Loading...
271452 WH17E - CiTV CLERK COUflCll �'�/�� 3�� PINK - FINANCE G I TY O F SA I NT PA U L CANARV - DEPARTMENT BLUE � MAVOR File NO. . CO .l . Presented By Leonard W. Levine Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date WHEREAS, Matt Morelli applied to the Board of Zoning Appeals for a variance from the strict application of the provisions of sections 61.103 (a) and 62. 103 (m) (3) (e) of the Saint Paul Legis- lative Code pertaining to building setback and requirements in a B-2 zoning district for his property at the southeast corner of Minnehaha Avenue and White Bear Avenue for the purpose of build- ing and operating a restaurant on the property; and WHEREAS, Following a public hearing with notice to affected property owners, the Board of Zoning Appeals, by its Resolution 8279, adopted May 16, 1978, varied the provisions of section 61. 103 (a) by 21 feet to allow construction of a new restaurant, section 61. 103 (a) by 30 feet to allow construction of off-street parking adjacent to the property line, and section 62.103 (m) (3) (e) by 8 parking spaces; and WHEREAS, The decision of the Board of Zoning Appeals was based upon its findings that subject lot was exceptionally narrow; that the adjacent residential uses establish an unreasonable set- back; that the previous building located on the lot, which was destroyed by a fire, had a 0 foot setback along both Minnehaha and White Bear Avenues; that the proposed building would be more beneficial to the neighborhood than the previous building because it will allow a 10 foot front and side setback on which trees and shrubs will be planted; that because of the exceptional narrowness of the lot the owner would only he able to provide 5 parking spaces instead of the 8 as proposed with the variance; that the proposed site plan provides as much parking as the previous larger bar and restaurant use at this location; that the strict appli- cation of the regulations would result in peculiar or practical difficulties or exceptional undue hardship to the owner by reason of the exceptional narrowness of the property; that granting of COUNCILMEN Yeas Nays Requested by Department of: ` (n Favor __ Against , BY -- Form Approved by 'ty ttorney Adopted by Council: Date Certified Passed by Council Secretary BY By Approved by Mayor: Date _ Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council By _ — BY + ������ the variance could be done without substantial detriment to the public good and without impairing the intent of the ordinance; that granting the variance would not impair an adequate supply of light and air to adjacent property, and that the request was not based primarily on a desire to increase the value or income potential of the property; and WHEREAS, Pursuant to the provisions of Section 64. 204, Marvin C. Anderson, 1822 E. Minnehaha, St. Paul, Minnesota, duly filed with the City Clerk his appeal from the determination made by the Board of Zoning Appeals, requesting that a hearing be held before the City Council for the purpose of considering the actions taken by the said Board; and WHEREAS, Acting pursuant to Sections 64.204 through 64. 207, and upon notice to appellant and other affected property owners, a public hearing was duly conducted by the City Council on June 15, 1978 where all interested parties were given an oppor- tunity to be heard; and WHEREAS, The Council, having heard the statements made, and having considered the variance application, the report of staff, the minutes and findings of the Board of Zoning Appeals, does hereby RESOLVE, That the Council of the City of Sairit Paul does hereby affirm the decision of the Board of Zoning Appeals in this matter and does hereby concur in the findings made and determined by said Board; and, be it -2- WH17E - CITV CLERK � PINK - FINANCE � TT COURCII CANARY - DEPARTMENT G I TY OF SA I NT PA lJ L �����i� BLUE R MAVOR File NO. w Council Resolution Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date FURTHER RESOLVED, That the appeal of Marvin C. Anderson be and is •hereby denied; and, be it FURTHER RESOLVED, That the City Clerk shall mail a copy of this resolution to Marvin C. Anderson, Matt Morelli, the Zoning Administrator, Planning Commission and Board of Zoning Appeals. -3- COUIVCILMEN Requested by Department of: � Yeas �� Nays � �O� In Favor Hu� Irsvin6 -�- NladdoX _ Against BY — Showalt�f ���' Form Approved by ity ttorne Adopted by,.Eciuncil: Date �+� � �� � Certi€ied �Pass�ed�by uncil Sec�retary � BY �sy,- �' Appr 17ayor: Date �� � a �97� Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council . By - BY �uBtisHEO �UL 2 9 1978 ..� ' .i(� '� :� �.r' �C �;_y q �r � v �' ' t + � �r r ` y��ti3i .�.t { .� k }��r a � r 5S •+ ��. -_ j• . � :.�1 �.;��' �•y 'i .t �f h } '�i � . :C � � -! t :. 1 d; �y. �'r � '! 4 . �'� ,� �-.�1 : :, ' � +� y .L ���qq � ' 1 . _ 1 ' t . a. , 1 �'y� y+3 � . � �� � � I . � � �Se C` l! �v. . . . 'J, ,� 1 ` f � r � . � � \� P'1 �-7 � / � � � t � \Z�{ � ;�� , ��, i. a , � �� \ � {� ' }�� r{ i Y a' ' � ��• � � �' - r . � � • � � ' ' t'v� 'y,j }. 4 ' {r '' � r 4J ���� . � : �� �� �� � � �j ��� � � . . ' :t 1' � _ ���S + 'i 1�� , � � �� �,�: ,��� . � � � � . . . . , - ,. , , , , ,- � ,. . . .., . , . _. � _ , � . : . . : , :: , �,� � � ' � ,` � r_ �;; . _ . � . ,� c-� - �„_ , . .. � ;'. ,. ,. . � ,� � � t,_ .j � , 1 � r . .. ',♦�. . - .� �� :ff ,S r�E f�' "�� . � �u°�.<I'�s �$�8 , A � ... . h. .�k.+r - �-- . . � � � � tfi � �� .. . I + .. � . ' �'� � . �� �'��� � '�R� �� ��� , .. .' � ��. } .I . r ,�r �•t k�g 4'� ' r A 1. �...,��il��',��Yif`� °, '' . . .�� i � r \ � : �� , ,�'.'6�t ��' �� , . ,„ , � � . . � � � .:. , ., , � - , . . : . _ .;�f �., F . a � 3 � x'°� G � ` �t/�i' '�� ''��� .. . �� ` �� ` • �� . � ^''� -.tn }2� "��£; . �� T"�� ���\�# l�/t .,��i�Y ��.�`�,. '1�'7i7!�F"�� �� � �"� �n� ''p � 'f���y�L ��+l�k� � 1Q' �109�. 'I�� 'C�,�t �`,'lbl�i F�b� �Y��' - � � ���IR�� , v��� 1��� � �t' � .o�' � � "A'wN►. �oer ��': .����: yy����. � � � � �: . � � ��}�y��� ����� ����:.�I"`'_;��'��� � '��,��:��'�` ���'TT^_�"� � .;t 3� ����r �� � �.f . .�, . � ! �. `' .a'Y' l���'�� ,, . � � ,. i" ':.. .� .l ��Y . ! �y� •�^- � � -�� �.{ _ - � "�'b,A- E . �'t _. � �, . � . ���.� � / ��, z . , � t'k '.� r�'t r� .. i , .� �� � � ( ��� ' .. .. .�_�!. ..�'���������� ��� �y �t ���� 3��,ta . . �� " � . f t.. � �r� � , . .. , . . � �� J �c� i h ft. �t �-, , � { ��� ` , � , , { '.r �Y t � ��, �;. r { " � � 1 . � � ' � � � ��i ��' � / � ' � � �i � F . J_ , ', � pyt y�`,y�'. � ; ,. � . '.� . . p�. 5 C ,� Y SM1Y ry� . . ., � ., .n- , ' � 1 J: Fy: I � - ^ ti 5���q�t��� , . . , , - ., . . , , . :. k ��� . �� '�� - �i � 1-,.. � > n� r1.� � � + ` � �� � �l7y � �� � y f � r . r 1 S.�^� `�c .,� c ` �, � ;y ti `�� � i . . _ H � �s ��� � . . � �n' i'�.� f ��� .�,`. r �F t t� F Y , ,/' . � �'t � ��� % k t3� ,� +� � i: ���� � } ,. t ��a1���� Y 1 � 'a �' . �� �� !�M� � , � " it ��f`! ���3���� i r i r � I'� . /�• 1 . l- A� � \ y F ....� r ,j'y*,:e '���}� ,��e ', � 1 � � 1` S 1�.. ; Y'$ ,p5�'F��''�) . '' . '� ' �" �.`��EWrt�� ' y� .�, ��,� . f k:L� N �, �� , �'�� :. , � � .. . H � • �: . ` .� ` -. {�x � r , d� � . c .� . , .., . � . �.:- ,. . . .... . . ._. _...r�.,._. _.w�c'�:��'�i._�.�r+. � ' � 6.'ti�i �bn` 3.�� ; . . ... . .. .. . .. . , . . . . . , , i . . .. . . . .. . � . . ., .. w � ` J k {-� pITY o,, � � CITY OF SAINT PAUL R°� '- DEPART OF PLANNING AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT , �i%i�ii b . ��, �- �o DIVISION OF PLANNING �.