The URL can be used to link to this page

261863 � / s�� - 1�Fi17E� � C�I�TY CLERK COUI1C11 � , PINYY"� - FINANCE CANA'RY - DEPARTMENT G TY OF SAINT PAITL BLUE - MAVOR File �0. 2f 1 �� nce Ordinance N 0. 1-`�'��(v Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date An ordinance amending the Zoning Code, Chapters 60 to 64, inclusive, of the Saint Paul Legislative Code, pertaining to Use Districts, Height Districts and Rezoning of certain properties in the City of Saint Paul, as amended. THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN: Section l. That the Zoning Code, Chapters 60 to 64, inclusive, of the Saint Paul Legislative Code, pertaining to Use Districts, Height Districts and Rezoning of certain prop- erties in the City of Saint Paul, as amended, be and the same is hereby further amended so as to rezone the following des- cribed property from "A" Residence District to "C-1" Residence District, to-wit: Lots 1 to 7 inclusive, Block 8, and Lots 1 to 7 inclusive, except portions of Lots 1 to 5 inclusive in railroad right-of-way, 100 feet wide across said Lots 1 to 5, and Lots 20 to 31 inclusive, all in Block 5, all in Morton's Addition to the City of St. Paul; situate on property located on the east side of Westminster between Nebraska and Arlington in the City of Saint Paul. COUIVCILMEN Requested by Department of: Yeas Nays ' x�it�tic Butler Konopatzki [n Favor Levine Meredith Against BY �Roedler Tedesco Mme.President��g $unt Adopted by Council: Date Form Ap roved by City Attorn Certified Passed by Council Secretary BY By Approved by Mayor: Date � Approve y M for Submission to Council By BY � �AHIT� - CITY CLERK PINHr� - FINANCE (jITY OF SAINT PAUL Council 2618�`� CANA�RY -DEPARTMENT File NO. � BLUE -MAYOR Ordin�nce Ordinance N 0. `�� _ Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date 2 Section 2. This ordinance shall take effect and be in force thirty (30) days from and after its passage, approval and publication. �- COUNCILMEIV Requested by Department of: Yeas Nays � Butler onopatzki In Favor Levine Meredith O Against BY � Roedler Tedesco Mme.President � Hunt Adopted by Council: Date AUG 2 9 1973 Form Approved by City Attorney Certif' P ssed by ' Secretar BY By v+r Approve by . Date Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council By BY PUBUSHED � � � �� / �� ___ --�...-.e....._,..._ � b _ � �. CITY OF SAINT PAUL OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY June S, 1973 KENNETH ). FITZPATRICK City Council of the Ci.ty of Saint Paul Re: Petition by Sherman Tnvestment Corporation for rezvning of property in Block 8 and Block 5 , Morton' s Addition. TO THE HONORABLE MEMBERS 0� THE CITY COUNCIL; Tn a letter dated May 2 , 1973, you request advice as to the praposed amendment o£ a rezoning petition pertaining to the above descr�bed matter, It is apparent that the property presently is "A" residential and the petition filed requests a rezoning to "C" residence. At the request of the Planning sta£f the Zoning Board recommended that rather than an amendment to a "C" classification, it should be rezoned to a C-1 classification, This rezoning to a C-1 classification met with the approval of the petitioner and the attorney for the petitioner, You now ask what procedure should be followed so as to present this matter to the City Council so as to canform with the Zoning Board recommendation and the approval of such recommendation by the petitioner. Rather than requiring the petitioner to commence a new acta:on in obtaining a new petition for a rezoning to a C-1 classification, it is our opinion that this petition can stay before tfie Saint Paul City Council in the same £orm that a,t now exists and the City Council has the authority to adopt the recommendation of the Planning Board and to rezone it to a C-1 classification rather than a "C" residence since a C-1 classification is more restrictive. T� the City Council approves the rezoning to a C-1 classi��cation, the minutes of the City Council meeting should so reflect and a proper ordinance would City Hall, Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102 612 223-5121 � City Council of the City of Saint Paul Page Two June 5, 1973 be drafted so as to rezone the property to C-1 classi- fication, Yours truly, ��2.�� Yv�"��.. PIERRE N. REGNTER Assistant City Attorney PNR:cg cc: John E, Daubney, 738 Minnesota Building cc: Roger Ryan, Saint Paul Planning Department , , � r � � � 224-4345 ' JoHN E. DAUBNEY s / -�� ATTORNEY AT LAW 73B MINNESOTA BUIlDIN13 ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA 55101 April 25, 1973 The Honorable The City Council City of Saint Paul Court House St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 Gentlemen an.d Mesdames: Re: N!y File #78�+6 Proposed rezoning of lands described as: Lots 1 to 7, inclusive, Block 8, and Lots 1 to 7 inclusive, except portions of Lots 1 to 5, and Lots 20 to �l inclusive, all in Block 5, Morton�s Addition - north of Nevada and west of .Arkwright Please be advised that the above described lands recent,ly wer� con- sidered by the �,oning Co�nittee of the Planning Board in connection with a proposed application to rezone from A Residence to C Residence, so as to permit the construction of multiple residential units thereon. At the time of the hearing before the Zoning Cormnittee a Staff recommendation was made that the property be rezoned, but to a C-1 classification, rather than a C classification, permitting a lesser number of units to be constructed upon the premises. This reco�nendation was approved by the Planning Commission, and on behalf of the applicant, Sherman Investment Corporation, it is hereby requested that the application be amended so as to request a rezoning from A to C-1 Residence, rather than A to C Residence. An amended plot plan showing the development for a C-1 Residence District is in the process of being completed by the ownerts architect, and will be filed with the Planning Department and the City Clerk shortly. It is my understanding that because a less intensive use is being sought by the applicant that there is no need to again prepare and file a consent petition, because the usage is the same but merely less intensive in character. If there is any question on this matter, please advise, and we will proceed accordingly. Ve tr y(� rs, � JO E. DAUBNEY A torney for Sherman Invest ent Corporation JED:pr cc - Sherman Investment Corporation 1 �-�--� � � � � u c � �G� �� ; _. � �� \ � o I �d!/ EST�ViENT CO �t �ORATION PHONE 224-DO61 251 EAST FIFTH STREET ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA 55101 Jul� n� �973 St . Paul City C�uncil 15 �,+, i�211o�� BonlPvard Caurt �ouse St . Paul, :�IinnesoLa , D�ar• _�:�r:�bers of �n� ��ou:�ci� . z �;o �,�ant to thar�: all of you fer havin� �ee�? so open i"iiiYiu�Ci lri reoar� LO �l�"1� Ti18.�y 1SSU°S L�iB,� Tr;�r'2 �3I'OUgr2'G out a�- both o�por�ents ar�d proponents ir. reo�rd to the zcL�in� for tc:? 82 units in the Arlin�i,on Park area. I d� rernember iv�r, i'�iiley questionino i�ir. B�i� 1`%!cGee as to YJCl°7? 'Gh@ proj°C� WOLilCI o°t 'uTi�°I'bV�?f O1' S'G�.'L't@C�. �'iI'. NicGee ' s c.ii�W2i �1a,S �jv u�.y� . 1 Cct:1'1�C1 lY1T'. IVICGe° LI71s morning ancs quest�oned tne ars;�?er to P�ir. Mile�' s qu�stior.. The 3Q aa�.� i:: his rrird taras the com�lAtion of the dra�yings for tne Ci�y Architect ' s office . I ca:� truthfully say that it Z�.rill �e a rc._�zirr:um o" 90 �0 120 uays . G:��e a�ai.� I 7nT�5t'l. to tna:�k all of ycu for ;��cur vo�� af confider:ce . I assure you �ver. NI� rerd�r�r ��ril1 pe pr�uci o`' it . _, Re.�,p�C v i �r` ` �%`--��"� ,� �-- t�C.4<�� ,-, � �J� � S��er:r�an F, Ru'��c�t �f S P�P�,�s k 1 � � �OARD OF �ZONING CITY OF SAINT PAUL OFFICE OF THE MAYOR CITY PLANNING DEPARTMENT VINCENT M. COUGHLIN ,7une 29, 1973 PLANNING COORDINATOR Mr. Harry E. Marshall �'�'1 p�� City Clerk �� Room 386 City Hall Dear Sir: This is written in response to the petition of the Sherman Inve�tment Company to rezone, from "A" Residence to "C" Residence, property on the east side of Westminster between Nebraska and Arlington. The legal description is attached. The petition was considered by the Board of Zoning at a public hearing on April 19, 1973. The Chairman of the Zoning Board noted that staff had met twice with people in the neighborhood and said staff was prepared to make a professional reco�endation to the Board on the petition and requested staff to do so. Staff gave the planning background for the area within which the property proposed to be rezoned is located, noting that the 1963 Comprehensive Plan proposed single family for almost all of the area, that the Planning Board in early 1969 voted to amend the Plan to include high density residential for the area, but that in late 1969 voted to not modify the Comprehensive Plan pending a public hearing on a development plan which the Board, residents, and property owners had developed, at the request of City Council, during the suIIaner and fall. Staff then gave the zoning background for the area, noting that over the last ten years, on scattered sites, in about a dozen rezoning actions, 24 acres had been rezoned to "C" Residence and 2 acres had been rezoned "C-1" Residence. In September, 1972, the Planning Board adopted a proposed zoning map for the area as part of a comprehensive zoning ordinance for the City, which proposed multiple family for most of the area west of the Soo Line