266384 WH17E - CITY CLERK � COl1IIC11 26���
PINK - FINANCE GITY OF SAI�NT PALTL
CANARV - DEPARTMENT
BLUE �-MAYOR File NO.
r` � �" � - o 'l. Resolution
Presented By
Referred To Committee: Date
Out of Committee By Date
WHEREAS� the Director of the Department of Human Rights
has advised the offioe of the City Attorney that the Director
has found there are reasonable ground� to believe that the
Saint Paul Civil Service Department has violated the Saint
Paul Human Rights Ordinance relative to the den.ial of certain
applieants for positions with the Saint Paul Fire Department ;
and
WHEREAS � the City Attorney� pursuant to Chap ter 5 of
the City Charter, represents both the Human Rights Department
an.d the Saint Paul Givil Serviee Department on a regular basis ;
and
WHEREAS� the Direetor of the Department of Human. Rights
hae been advised by the City Attorney that the Gity Attorney
cannot, beoause of a conflict of interest� represent both the
Human Rights Department an.d the Civil Service Department in
th is matter; and
WHEREAS, the Human. Rights Director has eonsented to the
City Attorney representing the Saint Paul Givil 5ervioe Depart-
ment and has requested that the Gity Attorney requegt the City
Gouneil to appoint Mark Reinhart� Attorney at Law� at the rate
of �35 an hour� to represent the Department of Human Rights in
this matter and the Direetor has re Qommended that the City
Attorney request that Dolores Orey� Attorney at Law, be re-
tained as the Hearing Officer for this matter at the rate of
�50 an hour, both fees to be charged to Code No. 00150-141;
and
WAEREAS� the City Attorney, pursuant to such rsquest,
has requested the City Council to appoint the above �ttorneys
at the compensation specified, now, -therefore , be it
COUNCILMEN Requested by Department of: H�n Ri�htS
Yeas Nays
Christensen _-_ _—.___
Hozza In Favor __�--
- -_=_-- � - __.. ,
Levine -=�� - --
Rcedler � � --- '
Sylvester Against
Tedesco
President Hunt
Form Approved by City Attorney
Adopted by Council: Date
Certified Passed by Council Secretary BY
gy `
Approve y May t , cil
Approved by Mayor: Date ,:,, ,
By BY
WH17E - CITV CLERK �/��1���
PINK - FINANCE GITY OF SAINT PAZTL Council ��
CANqRV - DEPARTMENT File NO.
BLUE - MAVOR
���` � � Council Resolution
Presented By
Referred To Committee: Date
Out of Committee By Date
Pag e 2.
RESOLVED, by the Saint Paul City Council, that the
Gity of Saint Paul, by its Human Rights Department , is
authorized to retain the services of Mark Reinhart, Attorney
at Law, at the rate of �35 per hour for services rendered
relative to eomplaints involving Michael Fay, et al. v.
Saint Paul Civil Service Department; and be it
FUftTHER RESOLVED� that the Human Rights Commission is
hereby authorized to retain Dolores Orey, Attorney at Law, as
a Hearing Officer at the rate of �50 per hour, relative to the
same matter; and be it
FURTHER RESO LVED� that the eompensation to be paid to
Mark Reinhart and Dolores Orey be charged to the Human Rights
Department, Code No. 00150-141.
.
COUIVCILMEN Requested by Department of:
Yeas Nays �
Christensen
� H�t In Favor
Levine J
�� � Against By
Sylvester
Tedesco
President�tAozza
��Y 2 � ��J Form Approved by City Attorney
Adopted by Counc' • Date
Certified ouncil cre�ary BY
By
Approv by Mayor: Da Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
By By
uB��srtEO Nov a y ts75
. . :-�--�:;;�, Cz�,�r o� ��z�;� ��ti�, �� � /'/�`
f':��--- �1c��b
c
'� � }�'; y�� O�`F'I�;�� U� TF3F. �SZ'3.' CvLT�+CIL
�i � ���.'.' .
