The URL can be used to link to this page

266267 WHITE - CITV CLERK �� PINK - FINANCE GITY OF SAINT PAUL Council f . � ' CANARV - DEPARTMENT i: � BLUE - MAYOR File NO. f' � - �' ncil Resolution Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date RESOLVED, That the Council of the City of Saint Paul hereby ratifies and approves the action of the Saint Paul Board of Appeals and Review pertaining to the following listed property and as shown by the Excerpted Minutes of said Board of Appeals and Review, dated September 9, 1975, and ma.rked EXHIBIT A, and attached hereto and ma.de a part hereof by reference: DATE OF BOARD MINUTES CASE N0. PROPERTY APPELLANT 9/9/75 39/75/B 1329 Lincoln Ave. Cha.rles Walk by Sussel Co. , Richard A. Zappa. BOARD ACTION: Garage Variance granted from St. Paul Legislative Code, Section 40.00(i) , requiring 2 ft. Side Lot Clearance from property line for any garage which � is to the rear of the residence so as to permit four- car garage to be built in rear of property facing alley, subject to the requirements of the State , Building Code. Property Description: Lot 18, Block 3, Stinson's Blvd. Addition. ��.��wi��,r�.��w. � . � � �. 9/9/75 4(�/��'�jfiBY T816 Ashland Ave. Jon Bjornnes BOARD ACTION: Garage Variance granted from St. Pau1 Legislative Code, Section 33.04(2) , pertaining to Rear Yard Clearance requirement of a minimum distance of 25 ft. from ma.in portion of the dwelling, so as to build rear-attached garage. COUIVCILMEN 'Requested by Department of: Yeas Nays Christensen Hozza In Favor Levine Rcedler Against BY ` Sylvester Tedesco President Hunt Adopted by Council: Date Form Approved by City Attorney Certified Passed by Council Secretary BY By Approved by Ma,yor: Date Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council BY BY WHI7E - CITV CLERK � �� PINK - FINANCE GITY OF SAINT PALTL Council �'��.+V l CANARV - DEPARTMENT BLUE - MAYOR File NO. � - " cil Resolution Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date Page 2. ProFert,jT ,�escrivtion: N. 100 ft. of Lot 14, Block 6, Egbert G. Handy' s Addition to the City of St. Paul. ------------------------ 9/9/75 41/75/B 1954 Rome Ave. Michael J. McGough BOARD ACTION: Garage Variance granted from St. Paul Legislative Code, Section 40.00(i) , pertaining to the requirement tha.t any garage which is to the rear of the residence shall not be closer tha.n two ft. (2 ft. ) to the Side Lot line, so as to utilize existing retaining wall on the east property line as the back wall of the new garage to be built thereon, subject to the requirements of the State Building Code. Property Description: Lot 23, Block 1, Highview Addition. 9/9/75 42/75/B 81 W. Congress Ave. James D. Beacom BOARD ACTION: Garage Variance granted from St. Paul Legislative Code, Section 40.00(i) , pertaining to the requiremen�� that any garage which is to the rear of the residence sha.11 not be closer tha.n two ft. (2 ft. ) to the Side Lot line, so as to build new garage on the property line, subject - to the requirements of the State Building Code. Pro ert Descri tion: Lot 8, except the W. 2 foot, nion ottage earrangement of the W. 2 of Block 57, West St. Paul Proper. COUNCILMEN Yeas Nays Requested by Department of: Christensen � � Hunt In Favor Levine Rcedler � Against BY Sylvester '�,d�sL�' President � HOZZs Adopted by Cou . Date 0� 2�8 �]� Form Approved by City Attorney Certifie assed o '1 cretary ' BY ��- �' � B Approve y Mayor: ate Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council By BY P�auskE� NOV i �975 G�G#� i �'� - � 9/9/75 - rieeting No. 115 , , �j(�r/B !