02-640Council File # � � — �.�Q
�°'�lGI��AL
��
Presented By
RESOLUTTON
CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA
Green Sheet # �.►d 33'ls
�
Referred To Committee: Date
1 WHEREAS, Juan Fuentes, Jr., d/b/a Auto Repair Santiago applied for an auto repair
2 gazage license for the premises located at 629 Jenks Avenue in Saint Paul; and
4 WHEREAS, the location was not zoned for use as a general repair auto garage use and
5 the Boazd of Zoning Appeals denied the appeal of a determination that such use was not a legal
6 nonconforming use;and
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
WHEREAS, a Notice of Intent to Deny License was sent to the applicant by the City
Attomey's Office on May 21, 2002, advising him that he had unril June 3, 2002 to respond; and
WHEREAS, there has been no response by the applicant; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, that the application by Juan Fuentes, Jr. d/b/a Auto Repair Santiago for an
auto repair garage license for the premises located at 629 Jenks Avenue is hereby denied.
By
Mayor.:
By
Requested by Department of:
Adopted by Council: Date � O y
Adoption Certified by Counci Se ary
BY: � N`
�.%
OFFICE OF LIEP Date:
�toger Curtis, nirector Ju�� s zooa - GREEN SHEET
266-9013 No . 4 0 3 3 7 5
1 ARTTffiil' DIREC1l�R � ITY COONCZL
,�� STY AT1'OR[�Y ITY �wz
ust be on Council Agenda • �°•° unc�' Dxxacrox rx. � Mcm. svc. nza.
• �
uly 24, 2002 (consent) 3 POR (OR ASSISTF�NT)
TAL # OF 3IGNATURE PAGES 1 (CLIP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE)
CTION REQUESTED: That the license application by Juan Fuentes, Jr. d/b/a Auto
epair Santiago for an auto repair garage license for the premises located at
„ 629 Jenks Avenue be denied.
COIMIENDATIONS: APPROVE (A) OR REJECT (R) ERSONAL SHRVICE CONTRACTS MIfST ANSWER THE POLLOWII7G:
� PLANNING COPII4ZSSION CIVIL SERVICE Has the person/fism ever worked under a contiact for this department?
COMMISSTON YES NO
. Has this person/fix's ever been a City employee?
CIB COMMITTEE BIISINESS REVIEW YES NO
COUNCIL Does this persOn/firm poSSe35 a Skill not normally possessed by any
. Current City employee?
, R Board of Zoning _ DISTRICT COUNCIL YES NO
� lain S11 YES anawerg on a separate sheet aad attach. ,
Appeals
UPPORTS WHICH COUNCIL OBJECTIVE? Denying a
iCense to Juan Fuentes Jr.
INITIATING PROBLEM, ISSUE, OPPORTUNITY (Who, What, When, Wheze, Why):
he location was not zoned for use-as a general repair auto garage use
and the Board of Zoning Appeals denied the appeal of a determination that
such use was not a legal nonconforming use.
VANTAGES IF APPROVED:
IS'ADVANTAGES IF APPROVED:
ISADVANTAGES IF NOT APPROVED:
OTAL AMOUNT OF TRANSACTION $ COST/REVENUE BUDGETED YES N
UNDING SOURCE ACTIV.ITY NUMBER
INANCSAL INFORMATION: (EXPLAIN) - I
' ! q h (°
_ yr
�7^
. , •;.'..;�..: .
1 ':_�. .� ��'.
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
Randy C Kel1y, Mayor
May 21, 2002
OFFICE ^S THE CITY ATTORNEY
MnnuelJ. ;anles,CityA!lorney Q ��� O
Civil Division
400CityHall Telephone:651166-8710
15WutKelloggBlvd. Facsimile:651298-5619
Saint Paul, Minnuota 55102
NOTICE OF INTENT TO DENY LICENSE APPLICATION
Juan Fuentes, Jr.
Auto Repair Santiago, Inc.
629 Jenks Avenue
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55101
RE: Auto Repair Garage License Application by Auto Repair Santiago, Inc d/b/a Auto Repair
Santiago for the premises located at 629 7enks Avenue in Saint Paul
License ID #: 20020000699
Dear Mr. Fuentes:
The Office of License Inspections and Environmental Protection has recommended denial
of the above-referenced license application. The basis For the recommendation is as follows:
On April 8, 2002, the Board of Zoning Appeals denied your
appeal of the determination by the Zoning Administrator that
the property is not properly zoned for a general repair auto
garage and that the legal nonconforming use status of the
property as such has expired. You had fifteen (15) days to
appeal that determination to the City Council, but no such
appeal was filed. Accordingly, Saint Paul Legislative Code
§310.06@)(3) permits denial of the license because the premises
which are proposed to be licensed do not comply with
applicabte zoning codes.
