270391 WHITE - CITV C'LERK � � 1�
PINK - FINANCE �y
CANARV -I�EPARTMENT COl1I1C11 �����Y�
BLUE -MAYOR GITY OF SAINT PAUL File NO. ��' ` -� �
.
ZIZGLIZCP. Ordinance N O.
�
Presented By
Referred To Committee: Date
Out of Committee By Date
An ordinance amending the Saint Paul Zoning
O�dinance, Chapters 60 through 64 of the
3aint Paul Legislative Code.
THE COUNCII� OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN:
Section 1.
. That trhe Zoning Map of Saint Paul, Sheet No. 20, as incorpor—
ated by reierence in Section 60.401 of the Saint Paul Legislative
Code, is hereby amended as followss
The property on the Northeast corner of Holly
Avenue and Mackubin Street, more particularly de—
scribed as follows:
Lots 13, 14, and 15, Block 14, Woodland Park
Additionf
is rezoned from R�-2 to RM-2.
� Section 2.
That this ordinance shall take force and effect in thirty
(30) days from and after its passage, approval and publication.
COUNCILMEN �
Yeas Nays Requested by Department of:
Butler
Hozza In Favor
Hunt
Levine � Against BY �
-Re�e�
Sylvester
Tedesco FEB 7
�978 Form Approved by City Attorney
Adopted by Council: Date
Certifie s e by Coun ' ecretary BY D
BY .
Ap by Mayor. e
FEe 9 �`97�" Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
BY 1 ���l�is�J `e.�� ' � ���c� BY
'!'i�.:i ��. �::
` ' � . i .. �. ., . . .�I: � ,. � � , .. � . . ' : ' ` ...��
I\'
�
. . . . . ' ' . , ' � . . �, ���+ ���� .
�i. r ��L` R.:._,�
�a� �,tY �A J, CITY OF SAINT PAUL
� ��
DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING ANb ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
... ` �Ni��•�� b . �. ' � � .
" � � DIVISION OF PLANNING
W'� •- �c 421 Wabasha Street,Saint Paul,Minnesota,55102
...
612-398-4151
George latimer
Mayor
December 21, 1977
Rose Mix, City Clerk
386 City Hall
St. Paul , MN 55102
Legal Descri�tion: Lots 13, 14, 15, Block 14,
Woodland Park Addn. to
Dear Madam: St. Paul.
This letter is written in response to the petition of St. Paul 's Church Home
to rezone property located on the northeast corner of Holly and Mackubin from
RT-2 (townhouse-residential ) to RM-2 (medium density-multiple family).
This matter was heard before the Current Planning & Zoning Committee on
December 1 , 1977 at which time staff recommended that the petitioner's
request be granted. Mr. Humner moved to recorrr�nd approval of the request
to rezone to RM-2. Ms. Grittner seconded his motion and it passed on a
6 to 0 roll call vote. !
On December 2, 1977 the Planning Commission unanimously confirmed the I
recommendation of the Current Planning & Zoning Comnittee. I
!
This matter is scheduled to be heard before the St. Paul City Counci] on '
December 29, 1977. �
;
Sincerely,
���'���� �`�� �
Donna F. McNeally
City Planner
I
DFMcN/cc i
Enc. �
I
File No. 8234 I
�
�
I
� '
i
i
`�� I.
���, ��, � ��;;.�.� '� �,� �
' 1 1 1 �
� � �
��
�� ��������������
� � � �■ d���rr��■��re�s
� � � a��e��e�r����sr��rs�r
� � � ���e���r�������rr�
� � ����r�������rrr��er
. ���o��e�����r�r�e�■
���.::=��e�����e�■
���o�ro�e���������■
o��a��o�����eer�e�■
������o����e�er�e�■
o��o��e��e ■�e�e�■
„ �:�����r�■ ■�����■
o��o�����e���e�o��
, , . o��o��o��Q ■e��ro��
� e��o��e��e ■e��e��
� � � ���o������ ■a��o�■
� � � ■��������o ■e���o■
� � � a��o��o��������e�■
� � ■�������■ ■o��a�■
o��o��e�■ ■oo�o�■
,: . ��������■ ■������■
� � a��o��e�■ ■�o��o�■
� � �������■■�.�■■��c�omo■
. �, � , �r ,
� � � : � .I r�..rt . i r� .'. ./.. � ,�/1.
