261967 WHI7E - CITY CLERK
PINK -�FINANCE � GITY AINT PALTL Council ��/y
BLUERY- MAYORTMENT F112 N O. ���q�' `
' Resc� tion
Presented By
Referred To Committee: Date
Out of Committee By Date
RESOLVED, That upon and pursuant to the pertinent app�al,
under the Zoning Code, by Michael and Norma Arrigoni, owners
of the subject real estate, situate in the City of Saint Paul
and described as:
Lots 15 and 16, Block 8, Fairchild's
and Howard Addition;
that the provisions of said Zoning Code hereby are determir�ed
and varied as and to the extent necesaary therefor to relax
dens�ty requirements so as to accommodate two duplexes on
property locat�d on the southwest comer of Clarence and York,
�ubject to the condition that said appellants, and their
succ�s�ors and assigns, otherwise, shall make due compli�.nce
with all applicable provisions of municipal ordinances, state
statutes and rules and regulations of public authoritie: having
cognizance.
COUI�TCILMEN Requested by Department of:
Yeas � Nays
K�ono�patzki � In Favor
Levine �
Meredith Against BY
�o��rac 8oedl.er
Tedesco
Mme.President� �rit, 4 �973
Adopted by Council: Date AU G 2 Form Appro ed by City Attorne
Certifi ed by Co il ary BY-
By
Approv by Ma Date 4 �p�ed by M o bmissio to uncil �
By
PUBUSHED SEP�� i 1973
�?�'�1 ^�'f</v
�Z'�°.'C.% d
� BOAR� OF ZONING CITY OF SAINT PAUL
�
OFFICE OF THE MAYOR
CITY PLANNING DEPARTMENT
VINCENT M. COUGHLIN
PLANNING COORDINATOR
Apri1 24, 1973
Mr. Harry E. Marshall
City Clerk
Room 386 City Hall
Dear Sir:
This is written in response to the appeal of Michael and Norma Arrigoni
to relax density requirements on property located on the southwest
corner of Clarence and York, and further described as follows:
Lots 15 and 16, Block 8, Fairchild's and Howard Addition.
This matter was heard at the March 15, 1973, Board of Zoning public
hearing, at which time the staff report was read and snapshots of the
site were presented. The Board noted that the variance request was not
represented and acted to recoAanend denial by a vote of 3 to 1. One
member felt that just because it was not represented by the applicant
was no grounds it should be denied since the land is zoned "B" and the
variance is very minor.
Very truly yours,
(.%��� / �'( C���
�'
PETER J. MAIETTA `7�
Secretary, Board of Zoning
PJM:mb
Zoning File 7470
� . � �
� �
421 Wabasha, Saint Paui, Minnesota 55102
(612) 298-4151
. . . /��
� ' ��
. � � �
������
January 30, 1973
The Honorable Mayor and
City Council
c/o City Clerk
Room 386 City Hall and Courthouse
Gentlemen;
The following contains the information for appeal for density
variance on the following described property:
Applicant: Mike E Norma Arrigoni
Address: Marine on the St. Croix
Phone: 433-2852
Legal: Fairchild's and Howard Addition
Block 8, Lot 15 and 16
Street: Clarence and York
Present use: Undeveloped
Proposed use: Two Duplexes
Purpose of Appeal: To obtain app�al for density variance
Cite section of Ordinance appealing under:
Legislative Code: Section 60.03, Paragraph B
�
�, � 1� � � � �
��Q 8 �973; . .
s
�t'�Y rl.Hsr�#f�Q � ��
9�r�t Paui. Mint�ta
.yYW�+� L�±'..t�L �M W:,.ww�+- � I�
S����� � �i � �
�'R�M "� ? �'''J � . �I.
c� at� `�'
��' . �. J G d��mi A i`�.s;�� �—
BOARD OF ZONING• REPORT AND ACTION _ March 15, 1973 ��.����+�
� Plat Map �k37 �
Acfing under Legislative Code Chapter 60 thru 64
� passed August 22, 1922, as amended to January 27, 1971.
