Loading...
269746 � WHITE - CITY CLERK COUIICII �sg��� PINK - FINANCE .- �\ R � . CANARV - DEPARTMENT ;�`��� � GITY OF SAINT PALTL f - BIUE - MAVOR ' Flle NO. f �-��'� Coun il Resol tion Presented By LICENSE C�NIMI7'TEE � Referred To Committee: Dste Out of Committee By Date R�LVED: That Application P 18328 for the transfer of Off Sale Liquor License No. V � . 2821� e�iring January 31� 1978, issued to Applebaum�s Food Maxkets� Inc. at �+00 N. Western Avenue� be and the sazr�e is hereby transferred to Applebaumts '� Foad Maxkets� Inc. at 2023 Ma,rshall Avenue with the fol7.owing conditions: � l. The transf�r shall be effective upon the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy by the Building Depaxtmen� for the building to be erected at � 2023 Marshall Avenue� as required by ordinance. . 2. The transfer shall be effective upon approval of all City Departments required to inspect the business operation� and further� 3. Applebaum's Food Markets� �nc, is authorized to make application for renewal of the liden�e at �+00 N. Western Avenue on February l� 197$ if the Certifica�e of Occupancy has not been issued for 2023 Ma.rshall . Avenue on or before that date� is hereby approved. COUNCILMEN Requested by Department of: Yeas Nays Butler .,,�,� [n Favor Hunt ""�*� � _ Against BY Roedler Sylvester Tedesco $EP i 3 �g�_ Form Approved by City Attorney Adopted by Council: Date Certified �ssed by C il reta BY By Approv 17avor: Dat �P � 5 • 19 Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council By � By pUBLISHED SEP Z � 197� • ,':"_ �.a-::. v.�•�.' Y Ur' �.�.TNT �..E'�.YTL �`h� t';i�'�`�. OFFICE OF' THE: CITX COU�CIL �[� .'(�:-��- :���, � �f 4 � . '� ":; 4��� �+s�_ . �.� . ,;,� �.. ' � �'�'``� Da t e ; September 7, 1977 ���. �� - � li � !i� �� i � � �. !G � C.�. P Q q � � '> TO : Sain� Pau! Cit� Cvuncil F R� r'� ' C 0 IY��tl I��e E' 0 r'1 LICENSE & PUBLIC SAFETY Victor J. Tedesco , chairman, makes the following report on C.F. . [] �rdinance - Q Resotution _ . x� �ther _ . , � E�LE : Application far transfer of Off-Sale Liquor license from Applebaum's Food Markets, Inc. from 400 N. Western Avenue to 2023 Marshall Avenue. This matter was heard at the August 24, 1977 License Committee Meeting. � Their recommendation was for' approval and to refer it the City Council for action. , _ CITY HALL SEYENTFI FLOOR • SAINT PAUL, bIINNESOTA SSIQZ . . � . .+�,��1� . . .. . � � ..�ij, ...-'�_J_-. '.C' �"" ,-� (;r_—� i� I i � � i�'"CR,r'...�i ��—C1 CITY OF SAINT PAUL ���,,�. �.f��.� c -r3_-, C1TY Op ♦F' � �, ::a�� ��� . Rose Mtx c ;�;:�_:,',%�� "-' A{bte�e.Ols�� City Clerk and �_ '�`�"`��:s'� ` Gountil8ecorder Council Secretary ��„ f ;c -�a d OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK BURHAU OF RECORDS �` 386 City Hall St.Paul,Mznnesota 5510� Phone�98-.���1 July 19, I977 Councilman Victor Tedesco Chairman License Co�.i.ttee Room 701, City Hall St. Paul, Minnesota Dear Sir: The attached letter of the License Inspector transmitting the applicatian of Applebaum's Food Markets, Inc, for transfer of Off Sale Liquor License from 400 N. Western Avenue to 2023 Marshall Avenue was referred for committee recommnendation by the City Counci.l at its July 19, 1977 meeting. Very truly yours, � City Clerk `�� Attach. MS:dcr i � °�� � 269'�4� RECEIVED SEt' 121977 I move that the Merriam Park Community Council go on record as being oPPosed to any request to issue or transfer���E��l���i�qucirulicenses to 2023 Marshall Avenue or to the surrounding area, for the following reasons: a) we have enough liquor stores within accessible distances. b) if a liquor license is transferred to a $ite on the north side of Marshall Avenue, there could be no prohibition against an off-sale site on the south side consistent with historical experience on Grand, Snelling, University, etc. c) A large off-sale liquor establishment in elose proxi.mity to churches, schools residences, colleges etc, does not comport to the rest of the community. d) the B3 zoning restriction, pages 35 8 36 section C5 of the Zoning Ordinances for the City of Saint Paul notes: . . . .impact on adjoining property by use of the site may not result in the following: 1) loud, boisterous, and disturbing noise levels' 2) hazardous traffic conditions 3) offensive, obnoxious and disturbing orders 4) excessive litter 5) excessive artificial lighting 6) substantial decrease in adjoining property values 7) any other condition inconsistent with the reasonable use and enjoyment of adjoining property and inconsistent �ith the health, safety, morals, and general welfare of the adjoining community. �1 n. , , l � � r V�.(� �. 