Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
270882
. � ' � City of St.Paul COUNCIL FILE NO. Office of The Director of Finance By REPORT OF COMPLETION OF ASS�SSMENT j[���DKXXXXXXXX YXXYX�(,�7t7t In the matter of the assessment of benefits, cost and expenses forao�t=ttcti0u/!!• coaatrncLioa ot sid�nralk� � vosic iacid�ntai tb�sato: t�tr�cC 75•N-OS98. Di�trict lto. Z� Lwy No. 13-A l.0. t26S873 • DI�lLL SZ., uia� sid� tso�.D�los it. to aorth 1S0 ft.+ (abuttlnf 1Z7 b 12S 1l�loa =t.) � To the Council of the City of St. Paul: The Director of Finance hereby reports to the Council the following as a statement of the expenditures necessarily incurred for and in connection with the making of the above improvement, viz: Total construction costs. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $ 667.47 En 'neerin and Ins ection $ 110.13 � g P . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Valuation and Assessment Services . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $ 13.35 Postal Cards $ .30 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Finance Accounting Costs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $ 1.50 Publications. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $ 1.50 Collection Costs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $ 3.00 8�t��d'aaxx� . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $ TOTAL EXPENDITURES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $ 797_25 � Charge to. . . . . . . . . . . . . . 09050. . . 4ft5. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $ 497.25 .............................................................................. $ Net Assessment . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $ ��n_no Said Director further reports that he has assessed and levied the total amount as above ascertained, to-wit: the sum of $ 300_00 upon each and every lot, part or parcel of land deemed benefited by the said improve- ment, and in the case of each lot, part or parcel of land in accordance with the benefits conferred thereon; that the said assessment has been completed, and that hereto attached, identified by the signature of the said Director, and made a part hereof, is the said assessment as completed by him, and which is herewith submitted to the Council for such action thereon as may be considered proper. Dated �ril 6, 1978 J. Wm. Donovan Valuation & Assessment Engineer 4 '.:,�� � t�w' ,4.� ' ,.i s,� .� �t¢ +5,,,) ,,�� f �r••:u �:t�.rY� ..t.M ` '�°. cs+ r -+� �, ?F "� �i.4���. s a ra � ,:`Y t''t . ' .w �'�' K '.- 'f y � ''7 . , ,�-r : /[,�� � � , �' � 4 T � �� � '�1 k�'�E'du �. �,v � f � . ` ' � Et' x �, .,,� � ��, z : �,�, � . � '" � ��aa' �-- a c�_ - a �d % _ • � � �.