264110 � . �
. �
:2 110
, CITY OF ST.PAUL O CIL FIL�
FI NAL ORDER Y , Y� - ,
B �
File o. x���
In the Matter of �� � � � �� �� � ����
� �Mt �lMt 0! ��i! �0�� ���'ii;�+l�1C �!f ��� �M �!�lrR�� !� �
i'� qM��t �h► h'11�1t �/. �'�� � �i��A�!
l�iE'id+l1 �i �M�► Q�1 1� � b�►�l�11�� �! �M� �Q �i �ilt ��M
fi� �!. !� U�1� �t. ,� a!! �Q ��t !s� �iwl3s =8« b
4Qf1 t�t �st o! �t 1rrd, �t �e!#1!� ewCb ili! �it'�[,� +�#�Ir
��asw � d� !aall!!�, a �,e +m�rr#rril a�itri■� st 1A�4+6it tare �w+��
�IOOrClti14�` �l��� Il��k M � t�� O� � �� � ��'� � =t r
e+r � l+t., o�astsMSt i s�o�ta !� ris��� �t. !�r !'1ili�rt ie.,,
�wMlso�r ira�►ls+rssds � i�e stl e� r�lc �s� ar1 #erRl�ata'� tr s�i
��e+or��r�. � � �
A�li� ' e+�t�N�ir 17, I9�
�lNi oet+rl�r �l� 3!T'9
under Administrative Order � ��� - approved �� �� ��� •
under Preliminary Order ���•�(72 I approved AuG 1 �74
The Council of the City of Saint Paul has cor�ducted a public hearing upon the above improvement, due notice
thereof having been given as prescribed by the City �harter; and �
WHEREAS, The Council has heard all persons, objections and recommendations pertaining to said proposed improve-
ment and has fully considered the same; now, theref�re, be it
RESOLVED, That the Council of the City of $aint Paul does hereby order that the above-described improvement
be made, and the proper City officers are hereby dire�ted and authorized to proceed with the improvement; and be it
FURTHER RESOLVED, That upon the comp�etion of said improvement, the proper City officers shall calculate
all expenses incurred therein and shall report the same tp the City Council in accordance with Chapter 14 of the City Charter.
I
I
i
i
COiJNCILMEN ! Adopted by the Council: Date AUG 2 9 197�
Yeas Nays
Christaf1�611 Certifie by Council Secretary SEP 3 1974
Hoz�
Hunt In Favar B
Levine
Roedle� Against
Syivest�9 Mayor
Tedesco
�� — '/F��M��hos D�pt• � � � x ��.F� � s J t �t + ���'; " 1 ,t ���E
k �� I T+Y'. .
M.'" T t � :. .� ` , S�.Y � .,� y,
.(�i"K'�"'�' µ- —rr��. � � , ` '"b��ia�"w �`� a'��lS'.: �f';)�►+�`,,y�r�"��r�.'.+��j � '` �''+�� ' ��#., � ,��
' � � � . . � - . _. •1 . �, �������' .�.... . ;, �i{'�..A
' ...e . ' � �—^,'^ i ��,
AD RA'�"i'V� ORI�$�t �����.� "' � � � « `
� � ,. ,.
,
. . s ,�
. . . , � C ',f � �rN 1`3� ��s b t `�.
' : �
µ
k. ' , i •� � � '�
`� b, d'�.� '� ��2�y,
. �.�'��;rr�,'"� ;,
. . � . ' . . . I ,z � a:� � rrr r� . .��. `s�} i Sb .c�,}'�,}:.
�r �� ��� � { 57�7,�� "�+
A�!!MI2�IS.TRATIV E ORDER, '' ' ,� �`� � �;�' .��,�,��,"�'' �'� ���,
I ;� � � �� � � � �� ' � �
�y�j s�.� �' t�"c Q�t ,
, I �!����#��M +�f1r �i`.�6,'`��t4° i�w�«t ����1�'{�'����
•, �i "y '�y
� ' I ��,� �� ' � �. ` ���� " ' ��`��'';
� i . � �r ;,�
' � � � , � {� "y�
, � F ,: p y� '�;?��`� ��y� .;t� t"�1
t � �
ft�P 1 ..� �f�{��� O.j .�.� .��4�`L��., �������� '��� �� � p . � qY ��knf� �' L�.,%fy}�;...
� �- � �msstigats tha n�csssity for �r ir►� �d pa�tr/e�, ��D1 �d��M������r �;F,� � '� ;�( ,�-r��
. . . � ' , . . �:�::, t k: .�. _..'i �F.. .,.ii° � t.n'�`'.
R i rs i n�ham S t. to I�fh t t+t Bear A�vsr !i� �s autlwr i sed to obia 1 s �w�.�� ��,t :"r�,��� �� ,� �
�°pre�,►s n pra l i A t nat^y ,p�an�s, an�1 �tkaR cast �st iwattat. 1 f f��► de�eri�i � t
:� �
'''r thts ro ect is nec�rssa��y sl+ou�d swba,t� t!� aie�'w�tol� 'a �}"�?`'�������" ���`}''�`d
. . .,�.,,. p � ., �/! ,��1� n.'�: ��� �e� Y``jr;:y i"�,
rot�pi�nenda��OAS L�D tfli D I 1"�LOf f 't� Dspalrta�tt o1°' �i r��at. �.,� , �' ��
�.�,,,..,.;, � . - . .� � �4 .,'�N+� 1�� .�� ,id i w.�s
�r �.�i . '� .. . . . I . . H4. +�A'� { � %
r�r ..� � .. � � . . ������p�� } �a! �d �.� c�'�-
.ir� . r.... . _ . . _ � .-� t �f `�l�ti '7�
. � � yd 1 r:� � F�
.. , . ., - � ��.�� � �� i �� �� ���
..�.. . � . . . � � ' .� ' � i;.�
. . � , . �u� ,-��� r��.
. . . . . �: n s U; 4'
. .. ,M�i' � ��..
� �. � Y � '�'I (��.:! y �'� �, �
; � . .
! ���
',' . .. . . I . .�� f
. ,. 1��pj��. E�i 1
' . . . . - ,w ' ��� t '� .��}' z��
. . � . . . �ii r� ��Ri �'y 1��.�i�`�}�'4+��+e
� - � . . '�iz (r ��Ziti� �o o yi��
� `>;4��"�� 't' ' :w�i �
� , ,
� ,; ` ,��k' ,+ � �
.. . , , . , �: :' i±s �F kk
. � � - � � � . y ,vi 5 a � y� �$P7,� Y �' ���,� 'n �S[ I�,,I
; i�
.. ..
, �
, .; `�
, , � _ ^� .' ;: ,
� � 1 + i. - #', �.k ( `44 � x-#�,7
;:
� � . - � . � . � � �,� � Aaa ti `" �7� J� �1:
. - . �. .. . . � ' � � / ,... �" {� �� ' , F' x.�si�,uh ' ��
� � , � p t+ � �.� � }� ��r§ I � �4'�'
� � . � � � s �� r: 'E \�� `:��g ��''�
; � � �C ;
,
a, � u��� � � , ;
� .�� {;
. . . . . . . �'' -� � ��. _. :
' . .. .. ,. � �� � .
�;y�o . ,;� � , �, .a:,
. . ti =,� � ,' w a
� �F r.` i, iy ' o-, <<+
. � � . . � .! 1; . �,.F�•,�4�
. . . �� }{a �;�� d /�� .. ��,�:
�k a �s � �
. � . 4� . .. � ���z ��r.
_. � � � � � � �� �
� f �^i I� � 4� /'y ` /�/ f �x7.
� —w ��/ * {Y 1� �f "�
z ,:'�'�ry �►�� • '' `; � 1'�i.,
APPR�D AS T� FOR : ' .�°`'� ' ..
� �� ��� �,� "� ,�: y� � �� •�"' � ,�; ��
sr:r � �� � r ` ,,i;�.<j is,
�� i� ��.
� ,. $i
Assistan
� .Att ey � r- �;s �� s�' �� ��� �'��� enfElCe�.
Z > �' y „�` �' ���f° "� :
� : c� �,. IS'; . �(,�
� y 1 ��' i �.d tk�,�r., Flt� : � 4"I',,. ��,� �`
� q �4+ :rNr �;T i. � �.5;� '�d �iwF`
. 3... . . 1 �,� 'r KY f: i .t�* :i ; � i 1 � fs
� �
. �' tr4� , J! w` .kf �.. '�.p+�d4 t.;.��y+$��4 ��
♦� ��
, - .j/� .'�,yr`" � .'',� �� i ttf i`�; t ~ S � �� ,�,Yr 5..'@rN'tik�ur8,
,��r `,f � t �
� L r MuY
.
� . u
� ; �y,
�I.G .14 ;� nu _ �'�Y���'���r p a�e0 " , .R" ,�
r^ '.-.1'ie'i." Y ..p i ( '�. . 'M'IFS}{
:� . 7, . F� .1 t/
k �U� 7 y t F
, "' 'r� °(di _F . � .A
� " � � . . . _ � ���,�r�!.'�'''zT �� �+ `"� Y � ''�, � T y ' t 4� l.
e-,,.� '� ,' ? 'f r k ' ;"1'�, � a��
'�' � . � ' � �' y , � �� 'F 3 q1 ��.�� � i r"
�v� � . , s � , . ,� , �y , , �,�t�p �- �: i 4a�� �e
V., `. 7 , c ;� ' �� � j ��� S r�{ t �.i.� � l 4���'`� cEi
it ' �= f � a � s .ri� ax.{' � X
� . � . � Y � :z � ,����syr, r� i�Wrar?y.. � � l,,J�.'4� s r,,r' f ; �#tF-� ,�' �'���r id �''`,..���p . .
� � . . . . {F.. ,�w��:� �;i�. �,...�� . , a,t n a�.. .� ., � � _
�:YVhite' CitV CNt,�c �;,��'i� �r+�s ��;��� ,�„�•i�.�,�rt�„ � •'�� �.: y, �
yt�
P�nk — ff�len D'�pt. �'�` r , "�
Gmt��— � � �F��'�'�YQ� t3 ¢'�+.�w,�w "3M�.�'9s M1.H' � ` el r r . . , ���t� l ''1
. �� �tA'�• �'�� � _ �,d''.
