Loading...
01-302� � ,S `° i� �� � d L° a�' }� � / ����� � z ��COUncil File # 0 \ � �01 Green Sheet # ��0.�8'y By Referred Committee: Date RESOLVED; at the Licensee, Vue Yang d/b/a Hmong Vienriane Grocery Store (License ID No. 19980005111), cated at 469 Anita Street in Saint Paul is hereby ordered to pay a fine of $200.00 for the violation of�the sale of tobacco or tobacco products to a minor. Said fine shall be paid to e Office of License, Inspections and Environmentai Protection within thirty (30) days of the adopti of this resolution by the Council and signature by the Mayor. This resolution and the action of Council in this matter are based upon the facts contained in the January 29, 2001 Notice of Violation tter to the licensee and the January 25, 2001 Tobacco Compliance Check Form. The facts were not cqntested by the licensee. Requested by sy: Adopted by Council: Date Adoption Certified by Council Secretary By: Approved by Mayor: Date By: JN O A as Form Approved by City of: BY� � /�, �� `, �'>',,. � ' a�-Ywwl ��� V Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council By: A DATE INITIATED �' . 11 �1 March 28, 2001 - Consent TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES 266-8710 GREEN SHEET oer�uirort omecron �e-3a � No 11028�. MNIaWafe m.w.,ra FOR ❑ diYATiORNEY ❑ CRYCLFPK _ ❑ wuxpn�amxcFS mrt ❑ w�uxuuam�iaccro ❑wroxfoxasasrnxrl ❑ (CLIP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE) Resolurion concerning adverse action against the Cigazette/Tobacco License held by Vue Yang, dba Hmong Vientiane Grocery Store, 469 Anita Street. o� PLANNING COMMISSION CIB COMMITTEE CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION What, When, 7. Has this perw�rm ever worked under a corRmc[ for this department'7 YES NO Z. Has this pereo�rtn ever been a ciry empbyee? YES NO 3. Does this persorVArm possess a skill not rrormallYpossessed by any curterit city employee? YES NO 4 Is this perso��m e targeteE ventloY? YES NO Exolain all ves answers on seoarate sheet and attach to nreen sheet �ousa�°si �es��.�c�^ ��r�t2g ,��,�@ � � ���1 IF APPROVED OF TRANSACTION SOURCE INFORMAiION (EXPIAIN) ACTIVITY NUMBER (CIRCLE ON� YES NO �, .-,,; ;�, �...F : 4 .. � t �" �i �'�v'� 9 "� � {�0iYY0 0 � ZV9i} �`!'oF �fc:eF�1.5Yd�SVglpLSp�{��' l- :.�..�:` �{iL�2�13h!Y o� -3oa. UNCONTESTED LICENSE MATTER Licensee Name: Address: Counci( Hearing Date: Vue Yang d/b/a Hmong Vientiane Grocery Store 469 Anita Street Wednesday, March 28, 2001 Violation: Sale of Cigarettes to a Minor Minn. Stat. § 609.685 St. Paul Legislative Code § 324.07 Date of Viotation: Place: Presumptive Penalty: January 25, 2001 Licensed Premises $200.00 Fine Recommendation of Assistant City Attorney on behalf of client, Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection: $200.00 fine (first offense) Attachments: 1. Proposed resolution 2. Notice of Violation 3. License Information Report 4. Tobacco Compliance check Form 5. License information CITY OF SA1NT PAUL Norm Co7emon, May'or February 27, 2001 OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY Clayton M. Robinson, Jr., City Attorney � 1• s O� Civil Division 400Ciry Te(ephone:651266-87I0 lSWestKelloggBlvd Facsimile:65l298-5619 Snint Pnirl, Mimnesota SSI01 NOTICE OF COUNCIL MEETING Vue Yang Hmong Vientiane Grocery Store 469 Anita Street Ci0'�3ii>i i����',...