259274 / � .
`' • Or/iMm���i� '�� , ♦
�.,'� �
� ORDINANCE
• �592�4
� � ` � COUNCIL FILE NO
PRESENTED BY � � ORDINANCE NO / �_1��='�!
�
AN AL1MI IdI STRpiTI VE ORDI I+TANCE AMELTDI N6 ORDI NANC�
NO. 15007, COU1+dCIL FILE 1l�O. 256639, ADOP3'ED
JANITARY 4, 1972.
THE COiTNCIL OF THE CITY. OF Sl�ATT PAUL DOES ORDAINs
Section l. That Ordinance No. 15�07. Council File No. 256639,
adopted January 4, 1972, be and the s�e is hereby amended by
deleting Section 1 thereof and in�erting the followinq �.n lieu
�nd in place thereofa
"Sectiori 1. In accordance with the provision
of Ghapter 319 of the Saint Panl Legislative Cod�,
a� amended, tlle Council of the City of Saint Paul
does h�reby establish rate� for solid waste collection
to be performed by the Department of Public Works,
which rates ar� as followsz
a) One-family dw�lling with no limit on the
number of container�, bags, and bundles
per week $ .90 each week
b) Two-family dwelling with no limi.t ��n the
number of containers, bags, and bundles
�pet. week 1.40 eae� week
e) 1'hree-family c7welling with no limit on the
nu�aber of containers, bags, and bundles
p�r week 1.90 each wreek
dj Four-fa�ttily dwelling with no limit on the
number of container�, bags, and bundles
p�r week 2.40 eaeh week
e) Bulk pickups from co�ercial, institution�,
and other establishments 4.50 eacll cu. yd.
or fraction tllereof
f) Pickup old appliances, furniture and
other misce�l�.an�ous items 3.50 mini.m�m for mn�
piece and $2.50 for
eaeh additional piece
� .�t�
;�� B_���
����%9�"�'
Yeas Councilmen Nays Passed by the Council
Butler
Caxlson Tn Favor
Levine
Meredith
Sprafka A gainat
Tedesco `
Mr. President (McCarty) Approved•
Attest: �
City Clerk M or
�� :
Form approved Corporation �ounsel By .
• Pr�4�:o Cit9 Ctsrk , •
�� � � ` ORDINANCE �
. . ; . �5g,��74
� COUNCIL FILE NO
PRESENTED BY ORDINANCE NO �� �
2
g) One-fa�ily dwelling with no li.mit on the number
of eoatainers, bags or bundle� per week for senior
citizens, widows, and other low income familieg
(hardship cas��) who make application and are
approved by the Solid Waste Collection Special
Assistance Committ�e. The City Council intend�
to subsidize the difference between the 35G rate
and the 90� rate, 554 per one-family dwelling
p�r week .3S each
week
h) Pickup from the Housing & RsdevelopYaent Authority,
the Independent School Di�trict No. 625, and Parks
and Playground�, and other gov�rnzuental agencies on
a force account basis, subjeet to negotiatian with
the Department of Public Works and approval by Council
Resolution. "
Section 2. �.'his ordinanee shall take effect ar�d be in force
30 days from and after its passage, approval and publication. ,
aus 1 s �sr� �
Yeas Councilmen Nays Passed by the Council
u t'
�- �f'lOpdtz'�� � Tn Favor
�� /--� �
Meredith V A gainst
Sprafka
�`����CO �✓t�e AUG 16 1972
Mr. President �-
d:
Attest:
Ci lerk Ma
�� Form approved Corporation �Counael By
�---
..
�IIBLISHED �� ], � ���
/ r ' �
�� Uu�iiub^�Prl�l�s , � �
r „
�� � . . QRDINAi� CE
� r � �o���� �� No 2�9�'��
PRESENT� BY ORDINANCE NO �`�/�J
� �If'i�'t�'I!i ��E� �� �OM��E!
l0�. 1li007'. �f. lZ3i� !0. =lfii3ls �D�'!!�
Ji�iti 4• 1l72.
'!� �401�I3. 0! !� .�!? N !�!_ !�e D� O��A�Z�
i�atf,ea 1. liat ORrRia�wta� �s. 1i�0�• t'�il li�l� !o. 3Sii3l.
�d .TanasY #r 1!'�'!a lli a�d ti� art is l�st�► a�i�i �
�t]..ti� s.�tioa 1 i�s�..t a�a ia�sst� �i. l�ols��ri�r� �ua lira
s�d i� !►1� t�sre�:
•i�at3,�a 1. L ae�st�la�� �►iti tl� p�se�ris�w
of �s 31! o! tlr i�iat la�l L�i�l�ti� �.
a� a■�i�l, t� �o�vil o! � �it� od' �ais! la�tl
�� ]� �rt•airli�i sa�s t'�ar �olid �aueb a�13�el�
!o Irs p�s�d � ttia ���c'!'rat o! l�1r].is �radES,
v'ltiai rsts� a� a� t'alla�a:
a� f��-laAtl� �11ia� �rit�t a�r 1lait vs 1�
a�r of cro�tta3siss, io�r�a, a�t ��
p�s w�t � .!4 �d► w�
�� !�-tai� dwilia� �►i�It �a► 13�.t aa 1�M
a�s of aestai�as�. D�s. a� Ir�l+ra
p�s wN� 1.�10 �a�t wvt
Qf !l�s�=��i�.�► awtlia� �riti a�s u�it � ti�
so1�r �f �o�a�. �y�. ard �s
rr �k 1.l� �t�a� w�t
_ � d� �anuc�-!'a�lf d�11i�y �riti► se lia�it oat tit
a�i�c oE ooat�rs, �gs, a�d Lr■rai�s
p�c w�l� 3.+� �te�ii� w�t
•j ilt Pia�aQs ls�ea e�o�se�rrial, iastit�ati�oss,
a�d ot�ws 4.S� �a�a� a�. �.
oac fsa�t3�a t'ia�e!
