Loading...
257090 � � .. .. . . . .'r,3...�._ , ' ... . .,. -�- : ���a90 - � � � . � ._�.A_: ' *FINAL ORDER �OUNCIL FILE NO . ' _By • ��,. File No.-- - 1�iAil In the �datter of ---__ ____----- - -- _ ._. -- -_ ---- _ __��._ -- _ _ __ Constructing a pubZic sewer ir�; �:�t:ST rIFT�l ST. from Maple St. to M$ria Ave. ; i�i- - EAST FOURTH ST. from Bates Ave.`�� �?ari.a Ave. ; in EAST THIRD ST, froen Bates Ave. to Maria Ave. ; in MAPLE ST. from -E. Fourth St. to Conway St. ; in CONWAY ST. from Maple St. to Maria Ave. ; in SURREY AVE. fram Bates Ave. to Maria Ave.; .in EUCLID ST. from Batea Ave. to Maria Ave, ; iri WII.SOfi AVE. from $ates Ave. to Maria Ave. ; in HUDSON RD. from Bates Ave, to Maria .��v�:�. ; in rLARIA AVE. and Minnesota Highway De- partment right-of-way from East F�ftt� �t, to McLean Ave. ; in an easement, to be obtained, in Lots 5, 6, 7, 8 and �, of Block 8, Suburban Hills Addition; in URBAN PLACE from Maria Ave. to Mouncls B].vd. ; in an easement along the centerline of Urban Place extended from Ntounds ��ule�-ard to the established Harbor Line., all to be known as MARIA-THIRD STORM Sk:4�TER SYSTEM (S-1438). ALSO, construct a public sewer in EARL ST. from Thorn Ave, to Pricif.ic St. ; in PACIFIC ST. from Earl St. to Cypress St. ; in Lot S, Blk. 7, Rc>�er's R�arrangement of Block 7 of McLeans' Reser- vation to St. Paul from Pacifi.c St, r•.autherly to the alley; in CYPRESS ST. from McLean Ave. to Pacific St. ; in CYFP.F,55 ST. 3nd Minnesota Highway Department right- of-way from Old Hudson Roac3 to the �~nuth ��erm of proposed Trunk Highway 94; iri � PACIFIC ST. and Minnesota Highway Dc,.�art.lent right-of-way from Cypress St. to the south berm of proposed Trunk tiightiaay 9'+; i.n the south herm of proposed Trunk High- '- way 94 from Cypress St, to 910 feet. w�st af Cypress St. ; in FOREST STREET and � � ' Minnesota Highway Department ri�ht-of-way from Pacific St. to the south berm of '� propose� Trunk Highway 94; in Minnesota Highway Department right-of-way from south berm of proposed Trunk Highway 94 t� the existing drop shaft located in Old Hudson Road approximately 95 feet east c�f �taple Street, all to be known as CYPRESS STREET RELIEF SEWER SYSTEM (5-1064B), ' _.CIUUJtJ1V-.�LC31.......�:_ivu+ uezc..... ...... ..�, ue..,..... ...�.• .� ....- .y....._. .�....♦ •�.�.�..u..�'1"x'iti►.r�v�o�v�v.r- es� _ _..__ -.._...._._._. �..,.�_i,,�_.-.�._-o,v ._..�r�-- par.tment right-of-way"fratn' Ea�t`-F`i_fth_§t:._to"i�i�Lean Ave, , -in an`�ars�f��n�-," �o"be _`.,"- ~ abtained, in Lots 5, 6, 7, 8 and 9, of Bl�ck 8, Suburban Hills Addition; in_ UR13AN PLACE from Maria Ave. to Mc�unds Filvd. ; in an easement along the centeriine"of Urban Place extended from Mounds F�tilev�rci to the established Harbor Line, , all to be known as MARIA-THIRD ST�RM S�Tr'ER �YSTF.M (S-1438). ALSO, construet a public sewer in EARL ST. from Ttiorn Ave, tc P�cific St. ; in PACIFIC ST, from Earl St. to Cypress St. ; in Lot S, Blk. 7, Roger's ?tearrangement of Block 7 of McLeans` Reser- vation to St. Paul from Pacific �t. ��r�utherly to the alley; in CYPRESS ST. from ', McLean Ave. to Pacific St. ; in CYPREyS ST. and Minnesota Highway Department righC- ' of-way from Old Hudson Road to the sc�uth berm of proposed Trunk Highway 94; in PACIFIC ST. and Minnesota Highway Dep�.rtment right-of-way from Cypress St. to the ' south berm of proposed Trunk Higtn.