The URL can be used to link to this page

271709 WHITE - CITY CLERK � COI1ClC11 .�� f��j PINK - FINANCE BLUERV- MAVORTMENT � GITY OF SAINT PALTL � l J - -, - File N 0. ' ��nCP, Ordinance N�. �(!>�� Presented By Referred To Committee: � Date Out of Committee By Date An ordinance amending Chapter 60 of the St. Paul Legislative Code pertaining to zoning. , THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN: Section 1. That the zoning map of the City of Saint Paul, sheet number seven (7) , as incorporated by reference in Section 6.0. 401 of the St. Paul Legislative Code is hereby amended as follows: The property owned by A & D Realty Company on the • east side of Gary Place between Iowa and Hoyt Avenues and more particularly described as Lots 34 and 35, Block 6, Hillcrest Center Addition, is rezoned from R-3 to P-1. � Section 2. This ordinance sha-ll--take effect and be in foree thirty (30) � days from and after its passage, approval and publication. . C4UlVCILMEN Requested by DeparYment of: Yeas Nays Butler Hozza In Favor Hunt � Roedler � Against BY Sylvester Tedesc Adopted ouncil• Date SEP � 9 t978 Form Approved by City Attorney� i Cer ' ied P d by ci cretar BY � s Appro ay • ate 2 � 197� Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council By BY . �� ,� + , � C{4� � � � Oil, Chemical and Atomic Workers , . � ---. InternatTOnal Union � �, � .,�. � �. �--� 923 EAST SEVENTH STREET :;r��-��" 'e NICK KOVACH, PRESIDENT ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA 55106 PHONE: 774-5943 . .',1 YM��+ti� . LOCAL UNION fr75 / ' 1 A- -_ w wv� July 18, 1978 s. .. ; , �w, � �� n. .. i irr fi .� � 3� r•� JUL 2 1 ?�7� �� 1V�►:QR'S C3�FlC� Mayor George Latimer City Hall 15 W. Kellogg Blvd. St. Paul, MN 55101 Dear Mr. Mayor: The membership of O.C.A.W. , Local 6-75, would like to go on record as being opposed to the rezoning of Lots 17, 34, and 35, Block 6, Hillcrest Center Addition from R-3, Single Family Residential, to P-1, Parking District, for the construction of a parking lot. By the time you receive this letter, you will probably have already received petitions from that neighborhood and other interested parties. This Local is confident that the type of mandate that all those signatures represent wi11 be more than sufficient to influence your vote. We, however, like to leave no stone unturned. We are confident that our friends of Labor on the Council will vote the right way. Hoping you do, I remain, Yours truly, � ` � ��:�= � Nick Kovach President O.C.A.W. Local 6-75 NK/mj �,.�o � � , ��.� - � � �'7�.'7�9 �� • � ��-E (� � riarch 26, 1977 Ms. rlartna Norton Chairperson St. Paul Plannit� Comtaission 421 Wabasha �t. �'aul, Minnesota 55102 Dear Ms. Norton: At the March llt� 1977: �eneral meetin� of the Greater East Sici�e Community Coun�cil, Actio� was taken puttin� the Coaru�nity Council in opposition to the proposed rezonin� of lots for Hafnerss parkin� lot. It is the feelin� of those ir�volved that� at the present time� this actian would be inappropriate. If there are any questions please feel free to ca]:1 our office. (774-2599). Sincerely, ,�' ' . /�C�.-,c.�, . "1�f�� ... -r_,��:/�i r'- Karl Hozicevif�h Chairman Greater East Side Comtmanity Council cc Nlayor Latimer City Council Donald L. Spaid !� 1 �3 �' r 7 � � � I �� ,� S , r' � . A & D REALTY C0. Page 2 2. Land use conflict problems have always existed in areas where housing and business uses meet. Housinq interests usually have been infringed on. 3. The location of the site in relation to existing comme�cial development severely limits its marketability for future single family housing. 4. One of the intents of a zoned parking district is to provide a buffer zone between incompatible land uses. �. Without any site plan for review showing intended layout and aesthetic controls, it is not possible to comnent on the impact of such facility / �.57j upon i ts surroundi ngs. (� 6. A plan is being prepared by the General District planning process, one of the issues being land use and circulation conflicts. This plan is anticipated to be in draft form sometime during 1977. G. STAFF RECOMMENDATIONS: Designation of the site as a P-1 district restricts the use of t e property to the parking of automobiles. Overnight parkinq and automobile maintenance are prohibited on P-1 facilities by ordinance. To change the use of this property to any other use would require a new petition and another hearing. P-1 districts abutting residential property have the most restrictive standards for parking of any district in Saint Paul . While granting this rezoning may increase interest in similar actions on other properties in the area, each case would be considered on its own merits. The use of this property for any of the purposes for which it is now zoned is improbable. Staff recommends approval of the rezoning. r`1�^ �=c�� '! v , r � � PLANNING BOARD STAFF REPORT February 17, 1977 Plat 1„iap 34 8084 i, APPLICANT'S NAME . A & D Realty Co. 2. CLASSIFICATION . � Amendment � Appeal � Permit � Other 3. PURPOSE . Rezone to P-1 4. LOCATION . East side of Gary Place between Iowa and Hoyt 5. LEGAL DESCRIPTION : Lots 17, 34 & 35, Block 6, Hillcrest Center Addn. 6. PRESENT ZONING: R-3 � 7 . PURSUANT TO Zoning Code Chapter: 64 Section: 210 Paragraph: 8. STAFF INVESTIGATION & REPORT: Date: 2_8_�� By� LJJ A. SUFFICIENCY: The applicant's request for rezoning was filed on a long form petition. On January 21 , 1977 the Finance Director determined that the petition was sufficient. The City Planning office received the letter requesting review and recommendation from the City Clerk's office on January 31 , 1977. B. PROPOSED USE: The applicant is requesting rezoning of three lots from R-3 Tsingle fami y residential ) to P-1 (parking district) for the purpose of developing offstreet parking for business uses on the west side of Gary Place. C. FRONTAGE & AREA: Lot 17 has a 37 ft. frontaqe on Iowa, and Lots 34 & 35 have a combine 88 ft. frontaqe on Hoyt. The depth of all 3 lots is 125.5 ft. and the total area is approximately 15,688 sq. ft. , not including alley right-of-way. D. SITE CONDITIONS: The entire site is vacant. Lots 34 & 35 slope gradually up to t e a ley an presently contain a large mound of debris or soil near the center. Lot 17 is about 5 or 6 ft. higher than the alley and is relatively level and landscaped somewhat by the abuttinq property owner. E. AREA CONDITIONS: The entire area, except for these vacant lots and a few lots to the north, is fully developed and appears well maintained. Newer, modestly valued, single family housinq occupies the area east of Gary Place and the alleys that separate housing from commercial developments alonq White Bear Ave. These areas are zoned R-3 and R-4 residential . West of Gary Place is the White Bear Ave. business district and the Hillcrest Shopping Center complex. Directly west of the subject lots is Hafners Restaurant & Bowling which has been built up to the lot line along the southern and eastern limits of the block. Offstreet parking for this enterprise is located within the block to the north and west of the structure, but is limited in space. On the north side of this block is the "1590" building, a small office structure with parking facilities mingled in with Hafners. F. FINOINGS: 1 . The commercial uses along White Bear Ave. are regarded as assets by the neighborhood and the corimunity. . � r. ' � �r,��."�� 1� ��f Rose Mix, City Clerk � August 11 , 1978 Page Two and that the lot be posted for employee parking only. There was considerable opposition which focused on run-off created by blacktopped areas,spot rezoning, infringement on the residential neighborhood, and the devaluation of homes. The motion to accept the recommendation of the zoning committee was denied on a 78 to 25 vote. This matter is scheduled to be heard by the Saint Paul City Co�tncil on August 15, 1978. Sincerely, �+��-� V V` �VU 0. Donna F. McNeally City Planner DFM/gf Enc. Zoning File No. 8084 � ' �' ��`�1.'��'�� • • �TY CITY OF SA'I1�I��A�L �a�c o��. DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT o - � o � � -"�� ° DIVISION OF PLANNING �� ^c 421 Wabasha Street,Saint Paul,Minne 55102 ... c'�61�-4151 -:-� George Latimer U,'� y � Mayor _�,�- ..� ;;. c� ...--- t c:�� N � '�� F t7 .,.U� (,.'1 August 11 , 1978 ��-� �° �-„ �,: _�� . ., � -...f � � Rose Mix, City Clerk 386 City Hall St. Paul , Minn. 55102 Dear Madam: � This is written in response to the petition of A & D Realty Company to rezone property on the east side of Gary Place between Iowa and Hoyt from R-3 (Single Family Residential ) to P-1 (Parking). The request was filed on a consent form petition subscribed & sworn to before a notary public on November 29, 1976. This matter was heard by the Current Planning & Zoning Corr�nittee on February 7, 1977. There was considerable neighborhood oppasition; major concerns were the encroachment of business and associated noise, crime, tr°affic and parking problems. Staff recommended approval of the rezoning. The Current Planning & � Zoning Committee recommended denial on a vote of 3 to 2, based on the concerns raised by the neighborhood. On February 18, 1977 the Planning Corr�nission determined that inasmuch as the neighborhood concerns had not been addressed, and that a site plan of the proposed lot had not been submitted to the committee, the matter should be referred back to the committee. The Commission advised the applicant of their alternatives: request another hearing before the Current Planning & Zoning Committee or after 60 days petition the City Council for a hearing date. On March 28, 1977 the Greater East Side Council voted to oppose the A & D Realty rezoning (letter attached). On May 18, 1978 A & D Realty appeared before the City Council to request disposition of the rezoning. A hearing date of July 6, 1978 was set. _ On July 6, 1978 A & D Realty, complying with the Greater East Side Council , re- quested that the Council lay over the rezoning to permit A & D Realty to attempt a solution through the district planning process. On August 8, 1978 at the general membership meeting of the Greater East Side Council,their zoning committee recommended the denial of the rezoning of Lot 17 (fronting on Iowa) and the approval of the rezoning of Lots 34 & 35 (fronting on Hoyt), with the stipulation that A & D Realty comply with the P-1 regulations .�,�5� � • n '� � C�� l�`� - C1�'Y �F SZ. PAUL DfA��t�'M�i�T (�� FINANC� A�JD MANAGEMENT S�RVlCES �1~ � Q ASSfSSMENT DIYiSlON �'' ��•��'�`�' 113 CITY HALL ST.PAUL,MIVNfSOTA 55102 � ��(� July 28, 1978 �C "RESCHEDULED HEARING" File X1853, Page Zoning File 8084 The Council of the City of St. Paul will hold a public hearing in the Counci2 Chambers of the City Hall and Court House (third floor) at 10:00 a.m. on August 15, 1978 on the: Petition of A & D Realty Company to REZONE Lots 17, 34, and 35, Block 6, Hillcrest Center from R-3 to P-1 for the purpose of installing, constructing and/or operating a parking lot incidental to business. The property. is located on the east side of Gary Place between Iowa and Hoyt Avenues. If you would like further information about this hearing, contact the Curreitt Planning Section of the Planning Board, 421 Wabasha Street or telephone 298-4I54. While the City Charter requires that we notify you of�the hearing, we want to help you to learn fully about any improvement that could affect you or your co�vnity. TherFfore, I sincerel} h�pe you can attend this hearing, so that . you can make your views about it known to the City Council, whether for or against. J. WII,LIAM.DONOVAN VALUATION AND ASSESSMENT ENGINEER . . . . , ,. , , _ , , . :. . . , ,. . . � . .. - ` � �� . ` -;� • '�,., ' �_, � t. • . , , . . , � , � < � - .