266201 WHITF,y �- CITY CLERK �������
PINK - FINANCE GITY OF SAINT PAITL Council
CANARY - DEPARTMENT ��� �
BLUE - MAYOR File NO.
RETtk� CO�C TO VALUATION B�tEAU Council Resolution
,
Presented By_' �`� �.�--s y �
Referred To Committee: Date
Out of Committee By Date
RESOLVID, that the p�roper City officials are hereby authorized
and directed to execute oA behs,].f of �he City of 3t. Fau], an applic:ation
to the Land Ca�i.esioner of Ramsey County for the conveyance of certain
tax forfeited lands �or use by the City of St. Paul for street purposes;
a description oP the tax forPeited land ia as folla�rs:
The West 20 feet oP the follaWing:
With easement, the South �.5 feet of Lot 4 and al].
of Lot 5, Block l, Messerli and �schbach's Addition.
r
COUIVCILMEN Requested by Department of:
Yeas Nays
Christensen �'��'y $� �j� ggg`/I(;gs
1��' In Favor �
Levine � �
Rcedler Against BY �
��f�d�
�
Vice President�� Tedesco
Adopted by Counc' • Date �� � � ��._ Form A d by City Attorney
_ � �
Certified ssed b uncil Secretary BY
.
B
Ap ed by Mayor: ate Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
By By
PUBUSHE� O CT 18197J ',
• CITY OF SAINT �AUL
OFFICE OF THE C�TY ADMINISTRATOR
� 298-4928
.
To
, �,,�
Fz•or Date �
_____________________________________ __________
II
For your: i� Comments or Reply:
Information i� ��7""v .►—
Attention �i �
_�Approval � .��� � �
i
Advice
Comments � J,GUCH;�i'I �/l�'
�1�/
Reply ��
Please: �� G�t��� �
n co
Contact me ° �
Return �� I`��D
ii � n Cj � _ a
Forward i� 1'1�
Prepare �� z �EP 3 019�5�'
Reply ii (�[y II[�111��� '�
Other: ii � p .
n
u _ � j
u
u
u
u
u
n
n
u
������`�,�-�,,�a°. ^r�. --��`��,�'„���5„x r�� ����}���,�P'vr�- ��x�����,��s�� �.�� ��.-.w- ,},± 's��:;_k�,s�§ :
>� S '=:✓� d. r�� a� Y"�• � ' �'' � �
.. �.r�C � �'� ��� � :, ���a�^. �'� $ � 4��
+�'Y. ah t:.�F :r�' �`�':�..` t v8�y � tk � y�� .i "n�. i
v��..�'x" ' ,-�t �
s i �,�k�F.� �� �.S`" be: f� i. . y t' F, ��' � 2�' a+4:o-,,,
��s��` zr e,?� �� #� � �`�' 'A�° ,r t`�Y Ftt '�' t '` F� #. ��� .
Y
F �„����;� v �,'�� ? � *a �n +��� ���' � '' ����' �" x
, o- �� �'��+�.. �' -� � � ��r '� � � z ✓ '� ` ,Ax,�,� ,�r&r �.b t'i�s� � � a . �
� a � y . � ` ,'� � � .�,
� �
.. �ri:z-'�Lr�`�xa :� ` st � �� a�. . ���� x � 'r � y ;� �. u �� � tF��°�� a
��" .
.� ; �r' `�,c � ' � �r.t',� ��
��i r a r� �,�� � y�,,,���� 1 �N � . ����� � ��,.q n� v �' �� � �'�� T a .
- s``�" ^�''"j�i'S��v '�` k'�'�v' r�`-�-,�2 F.:� K`^��s ��� l'x��t�° � �.
�� x c.„,,,,�.�.r stx, .�*_.-�,i'� .�i€ �`°�r .`+�`#�,�.' ��, �yq,S`y ��� �Y L -K� .. � � -'��o
�'` '�,try.de. - �v +� k '�,rf'�i�a a� _ '.t�.l a�-�'- '�' ��,.� M.�f�.r- ' �. a" �t� �++.
s �;�, ,�a���'��r�;� r'.' � �.,tw � 4°t�*'� '�#� � ��t'���F�,�t��#�`z�i "�'��`}*��.��'"i'"'��''�' s'�,`,y � 2 -�` ,R 3��5�'�.,t
�F " *���* � �-�a x � F �. .�,,. `�''�,s�s� �� �1 ��;�h 'z t't'a��` x.: �r,^,,a�"�'� � { a�` �� � � .
�� "Tr" � r-�. y ay� as .s..y�� 34�rya '�'�.��°'a�"`�?c`�� r.�� ��.s.� ��. � �. � ��"`'�
, e �}� �i ,r�, ,.y'R4, .�.t s �n,� � b, i �,✓�q i re-' `�?'�. � t ,� T,w� ��r�w. `��r `-a 3
x Ta $:...� v' y .�wk� �"�x5 � � ��.,. a �'��;.h � �.'�#; ���mk.'�t ', �f fi, �,' ��' ,�J'`�r�,�'�' K�# � ��.�,c�
'��� ��-��.� �i.p #:� `� ... a'� '�" ���
. � � ; �
.L[�:�F A� � `�� 1 e� .�� � � .T�'. � fJ.:.� 5��. ' '�@ ..J u� � 5^ -.i �' :.A* 'w `� AG k � '. ,n
P
�E �ar -� `.�'a < '�.a �-
'i`,��� >�4 '"`'^Y F�.'.'''ni .,.�J _ y x " ..y �..re � � �t �n"b�,. rY �n�, ;�� °q �X� ys"
� ��.xt �;�; x r � �s �. �to:. �x x�.�, :=f" 1:- .e J' ''.lh.��k '�t` ��,�rry ..� �`:� �,��y�'n. .
,��•�ts '� �1rk�C f� �5� Y•'fi` � �_+� ,� i } 1 f-: 'r. 1 ��,i� °�y'J` � �.:<� �''A�.x°�" y;:, k ,J'� ..e 5y�b�k'�.a Vyi� �„ _+ ,
;.��r ,�4�`- :�x->e. s �2 �� :vs A �, -� 2�, � � � � yr�°et� g �'� ry�y �.Rg�,�
rir !. 1� ' 3 . `t;� �M �
^�''°' �� xa� �j.i a ��.���'a�' ? ,�^�," � z� r -•. � �°'t ''S` -�,. s��rK��£i �} ^^� p w
� � 3 t 3"�3 ��`����� S,+}' � �k . +,..
.. ,,�`, �k�,'�s2+ � �?.a `�ik. 4 w ''��..-,a a r 5. t `�:2 1g' +,F � �r� ,�, Nfip �`f 1`r"'�# �a�
3`}�-t�'F.°�"�y; ��" ���"s t�. 4 �' �`, i �n > .�i` s"i`e�' ";*E,� c�; � x?�S•`'"{��� ��`2 �'°` .
:'cr�"�4 � �� a � .��14 ?-� �,., t&°� y.. �,+ •:'Y �' ... ro . � -,� �;.s .3. �,.�,a� ` -
x.n �#k T�+`" . �,. . ����,'r°,d�7`,r,�g•� ����'r�?e����,z r'�',° .
` � � . r � �Sr ,� �sr�
����2�� '�€ .. � " �� �..
�� ��V '°�n..'r,4�, �'kr �> a� �s �.� . ��, `' � c ��'4���� � �:�qy
� � .xr �`�� , �a*�x � '� .� � �; �, �s �� �'c�`�� �'��
sa y w � t�' �'�f,�'` �� YL� A� '� "��"��� �� .
'�'�t� , ,�. if[k ���r� h"�+:�d ��v. C � �M�> N, k ����"G.w'�+"rL °�,�'*�� +�?' �: '�r� 'Cp• ��',�`'^�q�� L �r '�i ,. y-,,.�
Y ,�
' 3 >+�,'V' '� �t > � �� i '`�i w P. r * �'�`y ',4 {+"'+ �,"4a , `-F ''pt `W� 'u"��y�J'`9r ��
'�� � y?I: � .:� .t � �.{y�.���.g,��.',�Z �'
J �a'�l ^�'`��v . .. .�5� !f h'r�� t2;� ��5�". '�'��h r. ,.
, a _�*} � �!� �Ta�1' 3 �` �� ' . y�¢ '.Yr�u'�lA{':�ras� '"�i .
, n .r e#��"�'3`�1''�, �+ . �+. Cw�:5. '�. .� � �,'?� k_,.� � N,�� . .-� �.
� � r' e : � � ��� -3 n �r � . �` x��'�`
y4 � � ' y . R ::. t �.f +t��� €� t`�,\ �€} :,N;�`��,t a++�y�'�.au�'��'�' .S.
:a � '� '��'� ; `n ;'• k�P` k A�`# � � +` € '�*s �`3kti� � "'f" :,�-
��� ¢ '. r � � �, � � x. .r �sw. � Y��x � � � �� �'i� � �`" �i� .€���v "� ��� � �� i.- .t��.€� ,
,:�z .� ,� .-t Y.. ?�� .2.. �.. ,,,,� k .� +a.��,?.�'��'�-� _.: C k7 � i'+c,
i..'-���, " � a .•,3 1 ,� ��'a',M ,�-r'3'�.�'�ir.�n�� i a �`''.t �f�"�, ,��.�S�� �.,t 1 i£ �t��'���'�i'°�w "p'��?a,. ���,�`,�p� �'"
r � ;
,-. x � . ' '� '� .. �
� , ', �'� . �,'
1�..: y f g 'E� .✓ N � � � ��
t � � � "�.3 � �l� �3f� ��kx.�a �1��: 'd�, 2 .� � 2 4A.. . . t T _ y�� ,`4.� � L t"�.a1'�t�'s-��a:
�i+y. � �f i � c , "� `��.�.k y��t .r` zs�' �Y�R
a �'�Rt�+�„ �W �.� � � �' ? X. ' r u,'"� a .: +-�z � .n �� 1 �, �-,,.��' .
