Loading...
265803 WH17E — CITV CLERK� �� �' '�"' ���g�3 PINK — FINANS',� w .� ,G�TY OF SA I NT PALT L Council CANARY —� 6�PYc�fMENT h� BLU� ,� -MAYOR � � File N0. . . -� � � Co cil R olution Presented By �CII�1SE COI�IITTE� Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date �SOLVED: That Application P 28l�6 for the transfer of Off Sale �Liquor Tyicense No. 27I��., expiring �Ianuary 31� 197b, issued to Hawkeye Liquor, Inc. at 1065 Hudson Road� be and the same is hereby transferred to Stuart Oil Co.� Inc. at 225 Grand Avenue. ;� Reconsidered and�Veto of Mayor overridden �' August 26, 1975 �� , S In Favor 1� . pp�r �_ Against Syi��1A�r � 1 ME1V Requested by Department of: Yeas Nays Chrisien�en � � In Favor � Levine � ( Against BY Sylyester/ Tedescc� Pres�dent�tK HOZZa '�� 2�S �9�� Form Approved by City Attorney � Adopted by � Date �F Ce ' ed s Cou cil Secretary BY By Date Approved by Mayor for Submission to.Council BY :BY Puet�sH U6 19 `' . � ,�°c,�.y, -'"`—� ,..�`�' 'f�/' .. �, f �r��.... f..y� .; ,/ �A' I . �y i,:�k9�#i .✓`�� 1' `. .�4`��.�.-�...j�,w� • v , � G I T Y O F S A I N T PA IT L �'�,�a „�'° � � ��'-����^�-���►--J �rssrriaoe OFFIGE OF TEiF. MAYOR , i' �''S k �"t �nr �9t t C /= �� � �'-o .� I.AWRENGE D, COHF.Y M"'Y°II July 29, 1975 Council President David Hozza and Honorable Members of the City Council City of Saint Paul, Minnesota Dear President Hozza and Council Members: I am returning to you with my veto C.F. 265803 passed by your honorable body July 25, 1975, dealing with the transfer of off-sale liquor license 2744 from Hawkeye Liquor, Inc. , to Stuart Oil Company, 225 Grand Avenue. The principal question dealt with during the deliberations of the Council License Committee and the City Council was that of whether the applicant would, in fact, maintain the legal requirement of separate building facilities for joint operation of an off-sale liquor store and a gasoline service station. This license would be a first of its kind in Saint Paul, thus creating a new policy. This sort of change should not be implemented without substantially more input from city departments and the public. However, I feel there are many other questions that deal more directly with the health, safety and welfare of the community which are unanswered and therefore, this license should be denied at this time. Council members stated to the effect during hearings that the era of prohibition is over -- an observation with which I may totally agree. But I must remind your body that the city is bound to uphold liquor control laws, archaic as some of them may be. 22 , , . ., � ' . � , Members of the City Council July 29, 1975 Page 2 Generally, as the city attorney pointed out, issuance of this license is a "judgment call, " just as is nearly any license dependent upon administrative review and Council approval. In making this judgment, however, I ask the Council to consider the following. The hastily revised building plans submitted leave doubts as to the control of access for use of rest rooms, which are in the same area as liquor storage. Service station accessories, such as oil, would be stored in the same proximity. A 24-hour gas station operation, combined with off-sale liquor sales, is rife with possibilities for violations of liquor laws -- such as sale to minors and sale after legal hours -- in an area of Saint Paul that already has crime problems. In summary, the orderly process of licensing must require as its final determinant whether there would be any community betterment or detriment. In this case, there is little evidence pointing toward betterment and many questions that, when answered, could conclude an overall detriment. I strongly urge you to reconsider and deny this license at this time. el CE D. CO N Mayor LDC/jfr BOARD OF ZONING CITY OF SAINT PAUL ' ` OFFICE OF THE MAYOR CITY PLANNING DONALD L. SPAID AIP PLANNING COORDINATOR August 26, 1975 Rose Ann Mix City Clerk Room 386 City Hall St. Paul , MN 55102 Dear Madam: On August 22, 1975, our office received a request for written recommendations regarding the transfer of an off-sale liquor license from Hawkeye Liquor, Inc. to Stuart Oil Company, 255 Grand Avenue. Pursuant to that request, a field study and office review of the proposed use of the subject site has been conducted. The following findings are a result of the investigation. The subject property was originally constructed to house a gasoline service station and a convenience food store operation. Closing of the facility was either a result of business failure at the location, or the decision of a major oil company to terminate all of its outlets in Minnesota. The facility was vacant for about 1� years. The site is presently partially used for a self-service gasoline station and storage. The area around the site is one of mixed land use of varying age and condition. To the east lies the Ramsey Playground property being considered for sale to United Hospitals. To the north along Thompson Street there are three frame structures currently utilized for housing. Further to the north� across Thompson Street is the Lindsay School site. West of the subject site is a small structure housing a wholesale candy and tobacco company, two frame structures used as a multi-family residence, and a duplex, and open tand purchased for right-of-way by the State of Minnesota. To the south, across Grand Avenue, the land use pattern is also mixed, containing a Mobil Gasoline Service Station, a small canmercial structure housing a facility called the :. Personal Awareness Education Center and some older frame structures constructed and utilized for housing. There is also open "right-of-way" land to the southwest. The relative condition of structures in the area is mixed, with the commercial structures appearing to be the youngest and generally the best maintained facilities in the area. The housing in the area appears to be suffering from the adversity of the use mixtures and related traffic, etc. Staff is concerned with a number of factors effecting the utilization of this site for an off-sale liquor facility in combination with a self-service gasoline station. The City of St. Paul Legislative Code, Chapter 308� Section 26 prohibits the location of a liquor facility in such manner that the main entry is within 300 feet of a school , church, or synagogue. In addition, State law 421 Wabasha Street, Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102 (612)-298-4151 0 ` Rose Ann Mix ' August 26, 1975 Page 2 prohibits location of off-sale facilities within 1 ,000 feet of any facility under the ". . .supervision and control , in whole or in part, of the Canmissioner of Pubiic Welfare or the Cortxnissioner of Corrections." The proposed facility lies within a few feet of the 300 foot distance from the Lindsay School , and well within 1 ,000 feet of Shorevlew Treatment Center (355 Sherman) which may well be under partial control of the State Comrnissioner of Public Welfare. While we are unable to clearly state the intent of the legislative authors of the laws and ordinances cited� it is apparent that they sought reasonable separation of these types of uses. In the general case, liquor stores and gasoline service stations are both generators of automobile traffic and provide the opportunity for increased congestion. Staff is generally opposed to the use of service station structures for combination uses such as convenience food with gasoline, etc. With the potential traffic generation of a liquor store and gasoline service or self service, and the high number of vacant facilities of similar nature owing to the recent and probably continuing "energy crunch" Staff feels that the issuance of this license may set a dangerous precedent with regard to future utilization of similar vacant facilities in other areas of the City. While full utilization of this specific site by the addition of an off-sale liquor facility is viewed by the applicant as a substantial improvement to the site and the area generally, Staff feels that increased potential for traffic generation and congestion wil ) have an adverse effect on remaining residential uses in the immediate surrounding area. It is therefore the recommendation of the Planning Staff that the application for transfer of the off-sale liquor license from Hawkeye Liquor, Inc. to Stuart Oil Company, 255 Grand Avenue, be denied by the City Council . Sincerely, . � Donald L. Spaid Planning Coordinator DLS:CLMcG:bj BOARD OF ZONING CITY OF SAINT PAUL OFFICE OF THE MAYOIZ CITY PLANNlNG DONALD L. SPAID AIP PLANNING COORDINATOIZ August 26, 1975 Rose Ann Mix City Clerk Room 386 City Hall St. Paul , MN 55102 Dear Madam: On August 22, 1975, our office received a request for written recommendations regarding the transfer of an off-sale liquor license from Hawkeye Liquor, Inc. to Stuart Oil Company, 255 Grand Avenue. Pursuant to that request� a field study and office review of the proposed use of the subject site has been conducted. The following findings are a result of the investigation. The subject property was originally constructed to house a gasoline service station and a convenience food store operation. Closing of the facility was either a result of business failure at the location, or the decision of a major oil company to terminate all of its outiets in Minnesota. The facility was vacant for about 12 years. The site is presently partially used for a self-service gasoline station and storage. The area around the site is one of mixed land use of varying age and condition. To the east lies the Ramsey Playground property being considered for sale to United Hospitals. To the north along Thompson Street there are three frame structures currently utilized for housing. Further to the north� across Thompson St�eet is the Lindsay School site. West of the subject site is a small structure housing a wholesale candy and tobacco company, two frame structu�es used as a multi-family residence, and a duplex, and open land purchased for right-of-way by the State of Minnesota. To the south, across Grand Avenue, the land use pattern is also mixed, containing a Mobil Gasoline Service Station, a small commercial structure housing a facility called the Personal Awareness Education Center and some older frame structures constructed and utilized for housing. There is also open "right-of-way" land to the southwest. The relative condition of structures in the area is mixed� with the commercial structures appeari�g to be the youngest and generally the best maintained facilities in the area. The housing in the area appears to be suffering from the adversity of the use mixtures and related traffic, etc. Staff is concerned with a number of factors effecting the utilization of this site for an off-sale liquor facility in combination with a self-service gasoline station. The City of St. Paul Legislative Code, Chapter 308, Section 26 prohibits the location of a liquor facility in such manner that the main entry is wlthin 300 feet of a schoot , church, or synagogue. In addition� State law 421 Wabasha Street, Saint Paul, NEinnesota 55102 (612)-298-4151 � . � Rose Ann Mix August 26, 1975 Page 2 prohibits location of off-sale facilities within 1 ,000 feet of any facility under the ". . .supervision and control , in whole or in part, of the Commissioner of Public Welfare or the Commissioner of Corrections." The proposed facility lies within a few feet of the 300 foot distance from the Lindsay School , and well within 1 ,000 feet of Shoreview Treatment Center (355 Sherman) which may well be under partial control of the State Commissioner of Public Welfare. While we are unable to clearly state the intent of the legislative authors of the laws and ordinances cited� it is apparent that they sought reasonable separation of these types of uses. In the genera) case. liquor stores and gasoline service stations are both generators of automobile traffic and provide the opportunity for increased congestion, Staff is generally opposed to the use of service station structures for combination uses such as convenience food with gasoline, etc. With the potential traffic generation of a liquor store and gasoline service or self service, and the high number of vacant facilities of similar nature owing to the recent and probably continuing "energy crunch" Staff feels that the issuance of this license may set a dangerous precedent with regard to future utilization of similar vacant faciliXies i� other areas of the City. While full utilization of this specific site by the addition of an off-sale liquor facility is viewed by the applicant as a substantial improvement to the site and the area generally, Staff feels that increased potential for traffic generation and congestion will have an adverse effect on remaining �esidential uses in the immediate surrounding area. It is therefore the reconxnendation of the Planning Staff that the application for transfer of the off-sale liquor license from Hawkeye Liquor, Inc. to Stuart Oil Company, 255 Grand Avenue� be denied by the City Council . Sincerely� Donald L. Spaid Planning Coordinator DLS:CLMcG:bj � � �-� - ' y` i . , � � � �.