% -9 Cassette Tape No. 127 �66�6'7 � ----------------------�---------------------------_ CASE N0. PROPERTY APPELLANT 41-75-B 1954 Rome Michael J. McGough SUBJECT: � Request for garage variance from St. Paul Legislative Code, Section 40.00 (i) , pertaining to the requirement that any garage which is to the rear of the residence shall not be closer than two feet (2 ft.) to the side lot line, so as to utilize existing retaini�.g wall on the east property line as the back wall of the new garage to be built thereon. APPEARANCE: � = Michael J. McGough PROCEEDINGS• Mr. McGough said that his garage burned down two years ago and he had installed a retaining wall of re-inforced concrete block on frost footings at the side property line. He wanted to build a garage now, using the retaining wall as the back wall of the garage. With a 40 ft. lot, and because garages and hedges of his neighbors were on the alley line, this would be the only way he could glace the new garage so that he could get his car into and out of it. He therefore was asking for a variance from the two ft. requirement from the side lot Iine. rir. Person said that there were no objections from the Code Enforcement Division to the granting of such a variance. BOARD ACTION: _ Chairman Wozniak moved that a garage variance from St. Paul Legislative Code, Section 40.00 (i) , pertaining to the requirement that any garage which is to the rear of a residence shall not be closer than two ft, to the side lot Iine, be granted. Mrs. Peake seconded. Pi0TI0N CARRIED AND SO ORDERED. THE VOTE• Ayes - 6 Nayes - 0 Abstentions - 0 ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 9/9/75 - Meeting No. 11�5 Cassette Tape No. �127 . �'�G�7"_ �� MINUTES OF THE MEETING ST. PAUL BOARD OF APPEALS AND REVIE�V Tuesday, September 9, 1975 City Council Committee Room 707 City Hall and Court House 1: 30 P.M. MEMBERS PRESENT: D. Donald Wozniak, Chairman Estyr Bradley Peake David Heider Ronald Glassman Arthur M. Tieso James D. Voigt MEMBER ABSENT: Norma Sommerdorf AGENCIES PRESENT: Department of Community Services - Division o£ Housing and Building Code Enforcement � Frank Staffenson, Housing Supervisor Dan Person, Senior Building Inspector Alice Bijjani, Housing Inspector Richard Perry, Housing Inspector Thomas Strohkirch, Housing Inspector Doug Schwab , Senior Plumbing Inspector OTHERS PRESENT: Jon Bjornnes, Appellant W. T. Bjornnes Richard A. Zappa, Representative of Sussel Co. , on Behalf of Charles Walk, Appellant John Kavanagh, Appellant F. J. Nahurski , Attorney,on Behalf of Valerie Batorewicz , Appellant Kevin blcCarthy, Representa'�ive of Clapn-Thomssen, on Behalf of Valerie Batorewicz, �Appellant James Beacom, Appellant Michael P�IcGough, Appellant STA�F PRESENT : Doris L. Getsug, Executive Secretary, Appeals Board Patricia Moxness , Recording Secretary, Appeals Board Chairman �Vozniak called the Meeting to order at 1 : 50 p.m. Mr. Glassman moved that the Minutes of the August 12 , 1975 , l�teeting be approved. PQrs . Peake seconded. MOTION CARRIED AND SO ORDERED. THE VOTE : Ayes - 6 Nayes - 0 Abstentions - 0 - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - --- - - - - - - -- - ---- - -- - - --- -- - - ---- - - - --- - - - -- --- Fxt��P�' �fi , , 9/9/75 - Meeting No. 1�5 . � �JC Hi G3 !T � � -8- Cassette Tape No. I27 1 • I �ss�s� � _ __________ _________________________________________�_________________________ K _�� n CASE N0. PROPERTY APPELLANT 40-75-B 1816 AShland Ave. Jon Bjornnes SUBJECT: � Request for Garage Variance from St. Paul Legislative Code, Section 33.04 (2) , pertaining to Rear Yard Clearance requirement of a minimum distance of 25 ft. from main portion of the dwelling, so as to build rear-attached garage. APPEARAN E: Jon Bjornnes PROCEEDINGS: Mr. Bjornnes stated that because the rear 50 feet of the original lot his home was built on was sold, he could not attach a garage