270495 WH17E - CITY CLERK COUI1C11 ������
PINK - FINANCE � TT�
CANA�RY- DEPARTMENT G OF SA I NT PA l.l L �
BLUE - MAVOR � Flle NO.
Ordindnce Ordinance N 0. � `'� l��
•
Presented By
' Referred To Committee: Date
Out of Committee By ' Date
An ordinance amending the Saint Paul Zoning
Ordinance, Chapters 60 through 64 of the Saint
Paul Legislative Code.
THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN: �
Section 1.
That the Zoning Map of Saint Paul, Sheet No. 11, as incorporated
by reference in Section 60.401 of the Saint. Paul Legislati�e Code,
is hereby amended as follows:
The property on the Northwest corner of Lexington
Parkway and Minnehaha Avenue, more particularl,y described
as follows:
Lots 28 and 29, Block 8, Gilbert Addition;
is rezoned from R-4 to RM-2.
Section 2.
This ordinance shall take force and effect in thirty (30) days
from and after its passage, approval and publication.
,�,
COUNCILMEN
Yeas Nays Requested by Department of:
Butler
Hozza ' In Favor —
Hunt
Roedler � Against. BY
Sylvester
Tedesco ` rri n � �97�
4�..� L Form Approved by City Attorney
Adopted by Council:- Date
Certified a d y Counc' ecre BY u! ���'�"���
By �
Approv by Mayor: Da Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
8
B
BY ;. ,_; Y
. . . �
� � 1� � �'�����-
� �
C�TY o,� CITY OF SAINT PAUL
'�°� '- DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
g ,�, �
' •'��"���' ' DIVISION OF PLANNING
�s �e'
�,� 421 Wabasha Street,Saint Paul,Minnesota,55102
612-298-4151
George Latimer
Mayor
January 4, 1978
Rose Mix, City Clerk
�
386 City Hall
St. Paul , Minn. 55102 Legal Description: Lots 28 & 29, Block 8,
Gilbert's Addition
Dear Madam:
This letter is written in response to the petition of Richard Sagesetter to
rezone property located at the northwest corner of Lexington and Minnehaha
from R-4 (single family residential ) to RM-2 (medium density low rise
multi family residential ). The purpose of this rezoning is to remove the
nonconforming status of his existing 8-unit apartment b�ilding.
This matter was heard before the Current Planning & Zoning Committee on
December 1 , 1977 at which time staff recorr�nended that the petitioner's request
be granted. Ms.'�';McGinley moved to recor�nend denial of the request to rezone
to RM-2. Mr. Hummer seconded the motion and it passed on a 5 to 2 roll call
vote, with Messrs. Pangal and Bryan dissenting.
On December 2, 1977 the Planning Commission confirmed the recommendation of
the Current Planning & Zoning Committee by a 16 to 2 roll call vote.
This matter is scheduled to be heard before the Saint Paul City Council on
January 5, 1�978.
Si r ly,
� ����
E ward J. Warn
Senior City Pla er
EJW/gf
Enc.
Zoning File No. 8243
<a�
. .
' 1 � 1 1 1 ' � �
, � � , _
■�■��■■�
�� ��������������
� � � �a ■����o��o��e��
� � � a�■ ■�e■�o��o��se■
� � � ���e�����o��■e���■
� � �����������������■
� � o��o��e�����o��e�■
. . ����:.-.::�er���■��■
o��o��o��e��e��e�■
. o��o��o��e��e��e�■
� � ���o��o��e��e��e�■
o��o��e�■ ■a�e�e�■
�� �_o������■ ■������
o��o��o��e���e�o��
, � � o��o��o�■ ■e��o��
� e��o��e��e ■e��o�■�
� � � o��o��o��o ■���o�■
� � � ■��������e ■e���o■
� � � o�oo��o��e��o��e�■
� � ■�■�����■ ■o��o�■
� � 0��o��e�■ ■�o�o�■
, : . �s������■ ■������■
� � o��o��e�■ ■�a��o�■
� � ���m���■■�■■���o�o■
� , � ,, , , ,, , ,
� � �:_ �.�_ _.I�..� .- � .� � ..�� ��..�l /,
. . l� .� . «. �_ �.... _ , � ,. �r.����.. /- -
, , _ � r� " , lC._. , �
. � ..i�L.� I /
� � /' _.w i ii � , ��� i •�. � %
� � , �� ��. /_ t �/,'1, �_��
, �r
� � . �Ir�i �/ � � �' �1 i.��
,� /
i
.
