The URL can be used to link to this page

257709 OriYinal to City Clerk � . . . �_ _ � ORDINANCE �, �, . ' � • � COUNCIL FILE NO �� !��'�� ' b PRESENTED BY � ORDINANCE NO . An ordinanee amendin fihe Zoning �Code, Chapters 6� to 64, in usiwe, , of e SaintsPaul Legislatiw� Code, pertai�ing to Use Districts, He3.ght �istricts and Rezoni�g of cert�in properties in the City of Saint P�ul, �s amended. THE COtT�TCIL OF T�iE CITY �F SAINT PA�JL DOES ORIiAINs Section 1. That the Zoning Code, Chapters 60 to 64, inclusive, of the Saint P�ul Legislatine Code, , inc u�iv , o ; pertaiai�g to Use �i�tricts, Height Districts aad R�zoning of certain prop- erties ir� the City of Sair�t Paul, as aa«r�ded, be and the same is hereby further amended so as to rezone the following des- cribed property f=om pB" Residence District to Com�ercial, to-wits Lots 29-31, Bloek 2, C. W. Young�n's Rea�r�sngement o€ Block 2, Palisade Addition� situate on property located o� the nArth aide of Ben�o� Avenne bet�veen Madison and Alton Streets ia the City of �aint Paul. - Sectio� 2. This ordinance shall ta�ce �ffec� a�d be in foree th��ty (30) d�ys from and after it8 passage, approval and p�blication. MAR 3 0 1972 Yeas Councilmen Naxs Passed by the Council Butler � � Conway � Levine In Favor ARo,.,� .�..� O Sprafka A gainst �— 3 � ;, ��r�,�� ' ' ' �ice P ` Approved. - ttes • • � t "th - ' �. ity Clerk ayor �� ` Form approved Corporation Counsel By PUBLISHED APR g 1q7� a�a�s.a r�.r . . . t . � �� ' ORDINANCE . � � . � � 25'7'�Qg COUNCtI FILE NO PRESENTED BY ORDIIVANCE NO �� a os+dti,,aaa� ,uw„diaq i� S�� 6►0 to 64, i�losl�, o! tiw S=i�n�t ra�o3. Lsgislatf�rs Cod�, p��a� � � Disttiata�. jMfeght aiatsi+atss asdl � o� c+�ct�eia �t,�, � ti� Cit� o! Saint taol, as a��l�el. � 4�IL GI� !,� CIS'S t�! 8� ��. �� it��r �actio� 1« '�4tat th� 8oai�g Cpd�, Chapt�� i0 #10� i4� �Qj.�i�lM� Of t}1! �i�t pilil ;Aq:�ili�T� C/��, �=�S� to �. �riatr3,at�i, �i�ht afstartata �md �se�in� ot a�rtsis Fsop- �rti�a ia t� Citr of �aiat paal. aa �, b� sad t�e sar ts h�r�p l�sth�r �d +w aa to r�t tlr� �llvrf,s� ��.. ' �'i� �=�1 g� "a" �id�so� Distsiat to Ca■rsa�ial, t.o-wi.ts Lot� 29-31, B1valc 2, ��: N. ?o�ro•� �w��t Q! aloak 2, l�l.i�a�d� 1Wditfv�tf sitsst� c� P��'t7 �=t�! oa th� aorth a� o� la�acfs �►�at �t�n lfsdi� a� �11to� strwts ia tt� Citr 0i iaist �ar3„ 8�ctic�a 2. ?his ordiva� sl�a,ll last� �ffi�t aad lM is foscs tl�tt� (30) cla�►s ls�twa aad aft�s itt� pa�saQ�• a�,ps,oval �- - , ---- � , , _ _ , .,.:,; :. . � ., .. . _ .: . . :. , . . _ ; ____. _ _ _ _ _ __. � _ _ _ _ _ I _ _ ... . r V 1� 1J 1 1V 1`� 1V t. � �,,�;. ,� � ��;� � �'z) '� � �-• _ � �� ,� COUNCIL FILE NO. - �y..�.�.�_� .,; , �/ ''! ,, F►2,ESENTED BY r ° >''��# � �"'`.► ORDINANCE NO!��" ' �� " ,. • - --- � .,,': � & i * An ordinance amending��the Zoniz►g. Code, "' Chapters 60 to 64, inclusive, of t�he � Sainfi. Paul Legislative Code, pertaining ,_��'�. to Use Districts, Height Districts and '>� Rezoning of certain properties in the ^-� City of. Sa.int pauY, as amended. �- ...y� THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAIN'i' PAiTL DOES ORDAIN: , .� '� Secti�n I.. That the Zoning Code, Chapters 60 t.;� 64, ;:�,� inc"_usive, of �he Saint paul Legislative Code, ��s---68-�� _.�; ,�� 6�c u-Z s�ve, a � �-, pertaining � � :,-� to Use Districts, Heignt llistricts and Rezoning or certain prop- �� , �� erties in tne City ot Saint Paul, as amended, be and the same , � i ;w � is hereby further amended so as to rezone the following des- °=�: `�-. cribed property from "B" Residence District to Commercial, �: .;;. to-wit: 1 ,.