� �,
. , I_ �. .�. _: ,.� ,. ,_,�r�,, i�/_ ,
. , � , r, " . " �- �s►,; , ,
� / / . . /v�/�� , � � /
� � / �
-� � ' .�/ � / . �-� � / �/. ,� � �
� � �� / �. ✓I �" ��/ .��
� � /1I��I� � �� I��/ I' � -
, � ilt
� / . r
MINUTES OF THE MEETING OF THE CURRENT PLANNING b ZONING
COMMITTEE THURSDAY, DECEMBER 1 , 1977, IN COUNCIL CHAMBERS,
SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA
PRESENT: Mmes. Grittner, Karns, McGinley and Summers, and Messrs. Humner,
Pangal and Bryan of the Current Planning & Zoning Comnittee; Mr. Robert
Straughn, Assistant City Attorney; Mr. Richard Amey of the Division of
Housing & Building Code Enforcement; Mmes. McNeally and Fox and Mr. Edward
J. Warn of the Planning Staff.
i
The meeting was chaired by James Bryan, Chairman.
ST. PAUL'S CHURCH HOME (#8234): A petition to rezone from RT-2 to RM-2 property
ocated on the nort east corner of Holly and Mackubin.
The petitioner was present. There was opposition.
Mr. Warn read the staff report and showed slides of the subject site.
Lionel Jadoo, Administrator of St. Paul 's Church Home, gave his address as 10501
Nicollet Ave. , Bloomington, Minn. and said he was prepared to answer any questions
the corranittee might have. However, there were no questions forthcoming from the
cornrni ttee.
Leonard Olson of 485 Portland Avenue spoke in opposition to the parking lot, saying
that the young couple who had attempted to move a house onto the Tot Lot a few doors
away and had been refused, now want to move this house onto the subject site. Mr. ,
Olson said he would prefer a house on the lot rather than a parking lot. He added `
that he was unaware of a possible advantage to the city because of real estate I
taxes, but nevertheless he was opposed to the parking lot proposal . f
�
James L. Dreelan, 952 Grand Avenue, spoke in opposition, saying he is the owner of I
a six-plex about six feet from the east borderline of the presew�t parking lot. He
stated that the parking lot was created during the summer, but in the wintertime, !
snow removal affects his property and he said he would like to see St. Paul 's
Church Home erect a retaining wall to prevent drainage of their snow from the
parking lot down into his basement, or not push the snow so close to his building. I
i
Mr. Jadoo answered this last complaint by saying that within the past couple of j
days, St. Paul 's Church Home had started moving snow to Mackubin and will continue �
to do this . He said they intend to keep the parking lot clean, they intend to !
landscape and provide a good parking lot for their employees. �
Mr. Hummer asked Mr. Amey about the draina�ge situation, and Mr. Amey said drainage �
would have to be to the street or alley away from the property. �
Mr. Hurroner then moved to recommend approval of the rezoning request. His motion j
was seconded by Ms. Grittner, and passed on a 6 to 0 roll call vote. i
i
Submitted by: • Approved by: j
' -7 �
� _ ?` � � � '
.�: ll,� ;- .�,�� �� I
Edward J t Wa Jame,s'�Bryan, Ct�afrman �
/ l
1
, i
a„ r
-.. 1
� �
PIANNING BQARD STAFF REPOLtT December 1 , 1977 plat t�ap 6 '
8234
t. APYLICANT�s r�ar� : ST. PAUL'S CHURCH HOME
2. CLASSIFICATION . � Amendment � Appeal � Permit � O[her
3. PURPOSE • Rezone t0 �2M-2
4. LOCATION . Northeast corner of Holly and Mackubin
s. LEGAL DESCRIPTION : Lots 13, 14 & 15, Block 14, Woodland Park Addition
6. PRESENT ZONING: RT-2
7 . PURSUANT TO Zoning Code Chapter: C4 Section: 210 Paragraph:
8. STAFF INVESTIGATION & REPORT: Date: 11-21-77 By: EW
A. SUFFICIENCY: The applicant's request was filed on a short form rezoning petition
subscribed & sworn to before a notary public on October 11 , 1977, and received
by the Planning Division on October 20, 1977.
B. PROPOSAL: The proposal is to rezone from RT-2 to RM-2 to allow the construction
of a paved parking lot to serve St. Paul 's Church Home.
C. FRONTAGE & AREA: The site has 154.38 ft. frontage on Holly and 143.34 ft. frontage
on Mackubin, for a total area of approximately 22,000 sq. ft. , or .51 acre.