���a c "F. �,'�j� '���� y 3- �� r"` •�t�^ � 1'� � � ,�iZ'� d�.,y � � .._ ,.� .� � � 1 .:4 i� ; '� � � .:,� irVr � � '._ :a� �s .. r`r 4 - .. . � � �}„ .. �� ",� ..�u�`-�r ..- ',� :a y M < a a t � ' 3�-' "'`'' ^- � < � �x ,� -�... � rr t �k � ,: �.4 � 3 �' 'S� � $ G.. � .°�. y : . "'a 5 i� -���� ; . t'�F��• , � '§� � . .L '�`',y �. '�t�� s s� a �`^.h S Y :3- f? 7s � vriw S .[.� c 9S k S* 1 �as $ � a 9�?�- : .. � �1y � .-.rx� . e� ele �a� R�,, ''�dD �w Y n,� f� � � �� e. �� � t a�r; � , r �.� .�- ti;�`�.K :� ,F t rs��t +i .�+a� ��'�r4, ,�''�* _�''�; � �" �,r�4 � �x "? + r- �>§�s`�€ : . ���h,� �3 �S` �, -.�- �������'��r. �` �,' .• ,����a���. � ,d�..uR'�1'r2+�y}: � , �" � s � `� I� '' '�`� �e �'".y� p ,n Sr �4` A '� b " .. . �� ; :�>u w ud x s '�. Ma �+-!'a': x3,� `�'x �x. '�' ;.'� �..` �k'.'. R'�T§r '�t ��, g � ,;A��°' ��- � v¢� �'i ' . z $ a � ��t- ,�s� � ,�, 4 Y x "� a °x z �. � ��.f x� s44 z+z 3`^�s, S �i.����� t ���� `�*i � �� �r r�'� � � '�� 3 j� ~ � '� ��:a�z 3 � >���1`"� t"v '��t � �w ���,�.R £ � ��. � w ��� ��� �..��z���r� ��� ..�' ��4 � "a���.��'�,a �� .� Y �^ 'S. �s� ��"�.: � �. }�.�.: .`�q,� ���,�c�°���-�'� :,, �r a .h +.., 'N�. r . F �3 .. �``' ��� �°"a �� �:..f" �{���- � -.:.� : � ri;. ; 4t3 , n �;,..,.'.. �� . ^''��M. .y,''�;��¢ .�. c �,s'r �` �k r�> am�' gr��tu�"'c �"',b +� c=�r '� ��'.:. r ..�� .����e �rF � "'�`�at�.�" �� � ���.` t+.'r .��_:� }� L� $ ;�� "k�,��;. �� � `�� *�`�:� + i �� h t�' ���� ; ''�, at� �. ,�L�y�N Y '` r .!�� >> '=b�,y, � 'g ��y �' �� `������. � .•� K � •� � r,. �� * . `�r ��: 1.����� � � k' �L�'� �& "aY� �3 . 3 �, �k.._ �` r, 3" rR..+:. .�.r �, �v,. � `*�� C¢�.�,"' a �',-t � ��� �,* `ts�.A'..�. �`+.i� ,� a,�' ?"w �� s.. � 4�r �� -- '� �'.*��.4 n • a : ,�c ��� ` nc ; ' R � • , , �' � �a �F �, `� ��. �'' `� `� ' ��, b� "� ��e ;,'� y �:; �,.4 �a . < � � �, � � � `3c .�-��, ;���'�'4k �a+�' � � 7 F �' o , A ' � X.� A£ ,- '��° ' .:.4 ,y h� $ ' � a �'� � a .•�$"� � �H�� r� ���F'�4 .,� y�'� N : r . +�+ rl,� 4�t'�`.�ta x° �f'y 'a^f + X�'. ''� � � � : � � *�♦� a° � � �^Y'�i �:L��': ?K� �- k�S . i-'r f � .F._ t �i 4 ��.-'�. ''�'T` «! � � � � a� 3. '"£�+� � � ea v' � r �' ,� �' i�� $�,:d �. ihF' �z,s ~ '�§'3 � _ } �� r`r �`�{',k��� � a � �.'4 �` �s� 2-r.'��d'� -��'�"r C v.'d` a�9 9 p �._ w �i� '�' � �;� � i �'d. ... � � ; �.'l��� �. ` sEe* ,� .: ''} ,�,,� r�wa �7�k,:� � �i s '� � ^a,� 4:' a , � �; � .r-u,{ � s �, �,�, ,�� £j ti, `,.R '" �'•� ' �� � �t �� � g ,�" � p '�.�+� r G?'•C � .p � : �'J p:�, �'� ,,, t .; �� ``4 ^k, y � �.�n -. �, . yHl� �O r � '� P - ��- �. ; � �ta,.�c'� � �`�• � � '� r ' bF �� `'R'+ r �F y..-�y�F a a. �f���� ���g• y �r�' �} - a �yi� �� `. 