� ,, .. ,
� . , . ,
, . ,
- � ..i,, � , �. ,;� � , ..
�,DMTriI3T 'I'�VE +[3�ER , .r,
. . . .. . f � " � 1 �, ��{
� •. , . . . . .. , � ' ' �. ' �� . 'a'. � l'- Eh ?� 1',. ��t.�
.� ' � . . . , �" ' - . �. , .. L. .�� p . �, �i N }`i par:.
t �
. '� �:k y
,,, �+ l �3�
. . , H� �erwr�S. pt�" �s�"�'; 4�..�.
T.. �
f�- . . . . . . j . � �,� ly��•
� :� .. _ � . . - .. o .. �. � � ��mh 1 �� �
'� ��;' AD�dINISTRATIV`E ORD�R, N��i,�� 1�.p �1..�, , ''�M � a�, {; � ;
._� . `� iil�,t���� l�ars� � 11� ��,� ,�." �-�: ,
� .:� � , � > �
,
, ,
VID/'lOt: � �, ,� , �,� ; y
� '� ± i ,b �'� � �� R��.��*���t
« '�� �C�'; t���� �i ,� }
T!� Dir�ctor o� ths rtae»t of ��bi i� Mbrlas s i ' t f�''� �
�'spa� � �r '�+�' ��Y :� ,. �
t lwes t t�� Lt�s necess i t�r �►r �1 ` �� ��+ar�►�r'��I!� ��i�1�=� �I� t: � ,.,�, k;a�a t a�:
f t+oat 1rh i tt �ea r Av�nue t� Ru tl� S C t�► !1s �s �rth4�i a�rtl' t�r �t���' � � 7;ki� �' �� ,�; ,�"' `
s�tw�e�►s, prepar�-p�el imi�sry pl , a�d �� cost s4sti�s�. �f f l,p� ; �� '�" ; ' "� . ''
! `` L ,+ try,� � ����4�,,, . ;� i
d�ie�r'�� t�lAt t11/"�. ��3�rt �� . . . ���� i�o ��t�,�i �iY�l�. SiiR� � a, i�� a*�..w�� a � .
�vttfi h#s r�dations to tf� �f �t�ctor af tM Depst�ta+raat o�``�� �, :� ,�t��N�;: ,a �;���� .
, , ,�; �
� �� n�{���,r{ . �� ��.�„,
f��`��,s� + � k� ��,. �
.
� � � '� � r�
!`������}4�,,.�� �`���� �
� � � � , �. .; � �. :, � �, r� _�'���t�'�t�
�
. `�q ? ����k� ` p+�,+, ��. ��
. . � . . . .e� �!': y�ql� J
. � � . . . . � . �� �;'�T 11' P��4
. , � i � �� � �.f� '
. . . t� .� � y � �,�'� a..
. � . � . . �:. ` �,^ � ��� a���..
�� .. � .k . � �..
. :. � . .. ti � . , .. �' inF� '�r?,- 1 , ,.;�.,����4+�s.
. . .. . . � .. . . � . � .. . 7���� m�'��, . a{��'.�,.
. . �. � � . �� - � � � � .
. .�., ,.� ' �., .i . ' .r` li,i; z . a ? a ],� .
� . � , � � . .. f ; ,,n � �'Y�"�s,
r y 4
F � '
. 1f �i� t . �S
� � t k } �.
. . . , . . . � . ��} e�:` �T��
f ac , fi p � ���
: � ! 4 �" �c +
,tt r
. . _ . . ,. � , � . � � �� , �jR ��t'�.
. � .. .. � � .. � .ca f {m,�^ •' ,..'a -d.,; i� _.;�:�' � a. �� � G .
. . . . t�y r �' Y L"�y���*'4 N�d
_ . ,� . :�� ����� :� ���.�.
'� h ' �
� � f � ���� � �" � 4 - w�l'; xx i� ,:i !�r �i
. . . .i t ,Y,' ..� ^ , �..i^i �7 'Y�.G,:
. , . r , . p G 1 ,3};.
� � � � " � ,� � t4 tip�
- . . . � � i 1 � .� � _ �.,�.ip N '�' .:
. . . . ..a z��.� »4t ��t��'i� ' : R ''�t, :, ,Y�P' �,���.
'e.�. > > t,r
� � �a ; r � °� y a' n �
� � � l,� �r1 �! + x�, ;+ ti'�
�
� .. � . . . -� � ��Il: '.1�� �; �+�f Ih k�.
. � . � �S' �I�y.: !L K k ��L� 1( .
.. � . . . P t �� 9�� ' y�'��.
. .. .. .. . '}� ��,i ` '�S�k�iY '��� 1 ��:�'..
k :
� � ... � . � : � 1. . � �p' S
� . . . ... . . .. . � �} '"�� l t i Y 4.'�.
j �
� i1';� • � l� '��'1`"t` } ,},
.
!.
,-. i�tr � , � � . ` § n : �.:
. � - . . . � r ` r . - k.
.. . � ���.t° -I
' . . . J r. .,j. � � Ml,.�
.�. �' � � J fc��. �. , � : . i
l
+ F ��a.� �. .�c �' �k-
,
, !
.
APPROVED AS TOFO ' ' '' '
' Fat" � �4:r �� ! ��i�
. � . . � � - . »�`� y xtf �.I ' �.� � tk!_
. . ; 7, 1 � ,,.F. S�� } ':
�•'��"�+ � � i�s � �'a
,{
Assistant it Att ' y �� �$ ��.� mie#t Hsa� I
� ���t ,�� , , ����� s$,
�' ';b,` ,� ,
/'�� , Mi } � L d�' °Y^ ^ u
1 ..� � . . .�� .. �f t��� { ` �� �� � .
} , •F r�.1�� ��1h:f
�I�ate � � .:. �;; �T� �
1 K�'
,. .� . . . . �°, °� u� ' ,��} � tii ; ��O * t,':' ` �e 1 w�+r'4;��..
. - i `� .y . � � � �.
- ,�n , � ;� : :ti F, � '9p�i1 r�� , q :#r.'�.
� � �' � q, ��
� r.� y� ; �'� C�' a t�_.
i . �` rtt , �7�r
6 A �,'�� �y� ' � �"'�
� � . ,� Fr.; .. l}t tJf�;�.' p�A.
. . . ... � . . . . � , .. . . . ,,a ',4;% .. e. ST.�'1.W+'"� . N�(?4'
` Pfnk� — F roelq DM�t- V i '�'i 1 ��r�;�'��4����#� ,�:�;�, � � ���*�':� �rtP�Y :t': r
�
V—'DrPt- , 't't ' v�:;i.,r �;L � y � =�
Ca»ar . . OFFia^ "OF �,T$E�� M�►'�YO�t ' ' ���.� � �.�..,, ;:
. ' ti:+ �4�
ADMI � TRATIVE ORDER (I' �� V .,,
� { ,
z, .,�.� > , �_ t
. . . � . - �N; , t 5 i. r
.. .. . . . .. . � . � .. '� � }�_,�� 1e�1
� � . . � if Y ' � .:� �
. . , � . .. . . . . . .��: f .. y�� ���� 1�'i. �f�:��.
,�. •� �; . . �.: � . . . .� �Vf7�l.7 L�M �lV� �t ,�? ! �,�+•�Y '� �^!Y �:
ADMINISTRATIVE ORDER, ` ' '' '' {,Ff ,
. , h; �� +�
�W��1 �{�s !4 ���� �. f' h�� ����r��3'��'n
N10/�. ' i ��;�
. . . �5 ,� t t �, + 5 1 . ��
. . . . . . , ���
. . � . � . . . � � .. . .. . � . '�.�.
.. � � � D���f�0t . Q t che Depa cta�se►t.�� f :Pub 11 c �'�ks �i •q��� ��1,��1Y\��� � ... �i 4y i.5'(i r 1 i•�i4 A }�.
_ i nv�st i gate ths nec�ess 1 t�r for ++ dsa{eg ae�d aMSr�l a���1 i�{� l�w��irr�'�y ,w ��, ., ' , t�,
froai Ruth Strest to McKnl ht . He is autlw�riz+�# to ob�ai� s� zk�AY � � "� `
` 9 �,,M�'��,',� � ��+, ;�� �
;x° prepare p�elia�inary plss�s, snd tke cost �stia�t�s. , If ha dst�rsii+� � "^ ,„` `�"� � �
� that this project is nacessary,� 1+� shou�d wb�alt t�e�s ala»g wFtfi ��►�d1,,, . t�;� � `;�, �� ,,; � �� '
�R
reooia�+endations to the Dir�ctof af tfie a�psrt�t o!� Finan�.' ' ` ��� �'��t";y „`'�'`
� .;� ''`���� � ,.,
, ;�: �.
� p
� :
.�.� � ��r�,. ,,r , ����
.� �,,; ,��.
,��- �
, �� ,�t� �
,le' . - . . � ' � . i� � '. ��
.�y , r .
� s . �
y'.� . . . . . � � I 1 I W# )'� 't..
.�. .. . � . , . . . . . . ... . . .{Tp,�', a i.�.�.
S't
- . � . . . . . ' . . . � . � . � � � , . � ��'� �
. . . . .. . � . . .. . ...� � ; � .
. . . . . � .. . .. ., . . . � .. ' % ��' d'�9 �� ' ,{'!,..
,
.: .
. t � , 1 Y:.
u. � .� .. ' - . ... . . . . ._ . � y ���:tf {4.
� . . . � .. � � �
. � . . � � k y� t '.nt+� i�h�
,- , ,
_� , ��:v , . . .
- . � . .. t� - ,�� ,�
.. . � . . . � ' " - , u fF �' o.`.
� � � .. � . . .. . � ' � +�� ��t�
.,:.,.. . . :.�� . �.. . ...: . . . .. ::-:� �.
. . . rF, .. . ....i- rt. ..r�, 6= r.
. . .. , . . . . . t
t . . ' . �' � . . ` .. . ., . A�';e t �7'�.
. -. . . . .- � �( W � . >� �� �` �� 5u, a "'�','
. � � � � . - 4 .µ� i � �j�i':.