�ay 9=�.; in the south berm of proposed Trunk High- � way 94 from Cypress St, to 910 fee� west af Cypress St. ; in FOREST STREET and Minnesota Highway Department right-of-471� £rom Pacific St. to the south berm of . � , proposed Trunk Highway 94; in Mi.anesota Highway Department right-of-way from south berm of proposed Trunk Highway 9�E to the �xisting drop shaft located in Old Hudson Road approximately 95 feet east of Maple Street, all to be known as CXPRESS ST REET RELIEF SEWER SYSTEM (5-10648), - `UIl Y Y 71�T---._. ...—..—____ _ . . _ �. � . .. ��_rT�� A�F�1 V V Gu... L�r.�� i. s -- - M�R��'��T�-� J' aP�,�;��:,� � —�n Favor �IcCA TY � r ro��ret PUBL�SHED JAN 2 9 972 �� , ' . . . •�- ��5� , ` v `' . tb ����9�1 OFFICE OF THE COMMtSSiONER OF PUBLIC WORKS REPORT TO COMMISSIONER OF FINANCE August 23 �g 71 To the CommiSSioner of Finance of the City of St. Paul : �The Commissioner of Public Works, having had under consideration the preliminary oTd�� of the Council known as Council File No. 255309 approved .� �xAuo�t�t 13� .� 19 71 re 1 a t i ve to i transmit herewith preliminary estimate of cost for the construction of a pubTic sewer in EAST FfFTH ST. from Maple St. to Maria Ave. ; in EAST FOURTN ST. from Bates Ave. to Maria Ave. ; in EAST THIRD ST. from Bates Ave. to Maria Ave.; in ' MRPLE ST, from East Fourth St. ta Conway St. ; in CONWAY ST. fram Maple St. to Maria Ave. ; in SURREY AVE. from Bates Ave. to Maria Ave. ; in EUCL�D ST. f rom Bates Ave. to Maria Ave. ; in blILSON AVE. from Bates Ave. to Maria Ave. ; in HUDSON ROAD from Bates Ave. to Maria Ave. ; in MARIA AVE. and Minnesota Highway Depart- ment right-of-way from East Fifth St. to McLean Ave. ; in an easement to be obtained in Lots 5, 6, 7, 8 and 9 of Block 8, Suburban Hills Addition; in URBAN PLACE from Maria Ave. to Mounds Boulevard; in an easement along the centerline of Urban P1ace extended from Mounds 8ouleva�d to the established Harbor i.ine. Ali to be known as MARIA-TNIRD STORM SEWER SYSTEM (S-1438) , - � � i . The estimated cost thereof is $ 702,��.�� 2. A plan, profile or sketch of said improvement is hereto attached and ma de a pa r t he reof. 3. Initiated by the Commissioner of Public Works x � 4. Improvement is asked for upon petition � 'LQ25;'� 8,�9�D ._ ti � ti AUG 1.971 � � �"��EIVED w; � Commi sioner of Pubi ic Wor�cs �- '� .�� � `A �,�PT. OF c. : ��' :,NCE �,`� � ,t�,E„ ,. � yy�,�,�1 , - '��, Zt�ti v,., , . . - . , . . _, . OFFICE OF THE CQMMISSI0�IER OF PUBI,IC WORKS REPORT TO CONA4ISSIONER OF FINANCE August 23 19 71 To the Corrnnissioner of Finance of the City of Saint PauL• The Commissioner of Public Works� having had under consideration the pre- liminary order of the Council� known as Council File No. 255310 approved August 13, 19 71 relative to -- . _ __ -- . _ __. . _ . -_ ,, r 1 also transmit herewith pretiminary estimate'of cosC for t'he co truction of a public sewer in EAP.I STREET from Tharn Ave. to Pacific St. ; in PACIFIC ST. from ' _ Earl St. to Cypress St. ; in Lot S, Block 7, Rogers Rearrangement of Block 7 of McLeans ' Reservation to St. Paul from Pacific St. southerly to the altey; in ' _ CYPRESS ST. from McLean Ave. to Pacific St. ; in CYPRESS ST. and