The URL can be used to link to this page

262970 .WH17Et - CITV CLERK I J COUCICll �� • - � PINK - FINANCE GITY ��OF SAINT PAITL N ��O CANARY - DEPARTMENT CI►UE -�Iv1AYOR File NO. u�cil Resolution Presented By� Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date RESOLVED, That upon and pursuant to the pertinent appeal, under the Zoning Code, by Central Baptist Church, owner of the subject real estate, situate in the City of Saint Paul and described as : Lots 25 through 30, Block 1, Milham Park Addition; that the provisions of said Zoning Code hereby are determined and varied as and to the extent necessary ther efor and the setback requirements for said premises ar� he reby relaxed in order to add an addition to the existing church on the site, _ subject to the condition that said appelTant, and its successors • and assigns, otherwise, sha11 make due compliance with all applicable provisions of municipal ordinances, state statutes and rules and regulations of public authorities having cognizance. COUNCILMEN 'Yeas B11t,lEr Nays Requested by Department of: 7Ht�iZ Konopatzki [n Favor Levine v Meredith Against BY �rx Roedler Tedesco Mme.President � �Iuitt Adopted by Council: Date �AN 2 3 �974 Form Approve by C/�i+ty Attorn�i7 \ . ��/"4.� Certif' ed by Co ' S ry BY � By Approve y Ma Da 4 Approve a r� ission to Council gy By PUBLtSH�D F�g 2 �974- � 2�2C�'�0 ' BO1�►RD OF• ZONING` CITY OF SAINT PAUL � ' OFFICE OF THE MAYOR CITY PLANNING DEPARTMENT VINCENT M. COUGHLIN PLANNING COORDINATOR December 18, 1973 Mr. Harry E. Marshall City Clerk Room 386 City Hall Dear Sir: This is written in response to the appeal of Central Baptist Church to relax setback requirements on property located on the southeast corner of Roy and Shields. This property is further described as follows: Lots 25 through 30, Block 1, Milham Park Addition. This matter was first heard by the Board of Zoning on November 1, 1973. Staff reported that the appellant wishes to: rearrange the use areas of the present church buildings and cons.truct an addition which would be within 4 feet of the property line along Roy Street. The present setback requirement along Roy Street is 12.7 feet. After the Board discussed the appeal with the staff, Pastor and architect for the church, and neighbors, the matter was laid o��er for further study. The matter was again heard by the Board on November 15, 1973. The staff reported that new plans were drawn which showed no building within 14 feet of the south property line and no addition to the front of the existing worship center. The staff recommended approval. The Board of Zoning voted 4 to 0, with one member abstaining, to recommend approval of the appeal to relax the setback requirement to 4 feet provided that the most southerly 14 feet of the lot be unobstructed by any building. Sincerely, ��2�/��G�� DAVID RON MADDOX �rn�� Secretary, Board of Zoning DRM:RR:dr ,(`�� r�. „�. Zoning File 7568 ! � J 421 Wabasha, Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102 (612) 298-4151 _ , BOARD OF ZONING P�PORT AI�'D ACTI0:1 November 1, 1973 ��o ,� � - .::=: :-: ' . . .: � � ..� ... • :�.�, - .. . : � . . � F1at�Map ��21 • '� . �Acting under�Legislative� Code Chapter 60 thru 64� • � passed August 22, 1922, as amended to January 27, I971. - / 7568 1. APPLICANT'S NAME . Central Baptist Church 2. CLASSIFICATION . � Amendment X� Appeal � Permit � Other 3. PURPOSE . Relax setback requirements 4. LOCATION . Southeast corner of Roy and Shields 5. LEGAL DESCRIPTION : Lots 25 thru 30, Block l, Milham Park Addition 6. PRESENT ZODTING: "C" Residence 7. PURSUANT TO Zoning Code Chapter: 64 Section: •03 Paragraph: j 8. STAFF INVESTIGATION & REPORT: Date: October 26, 1973 By; DGW A. HISTORY: A setback variance from 12.