,,.,�,. 3�' y tt�.t.�x�°T����� ;� �� � '` s;' 4��3�-8�„����4 ,�;3;�r l� '�",R'��� ��5�2� �, '$:�' ��"�.�f��s ��`+€,�'+� _
n 4t ' ' v� � �- pf �:.`�
� . �, }�.�y.��Y �� p'�S F�•CS�`,W �:i^`" �" x�!# 'F J.*"'��. � ���'F t.'�-' j ifs��'g '$�,���F,4�! . � �t �^� '��`���"}�+�
;:s�... s�q"""e,,. a. p y*M r . T,'C' .:� '.:'S -: 11 4' ':+� t �1_� f��yc :�,�'4 4�'' � .,�t� ��'$1u- ti
qS^ �, . �l ., k. " 4+ �'��, .j.}°�pw�:f'8� ,�.,d, -3te ,, � �g•�j-e �,�
�'a�,�,�"'� i , .r w. .J v �°� �
.&� 'r,.&a�#d g�l3` �.� �w,�� �4rT"� .�-,� 3' .w t ���pk5'���,..t„t a�'i "��� � x �`�'� .
�na
.: µ� ' . .�•• � �� �':�. . ��;'t �� l��' �.>.... ._ .� i i F �.� q� ��s� , ��G� � "'f �€�`~� '�'"� .� � i:�
,� .� `T p� �x�r'`�1 rc�" $ . s �^ .�. s. v_ a�v�J�t�`���,s� ,: 4� �"k1� c�K i
�� �'�� ��'A�i� :.. 7 .,s• *`'r:. . � •?.� '�;5� ^ �,y,t : s�, A�?:e� �'�. �� . sy�^�. �,Y � :�� k� f
�1�,�, . � _. *Y 4." :* '��. � '� � - n4 J�.,Yr�W�."f'�' a,�.���� � i ���.�
� �' °° � � � . 3�^��'��"'�",�,d�a#��'�?�"'� �'+s'
e xa r �. -u .. �"IC� ,n'wt,�, -_ ,� - . �
+�p .��j'� �-k",�.;��.�,��' �.. � t K3 �i*� c�,ka . �. ,r*ta. fa�•��,e�~� ��;
":;,,�,�+' .J"V,�,r� '_;��.5� ;��.a �-s�1 .�� ,��" y�� � } �
,d�' ;s �3-' ._ � ��$ � ,� .'�.
i
'� SY- �afWt �.�r j-7- _ . �' �'` ; ,�y � x
� �. " ��� � rv���{��� L . �' ������'�I' ' n ;F � ° ������ +� '�-
'� � z �`� C;- , 7�*`z 's� � �{'`
' � �'',a�k'�� �, ��€��y�+. .-. r � �' --� � § +�C�� �, ;�'�{� �.
t � e � �
x°� ~ �•y :'�� r a� , x "F-` �" 3 �a. -*�" �,,r�t°� r.x
� � � � v
'�� � = r �'`� ��� -,a�x�'`..,, ' r Y" t '� �� , F# � � �. ' �`�R��rytzti ��
�+. ^.c. �� y}+.�..... ,�� � . dak � . �`l�, ,�? � y� .K'�+n ,�� � �,� � r ° i 1. �'F�y ., �yarY""��y;A'
'(, .yC`�EY �.� �-F •b . Iy. 1 ' �]r''FPb �.� ��,,,� �t''
�` - s.d Sa��� r �� �'�+��� �- �c '. " vw , F t ... zq{ s� i '.y' a "^- r ,�'s,�����{�'°r4i" �*" ' �
t.�,�...��'�� �. k s � a a k d a j :.�� ��`�v y ��+ �g �,�a����t:' .
,,� ?it .y 7M1 .9 . . T+ ^� b�`��} �+ re
,^na�P��:rr ,�. � �.r �+,�..aii-i �'�.x't' '. � � ,� r i �,,rt �*:� �'s r�r � '�, ' �s � .�. `�� k '<�.�ti'�.�..
�; a �q �,�y�k� '7*�' '``�Zfi�.�C� Sr�;• ;1 '�3 � , � "�t YL +,;r � x.� x r3�� ,w'"�•�.��,r'��-� ��+ � -�S
;} �`N �S"''�.'L*s���� � � f r, ri � � '. " a � t �-t�� �'Fb.� z � `F a�k ss��, 1 �-�,� ��� '
� � �����#c�.'�ie' g G�-�. >y� # �. �• ..t v`� k-t -d�a 2 �` -k����}^ 'h-3�� 'i..s r. . ,�s,n,�,.".:�F..$ � '� c � _
s . � a.1 � �t � � x P ��. �. 5 '� �� � e„.` a . -,<,r{ n a, *1 �, . -k'� �a�^a r� � ��ia,&.�.
tr* � ,A ' � �'r , r �. d f�y a "i . t 4 �''`�<`�,� � � `�' .,�Y C�k''s�"x e
�'
`q i�„ia Er.z Y .#1°' ��g � �t+�A�'� �,��v
��` � , 'i ������ ti,�` �a �'�� 'y��a �.� �*. ;T+ ,� y�� .. �$ .�+" � ?°� +� �,�
�F�- ± '�.�"�` <� {:�-�Er ,'. F` �<x S ��y � h J # ��\�.^���` �n a._, w ,.. �rd'SL��� � ��� 'z����� �°�'�M'�,�t.
y ' <
�3 �' -�'�, ��`' l � w- ir '} t ��''"��`���-xa�� �*x����y�'�, x�cfi
� � ..: - �� � � � � � .f � .
w � e.A F �-r�.�''k� i . ,: r s^,�' �� '` ''"� _ ,- �,+
'
�.,.`��'�'� " �°< j���
7 y.�. � „': ' �d`"'`�'F��aKi*�����A_�.�'��*rr�a; :.,- , ,,; � �'1� ,. �t�'�f�Y�„�� '�C���l��� .�
* ' $ �� ��i-
-: .'��a�� . - ...:- _.. ,'� h{Y�•E-�,� d "���
t �`
Y �
� t C
C � �'� `"� 4 K�`! � � .,.yy f y,��.
'.���': �� � y#�� k �. . �:11 < � C � t R y��y y f�+ . � 3.,
f �s � #�4`
�wa��. � � t''�Cp.� i , t� n , c _ ����, �y+vf� ���'L .9� �L ,� w�.
'a Y
x
�� '"�.k�¢.4F .'_
ks> � �+�."� t�� ��� t �. '" F�x � t�., r;i �. � �`�. �' x r ' rx� {y � t .�'.:-� :.
r-c � k. , 5,a �¢l-.w4k ! .s7 ��� . L:. ,.�7s�f4 }.�:� � '�' ��� � �-4i�v�{ E"� =r>^��R�� � .��t',k�} �„�''.
r � §:'s �,��Si _ � � k� r � y�€e r� �y�� E�`:"+ ,G �'{� •.�;X,��.E �4 �'st';�v m �
_ � � �` .,s" d a' s Tx1'$�� 4 �h .,zw�� �' k k� 'a�t. R'���"ti`������ `� �s �����,
- ts �"{T i "�'-s.,4w;rrk' _ e }:p'�{ � .'�r h'r' 7C`,�� z,� +'+�`� ��' �}�"�."k=;3,s�i -ffii'�y r
A y. a:n+v"��{�,�§i,�.;'u� 4 rt,: � "• ., z# va';t y*w"P`2�": �, �v`s �p'� �',� � �z i �y, 9
',.�W�'��'�'�= &•v °�`.'Y{'.�y''�,�`°; :, P _ t �s x �, ,# rt c `�7��'d��' °�8'ts'`�� �. 3 �. +�.'���at��,.+�,�� -r. ����'
.. y . a,� k� -� .� � � � � '�,. .1? �S sF".�d i..a,,r. n s =„n ��..
��`aS y�,.�'g'a F�'"�e 3 '�., � �3�''�t ri At s .,x .� ��" r .� .
wh��a�. ,i�4�F�<y ��e; �F t#...: �3�+j" �� '��r.,• ':4 � "-�j. �`� s ai�e�,..�^��s�t 1.�,S�" ��.,�Y�R����
-�FiG ��� '� �'�r » .y ,��''� � � a � ,� ,, s.��� ��a "�a,, �� # '� `'�-
,.,t� � *w���F�3�� T i' u,,'a',�� z` � ,�+ ,��s ��� � ;..x y 1 t» .r��g;. ,y 1 '�'9 ` x ..�.'" �'4 -t�`�, �;�.�, �..
� ..M,. 5 9 i5 p : ly ,e+i 'rt� tS . �F � ,` .�� 'a `� ,� �S� � .
,.�� ,. �,y �,�,Y . 2tn� -�. t td �,, . �� M �,k��fr�`� � a,�,��e",� '��'ik ;� f ��,�, .
� � �� �rn^x R�"# v<x._';: i�^x��':` �s� ,� �.�l � y.� -" � A _ ��'?�,�-aRt; 4. ',��«.aa+� � �j`+�Sv+�*r ? � � �'`� r �� _
;t�� ��'�R�. .'�a;s`-e�. -: f x,- f ,• �` s�� + s „ �_ qit`� `��s f��",a'� � x J ��k .y�"�� xu �,4 o-� �;p,.��-�+ s��_ .
't�'� "rr A- � +�, J u � . ` w ���. � 3{ �:��4 .� �J Aa+� h . � 3
� 2y.,s,�_ � r ,,�y. �P� '°'+� c '��-� n$r �:. a: s� ; � �r<.. !�; �.fs+. � a.y �1'+�,v .. .x`y .. +��` �� "' a.+f"�'t" -
�a€� ;� �r+,.��,�� ,� �.< +k,€�� "„�'a
'� . �.F ��<'J� S,:'�A� �j h s '�4 �'. '�3 i4�-�L F� d °��7'j�*'s�pY"'��.`�3, 4''�';f�#�'s r,'� 5,, � `'i a �
t
§k'� . '.-�a�"�,� �`�'� � '� �x K �„ j � y t� �a�`� � `4�, a� ' �,"� 'r3�.,'���{^� 3� ��� ��� ��`�� �'`��'.
3 ^� x 12��,r£ 7r y y * !: 3 r.1 � � �.r�.,.��r a ,e �0 3' ��f r ,x��°.�S � ,�.�p. u � ..
� k;: � L� � 9 . 4 {r � F d
�3 y.� �,��#!a. i�„ � �i'� `� 'd��,�.. � `'`, k ':. ;#.�. "� �:: .. '` �.; �. ,���. a „, ,:rv�� '��.i�'��,2 �'� `�''�; � :v�s
.,i�` � �� y m�.�' � '`��t'�w-`�`.� I� �� � �� � � i� �'�£-� ce � t.'� ""�" �«e. �.,�'"' -'r w"�`Fa�'�`^:�'E '�,n* 4u '���r��r:`��
�� �� f?� `*, :r ��,� �µ� '� ',�, T �! + � � � +� _�r�
� '�'� � � ` h;*:�a" i"�'Y#'fr��S a � � �:'� � �. � '*u+ '"W �:,, ..t ` I x'°�P r' ._ �.''k3 .s. ✓e#� ° � .r; `C'M,,��} ; �:.�
- r rt �.'�. � � Y t - Y . `t'.ii - '„ 4 �" ..Lr v( 'N :C ' � Y �.
