The URL can be used to link to this page

271479 WHITE - CITV CLERK � � . ��"■ �� PINK . - FINANCE G I TY OF � SA I NT PAIT�L Council �. � CANARV -DEPARTMENT � - � BLUE - MAVOR Flle NO. • / � f�� in�nce ordinance N 0. ( l9 `i � � • . . Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date An ordinance amending Sheet No. 37 of the Saint Paul Zoning Code, Chapters 60 through 64 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code. THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN: Section l. That upon proper petition submitted to the City Council, and recommendation �thereon by the Saint Paul Planning Commission, and following a public hearing held upon said petition, the Council of the City of Saint Paul does hereby"amend the Zoning Map of the City of Saint Paul, 5heet No. 37, as incorporated by referenc� in Section 60. 401 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code as follows: The property on the south side of E. Page Street, between State and Riverview, known as 128 E. Page, and more particularly described as being the part north of the alley opening and vacated alley accruing thereto and -the following: part easterly of State Street of Lots 10, 11, 7 and 6, Block 4 , West St. Paul Real Estate & Improvement Syndicate Addition No. l, is hereby rezoned from RT-1 to OS-1. Sectian 2. This ordinance shall take effect and be in force thirty (30) days from and after its passage, approval and publication. � •:�. _ COUIVCILMEN Yeas Nays � Requested by Department of: Bu ler za � [n Favor nt , Hu�K _�.wN�!- � Against BY lv ter M�� ede s�� $ Adopte y Counc" : T�te AUG $ '�7 Form Approved C" y Att ney C ified ed by oun il Secjetary BY �— Appro d y Mayor: at �" A�r7 0 � Approved by Mayar for Submission to Council By BY o��Rt��E� �►U6 '� 9 19?� , -- _ _---. __ ._ _. _- ----___ _ - - --- -_ __ - _ :: _ _ . - ___ FILE COPY :. WMITE - CITV CLERK � � � }� PINK - FINANCE COIlI1C11 ;� �� f� � CANARY - DEPARTMENT G I TY OF SA I NT PALT L File NO. � ,v� BLUE - MAVOR O I��Z7ZG��ZCP. Ordinance N O. �� Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date An ordinance amending Sheet No. 37 of the Saint Paul Zoning Code, Chapters 60 through 64 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code. • THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOES OR.DAIN: Section l. That upon proper petition submitted to the City Council, and recommendation thereon by the Saint Paul Planning Commission, and following a public hearing held upon said petition, the Council of the City of Saint Paul does hereby amend the Zoning Map of the City of Saint Paul, Sheet No. 37, as incorporated by reference in Section � 60. 401 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code as follows: The property on the south side of E. Page Street, between State and Riverview, known as 128 E. Page, and•more particularly described as being the part north of the alley opening and vacated alley accruing thereto and the following: part easterly of State Street of Lots 10, 11, 7 and 6, Block 4 , West St. Paul Real Estate & Improvement Syndicate Addition No. 1, is hereby rezoned from RT-1 to OS-1. Section 2. - This ordinance shall take effect and be in force thirty (30) days from and after its passage, approval and publication. COUNCILMEN Requested by Department of: Yeas Nays ' Butier � Hozza In Favor - Hunt B � � �_ Against y Roedler S ylvester . Tedesco • �� 8 Form Approved by City Attorney Adopted by Council: Date . Certified Passed by Council Secretary By ' By • - Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council Approved by nlayor: Date Bv BY `�'`l�� R�i,�IV�p 1c��( ��TY °° CITY OF SAINT PAUL ti�� °i ` �UL 31978 OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK 4 '�-�' �1 0 ��a�� °a iiiti��ii� ,� ��' ' ^c C)1 y q� ��K��E� BUREAU OF RECORDS ... 386 City Hall,Saint Paul,Minnesota 55102 George Latimer 612-298-4231 Mayor June 30, 1978 Ms. Suzanne Flinsch City Attorney Room 647, City Hall Dear Ms. Flinsch: Preparation of an ordinance granting the petition of David V. Sass to rezone from RT-1 to OS-1 property located on the south side of E. Page St. between State St. and Riverview Ave. (see attached) , was requested by the City Council at its June 29, 1978 meeting. Yours truly, ��%� �- �'� Rose Mix, �i�c .0 City Clerk attach. MS/cw O , . l/�"' � �,T, �A CITY OF SAINT PAUL �''� � DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT 0 �� 9 : ►- �::::....: t•� �.