Railroad tracks from Wheelock Parkway to Westminster and west of Arkwright from Nevada to Maryland. As to the rezoning in question, the petitioner requests that three platted parcels of land be rezoned to "C" Residence which, when vacated streets and alleys are included, will result in a parcel with an area of approximately 139,000 square feet. Staff reco�¢nended the land be rezoned for multiple family use. The recent rezonings and street vacations, the proposed develop- ment plans, and the proposed zoning districts of the new zoning ordinance indicated multiple family for the area and these parcels in particular. Since Nevada Avenue had been vacated, the parcel north of vacated Nevada just west of Arkwright cannot be developed for either one or two family use; multiple family is the only feasible residential alternative. The parcel north of vacated Nevada at Westminster adjoins a railroad track embankment and bridge 421 Wabasha, Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102 (612) 298-4151 , � � � ' , - Page 2 - �� 3 and multiple family zoning; multiple zoning is desirable, especially if used for parking. The parcel on Westminster between Nevada and Arlington should be rezoned since the two northerly parcels would be rezoned, existing apart- ments adjoin to the east, and the parcel is proposed for multiple family in the new zoning ordinance. While staff reco�nended the land be rezoned for multiple family, staff believed the land should be zoned "C-1" Residence rather than "C" Residence. The "C-1" Residence will make a better transition between the higher densities to the south and the lower densities to the north by allowing more open space, less building mass and parking area. The "C-1" density will mean less traffic generation. The "C-1" Residence zoning was consistent with the 1969 develop- ment plan and the proposed zoning ordinance. Staff also recamanended that since the apartment development to the south has inadequate parking facilities, a contingency be placed on the rezoning to require that additional parking spaces for the existing apartments be provided on the rezoned site to relieve the inadequate parking situation. (A copy of the entire staff recoBnnendation is enclosed.) The petitioner's attorney stated the petitioner would amend his petition to "C-1" Residence if favorable action was taken by the Board. (Subsequently, petitioner did propose to amend his petition, but the City Attorney's office, in a memo dated June 5, 1973, advised that the petition stay in its present form and the Council has authority to adopt recaamendations of the Zoning Board.) Four opponents objected to the rezoning, stating that a new zoning ordinance is being developed which grandfathers many previous rezonings which were made primarily because one developer received some important rezonings, that there is traffic problems in the area and schools are overcrowded. The Planning Coordinator su�narized from previous neighborhood meetings residents' objections: the area should be developed for one and two family homes; life style of apartment dwellers; traffic generation and congestion; rodent infestation; and installation and removal of no parking signs. After discussing the matter, a motion was made to deny the petition, but failed for a lack of a second. Subsequently, a motion to recom�end "C-1" Residence was made, seconded, and passed by a vote of three for and one against. Very truly yours, �`��',� n - �d�.�.� � PETER J. MAIETTA /�� Secretary, Board of Zoning PJM:RR•mb Zoning File 7471 Back round - Plannin �� g g 863 The 1963 Comprehensive Plan proposed single fs�ily for almost all of the western part of the Wheelock Neighborhood, which is the neighborhood within which the property proposed to be rezoned is located. In early 1969, the Planning Board voted to amend the Plan to include high density residential for the area, in response to a rezoning request. In the spring of 1969, as a result of another proposed rezoning in the area, the City Council directed the Planning Board to draca up a comprehensive development plan for the area. The staff, after working with residents, land owners, and developers, proposed two alternate plans for the area. Plan A �roposed a linear park occupying some of the low lying peat areas and wood slope areas between Arkwright and Westminster Street. The Plan was a "New Concept" residential plan which proposed a variety of housing types -- multiple family, townhouses, modular dwellings, and single family -- and a co�nercial area north of Arlin�ton at Westr�inster. i�ultiple family was to cccupy 19 acres of land and ne�? apartments were to be constructed at a C-1 density. Plan B also proposed a linear park, but the central part, south of Arlington, was f.arther east, on ..ttie land the City recently acquired for a park. The �lan was a traditional development plan and propased multiple family west of �he park, single family east of the park, and comm�ercial north of Arlington a.�_ T'estminster. Multiple family use was to occupy 59 acres of land and new ap;.ttments were to be .:onstructed at a C-1 density. The Planning Board received the Plans in late 1969; it voted to not modify the 1963 Comprehensive Plan until a public hearing was held and appointed a committee to set up hearings. No further action was taken on the matter. ' � . r •. � ,. BACKGROUND - ZONING Over the last ten years on sites scattered through the area, in about a dozen rezoning actions, 24 acres have been rezoned to "C" Residence and 2 acres have been rezoned to "C-1" Residence. One rezoning was withdrawn and one rezoning was denied on land east of the Soo Line tracks at Wheelock Parkway. On all of the rezoned sites, apartments have been constructed or the City Council has approved building permits for apartments. In September, 1972, the Planning Board adopted a new zoning map for the area as part of a comprehensive new zoning ordinance for the City. The Board proposes ipultiple family for most of the area west of the Soo Line Railroad tracks from Wheelock Parkway to Westminster and west of Arkwright from Nevada Avenue to Maryland Avenue. The multiple family area constitutes � 76 acres. I \ In reco�ending the multiple family, the Board recognized the recent multiple family rezcanings in the area. In drawing the line between the multiple family d:�stricts and tne single and two family districts, the railroad tracks, the t_ew park, and the back lot lines of homes facing on Arkwright and Maryland were used. P1an B, previously mentioned, which proposed multiple family for ttge area, was also used as a guide for districting. The areas nearest the freeway iuterchanges and lands already zoned "C" Residence for which building permits were secured were zoned RM-2, medium c�ensity multiple family. RM-2 was placeo nEarest interchanges since it is more efficient and causes least _ conflict to locate the highest traffic generators nearest the transportation .� facilit9e^� °�hich they will be using. An existing apartment site and two . proposed apartment sites -- all south of Cottage Avenue between Mississippi • and Arkwright Streets -- were zoned RM-2, since RM-2 most closely approximated the existing and proposed apartment's densities. Z The areas away from the freeway interchanges and bordering existing low density residential uses were zoned RM-1, low density multiple family. The RM-1 was placed in the interior on vacant land and on land with houses on large lots. The RM-1 district was designed for garden apartments and town- houses on sites where few or no buildings would have to be removed. Lower land investment could support lower densities. The RM-1 was placed next to existing low density residential since this district has the best transitional density for boundaries between apartments and single family. � . . . 3 �,: ' , i .. . . . � � . I . IV�� . .. . 8�� .J THE PROPOSED REZONING The Sherman Investment Company requests that three platted parcels of land be rezoned to "C" Residence. When adjoining vacated streets and alleys are added to the, three platted parcels, the resultant buildable land area will be 139,288 square feet. The developers ' preliminary site plans show 107 dwelling units in three buildings, with some of the parking underground. The new apartments would be integrated with the existing apartment site to the south, sharing parking lot spaces and drives and a recreation facility. The Zoning Board received on April 12, 1973, an amended application for a 129-car parking lot for this existing apartment development. The applicant is James Rutzick. . 