^ "?°';°i ��t��� Q a 2Q�i Saint Paul, Minnesota 55107 RE: Cigazette/Tobacco License held by Vue Yang d/b/a Hmong Vientiane Grocery Store for the premises at 469 Anita Street in Saint Paul License ID #: 1 9980005 1 1 1 Dear Mr. Yang: Please take notice that this matter has been set on the Consent Agenda for the Council meeting scheduled for 3:30 p.m., Wednesday, March 28, 2001 in the City Council Chambers, Third Floor, Saint Paul City Hall and Ramsey County Courthouse. Enciosed aze copies of the proposed resolution and other documents which wiil be presented to the City Councii for their consideration. This is an uncontested matter in that the facts contained in the Notice of Violation concerning the unlawful sale of cigarettes have not been disputed. The recommendation of the license office will be for a$200.00 fine. If you have any questions, please call me at 266-8710. Very truly yours, ���ti�,�_ .� l� \ C �.�� Virginia D. Palmer Assistant City Attorney cc: I�Ey�`�nderson�Assistant Council Secretary Roger Curtis, Director, LIEP Christine Rozek, LIEP Steve Faust, Community Organizer, West Side Citizens Organization, 127 Winifred St. W., St. Paul, MN 55107 OFFIC£ nF THE CITY ATTORDIEY Clny'+on A 5irsson, Jr., Ciq� Aflorme}� CITY OF SAINT PAUL Norm Cofemnn, hfrs}'or W� January 29 , 2001 c;vu Dr.rs;a� 400 City� Hnl( IS tVesr Kellogg Blvd. Snint Pn�d. Nlirtnesotn 5�101 O\ •70a.._ Te1 ep h o n e: 651 266-87 / 0 Fncsimife: 651 29356! 9 NOTICE OF VIOLATION Vue Yang Hmon� Vientiane Grocery Store 469 Anita Street Saint Paul, Minnesota 55107 RE: Ci�arette/Tobacco License held by Vue Yan� d/b/a Hmon� Vientiane Grocery Store for the premises at 469 Anita Street in Saint Paul LicenseID #: 19980005111 Dear Mr. Yang: The Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection has recommended adverse action against the Cigarette/Tobacco License held by Vue Yang d/b/a Hmong Vientiane Grocery Store, for the premises at 469 Anita Street in Saint Paul. The basis for the recommendation is as follows: On January 25, 2001, a minor entered the premises of the Hmong Vientiane Grocery Store at 469 Anita Street as part of a tobacco comp]iance check. Tbe individual purchased a package of Marlboro cigarettes even after identification was provided and checked. It is a violation of Minn. Stat. §609.685 and Saint Paul Legislative Code § 324.07 to sell tobacco to a person under the age of 18. Since this is a first violation, the licensing office will recommend a$200.00 fine. At this time you have three options on how to proceed: If you do not dispute the above facts and do not wish to have a public hearing, you will need to pay the recommended fine for this violation. If this is your choice, you should make payment directly