� �� ;� Lots 29-31, Block 2, C. W. Youngman' s � Rearrangement of Biock 2, Palisade Addition; - � ;��. .. , ' �_'_-+tl situate or, property located on the norti�� side �� Bens �:T� Avenue ';�:� X� between Niadisor, and Al��n Streets in the City of �ai:�t Paul. �.� , ;�� .,:.�. Section 2. This ordinance shali take etfect aric� �e in aa$;; -^� -��:; force thirty (30) days from and after its passage, approval "-" :�,�,`; and pwalicati�n. ��`� �� :� �;_� :.�: '� .� ;�iti r: 3 � ��i: ..� �� Yeas Councilmen Nays Passed by the Council �� Butler � � :�c Conway � � Levine In Favor � ' /-� �_+� �, , Sprafka � Against � , � ..'�eclescs-- � ��. W ��resident (McCartyj R _.� �- � f Attest:Mr,'Vic� �;.. _ . Approvedt- ._ ; . . ' . - °T-�-, '- 1 �`, - . _..._ � �• : �.- =_�. �.,� ,..� �:: City Clerk �_.._� r a3;or.__. `� � �� Form approved Corporation Counsel By �______��'�' ;` _ .�_ ----------- : � _ __: ,.. � � , '- � Feb. 24, 197� M?'. Danie l �►. FC1.3 9 C:�xporation Cvunsel Bui ld it�; P . �': �A,�, �i�•. The City Council talay requested that you prepare an ordinanee granting the attached peti�i.�n to rezone Lots 29 - 31� BZock 2, C, '�1, Youn�an's Rea�r.rangement of Block 2, Pslis:�de Ad:li�ion, located on �he north side of Benson Ave. betc�=e.en :�iadisoz� and f:lton Sts.� to Cor„mercial �is�l•i:.t, .�;JI3�,TFCT to a ne�ative easemeat lira�tin:r the use .�t'�a� Pa . Very truly yours� City Clerk ng y , .� r � ''� BOARD OF ZONING, CITY OF ST. PAUL 1010 COMMERCE BUILDING • ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA 55101 • PHONE: 223-4151 ,2�� -� February 15, 1972 �� Mr. Harry E. Marshall City CLerk Room 386 City Hall Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102 _ Dear Sir: This is written in response to the petition of Harold Rutchick to rezone fram "B" Residence to Co�rnnercial for a parking Lot on property located on the north side of Benson Avenue between Madison and Alton Streets, further described as: Lots 29-31 BLock 2, C. W. Youngman's Rearrangement of Block 2, Palisade Addition 'ISzis matter was heard at the February 3, 1972 Board of Zoning public hearing at which time the staff report on file was summarized. The staff noted the proposed location of the office building as indicated by the developer. Mr. Anthony Danna, attorney for the petitioner, said this property, as well as the adjoining property rezoned for this use in 1970, is still vacant. He said construction of the office building would begin in early spring. A resident of the area appeared stating he wanted more information. He noted the petition made no mention of a negative easement to allow the property to be used only for parking. He indicated it was unfortunate that the petitioner did not purchase the residence on the corner adjoining the proposed parking lot. He said residents of the area would like to stop the industrialization of their neighborhood. Mr. Danna said they are applying for a negative easement to use the proper- ty only for parking. Mr. John Swenson, another neighbor, expressed concern over how the water from the parking lot would be drained and if surrounding property owners would have to pay for the drainage. The Board heard a motion to recommend approval of the rezoning with a nega- tive easement for parking only which would revert to the present zoning when the parking lot is no longer used. The motion was seconded and carried by a vote of 5 to 0. Very uly yours, - ''�..,s; �~e..