.. . . � � ..! } ! Y, . , . 4; ��?';
. . , � . . ,d . � .. . • � ,� ;1 �h�,�.
� ' � . � � ,. , .Y• . . .. �. � � . . � j `� . A',:
- ' ¢ . � F�'� , a��.
� . . „ �T . � ���`.
. . . 4.' , . �i..
� ��i
� !` �,
.. . . . . . . . . .t �.� pw3C7.,�.� ;.� . � ry:$ `��F.
. � � . � . . • ��
�,.,' J}r
. . � . J 4,�, t ,t
. . ��� i. �� , 1 ,
.. � .�. .. ' . r i � J � � � ��
. . . . r, , , ', '
AI'PROVED AS TO FORM �x � � � '��I
f L` . !t' { T �}.
;., o ..t�,,�.1 �'j:. ,� � , �:''� i¢,�'; ��:�
. , . . ',pg.�. . A�r c�i:
. . . r ��� � Y`" . �� ��,� � � � �� +1' ^Ma��:
a�� �
, , r_ �.
. - F � , . . . . - . . .' t' �, : �
� . . .�... i � . . .,.:.'� . �. .::Y ��, , ' ..
. . . . :.: , . .. �-,.� -, �,..�
. . . . ,�.':.'� . , .i� ... ... n:,��.
Assiatant Ci At o ey a ,
�{$ �.� , ►t�i►1 i� �
, a � ��� � ���':!C�+�►�
.. .. . . . � �"�:� �1�� 's8 i � '�i t .. f� S�' �,;
� �` �. "�"f �..�a ��'` , i� F,+ �''t�
� � } , � � " / .,''�' °�'� � '"
� . �� � f ��_
�� � � y:. �� -� � .i, �i1������ 4' 4';�� f
��at� .. .. ,._, .�.. � � � �?.�
r� ,I r ;�11i11�itM' Stt .y
� y",� �
—c � - � mt`° �f i#+.:wi4,'��,y�i'�VY.�1.. i�v..�. � �l. ��. 4a f `+�F{'
i ,, �;
�',� r � �,`_,�� �� ���� �'
. � � � � ,�et,�t''� � � s 'R;Vk�t ��3������ � "�d ��'..
� �`� ' y� �s ���.�
. . . �. �1�`t �, ` r :� , f�, 4�y�:, `.��, r'�k x � k" ," 4...
� t�; a w �" rs ��l�t ��'k e�: 8�c 5 ± x
. - . � . � . � i . ��, . .i�"'� ' . . �d+ ��. .� . . . � . .. ..,�y�i' 't��i,. x'. 3 �'��;� .,�-tt^ �,-�,�t
� � . . , �
� ' � IT ACTION INITIAL DATE
Yl�3� D�PARY�� Y CaF P�l�b.l� 19�0�
OF THE Bureau �, � S z,r,,
Cl�Y '� 5T. PAll1 Division I �EN; ' �,�
Asst. Dir. � LL J r
WTER-OFFt E COMMUNiCAT10N D i r e c t o r ;,,,� �.;.,� �
cti c-�(
DAN I E J. DUNFOP,D Clerical -�-r;q�;s.
Di rector � ��i�' --
M�y 24, 197�+ , .
Honorable Lawrence D. Cohen
Mayor of the City of St. Paul �
Roon 347, City Hal1 '
BUILDING
C Re: P-0503 LD NUDSON ROAD - Sirming�?am to White Bear ✓
P-054o LD HUDSOt�J ROAD - Wh i te Bear to R.u�h ��
P-ob13 LO HUDSON ROAd - Ruth to McKnight
Dear Mayor Cohen:
This letter constitutes the Rep rt and Recommendations of the Department of
Public Works concerning investi ations for widening and reconstructing 0l.a
HUDSON ROAD from Birmingham Str et to approximately 400 feet.oa�� �f McKnight
Road. . W���'� .
Attached for execution by your ffice is an Administrative Order approving
� this report with recommendation and authorizing a neighborhood informational
. meeting and the scheduling of a council hearing.
{ I . ESTItVtATE QF COST (Inc uding Right-of-��aay, Engineering, Inspection, etc.)
\
1 . P-0503 Birmingh� to White Bear $223,0OO.OQ
2. P-0540 Wh i te Bea to .&a�-�h �,f-��,(.. 151 ,950.00
3. P-0613 Ruth to M Knight � d 34,200.00
TOTAL $409.150.00
11 . ESTiMATED FlNANC1NG
- Assessments . . $123,800.00 . -
1974 M.S.A. Fund 285,35�.a0
T07AL $4og,150.00 . .
;, .
t
.. .� . . . . . . ... .. . .. �rbV���.
. . � � . . . . � . . . . . r.-,
'. : ' J. wtLL1AM•DONOYAN ����.LV ,
Voluotlon Englns�r c�.�-53�7
ROY E. BR�EpAHL, ��. C I �' Y F S A i N T PA U l r-�--
' �►ss'� vo��4f�o� Enpine�r BUR U �P VA�UATIONS �t- I1 �' '
2S6 City Hafi '' r-,'; r
Sain ���I, Minn�st� b3102 TK� �
Febx�:ary 22, 197�+
��7oZ/ ', ���C. I.
/ j,' ��.'v Z
2�ir. Clau�e Tnompson '
Desi�n En�ineer �, f�.'�����,�
Denar:;r�ent of Public �•,orti.s
LO"v,1RY B'JI?�Ii�JG �`
Re: P-0503 - Old Hudson R�.d �
Birmin�;c!ar� S�. ;,o �T:�i�e Bear ve.
P-05j+0 - Old Nu3son Roa.d
� t•ihite Bear AJe. to Ru�h St.
.� P-Oo13 - Old 'riudson Road `
Ruth St. to P��c'r'�night Road
`
De�.r Sir: _
Pursua.nt �o yo�zr request for asses ment infornation on the subject pro3ects, I
wisn to re�or� zhe folla;•ring• -
The 'co�al estimated aa�oi:,�� re overable by assessments pa.ving, cuxb
and gu�ter is $z23,8o0.00 bas d on �he follo��riz� estimated assessment
rates:
- A & B Residen�ial pro erty - � 5.00 per assess. Pt.
. "C" Res., Commercial Industrial property - $15.00 " " "
Directi Uenefi� improvements uld be fully assessed at the .follo�ring estimated
assessment rates: •
� ,
� Sidez�ralks - 5 foot
A & B Residential pr erty (subsidized) - $ 4.00 per lin. Pt. `
"C" Res. , Co�ercial� Industrial property - � 1.25 " sq, ft.
(Ot.ner �Tiatr. wa s vrill be pro-rated)
Concrete Drivewa.Js
6" thic?� - $11.00 per sq. yd.
7" thick - �12.00 " `� _ "
. � . . . . � . � . � �. .. . .' . - F �
.. . ~ . � . � .. . .. . . . . . . . M4'.
• ' ' - . � . . .. . . - .. .. . � .
'2_
____,_, _ ___=`��?J�.^-..i;P '-i._^_° fO:Li.�:._:i,; '.� i��O"_�l CGS.`.S 1T1 lt,he to'�al project cost.
-Y�i-_�.-.,�.on Services - $2,�+75.00
_.,�sce�?a�e��.;s Char�es - $ 615.00
�� -;�:1d ne �;r recoL}:°:�da�ion �i��at `he i;?zxee projects listed herein be treated
�.s o�e order and tne hearin� and ad isability before the City Council be held +
. ��je�..nr. . . . � . . . . .. . . . .
I� ;;•�.. �w-,-e 2�;' C':.°S�io:�s, �iease c 11 �^�e.
�'e��,� �-r�:, �ours, ��
�� - �-�.._:._ /
/ '
� `,/�.ri�/,;L ���.�.-,----.�_
J. T;�`_�lia:� Dono-fan
t �
� �Tai_u�.'.:ion Er,�ineer
�T,�:P�J?�:d_^�
cc: ;�izl�er �ur�ley
t
��:;
,. :
�
. . � - ----• - --- - - • - - J,ry arff,
.. . . . . I�'lJ��:�o _�:
,
VI . RECOMMENDA710N �
The Department of Public Works feels that this is a necessary and
worthwhile project and should be presented to the citjz�ns via
neighborhood meeting. ulminating at a public hearing before the
City Council. •
Yours very truly,
Daniel J. Dunford
� Director of Public Works
CLT:AJS::-5 �
Attachment
cc: Watter A. Hurtley APPROVED:
� :
Frank D. Marzitelli
City Administrator
y . .
..- . ... . — � . . . .. . ., 1 yaem
f��
+ � , , Honorahle Lawrence D. Cohen -2- � May 24, 1974
ill . EXiSTING CONDITIONS
Old Hudson Road from Bi�mingham Street to Luella Street (one
block west of Ruth Stre�et) consists of concrete pavement 24 ,
- feet wide. The pavemenit is in very poor condition and the ^
curbing is badly deteriprated.
I
O1d Hudson Road f rom Luella Street to McKnight Road is a 30 foot
wide bituminous roadway with bituminous curb on the south side.
Drainage for the roadwa is carried by ditch sections a�d by catch
basins that are inadequ te. In order to eliminate this, a new
. storm sewer, Project No S-1539 and drainage system is planned for
construction along with the paving. �
IV, SPECIA L CONSIDERATIONS
On December 20, 1973, tt�e City Council passed a Resolution (C.F; No.
� 262810) which designatedl Old Hudson Road frorn White Bear Avenue to
McKnight Road a Municip�l State Aid Street.
Old Hudson Road was con eyed to the city in order to facititate its
inclusion into the CiLy`s Municipai State Aid System and to make it
eligible for the use of �5tate Aid Construction Funds during the 1974 " �
construction season.
� Old Hudson Road (the no th frontage road ta I .S. 94) from approximately
800 feet west of Ruth Street to McKnight Road, which was relocated and
constructed by the MinneIsota Highway Department with the work on I .S.
_ 94, was transferred to the jurisdiction of the City of St. Paul
� effective Apri1 1 , 1974.