Minnesota Highway Department right-of-way from Old Hudson Rd. to the south berm of proposed Trunk _ Highway 94; in PACIFIC ST, and Mtnnesota Highway Department right-of-way from Cypress St. to the south berm of proposed Trunk Highway 94; in the south berm of _ proposed Trunk Highway 94 from Cypress St. to 910 feet west of Cypress St. ; in FOREST STREET And Minnesota Highway Department right-of-way from Pacific St. to a� the south berm of proposed Trunk Highway 94; in Minnesota Highway Department right-of-way frem south berm of proposed Trunk HigFnvay 94 to the existFng drap � shaft located in Old Hudson Rd, approximatety 95 feet east of Maple Street. Ail to be known as CYPRESS STREET RELIEF SEWER SYSTEM (S-10646) . � � 2. 1� plan� profile or sketch of said improvement is hereto attached and made a part hereof. 3. Initiated by the Commissioner of Public Works � � �.. Zinprovement is asked for upon petition O � F{;��jt��J��y�� �`r.��" ` � (, � "J�f^,•a <�v�' A U G �97� ' ��-�.� ' . ��-� � � , �-� �=".C��VE�: �\1�; o seioner of Public 'Works p �ji?T, C?'� <. ��y�'� ��l ,=1NANG� �C�' � '��'��,^ ����t����h�'V, ..,.K' �^C'':.h"'I � '.:� tt�n�. . � . . . . . +�5 i �fy�,rc�.'�d�F�"�4`$�.�,. ���ePA �:�'����t�'`,�'������`` � '?I r . . . °+ ��a�f yer� �r �, �' t�' '�'�'ti N y�s � . �;. ?< � `�� t �:�� . . , . . ..� . ' w .�. � 7�y ,�ci , �u� � �� v� r � ' �� , { � ,;r L N � i � , � + � CiTY 0 . �.�4 �' � j ��. ..•� . .... � ♦ -�• , . � � �'1' � . . d " � . �., ' � . . . . ► 4 . :- . .. � . . . O 'i . . , N. . . •� � • . . — ,! . . . . � ,- , . �,b -- � ^� i +.. 1 RICHARD A. SCHNARR C.r I T Y O F S A I N T P A U L GARY R. NORSTREM Chief Engineer peputy Commissioner ' Capital of Minnesote DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS . 234 City Hell E� CourF House 55102 ROGER M. CONWAY , ' � Commissioner � , August 23, 1971 Hon. Rosalie Butler Commissioner of Finance City of St. Paul Re: MARIA-TNIRD STORM SEWER SYSTEM (S-i438) and CYPRESS STREET RELIEF SEWER SYSTEM (S-10648) Dear Mrs. Butler: I transmit herewith preliminary estimate of cost for the construttion of a public sewer in EAST FIFTH ST, from Maple St. to Maria Ave. ; in EAST FOURTH ST, from Bates Ave. to Maria Ave. ; in EAST THIRD ST. from Bates Ave. to Maria Ave. ; in hlAPLE ST, from East Fourth St. to Con.vay St. ; in CONWAY ST. from Maple St. to Maria Ave. ; in SURREY AVE, from Bates Ave. to Maria Ave. ; in EUCLID ST. from Bates Ave. to Maria Ave. ; in WILSON AVE, from Bates Ave. to Maria Ave. ; in HUOSON ROAD from Bates Ave. to Maria Ave. ; in MARIA AVE, and Minnesota Highway Depart- ment right-of-way from East Fifth St, to McLean Ave. ; in an easement to be obtained in Lots 5, 6, 7, 8 and 9 of 81ock 8, Suburban Hiils Addition; in URBAN PLACE from Maria Ave. to Mounds Boulevard; in an easement along the centerline of Urban Place extended from Mounds Boulevard to the established Harbor Line. All to be known as MARIA-THIRD STORM SEWER SYSTEM (5-1438} , The afo�ementioned being under Preliminary Order C. F. No. 255309, approved August 13, 1971 . I also transmit herewith preliminary estimate of cost for the construction of a public sewer in EARI STREET from Thorn Ave. to Pacific St. ; in PACIFIC ST. from :' Earl St. to Cypress St. ; in Lot 5, Block 7, Rogers Rearrangement of Block 