267584 WHITE - CITV CLERK 1 •gC��j�(J
PINK - FINANCE ' COUj1C11 ►MSV l� ��
CANARV - DEPARTME GITY OF S- INT PAUL
BLUE - MA�f;R � i File �O.
- C ci ` sol ion -
Presented By �
Referred To Co mit . Date
Out of Committee By Date
WHEREAS, Ransom & Sons Construction, Inc. , 1005 Dayton
Avenue, Saint Paul, by its President, Mr. Ransom Simmons,
has ma.de application P8925 for a Building Contractor' s License;
and
WHEREAS, the License Inspector recommended denial of said
application on the following grounds:
1. Failure to provide notice of right to rescind
as required by law.
2. Willful abandonment of contract.
3. Delay in completing agreed upon contracts
causing �ndue hardship and concern for the home
owner,�.
4. Failure to provide notice of right to lien
as required by law.
5. Failure to comply with specifications in
agreed contract by not having workmen' s compensa-
tion insurance; and
WHEREAS, the applicant, Ransom Simmons, was notified of these
grounds and the License Inspector' s recommendation by letters
dated Ma.y 25, 1976, and June 3, 1976, and was provided a hearing
before the License Committee on June 23, 1976 at 9:00 A.M. (which
hearing was continued to and concluded on July 7, 1976) ; and
COUNCILMEN Requested by Department of:
Yeas Nays'
Butler "
Hozza In Favor
Hunt
Levine . __ Against BY
Roedler
Sylvester
Tedesco
Form Approved by City ttorne
Adopted by Council: Date ` .
Certified Passed by Council Secretary By
By .
Approved by Mayor: Date Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
By BY
, � � �����L�
�. - �
.
WHEREAS, at such hearing the applicant was represented
by his attorney, �rving Shaw, and was afforded the right of
cross-examination of all witnesses, the right to present
testimony and witnesses in his own behalf, the right to argue
the evidence, at which hearing all testimony was under oath
and tak�n by a court reporter; and
WHEREAS, testimony was received from Mr. Joseph F.
Carchedi, License Inspector; Ms. Connie Green, State Gonsum�r
_ Affairs Office; Mrs. Ma.ry Page; Mr. Joseph Kranitz; Mr.
Kenneth Younkin; Mr. K�rrneth Gauthier and Mr. Curtis Ma.11er,
both of the S�.ir�t Paul Housing and Redevelopment Authority; Mr.
Ransom Simmans, the a�aplicanti Mrs. June Jackson; and D�rs. Eva
Ward; together with do��r��.s� 'p�.atographs `.�.d �o�l�er exhibits
ma.rked A through Q; and . � :: . �
WI�EREAS, the evi de�c e r�c e,�'v�ed� e s�ab l i shec3 �hat the ap �.i�
e<,
�.ant in o�erating as a :buildzn�: ���raG�or �.n� St.. Paul. tot 1y
���led ta cot�pl�r -with Minn. Stat. §� 325.933-.1�38 which req��.r�s
oral and writtert notice Q£ 't�}e buye���s�r�gl�t t�� c�c�1 home
solicitation_ sale� contracts (after Augu:st �, I973); afid that
the appl icst�t �b�ii�t�t�ed tl�.� c o�tract wi th Mr s. Ma�ry Fage ��thout
arr� 3��.s��fica�ticm, taking $�.,OOffY.04 frcm�t her a�:-d.��ng �.�s��i- F
stant3.aL work in return t2�erefor; and that the applicant, in
delaying completion of contracts with Mr. Joseph Kra�itz and
Mr. Kenneth Younkin, by failing to provide notice of rights
under the lien law (Minn. Stat. § 5�.4.011) to them, by accepting `
pa.yments and ncat paying suppliers ,�nd subcorttractors, and by
filing and discharging deb�s ,in bankruptcy .in 1976, ha.s wilI.fuly
left Mssrs. Kranitz and Younkin with poor and incomplete work
and large debts artd/or Iiens rema.ining to be satisfied; _ and
that the appiicant consistently failed to compl�te `H.it.A. home :�
repa3r contracts an time to the detriment of the homeowners, and
that said a.pplicant would not be perc�tiitted to bid on' such H.R.A.
rehabilitation contracts in the future; and �he evidence est�blished
that although applicant Ranscjm S��ns is seeking to. do bv.siness
through a corporate entity, and -has done business in the past
through a now-bankrupt, corporation and a sole proprieborship, the
applicant in each case and every contract is and was the sole �
responsib�.e party; and that the applicant ia his own testimony
refused to answer questions relative to his. financial condition , '
a�:ked by counsel for the License Committee, and was unresponsive
and vagv.e in answers to questioning; and
�
��<�:;
WHI7E - CITV CLERK COIllIC11 •`"�'�����
PINK - FINANCE GITY OF SAINT PAITL
CANARV - DEPARTMENT .