. ���� :��
MINUTES OF THE MEETING OF THE CURRENT PLANNING b �ONING
COMMITTEE THURSDAY, DECEMBER 1 , 1977, IN COUNCIL CHAMBERS,
SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA
PRESENT: Mmes. Grittner, Karns, McGinley and Summers, and Messrs. Hummer,
Pangal and Bryan of the Current Planning & Zoning Committee; Mr. Robert
Straughn, Assistant City Attorney; Mr. Richard Amey of the Division of
Housing & Building Code Enforcement; Mmes. McNeally and Fox and Mr. Edward
J. Warn of the Planning Staff.
The meeting was chaired by James Bryan, Chairman.
RICHARD SAGESETTER (#8243): A petition to rezone from R-4 to RM-1 property
�ocatea on t e northwest corner of Lexington and Minnehaha.
The petitioner was present. There was no opposition.
Mr. Warn read the staff report and showed slides of the subject site.
Richard Sagesetter, 1003 Van Buren, said he had purchased the property when the
zoning was correct, and he was asking no more than what he had before the zoning
map was changed.
Mr. Humner asked if Mr. Sagesetter intended to expand and the petitioner said
no, that he just wanted to be in the correct zone so he could refinance if necessary.
Mr. Pangal said he understood that RM-1 had been requested in error, and actually
RM-2 was being requested, and Mr. Sagesetter said this was correct.
Ms. Summers moved to recomnend approval of the RM-2 rezoning, but the motion failed
for lack of a second.
Mr. Hummer said the entire neighborhood is single family homes and he thought the
City Council chose to zone that whole area residential R-4. He said there is a
question in his mind and that perhaps property would stick out like a sore thumb.
Ms. McGinley then moved to recommend denial of the request, and Mr. Hurrrner seconded
the motion. Ms. McGinley discussed spot zoning and said the petitioner could
continue with the present zoning, '
The motion then passed on a 5 to 2 roll call vote, with Messrs. Pangal and Bryan
dissenting.
Su mitted by: Approved by:
;
J, �
�� ,'✓?? ��"_'��_Z z
Edward J. W n . James Bryan, Cl�r�man
�' _ .
PIANNING HQARD STAFF lZEPORT D2Cembel^ 1 , 1977 Plat Map 26
� $243
1. APYLICANT's taar� : RICHARD SAGESETTER
2. CLASSIFICATION . � Amendment � Appeal � Permit � Other
3. PURPOSE : Rezone to RM-1
4. LOCATION : Northwest corner Lexington and Minnehaha
5. LEGAL DESCRIPTION : Lots 28 & 29, Block 8, Gilbert's Addition
6. PRESENT 20NING: R-4
7 . PURSUANT TO Zoning Code Chapter: 64 Section: 210 Paragraph:
8. STAFF INVESTIGATION & REPORT: Date: 11-21-77 By; EW
A. SUFFICIENCY: The applicant's request was filed on a short form rezoning petition
subscribe & sworn to before a notary public on October 20, 1977, and received by
the Planning Division on October 26, 1977.
B. PROPOSAL: The proposal is to rezone from R-4 to RM-1 .
C. FRONTAGE & AREA: This corner lot has 131 .2 ft. frontage on Lexington and 80 ft.
rontage on Minnehaha for a total area of 10,496 sq. ft. , or approximately .24 acre.
D. SITE CONDITIONS: The site is currently occupied by a newer 8-unit apartment
ui ing in excellent condition. The site is bounded by well kept single family
homes on the north and west and across Lexington to the east. St. Matthews
Evangelical Lutheran Church is across Minnehaha to the south. Access to the 3
garages on the site is from Lexington.