269�4� � RECEIVED SEN121977 I move that the Merriam Park Community Council go on record as being opposed to any request to issue or transfer�o�€Esale��i�quor�liEcenses to 2023 Marshall Avenue or to the surrounding area, for the following reasons: a) we have enough liquor stores within accessible distances. b) if a liquor license is transferred to a 8ite on the north side of Marshall Avenue, there could be no prohibition against an off-sale site on the south side consistent with historical experience on Grand, Snelling, University, etc. c) A large off-sale liquor establishment in close proximity to churches, schools residences, colleges etc, does not comport to the rest of the community. d) the B3 zoning restriction, pages 35 � 36 section C5 of the Zoning Ordinances for the City of Saint Paul notes: . . . .impact on adjoining property by use of the site may not result in the following: 1) loud, boisterous, and disturbing noise levels� � --- 2) hazardau� traffic conditions ' 3) offensive, obnoxious and �disturbing orders 4) excessive litter 5) excessive artificial lighting 6) substantial decrease in adjoining property values 7) any other condition inconsistent with the reasonable use and enjoyment of adjoining property and inconsistent �ith the health, safety, morals , and general welfare of the adjoining community. �� � � � � ,��c ,� ,�� ��. � P • � .� � �'��*�^v�'��i"'�� 5a`.' '��`r-�.�f .x" yY�rt, :rar 4 '�'£t°`.,�s ;..7 � . � +e.d. s- .v � Tz �,.���i-�.-.� v i4.''",� -'".�'-� .,�{ .:�F •_qs �..x. t �' . . r� s�$ .. 7 .., s V sf cxs t-e, ,y.�t'�" . `am ��" ''s t � , '" '+' , '; ',tf^.n',�,rms .t . K. .iF� 'a. ��'� �. a aa i _ zY^�; .. �` .r r, $`_ � '€f �4s. � �''� � �.E, �'.�,.'°�'a �F �'�s s� fr L �. v c��^��"-sa Ti ; ? _• _j,� � S t� 'h �'� �` �' T'S"` ..., f� � � F `l..: �Y� � 'T �1 f � � ��7 . 1. �.; � � J.. K ! � �`�' ,. � a �_"` � :�" .�'`�?�'"�"-"°'x` ..Sx.� ��,, ��Y 'ct e�� '' �� ��'mw�zs,�,� ... ..���`��.�i'�" `.��`3�`fi�e`°'� �:istw �5t.��� �a� °�.��'�,�'r't-�� �:,�, �,�-., +-�:'�x�� �� ,�� �,�.�x .��� � -.�� �� ���a � 3��C s.<,S3T�e��,'a*��-- - � '1 � x. �ei 'r:x �y 'tv.�. '�� � �, ";s' ^�s * s ��. . .�i.. L .r�.Y�.�, ::�.y T . s ,t� Yai«�, ..:.. �.Y-�'�� ,+�°.,r��':.., �x �� �� . ' - a�'�`.-� � '�, ..,o� - a. � %`fi •�'• �w .� 'S -� �z�'" .�or��Ry����r 'C''r. 'e+ .. " � `� s w` '� -.�� Ca�k �,,�,�t���� d�,�c�rn' . -"7 �'�a ��'4M�J'� j,1' �:-: �.:. o.,�+ G'A'. ��,�i..� 'klrt �c��.y, .�4",:sa'e �" � �x�} °fYt .r�'`3" ' .�: z x'. .. •� . .� F_. 5'� . , , s � t� � '� �� : . � .. : �'4� ���� ,' � "�. �� .,s,�. ��_. . . . ..-�.` '. ;`�'� r c � �3%`,.'t:: ..�. a�'.:� -_:+ �`+,:`.z� . ��+ °*��'� � ^�`�+,� ,b;.r ''"'�i'tti`°�t..�n�v � z i� '-.,, -�1^� '�Z' �r'� t � .r c..:� ��`' r `i� b� .c � ,t}., �,�. �`�,.- .:..:ta � 1� , � .� ��,t Y � �����y� J.' '`r� �I L y,� �`����.y� . � .. fi..�R.��� •�' } .. R ' t�Fy yi� .•q � ". �•:, 'a�i.��:! k �Y su ':Y.� „9, .� ;�.�4"�� � L .. l�t++ +y . . ' ,.�i' ` T� `S- ' t�y 'G_9 a.LL�y.��� � . " �. �p. �" s. .,:A*�X���K''2� �l�_`.$X�`,�i+{. �"b�.'" � � ..i�. r.� n:'' z .'�1 i ._:�. P -ft,� "� c i�.;i ���`�_ +* T'n,!,���.bi . e. x, .4e xs & <� a ,, ie a"n ,�+�..i^ if.���y.,s� y ,�:„i ea f. ..t �`h�t^' � M �;�'Y.^2 +�.� y S'7�� �� 2.0 i�.O m �ti .^l:? _ � � �Yy�,.� �� .�':+'^' r y ���6.r�£t'�S �y� �� � �� ��' t p t �..�'�e� ° � ����� �•a:4 '� �� >> i,. r.F: :' � ': -�" ,�95 .` , re� : 4 �-�7 ¢, yp . ;� a . .;: E.r °;h� ��,,� ��'x�m� � ;�" i . � x`oa�*w�l'ah 4"`c�' 't'�.h�"��� s.'.: -F ���"a.'''S S �... a'r yoy�.Po',.t""',�'y ,''7".,'t„ ��.�b s.+�L�R� °" � �. �a[..x��.:"�"�.� - �r �..' '� '=�".'��������� �ga �'�""?. �' -�9 -;�-i`�.�c�i �'��j-r`rti r��• � � c� � s ���� �� -�F' .:.�� � }• "1���'s�� � ���'x '"' � � . �:'�''�.��bu`;�'�� ��s � �, }'� � t .' a �;.r � '��4 f � s .... • � . .. .. x .& •r7�', � .y� 5-; F' �` � ,:��'s* .t.z.�'�a s�' 'x� ,=..�� ,3,�'.: -x -�c,: ��� � x�'� ��.�f �'.�r".:.k.��` �s,���'�-� j��J �Y"��;'d e"����` �r �r �� , : �s " �c^': -- a i.'.°.t-�� a �. +� er- '� �t '�� .�..:�, . .rb� ,�', ,�,�x� �� �'e � ..?�+ . ' ^�z � at.F._a�.:,. � �7 �t s^ ����� :t. 7�.� `' Y3��'1s.y�C� .�s. ,r . +z�',e .a,x,r �t `oy'a �,�,r � s : `'� ;,{"n; :� a x)�-.cok'��s, �-t g �. x � � � : , � k� ' � . �� �•� '��c ��i `F'�"k .�.�'`�, s j • . x ��n }pur ix � n�r�,f� � � �t j.x ; aFyi� �s* -:,y .S:- x�{�� �,�;� m r'�x.s � � .s'�'. ,zt�`� �s. .��� Lr',,�y..��'� .+ $ ��r��L+ir.�„ � � -- t k � i � r�� ..e� � x f-c-x�."' ",� i. �.. �,� , ^e . ���,.�'` ir"���'� �4 `gr raa��-r?"�"'�2 ����'�tYa''4�X" .'.-a+� ~ °�'�Av'',�"���� � f..��a,r"�2�.''r°' �'"K.v"'x ��� r- �. 3 ^� :,� � x. � � .�_:�� � � ��,�,�Y{' ? t �•{ 1�.v ': �."�, a''t e�s�-�* �' �' ''�` ;3�r �,���; � e-'�2 n '°� � 9�,�' ,_., `s�es'� Yr��' 'r a7 `'*`` r�' ' �.'?a a � ,�r.ym�f's ,� � i A a�e . r '� �k wx" �� i1s° vX r� c�'�y�a"r 4a� .1 ��"'._ ;� . �. C , . .y �.M1 : �kpa � � :�:. � 3�x'' . ..-� �,�k-� �:x��i �.°nt Ssi„���w. .'tY -r�z' s a . - `a t '� � �� �°�.",�i ��'�'tz�'". e�'"7s a.: t,3'�r:" � �,.,��_1�� �, ts"'�"��,rt. . .ra✓�,°' � c-�'�'� '€�.. ,r � 5�'-. _ '3 °~ ,ti � -�..:.>b- 4.r 4}at.�'� A yu�»k� r 3c .� �t : . . �w.�� r . .,�.�a rc_ ��d�x��'�"�?�`''� }*,��^i�z�,, �X�,�.� :�„` �1`# s�'�+��'*�j��,�+�,�'r;.. ,�'s�_ar�5.r�.r. a '�`' y _r���.�,k ts s..� i e""�'' ^ka� .,;Y;:... .�yr¢.'.�.�t ^.�3`.s_. ,���1�xri��� m. ..,.1�i > � �:, y,�.�.�s�" '� ^'-�,._ �2:a� ,,FF�ka' F.,r�' }-i'$� 4s A�<.y. +a�`T' ��i�"-a..^�;�s ; _ , t ,�:�:� n ,����: i r ,25.-�'r�"'�... s y � ,� �°`a�.r¢�������.ce� �� a r�s�rL'���*�?� - e,#. ���: �y3 r �s.