V. PROPOSED IMPitOVEMENTS _
, � The construction which i scheduled for 1974 will consist of constructing
a 32 foot bituminous rba ay from Birmingham Street ta Kennard Street,
a 36 foot roadway from K nnard Street to Luella Street and a 40 foot
roadway f rom Luella Stre t to 400 feet east of McKnight Road. The ,road-
� way will be 44 feet wide at White Bear Avenue in order to provide for
turn tanes. Minor slope,�easements a�e required at va�ious locations
and minor land acquisiti�n is required for a turning radius and roadway
widening adjacent to the�5un Ray Shopping Center. B-624 curb and gutter
wilt be constructed the ntire i.ength of the project, sidewalk witl be
constructed on the north side from Kennard Street to Pedersen Street,
and a new drainage syste will be constructed.
The new roadway will pro ide turn lanes for the Sun Ray Shopping Cente�,
a smoother riding surfac and a better t�affic system.
, �
. _ _ �
. I . .
� �: �
� � . . . . .., � ',r . ... . .. . . .. . . r ' '.'.{ r .
w . . , I � ' �1''
' . . . � . . 4, '1TT p.,`' . . �. � . . . � ..,
V
a y _
� ��'
. ...
CITY OF !SAINT PAUL ' ,1�
n;�
,.
,..
�
Caprtel iof Mi�nesota . �: �y ;«.
i � � � � � � � � �'' -
DEPARTMENT �OF PUBLIC WORKS
234 Cihr HaN � Car1 Hou� 65102
�;
DANIEI� J. DUNFORD
D i�recto r ' ' � `
f . .
.�:
.1u1 � 5► 1974
�
I
Mr. Robert Trudeau I
Director of Finance �
Room 109, City Ha11
BUILDING
Attention: Paul Desch I
I Re: OLD HUDSON ROAD - Birmingham to
McKnight
i P-0503, P-0540, P-0613
Dear Sir:
Attached are copies of our recom endations to the Mayor on the above
project, and Administrative Orde No. D-1383, directing the public
hearing to be held.
We have held the Public Informational Meeting, and an outcome of that
meeting was that a 36 foot biturt�inous roadway would be constructed from
Birmingham Street to Kennard St eet in lieu of the 32 foot roadway as
stated in the report to the May�r (Item No. V, Proposed Improyements) .
Also, the Administrative Order ites "Slope Easement Drawing No. 2228,�
Slope Drawer No. 2" as an exhib t. This was changed to "Opening and
Slope Easement Drawing No. 2263 , Drawer No. 4 (two drawings) , and I ,
have attached a copy of this dr wing (along with the descriptions) .
The other drawing referred to i the Administrative Order� No. 2258,
is the R.O.W, to be deeded to t e city from the Minnesota Highway
Department.
We will also be constructing a storm sewer in connection with the
Paving (City Project No. S-153 ) and it will be financed from M.S.A.
and P. I .A. funds.
Please set up the public heari g for this proJect.
For your information the follo � ing is a description of the proposed
improvement:
;I
:,
` `�
. , . ' . � . . . .. ., . . . . � . ... . � ..� � ._: . , .'p
. . � .. . � � . . . � � . . .� '� ¢
t � - . .�•�. . . . . . . . . ,.. . .. . ' � �y�.. .; ^ .;.�,. .-.,. '. '''ab}+:.
. . . . �A � . . . . . . . . . . . .
. ''I . , . � � � • . � . � � . . � . ... ��� .
+, . . � . � � � . . ���� f',
Mr. Robert Trudeau � July 3, 1974
..� ��� ,��
,/: ,�;�"; , u
. � . �I . � � �� . . ' y 1� "
ln the matter of improvi�OLD H OSON ROAD fr� Birmingham Street to y'�� " �;�{,
.. khr.
approximatety 400 feet e��aF_�,,+of M Knight Road;� City Project No. P-O�il�, y ^+'
aiso construction of a��5"rm sew�r, City Pr�ject No. S-1539, es fo� 1ow5: f :
G� ,4,;
% Regrade and pave OLD HUDSONIROAD by widening the roadbed to 36 feet 1�' F
` � from Birmingham Street to L ella ' t and to 40 feet; from Luella� �
� Street to approximately 400 feet�of McKnight Road, construct' > �, �`
/�� � concrete curb and gutter, d iveway�, storm sewer drainage facilities, ,. Y�,
�
(� ,� a trafftc control system at �White Bear Avenue� construct concrete ����
.,,� . ^.�h walk on the north side of 04D HUDSON ROAD from Kennard Street to
�� Pederson Street, construct storm sewer from Hazelwood Street to ;
Flandrau Street, landscape outevards and do all other work necess�ry
,,;
' and incidentai to said impr vement.
' Also, acquire easements in �he lands as necessary for slopes, cuts
and fills, including right c�f removal of lateral support from � �
subject lands or remainder �hereof, occasioned by excavations thereof
or construction of slopes , in the widening, paving and improving of
OLD HUDSON ROAD from Birmin�ham Street to approximately 400 feet
_w��as��;:of McKn i ght Road. � '
��,,,�,�..,..� .
��' �
f Also ac uire ermanent easlments for street and highway purposes on,
q P q
� ?� � over�and across the followir�g described lands:
A. All that part of Trect C, R gistered' Land Survey No. 91 described
.� ' as follows: Commencing at the northeast co 'rner of said tract; thence
- � south along the east line o , said tract a distance of 831 .45 feet
�; to the point of beginning of� the land to be described; thence south-,
westerly, deflecting to the Iright 56 degrees 28 minutes and 14 seconds
c4 � �� ,,4 ,1 a distance of 11 .05 feet; th�ence southeasterly a distance of 10 feet
`� � ;•�4 along a .curve not tangentlal with the last described llne, said
� '� � curve is concave to the nort east, has a radius of 683.21 feet, a
t �
central angle of O degree5 5 minutes 1� seconds, and the chord of
said curve deflects 123 degr{�es 31 minutes 46 seconds, to the left
from the last described line� thence north deflecting to the left
112 degrees 56 minutes 28 se` onds along a line (east line of said �
Tract) not tangent to said c rve a distance of l0 feet to the point
of beginning.
B. AT1 that part of Tract 0, Re ist�red Land Survey No. 200 )ying south
of the fotlowing described 1 ne: Commencing at the southwest corner '
of said.Tract 0; `thence east rly along the south line of said Tract 0,
a distance o� 229. 13 feet (2 9•77 R) to the point of beginning; thence
�asterly atong the last desc ibed south line extended, a distance of
469.43 feet more or less to ts point of intersection with the south
line of said Tract 0 and the e xerminating.
;�;
1�
� . . . . � ykr:
. . .��:. � . . :_, . , . ;.. � N.
. � . . � . � ` . . . •� ��.. �;�.
. . .. � .. � .. . � � . . .. r .,.
,�:`' v • i '� r y4q��,�
• . � . . . � . . t,
• � .
. Mr. Robert Trudeau - - July 3�, 19'74
` ,
,�.
if you have any questions or require additional information, please
contact Allen Shetka at 298-5311 • -
Yours very truly, ,�-� ,"'
- .s
: ,.,�? �,,A ,�,.•''1 t�,,.,,,. ..__ >'
•� �.�/� . �'`.`'s�''�,``,� M1,
� �..,� . ,
Daniel J. Dunford �'
��
� � � � �� D i rector of Publ i c Works � � � ���� � �
,:
CLT/AJS/ck ,` �
Attachments � ,t'.'
cc: J. William Donovan
K.
�
�
.
, , ;
� �a :,'
� � � � ,. ^.,
� � , .
� ,
� �s���o
i
_ � ; _
; .� �; , ���.��
�a{. �k ��. ����:3y . .
NY'�.��.tY '
3 I �I ^� '
- i. ...� �����;
��Y��-'1�'
�
I F��,
T
���
ti�
�f; t,
aatyd
�: �-
at:�I, � , �
c i�ll ,�`-
r
a
a
�
� .
,°� i:" ,}�,i���.��.
� ���I
� ;:
i� �
v:
q�k.
: w �; �,;.
.��r�w , ,�
a r
ti+�t��: �.'
mt tr��
�� � i
II
� II I,
'��^:<
�I �ai
;i: U
�
�
I�:
�'�` 1 �
�y�. ��
�..�
y��_
'��Ri�'� ..� .:.<i-
��" '
.{ h 'c. �8` �� g• 1�
S jy
�'L
1�!,
c
�%� i.� /_�, ' !i$'Jl''
� F��� J� 1'h _ h .
�4L�0 �-�e �. �e� �-+& y %1"�,�Tr ' s �{,,"7�`�, z .�W�r �� .. ,r� ,:f�r - ,�:�, ..���.
� _ ��q`iT���},��5��-� �" 'r,� �r� 'a��i t ��� Y y=�*1��'� �'�e �+�. y <�`�l� � �,�i4.�x�. 1 �i� . i, � -
� # �fl���.��J '� af�y�����r�������`"s`� �'���, � t : �r � �5� .�' {y '��. 3r� �`t�,'���,�b��� �� ;�� `., , , .
s,�r'� a rh t �r� F) Y y� t k y x �T"��r � �" ��, �A
�F T 7 �_ ,m � �' 3 �� `"¢
��. .14�,k",h +�x tYi.� Yt f � ' t? # � '`a � � .�}�4h� -i i,;,^ �'+ � � y�
� :� �� rca•'� �� r,� '� �� � � v r. '�:r � � � '�! � �i' , , � :3 y��:
rE 1�,`�€� ,a� ,: z� ���� �i� �sk��,w i s �, � ' '�� �r *r r �;F e�,�� �i�,�� "�
��,�,�'�-�.` �� r�`�.�i �i � � �'`. i a �" ' �,« i ."} r " '.. ./ b�"uki � ; ...