to the Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection, Room 300 Lowry Professional Building, 3�0 Saint Peter Street, Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102. The letter should be directed to Ms. Christine Rozek. Payment of the fine will be considered to be a waiver of the hearing to which you are entitled. Page 2 Hmon� Vientiane Grocery Store January 29, 2001 � t -�o� 2. Altematively, if you do not dispute the above facts, but wish to have a public hearing before the Saint Paul City Council, you will need to send me a letter �vith a statement admittin� the violation and requestin� a public hearing. We will need to receive your letter by Thursday, February 8, 2001. The matter will then be scheduled before the City Council for a public hearin� to determine what penalty, if any, to impose. You will have an opportunity to appear before the Council and make a statement on your own behal£ ' 3, If you do dispute the above facts, a hearing will be scheduled before an Administrative Law 7ud�e. At that hearin� both you and the City will be abie to appear and present witnesses, evidence and cross-examine the other's witnesses. The St. Paul City Council will ultimately decide the case. If this is your choice, please advise my legal assistant, Peter Pan�bom, and we will take the necessary steps to schedule the administrative hearing. He can be reached at 266-8710. If we have not heard from you by Thursday, February 8, 2001, we will assume that you do not contest the facts and wili schedule this matter for the St. Paul City Councii and have it placed on the Cousent Agenda during which no public discussion is allowed and the recommended penalty will be imposed. Sincerely, � �% ����� � Virginia D. Palmer Assistant City Attomey cc: Ro�er Curtis, Director of LIEP Christine Rozek, Deputy Director of LIEP Steve Faust, Community Organizer, West Side Citizens Organization, 127 Winifred St. W., St. Paul, MN 55107 a � . 30� STATE OF MINNESOTA ) ) ss. COUNTY OF RAMSEY ) AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL JOANNE G. CLEMENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes and says that on January 30, 2001, she served the attached NOTICE OF VIOLATION on the following named person by placing a true and correct copy thereof in an envelope addressed as follows: Vue Yang Hmong Vientiane Grocery Store 469 Anita Street St. Pau1, MN. 55107 (which is the last known address of same, with postage prepaid, in the Minnesota. / Subscribed and this 30th�ay � / /! ; `�� / Notary sworn to before me f-�7a��ry, 2001. rson) and depositing the �ates mails at St. Paul, PEPER P PAi�tGBORN tiOTARY PUBUC - MINNESOTA MY �MMlSSION FX.FiR£S JAN.31, 20� � � � 0 a x � W , O '� � C� � ;� o d ' V N a J Q a ' m _O i� I � N U C, 3 O', U' V', m 00 Iy i� �. I,(�0 � C IN � iC N � � V ' U Q ;-i.Q R � O C N N C t�.1 —,, O J Id � � O F � N IN C � U (6 J � _U a- — O � d N E •-- N Z � � � O I U Q> J'� � N �� � iF "O Z � � QIQ O I� V � � � W Z —Q I d �Z i�i I(6 � Z,� m'Z � I� J = N � Z'� O�} a � �_ � � N O' U_ W iN IC: �, i� �, � Z i �I� ; IN U IC N 3 N C N � � Z T C m Q � 0 U U c N � N C N, �I 7 Z: �� IpiN L, � a',.