� �� . � - � a� xay�'xry ..C�4' , � �e r-z. ��yd`�`i.� .. is .x- t T"�' -Y. � +,a 3::. .�?f"... ss� �� 1 �; ir�x` . L�C�"Cr 4' . L .r �'` �.F .�+. C'� �"t�. � � S'��yy'`� . `4 tf 5 2 4 •d'9'� s_ *� ,ta ..Ni` ,- ' r- �r -'xr ?9t r'y H+� � g i ,� «. zr: rF '.�'.- ° .� n.. : „ , ,en s,�a ,. � +. �� �� )T�� '' "Y �v:: ,r �'�f ?'k a x � �'' . ' t�'°_ �� z ? � � `� �..� -c �. ac. .' w ;�"�."1 5 y . �` 1 %i� _��y'7�� ,�,�"'F"� � +. � � ,k`�� ,���'.�� .:'�' -. s �{' . L�• ��•`+�'i s a:' 't � . ^rv,��e�.�� ♦ t:� � S:.�.-. �fi,:. `�' r,. � s? ;t a �.-6'=Ac ' �i�'�.. �� �$'''�i'"� �.'.,�x $.�'�"` s�s�•ari`"�n5 y:..�. ��,�.7i..� JL�"° �� � - -�3 ��r.;p! � 'w° "�• -�X�"+�,g �... ,� d_ t- ',� * �y1� - � s,° i��x,�S- �e„�-��• �'".'� t,,� t.•� � „�'' 'r aaC< ,p � � .. � � 0. �t `� }�c`k� �. €':' . z�' � Yr�r'1�' -4 �' . .F.*�. ��° ' * 9.. .,��Y"1'�'^ �.. �t t a`�� ������s .., �,..�� s '�F ii �� �# � x ,t� il'',a�� ^t- � ,� �n. 1� - � -. 3����, �� e.. s n.z� . r'�, "t x 'k .�. �� .i L�s�''�, S.�g.�-....x� ����c � .'r . •.� - - •.. � "K��. �.����'�RC r. ,� ~..••, o ' `�K ����#� ��!���! ����� ;� yd �� `��,�,� ��� -.��� z i�' a � p • .. '� �y e �cp .tf� C'; �`.a sv e.. ..r ��� r '� . � � � 1 i � I �'F � .� ,�JS` � ..,.. , k`�'M,, '. • (,E:a�' •Y'T� � �. ' ,. : 't -k ,� ( .! .'-.. l„'� �y, 'y '�" .'� . '.�iN, . ,7 x'�i�..� . .i. � t�. TV � �' M.� 5.�� � i'J � �ti �� �` i7C.� +��. 3 ..� � ! Y ` ,g - E^' `13 . -�t' '�.�"' ..- f i7-'l. /+'. .,1_ 'L '+�'� ,y� le��'�^• p r7 Ta y,� L s.: g-.� .Kr -.�'�S+F "!�'�`�4r'm .r���: ��,�y�itit.'��.± �' � r. � � t.:z'� a. � t'. �'�. .7,7, �`r Y� .�.,, .. �R.,., �..� �r ,. �- � r . . , - ,�s �' � ��✓ ,ri�..��� r �:. '� . s 7�.� ,m� � � � c+�r��� }ra��� ..v{� � F.�.- � _ '::� �t . � .-. � . . . �'� .�p } d ts �y �c:?'� `�' � _ �.'� ,�' ax�Y� .�`:�, . .i� .. 4 a- ,.. -�` .�" -a^y : . �;. xF a��*3 �3ty s s... x �r,,�ti �� v �'�.rx �" 7 -e ���.. �� .� e"Fd^' � p }`' �„c..e s t y3,�``�� .4 s ,� ss' '>� a'c. �@ [ �'.�'* `� ��. � .. .Y" 1..t� ai� �.'�.,. .'wS f� � .,.q I:V�4 Y94',�� �4 �� ..��S.T� "�'. � � 's.�t '�+�� �,� Y °�' { '� � ���4'.�rk "�gp' k'Y. .. a� � t'� y ti s, �,� ':.-T'""���,�`� "�'Ys `� {.u.. a1� •at� . a �, : �,. a',... � ,n'° -:�a�'� P �9� F �L�'4q.�°�'?,�j'*t r z�il _i G. V, ���.�n�.��Z�����' � �+1,�Y' � �`�.�xSU� �n ti �,'�"��t.r'��1��t �x ,3A`:r� � � � .. :- `e ` f q4��" :a�� +'� '��.s � v �v. u '�e+ *'�t. ,cf�, . K'` s +`�g �!� ,i: � s � }r� � ;.;` �s,. ,,,k ... t , S t � r�'ai a3'„yi ' '4�'�» �''��' � .�,a ° �ir,i��.JS a�r ..„_, ,�"r, � � •c�g��_ �Z+'{a .. ,y. .'t� .�..; � ,�, � ,r . rc�� ..a..:i��^.i z,�g� .x` '�S�' .' .��,,'�„t" "z'�.��. z= ��' ��-�'� °�'�� .+ih�� Se";µr 6 ..,.;�T s..� .e �',�. �:v� ;,,�t'sc`,�, -:�� �s"'.. `�. l��.� Y+se- '���',�?�� i T�.'y{.,'„w`° ♦ s 1. r �. t -y �+ ..v � _ '�" �� r�' . h_.- }� ��* 3, �.:. { xr r�» "' z ",�' '+„'°�ct'� T 3`e''� � ,a: `� h'E�9'i .� �,:��. �� �s: ,�y.:.�i' '�ir� ��- �.��""iG� :.. .� �'�9 1� Y .: k�'�X�r..!"i`.'y3 �� �x�„�..`"� .'w"'i��G :: r� . S 7 1,.•,.rm•a �,� ,� �, t�,t� :. ,�y '��+� s s� '0;�.'�-� Y �r- f Y �. `�` .::a�^ . � °�' f i `'�a.�.� s��yt- �'. �h z�.. �'y'a r.}. �'Se .a�'� r y �i �: �.� rr-�'.-�.`� ��y.� � � ..-'r t ` ���.'� �-.' S t'�1�,✓,�a.w; '�t�t�';t, � �.-. Y ..�} i ; "'S :9y M. " �a 'ro� �.• y 'y � a-i �.s' 'r a e t•a°t�',s��'. ,. t.. �'�y :S -�' � r � ''' '. � "-s ��'� •. '� s r }s y �x',��T�ir?'w' .t.��`. u �". 2�` .�y-;�. ,y,� "4�.' 'S=°"k-�'h�"-si v ,,:.���t -- ''tr,s,� ��z i '`��}`"�.!ct:�'���� # sy�, �F ��,�Y �� F J^ � ,� !� C,x^}y � �'a'��, :r'� "�"��� � c.>�r} wc �' �' �..�"��Fx�v r '�:'. tJ 7�aF: �t ��.a 3.�c,�'1 " �' ?��:" +'� r+•y�. � n y�.��'�'r� ,y .�'�+. � , ,, + s��� � �f �r b '"+`�-7 ,' ��.��d, p�Ye ,», w r �f'��'�?"Y`�.•,���;.�� ��,� ,�`-i�,�s r"����ykR.-t�, � �3'�, r. �� .. .a �� � �.. �a t -. - , F, ... ^ � s '�.� � - u y � '�,. �, { � �.`-. ,t� ,-� ,�, �' � r+�K� � ,y,�+� ty "S . .w,�,�-�. A �� . .. � .. . � � �-�''. ;� ��YP^e�.�--"`°�S,���iyk ' � .L�'N.V . ��ye+��r 'r' -y_i'_'pt�. . ., ��. ��� ' `�� c .. T ~ "k � . ,3'S '4{�r��'9 i�' '��� ,v iF ,x,#'� .C�� G �' ' �a1^9 RL � t` `'�'.: . i' C-+f�'�c3. ... .y Rt�'"-1'E. � . �,��"rJ:.. � zF:.+fi' r_..N ' � "_ +`�,.s��'1 ' �'+� �A�"" � .'�'� - .-�n`s�n�. s, r�c,� "r �+. '� �,. � y, � .��.s 'C 't? 'L'� .�:�� 1� �T 'S'q�,•'. �, �f. J f#�-Qr ,L'.:� Yl '� �sr� .Y"� 7. ,�x,, N�`.ta�s r - � �` 1 '`r'�,�'*a xy'.u-��^.�<'�� � � � ��+������ - '.xi s�r� r'y�}����`,r a ,�.� ,� ,�.�'7'�{ s ..�r` k. ! 1R.:. f �- �y,l S � 4y.+'�.t� f i.'r ..� :�„i�Il � �` �. fx.4 L�'W :1 ., j3�,.t �� i � C� ': ti'elA� �yt� � x~�i �e x �k?��'�" �t��.n 's{ '�'�x, a.� � ��_� ����' „as`.�,��� • '��-rT �c.z.. . x�" �S3' ���� � S.a�'i' �.'° �� �: �..�, � � •• r~�+ �c`4�,a j^ e x` � ,�d„�",s-n d'�"+�; �4�'� ��x �cx '» il�..�i(Y, ,f,;. 5.�^ y � 'X"i ' � ���At �..0 �Y� � .v 'i� �� �.,14� :'Y^'� SSM J i . 4 4 x .!' (�L ;p. x� a]�'?���.TA l • 'a^ Y . �,A` dE-,� �: il� 2"' 'L ..T � y�� .3 g�K'" g y � � ��• s"y.�' F ; � 'n ' °a�y Z'.. e ._ �`F i i�` �f..`r'� SdL�t�� ,�aF^���,,s� �„ z,'�`,�• ,EM,€}' ��sahs� ,X^`�'4'�'� a+.r��w �F4,� ��.; s� . 