259583� ORIGINAL TO CITY CL[RK �59��3
CITY OF ST. PAUL NOE NCIL NO.
' � . OFFI E ITY CLERK
' COU I ENERAL FORM
• �
PRESENTED BY
COMMISSIONE ATE
RESOLVED, Upon and pursuant to the pertinent appeal,
under the Zoning Code, by Virgil Doerfler, as owner of the
subject real estate, situate in the City of Saint Paul,
zoned in "C" Residence District, under the Zoning Code, and
described as:
West 42 ft. of Lot 18, N. '� of Lots
19, 20, 21, Block 2, Cruickshank' s
Garden Lots and the N. � of Lot 22
except the N. 135 ft, thereof, Block
2, Cruickshank' s Garden Lots;
that the provisions of said Zoning Code hereby are determined
and varied as and to the extent necessary therefor, and the
setback requirements for said property are hereby relaxed so
as to accommodate apartment buildings; be it
FURTHER RESOLVED, That Virgil Doerfler be and hereby is
granted a permit to install and operate a 207-car parking lot
for use with apartments on property located on the south side
� of York between Birmingham and Hazelwood, more particularly
described as:
West 42 ft. of Lot 18, N. � of Lots
19, 20, 21, Block 2, Cruickshank' s
b �
W � Garden Lots and the N. � of Lot 22
� � except the N. 135 ft, thereof, Block
� Q 2, Cruickshank' s Garden Lots;
a >,
a �
d �; all in accordance with plans dated Received December 6, 1971;
� � Q subject to the condition that said applicant-permittee, and
ti his successors and assigns, shall make due compliance with all
applicable provisions of municipal ordinances, state statutes
and rules and regulations of public authorities having cognizance.
COUNCILMEN Adopted by the Council pjU� 3 1 197�19—
Yeas Naya
utler Hu� � .� ,. �� ' AU6 3 1 �919—
arlson Konopa� �c:`:.:�� APProv
evine � °�-- `"�.� �,
�ereditll � '`V� =�n Favor
eredi prafka `�
S rafk
v A gainst
Te esc����dent��p#le� , _
� ����
Mr. P si t, McCarty
PUBLI��IED 5EP �► 197�
��
, .
�
` � ,
� BOARD OF ZONING, CITY OF ST. PAUL �j �
' ' c�
1010 COMMERCE BUILDING • ST. PAUL,MINNESOTA 55101 • PHONE: 223-4151
August 2, 1972
Mr. Harry E. Marshall
City Clerk
Room 386 City Hall
Dear Sir:
This is written in response to Virgil Doerfler's appeal to relax the setback require-
ments and application for a permit to install and operate a 207-car parking lot on
property located on the south side of York between Birmingham and Hazelwood. This
property is further described as follows:
West 42 ft. of Lot 18, N. Z of Lots 19, 20, 21, Block 2, Cruickshank's
Garden Lots and the N. 2 of Lot 22 except the N. 135 ft. thereof,
Block 2, Cruickshank's Garden Lots.
These matters were first heard at the January 6, 1972, Board of Zoning public
hearing at which time the Board noted the matters were not represented.
In response to questions from the Board, the staff said this involved a setback
variance and the site had a variation in grade but not so large a variation that it
could not be leveled.
In discussing this matter, one member of the Board pointed out that the legal setback
requirement is large because the lot is deep. Another member said this greater
depth makes it easier to provide a greater setback. It was mentioned that 15 feet
isn't a large enough setback and the appellant should have known the requirements at
the time he purchased the property.
Subsequently, it was moved that the Board recommend denial of the appeal because
there is no hardship and that the application for a parking lot be laid over. These
motions were seconded and carried.
At the July 6, 1972, Board meeting it was disclosed that the appellant had sent a
letter requesting the Board to reconsider the action of January 6, 1972. After some
discussion, there was a motion to reconsider these matters at the next meeting. The
motion was seconded and carried by a vote of 5 to 0.
These matters were again heard at the July 20, 1972, Board of Zoning public hearing,
at which time the staff report on file for the appeal was read. Concerning the permit,
the staff noted that except for those items under appeal, the plan meets minimum
design standards.
The appellant stated he didn't know how he would get the buildings on the site
without a variance.
As the Board considered these matters, they discussed the setback of the houses at
the corner of York and Birmingham. One member thought that the 1ega1 setback for the
subject site was too great but that the requested setback was too small.
� j �.
G �•,, � �
,
Mr. Harry E. Marshall Page 2 August 2, 1972
Subsequently, the Board heard a motion to recommend approval of the setback
variance because the adjoining houses are set back no more than 15 feet. The second
motion expressed the belief that the development would be an improvement. This
motion carried by a vote of 4 to 0.
Another motion was made to recommend approval of the parking 1ot application. This
motion was seconded and carried by a vote of 4 to 0.
Ve uly yours,
r
PETER J. MAIETTA
Secretary, Board of Zoning
PJM:PLR:mb
Z. F. �k7293
_� ., ,� �- .
. BOARD OP' ZONING REPORT AND ACTION July 20
Plat Map 3�
� , Acting under Legislative Code Chapter 60 thru 64
� passed August 22, 1922_, as amended to January 27, 1971.
' 7293
1. APPLICANT'S NAME . Virgil Doerfler 5044
7218
2. CLASSIFICATION . � Amendment a Appeal � Permit � Other
X-1148
3. PURPOSE , Relax building line setback requirements
4. LOCATION , South side of York between Birmingham and Hazelwood
S. LEGAL DESCRIPTION : West 42 ft. of Lot 18, north 2 of Lots 19-21, Block 2,
Cruickshank's Garden Lots & the north z of Lot 22 except
the north 135 ft. thereof, Block 2, Cruickshank.'s Garden Lots .