4.ry .. . ` . . - . . � . i . , STAFF RECOMMENDATION Staff reco�ends the land be rezoned for multiple family use. The recent rezonings and street vacations, the proposed development plans, and the proposed zoning districts of the new zoning ordinance clearly indicate multiple family for the area and these parcels in particular. Since Nevada Avenue has been vacated, the parcel north of vacated Nevada just west of Arkwright cannot be developed for either one or two family use; multiple family is the only feasible residential alternative. The parcel north of vacated Nevada at Westminster adjoins a railroad track embankment and bridge and multiple family zoning; multiple zoning is desirable, especially if used for parking. The parcel on Westminster between Nevada and Arlington should be rezoned since the two northerly parcels would be .rezoned, existing apartments adjoin to the east, and the parcel is proposed for multiple family in the new zoning ordinance. While staff recommends the land be rezoned for multiple family, staff believes the land should be zoned C-1 residence rather than "C" residence for the reasons below. A C-1 residence density makes a better transition between the higher density to the south and the low density to the north. The lower density of the C-1 district results in more open space, less building mass, and less parking area than C residence; the abrupt change from higher density to lower density can bP modulated more readily by the C-1 district. The C-1 density which allows 82 apartments will mean less traffic is generated � than the developers proposed l0i apartments. While the dif�erence in number �, . of apartments is only 25 for this particular site, this rezoning will set the . pattern for future rezonings. If the entire area is rezoned C residence , , . . � • � .l�'� .�� . . �. '_ �;,�,� , . . . rather than C-1 residence, the increase in traffic will be higher. Staff has observed that the existing apartment development to the south has an inadequate number of parking spaces. The developer should provide additional parking spaces on the proposed site for the existing apartments to relieve this inadequacy. The C-1 density will leave a larger area available for the additional parking. The staff believes Plan B of the 1969 study is still valid as a guide to area development. The Plan's reconnnendation for a park has been carried through to the recent acquisition of land for a park at Arlington and Arkwright. The recommendation for C-1 density should also be followed. The C-1 density is consistent with the proposed zoning ordinance which indicated RM-1 for the area. The developer could construct 82 dwelling units with C-1 zoning. The RM-1 district would permit 82 dwellings if parking is underground and 2/3 of the units are one bedroom apartments and 1/3 of the units are two bedroom apartments. In conclusion, staff reco�ends the land be rezoned for multiple family but to C-1 residerce rather than C residence. A contingency should be placed on the rezoning to require that additional parking spaces for the existing apartments to tt�e south be provided on the site to relieve an existing inadequate parking situation. � , - � Harry E. Marshall Albert B. Olaon �C%ty Clerk and ��TY oF Council Recorder , Commxsioner of Registrattion q`�'�y� a ,a a 261 ,d � �-=�� i 863 �s �� OFFICE OF THE CITX CLERK CITY OF SAINT PAUL BUREAU OF RECORDS 886 CiEy Hall St.Paul,Minnesota 5510$ March 2, 1973 Zoning Board Grace Bldg. ' � 7th and Wabasha Gentlemen: The Council referred to you for recommendation the attached petition of Sherman Investment Co. to rezone Lots 1 to 7 inclusive, Block 8, and Lots 1 to 7 inclusive, except portions of Lots 1 to 5 inclusive in railroad right-of-way 100 feet wide across said Lots 1 to 5, and Lots 20 to 31 inclusive, all in Block 5, all in Morton's Addition to the City of St. Paul. The property is located east of Westminster St. between East Nebraska and East Arlington Aves. Ve truly yours, Qh City Cler � ABO:ml � � � � � � � � MAIi b t9r3 �' �,AN�i11� epA� Z�'�� ,n r,w�, �� 7 F�� o _ . ' � � � � ti . � C ITY OF ST. PA U L DEPARTMENT Of �INANCE AND MANAOEMENT SERVICE= 2618�3 n� c«w M� li10! March 1, 1973 To the Couacil Cit�r o£ St. Paul Gentlemen: I have rechecked tbe attached petition o� Shernan Investment Co., filed in the matter of rezoniag, Lots 1 to 7 inclusiva, Block 8, and Lots 1 to 7 inclusive, except portioas af Lcts 1 to 5 inclnaive ia railroad right- of-way 100 feet wide across said Lots 1 to 5, and Lots 20 to 31 iacl�sive, all in Block 5, all in Mortcn's A,ddition to the City of St. Paul. The praperty is located east eg Westminster Street between East Hebraaka and Eaat Arlington Avenaes, frvm a Class "A" Seaidence District te a Cl�ss "Cp Residence Diatrict, and tiad that said p�tition ia sufficient. Yomrs ver�► truly G��,�c�.,l� � .� � � �� ltobert W. Trndeau - Director Departa�eat of Finaace i Maaageaaent services Se: X1317 c.c. Bnilding Hepartment Zoning Board Robert i�. Tr�deaa Froatage: 97� Parcals �ligible - 46 Parcala �igaed - 34 or 74� �eeded - 31 or 6b-2/3� � � " � � � � � ��'F � g� ,,��"`` � � ' �; �_�� MAR 6 1973 e1T1' ru�rw�yuv� tlUARQ S�tr�t Pault Ml�� , . ' Narry E. Marshall • • Albert B. Olsoa -City Clerk and ' • • , ��TY oF ' � Council Recorder � Commis•ioner of Reg�istration ��:;::s;°°"J 9, . �. � ` � W�, ti�� I � i7 � , i i OFFICE OF THE CITY, CLERK CITY OF SAINT PAUL BUREAU OF RECORDS �v1��3 486 Cit7�Hall St.Paul,Minnesota 55i02 February 27� 1973 Hox. Robert Trudeau Director, Fina,�ce & 1K�iagemeat Serviee� B u i 1 d i a g Dear Sir: Tbe City Council today referred to you for re-check as to suffieiency the attached petition �o rezone I,ots 1 to 7 inclusive� Block 8, Lots 1 to 7 inclusive� E7CCEPT paxts of Lo�s 1 to 5 inclusive in railroad rigk►t-of-w�{y, 100 Peet Wide aeross said Lots 1 to 5 and I,ots �0 to 31 inclusive� al1 in Block 5� N�orton's Addition to the City of Sa3nt P��1� located ad�acent to Soo Line Railroad right-of-�ay on the l�orth side of` Arlington and East of Westaitaster� to "C" Residence District. Ve truly yonrs� - a City Cler � �g f �,��12345�> 'Lo,� � �+, �� ,�Q� o . s, �.�`'0 C.>�Q�°ZV� ti i�l +1^ - �' � � `�'�'� �'�-�� ,�� MAR 6 1973 ` � � FILE � � c:��;MM ��r � ,� •''. . . � „ :' . . . , � , . � � , , � � SOO LINE RAILROAD COMPANY S O O L I N E B U I L D I N G N� MINNEAPOLIS, MINN. 55440 TELEPHONE 332-1281 AREA CODE 612 February 2, 1973 Mr. Harry Marshall Office of the City Clerk Room 386 St. Paul City Ha11 St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 Dear Mr. Marshall: Reference is made to a petition being placed before the authorities of the City of St. Paul by landowners adjacent to our right of way on the North side of Arlington and East of Westmiaister in St. Paul, Minnesota, for rezoning from A Residence to C Residence for the purpose of constructing garages and additional parking facilities for apartments. It is my understanding the lands involved are described in the petition as follows; Lots 1 to 7 inclusive, Block8. Lots 1 to 7 inclusive, EXCEPT parts of Lots 1 to 5 inclusive in railroad right of way, 100 feet wide across said Lots 1 to 5 and Lots 20 to 31 inclusive a11 in B1oc 5, Morton's Addition to the City of St. Paul. We have declined to be a party to the petition in question with respect to our right of way because we believe that it is out of order for the Railroad Company to be a party to anq petition for rezoning lands adjoining such operating right of way. �The S00 LINE is neither for or against the proposal and has no objection to this matter being brought to hearing.' Yours �1 , � •� '.�L�`�----� eo. T. Ber en Director o Real Estate GTB:lb �� yE � ��, �� c, � �� _�� MAR 61973 c :� � �� -� � `��' . . , , CI�Y Y1.ANNING �30ARl� ,• ° , S�int Pau1.Mienesota , , - ' • . . , � . , � � C ITY OF ST. PA u � 2618�� . DEPAfiTMENT OF RINANCE AND MANAOEMENT SERVICES i�a c«M+ Hew. ss�os Febrnarq 16, 1973 To the Ccra�cil Citq of St. Pattl 6entlemen: I have checked the attached petition of Sherman Iaveste�eat �o. , filed ia the matter of rezoaiag, Lots 1 to 7 iaclnsive, Block 8, and Lots 1 to 7 inclusive, eucept portiu�s of Lots 1 to 5, and I.ots 20 to 31 iaclusive, all in Block 5, all in Mortoa's A,ddition to the City of St. Panl. The prop�rty is located east of iiest�inster Street between East Nebraska a�sd Bast Arliagton Aveauea, from a Class "A" ftssidence to a �lass "C" Resideace District, and fiad that said petition is iasufficient. Youra very truly, ��-/�:�..�'?� 8obert W. Trudesu - Director Depar t f F aance i� Managa�ent Services � Re: % 1317 c.c. Btiilding Depart�ent Zoaiag Board Robert Si. Tradean Frontage: 0 Parcels Bligible - 46 Parcela Signed - 27 or 58.7� Needed - 31 or 66-2/3� � � . � � UU � � � � � � � -- MAR 61973 �� '�� CiTY PIANAtING BOARD, a�..� :: � � � �_, �� .E ..2 seMt Paul.Minnesota � - - � 2�'18 �� i�ZAiUTES OF 't'fa.� PiJi3f_IC NLe�2Ii3t; 3EFt)KE Z`HE BOl�RIJ Ol� Zt�?�TP�G �r? �.;:�U"S;iF,Y, A�'RTL 1�3, 1�73, AT 2:0� Po?�to �'�;�?Si:NZ': i�ime�: Cr�c.i�•r.�rae; F:essrs�. B�ns�nof, �?ci'art�.in and I�Iaie�:t� of �:he �oaXd; _M..�.� M;..> Ra�eF:ter ait.ci �9r:,� � uarriaul� of the Sta�f, SI?�i�i�74irT tt�`�T�,S��ff'DI�' CC:MPti�Y �;14?l�: A �etition ta rezc�iae from "A" �tesidence to `�^," itesi.dence �;coj��.:'�y �.t�C£;:a'�f� t3ri ��1t? EBSt Sl.ve Qf i�L�S�1Il?.TiSCf'Y' i�P_f:G:'een Nebr.ask.a an� Arli��g�tat�:. �Zra� Cochrar_L said ��ha�: t:he �t:�Ff had afLended meeti.ngs wit� the Feop7.e i� the neig�zbo�°hood i:xyinr i:� E~e.sc�lve thi_s p�:oblemo She s�id tt�e stafi is preparad �:o tLe'ii° �,i:S O�TT! pIC)�'�SS��ZLZ2�. Y:a?Cd�t}Gitt�:3�1Ct1 OTL tE1J.:3 41��:tE'� �O �f1E �£3�i3`C'T, anci S�1@ as1:ed Li�at tf�ey ra�t:e �i�cir ,_evcmmendation� ��ir . i3.pan sc�mma�izeci che ;��ar.�l�.ng l�acic�;round, the zoning b�ckgrou:�<.i,, .^,nd des:.�rl.hed �rie prop�sed szt� foz tlir �:�:'�uing�, H� said tae staf� recom�nend�d �:ta�t Lhe 1Gnd l�e rezon�d i:nr �ui�i.�al� i.3C:i1.Iys but Y:o "C-1" Resi.dence rather �han "C'� Residenceo �i2 a�:�o said ��a ;:oni.s.t�t�cilcy s:�eul�i b� placed an the r.ezunxng to i-r qui�.