�.� ,�����, � �s r � �-.-��p�� ,�� a�. � � � . ��,���� � �-�� �� �� . a�;���p�c ��`.
..� � . ,r _.. ...�u��.L,i�''�rMar�z.�..,..��� �. .:,�-..�',a..a.,.�w�..zSF���.'�r..�a�.....,..�..�°`..:_. a_ea�D�.x.;�s.;�.,,�.� �twz�.���` �sr .._ai��...-.t_ ��''...�-.,.&, r�afr�_'' ,._
. �
. � �
MEMORANDUM S ITY OF SAINT PAUL
. ` Q�c �� CE OF THE MAYOR
. � CITY PLANNING
SEP 191975► -�0
DATE: September 17, 1975 DONALD L. SPAID AIP
� � �� NING COORDINATOR
TO : Peter G. Hames
�' �' � ����;�1
F R O M : Donald L. Spaid � -
SUBJECT: Your Memorandum of September 8 regarding Tax Forfeited Property Described
as: With easement, the south 4.5 feet of Lot 4 and all of Lot 5, Block 1,
Messerli and Eschbach's Addition
In answer to your questions concerning the Planning recommendations on the
above captioned matter, we submit the following rationale indicating that
no change in the recommendation is in order.
1. The description includes all of Lot 5 (an area of 5773 square feet)
and the south 4.5 feet of Lot 4 (an area of 615 square feet) for a
total area of 6388 square feet. The area to be retained in public
ownership according to the recommendation is 934 square feet (46.7'
x 20') leaving a residual parcel measuring 116.81' x 46.7' containing
5455 square feet which meets or exceeds the zoning requirements for
buildability.
2 and 3. Because the remainder of Ocean Street is graded but not paved,
our recommendation is to retain in public ownership that portion of the
subject property which will be needed in the future to accomplish the
grading, paving, and construction of a Cul-de-sac.
The distance from the south line of East Seventh Street to the terminus
of Ocean Street is about 266 feet. If no Cul-de-sac is provided, cars
entering the street must either use private property to turn around, or
back out onto East Seventh Street.
It is our professional opinion that because a portion of the property
is needed for Cul-de-sac construction and is available on a tax
forfeiture basis, it would be more appropriate to retain the needed
land than to re-acquire needed right-of-way at a later date through
condemnation process.
If you have further questions concerning this matter, please contact our
office. "
DLS:CLMcG:bj
421 Wabasha Street, Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102 (612)-298-4151
0
��
,+`'�•t� : CiTY OF SAINT PAUL
=�� ' OFFICE OF THE CITY ADMINISTRATOR
i.• ,�, . ���
t!� r,
a ,.��: ,
� �r� ;.�.... .
..�. yfi� � THOMAS ). Kt�LtFY
3b5 City Ha(i, Saint Paul, Minnesota 551E�2
LAW'RENCE D. CONEN ^�^���
Mayo� f. b (612) 29f3-492t3
September 8, 1975
TO: Donald L. Spaid
FR: Peter G. Hame
RE: T� Forfeited Property; With easement, the sfluth
4. 5 feet Lot 4 and all of Lot 5, Block 1, Messerli
and Eschbach's Additior�
Your August 12, 1975 report on this property recommended '
: that the West twenty f�et be acquired by the City for a
cul-de-sac, and that the remainder of the property be
sold for residential use.
: Your rec+�mmendation is questioned for the following
reasons:
l. The size of th� lot would be reduced from 5,773 sq. ft.
:to 4,929 sq. ft. , raising the question of whether the
lot w+ould be too small for residentiai develapment.
2. The remainder of Ocean Street is graded but not
paved, raising a question of whether only a portion
of an unpaved street should be paved.
3. At present the Department of Public Warks has no
plans for constructing the proposed cul-de-sac.
ACTION REQUESTED �
_ _a..,,
In light of the above, please review your =ecommendation.
if you beiieve a change in your recommendation is in order,
request the Planning Commission to revi�w its recom- ,
mendation.
If you do not believe a change is in order, provide me
with your rationale. "
PGH/ca
r ����il�
MEMORANDUM CITY OF SAINT PAUL
, , , OFFICE OF THE MAYOR
CITY PLANNING
DATE: August �2, �975 DONALD L. SPAID AIP
PLANNING COORDINATOR
TO: Thomas Kelley, City Administrator
FROM: Donald Spai
SUBJECT: Review of Disposition of Tax Forfeited Property
Attached for your consideration is a copy of the City Planning Staff
Report concerning the disposition of the tax forfeited property
described as; With easement, the South 4.5 feet Lot 4 and all of
Lot 5, Block 1, Messerli and Eschbach's Addition. The City Planning
Commission reviewed and approved the Staff Report.
Also attached to this memorandum is a copy of the Resolution passed by the
Commission concerning this matter. Please forward this material to the
Mayor and Council for their information and action.
r\ .
� %.� \ ���,�,,
�
�: .�; ��i
�,��� ��'�IIIr,� .�
�
�� �,�� ��19?�a► 'j'
�,�� ������ ADMINISTRAtOR ,��
� �\�T
/�lJ
421 Wabasha Street, Sain� Paul, Ivlinr�esota 55102 (612)-298-4151
0
� ,�� .
_.. _ _._._. . ____--� ---._._._,_ , __-- --- _ __.___.�_....
.� . .. � � � �66�01 :
,
. .�
STAFF REPORT �
REQUEST FOR RELEASE OF THE CITY'3
INTE�ST IN TAX FORFEITED PROPERTX
WITH EASEMiSNT, THE SOUTH 4.5 FEET
OF LOT 4 AND ALL OF LOT 5, BLOCR 1,
MESSERLI AND ESCHBACH'S ADDITIO�T
ST. PAUL CITY PLANNING
. AUGUST 11, 1975
�
� �66��1
a
E s � V �. �v�r-H
� ; , �
w � o�S 'f�`
� �� �
� �, �a
o , �, �
3��^►fi �;
� II �' 3 �` i .5 �
`j i p ��' '� a; �i� Qj•a
�
� � N 5 � 3� a
_ _ _ � ? _ _.
ao -
� 3 `( 5 � � � � �� �I Ia ��
� u � �i �" v � tS
Ross � v.
s u � N° 3 7
,b �1 5 f� 1� V,
. . �es���
The City of Saint Paul has been requested by Ramsey County to review the
need to maintain City interest in South 4.5 feet of Lot 4, and all of Lot
5, Block 1, Messerli and Eschbach's Addition, with easement; which is tax
forfeit.
Based on analysis of the existing Comprehensive Plan, current planning
activities, and the recom�endations of J. William Donovan, City Valuation
Engineer, the following recouanendation is ma.de:
APPROVE THE ACQUISITION OF THE WEST 20 FEET OF SOUTH 4.5 FEET OF
LOT 4, AND ALL OF LOT 5, BLOCK 1, MESSERLI AND ESCHBACH'S ADDITION,
WITH EASEMENT, ANA RECOr1MEND THAT THE REMAINDER OF THIS PROPERTY BE
SOLD FOR RESIDENTIAL USE.
The land in question is located on the east side of the dead end of Ocean
Street between East Seventh Street and Ross Avenue in an area that is one
and two family residential.
As the Department of Public Works requires only a small portion of these
lots for its project, on June 12, 1975, the Land Comanissioner's office
asked that the City acquire the portion it needs for the cul-de-sac and
give them approval of the sale of the remainder, or assume the obligation
of keeping the lots ("faet becoming a rodent infested dumping ground")
cleaned up.
Aa indicated in the Valuation Engineer's report, in 1969 the subj:ect parcel
was withheld for cul-de-sac purposea at the request of the Department of
Public Works. No other city department requested that the land be withheld.
The land is not sufficiently close to any recreation area, school, library
or other public facility ao as to provide for expansion of any of these
facilities. Also, it is not needed as part of any identified Public Works
project.
Given the lack of any public use of the property and the general residential
character of the area, it is recom�nended that the City acquire that which is
needed for the cul-de-sac and relinquish any interest in the remainder of
this property to be sold for residential use.
,
� � . � . 266��� r- __..
� - ��.
�� . �.
. . . -„� .,
� � ���.. •.
C
� � � • � OFFICE OF THE LAND COMMISSIONER :.��''�g . ��.•�F;'i� ���:��
�'f � �
COUNTY OF RAMSEY K� �
S
zas c�,n Ho��, ��o� � '�UN 131975� ►-►:,�
ST. PAUL� MINNESOTA ''
q1� A�451S�� .�
ANTHONY J. REITER, Canmissioner 53� '
� � �t
J'uDe 12, 1 � f
Thomas J. Kelley .
City Administrator
City oP Saint Paul
800m 365, city xau
8t. Paul, I� 55102
�: Taa For�eited Lerlds - Cod.e 02-51500-050-01
� With easement, the 8outh 4.y fee� oP Lot 4
and all of Lot 5, Block l, l�esserli and
8schbach's Addition
Desr 3ir:
This otPice has received several requests that the above noted tax �or�eited
lands 'be ofYered for sale. These lots are locsted on Ocean Street, south of
Ba,at Seventh Street.
Sub�ect parcels forfeited to the State on July 29, 1969, and have been with-
luld irom sale since that time by the City oP St. Paul Por the thture con-
atruction o� a cul-de-sac in the street.
These lots are faet becoming a rodent-intested dumping grauad, and no amount
of money spent on maintenance will correct the problem as long as the parcel
is publicly owned.
As the Department of Public Works requires onl,y a small portion of',these lots
!or its pro�ect, we ask that the City acquire •the portion it needs for the
cul-de-sac and give us approval o� sale on the remainder, or a,ssume the obliga-
tion o� keeping the lots cleaned up.
Yanr�t very truly,
. _ - ��y'.�a-rk ���C�C�i�'
oa,}r J. ter
?+snd Com�issioner
JJJ�gee
Attach.: 3ketch
ccs J. Wm. Donovan
, .