N ��`3�"'t�w��.,,:�s�" r,. � SY = � } i>. '��w � ry{+� °�f "i �py ,��h e ':,g � ��,� �s ," � �{, t�� 6y,.r x r p1 a
y �L �l}��f°»�', ,'+� , x 5 i4��v� }Z'� � { ,a i ,��.)� `� j-�� �. i : e3> l .� y x c, X `f. 3!' � # y�° S .� # a .. �t� �� ii
�� 1� � Y t- ✓� ��' � f � �,`� �r' .: � � / . � t , � � y� �� �
� �,' �i �Y- '���X+ . �jp
*( .�� Z ��� �' �'� '.�'i� ri �� � f; S�� �� � t'� t"�: ° :y t f y�: 1;�+,p F��P'�-t`r i H!k t a ,'�"',*�i a'
4� .i + j �,� r{ t.� ti �$ ,� ' ,a. � .<� �r7' x :; 4.°,t � a� g��`��a w", # ,�rL
�.�'.!;��'�,.:,a r � r:�."t t � �� � '� �' 'w�{� , �+ ��.�, r� n �y.��a� �£� t h' S��y��.� iF s+a��� y�ik'�. ',�4-y5 k+�":SJ�k�s��°
.i.� k"x l�t� fx.' � ` -� J b' .5���� a „ -/ �'�, ,� � 'z�y4 ��.. y`���v.c`�(_ ����� 4 ������ �
���A�. ��°:)� �R�k: ' ti, :�+ ° G ' t w � r �.y ' � � �` t � k i d:<} �°�`f 4'�" �} �'� �� `�k� ���+�w"��t ��
� y f w
�� � ,iy �::S t� c+ ti � �, , `y e a ;,j�N� v,y�,�f �t y�, x * , 7 �t i� t �$�90 ��3w�� a �S a
�l a'�' • �.z � �r � � M :M� f.-�k 4 8: N .�t�' '�`r `�° .�S e„� #r't: �j,k.a�` ".,Y���i.`,y
r . Y,�; 4 j ��.w.�� � 2 I'+ f � � r ., y�. a �, �'�. r�; ay{; y �, F '3b�C�i J�. �r� „� ��t;-
� �',��' .ni r� .K:i.� 5 F'�::R { �. Fi.. ��.,���r' ���r�� ' � �cyti4���� _ ��.7 �i ... � 3E'E`e,�.4� �ys,�,,,�,+� ��.,y�� �r��
�'aR��`�.�a�t '4 h + S . d� } ti I ,;t � i �.3•' : + i i 'Yd �nn 34 a,� i a t 3'� "fi � "�i
r �� �,t .�r `'�" 2'�. +f `i �. '�`-a Q y � rj. ,i� �` .. �t t. t� .� r,� ��.� �t a� r �.��.�R�'�f �.a�aA+ �'� ,�+,����* >�...
3 a"k � . � �z .�.. ,�:t j� t i .�i-- { i' �# �:� u ^s �� r .�,� 'F S ��.-Yr R�
'�w��+��6n!F.t� � �:,� � � 1 +.����'�r �� �! ���3 .;���'� ..�_' Y�y�x.,�.;� � :k �4 �'o.��� �''�4�� rD,��.�+z��,�4�H i b ��$'���t ��� l.
r� t ''"' �: 4 � y� ¢ is � cy�,'I �' Y� +. 1 � � ,�' ':�, 4 i ,� E�f� +'`.d� ea ��d f i,C �4r;��,$'.f�'s) �, >� <m� „,}. z°' �
t i� � � � : ; a '� �� '"4 f �f z : � '. � -n'� �� : �+ �,; � +�,.��t t�,
��� J��a,f � r v� � :. � �i �'. -���, � e ' �. r� S� �t : '` r,Z r Z �i �.:F`� L '�� � � �:K �,�:��� � r.�
�d�1w 3� +� ;�� / '� * � �M #.:i2 r k� t,, � �'��rtn } e d�.:�,� t �.,��yj�x,wa r�� ,�.�,r�� ,,�,-v'* r�!,��qt��"��,'/��R i-a�i�,*rliar�.�1C��'�'����
` ��g� �,k � r �'f" { �, �� ,� .; r�� . e:• ;d y "h a a �.. �4 1 �* �` �. � .,'!+�`fC'� �€ ��?`Y^�i "k��
r� � �#�;.� . .�. x. �t . "'r k �,: " ;3 "Y"�;� ;i'i.. .i�.'h i '� . f tiI ! g ,'�v au� �� '�E� a; p,x��r' � s�t ,�'af,. ,r
�'� xe^ri, k fr�,�'L'.q ":� rw�M �-: � ��,, :,� r � �{ s,; er � � s:'�y Je�t�,� w � ' t ,� �x k� ; �
`��€ � t .� xi• � ; s" t r r �� �, � � .,� .X x � z*:� � et�4�, �w. ���b� ; f
r�yY , �r.'x�fi �a� r.� 3ra¢,�k „�� . � s, � r �. ,t .'.'� a ,�;:� �,•�� rF�,�`;�j, � �,t a, F } �
�;� 7 '�n, � .�vw�t�4 i�' ��` �. 5 4ei �w +. v �.�'� ,� � �'�, �? u} � t�����r� �'^ 4y-���(C': .
s�a�i� � �ih� f ,�F �fi s d tG 1 �1 l� .7� r � �;� � �:� l }r �r 4 .� 4� � �x,�e r�, �f k ri�''��'yr,j � :�P4'�Y�-.�S-xi�,.;.P�..
�"1r,,� k�l�:.� �ti �� 1;' � �r F �'� � -� }*'' d #�, 1 r{�� 7° �:��e :+x�,� � 7 }� r,& ��:r, ��x�rd m"�y, ��{�
a�� � a� �'! ���� �� �`�; '� � ` �t� �'r . � f i ;� f r�'„s v� £ �� ��� �''h .�":�� �aF��Z,t✓ � ��� 4't"
"! �� ' � �. rr w ' � x j: �� ; .��'. ,',i�€ .F u� , ;� •1- A+. . t �- �'y k .� �`# � �;a �
��t F x h^rx� t .a ,.,4 �':'ip a� '�s-� � ��� 4:: � �i t - i �4.t, � '�y1 . a f � �� ta 7��,.;g yf,� �"+�W� +Y'*�i'r = t �, �'���� � •
.� �! ' ci i' i � E �, �-,S. -+c� y �� � � 1 ` y x «�.'
�f� �,p J ^A�. ' �1� y ' i4 aE �• 'A'(' � � I � � }1 �Y':�� � �4' �ih��.f,�l�a j 1 y+�' °y�����_� �v
�x4��*F�� �ti �'����� �'e�, .,%�C f Tj�; N �' f{ y���� 7 �� 3'� � *'J� ��; � �5•` 'ii. # �.f i t��. '�� �` � � �.� �+1�i��•- *` �,�4����* �::� ^i°f�_r ,�"t' "
4 '
7,�� S.� r �`�x.-� ,k fi �,� � x � Y.� ;�' t t ' ` ��{- r �. ° �r% � �vfi�"':� � � r� �� r
`��i'N..�`�FAy�� r; � M.a f ,«:r ;n +£ `'� � �- � a.r y -.� r-y� .7 r�` x,�. { r F �,'{ �; �.s1N;�'�,��^�4::; t �.� '�'s. 5�y`r��.,,� rb'
''�'k r.`. � ':d "rrs t.;,� � .. � l.. r ,��¢� 4 ; s � �� 3 L �.. r £ {: 7.s.�.. �"+ y��y;� � ,� ��r�M����t_�
^� �i? � Sp -,�- 3� x P'� ,;� � > i �c�'M tt ' f � i6
�e,.. r' 4 4 , � t � .+ ,a !p z '< c �.. � +`,n{ �. � a:
*... 1 �� t 5 ,;�1 � .^�fi � l' ,j t�'. ; S�: i. � +� °� st� �} S� $� K� �..
+�t'.�r �.k�'Syi C+'" d 1 e c9� Yi��s S^ '"�`:�;� f +s f �_ ��k x ti r �y� Y '.:, },y� �'�. �$,� y �, x��H�r � L c Y�'k {_..y�� t `�a �+
�'� <°��r � �^ k �` ���� �c fri r �.d z i "� j ' ��,��� h y : � s Y ��* �d��1�� 3 }�"`s a
�`. �" �� °�+ ¢x � s °F+,��,. � } �� �- " /f .:�.y���"a ,:� -s.��� {�� ��?�1'" '�}'S�t e � r.�`���3 �; F
��y� „'", - �_� �. e"�:� � µ� r�z r-�++y � c .�:.=+i .. ����- . s �'.�� i �`» `,� � r'e KF .fu �,tYt� ����+..
��" .,. ,i- 1 - ar��r *� x �.. t-, � ,;�" �t y �i}'+ (`�':y i q�+'. � � .�. ��, ti.. '+.yk M' °,'a. � :. y ..
i , �. v 1 � �"; t -.,�`� A `� �. ,� ` i ��. 1 , A`z ,� � � � � �,�' ��������� � t F ��� �S .�d
�' `� `�-. � '� i�.t �� �:��r i K a � �� .� i '�- � �`�� � '� x�t � t i '��� � ai�--� A '�,,{: '� � r - � � r�`�'�+'Y�,,���n��
� t �
�_y"d h d �� i ��f � 7 T f. .` k .:��.� � .:.:� F'` k�' � Z� t�j F�l`.#' � � ..�`??i w�. �a }�`� u9�t'a�.