��l 9 � DIVISION OF PLANNI �'� �c 421 Wabasha Street,Saint Paui,Minnesota,55102 �/_(/�� '� 612-298-4151 �r� '� George latimer Mayor June 23, 1978 Rose Mix, City Clerk � 386 City Hall St. Paul , Minn. 55102 � Le al Descri tion: Part north of alley opening and vacate a ey accruing and following: part easterly of State Street of Lots 10, 11 , 7 and 6, Block 4, West St. Paul Real Estate and Improve- Dear Madam: ment Syndicate Addn. No. 1 This letter is written in response to the petition of David B. Sass to rezone from RT-1 (Two Family-Residential ) to OS-1 (Office Service) property located at 128 E. Page Street (south side of East Page Street between State & Riverview), to construct a dental clinic. This matter was heard by the Current Planning & Zoning Committee on May 18, 1976. A motion to recommend the rezoning was made by Mr. Pangal and seconded by Ms. Karns. The motion passed on a 5 to 0 roll call vote. On May 26, 1978 the Planning Commission, by an 11 to 0 roll call vote, concurred in the recomnendation to approve the rezoning request. This matter is scheduled to be heard before the St. Paul City Council on June 29, 1978. Sincerely, �_��brct,u,�.. � Y�e Donna McNeally City Planner DM/gf Enc. Zoning File No. 8293 ,,��:��, ROIL CALL VQTE ON ZONING MATTERS �' . Uate _5��----=-s--�� i Nlannin,� Cuuu�iis tun Me�tlny ,/ , , �r�'''' � � � �;�,;,.�`'� �� r� r��',�.r-.�`� ��` � �� 1 2 3 4 5 Yes Nu A* Yes No A* Yes No A� Yes No A* Yes No A* Yes No A* ANUEKSi•; ✓ - - - ✓ ,� ✓ I� ✓ _ki R Y AN - ---- - ✓ - — � � ✓ ✓ ✓ COCHRAtJE FEDER ' -- ----- -- f ✓ ✓ ✓ � GItA1S HANGGI � � ✓ � ✓ � HUMMER KARNS ,� � � ✓ � ✓ P1AY NE �/ � ,� � ✓ ✓ MC DONELL ,/ ✓ ✓ +� MC GINLEY ! .� ✓ � ✓ ✓ ✓ MONTGOMERY ( NELSON i/ � � �/ y '� k* NORTON � ✓ �/ ✓ ✓ I '� PANGAL � ✓ ✓ ' '� PICCULO STEGEMUELL�R ,� � � ✓ ✓ '� SUMhIERS- - ^-- •� �/ � ✓ ✓ ✓ TO�LER � VAP� HOEF _--- - / ✓ ,/ ✓ � V � TOTALS y�� i � Mo t i u n 1 `C' �vc��,2a-��,G't',�o� —tdla.�-�.6a�o __�L—�� _ Mu t i o n 2 �..�:.�„l-d� ✓ ca.�� — o u-r, � - ° — Mo t i o n 3 T /teCL ca�..�+.-� - �a-�-, � � ° 14ution 4 CZ t¢��.� �� _ o _ '".,�, � - v f4o t i on 5 '�y -� �-e� a.�.� — � e c a �' / - P4u t i on 6 ��-~�II �a-�,� - /-� - " - Jes s o I�.Tr o r) *Abstain **CaI1 Chairman last_ . ��+��9 MINUTES OF THE CURRENT PLANNING & ZONING COMMITTEE MEETING l�0�S� MAY 18, 1978 IN COUNCIL CHAMBERS, ST PAUL, MINN. PRESENT: Mmes. Karns, McGinley, Messrs. Pangal , Hummer, Bryan of the Current anning & Zoning Comnittee; Mr. Robert Straughn, Assistant City Attorney; Mr. Richard Amey of the Division of Housing & Building Code Enforcement; Mmes. McNeally and Fox of the Planning Staff. ABSENT: Ms. Summers, Mr. Stegemoeller The meeting was chaired by Mr. James Bryan, the Chalrman. DAVID B. SASS (#8293): An application to rezone from RT-1 to OS-1 property locate at 128 E. Page Street, on the south side of E. Page between State and Riverview. The applicant was present. There was no opposition present at the hearing. Ms. McNeally read the staff report reflecting staff's recommendation of approval of the rezoning request, and showed slides of the subject site. Mr. Robert D. Burow, 750 S. Plaza Drive, the architect engaged by David B. Sass, presented plans of the dental office proposal necessitating the rezoning. Mr. Hummer requested that a copy of the plans be put into the record. Mr. Pangal moved a recommendation of approval for the rezoning request. His motion was seconded by Ms. Karns and passed on a 5 to 0 roll call vote. The recommendation for approval of the rezoning request will be forwarded to the Planning Commission. Submitted by: Approved by: a W1`G�.eu . � �....�,� ,�-.�_ ��` � �� Donna McNeall James r an Cha��frman Y �/ Y � � ��C ��9 PIANNIN�. If�lAlill STAFF kZEPORT May 18, �9�8 Pl�t Map 48 8293 1 . AYt,l.1�AN'1"5 NA�1�: . DAVID B. SASS 2. CLaSSIFICATIUN . � Amenda►ent � Appe41 � Permit Q Other 3• P�K�'�5� � Rezone from RT-1 to OS-1 4. �.uc:a'PION : 128 E• Page - So. side of E. Page bet State & Riverview s. LE:GAL UESCKIPTION ; Part north of alley opening & vacated alley accruing & following: part Estly of State St. of Lots 10, 11 , 7 & 6, B1 4, West St Paul Real Estate & Improvement Syndicate Addn. No. 1 6. PRESENT ZONING; RT-1 � 1 . PURSUANT TO Zoning Code Chapter: 64.210 Section: Paragraph: 8. STAFF INVESTIGATION & REPOxT: Date: 5-�2-7$ BY� DM A. SUFFICIENCY: The applicant's request was filed on a long form consent rezoning pet�tion su scribed & sworn to before a notary public on 4-14-78, and received by the Planning Division on 5-1-78. B. PROPOSAL: The proposal is to rezone from RT-1 to OS-1 to operate a dental office. C. FRONTAGE & AREA: This irregularly shaped corner lot has 80 ft. frontage on Page and about 13 ft. frontage on State, for an approximate area of 11 ,640 