�1 � > � : > rr.,:. �f , ,_z .- .. . : . . � � . ., Y .�. � ; :. , - _ � , ?'; �' a � F .� � . ' � `y'. ` a ,n ��., ' � O . - � . 4 '.� d�.�xc3 -�j B� 't r � , . . . , 7' . � i .. � . . 4 ��:t... . . . .. . � . . � . . .. . �� �. � _ . ,� ., f i Y� � 1 i - . � - ' ' • �z:.-, t.:_ ��. . �._ . � . � ti�_,� '�� ?ti �� � , - , ..� , �, .. .. . • ;e, ..: 1.,y, , .�. . :. +'., . . , .. ','.� . +a;.. ..1� . .. . . . , . . . . `;. �:�...-. ;: :_ �.?'. : ;" ' �; . . .. , ..: _. . ��, .� . �.. , ' . ...' . �, . ,. .�, 't x." ... , `'. •'.' "� � 1 ,. - . � .{ .., ' ��� � _ _ . ' , . C_' 1 . 'i-, _ �. . � t 2 �� , _ . � . . ,� '�5 4' " � '{ � . +, . . � , . 1y ��. ti . . _ . � ° 'g� � �r:� - '� \ � _I � .Y .. � ., .� � .. . k �. �A � � � � � . � . . . - :1.� i �^, su�r °'vi 1 Yl 1 'ry ,," �� ' a `� �-'-� � �� . � � . � a;^= � 1 „ � . ,: ...� c.�. .. � � � � ,.. .. ,,�� � � . • �. . :, � �:.�,. � ,� � �.,� �y � . . ,, :. ' .. / . . . , . 3 . . �. - . "�.. " ,' ,. .- n \ ..,�, ., .. �:� . .�. � t, �� . "yl.. ., .. . J . .: y . .i. � . ..1 .' _ ' ' - � , �. . .< �.� . . .. � . . • ` ; $ .. ' � � i . E � i , , i e ., � . � . �'.. � . .�. . ' �` .. � � . . . .' � - . ,. .� 4 ;�. : . � ' R .: �.. . ,�. . . ' . . �. . �.. .. � .. ' : 1.�_. �'. . ... . �� . .... i� " .. .- . �e",. ..f.� . .. .. '� . '.-. .' . . . . ' . ;, f'�:�:1 . .,. ,� i . .: . �i: . � .... 5�. . ' ._� {.' r : ..Y . . _ x . .. .. . .. . .. , . .. . � . � � . . � . � ,.. ��: .. • . � Yx S . .. r . � . . ' . • - . . . . . � ' � � �`'' .'P) ' Y�� . .. ..� ' r`':^, vt �.� f � , . .. �. . .. �� 4. .,: . . � . , , . , ,. . '.: . . .� : . . . �. .> ' ! . ' �� . . � � f '�.��'�' �M� r , � 1 � \��`�!�b. J �� - � .' ' � *� �� �`, �, ��� :1 . } � .. � 1 I_ , � .• 1 I . � r� � � �µ•�t M� *� !. �', '.'�'.�� � �. f ` -� x c,�s„z � �"� :; '� � t � ��♦��� � �t '.& � Y �c. ;�� # � ' . . .' _�,`l�i� �.��.- S . � . ' i . � f. '� � t.:� � °� � � � . ". � , : .� ., • , .- G ! .: - . ,'e�' .- r�. + , ' - .. . . � � Ai'�. �: 4 �` i . . �� i' �:�'; ` �'r� t;m `� . t t '� I � d �� , . . .:.. , . . 1; ,. . . x ; � � r � � , ; 1 , , _ : ,i � '� �a ; � ; �� ` � i�i �7�� � � ��r � . ,y .�r��� t � fJ��•a i ' .� r � �� ��: . �'���� ��;���M �.,��, � � � �� � � ,� �`���IS �:��.,��: �� �'� �':�i ���,,�.�� �' �.���,� *�,,y, ��. r "�' � � p ��•�I �.�G�� '�� ...� ��I�\ . \; � 7�'i � ,. ���, _ . 'A� � 3 ` '�'a! ' .- '. . . �: ` � '�F Gj ^" iA , . .. � L ` k u � �1 ��� �'��'r� . � ,r�;#�; 'w►►�.'�w' �� `�� �' � � ���. t � . . '� ?:� r � � . i;J '��.�.. . �' ,,' .. P,. . ` . ` /" {i�- . j. 'I�r -��{, � � p6 . . �� � i, -;t i�. � ti:{ ,� : ,� 1+.�� �an. I ,. r ' � _ - �.�i,�,��� ` ` �� j•. x j� �i . . - �r em�G^.�, �a' � u � �> , 4 � '1 � .X\ ` �� ,�� � *p ��Y � , , . . e . _ ;, _ ,... � _ �� � L.» , � � � � �,: � ' i ' � � , � � . � `� � i � � _�� ,� '� � " '>r(r , � 1�'`� , � � f "� � ti I ���� ,, , k � t � �.,:: � . � . � ( .S` I j; . .. . :a s : •� �� / � 4 � , �R � Y lx���4� .✓ ^ i , ' . . ,�,.- ��i_ �{� � ..t'�- J � � �� N. � � � �� ��, � � � �„ . , . . � . . � �.' t a 4 " ,c ; � � � � , _.� . ��k' �F:� > �,�_ �� � S� .n �.x � - � ., .. , ' . . - �'�.. � ,� s d �'r rP*n - �� , � . � ��� ( � � . �4 �Y�a�.� . . (. , � � �� � 4 � :3 '#6 .'. �s #.�., . � ' � . � - �{`dX� `�ry .� . . � ' � � vr ��.: � .. � . ��� � ��. . � . ' e'w"° � �� � �����¢c��� - . . �.r �' � �."� s�,� i �' . � �.,. - . ,, . . . , ,. . � � . a . � �� . •: ., � #_: _ , � . ,. � . � � �.� � � i�s� �t h' r �F "��,���� ' � .. +, - , .a . <� . .. �,,�� :, t M1., �, a r �' r \ � *� �� fi �s� �,y+t i u,�$.f b , , � � y ��' ?`z,k����� ` .. . �. . . . f'', � .4 �r� r� ' '�'x'. \ "r � � �F '� �'r3 s�I�' , . , �_ . � , . . � , � .. . .� . . �' . °; - .1��. ..� . �._ , _ . � . . . . � .. . , � ..� , .:_� . .:. .,,,. -: �'y... ...,..,:' � , ,.'t.,�."�..z. , � ..�._ ..y.,..s...#s'�.rs _ _,�..e...- _,. , . , . � . . . . , : .*' ' ° n �;;� ' �: � �, t �-- , i. s'' a � ' ,. I . \� ✓". '4 I . . . A,�9A • r �ry. � ��r �,% . � � � e? .`,,t� ' � %1 ��,. .. . � �. . � . , '{. �C r 1 , i; L r �{ a 1 , .. , , , , : � ,�. ; � .� . �� . . , , . � �. � f ' . _ ; . . , . . � . � ..;� . . . . . .. ,.� � '�. . . . �:� , .� � . .. . ,-. . . . . . . :.. . .. � � �� . . . . . . . . . '.. , .. . , . . . . ., �� � _„� , :. ,�..'. . ,.��. 1 � . , ..,� . , .. . .,;� ��,� . . :...�.�� , . ��` , \ ; i . . ' . 4�.v ' � .r, , � : . - , � . � �{ .Y� ,� � F . .. � - .. . . ,l�� • � .. . . � . ... . . - � . `{� ! }i . ' .. ' . " "t I .� ,� . . ~ . 4 ., i� . � 1 � � . � . '.,. •. . .. ., _ . . � (� ` � }e �:. . �. . . _ , � , �. .. - •, . . . . �, � . .. , . � , fJ°` � . - :. . . .'�. . ' . . �. � . . '' ' . , . � � ,. . . - ..� . �� . ����: .. �. . .. x v' �� . �' . � . .. .. . � . , - ' . � ,:; .. � . . . � _ . i 1 S, , . .� ., � . . . . . ..� . .�:; ,� � .''_ . �. .�. . \. .. ..� . ..� �. .. , �.. ...�.P . ;.. �Y�,�J .,'�,J� �,�.'' � ',� . ./'�� - � . � � . . i , . ' , . . . . . ' ✓ f.-. . �.�:'.. . . �..r: ��" � . ' � � . . . . , ' `� .� ` 'fy S� ' t: . _ . � ., : . . - n � �.�. . �;� . . .,. y .. . . . . .. . . . ' ' . ,' , 'F. ''� . ..;A{� . '� .,. .. .. . . . ..'. . . . ... �.. . . . . . . ' . ... � � ., / � �'�~ .. � ' � . . ' ` _ _ . . . .,r .. . . . . . . � � � ' �r �� �� �, : ' . � .�� ,�i. •'^� . � � . . . . .� ,\ .�.'i� E,� . .,�-� . . \� .. t "..... . � � � . . .. � � ' , . , � . �, Y:r'l�. ' 1'k. � £'9 ��. . .��.�� ' '}.. � t `t y � - � ' �� � _ '� �r ' k � . . „ _ , . � • � ;. . . , . , � ,� \ . . � . . , ,. , � , . ;✓ . ,r' r. . , x' . , , �. . y��� ' ' � , �� 7i�E� , ai i � - , ,.: � ,. . .. . � . � ... , �� .��F y r �� 'N � h��; �losN b� M►d'rt� '� ,�iMf � 1�i� ,'� ��► 1 � k.. , '�- � ' �,�ir�t� e�'`1� .#ip�r�r�i�� � 1ii�':����ii�t ��� ,,, ;� 1�r !"�'of A� �'� A� �,a +�. II���;� �'�� ° .°a ;;. � � . , , " ; � a� '� �4r �' - t �r, �;�+��� �;� , ��;��r . . .. ' . ' . ty. � . ,.. _ ..� � ���������� ' ����A��y���t{ � � ..,r ,` r\ ;�',Op'�t�R'S� 0�'!R�i �!R ` ^ . . . . . .. ' � � .. � ' . . .,1 )`. .: F , . . "� �` �1 � 5 . . . . . � . . 1�"Sr , ,, . ' .. . . . � 4 ...� . � _ � . . ' . .. � � .. �. � Y���� � ..:�" �,:� 4 �n . re: . _ . . . .. . . . . ; - F�. �i' . .. , . .. _ .. �� � � � ,. r �' . . . , ' . , .