3y�} : � � � � M'� �` v �°- .;� x�3_ �,: '�a.�j' t� d i.LEl,.[ � i- 1 0.'h41 � •t� i:`,3.Y"ti�lr �.:3 �.�£..� �. _ '—�..{�. t �s..:i..� �_ :.1i � `a'��.Sa . x_ �:;. =';� .,. �a` -. . m� � .. � " .�:. ,��.. .,�:� .. �� , . . ._::. ____ : � �.Tx. �,���. a The assessment of benefits, cost anfl expenses have been filed in the office of the � � ° == ;' Department of Finance and Management Services. Within twenty days after the order �' � �'_ ��=.. �A� `� adopting the assessment, or making a reassessment, a new assessment, or supplementa2 ,�r k�,'������� assessment, any person may appeal to the District Court by filing a notice of appeal ,����, � ; ��,r��; � with the City Clerk statiag the groands upon which the appeal is taken. Such notice �� � � ` shall be filed with the Clerk of District Court within ten days after the filing with r� ����- - the City Clerk. � '' �� � ,� � _ x � -�. , F.x . .s...:, �,c. € 5` a �p,�, ". . �r � � ` �z0:' � �� y.. �. � a I a � �i � ��r �'y.r � 3r� .�v't .d� R �} � a4 x<� ' �'' 'y, �- '�r�x.*� :� � �:? '�a* �i > � -'x � �'' �� r t � ,S� �.. �� � �,$a.y R.�� '"'�,�, r - � } 4-s�� r, � '�.- 'jT,�i�t-g �r� '�'&.'"r�a;a,r'r s `� � s 1'a ��r��.� �¢ '�'� z ri- �F `�``9 �� M� # � � �K �� � �� r 3 � � � , } t . v a fi'J+x �.,r �!'� „"��.,#' �yrK p�^" '�v �, �,� ' �x . � � t. ; � "' f "+ ar� 4 € � �n�y k���+yt 5 t 4�'� -Tr ,. � r'3�. g` t�"��i ' SiY �1 �1 ,y� �. 'sp:;� ,..�k:�.' �y ��4a ��.er:T Q�°�.y�5 '`r+'C���a�i . � � � ��� � ,'` � s.: t r Y fi� , '�? �R3+� ? � '4 � �' kr�C M: ,� M��s ' : d " ..s � > x: 4, �" � .:_� • : �.' '�' �: r � � �.ss: � �t s �,, � � � � ���'�x � � 1�s � : ^�'i�' �>� Px'�' �. +�" s. : ,,d}��`�t� �!, � '� � � � "•��,.� ��` � . .c ��.ras r ha h,� t t �� f�. �F : a �, �Y 4wE`� �..- � ��'�'i� � ',�,� i #3�� t ' t.a - -. +� ' a r t .: y..a '�` e � � �'� � 4 �; �'e -`�:�� ����� � �� ��� r '�a.-� � ��. ,� : '�"� ��k '` r`�it � � � �. � '.��'�T� � �` �° � � ��'h s :_ �, S y�'��� .r ��� '�i i r ;'� �.� h ., "�fN'�.� y.:, �,.� `� � ? . �,�,�y �� � '� ' r'`'a�, .x, � f � 3K �y.��'R "j.�� � �• '?3-��t � ?` axk"���� .� ''Y � f�r"1 4 �'y� �r �'�y . s ,''c . �r�, ,r x p �' � f � '� .. �, �. +�,,�,'# �,} su N - c �-r � �, n �� � a�s ±�-t �K x �d `�` � 9,.� �i��� �.�a'z ��y- ,k�L"' � ir,� F#�°t�(�.'; �¢ � �yl� ��t.�` > I�p�{^� cN � 'tT� ! { . '1 f� .+P- `� -"V'�kl'. .F- � ''�K A'M1 i V+ 9 1�3w�./ �` �4' .'.,� a' �+s'c� = K 'a� `-� � �"` � `�cr.�Q-w�, 9� s t5 ��Gg�. {� y�i.�AY�, � � ,��+ � 4'. �°Fta�P� � s° � �.:. i4 :.S �f'.�� �i .... � �_(�i � �h9r�. Sl�y .A##��� f'p'4y'� �,�qt'�F C',� �l .:� b Y.! #� 4 ,;f k i�v&9.� .,� '�F{ @ �v."fi, �f �"�, �% s ' d'!,y, .� s � ,�� �.ev� 'i^,�,- , :�s� ,. 