sq. ft. D. SITE CONDITIONS: The site at 128 E. Page is occupied by a small , newer bungalow with fenced yard. Across an unpaved �all�ey to the south is a single family home. Further down at the corner of Robert and State are commercial uses (a gas station, restaurant and grocery store). Across State to the west is an apartment building and other commercial uses. Kitty-korn•er to the site is an office building. Down State to the north is another apartment building, and across Page to the north is a large single family home. E. AREA CONDITIONS: State Street at this point divides single family and duplex use to the east from commercial and office use to the west. Robert Street, a busy thoroughfare, is one block to the west of the site. F. FINDIPJGS: ° 1 . Section 60.471 states the intent of the OS-1 zone: "The OS-1 Office-Service District is intended to accommodate various types of office uses performing administrative,professional.and personal services and to serve as a transitional use between the more intensive uses of land such as major thoroughfares or commercial districts and the less intensive uses of land such as one-family residential ." 2. Section 60.472(c) lists dental offices as a permitted use in an OS-1 zone. 3. The site is adjacent to a B-2 zone on the west and RT-1 on the east. A B-1 zone is one-half block sou�h. � DAVID B. SASS Page 2 , F. FINDINGS: (cont'd) 4. Robert Street, a busy thoroughfare, is one block to the west. 5. The site is currently occupied by a small newer bungalow, which would be converted to a dental office. 6. The site is located on a,corner which would minimize impact on the residential character of the neighborhood. 7. There is alley access to the site. 8. The site is large enough to accomnodate the required parking. G. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Based on the above findings, staff recommends approval of t e applicant s request to rezone to OS-1 . ► . _. , I� . CITY OF SAINT PAUL DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE AND MANAGEMENT SERVICES DIVISION OF ASSESSMENTS AND VALUATIONS + April 17, 1978 To the Council City of St. Paul Gentlemen: I have checked the attached petition of David V. Sass filed in the matter of rezoning, Part north of alley opening and vacated alley accruing and following: part easterly of State Street of Lots 10, 11, 7 and 6, Block 4, West St. Paul Real Estate and Improvement Syndicate Addition No. 1. The property is located on the south side of East Page Street between State Street and Riverview Avenue, from RT-1 to OS-1, and find that said petition is sufficient. Yours very truly, Bernard J. Carlson - Director Department of Finance and Management Services . - , � �; . (� ! � , , , , ., , � . , � �-f . �; �� t� � � � �.__x...J� c � k� � �.: , x .; ; / �`.}1, Re: X2081 " cc: Building Department Zoning Board File Parcels Eligible - 14 Parcels Needed - 10 Parcels Signed - 10 a ��_. �� : �� z�� _ ___ . �: �t � .�. __. Telephone612/298-5241 113 City Hall, Saint Paul , Minnesota 55102 ' • � ;. 1Ntl�d� /1 0!lV09 �JNINNV"Id '1(1Vd 1NIVS ON ddW �t1l2�1Sf?Of�i � � ♦ H1a0N ,OOZ �„I :3�t/�S �v��a3wwo� � � • A�IWd� 3'1dll�flW � �-� 8L-Z1-5 31t/a ON 3�1� A�IWtJ� OMl ¢ £6Z8 1SIalSfO �NINNd�d Jl�iWtJ� 3N0 O P�� L-SO �� l-l� �o�� 3NOZ3a 3SOd2ifld J�1a3d0ad 1�3f 8f1S ��1Ga JlatJoNf108 l�lalS10 �JNINOZ — — _ _ _ y : � •' Q 1 "'� � ��'y� -- v �-.r'•• � .r --r '-•�•p� } s. . �� v v „ i�=1 <., -� � �f ouk RF0 rrtots A[s l ..� � �} • �-'7� ,.jQ V v V 1.� O r�. : . � O pip �? ' � v �r � � � - —--- Y I l_ O .- -- I i 1 � � �. '�,, o � �. o�a c, •,�- -, o_ o� b!d�pl � °I� ° • • o, � � E GEORGE , --� � � '' r� a yA /�'t� • � y O.._�.�'J�i.. 0.. /"`� T� • _ O ' ' _ � - V„�.I- i •� ` . � �Y Y Y hQ� O�U� ! _� ~ �r \ ' W O_ W — � 4! - W - - - • � -- Q ° •'q � ___� � o 'a o•o r� 4 - v~i 9 r" o --- or ,, -� .� ��•� !� � �� E. STEVE ST. oo�-'�`Z� ` ��'_ ; � o �� o _o 0 0 o b o o ' Q � a a �-_ 4� - - ' -o� ��; , y �� -- a '` _o �-�J� ,� °� _o a= - _o o_ � T�� o _ -, ,_` , '' o - `� .K�. _ _____ � - � 4 � � � � , � � . `� . .. _ _ - � . L "-A � � ' _ + o ,S� �a o Y ��..�.J � .�.r -, . F- E. KING S ) o � , , '�"`r o ; ' ' , Q ,_ —°- a u � o o -° '� p � . o� � � d 0 �o 0 ___� o:.: � - _ _.. -v l i_,_1 � 4_- � o. u , . ; TT _ __o Q_ bo _ .� . o ---o o ' !s• ,, o� oq 000�00000'oo �, � � �o __ o - H , _,. S � _ - �, 1 , _S � � �__ ��.� w � ° ' - :��_Q_ ° _�-- t3 _� .IDO boa ,4o}a�o; io�0��o P io., .4. ��. a _._ �_ , Q � E.BA R ' o � —o_ _°_ • . Q-_ 6- o 0 o p o o�o�o'o'o o p p o 0 0 � — � 0 � � ° " "_-__, i W o 4 E. A K �._ . _ y , i ' . io- -� - --� 9-- 6 00 00000;�0 000 00 �� v•�O o. o . _. ° E.MO TO _Q _ o � �,F-1-�. -u .. �, /. c a o � p c, o E. . Z MORTON � _ .