�
. . ��� _ _
� �� ��5�;��
June 1$, 1g75
Dgn3.�1 Durl.Pord
Directa� of public Wor�:s
Room 23�+
BUILDIl9G
Re: Tax torteited 2aryd wi�:,hhel@ f�ram saie:
Wi�h easeoent, th� South 4.5 fee� of Lot �
and all of Lot 5, Block l, Meas�rli and
Esahbe,ch's Additfo� - Code Q2-5150R-C150-01
D�r Sir;
fihe sub,ec�: pe�rcel, as indicatad on the a�;+-.a�bsent, oas witht�eld in 196g a*.,
�:he request of Yaur d,epsrt,�t far cul.-c�e-sse Pu�'pous. At that time, you
ind3.aated orilry the r�ater�;r 20 feet �rare �ue�scit�!� As �e�+ridenced by ths er�ach-
ad let�er, tbe La�3 Cc�i.,�sfoner requ�ta tbdt we sither ae€quir� wlaet ia
need�d Por turn arau�d purpwas and ar�rla��s t.hc r�ttnd�r aar relae►ae t;he
eati.re pe►rsel. Pl�s,�e reviar th� status o!' thie parcel arid �k� your recom-
mendatiai rtpar�t i;o �e a� soon aa �►ossible o
If there a�e az�y c�stioaa, plea.s� �all me.
V�'Y tru1,Y Youre,
J. Willlem Donova�a
Valw,tioA Enginesr
J41'D:RJR:d�
A tfi,a�h
cc: Dor�ld Spaid
Fraa�: N�ele
��� , ,
R�; ,
x
4� �
�� �
�'�:.��,�;rµ
.
� 266�'�1 _ _
. 6•'* °►. _�� CITY OF SAINT PAUL
. �� .f, • . �, s. '��;�t!'1"'!r•:°"...n+.-.t �
.. � � ' -.�'-_ . • =, � OFFICE Of THE CITY ADMINISTRATOR
e r ....,... ; ;
.........: + �""'�----,'
� �o • ^Q �! �; , ,
� ::.�::: B .: : "
�••. x��,;, � ����`�` : ,,., • THOMAS ). KELLEY
� 365 Cit Hall Saint Paul Minnesota 55102
y , ,
UWRENCE D.COHEN �6�2� 2�-�92$
Mayor
June 13, 1975
TO: J. William Donovan
FR: Thomas J. Kelley �JK
RE: Tax Forfeited Lands - Code 02-51500-050-01
Attached is a letter from Anthony J. Reiter and a sketch
relative to the above real estate for your review.
Please take the following action: ,
l. Donovan - investigate the status of this
property and prepare a report for Mr. Donald
Spaid.
2. Spaid - make a recommendation on the sale �
of this property.
Thank you for your assistance.
TJK/ca �
� Attach.
cc: Daniel J. Dunford
� �
� � . :� � � _ - _ �ss��
. �
' � r
- i.
'f / 7.�. � i�rr
� �`: _. � . _ CtTY OF SAINT PAUL
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLlC WORKS
DANtEL J. DUNFORD
DIRECTOR
June 24, 1975
Mr. J. William Donovan
Valuation Engineer
Room 286 City Hall
BUILDING
Re: Tax forfeited land withheld
f rom ssie: With easeme�t,
the south 4.5 feet of Lot 4
and sil of Lot 5� Btock 1,
� Messerli and Eschbach's
Addttion
Dear Mr. Do�ovan:
A reexamination of the referenced parcel has been campleted.
Ocean St. is presently dead ended adjacent to this parcei, and
the right-of-way width is only 50 feet.. Therefore, the Depart-
ment of Public Works recanmends that the westerly 20 feet of
this pa�cel be acquired for a turn around. This department
wouid have no ob,jection to the sale of the remainder of the
pa rce l.
You�s ve ry truly,
' �
�/T�c'�`�'`''a�a- ' Lt """�
,,
Thomas J. Egg
Office Engineer
TJE/RAH/bjh
Attachment
,
234 City Hall, Saint Paut, Minnesota 55102
� � �ss�.�1
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE AND MANAGEMENT SERVICES
DIVISION OF ASSESSMENTS AND VALUATIONS
June 2'T, 1975
Dor�ald Spaid
City Planni.ng
Gra.ce Building - 2nd Floor
421 Wabash� st.
st. Paul, Minn. 55102
Re: Request for a revie� of t�x Po�feited lar�d withheld. fromn aale:
With easGmer►t, the Sauth �+.5 feet oP Lot � and all of Lot 5,
Block l, Messerli and. Eschbecb's Additioa
Dee�r Sir:
In 1969, the sub�ect parcel as indi.cated on the attsched plan �ras xithheld
for cul-de-sa.c purposes et the request of the Depe�rt�ertt of Public Wo�ks.
l�o other City depar�ment requested the parcel be xitbheld. Upon revie�w of
this matter in responae to the attached. letter Pro� the Le�ru'i Caom�issioner,
the Depe�rt�ent of Public Works recao�ends the �rest 20 feet oP the sub�ect
peurcel be sequire8 by tt� City aad the rem��iader relee�sed. If this is
aceeptable to the P]rsnning Ca�mi.ssian and the City Administrato�, I have
p�e�pared for aubmission to the I�yo�t� and the City Council a resolution re-
lassing the ra�nairxier of the sub�ect parcel and a resolution suthoriziag
the City to m�k� applioation for the ccaiveyance of the cul-de-sac portion
per Minaesota Ste�te Statutes, C}�e�pt�r 511.
If yau have ar�y questioas on this �astter, plesee call me.
Vety t vatrs,
,
ill3am Donrnrsn �
Valuation Engin�er � � (�
JWD:RJR:dm
� � � � �
.1(1L 119T5
" Atta,ch. CIT�' PLANNIN� gp
cc: 3'boa�.a Kelley . Saint Pa�, Mioae��
�
Telephone612/298-5317 286 City Hall, Saint Paul,Minnesota 55102
. ' APPLICATION QY GOVERNh1ENTAL SUBDIVISION FOR CONVEYANCE OF TAX-FORFEITED LANDS
Under Minnesota Statutes, Section 28 2 01, Subdivision I.
In the Natter of the Application � (�
�f City of St. Paul ,G,66�J1
a Governmer.tril Subdivision, for a
Conveyan�:e of Certain Lan�ls.
Comes now ThC City Of St. PBUl� 8 �minicitoe.7 � tina
IName o subdivi ion
nn�i qlleges:
1. .r�,at a�Pli�a„t is a �a� municipe�l corporation, in Ramsey Cawaty, State of IYitnnesota
2. Tnat �b) Attaah�d hereto ia a resolution of the Citv Coimeil of the Ci#y ot
St. paul for acquisiti.on of the land hereinsfter d�scribed.
:l. That there is situated in the County of R�Bey , certain tax-forfeited
land �iescribed as follows: (c)
_ With eets�eat, th� $outh 4. all nf i.et �,., Rleek ��
Me�serli and Eachb�ch's ABd:�tion
4. That said lands are (d)
�p^•��a,t�-�-� d��irablo—�'or st��t��osa�
5. That applicant desires to obtain said land for the following purposes anc� reasons: (e)
To be used fo� street purpoaea oal..v
Wherefore applicant prays that said lands be conveyed to it for the use stated herein.
City of' Saint Paul
By
itS I�a,yor
and
�ts City Clerk
STATE OF MINNE30TA )
) s s.
COUNTY OF Raffi8¢3► )
Las�renas D. Cohen and Rose Mix
eac}i being Pirst dulc sworn, depose an�l say, each for himself, that they are respectively the
1�YOx' Rn� CitY Cl!*xk oP the City oi" 3t_ 'Pea.t�
;
thnt. they have read the foregoing application and know the contents thereof; and that the matters stated
Lherefn are true.
Subscribed and sworn to before me this
day of , 1�
. . �66�J1
city of saint paul
pianning commission resolution
file number 75-24
date _AuQUSt 8. 1975
BE IT RESOLVED, that the Planning Commission recommends approval
of the release of City interest in the ta�c forfeited property described as:
(Except the West 20 feet) With easement, the South 4.5 feet of Lot 4
and all of Lot 5, Block 1, Messerli and Eschbach's Addition, and
recommends the Report to the City Administrator for his consideration
in determining the disposition of this matter.
moved by S1 awi k '
seconded by �hnwa 1 tpr
in favor �4
against�
, . .
.
� �6���1
city of saint paul
planning commission resolution
file number �5-25
date AUQUSt 8. 1975
BE IT RESOLVED, that the Planning Commission recommends that the City ma.intain
interest in the West 20 feet of the tax forfeited property described as: With
easement, the South 4.5 feet of Lot 4 and all of Lot 5, Block 1, Messerli and
Eschbach's Addition, and recommends the Report to the City Administrator for
his consideration in determining the disposition of this matter.
moved by S1 awi k
s�econded by Showal ter
in favor-
against �
, � . �� � , _`� �
° , � . � �66��1 �
,
� ,
. CITY OF SAINT PAUL
;
�
. �
DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE AND MANAGEMENT SERVICES
;
DtV1510N OF ASSESSMENTS AND VALUATIONS
�
�1�._!��I,, , .�
J�ane 27, 1q75 . ��
O� �'�, _. �..,�
f �
6 � � r
Donald Spaid �UL 1 -�g�5 —
City Planning �� �
Grace Btxi.lding - 2nd F1oor � ��I�d A�+"i;�I��R���� ,��
1�21 Wabetsha St. ��' � j
St. Paul, Minn. 55102 ti ����-j-�� i
8e: Request Por a review of tax t�feited land withheld Pram sales �
With easement, the South �+.5 Peet of Lot 4 and all of Lot 5, �
" Block 1, Messerli and Eschbach's Addition
------___._----------- �
D�x Sir: - !
,
In 1969, the sub�ect parcel as ind.icated on the attached plan xas withheld
far cul-de-sac purposes at the request of the Department of Public Works. '
Ro other City department requested the parcel he �rithheld. Upon revie�r of
this matter in res�+onse to the atta.ched letter f'�am the Land Co�missioner, !
the Department of Public Works xecomanends the west 20 feet of the sub�ect :'~
pe,rcel be acquired by the Ci�y and the re�inder released. If this 'is � � "
acceptable to the Planning Caam�ission and the City Administrator, I have �
prepared fbr submission to ihe NSayor and the City Council a resolution re- '
leasing the remainder of the subject parcel and a resolution authorizing '
the City to m�ke application for the conveyance of the cul-de-sac portion �
;
per Minnesota State Statutes, Chapter 511. � i
,
s
If you have anar questio�s �n this matter, please call me. �
Yery tru].y� yours,
1
!