7 4 'c,,."'� �`� � � �a�� m �":t�' ��°�.��i+��'�' ,� a�,� 3'r.. :��` �,+ , .� ; . . ,� .-� i K'l t �?' i�:� { % • C � 4 A � �N �R�:�c � � A" � F �� �5� �'�« R�sii `�` E ._� a. } ,. +� y , f #'�`�¢ � {� �.:tl � �w,�,, t�x ti �& 3 �� i. �,'����:y ��� �..�� � �x� y �. H � l 4s�R �,�s � T�s x 3 : d'ti � �py� -E x r �{x � ,� .h �.t� rl.. �4. jr7 +8° #� ! K�'�]q . '�# '°.,� P.� °i,.t�a 3T� .. .. � ���r t �.lx� M/�°'+�. ..� � rt�''r�r �;.s R �� �' " .� � �'"�rti � `� � '2 .,�,��t - r . '� �, r - � ,,, �. �� y ' f : � 's� F� � . Y a i� � �. t.�i J x 14 �3�a� � � _ � ,ti� i � ° �".���, � t� �� � ,, �" r,,� ',4 �o-�„yc s : y'Y�� a � � 'h�'�' '` `Y•R*,t�',�'* wq'������ Fr �� �,� °r . �x ���a. ; d` #' f a .P, x�,y z �:�`c,�f'�{ 3 .�°s a �..s�,.�ps`i ��^t' i s � '� �:�'�- .� * �.t��;,i�'° �.,tx � .,2 � t' � ,1�"r".�'4��P � , � '�'?'�£�,r.�'"�`} ,y�� � 4s� � ' , ik ^f .,� � 1>c�� y_ �i Z �t ,��r��`�' a '� '�'t,��. y ,�'/'- s*' ,;'r£ y� �� r n.y4, '��*,;?��r �. ,a`� � ���+ c�, ��'�" .�,.,�.�+� rt°'"-��' ��� «'. r f .-.-a z�� y� �x� :. .I"' �;_..�� •� � � ��� y�R��� ,�. ��.ad R�, � �' ���k� *�i+"F''�� x,YZ���X`S '��'w>` x '�� �,�1m.�,�� ,�'� ,� Y ,� � �; o- �, n � �` 'c s�fi '° M�w `f�.�' � :��, �, - � � ��k .kt,;`� i'5. zz�'����y � �'`+ir ���;..r t„c � {�a �r�t'�h #' � ��{��i`ee '�. �, '�'�.: x .a'tt'� �.���1� wv w. y�,a � r�-� -,t�' �����' 3 ' a 53 ,�. �� ,�,,��-s'� ��''�;��=i`a tc#�# � �r +S z,a -� ^�w:�� � ; F ,.,•� �� '�`.�'�. y '�� '��"� �y���' '`�a °i��, , h� } '� .,:y�. Y`": ^�.,� �,2'��;����°F���e�.�.t�'� � � 7��., €'y: e,. 4i��?r^...� �Y���,y � � t r�t+�,,�^ a �,+r� �t e.. t��a t t M'�y } '^X'� F �,� �.'""- �`* � � w � ��k' ss> .����'d y3 t�� '� ,y� 'r�K � � r-r .; s � �r`,�, �, ,.'r ay � x.:��g A ' ; �',� "t� �y °� s8.�, .�� Y' ;# � � a `rt F �• 4 � . �c J �:r �.. � ,� �v ir .� �`.* � .:c �i'y i v` � `r`" ��,,�e�. � .g +1" s'� :� `Br � t.,�?�°�'�.:.a�j : v� i+�;z � �' , .� .ar,. .�:k ,�.± � �i ; �` a-* h �y�^� t ,� ,�� y"� `Y+ �„�'j� �w^,�,i'�°��+'�, ��t � �; �# .. 4 Y �., � � " �,s F . � tl ' .] y. �� . L q` w � � g"p�"� � � T' * � � �r a y; a �;.s.'��r �`� k PS ° � .. < _ f�r ,�a ..� � �,�,'�,Ft,�.�wJ'ki � d .f''._� �. �*:� � kt l 'L�`� t:� ��' � �• � � 'a � �,�� ��`�., r s ,'a t«+.iia 5 -�I f � � � �'& �' $r� ` �"^ �� '� : 'r,�2{�&f'� F . ,�. ,( ��} � �L t .=���� � M'�.�'v�ve �, �..�y �+@ �� � � ' P•kw €'a 1 .�.{ � � 1� �b ��,;� y'h ' . �r � �. �� .ri �� �' �'� 1 S n, qSJ ,�y�d � � 51 � n�� �$ ,5��'!� �a.�'l '� y � �' _ .iyeynf� Y.� ��.. ��. �� �'`� *,.i�dy' � �'�M' `. ���-w. `F' �1 � � �'1Fw° .��`dK��.., ,��.r.%�, ., n.,g� v.'�-��i�;°`� �' ��'� t �. a�., z ��$' � y �-�A �,� 7 ,�."'°r^���, �_ y '4,ap tl f ,; ,�� ^t �k.