�� y''N N',N C , N. � � m'� � ', � � ,Z W _Id h C' O; a C' o' UI ..�. ci N, �I � O' U, N O L I �Q N� U ' °U 3U m �� , �, w�� � � I I ��, N � 00�� , � N N U Uy'' N ����m � O� � ' Or V N 47 C � V . QOV�VY� '� iV U N�(0 m�Q�U ,m oo�Qp�QtU'� � U 'O�� ' w N�OO ���N ,� O N @ C U O U � C C � 'C ONUF� �w W >��ajpoN@a� �m � H pU� O� U� 3�U � � •a ' od ma Cn U O N NLLLI p�N , (n ' C �- « N � _I C tIl �� z ELL Eaa aiU a Z O Ooo ��m i a Z � NpO00t�m � } Q N ..N�NO.��m U� NO ��f� �'� W N N'�6Na�M N O� �. ,� � O � W I� ln O 6) W ��'�N _Ofl.�JO0000 o�-�o� O�-3o d � 0 a x � W O N Q N � O d V N R ' 0 a o� _'O � O G Q.' C 0 A E � 0 w C d w c d U _! �i � N V c, � UI iU'i O 'O �' i� I � l' ~ d m r � �� x � N ¢ W , N � F y N � Z � � _ ' ¢�10�� �, . J V � � ¢ —'v � � N �� U � ` � U V � J —� � O � � � N ,� � N � � Z � C O U m J � O d' � w Z _a F y Z m iW > Z '� m'Z �'� _ 2 N E � (� Z Z O Q } a'� r- ��I a I , l ,io'', a, U I C � _ G '� '� Z T C � Q � O U U C m i� �. � I=, Z �, �,� 0 'a N V !N N y N � � C � � m � 0'� x Z F I� z _Id . U m c 0 U m C N W � � m � � � W � � Z �` Z } Q W N � `� N C O � C O' U C, N �, O' U N O a � t ��a o oU �Q m �U ° o� c�t '', (6 y V V y%'O Nds@U+�+ (n N N � � � � �L N U" !nY O V 47 y C � U U N C N� U Q� U E o� � a'QL U y y ooa....�� '�� �N�Oo�°��m C O V Q U C� N Q 0 o � ON� > (0 � � f/1 " �' �O� QC�O�+-U�7(J � • p�j pa m' UON`ytW p)� � ' C=... fn OJ � N O �p V O�p Z��EaQaiUo_ O�O�O y�� O"'�OOOLmm O NNNOO mm N V�EANN O\\ N'�Nd o�w��--�� I�u� O�OJ ._. O C�JOO COO v� -' � � 0 a x � W, � 'N � M IN � y IU� m ' .� R � a ' N � p '(4 N N � c,m C .U'� � �Q R E `o c d N C d U — _1 I � ia, :N' (�0 C Q � � �U y rJ �p _ LL � L � � � Q N � � N � � Z � Ic ° o V � �� 'O 3 N F N � �a �� � Z aao rn .- _v � O � � W Z _ ¢ H �IZ W m '> Z'�r m i Z � �O � _2 � � � � Z Z O'} (6 IL1J a '> U c, J O U U CI, N ,M 00 a� m � a Ill N C ' ` i �, �'' �I Z ;U ', O a U! C m �' CI �, � � Z T C � Q � 0 U U C m � Iy, c: �' �i Z', N'', p',W L'� a y�N p7 N c � . � � m� � U Z F�' W !a NI C, O a ol, UI � �� �I �' U I N i U � � — ��'6 O I o U U Q � �U ' i V' "O'O fn N I N � O O�� �O_(J VY� N � U � � � � � p L N U V �� I O ° a»� O C �U i Q O V� V Y� • d N U �UN�(O�p�Q�U �o Ew_`oaL � ooaw�� 'a�c ° co 00 0 �w � m U o �Q ° c�— a y °oVO� � ON VI • W , >>(0 ��N� 7 F ' p� O�� U� 3 U m �� , � L (n U O N y'C LLJ Lp N (n � C'� � N V J� N w Z ELL �dQ a�U n � Z � ' � ��OOOLa1m Q Z '' O m N N O O �� } O ' �' N V�69NN O�\ �11 N �I NaNd�c`�') y 0� ��, , o.-W��norn�m _'�N ._I00_�JOOCOO � � 0 a x � W 0 N O � '� N d :V � R J 'O a ; o� _o N 3' � ',mi O �', a :m � a > C V ' U O ��, •� � O C d N C U —,� J � Z a '� T '_ F:� IN N �.a U � �,� �Q •- — O � ac a , N E •- N Z,� � N ,O U � J'W ' � N �H y tn �d'H �, '�'Z � Q ;� o �!v ��r, � C7 W _a t- �'Z N W � Z m Z � � � _ _ N E m � Z i } i4 W n. � U C � O U U N � �o N @ 0 Q x W iN c IN �IZ : . 