Loading...
269751 WHITE - CITV CLERK . t � PINK - FINANCE COUI1C11 BLUERY- MAVORTMENT GITY AINT PAUL � � � . ,..,����,�.,� File N 0. ZY�GT IZCP. Ordinance N O. f V��� Presented Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date An ordinance amending Ordinance No. 15881, ap- proved August 29, 1975, entitled "An ordinance adopting a new zoning ordinance for the City of Saint Paul, repealing Chapters 60, 61, 62, 63 and 64 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code and the zoning map of the City of Saint Paul. ° THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN: " Section l. That the Zoning Map of the City of Saint Paul, Sheet No. 17, as incorporated by reference in Section 60.401 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code, is hereby amended as follows: The property owned by George J. and Faye E. Kraemer on the North side of Grand Avenue between Cleveland Avenue and Finn Street, more particularly described as, "Lot 23, Block l, Groveland Addition, " is rezoned from RM-2 to OS-1. Section 2. This ordinance shall take force and effect in thirty (30) days from and after its passage, approval and publication. COU[VCILMEN Requested by Department of: Yeas Nays Butler Hozza In Favor — Hunt � 4 Against BY Roedler Sylvester Tedesco Form Approved by City Attorney Adopted by Council: Date �Gp 2�g � Certified a d by C uncil creta BY � By � ����,�CT 3� 197 Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council Approved or: Date � ,,, gy Y�I�Gk-r--� By pUBLISHED 0 . � .� � ���'��1_ � BO�RD OF ZONING CITY OF SAINT PAUL OFFICE OF THE MAYOR � CITY PLANNING DONALD L. SPAID AIP PLANNING COORDINATOR August 23, 1977 ����� Rose Mix, City Clerk 386 City Hall St. Paul , Minn. 55102 Dear Madam: This is written in response to the petition of George Kraemer, Jr. (Steve and Nancy Hendrickson) to rezone property on the north side of Grand Avenue between Cleveland and Finn from RM-2, a multi family residential district, to OS-1 , an office service district. 7he property is described as Lot 23, Block 1 , Groveland Addition. This matter was heard by the Current Planning and Zoning Committee on July 21 , 1977 at which time Staff recommended approval of the petition. A motion to recommend approval was made by Mr. Hummer and seconded by Mr. Willits. The motion passed on a 7 to 0 roll call vote. On July 22, 1977 the Planning Commission recommended that this request to rezone to OS-1 be approa�ed. The motion was made by Mr. Bryan and seconded by Mrs. McGinley. It carried on a roll call vote of 17 to 0. This matter is scheduled to be heard before the St. Paul City Council on August 25, 1977. Sincerely, � �,�',� ��(.(��' ��. `J��C.-�,-�Lt��.C� Wendy A. F arnside City Planner �J Zoning File No. 8180 WAF/gf Enc. 421 Wabasha Street, Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102 (612)-298-4151 0 , � � . � . �■ ' • , ������������� � O■■�■.■■■■■���� � � � o��e��������r��■ . � e� e��o��������■ ■■ � � e■ e��o����r����■ ■ . . e��o��o����������■ � ■����������������■ � e��o��e��r�������■ e��e��e����������■ „ e��e��e����������� o��e��e����������� , , � ���es�e����������s � � � ���o�������������� � � � e��o��es����������■ � � � e��e��e����������� . . ��i���������i����! � � � e����oo����������■ � �����������������■ � � o��o��o����������■ � � �����������������■ e��o��e����������■ . o��o��o����������■ � � maomovmoc���������■ , • - ,- �,,.. , , , � . _ �_ ,..