The URL can be used to link to this page

269395 WH17E - CITV GLERK �/� � �' a PINK - FINANCE �� COUnC1I F�✓��J CANARV - DEPARTMENT G I TY OF SA I NT PAU L � BLUE� - MAYOR . Flle NO. Co il Resolution Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date RESOLVED, based upon the report of the City Forester and the recommendation of the City Attorney, the application of Mr. Ben F. Westphal for abatement of an assessment for property located at 2073 Margaret Street is hereby denied and the City Clerk is instructed to forward a copy of this resolution to the Department of Property Taxation. : , COUNCILMEN Requested by Department of: Yeas Nays Hoz�� In Favor Hunt /� ��e -S1__ Against BY Roedler Sylvester Tedesco JUL 19 1977 Form Appro d b Cit Attorne Adopted by cil: Date Certif P� se Cou .il tary BY y Approv Mavor: ate .IUL 2�2 1,4.�" Approved b� Mayor for Submission to Council By . � BY - P LISHED �UL 3 n 1971 � F S( � � ��1TY U �� °��g� �4, �'s /' �, ° ;�4`'�e� 'S �i r� =' x � 4o aiiiiuiiii � � a,a.a�s�.. ab CITY OF SAINT PAUL d ••� `�s ^O �e.r OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY July 12, 1977 HARRIET LANSING Rose Mix City Clerk 386 City Hall BUILDING Re: Application for Abatement of Tree Trimming Assessment by Ben F. Westphal 2073 Margaret Street Dear Ms. Mix: On June 23, 1977 your office received letter from the Ramsey County Department of Property Taxation submitting a petition for abatement of tree trimming assessment sub- mitted by Ben F. Westphal. This matter was referred to the Forestry section of the Department of Community Services, and a copy of their information and report is submitted for your files. According to the Forestry section, there are 10 trees located on Margaret Street between Ruth and Winthrop, and these trees were trimmed on February 18, 1975. r�ir. Westphal' s petition states that there are no trees within two blocks of his property. It is this statement of Mr. Westphal' s which is in dispute. Based upon the report of the Forestry section, it would appear that the Council was correct in determining that Mr. Westphal' s property was benefited by the tree trimming. If I can be of further assistance, please feel free to call. Yours very truly, � J J. E Assi tant City Attorney JJS: g cc: Paul Desch, Finance Department City Hall, Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102 612 298-5121 � j � _.r/� �,jr ��, . . �, . . `J �?�� . . �w � '!.'9.i�41Q� � �� ;_ �� ' � ° - ~�� C 1 T Y O F S A I N T P A U L 1 .;. ; ; --� DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY SERVICES DIVISION OF PARKS AND RECREATION t:.!��i r;i T:;;:`:',�� 488-7291 FORESTRY SECTION 1224 No. Lexington Parkway St. Paul, Minnesota 55103 Ju1y 8, 1977 �Ir . Jerome J . Segal � Assistant City Attorney Sixth Floor, City Hall St. Paul, Minnesota 55IO2 RE: TREE TRIMMING ASSESSMENT - 2073 Margaret Street Dear �+Ir. Segal: Forestry records indicate that ten (10) boulevard trees on Margaret Street, Winthrop to Ruth, both sides of street, were trimmed on February 18, 1975 . Enclosed for your information are: (1) Dai1y time report - by crew foreman indicating wark done on February 18, 1975 . (Z) Memorandum of May 25, 1976 indicating Forestry Maintenance Assessment Policy for 1975. (3) Council Resolution, approving