tT ��'v h� , u � � KF 3; t � ' t � � �i ' * "'�� � �{ :, x t�+ty� '^�. p�
�a . � � :f a-" ��- �+z♦� '# r�� '� ��,�� 3 u ; z „ - 47 t,�a r�` � '�Sr��n s t'
+SY�u h��..� �y e� z.�1 �kvJ l ' s r ;1 k 4T. � 1 ' 1 kt .3, 4, ` � -.t'� r t J`, a � w fi. *�- '�� ����������
,�;. �,�„�:)s A �' -1 1 ,�y � } a n e- �i�� � < ;,� �. ' � S Y�. i k.�t�y { ��Y I �4., �`��a��K �'� ;e 9 L�
�f`.��. A���e � � `�;� ), ti�� � #�` k .i 'f . � d Y j� .c i ,y t d! -��r�t��� "��t� � � r . ,�. ���i'�y>A�_+3Y i��>,�"t`�, l "�,�''�.''i
"�" r�,� • F <<s ic��� e� � ., � �� t � fi�^�,, � �.'�a����kr + �,� .�� '.�"�' ,f ��+��`�
s 4� ,it^S'�,1 x�K� .� -1 r� � � a �,�;z n,S"� N X ' a ` �. � ; w"1�t ���qe `"'s��
.� 2�, p .r r c �".^l f !� +r 'y �° i J � •A � ��`� �l�. �"�t. � "«r-�
� J��,4 i 5� .� �;�� � ��� ���x � .: � � : y ��aF:#bs ��FTa�n-,�� n:. +f � .. d .i� y� � �+y��� �
"�"` a' {�,�Y � ��. . �:� ;N '°4��,x p -�•�Y ���':��� 5 s' �y .�,,,,A E's y, r <'�� gr�°t ,�yt�
r � r rJ� *�2 tfp t '�*.�,P � C^t t;� e� � r-�= l� , � � .,-. .t'�r ...�.. .�,+��,-„g�"'e j a ,�� x ,�
k��Yi:r4ij ?xt��r�'wr�s�. "��r �I�ts�;�r I � �4 s. � � v�'�rt�{ ���.-' "�wt .�,;� �' ,S,'�` t� � .�w<r.:� � ���`�rs�r . �°Fa �p� '.r:����{�''�'a�z s •r,
k�, '�r tS.`,t t �'�� t. � yi � 41 ` .X x } 'Sr�..:y. v ,�p,� � yx,�'�kr,3t `h' Xq* �� 1:�..+ .y, y6 *� k'��_'���
�k""`:� ,�R �# y, � '�'�x.. � , I � .�`�. y � �, .� i �'r r �,3 �l t t a:�e{ x�� A r f' a�
4} Y+ i . .: ,., .:., .. y .' 4 �"i i''.. , ¢ }� L�y�'�7�,y .N 7 � f ..4 u }5�� �
f.,,� t Y. " 4 ��F " F��' X � �'�1 S� : (' f F
t �# r f.F°�*r°r t +''�h: . s�� .� :i� z .�, a ,� .",� '� n�^ 1 x t �, ��✓ +a"�� .
i������Y� � ,a��'�x dz . .� °.'�'. � ti y N'. ( i � � �' ��.�? d r r.€ ��� t a��'� �a��x 3° 4 i;h,.��w���'���"µ�a,� a�;a�.�r ��.�,}*, �� �.:� ��..
�� w` �r �; ti�r g j;- � n.';x.�� .f.i 1 't a _ ,,t ,� �:T i^ ,�,. s � � � } � � � �� �� i �,� � 1!,�`,
�i L.t` .���,� q . a + � E. �c tf� f . � � '�,. �:� yg+r�k.�`'��6:�ir r r�s� �}fi '� ���.ar� 'e`�k�i+n°,t�°R•�.
�� +��a Y .� + '� � �, ( c e �< �t } �'s., S���tr 7' � :�+. � S���_� s . � � y., t� .�1�� `
� �� a h � x . �� .�' '� � , i � r, ' � � �+.�+� F k "S `t�a r Y !� fi '
t � ��� � g ��k i'�� r '�> 4 y. u' � r�l J'a �fi .�i- 1 �
�R� �� � � Y4 Rn F r� yj? � �,.+ y;b y .:1�. ^t�. 4�A,p yf�x,�"� ,y. '".'$ i �
"R. Y�R t if: � d a"1d �};� x �t }� �(. � .r � Y J.5�i/[ :.�A � ,�tt i � � � �'`� �`� � ,. �' +,�+ '�
� �i i ''y, 'a� # a E � -p-� s <� ,k,
4 � ` { Y ��i ,� ���„��``��.
�.
� ����„ n �� � ...°�. x � '� � ,�ii� �.,.��,e �n
�� Y°! ,r €.�. t , ,� _ 6: s-� �+f's i " „Y �4 ,:, ''�w�µt`5 � y��'2 {a'
�! Z -.. c�a t�. € y, ':k'�r:A"�' t� �'� � �
� 14. ... -. 4
� � 5 �2 >� t � � � x„- }� �� � � _)�. p� �. �
�, � c t � < �,�td �r� -�� 'Y � "�'x
r ,Y��. `6+� ' , � s�.. � ��`� � r�n�' �
s
�y 3..�,�,� i{h��'Z `�S, E � � y ,t� ; K . f f _ � ;�� 1:•� h"+'�{�`�,r���¢ � A{���^,�z�� .;�
� t �ii g Y .f,� .�'+'ia' i . hr� aP
S }� $ •a t � :a
qd �. ! �� .f��.. � f,- - {F ,�,i � R �t�T 1?� ,.4��4n S.f� ���.1�.
C� i.� � r a �/ '� � 'F'3� � `+j�2.�a' §�� :' � .`�`t�'�-tp�e �in i a�� �aM 'S:���{
a ���j�' � "<'��.3 ��� } � t > s...� T t . ��.vt;�� a�i.�y�e'��..H :"i� �� .�'4c R a. si� y g�, ?�a '' �x � �yV:a.�,�s s�r ��x �7
E x �i tr� i�. f r ?. 4 ..� k t ':.} y _` S � � y � �.� . �� � �.� ���-`�at� � �b � ` b�`�..�n�:.
! � �, ,{� �` ti i 4 � '� r.. �, u x,��,� .� '�<�'�i�� ,�:,r�t? ��h�' ".��'� � r �
� �:'� {f 2^ 'i � f; � l r !�x�:�X �; f � � $*� �C 1-; kr�1 �' ,y� 1 7 � ;g:�,,� �;;,w�'�� (�:5+, � �,-wt��,�r§�� �...
S�`a� �t���v$x 'C�''�`' a, � Y� ;�,a'4 ''�i 'ti' , a k`b�t'�� �. ��'�"'� ��C S�� ['k) t� �" �,�k�r °�'>�'g��»��e�s'i�.��.�
�+ d �`Y i` .. r ; � U !� "a.°J'�4h .rk`"I. 12 Y t.k7 3'�. "y �`.. y� N�'l l�
��, 1` �1'" t x ' .<J 2 .,r ,i J . c ,�a/t �si�t a.i r� �,a i5 �� ��f:c j�"T��{7' +Y..�..
� � Y� l 1's +L � - [ - �( 8^7 �.���k , x � x �.';4a x! � �� h � c�� i* � y 4 Z
��3 y ,, i � . :,� � 3� ';A� � #t d ! "' t � b' ±+ d�� � Ex , s% n� e;� ,� 7.`�' � - �. 'a, � w, t v i .,3�r 4��.�; �,
G�, y� ( :N i� � � '�s � ,ax � rh�,. �E, -�ys J y� v"�t, y_ ti '(e"3�h�.
9�� �"%�d � � Z' $�: � � aF Y .4 �. � � 1�-, k. �'�� ,� ��yk 5:� '$f�'� �1Yr'. �` �' 'S ' � .'�k �}�l. N:
k �.{� � j. N 1�' fi Y �l ' �.; � �3 Y' a '1� F4 � s� �/ '� �'� T�p�5�.+�t s
�� ;.1 : y w:� � l S`x , y � ' j ��� y .� _�3 7 '� �S �'4'�."�C :� ,"�. �^F..
k s„ M �,'-' , a r .,1 �' {
�,�� � � r '� � J 3 '�a �a: �' ' \ a �"' +T� ` �, "� �,� c � �!a r ,"s�i 3`� a� sti,:
� '.�z �'� � 1 x°;. ,4 ..'y ` � •� � J-, S :r 1wrY ?'i t �y!' l 3�'kC �''_i .�" t T �.,�,. �o-�
��. ':. yr�,,� - ' +�, , .� �7t ,. �q a:'Y^S 1 IIf,`.'yt� � i ; #.
� -�. .��. _yr ��; e��\ e � "�� E1'; � �ly, � �, J z. f i� •�T?F �9 �s �y.a�� �S{, +.�� �,;r �r�?�r f �.: d t 4°u'ei:�
��+s � � a,3 i, � .F E '.# , y � � �`'t �t i� ��- �� � X'- � '� �'� ���7�+"� a
r �' � `, '. x � ��z" ` � � fi4 ,�' :� ��,� � � ��s4+s
���'��:*4+'�"� ��J t�`� _�t �s ��.� � '' r i "",��t R i y;s �r c a� �S F. ?rGr`:�1^�?.+�'��F` �', i `"{"� �::� �-���'��� .
�. y,` � �;a> 1 ; b :t t �}t r"M t°r 'I!Y F y�` �t.� � -� '� �� ����,�'f zti-�' G rc�.�:r�k�''$.
� t: � '� y �.�r `4 � ,�f '! �F ,. • u 1� �, ��.� .5. ff tr 4� i '�`��i"�4.n''�i+ � "�'a '
� �. c w . .. . a 4 r � i i ��-t i F..�� �;''�r f r ;�S� � ..t}� t f�.
;, �� {' i' ' F a.- '� a d ' `'� �„ , �j x K Fy � � � G ��� „�+p � � ����:
�=�..,�a d t�?� {t .�.'4 �' F : s r^ f'; ��; . 1��«�+ +` � � ;e�, F� �.{t )F 8 i. r �_'� v, � t `k- i1`r.��
�,�, r t �. 'G7� . 3 .<� - f i:. .�� -' c �' .�r�� - � ° x t�" y ^;� E n s ��4r'+d�ci' 'wa"��'(� .��z+.
s� a.� ��;'���,� �' �..` �:,.y a.,�; i \"s. i z ��` ,+, � �'N�� "� v :ti5� ��,�, �44 ; �a��''s "�a.�'Ci i,1� kx� ,�.�r�,,'.
'�-�,W.�,i� y F4 >.� �, � ,q : 3�' �,.Y Y ' i� ` F � ar��� .Ai r ��t��'�7��t' ..�, 3 �7,F�.'� r �. , r Y.�t "'��j{;y fr�k5 3.
+�'e i fi '� .t� . w � n��.# 3�x 1 G n� z.��'. k r 7 �' e �&*�``s '� �, s���
� �'�i� E , _ "� ��4. i y i s � T� .�' � �`' � 3� .y�.�:� �F. °3�`:.
�y' d. ,�i y � ��,��� j '�?µ W � Y , ,y F 4 r " �„t` '� � �I£°yq : z a,�, ,� � c.�.:��'�71 ��}`� ^i� .��. t�i7�i 7,�{���'��� "
fp` �}5�.:.3 ,y ' �-`� r -;s .s.�{ / ' t �s.�r .s � ._ � ,�' `^���Z 4 a''ys.,: 6'� 1 � {. ���' ��eSF�i ���7 rC°�°t>i ��� r_.,ap'`�'�.