BLUE - Ml�y(}R , . _ File NO.
' Council Resol�tion
Presented By
Referred To Committee: Date
Out of Committee By Date
WHEREAS, the License Committee voted unanimously to deny
said application, based on the demeanor and appearance of the
witnesses, the evidence and testimony received, and on the
documentary exhibits, finding that the evidence established
all five grounds urged for denial, but particularly those
numbered one through three; and
WHEREAS, a copy of this Resolution has been mailed to Mr. T -
Irving Shaw and Mr. Ransom Simmons prior to consideration by
the Council; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, that the application of Ransom and Sons
Construction, Inc. by its President Ransom Simmons, for a
building contractor' s license be and hereby is denied.
COUNC[LMEN Requested by Department of:
Yeas Nays �
Butler � in Favor
Hozza
Hunt
Levine � _ Against BY
--�Reed�e+►- .
Sylvester
�°�- JUL �t 1976
� Form Approved by City Attotney
Adopted by Council• Date
CertiEied .se by nc Secretar�r BY
Appro y Mayor. te Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
By BY
Puei�s!��� JU� 3 � 197
:�. '
CITY OF SAINT PAUL �������
�(� � OF�+ZCE OF THE CITY COIINCIL
: ��
�� 431� f �l' � � . � � .
i3� Fie
' t�:.,�� tF_�� �E . . .
�..
`��;:., _ D a t e : July 8, 1976
COMMITTEE REPORT
TO : Saint Paul City Council
FROM � Committee on L��ense
Victor J. Tedesco , chairman, makes the fol lowing .
report on C. F. [� Ordinance
[x] Resolution
C] Other
T �T L E : Public hearing on the application for a Building Contractors
license by Ransom and Sons Construction, Inc. at 1005 Dayton
Avenue.
The License Committee's recommendation to the Council on the above application
is for denial of the license after due consideration of the testimony and facts
presented at the public hearing.
CITY HA.LL SEVENTH FLOOR SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA 55102
.�.�z,
. �•�,�r.�..-�a �J � . .
ea iq�r 1 y� 3 S. �¢� 7iT Ft'�t S v � f !Y ; i t ,i` R x�i �1; AwwP },1:� n "4 x��...i c.� .��
�F;��,"}�� f t �` ,� 5%� ''i. �':
'� ,F� �,�.`�F,f f S° n fa�.., 'S �, .��a� 7 �x_.� M� �; �; i�g �� t .,.� rn���. y' ��"�� C" a�3���,�'`'�°��.. :: +k. �?Jk°F s�r., �`, �. ,� �it'.
��Y�y,��.�,yp� �4���f��t „;p ��t�,�gv� ys� �,.�� �fY{,.,..,�° '��,3,z ���.�^,�'��s�''�Y�r.: F��',� r. ��w�e� c.�b�! 4 �'ri��6,� m,�iiT� k+ k ��' (+'Y �;
K�j.�"4,"�t^��t��� ��y rq•�J d�.�'F e,,t�1y S�:;�` R "��'{ K r,'"sS;�. +��£��"..."`i� ���:�,��c j''':¢r.s�� s�ti.'��J��,��:,,P" � ^���� �� o V�7
q� .b+ ��,� �� �+�� ' f : � :� .``� �d;1,� '�� �9«,,,��, )L, 'b/ � .�,`S � �
� .5'�'1'r`{' 4 4 t :Y �.'c�, l �,�1 t `� t � ry�A� C i I� �
% �g� �- � .Y w�..x .�'1:.1`��` � � .�!� 4'�#��:l� 1 r,� !^ .7,�{l�:;�Tx�V ��r' t�a�'�`�.���¢ ��s �C 'y ,.,,�5. � •��,'�`} {� ��.1�� � nt� �,�4 t t
�� #�a�, ?� �#+-+j�� � , 9 i.: p ���..'. i .t '���;. '�:'�S�' �.i rt y� k f� 7�f�...� e� � '��.,A�1 z��x � 7�'°GQ-.; 3F'..