2a�F�' xv � . Ys .. � -c,� - s s-- .s � sy am .y--- �, �` � � z��s .n. =� ` "k ✓ . "�� a ,. rad : � � r� r �,', .4F�. a''� �1.,.< > '�''- �-.y�a.�a°��-, � �+ �.�.e � a .� ':� �=z�r" i� �w �,�M S r � �'.� �z 5k °;i�+ „v� ��> t �u roa ae � �.a :��' x . a.. ,t a r '6' ;� � ��s,r `*,�,� � sx.'�� ,�?� c :�a ���i �� -. 'i"� .-��a�.`'v"„i.n��5^ -a-;�i ^"r��c. '��. s3 -x""- �f ;E"'_ .3'` 'u. ar'� x `:+s''� "'' �"* .. ., t�` �tf '` � �° sx"�s'�'.: � R� �rr"�^s,' m$ Y't'�"'.�.4� '��-�§ r�'� �t. � � �,�3�.7-r' -..�.u.s e°� S" 'x��z...� .,?'r?±S' � s: `t,.�t .if yyp+ i�., � �!4 ^v.c� . ..x vr�r�'!",w°`,,.�,y �s, sv",�'�y„ � �'<v�- :e3_� '�� _: �a '� `�� i.� ;� a�"'' � '�ti."•�r r i� ��±w�..3i �� £.�.... � :��S^ ..a� ��_-w-'c�� sa„�„r� �i°��,s.� c�"�e�„r„*Q„�k'� " . 4 "����d�� �"'�r"'<.x r° � �� ���r"+:_ . �w,,y�u+�.�!1� ^r. _ �" � � /� �^S�� �k'�'�,'h.«�1� s- ?l��' yy� f t. .... , 4, 4b�Ii. aYK� .�a' ��L�' e�' � �v".�*�'� h'%�'r�'t}�'te''3�� S'�` Y �.' �..� � rY�.x' l�%',�� a4. ^W'�'S �..t �� .+t� �*rlF'.�t' "�' *,�:� '�ii°s'; i .. ��:, � �,+-a� '?�. �-� s• ,� -�r ,r •�� �i'�+"��y,":�"o-�,.''�'£ a�c �i .rt.� �`y�`r��-.�''` . ':��^� ..,�� �� A.*�-:j x-..��' .:g��a�� - n �� 3' 3� �, sa. �.V� �.ES_y sa� .� z,��x �.=ai�Y���. �"` "v�^ ,�, � a t . . . a�- � r €'k. �' ��`�''�+���'4° £r�'t�"��'�"t� * �,ej�.'�•���"'" `f '�"��`"�ij'r"'r�7 ���r �:� �a .. ;' .��. ;�.r.�` ".a`�a'�' a,..;�'1a, ,.c �"�P�,-',G ��»Y'�''^Xc,.. � 4�� y ,�, "�'�^ � i '` r.. � � r -: �i-�.��.� Rr �y'� �"e,y,.��x ,'��' ��+�" �`i '��,.� <�4,jy y�'� ���3-: >:P"6:,' W �,, . t � �' a� a .�'. z�r� �„�.¢ �s J ,� g�,��� �� �,. s � { - y ,��. _ �t.,. .�, Y ,..� � .�� z � ;�:� 1. �� ,..T. � � . x .:s�� 3ii..�3 `f=,' �y��.'�'s c. � - y�� ..�%,�'�� � ryi - 4 �� �L �A�'��rx � 7 .�� s s eta .W+} � f �'4 �"�� t� ,�, {�.J°r:CF t '� '�� ^GC,,,,. t ,�;.`�ARC� s e 4 ,-'^i.K�.::� 3K. ,.h� �L,E ..�„ �Y � r a ti� - �.x?, y� Y6 �`t dAd 't. 5..`;�e�Y': .,t: 3 •t. „�t� � �-�b'xa�.��.. :.k�. �i�' �. ,� ��'- �,�.. � yp -"'��'�('st" .,^;-.�,ia `•wa ��.�-3- r �t . x , � .�✓. .�..zF; �,.. � g�,,,-- �}y�i��--r-�� �^tz��:= +' �,z,. t �`�,' �,�i .�, y'irsJ�3 x � , $a'y� �{ i� , ..� � �� �` �'}< J" ^R:..e � ��:.'i i � � 5 � � 4 ��_ �� � � ��.�s"F: � �� ���� .� �.3�.�`'��� -.Ti �„zsi�x �,• y.� : �b w r,r��t^A �` .�, #� .' � 3 3•s.�E.�`t y- . � . y . � i �.'� �,a.':�c�z�' ��k��•Y�r y� ��� '�''' K' � '',dr'�' w r t'.� ���~�'�` n�i1`r.."� '��� '`'`"s'* F .��`'t'# i a• . ,.. .c ..:�',�. . ; y�.,. L '3' '��.� _. �v 'y,w-k`�,.. '�� � ti��,� � Y � 1 .� _�. •,.'�S+� '� _e;�s.�r �':z �x �'`�s;..; ��' '��.... ,_.. ..xa' . Y'�'�.,�•?'�t w�q. .ys-�• •..s�F' .fi'. ��a'a<��a�.�2✓.��?'a.:�:r s.�.� .. ...,.��. ,�_. . . ..�xi--".'`�Z'.',�'..xz._��k�� ,.s.. _,_+n'?'���.�z:_�.�'.,.�°��-'" 2�9��5 1937 Ashland Avenue St. Paul , Minnesota 55104 September 12, 1977 St. Paul City Council City Hall St. Paul , Minnesota 55101 Oear Members of the Council : I am a lifelong resident of Merriam Park; 1 have been the assistant principal at St. Mark's Elementary School for three years and have taught and coached there for seven years. i am opposed to the proposed off— sale liquor store to be located at 2023 Marshall Avenue. The proposed site is very close to my school and very close to Merriam Park. For the past several yeers we have had some drinking probtems fil— tering down into our 7th and 8th grades. My con cern is that the presence of a liquor store so close to St. Mark's wilt make it that much easier for our grade school youngsters to obtain alcoholic beverages, especialty through another buyer who is of drinktng age. Then it becomes an easy matter to move up the block to the park for a drinking party, with the possible noise and vandalism arising therefrom. Merriam Park is a good community, and St. lN�rk's is a strong parish. I believe that a liquor store in this location would place just one more ob— stacle in the path of parents and teachers who are trying to form our young— sters' values. Sincerely, ��f���- ��E'>G�%/� Robert Peick 2�9�4� . 6ethel Temple • 1982 Iglehart Avenue � St Pau) MN 55104 O Phone: 645-1534 D REC SEP � �8�� 2 �977 Pastor: Lloyd Jacobsen OFFIC � MA PAT���`�R�'RESIDENT Church Ministries: ROBERT. SYLVESTER Argene Van Veldhuizen Septeml�er 1C� , 197� Hon . Rcbert 5ylvester , Pres . 5t . raul City Council St . P�ul , �1innesota ��1r . 5ylvester : I regret not b�ing able to attend council proceedings this marning . Regarding the liquor licesne transfer to 2023 f�1arshall please conv�ay to the Council my de�p concern th�,t you respect th� wishes of th� n���ighbnrhuod �n� community affected. The 1=:r:�e majority ❑f the people in the comm— unity o�;,ose tnis transfer as has been sh❑wn in the recon— sidered vote of the �fierriari t'�rk �ammunity Louncil , the p�tit��ns presented , and '�he written ano ph:�ned expressions of aQ;��ositiun . (�erriar�s F�arE; is a h�meHchurch—school n�i�l,uarhood and a �u�iness of tnis kind dues not fit int� tne c❑mrnunity . Ns a church we feel th�.:t the distance i�etween us and the liquor jtore vi�:lates the spirit ❑f the l�w , if' not the letter of tl�e law , �einu it i� s❑ close tu