{,�4 ' �" y� „ x , . . . .._ . . . � . .. � „ . . . -� , . ' .. , ' - . . . . . ' -�I.::� � . � ' � . . . t t , , �� � ^t,. r ' ^�' �z, .�x' ��� . ,,� � ��.. . . ' � . t� .:t3 �� ��. l. �. . .. -..���' a �. . .. } . �' . . � � . I . . . �1 - . - . `1 . . ��. � �. r,., .. . . . ,_ . � .�.. �� ' � ' . . . �. . • ' '�:� -.. " , � ' � ^ . . . . . . . �t , ' , ' ,. �. "' � . . . . � . k, �,. . . ; . �� . � . � � '� � . ��.� . � ���.. ' � .. � � . . � �� `. . Y : r � . . . . . � . . �.�� �� . � . � .. .' . Y �' }'� ,. ;.� . . � � . � . �� • - .r ` 'f _ - . , . � _. �� . � ' . . �. ' ' . �.�/ �� , ' . . 1=.,k .. . . � '� . �-_ . .. � . '� ' � , i��? , . . . . .. . . _� .� . . � , . . �., , . : . . ' � � . . �1. . .. . . . . � i . . � - . •'� , _ . . , .� .... . i' ��., i . �., . ,�, ' � '�� . . - � :A � _ . � .-_� .. . � i5 v n' , .� .. � . . . .. � . �. h �� � `F"SP,� � . � , . , .�, f � .� � , ' ' .. I , .. . ;r - ���.£ � �`� � �.. . ��� - ��� .� � �. � ' _ � . .. � � _ .. � .ti�,,. , . . ;. ' . . . , . . ' . . ... f ',r ` , , ,g 1 . . ,. . �i- ' � � .+i '.d , � �., x . . . . .. ..... ..._ . .�.. � . .. :. .. . . , ��y .. . , , . . � � . � � � � � . . � . . .. �� � � � . . kr ... .. ... � , . : ' '. .. '�' 'il , .�..��� ., :.:. .� _ : .� .. . 1` : 1, ' . .�^ ' $F�' • (''� :�� , � �" � �. ' , �,� , , , . . :ti � ,i` ,.a� �p ._. ; . f �: � {'. - � , , \ c .� � � � �... �.. �. �. . .. . .. \ � , { ��€': � . . ' _ .. c � , _,_... _ . . � � . � Y� � .. � - .�� � � . . �� . . . . '. .��i � �, - �. " . . . . � . � .. , . . .. . ' - ,. . .. ._ - . ., , . . . . . . � .. � � . .. .. . � � . . . . � ... ,y�. . . , . , . . i " � - . � , - . � ... - - �. . t: � . . . . . � . . � . . . . , s . . . . . � � . ' � . 3 4 �.^ . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . �`. � � .. . � . . � . ... . ., ! . . . . - . .. . `l . - , . , - . . . - �� .. .. . . � ' . ' . . ..'.. ., . . . �. ...:.. - ' . , . . . �.' . . � : . . . ' .. . � . : ,. , . , �, .. -... �. �..; .. .�� 1 . .. � , . . . � � . , ' . . � I . � � � ... . . . - . . � �� . . � .. � , . .. . � /, - .. . i ' . , � ..- � ' �1 _ �I � . . . . �. � . . . . ��. _. .. . � . .. . . .. . . � .. �p. . � ... " ., . . `. . . . . � ,� .� . . .. � � � � � � � .. , . . �. � �. -. . . . . . .� . , . .. " �. . . . .. . . .. . . . . _ ��::':: , � �.� . .. . _ . ..,, � � : � . "� ... . ., . . . . . . . . . ..., � . \ .. ,.� . � -. � �.� . . . , . . �. . . .. . . .. r x. . �- .. . � .. . . . . _ . . . . . . . .. _. . . . . . .,�!.. .� . . '" . , ... . . .;- � ,: ... �, ., . � . . � . �r ..}.�; - . � �� �, . � . . . . . .., . ._ . . . . � _ � . . .. � - . � , -�. . .._ � \ . ... . . .. . .. . . . . . _ .. .. . . . . . . .. . . f � . .. . , . . . . . � i , . . .. . , - . . . . i'. . � . . , . ' .. ., . . . i . � . . .. � � _� . - . • i� , • . . � . . ,� � - . . _ . . . . . . . . .� . . . . : . . . . . . . , . . - _ . .� . � � .. . _ ., . .. h� . . . � � , � . �. : ._ r , i , �� : „ . . . , . . . . ,. . . . .. . , , .. � . ,. .. . .. . . . �. . . �" �� ... ... . ' . � . . _ _ ,N . . . . .. ' ., . ., � �� , � . � . , � � .. � � - .. . .�,� . . . . � . . . . . �. . .. . . �- . .. , ` � . � ' - , . ' ' . . , . . . . . . .. ' . _, .. .. " � . . � , , G �� 1� , . ,.. , . � . , . : , , � . � , � � . ' �► srta�. . , . _ - , i ,.%, ,�. . , Q!�'f f►� �rl.�9t i l i en��#ng � d ; �► ��ars . ;I \ ',, ; . !l�.t'�l�► �mai�t +ri# i� •l�ns,!= ,� 3�"'3� rla#�g�.ri�t�erri� ��tti�: , �� � _, r... , 2e�tar e9►?�lrpr+oioe; � dai�esf �9�'+p�'�4�13��ao��-1�i '4�"� �M�► �� - r��►�dio6 !�1r ��to�11�t' �Rf �II� �II 1� 3#��Ir i'�alt �ip�i�+� .��AM!'�� � � � . �s., '1e,�n�R t!� i3r., �r .f'e�'` 1�'iR�n ,► " ?� �'�M�.`�l�.'� +�tts� x�+�,a�t �i� iM�►a� �r.�. � �t.�;�° A - �+�t � va��r#a. r�rrl,.ri'� �1�i�� .t�'�his".���. , w -V ; . ,, - � . t a� '�d` � l�la ]i�;. , ��at�trelwrd �?�� i,�,�e� �. t: ��; , . ��,' ; .� , , t � Y� '` ' � � ��" 1 � . . " . ... .. . ' . . . . . ,�. � . . . . . _ . ;� � , . ` , � _. , _ ,': �. - � ,� . . : , : - - . . ��,� ; , � . � �a�. , � � � . �; � $� , , - , . , - r f . ' , . ;,. : �:,. ri+ � > : �. , � - , � _ c � � , . . ' . I `.`�,. , , u. ;' � .x . s � ` . ,. , , � ; , � � '. : _ � � . � . ` ' , � � � _ . ' ���' .. � y;.; ., , ; ! . . i .. . c �. � - , _ . _ _ . . ' . . . , -, , , - , , � i � � _ I � � :; : � � ,_ , , ; � . _ . � � } . . . � , . - � ,; . . . i� � , �� _ � j� , � ; . ; �L , � !� ; . ;, - , � i�� _ _ ; , , . , -{� ^ > �� _ . R � �f , � , . "��,: 19"�3 , , '� �� , , � I . ��aa�ln �-i�nsiair f�, ' , ,�� i � . � D�ar Sirt - : f � � ' � ? i , � Cit� t�ecil a� t�ts'�s� S� 1 , iw�eg ��d � s�� . � 1rtt�r of liy�►roar t�Mn dat�d J1t1�r` �9� �qd, aqs#�iu6`�is � �t- � ` • ,rt�ardin8 't�e''irans!'�c o! ae► ott �.i�wor�lia�t� ,isN �.L��!ooe,� , � Itia,� ts eif�t t3i1 C�ar., to yau t'aor' � 'nvoo�nds�f.aa. , � . ' '1b� � �t#1 a11Mr x�we� �r�rmr', �a 1� r►t'1�' .0�� . . . aeb�Y'i�d°l�ear �p�t31 �+�nrisx-�{d�t si '�alr_1►l�rr��;. ` � � ` � , � A �' 'oi' t�aa�t�i !!.'L� �►. � ia � t� �rrr�t �oae�tti+ory► � '� , ; . Yawrr � . , .' i , . 2 �� � l�/�t - � �I ' � , A�• � � i . . . , � . i . , i , \ . , � , � � � ; , , r , � . : • _ , ; 4 . . _ ` � � ,� � ` . - ;I � a � CITY OF SAINT PAUL 4� ��TY p�� � - '�d Ros� Mix o :•,..;p::;:;: '� Albert B. Olso� C4ty Clerk and �d °°�"_�-' " ° ,; Council Reaorder Council Seoretart/ ��, ,�� �.. OPPICE OF THE CITY CLERK BUREAU OP RECOROS 386 City Hall St.Paul,Minnesota 6610� Phone 298-1,�441 'R�a, . _ t�.- , . . `��,Ff � ��p ... .. . .. n��,`r';'"�"�w �' � J}'.�rJ� `!��6'�v ii Ju�y 25, 1975 Honorable Lawrence Cohen Mayor Building Dear Sir: I submit herewith for your approval the followin.g attached Council Files which were adopted at today's Council meetin�: 265787 through 265803 Yours very truly, G�__ 't-'�,! /� � ity Clerk (,�,�� 1 / sc a c�s � � S � re��-�"►� `Z -�o ��S �3d3`'`� t`��C" ,�,..��k....�..r�.�:;�� ,� ..w��� . �." �;� �o � � . . . . . ��5��3 ,��-� ..,. ---�;�� s�:� .. __ __ .--..._._- Transmit to FIRE PREYENTION DIYISION for Inspection CITY OF SAINT PAUL DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE AND �, , ... ,: � • , MANAGEMENT SERVICES �PPL. NO. iNO�cnTe APPLICATION FOR LICENSE GASH GHECK NEW�' RENEW � �� �� • �� 19 A T E �-�- LICENSE NO. TITLE OF LfCENSES � .. � . � .. . . , f 00 FftOM ��►:, � j 1�� T���' f� 1 9 7 � �^ � 100 .. � APPLIGANT�s'' . . 