The URL can be used to link to this page

257138 on�a{'t+w�,To e�tr c�snK Q CITI( OF ST. PAUL �o�Nci� NO V . OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK . „ COUNCIL RESOtUTION—GENERAL FORM PRESENTED BY COMMIS510NE • ATF RESOLVED, upon the pertinent appeal, under the Zoning Code, by Robert and Janet Kuhlman, owners of the subject premises, zoned in "A" Residence District, under the Zoning Code, be and hereby are granted a permit to allow the expansion of an existing motel by building a 14 unit addition thereto, on property located on the south side of I-94 between White Bear Avenue and Kennard Street, more particularly described as follows: Except South 673 feet; the South 133-35/100 feet of part of Southeast 1/4 lying East of Kennard Street and West of the East 1257-32/100 feet of Southeast 1/4; also except said South 673 feet, the West 170 feet of East 1257-32/100 feet of part of said South- east 1/4 lying South of Highway 94 all in Section 34, Township 29, Range 22= subject to the condition that said appellants and their successors and assigns, otherwise, shall make due compliance with all applicable provisions of municipal ordinances, state statutes and rules and regulations of public authorities having .� cognizance. � 0 � Ltt > — Q � � O p�, a °'�� U � . � o a .1AN 2 0 19�2 COUNCILMEN Adopted by the Council 19— Y� Naqs 1972 Butler JAN a 1 ��c► Conway / A ro 19— �� O _�n Favor Meredith Sprafka � May r Tedesco A Sainat - - Mr. Presid�n�. McCarty PUBLISHED JAN 2 919�� . . � � . ,��_�� BOARD OF ZONING, CITY OF ST. PAUL 1010 COMMERCE BUILDING • ST. PAUL,MINNESOTA 55101 • PHONE: 223-4151 December 6, 1971 Mr. Harry E. Marshall City Clerk Room 386 City Hall St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 Dear Sir: This is written in response to the appeal of Robert and Janet Kuhlman to a11ow the expansion of an existing motel in an "A" Residential district on property located on the south side of I-94 between White Bear Avenue and Kennard Street. This property is further described by the legal description on file. This matter was heard at the November 4, 1971, Board of Zoning public hearing, at which time the staff noted that similar per- mits had been previously granted. The staff questioned whether a permit needs to be granted each time an expansion is made to the motel once the original permit has been granted for a motel in a residential district. The staff further questioned whether the section under which this appeal is being made is still valid under State Law since it allows by appeal a use not allowed in that district. Having viewed the site plan displayed by the appellant's attorney, the Board heard a motion to recommend approval. The motion was seconded and carried by a vote of 5 to 0. Very t ly yours, eter J aietta Secretary, Board of Zoning PLR/br /� � Z.F. 7255 / V O • , �� `�� ,'j �u�_ ��J� � �PHONE 776-9338 ' ' DRIVE IN TO oue Mo� o. C�t#� �t�e�u �.�#�� , �� Kitchenettes - Tub and Showers � ' � r � Air Conclitian BOB AND JANET KUHLMAN HWY. 94 o.NO 12, 5 MIN. EAST OF LOOP ST. PAUL, MINN. Honor�le .ti:ayor• a,iid �ity �ouncil. In t�iis pl, oiuos�,l I�w�n asxin� to be �;rant�;u �, p�l°mit -to ��uilcl a bauly n�ed:;�d ad��on to our i�4ot�1. Mr ;; ;�Irs Rert Ku'r�.l.nan Ci��y Viev,� �;�otel . 1600 Hu�son Rd �t r:�au1 �alinn. 5>l o DL��R i Pl OlJ 0�` �'F�OrLl�l Y V'�'ard 2 L�S 673 ' The i�o. 42.20 ' pl i; 12)�. 