1 �.� .. � � �
� '`� ,' .�-y D a t e : Nov. 21 1975
� °� � '
��-��
C 0 ���� i�� ��"T � � F� � �' U � i'
� 0 : �ai�� Pc�ui �s�� CQU� �iI .
r
�' RO �� = Cvinmi�ie� an FINaNCE _ �
Robert Sylvester , Chairman, makes the foliowing
report on C. F. [� O�-dinance
[� Resolu�-ion
� Ofih2r
� � � L.� : RE: Ca.vil Service Department
Please be advised that the Finance Committee has approved the
resolution referred to it suthorizing the Human Righti's Department
to retain the services of Mark Reinhart and Dolores Orey as
Attorney ahd Hearing Officer in the matter of complaints
involving the Civil Service Department.
Tt should be noted that this was referred to the ful1, City Council
for whatever necessary action is required. _
Ci?Y s'-'sLL S�V�'t�i �''J:OUR SrlI'`T PE>L'I.., ,III�:v�SJT� 55iiJ?
;Hi.(17E . -.G��TV CLEFiK � ' . . ' � . .
P�NK - F�N:vC�E ' y `�� � r T �� r '{¢�' T'�' COUI1C11 - �
r4NG:i`Y - 7F_:?-RT•AENT CA '� L �1� ��� 11'!Tl L i� V � .
��_�.� - �,A,�R � ���e N0.
� 7 •�,�� -, ! . �„ ,; .
� �°��� �_���'�a� ,�-.����,�"%������
��: �
-�1
-�-
i
�I_���
i�(i'_S C 11 t£(j �3y ---- - y- — — - --i - __--------------
R�•Fcrr�_d To .---------- - - --_- ----.— Com��iittee: Date ---
0;:t o f Cor;�m i t;ee By------ ---- -------- Da te --- — --
j�;I�F�.EAS� the Diz ector of the Departrnen� of �iuman Rights
has adviseci t��e office of the City ��lttorney that the Director
lias founil t�lere are reasor.�able graunds to belie�cTe that the
Saint Pa+_�l C:i.vil Sezvice Del�artment has vzolated the Saint
Paul Huu�an Itights Or:linance relative to the dei2ial of certain
apl�lica�ts for positions with the Sairit Paul Fire Depa.rtment ;
and
ZvrIEREAS � the City Attorney, pursua?a.t to Chap�er 5 of
the City Ch�.rter, represents both the Human Rights Depar��uent
and the Saint Paul Civil Service Departinent on a regular basis ;
aud
�i�IEREAS, �he Director of the Department of Hurian Rights
has been advised by t�ie City Attorney that the Gity Attorney
cannot , because of a conflict of interest� represent both the
Huna� Right.s Department and tne Civil Service Department in
fhis ruatter; and � -
_ _.
j�'HERE�S� t�he Hui�an Rights Director has consented �o the �� `
� City Attorney representino the Saint Pau1 Civil Service Depart-
z:ient anci has requested that the Ci�ty A-ttorney request the City _
Council to appoint Niark Reinhart, Attorney at Law� at the rate
of �3� an hour� to repre sent the Department of Human Rights in
this matter and the Directar has reconi-nended that the City
Att.orney request tg�at Dolores Orey, rl.ttorney at La�v, be re- �
tained as the Hearing Officer for this matter at the rate of
�50 an hour, both �ees .to be c`�arged to Code IVTo. 001�0-141;
a��d
.
j���REAS, the City Attorn2y, pursuant to such request,
has requested the City Council to appoint the above attorneys '
at tLie compensation specified, now, therefore , be it
COliNCIL\�EN
Y�a� ,va5s Requested by Department of: Hu�an �lg�lt5
Ct„istensen --s .,
Hoz�a _ In Favor � _._-__ -- _-- - -
Levine �i' •
R�dler • — - ��.
� __ Against � -
Sylvester .
Tedesco . ' - :- �
President Hunt �. . ��
- Form Approved by City Attorney
Ado�ted by Council: Date ,
Certified Fassed by Council Secretary BY
� .. 2.,��_�-. t..
�� — .
Approved by �!ayor: Date Approve y May � , _ i t C uncil
: ��
Rv -- BY� -
'NY7w.. —,CI T.V��CLcHK . . � . . � . .
�NK _ ,�,:.,�N,�t ' - (jI'IY �� �9AINT ��:1ITI. Council
n��nav -• ot_n�anaFVr
�l_UE' � - "�av:�R • File� . N0.