!
,
J. William Donovan
Valuation Engineer
JWD:RJR:dn
Attach.
ec: Thamas Kelley�
i
i
i
TelephonP612/298-5317 . 286 ��ityHall, SaintPaul,Minnesota55102
;
i
.<?..4..
= °'�! °' CITY OF SAIf�I:7`'�AUL
s
. oR���,,�fa?� OFFICE OF THE CITY ADMINISTRATOR
� � � ��6���
�` �"<.,`"� a�
. �►.� w
� ','` THOMAS ). KELLEY
365 City Hall, Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102
LAWRENCE D.COHEN
Mayor
(612) 298-4928
June 16, 1975
TO: Robert Piram
FR: Thomas J. Kelley
RE: Tax Forfeited Lands - Code 02-51500-050-01
Attached is a letter from Anthony J. Reiter relative to
the above real estate.
In this letter Mr. Reiter notes a rodent problem on these
lots. Please have this problem investigated by your
inspectors. Thank you.
TJK/ca
Attach.
cc: Daniel J. Dunford
� ,.
, � � �f'M
Y,� �\
-, . OFFICE OF THE LAND COMMISSIONER ti s � �� . '�� � ` ���
� , COUNTY OF RAMSEY ��, ,- �`+e-`V-'--t .
. 286 Court House, 55102 �� ,;;;`' ?. �k����"� :.,
� ,t '— i.
ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA .-�.-
ANTHONY J. REITER, Commissioner ��'�� C`�f `�. `298 5317 ,
�� .��.
c ',� ���'
,'T,.-,...__`_�_1� � :�
June 12, 197�-`�--�-~
Thomas J. Kelley
City Administ�ator
City oP Saint Paul
Room 365, City Hal1
st. Paul, N�T 55102
RE: Tax Forfeited Zands - Code 02-57.500-o50-Ol �
With easement, the South �+.5 feet oP Lot �
sad all of Lot 5, Block l, Messerli and
Eschbach's Addition
Dear Sir:
This office has received several requests that the above noted tax Yorfeited
lands be oPfered Yor sale. These lots axe located on Ocean Street, south of
East Seventh Street.
Sub��ct paxcels forfeited to the State on July 29, 1969, and have been with-
held from sale since that time by the City of St. Paul for the ftiiture con-
struction ot' a cul-de-sac in the street.
These lots are Past becoming a rodent-infested dumping ground, and no amount
of money spent on maintenance will correct the problem as long as the parcel
is publicly owned.
As the Department of Public Works requires only a small portion oP these lots
for its project, we ask that the City acquire the portion it nesds f'or the
cul-de-sac and �ive us approval of sale on the rema,inder, or assume the obliga-
tioa o� keeping the lots cleaned up.
Yours very truly,
+ � .
�i'I���c� ,� f��'/f�,-
�r
An�hony J. e�iter
Land Co�issioner
JJJ�gee
Attach.: Sketch
cc: J. Wm. Donovan
�";?�`l
_ _.,._ ._ _. ._... ._ �
, ' , r
� - � � - 265��1
, . .
. _ - . ,�._
Mrsrie N. Iang et al/FE� S`3&/9�(
' Mrs. Harold Drager . �
' Vfewed: /o f 2! � 6 q
� AppI1'ION: Messerli and Fschbachs Add i/��/��_
IOT: 5 BLK: 1 WARD: z •
� � ,vith esmt S'4.5/10 ft of Lot 4 and all oT
_ ' . /
. ' � 02-51500-�SO-ol
LOCA7'ION: . USEi
h.�ed.r� a��?� y.,s_��
„ ,
�t'��'°"t � Assessor�s
Graded .,�. Platted _,_,__ NOTICE.N0. _3l,d36 F & 'l Va?ue �3
Pnved _,^._. Graded • --'-�— - .
�,�.b Paved �_ JUL 2 �19b9 .
S�valk FORFEITID: ,��_ Iand: ?, 3 0 0
Sewer �� PLAT NO.: �. 7- �! � t0 BLDG• `
Water Y Torrens_�_ ' •
�� ______ Abstract�_ ZANING: �.�-���., i/ ,
�lec.�_ • -- `
' :� :G�-/9�4
Gradc: Fr. Mi.d.�,,.,_ Rear. .,"_ ' '
�4-�9-�s,.. � r
�c a. 3�� '�/g O�;�.�,� �.�.,� ' �.. �
�•c-�.�•..� c!.-r" s.�.,! �!fr'_a.� .✓ .�.e
Ii:;.�J.:'.(iS: , • V _ iY'-
-.�r+.�.O �1�)!'i/;Q %.%, /� � �� ' 9//9/64 _ ,lf�� t,.•..:: :
� f ^�. � :v.r�.......J
r� �. t., n, ?f:.�'._4J..J
/� 9y,t.a9 °
t � ��- � ' � s, �
• -- --- -�--- ---� ' �
p F sevEti,a Sr • .. ..__ .___.__..__
�. �o So . .
� �OQ ���' .. �� _ .
1 �
t� 3 L � ^ � Z �7 L �
L �� ' � ' �
, e •_ � ____ - --. �_�_, �. I
�'—�—-. � - . � � ---- - .. ___
, ; � , � � �sa:» ,s�.>� �
. t 11 >. o a . 3 ; �
.. __.. . _ �1o�--Q . � .
:y 7 , - -- .__ , . ;
�b a�. a•8 �---a ' �
, _ � �` , .
. �. _ ' Z •;
. �
� 1 � .�,�, N � _ �
N . � J - ... ...
� ' � ' �
_ �_ . 3
, _ . - ' —. .'SD-
. �_'_'-r----- _ __
� � j - . ,�c , ; � .
_ �14��
_ � ,, S ' � � ��, g � �o � �� I � � ;J
! I �
L
... , quvt 1°F� ` `"!'' �37 ' , {
_ _ _...�,,,�,
�
� •
i � { �
. �
. Fz
� '
. �
�
� ; ._ ; �, . , , � ... [ � , -. , , - -- - i
�. .
, ; , , , P; n < � , � . ;
. : , . ; � �,; f, �. E i � � � 2�6��1 ;
. 1 i .i . .. ' � I A ' � � I ,7 ( 1 �+l
� • • �� � � n_ S' ' Q I .S I '�' . ._ .. � ' ' (; . . . �
i.���' ' � � �. . '� • � �i
, ry I� j ,�o�I�� � I , i . � ' � , �
, ;. � I I , ��a^�j� �"���� ,, r � __f_ 'f_�,�,_�_ '���• 1_._�� �
� �_. �, .�o„J�..•,,,,i ...,_-, . � ...,.:.;. ,.. ,. .
� � r�.�:...-� --°. � , �f. -• - ^ :�
".-r ... � •. --•`�.. ; J +�.'v.r'_
. L ._ _ _. -�.-���+.-�J7 -_ �. _ _ � ' - . -� - � �� t ' • :-.� . , t. . . .
..+� ' � � � `-�
S . '� � J O �0�-• .�.j'r '(•.`2 ~ v0.,. �7j r .i�.�'t•i�T�..Q_",d..�.l '� '� °r•' '�, J<7 .
. �' n•b P Jri S �� 1..1..... � ., .. � � � �
- � . � ��`^ '� � 5
� - "' •. �. -, �;�--�.� � ,� i3�� ;`.��:�
' ~ ; G._ S,—.__ � • � '� I `�� # ���N . �. Q��
�� A ' � ,s: ' • Q , �- '.� , c ...: -a�•:;, ;
. _ . s. . V � . �� � ,... O �j' .. , � ,�aq
� CC�. L___'—� '�: '
. I ♦ . � � �iOP � 3L1+�36 • J'�.f7 /.r-•���1- -- �iJ� . ' �. .
` SO �: -`�/' _o_ � �- �� "� ,,.t- �
=' ,aa..�; � i"a'.`FY""� �-�... 'r -.,--'� I' ; i
�� : � � �•�� � __ �� �`I _ ' 3 _-�-ws.�-..l� ,��` C �'' �. ; '
. _\ � --�1• - -_ _ ` -` . �4-�-."'��. ` ` 1 �, ! i
�y � ?. • I T /° .� -� g e'�__ '.�C�:;;_-�' �: - ;
. L � ` - - � :. , -1 ��`:,�__� C �i r , . . - i
Q� w � i3G.8 R�_SO ._ ��� �, _ z yC4_� 3d� �
y...-` - �� °4 ' _f� , ; •.,• � „_ _ " �� 1 s' 2` r
�1 -1.. ..~ r �..�,,,�,, fp -1' h,y � �r� i
''�Z Vl ' �, . h _ f �„_,_ ! .: '� 'a �, " l ) �,� .. � .r :
1\ 1 `' , � � !O'. .1/ , Y
';. 6 7r.- �8� �•-�' . . I: - . �' �•
� . /� i 2 ,�' .- 9�_,....�,-.�, `�- �'- : � . `,
.� ' .Q '` , i µ �Q. ; U ; D /.,.._.�.T_.f. O '_�i5 _ ;:,�,,� - � ;
',� , •r � . � ' .� � �s�. ." 4 ;
te -_ •� �O.S S ...�V. , _��2 �t,11Yao'.-�D�iIJ��_: -- �� ' .
;,.-,. � ��:; t
� ' a:y at..�sf ,•. .� ✓ t
`� { � �.�-J _- 4 . .�q ' 37 ,�_. �f ' ' •
_ _ '' �„�� s v B. j zi.l 2z � ��r'?�' 2.s :2c �. _.; �, � �
�Yo .••- "� ��_ _ „ :.► ~~ �„-,F�� �
. q ' �. . .,.: ..r ..c > �� . ��
� .... :��o �i �s ' j....1w� _ � • � • • ( s
` , ( J' `'f` i
'_— D� � ". � .C.�_� ;f,r�F,,.r�f(J'i � 3C�� (� � � 5
. �`N . �� � /PO+ � 9__39- °-3%. •�S4-r�j�'` �'¢'�� - �,•r,.;,� ',�'.T-M G�• �♦ ...j . ;.
