96-1165 S���.�\--�-��.� _ 9 / � g( c�� Council File# `f lQ �� g5
I
Green Sheet# 3�3 g O
RESOLUTION
. C OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA �
.
Presented by
Referred To Committee Date
1 Resolution establishing a moratorium
2 on certain locations of cellular telephone antennas
3 WHEREAS, the Saint Paul Legislative Code currently permits cellular telephone antennas to be placed on poles
4 seventy-five (75) feet high in residentially zoned districts and in commercially zoned districts adjacent to single
5 family homes; and
6 WHEREAS, substantial questions have been raised as to whether the impacts of these exceedingly ta11 cellular
7 towers were fully understood when the current zoning amendments were adopted, and
8 WHEREAS,a study is needed to determine whether or not the City's present comprehensive plan and zoning code
9 properly designate whether cellular telephone antennas are an appropriate use for residentially zoned property and
10 those properties adjacent to residentially zoned property; and
11 WHEREAS,the Council of the City of Saint Paul desires to temporarily limit the establishment of cellular telephone
12 antennas within the City of Saint Paul until such time as a study of possible amendments to the City's
13 comprehensive plan and zoning code relating to cellulaz radio antennas has been completed and the Council of the
14 City of Saint Paul has taken action on the recommendations contained in the study; now,therefore, be it
15 RESOLVED, that under separate ordinance, the Council of the City of Saint Paul will direct the Director of the
16 Department of Planning and Economic Development to immediately undertake a study of the City's comprehensive
17 plan relating to cellular telephone antennas and submit its report and recommendations to the Council; and,be it
18 FURTI�R RESOLVED,that pending the adoption of an interim ordinance limiting the establishment of cellular
19 telephone antennas in certain narrowly defined areas,no permits sha11 be issued or granted for the constxuction of
20 cellular telephone antennas exceeding the limits established by the interim ordinance from this date and until the
21 expiration of twelve months as allowed by Minn. Stat. § 462.355, subd.(4), or until such earlier time as the Council
22 of the City of Saint Paul has taken action on the recommendations contained in the study; and be it
1
S �..bs�:-l�.��� - 5 � 4 � � �1 � �t� � ��,�-�
1 FINALLY RESOLVED,that the restrictions to be contained in this resolution and in the said interim ordinance may
2 be extended by action of the City Council for additional periods of time not to exceed an additional eighteen(18)
3 months in the event that such study and recommendations and the deliberation of the City Council requires
4 extensions of time.
Yeas Na s Absent Requested by Department of
Blakey �/
Bostrom �/
Guerin V/
Harris �
Megard � By:
Rettman �/
��e ✓ Form Approv City Attorney
By: -��l/G/ �-l7-� 6
Adopted by Council: Date � �,�`. � _ ,�q�
Adoption Certified by Council Secretary Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
By' .� . Ar���,..____�u: �'�� t�
Approved by Mayar: Date L� � r �' �'
By: �;�1 � �.e-��
°l`��1�1.s
c;�y co,�� °".9iiii�s° ,(`,,,�EEN SHEET _N_ _3 G 3 8 0
a �DEPkRTMENT dIRECt�R ITWJDATE ❑CITY GOUNCIL MIITIAUDATE
Councilmember Mike Hazris (68630) �oN �cm nrroaNer �arr c�nK
�L ENCA BY( ) �pp� �BUDfiET DIRECTOii �FIN.8 MOT.SERVICES pIR.
ORDER �MAY�1(�i A8818TANn �
TOTl1L#F OF SKiNATUR�PAOES " ' (CUP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SKiNATURE)
ACTION RECUESTED:
Resolntion pro�iting we consa,�ction Of ceuular tclephone antennas in certain narma►ly definea aistricts ana aireccing chac no permits
shall be issued or appmved by the City far the constru�tion o€aziy such antennas.
R��ro�'����°��(R� PERSONAL 8lRVICE CONTRACTS MUST ANSWER TFIE FOI.LOMIINO GUESTIONS:
_P�ou�NiNO c�lis8i0H _.Gv�.ser�CE c;oM�ttss�ON 1. Has nds person/firm ew►worked undsr a contract to►aN.deperan.M9 -
_CI�COMMI7'TEE _ YES NO
�8TAFF _ 2. Mae tt►is:plrwn/1hm ever besn a city employse4
YES NO
—����T — 9. Does this peraon/fkm poesess a skill not namaqy poetessed bY�Y��Y�PbY�e�
BuPPOR'ti'8 wH�tl CWNGL OBJECiIVE4 YES NO
ExplNn all yw�n�wen on ap�M�shNt ind�tt�oh to��wn�h»t
INITIATINO PRO�A��8SUE.OPPORTUNITY M�w.w1ut.wMn.whsn.WhY):
Cellular telephone tech�ology has advanced to du point where there will be a dramatic i�crease in the number of cellulaz telephone
towers erected in the City of Saint Paul. Current u>ning may not adequately address t�eight restrictions for these towers.