, � .
� �t� ����Y��c! .���J�✓+/�i/✓��� � .
�
'resentcd F3y ------------- �
---- ----- --- -------------------- ----------
�
I,. r, , �
�<<._�r�d To ----------------- ----- --- Committee: Date ----------------- �
0 u t o f Co r:i�;�i t te e �3 ---- Da t e ------------------ �
Y --- - -- �
__ _-- ------------- -- --- — ---- —
-- -------- ----— -------- - Pab e 2 . --- – ------ ---- ------ -- _ - �
RE50LVED, by -L.he Saint Paul City Cozizlcil. , tLat t�he �
Ci1,y of Saint Paul , by its Human Rights De}�artr_�ent , is �
aiithorized to re�tain the services of �Iark Reirtilart� At�torney �
at Laiv, at 1;he rate o�f �35 per hour for services rendered �
rzlative -to complaints in�olving �ii�liael Fay, et al . v.
Saint Pau 1 Civil Service Departmen.t ; and be it �
�
FURI'�IER R�SOLVED� that the Human R.ights Conlrnission is. � �
liereby authorized to retain Dolores Orey, At�:orney at Law, as s
a Hearin; Of_f_icer at tlie rate oF �50 per hour, relative to the
sarne matter; and be it .
FURT}��R RESOLVED� that the compensation to be �aid to - �
Mark Reinhart and Dolores Orey be char�ed to tlie Human Rights �
Departlnent, Code No. 00150-141. �
Y
. . � �. � . . � 1
.. .. . . .. � �. . � . � . .. � " - j ' . . �
. � . . - . � . . .. . �
. . . .... . .. . ' .. .. . . .. .._. .. . .. . . . . 1
. � . .. � _ . .. " . . . . � �
i
�
_ �
� - �
i
a
_ .. �
� �
�
. �
COUNCILSS�;N. Requested by Departmznt of: -
Yeas Nays . ' _ , ,
Christensen � � - -
Hozza . - Iri Favor .- • — �
_ Levine ___ -. _
Roedler ._�
Sylvester � . . Against ` By -
Tedesco • ".
President Hunt •
. - Form Approved by City Attorney
Adopted by Council: Date
Certified Passed by Council Secretary By
By _. ,
i-,pproved by Mayor. Date � Approved by htayor for Submission to Couzcit � .
6v By
����'� CITY OF SAINT PAUL
DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN R(GHTS
LAWRENCE D.COHEN DONALD LEWIS
MAYOR
DIRECTOR
October 23, 1975
h1ayor Lawrence D. Cohen
347 City Hall
BUILDING
Dear Mayor Cohen:
Re: Legal Counsel - (Applicants for Fire Fighter)
Pursuant to the request made by the City Attorney, Pierre Regnier, I have
recommended to him the following attorneys to serve as legal counsel for
this department in behalf of the above-captioned complaints .
Attorney Mark Reinhart
Attorney Delores Orey
Mr. Reinhart will serve as counsel for the complainants and Ms. Orey will
serve as the hearing officer. Both of these persons were recomnended
because of their legal background in the field of civil and human rights.
I would appreciate having this resolution acted upon in the most expedi-
ti ous manner.
------'�
Sincer-�fiy;r
�.---°;
..,,'"�`�.,�,,��.....,`
,�
J
Donald Lewis
Director
DL/cr
cc: Pierre Regnier, City Attorney
515 City Hall, Saint Paui, Minnesota 55102
612 298-4288
612 298-4144
��
4 .. . ...�.._4 : ...,• �. � .... / '. T .. — . •L
. � � .�. f .,;,',- ,�. T �
� t a � �
;`.� . � .'4Y ., i ♦ :.+ b� �', i :° s�. .
jY 1 �h� V * .. t t y '�
. .;
., ,„�' � ' .' � ♦ �y+ p
w: b'. ,`� a � � - f 4 .�'z ,� i
r ' i C J 'a�k� k. Y �.
� i ` 1 r �r, j x,'� �� ��• ,.�`�
_ .
,
•,
� � �r � ,.. � � ; a� F . `F� F � s � � �ot
. _ '�, :� ..r 1 ,, „t e r� '�:\ � ��F _ c�.