_ '� ..9 "�"� .R I �i-r--' �F M K . . � F { . �
r /� io � , h/,4�E f.{,�' � .� � .� �� � �� '.i �
_ f ", ti , /o :;NA S :�s�-"'.j� `�c.s;s + _ -="�'f1.� � �.-� i
¢a - . �� i2c� �- .�g.�,,.39_ _ . � . t tl ,
_`a... �s.,. i •• ,.� i �ti � �' �.:� T� V ,.�.V��:�.,-� � i
- 0'.- ' �y ' �(�JQ �j 141� • � �•=z r C' :a� �."'� 4
v . . ,,. .... , �� . ~ Y- ,.= " ,... - � j
'A^ �_ .. . . . /� . _� G Ja�� ♦��14 . 1 �'r,'� + .
�v .��. � •• � - ' '. . .i' ,_ ��Ir ( . � . .
. . • Y ,� � '� �O � . 1.. . .� -
O - � �t�` I ,�1 S�� •� � . : .
�.� is is i3 ie `ii 9 " ��7 -�__t.•.-�-»¢ ,a... .,� � •+•...
� ! ��.. '..-,. .`t J
. � ' � � -�^'c , . .-(� � -` . ' .'..�.��--..�
v�
.. _ _ _ __ _.� - - - !` � - , __ �n2 ���. . `� . � . . .
Y ' � ---T—° �' • • :'`'� � �
. . � 3%•0 _ _ : • �.,� __ . .,I � .. •� 'T• -- .� �� w.� ' � , � f
�- � r �1��z3�� �.p,s- .pC,r 2T: ''•- a'• � � �� �
�,� , �i6 �J' �d I /9 P� P/ � 22 I (,� i � Q ._.-» .:�
� � _�....\V � { :._.� � � -� �
( I� � bj� . . 1
. I . � �t �r� i � � ' . 1. ....�.1 i
� I -- � -- A�V �� _ _n � s� `��_i
t J�3 �i - �i'- . � --. :
. . •b.• . ` . . '�.
� � . � . 'C� �� awTO . . .
� O^ � �.V , . • �.. ' . . . , . ������ . .
� . � �R� � a r• � . � � "T �• J 93/ '����JM . • ;.
� ��/.�1 /f.Q, .• .. i. �� —�� ' I .. ' � ' I . : ' .. �
�. � I ! . � � .. . . '�'r�' ,,._• � .. ..
I ' � i .} - i • �. � .��'Y . . �.
� ti .. i � - - ~ � /U 1 l� j `�7. �G�� -�� I � � .�• . V /G
, � \ ` iS 1 /A� i3 �i� .�' � y j1 i ' ' g
t • ( �
� � ; � , I I . ,
j I ` / ' � � � — .l.^�_--
1• � 4' -� __�__'i�' ! _ �. r.r� � . �.'.�
� .4.J (_ _.__.__- ` .
� -- '
. ._
r � -v---- ----- -- . p� -- ;
I ( 1
,,.�l 1__ _- -� 1 -��--__.�.�_ i �----� �_' � i .
, � � . � � � . � � _�
�Y •� - . � �� .. - •�.. . T, . i� �{., .`�'" r{
� � � 7..
y o ' , '� � � f y �^'� ° i �. . � �.'� :��,V � ��t � t� .y s s
y3 p �'°.. � 'r, '. Sd1�`'� .� i,� �" ,�,d
'�r; -�a.� `n, /�
� �,�� ' tf, �tar'� g�,' . � �, � Wr �c/ ,� g .�.�:
4 ,� r +' � N . -• ��g'�'�. � �� . , : a . �'t '�'� ' `� 8
r., y3r.;y . �y '�'... � Y^. a:' � f. ; s �#'
+' �'�:i4 r � �I`- � 4'y��{Yei!! . � . d vk.: ` � .-�' e.)F!
,,4+ -., .: .:- � ♦x � h��"* a% "+�j, .� ��'�:
-v � + A
s _ .` s .�s': :.- iw "�* ..
,_ . , .. . ..,,.,
�.. �.� 1.. �.�3, k . .. . H... .. �y.. 1 i '��'e' t., .. .::�. .'�. 'v �� f J; �x-.,
� " w �.. � . ':; �. x • �r .. ��.' � � F
M1} i I
f '+�+��_ ��14 'u,'4 V.. d 4 D '�.,a. ,� € " 1= �{ 2.q ./`. ',�a�1 �� 5 � .
�,�,4 c 6 pr d : ,� �'N:. ��:: �:r 4�. �� �y� , '
a i°r .:p t,,�' '4' r) � l�f�� ,,�, '
�' r �:�! - y'4._ � �t� � k �'���A W:..� l�ai� ,� 'f�il������ f p� '.. .
�, $ �F�� j � +� 7'�-•
FA"�F �, �. �, �T� r�7 n� �.. ��n n� �� � .� x ` � "�' ��-. w S:
2 k��.g . � ti A. � 5 ..' ��.�`t� II { •�. '� .,
k� .Y`; �x.;.. `yy» "� •„� ^e� �'�' :.rt � •r �t l { ,, .
., � � :.!_'�`( A � i
� �'-�� dy, �:s� * �'*y�'� pr�� "�: � ;:.t .. . '�'�r�'p � ..� r:� � -w,.. �`ro-.
r.� .* f��
)} � � � y . 't +x�.�r �, �.��4.} # $ :a 3F,� ' .. �� y � �.u�73 `4-� r� .:
� ,.�. . , .s. �,, r p.� i �. . ; ' � � . , ..� �y . ..� �� '. :
� � ' 'h� u *.w�"�S j � ` '� �+ ri'!!
�' " `
+.. a . # � '�.. G "F �''�' 1 . .y� `�y r A `�`a
<� '�t3� `E'`:4 ri� .. �i, �=m �l,� `h�".;; ;��tL z d ' �F:a..
, '�.°.» �� � T . R �. . , _ � t _ 3'" �
� *.� . 'S � t � x �
s �` �
� 4 �.. t . . 4 . ..
n,r t�y � . J+7 t . � � �' � 'T''�' � �.y,
♦ 54�.~ !y'�', y ..� r � } _�.'r �� ^ �� h;'4 Y� ..,:r,y, `�l
, � . � ' W'A . s v � � ��
",� � . r. . .? � _ Y � k �'+l:� � i�S r 3� ��
y, .... .L .-• ..'."i � . . f l 4!� *� . �} � ��f yJ � Y;7
��
.' r . ",
.. ... :�L t . ��N .9
f� . '€ ' . ., . r. .� � w . � .
A � .
• w. '^ . . ,j. '8 - 1 .
� � i..' s
� ti ��' �
. �±. �. � � ' . - � .- i. � � �` � ' " . :
c,y '�� �D .,�a . � . . .
i rf�y .� . . .+"� .
� . $,:. .:. . ,
.- •.
t , j . ; , . � ��IIM�i� �� " "�' �
� �A°� �''� ° °
,- . . a _ , �,, x : ,. :;
.�.: .:. , - �' `, -.:� ' '�. : �k � ; .� <�
,
.
� ���'�� ± i:: ' �t �x" i z�S
� �; ;t ��".� ,�q r ,, �I:��' �..;
�6 . �"K.,.� • d �s�.. ay�. , 8��5 � �t+�
� � 4 fyl � � ."�,l '�.; � 4. '' . - � .
�`' •�� � � �1M7� +�� � •c���f ,r �� �w :7,.� x F� ��
+y � y.1� _ !'.� ' - . ..
� . Y''ll����� '�4 •� ������� , �
, '�` � �' �. •�� ��;� `� � � s 1� F�: � ����
_ y �_ , t �� �a r: ts._ + � }
� e ����.,,�' .� �\~ . . � - ;H`r e �l., }z�
. `-.. . `r'i te �,. ` , t �a'i, �
�i;- �. . ,�+ � " � � e
z'
',,�'��, � �z i. �+it;•:' y, .:"s � �. .� �. .�
, . . f + � 3. ::.. - � �.:, �F � .. „tpq�g� '�4,.�� .I
. :'� ' . . , � . � . .
. . , rr . � �,- C .� . S;.
£Y. ..`:�,� '� �� %"-I: �' : . � � r
T. lMII� l��r� +�,� �;"T.� �, �.r ,
: :
. . "�.� �:�������i�M�l� �yy,�� x .2 '"�������� ��`�,,. r ,��C��� ' . .�Y t
1l��9�� .�'�-,��'�� �'Ir- , �'!������ �`�'�+�s����
- , >,4. � j
, .'a . . �� ��� � �.� ,7� � �. , . . r' :s� . � ,
'�� . . ��F ���� ��,r,x�� :�.J�.� � ��A11MI�.'�� � . �.,
.. '.� .... � �' ` y� '
� � :�� _.- ,:r.. , . ..z>.. •.:� .;�� ' w`'.:�.a �.4� _ � �AI�N��I��:l� ` °' .
_' , -;. . . .. - � '� t. ` � . � � :.. ' ,` . . ,.�1r . �y s:. ' . .
. ,� ���! L � �^ `$' `�
�'�' � �' �� � a � ������� �.�►. �I�i�` i
, �t��-+i��it`��t
-, � , �
. . ?�� �� ���� _
.� ; . ,v � � �
_. . : l -
����� �
��; � .� � ,,,� ��:
�`` �. •:"��• 4 �" : +�.�
;� �_ � �-,
g_ .. ��. . . :,,- :' .. - t � .
yt .i� � � � � � y ; �,a.� :� r ,
. i, . ��` ��� ��l.�1� �. . °'s Cp: -
..r .. �'.:. �,': ' -:'. x .., . _ y 1�.
' ; _ . . z�' . a�r:. i" .' �`\ �Pa
,� .
�,.
� � ... . �;� .��'���� �' . t'- '� �. .Y. ;:�
. .
'� . ...° .. ..
.. . . �,., .�: . p :�• � � ��:-,r �. r' � ''
:f;� � .
�i Y � -
i '*': �' � � , �' �,� z y
� x �t � G �'*1 �x .!i
. . ���� �'t�� �.�_�, j -:�.• �"�i''.' , �'2' . . � . ��
3 � .`� .{.+�. �
.� , � , , ' E .�y _
': . � ' .� �. � .._ �♦ �X�.
Y� '. .. �::� �+ � , y ! >�..Rw� , .�; _, � � Yy�a�?�?,. d �,4 Y� a..;, �,.