D. SITE CONDITIONS: The site has been leveled but not surfaced and has been used for
limited automob�le parking. A brick alley provides access to the site. The
site is bordered by a duplex on the east and other older sing7e and multi family
homes and rowhouses across Holly and Mackubin on the south and west. St. Paul 's
Church Home occupies the land across the alley to the north.
E. AREA CONDITIONS: The area is primarily residential with one to four family homes
an row ouses. Considerable structure rehabilitation is occurring in the
neighborhood.
F. FINDINGS: �
1 ) The site was previously zoned C Residential .
� 2) A landscaped parking lot would not be detrimental to the neighborhood.
3) There is a lack of sufficient off-street parking in the neighborhood. �
4) The site would accommodate the equivalent of 12 2-bedroom units if rezoned i
(if the intended parking use should cease), which would not be detrimental
to the neighborhood.
G. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Based on the above findings, staff recommends the ;
petitioner s request be granted. i
i
' 1�
�
� '
;
- . . . . � � " . . '�t, . . .. ' . . � .. .
. � � � � ' '� . .�
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
�:��rr �,�,
/h,/ ��;,��',,.
f, (r� '��t ��'��•
ROS� hti: �� ' '' AIb�r1�.Olso�
City Clerk and ,,;.�,',, �_. -%'�,�,; CounotE 8ecorder
Council Seorstary `1�!`. . �,r,.,-
+,,,�':,�;-,,,,,✓'
OFFICB OF THE CITY CLBRK �URBAU OP RBCOROS
S88 City Sa11 St.Paul,Minneaota 66108
Phone te8-.#�.l1
' '
October 18, 1977
Planning Staff, Zoning Section
Grace Building
St. Paul, Minnesota
Dear Sir:
The Council referred to the Planning Commission for recotmnendation the
attached petition of St. Paul's Church Home to rezone property on Holly
at Mackubin aka Lots 12, 13, and 14 of Block 14, Woodland Park Addition.
Ver truly yours,
.
0.����,
City Clerk
Attach. �
ABO:dcr
cc: Finance Dept.
Mr. Erickson, Building Dept.
�
�� ��,��.- , f
�. � �A���-� ���
���►�� � ; � ^ ���az� o
� � -
�� � �
. � ,
�E
. . . . . , i�yJ 1 .:,J; ',��k:: �.1: I�'�l�. , ., . . .. # .� �
. . . . .. d' . ¢ � . � . � ,
. '� ? . . � � I I..� �. .. . � . ���� T ^ �` v^/A' �
� ,' . . . ., . , . . � .. . � � 1. ' �.^� _ . .
Short Form Rezoning Petition
TO THE HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCiI
c/o the City Clerk, Room 386 City Hall
City of Saint Paui . Minnesota _
Pursuant to the provisions of LAWS OF MINNESOTA for 1975. Chapter 261 , Section 6,
1/we the unders i gned� be i ng the owner(s),of property descr i bed as j.nt�,_,P ���) ,
,
Block fourteen (14) , Lot thirteen (13) , Block fourteen (1"� • T„± �,,,,,-toPn �1g,�„
Block fourteen (14) ; Wbodland Park Addition to St Paul
and situated (desc�ibe location with �espect to streets or intersections)�_
Holly Ave at Mackubin (cross street or intersectionl —
wh i ch prope rty was prev i ous 1 y zoned ,�- ���t��?�a� . and under
, Chapters 60 through 64 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code is presently zoned
_�'�'_. _ � � a more restrlctive zoning classification� do
hereby request that consideration be given by your honorable bodies to rezone
the above described property to a zoning classification of K M • .Z
under Chapters 60 through 64 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code.
. I
I
Subscribed and sworn to before me � � ` �
th i s f1,_ day of (,�C-r-o-Pti�•,� � �1 / �/ � � - .�.,. ����u.�G j � +(, /17c
�,li{c:f�, �r . ;'`>��L �r.-%� Address: !� �!�flF �� � {
' ��U.Y7..o��.R� I
Notary Publ ic. R-am3q+ Co. � Minnesota�- e«. , � �a� �� `r�l��"
^ �� h '`.�.. �.i
My Commi ssion expi re ' "` � , : �;�� Telephone: �a � -' �-35�� �
t�;` .' .., � :,y ,;� i
� MYCC•1.A7 RL�".%:.� . . .. 4.Y :3, 1��<J
.............r.....�......�w...,..�-......�.�_.....a
App�oved as to form I1�17/75 �
i
�
by the Ci:y Attorney. �
Z,�'i�° �I'�G ���.� .��b ,
1
�
� I
: ` r. --- _ , �
� ,.. , . . _ � . ,�, . � . e ..