-� �' �� o= � � � � ' -° � � [- `- � _� � � - ° �4a�ob o -�- ol m � � . c� 2 0 �U�• � -� -- � � O — - PA i � - � x c� � .::.,:;..;:;.. � ' o p o 0 o�A o � o ;::.�.•,`'; , � � , � » � �_�...�..��:;::� � O _ a ._ �, -Q � , .. a� � � , o a ; �:.� c,��`�k�rMtEr�c -�_$ -=+y d b o'o �� o, . �� , . � � °- �.• �-..� �:•�� slt�to" , o ��1 �� o0 0.0 � d � ` �c�• `;,�� ` �_ �. � E.SI� Y . O '�.,C._t^irtt�'-..i.< � .. , p =q O d D -O- � � 00 00 �OI000 �O� OI O � �� --- .d '�� L11L1 -=�'= ° e�o � r _o_ oo o,'P � _a . <_1 _ � _o-� � ;. , � o , ,-� , I '- 'K_ \�Q - _ _Q - � � � ._!I,V - O 1 O O p' �JO� 0 0 �_ . I v-- " �° --- � � o' o�-..� CURTI E ' � o'� � � � -7- E `� ..,� TI C . =;j 4 � �°i o° � � 6 6�ia o,O�o d;oo 0 0 r � 1.1- � - 0 " � � � Q''�-_o z5 _ -1 -1 T • i �ve , `� _ _r.,_r I �, �_ �` o -o a- , . - �=1 o d b s_r _i._ _ � ' d�o�b o 0 o b o�o�o 0 0- o -- = o: � o' � , _ �.--o l ST � 8EL ' � r . ,_ O � � O OI U j�" --- � � �' 0 0O' ��v �O O O ,�a o O 0000' , � �00� _ , �� .� 4 � , ' ,� ! � . - � • _� _1 � o � � Q�.� . � , 1 � I 1�� ;.�- - f 1- � � � t- ._O . .: j,, � I ��I ;I_._ ��., ' I-� a ; � l . : j .. . � , . . � � - - ♦ ' Nv °:v ' �Diviv�v�v'v O - ;. .. Q '.' k� o•�� o ►��o• � lo� ' b o d � '0 ' c b , .� i � R 0'0�o p o a o z o o ► T E WIN A WINO A r - - O (.; O t70 1O G��O iC�(�;�1;0 r` Q ' � - �� .r� �Y�:,ll. ..� v�vvvv�'OI�,I- v CO�O OOQC I i a L .I� --{ �_ � '_f I _- — I - l O O!O �, ,., • � � L� l . � 1_l.l.. 1 I � L1J�.1 o L3 - � �----� i,- j' i i • � �--- � J ��` .T,-T_.. � � ' � I �____ � �' :- -.-; I ^,rl;•n!lr) O i ��r,'Op �+� Ov_� - ��'�� -i. O,O � ' O�OO�OOOOOI �0 ., <� ST. WY MIN WYOMtNG � , '-- �c�o�oio� o)� o:.> n,, ,��,�o�F �� o , o� p o 0 0 � �, � � i , _L_• �- � � � �-� I� , ;-� ��, ��_-�� - - - ' �� - �. o ,�i �:I�' L- } � o 0 00 � j I _. , :_. ,_.l- T, 1t o , ` , �� ! � • �� ,.. . ' O n�0 OO�b1010 O I n! �c> >� O ' � �' � � C� O�O�oI0o��0000 � . 0-Q10IO.00�OlO 0oo'O - -- - --- ------ •- -- - �!L� :- _--�_ ------f—_ .. -AtiMA�tS' �.__,.,_� �--_ AREA MAP ,,,,,,, ,,,,,..T OAVID B. SASS LEGENO � �I r � � UTY �F ST. PAUL .�,�/� � DfPARTM�Nfi OF FiNANCE AtiD MA�IAGF�L1��iT S�RVICES 2`7� ASSE55MENT DIYISIOV ��(( 1l3 C1TY HAIL 5T.PAUL,MIN�lE50TA Si10? 1 �l�s y June 9, 1978 � � ��, File X2081, Page Zoning File g293 T'ne Council of the City of St. Paul will hold a public hearing in the Council Chambers of the City Hall and Court House (third floor) at 10:00 a.m. on June 29, 1978 on the: Petition of David V, Sass to REZONE from RT-1 to OS-1 , propertq located on the south side of East Page Street between State Street and Riverview Avenue described as: part north of alley opening and vacated alley accruing and following part easterly of State Street of Lots 10, I1, 7 and 6, Block 4, West St. Paul Real Estate and Improvement Syndicate Addn No. 1. � If yau wauld like further information- about this hearing, contact the Current Plamaiag Sectiosz of the Planning Board, 421 Wabasha Street or telephone 298-4154. While the Citp Charter requires that we notify qou of�the hearing, we want to help you to Iearn fully about any improvement that could affect you or your cor.us�t+nitg`_ The*efore, I sincerely hope you can attend this hparing, so that you can make your views about it known to the City Council, whether for or against_ J. WILLIAM.DONOVAN VALUATION AND ASSESSMII`i'� ENGINEER '.� � � � . : V ` �� , Y1 . . J ' . ' a P . �� r� . , , � ,� > r� , . � . � 1 i/` f` y ' 1 , ,._ 5� 1 � {'�� , S � _._ 1"��.:� ! � {� F ♦. �� ` Y 1 I' h _ / � � � �.��.� �,��f ..�� ' - � _. '.4 ` ' • i . � R � . f s ' . • �� , ` : . . ' . � ' . . ' �� , h�+ �Y 1 I • f . •� � � , i � L' ' , � .. .'�` � � ., . .��..'� �� \ .. . � . ,�'� / ��. �'�� /. �R - - . - � ° x �Fr.�, , :i . . � . " �. {a,;��: . . . - j ��i,� .. .. . i . . . . . .. ! . , i i, I . . .. �r, y� / . ;i / , . . � � , ' �. , . . i �� 1 �r� ,1 , � . - ' � , � ;�o; �s7s ` ` �� R; , . - �� . . '," � , .� � `� �� ;� � , ,�, , �. ; z ,...a�. . ; � X. �: � . , :: , . , ;�� $' . ` � t��.. �� r��'�� 1 �. . .�..j � . '� ,a , � >�ho�w'�'6�i7s-:f�t7►t�� • , + M �: i +• p • . ��. ' - � . - i M t � 1 i . � � I, k. � f + / ..�M1�R�;�� , r '� p� �7'�;� y. .. _ ' . . r_ S ��#�i� e�t" at�•QSd� ��:`��ar..t�'��+� ��t �� ;�� x' ` ; �yjy �/y�y , r - i'�,��.,'-� �``�i ��►^�'�' ��S�'i �;. ,�*'� � +1��•:-�• �'� �"•� �k��+�� • r f i a � )� � ly�,�`M'�R"Y$� +iAt'1►�. '�l�� MC�1�11id��, �11� 1;tiMr��1� � �',�� 4'� �:`.,�� 6 ��',ia�l�� .I... �1 _A ( �� s ' "'� �,. . .