�y a aH t t :.y5 J A._ V �S�r i-{'t f Ca°Y,�IF I? `v :FMii Y �S. A `2, t.,.�1 '��.'"N"P� N e�§,'TI . Y�..
'�,. Y t t �k� f: tP+ ti+ ,�' YJ 7 �^ a.F'k„p'dyt�^ �R aw.r ,�,y r g� r� i � r�s t,i 'Y � af t 4" .f
r��i �,� � I ,.rj F""{� �qrF Ai�� �h'!t'�}1��, �.'; �{�'^ '��`.l k-�iY` � �'. �.}�� � �4��N.�0.��� �.�'2'�����5 �S �C.
XJ R ..� �._u t a 4 `�'�i 5�7 ? �. a � g Slr�'t��n t„�,� �,3�r � � '�sn-,
�` ,.�� �^ J� `��� {��:� �,! t �.�.'�F rf ; �Y t =, r�r.��t �,'r�r.°r. ) t / ��i .a�, � {�7 +�,� �r�`Y• ,Ws. CI.�., i�d�.���µ,r g�'R^ a
�U.4���t= �� � �,;'� fi,,�t � ;Y,�i�l� � ��. n...� s s,,� �,., rp ,. �ry�.;14f ,�yi 1^f�.q�?,�� k�i;Y� ,�;:.,t,, �r�•�.jJV tS,,sF���G°i:� !��
�n�i ! ;.� ti 9 .�.� y x �.�i ���".f:,�: i n f 4e, �l H,�}���:.." � :;��n d ��.�� � 7 . N4 @�` ¢ C t:t,."Ci+.a �i.ft�r d �w. a1 ..�±t�A : ;.t.�,.'�; �� x � ���� �i
�': x � r Fx A + € � � s E * + t� x y �, f ��i j, r 1;. w � � �t u . � .3�
�" ''��� (� A' . •�Ra ��t yr�� .:,�y�� q .�� .� ��_ � ,_ � �,;.,. '; � * �� k{� � � ,�4 i�,p} r �,��11�, ,. ,�,. ..
J 1S. JI t �}"� N - r,.�1 � - '�". 3 �,'�t ��T� -� �Y�h t i . � r U' � x 4
y��.., , ���� Y r ft `�Y x� '��^ i f�La q„'..',t H 3 i p.. W� � �,r a�i�'. �" � r�v,�`}.r�` 4 5 � �, a��; '� .
?y �t � �' y e::�t ri r�Y;�-'�k ��` �:�tn .�, �,{ ! .� �� t �xiH�` a� k k� Y'� a r:���� ':
` p ���' � r � 7 rt�,,�'�` q,v �t�.A e�" .,.e� �3 ,�y
�Rl h�f.�w�'4 � pL"�x��j} J �4�� G .�z f �?.Y �y �}.,��( % � �4 }4�a� �y.r:f.� � �4 M�9 ..7 K!�.`• k,�' �n 7v �,rr i li.�.�� 4 "(r���°F°., ��.
'� + .. 'inp:-� � t� y �'� '��'�` y tii,� ,y ��' '� t� 3�. r 7.s r # . �Aa"�« � �:�, i ,�:, ��' � ' Fr ' i�,�%� � M...z� S � ,�: :�:-��, +."t..
tii«. �r u.. f x".� ,t.,? �y � ;g.,�,' y. .. � . '� 4 ��r `I a �'�< � R ��?� � Y ,"� � 7 �
rs�yx �+i� 3 s ..� + q R (�a 6�..� �g � �I t� ..e a i;'.�� r'�� v�' .:r q.t � f ,y�.- �` r :d� i �"��� a F'=f� � }+'u� �
� "rt��'., �"�:'ht {:�i ��'� ,j�a�# ��t v e y�p;f ?���k r�;,,wa�'r /r:' r '� �� � :. b �+yii�, t Y '��ya'� �` ;r ,�I,r 1 +�r�'y���'' 4� e{..-`�jt� ,�t�i x'�
�Nti r �:+ae F.. v k, a h i r Y �' f i r..� �" vr� , d �� � �c' { i:, �� � r�Y"1 ,.� '�3 � i �• r i ,j}�'., P .�.
k� �'.�t' �q T� r � , ' �,� t lc.�l` �'t i '�.�� ,� � 4 � ;,:� ,� , ".. I a� '�„:� y� r� '� ' �; , 4.'s �tv���f
� � :i� �x�y�.�� + '�c' �,, n'a 4� �µ�'� i �{ k':�4��}a .a� � .:,� k� pr� .: �f '`�. �< < � t,' p j ;� � �t� �'� x�� �$''3j A'�3 r �'`.