0 0 a a� V c ;m � IC im � N Z � c m n � O U d U C I� � 'c N A , j 2 '� �� � ° �n � N a� � N N N � ^ :� � � �'Z � � F"' W _,a y C O �', C O U w c � E; E o, U' N O r � �,�� O U tl ¢ (6 ... � U "o v t� m � C � C �w �, , ,i d Q V � � � , . �(�n N Y N U+�.. (A � � � @ � � O � N V'6 �Y ''� O V 47 yC �U �' U (�y CN� UQ�U 1�,6 EW ` o�aLU V� � �,� oo n.w � o ' `m c o V= c�EOo��: m �U p�UQV�N��Q ' � C U O V � - C C � i C O N UF- (4 a N � U 'N 11J >>Q a E N � � � O � C� O C� U � 7�U m � a�i • � od �a ln UON � y LW p�N ' (n —C�-...(n OJC4Ni (0 U � z �LL EaQ uic oa � Z(' O Q O O O d�� � Q O N O O O r� m ' } O � N"N�NN��� �, LLI N N'�ONd�M N O•� - ', � d . � o�w��n ornw _1 N '_, O n.�J00 COO o � - �-- OFFICE OF LICEDISE, INSPECTIONS AND ENVII20NMENTAL PROTECTION Roga Curtis, Dirrstor �� � � 0��3 CITY OF SAINT PALZ LOY➢RYPROFESSIONAL B(III]JING Telephanc 657-2669090 Norm Coleman, Mayor 350 St Pete Stre� Suite 300 Faesimile: 657-166 9 12 4 SainiPauLMvmesota55102-IS10 Web: www.cistpmeLmnru/[iep ""�� TOBACCO COMPT,IAL�TCE CHECK FORNI - YF,AR 2001 CN. DA1'E: J j 2 S � ol TT,�: �'- �$� LICE� ISE I.D. NU�ER: I.iAME OF COMPLIAlYCE CHECKER: 1M F NA�� OF ADULT SUPERVISOR: �� c.�,�•e–�.n,�`2�' NANIE & ADDRESS OF LICENSED VENDOR HMONG VIENTIANE GROCERY STORk — 469 ANITA ST ST PAUL, MN 55107-2332 � License Type: License # TYPEOFESTABLISHME*]T: \ n✓(>. Cigarette/To6acco �ess000s�ii WAS Tf� TOBACCO: SELF-SERVE?_ ASSISTED? Y �CHI��_ Wf�RE WAS Tf� MACI3INE LOCATED? bOES TfIE ESTABLISfNi IENT ALLOW MIlVORS? SALE WAS MADE: YES� NO_ BRAND � l.� , WAS AN I.D. REQUESTED?�,��o NAME OF CLERK: CLERK'S HOME ADDRESS ��� DESGRII'TION OF CLERK �e ,t-,n aSL� Qa:w— • bRIVER'S LICENSE #/ OTFIER I.D. TYPE OF I.D. �Y I.D. � AbSOUN'I' SPENT ON PURCf7?,SE: TF A SALE WAS NOT iVIADE: REASON (CE�CK ONE) � 1) LD. WAS CFIECKED 3.s� � 2) BUSIi�IESS CLOSED � 3) OUT OF BL'SIlVESS � 4) UNSATISFACTORY CONDITIONS � 5) DOES NOT SELL TOBACCO Revised Ol/2001 ��-3a�. Address � Licensee, CoMact) License � Cardholder � Type: C propeky �" Lice�see t' Unofficial C� All Street #: 89 SYreet Name: NI7A � SYreet Type: aAlb Diredion: <All> Unit #: �� CAy: <All> 170.33 0 �LEO NIEDORF .. E.__________ 25106 0 ;DOUA YANG 29952 0 FOOD MARF(ET GE ASIAN GRO� - A2 to �i. f26t1990 03I31t1991 469. NSt1992 03731f1 +0511992 03731 M 993�469 ; !7 6f1991 03731 M 992 469 �': ; ;GroceryC) Active LicensePrinted ;08N3M99808103(1001469. �.��� , __..,___ _ . 10735 3VUE YANG HMONG VIENTIANE GFAIarm Permd (NewjAciive_ 07N6M999 08�D32001 469, ' �----- ---- '----- -- � ----- - � ;False Alarms Active _ .05/0911 999 1 2/31 M 9S9 468 : ': " . �. `j ec • ..�..� a ' . _ , , . � - oa,,:.` .. , -_. � 0�- 30�-. '��-��������*� Licensee UEYANG T ypE -� p .a, -x�. _ DBA MONG YIENTIANE GROCERY STORE Stre Stre License Licensee � Lic. Types � Insurance � Bond � Requiremerds l SYre � Licensee Name: UE YANG ����; .�:' �� � Dire�z DBA. MONG VIEMIANE GROCERY STORE � Sales Tax Id: ENDING - Non-Profit: Worker's Com ONO+OOW � Und . � r p: � �� � -.�': � AA Corhrad Rec'd: OrD0�D000 .; AA Train'vig Rec'd: Oro0,D000 City: � � AA Fee Collected: Oro0rt1000 ; Discour2 Rec'd: r � O[her A enc Li censes Financiel Hoid Reasons GiYtieY t..,-�e-���b�a�i�`s�.