100 � T00 BUSINESS NAME - t00 BUSINE55 ADDRE55 � EL. NO. � � 100 RESIDENCE TEL. NO. RECEIVED THE SUM OF � /i j,�M l ,��� . .p�� ,�{f . . ( TOTAL �a ��/L/'4 "`��•� 100 ' wi�'���� .� . . � � * LICENSE INSPECTOR � � BY I N ICANT EPORT OF fNSPECTION FIRE HAZARDS EXITS .r •� �;,. • �� „ ' EXTtNGUtSHERS -- � ATING P`ANT ` — LIGHTING DECORATIONS FIRE RECORD REMARKS ����BUILDING INSPECTOR REPORT ��TRIPIICATE DATE NS ECTOR : �APPROVED �UL "° I� • 19 ❑REJECTED DATE CHIEF INSPECTOR � �''�-.'.�- . ..'•'.'__ ___ .. . . . .. .. . _ . . . . .... ..<a, .. � . f ! � ( ' � f��LJ�V'� �� I . ; ` � CI��Y l�F �T'. P�.lJL ' �; ?:�FR A. � �T11 CN DCPARTP.1E(�!T OF FINANCE AND NIANAGEi4tFNT SERVICES JOSEPH F. CARCHk:DI i' �t�'. D�rec�o1`- � DIVISION OF UCFNSE & PERM17 REGISTRATION ��cense InsPector �" 103 Publir_ Safety Bldg. �I �' 101 East 10�h Street St. Paui, Minnesota 55101 �, F�,: 224-1896 i. • February 13, 1975 ,' ' . � i�ir, kl Olson 3B6 City Hall . St. ?aul� I'•":innesota 55102 ' Dear Al: �'�'r.closed you will ii_nd the fil_e on the �tual�t Oil Co., Inc,, 2?_5 �u�_�a.nd Aveir�ie, ���er�t��ii�ing � to ti.�ei.r re�;uest for the transfer of an 0�'f �a7_e i � t ?iquor Li ce�lse frcm the Hai�keye Liquor Store, Iilc. a.t 111 ���ncord Street, to them at 225 �rand Avenue. ; �.��en the City Cc:�.ncil no lon�er needs them, ' � please see that I �et all the papers back. � `_ilank �-ou, Al. i 9c,ry truly �}rours, � �. � (�, ._:) . ,/%/,��. �� L�'.. y�;J, � ! f / 1.' '/�_cf:;�:�e Ir_:� ,ctor r -p; Enc. ' i � t i � � i ! ! , �J�Y ■ ��l_ ��i^i��:a,� �L:.:-^16,�� M � � , ' :� , ���'P�aIC�iTIQN FOR •,��� SA�E" �lG;�l1�R LICENSE � � Application Na � (7TIs furm mu.t E� f11I.d out in addltlon to the ayyl[utlon form •nd �worn �utemmt requfred b� the Llpuor Coatzol Commiutoner ot t]�� 3ta4 of 1�Inncwta,) � Name of Applicant___,Z.�.LS�� �. Stu��t AgP 44 Res;clence Addres�_ 2812 West Armour Terrace, ls. ,MN 5547��phone No 7_81-9528 ;� � Are you a citizen of the United States? Yes � { �'�tve ,�ou ever hecn engaged in operating a saloon, cafe, soft drink parlor, or business of similar'nature? � 1. �;� `,'J1aen :�;�d �4'here?_�?s�t��1r.2pJ..�.��h� —___.�--- . i P If co��,o�;�tion, �;ive date when incorporate No�.'�:t�>'�:`»:� 1,���1�969 :'?ai-�Ie <::ld .,c?dress of all officers of coi•poration, and name and address of manager of premises upon�which � lirti�or is to be sold Jari 4 T•. S u�_n��,�_��d,�_;nt i 2g.�2 W�S� Arnt�ur Terrace, Mpls. , � r�?�t 5 5 418 i;_�'�en 2i. S�uart, Secretary—Tx�agu�n�c, 28J_2 j�le:st Armour Terrace� Mpls. , 2�1 � ^ s54a.8 �•T�.R1Cti 2:1(1 :�1�(�iC:;SCS Of ii��)Ciholdera_ •TS�'!��� T t��. »j. . �..� i _�_�g .,_>..�z.��__.- . 2_R.L2._ ��?est �1�t�tzr .te� rG;r._P�Nlpls� t ------�—I��2J 5 5�18 ; —_----- -- _ -- _ F %'<,.le of�uz•ety conipany whzch will write hond, if?cr�,���n------------ ___----- --- ; _,«� _..___--�-_--- ---- --- -- - _ -- E �_-- -------- -- ___ -__ -- -_ , __:___--� ----- 1�1t� Y�ln�r -- -------Street Side ;e,t�°�een ';'�hat Crass Stxeets �� 2?..S , c':�:.-��d 11v�;>.nu� No:Lth , That�npson & PJc:as,_?txt . � . . . , � . . . . � Y�C''� :�':,y `rr�t f��m 2`] <Caderny, cotle�;e or tiniversi� :ne•suz•ed :?,)Cil� S'�iP.�° 5� ���"�?�,_r Y ( t t �a � _i.n area ,<. � , .�.,a� f :t fic�;Al i�}i� ,.ch (il l,'.�:i�iC'd .10- .,i.'.. _ei. ) ?_�_ _.��?+].r;�t, `� . _ s .._- ^�,. _`._—__. _ _ . _ . ils/ = "!' i : A_ `�.���' .�. �Lti� �.�'`� �.� blc��ks/ ` '`'�;�� ,:�r.;1y f<<.� fi��,n cios��:;t piiblic ar p;;.xoc.hial hi�h oz� �;,-�,de �rhE�ol (:nearured along Gtreets)2_'.�__�Q -fE-,�� � ]"'il�^ (il ('�C Q St :�C�tU01_ r�f'..�__ Tl�{r .l'-"CiY1 �±. . ��,� � r .,�,.,��� l ---_ . . ..,�_� ..�..._ ..Y,�... ;.�.. �..., ` �C;'� ' ;? -i':'� rl ' � �:)„}�fll:'(� 1]"� Ei2I' � �xi .,•. ..� � t -i-'..-- --- .�______.___�_._._._---- � � . �. � �. r;�s ,�r:F.a�Q :.�.,s��ti?_ l «���_. `� � � ,� � , _ - .. ' , �;�•, , 7 . .:.1 ,�i:.:.t . �l i �.t.lj .-- 7 �-�•<:a iL.1,,1,C,�{7 t�i �'�1,1_1 r �� Zall� 1.(�;�,1�C� _ _._ . -------- � ' ^ • ------- ----- .T Ic•,ic_d � � � .. -�f' of �'1�-;er._._ .�'L'u'.i!.'�� �3Y ��;,>1 i,� ,t� , . � : � ,�... � , ..: i .. „ r �_ . , _ _. _. _ .. _ i •�� ;.�;1,� -:.;.�t;n fur d�ur;:;`c�rn� ,sen;�ral food sto�-e u� r�;�?,a^.ive ;i4uor �-tore?._.�- _c�l�us�:ve ]_3cltxo� s{:c>x'e ; ��`v`:J }��1tty% �:�JC y0U Oj��'Y21ZL'(j j�Y2SCIIt bU�,IiC88 �t j)tf=C:ilt S3�QT '`E'�e,` e��r_�_�I��T13 f.�l;:�,`,;�3dt D.::C(:;nbe1� 1.974 � i ��O j't:i1 i.O`.✓ t``:i�'E,' i�71 ��On Sate" P10T1-111tOX1Cat117� jl!�1�OC 110E'":1�07---.'?d— ----- (T):?s .:�;l�c���::�n iiTl.lSt �C �i�ned by the appl;cant, ;>.��d if �� c��x�a�:;tion, �,y an o�cer of the co � rporatzon.) i (P?e��: ��;�� �tate abz�;l$catic i `or�n ;._nd i:::�.��:��atFan must be vex-ified.) , ", :iia;�ce of ] ���-:�:;��e is tiot reeornrncn_ded. �� ' �;:,'U'r.��ZT�O):L CO. � INC. . _ . : / . , � / ..:��i_--___.. -----_______------_19�_ �--'-_ . .- ; , .� __ L �- - _. , , ,�. ` _ ; i -_---�_ _ —--- / y/� , � i� � . i' __ . _.. ___ ��_�__ i�� �� �� _. _. _ ._ __� __. _._-�--- -- I 1__ Licc7�se Ii,,�p�ctor.— �,7��;,�3 L. �S Luart, A�PLICANT.— ; �� ��:�� . �. �x :�A f . „,. r i .{, � � _ �� ,� - -� ` . m ;. , _ . . . - . �_ ., , .. _�. , � , . � � .. . , , . � , ` ._ , � . _ _ : . � - f . , � .� �.... � .. ,y ." .. r, . . . �.� . : �:; . ' ': ... ., .A ':._ � '�', t `. � � t .\ � � - f ^�� �� . . _ . . . - 'it a . . ,.. . . - . ,� ; . ...��. , .. '� �,:. .. . .. � , . . � .. _ ;. • � . , i . . . �. , ^ . - ` . . \ . F r � ' � - �\ t 1 { � � ,... � ,F '. � . . � �� � ��. .:� . ' ' : .:� = . . .� � . � �. � . . '. ' ' . . ' , ' . : . -, '.,, �t�y . . � �, . . < : _ . • , t � „ •. : ;, . , , � � : • . , , { �,. � . �: .. .. ... .., . .� .._ . . . , Y : , . . ... � . . .. . . � . . � . � �\ .��. ... �� . . � . - . . . . . . •E i.. � , .. ., .. . �., . .. . . . .. � � � .�. -.'� ; .: . . .1 . . '� .. �.... . . � r .� . . . � e�.�,� ,� : , . .. . - . , � . �.. ... . �.. � '': . t ';. . . . . . . .. 1� . . . . . .. ,, . . � � .. ' � . . � . .� �� ` . . . ., - � � .4.�! � � , . . . . ,�. ... . y � �,.'� ._ ,- .,� _ '. .�: , $ -. ;; . ..+ . �. . . , < i 1 • f k , ; y . , _ �1 . _ �. � _ � ��� -� � . Fh� H . ' ' . . . - _ � .. . � , � . . . . , I , . . . � .. . <� '�.�". �� � . .� . .. . .. � . _ � . . �. � . . f . �, � ' , . .:� . , ' .. : . ' ._ � � .°. . . ; � . , :, ,, , :r, . . .,. . , . . . � - �-. : � . ,,. .< . .:� � . � � ' .�. �: � .. � � . .. .,. _ . . ,.. '.. . . _ , , '.. . s . .�.' � � -� , . .,.