E. AREA CONDITIONS: The area consists primarily of 20 to 50 year old single family
omes in exce ent condition with some institutional uses such as St. Matthews
Evangelical Lutheran Church and Central Lutheran School (one block north of the site).
F. FINDINGS:
1 ) The existing building blends very well with the neighborhood.
2) Parking and traffic are not a problem for the immediate neighborhood because
- off-street parking space (garages) is available for 6 autos with access from
Lexington.
3) The proposed rezoning to RM-1 will allow the construction of 11 rooms, or the
equivalent of five 1-bedroom units, and therefore not make the existing structure
a conforming use.
4) The existing structure of 7 1-bedroom units plus one efficiency unit totals
16 rooms, which would require rezoning to RM-2 in order to be a conforming
use (RM-2 would allow the construction of 17 rooms on this site).
G. STAFF RECOMMENDATION:
1 ) Based on Findings #3 & #4 above, staff recommends the applicant revise his request
to rezone from R-4 to RM-2 rather than from R-4 to RM-1 .
2) Based on FindingS#1 & #2 above, staff recomnends approval of a revised request to
rezone �from R-4 to RM-2.
�
. i' � •
t CITY OF SAINT PAUL
. ,
�tTY O.p
��� �
� 'a �ti
�
Rose Mix o ��;,asa,s^^°� a AlberF B.Olsos
ac�e�a�e�ft��i .,,
City Clerk and �,� �- � Council Reaorder
Council Secretarl/ ��, ` ��
.�.m
OFPICE OF THE CITY CLERK BUREAU OP RECORDS
386 City Hall St.Paul,Minnesota 56102
Phone 298-4�'JI Q
�l~ �-�
� �� �
r � � � � �
=���� � �
����� � J ,, ��� �
.S�;r��.������:�r}�9 � �.
��r� '4�����"��
��•;;�,.
October 25, 1977 �``'=a
Planning Commission
Grace Building
St. Paul, Minnesota
Dear Sir:
The Council referred to the Planning Commission for recommendation the
attached petition of Richard Sagestetter to rezone property at the northwest
corner of Lexington and Minneshaha aka Lots 28 and 29, Block 8, Gilbert's
Addition.
Very truly yours,
� ,
�� ���
City Clerk
Attach.
"�
ABO:dcr
cc; Finance Dept.
Mr. Erickson, Building Dept.
� ������ �°��� SZ
� � �
0
�� • • , �_�_ � � '7
.
� �� � so � �o pc�
.
Short Form Rezoning Petition
TO THE HONORABLE MAYOR ANO CITY COUNCIL
c/o the City Clerk, Room 386 City Hall
City of Saint Paul , Minnesota
Pursuant to the provisions of LAWS OF MINNESOTA for 1975� Chapter 261 , Section 6,
I/we the undersigned� being the owner(s), of property described as
� tz,L .�. c�s � �I f.�'� S G= /L �3�-/��- S �'I t� d�
and situated (describe location with i-espect to streets or intersections)
���r� mF LEx1�/`n�� � ��vvs��t�,a
which property was previously zoned � ���/D�L)T//1L_+ and under
. Chapters 60 through 64 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code is presently zoned
R�Q., , a more restrictive zoning classification, do
hereby request that consideration be given by your honorable bodies to rezone
the above described property to a zoning classification of Q M ! .�_
under Chapters 60 through 64 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code.
Subscribed and sworn to before me
this�„ day of �C �' /1�7,
,:M.�...:...:�.�u�a+� Add re s s�� � 3 r/� � � U�'�—.� /L
��¢i.VAUGFIAN
..y•��. Cp..lq�.
Notary Publ ic. �����g��tttES
P�b.ZA.190i (� J5 / (¢ � '�`�-
My Commission Telephone•
����
Approved as to form 31 7/75
by the City Attorney.
ZV9VI �V ���� Z� _� .�
• � • ! � • f� �► • • • �
� �� • s • • • •
� �
• �
. � . • . . . . . . ��
� � � • • • • • • • • •
. -
! • • • . • . � • • . . • •
. ;
�
�
.