t
� z. : t� ,7��' �� �' �.'�! � 4 : � , '�" f � 1 ?,� { A o � r � ;F� r> �� � �°t'�. v�„�
�� �e 8+. s' � :; 5 � �, � f e /�-cr ,� /1 f". t r� �.` � } x� Sj � 1;� '�Y a . t 1 � i � t�,.. cx x � � 7 k ��r'F
'�' a �'; ; �:� �' i x � F k�,a ���y��" �:;'i � r ak.. 1�. a A1���'1d'` �� � Y r� i .' Y� �{6 ,��"'��p` {, 1, f ��1c�4"'S{uu`�F
�� o ���.. � , t ,� 4�aj h V 'sr n � t t Y ,
yyk�� 5 f�;�, r!, r�.�y} � ta.,�r'�� } �, 11 �tn :�: q -�+�� ' � .. � i '�yrs x , �9 �1 ` .� � � � ��� F t t' F .... r) � .,-�t` ,"�'Sr...;,
t r t i a � �� P�h 1!� �, �
�t k�A� � '�� 1,, � rk$L'^'� � � ��4 t'�W ��` e � � t Yy.t � 't �� ar y '�� ��r�I� �' F Y� <� y � �:�,t3�� 7�e.a
i�� t I'! N :1 � i ,( l�� .i � . � � t �:. R .�
p� � �! '' ih ' '��,y i►+r♦ , ��#�. r k i ;� $ �-, t �'' �3 � r ia *3 '; �r��a^, �h�' .f �+�\ ak�� r .
�, -�+ ��r>}; f �{ �'�t � �-:� � a e � �`'.� '' � � i .. t r,, ,� w �' ,`
se"�'9` � f t �( �� � fid r � t ..� { 1�,, k �- ;: � i � � �,t � u � ..
�r�s� - r :-te �;"ti 'v'� r�.� fi�, atlr t � �. � i t �. � ��yi a �I' 'p „r��bi :. ; ,� �' ] � .�
��� } ) - T} i ;A�G '� � ��.�$ V �!t f i���,{ rr cS `}��,, f .� �y e� �, r 1 g . I �,.,.�'� i v��,�•r x Y F������t r�a
w�t{�g '� 5 � 9l � 1Fi` �', '�'�. ';� J� 4 �' ? • f�+ f Yf,° k.,F� *; n �.� I ,;i v �'� �.
r y,vyCr�ck 1��4 x F . �'�� R v � � ,�t i� �. �� ��wr i� i .,ikt �i li E}f° � � ��\ S ����a r� r��e�J�
e4t # � . ' 7 i �+I �,i�� r , . �4 t� e .S � di' 3 1 ..} �� t
� � N-� r !\ t r �RA:.�3,��7 1� ,;'� �n .�.��� {�- � � � .�r y���.Y �r!,}� S{ ;�.�.�M �f��r �..'��^q �F',1 '� A � ,w 3 ;�r �,�t����1�d �'
x� i y�'l� � r .. - � { ,i' d i hz � i; �g �a i a ; t �kr r �' w����t`�.�,��9 ,
[ � ^t i �� i,� � ' �"4{{ ._ �'� !� f'b � � .s �9 y�� f�
� � �F .� �� � :,� � t! '.r F !� �.! x i� : y 'i -� 1� e��-�..3 F -�.d � q� y i.�� �. �� ' t•��� Y�L�It ��ti �
��.�r r �:. �- � . t',,��, �. � �� �.r 7a � I.? { ti�'. Y '..C � 4 k.. }.h t i'..� �{a . a4 � �� �
t'� ,.. �y f S - � . , y � ��� � i y ��'' � °'' �-r u� �
�je. Y ,jr�c 1 Y A / ; � h�C ��. � ` +� � s J �' y} '�' h � i � d� . k ��'.:�k 3 "*'��f'+T•,`
��R.�. 4 t„�t 1'� � ; _ c. � r ��� °'�^�� {�d _a �t.t � �• J 4 -:ti '. � 9,�' u �� �
�g�x t .? �� . � � " p � a � i f, Mi ''i rh� if:� ,����i�'.,�w {� ''j�f �,� 4 ,.� �J ., v�n `.. ^�i�1.a .�t� �1 �
F e ' ,� "���y�': � �..'� �`� ��.;� '�� r F i i : � ,t�: �� /r�t � ti