� 421 Wabasha Street,Saint Paul,Minnesota,55102 612-298-4151 George Latimer Mayor June 14, 1978 Rose Mix, City Clerk 386 City Hall St. Paul , Minn. 55102 Dear Madam: This is an appeal to the City Council of Mervin Anderson to a decision of the St. Paul Board of Zoning Appeals regarding the appeals of Matt Morelli for property on the southeast corner of East Minnehaha Avenue and White Bear Avenue and described as: Lots 24 and 25, Block 2, except the south 208 feet thereof, Robert L. Ware's Eastern Heights Addition. This matter was heard before the Board of Zoning Appeals on April 18, 1978 at which time staff recommended that the petitioner's variance requests be granted. Mr. Benshoof moved approval of all three variances requested. Mr. Grais seconded the motion and it passed on a 5 to 1 roll call vote, with Mr. Parrish dissenting. This matter is scheduled to be heard before the Saint Paul City Council on Thursday, June 15, 1978. Sincer ly, Edward J. War Senior City anner EJW/gf Enc. Zoning File No. 8279 U , . - • MiNUTES OF BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS MEETING APRIL 18, 1978 IN CITY COUNCIL CHAMBERS, ST. PAUL, MINN. PRESENT: Mmes. Morton 6 Zachary, and Messrs. Numner, Benshoof, Parrish and Grais o t e oard of Zoning Appeals; Mr. Robert Straughn. Assistant City Attorney; Mr. Richard M�ey of the Division of Housing & Building Code Enforcement; Ms. Fox and Mr. Edward J. Warn of the Planning Staff. The meeting was chaired by Ms. Morton. ABSENT: Mr. Peterson MATT MORELLI (�8279): An application for variance on property located at the sout-Fieast corner of White Bear and E. Minnehaha. The appellant was present. There was opposition. Mr. Warn showed slides of the subject site and read the staff report, reflecting the staff recommendation for approval of the 3 requested variances. Mr. Ron Henry, the tenant who had operated the pizza parlor before the fire, Mr. John Nirte, 1400,Northern Federal Building, and Mr. Matt Morelli . 418 Johnson Parkway, the appellant, all appeared and made themselues available for answering questions by the Board. Mr. Henry presented an architect's drawing of the building that would be going in if the variance were granted and said he has grown up in the area and always considered that particular corner as commercial property. With a transmission company on one corner, a 7-11 store on another corner, and a drugstore on another corner, he thought the proposed building would be a nice addition on the 4th corner. Mr. Grais asked whether cutting the size 10 feet •�n order to be in compliance would prevent them from building, and was told that it would reduce the interior to such small dimensions that they could not build. Mr. Warn read a letter in opposition and noted a petition from about 20 property owners supporting the proposal . Mr. Henry said that with a bar and pizza parlor both in operation. ti�e seating capacity was about 150. Without the bar, this was reduced to about 75 or 80, which would be a reduction in the number of cars on the corner. Mr. Morelli said that before the fire, half of the building was a piz2a parlor and half was the Minaehaha Tavern, but the proposed building will be only pizza. Parking would be reduced because, as a general rule, people stay longer in a bar than in a pizza parlor. He then transmitted two other letters from neighbors in approval . Mr. Hummer asked what proportion would be carry-out and Mr Henry said about 70%. Mr. Hummer then asked if that would be classified as fast food, because if a large percentage is carried out, it must be ordered ahead of time so people can drive in and pick it up. Mr. Straughn then read the definition of fast food from the Ordinance and said he did not know if fast food would affect the variance regarding the setback. At this point Mr. Amey sald fast food would not be permitted in a B-2 zone and that it is a B-3 use. He added that the individual serving portion of the definition would not accommodate pizza parlors. � zi" l � - . MATT MORELLI Page 2 Ms. Frank Lockman, 1806 E. Minnehaha Ave. , said the corner in question had gone through many transitions. She had no ob�ection unless liquor wiil be served, as the liquor place had caused the parking problem. She said Mr. Morelli had an orderly business with no effect on the neighborhood, and she agreed with the construction. Mr. Mervin Anderson, 1822 E. Minnehaha Ave. , spoke in opposition. He said when the pizza parlor was there, pizza was being carried out at all hours of the night and he does not want to see fast food carried out on motorcycles. He has a double driveway and even then had trouble parking when he came hane. Fire trucks had to back down to White Bear because they could not get through, and he said the parking problem was awful . He added that he owns 38 rental units on the east side and wants them kept up, and he will appeal if this variance is granted. Mr. Parrish said he had no trouble with the setback requirements. However, he was concerned about the parking situation. He did not think that the use as a pizza house or bar would make much difference in the parking. Mr. Grais observed that the corner should not remain e�ty and pickup pizza would not be too detrimental . Mr. Benshoof said he was familiar with the entire area, that Mr. Morelli had gone to quite a bit uf trouble to put the most reasonable property on this corner, and it is an improvement. He said 10 ft. clearance exists where there was none before. Eight parking spaces (one handicapped space) are proposed, so he thought Mr. Morelli has tried his best on a small narrow lot to put the most reasonable building that could go on that prcperty without great detriment to the area. He added that a building across the street sits out to the property line. Mr. Benshoof said he has a pizza parlor in his neighborhood and that each evening he has checked parking of cars there since he received material on the Morelli r�quest, and never at any time Friday, Saturday or Sunday. did he find more than 10 cars at one time where people got out and went into the pizza parlor. He then moved approval of all 3 variances because strict application of the ordinance would result in peculiar hardship on the applicant because of exceptional narrowness of the property. He added that there would be no detriment to the public good nor to the intent of the ordinance, and no impairment of light and air. He said the request is not based primarily on a desire to increase the value or income potential of the property. Mr. Grais seconded the motion and it passed on a 5 to 1 roll call vote, with Mr. Parrish dissenting. Submitted by: � Approved by; �� G-'� �I,c.,�L � ����t Edward J. W r Gladys Morton, Chairman ', , , .� • C �APPL'�:��@M FOR ZONING ORDINANCE VA���NCE .��� CITY OF SAINT PAUL �'�"'�'�' ZONING BOARD A VARIANCE OF ZONING CODE CHAPTE�„ SECTION P�t�G �1J��� IS REDUESTED IN ONFORMITY WITH TH 5 VEST� HE Zt7NING BOAR TO PERMIT THE � ON PROPERTY DESCRIBED BELOW. � A. Applicqnt; NAME: _ N1A T T /�1/�D�� L - � � ADDRE55 ��[G? JOI�NSO/�,� pkw� . � f 1. Prop�rty int�r�st of applicant: (own�r, controct purchas�r, Rte.) p�.v��� � 2. Name of own�r (if diff�nnt) �� �+� � x B. Prop�►ty Description; ADDRESS ; , R°g�12T uJ�A�2ES , �r4ST�IZ ' 1. L�gai d�seription: LOTS �jLOCK ADD. � IC� � ' �XG�P7' Ht� SUJ1 M �O .O� T �iCEO s. �.o� _�;.• 9'7. t�' X �•�,�4 � 3. Prss�nt Use UAG. Present Zoning Dist. �� � ' C. Reasons for Rsquest; opos�d use -R�,�fiAUie,a,N''r" /'�(1 at eharactsristics of ths propsrty prevsnf its being ussd for�any of th• p��mitted � .s �� ,,o�. :�e? S/2� � S�,f�/'� C��.L..oT. � � ow do the above sit• conditions prev nt any reasonabls uss of yo r property under ' � h� terms of ths Zoniny Ordinpnea? '�...� Z� v�4 ���+•t�/G7-� �� �M►�T�'"� ..�.,g,uD /�,�5'�¢, � tate ths s cific voriati requssted, g v�ng distances whwre a propriate. Z a / �T �•�c•�. �a.a �c�, —r 3U S�Tf�.A�c �,� �,�•,rr�, s P•9-��,,�� �. Explain how your ease eonforms to soch of the foilowing: 5��� � a. That the strict application of ths provisions of the Zoning Ordinance would result in psculiar or exce onol practical difficulties, or •xcsptionol undu rdships. - r.