� tt�at addi- �iat2a? park3.n; spaces for Cf�e �cY��f�i.n�; apsrtments to the sn+zth b� ��:�viu�d an the s�_te tc relieve �n c:x3..si,.n� f.n��cJ�c�uate parkzng s;tu,�Ci.c�r.z.. i�x� .7ohx� Daubn�y� rr,;�«senf-.at�Q �Y�e ap,��icani;, s�ac�d th�� th� ,s�an fi��_�ci at t`:�s icin�e {s a plaz� for "C" Re�a.denLial developrlt�nt , F�e .zaid �ti:�, IZi+�zick_ =;ou�d �ril@ri+Ci Ei1S c'iz5��.:!C3C2GT! ii'�JGI ra�ci LO �tC,�� esi.dence, �_f �AVt3.:t1�"1a� �i:°:.1U;1 �S `.u�SP_?3.a tt:t�rei>y rec?ucin„ i:l?e �.�c�;�h::��• a� +�n?ts tta 82�� )-i: ��so sai.�l taat i�' l��'��dC �vtinue i.s ��acated, z.t ;,:nu1d ac;� � ,,ubst:�nti�al n�amber o� pax�Kix�� spac�s t�+ t�he plar.�. He said tEta� tne rF�-i.sed ;��.an c��ul� hav� � sin�;Ie b�zi?di.n� "n tt�;� zobrtY ::;d� ��ri.th �p}�ro.{�r,�a�c�?y 4f� Lo !,2 ,;.�iLs; �nci one bi��_�.clin� �n �he we�ti ;=ide ar3jac��fi to �?estm�.nsrer TN,�a��.-; rt_.:,r�:�r. ;s !��.annec�. He t:Y��n �resentec] s�me I.et�ers from a�ccu�r��i:s of �h� N4:�.�:;;��it:�:, .ZQ�.srtment:s. IIe saic? ttiey :�x:uld £i.7e �� amv�tcic�ci apglicatinr_ +:aitti iizt. Cit.y i��.e?-�c cti�ho zc�s o�r.i b:�t,r�lt cf LEie Cit.y Ca�..nci2r asking �t:�at t�ie tset.fti.on �e :..�rti�n.��d �rom :rf" ca 'FC��." ;esider_ce� iis . R�berz "r'erder:e�° sr:�d ti�a� � necv z�t4�nr o�_ainance is bein�; devel.o�ed �hat CR�S3tl�.t� 'i�iiP.p�,f c1'u^i?CiEiLt':i�T.' kZ2 c3 i.CZ'L Of C}13L?�C'S LA8C�4' �TI't1Ttc?13.�1' �C?Ca9i15C? O:iG devel.��s�ex c�ras aL-1� to ��c�ieve so�c *_•�-<.oazn�s of sa:�e inipr�rta�it p�-ope?-t�y� �Ie saica there ti3V2 't)C?t?i.3 c'1(�C�3.i:':.�I?u�2.. :Cc:,^Oi:�.Sl��:� ?3i:�r_'C1 LipOFt �ll'dt: OI1C. ?'EZ0111I1��, TjE? Si73.tj t:�?8� �@�OYE' �E�t? Yl('•, zOL3�TI� �iG�1t1i�13C; CJa:':7. t2s�S c9 IlENK3.it� �'fiF'Cr 3r� 8��i�y !?f'.2iF�:O5J1T!�' ttlE cniY�e�t of 9_�, and �re t��.al.;.z�ing che progo�e� ordinazxcP 'aefore i'rte Y�ibli.c has a ctrance t6 r'E'c'`.t�� i:C Lt, C�QICDF_�' C�lE.'}' il�ll%4? 1:��E?t? ?�f1C:lr"3Z r7C`�'!021 O?1 3.�:; �C'_ ��E't2 TEc7tj 3 CO�j� U� c'3 L@�L:f`t �?-C.' C�'t7LF �(3 �'icyiJ:t �',UileII l.ld Ci/(l:�C.�'! �lE' SUilCi�C'!i tttS Blt�j70e:�, ��2 :iB�CJ �IF? �1'd'C� 1'�'Cel.V�G I'i() :�E?u�i()�?u�'�. �zE' t:l1$L? �'r.�<ilC2C SOP.tE? qUZSC�..^.i25 �:��: ''�:Ftt-' 1ik�?:"Cj re�;ard;f_r.g the l�3�o�c�:_>s�.. �:rs� Pa�: Na��y. �SSI 'rJes;�r�inste,:; 4azr' tnat e}:�� r�Iiic i.s a �sr�I,t.�cu i:z i:i_1e �ves: Szae al�a said ��ZSf. .l''Il.�;il.951�3�7a_ S�:ilLiOl. `_3 �?rea�y ��rrer�cr.owded axzU f7otaldn`t be ��l.e tn har!�;Ie inore W;�:1=s�_�:�„ c�i;. : ,�onn A�sey� !+u5 £as�: Mor��nv. :�a�ci t(zat ra�z�y caz� iror,t th� �x'?_st.in�; �ap�rf:�.nent �c:Yk C3i1 C(If_ ;.;�tE;?':. zT?ii .G.[t�`i4TAC5., i>E�C&t23� O� c't �S..EC.:�C C?f �7x'OPCi; �:+�?i'ELitl�; E�ct.lities,. 3�l.or.1: t`:n ii7-e 1?.yd>.�y�:ta aa i�h�• si_:�eei He �shed fioa: �lic ecct:pa�icy' r:��e �x t_Iie �rese��t: r�par.tmen;.s � anci w�3s �c�?u �.:%6 ��ct of 119 saere uccupies3. I - � ; :'f�.:'-�:�' _�..Zt��,e:i�r:tc�.a;c t:;v.:�- z:��Tr - :PG 7e � -..__ ., . _ . . _.- - -____. _,.._.._ .i, - :�I;=. �nrp�rei Uett:I_�, i3o�.`� r;z±_°�- Streety JCiI� she dic�n't trust th.e �Idn;�, �uhit:h w•ere ;t;_�ser:�er'. Sh� �a�.�i c<iey :��,dn`� rOJ.ii3<,red ti�e �l�.�s before. She sr�id sfie �.��ulc� 1 z't� c:; see tE�:� �rc<� ;_�.r��:i�� res>;.eer,t ia? „ �nc: s�id a IIC'F7 part� in t'�� axe� c��a!fld b� a draea�r� car�:l fa: tte;: ur;arE:t_teiaz;; „ ?•?.�.., Co��gLli�� s!�.�cra��;.�E�c! sc�°;��,� o� L-he objQCtic�ns of the residenis � S�tre af t��zem �se�-r,e: �'��t Li�� z��:�:a:i.tti_��f; <:��s aF�.ssu�=�] i7e deve�.apeu fQr one An� ��a� far�.i.ly �iaraes, ].?7 ��1:•?i"i:. .3-`.3 C?L�z� G:i��i�C�EE:.2(.-.S� �i`.t �:i..:�E.' Stv�E.' iif �E'iC p2Q��.C-' l.il �ro��.ar��s:ertu� 1:Y'r��1C „��?tv-'�ted b;a �i�r- d=.-u,.ilr�;r;z�_��i� s�r�<<1d br>_ iar�e; evideil::e flf congestion t;eca�se flf ay�--st_�:�� ;;3rtcirz�; u �,�_c�;'s_�:r, c,;ith ,~odent i.nfestati.on... He aaso s�id E�� hzc3 hearv Z:lc�r i2U k3t�Li>7.T14 c.#.`T;.iS 13,;�'•� +>t?C?ti 1i23s:a^�.Z�'tj and .4L'tE reiz!c��ved withi.n Ott2 C;�J„ `.l�2E' � _, i-UT?.� �.-�LE�' :it'^SZ'.c;:lc"`tt! �� 11J-� �l:�Czi� l�(� I�ir� �'ekd�r�>.r, sa9.d ��:�L 1-f.> i.�ard onc. �),I�gatia:� �:-here a resident i_n�f.ca°,-e:i �:izat i>?�:C�_TYf; 6S�,S ;20�: rit-��.::':;:;cl,:��',� 2 �TO'�JjC-i:l �E'C8l1.SC L:iIP_� CQli�.d parl� 1�;i�1?�'C t�:E'y ;d�32C'I4T1: :-�pposed L-a ar.c? coc�3.d tu�:�� L,�rk9_n� t�_r.�ceCs receive.d over �a ti�e cJw�ier of ,.:ne t�i��.ldin�� i':T": Xyc�`L•."CE)7 sc�7.G GF2;.S Lvci::: `'i;?� c3i1 8'�F�.T.cation fCS� 'd pE�$"ITIt�,� �(l�� i'.i[1S�. l:(3:^iC' U8Cli tr= �_i�i;; ,�ca-:_d +=c,:- t-�� t�ark��g .l�c �app;:avalz sa the 3e��d does z-�tain c•:�r.,,.��1 uvcr rhE ��k�icf_.,.g 1;s�: ri,rj,�: �-,�� `:h��_z sur�una;�iaed �tie traf€ic situat;an :=��;a�d;_�;; access ..�:ct� Ebrc".SS '�.E' 1i�.Si� ff.^1'.<i t;� c'i.: �[7�Ye a:t: 8?X ctii3.dren OF $C�700�. :�? ;..'d �I.lt: E'X7.S.�".7.t1�� :?��8�'�[P.t'1ii:5 "t.'i�!11�' FYCi�d� !"fE �:CLs?f?�.:�12 :,`c':L�.� 'G:7�� 57:t?.:�:: �S"1�E.' c�:'S1?LP.^t� ttle (}03�.�lOtl Of L��.2Y1'��::r; `.'.C'�:':�'�71.'�i��:tyi.' t'sf'. r%.:�3C.� :7ttc.:+.� �'n/f: C1"��...Cq.ii'... .I�?" 't c(:c3tf 6�J'u�S CY.J'IL'tb t:U r' t:�` f f�. ��El%_ . z, .L S� � ` . i.C, �il:y ., � � ` i i" < a8 i_�"i?S: ��"4E' 4t ar'j: j'aT �; arr:? ��. > i?�z YJF1S r�c�l.itica�Ly �TZt�IiL�.�,3!_G'u LYl t^:3�;'t k1;? ii:a_f:7�YfP.�?Ylct;l± i.f?t�a 3 l�ut saici tt ey ttsual;.y ciara°�: r��i:e rr_c_or,�e�endati�+€as, �iiP secoraci �tias t��at t}�e nlannin� c;4cisfo�i:, c� :Fintiin�-s c:.ere p�tcn:�� a.a i�:r��zt�.on doc,rneoi.n ��i�:hu�,� any nex�hbori�a�.t ;n.,, <- -t_. � 's'i.ey ii�ve 3�ee:� ��v�.ra:,� z� fi�;,Ite t�� cont�.oversial �c�PS �,�t ro t-i�� c�ef?hha�h�ad„ Th�v are urtrr�;�ti:�` Co �.:-� *hc �e�t p�OF@SS101ta�l 'itl(SYRSCRC nf tiie staff„ 1''�+'S,> C�t�C[?3'�Y.� .�.��:i�j ' i�,'i: �:1;.: .°�i�ry _.�'-� .�ti:.:£;:iTI+LC1i�2C?_O!'t 1S i0-_ r�L'..i� �?;ti:: ! � _ . �en::r� . anci ��4��1 'CiiC_ �O 'r,ll'.�.��_ :.��"_' <:%:�= i:i'Y �(. ��,':'C� : F:. , . „ . • i..?. , ilt:�G'L�F3 S33.G ��,-, �.Jil,l!'.� ;:i_r' `t .. . ., -rr,:� -•,. � r�� . • N � . t.. �-�. t_a „ .�^_Ce-rnf�i�.L1$�-:�QP 'v'.� , il� � :il�.ili ' � ` if:{� '`"�1 ..�':f,�'['e: £i2U:�� j.�'.:`.x. cfr? ..:.�:Gz�_ .��i;U_ . _L. C� ?"[1S�7s°.C'�;,Cl71 �£3i }?c._c�:_FF� tif'!;j , ��b.3C�.L9.. 4L�:. ., 17��::.:i3.i�.�7_ a�4�!(� .. `.+..'��,�i. ... C�'� "'T � � � . _ _. z _ l)'. GYl:' �,l.liti[It�JS G�1. �iZe? _ e� .._.. c;'.i;ti.ai..?.i)t24 t�?E ��nQr�� E?.��.�il:'�:�t�,� ..`It_ 7�`.�: � . �J:£C:L. {7� �iii:: . 3" `3 � G c es iiU _ � t1 e:7��,i:12 u:_:1 � y� �� C''a2�:.�; C)'.'�.` ��iE •:7Y°u a>li� :Jf '��'e�: �!!1(:j 1"t r.7_;:ti' Q] ;>Z' . }�ElL2� ;, `1�f1L' tt?7i:.'_f�£1 f�i:�".� �r3k' �.a:::� G'f � 5f'CO11Cl- �°il � L�is:�E'.�:�� aiJ� 'i� � ��. _ �ci�rt4 ?'f.i�' .- �tr� es: _ �t�.��: ,� :. .. o��«.�:i�d�ri.�.i �,� �--�_ suh�,,::i °.c Lt�,e '�3p�.'+�C3i1� f�-Cv-+:1*7!� `t �t?t_? �t�?i=ii Gtt� .:��.:T' �C} �t.�'? t�l�? S)r.Y�C�.i•_t� �''.t�I, St:k=`_Ci. :lT'i��EC�ICt1 raS_ ,:l"iv ._.'..t�i5��'Dxi:_ _'S �1:f71;i 'l�?� .i�'1ci:'';;t ' 'i{i � rF T Ilt,'i:i.. �'+'c'.i. ii �Il IC.' ��•:1l°.I'tQS iLi2", i,i�1�Y2 ,.d7_d i[i81� _._ . i 't�i'i.3:' i'c?(.3*?a2f'i2r�c'It�'LL�T: trJ�� 4��C %:�'t.E �.lc�'?'?;1; �7� �:iC;'�c?3F:".� G�^. �,:k?� �3u::'�C_,i24'_, Jt. , _. .b'.� �.i�..� l;',_ 7'P�..°'Jz''�� .��_�T. ;i:ti1l?!.i'; 'L�C'. � '�tar,� _J } Ts7� i �� i - , - �1�I_7_G. :L:,' , ?`��&;_��te2 �t�:�:"_,,.. _3 _;3c. :':.��7.�t?t �.t�nL.?r3 ��t:�i i:�3P ��r,. r , tV a " ' � c sa...i.��i ir r:as J.y no,iti.cai..: "�'t3-L" II1b��C1S'�. e�r,l'n _i;ri . � ,'4 .. �_!,? �;%� .1 i:i', _ . G71 L`il i'�� . l:�t?Li.g�l'J(5:� �!<;2:1i2� Fit 3'ti.4]�`� i.r, I ., . �� ao�c� cs —+ `� � �. �.r�''� -�r� � ��<� � , , � �� -s i� � � � ,� i�l F. �w Il ��y� �k�' � t0 �OfA;t � I�I � i �.;;; s879� fihs. oi re , t. 1h+F. �- ) �, ^ J City Clerk . ' �� CITY OF ST. PAUL ��,� � DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE AND MANAGEMENT SERVICE$ ASSESSMENT DIVISION 113 CITY HALL ST.PAUL,MINNESOTA 55102 June 27, 1973 F11e 1C1317, lage C�GTED NOTICE You are hereby notiffed tlut a public heariag aill be held in the CouACil Chapibers of the City Hall aod Court Iiouse st 10:00 a.m. oa July 5, 1973 oa the petitioa of Shetmaa Iavestmeat Ccmpaay to rezoae fro�o an "A" Besiderce District to a "�-1" Resideace District - should read from "A" Reaidence Diatrict to s "C" Besidence Distr�ct - the property described as folla►a: I.ots 1 to T iaclusive, Block 8, aad Lots 1 to 7 inclusive, except postioaa of Lots 1 to 5 inclusive, 1n railroad right-of-way� 100 feet �ide scross said Lots 1 to S, aad Lots 2� to 31,inclusive, 8!1 in Block S, a!1 i� Mortoa'a Additioa to the Citq of St. Paul. The Zoaiag Board recoiomeadation to the City Couacil will be based oa C-1 Resideace District use, as the same was heard before the 2oaiag and Planaing Bossd. The property is located East af Wea qatsistex Street betweea 8ast Nebrask: sad East ArlingCon Avenues. For further intonsation, contact th� Planning Soard, 421 Xabasha Stseet, or telephone 298-4151. To cemply with the City Charter, the Departa�eat of Fiaance is charged with iaformfag you of thia public heariag. If you have any quegtions, it is recoa�neaded that yau attend this public hearis�g to afford you the opportunity to make your viet�s, both pro and coa, knaon to ehe City Couacil. ROBE�T W. TAUDBAtT Diractor , - ` , . . : . . . . � SOO LINE RAILROAD COMPANY S O O L I N E B U I L D 1 N G N� MINNEAPOLIS, MINN. 55440 TELEPHONE 332-1261 AREA CODE 612 February 2, 1973 Mr. Sherman Rutzick 251 East Fifth Street St. Paul, Minnesota 55101 Dear Mr. Rutzick: In line with our conversation of February 1, 1973, I am forwarding herewith in duplicate a signed letter addressed to the city with respect to your proposal to rezone lands adjacent to our right of way in the vicinity of Arlington and Westminister in St. Paul, which was the subject of my letter to you January 17, 1973. Yours truly, �.