,, R . . . . . • . • • • • • • •
�► -_ ►.l� •.�
. . . . . . � u � ' . • • . . . • . • • • • •
� � �
,�r � �
►�� • . . . . .
� . . . . . . . • .� � . '�-�� � . . � . . . � . . . .
,�L�I �
,
, � . � . �� _
�
� � • • � s • s • r w � • • • • • a • • • • � • • •
s
�
� •
� � � • • e e � • • • • • • •
e • • • s � a► s � � • � �
— �.
ri. �. � _ Jw �
�w� � �R � • A � • • • • • • •
• • � • w • • • • s �� �
� � � �
e
� � �
��� . .
• � � � w • w � w • • � , � • • w • • �r • � • . • •
�
�i�4 �I I����� R ��«�t .
Fa�•,'','�n 4 _., .,..� ��� , ' , .
���tt ri h1g ` '
f
rezone f.ro�.�{,t,�: 2�gz� •
s�zibed aa yq is 2B� ?�, ocg�
�yet�ts Additicm�t�o�the ��
corneA of Le oa P
��a Avenue. he Co
. PBal Iws:
o r' -
Co �r�tn
r
� t � �
#te4;.
pr��omme ;
���7L1',1� -1 v��'!n"y�,���6
�, k
_ �.,' t �� �-_,� ��� C.
- . �,.�
, .
, `-" " `" , CtTY OF Sl'. PAUL � ''`' ��`,
DEPARTMENT OF �INANCE AND MA[�}AGEMENT S�RVICES
. ASSESSMENT DiY1S10N �'�.���-[���
113 UTY HAII 5T.PAUI,MINNESOTA 55102
December 16, 1977
File X2016 Page
Zoning File 8243
Dear Citizen;
As a courtesy to you, and as required by law, we want to notify you about
a puhlic hearing which may affect you.
The Councf2 of the City of St. Paul wi12 hold a public hearin� in the . ,
- Council Chambers of the City Hall and Court House (third floor) at lO:OQ a.m.
on January 5, 1978 on the:
Application of Richard S3gesetter to RE70I3E from R-4 to
RM-2 property onti�e northwest corner of Lexington Parkway .
and Minnehaha Avenue described as; Lots 28 and 29, Block
8, Gilberts Addn. l
If you would like. further information about this heariag, contact the Current
Planning Section of the Planning Board, 421 Wabasha Street or telephone 298-4I54.
tdhile the City Charter requires that we notify you of the hearing, we want ta
help you to learn fully about any imgrovement that could affect yo� or yaur
cam.nesnity. Therefore, ,� sincerely hope you can atte�d this hearing, so Chat
you can make your views about it kno�on to the City Council, whether far or
against.
J. WILLIAM DO�iOVAN
� VAL[IATZON AND ASSESS;iEI3T ELvGINEER
, . . / ,. ♦ � .. � . . . ` � � � �.���.'� �
. . . . .. ( . � .
� � .. � � .. . ` . . ' . ' ' . . . ' � � F;� . 1. - .
. . , ' . . � . � � � . . . . � ". �,�. . . � . . , . ..
� .� � .� , � , ' ' ' � - ., . , �� _ ' '��� c .. � . . ..
. . i . . . , � � , , ' ' . . . . - f
, / / f , . . . � . . � .
� . � . � i . . . , . ,.
. . .. .;. i , . �
. , . . . . . / � . , � ' . . . � ..
.. . . . , . . � .. ' . ' . . , . .
. � � � � . 1 ' . . .. - ' � . � ' .
l .
- � . , ' . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. ` . .
. . � . , � � ' � . � . 1 . .
i. , . . � . . - . . . . : . . . � � . � . .
. , . � . . ` . . . . . - . � . . . . ' _� . � .. . .
.. _ . . . . , . - . �� � . . � . ' �� .�.. . � . . . .. �. . _ . .
�� 5� � ,
. , ;
� �� � ' , ,
1�oel� �el�iair� , � .