� ,�,e�-✓,�us �3�.� �s-�,�y� ,�y �%.,z.� . . o�� 1.�/�/,sii�E T� �E-��'���is��'�'i,�/6cS � � � Th�t��i g o6afianc�Q " � � � ��tl�� will not be a substontiol detri• CASHIERS USE ONLY -��� msnt to th• public yood or a � substantiol impoirm�nt of the � � �— intent ond purpo_s4 of the �,�j E'� Zoning Ordinane�.//J�L` f�_ � Iv �ro tn� �P��� � /lai4 T o.G ���To ,�/�6'lfBoGs . .Q . . �-��1�Z.�i��3r r1r�e� �37'r�s�. �i� � Signatur• T�E�tG,N 12• Cas• Numbsr Dat� Rec�ived � _ � � . � . , , �� , � • PIANNING BAARD STAFF REPOItT April �8, �9�8 P18t �p 41. 1. APYLICANT�S NAME ; Matt Morelli 8279 2. CLASSIFICATION . � Amendment X� Appeal � Permit � Other 3. PURPOSE : Vary setback for building and for parking and vary required amount of parking 4. LOCATION � Southeast corner White Bear Avenue and Minnehaha 5. LEGAL DESCRIPTION : Lots 24 & 25, Block 2, except the south 208.0 ft. thereof, Robert Wares Eastern Heights Addition 6. PRESENT 201VING: g_2 � 61 103 �a) 7. PURSUANT TO 2oning Code Chapter: Cz Section: 103 Paragraph: m)(3)(e) 8. STAFF INVESTIGATION & REPOItT: Date: 4-10-78 By' EJW A. PURPOSE: The applicant wishes to vary the building and parking setbacks and the requi e amount of parking in order to rebuild his restaurant which was recently destroyed by fire. B. FRONTAGE AND AREA: This corner site has 97.16 ft. frontage on the south side of E. innehaha venue and 84.44 ft. frontage along the east side of White Bear Avenue, for a total area of approximately 8,200 sq. ft. C. VARIANCE: Section 61 .103(a) states: Where the frontage of any block is divided into two (2) or more zoning districts, the front yard requirement of the district with the largest front yard depth shall be applied to the entire block frontage. Where the entire front footage of any block is in an OS-1 or B-1 Business District and at least fifty (50) percent of the lineal front footage of such block is built up with principal structures so placed as not to meet the requirements of the front yard setback, the setback required of new structures in the balance of the block shall be equal to the average of the setback provided for existing principal structures." This section would require a 30 ft. setback. The applicant wishes a 21 ft. variance of this requirement to construct a new restaurant and a 30 ft. variance of this requirement to allow for additional parking adjacent to the property line. Section 62.103(m)(3)(e) requires one parking space for each 100 sq, ft. of useable floor area. The Zoning Administrator has determined that the applicant would need a variance of 8 parking spaces from this requirement. D. SITE CONDITIONS: The site is currently vacant due to a recent fire which destroyed the existing restaurant at this location. A single family home abuts this corner site on the south and a duplex abuts the site on the east. A drugstore, a transmission repair business and a grocery store occupy the other 3 corners of the intersection of White Bear Avenue and E. Minnehaha. � , • � � . � . �Matt Morelli Page 2 E. AREA CONDITIONS: The area is primarily single and two-family residential with comnerical uses occupying all 4 corners of the intersection of White Bear Avenue and E. Minnehaha. F. FINDINGS: 1 ) Because of the exceptional narrowness of the lot and the adjacent residential uses which establish the front setback, the applicant would only be able to build a 40 ft. x 40 ft. restaurant, instead of the 40 ft. by 60 ft. planned. 2) The previous building, which was destroyed by fire, had 0 ft. setback along both Minnehaha and White Bear Avenues. 3) The proposed building will be more beneficial to the neighborhood than the previous building because it will allow a 10 ft. front and side setback on which trees and shrubs will be planted. 4) Because of the exceptional narrowness of the lot, the applicant would only be able to provide 5 parking spaces instead of the 8 as proposed with the variance. 5) The proposed site plan provides as much parking as the previous larger bar and restaurant use at this location. The size and shape of the site does not permit the construction of the additional 8 parking spaces required in the ordinance. G. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Based on the above findings, staff recommends approval of t e applicant s request for a 21 ft. front setback variance of Section 61 .103(a) for construction of a new restaurant, a 30 ft. variance of Section 61 .103(a) for construction of parking spaces adjacent to the property line and an 8 parking space variance of Section 62.103(m)(3)(e) to allow the construction of 8 parking spaces instead of the required 16. F1. OTHER CONSIDERATIONS: The Planning Comnission has approved and sent to the City Council several changes in the zoning ordinance text. One of those changes, if adopted by the City Council , would eliminate the need for varying Section 61 .103(a). Specifically, the change eliminates the requirement for B-2 and B-3 businesses to use the most restrictive setback of the block they are in. . t � �//(�� I(/��, r ..` r `w !!/� �j � . �1i/ //- � JU/ fa . �l f/J /c- N � APk s� M� �' � � I�!� C/Ty P 1 1�j� � ' �'� sar,��±/yM�,� �D q �nn��RO � 2� St. Paul, Minnesota April 10, 19?8 V I`'ir. Edward J. 4�iarn Senior City Planner City of St. Paul Board of Zoning Appeals St. Paul, T:innesota 55102 Dear P�ir. Warn: Re: The appea�. of: IJIATT MORELLI regarding property located on the southeast corner of White Bear and Tiinnehaha Ave. E. - further described as:- Lots 24 and 25, Block 2, except the south 208� thereof, Robert Wares Eastern Heights Addition The proposal is to vary the setback require�ents to enable the owner to rebuild his restaurant. According to this letter, there will be a meeting at 2;00 P. M. at the Court House on Tuesday, April 18, 1978. I�y residence is at 1822 East M:'tnnehaha Avenue. The Zoning Board, Planning Board and City Council should make a review of this because when the Tavern and Pizza Restaurant were operating on E, Alinnehaha and 1^Jhite Bear Ave. they had parking spaces for very few cars and as a result cars were parked all the way from :tifhite Bear Ave. to Van Dyke Ave. on both sides of the street. Half of the time you c�uld not get your car into your own driveway and at times that was blocked. Many times the Fire Department and buses had difficulty getting through. Therefore, if there will not be sufficient parking for the restaurant, I thirik the Review. Dept. should talk it over before the meeting. I�lso, I understand an application is being made for an on-sale liquor licen:.e on the opposite corner, and if this is true it will be very congested and the people in this area will not have any parkin� p]_aces. I understand a specified number of parking spaces are re- quired, and from the fobtage there, I do not believe there is enouUh s�,ace for them to have sufficient parking. V ry truly % � � � �. 1 t.VIPJ C kND� SUN ��� eva � 1 22 E. Niinnehaha Ave.-St. Paul CC: to G.Latimer, Mayor � CC: Robt.Sylvester,Pres.City Council CC: ZoninF., Board , � i� �, �l. , C.� � ���'" � ,. �_ �. �,, ���'.3 ,� ,� :�� , � . S� St. Paul, 2•Iinnesota darre 2, 1978 �� CITY CLERK CITY OF ST. PAUL � COURT HGUSE - ���� 421 :9ABASHA STREET � ��� ST. FAliL� IYIIIJItiESGTA � � SUBJECT: Zonin File i-:ATT I�ORELLI ���� g Zoning File No. 8279 I received a letter from Edward J. Warn� Senior Cit�I Plansies�'"dattd,j 'r; , April 7, 1978, adirising me there xould be a heariaa in t6�'Cit��",�,N �;+,�;�`:: ��' Council Chambers oa Tuesday, April 18, 1978, 3ra r�oor, Cottrt HOLtat., J � . „ � �t�,1���x.�� .�„ � �G ' I attended this meeting on this date and did not get �tucb aatiat�a- .: � ' tion explaining that I felt this Pizza Parlor should have mor� p�k=� ��;�. �. i n g s p ac e s, o t he rwi s e i t wou l d cause a grea t dea l o f coageetioa oa .