tne leg.._:1 riiinimarn. f�1ay I emphasize th�t th� law ��:rants tl-ie 5t . F��ul �ity Coun�il , " . . . discretionary aower in the qrzntin�; or denial of liquor li�ense applications . " I respectrully urge th�t th� Lcuncil rec�gnize tne will aT ti��. people in ci-ii� c��se an�l danv tn� transfcr ❑f this ,� iicense . cc : R . aut�er 5incerely , � . i�unt L . Levine p . Roedler (Rev. ) Lloyd ,7acobsen D . Hozza U . Te�:lescu �- . . . ��9��� ��z-�t �- C�xtr�r#�r �x�Y#.e� ��t����r�� C��ux.c� 1899 MARSHALL AVENUE, SAINT PAUL. MINNESOTA 55104 llelmont Gordy, Minister - - - Telephone 645-9159 September 9, 1977 R�C Councilman Robert Sylvester City Hall SEP 12 ���� 15 West Kellogg Blvd. st. Paul, Minn. 55102 COUNCI� PI3ESIDENT ROBERT SYLVESTER Dear Councilman, As Pastor of First-Trinity United Methodist Church� 1849 Marshall Avenue, I am writing to register mq protest against the groposed location of thQ Applebaum Off Sale Liquor Store at 2a�3 I�arshall Ave. I have some basic convictions underlying my opinion regarding this. Having dealt first hand with individuals and families who suffer the consequencea of the use of alcoholic beverages, I have strong feelings about any advance in the promotion of such. Obviously the relocatioa of this Liquor Store is for the purpose of more sales of liquor. All of us have read the atatistics of the alarming use of liquor on the part of youth. Many objective sociologists feel that this is far greater threat than the use of drugs. The location of an off sale liquor store near to a Burger Chef provides a good place for youth to obtain liquor. 4ie all �aer that the law is sometimea circumvented; youth must be getting liquor from some source and the greater the sources and the more available they are, the greater the danger to youth. Our Merriam Park Community ia concerned about this. In fact, lay persons have initiated opposition to this propase�d liquor store. We are all con- cerned abouC the welfare of our citq aad our communities and many �oin me in feeling that this proposed liquor store would not advance the well being of Merriam Park Community or the city of St. Paul, but would contribute to negative results that break down our community family and individual life. Sincerely, �'�t�m vw�/�v�-- Delmont Gordq DG:ag - � ' ' - w : ' � w f'��'���'. = �• = a 4a t . ' � � �"`�� s, -�-�', i M1 ��,.,�. w MARSHALL AVENUE THOMAS R. PEARSON'S ����4� �, .- `T� MARSHALL AND CRETIN STANDARD -- S�i� 2178 MARSHALL AVENUE ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA 55104 644-3436 / ➢ / ���f � —�G? �- �� �� �T ��'�t� �' � �� � ���L,�� - � _ R D ,�r—��� ��.:->y .�✓%�� SEP 121977 i G���-�� �,��p � COUNCIL PRESIDENT ROBERT SYLVESTER � ��� � ` �.� � � �/� u��� � f .���•C� ' . �,�� °� / �l> ��d � C�c.�����G�� � o'�o s3 .� � � -� �� ` � �'�`- ��� L�-�/ � ) v�� vk. �%�`z— �' ,��c�� " ' , � , ��� �� .�'� ,�=�� . � - C,.� � ��-'�.��- .� �-� ,���� �-a- � � � ��s� �-<� c�y``x �-'�"" �� �'�� — � ` . � G d c� ���'� � � P � L, a�I����� ~ �c � � �2�� ,�2.�� �� � � t �Y�`� � �.��4:� %'� � � -�� �-- '� ' ���- � � ��,T� �/l�� —��`%�� �"�`� � � , , � � � '� 4 i��t� � - ����� �,e.�'L�iJ1�Q/ � iC�4�/��vG�`�' ��/� �� � v �e.t,vLs /'�Z,�.c� / / i' �—`y��'� / N�tIAM PAPK G+E)NA4UNITY ppUNC�L �LUT]JON avc[rsT 31, 197? �69���J APPLEBAUM'S OFF SALE LIQUOR LICENSE . APPLICATION FOR 2023 MAR:iHALL =BE IT RF50LVEp �hat the Merriam Park Community Co�usCil g�o on x�ecord +�b being appo$ed to any requests to issue or transfer aff-•sale liqu�or licensee to 2023 Marshall Avenue or to the surrounding eirea, for t�he follc►�J.ng x�aaons s A) we have enough 13.quor storea wit.l� aaceasible :d�atanaee�. B) if a liquor licerlse i.s t�anaPerred to e aite.oat the North Side of Marshall Avenue, there cou].d be no pr�ohibitiqn sgs.inst eu1 oPt'—sale site on the South 3ide co�aiate� wi.�h biatariaal experiencsa on Crrnnd, Snelling, University Avenues� eta. C) a large off—sale liqwor establisho�+rit in clr�re proxieKLty to churches schools, residences, colleges� eta., doee not cor�po�rt to the reat of the cor►ununity. U) the B3 zoning restriction� p�geet 3S dnd 3G� setttion C5 of the� Zoning Ordinances of the City of Sti. Paul �teds "impaoL on ad�o3�ig property by use of the site �r not resu2t isi ttae lollox�rigs 1) loud boisterous and diaturb�ng noise levels 2) k�azardous traffic oandit3ortl� 3) off ens ive� obnoxioua e�nd t1�,�turb.i.ng ox�clers 4) �xcessive litter 5) eacessive e�rti:t�.cial ligh��ng . 6) gubstantial decrease in ad�o.tz�ing property rraluea 7) any other comdition incatu�iettqr�t w�bh� t,�e' reaeonable use �.