�� � � ' . , . �
. - �
, .
ee�ar A�: . � , , � ; ,
; �'!� o�r � t� ��oaa� �r ta�o �:to J� �s 19'7'8 �� lwu�ri�,�n �
�fli�are �! �e�rd a�t� �e r�s�o�►:�r�;� � �1 n�r�►t oo�' �' L��
#WeMt 1�lrpa�M�l�r ��t tL� r�1� � 1�. �tt�t w;,LMtrd to �t�! � �at� lttasi�
� `� �� � '�.� � �r.,
' �
�'! � lfeal�i '
� '
_
' ; _ .
, Ci�-CLss�llt , �
, _ ,
�'� , , , y
. ' • ,
' r ,
, �
,
, -
; � :
,
, � � � . ,
. . �.
. �
. : : , ;,.
Q .
� . . . ..� , . . . �� . .� ! . �. . ' � .. , � - .
' . �l- .
> �
. � ��D�`l'`�`�'
. , , , -
_ . ,.,
� . � �� ; � , � _
� � . , .
, � . ;
� . , . . �� ,
. . ; ;
, . ,
- �,
. � : , , :
. , .
� , , .
, , . , , .
, � ,
� .
. , . .
. ,��r► �, ��ra �� ,
. - ; , .
�.� zwaps . . � � i :
��+�r� � - - � ' �
, ,
D�ror N�.; Ln�yt: 1 ' , ; � , , ; " .
!M 4t�► Ce� r�Mlif� t�Mt � � #u� o�,��i Ir�,!�tl�m e�d -� , . , ,
i��e. #o s� �+as �► t�► � , 1+oa�Mt 1t� �Mr ��i� �"��'. �
, ,
yr��l I�w� f��;�S �t�t � �i �9, .8,�.��11��1�On..
� - . '!�i� t�e�l�� �s
, ,
_ ,
, - �.�i ' - , �
�� ,
� , �
' ' ' ' . ; _ �.
�1/e�r ,_
' � . . � � . . " . � " A�.
. . V , � . . . � . � . � �. � 1. . . �
� . . . � . . . . '' . . . . . . ..
. . . , ' ... . .�i: - . ' .
. �
.. + r . , � . . . . � . , '
� . � L � ' ' � � . � ' . . � � . /l
. � I . � � . . � . � . � � .
. ' - , . . . . � . ( . ' . ' � . _
� � , � � . �. . . ' .� � . . " � ' i \ ".
�.. . ♦ � � . . .. �' , � . . � � . � . . . ..
� � � . . � ' � . .� � � . � � . .
. , � � .. �' . 1` , . i - . . .
. . . , - . . . . • . . „ � � . . ' . � .. ._ .
.. . . � . - ' � . . . ' , . - , . . � - � .
. � . , . . . . � � � �' . �(,i
. . � . , . . . . . . . � . . . . � �� . � , L e
. . � � '� � . . ,� .. . . .. . �. '. .;
� ��*� �.� CITY'OF SAINT PAUL
�'�4 '- DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AN[a �CONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
� �
„� ., .
��a,� •~�••••�e DIVISION OF PLANNING
.,. 421 Wabasha Street,Saint Pa.ul,Minnesota,55102
' 612-298-4151
George Latimer
Mayor
January 4, 1978
Rose Mix, City Clerk
v
386 City Hall
St. Paul , Minn. 55102 Legal Description: Lots 28 & 29, Block 8,
Gilbert's Addition
Dear Madam:
This letter is written in response to the petition of Richard Sagesetter to
rezone property located at the northwest corner of Lexington and Minnehaha
from R-4 (single family residential ) to RM-2 (medium density low rise
multi family residential ). The purpose of this rezoning is to remove the
nonconforming status of his existing 8-unit apartment bwilding.
This matter was heard before the Current Planning & Zoning Comnittee on
December 1 , 1977 at which time staff reconmended that the petitioner's request
be granted. Ms. .McGinley moved to recomnend denial of the request to rezone
to RM-2. Mr. Humner seconded the motion and it passed on a 5 to 2 roll call
vote, with Messrs. Pangal and Bryan dissenting.