�_ , .� . , • .!"_ „'i.- � , .. /. � ,, ; , . � ,' � r LI,� �%� .L..r 1�._�./ � 'i ,✓. .�.,i�J1��.�: _�!`' w � • � � • , � _ , , � . • ' MINUTES OF THE MEETING OF THE CURRENT PLANNING & ZONING COMMITTEE -�.�..,� JULY 21 , 1977 IN COUNCIL CHAMBERS, ST. PqUL, MINN. PRESENT: Mnes. Grittner and McGinley, Messrs. Sherwood, Willits, Humner, Pangal an ryan of the Current Planning & Zoning Comnittee; Mr.` Richard Amey of the Division of Housing and Building Code Enforcement; Mr. Roger Ryan and Mnes. Fearnside and Fox of the Planning Staff. GEORGE KRAEMER Steve & Nancy Hendrickson) - (#8180 A petition to rezone from RM-2 to OS-1 property ocated on the nort�i�e of�rand between Cleveland & Finn. The appellant was present. There was no opposition. Mr. Ryan showed slides of the subject site and read the staff report. Mr. Hummer questioned the procedure which had been used in petitioning fpr the rezoning. Mr. Pangal agreed that there was a question about using the_ short form for this particular rezoning request . Mr. Ryan` said that in his opinlon the short form was appropriate, and Mr. Willits expressed his agreement with the Staff's opinion. Mr, Amey read from a portion of state law whe�^e th�. words "substantially equivalent"� were used, and said it was his opinion that office use is substantially equivalent because the use was permitted under the old zoning district in this particular case. Mr. Bryan then agreed to hear testimony in the case. Mr. Steve Hendrickson, the appellant, said he had checked on whether to use the short or long form petition, and that his wife had been told to use the short form. He said there is little traffic involved, and only his auto is involved in parking, although there is also some parking space in back of the site. He said he is the sole owner of the business, and has no employees. He added that he would do nothing to destroy Grand Avenue and that he wants to be in Saint Paul . Mr. Hummer then made a motion to recommend approval of the rezoning, provided that the City Attorney rules that the petitioning procedure in this case is correct. The motion was seconded by Mr. Willits and passed unanimously, on a 7 to 0 roll call vote. Submitted by: Approve by: '_ , Roge an Jafi s Bryan, Ch ; an � � � � PLANNING BOARD STAFF REPORT �Uly 21 , 1977 Plat Map 19 George Kraemer Jr. 8180 i. APPLICANT'S NAME . (Steve and Nancy Hendrickson) 2, CLASSIFICATION . � Amend�nt � Appeal � Permit � Other 3. PURPOSE . Rezone to Office Service (OS-1) 4. LOCATION . North side of Grand Ave, between Cleveland and Finn 5. LEGAL DESCRIPTION : Lot 23, Block 1 , Groveland Addition 6. PRESENT ZONiNG: RM-2 7. PURSUANT TO Zoning Code Chapter: 64 Section: 210 Paragraph: 8. STAFF INVESTIGATION & REPORT: Date: ]_13_]] By� RR A. SUFFICIENCY: The applicant's petition for rezoning was filed on a short form rezoning petition which was notarized on June 29, 1977 and received by the City Planning Office on June 29, 1977. B. PROPOSED USE: The applicant proposes to rezone the site from RM-2, Medium Density, u tip e am� y Residential , to OS-1 , Office-Service, and to convert an existing one-family dwelling into a photographic studio. C. AREA & FRONTAGE: The site has 40 ft. of frontage on Grand Avenue and is 160 eet eep, wit an area of 6,400 sq, ft. D. SITE