6. PRESENT ZONING: "C" Residential
7 . PURSUANT TO Zoning Code Chapter: 64 Section: .03 Paragraph: j
8. STAFF INVESTIGATION & REPORT: Date: December 21, 1971 By: ATB
A. HISTORY: This property was rezoned to "C" Residential on November 27, 1971.
B. PROPOSAL: The appellant proposes to develop the property with apartment buildings
built within 15 ft. of the front property lines .
C. PRESENT STANDARDS: This parcel has two front yards: on York Avenue and on undevel-
oped Stillwater Avenue. The legal setback line on these yards is "10% of the depth of
the lot or 31 ft.
D. VARIANCE: The proposed setback is 15 ft. or 48.39% of that required by the Code.
E. AREA ZONING: A Commercial district exists along E. Seventh Street. A "C" Residence
district exists southeast of this parcel across Stillwater Avenue, adjacent to this
parcel to the east and on both sides of Birmingham north of York Avenue. A "B" Resi-
dence d��trlct lies in the general area west of Birmingham Street. The rest of the
area, iti: luding most of this block, is "A" Residential.
F. SITE CONDITIONS: The topography of the site is not severe, The area adjacent to
York Avenue is higher than the area adjacent to unimproved Stillwater Avenue. The land
is vacant. Some earth has been removed from the site or used to grade the site.
G. AREA CONDITIONS: York Avenue is unimproved from Birmingham Street westward. Still-
water Avenue is unimproved as is Birmingham Street from York Avenue to East 7th Street.
Access from the west is limited to Case Avenue from Johnson Parkway to B?rmingham or
Barclay, then south to York Avenue. York Avenue providE�s access from White Bear Avenue
six blocks to the east.
9. B09Rll ACTION: To Recommend � Approval � Denial Council Letter
' Dated:
Yeas Nays August 2, 1972
Moved by . Benshoof X Benshoof
- X Maietta Date of
Seconded by: Maietta X Quast Hearing:
X Cochrane August 17, 1972
Secretary's remarks :
Council Action•
. Date.
. `
.,
� ~
I � D%
�.
_��� � ,° � ►
� �
December 9, 1971
The Honorable Mayor and
Members of the City Council
�/o City Clerk
Room 386, City Hall
Gentlemen and Madam:
My name is Virgil Uoerfler, Phone No. 488-6761 . The legal description
of my property is: All that part of the W. 42' of Lot 18; all of Lots 19-21 ,
and the S. 178' Lot 22, lying N' ly. of Stiliwater Ave. of Cruickshank's
Garden Lots. The property is located between Bush Ave. and Stiliwater Ave.
and east of Birmingham Ave.
The present use of the property is vacant. The proposed use of the
property is 136 apartment units and 206 car spaces.
The purpose of the appeal is to relax the established building line
setbacks to 15 feet from York Ave. and 15 feet from Stillwater Ave. The
need of the appeal is to establish a more realistic setback requirement then
what is presently required. The Section of Ordinance appealing under is:
Legislative Code Chapter 64.03, Paragraph j.
Very tr yours �
�✓ ' � S��
��� ---.
Vi rgi i Doerf ler
°Y'- '�'`�`�'�
_- -- .� -' �'�.--
_._._.,--- �� �?-.`.`�
���� �
BOAl2D 0'r' ZONING F:F.POKT AND ACTION July 20, 1972 Plat Map ��37
' Actin�; under Legislative Code Chapter 60 thru G4
' � Passed August 22, 1922, as anlended to Jai�uary 27, 1971. 7277
' 1. APPLICANT'S NA?ME . \'irgil Doerfl��r
� 7218
2. CLASSIFICATION . � Amendment � Appeal � Permit � Other
X-1148
3. PURPOSE ' . Construct a 207-car parking lot for use with apartments
4. LOCATION , South side of York between Birmingham and Hazelwood
5. LEGAL DESCRIPTION : West 42 ft. of Lot 18, N. z of Lots 19, 20, 21, Block 2,
Cruickshank's Garden Lots and the N. 2 of Lot 22 except the N. 135 ft. thereof,
Block 2, Cruickshank's Garden Lots .
6. PRESENT ZONING: "C" Residential
7. PURSUANT TO Zoning Code Chapter: 60 Section• •23 Paragraph: 4,b
8. STAFF INVESTIGATION & REPORT: Date: December 21, 1971 By: ATB
A. HISTORY: This property was rezoned to "C" Residential on November 27, 1971.
B. AREA ZONING: A Commercial district exists along E. Seventh Street. "C" Residence
districts exist southeast of this parcel across Stillwater Avenue, adjacent to this
parcel to the east and on both sides of Birmingham north of York Avenue. A "B" Resi-
dence district lies in the general area west of Birmingham Street. The rest of the
area, including most of this block, is "A" Residential.
C. DESIGN STANDARDS: Except for those items under appeal, the plan meets minimum
design standards . No 8-ft. buffer is required for covered parking. Garages adjoin-
ing the residential property on the corner of York and Birmingham maintain a 4-ft.
side yard setback. Landscaping is minimal.
D. F�ONTAGE, AREA AND BUILDING COVERAGE: The property under consideration has an
irregular sha�e with frontage along York Avenue, Birmingham Street and Stillwater Avenue.
The �rontage along York Avenue is 462.5 feet; along Birmingham Street 178 feet; and
along Stillwater Avenue 625 feet. The area is a;�proximately 172,749 square feet. The
maximt��m number of units allowed under "C" Residence is 172. The building coverage is
25. 1�.
E. TRAFFIC ENGINEER`S REPORT: The Traffic Engineer approved the plan and reminded us
that the latest Highway 212 plan proposes use of this property.
F. SITE CONDITIONS: The topography of the site is not severe. The area adjacent to
York Avenue is higher than the area adjacent to unimproved Stillwater Avenue. The
lan�! i;; vacant. Some earth has been removed from the site or used to grade the site.
G. AREA CONDITIONS: York Avenue is unimproved from Birmingham Street westward. Still-
water Aveuue is unimproved as is Birmingham Street from York Avenue to East 7th Street.