the 1975 '�ree Maintenance Program. (4) Council Resolution setting date of Public Hearing . (5) An Ordinance providing for Tree Trimming, etc. (6) P�Iap of area (drawn not to scale) showing tree locations . If. I can be of further assistance, please contact me. Yours truly, � �� Lloyd A. Burkholder Assistant Superintendent of � Parks and Recreation � LAB: sd ` enc. cc: Paul Desch, Finance Department � - �e � � ' � • � i �. �.. � ' • • = � -� • ..i••-�•ii�- . � . . - �ar• �f / � . . . � � � . �.ir�`tT��/�/7s.� � /� �� > ! � . - .- - . � �. ��:.�� ' e ,i�l �� •. - — � . �i� �• �.� �- - . � �� '�i � � �� ► �i� � � `'I � �� -. �� • � � � �,_�! _. _ /�, , - � �� : I� _ ��_,_ ,� -_ -_ ��l1 f�liC� - 1� r � '� -..- _;� / ��J _.• � NI� � J � �� r �'; r_�'��— �� //�'�� - �� ° �� I � � / !. ' � � � � .,��i;: +� -�� / m�d�lf�.��'`�-v ' �� . , .� = , _ :� . �' � _-1 ,,j.,-��: � � I� ; 1!� � � � � � � � � � �� .�,__s� � �� . • � - - -- • �- ' - - -. iar. � , 'i � �. _ -_- - -,��►/ _�►..' ,�: l�i�' !� ' I . ! � '.. _ _ •' �./'� � �•�� •► . � i ' -! -- - ' - ! � :�'"�' �' - � / �:�; �% " ��-" ; lc . �.�. _ "% ' ,� _ , _ - . , , i /1 � � " � —�� ' � � " 6� g Qll l � �I�a rr �f��v � �. d �,�?��. Q.� � �-� � �� rQ��u�- � s� - �,��w� - :*G ,�� - �3 5 sa fi,��s . � ^ �l `� /a s G► �`.-�c �.------- � �� . � ,� �, � 3 � 6�s ti _._. �'"5,6tP ico� !__/„� � �t ct�� u vc� � _ � . � pe c� e Y'-scc� � � , � . � y- • � - 3 " J��cc'.s `r� � � . G_ � �fn c(4�c o% � � �. �G '' «s ti �� " ,�,sl� . . � �, �s�i �o ir�� /�'` ,E'/� _ _ � // K �I�. _- _lJ ��"��xe l�lf� � - j/'�i n 7C Gc �fi d 7— 7- 7 7 - J_R *,- . F�l:'t��.f`^�12� � C1T y ��1 s �� _ x � hY�iiiioiiai � 6 �'"��° ab C ITY OF SAI NT PAUL ��, ,�o �s.a OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY July 13, 1977 HARRIET LANSING Ms. Rose Mix City Clerk 386 City Hall St. Paul Re: Application for Abatement of Assessment 2073 Margaret St. Dear Ms. M ix: Enclosed is resolution approving the application for abatement of an assessment levied as to property located at the above address. Yo s truly, ��'/�`�— r OHN PAUL MARTIN Assistant City Attorney JPM:rl Enc. City Hall, Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102 612 298-5121 ��..�� l ,5��''- �°L., �--- t.� d WHITE - CITV CLERK PINK - FINANCE � G I TY F .SA I NT PA LT L Council � � CANARY - DEPARTMENT 1 � BLUE - MAVOR Flle NO• il Resolution Presented By � Referred To Committee: Date ' Out of Committee By Date WHEREAS, a special assessment in the amount of $23.30 was levied for tree trimming on property located at 2073 Margaret St. , legally described as: West 55 feet of Lot 15, Block 2 of Robert L. Ware's Eastern Heights Acre Lots and, WHEREAS, assessment levied was invalid in that there are no trees situated on said property, NOW, THEREFORE, be it resolved that the application made to abate such assessment is hereby granted and the Department of Property Taxation is hereby requested to cancel said assessment from the tax rolls. COUNCILMEN Requested by Department of: Yeas Nays Butler Hozza In Favor Hunt Levine __ Against BY Roedler S ylvester Tedesco Form Ap ved b City Attorney Adopted by Council: Date Certified Passed by Council Secretary BY � By Approved by Mavor: Date _ Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council By BY