to the rear of his house and still have a 25 ft. clearance to the rear line. He could build a detached garage within ttie space, and thereby conform to the Building Co�e, but he preferred an attached structure. Mr. Person explained that rir. Bjornnes' lot was what is known as a back lat, which requires 25 ft. of clearance, whereas a side lot would require only two ft. of clearance. He did not have any objection to Mr. Bjornnes' plan to build an attached garage with less than the amount of clearance required by the Euilding Code. 40-75-B 9/9/75 - Meeting No. 115 ' -9� Cassette Tape No. 127 • 1816� Ashland Ave. BOARD ACTION: ,�ss��►`� ' l Chairman Wozniak moved that the appeal for garage variance from St. Paul Legislative Code, Section 33.04 (2) , pertaining to rear yard clearance requirement of a minimum distance of 25 ft. from main portion of the dwelling, so as to build rear-attached garage. Mr. Glassman seconded. MOTION CARRIED AND SO ORDERED. THE VOTE• Ayes - 6 Nayes - 0 Abstentions - 0 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------- a..,., -------------=--------------------------------------------------------------------- 9/9/75 - Nleeting No. 115 Cassette Tape No. •127 � �?�'`t�'�''''�.' MINUTES OF THE MEETING ST. PAUL BOARD OF APPEALS AND REVIEZI� Tuesday, September 9 , 1975 City Council Committee Room 707 City Hall and Court House 1: 30 P.M. MEMBERS PRESENT: D. Donald Wozniak, Chairman Estyr Bradley Peake David Heider . Ronald Glassman Arthur M. Tieso James D. Voigt MEMBER ABSENT: Norma Sommerdorf AGENCIES PRESENT: Department of Community Services - Division o£ Housing and Building Code Enforcement ' Frank Staffenson, Housing Supervisor Dan Person, Senior Building Inspector Alice Bijjani, Housing Inspector Richard Perry, Housing Inspector Thomas Strohkirch, Housing Inspector Doug Schwab , Senior Plumbing Inspector OTHERS PRESENT: Jon Bjornnes , Appellant W. T. Bjornnes Richard A. Zappa, Representative of Sussel Co. , on Beh alf of Charles Walk, Appellant John Kavanagh, Appellant F. J. Nahurski, Attorney,on Behalf of Valerie Batorewicz, Appellant Kevin McCarthy, Representative of Clapn-Thomssen, on Behalf of Valerie Batorewicz, �Appellant James Beacom, Appellant Michael McGough, Appel�ant STAFF PRESENT : Doris L. Getsug, Executive Secretary, Appeals Board Patricia Moxness , Recording Secretary, Appeals Board Chairman jVozniak called the Meetin g to order at 1 : 50 p.m. hlr. Glassman moved that the Minutes of the August 12 , 1975 , Meeting be appro�,Ted. P�Irs . Peake seconded. MOTION CARRIED AND SO ORDERED. THE VOTE : Ayes - 6 Nayes - 0 Abstentions - 0 - -- - - - - - -- - - -- --- - -- -- - -- - - - - - - - -- - - --- - --- -- -- -- -- - --- - - - ---- - - - ---- •. EX�ie�T �f 9/9/75 - Meeting No. 115 - / - � Cassette Tape No. 127 . �� XC�'��"?�- -4- � �ss�s� � C f � � � �! i f � [ ! , , i .: I i _ . i � . � l , � I � I � r ; f � i f i 'r ! - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - -- - - -- - - - - -- -- - - -- -- -- - --- - - -- --- - - - - - CASE N0. PROP�RTY APPELLANT 39-75-B 1329 Lincoln Charles Walk bY Sussel Co . , Richard A. Zappa APPEARANCE: Richa.rd A. Zappa, Sussel Co . 39-75-B 9/9/75 - Meeting No. 115 1329 Lincoln -5- Cassette Tape No. 127 SUBJECT: �6��6r� Request for Garage Variance from St. Paul Legislative Code, Section 40.00 (i), requiring 2 ft. side lot clearance fror� property line for any garage which is to the rear of the residence so as to permit 4-car garage to be built in rear of property facing alley. PROCFEDINGS: Mr. Zappa said that Mr. Walk wanted to build a 36 ft. wide, four-car garage. Because the garage next door on one side was on the property line, Mr. Walk wanted to build his garage three feet from the line on