On December 2, 1977 the Planning Comnission confirmed the recomnendation of
the Current Planning & Zoning Committee by a 16 to 2 roll call vote.
This matter is scheduled to be heard before the Saint Paul City Council on
January 5, 1.978.
Si r ly,
iqC�,.
E ward J. Warn
Senior City Pla er
EJW/gf
Enc.
Zoning File No. 8243
' 1 1 1 1 �
, � � , _
-� '
. � , . ��������������
� � � � r����o��o��e�r
� � � o�■ ■�er�or�o��se■
� � � ���e■����a���e���■
� � ��e��������r��s��■
� � ���o��e�����o��e�■
■��.s=s:�e�������■
o��o��o��e��e��e�■
� o��o��o��e��e��e�■
e��o��o��o��e��e�■
e��o��e�■ ■de�e�e
�� �:o������■ ■�����■
o��o��o��e���et�o�■
, � � a��o��a�■ ■e��o�■
� e��o��e��e ■e��o��
� � � o��o��o��o ■o��o�■
� � � ■��������e ■e���o■
� � � o��o��o��� ■o��e�■
� � ■�■�����■ ■o��o�■
0��o��e�■ ■�o�o�■
, : . ��������■ ■������■
� � o��a��e�■ ■�a��o�■
� � r���m�■�■�■■���o�o■
• �, , , ►, , ,
� � `,► � '= �� --.��� . . r .� . ,.�._ ��..i1. /,
, , j� ,.
_ �. ... _= �. �, ._.s���.. .�_ �
� � �' i' � i l�''.� , .
- = ..,_�.:
� � � i i
_ � ! � .�. �
� � �� �� •,����/.�._� - :
� � . i �
'I���c.s _/. ,� � i.i�
, i
. . .,� .
� . . �. � e: . � ! � �
� , ♦ , . � . . , . .. .. .... . .1 .. .
� .. . . � .,i�' ., ,� . . � . . , .
.. MINUTES OF THE MEETING OF THE CURRENT PLANNING & ZONING
COMMITTEE THURSDAY, DECEMBER l , 1977, IN COUNCIL CHAMBERS,
SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA
PRESENT: Mmes. Grittner, Karns, McGinley and Sumners, and Messrs. Hummer,
Pangal and Bryan of the Current Planning & Zoning Comnittee; Mr. Robert
Straughn, Assistant City Attorney; Mr. Richard Amey of the Division of
Housing & Building Code Enforcement; Mnes. McNeally and Fox and Mr. Edward
J. Warn of the Planning Staff.
The meeting was chaired by James Bryan, Chairman.
RICHARD SAGESETTER (#8243): A petition to rezone from R-4 to RM-1 property
locate� on t�ie northwest corner of Lexington and Minnehaha.
The petitioner was present. There was no opposition.
Mr. Warn read the staff report and showed slides of the subject site.
Richard Sagesetter, 1003 Van Buren, said he had purchased the property when the
zoning was correct, and he was asking no more than what he had before the zoning
map was changed.
Mr. Hummer asked if Mr. Sagesetter intended to expand and the petitioner said
no, that he �ust wanted to be in the correct zone so he could refinance if necessary.
Mr. Pangal said he understood that RM-1 had been requested in error, and actually
RM-2 was being requested, and Mr. Sagesetter said this was correct.
Ms. Surraners moved to recomnend approval of the RM-2 rezoning, but the motion failed
for lack of a second.
Mr. Hummer said the entire neighborhood is single family homes and he thought the
City Council chose to zone that whole area residential R-4. He said there is a
question in his mind and that perhaps property would stick out like a sore thumb.
Ms. McGinley then moved to recommend denial of the request, and Mr. Hummer seconded
the motion. Ms. McGinley discusse.d spot zoning and said the petitioner could
continue with the present zoning. '
The motion then passed on a 5 to 2 roll call vote, with Messrs. Pangal and Bryan
dissenting.
Su mitted by: Approved by:
) ,� _,
`,�j�� � l�����z z--
/✓�?"?