If you do not dispute the above facts, please send me a letter with a statement to that
effect. The matter will then be scheduled for a hearing before the Saint Paul City Council to
determine what penalty, if any, to impose. You will have an opportunity to appear before the
Council and make a statement on your own behalf. The recommendation from the licensing
office is for the denial of your license application.
AA-ADA-EEO Employer
. ° �
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
Rnndy C. Kelly, Mayor
July 2, 2002
OFFICE OP THE CITY ATTORNEY ,`
MnnuelJ Cervanlu, CityAttorrsey Q���')b
civit D;vision
400 Ciry Hn!! Telephone: 651266-8710
ISWestKelloggBlvd. Facsimile:651298-5619
Saint Paul, Minnuota SSI01
NOTICE OF COUNCIL MEETING
Juan Fuentes, Jr.
Auto Repair Santiago, Inc.
629 Jenks Avenue
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55101
RE: Auto Repair Garage License Application by Auto Repair Santiago, Inc d/b/a Auto Repair
Santiago for the premises located at 629 Jenks Avenue in Saint Paul
License ID #: 20020000699
Dear Mr. Fuentes:
Please take notice that this matter has been set on the Consent Agenda for the Council meeting
scheduled for 3:30 p.m., Wednesday, Jnly 24, 2002 in the City Council Chambers, Third Floor,
Saint Paul City Hall and Ramsey County Courthouse.
Enclosed are copies of the proposed resolution and other documents which will be presented to
the City Council for their consideration. This is an uncontested matter, in that the facts
concerning your failure to establish non-conforming use for your business location have not been
denied. As indicated, this matter has been placed on the consent agenda portion of the City
Council meeting during which no public discussion is allowed. The recommendation of the
license office is for the denial of your license application.
Tf you have any questions, please call me at 266-8710.
Very truly yours,
✓/ `J ��
Virginia . Palmer
Assistant City Attorney
cc: Nancy Anderson, Assistant Council Secretary
Christine Rozek, LIEP
Community Organizer, Payne Phalen Dist. 5 Planning Council, 1014 Payne Ave.,
St. Paul, MN 55101-3933
�
UNCONTESTED LICENSE MATTER p�_�,yo
Licensee Name:
Address:
Council Date
License Type:
Violation:
Auto Repair Santiago, Inc. d/b/a Auto Repair
Santiago
629 Jenks Avenue
July 24, 2002
Auto Repair Garage
Failure to establish non-conforming use for
business location
Recommendation of Assistant City Attorney on behalf of client, Office
of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection:
Denial of License Application
Attachments:
1. Proposed resolution
2. Notice of Intent to Deny License Application
3. License Information Report
4. 5/22/02 letter from Christine Rozek to Juan Fuentes
5. License information
.. , Page 2 �� "
Juan Fuentes, Jr.
May 22, 2002
On the other hand, if you wish to dispute the above facts, I�vill schedule an evidentiary
hearing before an Administrative Law Jud�e (ALJ). If you wish to have such a hearin�, please
send me a letter stating that you aze contesting the facts. You will then be sent a"Notice of
Hearing" with the date, time and place for the hearing, the name of the administrative law jud�e,
and an expianation of the procedures.
In either case, please let me know in writing no later than Monday, June 3, 2002,
how you would like to proceed. If I have not heard from you by that date, I will assume
that you are not contesting the facts. I will then schedule this matter for the St. Paul City
Council and have it place on the Consent Agenda during which no public discussion is
allowed and the recommended denial of your license application will be imposed.
If you have any questions, feel &ee to call me or have your attomey call me at 266-8710.
Sincerely,
i�
(,'L Qjl�t-C.= `�'� CC�-�r�:�
Virgini�. Palmer
Assistant City Attomey
cc: Christine Rozek, LIEP
Community Organizer, Payne Phalen Dist. 5 Planning Council, 1014 Payne Ave., St. Paul,
MN 55101-3933
AA-ADA-EEO Employer
(�2 lo�
STATE OF MINNESOTA
COUNTY OF RAMSEY
ss.
AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY U.S. MAIL
Kazen M. Doumany, being first duly sworn, deposes and says that on the 23rd day of May, 2002, at
the City of Saint Paul, county and state aforemention, she served the attached Nofice of Intent to
Deny License Application by depositing in the United States mail at said City of Saint Paul, a true
correct copy thereof, properly enveloped, with first class postage prepaid, and addressed to the
following individual:
Juan Fuentes, Jr.
Auto Repair Santiago, Inc.
629 Jenks Avenue
Saint Paul, MN 55101
t�z�, �,�.�r��'
Kazen M. Doumany
Subscribed and sworn to before me this
23rd day of May, 2002.
No ary Public
s��ra r�. sossa�ft�
,#�. NOTARYPUBLIC-MINNESOTA
MY CAMMISSION
EXPiRES JAiV. 37, 2065
oa�-c.�o
�
�
0
X
� W
O y o
� � O
d V N
7T J �
N
a v
0
O
L1.