Access from the west is limited to Case Avenue from Johnson Parkway to Birmingham or
Barcl��y� *'-�er south to Y�rk Avenue. Yark Aventie provides access from White Bear At�enue
six h'_�,cks to the east.
9. BG�1FtD ACTION: To Rec�mmend � Approval � Denial Council Letter
Dated.
Yeas Nays
rfoved by . Benshoof X Benshoof August 2, 1972
X Maietta Date of
Seconded by: Quast X Quast Hearing:
X Ccchrane
Secretary's remarks : August 17, 1972
Council Action:
Date:
. r� i
. f, . "
. ' � ' � _,
�
'• � r". � • City of. Safat Paul, ldinaesots
APPLICATION FOB 3P�IAL CO�1I�ACIL U3E PER1[1T
(Please print or type)
TO THB HOI�RABLE �dAYOR AND CITY ,ClOU�CIL �, .
96 the Citq Clerk :
City of Saint Paul, l�inaesota
Applicatioa is hereby� made to remodel o� reconatruct an existing •
instali and operate a new (cross one out)
��FILLING $TATION ' . . '
No. of islands and pumps :
, No. of tanks and capacity:
� PARKII�iG IAT �or (customerg) (empioyeee)',(private use) (pubiic use) (otber)
� (i e type)
Capacity of parkin� lot __ .Z, O �J _ �!q r. f•
To be used in coanect�an aitb: .w � �rf! f" �O►T �' .. �►..
,.
� � tta4S
[� �isc�r�xEOVS:
(in ;��ate tqpe such as Drive-ia itefreshffient Staad, Used Car
�~ I.�lt, Dry Cleaning Pick-up 3tation, Ice V�ador, etc.)
,�G�apacity of par�g area:
� � ; . .
*Location ��' : ,AE'. s'ie✓i l�iw,.,iV•1i+� T✓, lr..�v�.►� �eA4�t' �'� f"f»i�t✓A�"�Q' �4r'�•t.
Legal Descript�ioa : Lot , Block Addition
� �.�t /•s� �� /��r J!•i; o�d /.� t i e�rM,r,� �+►. �.t�"" /y.�3 �,•�,�.�
ApPlicant's Name . o'� S,t./Jwif�R.. .4rt.� �[,r�Mie4 t�j�,� �s d v`r/ew ly,f �' �`
� I✓<�'L'�i, D��i!"<t�F'� l�i7"'!"�"+�r+rll!"� e�w+►�'Fi!'/aM'tf'is 2'qI t,,
Home'ar Of i�a Addre�s: /'i��''` !�e/is,:e.r�3 A vE . ,tT, p,��c, .v�.rt,,y. �",�"'//y -
�` .
Phone Number ; �g�'l���/
FOR/B TI�.,APPL , .
. �
, /�J-� °� '.�� . _
$tu� datQ . �
Addrese : S'.+�..r o„P ,9�ir►t� , .
� P�one No.: �
�
�►hen �orapleted: file three copies of this application form aad tbres printe of
tbe preliminary lay-out plaas of the proposed facility with tbe City Clerk,
Room 386, City Hall aad Court House, Saint 'Paul, �innesota
Z-3 6/11/56 �
'�FXAMPLE: 1. S.E. corner of Maia St. aud First St.
2. 8outh side of Maia 3t. between First and 3econd St.
„-.."""� � r/ 3,
. -�,~-„'."`-�-�� �1�.� -'''"
Z���N
�� � `\ ` ,\ �\ } ���� ��� � U�T ..� i ��:
, ,� - � - .,t � � ,.-� , vr , J :
'` � �� � .� y Y_`';'' � , :V � � .p_ C.� O � v �'�
, ' �U � �� ' ,��- � F- � •
� Y� •' I �
� ,� �,y=-� � � �4�A ,�- � o � o � f �
_*
�� ��C�,� �_�� ` ,�;��� ������ �,�� �*,�,� O C�. --- I! � � � � � G,'
O � � ' '��
� �! ,.� � . �
. �--- �aR� �,, � �.. . _
; -
� " � ,'�? � ��—� ' ° '° � -� v °
v -�-- I��v;viv' �=v � � � ' v �
� �_ , � „ �
v O �i_�_.1�1 , v ' C"' � __
fl �� W
� �-�T r li \/ I
v --- - '- '` I � i i-\y, � � � I \/ � �
I � v �
-�-- —i iv,`�.,� 'v� `v
I � � �C � � � ! � _ c,�— � � � � � —
; � � � I ;��� �
Rt 1,� �- Q STI�.L.1�/AT�� � . �
�--� �-� � �.
;
� � � I � �
� O I O C,�;� ✓ � � i � � y �
�..� i � r---
� �� ` ��---� �'V I U j`%�`✓i `__v- � �;' ` V V V � `, `
� �� � i � � ! : ��✓ :� _�! S. i
_� ``�-� �� � —. I I ; , �__v__� � � �� I � V`� ---
-1--- �� `.,� i i ` I ; ' I ''� I � `-
.�.
� � I J i � I�i���+ .j. �'I s.�. � �r � w. �� �
� I j � f � , i i . ..... ;�.� '�-/ I � � i � � �
� � � ,� --� � �J , . ; v; Jlv �v��,�'',v�viv�� � ; T ; � � plpl � � �
' i Q � 'Li i�l ���,�..e�- ' � � ' i i ( � i i 17 I i
i i I 1__
s+
�,, � s CoMMER�I�l.