!j li�P old a�liasa�s. lasaita�sr aai
otlMS ais�lla■r�s�ur it�rs �.S8 �isi�M�e �es �
pisv� �+i ;3.� !�
+a� aii�#ioWl �3;�ri
Yea�e Councilmen Nays Paseed by the Coun�1
Butler
Carleon Tn Fsvor
Levine
Meredith
��a , Against
Tedesco
Mr. Preeident (McCarty) APPrnved:
Attest:
City Clerk Mayor
�� Form a roved Co , �
PP rporation �ouneel By _
�:-�.
, �
�a t�rei.a,� ,
r . ...
` O R D I 1�T A N �C E 2592'�� ,
,
COUNCIL HLE NO
PRESENTED BY ORDINANCE NO �j�
2
q) O�-la3.lp d�wlliaq rith so li�ait on t1�s a�b�s
� of coatsfa�rs. bsqs or buadt�s gss w�k tor �ior
aitis�as. �i�rs, amd �►t�c lar iaaoM f�silie•
(]l�ar�lsbip cas�s) �ho s�]ca� applicatioa �l are
appro�d �y #� SOlid llaat� t�ll�etio� ��aial
lisaist�ua� �to■■�itt�s. �a Ci�r t�utail int�a�la
tro s�idi.a� t� diff� b�tt�� t'1� 3S4 �s�tfi�
a�d tL�s 90C rat�,SS� pos c�-fa�,il� dwlliaq
g�r wek .�5 �:<�h
w�k
h} licl�np lroa th� 8onsfaq � l�lvpNat �antlu�ritr.
; tho Ia!lep�'d�sat Se�ol Dfstric:t Yo. b23. �d las�cs
aud llaggro�ds: a�d othes �s�tal agrsciu t�
a forc� acoonat bssis�. sob��ct #4 a�q+c�tiation rith
t�e �pas�t,a�tnt �! l�li.c lforl« aud approral by @onaeil
�s�olnticu�*
�sation 2. Thi.s o�cdiaaaa�s �a1.3 �.alc� •ffi�at and be in force
34 daYs fs�a�a a�d af�t�s its psssags, a�ra►a1 and p�bliaatioa.
,
AUG 16 ��
Yeas Councilmen a a Paased by the Counci�
�.,�� ' �
'�Da Tn Favor
��
Meredith � t� Ag�in�t
�Prafka
�a�t AU�6 16 191�
Approv�l:
A1,test: ^ L��.
City Clerk �ayor
��
Form s�►prnved Corporation f�ouneel By _
.. ._� � ! L::_-.n..... . .
�.S i� i.•. -
� .:��:: � ._
i. ��
* ���'��e .-'1� �,
,�'� ..,!,`, :y��
,��+y+F�L' - � ��
. �',r� �"',
�,.,.:.� ., .. ... �.�,.,s�T!
.�� ,. '�i, ,�,
��'�_ �'� , , � „,r.
,e �;; � � .� , yr' ,
.�w s. •� � �+ Y i � t �'
k ��-i �l��,
,t .�..4"�� 'X . tE �.I�i.
.,.. .a . � . 4
1".; : 9w � ;y�K `�;��p '
v� ris.�t r �N;���,.
� ti'..� .. ..'!#. '�P�f �.�6�
� �%`� �
•Y �;.�.F �" � �� i� 1
�� •� !'`., �...
���- t���.� �
�l`���F _ r.
�; : � -�����:;�.
�"^"�� ! t u- �3 ,�'"��X'�t ��.>wA.
e.�u��•i?�'�w+G ��e'�F�F�.
� .. .. . � :�';-
. ,... , �.�,��.,K'
'' 't'� �. � . .. +� w��5".'T,
F. � N,
e,y,;,... . �. ,
' R;
� �.J r�k �<:
�
;'��� � ��
�f�� � � �` i.
: �
�'y
;�„ ,
�' .�a�k �;
; �,��.='�.
r;�� } �, �-. .�y,�ic��.
�' Mr+ ,..� �„f��
�f:^-v `d+�' .,!:
rx++v.t�:�:{� �'x: .
,�.�, ,�ro.-`
�. , s�.
fA M^ � ,,,_.,,��
�y , �
r '� 4'�
. '
��k
r �.����� -A,
t
� �J�� �'r� � ,�:-.
. � }�t .
�� , . T�waw::�r
r � J��N, r �� � ,i�t%M1���..
?,�xq,� �. ', + .
�,*" 4 eN9�,: •}�t�.+,.
• -.^.3 � a.>`�.
'zw'�
r-,
,�
-a...,yw,.,. ... .-�..,..mg.�
',[°9�x� F ���. �i.
Y V}
adn� ., .t �` a
�m�.,' {�� 4{I'.
aXry R&, .. . . �
..�' - _'��s
.,"�F..
�µV� ,
y�„�
M,ia��
'�Y�r?� ?,.V. .
{L
�
..�"..� � S.
,.pyr.+n��. . i�n;t� '
C Y,�ye
����
.;`� . �-.
�;' , ;�.
�i,
i;
,,�Y , Yt Ad,:
�A
`.1.. .. 1 i�l .
Lt'
e>4'� . . k C.
v,,«.; �k�,:;�.�.:
' � �, ".�:
��� �,�,�.,
H d � � Y
��,��
►, , �;' r"�'��'
"�+ '�
�,y�^; �F���
�C���c,� � i� rG�Gt�c ���r�,n��
_ , . (. r. - � ��., ; .� �
.� _ - _ . . . .. .. , t.�.. .�. , .. .. .. A� ... , _t � ;1.�: . .. .
��.. ., . _ �.. ._ . . . _,. ., '•.
�. ,. .. �. . �T�r' i�
.
' �
� ' �� � ' � � :: � ' �� '... .t 1�! �.'J � '. , v. �:`_
�
. . . .. . _ . .,. ,.. . . ' l'
� � �r
. . , . ; 6 .� ��,. ;,
.,
.;: , . } . �
,. �� . ..� . t . .....,
�
�
,�. _ �., � �. .. ,, � _ , �� ��;.�e,. ���C
�
, . .
;;�. . . . . :,
_
, � ,. . � � _ . - _.
, , ,
„ ,
,. , � ,
. .<"_.
�c �Sc��n y�i� - J��,.�- ��, l��l
�
j� _ �/' . ;' � ` , �%,�/
�t� / ' . !