� �i . � � � ' . � _ �' . �. � ,1 . . , .. > . . . .,� ... . . ` ... �,�� . .f�� / , : ... .. ... ,.�.. . ., , I. a ' `` � rX�. � ' � �� i . � ' � .��wl;,�"�t,� �,: _ • � a; , x ,o` '1 � � + t t ".�; � t _ i , ,: ' • 4 ' i 1 �` �A. ' �' �f j i � �. ._ ` f. �� '� . , � ... ... � . �" i. .- , . , . � �. � �S �.;� �.-; . �, , � � , .,�, . : . . . . . ' �:� ' . � . �:i . .;. , . ..-,. '. .. , � ' 1�;. .�. y�' ��,�, / '��• .. � i �� , ` 'i��. � . 1 . '.' .. �. , .. �.. � . �. � , .; - { .. , � !, ��= � , , � '� :; r� ' r F � , — i , ' } 1 , '�!e .. t i . ' . . . . .. . . . '. � 't . . . . � � : � .. � j .. . . �. „ t 4d t �}Y¢ � - �� .. . � � � F�� H� � � � t � .i A� .� � � 1 1 �y �^1 ' f ��. 1 � . r . ` A 1 r�' Q.�„Q i ' '1. . . `I xA�. �� ` �- - , '. }�. S . 5` '"C' �, �k��Ni� . . . 1 - Y �)yF�� t . .. /� . � . , i Y�� 5�' . � a f` t� 1 - � V l�,r t ,�§. } j .� � 4 i r 4E [p� .�. , . � q F�. � b �.. t t '�a, _ � . . �. " ' ' . �.�t , s r:ts� r tr uvy. 4F' ��:t - � . � . 1 '�� r .��.+,.$r _nl �F�4'; . . � . t � � � ty� , �` ��. _ " " a�'` ° � �f ` � x�''�"' ' �� f -� ° + � ��i�F"✓� r�x ,,� � , , � S. c,��rv'�w, '"�� e �! �,.� .� . - ' � � ' �� c.: � �� €'r ��'�' _ � ,. .� �. .. . . �, . .. . . , , . , . ., ... _".a;, b¢;�. .,�.��.�'�9�'. , ' ROLL CALL UUTE ON ZONING MATTERS �' ° uate —s�� t Nl,�nnin,� l:u��n��i�siuu Meetlny ,/ , �� , ,,�^ � � � � �� ✓� �"�� 4�"� �'Yl `� 1 2 3 4 5 ves Nu A* Yes No A* Yes No A* Yes No A* Yes No A* Yes No A� �wutks�-.,.; ,� ✓ .✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ H k Y AN - --- - ,/ - — / ./ '� � '� 1� COCHRANE FEDER � �FtA 1 S - -- � ✓ ✓ ✓ � - HAN6GI � � ✓ ►� ✓ � HUMMER KARNS ✓ � � ✓ '� '� MAYNE �; � ,/ � ✓ ✓ MC DONELL ✓ ✓ ✓ � MC GINLEY ,� � ,� ✓ ✓ ✓ MONTGOMERY � NELSON i/ ,� � ,� � '� �* NORTON � ✓ �/ ✓ � I '� PANGAL � ✓ �/ , '� PICCOLO STEGEMUELLER ,� � y� ✓ ✓ '� SUMNIERS .� �/ ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ TOk3LER � VAP� HOEF � ✓ ,/ ✓ TOTALS yL:, � �" MU t 1 U 11 ) �v-t/�sL �Gbu ��.G�o(� �'!d/�� l� � �� - Mo t i on 2 ��K��-� r c4,� — � � � " ° — Mo t i on 3 I�aGL c�c�.-or-� - ��, � � ° t�lu t i on 4 Q �-�-t-•� �� - o — '��, i - o f4o t i on 5 --� �ie.cl a....�� — f� - �t N �' / " P4o t i on 6 � eu-�.vrr� - /-5� - " � !es s o I..T,o r� *Abstain **Call Chairman last . MINUTES OF THE CURRENT PLANNING & ZONING COMMITTEE MEETING MAY 18, 1978 IN COUNCIL CHAMaERS, ST PAUL, MINN. PRESENT: Mmes. Karns, McGinley, Messrs. Pangal , Hummer, Bryan of the Current anning & Zoning Comnittee; Mr. Robert Straughn, Assistant City Attorney; Mr. Richard Amey of the Division of Housing & Building Code Enforcement; Mmes. McNeally and Fox of the Planning Staff. ABSE(VT: Ms. Summers, Mr. Stegemoeller The meeting �as chaired by Mr. James Bryan, the Chairman. DAVID B. SASS (#8293): An application to rezone from RT-1 to OS-1 property located at 128 E. Page Street, on the south side of E. Page between State and Riverview. The applicant was present. There was no opposition present at the hearing, Ms. McNeally read the staff report reflecting staff's recommendation of approval of the rezoning request, and showed slides of the subject site. Mr. Robert D. Burow, 750 S. Plaza Drive, the architect engaged by David B. Sass, presented plans of the dental office proposal necessitating the rezoning. Mr. Humner requested that a copy of the plans be put into the record. Mr. Pangal moved a recor�nendation of approval for the rezoning request. His motion was seconded by Ms. Karns and passed on a 5 to 0 roll call vote. The recommendation for approval of the rezoning request will be forwarded to the Planning Commission. Submitted by: Approved by: � � ��u�n.a W1�Glea(-f,�.) �.�,� - � �-�.— Donna McNeall James r an Ch��an Y Y � . � : YLANN1Nc; li�WkiU STAFF ltEPURT May 18, �9�H Plat Map 4H 8293 1 . AYYLICANI"S NAME . DAVID B. SASS '�. CL�155IFICATIUN . � Amend�oent � Appsal � Permit � Other 3. PuKYUS�: � Rezone from RT-1 to OS-1 4. LUCATION : 128 E. Page - So. side of E. Page bet State & Riverview s. c.