�.d en3oyment of ad�oinin.g propez�ty and i.t�tcor�iutent frith the health� safety, mora].s and general we].tare of the ad�oining comrmuLity." For the resolutions 21 delegatea Against: 0 Abstaining: 3 � � � � � � ' APPLICATION OF LI UOR LICENSE . Q I BY . APPLEBAUMS FOOD MART, INC. ' ' ' ' . ' ' 1 ' . ' 1 1 � 1 1 • . ' T0: Members of the St. Paul City Council 1 Applebaums Food Mart, Inc. , has applied for the transfer of a liquor license authorizing ' the operation of an off-sale retail liquor store f rom its present location at 400 North Western Avenue to 2023 Marshall Avenue, both in the City of St. Paul. The Marshall Avenue location is within the patrol limits. This application is made possible by the application of Howard Johnson's to move the license formally held by Slinger's Bar to the east side ' where it will operate as the Ground Round. The zoning at 2023 Marshall Avenue is proper to support the application. It .is zoned B-3. , There appear to be no other legal impediments. The Licensing Committee unanimously recom- mended approval of the resolution for transfer. ' Premises In the event the Council acts favorably upon this application, Applebaums intends to clear the premises at the corner of Wilder and Marshall Avenues. The residential building at ' 253 North Wilder will be removed. Hopefully, the building can be sold and moved. With renovation, it should provide excellent family housing. The garage type building will be torn down: Photographs of the two structures are attached hereto as Exhibits 1 - 6. , Once the property is cleared, a new structure containing approximately 7,000 square feet will be erected. While the final design has not yet been determined, the building will , resemble the structure erected by Applebaums at its Cedarvale location. Photographs of the Cedarvale structure are included herein as Exhibits 7 and 8. It is anticipated that the building will be a single story structure compatible with neighboring buildings. I respectfully submit that the building wiil contribute to the esthetics of the neighborhood . ' and will. make a positive contribution to the appearance of Marshali Avenue between Cleveland and Wilder. ' When considering the question of esthetics, Applebaums will certainly strive to achieve compatib.ility with the neighborhood and also to erect a building that will minimize the source of complaints from neighbors. The Council should be aware that the resolution for ' transfer will become effective only upon the issuance of a certificate of occupancy by the Building Department of the City of St. Paul. Off-sale retail liquor stores constitute a regulated industry. Not only will the Council have control in this instance over the oper- ation of the iiquor store but the initial design will be subject to control through the , certificate of.occupancy procedure. The City will have the opportunity to review in advance the proposed design of the building, lighting, parking and other matters identified in the site plan. Finally, it should be emphasized as a regulated business, the hours of operation ' of an off-sale retail liquor store are closely governed. Off-sale retail liquor stores must close each evening at 8:00 p.m. with the exception of Saturday. On Saturday's these estab- lishments may operate until 30:00 p.m. They must be closed all day Sunday. ' The License Committee The License Committee unanimously recommended passage of' the resolution before the Council. ' There was a full hearing before the Licensing Committee in which a number of objections to the application for transfer were raised. Essentially they can be broken into two categories: First, there is apprehension over what may happen. Secondly, there is a , distinct anti-liquor sentiment present in the neighborhood motivating potential neighbors to qppose the approval of this application. ' ' ' To: Members of the St. Paul City Council ' Page T�ao ' The residents expressed apprehension that the presence of an off-sale retail liquor store might increase the drinking by juvenilles, increase litter and other forms of debris in the neighborhood and might encourage improper behavior. The testimony pre- ' sented consisted of a series of younger people testifying that they had for years en- gaged in unlawful drinking and professing fear that their younger brothers and sisters would continue in this pattern if the Applebaums application was acted upon favorably. In at least one instance a father and his twenty year old son appeared to express this ' concern. It was obvious that the source of the i1li:cit liquor was still present in the neighborhood (they conceded that this juvenille drinking continues to the present time) and that most of the liquor was available at a service station selling 3.2 beer ' located on the same lot as the proposed Applebaums store. It was also apparent that in the era of the automobile, liquor was available to �uvenilles whether from the immedi- ate neighborhood or other locations in the ltain Cities on a rather convenient basis. ' The Applebaum family has operated retail grocery establishments in the 7.t,�in Cities for many years. They have a reputation for service to the community and competence as business people.. This reputation speaks for itself. I strongly suggest that their presence as ' operators ot an off-sale retail liquor store will not aggravate or contribute to ttiis pre- existing problem. It is their intention to operate a store that provides a commodity much in demand by the adult population both in this community and elsewhere throughout the