r �Jt �_'` t�, , a �. � � °} �r y +. � '� ` 1 i� t y .;� 1 r. � {F at����$�`
r t . �:}f ri d 1,� � :' x t { ���, ' � �r t t�k '�� f S�'.yr
����� � !� � ,� � #� r � t �" i ' F,� .;r ��, r i�.� � t,� � . � r� ;�{ s��� y ; e #�,� ,�tr u�, s ,f
t? � n S 'l 1 A� r� ! ^� � 'i � �� �.��`r .,+�- Y�"��k �� w�i�'� a: � .i + ��-. p���?�. � K
oi�x � � �i 1 � F n Ir ; _ r �y� i t� '� 1 ' ii+P� k ��� n tfi x ��
`� � s 4�� ! ��� f�, ,� f � �r � �,+ r ,�m r � � � t r t ' .. "r t� �i S+. �� �
p �1�'�yyY � } a P >' a ,� d� ti t y� f�� � r4 � 1 � �-'e 7 �4.�'� �.� � . Y '� + '�. �.rr`^M{�'�t���� �
F�3� a .� ,�a ':r �. 'h� '��x i! � ., {,�+'.i �.., � 't t rk� .,�a b�dir a , x v�� �. ..i'.� i .e �„'�€
��6' :t :i. � � � �r j � ':i ' � x�R 1 ' � ,:ir t� ��� ',k �,���m� iri`� � .R�S� N � `+y '��,�"�a(�r�� � t" .
q '� �'.1t "k 4y �ti� t o � ��•: �s I�� �:T � � "�A T �l�� � �; � '�� 4 ik �� ry � ,� .?q b �q� y7 s�� ��s"�.,. ;�".
++� t � � % s �F7� ,�M � �.�.�vt.3 Y f�l� �
P�I
��r '�pyA�0.�`� � ' C� �'�� � � � x� +� ` r'��t� �" �r =� � ��°� r'l i I F � �, ��i ��F y� �. � � �a�it. �� ��k � �f 4�.� �`* 1��r�
, �� �� d�, _'. � � ,J�'! ��3�'�� 1�r{ rh.��'�4 �tr`F� � �, � ���� � ��i�l' �j ir��'.,� �i;� .� .r i�{-���, r � � �h'Z��`�� �'
�. .. }�.. %r. ���'� � �, a r r t �^ � a.
u���� P 11�.� y4 4, ���� �a - � I'�� , a {:.: �'�R �h; '� �� �t .�a 7'� �. ° � �':� �
� 3 J.� k ¢ � �,��r �ku��q� �etr� �{ � �f ' � j;� . . :.; ( at +r�,ri t i �� a ��'.` Y � .� s� . i .�,� .��"�C
�, , t...; � :�5� "��, ��y� � �� . .yr< r � � ��'� � �� �� �;A ��. �� �
�' �r� d i��� n 1 14 1 - i c P r u�"� � �. a G � t �F,i # I . t . � , � r 1 �`
s �k 3-� � : P '�Ai'� �T�h .' P' i.. �' ,� M1. { � °�.��r FS f�r� �i,' i1 t �i �y �'� ��5•
s f r �� i � t y ,a � y � �'� 'i .th +! �':''C 4 Y ti�§1' + t;,) 1 '� -: ,r qz� �f e k 'l�
w s 'S r� .n �A` � ! � I�:Ii�4 e., + r�., �����4,�, t� � . ���� ��t v - 1 h i��t�'� �"
� r��''P,��' � , ✓� T >T r 11 � ��`r` � F'?�� eW ,�; ; yy G � s��r � a {'j{ a � � :i'�� ''' '�TM �.}� x�s� r, .
� i. 4} -� '� h�• �. � n� � t�' i 'i' E ' �� d� �'� � ��.;� r �� S;�lS > 6 t! .:.x
�°�,� Y.�`�xrd1, aA��. }k .`.s �{ s ;..V' � °�+Y J� '�':�a r�p 1,y.:°n ,?a � j.�'r r� q, + t �'��
�Y_�$�: F �� .�w �41�,< ,�G�. �n�I .' } 'i': yd 5�¢=��e�X'����° �� �i �rt��l: A �.xi"(� ;��4 t � b>b�. � : � La��a y���,�i'�;r?.