� Y� `�
}, s' � 1^ � � �X `� � �'
� � � �^ '� ` �:�1' 3 ��„a.��
. .�' � � , � � t,." �,� rt�., . . � � � ,� -.
±�. .. ` � �« .. ; �i� .R„�" ��r��
,i - �',�'- � r � .-js :z�
, "� ' t '�x�
i.{ l . � .y r'. � f �n • ' �` p $an �n�+.���e � E "' "y#,�,:
�t.. . M� � � �Yr�i.
' � y � _� f'u �.`.
�•: ' # .. ' Y }'C'i.� '{ Z.V
4 .• . � . � � i � '� ��� . . k., r .�:?� ��.'��
� . 1 � . `s _ i .ti
:� �� � �.: { �°, � '�k
. .. . . ,� !' ' / ' / �J. ✓ ��;.`�
� , : � r �.
� f � �` �� i � u, ,
�r.
� t:� :: � � � b���� � ���5� � � �'� � ,.;° � � ° ti1 �
r ... . �" {r �.} s }"rw'C��- � �
x . . , ' k� y tf?i
>J u�- t ,��.
_ �`' � �j�'' j Py
a � � :- .�� ��.
t' '' . . ' '. :
. • . J� ' N.. . ...5 "> �4r 'i"(" N
1�� �1 f � � � r �� � r yF �k��g
. �c- / �_ - � :s� �j �� 3 ,�f' +�}q
��' i y
11 , .. ":� ' . A' 4 . ' � l`)
- , _. � _ � { � d. Y � . Y �� a k � t �7
\ a' ��` . ' . � ..l^ . � .kR� A � - ��
. ; _�" i � � ,. . 'l :^ } ` 1� t r� � f �t ' �.�
. . . � " �� �;` ����� , '2•" -y'. � _-�F �
♦ . 1 _ _ �t ';t � � F T � +9�
�
� � �r " � �`, �'`��''P
r: ::. .'. �,: i , �, . .
. ^�r .. +'4 , � , x '1 . ! t�: .� '. Ky,'�
� ' � ... . '�. o- , p . �� v ..�'- '� i
; � ��
, � .
., � ., .. . � _ Y.. � i s-: :� ; P . t#�'�
� �I�. �,..�s,,"�ri�st�►r ,� r ��
������ !S!�; �::.'�+",�►�i� , � �: -1 ��ir J i �5 ��� �y '��
�'\ J . �..� '..�����-����`Mlr ���. _ '.r; J.�,: T , �� k � i � r ,y ' �
� v- . . �4� k ' i �y� `�i
. ` °�.. P�. �1��ta: '� � fi�` � �`..
* ` a M� �
; � _ a � * P�
I�' ����:.�q�i ' . . ,4i r , fl, � ��k '�z � ,
� � � . �,,�, . . .�., t� - ' i �T i,� � �
. , . ., ' .� . •° . ��cF� s �� '�' ,�rG
, -� -
,- ,.
. ,
,�Ths ��r ���..��'.e�� � �� t�#' l��,a�: ��. r : ?� �;
4 ;�•�w ��►�p�to��C°1'� s'�+ka3s� -Rlai� ���1� �` �� _ ;��`� � � ; �� + ;�
t;' , �'b�� ��"�If'1 � �e�s� ��th` �i'�rr�s 4' �t� '�'�, � : ,,�.� :
,� t .
,
...
, , •
'' � 1l�rat'�Nat� � u 'K y,. � �� �a
. .
• i ' - e -� ,. ..- � K
� - � �'�i� T (, ��� ��.� , � ��
l �,
.a.:
. . .. ' : s :� . . :
Y.'� . � . . � r ��,, � f� .� �,.��
ny�� � '� F � i Y,'
� .. � . . �. � � .� �`�*'�7 -�"`,�'a 1, �` � v-�r �r -y
. . . __ 4�1 �� >
- . . . " � .. h S /. � � ��
. —. . . t. � .. � ... ,• � . � Jt � f f�f ��a;
� . }r . . .. � /� *. � i ..� � � } �'-, g �
M'` . ._� - .. ��`' �� f
r; ��,^4 y ` ' �n`
'{` , . .. . . � � � ,� 1' r C .��5
._ "��� . -� � , ��
� �7.;� i5
, *�'�Z� . � .s\.' , . . � . . � � �<'_ 'y. / k �'e 'T+`:
� 1 � , � ` �� 5 � � . � { ���7
� "!�"it �, ��, ��►7 ���X I '`�� � t ���
" �l. " _ � �'�- i � . � .. '3.✓.� �" ( - 1 .. � "t
" . � . t L," . "�p^� �� � � � `l' a � x`S� k �p�`�,
,�s _ ._ � ' ' .. 1� � < . � F�
. . . . � t 1 � � Y �r � �.i.