7470
1, APPLIGANT'S NAME , Michael and Norma Arrigoni
6033
2. CI,ASSIFICATION . � Amendment � Appeal � PermiC � Other
3. PURPOSE , Relax Density Requirements
4. LOCATION , Southwest corner of Clarence and York
5. LEGAL DESCRIPTION : Lots 15 and 16, Block 8, Fairchild 's and Howard Addition
6. PRESENT ZONINGo "B" Residence
7. PURSUANT TO Zoning Code Chapter: 64 Section: .03 Paragraph:
8o STAFF INVESTIGATION & REPORT: Date: March 8, 1973 By• PLR
A. HISTORY: An identical appeal was granted in 1966 but the property was not
developed and the variance lapsed under provision of Code section 64.03,
paragraph p.
B. PROPOSAL: The appellant proposes to develop the property with two duplexes.
C. VARIANCE: Each lot has 5,940.00 sq, ft. A duplex in a "B" Residential
district requires a lot size of 6,000 sq, ft. so each lot is 60 square feet,
or 1% short of that required.
D. AREA ZONING: The immediately surrounding area is zoned "B" Residential.
East 7th Street frontage is zoned Commercial. The area east of Birmingham
Street has "A" Residential and "C" Residential. The area west of Johnson
Parkway is zoned Industrial.
E. �ITE CONDITIONS: The two lots are vacant, wooded and several feet above the
grades of their frontage streets. The general slope of the terrain is
downward to the north and west.
F. AnEA CO:VDITIONS: The �,rEa is generally developed with modest single family
homes. Vacant land exists in a ravine between Clarence and Birn►ingham
Str�ets, east of which exists a mixture of apart�nents, single family homes
and vacant land. New Highway ��61 is proposed to run through this area.
S, B�AR.D ACTIt�N: To Recommend � Approval � Denial Council Letter
Dated. ,
Yeas Nays
Moved by . M�Partlin X McPartlin April 24,1973
X Berxshoof Date of
Stconde� by: Benshoof Maietta _ X Hearing•
X Cochrane
Secretary's remarks : . April 26,1973
� Council Action:
R •
-A- Date: -
4 � �
�,�� �
`'","�
�.�
�f` � �' !?�.Yr�i,�,e:; ;i e'l�tt s'.�d�; ;i�,F%1Kr ti'� ??�JE'�RU �3r ,i� ��raCr
<, ���:.; �:;F '!.'�-<�' . 7' r•
r�)[, 'J': ;'.5L'�ekY �.r?�lii:�` �`.i, r 9%:�. ,�:7' 1 v(3fl 'c' c�
.;(� .
I\L �111 .; �),l((� �L� j t � , i �� M1 1 f .. l� �1 a a t 1
. _...:..,_..__.
_t..:'L 7 C-� '.,_:S?<`. .S i.� "'t.'�,:C C! ;�c"1� C> 3''I d �"�8�t'L L�i �=1 _�.:? L�!.`a i."Cj i
iiL , ',i 1L �:;_��i23' L�;_ , i<US���:.�% £3'i7t� 1'�r;3 - ";;�T"t`L�u�.t ti)t °.�htL' 7t'���f'
;'!t_'�.�1!�L_ os�i� it,j,z� iK�.� ' ,? �� : 7��iti�b r t�7� ��r�e��, tc7 :°�:a�; Che �Fr���?:.�, ��=_q���.,°���c�rzts
:�� r��.��. p�.�^�:;����;;�,�ta_=� tr�.� i r�� ., ;t��.� .�.>;�� ��+rz�e�� �zf ::iacc�>xr_4 �ud Y��rk<
�it', F�U�;�'�.:i_E`�' tE'i3.:J Z_'�"t° St`.c3S'�' P'L�y•;lL'�: Ib:: t�i)S (1'r3�t_�f?� t�illj u�'1�CSWC� U1C1_tIt!?:� CaT C�'i.�
:-S.:.�:
�'7.s`:�i �'t3�.�FX�T..? :'s :��I_'.� � � �1�2y�i�,G_ ,�_,-' f--i:E'_i"�: a'�QjSY�E�Ei1.r l;tv �:�3E' r3t3�'311.i::iE�.t �t3i1� �l"E?C���+'Y��
[?C3 iC'S�7S`:i.�r.
..
