259630 ORI�INAL TO CITY CLBRK � 25963+�
.� CITY OF ST. PAUL ��NCa NO.
. OFF E OF THE CITY CLERK
, U SOLUTION—GENERAL FORM
PRESENTED BY �`
COMMISSIONE ATF
R�30LVED, that the Cauncil �cr�by ratifieg and approv�s
t'h�e action, of the Saint Pavl Bc�a,rd of Appeals and Rev3e� for
th� Aousing, Building end Fire Prev�ention Codea pertaining to
ths follcy�ing ].i.e�t►ad property and aa ahv�m by th� of'ficial
miautes oP said Bc�rd of A�peals, dated August 9, 1972, a� cvpy
ef �hich, marked SXHIBIT "A", is attached h�reto s.ud, msc�,e a
gart hereof by reference: ,
Caae 1�A. � Appellant
51-72-B 1454 Albemarle Gary HQgner
53-72-P 256-260 Charles John Sauro
52-72-B 2178 �. Third Street Lloyd I,�rson
5�+-72-P 846 Ho11y Robert We�tern
� ��
� �
� � ��
COUNCILMEN Adopted by the Councit 19—
Yeas Naya
Bu ler �.,�-.��;, �� P 8 197a
Hun�f �� -:�^:; Approv 19—
ar on Konopa'fz� "`"•. �
L vi e Levine j , �Y ' -
Tn FSVOr
M e ith MereditFl ���
Sprafka (� Mayor
Sp a Tedesco Against
Ted co M me. Presidellf�,�11�1
F APP '
Mr. Preside . , McCarty '�
; '.
' Atat� City Atto ey
���
puBUS�� SEP 16 1972
. � �` i
• • �'I�-���'� '� �J���� l�eeting �09/75
,
MIIIUTES OF TI� l�TI1lG
3T. PAUL BQARD OF APPaAIS
wednesday, Angunt 9, 1972
Rc�am 2�0, Bureau of Fiea.lth, 555 �e�ar street
Members Preserrt: Arthvr Tieso
P�orme� Seamtna]cdos'f
Tetyr Peake
James Voigt
Members Abserrt: Donsld Wozniak
Raymond Grov�e
Mitchell Kamin
A�encies Present: Buildimg D�psrtm�ent - aleaa Erickson snd PYaak
Stati'e�aon
bthers Present: C. W. A4ichsel, Dsa McMa,nigle, �]1.an M�n3gle,
Llayd Larsom, Le,�rence Pelsan, David Co�ter,
Gary Aeg�er, John 8snro, Robert Westera, Stev�e Ikeda
Mi.rxutes of the July 26, 1972 meeting �ere approv�ed as Mritten.
39-72-s 25 L�. Sev�e�rtb Street xewmans
SUBJECT
Conticzued frcm n�eting oP Ju�y 26, 1972
APPEARANCES
C. W. Michael
PROCEEDII�38
At this t1me, most of the Board membera, as yet, hsd no�t had a chance to
exa�aine the property.
• • .
,
ACTION
Unanimausly agreed to postponee the mntter uutil the Augu+st 23, 1972, Board
meeting.
43-72-H 453-�55 E. Page Dsn McMa,tiigle
SUBJLCT
Corrtimud f�cm meeting of Ju7y 26, 1972
APPA',,ARAI�CRB
Allan McManigle, D�►n 1�cManigle
�oc�a,vr.�t�s
A represerrtativ�e f�am the Rathchild Canpaupr tiss ao�t pres�nt. �aa�erdc��f
a�1d like to aee snoth�r stteapt at getting aam�ne !'rm the R�thchild
Caapanbr. This mstter mnst be resolv�ed by the Ae�gaat 23 Hoard meeting. The
Buildin�B De�partm�nt has a tentatiws schedul.e i'� r�inapectioe� on tbe 29th
of Avgust. �taftenaon felt that tlsia aaat be taken care of b�tor� cold
�reather eets in.
ACTIOI�
unanimw$ly egreed to coati�e the adtter ontil tbe Avgvst 23, 19'�'2, Hosrd
meeting.
�-70-H 359-�1 Msr3.e� David Coster
SUBJECT
Origir�l appeal� Mse the result of an iaspectia�n rgpo�t of July 29, 1970,
ahich required that Mr. Coater sxitch his facility to plain rooming units
with no cookie�g priviliges or provid�e a cc�m�].�►te bathrnaa� fa� each roan.
In s mation by the Board on October 28, 1970, �r. Cmster t�ss giv�en 18
mosths to provid�e bsthroaa� fscilities. As o! tkis date, bstHr000s ha,v�e
not been instelled.
APPF.ARA110E3
D�vid Coster
�
. PROCL'f�:DINGS
12 units ahare 2 baths. Mr. Coater wants to put in 9 bathr000s. The
building is nat licensed as a Rooming Hause. Mr. Coster ha,s purchased
fixtures w�3iich he Mill inatall. E�+erything else in the building is
in fairly good ehape. Coster doe�n't knc�r ho�t long it Mill take to
inatall fixtures.