� " ,, . ' ,. . , , . . , , . ,. . �, ,. . _! ; � , . . . ' .� , ' . . . . . . .. .. A� .. . �. . :. . . � . . . .. . . . . . � � . . . ` _ , . _.. . ;. �..' � • f . , . � . �. . . . . . . -. . . .. , �. , . .� , . _ f , . . � �/ . .. . . � . �. • . . I 'y � . . . . , � , . � .. - ' ' ' . � ., �'� J� .`w� I - . _ � � � . •\ 1 .. � � - : � .. r .{�. x .. . . \^ . . , . . . , . Y .. r M1 : , � . . � . � . � . � � � . .�. � . � � r . . � . . . . . � _ , � , � �. . _. . ., . .. .. � '.� . . . � :- . .. � , ��, ' � � :"':; . � . �'.• ' .- . . ... .. . ., � . I_�.. ..: .. . . . '.. . .�'. . ::: .�: � � . , i . .` . .,� . � ..� . � .� ' . .� � . ;' . � � � , � � � .��" .. , � •.� . . .. .. , � . .� . .� � i ' C .. . . .� � � ,. � - ' � � .. , . .. . . 4. . . � �1. .. . ' � . ; .'�1i�,�!' 6� ��78 . .. • , ,. � . :. , , . , ; , . � ,. , - � • '; � �.: . , `;, � �� 'M�.`: $tl11dX'� Qal�ibQ � � _ Di�r��aY O! �� . ' . , ' � M��macr� -��r�fxss�,: ; , � � , , . . _, . , . . . , . , � D�itiite' 83.�.i,, , - ,�. - - ;� , „ ' . , � . , , `S��ft� ��. todsy �id a�w1: �o lln�g�et lst?� a ��.oa �h�r �!�t�ios e�t, . . , . ��,.,: ,�.�'��'1�7►-�Ce►� �o a�is��- �ats" 17, ��, -ea�d �3S�, �oe1� � $�la�dut +c'�►��ie�., , ,` `�'i'�#R �-x8,�3).. •WiY.1 �u pl�il �d t�r �oti��s tb px'op�k�Cy,t�u�lc# � .�'#q�'�d ' } �ir�`��r'.. � _ . _ . � �� . , . � � . , . . , , . . . . , . , _ • . , � ;. ' , V'�try trft�7;��. . . � � ,� , � ; , . . , . , , . , _ . , � � 1 • ' `.;�o�a►:L�. `, � . - Cit�t �t�t � �� . . . . , , „ �, , ; ., `� �; � �#�i'f,�- �;,; . : �B �t�►� � ' � _, , ` ; , . e i .�� ' , l � , , . . . , y a , , , . � . . . . � .- � , ; �. > > � � . . � _ _ .. . , , . ,,, � . . ; . � •, • , , . . � , . . � , t ' � ; . . . � i , . , - , , , . � ; . . . ; ,r .. � . , . ' . _ � '� `� �� : _ . " _ . . _ � . i:. . _ • � . . ,. . , . _. . .. . ._. . . . . . . . . ` - ' . � ' � � ., . � . { . .. � . �' . � ' 4 � � � : . ��, k �, . . . . . ' �.. f . ... " - ...i �..�� '}.-. �-�..� ' '. . � ,�..: . .. , . ` ` .. • � , 3:' v February 17, 1977 pi$t � 34 � PLANNING BQARD STAFF REPORT p 8084 ` 1. APPLICANT'S NAME : A & D Realty Co. 2. CLASSIFICATION . � Amendment � Appeal � Permit � Other 3. PURPOSE . Rezone to P-1 4. LOCATION . East side of Gary Place between Iowa and Hoyt 5. I.EGAL DESCRIPTION : Lots 17, 34 & 35, Block 6, Hillcrest Center Addn. 6. PRESENT 20I�1ING: �-3 7. PURSUANT TO Zoning Code Chapter: 64 Section: 210 Paragraph: 8. STAFF INVESTIGATION & REPORT: Date: 2_8_�� BY� �� A. SUFFICIENCY: The applicant's request for rezoning was filed on a long form petition. On January 21 , 1977 the Finance Director determined that the petition was sufficient. The City Planning office received the letter requesting review and recommendation from the City Clerk's office on January 31 , 1977. B. PROPOSED USE: The applicant is requesting rezoning of three lots from R-3 single fam�y residential ) to P-1 (parking district) for the purpose of developing offstreet parking for business uses on the west side of Gary Place. C. FRONTAGE & AREA: Lot 17 has a 37 ft. frontaqe on Iowa, and Lots 34 & 35 have a com ine 88 ft. frontaqe on Hoyt. The depth of all 3 lots is 125.5 ft. and the total area is approximately 15,688 sq. ft. , not including alley right-of-way. D. SITE CONDITIONS: The entire site is vacant. Lots 34 & 35 slope gradually up to t e a ey an presently contain a large mound of debris or soil near the center. Lot 17 is about 5 or 6 ft. higher than the alley and is relatively level and landscaped somewhat by the abutting property owner. E. AREA CONDITIONS: The entire area, except for these vacant lots and a few lots to the north, is fully developed and appears well maintained. Newer, modestly valued, singl.e family housing occupies the area east of Gary Place and the alleys that separate housing from commercial developments along White Bear Ave. These areas are zoned R-3 and R-4 residential . West of Gary Place is the White Bear Ave. business district and the Hillcrest Shopping Center complex. Directly west of the subject lots is Hafners Restaurant & Bowling which has been built up to the lo� line along the southern and eastern limits of the block. Offstreet parking for this enterprise is located within the block to the north and west of the structure, but is limited in space. On the north side of this block is the "1590" building, a small office structure with parking facilities mingled in with Hafners. F. FINDINGS: 1 . The commercial uses along White Bear Ave. are regarded as assets by the neighborhood and the community. •6u�uoza� ay� �o �eno�dde spuawuo�a� ��e�s •a�qeqo�dw} s} pauoz Mou s� �� y��yM ao} sasod�nd ay� �o �u� �o� ��ado�d s�y� �o asn ayj •s��aiu uMO s�} uo paaap�suo� aq p�noM ase� y�pa �ea�e ay� uE sa��ado�d �ay�o uo �suo��e �p��w}s u} �saaa�ut aseaa�u� ��w 6u�uozaa s�y� 6u��ue�6 a«yM • �ned �u�es u} ��s�p �up }0 6u��ed �o� sp�epue�s an��sa� �sow ay� aney ��aado�d �e}�uap}sa� 6u��nqe s��E��s�p �-d •6u��eay aay�oue pup uo��ad Mau e a��nba� p�noM asn aay�o �uQ o� ��ado�d s}y� �o asn ay� a6uey� ol •a�ueu}p�o �q sa��}��e� �-� uo pa�}q�yoad a�e a�ueua�u�ew a�Eqomo�ne pue 6u��ed �y6�u�anp •sa�}qowo�ne �0 6u��ed ay� o� ��ado�d ay� �o asn ay� s��a�saa ��}��s}p �-d p sp a�}s ay� �o uo��u6�saQ :SNOI1bON3WW0�3a ��b1S '9 'LL6l 6u��np awt�awos uuo� ��p�p u� aq o� pa�ed��ue s� ue�d s}yj •s��}��uo� uo��e�n�� pu� asn pue� 6u�aq sanss� ay� �o auo 'ssa�o�d 6u�uup�d ��s}d ��auag ay� �q pa�eda�d 6u�aq s� up�d y •g •s6u}puno��ns s�� uodn ��e� y�ns �o ��Edw� ay� uo �uawwo� o� a�q�ssod �ou s� �� s�o��uo� ��ay�sa� pue �noRp� papua�uE 6u}MOys Ma�na� �o� up�d a��s �up �noy��M •g •sasn pup� a�qE��dwo�u� uaaM�aq auoz �a;�nq e ap�no�d o� s} ��s}p 6u��d pauoz p �o s�ua�u� ay� �o aup •ti •6u�snoy �«tug� a�6u}s a�n�n� �o� R��qe�a��ew s�} s��w}� R�a�anas �uawdo�anap ��}�aawwo� 6u}�s}xa o� uo��p�a� u} a�}s ay� �o uo«e�o� ayl •� •uo pa6u��u} uaaq an�y ��nsn s�sa�a�uE 6u}snoH •Zaaw sasn ssau�snq pue 6u�snoy a�ayM s�a�e u} pa�s�xa S�QM�p aney swa�qo�d ��uo� asn pup� •Z Z a6ed '0� Alltl3a 0 � V :}� ��,� � � . ��_�� , , , � . � �� C3TY OF ST. PA1JL �EPART�1�i�1'+1T UF Fl1'�IANC� AND �IANAG�M�NT SERVlCES ASSf55�V1Ff�iT DIYISIO�V 113 CRY HALI ST.PAUL.M1NNf507A Si10? June 16, 1978 File X1853, Page Zoning File 8084 The Council of the City of St. Paul will hold a public hearing in the Council Chambers of the City Hall and Court House (third floor) at 10:00 a.m, on July 6, 1978 on the• Petition of A & D Realty Company to REZONE Lots 17, 34 and 35, Block 6, Hillcrest Center from R-3 to P-1 for the purpose of installing, constructing and/or operating a parking Iot incidental to business. The property is located on the east side of Gary Place between Iowa and Hoyt Avenues. , . If pou would like fur.ther information about this hearing, contact the Curre�t Plann�ag Section of the Plamting Board,. 421 Wabasha Street or telephane 298-4I54. T�'nila the City Charter requires that we notify you of the hearing, we want ta helg you to leam fully about any improvement that could affect you or your com�u�s±itp. Therefore, I sincerely hope you can attend this heariag, so that you can make your views about it knawn to the City Council, whether for or � against. � J. WILLIAM.DONOVAI3 VALUATION AND ASSESSME�iT EPIGINEER �. . �. .. .1. _ t r . . , �: : . �- ��r . ` � . .. � �'��. � ) '\. ' r4 ' '1` ' . .. j ... � .. � 1 � � � � � �r . '� � ' �� . � ` � 1 { Y a,. � . . . � . ��. . . ,. ., ,' , '� � . .�� . , , . . .� . . , � . � . � �. ' �-', . . . . .� � � . .. 'I.Y �: � - � � ,; f / f 3 _ , . � , , = , �� .,� . :. ,-._ . � . . �� , . , . , . . ..;.�." . ` �:',' y*; � . '� � �, :.r .. � . . . i , � _ , . . .. . ,� . . , . .. , , . .i ,.�,..,, . �".� . �,�: . ., .. .1 , :. . . '. _ .: �., : .�,� ,. �..�>. .. : � � ,-- � .. �:. � � . ., . '. . . ' , �. .. . . ,_ ".. r� ._ r.- �.�.... .. .�..: . . .. �. . �� ... � :.,. . . . . . . . . , . �, . ... , .. ,.. .. � . , . .,i . . �. ' .� ., . : ., �.� . � � �"� .. .� . . ,_ . . . , j ,. . ,. . .. , , _: :, i � . ... � . . � .. � ..�. � .. . . .. � .. � �' /" .�.. � . . �. �` . ro � ' � � '. ' ; �� _ � � I • y V i � � � � � �' � . , .. ; �, _ . �, .. � ,• ;,' t.._ ,� �. � I;. `• ... . ': .., - . 7' �� r ��, \ . •. � .�. . � _. �I, 1 . . ..�: .. ,� • :. , ...�' � �.IC� �.. . '. '. . . a � • •. . . - � ' .. .. . _ 1 � . .. � . � , '� _ � - 'r � '. . . ' s1 . . . . �. .� ,r ,. • . , �. �. . . .. ,� ,. . . . . ,, _ `.{, .'' . . �� . ' '.��.' { l. ' , 1, ��`>'. t � ' . , : ;. - � , ; . ; - , `'� # ' ' r. � � �� "' , '�, �'� ��8. � ::7 . . .: - . � _ „ . . ` , . , ; . - . .- . ..� ,:.:� ,! .. ..,. , . :-�. . '..� •<r . ' . .. � . � -��' — �� .. ,_ . � ... . ' �yf. � . . � . . � �� . . . � :, . ��r ��, �� . . � . , '�..I : . . . r � ' � 3��or;a�=��a°6 � � .��- � 4 ' � . . . . -. .� . . ., . ., ..�., �. , � �� . ' � �v . . � {^. _ � .. '� . Y . � � i •��.'��• . ` � . � :I� . .�� . . . " �'Ci�t. €��u�;i-�11 �ia►ld.% p�bSl�tt;2�wt��€ tKt,3�ri� 1�. ,,.��$'+� i�13�'d.�. � :�t ' ' -. ' : , �#�.',A��s t� �ir a 'pa��:t�an o�" "� 6`�. �aib3��.t�?, t�► �'. '�bt►1� ��;t „�.:` ` ~' � �S �k 5 8i �� -, ,. ,' �3,a�tast �a�t�ar. �'�I :'1� A��`�,��-��;�►'` �; �� a�►-a�ti��e� Ia�r tar� ' ; ; �� , ',� i : ,� , _ �� , :�: ,, � '� ��►',��'A � ' ,; , , . � , ; �� M { �: ' °j ' , `a • ,_ �� ` � �� , � ��C�t�. ��k,' - � ` , ; _� :, , a� . ;� , , ,. �: _ ;. , '' � � � , ; ;�e�� `��i�.9t�I�� ! �� ' � � .� ,� ,: , . . . ��. . , � � , , ,' :, � � .. , . . : , � ` � � �le� : ` , . , , . . � . . . , . , � .. �.�: . � ,.� .. . . . . .�.� - . ..t ' . . ' . . .. . . .... .. �k. � � . , I .� '/ . � •. t µ, .!. . . " . � , � V , ��. � , . . . I Y . .� �.� . . 1 � / ( ��ti��, r . . . . - ' .. : . .� . � , . ' ., .. ' ' ... .. :.,'�1. � . � . < .. ..� . � ,� � " �.- .�� . .. , . .� ,. � � ' . . � ��.' . ,�� ' '��.f� . � � .�, �. . z '. i.. ... . ��.� . .` �. . ..,:�.'.. .. ;� . � .: � . . .�Y. .... � .... . .. � . . . . . . � 1. ' . . . •t.-. . ', � � ... .. .. �� • � i�-' . � � .,\ � �Y �: :. �. . . . . . ... . ., . . � . ,� �� .�. .i .� .: � .-� � . � �� ,��-i. . ..�� . a., . .,,, � . � - � . � 4 �. o.: - ` r � . . . ._ .�, i. � .. �. ., . ., , � � . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . ._ . ,. .. . . .. ,. _. . .. �� . . , ... ... .>� _... _ .._ , t: ,.. . ..,. . � . .. _ , , . ;.. ,x �� ti �`� _ �J i � � a # �i .... . , . , , , . , ; , . � . . „ � � ' � � { � r� , . , , , , . ' , , , ,, , - , ., , . > , ,. _ . � � �. ,� - . � . „ � � • ' f , � � Q. � . , , . . . - ., ; , . , , �, , , . . • _ , . . , , -, �,. _ _ � . �� _ '. . . � ..�� .