, , t . � � ;�71 4 M'� ��
,
h - . . . . .. P A ��� �� �)��.
. ..
. ' ' . t � ` r 4 .
' � _ . 1 — �� �' d � W,.
� � . 1 . � � �.,�a iF Y`� � � ���kt T
. _ . . t_ . .. t — . �`. . �.. ,.,, �' ��„�' �,��
, __ . ,I . ° k,;� � v� � �, .er _s
, � � , , .`� . + _ � '
� ; �� '�', . �� . � � .� . . _ h:e H �:.
.
7 ➢
.. �
�. L .. .. . .: � . ,�
' / '�� . ; . '� .. _ .` .., .' . ��...' ' �i�.L '���'
.
,
i , A �� ?
f
. . �� . '. .� . . �. . :
, . .
'., . . - .. � . , .� .. .. ' . ' �,
� : ; . . _. .'. .
.� ^- r S�.. 7: �
� . '��. � ..� ... .,� ' � ��. , �_..,a
Y
, : . . . . ". : ' . �
t.
. . ,� �: , . , - � -. . . , a��
r,� � � i
s^��
� � �
� . ... ' ' . . . . � .. \ . . ' t M,�h�. 0,1 �
. t
i
"-u. . . .i. ��.
.�.�. .. .. .�-� , .
� • . • . � � � t Y :
r
.... � .a ... Y. . . � .� � r�� � l
. . . , . � , .. � . .. G, & �asx� � �
. . �� . � - . . . ., ,r . _� . . . . . 'k � ., , � .... _ _. . 3�i_ , -, '
> '.� , a '. ���� � �
i � � .J; r rp; , ,;, t� x .s
� � .E.. . . : i _ r r
� �` n '� �' [�,�
{?' .��, t i.' S,�,- 11 ' ,�r�� <,
��' � � �� ..v �'�i' � �� � s,: .;- � �
� ,
� �
_ w °-' y ,�
7 :.-1 : ' � . �k' . ' . . .„+ ' . 'Y v
y
'. ' t` ^�.. . ,� � '�p- !'°,
� b a E �
t + ..� . . . . � . / �.y , t 4 Y.��/ 1" ,y 1� �'
�
� �, . . . �_ " .. ,. . .' r � �y'a
u �1� ,
��' [ �
� q ' ;.MF �k� . . . ' �� . " ri� °� t Y Y�
. i
�.
� ., 1
y �,' ;.,. .-�... ' . � . :. �.. , n .. .. ,. .
1 . .a�d.�''. � " � �I " 1'�� ��
' � ' . .. �, � ... . .. .. ��... : ,.x .: t 1 :.� � 3� h �
+ P� � .a. .. � � , � . ' � � � � .2\ +"'""e K
. � r ' _. -. ..� ' � � . �i .Y� r t� �' .
i. . . � �^` .;.., . - .. - ' . . . ,i � �`^ 4 a a"
. �
� � t � ' �� .� � �� �f :} � ;P.�S4 t �
. - .. .. ' . � + . � " .. . �' ;i
� �.' :, _.
t . - � , - � . �� � .
,. � ,� .,� . ��. , � .' � . a
, ' s � r�i . ' ��1/ :.. i r � (� . �* '.
�� . . � F ' . . �. � ay � 't + �J l f ,t'.; � � ��
1 �, i :
� ` � . ', ,�
, $a .� . ,, I � i�
" � .. ` ;}' ' �� 4� }'�S,} ,� S
�, . ! � . F7_. ���' � f�',
,`' . ,: ! � '; r t % �
i . •� . , . L �`��
S. �1'.. � � 'Y p �1
� �' � 'k . " . � ! / ;�. 7 �'� `�y }���
,
' ' , . .,c., _, ' . ..,� , ' .:,'..r, . . . . . I ^�:ry'
,
.