7 of ' Mcleans ' Reservation to St. Paul from Pacific St. southerly to the alley; in CYPRESS ST, from McLean Ave, to Pacific St. ; in CYPRESS ST, and Minnesota Highway Department right-of-way from Old Hudson Rd, to the south berm of p roposed Trunk Highway 94; in PACIFIC ST, and Minnesota Highway Department right-of-way from Cypress St, to the south berm of proposed Trunk Highway 94; in the south berm of proposed Trunk Highway 94 from Cypress St. to 910 feet west of Cypress St. ; in 1� FOREST STREET and Minnesota Highway Department right-of-way f rom Pacific St. to the south berm of. proposed Trunk Highway 94; in Minnesota iiighway Department � ��� ight-of-way from south berm of proposed Trunk Highway 94 to the existing drop �j ,`p�� <,,� ft located in Old Hudson Rd. approximate�y 95 feet east of Maple Street. Al1 ' .�0 ,� known as CYPRESS STREET RELIEF SEWER SYSTEM (S-10646) . The aforementionec��; � �� G�+ �e� under Preliminary Order C.F. No. 255310� approved August 13, 1971 . �/� D C'1� .� � � r ��'°� /�.� � � � ;�� �� G �' ;� 9�.�,o,�• � ��I � � �..� � '� ��8 L 9��` �� � ;tI �1 ,w ., ... R ,N,� . � �. . .. � .R . . � ^ . , . ... ' . .. . � n _2 . • - . ' - Since these two sewer projects have abutting drainage areas, it is requested ' . . that a combined hearing be held on the same date. projects have been put together on one drainage mapP�ease note that both MARIA-THIRD STORM SEWER SYSTEM (S-1438) Estimated Construction Cost Engineering 80 $634,480.00 Inspection 20 50,760.00 Non-Contract (Finance S Traffic) 12,690.00 TOTAL PROJECT COST 4,820.00 02�750,00 1971 Local Improvement Funds 140,000.00 1971 P.A.F. 460,000.00 Assessments 1972 Local Improvement Funds 51 ,550.00 51 ,200.00 CYPRESS STREET RELIEF SEWER SYSTEM Estimated Construction Cost Engineering 8i $��3,475.00 Inspection 2i $,28�.00 Non-Contract (Finance � Traffic) 2,070.00 TOTAL PROJECT COST 2 210.00 il ,035.0 1972 Local Improvement Funds g4,685.00 Assessments 21 ,350.00 r Yours ver truly, ��� � �'�-y Ro er M. ConwaJ�� / ,��_- � Commissioner of Pub ic Works RMC/DJD/kw ' ,.'� r� cc: James Schwartz Clem Schleck Richard Wheeler ' -- � �;�`�;,, �"�- : l' � T t : o r^' S �: .�'.J �,, Cr� � 1 � `�' �7 7�-t,, r`1 — -�. — ' ' 2���� ' �� ,,,��,a '�. �`��J, �c ;.:�_.�_s �a--c �._,, z__ G ��`O. c? � - . t� �r r `�N °r�, 1 /: o pu Et�� �'`�. � , � �,� � , C �� � p�'�T� �� ��;,�'� � � ��, �� r�Iti�����' �� � i �1'�'n � � '�et ��`yti��J� t i l:�r y� .:y �,. ...,...- . . .. . , . . y-��y,pyyyt �� ffj�.����.YL�MVAH � ' . .. . . . � . 1 ��,tXJ��' Il .�i �-4 / �.a``�.' �,1 y M��4A•�iy�'P"�{q4'K�n �'•�h�' � � � v�� � ��'+�1 tfit�a�S�Y ht��w�i� �s�� `-;'�t i i 4 r q ;. Va{uu4ion Enqineer 1'T t a,,ta�� F � �.jr ,� .,' =` j ,��`�. L��i+, 'f e�����'Id��`��;^" '&+5` d' !� � 4 •��7-b�17 . . � ,RQY �.a��QaH�.. ��. � I T `( � `= �' /� I I'�1 T p���J`�� t:�.�Nj � �� •� �� �; �,'j1�T �.r � � ; � Y � , � Ay,s t Yaluation �nc�inoor i ;r, • ^ � (3UF�''All �;; �/ALUATiONS � ' �^� c�t„ Han _ � � .;nin4 !',�ul. f,9innc;o4o 55102 . Jul!f 2?y 1971 I�fr. Dan�.e]. �unf.ord �et���.r En�;ineer De��,rtment of I?u�aic j�Tori,c T3LT:LI.DIT�x ��=� �'O}�Oif"� MLL�'l�l.-`.���'17_T'!�. �i�.C'iY`t'1 �fiftti'IE::Y' ;_� 1►3�3 �I1L'S?Z;a.21� �O L'OU2' Y'('+GL]Q^j. f1UT r? i;;i_P'�h u(? Oi T'O � n � F r, , � r � p xty acNeSement ��x the pro- p�.