�enr►Hte�cc�c•��- �•�ST S�"V�l\lT/��_._.,._.--.— ' �
A �� ,�:�;�;�ir�'� � .! . '�i� '; O � �,ia��?�'u, v ��'�/ �J�, , ',✓� � � ���v'
, ; , , viv; v ; � (�� I I � � ' I
� ",� i ; � � � � � � i � � , � , �
� � � ��-� i i i �� � i � ' ' � _ � -
; ! , i � `.� s: !i.,
r���j�
� _____�--1 �-- 4 i �T,
� TT ' ' _ � � � , � � � � � � � I
I ' i. �, .� � . �.;�� ;rl �ll •�/� �1�Vi i �V ✓. V `1 V � �IV'V� �V ' �� V
O O O � Oi �J ,��.,; �,- , ; . , � , , � �
' ' � I ' � � � � ���-�--; �
� , � �
' , i , � . ( i
.„.� a �
� � r ��_ �:°�5��' �_ •� i
� � � �-�-.���-- , . 1 i
C'►ti,Ql1'� � � � I V I I
�!I V;VI`�i ll V V V V V V V `� V V� V V
�_� �'�1 � � � ( � � � � -
s--,-T-r-� I � . r�
APPLl��I�T Virgil Doerfler �����D
PURPO�E Relax building line setback requirements ` /� A�� t f��
& Construct 207-car parking lot for apartmentsL.H tV V
� -O OhE-FAMILY
PRESEt�T ZONl�IG "�" Res•iaentia� � -O- T4��'0-FA�ILY "
}�� TNREE-FAi�ILY
PETITION S{GNERS FQUR- F�f��1iLY
� � � [�ULTI-F���ILY
{
� a nCQ���t�R�I�L �
FILE t�o. �2�� - �293 �4RrN � n !��
. If�QUST.RfAL
v VAC�►NT
�-ZO-�2 �
St. Paui Plonning �oard, Daf�: 1-6-�2 ;;� Pro@�r4y unde� co�t�id�r�ion
A'iYNUTES OP' THE �'UBr.IC HF�ARIPi� ��FORE THK BOA�ll 0�' ZONENG
. _ ON THU1tSDAY, J�J�Y 20, �.972a .�T `>:00 P,Ma
PRESENT: Mrs, Cochrane and ;�iZSe Quaat; MessAs� 3�Ic�'aAtZ�.Et' Maf�t�a and Bens�oo�:
of the Baard; Mr, L��setter and I�I�s> Galvin of the staffo
VII�GYL DOERFLER (7277�: An application for � �ermi,t to constr�ic� a 207-car
parkin� lo� fQr use wfth apartments on f�he sc��a�h side o� York beCween �ixmingham
and Hazelwoody . .
Mr� Rosetter made available to the Bo�rd several �ecc�nt sna�►shots of the slt�o
Mre Rosetter summarized the stsff report far the app�el. by �xot:ttlg tnet thie property
was rezoned to "C" ResidenCial on Novemoer 2ya 197}�o Tt�e appe��nat proposea to
develop the property t�ith apartmenC build$n�s h�i�.t witla�.n 15 ft� of the fron.t pro-
perty linesa This p�rcel has �wo fYanr yaaccls: on Ynrk Avex�ue and on undeveloped
Sti'lli�ater Aveaue, The legaR setbr�ck lin� on these y=�rds i� ld�o of th� depth af
the iot or 31 £t, The proposed seCbacflt �s 15 fte ar 48039% o� t�nat reqe�ired by the
Code. A Comme�cial distxict exis�s alo�g Eo Seve�zth StreeGo � t0C" Re�idence
district exists southeast of this percel �cre�ss St�.11water f�vea�e, ad jacentc ta this
parcel to the east �nd an both sicles of Birminghmm nor�h o£ Yc�rk Avenueo A "B"
Residence district lies in the general area west of Birmfnghar.� Stre�te The r�st of
the area, including mosC of th�s t�lock, �s "A" ResidenCial� 'The tapography of tixe
site is not severeo The area ad�acent to York Aven.ue is higher than the s�res
ad jacent to unimproved S�:illwater Avenue, T�iie land ia vac�nf:o Son�� ea�th has been
removed from t�e site or u;ed to grade the site. York Avenue is unfmproved fr�ra
Birmingham Stree� westward, Stil3�wster Avenae is unimprov�d as fs Bira►�.ngham Street
' frcna York Avenue to lEast 7th Street, AGC�ss fror�e the wes� �s �.im�ted to Case Avenue
from Johnson Psrkway to Birmingham or Ba�clay, then south to York Avenuea York
Avenue provides access fram White Bear Avenue six block� tc� the e�st�
Mr� Roaetter noted there are two homes adjoin:tng this property on the northwest
�:orner of the s i te�
Mro .2oaetter :;aid concerning the parking 1ot that except for thase f�ems under
appeal, the plan meets minimum des�gn standards, No 8-fto bu�ffer is requir�d £or
covered parking. Garages adjoining the residen�is�i property �n the corner of
York and Biranin�ham maint�in a 4-fts s3.de yarrl setb�ck. Landscaping is minimal�
Mr„ Rosetter read the response fram the Traffic �nd Accident Section of the Police
Department as follows:
File �7277 - 7293: ,�p ep al _ Permit: A nu�ber of �raff.fc consider�tions
shoul� be point�d out in this appeaZ and permit �o perm£t relsxsng the
building Iine set-back rQquirements and tr� construct a 207-car parking
lot for apartment use on the south side of Yorls beeween Bi.rmingh�n and
Hazelwood„ Birmiaghem is an unfinfshed street; in essence York Avenue ia
a deadend street, Whtle there would be na particular problems with
traffic movements in such a location, I feel that the usual requixements
for parking sp�cES for a proposed apartment ahould be strictly adh�rred to,
Because York Avenue is for all practica� purposes a dead�nd street, !t pro-
babZy will be necessary to ban all p�rking adjacent to thfs spartment
house in order to facilitate snow res��vaE and street clean�ng opesations,
• , VZRiGIL DOERFLER (�age 2� July 20, 1972
Mr, Doer£ler said that Binaingh�m will be developed thraugh ta 7th Stxeeta In
respc►nse to a question froan Mrs� Quastn Mr� noer�ler ststed the depth of the
property is 309 feet.