� ,:, � �,,,,.-� --� , � /� ,. .,. �,� .�-'`� ; .,- :?,• . � .. PETER J,. MAIETT9 �_ �� Secretary, Board of Zoning "y� ,.,.o- .� PLR/cf Cj �J -� � p �. S ' H� B. Mars�all w°`TY °F AIMrt !.Olso� " . � City Clerk and F�'��yL Counail Reaorder •Eommz88ioner of Rep�at�ration, � � " . . � , x .�s ,t :�s - hc OFPICE OF THE CITY CLBRK CITY OF SAINT PAUL BUREAU OF RECORDS d88 City Hall St.Paul,Minnesota 66108 January 11, 1972. Zoning Board, Comm�erce Bldg. Gentlemen: The City Council referred to you for reco�nendation the attached petition of Harold L. Rutchick to rezone the following described property to Co�aereial District. Lots 29, 30 and 31, Block 2, C. W. Youngman's Rearran�ement of Block 2, Palisa.d.e Addn. to St. Paul, located on the north side of Benson Ave. between Madison and Alton Sts. Very t y yours �__=�;^n c� � �� City Cl k L � o� � � �;� � �� t � _ � I_.� U� � �;`'� � `.' `:�J�-' �� •�li'ask11'�� k'�� Saint Vi�ul. 1''Iinnrsote: ��f/'�'�F i1 �� , y� � �� p �� -�.�"'..,�,�.-�._ �,: z � , , � DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE ' � � CITY OF SAINT PAUL MINNESOTA 113 Courf House,55102 ROSALIE L. BUTLER, Commissioner Phone:223-4646 Jaauary 11, 1972 To the Couneil Cit� u€ St. Panl Gentl�en: I have chsaked the attachesd petition of Harold L. B��cl�ick, filed in the Batter of zeaoaiag, Lots 29, 30 aad 31, �lock 2, C. iT. Yonngaan's Rearrang�a�t of Block 2, Pali�ade I►�dition to St. Panl. The pr�perty is locat�� o� t.�e aorth aid� ef Eensoa Avenne bstwaea M,adisas aad Alto� 3treets, froa a Class "B" ��sidemtial Diatrict to a "�ae�ereial" District, and find that said petitioa is sufficieat. Yonrs very truly, J. /i�L�-,�' aalie L. �tler �o�eaissioner��aace ,� Be: X1166 c.c. Mr. Amea li. �. fleidea �rs. Bntler l�rontage: 100� Parcels Bligibl� - 17 Parcels Signad - 15 or 8Sx beeded - 12 or 66-2/37G r � �..�= J � ;� 'il s. f,�„`�% �� . � -•._ �°� � ��, L3�f� `1a�� C w � ' � �1 � • �� ,� �f CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA �� ' �. • ' PETITION TO AMEND CHAPTERS 60 thru 64 OF THE LEGISLATIVE (ZONING) CODE � '�'\ . � ' � Note: The signer should appraise himself of the uses permitted under the new classi- fication before signing this petition. For further information about the rezoning of property, call the Board of Zoning Office at 223-4151. (Please type or print) Date; Jul_y 26, 1971 TO THE HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL c/o the City Clerk, Room 386 City Hall City of Saint Paul, Minnesota Pursuant to Section 64.06 of the Legislative Code, we, the undersigned owners of two-thirds of the several descriptions of real estate situated within 100 feet of the real estate affected, hereby acquiesce; and we, the owners of 50qo or more of the f rontage to be reclassified, petition your Honorable Body to rezone the follow- ing described property; (legal description and street address) Lo ts 29 , 30, and 31 in Block 2 , of C. W. Youngman' s Rearrangement of Block 2, Palisade Addition. ✓ from R rP�idPntial District to COmtnerCial District, for the purpose of iy�,�t��R��[Xaplts[bflxx��]axdv�xffi�j[a�c�p�i�s�data�ba�7[X (describe briefiy the proposed facility) Parkirig facility in conjunction with an office building on 2346, 2340 and 2334 W. 7th St. , Saint Paul, Minn. RECORD OWNER SIGNATURE LOT BIACK ADDITION Subject Property: . . oUfl ri H rm nn ALH 1 2 earrangem�n� o Block o n va venson an ition Mar Frances Svenson MFS 2 2 �� L s�. cs.