� . , _. ,. . .. . : :... � . � ,.. .. . �,. ,. ' . ' � . . _ � . . ... � � n�� .'.5 ,; ,�/ � ��� �� . • . . � . � �... . . ' � � , ' . . � . . '. . ) .. ' . . . .��.. . . . . .. � . . , �.�� �a� � � . ,: .�, , , �. , ( � - D�ue � � , !�IM � �Al'�.i�1:1�1�► '���! .��'�s = ' ����� ♦ ��It'`���o �- ;�� : �� ,;� � ��° _ � �.�� � , ���II�II�' �' �. .� d�+l��.:�► �r , . . , . �►� �. a�.'� I�Nr�r , . .. _ _ . . - � . � � , , , :, �- . ; . . . . ,� � � ��'�!!�ir , � ,� �. - , ; , ,. . ,-; ,,. _ _ ;;' � � � �,' � � �� �� d.� . . , . ��� ��� � Y��;� . � � Y � ��� � � � �� � . �'. . _ f � �. �lR: , �'s �M� ' � �:�M��M!' ` . � _.�. � ' � r i - � _ } � r a ' , f i i � � .� � . f � ' . :� F �� .. ' . , . � . . _ � i .. . ,,' .. ..'. _� .. . � � ; - . . . .. � , . � , . � Y `:.a . . . � � . . . .. . ., . i . . . _ . . �.� .:� , . r i�... ' �' � , ��.. _• � ,.. v .. . .�: . .. . e .. - . . . . -. , � . ..�� . . . �. .: :. . � �:� . . -��. , � � . . " . � . � . ' . f � . ' � .�i ,� . .. . .. .. . � . . .. .:t C. ,. . . . �� . �` �� . � � .. .. `; . . ... . _ , r ,y, ` •l f t': . ,, , � . ; '�, . . __ '. ' , ,. , `?�?i a i ;� � � �� � � � � i r b� � �:: , , . '� _ , � � �. , "_ - , . : �.: . , -s., -.0 -- -- �.�,�___.--- - !-- -- _ -_ - - - ' r _ � ' , . ;. ���8:�� �:� - - CITY OF SAINT PAU�L - -,� � -k= DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE AND MANAGEMENT SERVICES DIVISION OF LICENSE AND PERMIT ADMINISTRATION .� . 1 May 29, 1975 - .� �^ Mr, Paul Desch - ' Finance and Management Services 113 �ity Ha11 . ; . St. Paul, Minnesota �,.� Dear Mr. Desch: � I have been instructed by the City Council to request a public hearing on the matter of the agplication �ar transfer o£ Off Sale Liquor Licsnse P�o. 27l�. from �the _ Eawkeye Liquor, Inc. at 106> Hudson P�oad to the Stuart Oil ' :� Company, Inc. at 225 Grand �venue. . ` . The public hearing should be held on Thursday, July 10, 1975, at 10:00 A. M. in the City Council Chambers, - third floor City Hall and Court House. • Very truly yours� �� - /�� � �6'���� . License Insp ector ,:,;..: _ - , .". .��.5 ���.. �� � . ..3� ��- � . . . ����.a ' . .. . � . ' . �-�., . . - . . _ , . .._�� � . . . ` � . . S �r c � .. . . � �r ,: ,. � :. ._:. y - . � p'c�.. , Y z = �a , . r��"_�� ' � - . .. � .. '� �' , , =� # " � . City Hall, St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 - . � r � n ' • �;��2 �> 5� i , , ; � ���7� �.��k-�"�'c�z.�-L ; • �'��r-L- � ' '/,Y j,,-� 'nc./realtors • appraisers • consultants 1202 commerce building st. paul, minnesota 55101 telephone (612) 224-1341 May 2 , 19 7 5 residential sales/2767 hwy. 55/454-1341 R�CEIVED Mrs. Ruby ��unt MAY 5 1975 President City Council of St. Paul , City Flall Council President St. Paul , Minnesota 55102 Rwby Munt RE : Off-sa�le license transfer Hawkeye I,iquo�i, Inc. to James Stuart. Dear Mrs . Hunt: After discussing the above cas ' �S �aould like to request, hereby, before the Council sitting as request is being made with the Chairman of the License Commit � m � The presentation of this propc prepare than could be allowed ' the presentation must include � of operation on the same piec� station to prove full complia o r � � r Mr. Stuart presently owns ele � are in Minnesota and four in � � y � �° � are self-service operations . � � c� � �' � 0 impossible for anyone purcha� y H � � � � � store unless and until he con x � o �!; � � y � his car to an adjoining park� N � � � building for the cashier for � ,� connection between the two b� `-' " are operated. � � . v, A plan for remodeling the pr � Grand and Smith Avenues will drawn in keeping with the re staff. This transfer will � tax paying business to the C z I appreciate your cooperatic � helping present this case t< � Yours very ����j , � � r �.._.��_�-.. .. � � R�' ard ����" '�`to� � President, PARRANTO BROS . IrIC. �. � / - �� ' �,i.'. . . .. . .�. . . . _. .. : �� , / . . : .. . '..:. d . . . , . . . . , , . . . I N . . . � . .. . . , . . j .. y .. . � � � . � � : . '.i . . � . .. . . � - . � , . �� . , . - . .�r .. � . . . � . � _ � � r . ' . . . ,� ' . � � , ; � .. ,. . .. . . .`.�'... . `. , � -. ' ... . •� . .. . . . . .. . ' '� . . t � . . . . . . . . . . .. � � , ... . .. � . � . .' .. .. �� � � . . . � . . � . . � ., - . .. . . , . . . . . . . � , , .. / ` `� � � .a: I . - � ' ' . . � . � , \ . , � , , . . . . . � . . . . � , � , . ,i'�`f , .' � � . .. . � , ' , , . .. . . , ' . � .. � . . . � . . � . � - .� ,� . . . . . , .. . . ,. . , ' �. . : . . ... � 1 '� �.. �. . . '. . ,�, .. - .": . � . . ,, �._.�1 .. .. . . � � . . . � . � � .. � � . . .. . . . . . - . . .. � _ � ... . . . . _ . _ .. . : .. -. .. � , .. � .. � � �.�.7 ' . ..� �' . � . . . ' . :. , . . . ��' . .:<. . . .. . . � .'. ". ,� • ,. � . �� .. . . ' . ' .. ', �. .. . _� .� � .�. ... ,. . , . . � . . .. ., . �. � . . . .,, � .: . �. . . � � . . , � � . � . . . ..�. . . � . . . . .. , . �s 22', 1975 ', � . � � . - - � . < ,, . . � � , , , , 1�. Ri�4asd' 1�. �arra�to ' ' � , : , ` ;Prisi�t`Psrranto Bs�+as.,.i�c.' , _ . - -° : : ' .1�D� C�otrr�e�ce� �3�uildiag � '8t. P�au1, I�.nnesota .S5id1, � , , Dear�$3rs r " _ � - ` � , � . , , . , ' plaasa be �dvia�d a mot�.o�c grantir�`yc� � r�4aiiat,ta.�iave � Y�ariog 'b�fc�px'a. ' - • ` tb� Gity Coimci�., sitti�a� er s coa�iCt� of th1� �r��a, 3.� l�e�'tatter of ` • , _ �he E3fif-S�le L�.qupa�r f�.c.�wte traAS�e��!r, Ha�ye �;q�nr, Inc. ,to. .T�os . : . S�usrt;�rae adogt� bg �ha Cit� Co�c�l t its t�a,fl.�g,_ 29:TS meeting. . , , Sa�d haNUri� i� �du].e� �r Ma�r 2� 1 F 5 at 10:00 .A.M. fa the Ciky Cota�c�t�. : , Gl�aaalf+er�. : � � , � = .' ';. Yc�ara very. truly,, : - <, ; � � , � ' , r , � 3��� . /� . . , - . , .. . . � � , . . . �• . . . . � �. � ..:�., � . � . ., . . .- , . .� :�.. . . . . . . . . � �'� • ' � .,_ , . �� . : .� :. . '.. . . � '. .. , , . . � ' -` . . � .,� ��� . . �:_�.. � ' Citp tk , , . • : ' � � �. 'l�S.:dtmt - ±r ; ' _ . . . � . .. . .. - � . ,. . ,.. . ` . .. . � � '.�� ..,a . .. . - � . . � : . . . . � . .. � � / � � . �. �� . . . . � . � ' . � � . � . � � . . � � .. '�4 � � -. .. � � . . t � ' ' . � . , . . .. . � . . � .. � . .. . � , . . � . � .. . . . .. .. . . .. . . .. ., . . ... � � . � . - _ . ` � � � ... ��I .. . � � � .. � � . � . � . � '. . . , - �. . .. � �. . . .. . .. .. � �.. - ' ... , � _ . . � . . . . .. - . .:. . . .. . � .. -. � . � . , � . . . / . . . . . ., '` . ' . �, . . � . . ... \. . . � . �, . . � . , . .. . . ., . ' : . " ' . . , . .. . . �• .. . .. . . .. . � . � . ._. . �.. � � i�� ,� . .. . . . . . , . , . , . \. , . . . � i . , � . . � .. �.' . .. i � � .