4� ;� k� � ,� ' � . ;r`; � s �. . � � �y � � �r �fi ;�ra��a��'3d �; �' � �t'�F'x
�,+�� � n� h � ,� ,'�` f+ ��' �. a ' ^`l � "`� �"S aY,� �� y ,�� � 4�r � t� , �,�,xi��4�-�€.� *s�f �-
i�i e�' «$�y,n��' �, k�� x. ��. '\ "F '!k ��1 c�: ,�'. rip,d� �s ��{`��, f f'ba-�r ��` .,��X, lt„jy 'r �W.f wti :�;.
�.� ��,�'F r�'•. �i dv S t { dw# �,y �'4 �"� � � '�'".c4' •�� s f �� � T. �� art'F r�+l r�t��d t� {� r A �`, ?- �,�gr��.�'�p�E�YEr* ��.�__ .>
'�� �I` !'` � � �UX � � > ��� r �,.� x `�.*� ,:a.Y' a- �^ `' { t ..��t^' rl"s� ..'��y ��.�F3i-�'"�.''�"�°�'♦ ,� z��-�
fi � :. �s ,�' t ! { 1" � x �'�.w�F' +,� ��- {�� 1�'� i�, �.
���q ';M {h ;��� ��r�'r sx-`�'�i 4r:`� �a �, e�, `�t�� f,,,,� �,��' ..i � .� �� Y�`` � r't l �. {y f�� y,�^.�,.�, y ... �y ... ���`� �..
t + t 1 .yf ti} � ..,s y � �.�,, t�+�.�;.� �i� �` �"� 4� a1,�p�' ''� � � �t'` L�,,y'y`�!� tt^ t.�t�3 .+y' �k���s���.K.,�
E C �L-�� ,j� � ��. {'f �°` S .�1� ' d '9 �.� �1'�� � �Y 'Z. J � fil`A(t'�J� A d f�-¢,°"` ri.rBS�°
��`�41��f�>t il� t' -�t �, �.,;tft�� � 4,i r �r �kN i�_�T�,f�z .1 1 �` � .� �. X t2 't'4"^�H��x..� 'g�Y ✓' ���,y.�. �� t ��1;��'r �',��y���� i {..#�.,�`bf���'�.f,
'*7;��!,� � a '��� r A. ` � � � : � �� i � �`u3 �1 �� ��'"�; ��'�i � #'�r � � f iis ,� b �- $� +�i�da 1�i � ie
�h,�i"` .� � � J� aC �� � ..t t .t ��, . � „a � .tl�. 6 �4 i '� : r '�}t ard e �; � � �X- � 'T3i �>�e:
;�,"�,yc.�.. a3 w #� -.��X .k< :k � � '^"' � �,,.i .r �-t X� t�y �a� Ysr,( �,'E. �, '�,, u �5 :�jf��'u'�j ;��j,�.,,� �Yr�yi�' �a.�.�, s '
�tz� 'i'; Yf+AI" a' ,� *. ,, 4� . . � '^t A �+ +. � rir iP ,}tz �,T ;' ; tf � 4� �,� � � y��,L�: ��'�eliT�',�C�..� .
� .m { ;'�� �Q� �-;r� r ;ax G�' x * �� j'� . 7r: \ � r:: �' tr �', c h � .,4 �- ' 3 �'
� � � � � , `� �, �� ��'
�
.°:�a.r�_�� . =�'.ia,,.��1'�..�a3C.x,a�.��..e r_T� �.._��.,. �.-:�..et .... . _., h..�_�._ :�.'r`� _t-�5:>�na, „� �:���.�. .��,.w�..F.,�.' zC M...i�.,��;.-..�'�,�w,�..a.. . :�:�`:,�'�). =n' '
' CITY OF �AINT PAUL C � � �� �� �O
� OFFI(7E OF T8E CITY COIINCIL
M�M�
M/�
November 5, 1974
DAVID H. HOZZA
Councilman
City Clerk�s Office
Room 386
City Hall & Court House
� Attention: Mr. Michael Sirian �
The following ma.tters have been disposed of by the City Council:
Letter of the State Environmental Quality Council
transmitting a petition requ�sting an environmental
impact statement affecting p�operty bounded by
Larpenteur Avenue, Interstat� 35E, Maryland Avenue
and Edgerton Street.
.�;'� Matter of the assessments anc� sidewalk construction
for the improvement of Old H�tison Road from Birming-
ham St. to approximately 400 feet west of McKnight
Road. (Final Order adopted wl3�th the understanding
that sidewalks could be deleted at a later date) .
The question of the environmental ,�mpact statement was answered
in the evening public hearing on the paxking lot permit for the Dokmo
Development. That meeting was held Tue�day, October 22.
� The question of the assessments on Old Hudson Road has been
disposed of in the Public Works Committ�e and has been approved by
the City Council.
Please eliminate these matters from your Comm agenda.
s t �1 '
Da id H. Hozza
DHH:ls
CTTY HALL SEVENTH FLOOR SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA 55102 612/298-4646
�O
---" Ca � '� � �//o -
,
/ - �
.
• ° �
�� � � � ,�
. . . . . . � ���� �-
pwuxWpu���.nwu�nwann.Minawa�M1IM/Ip',�
`� a�bG,��!/ p��
I-94 AT WHITE BEAR AVE. EXIT • 5T. PAUL, MINNESOTA 55119 • PHONE 612-735-2330
August 18 , 1975
St. Paul City Council
386 City Hall
Saint Paul, Minnesota
Dear Council Members:
This year the Council authorized the widening of the
Old Hudson Road, and work was started in May, 1975 .
The Ramada Inn Saint Paul located between White Bear
Ave.nue and Ruth Streets, on the south side of this
street (Old Hudson Road) , was subsequently required
to remove, and relocate a power pole .
Enclosed you will find the statements our Ramada Inn
has received for this work. It is our feelings that
the responsibility for payment should be placed with
the persons authorizing the widening of the Old Hudson
Road.
We would be pleased to further discuss this with you
at your convenience or at one of your Council Meetings.
Res y,
G��� ,D�
Tom i s ch,
General Manager
Ramada Inn Saint Paul
1870 Old Hudson Road
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55119
� " �����7� J•ii� \ /
�.�c��S r
?v��'Q ����u, (�
� u
ft� `i�+� �
� � �,Z i� u
MILES � � ' � i 1�-
Of �
L.�IlES a?,,�
Phone Yow Nearest RAMADA�INN for FREE-Confirmed—Nationwide RAMADI�[NN•STANTe Reservations
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS
DANIEL ). DUNFORD
DIRECTOR
April 21, 1975 �
Dear �Yiends: ,
The City of St. Paul has entered into a contract With Fischer Sand &
Aggregate, Inc. for the Widening and Paving oP OLD HUD60N ROAD from
Birmingham St.. to Mclinight Rd., including a atorm se�er, City Pro3ect
7S-P-0613• Work on this pro�ect is expectad to begin the first part
of May, �975•
The work is being done by the contractor Who is responsible for equipment ���
operation, providing for the safety of the workmen, and pro�ection oP the
residents along this pro�ect as �ell as the genera� public. The scene of
activity is very tempting to children a� a place to pley, d every preeau- ,
tion xill be taken while the xork ie in progresa, but smal�children don't I
always realize the possible danger around heavy equipment and can't a].Ways
be seen by worl�en intent on their aob.
We request your cooperation in warning the children of the danger around
the work and in keeping them away from the activity during the xork day
� and also from the construction site evenings and weekenda when �orl�en
are absent.
There also �rill be some inconvenien�e to reeidents along this atreet While
the `+ork is in progress. This will be temporary and vill be offset by the �
benefits frbm the completed pro�ect; so We ask you to bear with us until
the work is d+one. �
If you have any questioas about the Work, you are invited to call the
� Department of Public Works, Constructiob Division, telephone number
� 298-1►138. The contractor is Fischer Sand d� Aggregate, Inc. , 6801 W.
150th 3t. , Apple Valley, Minnesota 55124, telephone number .�+32-7132.
Very tru],y yours, RECEIV��
�-f ,;���.�- . ��� xe s��'a
De.niel J. Dunford �' J'��fl�
Director of Public Works w�L11�
- JFK/Ss - .
� � � � � � � �►;t�i�r ��n��t �s- � �
' 3�1��0 S�;�tt�l� �.li�
•� ����� �i�� �" �� ��7 LI'1'� . _ .
'Lf
. _ Q���� 234 City Hali, Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102
� , � . �. ,-
�` ��!`a ;;s{ , t .
w t . . , t i � � r���i
i�z � - � ':, J' � � � ��� � ��}" �„�' � �e a ��1�?
.� w� . . r ;t ;
YA � .
` j'J � _ , ��}' . � �g K h
l X '
t"� �
i � � _ . . - - . t � ',"�.� .. �� � y�
'."/ .... � ... . # h �'� . i . ' ' '� ' `.k Z�,.:��
.. � � . . 'q �� ? p
.. ,. � .' . 1 1�v � 'ft0 '�"�,
; i
:: ;
,
.;� ,r ' . '^ .
` . . . �. . - .. � . i , �' � �},
, , .-) . , .;.� `
! Y �I r,.. . - .. . . . .. . .. � . , 4 �a ✓....
� � . �. . . . /R .. . � \ . . \x 'E,;'
r .�, . . . . . i.
�. , . . � ,�: '.
. .
�• .,... . ,; . , '. . . , . ��_. .� . �- . '., , . ( . .,.. . . , •" j
' . . ' � . - � ai � ti
4 ' � .. �. , n� . . � . . .. , . ' . . ' � � h�,� , Y � J rl
S ` . ; ` .� � ' . _ . . f�.� , � . � ./- . . . ��di
l:
... . . . . , . . . .. '_ . . . . . . . . , .I' ., . ` 'A
\
" � '� ��. �P,
,,.k r_. — � � `.� �I` � � �„ " . � �
+ ,(� � �}, ,
. , � .
. .
�. . �
,,, _�,, .�, , � �� � �� � ,� �
, .
,
. , , • . .
� .