� :, � ° East Minnehaha St. , from White Bear Ave. to Van Dyke St., aa ia� the `��� �,�,`',. � past. Copy of letter is attached which I wrote to Edward J. Warn. '�-`y:;•�'' I feel that I did not -have the opportunity Irir. Morelli and his at- torney had regarding the seriousness of this street parking. Therefore, I am appealing this case and asking for another hearing The Zoning Board said it would be necessary to hage 16 parking :�ces but after all the discussions with the Planning Board, Mr. h:orelli and his attorney, they agreed they could get byr with only 8 parking spaces. If somethin� is not done about this, I am goin� to take it to Court nnd demand that they have at least 16 parking spaces. Thore rcally should not be FICY.-UF SEFtVICE on this busy street. , �y; , � ,; � Ycr�► truly youre, �g:. : � � i!%�% 1h���`?�.1.�---s-=` Q.OZ---- �:tVIN C. AI�DERSUN 1 22 E. 2•iinnehaha Ave. St. Pa�l, l�.innesota 55119 CC: Edward J. Z�rarn CC: Council rI�bers CC: G.Latiner, r:ayor CC: ZOhI2�TG BOARD /� /�7 ^ ' � . . �.' '�'.I � �'J L�.��� /�/I F^ .. . � . .. , ��.. � �� � ' �' �' ��������i�'�� ��R�/�� ��< �9� �� �r . �" 1'!Be MINN�I/AMA AVH-N�./1� S'T. pAUt_. MINNBSOTA 55110 '.�t �4°� �S, � TtL61+HONE 7.'l8-4044 ,: . - � �:'.. . . � . �L� �` �� � � x•r . .i� : ` �t �, `" �O �lJ�,�11U117 1 T� f?���/��_�'�.�_�`_� _���/l�' .,�`,�� �,�,�� Y"d�'�,;, ` ,.�! _ ,r. �.., �� �,�' • �." � � t�,;� �* � ) r ,/ �^ �^� <<��.' N.��,ytyt'���� � �k � �,f � � ��, .,�/ ^�N��L�C ��5 .•'^ "f�' ,(„� / !�� y�' ��� .��T d '1�1y1 � (.� / /1 ��� C_)/LJ� �C�i. ✓ �":*�„' ', E '��; + ' �- //.'?..; ��� _�{`�t '�����'K? + ;.i� f� ��i1���. L�/I!� L�l' l-�.J C �� .�� �1 � r�ft r� r�t C�{`�`i � , . c. G�- �y �JS� .� ' + �,"�� t a;, � , , � (. .�a� *' _; ' ')1-i � ��,;� '� �� T�i9�/.�/�'i�// l/�v/2�J �I-�L L s� .��� � � ��'�'� �'�y�� ` ' ` , l_i1/.V �L c .Y, _5 xa� �" ?��• } �<�� �,� �/.2 � r-�� �/1� � — � '� ; . r,� `� I��E .� L-- t�C�iV��G U .� ,`� / , , � , i �`�,' l.c.!ff /l�'"' L�c�.w i� .�Sj �v r.� __ k� ' ;�.'�'�� ;� � ..� �i //J �s�vivr�/.�7 �,� ;� �, � ` � � � T �7�''' ��j �`� C t: M ��a '�R �A ! � �/7 u,G... / r" 1 . / 1 Pb � ,y y r. �++* ; ' --L ` �L.�.0 J L!/i��:-/[ 1� /�J��/C� J r �� /� ;�7 � �v- � � S �, �. � w��te,� :a c r�. �� ` Y� � // /� 'I {,./ y� ,. / /� � / / � d � T � r�j f/ Ll.../ L fw �� F✓/V r� J//,1 o/ /� � � 4 � '�"s 3"� 1J ?' � 4/ �/`r �� / /l GJ 7 4�.�.f-�f � '� . �,���, 1�.i �� �yl�h[ _ e� - � . . e � `�..r!n'"w. y. M'��r { '•I �w"/�� � ' ��I1�� � � ' � i�i'���yL.� �• r �r �;F � i�'� w- .�- � l�/ �/ � � ,' ; ______�--___ � ,��� �� 5 �'3� � �" �)�`�' , ` ' , ��,;; ., ' . ,���� . L/L ,� »� �, ;�(�°C�'•c�.za, ,�� ��M,,�.,.,Z,�., --��/G � '` ��� .� �� ��r� �° � � � S� I ��r �3 � ��� � b �jA�,J p { � , �t �� ' �/f v�'�-�c.� I f, � a�f, �.a � � --...,.--.---_,.4. .� . � � r . � '� rw� � . . � .. {A t4� � � �� � � . � �,: - . � . ��/.� -A� /� n/�� �if�' v— • {y '� �'�� ��` � � �L4'/ti�!/`�� �,` C���"" `���� . .(,� .. . � ���a.�� � , ,. � � . , ,� . . .; � /'....�. .______ ,, _.-------- r���,.. `� . . . . �! " ��� . . .. .. . �4 �� L}" r . , � , � .L1�L��6t�'.�;�,�' . , -- r .(� _�� �. � �,� . C��'�/ —`" �� �� ��/� ��..��f ;; . �;' . A 5 • . . ,, /( `'�./���j'� �. ����"/' ��'/ W��ti� , ' � . . 1 � 1,�;� � 'I/' �•� ��. /" � . . 4 � ' .. � .. '1' ' . . /( � _ � . � . ��-� , . 1�, . . . , � r^. ' - ' MI���� . . ' . � ... . � y'�� � . �:F" . � ,��. � . ' .. . . � ���� .. ' . ' . � . . . ....r......w-w•r..... .�;...���. ,.._....�.... ..r.,....--.. _............. . ,, r--.... .. .,......,.• � . .,_.,. . _... .. ... ....... . ,:7�,.' ����: . . .,;.: �:. . .. �.,., '� . � . '.�, � � . . . � . i�r ' . ' . ' . , �. , . . . ' , ., g� ' , . . , . �,pNING FILE � a,, r � :� � � R�NI'ol��.�.}�'� ����1� �1�A� , , . � , . . .. , .. . ' � � 17i� MINNI,MAMA AVRNU6 � . . , A , 8T. PAUI... MINNff9QTA SB11� ` � L '� !, �3' ' , ,��' TELCPHON[79{Qi•�t�44 �, � •a� �'t �' �;1� ��ly ,_: k�'. . �+,.:� . . v e y��?� �tl •.r,h�' �.. k k: l @I . � . I� .? . / � 4 ty� y r � �}q. { »t`���d�, v ( ,,,%'� / 1�,�' a ''�•; r� xi�. � ik �r �� � � � .i -1 ��,,� t 1� $ �& ���, � �� ..yt Y;��,. '. .\ . . q ��.,/ ,,��._�.. LC��L.:�,. j-i. ' ��� � ..y -� � /� � / ��• t�F � � l_ �..' �� , �r y r. �;.s,, ,��: . I�r' � ... .,� ; t'; y�y� y �� ' ' • "�' � ��,�� ,�",r�� p.. i �1 tl. nf't -. � �. � �... j (�• � L („�' � . � '� �... . #'c94�1.r. 'q-.tk pr ya..; � .... il � 9 .1 ' � �,� -� �t.. i 7 G iri': �s a`$lT. � n �r , �: �ti ��_-' t� �:--C. r�c�--!C (. . � , �,.,��fk ��,� � � ° f �e �� , � K x L, �' t: � ) °` . a : i 1r. �4. $ �', T- � i,. ,e�f , . ' . F �n � 1C.. C.�C. ��,'t....t.� �-�' �, �; N�r 1' S t -. �^ n y aS r ' , � � ��.'�C._ li^—f-�- '�.. � 'C.. "l�„r P 4 � ;�y,a,w� , ��' "r yy _ �1�� ��• ♦ � - r � 1 v�� 'w 4 3 � RS ^ t �� �. A �k P� ;� 1�',��. 1 5 t� � � 1 C �l� . .k,ti 3� r �� � �/! /� r x ,. � �:'���,� P-_._L,,L/ �< i ,.'�y�Jk ,, k��. � e � l ,/�'�.�'l. . �i �" X �j t} + a�. /' ��.G... �' ...��.._� v � f t ' � �?.5° ,7 > , �.�' �r t', " ] . ��'� � - � �� � � 1 t� �5�- �a' � � ` c��rL� ;'t �• � , � � � � , °X�:. �� �4 r • �' r �+,. �� i.� 'r q�.. L� . . , . ' . K, yr� 'kMl.y, �'Y r�,'p��a�.,.: �t W I _� �' . ' � ' r�A TTJn :Fqd�r�(. ��r��� . � . f!'.� .•'J.'�. . 1 !.�j 'r ����1 S)� � hr.. � .. / �✓j � � �' 4� . . � ,. x '1'.�� l �(j r.Je"'�F� 4 �•', 1 � . F'A J� iC J_,�'`-«i' t./ h S, t f p �:�.�- v�°, ' � ��.. y' � .� � } ' � ', � , � . d ���� ; `*� „� . ''a��' , 3' ' Z�...i:....-C._-��. i' -i� ;,��^"� � �,� �.. ��' � -'„� > � 10 SuY' J � � . . � . . �a �'e �. �/L� �, , F�4 {�.� i � , - , . . . . . . . : �� �, � ; w�'. . � , .. . � . .. , . � . . b�'.. � � . f'` �f '�� ��, �. �'.:L..._7 � . . ," � Q `'� ?�;,t�..-L.:. L.- � ,, ,�� , , . +;j + c'� �G �"�, Cl �` i, I •; `� . �t: GQ-�'�-'"�''`� Z��� / � I`• ,. 4� 4 � � �/' ,( n�l` . '. . ' ' . Y .�f'�. '�/L./l�C-� .. � . (_ � 4 * � r �„j,.: }" . . .. . ;.'}• . . , . ... �,.��'�� . . .. .. �n _ . . ' � . � . . . ,.,�. , . . . . . .. . . .. . . 'fA�I� . . .. ,� . . , , � '��..' . . . . . �� . . . s�� . . ..� . . . . 4�� t ' ' . � . . � . � � � {1'-. '* , ti� . . . � . . .. ��1�:-... , , . . . . � . ���� " . . . � . . .. (.,.�L . . . .., fi � ' - � ' Y . ' .. A�I � � � . . . . . � . �� ' . . . " � . . � - � � . .. , n , . y � � .. ....r. - .. - , .'..... ...,..._.. , _... -.r ..... , ., .�, . .. ._. � - � . �� . � , ' � �� �'� '� ���� 8�- . . ,�..;�.�r . ; , ! � . , � '�:� ° �'�r� fi � �rr� �' . M1 �. � . ' . .. � � �. >� Y, . � `� qy��j�.�� '' �M ��i �, � .���h', � . . ((�� iI�J�} r �/ i d a i�G w� �r'' � ' �i������� M' �F ilrrlf+�� ..�11�►� �_��� '° ��� �}wi .it�' ;�1• •:� ����. � . . . . . - f� 4 Ji� 1.� N1 .� �YJ. � 17�� MIMNQHAMA AVCNU6 � R : 2,Ya � . � � t ,. � � ,�T' • �!t .t'n'�,"" �; +1 `� .h 'f �, �r al'1 � '� � ` ' OT. I�AUI.. MINNE6QTA�i�t1a t: �"� f��c �' c��y+�! . k . j'! � . � . . . .. .. . y.. � • � � fr °�re i.,6.�. ` ° n: � T�n.pHOws�s�s.aoa.t � �,�? �r�!�' r'" �`�a" ,t �a r� „ , ��, ��r,t r� �� ,w, .: k..,�� ' ' ', J , , ? �'�) �`a + ,(;%�� �� �:�ti'.'�• �,.[ (�.--. '(.,.• �''! l. (. : , �'!' ? t� •T � . .F•� . . , .. . . .? � . . .`I 4 4� 1X' ��t �� .• � � �'�• � . � � . ' � r ,.t � � � �� �.,. ;` �"":��....��, ��.��'� } �-- Z L d,�. r �': r,� .,� � ; , ?t 1� �' ' r �� r �� �. !: ,� r4� z t�� ;? �` � � .��r ,� sr�. ,:i � t��' � � , �� + n > ':��,T � /'',�J p , • [ �� •l,_ �C� � („% � `�' P+���S �r � '�f�t• �.��''�l./• � ..� C �{' 1�: ��i�s * 9 ! ,�, - , f ;�. �,� $ �Z r. ,f ti !�'�u1� �� J _ A " ��3 y �� V ,�/") r +f�/ ) f��(C /f �V3'��y���� tC i1 � I �1�+' ��f !. ,����_���C. �'' _�/�T�•,.'V�..n?��*„ � � 1.�'������Gtim r� 'T l Y � ( a t� v ��� � . . . 1'� � .