Y . � # � ��.. ��a7 �4 � � r a M' -a H�{ (' � ��"C(..� y f,, � y'' y. , M��•p# y ,t g � � �. �
� i � xF
F � ���`��t v, •; �tb �y�. F � ` ' :ft� W�:�tr� 5 '� 4 � �;-f � � i a � ,�� �r`� � � '� a k �
� � ; '"�� �7�� ��4 t� Y;*{�� .{� �� �� I �, �AZ�+ � ���� �'r� � �,�y i 'd r�.'` i _ i ,� i��� �. �,�t � �i � M.'��
��G � ! � ,��.., � u s ,,�', �p t6 � � �� .,;� � �y, a � . K 7 F: $ �;� � t �=� , �`t�s 4� t� �,���,t� k�?"�`
� r ��� r � � � t � a ,, � �� ti � ^ sr; v �' ?� �'k
1 ,� � ��1 S 5�: .�� s � l �� �$f � 1 ";�� � �' ' H� � ,� {`� � � �&p
k���rk�+, � ��i� ���� � � � �`� s� �� (� 1: + � �� '� ��� '���' � �y�t 1 r`' �t� ��''�`�,� � �� �p ��+� � is�.- ,�,°-��i� ��{r.3 � .
3l .�.�. g ,, �k t a i � s.r,f : .4 �x. i y .. Y� }4 k a i a ��, `
�. 1 ���y�� �q������'tFJ �� ����i xs �S � y ��;�t C �' �xr� �4 �� ��?� ��� � �"'�l:i �� j..� �i 'A 3� ''��; �''�''����r �����+�,�.iA`��
+ �,_
t..n. y� t � ir' 3�.`-�`� , + 7+ % � �� �� $ ��` N�z � �!t �, f� �it � � /� { �,�� r d , . ,, �' �.,� ti+ 4��r�r��� .
� � ' � .��' ( ' u r �. fi,r 1 �d ,_ .� i � r i v,h �4..�, �t� i �'t� `K c .
� s k9.�t` �Y � i i ���� s�; S� -ya �,��e � °`'��.i 8� t� i � � �s �V t � � ���!'�.�rfn 4 jt-
.,$ d �. ' � �..�y, r r 3�rv, r�. .. ,._� e `tr( j.,.�. 1 . �e. � a�. �= � '.!� �� i r -- ��i� ��� r��5 �� ,�y����� ..
�� y�t� i ;"t '6 � � �U.i � _ ��,t .. s T t k �. g; - ! FTf �:�
� $, ��" "� ;x F ,� tr� �,.�. f� a, � � � :.�'�� �` � �t � tr.� �� � a � �x�.,:A�7jS��'r'�..� �"'� 1�,�y,;T.
�t�r'8i'y,Y�•'� �y '�'' - ���'�..,p,�,w c.��������it �'t 'a�� #y�� z Y'. + q,� '�"`�ui:�� �'a�'�� �d�������r F� at��;�� �� �.;1! �' �"..�<1 r`.yt a'�t°� ' ��;�`
� r� � .° ,� F3! rt � �I 1�s' a ,� � v�' 1 `r 7 1 .i � � � , k ana'i' �
�"� �`,; � r"! 5� � t; �.�q r ? �t y,�;t �, a ,���;; x y} ��'„�x � r . i�?�' +r d �,���� ,t r r � � .,
A . i ., i �' r'I � s '�y#J� (r;����4. �4�;..i�u f �1� y �' `'��' - I { � '4'$!�ki ���
�ik�t��.� � A� � �k�� � � 4 " ! t j t'� � �.., ..,.5 P �? `.�p! 3.�•` .� anat7';, r�.'���fiT �i r�Y�°�y�i i ,•p�2� �d/..r. �1��1�'�. � fkr a .
re�� � 3 ? �+� � .. �� �� k' � .. ,�t'd L��, r t'r ;� � �'aC�� °.i
q },? 1� ��� t n "��.: ' i�.. � ;. j��� � � �� .�. �i `jyy�, �;„. • R �, � r '.. �;� �},1``, �' � .
.. . �� � y ,�.- _ . � � � �'� A" 1���1�
�^t��if ,��.;:F. � �r�.:.�yh�� `,�,. .� � . � -,. ... � ��r.� �� � °4 �� • ��. ° � �:, � .��4 ...��. � �b�, �' -Y[w ...�.. �,- t .�f ��� ��r' � .