�
C
0
w
R
�
L
W
c
N
c
V
J
N
�
N
�
N p�
N C
C �
V �
-' a
N
m
m
N �
O. (�
F�
� o.
y y
C �
U O
J �
Q
N
0
O
N `y
!O �
N � m
C9 7 �
Z o
� O
U O
J N
�
m
m
W
�
Q
N �
a7 Y
Z
- �o W
¢ � O
(�D LL�7
U
Q
F-
Q
�
N �
�a
' w
Z �
m �
� ~
�
Q
V
¢
F
Z
Q
�
N �
Z W
C �
O �
a �
Q
U
c
�
O
U
O O
d
m
�
Q
X
W
N
C
a`7
4
�
�
Z
U
O
a
m
U
C
W
�
N
C
N
E
m
Z
�
m
a
�
0
U
N
U
C
N
3
C
�
N
�
E
�
Z
N
C
O
�
a
y
N
�
N
m
pl�
XIM
FiN
�
y
�
c
.
m
W
Q
�
Y
Z
W
�
W
N
�
� � �
� y C � Q
� o m a> a
E a�i m � '�n @ c
O � y U N � E N
w �
N C C L H h 0 'O (6 p O
� m'�o o� rna � o� m � a� o�
� �O�c�c c°- mrn� ��
� a N O N� Q 0 N� Q N � C C
� ¢ p wo ad y `oc
N N� p i Q � y @� � �
.N C O7 6 U N C') �>. Q�(6 N N
� U �� � O p N � � N �.
N J� C QC� �"' 'U< o � �� y E
>. C � O (6 -O 'U " 7 C � O
C O C m !A N
c m � � � a c Q �U
°' y a� � o r � rn�
� DoE•��'o_ o �Eo y�
�Q p'y � X U R d - O N p_ ��-
QJ 'V N� � T d C N N tn � C N
@� c� a> nm `� =� a3 ��� m'c
o�+m� o roo y _ �a�
° o cQ d a �"a� o>� o y y�
v � ic h`omw� m� a�iU C a 'c c� ��� �
N � V � � L � � U � @ Q � � L � N � o �
>,� �fl-� m �•� ° �N . mQQ � �cN
J Q Z �- o OJ i Z' C� O� N O�._ ' O
N tA N� �@ O O. N N C N (p = 0] C� T7 ��' N
�� N d� N� fl. N N �q N N— N N C Q' N( d
M N tA C`- N P') 1� U`p� � C� y V N Q N U
N� N O �� Q � O\ � E� N� C t� � N(n
0 ooU �Q � o0o moQUo O CLN �.L_.
OFFICE OF LICENSE, INSPECTIONS AND
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTfON O�� f �
Rog� C. Cunis, Director M
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
Randy C. Kelly, M¢yor
LOWRYPROFESSIONALBUILDU�G Telephane: 657-266-9090
350 SC Peter Street, Suite 300 Fasimile: 651-266-9124
SaintPm�l,Mirsnesota55102-I570 Web: www.czstp¢uLmn.us/liep
May 22, 2002
Juan Fuentes, Owner
Auto Repair Santiago Inc.
dba Auto Repair Santiago
629 Jenks Avenue
Saint Paul, MN 55101
RE: Auto Repair License #20020000699
Deaz Mr. Fuentes,
On February 22, 2002, the Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection
received a license application for Auto Repair Santiago at 629 Jenks Avenue. The
Zoning Administrator required a re-establishment of nonconforming use prior to the
issuance of a business license. The use has not been established and the time for appeal
has expired. As a result, your license applicarion has been forwazded to the City
Attorney for denial.
You are not authorized to operate an auto repair at 629 Jenks Avenue. You must
cease all operations by June 3, 2002 or a citation will be issued for operating a
business without the proper license.
If you have any questions regazding this action, I can be contacted by telephone at (651)
266-9108.
Sincerely,
n
�
' �� �,A,��
Christine A. Rozek
Deputy Director
cc: Dan Bostrom - Saint Paul City Council President
Roger Curtis - LIEP Director
Kris Schweinler - Senior License Inspector
Virginia Palxner - Assistant City Attorney
CAR/ji
AA-ADA-EEO Employer
L-icense Csroup Comments Text
Licensee: AUTO REPAIR SANTIAGO INC
DBA: AUTO REPAIR SANTIAGO
License #: p0020000699
05N7/2002
6�- G�o
05l17/2002 No appeal to ciry council. To CAO for Iicense application denial. CAR
04/08/2002 BZA denied appeal of decision of Zoning Administrator. Properry owner has 15 days to appeai to City Council. jjh/qa
03/21/200 BZA hearing scheduled 4/8: An appeal of a decision of the Zoning Administer, determining that the Iegal nonconforming status of this property
as a generel repair garage has expired.