that side, bur this would leave only one foot clearance on the other side. On any bTiilding closer than three feet of the property line, fireproofing was required on the wall facing the line, and Mr. Walk was prepared to have this done. Chairman Wozniak asked Mr. Person if his department considered such a placement of a garage to be a problem, and Mr. Person said his department had no objection as long as the wall nearest the property line was fireproofed. There were also no objections from Mr. Walk's neighbors. BOARD ACTION: Chairman Wozniak moved that a garage variance from St. Paul Legislative Code, Section 40.00 (i), requiring 2 ft. side lot clearance from property line for any garage which i.s to the rear of the residence so as to permit a four-car garage to be built in rear of property facing alley, be granted. Mr. Glassman seconded. ,: MOTION CARRIED AND SO ORDERED. THE VOTE: ' Ayes - 6 Nayes - 0 Abstentions - 0 9/9/75 - Meeting No. 1�5 Cassette Tape No. ��127 . �XGa�/�PT �� MINUTES OF THE MEETING ST. PAUL BOARD OF APPEALS AND REVIET�V Tuesday, September 9, 1975 City Council Committee Room 707 City Hall and Court House 1: 30 P.M. MEMBERS PRESENT: D. Donald Wozniak, Chairman Estyr Bradley Peake David Heider Ronald Glassman Arthur M. Tieso James D. Voigt MEMBE R ABSENT: Norma Sommerdorf AGENCIES PRESENT: Department of Community Services - Division of 6 Housing and Building Code Enforcement ` Frank Staffenson, Housing Supervisor , Dan Person, Senior Building Inspector � Alice Bij j ani, Hous ing Inspector Richard Perry, Housing Inspector Thomas Strohkirch, Housing Inspector Doug Schwab , Senior � Plumbing Inspector OTHE RS PRESENT: Jon Bjornnes , Appellant W. T. Bjornnes Richard A. Zappa, Representative of Sussel Co. , on Behalf of Charles Walk, Appellant John Kavanagh, Appellant F. J. Nahurski, Attorney,on Behalf of Valerie Batorewicz, Appellant Kevin McCarthy, Representative of Clapp-Thomssen, on Behalf of Valerie Batorewicz, �Appellant James Beacom, Atipellant Michael NlcGough, Appellant STAFF PRESENT : Doris L. Getsug, Executive Secretaxy, Appeals Board Patricia Moxness , Recording Secretary, Appeals Board Chairman bVozniak called the Meeting to order at 1: 50 p.m. Mr. Glassman moved that the l�tinutes of the August 12 , 1975 , �teeting be approved. Pdrs . Peake seconded. NIOTION CARRIED �ND SO ORDERED. THE VOTE : Ayes - 6 Nayes - 0 Abstentions - 0 � Lr?(h`��O�T F� E�t cFR�� ., 9/9/75-Meeting No. 115 42=,�5-B -10- Cassette Tape No. T27 • 8I .W. Congress Ave. CASE N0. PROPERTY APPELLANT , , ��6`� '-: 42-75-B � � 81 W. Congress Ave. James D. Beacom SITBJECT• Request for garage variance from St. Paul Legislative Code, Section 40.00 (i), pertaining to the requirement that any garage which is to the rear of the residence sha�l not be closer than two feet (2 ft.) to the side lot line, so as to build new garage on property line. APPEARANCE: James D. Beacom PROCEEDINGS• Mr. Beacom said that he wanted to build a garage with eaves lining up with his side property line. He had a letter from the homeowner on the next property to the side lot line in question, who stated that he had no objections. BOARD ACTION: Chairman Wozniak moved that the appeal for garage variance from St. Paul Legislative Code, Section 40.00 (i) , pertaining to the requirement that any garage which is : to the rear of a residence shall not be closer than two ft. to the side Zot line, t�e granted. Mr. Glassman seconded. MOTI01� CARRIED AND SO ORDERED. Z'�IE VOTE• Ayes - 6 Nayes - 0, Abstentions - 0 9/9/75 - Meeting Na. I�15 Cassette Ta�e No. �1"27 �' 1�1INUTES OF THE MEETING ST. PAUL BOARD OF APPEALS AND REVIEW Tuesday, September 9, 1975 City Council Commit-Cee Room 707 City Hall and Court House 1: 30 P.M. ME�iBERS