���,i / ,�v. .:i'r �` s ' ^ � . y.. e': r 14����� � I : i t S t' � .. ��� f�:�l� r M �� S� Y �• F; ��-+ ` ��1f � ../'T�"\/ � � �,��'�V1� � ��4 N�� !,_ � �, �� x � r ��:_ � 5n ?:�[ '��a�. ���.� . . � � �fx�.tN�ti�'��r r• �� +'i R-t!� � �L . ar , ����',t����� ���Y��,. ,1'p n -Yy. �.� :� . . . . 'yR N-., i t� r�F���Y ' a d a � ' . f �,; r r .� "'�l � ��'f vf '+� � r}�b �h' � ,� , ,y ;ar,u'�+y'"�,�` r ��+;�I��� 1w s:��� '.� , ,;� ' , �..,J_rF %�_` . ., � � � :�� .� ,��`�;` k y `" ��+"L t 't ; y�.i + v� 'n : ,�yF�� ('; ..,� �f � ,�:�`.. . , �S+"Yl"�6 , �r��r' '�3�.?� �''`y`� ,� .'" t . � 7 �.v t p r � � k +S ,y y i �'. S r � � � �, .3�r �,��y� �, (�,�` � t+[ r � ��k � • a � r�'`�� �i�� �� '.k� .o � ri! �� �►ry � � J 3 � �A A . + �i,. � Q y+J'f na� ph�" ~ � . Y ' . . �a 5¢���� ���f s �� � .' 6A: .,��ri y � 1 ��.,< f 1 � �. � . (,FT ��EY } ^ ���.q � �^ +uf� � +r? . L "� r.l� L . .;'��•'.,L ¢r� j�r'�}� ° M*fX.� , �� C?;, � ' �'�F'�` � l�r��4�`�'`" ° '�"��f �� n' t ' A« '`f � ��� :.�� F��ti ,, � � � F� , +;�3�`s'� . ti., � �, ri��°�� � .. � � � �9; S� � t �� "� `.y� k i; ( ��Y+7 ,� �;n4 j � 4 � ' � � � t . . V � �� ��5�` �. ��.'1k � . '1 r � 1> 0 5 � � ++r 4���� � �p , ' s. ` � �,�;.�. !7-4. .^G'', i��� c'� ib �,�&•q � , ' ; %��' � +}y.��', �T',r'?r �!�. � i'''�.-'�RL, �"'��i . . , � ,�� � �l��._,,�'ilV��� .w � �Y . � � ) i. `$ 4�t� 4( °�.:< ..� � ,� �l �' ra �e � �`i >,. 4 �� ' . ,� ' �-y'C,.�/ �,f,,dr �' n G ,-�_::c � ��' 4 u,k J��'�'.X�' '" x I � � p �� �� � y ., � .;�' M�,���� � j , - � .i� l:i '�' 4� � � ,:� rr� � � � �; M.�,�� .��.•� .. .J � . . . .. .. . a - � ,{ '. ��'� �, f Y , fr ����. ��1,�r � � . . , ��/ �'k �a s� �R�� �y �� y ' . _yiiya��.'/�� 4'��� . ..:t , . _ .. �.�.+-� � �'�.�/ �� /' . . , . rl�(i�r.�� i�.W�'P+' ��r �.� #_�'�. qt � J I�,./ � � f 'N a �'J Y �, �' '.�'bl J .�i l S,: .. . . 1 '�i�� '4�'�i. � ��� ^•���q �'�}K� �� � � � �;� t,f; y��$.t�''��7��t - 4 �+�1„.! .�,cw I �ti,,y,*��b . , . . . . . 1 .. j ..x 7x �,a ; "�,�� �`-��F a �'. - . � . . " � .� . ' � .. . � Iv+ �t i� `�� t�:. � 1 . H'I � �k��� �1��f t � � '� '�� ��� ��. � � � . �r � �" �,�o�ti' n ` �j ;� dd'rp.��'1 ��r1 .. � . �- .' h;'y,� � �1r 2 � 1 P 4 . M �'' �F . � . .. - . .. . . N4'�+X � ; �.s } 1 Q` �� ��/, �� Sd;y'�� ` . ' . � - - . � . .. . • ' � �� Y �� V� ' ^ �� '+.�., � f� t`.,���fi � ' �;�. s etp x � �'�,j:; ��,�r, � ; :,��r t • + zm �;� � ,�d7k,+f �'# t h, �} � �� ��� � '. . � ` �� 4 .• .' ,{� , , �t a��'41f 1 v,s � ' . - . . . . � � ) � . � � r��1 �'''�v o�',, �` r�r �3 ��1 , �'1 �!�y.� . � . . . �. f p�. i � 4 -w� ,��� � ' � � . �.: � • � • ,. .� Y ��'�'� 3*� '.� Al._� . . � ` - , '� � . . .. . - . . , . . 5R z Jj • y}`�' •��f�r*o��'rc+�'ytF^' ..:� o-6ro j►m F+-r-- •�,J . � !PV � � ��g'��,, i, >rs ��r, ° S,�R s �'xt a � `� ��' ■■ ,�• S�Q�`, ' , .' s !,} :� ` y.�` � ri y '"�,�T���+�t�;y���rr ,r`�4'R�7+w 4y���.rA �� � ��� � ' � ■■ '_��' � . t .. � ':'�i r:'' �•Y t� Y Tp g�il��F '*v�f��4. �!� � y/f���■����- . -. , .1�x. �� ` 1 7 �_� ^'� � l[1rr.�. � �n '" _ �{ —1 . � � � . - �ei,�!*$y ,p�'' � , ����r. � „�,+y �r� v„ � > 1 ) '!� A7h a,C M�' t '� t , � �d6r"������ � -"��4tt z.,R��t �.j���* �����I��'� � f � ' N � ,� . . . , , ' ,. � !�Y ��v'�' �J� 5 r 4 . . 7 � ��f� �L� .. ' M p�[:. � �. �.�b � � . ' , t N 1., � � .�,. � �! 4�tf" a ' '�l'.�} 4 � .> � Ty�� .,j'.,.f�..N �'�f�w ai . . .. . ,. , . . • � . . , l':. . . . . . � .. . .: . ,,� ,. . ..� . : ♦ ��,,...;�p�e�.. .�.:u.,-..tirf.qr+ ..�:.,..� :a...ww1+�w.��r+dw� .,w..+� �1i[�.r,.. ..,..�. � a�w.x�+�....,+�tw..,..,,.., . . ... . .. . � ....._._ .. * . +M .�iYntiY.�' . , . . , . .... . � � • � . ... . J a i . � . . � . f � . . � � - '', "i j 4 S ��: ��� ' . i iy:.. Y� � a.�,r - . ,. . � t. .� L�Cr�►R YJ�It.�ILiu-Yi. ,.t+�}.u;� Q'i� �t - �.P :�.� ' . . .. . , � . -' ` . � bs k�:7{� 1 I ^t ���� �. � . � L(>�u.f'.C.. �ac� /(�Gt� �t" TM� a�� � � bt�r. , ; fi , ��l �Il �F��4+��� ��4l�f�� �l N��� ! �`;, ` � �� ,:,' � �, �A' 17�6 MINNEMAHA AVHNUt �s/ d � ���: 9T. PAU�.. MINNEEfOTA sEt1� ��� �, t��: � 4 � � � � . TEI.ePHON[7.�IS•4od4 . � � . . F 4�,. ...� , � � � � lo �tio��� 1^ r ��,� / L�o.�c�,��✓ ���; . • �� 1i� -�,��,�� ,s T-d 13� �t E� �NS T� �!� 7"io�rl , . � �� R ,i3u �,�,� „�� � s � v so«�y ,�� ,� , �_ ��.s;.�u,e,a�.� �Fo,�n�ac�.y �a�v�/����/�s iz� , � � _ _ ���., �',�� SC L° o�2�v E�2 0/= GU�i r�" ��,�2 �. ., .,�v c� /?� �1ts 4�sa.q�� L�vC, S T/��?�-r� � � €� rz�r�l � � ' .G.,O f�/4'U� �/' �ni( T �y , . . � VI..��.� fi� / i.!�/ � � -r-'1 �.'h•. < '° A�!� /� � O C_.. ��/lJ �� \ .�' w 5!Y ; � . . .. � �.�� � ���fl 4�,�� , . _ . . . . . . , . . ��I � . � � ... � ...'. . . . . � . �ZQ/J2t-�,' .. ANATOLE RABCEV 1 CH ' \ ��"- '" � . y� 745 WHITE BEAR AVE. � .!� � � ' �� �.,�► J�Gi-d�t-Q� 774-9643 �°� � -- P'' . � -�� Du�� ��a �3 � _ ��''-�I , ; � 4 � � l.:a�s2.-Ia�'�'t/Y�..�!� 1 . � —_, � - � ry - � ... .,����� , _�Y��� ' , i - L t � � S l 1 I . � _ � ... ..- • ;�� .._ . ..___- ...,<.v.._._._ . � � � . . � � . , J � � . . � - . . � . . . .. - � � � . . � .� , . . . . �,. , .,' . .. � . � . . � � ..� . . . . � 1ti . _ { , .. . � . , � � � � !1�, � .�. . . . . . . . � � . . r ��,. i y� � a 1�C^t k 1 . � . � ' . � - � �^� �.' �q'J� .i t�n . . . . A � I 7¢ ��'n�.�7 y����J�. � � . . .. � 1 a c.t4y .+ <, ;< rx j}? 4 i� � . ,4'- ,� rt ,y, > p ��. :: , F �., , c � . ��`"��� ty"Y'� � ��dty ,}i r ti :.. . r!��J�������t�� �i�.{�� �k��{ �R��• f� ��, �}�'�wr���c'�ly`� ^' ��3' }: .i�SNr° d'P'x.i',°'�'I�S' �n,�Y� �,h.. "t . .. . �... . ��n.. ��j�� .M� q, t�j+7r ! ,Y,, w�d,';►: ,� 1�.�+}�y[ .. � 17�If MINMKMtMA AVtN4R� T `r Y q 5� � Z' � � � � A{T. PI1U1-.,MINP,IEBQTA liO�19 M x�� �, � �� �� ` ��� ^ T[I.�1'kIQNR 73�•��A14 . �"� y?:r �k � � ���'7; �? :;� n �;' , � . , �-,1 n �,� �^�. i ./ ��Q/I ' �r'.� "�.� ,` � ,� � ._t � .�"'�Y,LI , . � ��� ri�' ..a+ ` ��r4+. 4f ��..�_-. '-Y`..�„ . . {, s�e, �,:. . `y'�'"� .� � ' � . � . �,. +� `�. �µ � ^� //{��� rl� � }� �• ��� �. � .. , . , ,. . . +� �"f'��i �1��(,' f . . - . .w,�.. ' '�;L�"Ii"'��' •�i � �FtY�i. � a .� �� ��,� � k .. -.--•' � ,4C �"';.'L'i:1Z. . '�.-� �" ,;� :���,,3h , ; ,�+,,,.�,,�,.,,,,�t_..z;.,� ,: � , ,� , ��.�q,,�;;yf , p �� ;t �� � � . . . ,�' �f ��' � �M x Q'�,ti+t Y+�a.�y '��1. ` ; /,, � ��s //, \% // � �.t �+ �-lxS�4��'i�n:�!� 4:1�.`�� "'7' . . �� � �7 '� � �„��`�„ 'V���.� ��..!�'��� 7"' GC...���yCa� ��T���i� �c�.,+ }�, �� .'�� �.�� �-(..,,�.. t�-�,��.....-� �a r ��� �� � � �� t: t k� �.� �° `�"�Z��� � " C�,(� � �;� �� k. ;�����.� � q� � ? ;f� . L ��� �}� r ; � �:H S,s ,, , �' _ G�—� �,'��— �/� ,�'"�:....�,,.{;�,, ��-� �;��'� 'i `� ' � r. �.... �`... .�'s`"'� f F,. �� �1,�� �� �4:'�''�r�'^ ��"''� r�;:: � �,: �;. �� � , � � r .'�5,�,�� ,� x � 4 4 a� � ; , �r �'r.� # �.� -� . . �, < t �` � �f ' y/�� py. � �, /j { , p.d. . ���t � H? �. .. ! �.�'� . �..�"f ',?-'��. ♦ � . , . . . . y,1��� �' y+ �+Ff f "rr.4�•t�j�Z��. }�� '�" y�, � ,� �T 1�3r x.. �Y' �6S � � . � • , p� L TP' iWf9 1 I�(�•�J� �. yl.�+� l+f�7�, �'-.' . ' . . S� h E'�J! -1 � cr.- S r� . . �t. �i t .n�7 t . g . �'t ��" 1 / � '^��� •'� � '��...,-�'J P�� " N 1 °J 1'X � �.�^ �� � , �• �'i l�s+�:* ��rt r '. ' r. i� °��4'� � �'' .�f"' !R a �) "�' ti t�l� �, . � � ��,,}'�� �,� )�" : o �7� q y'`r t��w��y� a . � . . ' '.... ' � �^�� ' � . . �����t�}� ��.�� � .' y . � `r��!A�l� �q r�� qy�+� �"a'1`�'l;'�.... '7'L,...if�"F.....-/`�r'A��_-.�.!C, .� . . . "L E'1'� � '. . Jy !#��t ar �� ;}'i �}S�y���1K��'�p . . .. , . . � , ... � . . . t:���ci '.. d+�,.hl `�rY'�t� �'{ ���� 'l ,; )' ,�g '�7� A,} 4,�,t :�', ' Y ��Y1'� r �� ��������+, .. `�; . . � � . . . . . ,� fMt�� 7�.�� �,.... ♦V y �.�- � w���� ��#r�'� t.K♦ � i, ��, /��� ��,.L�.....:-'dz,-�"'�..���-�•.� . ' �` � y "4�ttKA' � dt :' � �!v^''.�- �2:- �,r t. e � . - :i t,.., ��'uy y� '. �'aJ.'`�1�rj '.,��� . . . 4 � � {., ( � � r1 L�� J]LYY`` ��5'l� . A � �', }r. FA� ' . � ;, � / ` k f '� / / � M�a�7r *P'1Li + x`s�.''. f� - Q ,�... � ti i��,�y 2�;',�y�� *? �,�^—�,' `�;� � �� . �� ' . , +*; � - �� o �M�y� tr...