characteristics of the alternate systems for compara-
tive purposes. The functional comparison will include
but wfll not be limited to tests for movement efficiency,
cost effectiveness, peripheral and direct impact and
sensitivity to variation in these characteristics.
2. Implementation - The Consultant will determine the
capital, maintenance and operating costs of alternate
systems; staging implications; necessary urban design
requirements and political arrangements. The Consultant
will also estimate patronage, fair structure system
' -19-
revenues and available financial resources.
3. Determination of Relative Merits of Alternate Plans -
The Consultant will make a rinal comparatiue analysis
of all the alternate plans as to relative efficiency,
impact and cost. The Consultant shall develop a
technique to compare the alternate plans based on
the evaluation measures established in Phase III .
The technique will recognize the interaction between
weighting given to evaluation objectives.
PHASE VI - RECOP��ENDATIONS AND FINAL REPORT
1 . Draft 7entative Recommendations - Based on the results
of testing alternate plans , the Consultant will develop
draft recommendations for the recommended circulation
and distribution system including:
a. Physical layout.
b. Cost estimates. •
c. Operational elements
d. Implementation plan
e. Documentation
the draft sha71 include sufficient graphics to illustrate
the recommended concept , and provi de for movi ng i nto
the design phase .
2 . Presentation of Recommendations - The Consultant will
meet with the committees designated by the City to
discuss the recommended alternative . The Consultant
will attend up to two meetings to discuss these
recommendations .
, -20-
' ' 3. Preparation of Final Reports - After receiving authoriza-
tion from �he City, the Consultant will make the necessary
modifications and revisions, print the reports and present
them to the appropriate committee at a final meeting.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have caused this Agreement
to be executed by their respective duly authorized representatives ,
as of the day first above written:
Approved as to Form: CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA
Special Assistant Mayor
Corporation Counsel
Commissioner of Public Works
City C erk
Countersigned:
City Comptroller
In the Presence of: BARTON-ASCHMAN ASSOCIATES , INC.
I ts
Its
} ,
.. _._.
_ . . _ . _. _ . _ �
; . • �
�A DRUPLICATE TO D6rARTMQNT C�� �f" ST. PAUL COUNCIL Np�� �
�,, � FILE '
,/ 4 • OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK
; , ; COUNCIL RESOLUTION—GENERAL FORM
� DA�
�RE3ENT BY
COMMISSIONE
ft;�fiUt.'�'•'U� 'f�s�t t��� pr���r �iLy o�i�.c��rs �x'a is�r�by
t►uthori�sd a�ct c�ir�ctetd to e��cuta itgreamunt bet�r�cn the o 1'd'
n�,B4rfog-�s��irr�q� �JSo�i�fe°s:zLainin� to�
at �air�t P�zul a ]`
- »s�/�;�r .s�Pi�iiic�s �/' f`r� '�S��e� �i-�° �i�l �����f �
� j
r ✓f/�/>>��liG/7
�� jf�v������"� CirG a/��J!�r'7 Qi�� I'irfi-���/ �a,� ys '
A.�fi'r�f';a�'�/�Y'/�/�f'pA,''P./ �/r��'r�I t �' �..�>`�or`�f"y o Gf.it/o. Ct3i7t�1�tJ is �'�LA Il d �/
� , u cepy a� ;�hicl� t��r
hex�tv uncl iiYCOr�c�x'n.tecl tierr,iu by r�sf�rcur:a.
.��~ -__
Adopted by the CounciL. 19—,
COUNCILMEN
Yeas Nays ��_����'"'�.�
Butler Approve� 19—.
oYr--Conr���
Levine ______Sn Favor
Meredith
Mayo�
Sprafka __�gainst
Tedeaco
Mr. Preaident, McCarty
��
_ ,