�:caL DESCRIPTION ; Part north of alley opening & vacated alley accruing & following: part Estly of State St. of Lots 10, 11 , 7 & 6, B1 4, West St Paul Real Estate & Improvement Syndicate Addn. No. 1 6. PRESENT ZONING: RT-1 � 7 . PURSUANT TO Zoning Code Chapter: 64.210 Section: P�ragraph: 8. STAFF INVESTIGATION & REPORT: Date: 5-12-78 BY� DM A. SUFFICIENCY: The applicant's request was filed on a long form consent rezoning petition su scribed & sworn to before a notary public on 4-14-78, and received by the Planning Division on 5-1-78. B. PROPOSAL: The proposal is to rezone from RT-1 to OS-1 to operate a dental office. C. FRONTAGE & AREA: This irregularly shaped corner lot has 80 ft. frontage on Page and about 13 ft. frontage on State, for an approximate area of 11 ,640 sq. ft. D. SITE CONDITIONS: The site at 128 E. Page is occupied by a small , newer bungalow with fenced yard. Across an unpaved a11ey to the south is a single family home. Further down at the corner of Robert and State are commercial uses (a gas station, restaurant and grocery store). Across State to the west is an apartment building and other commercial uses. Kitty-korn•er to the site is an office building. Down State to the north is another apartment building, and across Page to the north is a large single family home. E. AREA CONDITIONS: State Street at this point divides single family and duplex use to the east from commercial and office use to the west. Robert Street, a busy thoroughfare, is one block to the west of the site. F. FINDINGS: � 1 . Section 60.471 states the intent of the OS-1 zone: "The OS-1 Office-Service District is intended to accommodate various types of office uses performing administrative,professinnal.and personal services and to serve as a transitional use between the more intensive uses of land such as major thoroughfares or commercial districts and the less intensive uses of land such as one-family residential . " 2. Section 60.472(c) lists dental offices as a permitted use in an OS-1 zone. 3. The site is adjacent to a B-2 zone on the west and RT-1 on the east. A B-1 zone is one-half block sou�h. � . DAVID B. SASS Page 2 F. FINDINGS: (cont'd) 4. Robert Street, a busy thoroughfare, is one block to the west. 5. The site is currently occupied by a small newer bungalow, which would be converted to a dental office. 6. The site is located on a.corner which would minimize impact on the residential character of the neighborhood. 7. There is alley access to the site. 8. The site is large enough to accommodate the required parking. G. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Based on the above findings, staff recommends approval of the applicant s request to rezone to OS-1 . � .� � . �� . - � CITY OF SAINT PAUL DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE AND MANAGEMENT SERVICES DIVISION OF ASSESSMENTS AND VALUATIONS + April 17, 1978 To the Council City of St. Paul Gentlemen: I have checked the attached petition of David V. Sass filed in the matter of rezoning, Part north of alley opening and vacated alley accruing and following: part easterly of State Street of Lots 10, 11, 7 and 6, Block 4, West St. Paul Real Estate and Improvement Syndicate Addition No. 1. The property is located on the south side of East Page Street between State Street and Riverview Avenue, from RT-1 to OS-1, and find that said petition is sufficient. Yours very truly, Bernard J. Carlson - Director Department of Finance and Management Services --� __. ' � � r .-�, ��.._ � r ' , �` \_x�'L`ti k: � c.t�_ , �.. c. �.x`>j �..)�l Re: X2081 ` cc: Building Department Zoning Board File Parcels Eligible - 14 Parcels Needed - 10 Parcels Signed - 10 ;, :` .. � .� ��i , �� , „ , ... � ..' d `v `u� � �L�-.,o. P � a�,.. ��... . a... . _.. _. Telephone612/298-5241 113 City HaII , Saint Paul , Minnesota 55102 � � �� ; - �� . .:4��':��Q �. o�-�'��`� /�� Qes�.4 p�so �S , ,� , . . �Q � � . . � - ,p �� i r . • C2TY OF 5AINT PAUL, t4IMlESOTA PETIT20N TO AMEND CHApTERS 60 thru 64 OF THE LEGISEATZVE (ZO*IING) C00� . - ..-�..�.--_.._.-_ - . , , . , �� - lst 2nd � , • , 3rd Adopted � I Yeas Naqs BUTLER HUNT �. 2'714�9 - � ��X . SHOWALTER ;' TEDESCO PRESIDENT (HOZZA) � � � - ✓- Office of the Cit Attorney ota y Public, Rzcrosey County, Mir_n. - ��Y'�s�tc-M r�'prnr� commission expires RwMS�r courmr Mr CoMwisnoM t�tn�f�JUGY 10�IM� , ' � ' . `t . , . � . CITY OF SAIIVT PAUL, 11INtIESOTA PETITION TO AMENO CtiAPTERS 60 thru 64 OF THE LEGISLATZVE (ZO*IING) GOD£ Note: Before the petitioner's proposal for rezoning �i�3. be considered by the City of Saint Paul, property owners must consent to the proposed change. Before signing the petition which is a statement to that effect, the signer should be aware of uses per- mit�ed under the new classification. For further information about the rezoning of property, call the Zoning Section of the City Planning �ffice, 298-4154. TO THE HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COIINCIL c/o the City Clerk, Room 386 City Hall Date: <�1'� /�/��}�, �� City of Saint Paul, Minnesota Section 64.210 of St. Paul's Zoning Ordinance states that 677� of property owners within the area to be considered must consent to the proposed rezoning. Section 462.357(5) of Minnesota