Mr, Benshoof asked what w�s �he setback of �he two re9ide�ces at the c��ner of
York and Birmingham, Mra RosetCer said ehe Yegal �etback would be 26 feet but
he did nat know what distance ehey were built frcxi� the street line. Mro Benshoof
thought thet if the power poles �re located on the baulev�rd b�tween the sidewalk area
and the curb, then �h� houses could nat be m�re rhan IS fe�t fxom the stre�t linee
In response Co � qnestian from Mr. Maietta, Mr, Doerfler said e�e parkimg stalls
are 10 feet by 20 feet in size, In re ponse �o a queseion frcxn M�cs. Cochrane,
he said if the variance is not gxanted, he doean'k know hQw �a �et the build�ngs
ine H� said he has tried to "juggle" tttem and can't get tt�e� fn any o�her way,
Mrs� Cachrane said thaC she thought 31 feet fs unreaso��able bat that 15 feet is
too ,ma 11.
Mr. Maietta said that this area 1-�ss severe �opographya
Mr, Doerfler �aid th�t he saw no reason why Stfllwt�ter �venue woul,d eveP be develaped,
Mr, Benshoof moved that th� Bomrd rec�end approval of thE �appea� because the
hou.=,es slre�dy exfsting on the bAcsc�. ar� 3etback no more than 1S feete Mr� Msietta
seconded the motion noting tae thought the developsaeat would be en improveraento
Mxss �Co�hrane said she thought hol.ding to the legal setbsct� wau�d be cxnconscfonable,
Mr„ Maietta +�oted that if the lot caere not so deep the praposed seeback would be
allowed,
Tt�e motian carried unanimouslye ,
Mr. Benshocaf maved to reco�nend appr.ov�l of the parking lot pero�iC. The motion
was seconded by Mrs„ Quast and carried unanimouslyo
Sulxnitted by: Approved by:
lPeul Le Itosetter Mrse Carolyn Cochrane
. � � � `�,,i � - 5=
, ir_ ,.. -�;
• , ' City of Saint Paul, Minnesota
� APPLICATION FOft SPECIAL COUNCIL USE PERMIT
(Please print or type)
TO THE FIDNORABLE MAYOR AND CITY OOUNCIL
� the City Clerk
City of Saint Paul, Minnesota
Application is hereb made to remodel or reconstruct an existing
y install and operate a new �cross one out)
� FILLING STATION
No. of islands and pumps :
No. of tanks and capacity:
� PARKING I+OT for (customers) (employees) (private use) (public use) (other)
(indicate type)
Capacity of parking Lot Z p 7 �� r, J�
To be used in connection with;��� �n/ ��' ��T- a��0.S — Z
� MISCELI,ANEOUS:
(indicate type such as Drive-in Refreshment Stand, Used Car
Lot, Dry Cleaning Pick-up 3tation, Ice Vendor, etc.)
Capacity of parking area:
*Location : E: r�w/� �•.��►,.�y�o�, S�, 6es�apoy, Y'o.e',r � .T�'icc�A»�2 RwE.t�
Legal Description : Lot , � Block Addition
�ve4Z /o�' i� �o�s' /9-ZI a.�d /o� 22 excpFs� .tJ. .'.?S' /�..�5 nef-�!�
AppliCa�it�S Name : d� �'�`/�"�°�.e"- ''�a'p,. , C'r�:c.F s�ia� ,�,'i- ,1,�o��.c%r� Le�1•
✓1.e G i� D d���G E!� �?"�E"�PRi'9CE �.vTcciPP.�'/S'FS .�'.v C.�
Home or Of f ice Address: /90,; l.Jr esc�.J �4 v� , s`�-; ,og v,�� ,c,r�,v,�.,, ,3-f-��9
Phone Number . 2 2 � --� Zv.�7
�' . . , -
FOR,/s THE APPL ,
� � �Q-� � -� l
(S gnature (date
Address . Sa,,,P �� �6pre
Pbone No.:
When completed: file three copies of tbis application form and three prints of
the preliminary lay-out plans of the proposed facility with the City Clerk,
Room 386, City Iiall and Court House, Saint Paul, Minnesota
Z-3 6/11/56
*EXAMPLE: 1. S.E. corner of Main St. and First St.
2. 3outh side of Main St. between First and Second St.
+ 259��
oun.iwt�To nntrts�t
- CITY OF ST. PAUL �,��� NO
- • OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK
" e COUNCIL RESOLUTION—GENERAL FORM
C�OM SSIONER �ATE
�
RS�C�LVaD, U�a and pur�uarit to l:hs pertinsnt app�a►1,
uad�c th� foninq Cods, lyy Virqii Do�rtlar, s� a�+n�r of t.h�
snb jsat r�al �sta�, situat� i,A the Citp ot Saint �aul,
� in "C" 1�ssil�ac� Distaciet, �r t�t �oninq Cod�. anE!
4�serib�d asi
i�ist 42 tt. o! Lot 18, lt. � of Lota
19, Z0, 21. Sloak Z. Crnic�s�w�k'•
Gsrden Lots aad the x. � of i�ot ZZ
� �oaopt tl� 1�. 13S !t. th�s'�o=, slp�k
3, Csuickshanlc's Gasdsn Lotat
, t.hst th� provi�ionr of said io�i�q CoQ� l�r�by u� d�t�sain�d
and vuied as and to th� extsnt nec�asary therofor, and the
Ntback r�quir�■wnta !or �aid prop�sty asy �s�by r�la�u�d so
se to acoo�modate apastment buildinqst be it
lOxTBt�t �O�.VaD. Tbat Virqil Dofrtl�r be and hereby ia
qsant�d s p�s�i:t to install awd ap�rat�t a Z07-aas p►as'kinq lot
for n�ae �rith apartaenta on p=op�rty loaat�d on ths eouth oids
of York b�tr►Nn Bir�iuqha� and 8su�l�od. aar� particulasly
Qeacrl.b�d as:
Mest 42 ft. of Lot 18, 8. � of Lots
19. �0. 21. Block 2, Ctuie�kabank'�
dardaa I�ote and ths l�. � of Lot 22
�pt th� x. 133 ft. th�s�ol, S1ocA�
2, Cruickshank•a c3ardsn Lots;
all in acc:ordaz�ce with plana d�tted R+mceivsd Deee�nber 6, 1971 t
svbj�ct to th� oondition tbat said appllraaat-p�saittN, and
his snaceaso=a and aasigns, shall make du� eempliance wlth all �
applicabl� provi�io� o! snuicipal ordinane�s. atat� •tatnt�s
and rnles and requlations of public authoritiee havinq cognizanes.