� ��_�, �.� � � � � Geo. T. Bergren Director of Real Estate GTB:lb Enclosure U� �� („��g MAR 61973 �G ��L E �,�� Ci i Y ru�rNiNG b�IARD. -- Saint �aul,Minnesota i - � . . . � . ' � , . , � . . f SOO LINE RAILROAD COMPANY �� S O O L I N E B U I L D I N G l�N� MINNEAPOLIS, MINN. 55440 � `� TELEPHONE 332-1261 AREA CODE 612 February 2, 1973 Mr. Harry Marshall Office of the City Clerk Rootn 386 St. Paul City Hall St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 Dear Mr. Marshall: Reference is made to a petition being placed before the authorities of the City of St. Paul by landowners and adjacent to our right of way on the North side of Arlington and East of Westminister in St. Paul, Minnesota, for rezoning from A residence to C Residence for the purpose of constructing garages and additional parking facilities for apartments. It is my understanding the lands involved are described in the petition as follows: Lots 1 to 7 inclusive, Block 8. Lots 1 to 7 inclusive, EXCEPT parts of Lots 1 to 5 inclusive in railroad right of way, 100 feet wide across said Lots 1 to 5 and Lots 20 to 31 inclusive all in Block 5, Morton's Addition to the City of St. Paul. We have declined to be a party to the petition in question with respect to our right of way because we believe that it is out of order for the Railroad Company to be a party to any petition for rezoning lands adjoining such operating right of way. The S00 LINE is neither for or against the proposal and has no objection to this matter being brought to hearing. Yours �y, i ,;�- ;-�'" , �' -G �'r,/ �. ( � Geo. . Ber�"en Director of Real Estate GTB:lb � � �� r� � ll � f�l 7 MAR 6 1913 ��11�G ...FILE_� ctlY Nu�ir�li�ir� ��pNO _�..___._._._._:---- _ Saiti! Peut� Minnesota . . � � � ' � - SOO �INE RAILROAD COMPANY . � 5�8�'� S O O L I N E B U I L D 1 N G INE MINNEAPOLIS, MINN. 55440 TELEPHONE 332- 128I AREA CODE 612 February 2, 1973 Mr. Harry Marshall Office of the City Clerk Roam 386 St. Paul City Hall St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 Dear Mr. Marshall: Reference is made to a petition being placed before the authorities of the City of St. Paul by landowners and adjacent to our right of way on the North side of Arlington and East of Westminister in St. Paul, Minnesota, for rezoning from A residence to C Residence for the purpose of constructing garages and additional parking facilities for apartments. It is my understanding the lands involved are described in the petition as follows: Lots 1 to 7 inclusive, Block 8. Lots 1 to 7 • inclusive, EXCEPT parts of Lots 1 to 5 inclusive in railroad right of way, 100 feet wide across said Lots 1 to 5 and Lots 20 to 31 inclusive all in Block 5, Morton's Additiou to the City of St. Paul. We have declined to be a party to the petition in question with respect to our right of way because we believe that it is out of order for the Railroad Company to be a party to any petition for rezoning lands adjoining such operating right of way. The S00 LINE is neither for or against the proposal and has no objection to this ma�ter being brought to hearing. Yours .�r�Iy,� � . ,;,j t � �Ll %�i-v , Geo. . Berg,�en Director of�Real Estate GTB:lb � ��r��r`�- l� l� l� lt � U � �l -`_ _ ;�� I,� � MAR 61973 CITY i�I.A�NInG �UARD SafM Paul, Minnesota >r__- ,- _ ._ . . . . + re.,... _ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .;.^j�9,�E: BO�RD OF Z01�'�NG REPORT AND ACTION A�ril 19, 1973 _ � Acting under Legislative Code Chapter 60 thru 64 Plat Map ��32 passed August 22, 1922, as amended to January 27, 1971. t�C� : ' ,�V 8�3 �4�� 1. APPLICANT'S NAME . Sherman Investment �ompany 2. CLASSIFICATION . � Amendment � Appeal � PermiC � Other 3. PURPOSE . Rezone from "A" Residence to "C" Residence 4. LOCATION , East side of Westminster between Nebraska and Arlington 5. LEGAL DESCRIPTION : See File 6. PRESENT ZONING: "A" Residence 7 . PURSUANT TO Zoning Code Chapter: 64 Section: .06 Paragraph: 8, STAFF INVESTIGATION & REPORT: Date: April 11, 1973 By: PLR A. SUFFICIENCY: In a letter dated March 1, 1973, the Department of Finance and Management Services declared the petition sufficient with the owners of 34, or 74% of the 46 eligible parcels having signed. B. HISTORY: There is no zoning history for this site. C. PROPOSED USE: The proposed use is that of multi-family dwelling units. D. FRONTAGE AND AREA: The site has a frontage of 589.48 feet along Nevada Avenue, 423.86 feet along Westminster, and 127.12 feet along Arkwright, for a total area of 128,137.31 sq. ft. exclusive of adjoining streets and alleys. E. AREA ZON?NG: A "C" Residential district adjoins the property to the south. The rest of the area north of Arlington and east of the railroad tracks is "�" Residential. Northwest of the railroad tracks are Light Industrial and "C-? ', "C" and "A" Residential districts. F, c�"!'Z� �ONDIT?ONS: The site is vacant. Portions of it are lower than street grade while other portions are at street grade or higher. G. AREA �AidD`TIONS: An aoartment development exists south of the subject site. Single family homes and vacant land exist east and north of the site. arlingtc�n Avenue is an east-west through street existing one block south. Westminster is a north-south through street adjoining to the west. Railroad tracks elevated on a grade run r.orth-west of the site. 9. B01RD ACTION: To Recommend ; � �lpproval � � Denial Council Letter "C-1" Residence zoning Dated: Yeas Nays June 29, 1973 29oved 'oy Maietta • Benshoof X X McPartlin Date of ` . Seconded by: McPartlin . .X Maietta Hearing: _ _ X Cochrane July 5, 1973 Secretary's remarks: � � Counci Action: . Date: � - � - ___ � �� . �� '� � �_ "�, �' � � � �� , i � � ;� ,� � � I �� p�,a�; �� ° y � _�.� ; k. ' �� A. p'�ti� � � � , City Clerk ,,, - - � CITY OF ST. PAUL DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE AND MANAGEMENT SERVICES �,(a� ASSESSMENT DIVISION L�� 113 CITY HALL ST.PAUL,MINNESOTA 55102 � June 22, 1973 gile X131�, Page You are herebq notified that a public hearinQ will be lt�ld ia the Council Chambere of the City 8a11 and Court House at 10;00 a.m. on July 5, 1973 on the petition of Sherman investmeat Company to re�ore fran an "A" Residence Dist�ict to a "C-1" Reeidence Diatrict the property deacribed as follows: LoCs 1 to 7 1aclusive, Block 8, sad Lots 1 �0 7 inclusiVe, ixcept portiona of Lots 1 to S iaclusive in rai2road right-of-way, 100 feet wide across said Lots 1 to S, aad J.ots �0 to 31 inclusive, all fa Biock 5, all in Mortaa'• Addition to the City of 5t. pavl. The property i� located Eaat of Westminster S treet betaeea BasC Nebraska and Eaat Ar2iagton Avet�ues. For furehar information, cantact ttee Planning 8oard, 421 Wabas'ha Street, or telephone 298-4151. To comply with the City Charter, the Deparcmert of Finaace is charged with informfng you of this public heariag. If you have any que:tions, it is recommended thst you attend th�,s pub2ic heariag to afford you the opportunity to aiake qour vieas, both pro aad con, kncwn to the City Council. aos�rr w. r�uD�av Director ��3 CITY OF SAINT PAUL OFFICE OF THE CITY ADMINISTRATOR FRANK D. MARZITELLI August 7, 1973 T0: Mayor Lawrence D. Cohe �1� � FR: Frank D. Marzitelli RE: Zoning Code Amendment on property located on east side of Westminster between Nebraska and Arlington I have reviewed the above referenced matter and am in agreement with ` same. Your approval and submission to the City Council for action will be appreciated. FDM/ca Attach. ' City Hall, Saint Paul, Minnesota 55�02 O 1�ay 2� 1973 Mr. Kenneth Fitzpatrick City Attorney Attention: P+Ir. Regnier Deax Sir: The City Council referreci to you for advice and report the attached letter oP Mr. John Daubney, Attorney for Sh�rman Investment Corporation, requesting that a pendin� petition to rezone property in Block 8 and Block 5, Morton's Addition be amended to request a C-1 classiPication rather than a C Residence classiPication. • Very truly yours, City Clerk .»I - 1 � .' ' " � �. � ' • , . CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA • • . . ` PETITION TO AMEND CHAPTERS 60 thru 64 OF THE LEGISLATIVE (ZONING) CODE . Note: The signer should appraise himself of the uses permitted under the new classi- fication before signing this petition. For further information about the rezoning of property, call the Board of Zoning Office at 223-4151. (Please type or print) Date: TO THE HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL 2618 f3 c/o the City Clerk, Room 386 City Hall City of Saint Paul, Minnesota Pursuant to Section 64.06 af the Legislative Code, we, the undersigned owners of two-thirds of the several descriptions of real estate situated within 100 feet of the real estate affected, hereby acquiesce; and we, the owners of 50%, or more of the f rontage to be reclassified, petition your Honorable Body to rezone the follow- ing described property: (legal description and street address) Lots 1 to 7 inclusive, Block 8. Lots 1 to 7 inclusive, EXCEPT parta of Lots 1 to 5 inelusive in railroad right of tray, 100 feet wide across said Lots 1 to 5 and Lots 20 to 31 inclusive all in Bloc 5, Morton's Addition to the City of St. Paul. from A District to C District, for the purpose of installing, constructing and/or operating the following: (describe briefly the proposed facility) RECORD OWNER SIGNATURE IAT BLOCK ADDITION Subject Property; � [��'�e '� �/ � .