�„ r•�" a '., � `Yt" �f }�"j'w ' ° � �tii� A. F �.,r� T�$fY.� �� a a y i ... �-� ;' � yw r.. ��. - _. h�r r t��' k y # { .�*�S "',�4 ..s. ' ;� «a'+$ v w� �°'3: �?�fi '^�, i;+sr''1 �rn;� � � , �s�, � � '���°��t�,'�r,•f+w� �'" ny a., s x«� w' ,�, �5 h a f r .� � ti�-'� ��-t�. �t L i E ��r;.:� ��y�°� tv���.� }..� � q.-� 7 �},� ``�"'..� � '� �� �. r? � �,� �, `A+l � g'�`„�t t3 s. } ��:- .3 �7 a'g"� t�,r � g� � � . �,�£ ��,.,� {� �S� �: ^� �: �� ti� ti 1As:7F ��'�Fb'�� wa�'�at�'ti x� A':� � � a�`;.�-y�a..a��� �y,;' �..� if T. � �,y"��, l � .'*�i 6 . . ��. .. ,. 'Yu :- �. : ,�" �; : �+ � is+ { #-�,� �.:� � :: �^>�. r i' � ��., s `,�* "+� ��' � .,.� _ �'t ��. � . ti� "A'"�' �t .�+�����'r�:� �' •,� a ��` sr..�' # t"'�i"� '°' u *� a Y y 1 :; �.,a "�� ,i` �.>'Y'Y�,,�'� k�.�'' �` �`�- i ..°''�t.� `��` +''?.�.`'�"�' �'�r',1.��5 r- aFw ' {�' `p�@i'�°�3 '�d g ��. P �'a r _a,�' "� � ;'', ; � '1µ. a,s�"� �'��r"�,. ;�a+A"��r y�•�,�� � � � . _. . � � � f�: �c "�F � ; �� �r;_�`.y�.# AY 's` �'*s;��'�rR � ,�«c� W.�r �, �4� �:' ���t �.� ��*'�'��'�^� �r � �.� � ?�`�,�. �..�s 4q���3��5c "�..�� '��a 's�'' �.�'a�t �4� � a�,'�. �- }.� rr F"` - ��1.�. �: '�- k -` a'��x '����'�' � a �� �� , ���r �� c 4 +�a ,. .` � r s ' � ,C �. +-� -�' �`s��, #�A""-k S� __.; i+�{'�'�! �A�"ryh+ � t d �, ,� d-'•��� d. ��f � c " �" r ..x �, * -_ ��. ; t''�t R .. `#r a '4w'�. s, ',a '� * r et 4 ,. *',X $ � ..� �s y� �r,F' d c ' y g. . - . , i �A' 4. a � �.� � :�a . 9� �`�'yR , ......, ..�a. . m.. .. .., r� ,., .�,., , r , � � ��°�2•.ef � : � _ ..sr . s°- � -� •.; h- k .:�x.,.s,� �` .�.,.�.¢> t��.sF`�r_ � .� �.. . �%.'.Y�� . .� . . _:G..�`�..i'ia. 'r�..'�._� . s fir+x..Y: . . , . : , ; . , . , , _, . : � . . , • � , .; . ��� _ ?� 6�'g _ � , - _ . :�: . . . . . .. � .; . - , �, \ � � , , _ , , � � . . , . � . . .. _ _ . . . ., , - _, ,�. _ t . - . _ � �.. . � . . . � �-�� . .. ��. � ,, . , . .,. -. �. , ��..- . . ,_, .r ��. , . . � � � � � t, � f � � ,e - `. ..' � - � � , �. . . . .. _. . . . .. . , j . , , .. . .. - ., . ,- �.. . , . .. . ..� . .. � �: . . - � -. ,. . . ... . . . � .. . -,'_ � :'_ � . ` . ' + �. . . " . . . .� � . . - . i. ' . ... � � . . , � . � ' . � ' .. � � i . Ap�.� .�, l4'1li. - ,, - - � � , � �; , . , � - : , : , � ' k � >- �, , . . , , t�. � _ • - , ''r . � , �� � . . . � ..P.: f � . ' � , ',... . . .'. ".:..;_ �. . . . _ . .`- .. �.. ,. ,��r ', � HI:'. �+Iqcd t�t'�r2��� �1r�lw��'ii' ' ,, . , . . . ���".a�r. �,� �����., , . fi R+�`�x�3� ���t�t�:"�a� , � . �5�. ,P�:.''l��teo�a� . �rwc ��: `' ,, , , - �. . �-.?�t�► t�bMmd� rs� s dat� a� t+�AsKtet�°.#�ac ;�"��,,, �1� �i i�s±�� �; �: . ;�►��±�iri� �:+a a�l . _ wrw�� ,� , �,.y� r� d 4 � ,�,�.