� � . �:: . ..'� ... ( �. .. . . ' . . � � . . . � , � . . . .. . i . � ,:.. . - . . - .. , .. , ...... :..��" . �.}�:'.. ��,.'�.. . . - -_ . .�. .:�._,�' ru. �.k,-c .... r.u,� 5:.� -.�T � i.a.� � ...� ., y. . ._ . � �:+la. .. . . . ;. r . : . . *w. ���:- . . . .�, . .� , . � . � ' : �� _ � i .,�.. ., � .. '. . .-..' � .. . . . .._ . . - . . � - v .`. . . . .... . . . . � r .. �; i ��� � - ....- � , ` � � _ �.. • :.� b �f . . . . .. .. . . . � . � .�; f ";�.1 . .-.. . . ;� � �: � � .. . . . . . � . ' � � .. . � � � - - � � �� � . ` ..� . :- . �' . . . . . i ' '� .. . , .. .:_+c. . � .-- . , . . . �,.. �..�. . . . � � . � � ,. , � .. , � ��....: . -�. .. � ._.. � � . . . � � r . . � i . � � l.*�. 1 .. � . � .. . . � . . . ' . � • ^ � .. � . . � . I� � . - !�i �`: �� . . . , . . . ,����A .. . . ' . .. - .. . . - ' . . .`,a+e .. i�r �. . - . . . '.� . . ". . . : . ,� . .. ' .� �',. '-. ..' . ._ ' . . . _. . .. . . . , . . .. ' . . _1 � .. . . � .. . �, � 1 '. . . . . . ... , .�� � ..�� � . ,.,.., . . . ..,. . .�.. �. ' ��. . .. ..'r � � . . � . +. - : .. . • .. . � ' ' � r . . :... . . . . : .. . � ... � � .. . ..;'. _ . _. .. .. . :, , .. .: j,.. ' . : ' .. , � .�`. . . . . . . . . , � , . . .� . .. , . . . ,' ' • � ,� .. .. ,. . . � . ,. ..: : : � � " .. � .._ . . .. . , � r. -. r` . '� . . .� ' . � . . .� .. ! . . ' r. . ��,' . � .. , n. .. . . . � . � . � � . . .. \ . .. .... . . . . � .'. � . . . , ... . I . . -.. � , . .. . "* . � , . -.'! .� 6 . . . �. ' � ' �... � � / , .. { . . . . . . . , .. . � . ... _ '... ...' ... _' . .. .. . . . .. " �.:. �,.. . '� . . w. . . . . . � . � � . . � , . . . . . . , . ..i; . ... . ... ' • �.:� .. . :. . .. . + . . . , . � . ' t". ., . � " .� 'r � . .. ' . . . • , . �� . � Jnly 0, 147S - ( { . y . ,. , , , , ;�: P�e�re.;�i►g,�te�r , ' , . f � �f'C� l�t�tosas�r� � , . R�" f��, Ctt�i 8�:� � . , . . - ,. , ; � > St. P�ii�. I�Dlt�60� ,, i " , ` � . s . . � , : , . . „ , , , , . , , . �:DaA�','>�,xt r , t • , � ' ° � : � , � . , " ..� . . ., : � � �Tl�e`,Ct�y •Goutt�l�. t+b�s'��,a�tet .peiblic h+�at g.�,,adopt� a�faat�oei to a�p�teA�i ~ ` . � '" ,� . t�a ��.�t�.ar gos� �� �caa�iat at.:�an� l�,3a1� Li,quoi�� �ic�► �i!r�p- ": - . ' � , `�8a�ica�ra'.��qeor.�IaC., at 1t36'! Bud�o�a '�� tQ t�cR St�ias�; 0#.1 C�t�as,,'I�.'; st 2ZS Qfc'a�d Av�ur,: � W�11 yoti plas�l p e �hs prap.��t, s�aeol�ttitn� � - -�. � : a�ro�tag �hl:s �aatfo�t. �; ; . ,. , � � . : : .; . , � , , .: � . , . ` 1h�� �rou9�s, : • , \� , ; . , , � .�'. . � _ � ,:� \ .J , , � , . a C f�.t�► , , � . _ , � , . . . ., : , ,. � ,.,� . . . , _ �., ; : A8t'�� ` _ A, , . �� eA� :D�. J!i►wp�t C+t�'t�ltsdi, Li�p Itr+r�a s � ` ` �,' V ( ' f ' . ' . � ,,. �, . , ; . � _ , `� ; �a � � ` . = ; 4 - . ,. , .. , . , , , . : , : � . ,y � : . , , , _. . ,. . , .. , . , � , , � . _ .... . . j. � ' . . . " ' , t�• I ... � . �n � . �_ � . . . , ,.�t. . . .. . ' � .._ ,{ `_" _ . � . `.- Y�, . 1. . . .. . .. .. � . . '�.: � '. :" .. . � . . . .,. .' . � ' . . '.,f. . . +t .. . ` / , � . .. . . . . .. .k . .. .. . .yy..: . -� . .. . . .. � . . . � . � . _ i. ... . � . . ��j�� � .� - -,�`'` , ' ' " �" �����'°� ��?,,L„ 7 ,� , . � A ,"`'�� / � , ,�. ��� •;-�,� ; a parr�nt��rc,�+nc./realtors • appraisers • consultants �4 � � s...- °� 1202 commerce building r" } st.paul, minnesota 55101 ,� `' �„ �, �, '� ' - telephone (612) 2?4-1341 , T' � - � ?�� _�--. �' ``�' - residentiai sales/2767 hwy. 55/454-1341 � riay 2 , 1975 � - RECEIV�p � Mrs . Ruby fiunt Presi�?ent MAY 5 1975 City Counci]_ of St. Paul , City F�all Cou,�cil PresiCi�nt St. Pau7. , Minnesota 55102 - RR�hy f�t�tlf RE . 'Oi }=--:-�:;� F? 1_1_r'�']'1SE? tL'%zt:S:��-1' ?'d:•:t:.E.�'� Lic,,��r, Tnc. to �7�ir:�+cs Stl.zart. --- - . Dear Nlrs . f�unt: ' After d�.,,�ussirig Lt?e aho�e cas� with inany men�her_s of t.h^ c'o�.���<.il. I would J_ii_e to reqta�st , },ereUy, a' hearing on the above matter before thF� Cot�,lcil sif�ti.ng as a �commi'ttee° of `the whole . Tiiis � i�eque�t is b��i.ng made wi_th the -corisent-of Councilmen Patrick Rodl er , < F . .._.... .. ._. . ' CYiairn�an of the License Conunittee`:"� �'�^``' - i ' The presentati_on of .this proposed transfer requires more ti�>>e to � prepare than could be allo�•red before the license cornmittee . Also, the presentation must include legal opinions regarding the method of operation on the same piece of land with a self.-service qasoline stati.on to prove full compliance with statutes control_ling such use . � Mr. Stuart presently owns eleven service stations , seven of which � are in Minnesota and four in �^7isconsin. Al1 of these stations ' � are self-service operations . Experts will testify that it is :, >� impossible for anyone purchasing gasoline to also enter the liquor �� store unless and until he comoletes his gasoline purchase and moves .;� his car to an adjoining parking lot. Also , there is a separate ;,; building for the cashier for the gasoline operation; there is no �� connection between the two buildings which two separate businesses � are operated. � . . A plan for r�modeling the presently boarded-up Gulf stati.on on �� Grand and Smith Avenues will be presented . This plan has been drawn in keeping with the recomrnerdations of the City Attorney ' s • ' staff. This transfer u�ill bring, in my opinion, another. profitable tax paying business to the City of St. Paul . � I appreciate your cooperation in this matter. I 1_ook forward to `� helping present this case to you. -, Yours very truly , � ,�---`_.---__ � _ � � -� � �_ .����� � ,,,r �_�� �__ P.ichard -ht.- �r .arito"�'r President, PARRAIJTO BROS . I�IC . � �, y ,�,.,, . w y,.,.. .;, . : . ,..p .,." � , i: rt , . �Y�" . 't F' ', a':1 _ ;� .� �t� ' � 'f�;' r � � � �� �� � .,� ;, , . � � � _ . � � � �. .-�. n ' .� " , , ��^ • 1 > • 'i,. � �c � @, ; .- ,y * r'� �' �'��,r 'M. � + i ��.� '� � .� Y: ^S 'S � t r� � �r;_ �' 3 . : i �i'� 1 ,� � � t + ` ` ` ,( � �� � . , � , �:3 '� 'a -rN � � L: � „r a ��,. , . , 4; ,.'j. ' ✓ x,. ` ` � t'�1 „� �;jt e. . ` r ,.� r r � ��. , s � � � �+ �' i � . �� �'s.� . ,t �c ' x �� - € . A „ . ., ,; ., . ` ,� , . , , „ , ,. , .. . . ; .. ��� � �- - � , "+� I ,c 'a � ;� �`� �� � . ._ ,�ti � , ���1 . . ; �. : . - •�- , > • " , .. .. .. . � . „ . �., . . ..'.,.� /. .. :.�.- ...5 �.' . � .t ` .... :,�.. . �,. .r. .'x'.. ` . ,t y� - , . � L . � . �� .. :' � � . ' -...