PRESENT: D. Donald Wozniak, Chairman Estyr Bradley Peake David Heider Ronald Glassman �lrthur M. Tieso James D. Voigt �IEriBER ABSENT: Norma Sommerdorf AGENCIES PRESENT: Department of Community Services - Division of t_ Housing and Building Code Enforcement ,<; Frank Staffenson, Housing Supervisor Dan Person, Senior Building Inspector Alice Bijjani, Housing Inspector Richard Perry, Housing Inspector Thomas Strohkirch, Housing Inspector Doug Schwab , Senior Plumbing Inspector OTHERS PRESENT: Jon Bjornnes , Appellant W. T. Bjornnes Richard A. Zappa, Representative of Sussel Co. , on Behalf of Charles Walk, Appellant John Kavanagh, Appellant ' F. J. Nahurski , Attorney,on Behalf of Valerie Batorewicz , Appellant Kevin N1cCarthy, Representative of Clapp-Thomssen, on Behalf of Valerie Batore�aicz, �Appellant James Beacom, Anpellant Michael P�IcGough, Appellant STF�FF PRESENT : Doris L. Getsug, Executive Secretary, Appeals Board Patricia Moxness , Recording Secretary, Appeals Board Chairman ti9ozniak called the Nleeting to order at 1: 50 p.m. I�1r. Glassman moved that the l�Tinutes of the August 12, Z975 , A�teeting be approved. Mrs . Peake seconded. P�IOTION CARRIED A�VD SO ORDERED. THE VOtE : Ayes - 6 Nayes - 0 Abstentions - 0 - -- - - - - - - - - - - - ---- -- -- - -- - - - -- -- --- ---- --- -- - -- ---- ------ - --- -------- : c� c�a � � . . r �- ` V _ r • � • � � � ?`�• STATE OF MINNESOTA � Couat� of Ramsgy se. � crc�r o�► e�n�rr p�u�. � . t..................................�e..�...... .........._.............._.........ci�► ci�k oi the Cit� � Ssint Paul, Mi3naesots do haeb� certify that I hAVe oomparad tbe attach�d oopy ot Couadl Fi1e Na.........2��................... �s adopted by the City Coundl...__.._..D.�t�r..2.$.,................19.:T�.......... co ti " and a ro�ed b tbe Ma � PF Y Y'or.....................Q�.:G4��..��......_.._......19.Z5.......... � o with tt.�orlglnal thereoi oa flle ia acy+oSice. v� ............_.......................•---..........__....--•--............_....._...................................................... 0 � ' ...._............._.. .........--------........................_._..._....................._...._..._._........................... W �o.:v.. ««».«........�.....a...»..�......................................... ......................"'......._.................... ».._...�.«........""'...................................................................................................--•-".... . ;. , . , ........... »............"'........................»....«.»..............................._.._............................. - �,* .., �, A� . `1 � � . `� r -y_ l�w � . ..»......�......»................""..........»..........««.........................................._.........»................. .cr . �� .JP. ... - . , y M 7... „ . } «........»�................"'................»..__...».......»........_........................................................... �Y-•w ° ... . . - � , Csrk '. 1 � ..»............""'........................«................._.....""'....._..........................""........."'........_.... J�. •. I further oertify that said copy ls a true and correct copy ot , - _ . ,; ,q ' �r ' '` ,�:., said orlgiasl aad the �vhole thereot. <,t s; •�^ ^ WITNESS my hand and the�eal of the Clty oi Saint Paul, Mlnn.. this............�th...........dity oi....._..... . ........... .......A. D. 19.7.�. ..._. r,. .._..... .. Clty erk.... ................ Q $ �Rb � '.) 0.