. . . � .i - � . ' . . .
. - ; ' _ . ` ���� � � �
, .
Ct� 1� ,, /�
. ,
, , � _
, � . - . .
, _
, } . .
. . � ' .. `4. � ' . ' ' . � � ( . . ' � � !
� � - � . . . ` . � . .
� . . . 1 . 1 . . . " .
. � . . � . . . ' . . . : . . .
. � � � . ' ' � . . � . � . . - - . � .
' .; . . . .. .. , � � . . . . . � . � .
. � . ' . . . _ . � � / . � , . . �
" \' . . �. . . .� ' � . . . . . ' . . , .. . �
� . . . . . . . . � � �'I� . .. . . ' . . . .
. . . . . . . . . �. � . -� . . _ � .:
. . . _ . . . � � . � . , . . . ' � i . � .
. . - � . . . � . . �� . .. .
, . . , . . , . � ' ' � ' . , � .. � ..
�
. . .�; , ' ' , . . • .. . ' .`� . ' .
� . . , . . ,\ .. . i..' ' . . ' ., .. . • ' .
. . . . . � . �. , .. . I :`\ . , �� �.
{ , ��iwi �9, ],97'I �'
. , ,
��, ,
, � ,
ll�tt � . . ' �` ,
� ������ � ,
`�;. , , , � .;
_, � r ;
�11�IIt �. Lfl�slO�t ` , .
'� �� �� aMr �:,� 1� �r4tii+�rt,rL' d�,� �Mes1'r
, tl�r�t �� � .a� '1�wt a�'I�i�1� �wMr►�r,�! a�i1�r' ar� �a .��.
,:�IMMIt L�IMt �3 , r s � '�k 4Y�.#'l�t� ,
, , ,
. :� �+�qqr �► �ts�'y �
,
. . , ,
. , :
QZ1� Qt��l� ,
!
�l�r � � -
, � � , \ ,
. �
� ' , " , _ , �.
' ' . , i ,�.
. , i �
. �
, , .
� : ,� �.
- ; :
� ;,� :
�
, � ;�� ,,.
, ,
, . , , „
. � �
� ,,
C�TY o,� CITY OF SAINT PAUL �
'�'�� '- DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
� . �
� •::�:w�. ,;
,�� �� DIVISION OF PLANNING
�,� 421 Wabasha Street,Saint Paul,Minnesota,55102
612-298-4151
George Latimer
Mayor
December 27, 1977
Rose Mix, City Clerk
386 City Hall
St. Paul , MN 55102
Legal Description : Lots 13, 14, 15, Block 14,
Woodland Park Addn. to
Dear Madam: St. Paul .
This letter is written in response to the petition of St. Paul 's Church Home
to rezone property located on the northeast corner of Holly and Mackubin from
RT-2 (townhouse-residential ) to RM-2 (medium density-multiple family).
This matter was heard before the Current Planning & Zoning Committee on
December 1 , 1977 at which time staff recommended that the petitioner's
request be granted. Mr. Hurrunner moved to recommend approval of the request
to rezone to RM-2. Ms. Grittner seconded his motion and it passed on a
6 to 0 roll call vote.
On December 2, 1977 the Planning Commission unanimously confirmed the
recommendation of the Current Planning & Zoning Corr�nittee.
This matter is scheduled to be heard before the St. Paul City Council on
December 29, 1977.
Sincerely,
���pw���' IM�-t�t�t�'
Donna F. McNeally
City Planner
DFMcN/cc
Enc.
File No. 8234 �{��
� v
c�.&5
id , �
''r„ ',�t;� ;� '.i�,;
k+
� � � � 1
1 , , �
����
�� ��������������
� � � �■ �����r�rr��■er■
dr�e��e�ro�e���rs�■
� � � ���e������������r�
� � ����������a�r�e��■
. a��o��e�r����r���er■
���.::=��e��r��re�■
a��o�ro������■�e�■
a��o��o�����a�■�e��
e��o�ror�r�r�e■�e�■
o��o��e��� r�e�e�■
„ �:�������■ o������
a��o�����e���e�o�■
, , . o��o��o��� ■e��ro��
� e��o��e��e ■e��e��
� � � ���o��o��� ■���o�■
� . . ■��������o ■e���o■
� � � a��o��e�����a��e�■
� � ■e������■ ■o��o�■
� � o��o��e�■ ■oo�o�■
, : . �e�������■ ■������■
� � a��o��e�■ ■�o��o�■
� � ���m���''i��1��t�JL�l7�1�■
, � '' �, �, � �,�� , �' �
♦. �..I�...� � r . . _/_ � ../L. '
i �
.
