259441 r �
ORIOINAL TO CITY CLERK �59441
. CITY OF ST. PAUL ��ENCi� NO.
OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK
` ' �OUNCIL RESOLUTION—GENERAL FORM
PRESENTED BY
COMMISSIONE ATF
RESO�V&D� that the Council hereby ratifies and approves the
action of the Saint Paul Board of Appeals and Review for the Housing,
Building and Fire Prevention Codes pertaining to the following listed
property and as shown by the mfficial minutes of said Board of Appeals,
dated July 12, 1972, a copy of which, marked EXHIBIT "A", is attached
hereto and made a part hereof by reference:
Case No. Property Appellant
31-72-B 1918 Saunders Richard Lonnee
32-72-B 1324 Payne Avenue Leafgren Furs
by
Robert P. Zeafgren
34-72-B 1688 Ashland Gerald Rlingner
47-72-H 719 Portland Avenue Patrick Stevens
41-72-B 480 Cedar Avenue Northstar Fire
Protection Co.
by
Vaughn Duschane, Jr.
48-72-B 1021 Fnglewood John Sach
/``
� ��
�
�' ' AU6 10 197a
COUNCILMEN Adopted by the Counci� 19—.
Yeaa Naya �
t� r Hunf .�;�a�� AU6 1 1 1��
.TM .�,.
C 1 on
Konopafzlc� `' �'= pproverl 19—
L v ne Levine `
Mereditfi � Tn Favor
M ditl�;prafka Mayor
S a�--- v
Mme. PresideIlt,��� Againat FQ PP VE . �
Te esco �
Mr. Preaid t, McCarty
uty City Attorney,
���
PUBLISHED A(J� � 9 197�
. , ;�
. � � Z �.�L�� � �/ '!,/12��(�
„ Meetin�r, IVo. '(3
. . �59441
r�zrrtrrES oF Ti� r�rzr�
ST. PAUL BUARD OF APPEALS
Wednesday, Jul.y 12, 19'(2
Room 210, I3urea.0 of Health, 555 Cedar Street
i�iembers Present: Raymond Grove
Estyr Peake
Norm�, Sommerdorf
James Voig�;
Members Absent: Donald Wozniak
I�Litchell Kamin
llrthur Tieso
t�gencies Present: }3ui].ding Department - Glexln Erickson
Fire Department - Dan Norrgran and R. F. 3uttori
Others Presen�;: Richard Lounee, Mrs. Lonnee, Robert Leafgren, Gera:ld
IL1in�ner, Patrick Stevens, V�.u�hn lluSchane, Steve
Ikeda., John "aaCh
7.'he minutes of the June 28 Board meeting were approved as amended.
31-7�-13 1y18 Saunders R�ichard Lonnec
�U&TECT
`ir. �,onnee is requesting a variance of Section 34.04-3 of the I3uil.ding
Code as he is gui].ty oi constructing a patio ?' trom side yard lot ii.ne
wliere code specif'_ies �+' .
�\PPL:11liAidt;ES
Richa.rd Lonnee, I�Irs. Lonnee
PROCEI;DINGS
At the time :Jlrs. Lonnee designed and had the structure built, she wa.s
unaware of the side yard code requirement. The attached redwood deck
stands 2' above grade. A fence attached to the patio was constructed
to all ow ma.ximum priva.cy for both pa,rties concer.ned. The patio, r�s it
stands now, does not obstruct ar�,y of' the nei�hbor's winciow;.
. ' ,
ACTION
P+totion by Voi�t to waive Section 3�+.04-3 of the St. Pau1 Leg:tslative Co�lc
allowing the pa�io to exist 2' from the sideyard lot 1_i.ne. Secon<ieci by
Peake.
Tf� VOTE
Ayes: Grove, Peake, Sommerdorf, Voigt. Nayes: none. llbstention�: noi�e.
i�iotion carried four (4) to zero (0).
3�-72-8 1324 Payne Avenue Leafgren F�xrs
by
Robert Y. Leafgren
SUBJECT
i•�r. Leafgren is appealir� �the installation of a ladder and roof scuttic�
ope►iing. Code specifies that ma.cYiinery on rooftop be accessible by
inside or otitside ladder.
11PPT',AIjANC�S
Robert Leaf�;ren
PPOCEEDI.NGS
tdr. Leafgren �ppea:l_ir�, both means of access. An openic�; in the roof i�
a possible entry ioz• bur�;lary, which is one reasori they are conatructinf,
a riew buildir.�;. An outs.ide ladder would be dan�;erous since cilila.r�n could
have ac�cess to. roof a.nd roof`top ma.chinery. Not installing a roof scuttl.e
woutu improve security and insurance rates w�uld be 1ess. The bui]..dinE,r
coilt�,ins <3, hi�h concentration of value. i�ir. Leafgren su�gested tYiat hc
wo�ild �.eep an extension ladder within the uuilci:i.n� anci �,vailable for roof`top
a�:ceUs.