�4 � � �"� � ����t�: ��i��,'�!- �� . . : . ' ' ` ,, � . �':�`� ���iF��'��-�ti -���`�i�l.�� � :��^��,y,�. � � �#.� � . � � 7� �� '�.'�'���'��`�'���� +�'/1 f , ,_ . �. - ; . ,.. . _ - . _ _ ,r. . .. �.. . .- ' � . -- .. � . . . . - �� . .3r,7 �'�'1 � � � � � � ��� � �� - , - . � ' I . ,:r.. �. , . . -� , , . _ , � �. ' �' ' " ' � . �. �_ ' �A�l,sda� ;: , �. , .. , . : . ,. ,. _ ;` , �r -�e i�arics D�t�. . . , � . F , � 1Rslstae,tod E�t ;' a , , . � . 1. * ., . . , y'�.. , _ . . �.. . . . . �. . "_�.� , '.�: ; . ' . ,. .: :: ..: ; . . . . . .. '.� ...'.' ._ . . . �. � ,.. � y . :. . '�... ��i � . �. d ' . . ..-. '/ ' . . . ' ; . ' . . s . . I?�, . .. , � . ... '. ' . ;: , . .:'.� .. .. . . . .\. . ' � . • r .. . . . .. . �. . :, ,. . , , .. � . , . � .. . 1: r.. ': �. �. :. .... . . , . . ., . �: . . ��. . . :. . �_ �._ '.. . ....' . , . . . � .. ',- .: _�S , . � . . _ - ' ^ ' t :.. , � - .� . ; � . . . _. . .,. . , , :', ,� .., "ti ' ��. � . . . �. . � .. - '. � � ` , i ` � , R� J :: . . . . � � . . t� . ' {� i..-. ',.l %e . :.I .:� t.' "� t� ' . . � . � . .!` � mw.r . `� . . . - ' . � ,� ; . i .- . � . ' . - . . _ ',j �,'�t,_�+ w i � F , . ... . ... . -. �, ' ..,-� � �. -.�� ,. � , ' � .. ... � . . �_-. . ' � � , ��. C p ,�� � � G �. 7 � ��� �� � ` • CITY OF SAINT PAUL DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE AND MANAGEMENT SERVICES DIVISION OF ASSESSMENTS AND VALUATIONS To: Robert Sylvester, Council President and Members of the City Council From: J. William Donovan Valuation and Assessment En�ineer Date; Ma,rch 30, 1978 Subject: Sidewalk Assessment for Stephan p. Shubick 127 W. Delos (Bidwell sidewalk construction, Contract 75-M-o598, District No. 2, Levy No. 12) On March 7, 1978, the ratification of the assessment for Mr. Shubick's side- w'alk wa.s laid over indefinitely pendin$ an investiga,tion into Mr. Shubick's cla im that the new sidew�a,lk is too high at his driveway causing runoff to build up in his driveway area. A viewin� of the area by Finance Depaxtment and Publ.ic Works staff shawed tha.t the sidewalk construction was done properly. Any ponding in the dxiveway area is due to large areas of concrete driveway which have broken up and settled over the years. Survey eleva.tions taken shaw that the sound portions of drive- way at the garage doors are hi�her than the new sidewalk and that proper drainage is not possible only because of the severely deteriorated driveway. Ftarthermore, if the sidewalk had been constructed at a lawer elevation, it would probably have resulted in dama�e to Mr. Shubick's property to the south of the driveway which is somewhat higher tha.n the drive�way. Based on these findings, this of`Fice recommends that no damages be paid and that the public hearin� on the ratification of Mr. Shubickts assessment be re- scheduled For April 18, 1978. � ���� j . 