�� .. Y\ r � � ,s� � , � . , - . ��' _ . , . . . ;�. - ,::. _. . . , . .. . .. . -., . , +' � „ .. ' � � �. '' - . � � , �� . �, .. . , , . � .1 � �� . � ... � . . ' . - ��- . . � .. . . � � . . .. r � l .. z , , � ` i � - }- � `�� . . ,. ,: . , . ., � . �.. . . t � .�� . '(�� , � . _i . ',' , . .: ' , . .�� , .� , . ; �',. G l � ,/'� t'' ' � � � Jt�t 3.:, 19�� , r ,; � . ��.�� . � �i . � _ � " - ,� . �. . . - � . '��1� S�t��°�,. � y � • �� .$�lt� � , ' � ` �.:' s ' �ias;.:��d� � • .� , ; . , , < , - , . , . , ; , , , . , _ . ;, ; _ - ' } „ �a , , � ` � .� ;5.�'S. „; . ,�u , r , ` �. .; �� t,�+' ��.a�t3.�.�+ald � .1�� Qa� J�',Y\�, �97'9 �o`e�us�c R�t '�'��,��a r,� , � �:JL i� .1�.;li�l��! �►.s'1�#to�'L�aS� I�'!:•3at .aad �, �.4e�k 6.."��'�uir� �'� j � .� �� .�il tr�t1� t1�t:.0 ati�� c�o�ulrt�#�r► 1� �ar+�#.t� �►,t.�;i�-�� :��,� * r� � � ��1G��,�II..iMpRl�tit'�'. � ; . � � 1F:�' r �� ,�, � � � � � . 1T��'1� L�7 ��s �' . (' , �. , , . - � �� , � " $+�t 1�* ,� ` ;`+` ,> � �i3t�yr �C1�t, � �.; ^ , �-, � ` -'��- , , .. . � . , , ; , j � . � : . �� r � �� - ; ,� ��' ,,+ � ;`; . ,i. .. .. . . � , `,,,. ' .' , . , � . � F � � , . � . . � � � i ` ( 2 I ; . J ' F' ' Rl i' . � ; . , . . �. . - „ -, , � ,- , � . : ` ' ,: . .. . , , , `, : f� x . . . , , .. : '� ,,' ; • � ,., ;;, ,.� � . ' r , � " ; t , , � . , . . ` � �' ,. , , � � r � � _ ` , � . � , 5. „ �� ' b � �� i. � �t : � , , , .:, , , ° . . . - - x i � � , - , . ,. ... - , -� . . . . r . , � � �i��. ... ." , . ., � . . .. , .._ , .: .. , , .�. � - ,. .,. it. . . �. . .. , . 'j.. r: ' _ . . �' , ' • , � . � .-. ,. .� . .. . , , . : �,. ., � . . � . � � y` � , a � �� 1 ' � • � � � ,,. / \ �\\\\\\R11�I _�.��'TY °F';,,, CITY OF SAINT PAUL '; .�'�"' �`r OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY ;� ��se'tii°i �� .,a �= SUZANNE E. FLINSCH, CITY ATTORNEY �''`��,,,lm1ea!��.��'� 647 City Hall,Saint Paul,Minnesota 55102 George Latimer 612-298-5121 Mayor - May 24, 1978 Mr s, Ro s e Mix City Clerk 386 City Hall Saint Paul, Minn. 55102 Re: Petition of A & D Realty to Rezone Property By letter of May 18, 1978, you requested advice regarding the � above-referenced rezoning matter. It is our understanding that the rezoning petition was found to be sufficient and referred to the Planning Commission by the City Council in February, 1977. The Current Planning Committee of the Planning Commission thereafter received a report from the staff of the Planning Office, held a public hearing, and made its recommendation to the Planning Commission. The Planning Commission then tabled further action indefinitely to allow A & D Realty to meet with area residents and reach some sort of compromise. A & D Realty has now requested that the City Council set a hearing preparatory to acting on the petition. A petition to rezone property is jurisdictional. Once the neighbor- ing property owners have granted �urisdiction to the City Council by consenting to the petition, the Council has the authority to grant the reguested rezoning if it finds such action to be in the public welfare. There is no requirement that the Council act within a certain period of time, so long as any delay is not unreasonable and a consenting party has not changed his position in reliance on the failure to act. The Council' s authority to act on the petition is limited by Minn. Stat. s� 462.357, Subd. 4, which reads as follows: "An amendment to a zoning ordinance may be initiated by the governing body, the planning agency, or by O � � � � 1 •�111 1 Mrs. Rose Mix Page Two May 24, 1978 petition of affected property owners as defined in the zoning ordinance. An amendment not ini- tiated by the planning agency shall be referred to the planning agency, if there is one, for study and report and may not be acted upon by the govern- ing body until it has received the recommendation of the planning agency on the proposed amendment or until 60 days have elapsed from the date of refer- ence of the amendment without a report by the planning agency. " Since more than 60 days have elapsed since the petition was referred to the Planning Commission, the Council may proceed with the matter either by setting a public hearing and acting without a recommenda- tion from the Planning Commission or by requesting the Planning Commission make its recommendation as soon as practicable. Sincerely, •�, ��'�._.__•�_ �"�`�._ SUZANNE E. FLINSCH City Attorney `��/ �� ROBERT O. STRAUGHN Assistant City Attorney SEF:ROSser - _. ,� . .i � .. � 1 -: �. rG~I �_r�� 8HEAR & ROONEY, LTD. ATTO R N EYS AT LAW � ��JO NORTN[RN F[D[RAL BUILDINO SIXTM AND WABASHA HAROL05NEAR 9T. PAUL, MINN. SS102 THOMA9 J.ROONEY IARRY NEIL90N f61 21 224-336 1 P�Iay 15, 19 7� City Clerk's Office Ramsey County Courthouse St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 Re: A & D Realty Co. Rezoning Petition To Whom it May Concern: Please be advised that this law firm represents A & D Realty, a partnership consisting of Albert and Donald Hafner. Some time ago, a Rezoning Petition was filed by A & D Realty seeking to rezone Lots 17, 34, and 35, Block 6, Hillcrest Center. On January 27, 1977, the City Council referred said Petition to the Planning Commission. On February 17, 1977, the Planning Committee by a vote of 3-2, recoa�ended that the Petition be denied. On February 25, 1977, the Planning Commission laid over the matter. At this time, we wish to have the matter placed upon the City Council Agenda for a decision by that body. Consequently, I would appreciate it if you would place the matter on the agenda, and notify me of the date of the hearing. Thank you. Yours truly, SHEAR & ROONEY, LTD. � I ��t�lo� � Larry Neilsor_ cs � ' � - - r� �t � ,,a . . ; 1 � � :. l ��:: �� c�' . ,.. '�.+r'---�:'`•l � • . . . . . • .? `, X , � ° ` � .'� , �� ,a. . � 1 � - .� ,. ?� �. ,. w., `� .. , � ., � i ,S �i� , ,., � ' . . .� . . , , ,. , , . .< ; , .��. . . . . . � . � ,. .� . � ` .. -` �' �. � . � � • . � _ , '� .. . , " �y.�. �. . . � . ,. � . , ., �. � -' � , ,� � ' . � . "� . ' �. �.�: �,.� 4 . . , . �. , . � ��, . , . , . . i _ �. , � , , � � � � � r � . � �- �. . � . �. . � �.. . � . -� �� , . .. ,i� . , . • . . . � .. . . . �. . . . ,. . , : . ... . .:-. . ,�. . . . i � .� � r . ..�, .� ..� . � . ,�._ , . ,.'. ' . ' ....,� eS • . .,� - . �.., .. .-... ..� '.: . . .`. . .. . . '. �..' �.� �-:. ` .. ,.. . . � . ' . ' . , . �. , ' ! •3 c ., . ',_,.:,� :c, .. '� . l ;' : . .' _ • , �' . _. .._`� �..� . .i ;;� .:: , . � } .� ' . : .. �.� s � ,;, .'. }. . . �° �� - � � �� i = 1 � . 'e � � � .?-.�- '� � }. � i , � � . . � .�' .. . , .� . �� .��} _�� I f' � . �� , � . . 4 a� � � . ' : -. . . ., . � e • � � � � i i ,-��i � �� ) ! / , , � ! "� r :��r�:i�►s.�t, ' f � � � { , , . , � � ` , r � � . . � ! � , L . "'S j i � V f � � �,�� ,� , �.� '. . ,r .,:f } }� y, . ' ° , �t �� '�od�ql �rweli^�� s tw1#��r'.�i"� �' sm�!`'��. *"�� II�►�� ' `�f► ir b;��.�►.,��'R"�fl#�E..�tt �t� ��' N� �t �'��:#i� �►`IM '��lul�� p'��i�. k' 1 `��.��`,;��i;�lii 7�'�! fii0'C11 �7i � � �:t� ��'8�1:`,�P+��'+�.:�.`�w f ' ' , �' �I�i`�d�� '�"`�S .�i1,�`a�'�if� ��R`p�.��►',:�'� ��'�+�1�R. � ` � , � 'i�� 3�' +�`'�ti�#iti�tal� �r I�wt �''�� t�,`'aa►1 i��w±�r<`+��!#�,` n ��o'f+�r t�r �n�" to,'� �y 11�to�;°�,� h f�+l�"e�t�:+�otd �t�i o�`��,_ ` ;r' �;. <��• � 'a- � � �' � ; , � . . ; � - , . ; ; , ; , . . . . , , _ _ a�T`,��"'� ;��+� �• � , �" C.�.�e ' {.. � . /. . � �. � ��.�I t {+S � ��/� � d+.� �t ' ' �' � ,�'.1 ` �_ , �,�� `. � a �:.(� . .' ` ' , ��i��:i� . { ' �y�• '� ± . ," . ., / � . �� '� 1 L�.�' 9 � ;"� .. :. ��' �' �. .� � ... ' � . . . .:. ... �... . • .�.. . � ' . . . r�. . �� . .�.. . , 1 . . f , .._ �. . .�. ' ` � .\ . . . . . •' V- {�' .¢ F .:� ��•�*.� � �-7 �• � . t� \y: ' ':�'��+�'�*'�~ . . � i . r�;�. � � � �—. , . - ° � i � � i� . � � � . .. ' . • , - : �� _�. . .-. .,� . .� , . , � � . � . � . , _ .� . � . . . ._ ..,'.,, ,.. . :.�_ . ��'� � ,., .- � �: ' �i :i: � �: . . � : "_� - d ��''AW f� , .. . . . +'t> . . : � � .,�. � ' � .� � . . ... . �,. �� _ . ., . � •t . .. �, � . � , . ;. , . . .. � � . . ` . . _ . ' �a.d� . -: ; . , :.� � , .. . � � . . .. , - , . .�� ' �-. ..� , ,...��.r ,�.. �. . . E� , . . . , . ` .. S :�� .. � - ,; � .� .. '. . i ' � � � �.� • y � 1 . .. ... i. '`.�:. ,. 1 ; . � � . . .. '� , , . / . I� �� t � /� �� 1 I. . . � ' ., ... . .. 'I . '�� t � 1 � .� ... ' .. �.` ' � ' �� '. . � : .. ..�. •.- .' . �. . • � _ ; . , , ,��,, a; . , . � � �.�: � . . _ . . _ ' � . , �:� ._ �:� ; . , � � a� F �i �' I � ;� ;� �� GREATER EAST SIDE COMMUNITY COUNCIL District 2 � _ 1575 Ames Avenue . � �: St. Paul, Minnesota 56106 -";,,,,.v.. "` . . Phone: 774-2599 ��- �:w:�,...: �� ,. ��;'^��. , August 9. 19?$ Mr. David Hozza, Pre sident � St. Paul City Council , Seventh F1oor, City Hall � � . � St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 , � , Dear Mr. Hozza, Last evening, August 8, 1978 at 7:30 p.m. , the Greater Eastside Community Council - District II held its monthly general membership meeting at Hillcrest Hirise - 1743 E. Iowa, St. I'aul. The second item on the scheduled agenda, under New Business, was the discussion of A & D Realty�Hafners' request to rezone Lots 17, 34 and 35 - Block 6, Hillcrest Center in order to construct two employees parking lots across the street from the business establishment. A brief summary of those proceedings follows. The GESCC Zoning Committee's report was presented by Mr. Otas Helemas, Chairman (see attached) which recommended the following action be taken: 1. That the parcel north of the alley (Lot 17), proposed 7 car parking� lot be denied . (Motion to grant: 5 no, Z yes, Z absent) 2. That the parcel south of the alley (Lots 34 and 35), proposed 22 car parking lot be granted, complying with all legal requirements of a P-1 zoning, and that the agreement to use it as an employee park- ing lot be honored and perpetuated. Visual sight screening to be placed on the north, east, and south sides, to be asthetic-and func- tional, either by fencing or planting. Lighting to be placed in such a manner as to be of least annoyance to adjacent residents. (Motion to grant: 1 no, 6 yes, 2 absent). After lengthly discussion and debate, and presentations by opponents and supporters of the rezoning issue, a motion was made by D, C. Hoffman and seconded by Jayne Lallier to accept the recommendation of the Zoning Coxnmittee. The motion failed to win approval by a vote of: 24 for, ?5 against. After the votes were tallied, the following re5olution was moved by Bruce Haug, seconded by Herbert Haxnmer,. �.nd passed that: "The GESCC recqmmends that the City of St. Pau]. City Council not grant any coxnmercial e stablishment any reque st for zoning change s or building permits within District II on White Bear Avenue, until the prob- lems with the Flandrau-Ht�yt sewer systems - both sanitary and atorm water - are resolved and corrected". A further motion was introduced by Orville Kemp, and passed that: "The GESCC support the rights.of the homeowners who live east of White . . ' • � , Tv: Mr. Dan Bostrom-Chairman 8 Auguet� 1978 Greater East Side Community Council - Dist. 2. �575 Ames ave., st. �'aul, Minn. 55106 Sub3ect: Bezone from R-3 to P-1 Zoning File 808$ applicant: A & D xealty Company. Location: East side of Gary P2ace� between Iowa Avenue and Hoyt Avenue. Legal description: Lote �7,34 and 35, Block 6, Hillcrest Center Addition. Dear Sir: Upon receipt of a notice for rehearing before the City Council� on 6 July, 1978� the District 2. Zoning Committee in a letter to Mr. Hozza, Chairman of the St. Paul City Council, requested that the above stated petition be returaed to District 2. for consideration. The request was honored. , An informational meeting wa� held on 26 Ju1y� '1978, with representativea of residents opposed to rezoning, (7members) the petitioners (4 members)� and membere of District 2. Zoning Committee (2 members). A proposed layout was presented by Mr. Nordby, of K.G. Nordby and Associates (Commission Nr. 55-76 dated 12/29/76), Archetects for A & D Realty� stating their propossals for site development. The residents voiced a strong objection to rezonin� on grounds that their properties will be devaluated,- traffic noise from patrons of Hafners Supper Club and Bowling Alleyss occuring at a late hour�-the time of refuse removal at early morning hours. Concern was expressed toward a con�inuous expansion for parking space toward the east, relating to the present ownership of residential properties owned by A1 and Don Hafner. The matter of run-off and floding were mentioned� and are being addressed at the present time by agencies of the city, in obtaining relief to this problem. An agreement was obtained from Messrs. Hafner, that if the petition to rezone is granted, parkin$ is to be for emplayees only. The informational meetiug was concluded in a cordial manner, with an exehange of information benefici.al to all parties concerned. The District 2. Zonibg Committee met on 3 August, 1978. A quorum being present, the committee addressed the A & D Realty petition for rezoning. Information and data used was frora present and past meetings and hearings. Aft�r due deliberations, the Di,strict 2. Zoning Committee makes these recomendations: 1. That the parcel north of the alley (I,ot 17), proposed � car parking lot be denied. (Motion to grant: 5 no, �2 yes, 2 absent) 2. That the parcel south of the alley (lots 34 & 35), proposed 22 car parking lot be granted� complying with aii ie��. requirements of a P-1 zoning� and that the agreement to use it as an employee parking lot be honored and perpetuated. Visual sight screening to be placed on the north, east and south sides, to be as��tic and functional, either by fencing or planting. I,ighting to be placed in such a manner, as to be of least anoyanae to adjacent residents. (Motion to �rant: 1 no, 6 yes, 2 absent) Otas R. Helema - Chairman �� /�,• Ir' —'C�� • District 2. oning Committee. ,, _ _ , ' •' i ,. GREATER EASTSIDE CQMMUNITY C.(1iJ1�IC,IL. CEI�IER.AL MEMBER.SHIP 1viEETING - AUGUST 8, 1978 ?:30 P. M. -HILLCREST HIRISE= �I7#3 E. IOwA • AG � NDA � , 1. CALL TO ORD�;R - 7:30 P.Ivi. - Dsn Bostrnm, Chairman ' 2,. NiINUTES Consta.nce Brandenburg, Secretary 3. TREASTJRER'S REPORT Karl Neid, Jr. , Treaaurer , �. �O�RESPONDENCE A. Payne Aventxe Harve st Fe�tival 5. CO1V1NiiTTEE REPORTS: A. Communicatioas - Constance Brandenburg, Chait�pereon - B. Zoning - 4ta,s Helemas, Chairman C. Bike S�fety - Jerry Bahls, Chairrrian � D. White Bear Avenue Days - John �Vanella, Comrnunity Organis�er E. 1vlayor's Budget Advisory Committee � Dan Bostrum, Member - F. Other Committee s ba OLD BUSINESS ?. NEW B[?SINESS A. Proposed consolidation and busing between Frost Like. Pzosperity Heights, and Fraaklin 5�hools �- B, Hafner's rezor�ing request 8. OTHER BUSINESS � . - �• 9. ADJOURNMENT - 10:00 P. M. , , , . . . .•.• � . • t, �� , ; 2'7.1"�� 7ELEPHONE: 774-9511 OFfICE NOURS: 8 A.M,to 4:30 P.M. MONDAY THRU FRIDAY n .�� `� w� � INDl1STR�I�1L WORKEt�S 1� `��i'� a = � � WAREHOUSEMEN, DRIVERS AND HELPERS � ,,�� , LOCAL UNION No. 847 287 MARIA AVENUE °� . SAINT PAUI, MINN. 55106 August 11, 1978 Councilwoman Rosalie Butler City Hall , 15 W. Kellogg Blvd. St. Paul, MI�TT 55101 Dear Councilwoman Rosalie Butler: The membership of the Industrial Workers, Warehousemen, Drivers and Helpers, Local No. 827, would like to go on record as being opposed to the rezoning of lots 17, 34, and 35, Block 6, Hillcrest Center Addition fram R-3, Single Family Residential, to P-1, Parking District, for the construction of a parking lot. ,� By the time you receive this letter, you will probably have already received petitions from that neighborhood and other interested parties. This Local is confident that the type of mandate that all those signatures represent will be more than sufficient to influence your vote. We, however, like to leave no stone unturned. We are confident that our friends of Labor on the Council will vote the right way. Hoping you do, I remain, YouBs trulyr% � � ,. ,, , ,' j �. ..e!•�5-�-�-� �� / James Astrup President Local No. 827 JA: jk CC: Randy Kelly, State Rep. 66B CC: Dennis McGinley, 1831 E. Iowa, St. Paul, MN 55119/ � � Affiliated with the I. B. of T. C.W. & H. of A. Central States Conferencs of Tsamsters Teemsters Joint Council No. 32 iQr'1, Chemical arld Atvmic Wor�ers Inu�natior�al Un�on 923 EAST SEVENTN STREET �'A- NICK KOVACN, PRESIOEN7 ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA 55106 PNONE: 771•59�3 • LOCA� UMION �7'i July 18, I978 Councilman David Hozza City Hall i5 W. Kellogg elvd. St. Paul, MN 55141 Dear Councilman Kozza: The membezship of O.C.A.W. , Locai 6-75, would like to go on record as being opposed to the rezoning of Lots 17, 34, and 35, Block 6, Hillcrest Center Addition from R-3, Single Fsa�ily Residential, to P-�, Parking Oi$trict, for the construction of a parking lot. By the time you receive this letter, you will probably bave already received petitions lrom that neighborhood and other interested parties. This Local ia confident that the type of mandate that all those siqnatures represent will be more than sufficient to influence your vote. We, however, like to leave no stone unturned. We are contident that our friends ot Labor on the Council will vote the rigfit way. Hoping you do, I remetin, Youre truly, i'� • Nick Kovach Preaident O.C.A.N. Local 6-75 NK/mj ccs Ra y Ke11y, State Rep. 66B erb Hammsr �� • � � •- �• — •��• -• • • • • • C • • ��• • — •— • ' • 1 • — • • • •. • i � � �� 1►* 1 L��_ �� . ��►� � , �� 1�► .� � _�t. � �� 1 il'!��1�`��:U��. � 1��.►�� I • �,,� � � �!� � � � J /' // � �_ �� .�'/a� � - a� � -/ , II�-'• �1 1 � I� � t� ` ��, '/ �� • ♦ � �e L/ 1 / � � � ' �- - ' / � si/i'«, _ ' _ _ _ I _ ; � . �i � \ � • r . �—'e.�i�. �1 �.' . � \ ��/ . .�' — . �i :%� � � � I I \ .� � ` � .� � � L � � , !� .- .� �J�-�� / �, --�;— .. ,— —� �.�. � ,.�!.!,'r/l".�� % " •�.•�.� '��v� . . ' . � / .. r .?_ .��.*.,..� i v �r� ./ i. ,_ �� ` ��l�!i/.l' � l�� _,Ii _ � � i_ •_i L � ��'!�[��/ _ / i� '� �L�L. 'L.0 _ � � _ /� _ .'� _�.. ' � � ►�r► `.-.. , � �i_:,_ ,� �.�:.� _� ■� � . �I%//fi�//. �/ � �� ri ��/�''%rU�J�sS%/'1��' � ��.i�_ .1L '/ � ' ii��L ► / � � .�_�� . . � i . �� "� � :,..% .:r��_ � � _ .�.� .. � . � _ . j `,� �.� � .• �:a,.a� �` �. � � �� .. 0 � J � .al7 � L.l�% � � � _ �_ _ /✓�_�1� � . ��'� ,. _� �� r�jl.��" r - _ / _ � • - - .- • ... . . . : • . � • • - .� •- • • � • • • • •. • � � �1 � � , � ..�. /�i��/ �`� � �' f T ..�� - - - -'4 . ' �" � .s /�/�f!!i� !--� / � � > -� '' i �- � ' � ��'�i��. i . ,/�„�� '�. .��ly'�f'� �,�:��.� -� � .t � ..' ` ---� � i ,/ L.�.i � �� `/� � ' \ ia � t/_ �.��► • / � �� . � _��• _��\` `. . �� ``• 'l�`�.��.i ,_ / ' / � . ..J/ � � �:/�i :i.♦ .� 1 ,��. �� - �_�� ... • • / .� _. i`�%i�ir_ irnl I / / _![� : .rr� /'✓�G: .�/AC�._ � � , — � .,�� ,�J. � �rl ' 1 .= :/�.. 'o ��/� /, � .�� :. .. .. . -- �"i..�i.'1�'��.t,r��'i .'�! .'�' '1;' /� - , � . � ► • i��. � � . � �• ��_ ,;,.s.r .ti�.�,.c��i., i � � ��:.��-��/-�-_ � . , " .�_�.�/f.►.. .�[i. � � t ,i — — � ' I j ��r ,/ � / , � : _ / 1� � � ��r�� - �� r � � : I � i /.L►��' �� . 1� \ � � � `i i � .._.� � . .� �- L/ ��.i�l/� � �'♦' .� L'�5..�'`� � �I�i�.l�� . � �/ �� %�„ �J � � �� ...._ � , r• .i / L �. � �..�+.. � � � ii ► '� ��= �,l �� - i. ..r � i • s �� .r� /1 �t, r � �' _ � �_ , . ., ' �3 pr �� s2zol. � � 1 � � _ .__._ �_ . �rle, th� ��d�rs��;n�d, are oppos��d to the rezo:�i_�g of Lots 17, 34 �ld 3�, Block 6, Hillcrest �en-�Er AdcL�. irom R-3, Si_rigle Fa!nily Re��_dFr�tial, tc P-i, Pai•iiir_g District, ror the coristru�±ion cf � �arking lot, NAN':E .ADDRESS ' ' � - ,� /�''�� c��yf-cPti� . �` ` `J� � ti _ - .�_.�� C� e '�!� .�r^ � _ :-� /�� .�� r-- r � ��-- � � �,�.-�L- � C�= ---- . ; �. ,�.-- �� , . ., . , • � � /,-'�17�� r r L.��L ,..r'C..�. , . :^ ,. - , c- { . ` �, i.�� './✓, i�'� `. l��1 �'�� ''` � f"C �� / � � � �� ---�� s �x. �u� � �r -- .l� �/ - ' -�--�s-r-� . .-. f � �j / � — � �_;� ' �. __�____.- r�,�,v-- _ t �S� z. � I--] ,__�__�,�_ � --,� � � � r°�-� � � ? Y �..�. �� '��Y - i� �� , � �Z � ��7 L, � � � c.k t B b o `� , � _ �_��'� Zv.- . �� l�� '� � _ � � �� . _ � � _ �8 s�� ._ , -- /�y� � � : . . �- `�' � .._l��......_.�� _ _.G._.___ .�� '�.� _�_ �. � `� -,,� __.._. _1��`1_�..�1 --------- ��: ..�._...._ � ��7�. .� _- - . ___,(�� ._ _..__.� �._��-��- � __-__-. __..,r..�"�-� ��.�� h , _�.,�� -� _Cr _.._ .� . ' � _. —_. ___1_ff�=,Y � �'_��..� �' �--_.__. -� ' � � �'�,�,�.-, , 1�'�S� � z��r ., i , , � , � i' E �s� ITIQP� �7 � I�Te, the undersi�ed, are opposed i,e the rezonirg of Lots 17, 3�+ and 35, Block 6, Hil�cr�est Center �ddn. from R-j, Single Fa.mily Residential, to P-1, Parking District, for the c;onstruction of a parking lot. NAI� AT�DRr,SS � [ Q �=5 �- ,. U C� � �►' , . o� �. ��--��J �13.�"�� 2t.--� _� ' t�' ,.��=,c- � y �� h�'. 1,�u,,�' C�L�.�. � ` t' r z.�� /"il�W- ��y�- � , - ,,' i �...�� , � �'l.' isf' ..%yr.c � /�`� �� , . .-:: i �6,� �� -�,�- .�y � � � - :. ,.�:��s�.�.�,/.� ��, _. .�.. _ �.;,�,c1 .��' �,t o�-�` � ��. �> , �� -.� � � z-; ; r � ., . _ /�� . ��T �!/� l LL- , � . — G -�:•F�-�-- � _ � _ .�,-. 3 � ,��"� '� - - ` �- �_ 1 �� 3 � � � � � , , � �� ..., _ � � __._ . �.��. � _ � ��t..� .�w+�.,�, _ _I K 7�S 1-�c� _.._.__ �.. `�a�' _ __ �g 7 �— - l�� _ S` _. GZ�t--�� , _ � � , ` � , . ' PETI. TI0I�3 �� !"�J � r . � �y �c� We, the undersigned, are o�.posed to the rezoning of Lots 17, 3� and 35, Block 6, Hillcrest Center �ddn. from R-3, Single F�ily Residential, to P-1, Parking District, for the construction of a parking lot. ADDRESS - /�9` � . - /�9� ;, __ � � � � ��_ „ � r, ,.. � I �� . � � % � . . /�z � � _ - C� � _ � �o - � . , � 1�.Tr � ..��,,-,C � � • . - - - , J c„�.� �a �c� ��y�,� � �o G �., �' t-_1,�.-�__ `r�� u. � i �,> �- . / .- - � -,L_�' i v ,�,�,�-� ��z �.e _ . _ b , , �I . � • .. -. ....__. . _ . . - . . . . . . _ . � . � � _ • • • •: . � i , ��. . � � _ - � , ' ,:..'J � - `/ � �L.�"�� ,�., "",� i � / i S�'`----�-� ' � �-�-��.� i:, ��- � /�Ii. , �_ � � � � i��i . .I ii � ' /%J L ♦ � 1 . � I .i . i • i � � iI � � � -�_ !�_� ��"�.�__ ' . ; ,� , ; . = � - � . , . ,�.. �, . � - . _ . ��_� ;/7'�''l� �' �r',,';� , _ " _ . ;� � � ��, _ = �.. � - ir��_ - .. . �� t�.�,/ I/i�.% �. � � "� �I/,/��:� _� . %1�1,,, - �,� .��-- :'-�f'.�i��-�l- - � - , i.i ��.��C� � �, _ ;� � _ / i��i ��/'4s:L.