�°' Adjoi ing So Line Right of Way The S00 LINE is neither or or against the proposal and has no objection to this matter bein brou ht to hearin and signs the petiti n w th that understandin . Morto 's Addi ion Sherman Investment Co. Lats 2 3 4 6 7 20 21 22 23 24 25,26,27,28,2 ,30 and 31,B1k 5 -, ,, ;' '� State a � Co ey ( �' " , being first duly sworn, deposes and states that he is the per w circ la ed the within petition consisting of pages• ► that the parties describ above are the owners respectively of the lots placed immediately following each name; that this petition was signed. by each of said owners in the presence of this affiant, and that the signatures above are the true and correct signatures of each and all of the parties so described. Subscribed and sworn to before me � I � � th s ��day of � " , y�a Address; =a ��v Telephone No. �3�.-/�L/� :•„:::,:: Y;, • Approved as to form 1/4/65 FGI 1/5/6 �'��'` �AMES d. �FRACY Office of the Corporation Counsel �► NOTARY PU6t1C— MiNNF�OTA � HENf�(EPtN COUNTY • A4yr Commission Ezpires Oct.6,1�978 � {�► � � g (� � � , �y u u - ,= , MAR � 1973 �"�� : J� � C111( hi.n�u�yM n�ta� °— • � �� . ', • • ` CITY OF SAINT' PAUL, MINNESOTA ��VC:� f�/ p . O ' • '. + +', PETITION TO AMEND CHAPTERS 60 thru 64 OF THE LEGISLATIVE (ZONING) CODE ��Q . Note: The signer should appraise himself of the uses permitted under the new classi- �, fication before signing this petition. For further information about the rezoning of property, call the Board of Zoning Office at 223-4151. (Please type or print) Date; Nov. , 19'72 TO THE HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL /, c/o the City Clerk, Room 386 City Hall �W City of Saint Paul, Minnesota ' e( Pursuant to Section 64.06 of the Legislative Code, we, the undersigned owners of two-thirds of the several descriptions of real estate situated within 100 feet of the real estate affected, hereby acquiesce; and we, the owners of 50%, or more of the f rontage to be reclassified, petition your Honorable Body to rezone the follow- ing described property: (legal description and street address) Lots 1 to 7 inclusive, Block 8, and Lots 1 to 7 inclusive, except por�.ons of Lots 1 to 5 inclusive in railroad right-of- way 100 feet wide across said Lots 1 to 5, and Lots 20 to 31 inclusive, all in Block 5, all in Morton's Addition to the City of St. Paul. �/ from A Residence District to C Residence District, for the purpose of installing, constructing and/or operating the following: (describe briefly the proposed facility) for purposes of constructing garages and additional parking facilities for apartments on the North side of Arlington, east of Westminster RECORD OWNER SIGNATURE LOT BLOCK ADDITION Subject Property; ✓1. Robert H. S rei 1 `� � 15 21 Dawson's Lake Como & '✓ Dolores M. Spreigl G:-�tr� - Paul n Avenu Add. to City of St. �2. Robert H. Spreigl - � 16 & 7 21 Dawson's Lake Como & a venue Add. to Cit of St. Paul ✓ Dolores M. S rei 1 ;�c��p � ( N. 10 ft. of lley adj. vacated & 3• � „ Lot l B1. 1, Strubs Addn. to the 1 ax . nc City f St. ul � tte 4. � Freeman L. Holden �,,,,�� 1 & 2 Newell's Add. to the - ✓ Ida H. Holden ,(��.��% City of St. Paul - - ,�- � � Newell's Add. to the 5. Shirley Ann Horrigan ': `��i' it of St. Pa,ul 6 " � % • Newell's Add. to the , n o i an � 5 't o t aul � Jose h W. Horri a,n „ ( Ex• r ilroad; Lots 30 and 31, B1. 4, 7 P g orton s Addn. to the Cit of St. Paul � Vera S. Horrigan ( $ Wisconsin Central Rwy Co Lots ,3,�+,5, ,7,8,9,10,30 & 31, __ 1 ots 2 �+ & Bl. , Morton�'s Addition lying 'thin strip 00 ft. in width being feet on either side o Cente line St. Paul & St. Croix Falls Ry. Co. State of Minnesota ( � County of Ramsey ( SS ' .�" �. �`llys�.� K. ��2� c�� g Y � P � bein first dul sworn de oses and states that he is the person who circulated the;within petition consisting of fj pages• � that the parties described above are the owners respectively of the lots placed immediately following each name; that this petition was signed by each of said owners in the presence of this affiant, and that the signatures above are the true and correct signatures of each and all of 'the parties so described. Subscribed and sworn to before me P this '2�• � day of �-f�j j �j�3 �Z� � �� . �� /�ii�,7fH4, Address; ,��,� Telephone No. '�ZN -� °� � Notar Public, �ey County, Minn. My commission expires /Ofj�7,S Approved as to form 1/4/65 Office of the Corporation Counsel FGI 1/5/65 g � � V Lia � � Ly � ��v� �� i « .��'�.� !� .___ _ MAR 61973 ' CITY PIANNING BOARD. S�int Pauf, Minnesota : . - . - � � : �. � � �� 261863 � • � ' � � ' � CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA r , . ' . � PETITION TO AMEND CHAPTER.S 60 thru 64 OF THE LEGISLATIVE (ZONING) CODE � Note: The signer shoulc3 appraise himself of the uses permitted under the new classi- fication before signing this petition. For further information about the rezoning of property, call the Board of Zoning Office at 223-4151. (Please type or print) Date; Nov. , 1972 TO THE HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL c/o the City Clerk, Room 386 City Hall City of Saint Paul, Minnesota Pursuant to Section 64.06 of the Legislative Code, we, the undersigned owners of two-thirds of the several descriptions of real estate situated within 100 feet of the real estate affected, hereby acquiesce; and we, the owners of 50%, or more of the f rontage to be reclassified, petition your Honorable Body to rezone the follow- ing described property: (legal description and street address)Lots 1 to 7 inclusive� Block 8, and Lots 1 to 7 inclusive, except portions of Lot 1 to 5 inclusive in railroad right- of-way 100 feet wide across said Lots 1 to 5, and Lots 20 to 31 inclusive, all in Block 5, all in Morton's Addition to the City of St. Paul. from A Residence District to C Residence District, for the purpose of installing, constructing and/or operating the following: (describe briefly the proposed facility) for purposes of constructin.g garages and additional parking facilities for apartments on the North side of Arlington, east of Westminster. RECORD OWNER 15T�NATURIti LOT BLOCK ADDITION 9 Subject Property: A 100 ft rai oad right-ofpway run � M 1s.St.Pau1 S. Ste By; etwee arts of Dawson's Lake Marie Ry Como Phale Ave. Addition to the 'nn. & St bs Addi ion to the City of St. . 29, Range 22 10. Joseph W. Horrigan $ . 5 Morton's Addition to e i y o . aul Vera S. Horrigan 11. Joseph W. Horrigan 9 5 Morton's Addition to Vera S. Horrigan the Citycg' St. Paul , 12. Joseph W. Horrigan 10 5 Morton's Addition to Vera S. Horrigan the City of St. Paul 13. Joseph W. Horrigan 11 5 Mortonis Addition to Vera S. Horrigan the City of St. Paul 1�+. Joseph W. Horrigan �bj to sew r easement; 5 Morton s Addition to Vera S. Horrigan. the City of St. Paul State of Minnesota ( County of Ramsey � ss ��,py„��(, /CuZzic� being first duly sworn, deposes and states that he is the person who circulated the within petition consisting of �j pages• , that the parties described above are the owners respectively of the lots placed immediately following each name; that this petition was signed by each of said owners in the presence of this affiant, and that the signatures above are the true and correct signatures of each and all of the parties so described. Subscribed and sworn tQ b fore me ,� r-�I ,�, �Z � this 2�� day of �� 9']3 25 � L�, �v4 i •�a,� �y��.c.. Address; ..,,,, Telephone No. ZZy.O��o( Not ry Public, County, Minn. My commission expires ��.,,,� Approved as to form 1/4/65 FGI 1/5/65 k Office of the Corporation Counsel ' � � �� ;1 �� - M�R � 1973 �, � CI Y r+•+�ti�;�►irV twARQ �alnR P_pu4,Minrwsota . ��r/�� i�� A �.� '� , . �- �� :_,< �:,� ..�. #_�;� , � .. � . .. . .r �e��.,.. 'r,'�y+ ,�i�..+'��,,,��c�� 'y�c� 'f�c��'� wr '�4 - . f ��"� .:,.� �` , � ,��9.7'�1 a • �:�t �. �{.� � . . . � ' �� . .: :j 1'�� .� �„�, t. '�h:� � � ��s� + -43'Y`' ,� 0. � ... � .t . . i' . � -: �.. .` .�. �� ' - . � _O�I1�f ,.IEtA� '�SUS.��IO XTI�. • :�� •-` °`� '��` ��'_ . �. r ; � ' _ �_� 4.�,, � , l�Q00 {�rl�txKO►��',8�'Z",fJ138i:I�I ffiiT,'�i3 t►a'u�tdt Os� 8AS'1"4�1� tD� � K�tT�'I�4 -. � , ;• , �� .. r ; ' ` --�i�sla �NC4 a�i3 :3a4cw bnt�lrxsq �sa►i srl�r '�� Itie�d •st+�rtqq�f bt�aa�efs �ea�ts �r�°T �, tat� f � _ �eli 1sro�R rad2��eeKoTn2 zfd?��,� �ca� .o�ti�tyt9sq a�td�:yt2aa2a ert42�c! aer2�a��'� ; � � � ,,l�tl-�! �s s�2l�0 gaYaaT ko btso8 �d? ,ltRa,,��q�q �r �a.tt�� n � '�°� ' _. . . . :'. . •Y�� , . . {y f: . . . � . .. ,�.- . : .. i:. t 'd . . . � . . � . . . ��.A�� ZX..:�� $��{ � ' {��, . t- . � ;. �� .�, ��` �iA3`i� . . ,. , ' . ' _ t . .Ilt".�lUGO YTI� iMl! i10l11dt �.I�iIflAiOfi.° _ � __ N . , !,. . . lt�bt .��3`'J �+B �c�ti1[, R�x+tt� i�t.�� . , +��a C .; :... . �. . . . . � � - . . _. . , . . . . .. . . �. � - s �3oa�ra�li �So+e� ��,ka�� i� �l . ,.: .. . . . :. � . . '. . . .': • .�. ��k � . ... . '' .. ,.. . . - , .', j ,,... �Q ��Z�O Y9N��K�4liQ ;��It `� ��OJVW ��D�j�i.a�ii �� PM�R��M�� + �� Q , . '" �o ,=`#�s2 04l t�t�4�trr �s�l�u,�2s a►i�r#�+� �a��x �o �e�o��u�E�so�b�`��rrs�ee� �d� 2�i a�if �oN►� 3' � .Yb s�a� zo �'t1� 20 ��aert�ro �c�� r �a� ,soa�t,�p�s �c6��d ;tr��'��a ets�ya. �' �rl3 � " , *�w�lo! l�Q�`saosa�z o��r�bog;,e►ld��a��H �c�+r+� ao2��f�q ,1�►22k�s��r� +�ci oJ �t� ed� , M �;. ,. � ,, , �ilM�j�R� �'�'Ort��[, .