` :; : ' • : ` �`. : _ ' , : :
l
\
\
. • � ;�V����
��lTY �
Area Code 612 � /��\\ THOMAS J. STEARNS
22$-5121 � � \ ARTHUR M. NELSON
z� al
• • � ` -'�I PAUL F. MC CLOSKEV, JR.
� � �/
/� R. SCOTT DAVIES
� "�� PIERRE N. REGNIER
DANIEL L. FICKER
JOHN C. MC LAUGHLIN
CITY OF SAINT PAUL ROBERT C. HOENE
KENNETH J. FITZPATRICK A. KEITH HANZEL
r�}5t' g'YdTTt TERRY F. SULLIVAN
City At�'orney LEGAL DEPARTMENT Assistants
JEROME J. SEGAL ROBERT W. MATTSON
5'�fe�ial�tsstslaitt 647 City Hall, St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 Investigator
DANIEL A. KLAS JL1],I7 ],Z� 19�]2
Qorpemet+err 6onrrsei
T'he Honorable Lawrence Cohen
l�ayor of the City of Saint Paul
City Hall and Court House
Dear Mayor Cohen:
Re: Rates for City Solid Waste Collection
Enclosed please find ordinance providing for an increase
in the rates to be charged by the City for the collection of
solid waste. This ordinance is required by Section 319.14 of
the Saint Paul Legislative Code. �ection 319.14 requires that
the proposed rate amendment be publi�hed in tlie official news-
paper of the Cityat least 30 days prior to a public hearing
and, further, that the City Council conduct a public hearing on
such proposed rates before it may adopt a change of rates for
solid waste disposal.
If you are going to transmit this ordinance to the City
Council for action thereon, the City Clerk should be requested
to publish the full text of the proposed ordinance in the Legal
Ledger at least 30 days before the date of the public hearing.
Very uly yours
�
E J. SEG
Ass tant City Attorney
JJS:ja
enc.
�
*; _ ,
,;-..� -� -- -• , -� -,-, -, -_ _
• - . �'.:oi �....� ±/ :� _. � �..� . _ ., _.a .�._;
^ � / . . , . .: , . .. ,..�. �... . . . _. __. .
�� ;/ /----� � �
_�„ .� .,., ; . - -� , �;-��L�--�/ _.
,���. � ., . _ . -- — --
,
�T A...LYLIIvi=.7�."�'.1L� v_..'`.T:.�L".vr ___''�..._aJ .._..�.__.___...._.
�vo. i5��7, c���:CIL Z'II,r �.�. 2s����, �:,����
J�i�J�.°•Y 4• ].97 2.
TE�' CC'JL7�:IL O� .i.:� CI`PY Oi S:Z P7T :t�`JT,� :�^..:.a C::.�.s.Ti:
Section 1. Znaat Ordinanc� Lla. 159�7, C�.��ci� �i�� _':,. �����3,
adopt�d January 4, 1972, be and tav aa.:.� is ?:^r��l u.:.�z��3 a;�
deleting Sectioz 1 t�rseraof an� in�erting t::� f�Zl�:�in� i.z �.:.�a
and in place ttiera�f:
"Section l. In accordanc� e�ita t:�� ��ovi:,ioa
of Chapter 319 of t�e Saint naul Legislativ� C���,
as a:nended, t.'�e Coancil of t'a.� Cit� o� �ain� ?aul
does hereby establi�a rat�� fo� aali.�'. :.:3t� c�l'_�a'.:i;a
' to be pa�fo�sd by t.''z� D�part.-::zt of �::�Zia :"��:.�,
which xat�s are as follc�vsz
a) One-family d:��13.i;g ��it� :�o :+.�it c: �.':�
nu:nber o� contain�r:,, wags, a.�� '�:�.�?1�.;
per week $ .90 eaca ^:�ek
` b) Two-fa�il� d.•,�lling t�iti no li�it �n t::e
� nexmber of container�, bags, and bt:.-�d�.�s
per week 1.40 �ac� �•re�lc
e) �r�e-�=.�i1� c::��1Z':� �:��y.�. :� ���.w ___ �':�
au..-i,:�r o� c�:�-ai:�::�, __�j.�.�� ...��1 _...ar._.�J
per :�e�:� 1.90 cac:: ..�ek
d) Four-f�..^iily d-:ralling wit� no li:..-�it on t�:�
number of container�, bag�, and bundlcs
per ��eak 2.40 �ar.� c�eek
� '
�
� e) Bulk pickups fra:7 c�:�.r:°rcial, in�tits�io.^.�,
� and other establish•n�nts 4.�0 eac:i cu. yd.
or frac�ion thereo:�
I fj Pickup old a�pliances, furnit�xre and
other miseLllaneous ite:as 7.50 raini;,i:.^i �ar �
� piec: and $2.50 ��_.
� eac� a3ditional
P_--
�.�� �.
Ga`��
Yeas Councilmen Nays Passed by the Connci�
Butler
Ci2T130ri � r.
Levine "� `��y�
Meredith _��w;.;�
Sprafka
Tedesco
Mr. Presidant (1"dcCarty) Approved• --- -
Att�st:
City C:ar:c � :,_ �r - -- -
��� �
„ __...,_�
.��-^i wr^rcvvd Ca�^e*ation Cour.sel��— �_ --- - _ _ _
��
�i �
* • .` � � � ��v �s �/��' .
. ��
d d d d d
H H H �-3 H
H H H H H
' C1 C� C� C] C�
H H H H H
Cn �P G� N I�
H bH � � � N t0 N N HO
� t'i " � W U�i m c0 N C/� tA'i
z z �
0 o rr�
. .
i
0 0
� ►� c'a cn E--� a-� i--� - � N
Q U� ''d Cn !--' N O N O •
" f�/� p �i-� N �7 F' tD W �7 I Cn
H �si �C
O Ui C17
� �
1
�
�+ �Z F-' !--' 1-� H' i--i
W �} CT� fA Cr7 CT� •
��-+, OD O c�D � � � C�n
- t=J
�
!� I?d CJ� IO ►~A 0~D F~-' O �:
O !-� O �7 0� t--� tn t0 �
F�
C1'� I�C N I 1--' 17
rP N � ►f� �P . O W � C3�
, .
