257427 �
ORIGINAL TO CITY CL[RK 25`742"�
, CITY OF ST. PAUL FIOE NCIL NO
' OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK
' - CO N R;�UTIO —GENERAL FORM
PRESENTED BY
COMMISSIONE ATF
RESOLVED, That the Council hereby ratifies and approves
the action of the Saint Paul Board of Appeals and Review for
the Housing, Building and Fire Prevention Codes pertaining
to the following listed properties and as shown by the
official minutes of said Board of Appeals dated February 9,
1972, a copy of which, marked EXHIBIT "A" is attached hereto
and made a part hereof by reference:
Case No. Property f, Appellantl
2-72-H � 932 East Third St. ; James Klinkner _
�
3-72-F 1115 Dayton Ave. New Hope Baptist Church
New Hope Baptist Church by
Rev. Kneely Williams
�Eg 161972
COUNCILMEN Adopted by the Counc 19—
Y�a xay8 �E8 17 197�
Buti�,�'/1�
ve 19�
Le�ine
n Favor
Meredith
Sprafka � Mayor
Tedesco Againat lUQUSHED FE 197�
Mr. President, McCarty M A ti'
Asst. Cor�oratidn Couns�;
��
.
. :iCE.-L.1i11� i�v. .
r .
MINUTES OF �:zE MEETING ������
SAINT PAUL BOARD OF APPEALS
Wednesday, February 9 , 1972
Room 210 , Bureau of Health, 555 Cedar St.
1:30 p.m.
Members present: Donald Wozniak, Chairman
Raymond Grove
Estyr Peake
Arthur Tieso
Members absent: Mitchell Kamin
Norma Sommerdorf
James Voigt
Agencies present:
Building Department Frank Staffenson
Bureau of Fire Prevention Dan Norrgran
Others present: Thomas Anderson, James Klinkner, Margaret
Grady, Robert Kelly, Rev. Kneely Williams .
The minutes of the January 11, 1972 meeting were approved as
mailed.
h 2-72-H 932 East Third St. James Klinkner
SUBJECT: Inspection report of January 5 , 1972 from the Building
Department to James Klinkner, 438 Laurel Ave. , indicating poor
water pressure in the cold water line of the second floor dwel-
ling unit located at 932 East Third St.
APPEARANCES : James Klinkn,er.
PROCEEDINGS : Mr. Klinkner reported that all other code deficiencies
but the defective cold water line have been repaired. He has dis-
assembled the fixture but can find nothing wrong with it. If new
piping is needed, it would mean tearing out the walls to get at
it. He cannot financially afford such a major expense at this
time.
ACTION: Motion by Wozniak to waive the requirement that Mr.Klink-
ner replace the tub faucet or replace the cold water line to
- 1 - EXHIBIT "A"
, ii'�:�...]1.111 y �`i U• l.�
�� �
increase the water pressure to the bathtub in the second floor
dwelling unit at 932 East Third Street.
Seconded by Grove�
THE VOTE : Ayes : Wozniak , Grove, Peake, Tieso. Nayes : none.
Abstentions : none. Motion carried four (4) to zero (0) .
5-72-H 251 Dayton Ave. Mrs . Margaret Grady
SUBJECT: Letter dated October 29 , 1971 from Robert Ames , City
Architect to Mrs . Ray Grady, 251 Dayton Avenue citing code vio-
lations which must be corrected before a Certificate of Occupancy
may be issued for the property.
APPEARANCES : Mrs . Margaret Grady, Robert Kelly.
PROCEEDINGS: All code deficiencies have been corrected except
for providing bath facilities for each dwelling unit. This is
what she is appealing. Presently there are 3-1/2 bathrooms in
the building. There are 12 dwelling units with 13 tenants in
total. There is one complete b athroom on each floor. None of
the tenants h ave complained about the conditions . The modest
rents �he charges is about all she can get in that area.