�� �� �� i, r. ...����. ��' �
, . IF��/!��'! l�'' .
. � , i..•�... ��-/ ,
� , s '� �, � r �
.,.,. ,
� � /- '��,�! ✓ ' ����.�.._ .�r-�..� '
� � / �
����I� _/. .� _I /.//
, _ _ / ' ,/
r � .
MINUT�S OF THE MEETING OF THE CURRENT PLANNING b ZONING
COMMITTEE THURSDAY, DECEMBER 1 , 1977, IN COUNCIL CHAMBERS,
SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA
PRESENT: N6nes. Grittner, Karns, McGinley and Summers, and Messrs. Hummer,
Panga and Bryan of the Current Planning & Zoning Comnittee; Mr. Robert
Straughn, Assistant City Attorney; Mr. Richard Amey of the Division of
Housing & Building Code Enforcement; Mmes. McNeally and Fox and Mr. Edward
J. Warn of the Planning Staff.
The meeting was chaired by James Bryan. Chairman.
ST. PAUL'S CHURCH HOME #8234) : A petition to rezone from RT-2 to RM-2 property
ocated on t e nort east corner of Holly and Mackubin.
The petitioner was present. There was opposition.
Mr. Warn read the staff report and showed slides of the subject site.
Lione� Jadoo, Administrator of St. Paul 's Church Home, gave his address as 10501
Nicollet Ave. , Bloomington, Minn. and said he was prepared to answer any questions
the corranittee might have. However, there were no questions forthcoming from the
committee.
Leonard Olson of 485 Portland Avenue spoke in opposition to the parking lot, saying
that the young couple who had attempted to move a house onto the Tot Lot a few doors
away and had been refused, now want to move this house onto the subject site. Mr.
Olson said he would prefer a house on the lot rather than a parking lot. He added
that he was unaware of a possible advantage to the city because of real estate
taxes, but nevertheless he was opposed to the parking lot proposal .
James L. Dreelan, 952 Grand Avenue, spoke in opposition, saying he is the owner of
a six-plex about six feet from the east borderline of the present parking lot. He
stated that the parking lot was created during the summer, but in the wintertime,
snow removal affects his property and he said he would like to see St. Paul 's
Church Home erect a retaining wall to prevent drainage of their snow from the •
parking lot down into his basement, or not push the snow so close to his building.
Mr. Jadoo answered this last complaint by saying that within the past couple of �
days, St. Paul 's Church Home had started moving snow to Mackubin and will continue
to do this . He said they intend to keep the parking 7ot clean, they intend to
landscape and provide a good parking lot for their employees.
Mr. Hummer asked Mr. Amey about the draina�e situation, and Mr. Amey said drainage
would have to be to the street or alley away from the property.
Mr. Hummer then moved to recommend approval of the rezoning request. His motion
was seconded by Ms. Grittner, and passed on a 6 to 0 roll call vote.
Submitted by: • Approved by: �
�
�/�-'' - �l,' �_��-� � - �
f , ,
Edward J. War �,�a?�e,s �ryar+a Cqa�rman
i
. . . . . � ..Y; , .
�. ,:. ;i;. �, . ...- . . , .
.
,'�
� � � �� . . :...�. .:., .� . . �.. �,- . . �„
«._._r
� PIANNING BQARD STAFF REPORT D2C@mb21" � , �977 P18r j„LP 6
8234
1. APYLICANT's t�at� : ST. PAUL'S CNURCH HOME
i
2. CLASSIFICaTION . � Amendment � Appeal � Permit � Other
3. PURPOSE • Rezone to RM-2 _ '
4. LOCATION . Northeast corner of Holly and Mackubin
5. LEGAL DESCRIPTION : Lots 13, 14 & 15, Block 14, Woodland Park Addition
6. PRESENT 20NING: RT-2
7. PURSUANT TO 2oning Code Chapter: C4 Section: 210 Paragraph:
8. STAFF INVESTIGATION & REPORT: Date: '11-21-77 By: EW
A. SUFFICIENCY: The applicant's request was filed on a short form rezoning petition
subscribed & sworn to before a notary public on October 11 , 1977, and received
by the Planning Division on October 20, 1977.