N
.
W (W f�-+ I tn W N W W (�n
� I '
1
. F-' F-'
d� �p
�
� 1-� W CA
�7 W W
U� � s:7
e
• . ,
. . .
} . .
DISTHICT 1 7-20-72 - 7-26-72
STOPS .35 .75 1.25 1.75 2.25
A 195 120 75 195
B 221 99 109 11 1 1 221
C 21.6 75 l25 15 1 2l6
D 195 79 107 8 1 195
�'E 203 89 98 15 1 203
F 240 65 155 17 3 240
G 221 69 142 1� 221
H 221 63 150 7 1 221
I 229 103 126 229
J 224 100 118 6 : 224
K 227 91 133 3 227
L 2l1 75 135 1 211
Ex. BOOK 189 59 114 16 189
2792 108? 1587 109 6 3 2792
DISTRICT �
� STOPS .35 .75 1.25 1.75 2.25
A 226 1�2 119 5 226
B, 212 93 116 3 212
C 216 103 111 2 216
D 206 9l 111 4 206
E 229 100 118 11 229
-F 254 117 17.9 15 3 254
G 197 71 96 26 2 2 199
-=H 209 72 123 13 1 209
I 207 83 111 12 1 207
J 2l2 1Q2 106 4 212
R 216 103 108 5 216
L 221 90 120 10 1 221
EX. BOOK 144 65 73 5 1 144
::2749 1228 1395 115 3 $ 2749 `
DISTRICT 3
STOPS .35 .75 1.25 1.75 2.25
A 218 83 122 10 l 2 218
B 253 40 176 26 2 9 253
C 205 68 128 8 1 245
D 22I 75 135 9 2 221
E 198 44 117 31 3 3 198
F 232 lll 118 3 232
G 217 92 122 3 21?
$ 243 125 110 8 243
I 201 96 103 2 201
d 2?2 103 134 32 3 272
K 229 I06 109 -14 22.9
L 204 60 11B 23 1 2 204
EX: BOOK 196 66 115 ]�2 2 1 1g6
2BS9 1069 1607 181 10 22 2889
�
�
DISTRICT 4
STOFS .35 .75 1.25 1.75 2.25
A 240 99 _ 125 16 240
B 220 83 122 1� 1 220
C 238 117 108 13 238
:� D 215 72 136 7 215
E 214 63 11? 29 4 1 214
---F 228 92 103 32 1 228
C� 226 106 112 8 226
H 210 95 105 10 210
I 243 101 142 . 243
J 229 66 156 7 229
` �K 221 97 122 2 221
I, 235 72 161 2 �35
EX. BOOK 166 62 96 8 166
"'2885 1221 1509 _148 4 3 2885
DIS�.'RICT 5
STOPS .35 .75 1.25 1.75 2.25
,A 273 98 - 149 24 2 2?3
B 258 126 125 6 1 258
C 24? 102 141 4 247
D 246 95 148 3 246
-E 231 77 151 3 231
�'F 23? 105 I26 6 237
G 244 83 155 6 244
H 239 82 149 : 8 239
I 209 63 144 2 209
J 219 98 113 8 219
K 238 91 125 1? 2 3 238
L 217 89 114 13 1 217
EX.BOOK 165 58 100 7 l65
3023 1167 1740 ;_107 4 5 302�
.. ��` . ��_��
�iT"�$'�.� . 1 �
Y
,t� :,-���` ;� '�' CG x r� ca r S tL I Z r P�L��L
�y� � ��,� �r�'`�
.7�� �� r� ;'(*{ n��l�1�i�'. U1� �l�ll�: Oli�� �)IZ
i - 9_�� K. .,�
� F C�I k •. •
:I:.:. 6 P I.L�,2{h);.. "Y . .
{. r �-_ti r ;l
+; _ YC �
�r p �;��'
�.� ��-� ��. Augt�st 16� 1972
:sti.�
r.���-•tz:,���: n. co,f�:� T0: Hon.orable ��mb�rs of St. PauJ. City Cc�uxac�,l
�t.�,-c,�_
SU�;Ml�R� �F P�PflS,AL `.[t� .i1�CRF.�SP Rk`t'� k�R REGULIi�'{ CI�'Y FiEPi1SE GOIz�,�C:'Z ItiAl
Th� Pulal.ic I�,�'orks Ilepa.rtment ha� requ�sted, and the a�dmina.stxa�ticr� c;(a�.c�rs, s�i.th
�� 3�aCZ�ease �aro�► ry� ce�.ts fi;,a g0 een�; �eekl.y �Fox cu�,t��rer y noti x°eceivir+� izn:i.i�x.tsd
�ic�up frou tt�e cYty. �e�e is nc, c�a.nge proposed for �i;he 3,�--cLn� custo�ner�. �
xh�.s pmposal �hould ta� cor�fined to �he requested cha.r�e in �he otd�.x�a.nc�e '.
reeogn�.zin{� thuxp ar� n��ny otk�er lon�er-ra.n�e prc�posals to�la� c£���ti�i au.d cons�.dex�ed
conn�cted �aith the er��ixe prot�le� of coZlecting and d3.sposfng o�E sc�lid �ra�-�e and
garbage �ene�a�ied in St, Paul&;:
'tsro r�,jor fwe�car� are the r�asc�n for the xeque�ted ir.;cx�as�s �i ne�.r t�ip�.�.r�
o� the cos� af di�po�-�l �xad h�.�hea: wag�es for lalbore :
B�.s�d c�r� 7.3�000 aus��exs� abcut 10,000 fli11 �.yfng an3 so�e 3,OCO suhaid�zed,
thv �a:�ld��.�n� r��.c3.3.'ly identii�,ab2e increases ha.ve accured since the c�.ty
. �im�3.ried co2.Iecti�r� r prog�a� sras irya,v.gurated Au�st 9, 1�71 s
DT�POSE:L
An a�ra.�e of �2QQ a cta,y r��re e�ctn�se, based �n a x�.�e o#' �1�fl5 p�r cubic yai�l
at the Ba,le� p1a�� 6,391 cub3r, yards delivez��d fox �0 �r�ir.g days in
3�1y) compa�d 7:a .40 cer:�ts fer 20 frorkinb d��.ys in June` Hh3.le the Pi�'s Ey�
L�.ndf'ill wa.� sti11 open, �e dail�3r avera.g�e 3.r� Jur�e �a.s $1.�9 and in July �33�.