ACTION : Motion by Tieso to waive Section 54. 11 of the St. Paul
Legislative Code which requires that each dwelling unit have its
own bath facilities . Said waiver is granted to permit 12
dwelling units to share 3-1/2 b athrooms . Waiver is granted
until such time as the property is sold or any other right, title
or interest is transferred at which time said waiver be nullified.
Seconded by Peake.
THE VOTE: Ayes : Wozniak, Grove , Peake, Tieso. Nayes : none.
Abstentions : none. Motion carried four (4) to zero (0) .
x 3-72-F 1115 Dayton Ave. , New Fiope Baptist Church
b
New Hope Baptist Church Rev. Kneely Williams
SUBJECT : Letter dated January 7, 1972 from the Fire Prevention
Bureau to Rev. Kneely Williams dis approving use of the b asement
for a proposed day care center because it does not qualify for
use by standards of the State Fire Marshal for other than auxiliary
purposes .
- 2 -
i
. . t�.l.t.,.J ♦ v ..
� ,I
APPEARANCES : Rev. Kneely Williams .
P ROCEEDINGS : Rev. Williams explained that the proposed day care
center is a joint effort of Independent School District #625 and
Model Cities . The church would simply provide the space. The
church is in an area where day care services are badly needed.
It is proposed that approximately 29 children ages 3-5 be cared
for there 5 days per week. Hours would be from about 7:00 a.m.
to 5 :00 p.m. The basement consists of a large room and a
kitchen. There are four exits from the basement. The boiler
room is enclosed. It is proposed that food be brought in from
outside and that it be only warmed up at the church.
ACTION : Motion by [aozniak to waive the requirement that the
church basement be used for auxiliary purposes only. Said waiver
is granted to permit utilization of the church basement as a Day
Care Cen�er and is granted on condition that a limit of 29 child-
ren be cared for and that if the kitchen is to be used for other
than warming of precooked foods (i .e. , if original cooking is to
be done in the kitchen) that a hood, vent and automatic sprinkler
be installed above the cooking facilities.
Seconded b� Tieso.
THE VOTE: Ayes : Wozniak, Grove, Peake, Tieso. Nayes : none.
Abstentions : none. Motion carried four (4) to zero (0) .
A discussion was had concerning a citizen's request to "grand-
father" the Housing Code. A number of possible recommendations
for change in the codes and procedures were discussed. Mr.
Anderson was asked to provide a rough draft of these recom-
mended changes to board members for discussion at the next
regular meeting.
Meeting adjourned at 3:50 p.m.
���� � ,
Thomas W. �Anderson
Recording Secretary
- 3 -
o�..�,.�,�.�,� 25`742'7
, � CITY OF ST. PAUL �uNCa NO.
� OFFICE�F THE CITY CLERK
� ~ COUNCIL RESOLUTION--GE-�IERAL FORM
PRC3HrTED�Y
COMMISSIONER DATG
RBSOLVED, That the Council hereby ratifims aad approv�es
the action of th� Saint Paul BoarB of Appeale and R�view for
tha Housinq, suildinq and Fire Prevention Cod��s pertaininq
to the folla�vinq listed propertiea and as ahawn by the
offiaial minutes o! said Board of Appeals dated F�bruary 9,
1972, a copy of which, marked EXHIBIT "A" is attach�d hsreto
and made a part hereof by referenca:
Case No. Property Appallant
2-72-H 932 East T�ird St. James Rlinkner �
3-72-F 1115 Dayton Ave. New Hope Baptist Church
New Hope Baptiat C�urch by
Rev. Kneely wiiliama
,
�Eg1619�2
COUNCTLMEN Adopted by the Counc 19—
Yesa Naye
But�er FE8 1 ? 1972
� ApprnvecL 19—
Levine .
Tn Favor
Meredith (,
Sprafka � ��r
AgSingt
Tedesco
Mr. President, MeCarty
��