�� . � :.,.. . , '� -� . .. � . '. � .: - �-�.�.. :.. � �� tv.� :� ' ...... ..; �1•�::� ... .. .,.' . �. .: '..;, A . t ' 1� .. � � . � . �� ... ., ! �.. ':�' . . . . �' � � i ' , .. � .: � .� r '�� ti �.�� , � ... i . � � - . .. 't � ., . . .. � .. :-'S', :�'{ ' ' .. . , �� . � � � . �. .. � ��X �r , .. ' ' .i. .. ' . - � . . . - .. . :'� . '; . . .. :=.d{�;. .:1 � . . , . . �;�" \ � - €� - , • , .. � . �,�� ��1� . � . . ... .., _ - . . . . ....,, �. . , „, � , ..: i .� . . , , '.� . � y. � . ,tc, � t - . � �, . � " � t � � �.,� � ,� 1 j .. � ,+��� " .. . � ��k � �"� .t �'.�3y r ';A. \`, \ i .. .. . . ,, _ „ ,, , ' _ , , r � ,, �, • ,• k " a . >: � � _: r �t ! � . .. �. ' � � - , � '�;.!<�: f ;_� t � � ''�r 'n �..,, . .�' .�. . .; . �. . . , �< , . , � : - .. . , . . _ .. �: ."�� , . . ; .., . a� ��. . �w '_ . . , _ i .. . ... , . i 'Z �� �• �-�� � y�' d � '� ; � �. . : . .� '.� . . . .�.. ..: ' '�.. � i ,*� ; ' '�.�;:,��. /4 � �. � , . . , 1 � .. ...�� ��� � �� - ,� �/+r f� , ` �y •�'` + `' �.: 1 \ � '����.� i*��I������: � S��- � 9 "• � � � �t - ���.�� ���i� ♦ . . 1.. ..� 1 `�, ��c' X"P ' , . , } . w . . I• `�a� �� ^�� "��� •x' �.tl 6 ,�, 4 -w r'i''� 1� f`k + , '9 , � . � `l .�'. . .�: �t' ! �+E ' Y -� . � .•. � i � . ' �f,�� � ��* n ��J ; � t� ��Y' ��• � , r� ���: �A����•� �.tr�« k' r': .. � ... ' . " � ��� �� ��t�� � � �� / ti ,, :.���.��i��' � ; .��i��'� _a. :�. ,� � �+�'�I+a +�l�i;`�w,� - - ;R- �� :�`�""� ' , ' « � T �� � �.� � , .. �• � � � v ��� t�� .. 1 ,� , � �� ' �,��� �'qK" ;±��±����.`. t�: �'1a� ��e��aw� ` �� �. �' w�► � �'���� � '� �, h � �mc;�r1�: , *�. , � :3�il�+r �"���� �' n1�?�r�i� � ; '` t � _ , � • � � � � , '�� � � � �,�� � t � � �` ` � �; ,. : , , , �� � �� . , ,- _. : . � t - -:,:' �. . �., � _ . . .- . , ... ..� � ;'��,�� 1 . , � , � . � � � . - . - ti �. � . . . ,� . '�.. ... . ; '. �. .�-. . i��� - .-� � . ' .°.. ,., � . ,. , �.� '. .`.,. . , _ ``.� � , . ., � , 'i ' `\ � ., ... r ., , � � � . .�� , .. � ��a ` � . L`. y �. � . � . �., 1 , '1:^' ���` i. • . ,��� �V�.li '. . . '� r.. . .. .A_ ., � � . � ,) ' '.�. � . , �r . .. - • � , � . .. .. G M�`. - .�G' , ' . _ . .. - . �t . � . � . '. ' . .r. . ' e . � �_.. ' .. .. � ... . ..,. . _ .. .. . ' r 1' ^ .- . ^ . . ' .' :. .',:� 'J. _ .,i . . ,j. .` -�... � . �.� . . . �-� . ., .' . ., .�., �'. . . . . ,. . . . ... �.''.�. .:�' . L � '. .�.�- .F' �' .. ..... _.. �.,, � � ' �4 , .,� ., .. . . . . . i .- ', . � . .. � ��: ' . . . ' ,� � , '- - - � . . ': . t -.... � . .. " ....' . .. . , . . ^ . . 4. , � � . - . i . . � . L . �r. 1' ' l . S' . � 1.._ ! `vy . _ .. 4r ,1� 'F� , , , �4 . , . _ .�;, � ! c'y � _ ' . ..` . . � �. , _ . - � : �«r,� � . 4 ' � �y ,� .. . ' .. . . . . .}.; , ��A i '� i b .: �'�.p �. � � . ' �i���� ' � . , . .. � ��" ��i` �"�N � � . � •*�. . .�, �. . Y � f�F� . : �':' .� . . �� � . .,� � , .. e . . . . ; , _ .. . ,. . .� � � .. . . . . � . . �.. ..� .. . . . �.� . ..�. ., . i L. ,., .. . . . �. ..♦... ,.r.,'� . .. . . . ' ` ' �:'� .. ,:.� ..�. . ..«�. , x � . .. V � . .�t • R���'((''f`` � .� ... . . - .' . . •. / !•• A��e \.+Vl�� ( . . . . , . li.. . . ' ' ,. ' .. . .. , .. , ' . . _ , 1� . . � . a., r Y � . , . . C ITY OF SAI NT PAUL OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY Ma.y 8, 1975 PIERRE N. REGNIER RECEIVED MAY 1 �-1975 Councii President Ru�y Hunt Honorable Ruby Hunt City Council President Seventh Floor Court House Saint Paul, Minnesota Dear Mrs. Hunt: It is my understanding that you received a letter from Mr. Richard Parranto requesting an additional hear��:g an a proposed off-saale liquor license aR�licatio�. I did not receive a copy of that Zetter. In it Mr. Parranto indicated that the plan rejected by the License Cocrnnittee was drawn in accordance with the "recommendations" of the City Attorney' s staff. This language creates the impression of approval or participation in the preparation of their application, or that we recommended they do or not do certain things. That is a totally in- correct impression and we at no point urged or recommended the applicants do or not do anything. Perha.ps Mr. Parranto misunderstood my interpretation of the ordinance and various attorney general opinions as being a recommendation of some kind, but it is difficult to see how that could be. Ver truly yours, • . � PHILIP . BYRNE Deputy City Attorney PBB:jr cc: Councilman Roedler Councilman Sylvester Councilman Hozza City Hall, Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102 612 298-5121 C���-- , • r . � . CITY�OF ST. PAUL �ARTMENT Qf FINANCE AND MANAGEMENT SERVICES AS6ESSM�IT DiVIS10N 113 CIiY HALL ST.PAUi,MINNESOTA 551� June 10, 1975 File X1655, Page You are hereby notified that a public hearing will be held in Roonn 707 of the City Hall and Court Houae at 9:00 a.m. on July 10, 1975 on the application for trensfer of an Off-Sale Liquor License from Hawkeye Liquor, Inc. at 1065 Rudson ltoad to the Stuart Oil Company, Inc. at 225 Grand Avenue. For further info�mation, contact the Division of License & Permit Registration, 209 City Hall, or telephane 298-5056. To comply with the City Charter, the DepartmenC of Fiaance and Management Services is charged with informing you of this public " hearing. If you have any questions, it is recommended that you attend thfs public hearing to afford you the opportunity to make your views, both pro and con, known to the City Council, R�ER A. MATTS ON DIRECTOR � ��9J1��-- . � � • T. A 3 CITY Of S P UL DfPARTMENT Of FlNANCE AlVD MANAGEM�NT S�RYIC£5 �ss�ss+��+�o�vts�or++ i73 CITY HALi 57.PAU1,MINNESOTA 55102 Jun� 17, 1975 File RZ655, Pa�e . AME[+iDED NUTI!CE A public hearing scheduled for Jul}r 10, I.975 ia Room 707 at:. 9:00 a.m, is asnec�ded to read: A public hearing �+ill be h�ld in the Council Chambers at 10:00 A.M, on July 10, 1975 on tha application for transfer of an Off-Sale Liquor License fron► Hawkeye Liquor, Inc. at 1065 Hudson Road to the Stuart 0i1 Coa+pany, Inc at 225 Grand Avenue. For further informatioa, contact the Divisfon of Licer�sa � Permit Registration, 209 City Hail, or telephane 298-5056. To camply with the City Charter, the Department of Finance and M�anagement Services is charged with infarming yo�c of this public hsaring. If you have any queations, it is recommended that you attend this public hearing to afford you th� oppertunitq to make your views, both pro and con, known to the City Council. _ ROGEIt A. MATTSON DIRECTOI