2'.his core��i��s to ;�ore tha.0 8 c:ents per s�, b�,sed on an avex,ag� o� 2�60a stoops
da.ily.
3�AEQR
�a.lary iner�ases for 1.2 c�r3.vers, 12 3.aborers of 2$ cents �+er hour per cz,ex,
ar n.t�iout $27 a cl�,v. This. combined xith �crease� for six supervisaxy �.nci
f3e�.d �er.sonn.el a�ds anoth�r 2-plus �ent� to the pex•-stU� r,ost. Ccrxesponding
percenta�e inereases in £ringes must al�o be cansid.ex°ed,
„
� fi
hDLTAS�ING IS �i BFi�iKBOi�A C�F DA.ILY (�STS. AS REPO�E7 BY PUBLIC WOR.�,S �FPICIAL5 s
(:ozr.�utPd an a. da.�.ly t:a.sis by th.e'I�.yor's Qf�ice) `
b:
, �. �• Cot�nc'I.1 Rsflise Hea�in� _--2
D�rect Labflr �
Dx�.ver�7�.�nrer Teams (12} $93 x 12 �1,I i�
Supervi�ry, fiel,d clerks (6} 230
F'ringo BsnQfits, vaca.tionl 35�
i►7u4 .
Di.�sa1
.�ul,� Averr�gs, 20 �.aqs� ��..OZ campactad yd. 337
Ye�i.�le
Deprecia.tion and Operatic�n� (each at $1 an h�t:r 192
Misc.
pverh�a�,d� �..ncl�ding billing, plione, ntilities,
pos�ta.ge� etc. 50 _
ToTnL3 �2.279
Average daily cost fcr ea.ch af 2,600 customers ---- $.88
�.--One mari on t�a.ca.tion in a 30-member crew replaced at saa�e sa.lar,y i.nerease�
� pro��n budg�t 3.3 P�r esnt.
2--^Depxeciation calcul.r;.�e3 at si,x-year �iteoff �or rep3,acement.
3--�Reserve allo�ance for repa.ir need.ed but un3etermi.ned and not iilcluded.
Al.l.owance also needecl for 1972 vg�' raises ba.sed on outside la.'bor contracts.
Costs per stop 3n cents
Dri�r-I�borer 43
5upervisory,field 11
fringe s 11
disposal 14
vehicle a
Misco 2
88 cents
NOTE: If all customers �re pa.yirxg �t 1e�.st 90 cen�s per pickup� daily revenue
w�ould, b� $2.3�A based on 2.b00 customers. This is in►pox°tant in considering
the discussed subsidy progx�,m for senior citizens and eld�rly.
It is appareat ths.t from th� a'bove calculatians, the City �uncil �s fairly
cZose in adopting the 75-cent rate last year. Tlae increased labor and disposal
cost�( note �that July was a lot� month for �eneration) com�ined with m:lnvr
underestimate in setting the original rate due to Jlack of c'exQerience in t,k�e
�xo�ram wi11 ,,,-iusti.f� the ns�r, 0-cent rate,
__.��_._. ...__ ._ .. __.. _.,. �
. ,..�_ .
_.. _ ,._ � :,..;w... . . .
_ , ._., _ , . ,
__. _ ,:... �._;. _
• � Council re�,ise hearf,ng ---3
., ;. .
(JOMPARAT�V� CfiARC'ES � �
The t�ndency �to comga„re c3,ty chaxges �ith t,hose of priva,te haulers� w�ile '
s�rving s�me purpose, ca,nnot be the sole determination �c�a,use of em lo i
gua.rra..ntees and fringe-t�enefit proerams a,�ra,j,l,able to �i.ty r�orkexs �Ehat perha,ps
are not duplica.ted outside.
Ho�rever, at the request of the I�4ayor's Office �.nd the C�.ty Council Public kTorks
Comm�.ttee, the Rtblie i�orks I1�partment on Augu.st 2� 1972, wrote to all priva.te
haulers a�king them to co�npl.y with chapter 321g of +Yie �alici j��aste O�iria,nce and
subru.t to the city any propc�sed incr�ases in collect�.or� ra#;es. ,
�s af August 1Q, 13 haulers svbmitted their inten�ion to r:�.i,�e x�,tes
from " c BeneYally
50 cents to �1 a iac7rath� and more. The report is a.t�a.ched.
DEFICIT
��ici� has been �aid of the so-ca.11ed d�ficit in this pra�ram. i�hile 3.t xs a
prc>�lem tha.t must be co:�tended tirith saon, the ai�oTr� f'��u�s and. pr��r�.aus
dis�ussions wi.th the Public �lorks Commi.ttee ina�3,�a,te �to the ad.�inistra,tio�a a�
thi s time tha.t the pzv�-a,m ¢a,n b� opera,te� on a soundr efficie�t arld ��If'-
susta.3.ning basis. It is providing a needed, necessary s�r�,�ce.
Key to �he success, howeverp will be agree�ent Norked pA't �?8'tN�@21 the �iayox°s
Office a.nd City Couricil ta px�avide a subsidy fund �for pro�t�cti.on o£ �th� eld�rly
and lo�r-inco�Q customers as a pr�per #�nG�ion.
We feel tentativ+�ly tha.t perha,ps txo �okk�eping accounts ta�txld `
� pirogxam into i�ts proper serc*ice pex�pec�ive, E�ren wi�h �.he uriof�cial.�1�p-cent
subsidy for �he 3S-�ent customer� at present ra•�es, the defic�t tia.s been an a
down�aard curve since the init�.al "start-up" cosics o� f.he p�:ogra� created mo�a
tr�a.n o�e-thix�cl of the $a1��030 defiGit reparted as of� JuZyoY.
Thfs ho�ver, is a sepasa�e, though �la.ted� c��.�ussion.