� , i r
�P �' y 5 r�" x � a Y1"
y� ���.. � �� A �� � �Y 1��� ,yR.�� T1"�l A4 Y . r f
� � ",
a . ' � . '< .A'}V :
.;� r :���il��� '�`.Y. . ?�... a�� l "�y�, r..� -i'�yx
... Y �.. r �R �.''� . t �`t -. y�` &���;
. � � : . � ..�, _a' S 1�` # ..'�j[, ,�� .. trF '*°�e4 J � d:" �� {.i VZ
. . .,�F'T " �� ..��...�� � r� #� � . S ,� �:.. ,ti�'�t � 1y'� r•E�i��y
. .cP , ' F X .� . - ! };
�. '. _ ,.
� . . . n
" �:'� .- a�� S L�Ii �� 'pY �" 'ti s �. , �
� Fj��x ,� .�.��. . � . ,,, �' . :.'... �.
gt �: .. � " �'�.F.,� ", . � �
, �' m .�_. � 1 �:% r '.. y � fi� .
t � z x, r w� � :+: 5 �4 '�� `
c � �, .� - ,m :�a �.
,y�+i^� .h , M, f 3�" �� e:� . a 4 y�,� '� • ��1k �'�'t� p �.. f �9.��� � f� 1. �`.
a�
r x.: ��. ;�r. ;:t . ,� . . 8� '�.�� " M �1' fd'6, ,} � �.'�� 3k., ;'. '�^bL 3 `� �. *��j�,.+ ,�.�r � a� #l�,' 1' :;�
. 'S X � d, ��+yt 4 ��1 � ir� .$!��,, � �.:
�x��y�. 'd r�, e-r.' . '�x : < ,q.:V� �. �,q'� �a��, t '��.,,��� ��.� t���''��8`x y ��.�,''r�� �� �' .�
�'�" "��' _ .' . �- ?t �� � r s(
,� „ _ . . . y` ' :
:,,�t �Tj` ' :,.�3.
j � `"� ;t a `` - � � ^.�.� , �� �P�` x �: � ,,
�t� r � a .J � ��•�`"�' 4. \ s;� �.. � ��� � �� �a ; ','�t� k.i��4 r.- 1.-a- �' ��3
, � . ... . � , Z��� . �. .. .. $ F'�T ..� �� . ..?Hc� j " i�� a� �
�.'� d+ r,.�+ �} < yt �r a.
f'�ic � r���i.,: r*u `� � a�, � �A� �' � �'�%� :i��i i�rli''�� Ya�. �' 'rF*. e� �S��
� te
;4`�'• '•9 F . G . } yy � �' �J d1 .
� . L 44��_ - y} � �i' ��� � ��
�.. . !fi.' , :. - � f �
w
. .. - �' � * . . .,; � �� ; ��. i�` . 9�P ���'*� $�:
..� .�, ,�s �. .. . R y. '^,,�>j � 7
.. _ . .. . .. .'`.. .. ,..� .._ �� �.�?=�?`.. ' ' � .. `�#2� r �.:�4s^�H►''.�:�.$',� ..;..:+3e, �- �t.,�. �.Ji'. �., s��r�L:r .,:���""���:�3c.
.s x� r � �� r'.'Rr: 'A5'w4� '�'"- �'� i k, r�- y � �, ;�& p�,. �t -x �,.
�r,- Y �'�u *�. {t �z ���> . '�' R� r� ��r � �'h � � 'ia:. �, J . � ��d
y. �' � .0 +�.,
r�,..j �. � b -'� rty-. U'�'�}1y.",� � �' (k'� � �1 +f w �
Fi' ] � f�� `� � �: y� � . �C� ��pT' � .i� � i � J � � � 2�
3 5� ..:�� r' • �, .. �` �� � �. X �'Y � � 'F'
� �� ���_ i y; .,� �� � `,�..r� ..`.t, �` ` 'v� :� ,�,,��'� ��� sY.F v� �,c ^�� ; ��
�y�..�s�. _� � .�` � M: h -� '� ti� Yy� i.� =�y���.�v�.�s' 3� ��..:����' rX.-�.^�`� t+ °e:""� -� � �ij
��y 'N vr�,. �1 sF`. 'S afv����� ��� �`�ii�-ai �f�u '�-� -�p '� �1. ��s� �f"
,�� <- 3, 7�.x� , ;� a R ,�x a�� a � .a. � �� �s 7�a� �
+ � � � .� �` '`., � �.�� x:' � ir C� t. �S . 1 Y: 3�t����F�4 '.' :. �f ?3�.�,.� '�!".
F � ".�."1.�. � ,, � 5.:� �4, �,'�� w�r�s� .r a > t'b'r�'� a �a�' �r,�
' g� ~"���'� � "�,,. �,r�*� � ! �' ��. , �"�- � ��
� sy �.. 5 ,• .s. � s�„ '.� ��,t'+".�.e'. r1n,. � 3 �:r..3'";'' � i�'.� �-� - 4 ?'�
..�,�,- y �, ii , z�-�� ,�':
. = �_. � - `
e- : �'� '��{Q, y .r
< ��-� ti . �� �.. �f rt`6 .x . _ `i� < ° , �>��''��se'�^- c�'"�. .ti �c'.�"� r�.*�'� .. � � _ es�t 3
?`� d .w'L��.�� NF� „�` ;, 'r: ? ��� v -� � f� �jS' t�s,,.'�..a.. y t .
` t �� n� . � a . '` -' yi � �',"'' �' P" u '"�:� �
� � F '��,, � o � ^+�, ' < . � aK. �'���'�� '�r' *�y-, ' ���'� {zr ?i�`` ';��'I'Y - � �'��y:
��, ;` ' . � � � ,- YS* .a.,�°Kc �`..;$, '�-+h S1C s- r; ����� "�9
.,„, � ���Y ,,,.1 A �. . '�. �'9 > �,, s �. >c" 5`.�s r N fi� . p i,,,;s�rti8
�4 �;a�; �� . � .' ��,,% '�I�' �.'� r.'�'� . + i:��� �:#.#' ,i ti�,.,;- "�: � .� ���� ��"��r�.X ..�, * ��;rr .�
+� . y� x -� � � r '. t ._ s�' � ` fi--a : :,.� i .� fi wK ,,�,n,.-�'eC� , .
s Z �'.^''
� �'�+� '',- " �'F�r��'..���.,.A��� _b, � y� F,r � ti.�� ��ta� k 1 r�� � �t 3 �,� ��'k A.�, f �F€
�"�� � ��S"��if�;'��,' �,. ����.,,�^�.�+ t��- � �.' �.F°� � �x`' �� �* va
��y3b . . :.` � �,_\ 4 jR _ t i..•_ �� "` ¢ ��'�#..y, ti..`���q�} �� '� �, 3 ,-�e- � . �� „��.' 6a '..A �
�-� � ' � ,�r e� � �- : { �'r � r 4 � + ro �s ��,, ,a�-�,���t }r x ,i �4�?
�- ' - � �' �,.r
� c .b � � a, �.! ,�5 c . �x4 t . 9- '' aB,,lH� �.�L �: � .. f+� i,,_ . a x"� %{r+y �T . ,SSc�;:
`*�3 z. x �'� �, ���� � "�•��� Gg 3'� � �;i e=i�"�. �a s+ x .-�. �t�%'a���' 't`y s� ±' ��
�ar� s'^ � _ �'�'�',-� t^r - -�g`�'.��'� � �. .: �^$�i�, ♦ �;-� '�� � +�E .�:,°6�ng�'r�,..y :?�.
'�' � . w _: <'� ff?�3,� . �aa`k R,:s. �' K. . 'n" k,.. }.'''
''� l ?3� � _ iG'�aY'�..'*�r6 �i.� �< 'i!:. - c d u� ir� a �: � "� '�; � �4 '� �.- ' �' 1 ��•� ; � �i,h, �,, �'
. � . a.` ��. Y �; '�':h aS�' ,+ro' p''�' �,�y� �.J.:.: ��.*�,�c�+•� '���.'.�' v �W�.� �e
. ;a ��it ` t .S..s, �" t` :.
y _ -. w� .k < . 1 A C 1}}`;;` @ R..: .� �� V 'e _�� � �.' : �} s"£. .y J�2� �.�4 �'f� ;�i� �'
�E .��`�`� ':$ S ���.. j`a.�1,�,�r�•r,�, < '�"a �l i��-e� .- _ .;^ "`��F�'t `'$1.'+Y° a4 : 4''�
bt� � r� .4� R � �i � u� <; F � � s ��: � ��� � r .
17#. - x ,�x �' t r � .ir�o . .�J + �'p)'�
�, g L. .�`p��' - rr d X �1.� � S'r�l"'c� �x 'j L�'i�Gri`�'�'� ..�K �S 7. 4•'� '� � v+u,:3r� t ,���'�E
4+ � �v:'� - i ,Yi i. °S . v��t� ������'�y 1 t
� : �k zj'f1 �', ,� `���,e r -� i � ; x a ,-� x..�. "'+ G .;:n ' � ,_, �,'�„ . p �r' ��
� 'F� y ' �,�,�4 � - a'` t;�t �e��a -�'�� � ��w Y�'�` a a . F � '*s .- �d
�° t ...1 e.r7S �` '°1e��i- ";,�s���� a °� � � �� '�r � 't '3 k '�r
�SGr,� 3' x'� K y .. .. �. . . .. �
s : '�' S��G�
� k' � � i � �'�' ,,,r�•�`" '�k�M. ,.,� •�,� �i�' ��'i.v.,, � :'��"`� �i�,..�' ��. x.
����^ x f `f ':i ¢"�, a � '�.c��; ������k'�` ��. ,� ��`,�►'� � ,� '- :�� � ��,�� '' �' a
�y�Y t' �i su-A i' .z�1C�' r �, ''' +` .J t�.� �c 4�.'� . �F.�e - ��� f 't � �"S , a t'r,i
i'r,' '. r - 5.,�c,- �'3 ro�af�.' . �,��' . ,x 'M �s.'�z �T�.�s ',,aTr' 3 k:�',$' " �+.�".�t.�r, �� - �
� ,l i ry � _'. ' ��`�r ;v�- ." ;t, 'S'i �nx .`� i� s,; 3' � ,3��, :.,' y. f
+N , •: ; ' fir,.r Mt: '. e . t tib' ,tp' `t'i{'� v. � :
� . 1;yy.a� � Y 2'� x� +�,y .� '_ rG .