Edward J. W n . James Bryan, CFj,��S^man
;'
i ,
i r
PLANNING BOARD STAFF CtEPORT DeCember 1 , 1977 plBC �p 26
. 8243
1. APYLICANT's 1v�►ME : RICHARD SAGESETTER
2. CLASSIFICATION . � Amendment � Appeal � Permit � Other
3. PURPO5E : Rezone to RM-1
4. LOCATION . Northwest corner Lexington and Minnehaha
5. LEGAL DESCRIPTION : Lots 28 & 29, Block 8, Gilbert's Addition
6. PRESENT 20NING: R-4
7. PURSUANT TO Zoning Code Chapter: 64 Section: 210 Paragraph:
8. STAFF INVESTIGATION & REPORT: Date: 11-21-77 By; EW
A. SUFFICIENCY: The applicant's request was filed on a short form rezoning petition
subscribed & sworn to before a notary public on October 20, 1977, and received by
the Planning Division on October 26, 1977.
B. PROPOSAL: The proposal is to rezone from R-4 to RM-1 .
C. FRONTAGE & AREA: This corner lot has 131 .2 ft. frontage on Lexington and 80 ft.
rontage on innehaha for a total area of 10,496 sq. ft. , or approximately .24 acre.
D. SITE CONDITIONS: The site is currently occupied by a newer 8-unit apartment
ui ing in excellent condition. The site is bounded by well kept single family
homes on the north and west and across Lexington to the east. St. Matthews
Evangelical Lutheran Church is across Minnehaha to the south. Access to the 3
garages on the site is from Lexington.
E. AREA CONDITIONS: The area consists primarily of 20 to 50 year old single family
omes in exce ent condition with some institutional uses such as St. Matthews
Evangelical Lutheran Church and Central Lutheran School (one block north of the site).
F. FINDINGS:
1 ) The existing building blends very well with the neighborhood.
2) Parking and traffic are not a problem for the immediate neighborhood because
- off-street parking space (garages) is available for 6 autos with access from
Lexington.
3) The proposed rezoning to RM-1 will allow the construction of 11 rooms, or the
equivalent of five 1-bedroom units, and therefore not make the existing structure
a conforming use.
4) The existing structure of 7 1-bedroom units plus one efficiency unit totals
16 rooms, which would require rezoning to RM-2 in order to be a conforming
use (RM-2 would allow the construction of 17 rooms on this site) .
G. STAFF RECOMMENDATION:
1 ) Based on Findings #3 & #4 above, staff recommends the applicant revise his request
to rezone from R-4 to RM-2 rather than from R-4 to RM-1 .
2) Based on Findings#1 & #2 above, staff recommends approval of a revised request to
rezone �from R-4 to RM-2.
� . . ,� . . � . : � .. . � � . .... M1 �. . . . . . . 1� � . � .
. .
GITY OF $AINT PAUL
�l=X �,�
�^.�� ;,\`°y,
� i
Ros� Mlx o f;:�',�::";"::: a AI6��L OI�
City Clerk and �, g4w�••�`�� � Couxeil Reoorder
�.'OU?1C'tl S'801'!�C'Yy � p'
w��� h
+.♦
OFPICB OF THE CITY CLtRK �URtAY O! R�COROf
J8a City Hall S�Paul,�finr�aota b610t
PAone saB.,iAt1
vV
��
� ��
. � �� ' i�•� �/� rj�
�'!i v 19 �-�.
�� � .�ii
,��nr ��,�,-� �
���+-������
�;��a��
October 25, 1977
Planning Commission
Grace Building
St. Paul, Minnesota
Dear Sir:
The Council referred to the Planning Commission for recommendation the
attached petition of Richard Sagestetter to rezone property at the northwest
corner of Lexington and Minneshaha aka Lots 28 and 29, Block 8, Gilbert's
Addition.
Very truly yours,
� ,
�� ���
City Clerk
Attach. `
ABO:dcr
cc; Finance Dept.
Mr. Erickson, Building Dept.
������ �'��.� $Z-�,�
-� �� -
��
�, _.
, . .� , � ,
, �
,• _
2,,�.. -�- �y
, � ,� so,oc�, pc� ,
,.