:�t'=']UhC ,-._ _ . .• r'�� .� i . -��. < ,� � 4 � L. ' -i' -
_itt_lt: ��� 1 '1 t' . , ,. 4:E1_ Ct'�If,[l�)Ci � ..5f1.Qil` .:F�,* '3].1 .. .%
. .. � _ _ c� . . _ . . :r:Et `L'; <.�;�.� 3., .�� �
?t:ci._Cf?t �P' ���i'�'i3t+_ i:'c ..�:3`Jt . � 4c:.1 - s;��a; ;• �al ��: t IP_
't . i :'�:'�� . :cj �Ci? f f3j)�4,'�� - �!["t�' :ifi?t'7l�tt 5�'�::
S�1;0Y1Sj2ii P)y �°�3' , }'iEC;iii�L�t:?t= �4i(j f;:�, ;Lk'C1 �1'd � `lC`i:C' Cs� 8 t�J �
i"is" , A�'_f�3.E'~?�i1 .:<5LV �ii, �.C��:1Ci� �f: vti' C? :U2 ifi�t: 1�1;_�� �CiLi. jf�:Y' vEt':�tiuC 'l.it? c`�.�i:i�.i.f':�ilC.
::'i�,St1�t l�.i�;xk-' . ;it. }a? � . I"-:; f;?<3?i3 Cf7C!Ci'S.ki ::�. , ;',`.Y4 �'':i...i.�=3ntCE' . YT2� {t' x��35 ri)I" ..... ..ar„
rv��• � j
i
�„
;y°,2��.iit�.._ ^:j".l';'CJV:'C� C�'
3'
_'di1�.. i c',te: 'C.�.�..�. .i.L�... . t:�Y�i�� '-'it �rt?C�ft�.'F1��I�
. . .
�^��''�'!
^ � ��E f� '�
`',*.�,'._ - �
�.i
� !YT
+m
i �,�.
��I I � , �
�I � ���'� +�.
��
�
_.__�M, `, �' ��a��:.
���� �
r , � $��;,;
�'�-�iF' '`, . �y zS:;��t
. . . ._+.,.�:� � . ... ,_s�
�
' ' ' ; . /
�� ������
C ITY OF ST. PA U L
DEPARTMENT Of RINAHCE AND MANAOEMENT SERVICEt
il� C�w M� if10!
April 6, 1973
City Clerk
File X132p, page
You are hereby notified that a public hearing will be held in the
Co�ncil Chaanbers of the City Hall and Court House at 10:00 a.m. oa
April 26, 1973 on the application of Michael and Norana Arrigoni
to relax the density requirements on the property described as
follows; Lots 15 and 16, Block 8, Fairchild's and Howard
Rearrangement of Tracy's Out Lota. The property is locaCed at the
Southweet corner of Clarence and York Streets.
For further information, coatact the Planning Board, 421 Wabasha
Street or telephone 298-4151.
To comply with the City Charter, the Department of Finance is
charged with ia£orming you of thia public hearing.
If you have any questiona, it is recoaaaended that you attend this
public hearing to afford you the opportunity to make your views,
both pro and con, known to the City Council.
ROBERT W. TRUDFAU
Director
�; � � b ���5 , o o °� � � �� "�
. a . �, r�, P►� ; o � — ��
� � G � �
•k ` �
p 1 � / O � \ \\ 1 \ ��.'.
• # l/ N�\ \\ 1 % ' ��.-;';:.. .:'�s
/ � O \ �� �y 'N
. '`� /i C \ /� \ '� � �`�
e � � / �. \ ;. /� y 4h _���i�$�i/ ��
� / � � .Y'r�
\ �
\ 1'
� 1 � / �,� � / I ' - r .-1X^ Y ��.y .