���Y�F�,i��i ��. . .. � .x � t� �t4�;A �t;Y F ��,fft i r e �,yf �8 vti . - . . .. � kxr i � , � �r �y�d� `c�1 1' � � �i,�F.'+� .� � ` . ..:#��K`1 �xr ' .. ' � ' ' . � 7.� � � .. t� s 's �� �r�i ,: �� �;4,`j . .' . � , .�, � '.. { i - . • ,�''� �� ��N , �* �w td t N'��i. � ni��j �.,. y �' , . . . � 1: i;t . . . K �� It'_ F �}��y�' l:1 ^�, � � . .. . . } ht,� 1 � . �� �.' �• 't t �,1� „X� 1 k 'f!���.r7 1�1� t� �� >'1 � � .. . . � . . � . . 4{ �d , ft;, �'{ ; �*.� -- �,� ; 6 A � �} ,�" N Nl 4! V'. q . ., � . � . , . . �q`�1� is }. �1'�y� f��� �f . . . l.� � � � ..) }1 r r��' dh��l '. . . ' r . f,. � 1 1 � �xk f ��: as f ,�, ! Si�+ i � ; x at �i k,ty� y} a., � 4 , , iy ��pr . , L� ��1-,r f+. ; � . . . ' . . �, .� dr t!fp H c. �� '�� � j +; �t� + , A r�t,S {� � r r'y �t �'. �ti'Y ;...ai)_��.{i � At . ' , � . . . . . � �� '. d � �. � � Z. ;. ,,,- ..... ....: .,. .,'.,.. ,. , ...., ,._,-.,. . ...,. .___,. ...-...... ... ...... . � T t � t pr'T s ��iw, w n4i r.,a . t '� .i �. � � . .- ' � _ � ' � . . - . . . ��y}h'�, f ,j� i �A' � ;R 41� (f M il � . . . ' . .. �Jl �r�ift� 1 - !�� t� Y; E ';1 � . . . r�' � � ��,�E� � ry ) �t�,44P ,� F <�. � } ,� x r . tl a�t 4 .. +lr � � . �'} � . �,,•.. . . ,:,.��'���4�����.� ����.� � �� e.�; / . , ,. xk � � {�5y }'� "�4< -. ` Ax"rN �� '� �`� . .. . . :.� _ . y ; L�y� R,� I }� 14.�3 1 !J�' h' �. �5 . ,. � . �T'rur'!Nr9iw , . �� • �� . i 1 , �•' .. . � . . . , . . ��.y . ,`F}t ka i� �/c' � ,N1' ' , , . . ., .. . . , . . . . . .. . .,/ s � _ Sb ����"� �'�'fi�`�M � °� r �r a� �� � _ ���, �i ,r r � ...t y .. t ��, � .: -� R ���r �'k.isi��' �, 4 ,' � i1}�:.'$�.�u����� 4 �. }1 ` `�f� �� v 1 t, C � �� �Y >. �, � �t Y 7 .4� +�� �{ a �4� ' t ��' , � � ,.,. d�� x :1',� �M° �'�4 t+ i:�#� �5' � 1 -� � ;?a t t t� � e t � ��'� �'j* r� (�t� � ',+` � � � 4� ���� � }rF c� �R � ���"'' �` �i����.kV'� � M " n, q,}( +',N�' '; y X �S�+ :. � . + ty ""-'����rs '�9 � �G �� � �' � ,�y�r" ��) W— y��f �.. H�;.�� �,� f �'� 4 �k F4�e; f� 9�""' I i � �i M� k'�� � 'w , +,'(4r :. ,. . : .. . �,.��.^r� � �t,f ` .St ,� d ��, � ,�.� ��f�.i� W+j � �� �.» ..����-f` �.��, �� � n�����' �'��i ��' t��� 'f� �d.,' wF•'�'T'+►,' � p N`S �",r,� 4i�i+0;�. �°`V' r � "�,`: � / � jq,!p � V�}' �� 9 �r r � 1 � . ' � �v.' F� . ,��5�*r �� '- / �y �, *r�t`�r',.�..G=-" !!�::..� r..... / r��, yr ��;. ; 4 t, ��„ �a a r � ���. +�1,� ��e :a�� `�k. '% �". �[, � . . � . .. , . . , . �f�� 3� �y ', 4� �^,'. M1;W�.:��,' ,J�i.. /,��' w , •:�, 1�: �: F����t M ..� . . ��.��,f,..�'./r F•'�."��/'!a .. 'p���. . �. ,h. � � ''�,4��,�n E�� . �' �� �.r'r►� ,,/ . . i."'}� .. ' � .l� ¢ `'� s ` s x' �;`,y y' * .F. /'� 4.1' �t. ��4 �� � ' . �� �} �l,:.p�,.�, ,,,�/ � F ��i.c� + �,�� � . w _ ./ YI� Rr � �, �:� qi J � ����r..r , � � 4 � ' t �'� ��S` R'i� ,o , ' ���'y r�4'�.y,�� ;.. .�i ��� �. , , ' ., , -. ., ��.�� �r " � d. %., �. J�' //�.�+" � �`{ >C: _Yq7'n� F e�fl ,`4���y � .t . . � ��'' �j ��-F"Y'�� {T � �l �Ir{\)� iE��Yi �� ( tif L+ n�A . � ;,�,��"��.,�,�,.,�'_ � �'��i'�- �+�".�'� . ? � ,:'� � 'dr. .���h Qa {�t r ` ` ' kr.x t � ��r, 1• •' � ��.s��� � :,r�9 .. .. " . . .. �� I� . a ag� ����Cn�� ���. �✓,/� n• ' y � .. f' ? 1._� �; i ,iyj k�A+ +�,"+j���t� y �' t �yrr�..w F�r':.�w�ec.t(•, �{ r.I �� tf' rfa . {y;�'�+ �' :.4 : r�' �,����'r����i�`..,,V ''"i.,�.""E�'��'i�'�° ' ''t'"�'',iG1!{,,.; }� � �„�f!„ ��,�v��" ��`,�';'� "� t : rrl �xt. � r* i<i �� �: �, 7� - .. j .�� ��J Yi��r+l1e5�^�" y, •}.� � � i � +� . ' �,J � � } o.�,flP�,���°.c S�i� "': , ,k• '� ' • ��S��rs''����.�n� � a'b� � � � � * �' � 1 � � t r f�'} �rt ' Y i1� t. 1f.�}�� 1 .,.. y f? .r��` � F _. . ,. . ', f-1�� •,{, �x�.'� t },'�SC{�i. �r�l+�yk��0� r ' . i �t3�. , . ;;�. . � ,�.��dM1�" � A � �� 4 j ��t` . r r F�,�,�,i g'£E r r���T a� � :� Y ,E[�� ,, +f^�r.i �.. � . � �,� ,����w �. �"'�µ�� . T� E.� i �., � ��¢:. �. q++' �.�.. �� � ,.�, ' ; ...a h�F , . �"`a Y } . r.•y• � }, k, -Y49 � t�. . � ' iX� ,,� a�'a ,,. ;� t"�-X . ,' S'. �G .�,�1 Y 4 1� t: � •e 't�,::��,tl� �; �� �S i � .. �4' i, 4: ��y t � � f j� ;�,,.�r�"i 1C��� �'k'�,a � 1 y ��'' 1 4 / ��� �? � � � . . �(' � p� . � . . � ` �� y )V�_�a b i. !! p'�,� w,, �} fqH� t. � `�I . �T � I � �t.jiBr.�' � �}�t�T+ � ,'lr.� q k #�. ��` �+�.:-'a 'lfi ' .. . .,r�" � �� F R �., � 1.��./ �a�r;`'� ,�� ���g t v� � r t tr� � � �� � � .�` .y/,.y�,4n � �,��� � ��u. #i�a �� �n K - ..a� ��� a 4� � . �,� ,'������F- 1I �LL 'N' € K � i4 tr�':� q� �`�" �!�G�'�,, � • . i77'�;?i�� �*r 5 L ���'� � , j ,•,� ,�', �,,'' � � � l.� .��i ! ��t 4. . . . , . . . �. r .j5r�'F i s ,y �3.. �µ '.� ra. � N44, iG� �"�� - ' . '.� �N x� � � y + A o- ' ��: �,�+ �,�k+'� ' . 1-s, , ���y'Jr�' r rs'�'1��Y�� NA r ai � �+a S1�,fM'�� :� ��,y�,�+;1,� � ' `�f �,4" E �� �>,';,��a,� m�.+,�� � 7 x: �'�,r� �� � ''� �. , ' �8 �',��t � � �� b�c, . .rf f'�rv � � a �'. y� �"'..64�ya-� '�:�� 2� .. . � . � . � ,�ys� � ° �� r � .� i zty'�1�� . '� .. . . . _ . � . � . - , t �. . � . . . ay t% w x� 11�� � 5'kt u� : �,tt �'�'i�t r 4?y,�' . . � qy��� '�„�i� f l,, . � h �j� .G .� / n P� ' , ' . � � '1 l+ .. /. !.' d�.v��{ .,/�1F4 .. � . . ���'�1'F�1'y A ��.�4�i Y' .r 2�ra . ,� � . . � � .., � d�`5�'n r#�r � � :'�y � �v '�}�}' :�ro ' � g`s`^'����n r- `F � �>F� id� 'C�.kr��„D> .� a� � . . . . .. . '(��,� r,�.; '��$f� rv . i,_: � 'Gy�A��:�+ '•"gVt p . . . . � . . .. � , w�(r` +�{,° 5��9�v .,y, ,� �h�i,�-, x r � .: l 1�r , , ; > >��t��'�z �` E ".,,,�,�� a `r��,t' a��+�t�l�>� � '�.� � � � � ' � � ty�a �w•����C " 1 ri�;n`` h2rR � . r - . . - r4 ii.�' `��x t ✓�. y F p p� U�.� . �f'I��/jA��aR��/ �I�JT p''�+j!` . . . .. . � � . . . . (? j ';��� � 1� �' M���*� . �[ ' �:r1'* Y) i�'�w(FL� � � , . . , �� AJ t� �� �. k . . ir i :x� +t��x r ��v. w.�r. . . . . i r.+._,�'�, r t � � � . ` °;..��� 4Y� r�,`,,�',f� .. . . ' . . �rt r y�, , �ix. j'n . '. h � � �n 9 F� . . . . `���" [ . c 4 ! , .i �h� 1 y, Hl �.f � ,� t; � i qy �} � .. . .. . - � 1� i� y.� rq t � l}t .�� �"� . ' _ ' ( ` F . /SC � . a S 1�1�� q,�' Y�7 ,,glrf.�� „.�� y� � . �. . ' . .� ? � ' � H 8 r ,� � f.I�,��N� !1 . h '- . , , � . 2�j `'�r "� `�_ h� „{ Pe ,1 f i . 'k . . � . . . . Y ! ' 1� . �' �6 �n e ', ,� x . ���, �`4x�''' ���,}*� t . .� � ' � `4� + . � �:�+,� ,���k.vhy` ..V;� .' ,,r ���m �a*+.t� = t^�^r^�� � f��nee^-n k 'r`?°"��'"",� ' Ar � r��4� �� '��� ri �.:: � �. 4. r� r.a �i�,���' �.l �3+ .7k u , t � 'tv h��f r .. � t�'�.�j'�^v v. .,d 1� i � "�p�c v . �� 4 � 7 �"" � i r. � � . l �. ,�' '�>�'�,'`� n k4 .t �A� '��, 1� 1 { � ��fl.�`� Y� 1 . �.ati�+��t f.v� t iq,y� �L w �� n ' r� , � �4�i. '.,r y ��� '�,.+ . , a������ ,"c�t Y *',"�r +5:�,�.iv� t. A ,�'S '�' i:, `�' f /', �' + � �`' k � t �s['`' .,i .�„ w +, t�: � �p � fi t` v,�of �. ~t f t 7 �I: .. ��+ � � a � K� � 5 �,�,,.'m rr, j��'�t na G�a�' a Aa Z{+�*�'' ��5 1 Y �� � '� ` Y '',�,) 1 � +, Y -Y f�' � �r � �d, �����:,�� ��.i �/� . c '� r � � t£�i� -1 �It��} w a'�`�.�'�r'��L I.. �. ;����.. ��;,�� :;�d c � + F�<. U , �,P �! �..M � '._.�� �$ . wqWw4w� . � �,� ,� � x. e �n e �r '���` f�ag�� 1 � ti : n l nl��, a i ';C .: �ti y. 7 't� , q • r �� ti � +� � 1 n �` i�f r , . � � �r ��r�1 r�{ . a Yt j'�t ��U.k '��N�.�F 4 �J , ?( �,,e� � :..� . ,�" i 1 �. ��lP,� �3 .ti,�°f�� �t�FP.�,��:. �y(��f�,4`�Y /.�'� �� x `q '� � �� ��� � �u� s';�'` ul���' 6 .. t�uR� . � �.Ai � ��4� • � F��� ��• � �LL.k �^ ti , tr v ,- tY . ,� r * ��„ •- � �`T '�l��iR� '�', ��y..ac,H.l� "�� 7 �J �"p���a . �:� . , ' '�r f i�^ T`f \...1�'�� ;��F'r ��R.,y�,`�'���< 5'�. �.Y.,- .#, �T'"Y, ty,� �; , . . ''�•u .,, � .,. � ,. .,. , , .o.. ._..:� .;,... , : • .,.Kr �." ��.-..v,yrowv. . 1;.. ., , .. ,.: �, . . � . •.,... . �-.. u.a. ..:.y«:7o4'rWr-.......... .. - ...., � � ...,._.. _._,,...».�. . . . .: . . . � . .. . . � ,.. . J } . � � � . � � � _, • � � . . . . � - .. . .� . . � . , .. , .. � , . �� . . � , . � ` . � . � . . ,. . � Y" i�. .f-. 