��ra �s�a°�� s ao.�Sq2�capeb .C�ps!) itS'��qcng b�t�sa get2 � ;. ;' �t :��t#��`�st.w�"t at �.#�t 'ta � �OUa� $�� T +aw� �t. s�a►t� �,�:� s, ,�a� a� �tt�K at.�i1► ��ia�+twt-: � at dR � MNI : �rR t �o�t �►.�M � �r�r � Oat �•'� �.� : . -.� . , .� .t3 '15► t#x? � at ao�t# *�'+±1'!wM � ; r ,� �!��os. ,i�2x?��'�°� �' � . . o� ��t�t��.�Q� , _ .. , � . ,. ��li�M� AF, a�ai'� , .,. ' :8n�.�`�! Rsd� �tltgsq zn�btx� �{n�i'��c?a.�+�a ��,Il��Al.:! ,� ±oq�tusj'�` �� t.. �= ,� �"�li ilt�t�� '�� I� '7i0�(�?A.t2�s't b��toq�q,..sel�3 �!lC3�kxd si� �tlseb� s . � �'.�'R�:'!�r �Ol� � �d,4 �r0 �t ��;�L�t�4 �tl�, ��i T� . � , . , � �� '= ,-�_ _ . . :. ,.-„,, � . � �;_� � . ;�,_„ -. 'R ` . = x � :. _ . �► si�► s�c►�e raa�`�a,,� K xxu�is ` �niro oa , ., � �"`�ot��2�6J1'�'s�no�lt : . �., .. . , , . ;: � , . �_� ��t�� t�aua �- � =� E.. '. t .�t y. � . Ir� +I�t idl� _ . . , . �o'-�toi� � .� �. `'*� �t � ¢O�t dt�t�i21l�A tt�dt'ldI' k t,, , . '�r + .`F . . �'" - . � '.3� . �' - ., �� `.. �i'�t �� + VK � � �,� ice�. . �•'�k!k i �'1r...� Y � i t',� �' � t. . .. � } � . . . .. _ .� �� .. �� ,4�t � +�;0� � � � � ;�Q� �``°� ��j: �' ^i� .�; ,.�-s r��' � � Y�:li �' ° tp "� rn i�t �,��s :..3iM ♦ u � _ , � i" `t,; ��""{ '.1', �y,�' � �'� " �Qiil�' +�' %' ��t�.�. �: Y iF'M_ ��3 '4 `�`Y�1�� `� ., . �. '�! ,:1 iv `e FS � . ��'.!Rf. � • .c.�� ; �s`. a,� .�� >• .,.�,,.� ,� �� ,�'..' a� �.i" �.�.. �r � : � . �/ ._: �,r'�J �"Ga".:y�a v .�, 'ti s '�%� . � . �,..^'-.. �w:. :-y,f!!!9 �.� x � +�, K�gp � e'� � c��'$ 'T�r; ,a +�a• ,'� �/ ,�d . ,r . . , . ,�. . �.'. ' ' � { �1�� :.�.3 ��+' �x��!��-� � �re��: ... ,. . �it i� ..�. :�� .s�, E:: ., � , . _ —.i� � . - .�i�� ... . .. � . .... .. R _ . ti , �� -4�'J' t1Q�.'1'2t1!l�A► e - �! � � m N ^ b ' • . . �: . . _ ..�� . ps� �f ��} �'.E�,J,:� '�O ��r�'� . ,, a '�� b,,�,r.. .e . � .� •� ii/Ri3 . � - ' .. .. . � . . � . . .�i'aol�snM � � 20 .S'� . .,�, at32 � oT �: ,:f 3 :...i �,r�� .... . �. . - � • '. � � ��'f"J�i�'�' .+�'�I. °�U� �'�- •O� tI0 1� �i � � �� ,�� "r l� .. ;:: �� . : K \�t ... ' . � � . . � . . .. � _ �� _ .��' p�. ; ''��_.� .: ° � �1o�e 2a a3R7� � t� � " ',� �„ �� Ot�� i O 1��C�N4C,� . �� -f� ��'r '! � � �,, :� +re ?�d�..�� ::.�rsaoq�b .cexc�+a�ee �luA �as,t! �e2sd . - h � . S�sir� . • � ;!o `�a3��.t�.�oa ao�t3#trQ ao�d?Yw, �d1 b�►la�ttoYg� �dw, , : i��t`�.i ` � �^ � a��q a o : , �o �lwti�eq�e�x �sawo �= er=R +�vod�i l�dtias+�� "e�t� +� #�d� � �4 �� . :._� -��wF �s► ;easo �a -b.a8:. �.w� ;��o��ar��a�r t,��i ,a.�u ao�e �.�ottd��. �,��e.:�� , .� ��'. ; i�str�?��?t�,�svs�dA .�rsu3�a�.� +�l� �a�4� �►ct� t�c��2!!s alet? 34 rs�aa��rq �tt� t sYS,wira '� � ° ,� br�fl�q±n►b' pe a�tizsq erd� 3c �.is �ts �da�+� !o a��j,t�;; - �c� �+� ' � T',:. � t � .. ,:: . . . „ . .� . � 9 �,+J ! e+� �� r '' � ,cr��":.� a.'�K��,"fir�A�.y� � ��i�Y . '�f'��S �� '-J�i�� t �'��1.`, � ' ._. . , . .�,��E � l�..��r1.• .��'. �i�.t -. JJV �Oi/ � . ..� .e:�. �' ` . . ' , . . . y �: ��x.'� .�'.��'� �sa��$� g �i � �j* �`�x { •��tt+Dl�Q��Y� , ��R� .. � � e t.SEY.� E�{�'lliliD.�. �9� '1� : • , f . � : ' ,m � �'. � < ;��bVM0�3 0�. 'aA bsva�qqA . ,. ,. • ��►�a�t � �� Y�! � � .. ,_ •,; . �;;. � � �� ,� Q wd�:�tb '0a#2'3C) ,....�.. : '' , �iitldtuOCa'tto��' � �\��,d '3:� �.� ' �a, � ��<. - � . . ;; �J . r .� � � , y�{ � :. �};� . � �� :� � ��'�� - s � , . [{' ,_ ' , 5 _ � . . .... � ., . .. ��„ . . '1i/ ��.�� . . - .,- . ..t�. ,`� ��'�`-a�.. , } �} n � 1" ;. ,vJ� 's,. ' ., -�� .� � �� ' ` �� ;�. .S, , �,� �� -;:� r�.. xt • '�� , .� � � �. E. 1 ' �. � � • w �� =� ac�� . , . -.w= � . . . � . . 2618�3 . . CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA ' � ' ' � � PETITION TO AMEND CHAPTERS 60 thru 64 OF THE LEGISLATIVE (ZONING) CODE � Note: The signer should appraise himself of the uses permitted under the new classi- fication before signing this petition. For further information about the rezoning of property, call the Board of Zoning Office at 223-4151. (Please type or print) Date; Nov. , 1972 TO THE HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL . c/o the City Clerk, Room 386 City Hall City •of Saint Paul, Minnesota Pursuant to Section 64.06 of the Legislative Code, we, the undersigned owners of two-thirds of the several descriptions of real estate situated within 100 feet of the real estate affected, hereby acquiesce; and we, the owners of 50% or more of the frontage to be reclassified, petition your Honorable Body to rezone the follow- ing described property; (legal description and street address) Lots 1 to 7.inclusive Block 8, and Lots 1 to 7 inclusive, except portions of Lot 1 to 5 inclusive in rallrtq,d rig�it- of-way 100 feet wide across said Lots 1 to 5, and Lots 20 to 31 inclusive, all in Block 5, all in �_ �;,o��n's Addition to the City of St. Pau1. from A Residence District to C Residence District, for the purpose of installing, constructing and/or operating t�he following: (describe briefly the proposed facility) for purposes of constructing garages and additional parking facilities for apartments on the North side of I�% Arlington, east of Westminster. RECORD OWNER SIGNATURE LOT BLOCK ADDITION Subject Property; W. 1 ft. of t 29� and all of Lot 30 2�.. B1. 6 Morto 's Addition to the Patricia J. Malone � City f St. ul . - ��,.� Morton's Addition to 25. Shirle Ann Horrigan ' 1 & 2 7 the City of St. Paul �. o ve. & Easemen s; vacated �26. Sherman Investment Co or tion alley betwee & Lot ��, B1. 8 or o s i ion o i y o t.Paul �27. Sherman Investment Co ora ion Sub'. to Ave Easements• v cated ey e ee o , . , orton's Addit on to ity of St. Paul ubj. to A�e Ea ements• va ated ,,28 Sherman Investment Corpor tion By• ley betwee & t 10 • ul ✓29. Sherma,n Investment Corpor t . to Ave. & Easements; v8acated etween & Lot 11 B1. o s A d. to City o t. aul r30 an estment Cor ora i b ' o Ave. Easements• vacated lley between & Lot 1 , Bl. , Morto 's Add. to Cit of St. Paul �. o ve. asemen s; vacated �31 Sherman Investment Corpora i 11 l�etween Lot 13 Block 8 u � o Ave. a em s• vaca ea ✓32 Sherman Investment Corpora ion e gtw & Lo . �� 1 k �u7� � 33 Sherman Investment Co ora ion a ey tetween & Lot 15, B�ock ,e �P to s Addn to it of St. Pau1 ve. s m s• va a ed � 3�+. Sherman Investment Corpora io a� �y e ween & �o� g�'� �1. �, 0 o s ddn to it of t. Paul State of Minnesota ( County of Ramsey � ss ��(� p�� , f�UTZ� cI� being first duly sworn, deposes and states that he is the person who circulated the within petition consisting of �j pages• r that the parties described above are the owners respectively of the lots placed immediately following each name; that this petition was signed by each of said owners in the presence of this affiant, and that the signatures above are the true and correct signatures of each and all of the parties so described. Subscribed and sworn to�e�ore me this Z�c� day of �< <'� , �S 7� 2�l C�, 5 �,�'`� . �. l a�.1 �.�,,;� . Address; � Telephone No. Z Zy_V� (o ( Nota Public, R�y County, Minn. My commission expires � o�� Approved as to form 1/4/65 Office of the Corporation Counsel FGI 1/5/65 r �� _ - ��I.E ��.�- - � .� �� O��NG _..y,�._..�•�'r MAR 6 1973 `��.� i r � �.,►,,,,��v� avNRQ ,,. �aiM P+�ul�Mint�esota � � J .: .- �� - � �. � - . � _ . - ,�61 " , , - .' � • � CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA 8[�� t �� ' ` ' � PETITION TO AMEND CHAPTERS 60 thru 64 OF THE LEGISLATIVE (ZONING) CODE . Note: The signer should appraise himself of the uses permitted under the new classi- fication before signing this petition. For further information about the rezoning of property, call the Board of Zoning Office at 223-4151. (Please type or print) Date; Nov. , 1972 TO THE HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL c/o the City Clerk, Room 386 City Hall City of Saint Paul, Minnesota Pursuant to Section 64.06 of the Legislative Code, we, the undersigned owners of two-thirds of the several descriptions of real estate situated within 100 feet of the real estate affected, hereby acquiesce; and we, the owners of 50qo or more of the f rontage to be reclassified, petition your Honorable Body to rezone the follow- ing described property; (legal description and street address) Lots 1 to 7 inclusive, Block 8, and Lots 1 to 7 inclusive, except portions of Lot 1 to 5 inclusive in railroad right- of way 100 feet wide across said Lots 1 to 5, and Lots 20 t0 31 inclusive, all in Block 5, all in Mort��nts Addition to the City of St. Paul. from A. Residence District to C. Residence District, for the purpose of installing, constructing and/or operating the following; ' (describe briefly the proposed facility) for purposes of constructing garages and additional parking facilities for apartments on orth side of Arlington, east of Westminster. RECORD OWNER SIGN BIACK ADDITION Subject Property: . ve. asemen s• va ed ✓ 35• Sherman Investment Corpor io ey �etween � Lot 1 , �1. � o it of t. Paul u �. o ve. asem�n s• v cated ✓ �6 She n Investment Cor ora 'o lley etween 8c Lot lt5 B�. � paul . Subj. o Ave. & Easements• v cated ley etween & Lot 1 , B�. � � 37 She man In.vestment Cor ora 'o r • • Paul Subj.b �WAve. & ots oentlocva ated ✓38 S o a • • . Paul u ve. asemen s vac ed ' -- tween Lo�o31'tB3ofk t�' Paul �39 Sherman Investment Cor ora ' � / lle`� tween Lote2eri Biockc� ed 40 Sherman Investment Corpor t' � y � ' ' Paul Steven Rutzick and James ot 7, Blk 8, Morton's Ad� utz c State of Minnesota ( County of ftamsey � ss ��4^��a.