B. PROPOSAL: The proposal is to rezone from RT-2 to RM-2 to allow the construction �
o�a paved parking lot to serve St. Paul 's Church Home. �
C. FRONTAGE & AREA: The site has 154.38 ft. frontage on Nolly and 143.34 ft. frontage '
on Mackubin, for a total area of approximately 22,000 sq. ft. , or .51 acre. �
D. SITE CONDITIONS: The site has been leveled but not surfaced and has been used for I
limited automobile parking. A brick alley provides access to the site. The
site is bordered by a duplex on the east and other older single and multi family
homes and rowhouses across Holly and Mackubin on the south and west. St. Paul 's
Church Home occupies the land across the alley to the north.
E. AREA CONDITIONS: The area is primarily residential with one to four family homes '
an row ouses. Considerable structure rehabilitation is occurring in the
neighborhood.
F. FINDINGS:
1 ) The site was previously zoned C Residential .
- 2) A landscaped parking lot would not be detrimental to the neighborhood. �
3) There is a lack of sufficient off-street parking in the neighborhood. �I
. !
4) The site would accommodate the equivalent of 12 2-bedroom units if rezoned
(if the intended parking use should cease), which would not be detrimental
to the neighborhood.
G. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Based on the above findings, staff recorr�nends the I
petitioner s request be granted: ,
. 1
. �
�
. �
;
�
�
i e
��
_ !
, • ' '
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
�
,��Gt�lY U�t.
d�ti� i;'`�yi
Ros� Mix �' '� �f� `� �"' Aldte�r.Ois��
City Clerk and �• ��� .._ _.��� Counoil Reoorder
Councfl Secretary 5,�., ''�'
�.,`:���
OFFICE OP THE CITY CLlRK �OREAU Of RECORDS
J88 Ctity Hadl St.Paul,Minnesota. 6610t
Ph.one t98-�.l1
, ,
October 18, 1977
Planning Staff, Zoning Section ,
Grace Building '
St. Paul, Minnesota
Dear Sir:
The Council referred to the Planning Commission for recom�endation the
attached petition of St. Paul's Church Home to rezone property on Holly
at Mackubin aka Lots 12, 13, and 14 of Block 14, Woodland Park Addition.
Ver truly yours,
�� �
���
City Clerk
Attach. �
ABO:dcr
cc: Finance Dept.
Mr. Erickson, Building Dept.
4 3 ;
�~��-� � �����
����� � ���
�� , r
,��,
� � � ��
�E
o �
. . � . ,.. „ . ,V 1�';'� ... . . . � ' � 1 � . .,
, : ` . , , .. . . . �. . � � -� �� ' . � . , . � 1��,�,�y�� , , � . . . .
'TL��[ :I
�� '7'T O ��
. ,' . � W ._" " �
Short Form Rezoning Petition �.
� :� ;;.
TO THE HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL
c/o the City Clerk� Room 386 City Hall
City of Saint Paul , Minnesota _
Pursuant to the provisions of IAWS OF MINNESOTA for 1975. Chapter 261 � Section b,
I/we the undersigned� being the owner(s)_ of property desc�ibed as T�nt 1'WP�17A �i�) ,
Block fourteen (14) , Lot thirteen (13) . Block fourte°„ ��^� • T nt �niirtctan ri a�,�
Block fourteen (14) ; Woodland Park Addition to St Paul.
and situated (describe locatian with respect to streets or intersections)�_
Holly Ave at Mackubin (cross street or intersection)
which property was previously zoned � I��S/Q���T�d�--- . and under
, Chapters 60 through 64 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code Ts presently zoned
R'r�• �> �r�il�E����� ' a more rest�ictive zoning classification� do
._7—
hereby request that consideration be given by your honorable bodies to rezone
the above described property to a zoning classification of �_• �-
under Chapters 60 through 64 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code.
Subscribed and sworn to before me '� ' �
n .�. `9 j�
t h i s ' day o f �S(',Z¢,�� � � � 7� !/l � � �,�;,��.��. ����sc�.,s ���C, /Qcr»�f.
`� '' .� �e-
. _ ,_ �
,�-<<rc�,-�.. C r'. ��,-.ti< <-+--� Address• !�
1 �U-IL.O�CC� _ .. __,�}-..�� �M . V��D I
Notary Publ ic. Rams�► Co. . Minnesotarr - . ;-�� ""r
� ... ...._..., _._ --,
,-� �> t P oZ� � - �3��
My Commisslon expire � , ' . ..1.. .. _., :, 'Tele hone• I
� �". .....,.� r;.:. ,;:�Y � I
�':` -��I ' _Y' :3. 1�t7:;�
. P�v CC��rv'NIJ:'..�:�i �I '�. .. -'' «� ,r•..-r� '
•�rt•�r��s�I.�-.�•r.i.....,�..w r
Approved as to form �1�17/75 �
I
�
� �
by the Ci ty Attorney. ������� �g L� ���
�
i
I
��/v-
CITY OF ST. i'AUL
DEPARTMEfVT OF FINANCE AND MANAGEMFNT 5�RVICES
. ASSESSMENT DIVISION
713 CITY HALL ST.PAUI,MINNESOTA 55102
December 9, 1977
�
. i
FiZe X2014, Page .