COUNCILMEN Adopted by the Co��� Alit; 3 1 1t17219
Yeas Nays
� H�nt �"� AU6 31 197t
Car n Konopatrl� � � APP�°1''� 19_
�o",�_ ->�
e Mereditli ��`� Tn Favor
M dit•h Sprafka, z � �r
� �������'f�C`S�d�nt� roOA;tlllt
e �
Mr. Pre 'dent, McCarty
���
�`��. — -
r �.
.� , ,.. _
� . �.
. . , -
..
. : , . ; �, „ .
,�_ . . :
� 3 x
. . .
,w�� . . - - /' . �:' . • ":
y
.
�� . . ..' ,. r � x �' �
.
,-. .. ... . . ...
i
� x � ,. . .: . , s� i .:.. . .. . . . .
�r
. •. . . � . : - .. . .
n '
�-
.
�� I � .. . .. . . .. ..
• +h. a . . -. '_. . � r ' . . .
� .' �
. �
� �: ':y . . ..,. �. , . ' „�,.y . ..
y �' . . � � , :� ':,. , :�. . ' -� . ..
. .
:
Z � ��: , . . . . ,. , . ..� „ , . .
z , . ....� . �,. �, ... . ..
� - � � '„ �. .: , . .. .
k � .. .,. r , �.,- �.." . .. . , - � . -.
, �. . . . . . .�. � .. .
.
.. . .. '. �- . � . .
�
� , . �., . . ,. . ,
YX �,.� ., � ,. . . . ., .`: . : . . - .. .
. , ., � .: . �, .
� �
¢ . .. , .� .� , : � .. '�. .. �� � . �
_ , .,
y
,. „ - . . . , .. . .. , .
„� . . .. . . . .. . ��, _ . .
� � -� �.� . �, r '� . � .�:�. . , . - . � � . .
.
. . .,,. ; . � .
. . . �.�� . . . . ; .
:
� w� .-� �.: .:.�:.. . ,
� , . .
�
. . -
.
.
� �w � . . . , _ . ,
.
� �� ,�, „� • ,° ; �, ' i. _
,
� . . ' _
, . �
;> . -. . .
e. _ . !r
, , >:
h . : � . ,," , .. ,
. ' ' �
2 , � �
�
,
+} �, i.� y � : .. , t , . ..
� ��� . ..�' , n. . . . � .
.
d" ,�.±�.r ., .�. ,. �. , .� .� .>� � , � - �
�#��� J, y if' '
� � �.
�'�V^�� � $ i `r .' :. .j` .
�� ,�� l� � �t , . .
]' ��F t
���i � � :. +� .
��� T r t �� k �i ` � �� ; '� r. �x � .
���e� � ��s , � � �
�� � � .�� � �b s4 N sy�� F* � .
11'� S �`1. tf � Y 3 4 F ' .
1 k.iZ y J: Y 3 1 tt �~ �� . .
�� F
Az,r 1 i � J k s � �'� ��.
Y� �Y 1 Py, ,k � _
k�'� r .�r � � � � x � 'r'
r 3e � ;.tM �Y �r � � `� : , _: . .- '. .
4wyr _'� -�," � ' �i' . � �� ", ;,'' rvkt 4 x �'_ r _� " •�� �,,..,,,r,, '.,....�+� �--""`� .
��y, .'m .+.... �r�rtl'(+sui.rG..-,��i�iiY����*wk+AM� «.w+.� �4�wx. �aw+Y�. JF.++t-r„+.+4Fr ,wy+�+�} MF.w.'� '°""'� �• {.. m�-. "�
tt"�{'T''�'C S R4 �✓ rc f k..W i1M x� � . �.. .
i �.
, ,
s '
��`�ya, �' ' �. � �' t '� � �� � �� �
_
b
��� � � � � ��
�<
, ;
�
�.�
. N�": 'w '' . ",._. . �r ,, . , _. �: . �' - ".. ,,. � /� �„+�,_,�„� �"`
,- . �
, f
a 77�, § F ra +ti..� �„�: t_A ::s � .,,� ��., � �_ �47�8 � :...+�m t Y .,� .
,� r t.t x A�� �f� p� "� ' _�yr•� * ,
� '� � � � .�" � � 4 ��, �j � �
�,.. .,,, �� . ,�i S � - �''`.�
,
� ��. � a. „ �; � , ,�
�.� �� �^„. ��,�,�.,;.t.. ,.x �+ ���', ,i � 'fr,s� � �
,�''���: � ++'������ �t k a y ��:'� a�.a� � .F.� i a r` _ ' C .,..t,��` ..
�� �. �� �6� �a ��,�, �,�. t �ty��. � �� °�d '� M � '� �� �� �
''ti� �a.. � � �� �"t�� �a s, T� " ,�"� � � �� ,� f
1 � F �� i ,` v "4� . - �
}'nY �� �fd :„� l, " F S +hx'`,''€ , �„� * ,"M. }y >�
��` �k � Si5 �., � � .
1.� d 2 i. ;(��T n�,: 0.�,° �,.-p �
�,���' ��� r� ' �^`.� ti- � }r +r�'a � '� y r �,i]�� �a �.��J . �:�, >' . .