�,._ �` ' �u�L� c�l being first duly sworn, deposes and states that he is the person who circulated the within petition consisting of �j pages; that the parties described above are the owners respectively of the lots placed immediately following each name; that this petition was signed by each of said owners in the presence of this affiant, and that the signatures above are the true and correct signatures of each and all of the parties so described. Subscribed and sworn to before me ,p this Z� a day of �� /�J73 ZS1 �. �j�-C� .�'�, �Z./o�,� �c•,4�. Address; /,�.o.,,,. , Telephone No. L �-r-I-Q O(o! Notary Public, R�a+�sep County, Minn. My commission expires Approved as to form 1/4/65 Office of the Corporation Counsel FGI 1/5/65 ,(p ;- � � � �i�'11� ;f � � _ - MAR 6 1913 ,� : �I I Y r�n,,,�►�ru ��ARD. .-• -�--�-�� -�q� Saint Paui� Minnesota �- �� ';. c. � " ��;� �� `W� � ' ..f� -:t .-.r� . � � . . � I .. ' L .�, r t t��l +A .,t F` r"�y+�. �i i �F"� 7�,~ � �r, � i�'�' y,,_� .� .� I / 1 ; � 't''-� .�' � ��, 4� c� � s Y � ..M�� '-� Y l � I. �._�i.....�.1.—_.�a+a .^ ' ��+'M_'��'��-�� r � � � ' � . . •�--'�T ��\ �y. 1 • y,,. " _ _ — - � � • �'� � .. , �l� �..� �.1 �. . x ,� N, .I � _ - -.,--. ---- :+— G..-.. . •� � , . -......T. --�- h _ _'__ I � 1 •+ } x,`R �C � s - . ' '� Pr• I '�i t fw � ti . . � �' .�� . . . aS . .� � �U I ��•.. - - „ ,�� .. . � v� ,._. � znC� � � ;�3/ � .�ci . � . '/ � 26 ?.3 ��, �3 � 2/ 2Cn ' 30 22 � - �' ` _�o -:..-.,�.""'._. � i � , g � �. !. �� __ ; ; / � � . `L - ti� �7 i �� .,' ' I ' � -�� _�� / t .:� �—_-� > _ � __ �-G �� , �lo.a3 � �o.7a�//O �o`.�_!•7'%'l(�.:'...� •-- -_. 1 . _ �� k �� , y .: _ , o tio � � � ��/vT�N.�I � A � . �� . ' • �. � _ . ' I ace�-�--e'�-"� A�9s.tt �_�_ � ;r ., w r/_G �lo.n/ � �tO.C, �-'-_� • yp,� � Nc�—�� ' . ' i � �_ I � f ; j � ° zF � .. , � ... ( � • � I . ( r . i ' � � � � �� ' i I • .: . � � .. i w,� i"-'•`..`!� . . . � { � . '�; �9 '.� �: �, 2 / � .. . ��/�� // /r � /3 �'7'�. ./5 /6: /7, t'8 j /9 i - / � � � � i _ �� .. � ... � , � � , ' .� ..� � ' ' � � t i � . �- I ._ :_ _ -�- -�-- -.. . .._—._1___� � i- , ; . , - -- ,' •- t�r� } I I`_�'• - � • �'_"� -- ----- .� .�' . . . .. . _-�- �T-. __ _�� -� . � -;- ' � � ( � � � � ' w � ... ' 1 . .� i ' I � ' . � 1 ,� , , � .�. i . ' .. _.. �' ' •. � . • � f. .. . . ( � � ' ' ' �S � ��f + �3 2�� / � ?n � "�F i .3�i � � � _ -- �:�� - �6 *.�._.��. � c i - - - - i � 3 n I 2� ; c�3 �7 ; � ! � . ' j . : ��` i � j ( •'I ; � � i i . � N - "- - - - , + � ' I � ' I , . .,.� ' � . , � � '1 .,.. 1 ',. . , 3 .f 4 - _ � � - i �4U 3�.8fi � ��'/.5�-� I � �"i - . . Kl. ��F1' U I- � I � R�- ... .... ! f' �- �' , . � _..._ � ��, � ; - -_. �°�l�.��4�� - , � �• 3�.�6� -40 - „ -T ,. -.;,. , „ � ' 4o a9.s ��.—�� ;. . ' ' � ' ! . i ..!_—�� . ' ' i � ' . • � I�-�� . �""_ _- / �� _ + � � �,�- �n' ? S�'i.-.�cy }.. ` : ' i - _ I N., p � � �/r i �! � �- � � � r � � . ..�� '_ � 1 9Cp � �� ...; �25:p�, - � . I 1\."� . � .r � � � �' ��'�('Y��ll .� ! �`�� '�e � . � � / � �� : � � i �:�8� � '�� ! i o �I i/ , /2 ; i3 � i� i.s i i� . �7 ; /8 � , � � — (n, � � ``� f �� ' � - - - . ( ,� � ` _.;..� � � - � Z i � - �O 4' . . � � � { � f •' �-' � � ...�, `I I �' =, , � i i , : Y , ; y � � .. •, . i ' r ��,� ' � �3;+Sc 8 !. .ay-, � � . `o � , � --- - � - ; . � � i � � -1--- � �._ ---J _ _ , _ --- --. -- -� , , �� .� -- � ---_ �. _-_� --_.-- _ _ .------ , --- . . - - . - -- ,- � _ --—— - 'T-- ��- . . ~ � : � ; . . `� _ _ ; � _ _ I� -- ! � I �� .�� ; a � , , . �: � .. . , � _ � � � � � , � _ � 1 . ,. � � � . ' � / ( 30 2 � � 28 � ?7.� 26 ' �.5 .?4 , �?3 � 2�°' 2/ � �� , � 3� � � . ;�;3 9 E '� ` �rT /' I ._ �. — � : ��. � � � � - � . . ... .. • l t, �`,l .- , . . . /Cr R4�� ,�yv� [+p, ,.; � -"a.. "t`- � � � � s' ti s�icr�lr, � , ,� j �� >' ( ' � � '. , �C ° : �_ � .,' _�'�Fp -a9 � �39_.! � //C 1'� 4U 3` /d •ZsRf' �� i .�__.. • : , . � r---�- , _ `�'� — 1 � sd.39� -- - . ,�. � tYy..` ,, � . � . . � + �1a �CQ . .� ti'� Ryr " V{._.e'i . , r � � "i . . . ��'��...- E . �.* �' � .. �i . ,_ r r� ,..'�� // ar o'� ��i2//7� G°if Z.'f777� : . � --- � .� ,..� . . - a�.�.� Iat• e 2 t�� -�: - � , � �,- -T - � �,4o s9.�2 i r��; �..3 4� ti �i o 3 y 7 2 �t a_, v� �.t ��r i �P�!� �" �r f.�s/� � . / �r i ' �� . 1� �C�.M A'7_ �� /f�}Q L , I :� � - " . �. �'� J � TYf✓• �N �"� 1 'i i � �+ •i - i� �� ' , nYr• s� ' . 1 � ' I I � �,� c� � ti 8 9 /v %%, ��. � � f�`` /��:` / 8 /� n, s � , t. r ' � -I f• � f �f.;� , ' �: ' . ,` �r �,�, ,' � � � �=;. t � ....... r . � ;d � .� , � r � ' � ' ' ti ,�9.b6} �. • -- .:' ni ��dG� �y ��a_' � ; � � ,� v a c• ,� � .` _.�-.�`� V�u� .� ,.�� Z%bG. T � �t �" �/ �''''� . •� } � 'I` I ,,/ �s �Y r ' ' •:\;i'` - �. , S !�. 9' 'J� i I � (,� l�-C� �' � a r` �..""" ' f ' �. ar � , :... . ` ,,• ••,. �', , , � < � `�� ` � - �/ � 3j ,3r.r 2� �8' r 7 � 26 �?.s j 2�� ,��,'• ��> zf`; �o� , � ; 3� i.: r� N � �ji . m�' . N � .... � ; � � � ` � ' ` i-� 'i �.�.� . . Y M � r � � � i . 1 � q� s:i `._' . �: ; � m � , � ' . r r � , o� �.� � . I . � � �`` ,,,, .R3. ,`.�' �U 39•6'. * �id 39,� 4 , . '�ff` 30�� '�/./U 3.�:,�°.�� _" � ..1__,,—� '_ -j, . ,r� F ` ' r, ,+f'yr�,� i. .�_ r.�lo.c c6��7.7. � . _ � ` ' � ' � �' N .w �,- � �.y�ay }�l� '' " 1�..�K 1 �� r t . � ' �. ''.' �r`� '• � �' »,x , ;� ,�, �'��J�r� r t. ':;cr .�:�. � f m � x '` � T �\� QN r...�--^ L�' Y 4.�34_�"�. �_ j 1� '� i. . : . i � t � �....�,^r .g .� . 1. v •- � . if t�� .; � ... .�r � � '� :.. . .� '�, J : � . . , a�. . � �.. ! ,il '(' � . �. M�F , � _,�t-�f� �AU L�� p •��' } � ;� � '�'�� : . � ...-.]:- _ C ��^+..^""� ��4 �-.��'t,.. ^r ..Y�/� � �� . I t5 t r � . I � :n . .� '� ,'.� �. . f .�l i � S � + x� �� '}�� t -��+ �.. � .n i �'� C �,� �� ( t' �; .�. ,�r t �' s- � 'L.r� .�;�. �'. r`'�'��,' � :� � , i " � �, : _ __. � va�� ' � • . . ��•" ,�d,y�cd� � ,c�c �A MI�� ' , - >: � ' ! i—�= � � � � - � � � 1�._!= � � 4�� , T �� '� Q�/�. , ' ; � < � � , � � I � i� I �1 � _ ��/� ;,, I ! � � � � � , ��,, � � � ;�v, ; G, < uvv' � �' v � uvv � 0 �; iO�. m _ _ I I `� ' < �� v � I 't � � I � :_ -- ? • 1 i � _ � ' _, I _ � < � i � �t-1 � QA,� � �'/ � ' .'� � I � � � ' � ' � "� VVVV �/ v i , � I �. (r. � IVi i � �..� ► � � � . : . � o�o� a � � i° c ,Z�i , ; � , � ! -- - -- - -� . --�Q� E . � � , � ; � , , � i i � � � , - � � � :� ; i � � ' I �, � � I I I I I _ � i i I I � i I � vl v � ! � I 35, _ , , _35 � _�_ !-' -� � - � - - i -� � � � i: j i i i i --- - i -- �rF � ' I I . � � � � i i i , i , � � � �� v �� v �v v � v � ,v o, i35 i i 1 ,5 ' � , �� V/ � � � i � T ��-1------ --- � �_ N�'��3 �II A��. � - ►-1- � ; � - -T -� I -0 ; I i I � � � � � I I � � ; ; �.' � Q O 'O, I Q � , � �� U V V'V v�v � ��v � u � v I I i � , ; � - i �_ � � � i � ; ' _1_ 1_ _� _1_ ' - -- I I T T __ :::. ; � � - - � � 1 I _— _ v L I , � ► � O O�G v � � � � / - -- Y i! - t ' R9 �Q- -l-�-� - T. - r-; K �; � i i � i >�?�� i i � � ��'�✓ � U V V V V V �/ �/ V �/ I V �/ V �i �' V V V I i � i i i - �w � � � , ,�s=.-.;r--- i < — _��_ -- — — -- I _ : 47 .� � _ �y4 �, c �� , !�y I j ` I � , b , VV �/ VVV V''� S/.VVVViV r•� I � � �+ . a 4 _ � 1 � I � I i � .. � t _- -�,._.�. .,��:: - _- -- - - _.:�- r �;` � _ : ' � � � ' � . ; � � ; f -, �/ f:. K, � �_ � ::;.� , � _�"��' "' � v � � 0 , V �/i�/ � V �� > . �. �"�y � .� +•�--� - � � y `� - I � 1 1 !� i - . . . `4 p��yi V . . f;�:i ' - � �" �`' a v _ (Q, � 0 �-,��; ,--� . `' _.��_. - -S��v�,�� 4� , �, „ -. �. �' � , L_ Q � � � � VVV� � � � . � � ;v, i � � . � � � r-� � -+-��_ _ � � . - _ -t -y-r -1 .1__� � -- , i � � i - • ; i i . � I � �'' _� i i _ ,v; , V �;V V ; _,� , � � �,-� � � � - - � , � q i ,- Q . �4 � i i I +—-F�- L. � �� . Ci 0�� - -- - � � � � .a � .� ^ A�EA MAP APPLICANT Sherman Investment Company LEGEND — ° ZONING DISTRICT BOUNDARY � SUBJECT PROPERTY PURPOSE Rezone from "A" Residence to O ONE FAMILY "C" Residence FILE N0. 7471 ¢ TWO FAMILY MULTIPLE FAMILY DATE April 19, 1973 � � • ♦ n COMINERCIAL. SCALE = I"= 200� NpR7H ♦ r� �NDUSTRIAL SAINT PAUI. Pl.ANNING 80ARD V VACANT �� 2E�% .L�.�,.�.,..�..� ?�2�2 �,�2� 3�°a ��22 r*idtc�pt�a ��..`._ -r - � Ye� Na� BUTL�;R KOIu�PAT��J: �� 2618s3 �� Ra�� . � TmES:o � �e p�sxv�r (�,�r) . _. • , � ` ROLL CALL FOR JULY 1973 �� 3 Yeas Nays KONOPATZKI LEVINE MEREDITH � � TEDESCO '� �PRESIDEAIT (�� THURSDAY FEBRUARY S M T W T F S ' 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13.14 15 16 17 FEB, 197,3 1�'19 20 21 22 23 24 25 �6�27 28� - � �.��` ��G�� , %� � �- ��"`". � � �� , � ��.. � � /3�7� ,��.�� , �/..� .�.� ��.l� Gi .�,�� -- . . �� 53 - THURSDAY, FEB. 22 - 312 FRIDAY ` J A N IJ A R Y M A R C H S M T W T F S S M T W T F S 1 2 3 4 5 6 1 2 3 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 11 12 13 14 I5 16 17 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 28 29 30 31 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 FEB. 1973� • ' a:oo � � , _ , 8:30 "' 9:00 ._ 9:30 � � - 10:00 . . 10:30 11:00 ' 11:30 12:00 1:00 1:30 2:00 2:30 3:00 3:30 4:00 4:30 5:00 5:30 � ,. .. � _ - ___. �--_ r--_ _ _ — __ _ _ __ _ LAW OF'fICEB OF �n, . �°'="�"'^,. , . F ,._. � /'��" � � , — l�� E ��IAHN E. DAUBNEY � � � � -�� ✓ � � �- e — , 73B MINNESOTA BUILDIN[3 � � " - � �- , ; �' :,, __ ST. PP:I]L,MINNESOTA SSi�I , �� '� '� �\� � ,� rf —, � a f:i!� .+�� = . " .._x` ..._ "- _ � EISENHOM/ER'USA - The Honorable The City Council City of Saint Paul Court House ' St. Paul, Minn. 55102 .