City ' of St. Paul. � The litter and debris problem relates directly to other businesses presently operating in the neighborhood. Complaints of beer cans being strewn across neighborhood lawns and up ' and down alleys evidences the earlier problem of juvenille drinking. Most of the beer cans were identified as 3.2 beer. Other complaints were voiced against a local eating establish- ment. - ' Again, I think it appropriate to note that Applebaums has operated many gr.ocer stores across y the yIetropolitan Twin City area. They are a St. Paul based, family orientated business. ' They have contributed to the growth and stability of neighborhoods throughout St. Paul. The problems. that are cited are not problems that have been precipitated by Applebaums nor problems that they have caused in other neighborhoods. Rather than aggravate the existing problems, I .respectfully submit that Applebaums may be a mitigating influence upon the other tbusinesses operating in this vicinity. The second general eategory af opposition can only be characterized as anti-liquor. The ' alleged evils of liquor cannot he addressed in this application for transfer of a license : from Western Avenue to Marshall Avenue. Those concerned about the availability of this commodity lost the argument with the repeal of prohibition. Liquor is recognized as a ' legitimate business. Were the application in this instance for a fast food operation, many of the complaints would be identical. I respectfully submit in light of the well known record of competence in community service ' established by the Applebaum s Food Mart,. Inc.. , that this application .is proper. . I request that it be acted upon favorably by this Council. � y . f X j' + .�°', ..,. y�� � -.�++y°" Edward J. isco�.l, for LARKIN, FMAN, DALY & LINDGREN, Ltfl: ! t � WE� AS T� DiAIi.SHALL AVENtJE BUSINESSrtANS ASSOCIATION�NC. F�'EI, T.ITAT APPROVAL OF TI� PLANNID APPLEBAUti'S I,IQIICIK STO2i,E AT 2�21 rfARSHALL AVE, ST. PAUL, WOULD BE AN ASSET TO OUR LOCAL nUSINFsSS DISTRICT. • NE AR.E �TROLE AF'.ARTEDLY IN FAVO�t OF THIS PROPOSAL TO DEVEI.UPE '�' TFiE1T PI�OPERTY IvTO SOA�'sTTTIAIG USEFULL AND HOPE TF�IT APPRQVAL IS GNF1�t FOR Tf� pROJECT. SINCERELY, � � biARSHALL AVENUE BUSIIU�SSr1ANS ASSOCIATION, II�TC. ' � ; _ � �^�� ���__ ) ����r��, ��72-�,r n� �2a5� ��'" � � � / � ��;K.��c �/w"I� � .�/ SvPP�Y �'11/ , � �'^�� ! � �r� �C� v� �✓ tto�.�' ' 2�°�a �-'� l `' l� f � r t " r / � �Z !-, i �,���%�JC���7����C�G � / G���- ��'�iG-�Z2 J��F� ��� � ,���,� . ��� � � �' P� �," r (�� �', . y� �G' �� ��-�/��-��� f : .�` J i�` �� �S , i —� �!" ��, �� � ��-�'��_�; `��sr-%�p�'� � ���/'� ��Gc- � . �-_ -���.`. ' � � .., ��` � �J J � t! �f G*n'�i't/.f�" .� � � � i � ��_ . � � � ;. r J �. E '; �' � . n �-'°�`'-� �:: �,��- ;� o y G/ ��7���. � C�-- �' : '� /� r � � /k� ��.� �.���'�f � � t , � � t�' ' G/ L Cii ,� � •, /"`/ .� ���^�.i���i�. �- � % . � f"� �Q✓ �� ao � � ����� �r ���� ` � � � i . � : � �� � � .L -�. � _ .. , , , , .s� � , ,� a ���, " :�. - � `� � , " -�.;:�` ; �'�,�� ' . � .,, K �,..: .��, �. . � � � . � � p�- - �.;� _ � a ' ry.� s , _ � t�� ��. � - . . .. . ,,;� 1�: .i . _ �,. I:"Y � �; + ' r �l' ~ R ` . ... r .r t._ . .. 6' :R ` -� .!., � ;�' '•� �*� •� ,� �� �. I ' ____ ___ ___ .____ _ _ __ __ ____________ ____ __ ______ __ ___ _ : i y�' . . • . ; � O . ' . C�3 ' � : � . . > � � � , '. . �� - , { p , � �: � , . ,; , � ` ' � � '•/ .�� � ���.S,.h� 4� ��. !�_ ' � ' tj? ! . ' . r ;`� ,�. � c �� �: rt. , �..' � .f�.� '� �. ^a ... •HI, 4�, p�. �,I . . . � . �+ ��- • �' " 7 � . :�,, � ��.� . � �s � ��,} , " f + 4 � ,{ y t . e z..�.t Y�,Lp . . ' � 1.• ��' y,�y ('k . 1 4� ••��1� �'� `,;'( `�,(t�`i �. y7 k�F . I� '� ;t `� y,,�� , �;r� 1': t�. o'. . .:j� ,� ; t � � � ��.��� ��� �.������ ^ '� -��� w *:+`a��-' . . � ��L'�{ �:� �K����'��' - � � .. 7 � 'c�& "�"- ,n� ��. r . �.�,, , . .. ��n �. . ,�. }, �,'�°` � �.:A . `7 �'a. P -.a , • �i�'. � �,4 v ;' � , '�'' ! �'� {�' 4z .- ', . � � ��•h , ' � �^.e y ` �'. � '�� . � + .�`� , ,,t . ,.t� : '� • � �, / f I ► . � ��� '�� � � x;�_ „�r,�. . , � � � . ." ?L I � 'I � , ' . ' � .. � ��. � �. . I i ' i •� � � . , � . , �'�;'h.� .... I _ , ` r"y � .,. ♦: i I I i V � & s This is the Applebaum building in Cedarvale. It is the intention of Applebaum's to construct a building similar in appearance at 2023 Marshall Avenue in the event their application is approved. I ( I ---- - -- -- ------__.---------------- - - -_ - r b 1 �'_ Building at 253 North Wilder. , � This building will be removed. Hopefully it can be sold to someone who will move the house and renovate ,;.=: it f�r use as a residence. ;��' �' =, k '�� � 'E _ R�.�' � r� - - ;,. __ _ �.-�� �,., ___ _ _ _ _ _ ___ __ _ _ ____ •� 2 ; Garage type building formally occupied by Quigley Motors. t � � • � � 3 :�, = A photograph taken on Wi.lder looking �f toward the southwest showing the closeness of the Quigley garage ( buildin� and the residence building depicted in No. 1. � I I . ' - _ - . ' --_ -------- - - _-- ---- . . . �, :, , ,_, , _.: , • . �. � �� 'i� � " . . � ,� � �� �� � � � � c �ti t e �'� • . . � . . � ' �� � � ��y+/���/iJ� s � - . . � � . ,� .. /► `_ � �� / /�(� � f �frr� F # � iw� �( / . J . /. ' •' i �t . i � ( "; , . , , i r' . �,• a , � 1 '�i � � . . . . . .. . . . I' . . .. � �. .. . �. _ . .. �„+ . . . .. . .. . , . . - .. . . � . . . � • ��.