02-1052Council File # p �, � ��5'�
Green Sheet # 101117
Presented By
Refened To
Committee: Date
1 RESOLVED, that upon execution and delivery of releases in full to the City of St. Paul, the proper City officers
2 aze hereby authorized and directed to pay to Praxus Consulring, Inc. the sum of $15,000 out of Tort Liability
3 Fund 09070-0511 in full settlement of its indemnity claim on behalf of Fanners Insurance Group for no-fault
4 benefits paid to/or on behalf of Jessie Sutherland and Shawna Bradlich arising out of an automobile accident
5 with a city-owned dump truck on November 5, 1997, at Snelling and Englewood Avenues.
Dated: NQ'(Jt�.fyl Vwt� � � ZOUa'
Adoption Ce�tified by Council Secretary
By:
Mayor:
By:
RESOLUTION
CTTY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA a3
APPROVED:
Adopted by Council: Date ,v�� �',. ,.a��
�T
Reque�sted by Department of:
e i � A�tk�V Hc
By: A��U�A •� ' •W �
City Attorney's Office
Frank Villa�e III
il/s/oz
rc'�•2��
�
TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES
Approve settlement of inde�ity claim by Praaus Consulting, Inc. against the City of
St_ Paul for no-fault benefits paid by Farmers Insurance Group to/or on beLalf of its
inc ured and passenger.
PLANNING COMMISSION
CIB CAMMITTEE
CIVIL SERVICE CAMMISSION
GREEN SHEET
m�u�rtortecraR
o�.-�cQ�. �
No ���
arvaua
❑ an�iiautv � arca.ouc
❑ AI4RULiflIMCFSOR ❑ pi1111C111LaFI1V/KClo
� M`fORIORAfiifAlR) ❑
(CLIP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE)
Has this PersoMrm everxarked under a cantiact for ttris tlepsrtmeM7
VES NO
Nas this peisoNfirm evu heen a ciry empbyee9
res rio
Ooes this Pe�saMrm P�aese a sldll nat normelNP�aesseC by anY curteM cdy emDbYee4
YES Ntr
Is Mie P�eoMfi�m n taryMed vendoYl
VES NO
all
antl attach to arem si�eet
On November 5, 1997, Jessie Sutherland collided with a city-owned d�p truck. Both he
and his passenger Shawna Bradlich were injured and Farmers Insurance Group eventually
paid $36,390.03 in no-fault benefits. By definition, the City truck was a co�ercial
velucle entitling the auto insurer to recover all benefits paid to the egtent that the
City�s driver was at fault. '
Conclusion of claim on terms acceptable to City of St. Paul.
IFAPPROVED
None.
��aYG� ������
�� � , ��
m��� � � ��a�
[v
The claim will proceed to mandatory intercompany arbitration where the City faces the
risk of a worse result.
AMOUNT OF TRANSACTION S 1S � OOO
Tort Liability Fund 09070-0511
INFORMATION (IXPWN)
COETIREVENUE BUDfiETED (CIRCLE ONE) /YES / NO
ACTMTY NUMBER
11/04/2002 13:54 7652811378 PAGE 02
11/04/2802 11:35 7652811378 PRAXIS CONSllLTING PAGE 03
PRAXIS CONSULTING� INC.
P.O. Box 5• Murtc�, irroiaNa 4�308
(888) 357-8276 . (765) 281-I378 AAx
vnw�.Eoraxisc onsultitie. com
������
INDEMNfTY RELEA3E
PUR3UANT TO SECTION 65B.53 OF THE MINNESOTA NO-FAULT INSURANCE ACT
1n consideration of the sum of fourteen hundred seventy and 00/100 dollars ($1470_00), paid w
"Prsais Consulting, Inc. a/a/o Farmers Insurance Group a/s/o Jessxe Sutherland" by City of
St. Paul does hereby release and £orever dischazge from any claims, demands, acrious and/or suits
it may have against it for any and all liability City of Si. Paul and �atzicia Ann Legato Ynay
have to Farmers Insurance Gronp pursuant to The Minnesota iVo-Fault Automobile Insurance
Act, Section 65B.53, in regard to a claim for bene�ts naade by Jessie Sutherl�nd uz�der The
Minnesota No-Fault Automobile Insurance Act to, Fa� Insurance Group as a result of an
automobile accident which occurred on or arow�d Novenuber 5,1997, involving City of St. Paul
and Patricia Ann Legato.
IN WITNESS WAE�OF, we have executed this release the 4th day of November 2002.
—�Q.i-�-x1�� �
On behalf of Praxis Consulti�ag,�
a/a/o Farmers Insurance Group
STATE OF Indi�na ]
COU1V�'7C OJF Aelaware J
Oa this 4"' day of l�tovember 2002, befoze xme pezsonally appeared, Susan Bissey who by bezng
duly swom clid depase and say ahe resxdes in Zionsvilie, Indiana chat she is a Subrogat�on
Specialist of Praxis Consutting, xtac., corporation described �u, and which executed the above
iastzument; that she knows tUe sest o£ said cozporation, that the seal affzxed to such insmunent is
such coiporate seal; that it was so affuted by authariued mebnbers o£ said corpozation, and that
she signed her name chezeto by Iike ordez. :, y � �w..,
5 D-� �� `�° _ „��;•.
>•�f - � :
_ _ ^'�;:
011r Clai»l: H6t62195
Your Claim: 59&0�22
1Vota;ry - - _
_ _ , _
=��'-%^ � ., -
�;:��� �
'� -
� �s
11/04/2002 13:54 7652811378 PA6E 03
� 11/04/2002 11:35 7652811378 PRAXIS CONSULTING PA6E 02
PRAXIS CONSULTING, INC.
P.O. Box 5• Muc�c�, Irmiwxw 473a8
(S$3) 357-82"76 • (765) 281-1378 FnX
w�t�w Euracisu�nsuhing.com
a�-�os�
INDEMNITY RELEASE
PURSUANT TO SECTION 658.53 OF THE MINNESOTA NO-FAULT INSURANCE ACT
In consideration of the sum of thirteen thousamd five hundred thirry and 00/100 dollazs
($13,530.00), paid ta "Praxis Consutting, Inc. a/a/o Fazmers Insurance Group ale/o Jessie
Svtherland" by City of St. Paul does hezeby ralease and £ozever discharge from any clauns,
demands, acrions and/or suits it may have ag�ainst it for any and all liability City of St. Panl and
Patzicxa Ann Legato may bave to Fsrmere Insnrance Gronp pursuant to Tbe Minnesota No-
Fau1t Automobile Insurance Act, Section 65B.53, in regard to a claim for benefits made by
Shawna Bradlich under The Minnesota No-Paulk Automobile Insurance Act to, Farwere
Inswrance Group as a eesult of an automobile acczdent wiuch occurred om or azound November
5,1997, involving City ot St Pan� and ��tricia Ann Legato-
IN WITNESS WHE�Ok', we have executed this zelease the Ath day o£November 2002,
_..�-�� ':"�'�""y--`rC^
On behalf of PraYis Consulting, c.
a/a/o Farmers In�urance Group
STATE OF indiana ]
COUNTY OF Delaware J
On this 4 day of November 2002, beEore me personal�y appeared, Susan Bissey who by being
duly swom did depose and say she resides in Zionsville, Tndiana that she is a Subrogation
S�pecialist of Praxis Consultiung, Inc., corporation desczibed in, and which executed the above
ine+nimrnf• thot ahr+ lrnnivc f}ia et+a) nF eaid rnrnnmfinn thcrt ahe seal �ffixed tn such instnlment is