� i � : r' � �L��.��f'1�- ,i� ,_ / � / i .. . � s i , ��".�. �� s �� .� / / � � � /' �w � _�a ' _� � _ � �we��!3� ' �� . . �•�s . \ ' � � '� / _— / � i ��.�� LIL/ � / `' /iL / /� �� --� �/l�(. � . � � i !�i �� 1� ' � �� ,: � .�_ . ;t;� � � - . �. , `�-'� - �' •� - � ` _ /r._. ' i��- _ ��„'��. � / j� - � �� , �� %, , d.�� / .� /i. .i _ o � 1�� . � ///' „��I/�` � � � � / r � � , .�, / ' � - �...ii��J�� i� I%.L/ i�iiviL/.' �l/�/L.�t�..tiV��,I.��ii.a/ < // /'.... .�� , 1�"� ./ ' ��....�� .� i ! �/.J� - - � � � PETITI C ��3 We, the unders�gned, are opposed to the rezoring of Lots 17, 3�+ and 35, Block 6, Hillcrest Center Addn, frcm R-3, Single Fa�:lv Residential, to P-1, Parkir_g Dist�ict, for the construction of a parking lot. NAP�1'E ADDRESS � � __ ��lJ"C , . d � �� . � /.�' �a.c. . ' ' �?/�� ...�r J�'�e� D° , � � - � � � � � � - / � _ _:,�7�� -z�� ' F � - . T , � /�30 � � _� � � �" .�� , i � � ° � _ �- - � _ 171 � - _ � 7�L �, . . � �� ► . G ,�d „ - _ � ; � - � �� ' �� . -,,�� , ; � d; t . _ 1(O �� o� �"� � � � _-,�;.= -� ^/ �D� ��J :r� ' ' . o-�-% _ , r_�7 � �-� _____-- --��'r� L�' _ ` ! � 2 � 'f� Y,l�ir�',�a c� � � . . , . . , �PETITIC �3 We, tha unders�.gned, are oppossd to the rezor:ing af Lots 17, 34 and 35, Block 6, Hillcrest Center Addn. frorn R-3, Single Fa�ly Residential, to P-1, Par':cir_g Dist-rict, for the construction of a parkir_g lot. �'� ADDRESS _ ��—� �'�1.�.�c C .�ir�c��c.. ` � � � /J �1"`' .Q�g�J N--f'lca�;72%'1��'!J y'��. -- � .S`S`' Q.��!` Ll ,. �/1'r.r(.(U JC P� ..�G� f ! S S,^ �✓ ,�L-i � - �s/ �, � C� Q.� ,w � 7S/�; � � �'�21 � - C�� Z`� �:� � 7 � . �-L-�'._c-y�... Gr�7-r �C_.�' ( �^ � / �.�1� C . �--�2, .:. � �1 (,L �/ � � r - . - , : - � / 7a7 -_ .. � "l�� f f � �� %''' �t � � i� c�, �c � � �� ?�? 1� �C _ . . ,/74/ _ v C� /. t � ! �/ / _._._ �_ ! - _ E� ��`�- �– _ �.��— r . � ,r /-- - . . - / , , S , _ - ...5_ ; ,; . � � �� - �� !.� � A�-q -9�_ � � ,�, ._-�.rG�rl J __ `� � '� � � � n - � , -- `� � � �� • i . � , . PETITION ��Q v � ��y�c� We, t�-,e undersigned, are opposed to the rezoning of Lots 17, 34 and 35, Block 6, Hill�rest Center Addn. from R-3, Single Family Residential, to P-1, Parking Distriet, for the construction of a par•king lot. NAME ADDHrS5 , ' / �"DO - � ._ ao . � � � � . _ � . >--.�-�• C� � '�. ;' oZ �' � .� o } . 23 " � � � �� - .--- —L — �� _ % � � � � r :_; . �� - . = s� _ - - � �- .��'��.r-��-,. __ �� n � � �-� .��:�33 ��a �'�v :C - u.� _� �. �r , . _ _ - � * � � � - ��1� _. - //'GC.c, _ ..� -/�-7-�-c-c , � � .. r � GL= ;/: �'` .:S 3'.� ��1✓�.� � � a:. - ��i�<� �h1'�'�,��;��---� — - � , '► . ', , � I' i�; 7' r T I (� t: .,.� - ti�7c, tlie UIZ�CI�JlV ied, are op=�a:�ed t,o il��. r��r.i:�� ci' I,ots 1'j, :•:� ��n�l j-}, B1ock �, Hillerest Ceriier xd�in, frorn R-3, S:in�?.c F;.r,ily Rc;�iden�i;:�l, ta .'-1, �'� :�:,ing Di:.�,rict� for the construction of a parking lot. TUl?�� APDIi1?:,.", � �^ ' --�J�==�--=� ��— ,.tF' ��1 , �� -� ..� d � �� lf�� .. .,., , ,� �,�.. i � � s- �' � ,. _ �.- . � �n �� ,1 � ��-- t+-,�-<-z.� ;�;,; . . . '.• , � ..,... _.... _..._ .___._. �~�.� 0 V� � I�i: '1' I`T' i �1 1; � 1 t�y(��I ��lc, the under:��;;r.e�9, ar�; u�,;:;:;c�d t� ?t;:: r�::: :;j- � i' I.��°,:: 17, �;!; r�rul �',:.�, `r.;l.ock t�; tlil.lcrc�:t Ccn��r.r Ac1�3;i. froi« R-3, S:in�;I�� Fr;s:i1;; Itc;.�:.acrri;_ �1. , L� F-1 , I':�:�i:in� Di:ti,ricrL, for i.lie coi�st.ruc�tion of s� ��arking lot. I�I/1?.� A�.�i�:�r:;,, -��C4•C..�G.-— - � �� . , ,t �� "� - ;� T � ._..` _� _ , ._ ` /� �-6 �--�-L. _..._ . � � � � ,, , ` ', P E T I T � 0 N �r��( �J • ; 41e, the undersigned, are opposed to the rezoning of Lots 17, 34 and 35, Hroek 6, Hillcrest Center Adcln. trom R-3, Single Family Resident3al, to P-1, Parking Distriet, for the construction of a parking lot. . NJ�1E ADDRESS / �G� � �.�� %�e- _ /�� ' � � � ; � � � � � ��_/�� .� c�- - � � �_ - . . , . . . . . ..t'. "� . ' .. _ . . : : . ' . ., . . . �� . . - . ' .. . � �. ' . . .��-i � . . � . � . . . . '.J . . .. �.:. . ... . .. � i. . . �... . �. ..�. . ... .. . � � . : � .. . ... � � � { . .. . .. . 1 t � . � . . � � � e ..�. .. ' ,' . . ' ' . . � " : ' :.. . ' ' . , . . . \, �.. . — . � �� , .. �� . , � , f ) _ . . . � � . . . � , . . \' . . . . . � �� ..�� —. . ..� � �... . . . .�� . �'i . . ., - ., .. . .. , . . � . . .�. � . � � . . �... . . . . . . �...�. ,. �,. '/• � .. � . . � � .. . . � � . . .. . � . ' � � . , , ' . � .. , . . . . . . . .. _� , . � � ��.. .. , . . . . . -� . '. � .. . . .. .. � � . . . �. , �. . . .' .� _. -� �... ., .. . � .. .... ,...�' �; . . . . � � .. � ` , � . r 1 .�.� '. . . _ . ' . . " , . . . � ' . \ ', _. - - . . . .. � . . � , l �'Y. . . � ' , .i. . ,,. - �� ' . .� . . �. s, - . .,. .,, �,. . . � . . �. . , . .. . � , . ... '.. :/.. '. � ! � . . ' . . . . '.. .- �'�". . � . . , ,-I. :� .: �.. .-�. .a��. � . � . . ... .. .. , �.:. . . . .. :: � . " . .. . . .' , \ .:. .� .. . . '�- .,. .. . . .•. .... . � . ., . . _ .. . . .,.. .. . . . ' . � �' '. �. . .. � . ' � � ' � . .... I. . . . . � ... .. . .. .. . .. . .�.�. -i. � . �. . . . . , '. �.:. . � . . , . . . - - .�. , �. �.,� , . .. . ., .. � . . �. . . , � , . ; -. ��. � � , . . � - . , ' . � . � . . �. . ...- - . . , '. � - � � . . � � . ;. . .,� .. �,.+ke �`_' , . , . - . . ,. . . . . , . . � . . _. �, , �...� . '� . . . . � . . -� . �., ., .. .. . . � . - . . ' ' . . : . . � .� . ., . ... .. . �/ . ._ ' . .�. . ... . �.. � . .. � .. . . , ... - ... . . - . . . . � .. . � . ' . ' A�wt:is, ,19't� ' _ r� , ` � ,. ,. . ,. ,: _ ,. . ., , _ . - : . - : . • � , , , ,. .. - - , . , i. . _ _ . :,: a1r. Sas�naae lLtnsah . . . : .>. � Git�►.A�etosti�y � , �. , , . . .,. `- R�aa '�847, .�C�t�► Bn�.l � , , . � , .; -: $t. 'F�nt1, t�m��o��t , : . , . . , , � . � v ' Dias :l�. F3.��chs �� - , -. , , � '-' ,' ;. . � � . �Th� Cit�i t�tus�fl r�q�ast4; ��`� p�rrpata a� o�sd�.n;ef�aa� �i��ag � ` : ptti�o� a�` A i D ��sltf .Co�p� to,r�t�t+a��ts P�P� +� �1e,+rulait�. �i�lt .,. ., . . e� �t� Flsea ba� Ieyas 4roA Ht�►t `larc�i �� tm P-1. �d'dss�tt'iba,d #s . 'i.o�s 3� ii�d ��, sioari� 6„ :�#.11air�Q G�nesr ;l�di.li�n�. Lc� 37�, Bf��tir`6� �_ H�llct�s� E�ntsr A�ddi'ttoa va� ,�i�l�t.a! �roo e3ur p�pahta�t aad�� r**on�w1. ' . . _ _ �'exy t�u��,�►�'s, _ . , , � - . : , , , . , - , � . .; . , ,. . . , . , , . _ �. _ . _ Ae�sa Y�i�t '�� • r _ QitT, �:1�cit - �' . � _ _ :_ . ��llf�p.td�� . ` , � _ , . . . .. � .. � \. �. . . . . .. . ' ? .�� y �,. . `. . .: .. . , . . . .. . . ^ ' '♦ ., � . . � � ' . , , , ,— � _ �. r , . , . . � . � � _ _ , , _ , . , . , : . .r. i , , . . , . � � ;:. . ' ,cv .. � . � .. . . . i . . . . . . . . .. � . . - � . . ... . . , . � . . `. . .. ' ,� . '.. ..�. . . ._ .. . . _ . , . . . : � . . � . � ' . . . ., � : . � . ,. . �. . . . . . � . � '; - - � - .. , i- .. - .. . . . � . . . . .;�. ._ . . � . .. . . , . . . . . ' � . . . . � . . . . .. � ".. .. ��. / . . ' . _ - . . i . . ., � � ,. . r , . . . . , . � . . . . . � . �.. ��•:.� . , - , . , �- . . . ' ',. . �� .. .. . . . . . � �, � :: . ' . . . . . ... . --. .: :� � .: � . : � . '� � .. . .. . . . , . . .� . .. /. _ . i . . .., ' �' - . � . . �,�_ . , . . ,. . . >, . ��-. .. .�. .: , � :. . . � . � ` . � . � . . '. ',. . ..� , � , �1TY o, CITY OF SAINT PAUL ��` '�� DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT � ti � ��t � . .' DIVISION OF PLANNING ��P ^c 421 Wabasha Street,Saint Paul,Minnesota, 55102 ... 612-298-4151 George latimer Mayor August 11 , 1978 Rose Mix, City Clerk 386 City Hall St. Paul , Minn. 55102 Dear Madam: This is written in response to the petition of A & D Realty Company to rezone property on the east side of Gary Place between Iowa and Hoyt from R-3 (Single Family Residential ) to P-1 (Parking). The request was filed on a consent form petition subscribed & sworn to before a notary public on November 29, 1976. This matter was heard by the Current Planning & Zoning Comnittee on February 7, 1977. There was considerable neighborhood opposition; major concerns were the encroachment of business and associated noise, crime, tr.affic and parking problems. Staff recommended approval of the rezoning. The Current Planning & Zoning Committee recommended denial on a vote of 3 to 2, based on the concerns raised by the neighborhood. On February 18, 1977 the Planning Commission determined that inasmuch as the neighborhood concerns had not been addressed, and that a site plan of the proposed lot had not been submitted to the committee, the matter should be referred back to the committee. The Commission advised the applicant of their alternatives: request another hearing before the Current Planning & Zoning Committee or after 60 days petition the City Council for a hearing date. On March 28, 1977 the Greater East Side Council voted to oppose the A & D Realty rezoning (letter attached). On May 18, 1978 A & D Realty appeared before the City Council to request disposition of the rezoning. A hearing date of July 6, 1978 was set. On July 6, 1978 A & D Realty, complying with the Greater East Side Council , re- quested that the Council lay over the rezoning to permit A & D Realty to attempt a solution through the district planning process. On August 8, 1978 at the general membership meeting of the Greater East Side Council,their zoning committee recommended the denial of the rezoning of Lot 17 (fronting on Iowa) and the approval of the rezoning of Lots 34 & 35 (fronting on Hoyt), with the stipulation that A & D Realty comply with the P-1 regulations •��5� . Rose Mix, City Clerk August 11 , 1978 Page Two and that the lot be posted for employee parking only. There was considerable opposition which focused on run-off created by blacktopped areas,spot rezoning, infringement on the residential neighborhood, and the devaluation of homes. The motion to accept the recommendation of the zoning committee was denied on a 78 to 25 vote. This matter is scheduled to be heard by the Saint Paul City Cou ncil on August 15, 1978. Sincerely, `�'��-� � �{�t.c0. Donna F. McNeally City Planner DFM/gf Enc. Zoning File No. 8084 � PLANNING BOARD STAFF REPORT February 17, 1977 pi8t �p 34 8084 1. APPLICANT'S NAME : A & D Realty Co. 2. CLASSIFICATION . � Amendment � Appeal ❑ Permit � Other 3. PURPOSE . Rezone to P-1 4. LOCATION . East side of Gary Place between Iowa and Hoyt 5. LEGAL DESCRIPTION : Lots 17, 34 & 35, Block 6, Hillcrest Center Addn. 6. PRESENT 20DTING: R-3 7. PURSUANT TO Zoning Code Chapter: 64 Section: 21Q Paragraph: 8. STAFF INVESTIGATION & REPORT: Date: 2_$_�� By� LJJ A. SUFFICIENCY: The applicant's request for re2oning was filed on a long form petition. On January 21 , 1977 the Finance Director determined that the petition was sufficient. The City Planning office received the letter requesting review and recommendation from the City Clerk's office on January 31 , 1977. B. PROPOSED USE: The applicant is requesting rezoning of three lots from R-3 single family residential ) to P-1 (parking district) for the purpose of developing offstreet parking for business uses on the weSt side of Gary Place. C. FRONTAGE & AREA: Lot 17 has a 37 ft. frontaqe on Iowa, and Lots 34 & 35 have a combine 88 ft. frontaqe on Hoyt. The depth of all 3 lots is 125.5 