# ./ , , �� � � \ ;�
, ,
� � ��� � � �: � � -
,
.. , r : . , :
,.� . �
, , _
, � � >�,. t: , . : _ � ., Ya
� - �', ,
, . �r . �� �,:
, , ,
„ ,
� . ., :- `
� _ . _
- . , , . '
:, _ , . � . ._ : � , ,' : ,
� . , , _ .
. �
, . �
_ , . �:.. .
,
< : , �d., .
,
.
, �k
���
�
.. . _ , ����
�
. �
. � � �r� � . .. ' . , , * .. j �_.
.. % , i; , . ' S1 - .. . ' . .. . . .. . .. ' . . �;�. .
. _ .�1 �'''��'� ... � �. � . .� . . ` � ; - � � � � � ,,
- . F' '� . , ,tt � .�� �� �_: f �'`�. � . _ ,
.
1 �,:.����� � +��R��� � , y i ,
, .
. , , .
;
, . , .
1 �r �. yy�y���� ����� � �
.���. �." �R 711�q1��!!�!� .'�� ,�,�r � �' . .. i,
��� � .. � ,�,. �
, �, �.'� . , -
,� � : �� . '�;:_ � ��I�`'� �II► •��II� _
" , � x
� , . .
. . . : •- ;4,
, , , „
,
.
.
. -
,
. ����. : .. , #
.
. . :
, . , ;, �
�+ '
. �. , .
, f � e .. � . .�� ', � ���� ` . .f . , ' ... �
, " � . .. . . . ' . . . ', . � ' � � , . ' . �,''. . . -� {
. , .
„ �
., .. �� .. � �., ,. .�, .. . . . ... �, .
, , •
. ,.l ,. . . ,.. . - . . _ '..', ' . . �' . , : _ ,.. . ,
i . . � .. � .. , . _ . . � � . � . � .
. .� , . ... ,., . . y .. ,� � � :.
�.. . , . ` : r .
i .
, . ,
�
.. < , �� . �., - ..
. , i
, . . . � ,. ., '� .. � � , .i �
.. � I .��� � ' � � ..1 �.. . • � �(. � '�` T
� . .. . � � - . . . . . ' _ . _ . . . . ,I
r� . , � �, " . -.: . .'� � ` . .` . .
� �.. . '� �'�. t
� . � 1
.. . 1 �� �.�� ��". ., . �.. .._ � . ' . , '.. ,i
i,
��_ . � ,
. :'. . ' . ' , � . .:w,� ' . . '. ' '.. . ' . � .
, _ .. . . . .. . ...a �". .:.. ���- . ':.:. . . . . . .-. . - .
. � d�:
.
. •
.
, �. � �
. „ _
, .
_ , . . , , `
: . „> ,.
_
� _ � }
1 ' � �`:
. . • . �
� .:r' t _ �R-
\; , ` • ,.
, i l: � ' •, -i
, .� ' ! � .
� i .. �
, l . ti ` �
,� _ � �
_ _ . , , .
_ ; A _♦
� � �� � , � — • > .. �
, : .
, , . ,". . .` ;, c` . . +
_ . .:.: , :
:: �j� � . � . � : �_-��� �. .� . . � .. ,. . , ... . .. ' �..: :... �: . :,.. . . � . �' .. .
. .. . � ' : .. ' . � .. . . . ... . - . .. . . - . �_ti`
.. � . � . 't.� . . . . . ., . � . � � . . . . � � � ,
. . . , _ i. . . . . . . . . . .. . � .. � � ..
" I
� . ,
.
. . ,
, ., ..
. . \ . �. � - . . . . . � ' ' � k� ��'Hg�-.
. � . �, �. ' � _ :$ � "S
� . . . . .� ' . � , , �: .� � ,:. . , '.
�t, . � � . .� .. , . . �. ..�.; . . . t' �.,,,. • �. , '�
. . ... � � � , .. . , . . �`i?;
, . ,
�
. . . , . ;, . -'
.
. . . . . ,�. . . : . ,. , ,
. � . re.
. , .., .. ; . �
. ,
s. . . ., , �
, >i
,, � . , �� ..: . �� .. i. - . , . � ����� . -. ,�3��
. .- . .. ��. . . � . :' ' � = � ��, F \ �
. . . . ��,� , . , `. i
' . . . ' � . , ... . . ... ' . .. �-. ... �. � . . .. . . � . � . . .. ... . . . � . . ....�... .. � � ..
r
— - � — - - -
- _ / _. ` .. .
J
✓�
� .�
�47 F COMMERCIAL ELECTRIC COMPANY �
OF THE TWIN CITIES , INC.
228 E. ARLINGTON AVENUE
SAINT PAUL , MINN . 551 17 YOUR ORDER NO.
ELEC"I'RICAL INSTALLATIONS 1 S1i1itf0
ST. PAUL. MINN., `��a 16 lg 75
• Raaads I�aa
1870 02d Hudsoa Road
.Si�Ot P3111I� M�ATl. SS�19 TERMS:
NET CASH: � DAYS
FOLIO
, �Z
INfi€RF{T WILL BE CHARGED AT THE RATE
OF O�1 PER ANNUM ON ACCOUNTS PAST DUE.
2r�pozssy sasvic� to buildf.ng.
Remov� tquip�ept lzoa poI• a� zeiristall st � po
lctca tit�a.
�vctsical pQxmit 4 07
3 3" no tbread conr�ectoYS 10 93
4 2 x 4" x 2U' le�mbez � 99
lot Qails 35 34
1 � 4/O ilua�inua wire 1 89
L4 2x 4" x B� lunb�s 3 32
lot Scaffold renta 1- 1 �k 1 57
Z 2 x 4 x �O� lumber 6 03
3 3" �intYanc� bA�d� �
2 3" yalvatsized eouplings 54
6 3�� Kindozf stxaps 8
b 3/S x 4" bo2ta 10 59
30� 3" yalvanized conduit 03
6' 3/8« tbrQadQd rod �
6 3/8„ bo2ts 45
6� #4 base oop�x trire �
3• 3/4�� riqid eonduit , 10
6 A�4 Kea z neys 4I
15� M10 �i wixo 49
1 zoll � 33 9M tapQ sg
10� �" BMT coisdui t 27
IO� 3/4 N Bt�IT Condui t 88
Zp! 1�10 11a1 xix•
�,2 � x 2 bolt� �►nd r�uta 49
3#► duct sea 1 �
lo creditm oA lumber -� ��
lo csedits on 4/O wire gs � �'�
lo cbazg�s ot� lumbeY 1 � .
lo charyss on xite �
4/a1-23 Nens.n 1� �
s��,g lia ns�n 1 00
S/23 Hansen 2 3 pp �
S/�3 HeAaen 3 OO
S/23 .Tvuzn�y�an Scbaidt � 13 50
5/23 Jousu�yman ScborOS 7 50
5/27 App�centico K�nd�rick 7 �
S/28-30 Joust�ysan Cle�n 9 17 SO
S/34 Journeymaa Sc2rtzer 9 50
5/28-30 Hansvn � �
S/28 Appxantic� Is4ndz,ick 1 �
b/�-3-4- -6 JouYn�ymsa Pegler 33'� 6S Z5 '
6/2-3-4- -6 Jouxnoyma� Clemen 38 74 00
$a,49S 95
� �
� Ct T y ��+� � � (�`e' ���[1
��*�V ,p, �
i
��. , !, �'i,T L
� _- -
. � •o'a.;=_as�ta�a�� a
oe:laaa�.�is��
� a 99�muBi��4f, ♦
�. « a C ITY OF SAI NT PAUL
�'s �c
ro.♦
OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY
October 10, 1975 PIERRE N. REGN{ ER
Mr. Tom Kirsch
General Manager
Ramada Inn-St. Paul
1870 Old Hudson Road
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55119
Dear rdr. Kirsch:
I have investigated your claim concerning costs incurred
by your company in relocating your service due to the
widening of Old Hudson Road. My investigation discloses
the following facts:
The power pole which was relocated is property of NSP.
Under the present franchise agreement between the City
of Saint Paul and NSP, NSP is required to relocate any
of its power poles and utilities l.ocated within the public
right-of-way at their own expense and at no expense to the
City in the event such relocation is necessitated due to
a public improvement. The widening of Old Hudson Road by
the City of Saint Paul constitutes such a public improve-
ment and, therefore, the cost of relocating the power pole
in this instance was the obligation of NSP,
Your company' s service from NSP is an underground service.
Your transformer is located on the NSP power pole, and
the underground wires running from the NSP pole to your
building is owned by the Ramada Tnn and not owned by NSP.
The underground wires from the poles to your property were
locat�d in the public right-af-way and there is no record
of a permit being issued by the City of Saint Paul for
these wires, It is my opinion that your wires are within
the public right-of-way without the express permission of
the City of Saint Paul. Further, you have an agreement
with Northern States Power whereby your company has agreed
� City Hall, Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102
612 298-5121
_ _ . _. __:.. _- . .,_-�,r--_
� r
Mr. Tom Kirsch
Page 2
October 10, 1975
to bear all costs incurred in relocating your service
wires in the event such relocation is ever necessary,
and this agreement is to protect NSP.
It is my further opinion that your continued use of the
public right-of way for your service wires is there with
the implied consent of the City of Saint Paul and that
. the City, acting under the police power, may require that
you move or remove your electric utility wires from the
public right-of-way if their presence or existence
obstructs a public improvement.
It is my opinion, based upon the foregoing, that the
City of Saint Paul is not obligated to reimk�urse your
company for costs incurred by it in relocating its
electric service. It is my opinion that the City of
Saint Paul has the right to require that your company,
and abutting property owner, move or relocate its wires
when the relocation is required for a public improvement
and that this relocation is done at the expense of the
property o�aner and not at the expense of the public.
Your company' s electric wires, being located in the
public right-of-way is there subject to the paramount
rights of the public to use the dedicated right-of-way
for street purposes. The widening of Old Hudson Road
within the dedicated right-of-way constitutes such a
public use.
If I may be of further assistance, please feel free to
write or call.
Yours very truly,
JEROME J. SEGAL
Assistant City Attorney
JJS:cg
cc: Bureau of Valuations
--�1 City Clerk
Department of Public Works