AD1/ANTAOE8 IF APPRONED:
Location a�i heights of cellular telephone antennas will be well planned in have public scrutiny an�d acceptance of zoning sta�ards..
QISADVANTAOES IF APPR�IED:
Cellular telephone industry will be reatricted from erecting 75 foot frcestanding anteanas ia or near residential zones.
, '
DISADVANTA3@8 IF NOT APPROVED:
The City cauld se,e a proliferatian of cellular telephone antennas that could be aa WIl as 75 feet anywhen in the city.
TOTAL AMOtlNT OF TRANSACTION a COST/RHYENUE BUD�ETEO(CIRCLE ONE) YES NO
FUNDING SOURCE ACTIVITY NUMBER
flNANC1AL INFORMATWN:(EXPLAIN)
Council File# —� S
O R I � � n� /� Green Sheet# 3�n�J�O
I V /-1 �, !
RESOLUTION
• CI OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA
Presented by
Referred To Comm' e Date
1 Resolution establishing a moratorium
2 on certain locations of cellular telephone antennas
3 WHEREAS, the Saint Paul Legislative Code currently permits cellular telepho antennas to be placed on poles
4 seventy-five (75) feet high in residentially zoned districts and in commercial zoned districts adjacent to single
5 family homes; and
6 WHEREAS, substantial questions have been raised as to whether the ' pacts of these exceedingly ta11 cellular
7 towers were fully understood when the current zoning amendments re adopted, and
8 WI-�REAS, a study is needed to determine whether or not the Ci s present comprehensive plan and zoning code
9 properly designate whether cellular telephone antennas are an a ropriate use for residentially zoned property and
10 those properties adjacent to residentially zoned property; an
11 WHEREAS,the Council of the City of Saint Paul desires t temporarily limit the establishment of cellular telephone
12 antennas in certain narrowly defined azeas within the ity of Saint Paul until such time as a study of possible
13 amendments to the City's comprehensive plan an zoning code relating to cellular radio antennas has been
14 completed and the Council of the City of Saint P 1 has taken action on the recommendations contained in the
15 study; now,therefore, be it
16 RESOLVED, that under separate ordinance, e Council of the City of Saint Paul will direct the Director of the
17 Department of Planning and Economic Dev opment to immediately undertake a study of the City's comprehensive
18 plan relating to cellular telephone antenn and submit its report and recommendations to the Council; and,be it
19 FURTHER RESOLVED,that pendin the adoption of an interim ordinance limiting the establishment of cellular
20 telephone antennas in certain narro defined areas, no permits sha11 be issued or granted for the construction of
21 cellular telephone antennas excee mg the limits established by the interim ordinance from this date and until the
22 expiration of twelve months as owed by Minn. Stat. §462.355, subd.(4),or until such earlier time as the Council
23 of the City of Saint Paul has en action on the recommendations contained in the study; and be it
1 �,�s:
P
.
q� -�� 45
1 FINALLY RESOLVED,that the restrictions to be contained in this resolution and in the said interim ordinance may
2 be extended by action of the City Council for additional periods of time not to exceed an additional eighteen(18)
3 months in the event that such study and recommendations and the deliberation of the City Council requires
4 extensions of time.
DRIGO ��q
�
'
Yeas Na s Absent Requested by Department o£
Blakey
Bostrom
Guerin
Harris
Megard By: '
Rettman
��e Form Approved by City Attorney
By:
Adopted by Council: ate
Adoption Certified Council Secretary Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
By: By:
Approved by Mayor: Date
By:
�:,
�"1 .,':
...t�� .i ., 4....,_
',-�.
�
1���{��`:�,�"'_ '� h+�'T � ' O -�
I(�
'1(,n�l C�5 �.,;
�:��.
;.� �,
- �:�
y�� jOLD ,� . ;yp .
.:t��l� ; P `CON � a. , pCClj ' N"..; �..���'
�� RAD N COO_:OR , �
�BW LO�� ��1�1N�,_D��E_XC ���;PU�;STER� a�`fl DRYWAt ,� O FENCE��' �
-�fi'�`::�$�,..+,s�z.'��-:,,�TzE' ,,,,y a'�', ca�rt�-'yi,f rr3r �r -'�e".�a--��. �#ua�, w.�
._. .�.., y�� � 'x� .i+v.�.y��p�`�..�ti� �"t�.�-r '� L�, '�w�:'''6� --�'�� t..�- �z,',� -�. _
. D;ADOi�:lON��Q'AL7ER��°,REPAI.R��;�:�MOVE ' �,D�IYRECK�_,,:-
'",:SIOEr <;'�'�o��,.:�xCf�OSS..STREET5�4�t'
f• x � x
r z,�. �H' �F.F..�3'y,.Y'�l.c'^�`�." a�„� ..:..� -r� : �s.�C��.� . �¢L,_'"+E"`b�
` �' ���i.i_�!;+�r�, � �+., a.''� '� { _3 1,.