ft. and the total area is approximately 15,688 sq. ft. , not i�cluding alley right-of-way. D. SITE CONDITIONS: The entire site is vacant. Lots 34 & 35 slope gradually up to t e alley an presently contain a large mound of debris or soil near the center. Lot 17 is about 5 or 6 ft. higher than the alley and is relatively level and landscaped somewhat by the abuttinq property owner. E. AREA CONDITIONS: The entire area, except for these vacant lots and a few lots to the north, is fully developed and appears well maintained. Newer, modestly valued, single family housinc� occupies the area east of Gary Place and the alleys that separate housing from comnercial developments along White Bear Ave. These areas are zoned R-3 and R-4 residential . West of Gary Place is the White Bear Ave. business district and the Hillcrest Shopping Center complex. Directly west of the subject lots is Hafners Restaurant & Bowling which has been built up to the lat line along the southern and eastern limits of the block. Offstreet parking for this enterprise is located within the block to the north and west of the structure, but is limited in space. On the north side of this block is the "1590" building, a small office structure with parking facilities mingled in with Hafners. F. FINDINGS: 1 . The commercial uses along White Bear Ave. are regarded as assets by the neighborhood and the community. . • A & D REALTY C0. Page 2 2. Land use conflict problems have always existed in areas where housing and business uses meet. Housing interests usually have been infringed on. 3. The location of the site in relation to existing comme�cial development severely limits its marketability for future single family housing. 4. One of the intents of a zoned parking district is to provide a buffer zone between incompatible land uses. � Without any site plan for review showing intended layout and aesthetic controls, it is not possible to corrment on the impact of such facility / �;5?j upon its surroundings. (� 6. A plan is being prepared by the General District planning process, one of the lssues being land use and circulation conflicts. This plan is anticipatPd to be in draft form sometime during 1977. G. STAFF RECOMMENDATIONS: Designation of the site as a P-1 district restricts the use of the property to the parking of automobiles. Overnight parkinq and automobile maintenance are prohibited on P-1 facilities by ordinance. To change the use of this property to any other use would require a new petition and another hearing. P-1 districts abutting residential property have the most restrictive standards for parking of any district in Saint Paul . While granting this rezoning may increase interest in similar actions� on other properties in the area, each case would be considered on its own merits. The use of this property for any of the purposes for which it is now zoned is improbable. Staff recommends approval of the rezoning. 11� �� n . March 28, 1977 Ms. Martha Norton Chairperson St. P�ul Plannin� Comm�ission 421 Wabasha St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 Dear Ms. Norton= At the March 14� 1977� Seneral msetin� of the Greater East Sid�e Community Council, action wa9 taken puttin� the Cammaxnity Council in opposition to the proposed rezoninB of lots for Hafner's parkin� lot. It is the feelin� of those i�volved that� at the present t�ne, this action would be inzppropriate. Lf thsre are any questions please feel free to call our office. (774-2599). Sincerely� � � ' �. � ��CL,�..<;� �,r "��fL' �.,c'.,�.��c�:j� ,i Karl Hozicevi�h Chairtna�n Greater East Side Com¢munity Council cc Niayor Iatimer City Council Donald L. Sp�id �, , 1 �3 �, 5 .� i � �1 j�'�� • � � � Oil, Chemical and Atomic Workers `r'�' -" . , � --�> Internationul Unron � e� �. � �. ��- . .,o,� 923 EAST SEVENTH STREET :r��,-�� + NICK KOVACH, PRESIOENT ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA 55106 PHONE: 774-5943 . ' �h11 YM��~� LOCAL UNiON 675 / ' 1 A- —_ w w"�,. �T111�7 18� �.978 r^ + , w , �� ra •. � J j• , �' • ir s+ ..� �. � t� JUL 2 1 ?�7� `� �:�aR�s oFF�c� Mayor George Latimer City Hall 15 W. Kellogg Blvd. St. Paul, MN 55101 Dear Mr. Mayor: The membership of O.C.A.W. , Local 6-75, would like to go on record as being opposed to the rezoning of Lots 17, 34 , and 35, Block 6, Hillcrest Center Addition from R-3, Single Family Residential, to P-1, Parking District, for the construction of a parking lot. By the time you receive this letter, you will probably have already received petitions from that neighborhood and other interested parties. This Local is confident that the type of mandate that all those signatures represent will be more than sufficient to influence your vote. We, however, like to leave no stone unturned. We are confident that our friends of Labor on the Council will vote the right tvay. Hoping you do, I remain, Yours truly, -, . �+--`� � Nick Kovach President O.C.A.W. Local 6-75 NK/mj ��-�+� , ` � � � , lst � � �2nd 3rd �la Adop ted Yeas pays BUTLER HUNT , --� �`�� 2'71`7�9 � / MADDOR ` ��'r/ _ (� `t�Q T - SHOWALTER � ' TEDESCO � PRESIDENT (HOZZA) � �'It.l�I ' : � ., �— _ � � g di p i�%a�"„� � j �.. IIII�,�;��J�� i �_.:;; �8 6. /q� � � � �� : ��k��z �. ��:, � ..,� �� p � �A AYE �� Gl ST. PAUL Me 28-56 L �� Dist Eztena YtBil. Heat/Type Style ❑ Dup�x 7'�SMCO 1953 6AS FA . RMBLER FierN ' p (�' � Lot Size Foundation Size Bese Ta�t � Tex Incl.Ast.[] HS . �.{�-��y .r �7 V . . �x 2ax�• x i a� N �� C f�4 Floor 2nd . � B�nt Mtg.Bal. � � X�R 13.61f'� . LR . . .RecRm�� 6 M2.00 �. � . Y, x 1oX12 DR 2200110 MoPayP&I , . �X 17Il9.9 �iCT � � � DwShf.❑ ' � . .. . � � . N 13.sx9 BR �rdo�Nood�Fan IM. Type .X %9.9X11 ... . BR . . �. � Air/CpW:CfA1T:� � � - . . .. 8R 12.iX'W C:Wh.�C.Swr. EIem.ScM gp � � Well ❑.SB tIC� �NAYDEN H6T . . . . � � . . . Bth F ks Look Box Jr.H: � ��X %161f - Frtn �� (�r.SZ.�OBL�2 STRY HAZEL'.P►RK � � . „ � REC 32X13 PacS li.PRESENT�TI011. Sr.H. � .. lenal/Rm�s LUt 1 �K 6 NI ST CENTER. dITRAL .roNISOM �+' �. i AIR �T 4.ECTR l'0lNIECTED 6ARId�E EXTERIQI STIfCCOED B-4 CLOSIir a�. -- _ -- _ . �... . . "_� .:.. _��-- — _: . .__ _.__ k.IS7 . SALaE _ �NIST i�E NM(T L�tS�T QTR L��AES;,. - �;�0 tP. ��I�Tt� � lMt1t� TL�,�e��PIt! 4�'1 �� ;�� 1863 IOMA E 716 3 43�900 EXPIRED" 63 O1/O1/T8 41 1 52� --- ----•• -•-- —_ �-.m .,.r—��°--� - lia�Fj�'y� 1 T ?r� �E71rkR�D 3 . 7f ;�+�'� 932 IOMA AVE M 744 3 51s900 PENDIN6 CO—UP.. 122 03/15/78 8 11 1853 576 iOMA E Tlb 3 S1s900 GANGELIED 28 11/08/77 56 . 45 676 � 586 lOMA E 7l♦ 2 34�500 GANGEILED 61 05/09/77 20 19 596 61tl IONA E Z,}�S. 3 36.500 34�000 LB.....CONV 140 140 Q /13/T8 81 �.1 9 280 �i26 I�iA,,� ��fi. ..3 "°-49s9QQ.. e�1V�D >'.�17 `b�/D5/77 93 "9��`:.`�� r.rw I .�a�e f��t'G �4�S`�D �— �3� �q y� . � `� _ � 34 0 I'11�3r'tK NT' j�-��-- �C�e.f vuJ d�C��c . A S K_ � •. i;� . .�ss ��s �,n�•��,w,�ea s�.rtd a.. S w ta. '�a.e.� A�'" T.,w� O r S� 1 C.. �y, �ob .e oe ... � b �o� " �t' 8 � 3 °'° �Oss �� J REAL ESTATE BROKERS, INC. �4�2 PROSPERITY AVENUE ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA 55106 774-8703 �0622 L-s58,�00 3-558 900 VA 6/13/78 37 DAYS LB-�9 98-49 � �� . �� ,g��p f; ..��y'c y+� r 'h.flQ": ,ry q .R<. � 4 �4�Y °i ' 2 4, Y ��;,. � �� n,l � I` q° � Y R I@� . y"3 � p � ` 4 ;� �f��'��\ 'ki.S�,. ��°�.�..eh4+�'.S.'�� xy� Ce.� �... �M. . �:: Addr�50�BARCLIY� G�T:PIUL M3�tt'�8 LM�)!0131� Dist Exterior Yr.Blt. He�llType Sryle Duplex 716 BRiCK 110 STUCCD 19S F.�.GAS_ RIIBLER� R2nI Lot Slte� FoUntlation Size Bese 7Na �Tet kICI.ASt.C. HS 83 1I 133 1 SF t J05.38 � - H C D 1tl Floor _ Znd Fba r dsrnt. __� Mtg Bai. % N 23.Y1113 LR k:_Rec Rm DR k; 220�i ll0 mOArnp MoPay C 61 11.71I9 KT i; p�hc h0 Drs,__ P _. N 11JIt9 BR II:.r d o��'Fiood"Fan Int....TYpe % 11.X11 BR l�� Air/COnd.CENiRLL M 12.101110.3 BR F;C.Wir.IY;C.Swr. Ebm.Schl BR u WPJI ❑' tiG FNOSt LIIKE FIILL Bih 8159ENT i�:fr ICS il,Lt�ck Box Jr.H. 3 SEISON frm 27I79.6 d�.Gar.Sz.DOUBLE NAiEL PARI! PORqI 23.9Xd Par.Sch.PRESENT�Ttdl Sr.H. L IlRmks LOT 7. BLOCK 2. PN�LEN TERR�CE. FENCED JOItlISdI YARD. NALF BATH IN B�SEIENT. YERY CLEAN�ID rELL KEPi. CO-OP SPLI� 60/10 ON 6%. Comm 7'bSB % Listet OLSON/NEIIERI Ph.77I-76M &kc R M-BURP15 RLiY /23 Ph.772-3167 Po55.Oate SN/7! � 7 d�ys oH mkf � ' � REAL ESTATE BROKERS, INC. �4�2 PROSPERITY AVENUE ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA 55106 774-8703 ! oezo�- ge,eoo s-l�sa epo AguM — �8/08/7� 1S ,DAYS L8 �0� SB 10d�, � ' ,p ,��i �� + �� y .i��,*�� y'�,�'� A:� ? C A k A ,.M'7" ,a k '6 � a 'n � ' �' �i+�'� �i:. ' . �� 'y�xE i�, , ; `.. 'N. � .A. -�� . R�� , � �� . �'Y�:' �� ♦ �y ^�e. :.:X'� Iwd�s�o stKS Cn r sr.P�a Ma za-3c L �e Dist E�9rqr Yr.Blt. Heat/Type Style ❑ upbx 718 CdP. 7970 GAS f.�. I(PANSIdI� Rln� . ' Lot She Fountlation Size Beso Tex Tex IncI.AS4I1 HS . 10 1I 700 26 Y 71 . 620.00 C 1�1 Floor 2�M Floor 0(I Bsmt.2Nt3r g.881. x 73t19 LR Kl Rec,Rm SPACE 31.1�Si DR 220f�110 t OAm MoPbyP&I t�tts.6 KT Il7 DwsM. z63.0i _ �2at2 BR 17.6�1] u fC:r8o HOOd GI1Fen Int Type X BR e1t13NY10 Y� AidC � BR kIC.W�r.�l C.Swr. EIem.Schl � � BR � CJ Well i� e�tiC x1zEL vlfpc - FLLL Bth V [! S Cl t Jr.H. % 12Y12.6 FrmOEM � F7Gar.Sz.1 U . Par. h.El. SACRYEXT Sr.M. I/RrtVcs LOT!. BIOCC 2.B1AY111GIIIM 21D AAO. N ING FlIIM(LENTSCH Y9- Comm 6%SB 10 %Lister JqM CELI6ERGER � Ph.18l-6763 9rkr.LpiStx CO IM[TIE -{106 P11.222-Q11 PoSS.QBte TSI.--�- �J'� d�ys pn � ��T �II'! :�IG� M"N " :��{� �� ;�, �;3.� ��` o.grw ,z�� II�Ip4� I ,I Gy��, �� ;;,��dih I, ��m�,;R� � ":..;...:'. 3 ::V Addr 1675 HOYT E Cit ST PAUI /B-28 L 77 3847 � o�st�x�e�w� Vr.Blt. Heat/Type sryryie ❑ a,� - 716 1LUIW�� 1952 G F A 1 1/2 STORY Rent . . �Lot Size Foundalion Size Base Tex Tax Incl.Ast.❑ h�$ 50 7(128 33%25 625.48 .I6 � C D 1�t F Flow � Bsmt. Mtg.Bal. 1f 18%12 LR ��REC Rm 30z15 � � + DR 0 2200110 60 MoPay P 81 . 117f9 KT � � DMShf.� ' '. K 12X11 BR ❑f8o OHaod OFan mt. Type z i2xi0 BR 'Kx�z AirlCond.wIxoal BR Q .Wtr.�C.Swr. 9em.ScM BR �❑Weq -tiC NAYDEN H6TS FIRI�[.T. ING RM OF ICS ❑LOCk BOZ Jr.H. . Frm � Gar.SZ.1.1/2 NAZEL PARK 1oX12 LDN AM Par.Sch.PRESEN7ITION Sr.H. L Rm HILLCREST CiNTER-LOT 18 BLK 6.�SUPH1 � . . . . „. _ . .. . . � F ��f ' �.lEJ _..__�._....� ' lifT SALE LIST SALE MRKT LAST QTR AiDRESS 0lST 8E@ M6IGE PllCE DfSCR[►TIUN ORI[R BIq�R DA7E TIME ISS. wtLl! /IC/ 1875 HOYT Q. T14 3 �i2�300 42�000 GO A�..FNA 36 16 OW'il/77 3S s3 672 2916 1875 FIQYT E Ti6 3 43rS0U E%►1J6EU � 57 O6/30/77 9S. Z+5 744— ---- -��- - _.. _ �3 0 �A�ls n�,��zK�,r T�� . ..�.�,. � i I V i �- �+ _ - - � _ I � ._ .__.., r__ O_ ,� .Q. •A � � 1 Q " , , Q , , { � _.__._.____ f�, .� � , _o _ .o � o _ �-- ---- U � , C?;O : u • � O O j„_ ,.�....�..�.---. oANO .� 3, „�.�.,....�.��. A�. �=, � ; •° � o00 000 000 0;; �! , � � � , � � + � . . v .i , ; � j - � , � � W I � � � i � � �p �1 �R -= V __L _ __ -I--_ _.. . - tf �� -- -- —r— � - � - -- --� i T . { _. f � J , ' I ` � ; ' , � I I � � , � I � ' . � O O O O O 0�4 ' � � ODIO►. 00 � O i ! I ; I . � � M2070 1-f30.300 S-f29.S00 FHA __ 02/07/76 6 0�115 LE-101 SB-101 r,�� I i,I,�N�mk��9g ._ ��, ��i� ��i'�i��M: � "I r a 3'e, '�` �� 4 f� �� .� � ;�;�� i y�� M; � � x:.x 1. ..A�Y^fi $'t nR :, .. .,.., . . .. ' i Addr.l E. Ho t -28�Code 6100�.. 1 Oist. &. Brkr. P kviex fte tara 0 P "4- rior Yr.