I am atta.chin� earlier camwunl.cat�.ons to the Public k�orks Com�sittee that �i.ght
be beneficial f,a this hearing,
Y
.Si�l re�,y�
� �
� �.�s---
Phil Jdee `
Administrative Asst. �o I�ayor :
- r
• �„
/ .
F
, , ji:'
� k.
(.
- -- -- - -- . _ -�- -- --. . -� ---.�. _ . . . _ _ . --- -- --- -- . _ _ _ ' .. _ . . , . . . -
;�y: s
x
0 0 � � � • r��' � o�`i w � ,
. ►i � � N � N �S' � N
�i �
� _ ro o ti o 00 � �?
. . . � � - vw � . pa �' ►�t o�i N •
� x o� w ro ►-+ � �' a
d �
a m w � � . x' � . d � �
� � r � . _ cn a� ov �
I't t'� K p►
K � 0� . � . 0 � _ � .
'Cf ri • - ry� • , p
. y �� N ;. ' • , -
N ' Y � . � . • t3 ' "
" � . . . �
n � ' C � *, . .
� � .
� C � G • .. � C � '•�
�C �C �C �C ' � � �C `C n C7
L=] 7
� ..0~0 =• V t�i� ' ' � � a N � t�
, . . • : . . t'1
O�Q r . � � � � C
. . . .. .J � _ • � . . • . • .J � � F
a, zt-i� ra �
' . �"' - !'' / � . r +.' 7> b ►-�i
• . - • �n '7 C
� � 9
H
tn tn C=! tn ,-'� N r tn t-7 � cn [Tf � ►-3 tA [n�tn tn r C�7
t--� r-� �C W � . � t r C � n C tD E Y• W e-� rr i
W � A • M �h ►-h • tD l9 . lb (D W i • • N rA �
• • K O W fa Ca V ri T' r''� rt 9 x' Y !� f.' O �� • ^�
tn tn Su O � � � tn �C r-� C) r�G r-� r-� r-� rD N U U tn � -
O O w w w �C r• r-� r-��G r� � �o O r� �
rr E r� r-� r-� n o • rr r� o :� - ro E :c � O r-�
►1t i�l . �C ti: `�i :- !Y Y•�C �-t `c: `� '^ ►-+ O � M `C i=]
O ^v "' *� � • �' or N :. � ' �C :3 f� O
K ►i !D �n tn Va fJ W (D O lD O t� O 7S' rt � +i � 5.�,.
W W N � �C +'i n � K rt K �i r't in �' m CJ �
� N tn r+ • • • `SJ � C� U1 ►-+ r-' rt ln !J
O O !D Y U O N n £ r n E n 4'� n CD • `C O O n ;x�j
� � � o o v� a m �e r � � c r� � ,� �n �v � �,
0o w � �e � r� n r� ti n < o.. o� �c �
s� a r� E � S �' rt rr cr �- a-�cn o- • sn � su
r � 0 7c' x� x - a w � •. �„. � cr s� oo -cn 'ro
oa � ►t . . . ,. � �
v' G �� tY � r G� <n O{n G'� G rY-� fn r
N r r. t� m tn O :� w o � ril rr cn o �n
N
m � O K � Z' � K Vvi A�i ln O 4�i V� � � i t�jj
v' � v� . o � oa o 0 0o v+� a
.. � � o w ° � � � � �o t' G �
N ►'' E3 A, v N.O O � � � O �
x �a
. - . 'G . - ' . " �� 0 � , ,{/? a . .
O O �j
fD • • ►-� Cn • v uj . -
. v ��, ' • W ln � p ` p
' ' . . � .- � •
fJ "
O
Va t�a [rJ tn _� N � W . t-+ N ri7 E 7 C7 � H C� �n-tn tn ln tn
r.+ r ?C w • � - � w t�- � -. C r9 O C i� F !b W r-� r-� o O
0� -� O rt • . b7 rn t� M b7 r-� i �-h .� tD !D (D fD W � • • L� t t>
• • � �"S Vl Y• CJ Y- G Y• n i: 1A .^J o �/? rt T; N• 9 �"i r7 � �✓' n n Q Vt • N
� � � O � � � � � � fD W a f5 W�C � � r-�`G r• r• r-+ CJ !D O O ln O �
tn tn n E ►-� E w � r• � • r- � • �C t� r r�`C r� � r O ,Y o
M Ffi ai �G T+ �-x'`C r�-+�G ('v � r�-� ln`C � V�i rr � (9 `C rr ��,' v �S � �' O � M C") fD
O O ft' ^O • �C � `�G � n��C � `C �' Q' N ? • � E F'� � �D O O
K ►i O fD � � r-+ � � A� (D N rn O (� O m o r� � rr + rS rn
� a, w E E �t • <n o w K n � cu n n n K n r� E �' m � o
� N I9 � ►-+ tn �tn 7c' O N • r f]. 7� tu 7�' cD ►-+ rt tn lD ►t 7.
. O O ►i r-� Oo r-+ tn r-�tn o • r � f� E f) 60 l) � (D `C o O ►t �
� � - n r� • �t • �e w v �o re �e � � � �o c �' �s � �'
0o w a, w �e o» a� • � v, �e c� m n �u n n c� r.�. a� r� o
a o r� o 0 0 0 � n v- ;. v-jn v� m �e �+ � m sn G �
r a m o � -cn <n o • o � o. � v,� rt � c� v� r-� m
40 N m rt r� � +9 Gr' in v • A� • v� O r-� a� tD H
CJ' W m Cl. N • � Oa �S1> N G� i!> N�l/+C� lD G ►-+ m t-� •
fi� 1-+ W A O E A t� O� • A� '.,.� ln v N +i f7 0� rt � C/�
� 00 • ►i O. G O O � � �' • O ►t • • C O n
, . M fD �D ►t O • ►i 1V �J W v. N-Cn f+ v� 'tJ O
. • t7' "U � � O' �C ln OQ ln ln r A tn CL � ^o
60 p ` � ID O iD {� K m
' w CL - CL �Va N '2," �
. � . � . • . _ N lJ� �C'v
0o v v '
i/)�t/a �/a r af ►t ►-3 vf Q' ri ti 2: O� in i/> � Va tA�/f tn � N in ln i--i �7 .
t , fD (D W �" f> �-t G C� �O � <n O N • 0 4 r Y
!�L� � � !t � rt ('J O O rt ;� y i� . . • . . . . . . . � C7 �-i ,, .