��c7 ,-,�'1RTA-Ti�1�D ,J.�)I,M ,_�T,i�,r'� !:;�.1 ����) is a� .follot,rs; T.st-�.m�,ted. �;o;;n1 �.mount re;;o�,��.,��bl� hy �,sses�?nent� �'7?_'�00 ie , t:;,t1.P?�.'�:�Cl. �.�,�^E`,^,^mC!1�, r�,�Fn ;�; 11 R�. �3 Itc�:;j'l.��nt]_�,1. P'^OpCZ't`I ��,O.OIj pE!X' FC�. f�:, , G 1,e.">.� CC`r!t1t. },. rY��7.. .1.'.rc�pCZ'1'.,y �j� rr �r n . �.1.C�'3.f;�' 1?1COT1�0?"�i: �� . , c t��e fol.loVri.i�; 1d:itiora�,1 co,;ts iz� the es�imated �ot�.7. C:Cp�?).C�]t1aT'c.^,' fUr trl'i.i 1.T1]C)rOV�?'!�Cl`�;� `f,�.1ua�`;:ion � /�,:a�;sm^n�; „�:�v:i_r.r..^ ��].,1a50 r�-1-�';C. �.�)�`��.,i l(�)�) ��-'?,TC',(j� n �n) �..�J3/ i�i? rCJ� !> Fnc.lo;ed i,� o�ar �;;-!;irn.�,�;+� m,<,,n. i�7.�a^e retuxn �.t yot�r convenienc�. Vcry i,r�:,.i-Y 'f�'�"��, • ;l,��'�, <�?' %y:;;l� :�^',,_-1 !�i f � . �. _ , _ � ;� Roy " , ��rcd.�.iil, ,Ta^, llssistar:t �,%a:i,u.��.t:ion I;nrri.n�er RL33:clm . Enc. cc: Pau1 z�c,^ci��. ✓ ,,� _-�' � � . ,r •. • `��\✓ ' • / � , � St .� aul , P`inn. � Jan. 10, 1972 � �`rs . Rosalie L. Dutler % � `' ��`o� �s�c�, , z L!/.c-�/.-s�'t�"� J" � Cor:imissioner of Finance, 113 Court House, st.Paul, r.�ir�. , 5�102 Dear Mrs. Butler: This is to protest any assessment against my propertie for the proposed se�ver in ?�;ilson from Bates to R�+aria as outlined in yours of Dec. 30� 1971. A''yriad reasons for protesting include: There is no legal nPed for the sewer. All St.Paul seweraFe and water systems were adequate until grafters in politics gave use of them to suburbs for a consideration. It is confiscatory and unconstitional to levy assessments against our poor old homeowners who are presently ma.king the greatest struggles of their lives to rer�ain in their homes in the face of confiscatory demands from tax collectors. There is no good reason why the six old widows who live along my block should be put through the tax-collector's wringer to pay for benefits to richer persons living anywhere from Lak� Forest to Lake �':innetonka. Please consider the assessments already paid by homeowners who live in my block� which was on the tax rolls and paying taxes and assessments for 50 years before there was anything taxable west of Dale street: Assessment for r�?o�itrds Park. AssessMent for enlargeMent of ���ounds Park. Assessment for water and sewers and street improvements. Assessment for right-of-�vay and construction of ARounds Boulevard from Seventh to rv?ounds Park For relief sewer under Hoffman. Right-of-�vay of Johnson Parkway and original grading. One �hird street bridge that was never built. Another that was built.. Dayton's Bluff taxpayers paid for every public improvem�ent on Dayton's Bluff. Then they were assessed to pay for land and improvements at Highland Park on the theory that they were benefitting from that. After Dayton's Bluff residents had paid for all their own community improvements � politicians changed the rules and made them pay for community improver�ents for the rich in Highland Park. They have already paid and paid and paid and there is no legal reason why they should pay ��ore because some new branch of government has issued an order for �300,000,000 of sewer improver�ents in St .Paul. The St.Paul City Council should launch a vigorous attack against such an order, which is clearly cc�nfiscatory and unconstituti�nal. You