I�r� � � y� il } � r ����y�p f�
���4 ''�ya��� t x .:�".{� *,�.�5 �y�,r .�•��� � {.�fir� . �+�l . 1 � �� �v � `'.��hw't�� j€ rA',�{j����'��,�'"S''�'"�'�
tc b k � ; � +f '� ���� '� Fz � t'�!!n�, �;�4 a � �s M
c ,, *„- y� ,, ,� . R�'� �
,��y�4� " � „ � �¢ -f, .r�a�i+w `'d�,�� �a}� , `-� �,� 3 ,� �� i,; �5,�a ' � )��;���� �3F�� `�""�
E '� } '� � N S 4t� 'Y('} �j } ��'�•: "RF .h �3..( 2
� � j�,�,u t r� � c�!'�; < a�' �� r �' , 6.qry y�l � �y; � t 'i ,.�' `� + r� t P`+y r��a9,: � { y w �; .�..
d t} r � war��t ,c e, 74 0 ,`,. J�1t ( ] t�;4t� ���'�x� a i'.�'Y �� �r;�.a� �i�•�d,y a {� 'E�'�, �!r t J "�'j s�r .r t�`���� 4�. ,
f I 'f� j`�":_ p :'t \a + f i•, � si ,�a� ' � ^� ' , fi �
±
i �,y � y�n1 �. � �,� S � 4,� �..,€" _ � i �,�TS� r �,:�.� . t �'�"�+,�r�Xp� ta�
� t t
�` 'Y t.e' �bY• . zf�t �..,firl i " r �� X ,�� I+IP����f y � � y'r�' < f �F� uki# Fi�
,� �'h t g� � a t �}'�� .�r r - n ..� t :fi ,� . r C s�� y, .� � },➢y,r+� b,.y a } . e ,,�
)t rt ?�'i, t f f�V. r���S ; � t s : N , , i'�; �ti �i „�� ;(: ,�a '� ! , f -'� ! �� t r j, `y �wf v'X ?Y�+�i 2�.Y�, fi.
1! � W ' � f�. "t 4� �' F.i X ; �� J� 'r h ��d h r+, i .' .:4` f .`*' y�t 1�� � �,r� =�Y�y
C �.� �s'� ( i ,�.� r� ��� � � }�:.4 ��F � ,� �{Y A i S y �n.-a b,�� { +�2� ,�}�.-! r. P +,;, L "j� i ��9 1d;,+. i i Y��;� �'i r �^+ � rR }r��A ,
i�° i }: ,� tik^4�iy+�,f . y t_� P �„ � ��,t �r c�' �' � ��f !9 M"e...�r ' .;f t m'�^�y,�-i � �{�a � '_x i s �� �'�,$!� �y�'` ..��G,.
� � s $ ,x ilr.a'A �� t � i � �; 1��� � � 1�w�'y, ts >A� 2 �� < iw ~'es� 'H�y��i'i1 r t �„ q 'J' �-�� r`�� �j, :�
�` � .� �+ �; p , � R� ., FA '1 x k � �� � . �� fi r F� � k�.� T� bk" t i : �,.'�, t � .� +� � ('
a lf�.� � b� �9 ,� � >y��r` ���� �f1�:Ej � �����.� �z� �_y'�+f' �1y�{s� �. .� �i �-4� � �� .-, �p�f S `��.'��x�` v �.z ���t��ys��'.
�y ¢� ,���,�� Y�!' f .art�'b`�"' � � { �t D ¢ �'� }t > ��Tyi 'k'�Y'7�.�!���� i ' �(� t 1��. l 1 .�+'1�1, ^,'.Ut �if
k f ;.� y,* �'c� � � '�ti ZF V �� � �'.1 ";��r e i7 * �.�''�r ,�"^ N��� ,: � �(r��.:'�t�J+ ��'s * '` q�.�.; < <y L�q� �kk`3� .:.5 S�i �k'��a� 4
r �•u*�ti �;::� �.�(7�`�'`" � �' a..�,;i � � � 4 { .' lt'��i 1�� �A+ }n Y��,�^.�� �X ��; y � �. 1 � `h.. i1. !d� ' f}2 ti9,�'� � x',� � � r��;��� �.. �a
} � � ! ���i < . x 1� 4 L 'f �. � •.`+ � } _ . ^ �-�..