.'�i�.�1 i��l�'! .
1•;o�ion i�y `lo��t to tiraive the .rcquirement �hat a me:�,n:; o�' ro��ftoi� ,�.c�•a�:::, ����
')2'O'✓1:IC�C1 '�.1; �j,"�I .'�6;/'lle i'."JE'(]UC. uBCOCI(�.E_'C� UjT (iz'OVC� �
����a�; �JO�r�,
;1yes: ��r.ove, Pc,a!;��, ;Jon�raerclor(', V�i�t. P1aye�: nor�c. :�t,stent.i.oris: :onc:�.
I�?�tior� carried foul• (��} t,o r,t��ro (0).
.
'��-"r'�'-�'� l.�B�3 Ashland Ger�.ld Kl i r�;ricr
;�UIkTEC'�'
�ze�ar�t�.n;; an appe�.l of Section 33.04-3 whieh specifies a 4' sicle-yard.
cJ..e��rance. Mr. �;:1_in�ner constru.ctecl a pa.tio to thF: rear of h:is home aeven
ycax•c� pr.:ior to �;hi� da,te wtiich is in violation.
A PP���itAPl(;P�S
Gera].d IClin�ner
PROCL�DINGS
At the time of construci:ion and until recently, Mr. Klingner we.s �ina.wa.re
o: sicle-yard clearance requirements. In his opinion, this s�;ructure
enhances his property. The violation was bro�u�ht to his attention by the
BuiLdi n� T�partment as the resu]_t of a complaint b,y the nei�;hbor:� to the
west. IIe feels the nei�hbors would now like to withdraw the comp:Laint.
ACTI0�7
i�.ot.ion by Peake to waive the requirements of Section 34.04-3 of the St. Paul.
i_.e�iel_�,tive Code to permit the patio to ex:ist as previously constructed.
:;econc:ted by Grove.
`i'�II?, VOTE
J�yes: Grove, Peake, Sommerdorf, Voi�;t. I�layes: none. Abstentiona: none.
i,;ot:on carried four (4) to zero (0).
1�7-7�-�� I19 Portland Avenue �at.rick �t;everi:>
aUt3J�:Cl'
�:r. �tevens is appcalin;; �ection 5�+.�-5-3 regrzr�l_in,�; th:ird E'toor occupancy
i n a. wood_Crame bi��i1_d.i r�;.
A i'PEAIZANCES
:'�,i;r-ir;c uteveris
?iZO�;i;i;DI:dCrS
This appeal is a result of �3. le�,ter regardir�; �j. ('ire inspecti.or. ciated
J��nc: 30, i.g7?_ from R. I'. ;utton. The buildii�r ha,s an outsicle f'ire esc��p�,
Pr��m tiic third `':Loor t;o ,.;rade 1_eve1. The appell.ant wou:�c3 like to pu±
f�.ve persons in t;:iree rooms on the third floor, thus increasin�; t��e
r�.ccommociations irom �,a to 1�+. is. Sutton stated that there are two mean:�
oi' egress from the t:iird f�oor and he feels that supervision �t the hom�
i s E;ood.
.
� � �
ACTIOTI
tviocion by Voi�;t to waive Sect.i.on 5�+.15-3 of the St. P�LUI_ Lep;isl�.L.i.ve Cocic•
'to enable third f.loor occupancy of 719 Portland �veriu<:�. aecondeu by
Grove.
THr VOTE
l�res: Grove, Peake, Sommerdorf, Voigt. Nayes: none. I�bstentioris: nor�e.
hlot:ion carried faizr (4) to zero (0).
41-72-I3 1+80 Ceda,r Avenue Northstar Fire
Protection Co.
by
Vaughn I�zSchane, Jr.
SU33JECT
Appealing requirements 1;ha,t a 750 G.P.NI. fzre pump be installed at
�+�30 Cedar Avenue.
APPEAF2I�NCES
Vau�;nn Ihz�chane, J�r.