1 . . . . . . ' ,. . . . . . . , . � , . :1� . ' . . . . � . , .... ' . . , . � .. . . ... . '1', � . . , .. . . . ... . . . . .. . r . � . . , . , . . � � � � . � � . . . �i � - � � _. , , � . .. .. ..g'r; i...:i �� ... .. . � . .�irae H. , .,... :, .t. �ei�.> . - � . ... �..,. � � ►d r�c��!���r_c.y�.� ������ t����� - R �' .�� 17NG M�NNF-I�AHA AVI"NUC ' � '8 � � �\� ST. PAUL. MINNE50TA 55119 TCI.EPHON6 7�5•,�44 C (,l�rl U/? 7 1 T i 7� /-� (f L l' vl_� L`��/✓ , --- � ' ,� T� �i.�E��'� /_� i �-�.� /� �!� n.J� � �Ci�? Ti���✓ �)f�� �G%/L L�//!/ Lt- L�._SC L� L�LC G` �.S � ,�t"�� %/��:,�',�i✓ : //"u.c'i� 7��L L y .1�U�tJ.v.�L L Ji�s /'%? � �-Z� O N T/>`E �L- L�G ic''/V�i�.'' C� /= L.r./.H' /rC �L.� i� /� /v,� /�J �iv.v�J/.0 .�/,4 .�Uc � � � _ST, f���1 u L� 1 �Lv�) ��/,� �.�� �� /�.�l�C /(/J !�� L�.JCC / i Ui✓ i O /�/S �/�L� �L�SA L . `/�L/Z�� , �� 1 / ��,��=� 1 � 5 � � �� � I����u� .� 7 7 � - �- 3 �. � l�e�e� �,�'�c�d� �,�D e� .� S �' �f I /� , � ���a��,� - �� �� � � �� �� � � . � � � �� � � � �.� �,�- vl�/�' CITY OE ST. PAUL D�PARTMENT OF FINAMCE AND MANAGEMENT S�RVICES . ASSESSMEiVT DlYlSION 113 CITY HAII ST.PAUI,MINNFSOTA 55102 May 26, 3.978 Fil.e X2076, Page Zoning File 8279 Dear eitizen: As a coeLrtesy to you, and as required by law, we want to notify you about a gub�ic hearing which may affect you. The Coune£1 af the City of St. Paul will hold a public hearing in the Cou:tci2 Chambers of the City Hall and Court House (third floor) at I0:00 a.m. on June I5, T978 o�t the: APPE.4L of Mervin Anderson to a declsion of the St. Paul Board of Zoning Appeals regarding the appeals of Matt Morelli for propertq on the southeast corner of East Minnehaha Avenue and White Bear � Avenue a.nd described as: Lots 24 and 25, Block 2, except the r south 208 feet thereof, Robert L. Ware's Eastern Heights Addn. If yo� would Iike further iceformation about this hearin�, contact the Curreat Planaiug Section of the planaing Board, 421 tdabasha Street or telephone 298-4154. While the City Charter requires that we notify you of the hearing, we waat to helg you to learn fully about any improvement that could affect you or yaur ' co�nuaity. Therefore, I sincPrely hope you can attend this hearirg, so that � - you can make pour views ahout it known to the City Coanci2, whether �or or agaiast. J. WILLIAIK DONOPAN VALUATION ANI� ASSESSMENT EIvGINEER . .. . . , , .. �.. � : a-�':. .. � .�. . .. :. .: , ..-. . �,.:�-' � ." ' .� , . . . 3�('�t `f`' ��° ".j .� ,�.., . -, j _ , . . � - . - .. 5ir:�: x � � -,� � � . . . t � f �r ," � i ' � ��� �.! t � 4 t � �t � r y .�_ . : ; , :.. ' � ' 4 � - I' r �d?, - r . . y � � . , � � } � .�� . .l ,lL, } ��.1 `! ' �1 � , .�� � , � j ; q. . � � ��� , .. . ,-�� , .~ ' - • � . ,.: � � , � . > , , , � , � ' . ,� : , „ .. , i, f t V� f i ` :t � � ,, •��,! i �� � � � �; �, { i iq u f 1 + , _ r ` ' ,y, Y3 �� ' �_ . . � . . � - — , �.���� �.� ra;'� � t, � - �., { _ . .. - �l �� ,: ' �i l . ' . _ . . _ . . � # . t `i.; , t _ � i � 3 t -.` . � {� '��� '� . . , ,. � . . � -��. � . . � �f.i: _ 1 ! ` 4.1� �•) � `f'iti . . t . . . . . �. . � �, . .-. , �� . . . Y. 1' f' � ,` . .. \. � � \ J tx[` \ �r {,..r � r j', '# ;� � .��� � i � , j` y ��,�i#I�II��.�;�d�i�, . � �� ' �� t �i � � , � � '" , . i i ���_ � , �_ ��� �- ;/ ���' � ,i '�`���` ,�l�, #�d�g►��st` a.d�►�i o�` 1ri�tt�ag;•��is' � �r`,. 19� �a.�i�!r�' � �� �!�' � . � �!�' � � A�ad.�+�'�to a:d�t3� af. 'r.�,��. lp'�'+� �lo+�d.;:fif ����� �� � ��r e��#',�tatc ���,�or ��F�a���l�a +�,�Iwiw�� �:� �. `;�t���hha�;;��► Y� �' ,' �': . +� �� ' .'� �r'�i�►• �Il1�. �a�+�-i�� �!�tt����i;�• 1N�i�p�.7 � +u� ����.'b� �� , r•' , ,. , ; � � t.� t S J , � ��t` �/ , �I . ��� �- 1 N' .;' ( `K:-: .i t1 '�-1 y.. � y�,{ . !. . .�� ������ _.t ' ! — t f �u- 1 ry \ �t f .,, ; r r � �`a � # '4� + �� i ," ` _ ,, ,(l:ii'�:E�cs�c t � ,�, ,��� r�' �; r� . ) a' < �, ' �• ` i ' �� .s ', t�t: �►�1�;.�t�'1"�� � s � ' � i ,.�� 8i�e�l.� . - -,' , '; �� � .`.' . . r� ' . 1{.:..E t � � '�".:,�9C��1ell,l�f�, _ ' 1 1 �w , � - . , �� ..,. - �t�l1'�.�D1".=O� ,�"�,�t��� ' . ,- , _ , • � � �� ' - �� � � ' ,� d� � • ��� � � . , t ��� / � � , t � i � � _ I � . ' F� ��' o _�(�� I. . � .� _ {�' � .. .� . � i �K� . i ' 1. � ', � 1� �. � � . r,� tl �: . i. � . : ; �, . � , ' .1� ,sY�:.. . .2.�./� � ' � �.. ' � ,' " .. . � . �.. _ .�` �.� ` y � d ��1Y �y, { . f � V. , r K x . , , ' � -- . .-� . J. ..: , �f. , � �.'. . , �r , �. ,,,,� . . . `. .t , .. t P � - �'`- r �I,F � � �, 57F,�ti � � 9��� ��� � � � � � '� ` Y _ "F. � � s t s- �� i i r� ; t ., _ . <t �, � i � ` �- ' ` ��;�v ��ll-�. ... , , . ;� .. , � . . . . .. . . .. .. . . . r*rF...n � '.' , `% � ,� �- � . 9.�3 ,�� -� St. Paul, Minnesota June 2, 1978 CITY CLERK CITY GF ST. I'AUL COURT HOUSE 421 WABASHA STREET ST. PAUL, MIIJNESGTA SUBJECT: Zoning File PrIATT MGRELLI Zoning File No. 8279 I received a letter from Edward J. Warn, Senior City Planner, dated April 7, 1�78, adiaising me there would be a hearin� in the City Council Charabers on Tuesday, April 18, 1978, 3rd floor, Court House. I attended this meeting on this date and did not get much satisfac- tion explaining that I felt this Pizza Parlor should have more �ark- in� spaces, otherwise it would cause a great deal of congestion on. East Minnehaha St. , from White $ear Ave. to Van Dyke St. , as in the past. Copy of letter is attached which I wrote to Ertward J. Warn. I feel that I did not have the opportunity Mr. Morelli and his at- torney had regardin� the seriousness of this street parking. Therefore, I am appealin�; this case and asking for another hearing The Zoning Board said it would be necessary to ha�ge 16 parkingsg�ces but after all the discussions with the Planning Board, Nlr. Morelli and his attorney, they agreed they could get b3T with only 8 parking spaces. If something is not done about this, I am going to take it to Court and demand that they have at least 16 parking spaces. There really should not be PICK-UF SERVICE on this busy street. Very truly yours, �%%�%�RVIN C. APdDERSON 1 22 E. NTinnehaha Ave. St. Paul, I�linnesota 5511g CC: Edward J. Warn CC: Council Me�bers CC: G.Latimer, Mayor CC: ZONING BOARD :�.� x;d..,:..�; K G'1 ,"�� � ' 1 � � - � '] �� .— � :- ,-..' . . .- , > _ � • � _ .° . ; < � . � �.� ���" -. . �; _ . . _ . ; ` , ^ : '' _ �c . _ - . t ', , ... , _ _ . , . - , , , - ,. . . . . � . , , . � . , ����> �.�.��.�.� _ ' £ _ .. - . , . . . � .� ����� R .� �i � � � , . ' � . . . � .�.�'_i��� , ' . . .:. .� - � . . . ; . ... . . . . . . . � , - . . . ...� - '' .. . � , . . � . � �i 'y.:. . �. � ... - .. .. � � � � � � ;-� , Y� ��r� �� _ � ' . i y . ' . , , . � �_..�,_�'�-� � . � ... '� � .' .. ' .. � �X�• . . F r [ N �i ,�e�',�' ������I�II� 5 Y Y . . . " _., � � � � � , ,� �-�-� - ;� ,. _. . . . . ,:.. + . . ..,, ;;c � �� �" . .. . . "' .;;`• � ...� . _ �:- .�..•. - ;,� . � ., _ � � . . .. . . - . � . ,...� � ' ..- '.".` �� .. ;�� . .. .,. , ..,. .. . -.- �, . : _ , . '.. ,. .. ,.,.. �... , . . ..,�-: • .. � a ,. .� • � � . - - ` : . , , , � .; _ « �.-: � � ��' �'���� . 4 -. � t � ' x ', � �M�M�� .�"�t���.'�, �'�,�.�-���� '�.� .i, ti '_- �:� ��� .+�'" ,�' �< �,,{ s �, '�' +�'� �w � � ��` .'� � � �������� _ . _ :�1!�I�i�ll�'�ir �.�� , � , . . � - � , �,, .� ... � ��►�:�i► i�i� �������:� �+�`� : � A y ' . .. a .� _ . � • • . . . �� f - .. �:+il���._�: � f _ •A� S1, �, � a'e � ��r� �-���� � � '.�, �N► �'��-'' "# - . r a . ���:� .��� ���°����� ��R��'F��� . � �S.�, �.t �i t � k _ •�,� �..� �� � ����� , � �� a� r 'X{ , ,;_ .. `c....;-. . �. �y . . .. . . . .. , . � -. :r, .r � . x'. ' ` ' �S i �~�y�•��� �•���� �������� t t . � . � � '.." .. �� � � �. : : : ��. �'�'� �'���� �� �� -� ;'�� � � t 4 ` ' � ' _. J �� . � py �. � � � � •.�. r " � ���,;� ��_.: . . . " t � �. ' � t�. , � �� '�` �'� � �a������ .• '���. �� ����+� �;' ��»� ��.������`.