&L Ik�etRYPe FIeaNCmt st [I p�P� � 1 C FA ------_ N x Rem Lat Size FoundationSize Beae ac aK Incl.AmM.I )HS 61( 4 4 8x 4 8, f INFiS 1ri Floor 2nd flaor Bsmt. 1 Mtp.Bal. � 1 .1X11. LR I Rec.Hm F 7k 8p0.00 �8X Dfl - 120 110 . Ab. Inc. &I � 11 6R8 2 Kit DvaM. .26 . T&I .6%11.4 BH - � R& jFlnod� F Im. Type � 11.6% 0.1 BR AidCond. . 8 BR C.Wtc C.S1v. Elem.ScM. , � B 1Nk11 I tic H en Hts. . Full Fr rs. Jc H. N ��h�Bl c 9.H. � n est Ph. - Jo - &Re�rks M 1 2 of Lot 1 and al of Lat 16 Block ' - � H t d w t so t c, i . t�n. O�k floors. �rY edce nrS6hDaa7wod. s • rap t �t m ��rsAsi�wrarAxw�... �rry sc 3 ' 185i NOYT E 716 3 32r500 EXPIRED 46 O1/15/76 93 2 4g6 � 1854 HOYT E 716 3 30�500 29�590 LB.....FHA 101 101 02/07/7b 6 10 590 2070 , �y� ,�hy s I'11 r9�IK.�t T �K t..._ ' SCA�E� I"= 200' �hlai��N�. ! � ""• �`�' �+�uu� � R�+�� 6 SA�,i�--.� I.ANMING �OARG , V V�CA(�J�i �,�----,-...........�r�...r.......,.�._...�...._.�_.;,.._._._..........�....... ,_...�...._........__._..�...�. � i _ ..... i i � � _ .. _ O 4 , .A � ♦ � � 0 1 � a ----�� -- _o , f _ _ _a ac o .�� ♦G � j `` Q�o.`� � • � ( o^ o � � i� .�...�.r...---- oA N 0 .� 3, --.�..�._.. A�. � � -.� , - � ; ��- ; o00 000 000 o�; a � c� ! � I � ' � ' �R = ` W v v - - -�- - - � � � � � Q �"'- • Q -- ---�- � - - _ __._, T _ i 1 , � J � ( � � I � � � _ ' ; ' . a. ,o 00 0 , 00 0 0 00 0; 00;0� � - -- - �, ��ra � �� M ' r--*- �--r-r-- , .-. "i""1T, � , , � v � � ; �'r ' � � -�_ � QjQ O `�Q ;O;O O ,U O 0;0;0;0 ;0,( � , � ; ; i_ iL_ � �l ' 1 I , _ , , . .,� � ; ; _ _� L---- -_. _ _, .. .... _ _ ._� . . .. ".__ _. _"_ _.,, p � . _ _IT�-�--j �. _.. _ _. __'__ _.� __ _ r. -T ( � � � � r� ' I f � t ; ' ;� '� ' � � , a , � I � . � ; � ; � a, c� � � � �R c� o 0 o"�L° I � 1° ° °►�1° ,��0� < (�— yoyT �.: qVF. _. 'a�� c�, a� � � c� � � '• - -- --� -- , ; ; . Q m ,�a m Q � c� o, � a, c� � o�oi - - ' � i �� -- - . , , , � , � i , , � � � :� „ I � � �� ; � , , , � . � , , � � � � � � � � � � � - I , - - 1 -�- -� 1 � � �;L___.�. � � ' ._ _ - - - --- ' - - - - - -- --- - i �i� i ! � ' � � � � ' � � a.M • � � � , � I � I � � ' I 1 + I Cb� • � ` , f � I � � � � b ;v = � ' � - - - .o ; ; ; ;' b0000000;o�o � o �oo�000 � . �.. � ---� Md 7' N �4 VE. q b �o o ��7 � � � ' � a;o►o� Q Q !c�� o 0 0 0 0 0 o;a,o 0 0 0 0 0�0 _ < < � f � i ' � , � � < � � � ! _ _ � � ' ' _t._--i_ � _ ' --L. �l_�_1_,�._.`..!_..1 � � ��T � , � � � ; � TT - ' � � � j • ; � � f ; ' ; I I � � � p �010010 O � � m , � � � � � �OIOIO�00 C� 43iC1 100 � (� G� � , . ..�_........., 11/E 8 A V� . � � � � i� ►� ,� ' • � Q �a �� Q � o 0 0 o b � o o( c�; m o� � � � . � � i i � 1 . � i i � � � � � � � ; , i � �i � � . _ .L. 1- - _J �._1�_ �R - � _ _-�- _ _- - --T- _ - -T- �-- ._ ._._r T-. _ ;-,-,- - - ,� .� � .F- � i� � , � i i � i � ��--- , � ; � _� �, � I = . O �, qv � � � - -~ OOOO Q � � iQ � � v � �� ; � �� i �Q I `~ � �w��s� s��a• � M P o ' �?--- o o c� o o an o o+o 0 00 oI'oio, '� � � � � P I � � � ! I � I 't � ►. t __.._o � � �. f � i i I � � - �.1 0 �: o-- �. ,---_�� _.1J. � � � � � �� C�� -�_�.__� '�"'' I , ' � ! t � i � i� ; , � � O i � i I ' , i �a ��b o o .,, ; �, o �o o �i c� o 0 0 0 0 o a d� b ; . • ; , _ . ��A ��►� 1 . . APPLLG44T A & D REALTY C0: ��;�;D � — ZONING OISTRiCT BOUNDARY PURPOSE REZONE TO P-1 ��:CL1D SUBJECT PROPERTY O OiVE FAAAILY 8084 � T W 0 FA M I LY FII.E N0. �� AAULTIPLE FAl�AlLY OATE 2-17-77 ,� • � n CO�IMERCiAL SCA�E� I"= 200' L NORTH � ° i1°�' ��'�USTRIAL. SA I.ANNiNG 80AR0 V Vw�iCAN�" ._..�.._.......... . i , , . 'r � + -- j�� t � �-. . • . . . • . 1' � _ � . . �� $ og CITX OF SAII�T. PAUI,, MINNEOSTA PETTTION TO AMEND CHAPTERS 60 thru 64 OP THE LEGISLATI.VE (ZO�JING) CODE TO: THE HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL Dated: October , 197b c/o the City Clerk, Room 386 City Hall _ City of St. Paul, Minnesota Pursu3nt t� Section� 64.06 of the LeFislative Code, w�, the ��r,der,ignc� ovrn�:s � of two-thirds of the several descriptions of real estate situated within 1aQ feet of the real estate affected, hereby acquiesce; and we, the owners of S0� �r more of the frontage to be reclassified, petition your Honorable Body to _ rezone the following described property: . � � Lots 17, 34, and 35, Block b, Hillcrest Center _ � f�om R-3 Di$trict to P-1 District, for the purpose of installing, constructing � an3/or operating the foilowing: parkzng lot incidental to business REC�RD O�dDTER . . SIGNATURE LQT BLO�K ADDITION � � Hillcrest Shopping Center ; 34 5 flillcrest Center Associates � _ . ` . . � �3.�rnard H.-Unger and 35 5 Hillcres� Center Pauline L. Unger - . � . John I�. Horvath and 36 � S Hillcrest Center �iary J. Horvath Roz�lla M. t��ilhelm 13 6 � Hill�r�s� �ea�er � Orville F. Kemp and 14 . 5 Hillcrest Center 21�r,�orie Kemp Gerald� L. Quernemoen and 15 6 Aillcrest Cent�r kow2na E. Quernemoen . Ri:.hard E. Feiertag and 16 6 HiZlcrest Center � �fartha M. Feiertag Cora M. Anderson 3b, except the W. Hillcrest Center � k9 feet �.hereof„ and . • � ' the W. 48 feet of I.ot � , 37', Elock 6 • . ICarl B. Meier and 37, e:ccept the W. Hillcrest Centex �.M.argaret C. Meier � 48 feet thereof, and � all of Lo�. 38, Block. 6 . G�rald I.eroy J�nes and ' 20, except the W. 2Q Hayden Aeights Georgann Marie Jones � 'feet thereof, and the . �i. 30 feet of �.ot 19, . Block i �. � � � � . � � � ( �(. . � . �`7�.`��y [��`� Page 2 . RECORD O�dNER SIGNATURE LOT BLOCK ADDITION Louis A. Sass and W. 20 feet of Lot 20 Hayden Heights Lorenia C. Sass, and Lot 21, except husband and wife the W. 10 feet thereof, Block 1 John A. Laska and W. 10 feet of Lot 21, .Hayden Heights Rae V. Laska all of Lot 22 and 23, except the W. 30 feet thereof, Block 1 � . rlarie L. Snyder . 24, except the W. 20 Hayden Heights nte feet thereof, and the - _ W. 30 feet of Lot 23, � ntE Block 1 ' � John E. Tuchner and 25, except the W. 10 feet Hayden �Ielgtts Dorothy Tuchner thereof, and the W. 20 feet of Lot 24, Block I � City of Saint Paul, E. 29 feet of Lots 27 Hayden Heights :s a Municipal Corporation and 43, Block 1 Robert L. Scott and 44 � - Hayden Heights Leota M. Scott , s Anna Herold 45 1 Hayden Heights Amos N.. Johnson and 46 1 Aayden Heights �e Bertha F. Johnson Stanley F. Turnowski and _ 47 1 Hayden Aeights Mary E. Turnowski � . sd Mary G. Bunde 25 2 Sayden Seights Winton A. Smith and All of Lot 26, and Sayden Heights neLoris J. Smith the E. 26 feet of . Lot 27, Block 2 Donald T. Solheid and All of Lot 27, except Hayden Heights: Margaret M. Solheid , the E. 26 feet thereof, . • - and all of Lot 28, except the W. 7 feet thereof, Block 2 Aobert K. Wilson and 29, and the W. 7 feet Hayden Heights Lorraine C. Wilson of Lot 28, Block 2 Mary I. Navins 30 2 Hayden Heights Marie P. Jaspers 31 2 Hayden Heights Dworsky & Dworsky 32 2 Hayden Heights Robert L. Helleen and . 33 2 Hayden Heights Jeanette E. Helleen _ 2 - --- � . j . . -* - • _.` � ;, , -- �' .i ' ��.�� 1��tc..Q �( CITY OF SAINT. PAUL, MTI�NEOSTA PETITION TO AI�ND CHAPTERS 60 thzu 64 OI' THF. LEGISLATIVE (ZONING) CODE T0: THE HONORABLE MA.YOR 11ND CITY COUNCIL llated: October , 1976 c/o the City Clerk, Room 386 City Hall � City of St. Paul, Minnesota Pursuant to Section 64.06 of the Legislative Code, we, the undersigned owners - of two-thirds of the several descriptions of real estate situated within Id0 feet of the real estate affected, hereby acquiesce; and we, the owners of 50� or more of the frontage to be reclassified, petition your Honorable Body to . rezone the following described property: Lots 17, 34, and 35, Block 6, Hillcrest Center from R-3 District to P-1 District, for the purpose of installing, constructing and/or operating the following: parking lot incidental to business RECORD OWNER IGNATURE LOT BLOCK ADDITION - "� X Hillcrest Shopping Cente _ 5 Hillcrest Center Associates enera artne � � - ' Bernard H. Unger and 3 5 HiZlcrest Center Pauline L. Unger � . . John L. Horvath and 36 5 Hillcrest Center Mary J. Horvath _ ` Rozella M. Wilhelm 13 6 Hillcrest Center Orville F. Kemp and 14 6 Hillcrest Center Marjorie Kemp Gerald L. Quernemoen and 15 6 Hillcrest Center Rowena E. Quernemoen Richard E. Feiertag and 16 6 Hillcrest Center Martha M. Feiertag Cora M. Anderson , �- �� 36, except the W. Hillcrest Center 49 feet thereof, and . the W. 48 feet of Lot 37, Block 6 Karl B. Meier and 37, except the W. Hillcrest Center Margaret C. Meier `",�j��,�C•T� 48 feet thereof, and all of Lot 38, Block 6 Gerald Leroy Jones and 2J, except the W. 20 Haj►den Aei;hts Georgann Marie Jones _ 'feet thereof, and the W. 30 feet of Lot 19, Block 1 , , .� , �' . ` ' � I� ' . . Page 2 RECORD OWNER SIGNATURE LOT BLOCK ADDITION Louis A. Sass and W. 20 feet of Lot 20 Hayden Heights Lorenia C. Sass, and Lot 21, except husband and wife the W. l0 feet thereof, Block 1 John A. Laska and W. 10 feet of Lot 21, Hayden Heights Rae V. Laska all of Lot 22 and 23, except the W. 30 feet thereof, Block 1 Marie L. Snyder 24, except the W. 20 Hayden Heights feet thereof, and the - W. 30 feet of Lot 23, Block 1 � John E. Tuchner and 25, except the W. 10 feet flayden Heigt Dorothy Tuchner thereof, and the W. 20 , feet of Lot 24, Block 1 City of Saint Paul, E. 29 feet of Lots 27 Hayden Heights a :Iunicipal Corporation and 43, Block 1 Robert L. Scott and 44 1, - • Hayden Heights Leota M. Scott Anna Herold 45 1 Hayden Heights Amos N.. Johnson and 46 1 Hayden Heights Bertha F. Johnson Stanley F. Turnowski and 47 1 Hayden Heights X �tar.y E. Turnowski Mary G. Bunde 25 2 Hayden Heights Winton A. Smith and All of Lot 26, and Hayden Heights DeLoris J. Smith the E. 26 feet of Lot 27, Block 2 Donald T. Solheid and All of Lot 27, except Hayden Heights Margaret M. Solheid the E. 26 feet thereof, and all of Lot 28, except the W. 7 feet thereof, Block 2 Rabert K. Wilson and 29, and the W. 7 feet Hayden Heights Lo�raine C. Wilson of Lot 28, Block 2 Mary I. Navins � °�' �-�0 2 Hayden Heights -Marie P. Jaspers 31 2 Hayden Hei.ghts Dworsky & Dworsky 32 2 Hayden Heights Robert L. Helleen and 33 2 Hayden Heights Jeanette E. Helleen �� . . . • �� .._ .. - . . . ..� �• � l ' .