�.-� E. Estelle Barnett E � �--�--�--�1 3 2 " Harvey J. Collins,Harold HHC H. Collins,Mervul B. 4 2 " Col i 5,6 & Harold L. Rutchick HL 1 7 2 " Chicago, Mi w. , . au icago, M1 w , t. a 26,27 & Pacific R.R. Co. a Pacific R.R. Co, a & 2g 2 " cprp. or�oration ,2, 3 . �� __..�.-= - --_ _ �...��....,. .-. - . _ _ a�..r.6 , _ � {�� G- ( (T�tle: V i ce Pres i dent na ..u, n �, _� . -- - . . aES ,,,,. � • �►. .. j , - i.,. ��AKII OF ZONING REPORT AND ACTION February 3, 1972 ` , . � Plat Map 14 , ' �1c'ting tinder I�egislative Code Chapter 60 thru 64 � • ��assed Au�ust 22, 1922, as amended to ;Tanuar_y 27, 1971. 7298 l. APPLICANT 'S NAME , liar��ld L. ['�utcl�i rk � 697g 2. CI.,ASSIP'ICATION . � Amendment � Appeal � Permit � Other X-1166 3. PURPOSE , Rezone from "B" Residence to Commercial to allow a parking facility in conjunction with an office building 4. LOCATION , Nortr. side of Benson Avenue between Madison and Alton Streets S. LFGAL DESCRIPTION : I.ots 29-31 I31.ock 2, C. W. Youn�man's Rearrangement of hloric 'Z_, Pal�is<�de Addit�ion b. 1']ZI?S]?N'I' 'I.ONINCi: ��I�" R��tii<.let�cc� 7 . PU1ZSlJANT TO Zoning Code Chapter: 64 Section: •06 Paragraph: 8. STAFI' INVESTIGATION & REPORT: Date: 1-27-72 By: PLR & ATB A. SUI'FICIENCY: In a letter dated January 11, 1972, the Commissioner of Finance declared the petition sufficient with the owners of 15 parcels or 88% of those eligible having si.gned the petition. B. }�ISTORY: There is no zoning history for this specific site. Adjoining lots wc�r.c re.zoned in 1970 to Commercial with a negative easement to allow only oil:-strcet parking for an off.i.ce building on West 7th Street. C. PIlOPOS}?D USI;: Tile petition declares the proposed use to be a parki.ng facility 1>ruvidecl in conjunetion with an offi.ec� buildin�; on Wc�st 7th Street. ll. I�RONTAGL; AND AREA: The site has a frontage on Benson Avenue of 120' with a depth of 140' for an area of 16,800 square feet. E. AREA 7.ONING: West 7th Street frontage is zoned Commercial. Irregularly- shaped Light Industrial districts exist east of the site beginning one block east. A large area about one block west of this site is zoned "C" Residential. A Commercial district adjoins this site between it and the railroad tracks. 'The rest of the area is zoned "�3" Residential. 1�. COMPI�I�.IiENSI\'1, PLAN: 'The Comprehensi.ve Plan calls for Light Industrial use of this propc�rty with medium density residential use across the railroad tracks and with Madison Street being an arterial street connecting the arterial street of St. Paul Avenue with Shepard Road Parkway. G. STTE CONDITIONS: 1'he site is level and at the same grade as the adjoining properties. Adjoining to the east is a single family residence. L� enFn r.nrvnTTTONS• The Milwaukee Railroad Ford Company Spur Track is adjacent � - � — - - ��... . I . • L . '� �� MINUTES OF THE PiTBLIC H$ARING BI:FORB THB BOdRD OF Z0.*tYNC ON THITItSDAY, FEBRUASY 3. 1972, AT 2:00 P.M, PB85ENT: Mrs. Cochrane, Mr. McPaxtlin, Mr. Dooley, Mr. Benshoof an�d Mre Swesey of the Board; Mro Rosetter and Bv Reitter o£ the staff. t�AROLD �TTC�iICR <7298): A pstftion to rezo�se fro� "B" 8esideuce to Cc�a�mercial to allow a perkin�g €�cility in ccmjuncti�n with an office buildic�g. Mra xosetter su�ariaed Che staf£ report, a part of the file, by e�oting thege �.