�� ; fR�; � WHITE - CITV CLERK PINK - FINANCE G I TY O F SA I NT PA U L Council CANALt�- DEVARTMENT � � Bl,liE - MAYOR File �0. � � � ��. ncil Resolution Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date RESOLVED, That the Council of the City of Saint Paul hereby ratifies and approves the action of the Saint Paul Board of Appeals and Review pertaining to the following listed property and as shown by the Excerpted Minutes of said Board of Appeals and Review, dated September 9, 1975, and marked EXHIBIT A, and attached hereto and made a part hereof by reference: DATE OF BOARD MINUTES CASE N0. PROPERTY APPELLANT 9/9/75 39/75/B 1329 Lincoln Ave. Cha.rles Walk by Sussel Co. , Richard A. Zappa � � BOARD ACTION: Garage Variance granted from St. Paul Legislative �,,, Code, Section 40.00(i) , requiring 2 ft. Side Lot ,�,; Clearance from property line for any garage which Q; � is to the rear of the residence so as to permit four- r. car garage to be built in rear of property facing alley, subject to the requirements of the State Building Code. Property Description: Lot 18, Block 3, Stinson' s � Blvd. Addition. 9/9/75 40/�7�SJ�B f 1816 Ashland Ave. Jon Bjornnes BOARD ACTION: Garage Variance granted from St. Paul Legislative Code, Section 33.04(2) , pertaining to Rear Yard Clearance requirement of a minimum distance of 25 ft. from main portion of the dwelling, so as to build rear-attached garage. COUIVCILMEN Yeas Nays Requested by Department of: Christensen Hozza In Favor Levine Roedler Against By — Sylvester Tedesco President Hunt Form Approved by City Attorney Adopted by Council: Date Certified Passed by Council Secretary BY By Approved by Mayor: Date Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council gy By �� , - M EN T G I T Y O F S A I N T PA IT L Council ��r`� • '', File N 0. � �' '. �' cil Resolution .ted By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date Page 2 . Prop�y Description: N. 100 ft. of Lot 14, Block 6, � Egbert G. Handy' s Addition to the City of St. Paulo ------------------------ � 9/9/75 41/75/B 1954 Rome Ave. Micha.el J. McGough MBOARD ACTION: Garage Variance granted from St. Paul Legislative Code, � Section 40.00(i) , pertaining to the requirement tha.t J; any garage which is to the rear of the residence sha.11 *�°� not be closer than two ft. (2 ft. ) to the Side Lot line, so as to utilize existing retaining wall on the east property line as the back wall of the new garage to be built thereon, subject to the requirements of the State Building Code. Propertv Description: Lot 23, Block 1, Highview Addition. ---------------=------- 9/9/75 42/75/B 81 W. Congress Ave . James D. Beacom � BOARD ACTION: Garage Variance granted from St. Paul Legislative Code, Section 40.00(i) , pertaining to the requiremen� tha.t any garage which is to the rear of the residence sha.11 not be closer than two ft. (2 ft. ) to the Side Lot line, so as to build new garage on the property line, subject to the requirements of the State Building Code. Pro ert Descri tion: Lot 8, except the W. � foot, t�nion ottage earrangement of the W. � of Block 57, West St. Paul Proper. _ �C COUNCILMEIV Requested by Department of: Yeas Nays Christensen �� gunt [n Favor Levine , Rcedler 6 Against BY Sylvester ��' President �� Hozzs ai��T � � ,�;�rs Form Approved by City Attorney Adopted by Cou . Date "�" CertiEie assed o '1 cretary ' BY ��• B Approve y Mayor: ate f f Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council By By r',?L!:i±Et� 'V�Y ) 1�%� ' . �� .. �• ��.. r � � � � � � �� ,J� \x�, � ,v � � � � \ � - \ ,q f� C Si� � w ":'1 y.� � M►r µ � 'd � � 0 �� .i �' s' � � t�'�' ,�, �� i+�r � � � � w � � � � � � :� �,� �, n � ,� c� � � �. � Q .�: � � � � -� ' � �� V � :� -. p a�= � � r� tiD . �r ,�,..t � �a p � � :r' �4 \ � �� Qn �J $ ��' L• � 47 v�'\` � �r'" � w � 7P 1 � (��. � � `�C ` �� _, A �i r�1 ° �� 6 �' r �. �C u �^'y �G � � , �V r t ' �� M _3 �� . � ��-� �:� :� �il (� � C.. �' :3 �t , � � � ^ ` `t� �. � . � � � n � <o L � i � � ... t