PR(X;EI:D'INGS
i�?r. D�z�cnane sta.ted that the Fire Prevention Bureau refuses to acc�ept a
proposal. which was accepted by the City l�schitect. A�; the ti�►e pl.ans were
submitted .for the Ha,nover Building, a 750 G.P,I�i. w�,ter pump was required
by the Building, Fire & OHSA Codes but not by the State Code. Since thr�t
t��.me, however, on July l, 1972, the State Buil�.iri�; Code has superseclea tt���
City BuiJ_dinr; Code. State Code now requires a. 75 r..P.M. pump fo.r 1:hc�
ilanover Builci.in�. �.t this ciate, the Hanover Bizild.in.�; compl.ies wit;h tn<�
code. P�Lr. E.rickson, however, wanted to make cl_ear �;h:�t in his c�onvers�+.i;ion
with I�1r. Duuchane he agreed to a proposal and tt�.a,t he was extendir� ,�
cou�litiona.� approvat coni,:i.n�;ent upon the approva7_ o.�' the F.i.r.e 1�1�xshni 1..
3ot'.� irickson and Dan Norr�;ran feel that the Sta#;e Code re�ardir�; fi re
purrrps wil_1 be chan�ed. Zf 1�1r. 1�zSchane were �;o re.:,ubmit liis plar�to�l;�.;�,
t'�ey w�utd comply with existin�; code.
�1CT TOP1
°�iot�or� t�y Peake to �;rant a vari�.nce to ena.ble tYic i n.,tr�J.]at:i_on o(' t,},�,
propo,ca 1.00 G.I'.P�i. wal;er pump at the Hanover 3ui.lu.in;;. �econdt;ca t,;� .'�,;. :,.
ili;�; VOT�
t"?��'S: ii�l'O'JP.� `�01�;�.� tii(�IIL�?lE'1'UOi'�L� �G3}C@. N&yC� : llOrn1. i1U5t.CflE, I.O��1;: !1!)tiE'.
�`,...�r: carr'_ .;i .'our (L�; ';o �c:rc (0).
•
. . , , �
~ 48-72-8 1021 Englewood John :;acli
SU$JI�CT
Mr, Sach :is appea,lin� Section 5.02-1B regardi►u; ce il.i.►�; hei�rht rec�ui remcnt;s.
Ak'PEAI2�NCES
Jo11n .�ach
PROCEEDINGS
Mr. Sach is proposinr, to add a dormer on his hoane. In order to have
adequate pitch for the dormer, his ceilin� must be lowered to a height
of 6'10". The proposed dormer must be constructed to acco�nodate separately
accessible boys and �irls qua.rters. The ceilin� will not be less triar�
6'10" at any point.
ACTI0�1
Idotion by Grove to grant the appeal to enable the construction of a doi-mer
with the ceilin�; hei�ht of 6'10". Seconded by Sommerdorf.
TI� VOTE
l�yes: Grove, Voi�t, Sorrtmerdorf, Peake. Nayes: none. nbstentioris: norie.
h:otion carried four (4) to zero (0).
• 259441
. uu�ucw�rs�ro MnN�s�e
� CITY OF ST. PAUL �uNa� NO
OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK
� � y COUNCIL RESOLUTION—GENERAL FORM
rRes�er
COMMISSIONER DA�
t�SOLVSD, tbst th� Cou�cil i�by rati�ia sad appro�� tL�
ution o# th� 8tint Paul Bo�trd of A�aU and � �e !� �sin�,
Suildi� and 1is� �3on Cod�r p�actainin� to tb� lslle�i�lt��t�d
Psop4rty and u aharn bq tb� Gffiotal �� ot said 8oas�d ot 4rprtl�,
d�t.�d Jnly l�, 19fZ. a e;opy og +�r6iob, siar4�d �IT "A", i� stta�iwd
l�to �aaid � t p�rt �� b� r��nors
iCa� lio. � �
31•7Z•8 1918 8aw�dsn tiaLatd Lotnr�
3�-73•D 13ZA► Pagwt ,� L�a��na T�r� :
b?
�srC P. Lrt��
3�►•7Z•3 1638 Aa6land O�sald �lin�es�t
47•72•H 719 Postlar�d iwuns htriak �t�na�s
41-7Z-D 480 C�das Aw� l�astMst.ar lir� :
lrot�ti.en Cv.
b!
Yau�ti tlu�s�utaa, J�r.
�a-�z-s �,ozi �i.MOOa Jodn a•�
AU6 10 197�8
COUNCILMEN Adopted by the Co��c� 19_
Yesa Naya
utl H u nt �:�'\ AU 6 1 � �972
C n Konopatzld "�'� Appro� 19_
zt
� , e Levine -
MereditFi - Tr Favor
� ��Sprafka �r
s �-- �
aco
M me. President,,�#� - A°i17*'At
Mr. Pr 'd t, McCarty �
i
� �8