�' to 4' was granted in 1961 for the north 15' of Lot 28, and all of Lots 29 and 30 in Block 1, Milham Park Addn. , but the construction proposed for the site at that time was never undertaken. B. AREA ZONING: The areas to the north and east of the site which border University Avenue and Snelling Avenue are zoned Light Industrial. To the south and west of the site, the area is zoned "C" Residential. The site itself is zoned for "C" Residence. C. PROPOSAL: The applicant wishes to relax the setback requirement in order to add to the existing church building on the site. D. VARIANCE: The proposed addition would be in violation of the required setback in that it would be 4 feet instead of the required 12.7 feet. This is approximately 69.5% short of the requirements. E. SITE CONDITIONS: The existing church is constructed on a part of the site raised about four feet above street level. Two older frame houses occupy a portion of the site. This portion of the site is also raised about 2 to 3 feet above street grade. The remaining part of the site is at street grade and vacant. F. AREA CONDITIONS: The neighborhood is composed of older single and two family homes, as well as several multiple-family units along Pierce, Shields and I-94. 9. BOARD ACTION: To Recommend ; � Approval Q Denial Council Letter _ , • Dated: Yeas Nays December 18, 1 7 Moved by Norton • Norton Maddox ; Date of � Seconded by: Maddox . . Willits Hearing: Bryan �' December 20 197 Secretary's remarks: Rupp ' " � Council Acticr.: • • Date: . . � 2�2�`�n MTI��EJTES OF �'4�E PUBLIC HEARI'�3i G BEFORE THL� B0�1RU OF 'LONIPdG QN THURSBt�Y, NOVEMB�R L5, 1973, AT 2;00 P,M� PFESENT: Mmeo Ncr�ctozz; t�fessrsa i4addox, Wi2lits, Bryan and Rupp of the Beard; Mro �ric��son, Assto Ci�.y Architect; Mro Ryan, Mr, Wilheim and Mrso Barriaul.t of the Plannzng Department Staff, CENTRAL BAPTIST C�iURCH (7568) : An appeal to reiax setback re�uirements on praperCy located an the sout;heast cc�rner af Roy and Shields, rir. Ryan said they met wi�h the agplicant and the neighbors most af£ected� and the $rchi�ect drew ug new pLans� T'he glan is satisfactory to che neighbor, Based on the changes anade, they would recoasnend �hat the varaance 'ne grantedq but would specify ttst�t the raost southerLy L4 feet of the lot be unobs�r��cted by buildicsga Mrso Nnrton aaid she wou}.d �.i�Ce to con.gratulate the stPff and �he archi�ect far coming up with �:he so�_u:ion �a their coacernso She moved they re�oaemead approvsl. af �he appeal sttbjert to �he re�omraersdx�tions of the st�ff� The motion was aeconded by Mra Mt�ddax� The mation car�ied by a vote o£ 4 to a with Mro �ryan abstaining because he was c},at at the fir3t meetfng on this ma�tero Submitted by: Ap�=aved by: Roger W„ Ryan Wi212am Ho Ruppt Jro . � 2s�� MTNUTES OF THE PiJBLIC HEARTNG BLFORE 'i'HE BDARD 0� ZO1�iIdG ON THUR3DAY, NOV�NiBER 1 A 197 3,, AT �:C1Q P�I�f� PRESENT: Mmeo P:nrton; Messrs� i��addox, Willits and Rupp of the �sard; �''ira r,xicicsan, Asst�. City ArChf.tect; ?�1r„ Ryan,. Mr�, WiZ�leim �nd i3rs, Barr.isc�l� of the Planning Dep�rtr�ent SCaff� GENT�iA�, B�pTIS�: �:HURCH (7568`1: An appeal to rel.E� setback req�ire:��n�s on propeg�y lo�ated �n ti�e sc�uth�ast cariier of R�y and Shields, A�r., Ryan showed a site pi�n fo� the additis�r�x and ga�e s staf� �ce.