�.`�"'a.��P z 1�ks���''�v���e�,��'� p� qti6 � �� �� �:., � � 251 Licensee Background Check Required f� License # 80005111 Save Changes to F6story _ _ �False Alerms Adive Mail License To: — �t� Mail To Contact t ( f'. License Address I ._._. __'_'_.__, .� - Mail Invoice To: ---- t�` Mail To Cor�act � � �' License Address � 991 469 . 993 469 . 993469, 992.469. ST�1'!.!! �. ;x�s-�� �.,����, . �, 001 469. ,- SN911999 12f31t1999�469. � .axf� ;, _ .., . . . . r= 7 2:04 d1-3�a._. Typf �' - . _ �� � Licensee UE YANG Stre �� `��'� """ DBA MONG YIENTIANE GROCERY STORE SYre � License —� Licensee j Lia Types , Insurance � Bond 1 RequiremerRs � S[re, ! C' Property fi Licensee C' Unoificiel i Praject Facil'rtator: ASUNCION, CORINNE �'., I Dire�t i Street #: 69 ( Adverse Adion Commerrts Und ' I �reet Name: NITA �� � � Street Type: ST Diredion: �— � ; UnR Ind: r� Unit #: r . . � Cdy: T PAUL � License Group CommeMs: "� Stete: ,�dN , Zip: 55107 �n52000 Failedtopacco compliance check conducted p � � y LIEP. $200 matrix fine. To CAO for adverse action. � Ward: R ¢ i Dist Council: �3 7l1212000 Passedtobacco compfiance check. SS —; ! 5l30I2000 Alcohol compliance check mdicffied thffi Licensee: UE YANG i Licensee DBA MONG VIENTIANE GROCERY STORE �` Comments: Sales Tax Id: ENDING " 8us Phone� 6511�a ; 1703: False Alarm 2510E' Alarm PermT Grocery (C) 2995'� � �� ; License # �8( _ ift { 08N3J1998 ': 08N3f2001 Save Changes to History � ( �[False Alarms Adive __ �''.--_.�___= N [ $2W.00 � �� 991469. 993 469 . -,�., - 993�469. 992469, : � _ � � 001 469 . 001 469 � 05109M 999 12131l1999 469 , � ':: " , .::. 1 '.. . � ���_� : _. �� � ' - ���} 12:oa Pr� License Group Comments Text Licensee: VUEYANG �BA� HMONG VIENTIANE GROCERY STORE License#: �9980005�11 01/25/2001 Faiied tobacco compliance check conduc[ed by LIEP. 5200 matrix fine. To CAO for adverse action. CAR 07/12/2000 Passed tobacco compliance check. SS OS/30/2000 Alcohoi compliance check indicated that alwhol is not sold here. LIEP to send letter. CAR 09/09/7999 Congratulations letter sent. SS 08/17l1999 passed cig compliance check. SS 01/26/2001 Interdepartmental Memorandum CITY OF SAINT PAUL DATE: Mazch 28, 2001 TO: Council President Daniel Bostrom Ward 1 Council Member Jerry Blakey Ward 2 Council Member Chris Coleman Wazd 3 Council Member Patrick Harris Ward 4 Council Member Jay Benanav Ward 5 Council Member Jim Reiter Ward 6 Council Member Daniel Bostrom Ward 7 Council Member Kathy Lanhy FROM: Peter P. Pangborn Legal Assistant City Attorney's Office RE: Removal of Item 25 From Agenda Deaz Council: Please remove Item Number 25, Resolution O1-302 - Concerning adverse action against the Cigarette/Tobacco license held by Vue Yang, d/b/a Hmong Vientiane Grocery Store, 469 Anita Street - from the agenda. The licensee has paid the presumptive penalty of $200.00 as recommended under St. Paul Legislarive Code §324.11 for a first violation of seliing cigarettes to a minor and no further action is necessary. Thank you.