� . , 4 F' �y�.��n i ��'� ' `�t4 ��'�; � _ ��'• t ,�� a; tia�.�+.7� r* ��
��� �-, 1�6i`✓�� �1Y� ��'� `�.i���e f` . . �_'z C t . �f ��,��.�:�� .;�•� � '+t:�'. ��it���� dF 'a� ., !
�`�. . . �.. ,�
� �::�` �; a .�£xl��� ..yt i�. `� �r� � �:!'� � � Y �� �,y. t+4��.�z��d L� �4 �
i x < !j.,y �'�' ; � a»� �cfi. ,s�� � ,: -. i'-Y- fr�+ . r .�.s �.p�. . �� �.. f �
y� ?, n ��: d _ 1 . . py . ..'�T ��� ¢,� � ��J,'�4F� 'rf' �y.�•ar �i�i qac���-_ �C�����*�+�_ � .i.T�F,Jk''f: �.t:-;"a+�`F '.� ��.* .
�wi��y! .�y R C t "����}r+''������ .{�'l�bt ry«���Y'X1� ` `'� { � ,
0 ��1r�
�ip,.'"� '� �i��i�St� .�.sr�, � ,. � ���$.-'K'^\A'' '� �i�.�-7 � -/� ?�� i;9 '� �fs� 's��i��L �iti'1... _ „''..b
� ��. " - ,. �:_.�.'� ' e_. :..�*t��`s�' -U .i�' .. «r, a
_ ✓ ' .�-.p ''��,. ' .. " t 5 ...���G� _ s. �,i3O; r..
� � �„' ' .. + �. � .: y �,., ��,� �',„�, h, 5 �'c* t
t , �f:sT',�`'�i�.`�s''�`�i. ,�}� �"�`� v�"�r�N�` .�'r tf�t �`���yF'�S `�1 ��'i'�fl'"n�t�3P'"r+x�r w. �r� i�c ��` � ..
z�� +�' ,3
�� �1� ; 'R 5' �`' z� s P Y i' � }� B .3����, �� � r
� :- � .s r � ��'3. 14 7�� � .�� �.�' a.�t=i. +�i :.fS� ��,X ���f '
� � � ^ r��t�t �R+}� �� ��z,.. #,� �2 . :�`�' �'°' '4 � x.Y � �9� Ay� �,�s�
•y�iv� #�
i �*.s �. r 3�� ..} �� 1 �,� .'g - }� q �t ',: � � . ; ' �s�p r � .
i ��y
r �+,,'72t�' 3^�"� ��q �al �c� t ��''�' .�.E�d����� _�1t�.� .�'�J��1 i..r'..sb .���+.W�i " � r -,
�i'^s�r�S�Sr��'-r� S++st .a.. '1�; 1!i�:+��C5�� , z J
.f '� !� • ¢�
� � �#1 ��'�T�i`�� � .:'°1�,�`R f. � i+`�r r=.� i LS �p�'i f��x� '��W�,�•� �i,+'F���,j'.cx��A�"Lx.�,.�''x y�t3k . -!i+ �� �°�
p d ;44� s .� i 4 yI�Y� +ie �
�;� �rca .3"§ '4� ��_� .Ji:. �t , F.",� .i4 .:� :.� � X Y"t�ai�R�r r-"�,y,� ��
� "
r a c. `� � : .,� . *' � � -. � �pc ti'� .�'
3 Fy k'" 1 �,,� ¢�.F+4a �. . sr3 .y x t :• �. 5�... . 5 f ; e
s '� �.{ zr�k fi�I � '� ����d �` Y,�� ° , ',��,��t �''.e .4� g�.� �y�� r�� 'ts
y ` ...i t f.`""'�-? r ='�,j,��' ���.� .._r'+A"ti+''+li.� .�Yai°���'�� '��',�o�, . . ��'�'. d.� �
'��F �s'.� ..9j,'�-t� t�`` '+tF ' . �'S'�`"��� � �:�a �,K x '��:) - �'_'.�' ',�,L.��'°9`�
�:� �,� � . �� 3..' {i �; :s '.� s�t3y'�,, . r., � ,� � � * - .. ;... "�
�� _.k +. . � t"` `�► � ew.,c -'�' 5i" � �r � # � � t��+,�' �`r �y. �"� Y:�.:
k} �, ' , �S • �f�{u .{ d " 'ia§ . •a,'.*7�'a a,{v.P�.*7r�tt�rY�iY� Cc"�ti�kt .�a;
�a � . �,� . � � �t h � �L i'A Y4% YS ' �., y � r + ': a � }, z �! a
� - . .
�" ��%�., k rt: � : �,;�aw a , i � ��' �t �
-�,^ i ��e y � � �.�x shx� y�,,:!F"' 4,. �z�-;y � , q}$ t �y r>x "3". � f �' �r �.s�:.-y� -r.. ' ,;
; ' '``' R c rr*' r�- '�� Y$�:^ �:
5��4^ t' f 4 �.� '� ''y„ �,s�ilE� k _ k .�,`� �. ,rco +,"� a�. ��
��� * � a :. � ..� : k ' �
'�' . �lT',� +�qy � . s�' q W k" � � _,k�y ' ' �*�ii. ��;,a�, � �°�d' .! '` '�� ' � _
2�s . s. .«� r ry,'"�.����. '.� ��7��� `,. k, N:H s l'V'ks �: 'P!'��t� '!'�� ��:4�" !� ' '�'1�f r �`Ty: .
s�` ' , .,��tr�' �,i _., .< , �,.j` ."�; � � � 4_
g, y -'1 ._ F � ,,4� � ,Y �, � �3 �.
3�` �.' ,r
�"4',R-� ' � 2 .�.P9 y P :��� � � t ,�: J�'�t�t�.0 '_4� 1�� � .: � � � " � 1 -'?� � �
�Y�� ' r �.. ,'�'3 ,� . i�T" � '''� q .-raf'l;�F�" �tt�' ^" � t�; . " � �
` y � t 3v� r
��e h', �. ."'�'f`s�°'y,.�'�..'8` �T5 -%.e ''�y,Y��� t4 .:T� -w'Y `F�^` e.;!R i� '�. ��'s�a ��`,c. ..
♦
T � ��i�5��� S �.. 'A %. h �,
�� ��.' 4 �i� � � ,�� �+�� '�k � w y.�i'w�q.r ��� +h.
y r"'�; '. i".� . x-+e .�. r..c -< <s:� f � . - Y+'a''�.�'l� <
�y � �' ��xy.t� � 7^ a s .: �� c ;�°�./'` �, . .. y 'K``.c �J� s�F r z�v � . �'e �,q ,
r `
�§��i+. '�' y� 'F �" �<� �' f a't�,.i f �ar�$y-k � -�y .&"if-. t� ..e �� :.*;r w� �t � , �.yY_� �' ���xr. .� ���s, .
� 'k'M1 r 'S'� �3 � � � i �r �� i .. !'� t.2��{��; P' ti ;� . .
��`r,��� ..:. 4 �; r S � '� ���F. .�,y�7 _ �-� . a � . � �,q' . 5��.` � . Y ��' 4
m. q � �.' '""a.-.4'kc ' '�.'a�!e. � :',� .,� a�.y� � _ o .. � Y ^�t:? { .. 7' ,�: a °-•
`�^��� e �'`� �, "`��� �.� �`� � �`��k � � �:� '` .� �,:,�,�r'�S � �s c. '� as�+s � f f �
�y� '�¢ 4 �,
� ar `s�����'�3�*�'' �' �r ���3:,��i'A�,.� � v w� � �a� ��,a�'.: ,a.r '� i r'�' _' : �" " .." r'r.�.�"L`{ � �k ��
� �- ,
;. . ,-„t yc �s 3`�,, ,n$�j � k F Fh��,� i.�,._ ti � f-.i �. x.u� .� 1 "7':
� .,, E;c�$�i'�1."�'�s� 9,��� 'gP : s��. -�,.... . .1�':; .�`� uL'.� 7 iy,'j.Y .. '�S; "�? :��s �^'�,..e
4¢ -. -! ,�y��,. ..� : ��`� , }�''
_+'�. �: T h` f � .. � . gc.
4,�.. -2�: � �t��� xr� -§ yytq�ai;.ta`�� �.'� �.=�. �, � ' .+i _ S y .1, °.� z�
�.; r�S_'�� .�� ;���i'° .� 'R' �... t.� g� "i LL� � y e. �°Y �"• .r v; � . �,t'x �'..
4 f �.�..� z�?� ,� .��y?t „ � ��y �` � 5F� � ,�:��� „X s � ,,• �
�•,�' ��A, .�� +4 r,��.� : .�akP, :� �.� �. . � -r .,r'� ��^ 7 y . �r � � �{ �•� .1 y�.��: � .
��r :., t y� c. �� �`,�} �� � y '
�Y�.�� dt � � R^ '��J`�' � 1 ....14 ��fi �� �¢
s � � .d � e. x- a � ;�.,,�r � � .
� i4x i t .fi _j 4�4fr - ���r"y s�y '�a+ � a "
� �.�.'°z+� ;,1`. .�r"�` .�� ' .,' . �`�x.� � Y`' . _ r. .•� , �. r��A r �.. .. .. :. �
_ �t,���,
:
�
R4 .w.'�,'b'"x.� �_a'9� ;°_.±{'S'��� �"�� ,. _.� ::.�.Y�"°�.-~. .. �+.��,��. a_ ..r:" .,����. ,.�..:.:s..�v'. iQ�. .-e_,�, �z4�_ -�;.��. ..�4s;'�;....r,..at�.t'.��c�i�.
e.. _ ., .A� , _ ..-, . .. . . .. ..
4 G�tT °� � � � CITY OF SAINT PAUL �
. �` •'r,�
�., � a� OFFICE OF THE CITY ADMINISTRATOR
�� ...��^o� �f 6��1
� .... e.
f� �
�v� .o. THOMAS J. KELLEY
s +�-•
365 City Hall, Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102
•,.AWRENCE D. COHE'V
►�tayor (612) 298-4928
June 13, 1975
TO: J. William Donovan
FR: Thomas J. Ke11ey �J�
RE: Tax Forfeited Lands - Code 02-51500-050-01
Attached is a letter from Anthony J. Reiter and a sketch
relative to the above real estate for your review. "
Please take the foilowing action:
1. Donovan - investigate the status of this
property and pr:epare a report for Mr. Donald
• Spaid.
2. Spaid - make a recomriendation on the sale
of this property.
Thank you for your assistance.
TJK/ca
Attach.
cc: Daniel J. Dunford
•
.,,: ,.