Statutes states that 2/3 of property owners within 100 feet of the land proposed for rezoning must give written consent before the Citq shall consider the proposal. However, when the owner o£ said progerty has owned for any time in the past year additional real estate contiguous to the land proposed for rezoning, 2/3 of the property owners within 100 feet of this larger package of property must give written consent. Pursuant to Section 64.210 of the St. Paul Zoning Ordinance and Section 462.357(S) of Minnesota Statutes, we, the undersigned, own property within 100 feet of the petitioner's land and hereby petition your Honorable Body to rezone the following described property: (legal de,�c iption street � �ress) /oa� � �ct y C' �T�° -�'�" ✓ fzom �� District to � S� � District, for the purpose of installinq, construct3ng and/oz operating the following: (descrire briefly the proposed facility) RECORD OWNER SIGNATURE LOT BLOCK ADDITION aubject Property: wES sT.�,u� E p�� s-�*� (� g �. �J. ��°- � s .=u�a,s n1Di6l� ��o� J �-�s � �� . ,� „ ^ �r %�' � C . � �� '� !O , J�� ,! � \. � �.Q c�.9�o�cS1,�� . . ' State of Mirinesota) ) aa wnt of Ram Y ) �, J� � � befnq first duly sworn, deposes and states that he is the person who ci culated the within petition consisting of �,., pages; that the parties described above are the owners respectively. of the lots placed immediately follawing eacb �ame; that each af the parties described above is the owner of property which is within 100 feet from aay property ownec� by affiant or sol.d by affiant within one (1j year,precedinq the date of this petition which is contiguous to the property above described; that none of the parties described above has purchased r is nurchasing property from affiant contiguous to the above described property w'thin one (1) year of the date of this petitionj that this petition�was signed by each o aid owners in the presence of this affiant, and that the signatures above are the tr e d correct sic�natures of each and all of the parties sv des � � �� , Subscribed and saarn to before me Addr�ss: 7ld e� �'a �. ��_ � f/� �a� Te lephone No. a��-g �::is�9 day of Avproved as to form 10-27-76 �_ - 'ce of the City Atto_•ney JUDITk'I M. KLlNK Notary Public, Ramsey County, Mirn. ��tr�r rue��c.Mi�� !y canmission expires RAMftY COUN7'f/ � . MrCpMy��bA�'IAN.fHLY fY;/OAi „ � � , . � , . , - • • � � r r x CZTY OF SAINT PAUL, t�IIMIESOTA � PETITION TO AMENO CHAPTERS 60 thru 64 OF THE LEGISLATIVE (ZONING) �'OD£ Note: Before the petitioner's proposal for rezoning ai�i be considered by the City of Saint Paul� property owners mvst consent to the proposed change. Before signing the petition which is a statement to that effect, the signer should be aware of uses per- mitted under the neW classification. For further information about the rezoning of , property, call the Zoning Section of the City Planning Office, 298-4154. TO THE HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL �tei �/lC{ '7 � c/o the City Clerk, Room 386 City Hall � City of Saint Paul, Minnesota Section 64.210 of St. Paul's Zoning Ordinance states that 677. of property owners within the area to be considered must consent to the proposed rezoning. Section 462.357(5) of Minnesota Statutes states that 2/3 of property owners within 100 feet of the land proposed for rezoning must give written consent before the City shall consider the proposal. However, when the owner of said property has owned for any time in the past year additional real estate contiguou� to the land proposed for rezoning, 2/3 of the property owners within 100 feet of this larger package of property must give written consent. Pursuant to Section 64.210 of the St. Paul Zoning Ordinance and Section 462.357(S) of Minnesota Statutes, we, the undersigned, own property within 100 feet of the petitioner's land and hereby petition your Honorable Bod to ezone the ollowing describ pro erty:� (le des i ti n &�.s�e�ad�ressl� �'ty ` ��1'� fj�- u� � �..-� � ��t� ��-��-�;, �..,�� a�t- .� ��°�`r� �/ T, � � �,c.� . ��P,�� - ,a�.� �rom�L DiBtrict to �'`j.5 — / District, for thn . � purpose of installinq, constructing and/or operatinq the followinq: (describe briefly the proposed facility) RECORD OWNER SZGNATURE LOT BLOCK D T N Subject Property: -: -- a r /�/ �c. S� �s � � K' ,� r� � �-� ��- , ` 70�' S. -��-�-' �'�a 2'�-� S y ;�.