� � ' t'�-i�' �::� $.. �' �� +�i� �: � ,a.� �_� k v �..r. �y :*p±./�
`�i s �, � Y „ v. � " :� ' ✓�f
z ���' 1' ,a -x � � : /y -
�.� .. J��i . t4 �
�: _ x; ': '. x � � .� ) �/'
e'
�f � �• ��Y y. • '. , � j
{� . � dl�� w F�ir �. ,..1�i^✓, �. . � ( �+ .
t�1n +f 4 �L4 � �..�4} S1 '.� 4�Y' �,r ..r S "t �� ,� yfT.,ryY /fiR't ����,d �
..< � 7 � �, '� �S �j�` �� w��-j J ' �
� �`''`V � ��„ 3 _ 7 Y t � �- / � �
'A " J ,A' r •Y ,
y4 y �� # �./fY,r
� i yy� zp,t ,Y � • ...�J
{? � (y'. 1 h .L '^`� ht�� 3" � � �
4� }.,p � ;�a',, .? ) }��: sN,��4. �f4 . �,��.., :�F/� {
�h 2; L b �k �� '.J i
�r v y a � x
�i r lw " '�` \ Sti W,+( S rc ��. x 4/�� •��.�. ��{r
)�'� 1 �r f'� P .. � S�3 d� 'V , `,; .
}{� }bM1 k M � -I� � .
fifi ! �' � � ��
jf++��k � �' �.1 � � ,j � � . .
'� � y `' � f r' t'1i � °�". � {�/ �`. j
. ,
�4 � v �,�
" � �� �' ���4 ..�.h �" F✓.• �
rt hry ,.i.�r , ar.�,� .r. �:, � t •x r � '� } ...
�� ���f�; � �h�„�� � � � s ! . 1'�� r: f� .
I ,� � v„�+����..�r++�,a. i *� � � � �� �
���..OR�� y',� k ���µ ��yU��• .��.� �? 8� A� � C �fi. � �' ` *` , � �l�
♦/ ,� .�,�s��l�,� /+ �j' �� � ���� .� ..
. , . , . � �d ,: ,� �
� .� � ..., .: .. : .'� ,.f tiw � � � .
''!► 'M� � J t+r- 5+r .�°. �+rr-� _ �'"^� � � � .. ���• �� � � .
��� � '��y�, y[ � i v� �.J: �—j •e � `�'� F } C� � � � ����S ��1 `,�9j1,, �
�lF.����1�� h 1 ,..�# I � .,ur �i �+� 1'41{ �'(� �.�/S .. .,
z �» � � 9,r
� ��...,.. ' � M . � ,� L�:1�� ,�/ 1 . �.-
, , �:
�.���.
.
� -.`� ,.� ,z , ! � a
° ,
�,,:.w ,,.,, _ : .
.
'� .. . , . , ,.. ,: ,,�.��.i ��,� �. �`
y t J ��.�wr ���. �� . I / M'�M . ..
�C R �44 �' f�'�� d M � '�� °ytil. �-�r�+-- ��� � �yy�� a�{, �*Y . �i �
� sa �T���� y�-.. � t ., s.�:� t ' - �1 F' -�r �.' .{,�L�,� , : I
� 4 _ k ^^.f"i^�^...�., f `�1 df�l;:.
�y } ���� ti F � P ��j y � �
�J ��+ N *, � �� � ''�
; �� � � � �v � •�._ �+t -" � aa4 � � � �.
. ,-� � .b .^k
" �''�4 �� .}j d .'�;�"� �R'"° t � ��,
�......� r ` ,� ������"i�'f��p ���'� ,��yr � rt,1 k � "'�` �l..""'r": ��y ���' � ,� }..
� c. � ;?:. ,e � ! 1
x�
t r X y'. yn ,5 �-. ,f%/'.. . .
� '4: ,A ��p '"` . . '" f•f {�.. . .
�i� -l� \\���] s : �+ '� P' y � �y�� �
���1 V"^,�� �'�1'�. h �� - � d iJdV` �� � � , ..,
Y h K^�.� 'k� p - N ' .l `*�, y� �*'.'i
t
� "F'��G T��. �. �.� S & i � . 7.i � � �M ){ .
4 ''7 t� L,;t � * r t y9 5 .c ag, �+ � �1
i �+�°'� b ��`'� ��;� ��A Y�'��� �'�` � ��w �� �.:� .
� i '; �"�y��„y � �� '������1 ` J/{� /fr�' l ���
��� � �I �t "1Y.� �� -'� �< �` a � �i ' � '�. J f /;�` . .. . !` .
S_ _ .
} f¢ /J, Y}Jj f y, ' �
'�'.4 '� "d. � .N �yi�� Y , d M1 �� !. .: �✓ �/I�Y' ��"' �� •� ' ��}£ .
�= � k� /� .'. }�y,�' , �� .,�
.�p,�� � :i�,s . �;� ,�k �.er
i`i�f� ,.:� � ! y � L � _.1
.Y�� 4�Y � � ' . �'�� .
� � t � � � i ��;7��.� ��.� ��j {
f� 8 y YJ . , . � J/ � � 1. . .
, a :y ���� a � y� '� � :irZ � _ n� w1� �' , � �/// � . . ..
�(� �.A r F .�My, .-w S �. . . '/.�� Y � .
4 q+�� _ , ;'b�� �� y� t.�. "n� $ i LLt y.� "i
� , {� ''�: � �� ��� l ���:.�ry� � ,� `�j� .' .�/ � ��'�� � :"�';� a � ti.
'�a� �, �. �, `: a�.
�
r
.., i. � . � � ° - � �.
Y, � Y y� ',1* �. �E .�+�F k d .'v" �� �"R �
�
� .
�#➢.
� ` �
� ,� , r-.� i f ' '
�� „ ,y + �"rr^.'
� . �
� : , �, �, ,- � v x��� , .