� �� ' � � � � � s�£ ���. �� � �'� vM'�'� i � f�� t �M.� � P.. �3 �hpA��; ���'�n
� / '" ;` .,� :.� � , ,f - i �.t � . � � �;1 � F M:. 1 .. "` � !`i �r : � . � '� +,� �� �. _
� � � + 1'i X� i d,: ,� ,� �' a: <` � W�,� �}� k .,'r�fR t tl!��,+,`Y�. Ytk YF�� fd�' F
�ii�`P� , /�� �� ?�` I � 4 �,q i�J S �l � P � '. !'a(� {�,,p� �.i �F � �.
a x ;i4 t �mn,� C r� ; . � * � y' i 1 /� e f �1 �� - 4 i..� n ���F�'"d �...u�y .
i �,(��� i� � d � .�� j � 1 '�� � 1 I � f .� u �� � � a' �kt�"�+� e� � � h{'R�'a :� F �`,A•.�
y,� ��r 1 � �.,� ( M � �"�.,�� G '�� � � ! +�T !i �# r' �� .. y;.. F 1 4 � k� ' .
r� ! , � ;,-lx ! ; ,�'? i t: .; � �-d I a ; 1 �� � ,�„ ,� Y � � 1� �,r ti�'� 'r�.
X ^� t ,'F y � .i' �4 �9`1 . �F r r �'ti�r� A:� j� , } r� rl f�`' �1'� y ai i��i; tK �.:} ��a 1� trt�yi.... �
;�,�� �, � ���� � ��t,t���. , � ;a �r .�r� ,} v.�' r �,` r' �� r � � ',�������� �,,
�r � k� ,� * � �g �� + , , ��, �. �� R � '� t� ` � �� '� � `�i �r;:� "�. �y a ��a�� wt ;�i+�
.�it f4 -� � �, n `t_1 i 'C�n �. ' ,� � � , r� �"' � r '� i G. r� . r �` �` ��-��+,r f'� ��
4
�(�%`E g,�i� .. � y � ��• r'�� � �/�1� � � a �f , ' v � � � �i t $. .��d i '�(�. ) � ,t � � t,� ]x���> °,li�' :
�ro}�P'i' 4 n_�: } � ��j 41 �' ��� � N � �t; 'r[!� t.''. "� �:f ,,� � ! '6 � ./4 �' kF' ++R ��y"��(�2.� ta'�^ .
�a�, �1 +� 4 1 ! M � w A � � . -; , t � �� . � P . *� � i� - 5 iw � `aa�
�� � s', a .Y� 1 f , . � � ,,,� / � r,.� �� L" R t.
i A ,��, � � � t , �� � �yb y�', Y 1 t � , � i �E;. t r �.r H� � i� k t,�i�! ? t � �� ,�Y��' 9�2i'�1�����.
k v� ��� a � { � � � ��: ��'� ." r���� i � V ..:� t, � �� ��� °�� , .: � ��� 1���9 � } F�a �('�{ � ����}�i x
y� � � " � ��
�y t '�S .�or ,�� �r [� �i � ��i; - �e� ♦ � .� �, i�;� � k j -' ��. ^� -� n '� ,� d��f� �:
�j! f . Y=R ! 1 ' .� �1 � � 1 y 9 J
� P M1 �.: .: . � \ � i, � 1 y F�' f 3 1 � ;.. �y� N .��
1a� 1. _ � � V�„4 �.X l . � -fi � y
� k Y"�k X,Y c �� ���
� . 3 � < � . r .t 1 � �P -r r l.� ' t r 'CF d t � '
� f� � � } p ,�� `/ � � .. , � �: y - � � � YY'.'� ,{Y i :
� � � r:� c-' . l � �i i4
"xf�� � � ` �i ��� � i i� ��` �, � i��. �."� ,�.� � '� �_ �:; � s� , �,t `x�v� �b
< � � � � ��. �
�� � ����5 +.�Q� � �. � ��r -��1� ra�r r� � /:° t/s r.� r � i��; f � �� � y � s�a �s.j,� �. a'��
11 �g�� )' � �w i �� N�� `f � 1.j �'� q � fl � ,� f � � � 4�� t �. �t r` t s � E a �"�`y�'�+C+L��
� ( f"�� $ . � l . 1 ,. 't°.; w'. ' � 1�P � ` " t 1 ! �, i d� : �¢ <�"7+ �e! �..a 'S;�f. .
a -� U '� , y�'� a°R�H r x� µ � Y D 1 � i� 1 ' hc y q ..,,a y,� ,� � �r y�, �3� �,;;,,
._. .�$ ,.._. £� . . , dt .. . .! � ,u'3.4 _�..:a-�,.,, ..+r.., ...�.r.� . . .r...� A'.,�_. , �..m_. . r�E..u. � ... a .�_ . ., , ..�c , e . . RiS�. _ !�o,��:.af i�F