ACTION
Moved by S�erdorf to allow bathroa�n �acilities to remsia ae noa
provided until tranafer of title. 3econded by Peake.
THE VOTE
Ayes: Tieso, Soammerdorf, Peake, Voigt. Nsyea: aoae. Abat�ations: ao�e.
Mation carried Paur (4) to zero (0).
51-72-B 1454 Albema,rle Gsry H�gner
3UBJECT
Appesling section of the Uniform Building Cod�e which restricta the
construction of � t�o-sto�y dcyutble gsre�ge.
APPRARAI�CEB
asry Hegner
PROCSSDI1KiS
i�. Hege�er �raats to loPt 25 psir of baming pigecwa xhich he pnrchsaed for
a conaic1ereble e�m�ount of ao�onmy. �e feels that the secaad eto�y loPt �111
giv�e ad�quate pro�tection agAinst receat break iao, �i.ch be lsas eaperieaced
recently. The second etory ares will slso be uaefl to �tore seaaoaal toals
e�nd childran's toys. Five �reeka ago he eo�uld hsv+e bnilt the garage xith
no appeal.
ACTION
Motion by Tieso to allcyw for the constrnct3oa af a t�o-steuy dorotble garage
at the e�bov�e-d�escribed prvperty. •�>F,��u(�D �,Y F'����
TI� VO►1'E
�j►ea: Tieso, Sam�nerdorf, Peake, Yoigt. asy�es: none. Absteatio�na: noae.
Mo�tion carried faur (4) to zero (0).
� 53-72-� 2y6-260 Charles John Sa.nro
3UBJF.CT
Regarding a survey of April 25, 1972. Mr. Sa►uro is e►ppaaling tbe entire
surv�ey. Mr. Sauro atated ttaat the Thame�s-D�l.e HIiA t�s inspectmd the
property and agreed to tske i� ie1 the n�ear fliturs.
APPgARAl'�CES
John F. 8auro
PROCP.'�DI1GS
The building wa,s placarded two ciays ago. Irtr. Sauro's reqwe�t for purchase
of the property hae been f�.led xi.th �A. Aa said tbat ttsia astter �ill
be considered at a September meeting. Mr. 8auro stated he ie asking !os
n�e time to take care oP things until he finds oat �hst �A xilt do. Tieso
xvuld like to see saneone Pra�n the HRA ofYice c6me bere to e�lairi t1� aitu-
atian. StaPPensott feels thst tbera i8 an extsnsive amaiunt of daterioratian
at the prvperty. There ia oc� tenant in eaeh spartmant. PrxeBnre slux�td
be revised ao the,t Bodrd of Appeals natifies t�e Building Dapartm�nt of a41.1.
appeale as ttuy are filed.
ACTIOn
Mation by Voigt to lit't cond,eapatio� uatil the Nouaing and Red�ev�elopm�ent
Authority me�lces a d�ePinite caomitment r�gardixag the purctiase of the
property. Poaition letter of 1�tA aust be provicled by fie�pt�ber 13, 1972,
Board meeting.
TFIIg V0�1'E
�yes: Tieeo, Samaaerdorf, Peake, Voigt. I�y�es: ndeLe. Abst�ations: noe�e.
Hation ce.rried four (4) to ztro (o).
52-72-8 2178 S. Third Street I1cyd LRrson
SUBJECT
1�. Le�reon is appealiag the requirement that a gar�ge be x�o cloaer tban 2'
t�am prvperty lin�e. H�e praposes to extend the ge�rage 8' to tY�e back. To
build the extenBiOn 2' t'roaa pa�perty line t�ronld e=este an u�attrae'tiv+e
appearwnce a,nd liait the s�mau�nt oY u�esble spaae.
APP$ARAI'�Es
iloyd Lnreon, Iaxrence l�el.son
" �xoc�nrr�s
Mr. Lexson feels that the proposed additioa �ai1d not be a d�etriment to
anprone concern�ed. Mr. I,e«wrence �elson is hera to appear in apposition
to the prapoeed constru.ction. Mr. Nelson doesn't Peel that he wrntl.d be
able to build ar�prthing wh3.ch didn't meet code. Eydatir�g structure i�
13��� t'ran Property line. According to l�r. �elso�, esrboa moaood� gas is
strong in his home, eve+n xhen 1� hae the Mi.nde� cloaed.
ACTION
Mov�ed by Voigt that appe�al to conetruct a,dd.i.tion to extstibg garege as
prvpoaed by appellatrt be grant.d. 3econded by Sdmderderf.
THS VO2S
l�ye�: Tieao, Son�erdorY, Peake, Voi.gt. �Te,yree: none. Abstentions: none.
Motion carried faiu� (�+) to zero (0).