Zoning File 8234 . . .
Dear Citizen;
As a courtesy to you, and as required by law, we want to notify you abaut �
a public hearing which may affect you. .
The Council of the City of St. Paul will hold a publi.c hearing in the "
� Council Chambers of the City Hall and Court House (third floor) at lO:OQ a.m.
on December 29, 1977 an the; �
Application of St. Paul's Church Aome to REZONE from RT-2 to
RM-2 property on the northeast corner of Holly and Mackubin
Streets. � The property is described as: Lots 13, 14 and IS, �
Block 14, Woodland Park Addition. �
. 1 �
. : �`.
k
If you would like further information abocst this hearing, contact the Current
Planning Section af the plarxning Board, 421 IJabasha Stxeet or telephone 298-4i54.
While the City Charter requires that we noti£y you of the hearing, we want to
help you to learn fully about any improvement that could affect you or your
coQrnunity. Therefore, I sincerely hope you can attend this hearirg, so that
you can make your views about it knowre to the City Counci�., whether for or
against.
� J. WILLIAM DONOVAN '
VALUATZON AND ASSESSMEI3T ErIGINEER
.
r I
1
i
1
I
I
i
I
, � q"� „,'t °''r � 7a,1 t> �aq �1:.
��,`,°!'� a��
��i�`iiL.,�-.fl4: _ ��-0CA y �, a'F�R;y""S�'.'_'�f
'�,r, ��°viiS:�`�.a .z;A, ';T,'�`. -Y�; �:
:� i�F '�'�
_I .
re � ���� �
;
�aa�i
�
r;;�
�'
:
i
�
"j `
�. , � �
x x� �. I
' � ��� .��� ,
�`�"',�� �.�. �;:�� �-�'� ,��
_t,�.,�� ,, ,,�,
�
i
�
I
I
�
, ,
, i
I
�St 1 - I �7 � . `
2nd i � � y
3rd � 1 �fn Adopted — � �d_
�
�
� , i
Yeas Nays
BUTLER
HOZZA
w�j��
HUNT � � � y
� LEVINE
�gL� � i
TEDESCO
�
PRESIDENT (SYLVESTER) �
�
_ v . v
- � ` r v �— `r'� �� ' 'v ; v v � �;��
�. �A �A � � • ` .,_,�. y V
. �__.�__ v �► 1 �v � � j � V
I 1 O� � � w V
� � ., j ;��.� � � ,
,� /-� � , ,
�� � O �.: V l.J V V V �/ ;P�il��'� � � I
' V i �
� � � 7 6 i 4 6 6 I 3 E,�� � �/ O (� � �
.� . 4� O 12 12 'Yi 71
LAUREL. T�.a.�.�. AVE.
U� ¢ ¢ � p v e g s �� : �
' -a- 00 L? �. � ° �- � � � � �
_ _ �_1_ . , � �
-O- '^ � jA _ _� � � '
_._� v/ MI
. t Ae I � �
� � � ¢ � � -�-�O O � � O � p� �O O � Q
� � � � • 5 17 �58
ASM L.�I�D �AVE.
9 ,
V V � P � ¢ ¢ n� I� 12
I II .� �,J RH G'V ��¢ � �I � T T 5
V
__ � I 4 A 6 m � S�oA(/LS CHURCN
�O HOME
I i � `+� ,��� i
V � � � i G �'��• i � �
e � T� Q (� J r-� � i�s Q i
� boo O
�-� +;, g �2 �� � Q T � ��
--�-•-•T RECTORY HOLLY V E.
2q i �3 RH�
� � � \.� �i �'� !� v �� b 5 8 7 6 � 8
\� � � 10 i O � RH i T � O V Oa O (.•� ¢
- � 2 p � _" �-!
___7_ .
I
I �
� �R H � I 8 8 '`� I I I � I I � I
� ac� ; , � � , � , � , ; ,6
�- 2� Zo a � � --�, O o o � � � � ' (� � 'o 0
RH � � � T � ' 1 RH
� RoW �RTI...P�ND AV�.