. � � V r't r`t !D cn 'C7 � cD t: t=1 N N � N N N N N N ri ln O r-+ ln 'v tr9 ,
. o �� ro m c9 � a w � .. n v+ �n � tn �n v� �n tn v. :� o 0 0 0
r ri u. • rt � c� ,t t� .i� n
V 'v � t+• f; `� ti ' :.� �r„ '
1 - . . . w1f "C J E •� r�q L1. - � ' . " ' • � . . . �y� / �
. _ .. . . . . ._ _ _ . . --- _ . • . _ a �
, ' ,�\' _ . . � K G�� l9 ('�J P�b � ,. '
l � •
_ _ : . . ti a t� o � � c'' t�-� �
_ � • w r-a - 9 �
� � � ,. . . � � a � a, � �
r � (n
� . LLO� . • ', ' ' � ��V' fD W C-' � � " _.. � .
. . - : � � y . : � . � ►J � � ° � �
n � : . : � . i �e `_'
• � N
' � ��G rt , � ' � , 7�
, . � , • . ' � - �
' E q � � - � � : . .
. fD � rt F'' - n
O . . N
xaai - . . _ ` r �
. �� r-n c� � .. � i { v�
w m E •
W W
. � � � , : a�V. .
" ` � � � • . . ' , .
r'p O "
5' n rr
• � � � OQ 00 � Y 1-+ h-+ �
w C C • • �C • 'C 'C `� t��s �
- tn r,• r+. V V W W N N C [�
u, a
� o :a . '• . . • . . • r r � w �
r. �, : a
_ ON7• N� . : .
� x � � �o y d
►-' � c� N
�C n o •� . rr n -� 's �a t� ►v
r / f'' �:r
n � a . � , r � � � � f
�� �
N N Y ►-+ Y N ►-' Y ►-' N �
� � . 1 I ' 1 1 1 1 I 1
�
�'t � (D N A7 W N C� A� N G o tY�
. � fA G7 . . . � ► � 1�-4 t'• F�"� Y• F'� W �
- F'� N 1-� Y� H T-� h� � N
' � `4 � ' �C �c'i �e'. 4'i �C U.� C�1
. y ^, � . . _ ' V - r V V V tiy
ti G(j v
. . . . � � � . �� �Va�CA , V �O �lA t/> ►-� �; �."'.
� V� � W r-+ tn .� ►-+ r+ i� � T r,
'n T? . • lI� r+
� � m oo E :� �.Nno x ao� �
v, c�u 7 . � E x x £ E ,. ,..., ro cn
t! � � . " � x " „ � :� �CA Vt � 5
� �t/� �Cn � W O
W W •
n C w �. _ � � • • [s N o' t=i c=i
� K � O+ O v � ln P� � cnr
O ll� • tt
' m � x . _. . °o � _� g °o b m �'
� ' o� � � � . . • - - � ' � ' � � • ~ �
tu �c' � _ _ U _ cn
ro � y . . - '. `� . •
. � w • .
oa r7
� V � a' -
� � � .
"S a. C7 r N e-r C/) � W N r+ in{A .L� N r-� r 9
- '� ' X t - � K � i � � N W � � � ln r
. 0� fi n Y• C� W r7 � ."� W � b.' M ''; t� � • �M M M 1�t� • • �-t� M M i7 Y
- f.' N � O. rt C. 9� Y O. N � �r`' S.i O t'• � G� fa T� G� V Vt f� f� N
tD .'i ►-� � � � � C? � � 3 � ln � � � � Yw ►t
G � r-� w C� rr � r• rr � w r+ w w r�• r� r• r� r• � G�
- . . . . � a v, (D aa r� f� r F� a' o r-� � o r-� rr ,-• ,-� ,--� r-� rr � r-� e-+ r-� n � i-r �-
x Wa.. ft � rt �"`G r�- r-r r � `G r-� 7 � w`C `C `C `C � O � �C `C �i (D
w,, r-t rr o s� o . `�C rT •. . � � N •• •• •• •. r- . •. r� w
O C W 0'� G K O � � �"tn t9 A � -V> SU
. O iD � � � Q'J K S:> A r-� � r W � 4,' � �,' E f0 � c�o�Va � U� Y'�
r+ t1. c�i r+ p -cn�G Y. -v>`-C • �n T.' �' �' T.' � O • �n • tD � Z
` � o,. .. [� n � �-• r-+ n> oo � ►-+ r-� r� r Su p O • �n n �7
O A M C A . �C • -tn O `C `C `C `G � t� O O O '�7 �i �;
� � o' r o rt t� tn t,� tn� v w <n
. . ' � � �C' � N rt O' � O O ln ln • '� N as tn rn N O � � � � K W
(D f� v N 4i • V> O CJ • N fD f� (9 � L O � O � �
�. � . i�T 'LS n �S � h r O O� O ri O rt rS �-t �i t' 7.' • �j • '0 tD r3
. O A C 0� (D Q • O C C C C � • • W Q• . .
� F'-'O rt ln C� O ^O � • • • � n �
. � - " - : ro r► N +t o n O r� O � � K7 � Q'
' . y K r �C � �' rt • O -cn-cn�cn-tn w � �C
- cn � n v O N tn (�D � ' Oo rn ln � � 'O �
� r* rr w � m rr •t o a o 0 0 � o -
. . � a o a y ��a q ' oaoo v � N -
w cr � � o � o o .
Ao ►-� m rt H �n o' ri c.� 7 ia � in vs tn• tn t-t �
_ ' , � K • V ft � t't tD O O n `i � .� � . • . • .. � �' �
' • � � O " \ It' t7 Cu Cn 'U SU (J G CT7 O � V� l!� l/t F+ O � � '' • ••
' A. �C V tD (D tn ro (D E1. tn N .. d C? O O ln 2� T7
., . . .. . •� hfi �. . . : - N ti A+'D '� ' F� s' � . �. . . • - 5�.. d y , . .,.