2-12-02-Zoning requires a re-esYablishment of nonwnfortning use resoiutio� fcom the Planni�g Commissioo in order to approve this Iicense. Zoning is
denied.JJH
` �O
pa
P�tldress I Licensee l CoMect 1 License l CartlhoWer 1
Sype: C` Property � Licemee t Unofficiel f• pry
$tred S �—
SG'ed Neme ENi(S
Street Type u1tl> ;+.,'�
D'vedion: cnL> '},.'.
UnR #. r
CdY: <Alb S
-- �;
�����.
_ �
� �
30057 0 BLUE COLLAft ALHLUE COLLAR AUTO:Ndo Re�r
"'_-' __ _ '_"_'__'___' __—'__
57599 0 D J'S A11T0 REPPO J'S AUTO REPAIR Auto Repa'v
. - . .. _" "_ __ ' ' '
990004407 10637 ALL SEASONS M ALL SEASONS MAWTfAIarm Permi
_'_ _'____ " __' ' _'__" '�._
OOOU04939 10637 ALL SEASONS M.ALL SEASONS MAINTIFUarm Permit i
Felse PJerms
fetl _ D7i917199.3 07AT171994629.
9etl Ntemptetl no[ k0711917999 071f 8f1A00 629 ,
ded 071I8 Aftemµe dnotkO7N7A99912f31A999629.
ueMLkense em'vetl no MR 10J16f2[)0� 101I6R001 629.
' ' ' ____"—"_ _'_" ' —_ '__—'
. A7 A7 f2QD0 1?731 R000 629 .
97 A7 f2001 12f37 R001 629 .
��v
� �J
-h= � . -t -s 'z
TYp � � Licensee O REPAIR SANT7AG0 WC
�:.Pif"„ ,�t �?°;fx rti�, ,Y=
- ^�� �m dBA TO REPAIR SANTIAGO
Stre
Stre License I Licensee , Lic. Types l NSUrance 1 Bmd ' Requ'vemerAs !
SYre� I(.' p�operty �' Licensee !' Unoffciel Prajec[Facd2�or. ASIJNGON,CpRINNE -'+
' �re�� StreM # 29 P�veru AcGan Canmerrts
� ____ — . _ _...
�rt �; � SYreet Name � �
" � i Siree[ TYpe:
� Un31nd
+ I C3y.
� State:
� JVard
— Dist CouncS
� � Llcensee�
��# � OBA
`- I'�.r�� ' Sales Tax Id:
Dirediart
UnR #:
PAUL �°",°` °
Zip: SSW1 5117l200
– ppficefior
_ ��,� 4108200
tl1�YY541
�1Y Coun�
'O ftEPNR SANTIAGO INC LiCensee
"O REPAIR SAMIAGO Commer4s
2 7 3 9 BusP
�' .,Ni������. � ., ��
�e �c , aarnnonz � oqn�c
appeal to cily council. To CAO tar license
iel. CAFt
A tlenietl appeel af tlecision af Lm�ng
Property owner has 15 days to eppeel to
�
Total: - - ---
�
� 0000C�� e# 20000699 Se CHangestoHmtoryr �. � ��6�9
629.
b �.�� D
AfI�E
rYp �` ° $ `�� � ��� iwens� ro �aaus s�wrwco wc
'`�= n— � �-�" `^�'--° ��'� DBA UTO REPAIR SANTIAGO
�Ire
SYre � �nse Licensee � ��, Types l hswarce 1 Bmd 1 RequiemeNs l
Stre �; Lkerrsee Name: UTO RH�NR SfWTIAGO WC f_ e� �_'�;-,-
Dire�; DB& i0 faPPL2 SANTL4G0
' SelesTa<Id 22739 `�""�``
�� : � Non-Profq: r Worker's Coma ONOA000 `,�°�.e?,.tib
. AA CoNred ReCd: DO AA Troining Rec'd OAONNO
CaY � AA Fee CoAeQed N000 Discard Rec'tl r
i �
��
1
�Mad trvace To:�
�' Mei To CorRaG I �.
�' Licrose Atldress �4 629
t BackgroundCheckRequired r g�'�'¢y�{ auettl`ec� I g3g629
]OCE 629
( Lieense # 20000699 Seve Changes ta FWYwy r . �_,;r; � _�� _ _ _ _ .
� �, �'�" �"" . _ . �• , : .. .. . Mal ls�
_ '"."'..� . _ . . :..': . '. ... '.� CNeaTOCONeet�
BusressM102f77 ROOZOOAOiD00i � ( ) t �se Atldress ''��..
IXher 0 2111 2 0 02 00AOiD�dFUENTESJR JUAN _ _CNAJER __ �(651J208-9590(651 