� Page 3 RECORD OWNER SIGNATURES LOT BLOCK "'ADDITION Frederick S. He�rring 1 and 30, B1ock 1; Lot Kerwins Out X Alice Mae Thaemert 1, Block 2, J. A. Hum- Lots Floran E. Herring phrey's Subdivision "A" and . Lot 30, Block 1 and Lots 1 and 30, Block 2, L. T. Lawton's Subdivision of Lot 8 x ± Hillcrest Shopping Center � Associates - � 34 6 Hillcrest Cente ar tn Donald S. Hafner The West 49 feet of Hillcrest Cente and Albert M. Hafner Lot 36, Block 6 Louis A. Sass and 21, except the West Hayden Heights Lorenia C. Sass 10 feet, Block 1 A & D Realty Company, 26 and the West 10 feet Hayden Heights a partnership con- of Lot 25 in Block 1 sisting of Albert � Hafner and Donald Hafner Al1en Nilva and 27, except the East 29 Hayden Heights Bert Gitsug, feet, Block 1 � executors of Estate . - � of Herman Pastex � '� . Hillcrest Development �� Block 8, Aillcrest Hillcrest Cente� - eneraZ-P-ar�n ter Plat 2, except the West 100 feet of the South � 171 feet thereof, also except the Westerly 240 feet of the Northerly 78 feet thereof, And Lots 17 and 34, except that part platted _ � as Hillcrest Center, Plat 2, and a11 of Lot �3 35,y Block 6, Hillcrest Center xi� Hillcrest Sho g PPIn Center c: 1 7 Hillcrest Associates ' enera ar ne � � Center Plat 2 � - � _ ' p-� � . ld-� � r ...t . , ' �� , � ° ._ �� .00 . , . �k ' � : . �'7�.r7�9 � �� CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNEOSTA �� PETITION TO Ar1END CHAPTERS 60 thru 64 OI�' THE LEGISLATIVE (ZONING) CODE T0: THE AONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL Dated: October �_, 1976 c/o the City Clerk, Room 386 City Hall City of St. Paul, Minnesota Pursuant to Section 64.06 of the Legislative Code, we, the undersigned owners of two-thirds of the several descriptions of real estate situated within 100 feet of the real estate affected, hereby acquiesce; and we, the owners of 50% or more of the frontage to be reclassified, petition your Honorable Body to rezone the following described property: Lots 17, 34, and 35, Block 6, Hillcrest Center from R-3 District to P-1 District, for the purpose of installing, constructing and/or operating the following: parking lot incidental to business RECORD OWNER SIGNATURE LOT ELOGK ADDITION p � '�- �1��" Hillcrest Development � w�34 5 Hillcrest Center �;f� ��,�-^ _. �e.r . . �� y".-�,,, �,��,� Bernard H. Unger and 35 5 Hillcrest Center ,� � "�ad' Pauline L. Unger �� John L. Horvath and 36 5 Hillcrest Center Mary J. Horvath �f� Rozella M. Wilhelm �,; ;�,': �, �%,�' ',; 13 6 Hillcrest Center � � ! Orville F. Kemp and 14 6 Hillcrest Center Marjorie Kemp _ _ �`,�Gerald L. Quernemoen and � ' v�� 6 Hillcrest Center Rowena E. Quernemoen � Richard E. Feiertag and 16 6 Aillcrest Center Martha M. Feiertag • Cora M. Anderson 36, except the W. Hillcrest Genter 49 feet thereof, and the W. 48 feet of Zot 37, Block 6 Karl B. Meier and --- 37, except the W. Hillcrest Center Margaret C. Meier 48 feet thereof, and all of Lot 38, Block 6 �; ." Gerald Leroy Jones and v 20, except the W. 20 Hayden Heights (°. - Georgann Ma'rie Jones '` 'feet thereof, and the W. 30 feet of Lot 19, Block 1 : P�i 1 dred Condon � `� a8 � Fiayden Nei ghts i�_ �u �,�� .� � _ �. . ' ,� , � . . -� Page 2 RECORD OWNER SI ATURE LOT BLOCK ADDITION Louis A. Sass and �0/� W. 20 feet of Lot 20 Aayden Heights !� Lorenia C. Sass, and Lot 21, except '� �� husband and wife the W. 10 feet thereof, Block 1 /� �- ( John A. Laska and ,� /, ; W. 10 feet of Lot 21, Hayden Heights �'� Rae V. Laska � � '� all of Lot 22 and 23, � � �except the W. 30 feet thereof, Block 1 - '" � j , Marie L. Snyder ;; � ��24, except the W. 20 Hayden Aeights �' Contract Purchaser � feet thereof, and the W. 30 feet of Lot 23, �. � ( ��, � B}.ock 1 � ! �` �, '�, � l'I/John E. Tuchner and , � �v ��r�'W" 5, except the W. 10 feet Hayden Heigt Dorothy Tuchner ; thereof, and the W. 20 NOW OWNED BY A A D . '� feet of Lot 24, Block I � °;::�,�_ � ` 7+ '�ity�f Saint Paul, E. 29 feet of Lots 27 Hayden Heights a Municipal Corporation and 43, Block 1 .:.-� � Robert L. Scott and ��f r� ,, _ ✓ � �4 1 Hayden Heights Leota M. Scott ��--��i '� +�' � Uy Anna Herold ,! i��i.L' ��1JL� 45 1 Hayden Heights � ��. Amos N. Johnson and % r✓ 46 1 Aayden Heights b�'-� Bertha ]L, Johnson , � . �.�,/ � . � Stanley F. Turnowski and !� �47 1 Hayden Heights ��_a��"�� ary E. Turnowski � ;ti�',�,. _ ` �,L Mary G. Bunde ,.- '' - ��ee�� 25 2 Hayden Heights Winton A. Smith and AlI of Lot 26, and Hayden Heights DeLoris J. Smith the E. 26 feet of Lot 27, Block 2 �.� �.— � �s � Donald T. Solheid and , Z..�-( � , ` �yt.All of Lot 27, except Hayden Heights � �,v, Margaret M. Solheid � ' - the E. 26 feet thereof, and all of Lot 28, except the W. 7 feet thereof, Block 2 �, : : Robert K. Wilson and , and the W. 7 feet Hayden Heights n� � Lorraine C. Wilson � �/,��-�28, Block 2 f�+.c., � ,, I�ary I. Navins 30 2 Hayden Heights � Marie P. Jas ers � � ` � �`-" P � . � �l 2 Hayden Heights , � G�„Jl �q T,�,� �.�� Dworsky & Dworsky � 32 2 Hayden �tefghts ,.'( Robert L. Helleen and }' � 2 Hayden Heights - Jeanette E. Helleen � .�� :� � : _�. �� ` , .E '=:�' '�.s✓ � � , _ . e . ' ,. � ,_ . , • . -' Page 3 RECORD OWNER SIGNATURES LOT BLOCK "`ADDITION Frederick S. Herring ��C'F�f��p 1 and 30, Block l; Lot Kerwins Qut Alice Mae Thaemert �� 1, Block 2, J. A. Hum- Lots Floran E. Herring � phrey's Subdivision "A" and Lot 30, Block 1 and Lots 1 and 30, Block 2, L. T. Lawton's Subdivision of Lot 8 n � Hillcrest Developme �� L� s=�- 34 6 Hillcrest Cente , +��`��i �, + ,rv�� Donald S. Hafner -'"" �i � � �vThe West 49 feet of Hil.lcrest Cente and Albert M. Hafner Lot 36, Block 6 , (��,G'.ti� Louis A. Sass and 2� 21, except the West Hayden Heights ; ;�� , � Lorenia C. Sass � 10 feet, Block 1 �'`� � %' �.. , _, A & D Realty Company, 26 and the West 10 feet Hayden Heights "1 a partnership con- � J ,/ d of Lot 25 in Block 1 �r ,{ sisting. of Albert �`''`-°�-��1 y � ^� �f� �� Hafner and Donald Hafner ` �.�:,Allen Nilva and �� 27, except the East 29 Hayden Heights t;,��' � Bert G�tsug, feet, Block l , and Lots �� " executors of Estate 41, 42, and 43 except of Herman Paster the East 29 feet thereof, � Block 1 ,� ; '� Hillcrest Developmen , �- -' � 1, Block 8, Hillcrest Hillcrest Cente� � , �q�,r�' Center Plat 2, except the West 100 feet of the South � 171 feet thereof, also except the Westerly 240 feet of the Northerly 78 feet thereof, And Lots 17 and 34, except that part platted as Hillcrest Center, Plat 2, and all of Lot . _ , � 35, Block 6, Hillcrest Center �, ;;�apitol Acceptance � 1 7 Aillcrest ' ` t'`Cor oration �v�,� �' P Center Plat 2 , �` �' `� �� }�" � � �4� � ..;�: ' �� A & D Realty Company', a partnership Lots 17, 34, 35, Block 6, Hillcrest Cente� � y `�� consisting of Alber f r and '� 1�� Donald Hafner Albert M. Ha er General Partner '�'� �.,;;;;, STATE OF MINNESOTA ) �"� � � ' ss. ��.� '' ' COUNTY OF RAMSEY ) � Albert M. Hafner, being first duly sworn, deposes and states that he is the person who circulated the within petiti�n consisting of three (3) pages; that the parties described above are the owners respectively of the lots placed immediately following each name; that this petit'ion was signed by each of said owners in the presence of this affiant, and that the si tures above are the true and correct signatures of each and all of the parties rib Alb t M. Hafner, Gene al Partner Subscribed and sworn to before me this � day of ov• , 1976. �' , � i � LARRY NEILSON NOTAR PUBLIC �'-' NOTARY PUBLIC- MINNESOTA RAMSEY COUNTY My Comm.Expires Dec.10,1982 � yvvvwvww�^"'• _ � , , . , -� ` , � • • _ �� STATE OF MINNESOTA ) . ss. AFFIDAVIT COUNTY OF RAMSEY ) CITY OF ST. PAUL ALBERT M. HAFNER, being first duly sworn, deposes and states that he is a General Partner in A & D Realty Company, a partnership con- sisting of Donald llafner and Albert Hafner, and said partnership desires to have the following property rezoned: Lots 17, 34, and 35, Block 6, Hillcrest Center; That affiant does not have any legal or equitable interest in, is not in the act of purchasing, nor has he purchased or sold within one year preceding the date of the attached petition, any land contiguous to the property sought to be rezoned as described above, except (see attached) ; That affiant understands the word "contiguous" as used herein to mean parcels of property sharing a common boundary at any point without regard to the presence of public thoroughfares. A & D REALTY COMPANY, a partnership j � �, �'; ; � � � � ' � , ';\ � �`�•r'• �� ;�� F �, ' ,,, By: li Alb rt M. Ha ner STATE OF MINNESOTA ) . ss. COUNTY OF RAMSEY ) The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this a,°� day of �,p�_ , 1976, by Albert M. Hafner, partner on behalf of A & D REALTY COMPANY, a partnership consisting of Albert M. Hafner and Donald Hafner. I � ` � NOTARY UBLIC � ■ LARRY NEILSON �� ; , ,�� `� NOTARY PUBLIC- MINNESOTA �� ` RAMSEY COUNTY �;. ,,,,�,, My Comm.Expires Dec.30,1982 xvvvwwwvv�r.r M '� �� , . . J - ► ^o . , . REAL ESTATE OWNED BY PETITIONER LOT BLOCK ADDITION 25, except the West 10 1 Hayden Heights feet thereof, the West 20 feet of Lot 24 West 10 feet of Lot 25 1 Hayden Heights Lots 26, 28, 29, 31, 32, 1 Hayden Heights 33, 34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39 The West 49 feet of Lot 36 6 Hillcrest Center Lot 1 8 Hillcrest Center (,,�.. �.,� . /��'., � Plat 2 �t✓',�� ,��'� ;,.�...�' � ;� �`,�D�.= �h.::. �� .:., " ' �`, ' %'`� , `� ^ . ��;:� ! i � i � � � i 1 � i , � f � � � � � .�.�..�....�.... , � ; ► i � i i I ' � ; � . . � i : I � . i � � <,:� y--.,e.,;--�I�"�,_��i '=—•, .r:+ t—� � r E . � t - � . I ' i f i i . I { � , ( � + �.:�...........,.. _ _ �..__...�. ._.�-.� ..4.-.^..._._. ....._.__'_-°.�_��e!'7_ _ _.______._..._._..�.....-.._._..._.._...._,...`._..-'-._..........._...._._...._.�..._..._._..._•____"_— _---------.__._._.___.._�._-...._._ .� .r.,...._.r.,..�..».. .Y . i � . . . . ___. � *_._ _ _.,. ._..__._______"' J._...�._�_...��.-.-J...._.... ._._...�_____.._...,...,* � . . ,�,� � i + � �� ,. 'Y ( . ��'� � .�_�_._._ .,..10,�.._..._..._._...�. , i � � � • , � � � - . ` � ' i .�.. . . : 1 � � �� f � ,�i i � . i , � ! � �� `! � � �� 1 , �� / � � � � � � � . �:f��- �y i � � . x4 �, ;, rIF. � _ _. �_. _ _ . ----- - - r w.. f �. �.w / ,.. 1 � ��t f �: I - 1 . , . �.:. + . P,#.'.,. _ . - � ,� ,ti�r . I � / � �� J��~� , � � �' .� �� .._ , � .r' 4�" _ � x I ;,��r 'y��`'� S . � '! �.. �. ,}'� :� ''� �.�.�'a'Ft � f � ��r`a��fF y. � �� T � ai � j ,, '� ..,,�-� I � t� ��'�}t�,��'`� ...::�. � . f ' � � � - t f'��'`�a��'tG�� 1 0 ,�� ,�3''� � � � �� " r 'da .� a, .a� � � � ��'`�'' � ,��1 ,��c! � � � � � � ' , ' . ' f �1 -� �' _ .- �f �` '�(, , ; � - � �.. �� ` � �/� . ��./ , �� . ;�; • : _ ... � - � 'f� % � # . . .�,... �_ . �_ . .� ._._._ - . . �._ � � � ,,� -t i- �'� C _ � � � � � -,v , ;� 1�� . �� t �� ;i, . ✓ � '�. ,.�- ' � .� �` x°. � fi° I ; . i �m t � " � �� .' ,jc` �; X ;,� .�.,'�;., . �' F � ' . , -fi ---�: .-�-- �---. T.,t- r` .�-- , � j. ,r... .:l ,; � `... � _ _ � ; . �.•. -'F � . � � { � . _. .; � ,_ ;Ui _ � � ,s��-�<_ t: �_ ,.. �,� _.... . . _ . (jp �� Z ,�''k'`",/� y, ' �' 4:�' ' �, � • � �.` � \ „w� •N;q�l�� =•1 Z � . �`�'�1�1! � <;�,s � ..,'.�' � _._ t' � � � 2 � �� -x7i� �nio�.,zt c"'�-,�+� �rr�" , � � � �. ,��r� .d" �� j�' �� :� fi � � �c�•Z� � �� ' '<< cn ' �,--�,-�� -�._. � :: � , , � , � _— __._ I� �� 's'�.� ., ' : ��:� --� ��+�� ;-_�_1.....�.;.._� .�:.. � � � � - 7� __ �d j �F —+� � 4 � f� � '~ • 5y �:: { � �_ .,��*�' _._:�... 1 ; � � � � -�� Jr1 ��J �sw��... L._:�� --"�`�" .�`��- � •(J� �� ; � •' ~�V � {`,� � ' , 1 . � �. � � 1 . � _ �}'� �. � r t.. . .�;� �,� _ �y � � � /i� -.•-, "-- ...,� ' ,,,r , j t E� ; , ( _.i,�,2 �,�"-_ ,t �fi '', , �/ ,�`�+,'�� {�, � " � � � � ,� � � ,``� , t ��t�+.�,��.. ,� ,% � 4� _ � � �```' �C,. , `.,s�� j: '` .. i�`, -, � 1 I `�"- I �✓'�c.°�,^'\°�. r I • ' t � � � �, �4. � � ��` ;Oo ._ ,��,.,�-� � � ,, .;;� , f , � � r�, ...,; rc , . � � „ , � � • 1 — ,�--��------ -- '�"�� . .� _ ""` - - �, _....� -- — --�..�. _ .�..__ __ _ — - i -._,_..,.,,.. -- — — _ ,�'r, ^_._ � � _ _ _._. ._.._.�. �-__�-.._.....� . _ _ ....._._... -----�--- . ��-_- .._....._ Z \ ��t'�� r� � '..�'o ; �.��1 N t� �.l z3�� .�`� � � � ( � . �' � � , �` i � >-- � . — — f=�r� ' G �1..-�.t __ _- .