52 � ps th�,�c Paz'� Oi' u� '- Sly oi' Sec 3�:�-2�—h22 � Las-t o.i Kenaz�d St and Sou-�h of I �4 Service Lane Presently ��;e n�wve a 13 unit iw7ot�l ana are as�in� f'or �, lo� f-L �.dd. or 14 units rve have b�en doin�; �, 1ot os u��;radin� to our �.Sotel in th� 5 ye�,;:�s ��, �ccordin� �to_� bussines� d^�e ne�d the BYtY�a roomw. Thank you T�Zr: :c r�Ir�ti. kobel°t Kuhlr��.n Owne�°s ',� O�erators G� � � � � �� ,; r_;- �`�, �T'IY r��ti.,��r� �va..0 Saint Paul. Minneaota �;��J ZONI NG F!LE �Iq�._ `s , �BOARD OF ZONING REPORT AND ACTION November 4, 1971 ; , Plat P9a p ��4 2 ' • Acting under Legislative Code Chapter 60 thru 64 �� ' passed,August 22, 1922� a� amended to Januarq 27, 1971. 7255 � � 6936 . � !:'':"-i�'•'.�d'i S Pd.�l'�t�; , Robert and Janet Kuhlman 6378 - , ::`,�1�STL"ICATI�N ; [� Amendment � Appeal ❑ Permit � �ther 3125 X-1134 3 , � :�kr_;;?, , Allow the expansion of an existing motel in an "A" Residence District 4 , L�C�,T1��1� ; South side of I-94 between White Bear Avenue and Kennard Street � , I.C�AL D�SCRIPTION ; See fi1Q G� P:ESrPd'r 7,ONiN�„ "A" Reaid�nce ' . Pu�zst�,1NT 1'� Zoninp Code Chaptera 64 �ection: .03 Farat�raphs r f3 , ;'I'AI"F IPIV�STI�ATION � REPORTa Date; October 27, 1971 By; PLR A. HISTORY: An appeal for a permit to construct a six-unit motel was granted for this site on June 7, 1955. An appeal to enlarge the existing motel was approved on January 20, 1968 and again in 1970. D. PROPOSAL: The propoeal ie to coastruct an addition to the exieting motel to contain 14 more unite. C. PRESENT STANDARD: Chapter 64� S�ction .03, Paragraph r permita the Council to allow a motel adjacent to a trunk highway. D. AREA ZONING: Adjoining to the eaat ie a large tract that is zoned Connnercial. The rest of the area ia zoned "A" Residence. The Comprehensive Plan recommends Commercial use of this property. E. SITE CONDITIONS: The aite ia occupied by an exiating motel. The ground slopes downward from the motel to the highway. Fe AREA CONDITIONS: A large percantag• of the area is vacant and rolling land. A single-family residence, a restaurant and motel is to the east. To the south are acattsred single-family r�sidences. , :' 9. BOARD ACTION: To Recotmnend � Approval � Denial Council Letter Dated: Moved by . McPartlin Y�88 Nays 12-6-71 X Ames - Ch. Date of Seconded by: Benshoof X Cochrane Hearing: X McPartlin 12-9-71 Secretary's remarke: Maietta Maneur Council Action� X Doody X ' Benahoof Dooley Date: � Prifrel `--��.�`�---�_. __ � �Q _ a .� . � __.__.___._ - . _ � } � � , � .---�.. _ i i m � v � i i I � � � 0 �vvvvvvv � •R •N v � cotH L � MC l,t,AN qVF � i � � vv � v �� , _ � v � v � �r� T-- g � i � ;-T-� � � � i i � o; � � � � 4 , , �� L , ��M � � G � iV AV� . � � ----.-- � � -- � � z � �� u � � -- - I r � 1 O � --_ .,___ __ _L _L_ __. _�___� � �_�_.1 � > c� , � , � S � � �a� , i b � � � � � o ,� o00000 0 0 0 0000 � --- - - --�---�- � �.--- -_____�3 btiP��.�--- ---�------,g-b��;------- . _ _ �_. O � O C� II �� o c o o Q o o � � . t ' � � � --- --�--- _. . _. . -- o . . o - � LEGEf�D � � APPLiC�►NT Robert and Janet Kuhlman PU��os� Allow the expanaion of en existing LA�lD U�E motel in an "A" Reaidence District O ONE-FAMILY PRESCNT ZOf�ING "A" xes�dence -�" T1I'd0-FAtViILY . � THF�EE- FAi�II.Y PETITION SIGNERS �' , - FOUR-FAMiLY . 7 MULTI- FAMILY • •nCOMMERCIAL FILE No. 7255 NtaRTH n !