� p , � O'' �"i t9 `«1 fD . � . . _ ' .. � .,
� o
/� _ � K ►�c1 CD : r: . . . . ' -
. , � . . � � . . • . . � • \\ � .
' ���'�����
�b����a� ��'��'��'� ���.
1158 STRYtCEF2 AVE.
S. S7. PAUL, RRINN. 55118 �
224-2695 - 454-2307
s/ii/72
llepartment of Yublic tdorks �
Room 234, City Ilall
St,Faul,.ln. 55102 ' .
Sub3ect: Rate increase £or s�lid waste disp�sal . _
GentZemen:
i�?e have been liauling refuse for Many years F�ith out a rate increase.
Put our dispos.al. f_ee have sicvrockeri. The St.Paul Pi�'s r}•e I,andfill
has cI.osed per�nan�ntly .Tiil.y �.st� 1972. The ne�a landfi].1 zaLes have
be�n ra�.s..d ]_OUi anci h?_�'rier. ;!e ar.e forced to p��y SOc for each tire
��p c��tI^n at �imezican System �;�lj.�.j.11g Plant. A rate incr.ease is ne-
cessary, so �,e can giv� the �eople of this area tlie hest service
avaib:Le.
T;esidential Rates: (curh or alley service)
OLD RATE NEW I2ATE
One-fa�►ily d�,�el�in� with no lfr�it cans,or ba�s .75G a week 1.00 a �aeek
T�ro-fariily dwelling ��*ith no limit ca�s,or bags I.1S a caeek 1.50 a iaeek
Three-fariily dFJellinQ with no li.riit cans,or bags 1.60 a k*eek 2.00 a week
rour-family d�aellin� with no limit cans,or Uags 2.00 a week 2.50 a s�Teek
No rate change for Senior Citizens. 1/wk. services .�5� a week.
Commercial and Industrial rate increase approximately 10%-1�7>.
ry ruly,
. . Duane Soutor ��
. ACTIO:V DISPOSAL
. �
;
:�Q, _
' \\
< � �
. . August 1, 1972
. � • �
. �
As per agreemr._�t or the City Ordinances, a list of refase removal rates and
ehan�es are as f o11oWS:
1 family residences - $3•�0 to $�+.00 for �reek7.y service.
- $2.2j to $3.�0 bi�monthly s�rvi�ce.
Dupler.es - �5��0 to �'�.OU for weeka.y serv�ce. �
- $!+.00 to �'�6.OU bi-monthly s�rvice.
Th�eeplexes - we have noi�e that we kuow o�. �
4 Plex - �8•00 to y�12.00 weekly service. .
- �6.00 'co �10.00 bi-•monthly service.
Prices depend on lccation of barrels.
Rapid,Kleen Disposal, Inc.
• � Richard Leo }iomich ��
. ��.��fl...t.� .�� i�f�'��v�,
Secretary, Treasurer
� . . . � .
� . . ' � , � , :
. f . .
� h
�
` � i
. • , t
" I
' .' . ' . ' . . . . . � L
� ' i � . . - 1 . . • _ 1
• � . . . . � . , � . ' ' - ' � � ' 1
' ' 1
' . !
_ ' � / ' . .. � . .. . . " . �
• � • ,.S . � � � .
__ . 1 • l ;
. ' • . . .. . , ' . ' _�
' � . .
' , . . - � � t
; .
� . ..
.
1� ` �' `
: .
' � �r,
�, �`s, \ `.
(_; i •r 1 c�r� S.� i �-T 1'.�c T 7.
. <�rric�: c�r- TIII? �1���-<>>i
<�_� �� ,
!�t -
�� ,Tuly 26, 197z
]._��:u�:�ct: l�. G<�m:�
?I.��o x
Chairnian Ruby Hunt
Members City Council Public Works Committee
Dear Council Memberss
Attached is a cost evaluation of the city reflzse collection prg,;ram as of June
1. My own summary of the report follows for your information:
The program is losing approximately $2,800 a rreek at present rates. but of the
accumulated�loss� you xill note approximately $56,000 (of $14�4�000 total) was
due to the cost of going into business in August� 19?1. On 8/9/71�
the city xent into combined reflzse collection after many years of collecting
garba�e � only.
Our costs xill be reduced about $700 a xeek shortly Khen, as tenatively planned�
a 13th truck is removed from operation due to purchase of nert, more efficient and
economical compactors.
We are mainta.ining a "subsidy" of 40 cents a home for approximately 3,000
35-cent customers.�•�: At the proposed rate of 90 cents for regular pickup service,
the subsidy rrould increase to 55 cents or about $84��000 for budget year 1973.
Hoxever� xe estimate the addition of new customers to city service from those
Hho no longer xill haul their own refuse bevause Pig's Eye is closed will cut
doxn the total costs.
As close as rre can evaluate, it Will take 12,000 flill-p�y customers or
equivalent to make the refuse-collection operation break even. There are now
about 10,000,
e feel that the program definitely should be continued � and can be made
truly self-sustaining� sound, con�petitive and efflcient bys
1--New� safe and more efficient pickup equipment that �till cut back staggering
maintenance costs of the old machiries.
2--Increasing the volume of service, pertsaps through another effort at promoting
the service`to the public. �
3--Greater cost control on violation of service rules by customers. �
k__��e tempora.ry consideration of a subsidy to clear np back deficits. ,,
Sincerely, �
Phil Lee
��.�� s� � �����• `` Administrative Asst. to Ma.yor
L_ µrs. L
i
�/�l.�.! �-I(( ,�'./)// /
���_� `�,�L�f1-..��� Y
` ` K l
. ���,.. _
� _ ."_ i � �' �:�... �......_..�. -_
3�.�a � Ad�r�_ _ �� - I :;
Yeas �iays
:iUD':., . .
,
KOr?OPATZKI �_l(����
f .� .,, C��,
( I�'�t2�',DIZ':z
u
SFRAc:{A (`�
V
. TFDE.�iCi�
�LC e
�:te�-r-R�sIV::NT (�E�j-�.✓cY1e.