. �
Short Form Re2oning Petition
TO THE HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL
c/o the City Clerk, Room 386 City Hall
City of Saint Paul , Minnesota
Pursuant to the provisions of LAWS OF MINNESOTA for 1975, Chapter 261 , Section 6,
I/we the undersigned� being the owner(s)_of property described as
�L t�.i � � ,`� CI �1. S �/[. �3�ic.-r s .c7 A rJ
and situated (describe location with respect to streets or intersections)
�l. l�cl Coe,�,��� oF LEx.t��[�.�i�A�a
which property was previously zoned C..� 1�P.�/DE'L)?'�L� , and under
, Chapters 60 through 64 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code is presently zoned
�.�� _� a more restrictive zoning classification. do
hereby request that consideration be given by your honorable bodtes to rezone
the above described property to a zoning classification of Q M � �
under Chapters 60 through 64 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code.
Subscribed and sworn to before me
this�, day of OC �� �l`�7,
�_� eea�A041w��....:.....:•:��► Address�� d 3 r/� /�J � (/!"�-� /L
JANE 1.VAU(iNAN
Notary Public, h�� C��l���
F.e.za.l�es S—
My Cortimission Telephone: � � 9 �¢ y �
vG2�.t,Qf7`--
(J
Approved as to form 11 7/75
by the CiLy Attorney.
,
za��N� F��.E .�� �
� .
• • i� � • � �► • • • �
� ,� • • • • • �
� �
�
• �
� �, • • � � • � • • � � d' t • • • • • • • • •
• �
� • • • � • • • Ml • • � • • •
• �
�
�
• � �r # • • • • • • • • � • • • •
" ► ___ 1►,I,� �.�
� • • • • �• � u '' � • • • • • • � • • • • •
� � A
��r� �
►�I, .
. . . . . . . � • w � . �%/ � . . � �► . . � . . . . . . . . .
;�.t�� [�
.
� - ����� ��i,i�, -
�
� • • • • • • s • • w � • � • • • a • • • • • • • •
s
�
�� •
� w � • • d e • • • • • • • •
� • � • s sa► s • � + � �
- .•
' � _ .lw
�
w � t rP • A • • • � • • • •
• • e: • • � * A► • � �
� � � •
� ' �
� • � •
� � • * w • w a w • • � ±
« • • • • • • � • • • •
� �
�
� �
�_�� , �"I . � �I ��,;���� CITY OF ST. PAUL �� - �����S
� DfPARTMENT OF fINANCE AND MANAGEMENT S�RViCES .
ASSESSMENt DIVIStON
173 CITY HALL ST.PAUI.MINNESO7A 55702
December 16, 1977
File X2016 Page
Zoning File 8243 � .
Dear Citizen:
As a courtesy to you, and as required by law, we want to notify you about
a public hearing which may affect you.
The Council of the City of St, Paul will hold a public hearing in the .
Council Chambers of the City Hall and Court House (third floor) at 10:00 a.m.
on January 5, 1978 on the:
Application of Richard Sagesetter to RE70NE from R-4 to
- RM-2 property onti�e northwest corner of Lexington Parkway .
and Minnehaha Avenue described as; Lots 28 and 29, Block
8, Gilberts Addn. f
If you would like further information about this hearing, contact the Current
P.lanaing Section of the Planning Board, 421 Wabasha Street or telephone 298-4154.
�Jhile the City Charter requires that �ve rotify you of the hearing, we want to
help you to learn fully about any improvement that could affect you or your
com.uanity. Therefore, I sincerely hope you�can attenfl this hearing, so that
you can make your views about it kno�on to the City Council, whether for or
against.
J. WILLLAM DONOVAN
VALUATION AND ASSESS:IENT Eir'GINEER
� '
�
, ,
�
��
lst sZ � 2nd � � � �
3rd -�� I ( (� _ Adopted ��
Yeas � Nays
BUTLER
HOZZA
HUNT ,���Z�4� /
. � LEVINE
ROEDLER � •
TEDESCO �
PRESIDENT (SYLVESTER) I
� _ �
. /