O8O F !�I��.. �� ` L�c3 �.�:�,��::
_ =._WARD:' = "LOT. %.BCOCK�:• " '�"�i.. .;��z :..�''AODITIONOR,� AC�?�°.��"�"�='��. �:�
_ �} � _C,7�.(�Cl/���s� 3 _SfT`��?Z� le�.3
.., -
- :="WIOTH:w :�:OEPTH"x' ;;SIDE LOTCIEARANCE �BUILOING LINE=,"`r.
}�'-_- +. � � -'r�ca�c r - � ` ,a f.RONT • �REAR� ',
- LOT; �'�.� �"x'�'�'� � ° �= .�/ / �s^r / ,
.�r -.r h.t:"..��. �`�� -�: -•� � ..�� I�.r`�� "+-.w��./�i..l'..�
STRUG� x"� W�O , ; � ��L`ENGTHe"'q�'-� '�`�HEIGHT'X�,s;�.'� �STORIES,�i=
.�s � ��. ��.�rr � � �h,�� : ,"`�'"`„is t��� v �� -.�:s.�,,,°.Y'�y,v.,;�� X�N
TU R E,.,. �� �L,�.�.-¢ F.. � �. � ��f��� �'��r "� �°-r
���.�,� ��. �.::�t�,�.�.�: ���:��:t.. .��r.���� .�_��1��.���^
�.,
�;<BASEMENT�-'`�- ti;� '?�-TOTAI:_F_LOORJ\HER:�,,� ;��
. � -.� --�+ - o.- � r: X,.r � . .- -?-Y�,' { - x,�,^
� /�� ��y,�- ` ❑YES.�� NO� SQ.�FS,� ' •- ' ����-.�'s`e�
��J i":*`.. �. ��;�:�. ;�' -t,=�*'-��INCIUDE BASEINENT.�.'_:.,•.x..
-:OETAII.S d�REMARKS'-s:.aN�'r --: r�,..r r->..y.z-�z.�'.'�,° � -.�`a�,s-�..��se�r-,�.t?,,.�c��:^i=
_`1 '.= ■ ;t� -�`Y `�F., `� . �.E.� _ �a r w r��� �„t,�"
w,-cw-
. ..y _ -r' .J::i.r= E .'� 1.::34..� .., t ."k�.T'ei..�W"' �°.�"� ,`.'X"
: F
��
�� � �f:� . '�:h..�. �#rc . °ST;...�'i.�'�`i J.'*+.+.
�.,.-. r r .� �,-�, ^-�.- � ' �,.�s -�»,�,�,^"U� .���„7
4 �
-•�.�_ �y�,4 � � �,r. .��"` ,, ����
- a ,.2._`�a" _ - ''.".�.`�i•Y-�s �'1=}iirA2 x ,': e?s.;��- .�+� �, �?r_��� _
` ��; -��v;,�,� r ';,�x'� �: ...�� ,3."_?'.�'�' �i� k,`:-� i .:
�• �-'''=����� � " ��Kwa4r.:?14i��'�+� � '�"' ""''n
�a,s. �.:^,r. - e-� .c�^ �� !�'�'..<-.,.�.,x:
,'3� .�WC'.���.�i[.?�....� c!f _���v Y�`�°,��W
. .�y ir. -�.. . .. . . . . ' .. - ..
`"��� '
��� � �� � � � r ��
.. ARCHITECT. .'�°�6`. � :c � �' " ..��fi:.:��.--
ay''"a � � �r$'�.
�
���� 7: �.,�,r L�r-� � a 9z9�
s� ., :,� �.r .�,,� ��•r.,,,,.;.� .�, .:� . � +t��;
��.
�MASONRYa ��'QL�?�� ''' a. a �! �-��- `� ,�""�+�
�� . 'y� T +�:
a 1��M� E �/At1), TION
� ��
-
"�. .P N�CH C I;�
-
t,�
�__<
}:^..
�`,I ,u ' �,�«�y�, D
F. �.��.'•4.� � Psq.,
l'.y'..
„�- D ..+�., �1
�,K�. .L� P
�ti., FOR: S �
.:,;A '�
ti���.
�� .
l�t�
A�
�'.
��;.
._�a.yY _ � .,__ /.l _ .�. .