�ort fc�r ttze matter- E€e 581Lj they weie coacerned r�bout tih� in.�r?equa�e off s�ree� ,�ar��c�g because no addi�fazial. �az�.k..�ng wil3 be provided, He said they rPCOmm�rad �s�e�t the varzance �e ��ant�J fo� t[�e portian in front af th� exist�r�g �s�#.i.ding £or the enrry�aay, but thaC �h� res� of. �the building ��x.ng south oe set back 12 fc:�•�� f;cism i:he g�operty 2�ne� Ther� is a house �}us� sou2:h €�f the ch�erctt znd �:h� addition waca:�d I.irnir the sigh� lines� Mso Rodr.ey �Ieujatir. ��p��esent=`_ng Che appellan*,, st��ed �hai- L-.hey havn c�i�nged th� plano Th�y nc�r.� p�a�;ase t�► �uild within �8 feet af F:he SOi3�E3 FtY'�i}��7�*:�s I.is�e..., and the 35 fooG he��t�� indtcated on the ap��icwtic�n is c�n�.y a�+�lnc�bt,s� z�; ahocrt , 40� of L•he b�+i�.�t�ng �re��, Tt:e problem is tt�at w�.th t�ie pr�spnt se�t;ac:u. t:�.a�+ir�ment there is no wby fo� ttie� i:o mi:�t Chs buil.di:�g ��ogrs�� nee�s �f �he ccsragx�gati�aa�. That is rahat Ied ti�eu�� app�.y., Mr� 3ohn. Andzrsar_., Pasr_or �� t;en�ral BagtiCt Chur�i:,, said �che sLaff :.r�c�c�t=sa�endec� ehak the setbac�. v�riance be �ranted onLy to the. ar�a in fr..ent �f �� F�g�s�.a:tt waYshz� ��ea., T1Ze �7.an is tt� r�made2 the woAshig area i.�t�i ::�c�Q��-i_r�F�1 ��ea fox the�r church ��ogra�s and co�nunity tYsa�e� :t� wi11 �S� a u��z:�i_Fs_ed �;E::e o;E g}'mnasium fscYl�.ty� Th.ey are corests�uca:2ng a muli,i�-easa�e bui��.r�g il-:�� 4.t;�ld doub?e thezr ��;rE� fe1.�.�ws�eit� needs and �ossibl.y c�u�un��y �xeeta.��, t:y�:� ;;:�tu�3tians and wo�s€�ip� T'zaey are sha�t�i_:,tl tcEi�i� wosshiF fx.aea the ex�s�i_:�n 7.�arship ��ez� to the a�th�r iYlIP�.S`.1"•1i9s3G�� a�•��., ki�'.> Rupp asked 'now rnyny ��f stree� garicing r��ac�s �:l�ey k��ve tai�ci w�� *:t.� e:�g?�t,. Mr„ MQCls.enha�€pt. �r4�1 t9c�rrn F.c..�_ satd �he �eig�barY�eoc� was :�o� `r;ei.��, r_c��.:��c�d as mogt �f `!a� ��:�ghb;x=� �3:� r::d s�sd co�}.d��'ti c,�;E t� ttie r;;�:�v�:�c��y�, �� w�r ca�fused �bo�t some cxf t:he e!��tt�ges that c�rez�e hea.rtg u��r1e ��±�.i �:i��:�„� �,:::s�c ��±.{�i!�:ed te� hiw� he r.hes�l��i ?°� w3u'?ci �,e s��c!,ang our. �a �i� �� c"sr3 6€� �.h€� ��:�;.r3e�..�c bea�ty o� th� area-� ltiiir� ��a�3�ax as�ec� if th� ��ap�.5.r��1t wocxld he �dv�xse �o � c.as��:°�rrs�._�c �ry;�. �-t�� d��t��ce fsc,m r�ae p�ap�rty l ine� �he s�aff ur a�sid �z;�e ta s�� fe�t t�:�c?� A*�r� �d��> ��3 iesnt wou�.d �itce to see 4 i��r.> Mr, Ne�j�h� said ti3at the �r��b�.em is �hat they are sa �.imited x� s;�ace:, Mr, I�ar��n, 4�5 Noxth IZQ,y,. �sked z� a��y hr,us�K, �Arere gt�xng �o e�Q 1�;�s�a cl�wn to mak.e mora� p�rk:i.�g: Mr, Anderson said r.hat ;us� looking at �:he plan Q�te wc�u�d thx�k �i��g� w��=.td be an inc�°ease in �xsage�. �e sa�d �hey dtan°t expect an incresse ira t�e pres�� Central $aptist Church (7568D Page 2 November Lr 1973 membership. �ust mo�e facili�ies, such as a mu1Ci-use facility and servicea He said he didn't thxaic the pa��ing would be affected by thisa Mr� Rupp said he made two trips out there and parking was one of his concerns� He said it might no� increase the amount nf people that use the £acilityr but they might be the�e ma�e ofteno Mr� Anderson safd he cauld see where Chis might make a differenceo He said they wo�ld �ike �a stay a� thi� Iocation, He said they a�e � member af the Hamline �idway Comm�nity Council and he knaws that parking is a bi� factar in the development of rhe areae Mr� R�pp asked t:he applicant zf they wou�d be adverse ta warking oue a �ampromise on the setbac�� Mxo Ryan said ��ey wauld be hapgy ta discuss this fuxther wryth th� applic_anto Mr, K�pp said maybe they could go with � seeback of 8 feet ins�ead of 4 feeta Mr, Wi�.