do not have to be a Butler Brothers engineer to know that it is wrong to hook up Forest Lake sewers to St.Paul sewers , or to hook up Lake rlinnetonka sewers to St .Paul sewers. It is perfectly legal to tell those communities to extend their own sewers to their own disnosal plants. There is no reason why every new concrete highway should be hooked up to St.Paul streets . �Tei.t:her is there any reason why suburban sewers should be connected to St,Paul sewers. +; , , , �, Sheet two--L�cConnell Please consider the preser.t practices in richer and more advanced states: The Tllinois Envjronment`1 Protection Agency is preventing builders fro�r. connecting netiv homes to sewer lines in communities where tr�e sewage treatmer�t plants are overloaded. The ban has stopped construction in much of Lake County and in other areas throughout the Chicago suburbs . If the St.Paul City Council had taken similar action 20 years ago there would be no need for the �roiect outlined in your letter. R2ost rental property on 1?ayton's Bluff was built by men who never earned more than $75v00 per mrnth. They and their families were extre��ely frugal and it was a ma�or accor��lishment for them to get a �5�000 home paid for. Then the �5,000.00 of insurance the father left was used to build a duplex. That would give the widow �50 to �100 a month and a business of her own in renting and caring for tr.e duplex. It was the best method knovan ta man for providing for a widow. It still is the best way a man can provide for his own old age and also that of his widow. Tax collectors are confiscating their meager incone, food, medical care, clothing, other property and even the widow'�itE T�Zost men no�� working under pension plans shall never receive one dollar of pension. I�ports of textiles � watches � shoes , steel� etc. , have ruined the business of American manufacturers of such articles. Hundreds of co�panies have gone broke because tr:ey pay wages four times as high as foreign manufacturers and must sell their product in co�:petition with lo�v-�xa�e producers. A Dul�:th steel mill has laid off 2,G00 employees because their custorners are now buying Gerrran and Japanese steel. In sor.�e cases , workers have voted to l,et manage�:ent use the pension fund to finance another year or two of manufacturing and etr�oyment before going out of business . It would be good soc:.al service for you and other members of the St.Paul City Council to resist orders for more sewerage and transportation assessments as they come from nev� units of goverrunent. It would not take much of a lavayer to prove that such orders are confiscatory and unconstitutional. Sincerely, From C. E. McConnell, J �J �J �.. �_ 1 � 733 �'ilson avenue, -- St.Paul� T�finn. � 551c�6 Tel 776-4343 �S � ° � u J��.-�uary 13, 1�l� 2�ir. �. �. ��t��onn+ell 7�:i jk'.L�.�4�'s �i�,��:L:41� ��. P�+�1, I�i�r�le6ota 551Q6 D�ar tir. McCon�e�11 i Yaur l,etter a� ab,�ection tc ths propo�a�d "Cypx�eas Street Relief Starffi 3ewer Sqetem", hea bee� r�c�sived arsd wi13 be rs- ferred ta tha� CiCy Clazk for prea,�at�tia� to the Ci.ty C�uncil at the public he�ring �O bs h��d on 3ane��ry 19, 1972. 'Z'[iank yau for yaur ma�y valid camc��nt�. Very truly youx�s, Roselie L. Bu�ler Cc�mmi�aionex of �i�Anc� cc: City Cl�r�c� Fina�ce Pile