CONDITIONS: The site is level with Grand Avenue. There is a single family wel ing on t e site in good condition. � E. AREA CONDITIONS: The surrounding areais mkxed use. To the east is a new 17-unit apartment ui ing including two dentist offices. The four corners of Grand and Cleveland are developed with comnercial uses. To the south are one and two family dwellings and an apartment building. To the west are three one-family dwellings and three office uses. To the north are school buildings of St. �� Thomas College. � F. FINDINGS: 1 ) In general , Grand Avenue is a mixture of multiple family, office, and business zoning. 2) Office use is about the same intensity of use as multiple family use. 3) There is office use and zoning on the same block to the west: G. STAFF RECOMMENDATIONS: Staff recommends approval of the petition to rezone to OS-1 . The proposed zoning and use is in character with present development of Grand Avenue as a mixed commercial residential street. G.�. ��� � ' �� � �.�. / 1 `,+ ,: , 6..r. (� . � Z - � 'p O � � , ST. THOA/AS COLLEGE � W , � . . i � � Z � P � i O� �O O � , �'i � L � _ � � � . — - ._. , .� � � i i , ; i i i i i. -. -• _ , � � b o� b� o � o; � oo� , , , , � � � , � , � , � � � o � I � I � i P� 1 I I � � � � � � � � � i � I �-�.. -�.�� ���� � � 1 I —��. J__ _ � I � I I �, � � ' � i v . �'� � � � � 44 0 ' � � 00 � I � �RaN - _ � „� � •� � a � M � �os-�^ L,_2, A � ' �,4 c�� ,i�rJ � � ° O° O � � ¢i � ' ' � oo �o P `� � � - �►� ,� . �� ; . . � � � f : � ' '�.�-`t' � � Z o � 2�� � r�l . , —.-,...,,... , �� __�__--Z — � . _. _ . � 1 � r t � � -- - � r. :,t , j � i V- O , . 4 �' � : � 4� A t7 �U ¢ O � p � p 0 - — _�,,: . A�tEA MAP APP�ICANT �Steve & Nancy Hendrickson) LEGEND George Kraemer Jr. IONING DISTRICT BOUNDARY � ..... PURPOSE Rezone to OS-1 l�GLd SUBJECT PROPERTY 4 ONE FAMILY FILE N0. 8180 ¢ TWO FAMILY DATE 7-21-77 �'� � MULTIPLE FAMILY • �► � COMMERCI�IL SCALE � i"= 200' NORTH ♦ �� INOUSTRIAI. SAINT PAU� P�ANNING BOARO V VACANT �, . � CITY OF SAINT PAUL . � �; ..1'�� Ros� Mix s, . ' t AlbKt�.OIsN City Clerk and � . _ ...- ?, % Counoil Reoordar Council Secretary ` ':� ' �;�' `� .. ... �..j: . , ...e.�:.✓'��. OPFICE OF THE CITY CLtRK BURBAU OP RECOROS J88 City Hall St.Paul,Minnesofa 66108 Pitone t98-.¢8.l1 JtLly 7, 1gj7 Planning Co�nission Grace Building Dear Sir; The attached petition of George Kraemer Jr. to rezone pro�perty at 2091 Grand Ave. aka Lot 23, Block 1, Groveland Addition was referred to the Planning Conmaission for recomnendation by the City Council at its July 7, 1977 meeting. Yours truly,� ` .�C��O''�- City Clerk �� attach. ,` , MS/cw .��,.,, . � . . . Y� . . � (f R� �t'' . , ' � , , " ' .,�'�` ` � ` ;� � +'��� r� i � `� Vr °�'� �� � . ^ � �� . �so ., ;� _,��� � Short tc.,r�,+ Ne2uiiiny Peti [ion T(� CNs Hl1NOkABLE MRYOR ANU CI1'I COt�tJCIL � c/c� tr��� �.; ty Clerk, Raom j�Sb Ci cy f�al I (:ity nf 5aint Paul , Minnesc�td Pursuant tc� the provisions of LAWS OF MINNESOTA for 1975� Chapter 261 � Section 6, I /we [he undersigned� beiny the owner(s) of praperty described as _.._ - -°��-�� -...�.__r1.���.� __��.z_��__.____--��---�,�.---�__ /y� h ,�� �A-�l o��T�on� ancl 5 i t��a��d (ci�scr ibe locat ion w� th � t•sy�ec:t t� streets or intersections) � � ,� /��� � � !�J ��. 