�-e, ; ;,� State of Minnesota) ) es e County of Ramsey ) ,��„� � beinq first duly sworn, deposes and states that he is the person who circula�ed the within petition consisting of pages; that the parties described above are the owners respectively of the lots p2aced immediately following each name; that each of the parties described above is the owner of property Which is ' �ithin 100 feet from any property owned by affiant or sold by affiant within one (1) year precedinq the date of this petition which is contiguous to the property above describedi that none of the parties described above has purchased or is purchasing property from affiant contiguous to the above described property within one (1) year of the date of thia petition� that this petition was signed by each of said owners in the presence of this affiant, and that the signatures ove are the true and correct 6ic,�natures of each and all of the parties so scrib d. I Subsczibed and aworn to before me Address: 7 � S', _ , , Telephon� . � � this day of � �` �'j� - �Orj � Approved as to form 10-2 76 Office of the City Atto_-ney ■ Notary Public, Ramsey County, � EDWARD L. BODEN ��y Cor•vn i s s i o n e xp ir e s � ” MOTART PUBUC-MINMElOTA � RAMSEY COUNTY � My Com�w.Fxplrr�Merc�7.1984 x ' Jy � .Y� �• �+ ` � ^ i �� v` ' r � 1, �" � �, U� Ui e �f.f. � .�corA �'J : v � � � �; ,�„ ___� <.;�'��. .T i f j ,ROO � O ' vv v � O � Tj�. V pi0 �? v v Y�� / Y l I4 ---- , I_ . � I , - 1 ' ( ;. � -�.� � o � �jt , o�a�,-,�-O, o- ��° b'�� ' �� ° • o.,, (/,C(�� .__t (� YY �C E C�EORGE �� 0 q . 0 - � � ' �� r Y �t _ �1 'O:: _ Qi Q �- - � � p�� I.,Q ,• �,v'r � 1 � -- �� - - - - p --" y� � -�,. � . � p ►s Q � ' 1 Q p Q O'0� C - v~i - Q V � _._ Or -�+ Y ,- �. ` � r • O �' �� P �-/` ` �- i E. STEVE ST. o � ,��,% ;- ' i o , c� �- o 0 0 0 obo o ' , Q �¢ a o- �_- � - - �p; `� Y � - .. -- � � -` p �-iJ`_ _J � +-- ._ - a _O O� � � O -� y � , � _ � • +-._. _ - - - , �♦� -- � i O �� ..� t1 p � - � ►'+'�� G - i � _, � w � , (� C) rs� '� �. _i�. . � i �� ' r .� � F � _ E KINC� S L l _o_ __� � � ,,,o....c o � � � i0 0� � � U 0 _ - �. O _ � �., � ' O� I � O - � p 0 0 � -�; ll_,_ % tT o_ -_ `"o Q. ° o . � ° ___° o ' 4. ° ,_ o oq 000�00000'oo _s 0a � �H - ; .• S -! _ ¢ , , , , , �-- o 0 0 "-:;, I ° ' ; Q _ -0 _ ---- rt �. �0 4 b o a �a o;�o; i o p�0 o P �o � - - - -- -�---- o - , A R 4 E. 4 . 0 -o 'y� o b ----°o o -' . Q-_' 6- o 0 o p o o'o•o'o 0 o Q p o 0 0 � E. AK � � - - r- 0 - � 0 4 • '�' _�--�__0 Q-- � _ a � ip p o 0 o O o;4 o O o O O O � "a -- ��p � a o . _. E.MO TO Q- o �� - �• �Q - /. � __�_ - „ a o, a E. MORTON o . -� °-- -' F 'v-- , � o � o $ . , -- -- Qo b o _° o� ,1 J �O � � L`n � _� , � ° ' � .� - Q � � � � •r- - ° - PA � i o - o x c� � .:.:.:� , i(1 � - op000,p o O •:;4:ti'::ti � 1 � V ti•'.., � 7 -� :}�L} Q � �:�.;i:;: 1 � o � ; ,�=;,��c,;-�`��1"NEE�/C� _� ��:I...... � a� o �,o 0 0!o a � „ L :o ~ • - (�'�`�'�✓ "�!" �� " r� 4' D'� � � � Q `'C` `•(`�C t'!'` li�� - � E.�� Y -tr_��' n r� V`�` � d � d �j -O- _ � � 00 00 '0000 O� OI O ' � ' 1 1 4 .�♦ ' � �� -=,== � a�o � r _o_ o o �a , � -1 _ g b - ; i , o , , -�s- �� -- _ =� - - � - ��►� -_ o � , o, oa� :��;�o 0 4,o�o�, - ,t-- 'o _ _ � � o� o�� CURTIGE o'�- � �� -.,- E �- .�,� TI C _::j Q o pi ; o o � � 6 b 1�d •��0;0�0. o;oa o 0 ' _. o � - , .� v. � � . o �"'� � � '` ' '��.11 -T- ' � ,- _'Q - 0�,._o u_ I - _ -1 , ;, j �„ �,�-�- -T- - - -�� `_ o o � - o- ; - - L."_i o � e S_,. ��b o 0 o b o�o�o 0 o-j n — � o , .a � � - .• 1 ST i E. BEL ' � - � �._ O �, IO � O IOI �OjC' __ � I ,� lf__ °. � `00� �� DO� O ��d0 00000' IO �00� _ � , � �. � 4 � � . , , . � � ° . _ �� , _l.� , o , o � � ; a�.� , ;_L �.�..i ., , l . : , ., . � , � � i ._�_ 1. ` •� 1i_ '_, �.,_ _d , ,` ' "I 'i. � o � � � t � � ' ' . � � • � , i � ' ' �. ,, 1 .I. . .. , „h, .� „r ��r�,,, � I. . v k� o•c�� c� ; �o In,o � o ' b �o b � '� ' �; b � � R b�o ao p o 0 0 = o 0 1 T E WIN A WINp A _ r ''- - O �.I O J�O O G��O id01�110 r` O ' •�� !' ��l'�j�lj. IOI 00� � CO�O � O'O pOQC , � ._, � j�-l ' � � o ' . � . . � . , . � , :, � I �. ..� L�_�i 1 _ �._� ��- �� ' ��; �- rl- I t��T� O i ��r,'OU �� Or^ l ' J i:I :� � �? ' I �p � \' O�O OiOOOO•p I O' �.C� _ �_. ST. WY MIN WYAMING . . �' , 1 �'_'� ;_ _ . .:',,�', `_I ` �� ° �: .� °� 1 _ � o-,; . �._ _ �oo;o�o. c o �- �Ic � o , p�p , o� oo � o 0 0 0 0 0 00 `' ' ►_ � ' J ' i_ ;_ :� ' _. i , ._. .- � � - , - , � __� , t . _ . . . � r !1�Tr 1 n�f �� O ' � i' I ..F' C� O�O�o o�I0o00 � . 0:�10I0!�lO��!o 000'0 - � O 00 OO��bb�o 4 � ��_.�----1-- -----�—- � ' — - -- ----- .�, - - �_.�____ AREA MAP APPL.ICANT DAVID B. SASS LEGEND — — ZONING DISTRICT BOUN�ARY REZONE from RT-1 to OS-1 � SUBJECT PROPERTY PURPOSE O ONE FAMILY P�ANNING � DISTRIST $293 TWO FAMILY FILE N0. MULTIPLE FAMILY �ATE 5-12-78 _ � � • � n COMMERCtAL SCALE� I��= 200� NORTH � '� � �NDUSTRiAL MAP N0. SAINT PAUL PLANNINQ 80ARD V VACANT