1 �"'\. JWD:MJE: t�tn �� / cc: Paul Desch H�.rtley Thomas Telephone612/298-5317 286 City Hali, Saint Paul,Minnesata 55102 n �, i f. �;. ti�, ( ` - , y' 1 � x ` ' ��'r R j � t `'\ � r� � t e � ,�� t � 1, C��� ti, ��ti� . . i . . _ . . . . „ �,�� 7� r `;j . ,' ' , . � �,�,. .. ' ��� � �. i � . ` •� � � f��� � ��, �a � �` �� �, � `f t- '1 1 i'" ` �' `� � a �; � A t � r �;f _ ' ��A� t` + I �1 ,�`r� '` . .. � r� - r,� �7� . � . ' � 1 ; '. � �, ,+.. ,{, � � � , } F �� � . '�:. -. . ' � � y _ /� 1 � � J �` ��/ � •y ,� � t �' . . ' { ` � �� � ,� ! r _# I a . ` . 1 4 � , . . . '.�. .:i�� � r<�x� � � -�� ! � _ � s ` +, f K , �; y �, :� , , ,. ,,. . . , �. , � .L•. Q' .. � ,I t j". , t � � , r . � . ' " � .� . . , ,- ;� 4 ;. � + ��`�.2 #'�, I�►'� '� ,, ` k�� . . k . . ' ' F / t 1 � �' . ' , ., . , h' } '/ ' �I; , � '.� �, , ; �.�. . �. � � . . �. . � . . , . ' , . ... .- .. � .. , .�'. ,� • . � - , � , � r .� ' °M�� Ha�'d -t�r]sc�,r,'.3�i�e�to� , : � < , � „ , , � 1, `.�'�tr a:�� �t� �t �!d!t.8iI►�iiasi� � , � �' Y , �p r� 1, � � �� �. ���� .i+�,�`�#�� � - I ; ' ,� i � I� ; r ' 3, : , � , .. . . , ;$�� ��'�. Mi'�ns.Sb'�B. , �� �'���� � � ,, i v � ' �Y��'s r. , � , . �� � �i � ? �� 1 , �� , ' �",�1��aC'tC� ���.-t0��► adOptt�a���e>,�' �1t�l.r�1:�ra��ti� aa�+�►!+�'��ty;����. ��'�:. , , � � . ��i � �'� 'e�i�reeli� ��s�i���os,` G�o�aeaas����'�-�►fl��t3� :���'r��.�a� '��� �v� 1�. �-��«�fa,��; _. , � :� ' .� .+i�t'�.+�rs3�r���!�.��r11y�� +�pit"t .eiii+� ����o�ii �r�� t:0`��t�ri,t�L tb;�1��:l��k°t•��� Ftr�.�' ��'�la+��►t �� _ � ia�atia� s�s �.ac�t�et.�`�oma�d� .�d� ,t�►�r a�s�pr�rir� ��a►''x� �p�e � t, ��'';c�P�tr't+�'• � , ' � „ .t .i . ���,'�"�i '"'*"�'�.�I��� :,+ � r � r � i � �._ � �� ,,�y � lu . . !' � ! 4 i t � ,- � � t t� t�� � � :� + ; j {� - r t � f• . .. \Yi.itp �lF4�i�ir 1 I � � } .����. " \ - � Y / � .' t f ` b ` 4� ' � s��'1 '���,�, ' ��� � . A�` 5 ��� _ �� ' � ' . } � f} ky u�q . !�� 7�V4iLi ��!� /. , t I l , , �. ., _ . . , . , . . . . .;. � . . . '� _ _ . . . -. . . . <, � . 1 . /, s /.: , � t , f � � s ' \ � . / � '-t ;�`� a " yx� ., , ;' �� ' �Y- �� `���_I ; r ,,: ��.' � � t E� ��' J n�'� 3. �� , . . . � i 7E h t '# r + '^i�� . � � �� � � � t � i a I � � � � ' ° � �� ,� � ����'�� t , ' �t 1,' � � �� , � ��r� *., _t 1- '. �`a,� � , � l �^•s � r . . :1 / 5 4 j 1 ,.� ���` � � � . �^ r.'4� 6 r t` y F � �i��. r. � .�,, ,.�,1t,� .. ♦ s •.ik'..,d�"s . . . . .... . _t �,{:..,, . .. . � ... . i.. ,-�f ,. .�. .. ... . . ..�:k . 'i ..,. af,.:�.d .. . , - . a ... �z. . ..