9� Fi�/� which property was previously zoned �D/f1/l7 � rC:/��" _. and under Chopters 60 through 6G of the Saint Paul L�gislatiye Code is presently zoned � �y, a more re�tr`ictive zoning classtfication� do ---a� _�•�� l � � .� hereby request that consideration be given by your honorable bodles to rezone [he above described property to a zoning classification of �� — / _!�� �r��!er Chapters 60 throuyh 6�+ af the Saint Paul Legislative Code. �;j. SuG�cribed and sworn to before me • chis ��day of � �7 �"� :�z. �, � Ad,dress: � � •�� , � c/ � . / ' Notary �ubl ic� Co. � Minnesota 5���� My Canxni ssion expi res � �- ` �' - �'� Tetephone: C��� 4� X AAAAAAAAA�AAAtO�R ��,,��„� JOHN S. MERRICK ���� ;� NOTARV PUBUC- MINNESOTA � '� H35ro�8Cp��9�He�4;1�83 �5 )t � b� the Ci .y Attorney. • ' (�X.r " I C[TY OF ST. P�U� D�PARTM4ENT OF FlNANCE AND MANAGEMENT SERVICES ASSfSSMENT DIVISfOIV 273 CITY HALL ST.PAUI,MINNES07A SS1D2 August 5, 1977 File X1946 , page _ � Dear Citizen: As a courtesy to you and as required by law, we want to natify you about a puhlic heariictg which may affect you. , The Council of the City of St, paul will hold a public hearing in the Council Chambers of the City Hall and Court House (third floor) at 10;00 a.m; on . August 25, 1977 on the: Application of Steven & Nancy Hendrickson to REZONE to Office Services (OS-I) Lot 23, Block 1, Groveland Additioa. The property is located on the north side of Grand Avenue beCween Cleveland and Finn Streets. ` If you would like further information about this hearing, contact the Current planning Section of the �lanning Board, 421 Wabasha Street, or telephone 298-4154. . While the City Charter requires that we notify you of the _hearing, we want ta help yau to learn fully about any action that could affec� you or your community. Therefore, I sincere2y hu�e you can attend this hearing, so that yc�u can make your views about it known to the City Council, whether for or against. . J. _WILLIAM DONOVAN , VALUATI013 AND ASSESSMENT ENGINEER e "�"— , �� � -- �- x' ;s�;�'�^ �,�Yf.� tai: A, �. x �,`�°� r`"''� b�..�� �as �f, �• � i twese�,. j .., . �;; . - , • -. _�n _,-. :y-L-,•-1 _ � �` f , r� . � <� � ,�,s�.>� w x. �. ���ted �.` e�; .', �'�{� � �` ��^�' �',i�','..3f � � ~ n,.i��:� ts` _� r�<<.�, -��. . _ x. ��,�,. � . . � �' ._ � � � � � ��y, l d'/�7 �� � : W CONSTANCE ZIMNEY , PIO3 GRAND AVEtJUE " sT. PAUL� MN 55�05 AUGUST I1, 1977 J. WILLIAM DONOVAN VALUATION AND ASSESSMENT ENGINEER CITY OF ST. PAUL DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE 8c MANAGEMENT SERVICES I13 CITY HALL ST. Pnu�, MN 55102 RE: REZONING OF ZO97 GRAND AVENUE DEAR MR. DONOYAN: • MY HUSBAND AND I WILL BE OUi' OF TOWN ON AUGUST Z5 AND Will NOT BE ABLE TO ATTEND THE RE20NING HEARING ON THIS PROPERTY� BUT WE WOULD LIKE TO EXPRESS OUR �ESIRE THAT THIS REZONING BE DENIED: PERMISSION. WE BOUGHT OUR HOUSE AT ZIO3 GRAN� TWO YEARS AGO� AND SINCE 7HAT TIME TWO HOUSES ON THE BLOCK WERE REPLACED BY AN APARTMENT BUIIDING. (F 2097 IS RE20NED TO OS—I� THERE WI�L BE ONLY ONE OTHER BUIIDING ON THE NORTH SIDE OF THE BIOCK WHiCH WILL BE USED AS A SING�E FAMILY RESIDENCE. WE FEEL THAT THIS CHANGE AWAY FROM A RESIDENTIAL ATMOSPHERE MAKES THIS BLOCK A IESS DESIRABLE PLACE FOR US TO LIVE� AND WILL ADVERSEI.Y AFFECT ANY ATTEMPTS WE MIGHT MAKE TO SELL OUR HOME IN THE FUTURE. FOR THIS REASON WE REQUEST THAT THIS PETITION BE ,DENfED. �:: VERY TRULY YOURS� � �� � � . . CONSTANCE Z 1 NEGY%y� .