�.its cla_�itz.ed so�ue o£ the f�gures for �he Reighbors� Mrs a A1oz��on moved to tab�.e this mae�er to the next meeting or u�.tiZ the staff can work with the a�splicant. The motior_ was seconded 'uy Mr�, �dds�x� During �he vote„ 1'��'� Rupp said Exe would like this tgbled £ar one rQOnth it�stead of icwo weeks bec�use of st�£f schedu�.ingo rhe matian carried un�an�,mnusly� Mr� Rupp said rhe t��ao neighbo�s that appeared at the meeting shae��d be notified of the ��eting crhen it is scheauled, and aLso when they meet to discuss the plans� Submit��ci �y: Apgraved by� Roger W� Ryan Wi1.Iiam �I, Rc�pp9. 3r�. City Clerk ♦ • AJ�� . � ' - , ��.,'� CITY OF ST. PAUL DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE AND MANAGEMENT SERVICES ASSESSMENT DIVISION 113 CITY HALL ST.PAUL,MINNESOTA 55102 December 7, 1973 File R1421, page You are hereby notified that,a gublic hearing will be held fn the Cow�cit Chambers of the City Hall ac�d Court House aC 10:00 a.m. on Decembe� 20, 1913 on the applicaticn of the Central Baptiat C►►urch for permit to relax the setback requireaeents on the propErty described as follows: Lots 25 thru 30, Block 1, Milham Park Addition The property is located on the southsast corner af Roy Street and Shields Avenue. For further information, contact the Planning $oard, 421 Wabasha Street, or telephone Z98-}4151. To complq with the CiCy Charter, the Department of Finance is chargad with informing you of this public hearing. If you have any questiana, it i� recom�ended that you attend this public hearing to afford you the opportunity to make your views,. both pro and con, known to the City Council. ROBBRT W. TRt1D�AU DIRECTOR v , � . 2��p �� : . .:_ � :. N .t �_� ''�it th�ie �: `g4, F� t' - �_:: � . �� + ��, � � �4� � C1ty Cl�l'k�� (December i, 1�73J N a . � 262��0 , CITY OF SAINT PAUL QFFICE OF THE CITY ADMINISTRATOR FRANK D. MARZITELLI TO: Mayor Lawrence D. Cohen �� + FR: Frank D. Marzitelli � RE: Variance in Zoning Code -��entral Baptist Church, Lots 25 through 30, Block I,� Milham �ark Addition ' I have reviewed the above referenced resolution and am in agreement with same. Your approval and submission to the City Council for action is recommended. FDM/ca Attach. City Hall, Saint Paul, Minnesota 55�02 ,,�..a�.,..... � � .� V 1 !L 1 ♦ V � ��lir �� r �r � r� �o �-.,.�:.. (� OOOOO 4O � ' � C� P; � � .�� I � � � �d Ip� �� s o . , , ,� � _ . , , �= : 7,,V •; v.r: � � j � � � • �,, ,;� `�: .I, ^ '-a Ji:',��i •^.•,I�I ,;ol--a � �,� �" � a j s 1= 2( � �� ^ V V ^O O ^• .: - IS ' . � • , w� 0 � .� � �; • • , �•° I I 1� IR lY dSP/TAL T' ' � , a � � � � � � R � � �- � R ' � � a � v C�I = . � � t� � O . O O � � � • � ♦ � �- ' _ ' � O O O � O O � R. ' ^ . � . O �� - -Q- _Q � � fi A P. O. � � . O I Y- O O -fl- O O � � � . �o O �' , -O- �s � - S�FfiI �LDS AVE. I � _ : s o � ' -- - .F � 5 � � � Q �.. —�A_ � . � � � -- - _ � - � 5—O � � � � _ � - . . � O O >— . 0 0 0 � � ' � � O �" O � p S STORA�E �. w 0 �. 0 � , ' v — • ' � c,, o � LU ♦ >- . - __ w a i � � , Z � Q �e � � o � �- 6i ,��, ' � �� ; v =�..� � I�� 5 I! 3 � HONY � � � V 1 . ��A �� APP�ICANT Central Baptist Church LEGEND "'� � ZONfNG �ISTRICT BOUNDARY PURPOSE � SUBJECT PROPERTY Relax setback requir.ements � ONE FAMILY FiLE NO. 7568 � TWO FAMILY �� -�}- MULTIPLE FAMILY DATE November 1, 7973 � 7 O �7 e e n COMN9ERCtAL � �CALE� !"= 2Q�J` NGRTH ♦ '� v iNDUSTRIAL SAINT PAUL PLANN(MG BOARD V VACANT --------- �,