` ��f . . � i�. `.1� . - . ... . . .. . � . . . . . � . . .. . . _ .. . . . .. . `1 ., - .. . . , . . . . , . /' . _ / . + —.. ' � � ; � . . , � . . , . . - � . . . .._' . . . . . . � � � . ' , � � , � � � .. . � . . � . ' . .�. . . ` � . � ' . � . . • � . � . .� ' . � � .. .. \ .;-� �;�, � I ' ' — ` �� . , • . — , . � _ � y _ , '. : . �. — ' r f - � _ �_ ... � y ��. , . : .. . . . �R_ ' . ` . . . �:. . �� �. � y , . i —. �i ; ��� ��y �� ,-... � ,.� �1 _ �_; < . ` ,. ,� s � � . � ,. , ,�' �: �: . �� _ u�, � . � _ , . . i � � `E. � ' _ � %�� , i _ '�/ •� �� ���" •t�' � � . , , ,. �� �- � � � 5 " - t1�t�aiq�ldq►'� ��� ` , ��3: �s !lt1l,- t�t�r t�tu11 , , \ � � ,�� ,i . . . . .���r���•�� ,� ' ' 'r.. }�� �- ., ' f' � � !,� � . . - ' ... , . . . . ` .� ' ' . .1 �I. .. , � . . �YM�' Si�+t ' ' `` �- .� ;� , _ . , , , ,i � �, ,. '� �t�ral��et i��sr' o� t�� t�d:a�r L�r t ; �!�#�p�. t�=,ri�p��, f,, iip���►��:i I�na! Mss�ts. :;�. loir tra�l+� �pr�".:.�r � �,.�, � .'F K � ! �►" tkA� �1.-�iwt�era�m��as to �3. �!� i�iirr�t wr�� 'i�r�� �lo9i� 3�� �� � :; �r�e�wdit�ea ;� f�t�►'. �.��� 1� ,aa��► _�; 1�T'�'a��g ' , . �'. � '� � 1 �/�'! ,`����+� � � � .�� ' ' .St'�' . . . . . - . . , � µ � _ _ � -. � � . • . . : ' �; _� . . .-':;.. � - ,; 1 . f 4 ', : �. � . , .. " 1. ' . � � . ' . � . .� "' .... � \ y'a .t .�� -� . �.�� ' . . ' . ' , . . � . . , ,. , i y� _. �:.. . , .. . . , . {���,��. ':. y:. . ' ... . . .. . . . / ' . � . - ' . . . .. . . . � _ �+��i�• � � � � ; � � � � - " ' •7� , �i� _ _ '' ! ! j .,( r � � . . � �. . . . .. ` . . . � . . . ' ' . � � ' `f . . , . .. . . � . . . ,, . .. . . , \ . .. �,- :�� . ;� .t - � .. . � _'. � . , ,, .... � � �. . , . ' , � . . _ . . . .' ;: , . .. � ' . � .;� . . . � � �, . . ;; . . . .. . � . '. � � s �' V � j ,,�. , � � . .. � ��� , , , ; A;� • , . , ,. � . ,�: - . ;: - • ; _ . \ ; ' , . .. � �.,.. � , , � . ; � .��i . �.1 . ' . . . , � . . . . . . . . . � . . . .b ; rr � x - � .. � . . . . � i: _ ,� . � . . - . ': . • _ . _ , �.' � . _ .� '_ . . . . , .r, . t �S ( � * � S� . , � � . , � , � �.. . . .�. : ' :� .. .,,;, dr , .,.t+r. . ,• r�� �/j� : CtTY OF SAINT PAUL DEPARTMENT Of FtNANCE AND MANAGEMENT SERVICES auly r3, 1977 DIVISION OF LICENSE AND PERMIT ADMtNiSTRATION . . � Mr. President and Hon,orable �embers of the �ity Council Saint Paul� Minnesota Ms. President and Honorable Members: ' Applebaum's Food Markets� Inc. currentZy- hold Off Sale Liquca� License No. 2821� expiring Januaxy 31, 1978� plus miscell- aneous licenses� issued to them at E�00 N. Western Avenue. They are r�questirig that these licenses be transferred to 2023 Marshall Avenue� Which is lxated on the north side of the street between Wilder Street and N. Cleveland Avenue. They ha.ve requested that a public hearing be scheduled as soon as possible for this transfer. �ery trul,y yours, �� , `/��Q�� Joseph F. Carchedi. � � I,icense Inspector City Hall, St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 � , �� i �fi�"74S I ; ; . , ,����� __ 1 � . � . � � � � � � � � � � - � , � , � _ 0 d � o � � i i 1 � � �. d e J i , / i `� L !'J , U/ � i . a �. , ,i, , � ��� ; - ;-- ------------- - -- -- - - ---- ----- - ----- ( �_'t"_ ----- - ,, ------------ _ -- -_ -__------ _-- --- ---- ------ ------ + '-'---- . ; � ----- -- --___ --- - -_ _ __ ___--------- ----- ----- __-- --- - - --- ------ -_..._---- I' I i ;i � � � . f � -- --- -- _ , i,: -- --- - - -- --- ;; h - ------ -- - i -- � i' I � � ---- - � - ----- . �i --� ---- - �- i . I �i i � R - �-�--- '- �,� � -- � . j, �'�. ' � . � I ( I Z �: . �,� I; `_ li I � li � ,. � �� � �. ��.�.�i.;. . i': o�`�� ���r��s � ..d��� ��L ���r �rc� � ;� /JG�c���n� �/�G� ,G������e���� �G%L��ecc� a�u%�� ��� 'i�l'� .lJ�l.�i2trl�'/G. C%�'�f/L ��r��jP.�� ��.'��Y,�?�'�f/l�� ,�/.TJ ;;G��D �lrlaC�L �lJC�G��G ���c.tJ �O���r� /�f�%/���:�-�/ �'i i';c?��/�,G /�UO2fi 4C�I� G�i/7 4GGt.�I//Y�G�Llfi -Of/L�,YG'�i ��G�2�. � y� LG�l'i �j F!l�U l'i G//� Gr/f/��i Q!/L�i l,ri /.J��lG'C�i1Z/ ;; ti�i�,G� o� ,��u.r 2 �2�0 .�J�� ac, m� �� ';'�� G� ����� � .���� ��� .�:� �� !' ��� � ������ � ����� �� � ��� ',: ./��0��� � .f��il2�c�s�� ��2-� � .�r��� G�i �� .i:��L� Q��cr.r'.� �O y�/Jo��If� /�u.�v'��L, �.�i� �� �/ ;; ���G� � ��o .�a.�tl�f/L .�Jocc.�� C.�l�'i1� ���'� .� ;! .,� �lc� .c� .-Lc,ro�� �%reci° �ota� �/I�Y�'L o�if� � ..o��,n�� v� �� ��.� � ��'22��� ��� � � ;!����a� .��..��. �.�� �r,Z���zr ��� /Jfo���.� � ';: ,iv/L2��v �t2/� ti�'u,d� ��rr� a� �2G o r�i�L ��o �;; � �lf� G'e� �./a���G!'!cf -�ii1i ���GGdL .AlG'�z1�O �� L� 0 li ;`40� ,.�a�� G� .�«�-ls� �i'Jo2� �/���/L��1 -C.� .� � :; ��J.f��/1��f� �G dYI� v� �GtY� d�f/1i ��a-D• �'-c. ������ , ..�.� �� ����..�, ,�v� � ��'�i ��' �' �� .�� .�i�� �,o,oar� t/�� �� ;��O�D.I'�G� �Q'if7.l'�t/1� d� C�C. ��fGGr/L �f�'.t/fi � °'�GoZ.� '���/ �����. �oT� (��J .� i �� � �f+ ,,�a�s�a�(/ ��2� �� >a��