5k-72-P 846 Hol]y Rflbert liestern
3UBJECT
Mr. Wsstern ie appesllbe certsin items listed i.n inapectian letter dated
July 24, 1972, t'ram the Bt�il.ding De�p�rtmeat.
APPE�ARAI�EB
Robert Westera, Richard 83man
PROCBEDI�3
Mr. �lestern reqaested en inspectioa b�fo�e he �a►s resd�y to sell the house.
Western caanplied �►i.th ell �k reqweated in iaspectimt letter o! Oetober,
1970 and as a result, reeeiv�td a letter o! cong�lie�ace dsted January 27, 1972.
Mr. We�tern �ecured an es�nest aon�y co�tract �ated J'�].y 6, 1972. l�r. Western
then received s letter dat�d daly 28, 1972 as a reault of a stirvey of the
praperty. The sppel3ae�t is a�ali�ag eleetrieal smd. pltmibing requirements
of that letter.
A campliance letter is good fe'� s six-month period. F�A inapecto�s ax�e
ea�errtially sdminiatratcrrs end nat ia�psato�s. �r. �imon Yeels that b�r
aha�ld be a�are of e�ll ite�a �hi.ch are rsiv�sd. Mr. We�tera agreed tbat 1ie
xill me�ke the purcbaser aMSre o! all items meactioned in t�e surre�y. 1rHA aad
tbe aBailaing D�pei,rtment i�u�pectic�a eare qnite airrsrent. Idr. Wsatern �a
unaware of expirstion date of l�ett�r of canpliaue. In l�DP areaa there ia
an egreement bet�neen FHA and I�A tbst 1�iA trill sbid�e by city inspsctit�n.
Mr. Weatern Peela 60 aaq� aervl.ce ia acleqvete. Campliance letter only calls
items t+hich �w�ere an the original. report. No ae�r i��ns are called oa a
campliuice inspection. I�r. Westera is sp�ealing ctiange to 100 a�mp serrice
and plumbing requirements.
_ , .
ACTIOK
Mation by Tieso to enable preesst strps to ra■ain as canatracted; ba.7.ance
of fluing on 60 amp serr�riice tc camp]�y xith 1�A rsquir�aents rather tt�an
instaLli.ng 100 amp service; and it�rtih,�r, Ma,iver is grsnted so that
caa�pliance ia nat requir�d as p�r Item Ao. 6 vAear Sleatrical, Item4 I1�.'a
1 e�nd 2 uncler Waate and Verrt�, Item I�o. 1 rom�tr Ia�mdsy Tra�r, Item Ao. 2
under tbe hsading Wster Cloaet, and Itean �fo.'a l, 2 & 3 w�er ��ing
Kitchen 3ink. (AL1 itea�is referred tc are li�ted in ]retter o! .�.'�y 2�, 1972,
tram ttie Building Da�art�ent to Richard Si�m�o�.)
50-?2-B 809 De�y�on Avenue $styr A�radl�ry Pealte
SIJEi.]ECT
Appealing irratalls�tion o! rails in�aid�e of sid� srms o� stoate ate�pa.
ACTION
Dwe to ],sek ot qvca�um, the Board �ves unsbl.e to he4r the case. Th3.s csse
�vill be heard on August 23, 1972.
259630
p����n����
. CITY OF ST. PAUL �N«� NO
- OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK �
� COUNCIL RESOLUTION—G�ERAL FORM
n�esr�.r
COMMISSIONER �A*�
�/QI�YZD, tl� '�Ls Cedn1011 l�reby r+�t1liv idl �ll�q-
tlr �ien o� the Saiat P�n7. Dsar!! e? l�psair ar�d �rni+Nt t�o�
� �in6, �n6 and �ir� Prrr�sE�ien Ceidn perrt�tini� t�
t� i'�ll+wri�o� li�t�d �epe�r6� and u � by t�e ottl.eia].
a�i�ao�s � said Heard o�' Appesis, dat�d Angas� 9, 19'l2, a mop�r
O� Nh1Qh� a�GAd �'ffi1' n�"� '!.i t�t�tCll/d h�0 aAd s11t!!� t
latt � by �a�t s
�� �� ����
�1•T�-s 1��4 A�tb�r.Nr3�r tia�7► 8�
S3-T'�! 2g6-260 Chsrlts dobn Ssu�+o
'f 2•7�-D a178 s. 'lbita Af�rrs�t Llayd Iarrmn
�►'72�1' 8�6 Sol]J► Robest Ne�era
SEP ? 1972
COUNCILMEN 1�dopted by� the �Council 18_.
Yeas Nays
�.� SEP 81972
Bu � H�� � - ::, �
lson Konopa�d `'��`;`'� Appro� 18_
Levine ���
• Mereditli �� -�—In Favor
re��Sprafka � ��
S Tedesco ero;,�At
T d aco M me. President8 Butlel
Mr. Preai t, McCarty
��