/ y Y ••'.`�
� ,. // ! ' . .. ♦ -Y.'� '�- ./�' �
% /� f ���y�R' .'1� �A-`
( � .�- -��-�' '��
1 � ,' \ J � i"�� �' !`� �'
� '� ��� �
� _ _— . _____ - � _ _�-_ � � "---��-- �-�-r'{-��i
� %1 ', \'� I � .. t ..a, �...�.�' � � \\ � , / �
� ` ./' -� :.� � .y.. '� � ' � � � �
� � 1�` � '� �t ' - ; � �'!'s ` � � � �/
I � � " 'r'� �
f/ � { �' f _k .... , . "�
' �,
. % �� - �r� ���` :� �►- � , , �� ;, iI ii�
� � �� ( ��: � X � � � ��� , ,
,
� �� � ,� �-� . � 1;t�-.�.�..k�--� �- �Y� �i ���� � � � �. ,
� �� s f l
^v ",'4� .�"- , �r � ' I \ I � � �
! � � '��- � r' � �� � ��' Q � �� � � � � � �`�
���• `_ J � .\ �/ � \ \ � \,� �1 � \�
/�� . ' I� . '. .. \ \ �/'� 1
� , � : 1 � '�' ' � , / . �� /i \ \. � V� ._
� � 4 i{ / �\�� '� \
�� t`..,� �� �� ����, ���, � � � ���� �'� :� � �� � �y, �
.' a ' � � �
�� rV� � � V �.� � �� ` � � � �� � - - - �as
� �� 0�� V � � ��' � � �
,.��� � �' � 0 �' � -_ �' i� � �." � � �� � �- r - -
— -- ' '� � �\�� �� r� ;� �
� � i � � � 'Ld �� � �\`� � �� �, ,- �.� � � ,. �� �/ v 'i u" ��; � - -- --
� I � � i� , �� � �� '�' �, � -- �
� d� � � � 0 , �� � �
—� �' �� �� �� �'� � i� � ' I � ,q � � �
, , �-�--'�_ '�
) ��/ i� ' , ,T r—�---�—� I
� � �� � � � � ;
- � _ � � ;� '� � � _ �� � ', � —v � � �
� � ' ' �
,�? ; I � , � I `✓ V' '�-- --- I �
�,' ,� �---� ;I ' % ; I ' _---1 � II ! V ; (� �
�� � - ! � ' � G� O � � �f � - v �
� � i � � � � � � �, �
, U „ . �
�
,
� - - --
_ O 1 � � � % , ; � i � I , �/ �/
� � f�'' � 'i_ : ; ; ; � '�. , — � �iu .�✓ -'� V, L- � �
l � � � � ' � � IRi� �
_ � ; �,� , - - - .
� � �, � � -
� f ' i � I � v
�
— \ �1,
�a �
-G- qc� S� Q L L��A T n r--- AV E.
-C� C �iG' I ' r, �� �� ��' C � � ' �� '�� �� �� �
� .� : - --— j � -
, ' ' � % j � ' � V V ! V
� ,
I-- �� � � i � ; � � ,� � �/;�/ `✓�V �: '--�— �
-�- G , ! I i � i '�; LJ.! � r--� ---� �
�--- �- � -�-- - �-�- �L � � �
� � ..� � � �.� � i � � �
_"-r .� C I , � � T � ' �' .� .
� , ! ' '' ' ' i I , i
� \ �� � � � 1 i � ' � ! � ' I � i � �
i -- - a _ J � ; � � .I � � , �
� - � IG � ' p ' � ��G !, � � `�'I �✓;�� � ��; ;vl i
' I e c �; �'' '; , ; � O i7
�e �
�'.
� �� � �' ,S • 2 J" -
.
v � � �' ��? a � O!�' O;'O;OiO O � v �. �����i �' ! O
� � �, I ' �1' �.;�..� � � I � � � � � v � � '
, ' ! �_ � 1- 1 � I I � � ! , ?� i � i I
t
�...---. � -- ��_�i��:.` _ � .�� �� - -a�s-
O � � i, , _.__ i , ;
_ _ � ��� � � � � � � � � e ��� � � ( '
i � � � i ' '_ �
�. . I � � I i 0 i ' �� �
. �;� ' � � � ' , - I-
�REA �i�P
APPLICANT Michael and Norma Arrigoni LEGENO
-- ° ZONING DISTRICT BOUNDARY
PURPOSE Relax Density Requirements
LL�1Ld SUBJECT PROPERTY
� O Oi�IE FAMILY � - -
FILE N0. 74�0
� TWO FAMILY
MULTIPLE FAMILY
DATE March 15, 1973 � �
� � � COMMERCIAL
�'QtE - I"= 200� NORTH � �° �tiOUSTRtAL
�17" PAUL PLANNING BOARD ' V VACANT