G� ,. -• '� � �
_ �r � . �} �� �5� .;..�--.-! �
:� e i:�x -:' � }'k� "��` �a ���,��� :k i"r.."."'.� � �� °� . ..,��� ` :
� i k y �..+'" �'� �r� r� .n'�i�'"" �!" - �`'��", � � '
� �k �� �, 3 ,,, ,w+ �t�;�
� �s � � ��. 4 ��"� � � * �� � �
�J }'�' �'��✓ '.�4A' ` ''��"_' � ��.!$���M , `� ����/� :
�,` Ly,i+ � y+� / 1
;r `
t
���
.rv'. . � �.,. . : ,. , -.
�
�
.
� ar r '` � � � � ��� x �i ` �.f✓ j
�..... '— ; � "r , � '- � fi� �
A+Y'�_ �4+� �+�+s lYW" �.i Yr ti4M�. 4 y..�N. �a J.iw y � �.W,�, '.�'i+ r�' �
�
y m '
4a� 14�
1 � I F � 4 1 Y, fi�yR�� �� �: .. . �
v � ,
. ,.
� . :
� :�� ' ,�. '� � > . .r � .. �
�
, � - . .�. - :, . . ,.... '�'�. .
4,,r � 3
s . '. � � '." : .. . .�..�
.. • �` , . , , � ,
� .:. . ' .'.l `Y" . ; '. ' _"'.` .'M ? b Y .
�
'w •
,�
: , ,
�. � ��
. . , . .
„ ,-; �. .�. �.. .. - . .
. � , c ..�:.�. .:: � ..,.....;� . . .
� �,. � �
�{ F ` 're +�� tt J��. �.l.,����f ,w :47 '�+�� . .
r '� ..k� K�� �M 5 ±,
� : ]
. rt dc . '��f. . , , . ..s�v` .+ .. . � . . ,. . . . ..
. . ., . , i4 •tA.:{�W ir�. . . . . .. . . . .
r't'""` ��`} �
' � � �
� �
_________-�--- - -�
-�_� :l,...____r___
_.._ �._ __ _-_- ----
, �. . �., .
_ _ . , ,
/ �� ��..,-�� � sri �G� .� .,j
� _-.4__-- --,,a,.3.5�
� � i �+ =�_�"` ------
�
1 .
I �
� j � �
� �
' '
� � ��
� j ,c �--•--s �
� • ' I �;
1 ;' ,, � � ,� ��� `
� . /r� - ;� � f �� ;�-,,h.� �
� - � ...._. � � , �'TM'�'�� �(') .
/
� � �___, � � ,
,
i � � 1 _.
;t
t { 1
� � �
� � �
�� �, :.�� � ___ �.. —� �
�...�_' �.- _ _ __ -- M� i
� �° ..��.�...,. --
' --, ' .........�_.._
j" � I ; • � � ____._. _
,
, �; �� .. �5 5 ___ .__. .
, i , _..,�.__-�: '�G.O
, — _;.,��:.._�._._.__ ._..__.�___ �
. .
. q �°'J F :a _ „ �
- � .. I . S � �' '-�* ✓ �/ ` y' :! ��b�^�.,_.-..,
4 , ;� '�,���r , �, %%�� � � '"d?- � .
� , ,;- � .. � d �
� : � �� '�,. � ' i*
. -- ; � ��ff /r "� . _
�Y : �J
� ' � �% �_
� ; 1 : �` � ,i�'�' ,.-�-� i
�,.: ` ` � -^�/e`: ,/ _.�..- d1 E
. .
� % �
i � " ; --
� � f : �
....,.�_ � ,
l ��"�;r' ,�
�.
y , �, , i f
.....� � i � � r�1�, � ���' �� �j�� .....,.... . ...
_��...i,.,._ f �.� _ ...___
i � i ' ff��..� 9 -� Q� r
1 � '- /i� � � � .��
4 E� I ! �,f; /y�'� ' - � _'—
� �,
__ � � f �__
.,��`��. i f'"/: � � ;
, } ;, r . �
� � � �, �,:� , �.��_
: .._
-- '�'; ' ,�//' ; ,.� � �_ , I �`
�
�,�- '; � ij� � ,'�,
• ! „ i,�` /� � '�---,....._---=�''� ! �=��°_��
� � � `�!f �f�J" ; , ✓- _
: �
� r , , r �
`��_� I �
. . � �i t ,� .� . � ; / ' l -� i �r�� ,�'
�� . . i . � //��.! 1� /�� /��/�/ .'' '. /! ',//� ,!,%;l� i,�.',/ % %/ J/�,
1
, ,�_...._..� � � � I r�i . , , , /": � �� �f,a i +/-�i;� ����
� ��. �r,�� sj�; i. , -i/�.
� .._�___l � � %/ _ -- � :�.---�'r. x"-=-.
. � ,f" - ;�,� ���
1 i '
, . ,
' � � ':A�AI�T M�NT
� � , _..r_
�,; _._. _--__._
i ' � f �
,f ��r� , , r ii f/l±'�ii;�,;"�/% � '``i!'//
� / � ' ' `
' � , .! y,,% ,//����;�/f/:% ,'. ,;i''^i ,i'��/ ;'% `f,,.. / /�ri �
. � '.�f ,'����f!��/ er` 1�1� ��� �/, ri , � / . . ... . . � �:
i,
( ' ���
-�... , ____� _..�
►��v�. __.___�._-
� �,V, .._.____—_-
__�,; __________._. � _�._____ .� .,.
�
� , � � _ — .__ _.. _._- ---- —
\____ __ -_ -____ --..- __.___ .__ .—
_—_._--- , / ` r
--- � ,
; � i ' ��, =�� �
�
� � � �. � ,
. , .
�
. r ,
�� v
{ '� �
No
h
C
Ci e
re
q e,
; a oi
II1k.� io-
ca . ve.
betw�e ood
9ts. .
Dated �- �'°
� A�,.
�
(A 1�7t)