` � � � � � � �
�� � � ► �b � �� � � 5 �� ? p oq ; c� � o 0�9
� � � , � Q m � � �
� , , i � , � i
�
, � � Y
� o; ; ;PW „ o .. � � o � Q � � � , � � � �
� , ��s I , ][ � � I I � Q �
k �i V � � �OI � � � �
i
_ _------ - --- � --- .� . -
� � � 6 i i �� � '• �= � i i � O O i 23 � i�
` � �/ �/ v� � I i � 0 � (3� � I
Z � � � I I � t I �
; I- a I I � � � � � � � j I
I _ � J I f � ( I ��� I � � � � �"� i 1
�
� � Il'�' !� ! � � I I I I I � I I I 1�' '� ,
........,,.e.,.,.,.
AREA I��P ,j
APPLICANT St. Paul 's Church Home L.EGEND
"'� '� ZONING �ISTRICT BOUN�ARY
PURPOSE Rezone to RM-2 �� SU9JECT PROPERTY
O ONE FAINILY � ` 'ST
FILE N0.
8234 � TWO FAMILY �
12_1_77 MULTIPLE FAMILY
�ATE � �
• � n COMMERCIAL �
.
SCALE� I"= 200' NORTN � "'� '� �NDUSTRIAL �.Q
v � T .. U �
_ , r V V— � i V • \/ i v. v_ �
- •A •q - � �
V - { i v i , � .Y.' � " v V y
_� _ _ , I
_ f �
ti
. 1
; ,T 0 ;�.> �►�,� , , ` ,
�j C� <_ � C� v v v �- � � � ��
� � . �.. v , ( �)
I 7 6 �� �6 6 I 3 v �.�� .�4� v � � (�I ' �-i
12 12 'Yi 71
LA►UREL T.G.p.,.�. AVE.
pl � � � � v e s s ii : O �
� � p �. � ° �" ¢ " � � �
_ _�_.�--- . , � �
_ � � m �.�. I i ,
--T— - - - � � ' � __ � � (�
. Q t A� � ' � �
I � � � � � �''0O � � 02a � g O; �O Q � '.�
� . S 17 5@
A5�1LA1�IJ AvE.
9 1 P � � ¢ g �C 12
� I � , C� �l - �
� I� � RH v � � T I �I 7 7 5 V
_� I �q pb m � ST,PqULS CHf/RCN
— �O HOME
� � I �.� •`.� i
'.....-' I
(� I
8 7 7 I �i IJ � 0 Q Q `�J•� -,' � O i�s Q I
'w ,, y 12 �j � � 7 �j ��
RECTORY HOLLY V E.
?,q i 13 RH� l
1�-� i ('� �� ILF ;� � (l� ( 5 8 i 6 � 8
� ` � � �o ; f ` R H `r i T '� 0 V ¢
_ � , , O , Oa p �
--,-� , =o=
V �R H � i 8 8 '�'�}" i I I � I � I I �
� � � ' I 1 I � I � I � � 16
�- 2� Zo o � � -�� � ° o -�;- b � d � b �o � 0
� � ' ' RH
RoW �RT�..P�ND AvE.
� ¢ ¢ � � � � � , � i
� I� � ► � �b � ,c� � � So� Z poa � a � 00�9
� � � � � ; � m ; ' � �
� � � � �
i
� , � � - Y
I �� I IP W V O ^ � O � U � � � � I i I
i �' L.J
i ��s I i Y k r� V � � i�l � � � I � '
I I �I � �
_ _ -- -----
� �� • -
` ;� p 6 uj j �� ; j� a= O i ; � � p � 23 � ��
, Z � � , � � � � o � N �C3� i i
� � � `� i
�_ Q i i i i i � � � i i O � ,
+ r J � I ��a � � I t � � �
iC'' . � � � " � i � Q
_ 'I � � � � �
,
-�----�-----�,. ,
AREA R��4P �
APPLICANT St. Paul 's Church Home LEGENO
'— '— ZONING OISTRICT 80UNDARY
PURPOSE Rezone to RM-2 � SUBJECT PROPERTY
O ONE FAMILY � 1 'ST
FII.E N0.
8234 � TWO FAMILY �
�ATE 12-�-» MUL�'IPLE FAMILY
� �
� � n COMMERCIAL �
SCALE� I"= 200' NORTH � '� � �NDUSTRIAL �„Q
cw�►�r nw�.. .,. . ......._ -- - - - -