�
:� ...' :. .. , a, �..�- . .. . -. '. ;.. . ,. �: .,,
e : J
.\ ' } , . . ` i... .J. 4�"d
�' . � '���:� �� ,y1 f :9[ `t :� ��� T1:
. � , � . I . . . i. �
t �
. . � ' i � ' . — 4"�'�' f'�� ���. '�'� !
5 <^ ?
..i . �� . ": . , �, ,: . �,
- � .. } # � j. . �� . ( '�� ..v �� }
7 / ' ■ S .. •:i �,- �:� { � ��` �eS+'�
. `b � . `���� [��y ��������^�� - _' �� ^ ��� ,� 4
�4. ' _ �`^ j� ? ,� . . ' , � . , � ��•"� I x .i
,. , r yJ
z' . � .. - :��A���■��P��� . . ��` • � 6+k'+'�
. J. ' ', �r P .
„ . �- � �,�'.r n^ � z ,:'. d , . �. .. i� `.�, r F��-�` '. -:rt ` p_t3.
��y( a yf
� � .�T��¢� �- � � l, � �' , i �� � �n,�.�
. _. ' � . � ,;� ,, �' , ,; � ;;.' r a'� � ��'� ��,��� � '��� "��ti•
JJ d '
z � � �jj1Y+ ��5�y1 �'''�i. �R �� ��.'.._,,i�c; ���'�;�h � j ��
.4 at . II�7I�II1�� ll�l��������1 �'.' �. . t,�� rf �. 1 �'.
� . '
. � ,a. . . ''3 : r. � ,�4
r _.
. � � • ;: .,: �
e .' , J..: ! ._ , �� . , % ��
� ^ y ���'��� -�.. 5 �.. t �
.. � . ; �;161aM�u��'��,��,��`'.���
` �'; �; �
;, ;
.
. ... _ ,�. � ,5 .,
. . , a�. + ... ..
.. a_ � •.
. . �' e
, . .11Vu�u�iNal��e� i�. �Il�i�� '� . - M 11 _
.: . - ,< .
..
.
�<
� -
�� �
, , ��_ '� s �
�" > ° - _ r t� � .
, , ` � '��^�t ` ' a � , :
} , F �=w � ,,��: �`�,�,'
� � � "� �
.
,
..
. .
, � ,
. n
_ �. ,..
. .
. . _
,��� � , .
�" .
_ . .
, � '1:, , 1 ,'� �'>Q��'t �r + '� S ,• �!
. � �' � i k � �' �� �.
� � �� A : '` ���
-� � ' �> ; � "'�` . � � � � � 1 �?,t � � ,:r,
., , I ,
, � y � , r ';
�,;'. � �� E , � � � � y � r � ��'
r � 'r � � � 1: f��
; ` - � � � � �
I n �,"r j �
1� ' � .. � . . � �. . - . . vi as
x r � �,.':
7.s` ," i � , �
� ' l. � ` ;. tr,.� ��
� , ., ,
� , .
„ , ,
;, - � , '-. °.„ .< . r. ' ' ' .'>' ' �� �,,�Y
� i - „�. 4
.
, : � --
. � � ., j� �` . . -- � � r�; � ��.
. ,
, . �. . ' � �.. .
_ . . .. ' .. " -t � �ri� ! � .. ,- :� , � _. _ � }'.�
' •;
3 -.'
�
� � � i . . _,� � e .,- �. . � . ,
, _. , .,. � .a.
. . . � �� .>.� _-, ' . ' . �'. s
: , ,
�.:.. _. _ / '. . . ' . . . �...-�� - -�� ;.
�
, . . �;
r ".A'�., ,r - ` , � � .�� _ '��t .4� ia.'
.
. _ ', ..- . � . . , . . . +_ -�.
y „ , % ��
,k. . .. . .._ . . _ ._� ._ „ . .. , , . . , 's; . . "'' . . � , ., . . '�.,, .. �`J� , �,,. , �..a