� no �oning history for this ap�cific sit�. Adjaining lots were re�oned in I970 to Commercial with s negatfve easemeut to allow oaly off»street parking fo�: sn office bnild�ng on f��est 7th Street. The present zoning is t°B" Resider�tial. The petitian decl�res the proposed ase go be a parking facility provided in conjwaatfon with the of�ice bniZ�ing oa West lth Str�et. The aite hss a frontage ou Bensott Avenut of 120 feet with a depth of 140 fee� for an �r�s of 1.6,800 square feet. West 7th Street froatage fs zoned Coa�aercial. Zrregularly-shsped Li�ht Iudustrial disitricts exist � east of the aite beginuing ame block east, A large srea about one block west of this aite is �oned "C" Residen�ial. A Comm��rcfal district ad3oin�s thia site between it and the rs:tlroad tsacks. �he r�st of the area is zoned "B" R�sidential. The Camprehensive Plan c�lls for I.ight industrial uae ofr this property aith �dium desesity residential use acrosa the railro�d tracke and with Msdison Str�et being an arteri�l street COiltl@CC�llg the art�rial street of St. Paul. Avenue with Shepard ltoad Parkwey. The �ite is vacmnt and at the same grade �s the adjoiaing properties. Adjoiaing to the east is a eiagle family reside�nce. Mr. Basetter added that the petitioner states the parking lot is be ueed in conjunction wfth an office buflding and has f.ndicsted thae the offi.c8 is to be located on l�ts S, 6, 7, a�d 8 of ehe same block. Mrs. Cochrane sslced who use� Chat for p�arking now. Mr. Antho y Daans, repreeenting t�r. Rutchick, said it is aat bein� used y�t but will be used for parlsiag fn con�unc�ian with an office building. Const�etion of th� office buildii�.g shoulci begin ia �arly spriag, h� said. Mrs. Cochr�ne a�sked i€ the lpt �l�eady re�oned for par�Cin�g c�ii� be used as s!1 dae parking lot, Mro Deaa� answer�c3 t4sat £t would b�. Using a sit� g.'�an, he poi�ted out the location of the psoposed building aad tit±� Iots to �e resoned. He ssid the purpose of thi� rezoning peti�iosi `wes for of£-s�irec�� psrlciag only. Mre Beashoof asked if there ia an 8-foot buffer zone an t�� es��t side end wats eald that there is. Mr. McPartlin aeked what kind af; bus�.nee� is goiag ia theree Mr: l�sana said a �ank would be bailt. Mre Leo 5kairdi�, who said he repic�sent�d the area, �aid h� woua.d 13.ke a little mor� informatioiR oa wh�at they aetual�y. ar� ;oing Co do. He safd �Se etncierstood thst th�s was not to be a negative easement but was to be caa�rc�al. He safd Mr. Ru�chick negotiated to buy two homes there. '�re prese�.tly is oaly oae hane Ieft and this man was off�red a price that wme l�sa tha� he p�id �a� it, the p�rking lot would w � , � � ' ,HAKOT�D I2�1Ef;lilG�. ��age 2°� ��s�u�ry 3, �`G72 � . w further decrease the desirability of his location. Se said the petitioaer got the origiaal parkiag for ehe bank snd noro� they ar� camiag in and getting three more Iots. Mx. Dauns said the only reasan for the coaaaercial soaing is for off-�etreat psrking. In order to guarantee the residents that a building doesn't go up there. they are apply�ing for a ze�cming with a x�egatfve essemeat. M�o Sksarda expressed his concem for the residents in the immediate aree. He aaid he wauld lgke to stop the iudustrislization of their neighborhood,� under ehe zoning Isw theq should bt s singZe-family reside�tial neighborhood. MrB. Cochrsne asked Mx. S�rda if he w�ould object if thep were to purcl�se Mr. Slattum's house. Mro Skarda said he had :tot a�ct�aslly cantacted Mr. Slattnm as he is in the hospit�Z, but said �4r. Slattum h�d ob�ec�ed earlier when he wsa offered $I2,500--take it or lc3eve" i t. Mre Danas said to his recollectton Mr. 8lsttum was not present st the hesring for rezouing in 1970, He h�s a busia�ss on the lot himself and is acCually in violation of the code. Mr. Skarde said he was only ststing what he kao�aa about this aftuatio�n snd cauld not speak for Mr4 Slatt�. Mrs. Cochr$sie asked if there wete any other objections. Mr. John S�ex►sou, 1871 Norfollc, ask�d if there is s City ordisance regarding dr�in- age of parkiAg lots Mr. Rasetter explsir�ed ehat ttae surfuce drain$ge should be out the �pproa�ches or iato a eatch basin, in eithe� case the draiaage should be indicated on the plan. Ia developing the lot, the �savement should be sloped ia such a way ss ta prmvfd� drainage. Mr. Sweason asked if the prop�rt� owaers ia the area x�uld be charged for the expense af th�t dr�fa�age. Mr. D�sme� safd the develop�er wi12 pxuvide the drafuage. M�, McPartlin moved agprovsl�of the rexoaing wiCh � negative easement to provide that the 2ot be used fo� p,�rking only, the property to rev�rt to present $oning when the parkiug lot is ao langer used. Mr. Benshoof seconded the motioa. The vote for spproval was 5 ta 0. Mgs. Cochrane urged the d�velopers to try ta do something about the coraer house. Stne �aid it dtda't �eem that th�y had made a verq good-fafth offer to that homeowaer. Mr. Danas said he anderstood the owaer was askf.ng a verq high price for that house. Sc�bmitted by: Approved by: P�nl Le 8osetter Mrs. Csrolyn Cachrane br � . r `- ` ' CITY OF SAINT PAUL MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE ii9 c�.e M�.. ss�os FeMrwry 11, 197Z City Clerk 386 City Hall lile Xllb6, page 1 Ya+� as� Mseby qoti#ied thst +� pubiic heasio� ail! be ��id io the Oouoa�l Cbn�ba�t o! the City Bali sad Court Ho�ss in ths Citq af St. Paul at 1Os00 s.w. o�n Febsw�cy 24, !97'2 0o t�s �titioo a! Rarold L. AuCahiClc .t+o ss�oae fras a "a" $�e��d�atis�l Hii'triat to a "Oorescial" Distr�cC the property d�scribed ae t+�lla�ra: t,ot� 29, 30 and 31, Slock 2, C. W� Ycun�so�• �earra+a�e�aat of Blo�1c 2, palirads A�dditioa to 8t. P�ul. T!u prop�rty is iocatsd oa the �atth •ida of Daosc�a Avanw� b�etMe�p ya,disoa aad Aitoo Sts�eCs. For lurth�s intoroation, cootact ths lxanaio� Boasd, �� 1010 �� fb�rce fuildis�g or t�i�phaaa �2�-4151. Zo cospiy piCh th� City Cl�ast�r, tbe D�past�eat o# �i�uea is cLu�ad Mit6 i�ormias you o! thit public hearin�. 2! �ou liaw aqy qvestl�ns, tt is ssaaraad�d tl�st yoo atteesd t�is pub3ic ltesri� t�o a�far�d �rew the opporwnity w wke your view. bath pro sad ea�, k�o�a- to tbe Ci�y Couacil. �t�ALIB L. Et1TL� Qo�sisaioars o� Ftt�aee � , �� , . � >�� F�� ! . � ��' �a< ;� � : ''1 �� '�: �. i;. t ,�... � . �,�.? �7 0 April 10, 19T2 Mr. Dan Klas, Corporation Counsel. Dear Sir: The attached Ordinaxice, C. F. 257709, Ordinance No. 15�53, was passed by the Council c�n March 30, 1972 and publ3�hed April 8, 1972. It h�.s b�en calJ.ed to my attention that thi� ordinence, amendi.ng the Zoning Cod� to rezone certain praperty on the north sicte of Benson between Ma,ca.3.aon and A].ton Streets, shcruld have been sub�ect to a r�egative easement limiting the use to � parkin� lot on].y. Very truly yours, City C3.erk AO//hp \_) I s# '�� . � . 2nd . , ,,; `� ` Lail� over to 4 �:� �3rd and app�� Adopted z � �' Yeas Nays Yeas Nays Butler `�.Butler 4�� Carlson Levine 25�►��9 ��evine Meredith � Sprafka � �prafka Tedesco T`�'�b �,/ Mr. President McCarty `Mr. President MeCa�•,�i � ry� O