� INDUSTRIAL � VACANT St. Paui Planning Board, Date� ��o�= 2�, 19�1 � Property under considerotion . . � � , > MI1�3UTBS OF THE PUBLIC HEt�R�NG B�FORB T"dE B(�D QF Z(�TING ' ON 'I'FiU&SDAY, Nt7V�FBBB 4, 1971, A� 2:t30 P,Ms PRESENT: Mesers. AmQS, Benehoof, t�cPartlia, Dcxr�dy anci Mrs. Cochrar►e of the Board; Mr. Rosetter and B. xeitter of the st�f£. HOBEItT Rl� JADtLT RitiiLMAId: Ar� sppeal to ellow the expansios� o# an �.xisting n�oLel in :n "A" Seeiden�atal District. Mre Rosetter gummarised �he �taff report, a pert of the fi�e, hy n�tir+g thet an app�al ' for s germir to constrnct � gix•uui�t motel was gra�L�d #or this �ite on .Tune 7, I95S. An �ppeal to enl.erge tlse existfng� motel was appzoved on JaAtt$�Cq 20a 1468. and $g�in in I970. The propo�al is fio coaatruct aa sddiCf�rn to �he exiQeing motel to contain 14 �re uni�s. Chapter b4, Se�tioa .03, Pa�agraph r af �tc� Zan�ng Code permits the Ccwa.cil to a11ow a motel ad�acent to a �ruak highwap fn any zoniag dietrict. Adjoin• ircg to �he eset is s large exact th�t fa zoaed CaramerCial. The reet of the area is zoned "A" Re$ident�:at. The Gompreheneive Plan recn�aenda Co�nercLal use� �of Chis proger�y. �he site �,s occupied by an axisting motel. The grauad slopes downward from the moeel to �he highway. 9 large percent�go of the are� �8 v�cant sad zalling lsnd. A siagle�familq reaider�ce, a restaurant �md �ro�el is Co Che esst. Ta the sauth are scattered siagle-£amily reeidences. Mr. Rosetter qneseia�tcd wh�eher :n appe�l is ne�essarq for �very expansian of xhi$ ease once permission has origia�lly been graated for ft. If awch �ppeal i.s necess�ryQ ke queatio�ne,d whether the section uader which th2 eppesl is m�de is still valid under state law. He notad �hat iu the past, iC ha�s been gointed aut to the Board that etaCe enab�.ing legi.slatfazu proh�bits a uae not alla�rred in a� particu�.ar zaaing digtr3.cC ta be �r�aCed by �:sns af aa sppeeb. Mr= Eldon D�,Morr�,a�. 22I Cl�rk, White Beax� Lake, repreeer�ting the �cpplica�ts, dis- played prin�s of th� esist�ug �tet �n.d �inted out where the praposed sddfCions will be. T6exe wss no opposition to th� sa.atter. 1Kt. �icFar�lin moved t�ie a�peaY be granted w Mr. Beashoo£ seconded the mvtioa. The matioa cerried isy a v�ot� o.f S tce 0. Tn answer to a question z�am Air> Ames, it was �+i�ted ou� tha� T-9�i in ��ont of the pro�erty ts finish�d and the I�ig�.way Department woul.d not b� ¢:��Cing �nq of the subj,ec� property. Submitteci by: �gpxoved by: Y�esi L, Rosett��c Robex� T.o ,�nn�s �� . � � � � CITY OF� SAINT PAUL � � MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE 113 Cour� Man� 55102 Novewber 26, 1971 Cit� Clerk 386 City Eall File X1134, Page You are hereby notified that a public hearing �ill be held in the Council Chambers of the Citp Hall and Coccrt Soccse in the City of St. paul at 1.Q:00 s•m• oa December 9, 1971 on the apgesl of Robert and Janet �uhiman to add 14 uuita to a u�tel in an "A" 8esidence Distrfct an the property described as fcrllc�s: Bxcept South 673 feet, the South 133 3S/i00 feet of part of Souttieast 1/4 lying East of �Cennard Street and West of ehe Esst 1,257 32/100 feet of Southeaet 1/4; also, except said South 673 feet, the West 170 feet of Bast 1,237 32/i00 feet of part of said Southeast 1/4 lying South of gi8,hw8Y 9�+, all in Section 34, Tawnahip 29, Range 22. The property is located on the South side ag Rudson 8oad (I-94) between White Bear Avenue and Rennard Street. For further informatian, contact the Planning Board, Rooe� 1010 Cort�erce Building or telephone 223-4151. To canply vith the City CE►�rtex, the DepartmenC of Financa is cherged with informing you of this public hearing. If you have aay questiot�s, it is recommended that qou attend this public hearfng to afford you the opportunity to n�ke your views, both pro and cons kncywn to the City Cou�cil. 1tOSALIS L. BUTLBR Ccm�nissi,aner of Finance �� ."ai � — .� �. .Ng i�• II, :.i,�'��I �I� �. r�3nl. . ��: .I ih. ,' If.. f,,_ If pi a ,+ �I� + s� , � ie �, � (,�Mu�i�MO�ir'.�!', 11�M1) i