� �fi. �•_ Y � ,� :•���� '���N��,�'� � � ���� _,. , . _. ., _ �.�;������ �{���` �� ' � � ���� �� r�`�_� ,� '!�'.:'� �'� � � �.t�- . _ r � r, , � +�r'� �1�:��'`�N��► � . , '`� .� : . . . �. 4 ' ��:' . . � , . � .. t. g y.:. . - �� � ��� � ��' � a� y _, . � . �:;�a�� �pll������ " ;�.� �'� �t �III� � ;�`"°. . ,�" � �MM��Mr��NN��� � .'� 'Y , � . :��3.` `�r �� � ., �������� � . � �y� � ;; ,.. . . : � - � . .. , _ � .. , .a-� � _ , , . .. , . - �. '< , � � * � -:« . ' �s . � , , : . . . _ , ,. , ;,. �. . : . ., . . E q _ ... . Y' ,�. . .... - ',-.... � . , � .... .: . ...' , . . .:� ....:, �. .�-. -' '�A '.-, �y— q ,fti . . . � � �*!1� . t • � �. . , . , ���� . � � . �. .:t �, .. : . ;�.. " � ' .. . . , :' - i i "ti � � � �rr��� �'' �I�� - * . . � ���� k � '} � t 1 .. � ' ��'.. • "' - . � . '.: � .._ _ ���, ♦. . . �. . �a. � - � . ... •� . ... ... -.. . . - 1�� .�::. -�..... �.. . .� ... . . . . . . . � 4 . , . -` .:.. : .... . . . . . . .'.` . ...r � . � n .. � �. � . . .. .. . . .. . . . . ' . � ..� .. t... �. . f. . . � ` � . ,. ._, ' J e - . .� . � � .. ` � � £B`�� '_t�r � � �+�F Y .� [*� ! ; � . ..•� . ' , .,',. .;. . . . ..... . .. - . � e, -' - ., . ' �.� � ��. .... �. . ' �. e ":A�_' �� .. . � y . . .. �., .. . r .. .. . �:� . . w .. . . �. . .. . . . � � � . a, - ' ' �x ... � '� .� .. :�..� �a. :�� � p�... ..(� '.-��_ . . . . . . , ♦.. - . - �� . _ . . � ... .E . i �o-7 � . .. '`k ' � �- � .. � • . . . . �^ . . .. .1��. ��, P . . . . . � � � . � .. � ' . ' ! . ,, _ . , � . . . .. . . �.�,. . , . � . .. ' • , . � �. � . . • , . ,.', . ' . . . - . , , ;. , � . _`� . I , . . . � � ' ' � , . - � . �� ' ... . .. . ' � . .. . . . � . ' � . . ' . ` �� . , .. . � � . , � � . . . � � .. � . . � � .. ' i . , t r, . ' April l�s.�� .� , � . , , . , . , . �. _. .� .. ,` , � - ' . ` , . � • � , �' • .. . i. . ' � ' � . � . . . . . ' . ' . _ . . . . . . .' ' . . .� .. . � ' ' -_ ' .. _ �•. �� , - � � _ . .... � � .• . . � .,, . � . . ' ... � .. �' . . � . . .. • . . . . . . . • _ ' . . � ., . , . . � - - ,. _ . � ! . ?1r. Prssideat sad ba�orable Ne�bsr� ' . of the,�%ity Covacil � ' � ::aint Paul� �:innesott� . Mr. I'resident � Kodorahle ."brLbars i . - . � . � . . ; -2?.e �.nner�at.s �avera� .Incat�paraLed, curreatly halda , . , . , - On Sale I�.quor I,ice�nes bio. 9k07��isaued to t�em,at 17.8li h. � „ _ - . � t��iimehaha Avenue. - -. � � � . � . � . ?3ecquse�af�`a f'ire� they ,request tt.at Lhis �licenae be . ' . � transferred -to 17 S3 E. �"iibnehaha �veAUe, .and aaY thst a pnblia � . + . • ' . hsQt-ing be schedul'sd as soon as rossible. . •. • . . , �Yery tsulY �rnu'$, . ,. r .� Joseph F. Carchodi - . � ' License I.aspector - . � I . t " � � - ' - . } r , �y. • .a!`i. • , � .. ' . Yra. . °������''r , ,..,,"�„�„� =R,���°'TY °P's;±,,, CITY OF SAINT PAUL '; �� a', OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY ;� �ii'ii1 ii c- �.,� �= SUZANNE E. FLINSCH, CITY ATTORNEY �aa• ` 647 City Hall,Saint Paul,Minnesota 55102 ��"irt�me.... � George Latimer 612-298-5121 Mayor June 29, 1978 Rose Mix City Clerk 386 City Hall BUILDING Dear Ms. Mix: Pursuant to the request of the City Council as expressed by your letter dated June 15, 1978, I have prepared and transmit for the Council' s consideration a resolution denying the appeal of Mervin C. Anderson from the decision of the Board of Zoning Appeals in which the Board of Zoning Appeals had granted the variances requested by Matt Morelli for property located at the southeast corner of East Minnehaha Avenue and White Bear Avenue. You will note that the resolution requires you to transmit a copy of the resolution to Mervin C. Anderson, Matt Morelli, the Zoning Admini- strator, the Planning Commission and the Board of Zoning Appeals. Yours very truly J. GAL As i tant C' y Attorney JJS cg enc . � �,��� �s`N � �`���,y� � :�at� h ��� - . . e.�� � � . � �. . / r '.:��. ��� (�. �� . .. .. r. ��- "�,'� ,C«r.. / !�1 11l�1;�►��.f�/ � �r. .�����.�.-�!4 ''lG,.¢,,.. si�.,l�„ �ic,�.,/�;�r`it�: , . . ]�� . {' r ��. � ���.1��?���.1,� _ , �--� � ,. 4 E , ,• ... � ... '.. ':. 1,]. V' 4 �n .I � • - � . . . . 4..,.� . . .. . ? „ � � '.� .1,%N.l.�NINNI.lMAMA AVI N��f' . . � f! �,�..�"� G ,��,,�j �.,�' .�, tt"� k ,. � � '� _ - EiT. P�A1JL. MIMMe6+.R'ATA :iS311R ��y�,. Tr4cr�HO�vR 7"J�•+loAl.e � �� C�1,����7� 1 r ,,�,, ,� c �� � v�� �,- ,����/ , i ,l ___ . � �� � � �1,�1�..��'- i�s i� ..�� ,it��<� �„✓.� . !�C��� T���.,�f .,,' Y�� ::r'' �� .,c3�.�i,� .�:.•� �- l.�..s��a ,�G►�..c �y �s ,� �. r ' ' ,r�� �ia�;x�:l,v , ��-�,�,��,%��c �y �s'��u,va�c.Ys �'' . t�i? � .-�.� U/�! T/�� .:5�:' t�'��n�iv�:i:-� �? /_ � �' ,ti' � �F� �/��� �C f� /C'. .�� �V i� .�// /f'"�/�i�l�/�I�i� /�f/ ��l�C' � . . . � � . � �, � .. � � ' � � � . . � � I � � � � .. �► � �SST�• f�.n7uG.� 1 (Lr1,�� /�,��,��. v /��G�'� /(/,;� � . ,�` - � ; ' .,;l� l.�J tt� i. a,r�1 � Q %N�;� /�/r'� �'�ts.c� .c. � k r. ' � ����� � �CI ' ��iV L�7S • �i�0 � �G r ` D '" 5 ,�„"i/ t L�se.+4` "�° '�,� �i�'- ti13`S� �� -� ��S 7 �,'7',tJ.. ��'°x/, '.� _ , �; �-. �;:',......._..,�:, - ,. _ _ k �1/L.�J �.e�c--►�../ (:�c-t,-�..u'c- . °��(�-a � o$ .� � �'�' � � .. � :� � ,� : ,�, ��...r.,..._______.___.�, ._....___...__..._. _._��._..__.__.__w_._��,..__ __._. .._. P� :' . . . � . � , .. . .., . � .. � . ... l '� �!� �� � - �. . .. . . . . Yh_ _—_ ___—_ _ _ — . �.sro� ��»n—r...�.f«�1�+�—m.��. — .. � .�.�.�-•���. .. ../�; . - . � . � . :-.5 ' , . . .. . . . . � . .t� . . . „ . , ' .. �.,�.�, . . . . :y y. 'r;� � ,.�. . . .. , ,,; .}'� . . - � , . . . . ..�, . .. .. : . . . �.':'�' � : ,, ' : . . :�N ^. . . .. . � .. j',.�,,.'.;.. '. .. � � . �!'N ,-Y � - . ¢r� . . . . . . . r�F �� � � � . ., . . . ..f���.`.' � ' ' � iE' ' ,�� + � � . � .:•)?' J� i � ;,A:.. .. . . . ,,ry . ��. . . . ry . � . � `..��i,;" . . -- �� ZONING FILE ���� . �::�.: :�:. �-� ,,�N . .� �� � . � .. , , I s,, ., , , . , .. � 1'�t�S' r��,. _ �.^ �^ ,�+k r. .'e , ;t.. ;' . �'� ,��/C.0 s% i�� !i �i,:.G�.rw., ; r�� � „� � ' � � , � . , Y � I��,:1�,1�!1�r.1.��. ;� � l?�� C.,��"�.1!� .��. ��.�:r��U�>,�c . . : . _. . . . . , �� �INt��M���Nl.�1,Afan�N�if�,����1: � ., � . � . � � �. ; laT. 1'AUL. M1NN�SL?TA �•ta114� . ; .�; _ TCt r,i�►+aNF 7:�lS,w��4 ' � � '' . / �' �.(�`� G'i'� 1 � � � �� � � i.� _l U i� �; ,."��/t�� ] � • w _T"�� i,/�E',.'� ,.� i ,-�� /t �"<• �.,,✓.:; ;,.,,f����� i;-.-. ,✓ ;�_ .,'I �3c;�« ,�„� 4= . �f. ��=,� `%�:�� �- �y ��Y :? ) r , /t� �J f/,li',(:'.�.✓ � f / c>�c'�) )/-�L L Y _�TC.?/U;2/�i�L 1�_'; " " _ / i;..� :r_ �.�-� ���'V %i�!f` ._ >!_:� � �����-i�;���.? c.;� ;._ �-c./H /I�C L��" f-7 ic' /�' �V.� //J ;�ii�it�� //.4} fi,�� ,,;7�%'c ..:?�, f/�L1!� ..� ��l.��:=_� /�.�.�.� �./ /_ 'i� /�/=7//c � _ _ ,�. � ic�� !� l�.,J C G %� !✓it/� i �7 1..�-1/_5 �/t [� �G�:S<-� [,L .� ����, .� s _ ____ _,.. ...__ ... ��lll� : ,1� v/� k,�L.�.� J'!-I c �v i� � f�� r:� ,. U�.��,vc. �� /�r'oi'.' [.'�� /1�?i�� � % —»-' -- -- .._..�.....__. � _..�_ c:;✓ . � --� t �GCr�:�'L.r ,, , l.� �., ._ � ��; C�-. �.0�-�c ,. /�� , �.� c. � � � � .� . —� �.�_ �..�..�� �� � �°�. ..-�'.� 1'`��_ ; --.---�..r_________,____r_ ,� � . , � r— — _—___..�._.....__...._..............____ , 1 _..._.�._........_.....__......-..._ i iI � � 1` [ � � a2 j � ����f ���� . � . 1: .,:a=!y�'�'b� - � r,�ti 1 ..i '�� � .,. } � � � �p`��� �' .y' .'�. 1r. .. '"� _ ..._-�--'--r'. �(��= t . : .. - . � � . . � � �, � P�..:. ,,,...,��__r....._....«_^-•�__.- .... .. ..-._.,,,..,.__...,.,.._.. . ....,........ . L.m..w..._........_.... ._. ........'... . . .—.--..... .�..,.r, , . . ,. �;. � . . : . . . ' � . .. . . . . . _ . .. . . . . . . . . . ".��. r.� �� w • ' � ' � ��4 G �t JL:f' �1...�Q /� 1 � . ?`: ` � ' � ��C�N���'±�.1��'.S � ��,.�11 f�1�1��1� / +` ' . : `t'� , " , .. . . . . , ..1/(IG MI��N/�IIANA AVF�N�if � .. . . . ,'�"rF��'l�•��iw�.Y1►.•�',�„� ..(Y. 6T. f:AUI,. MINNE6�lTA f;!i/19 TC�.e_PHaNC 7:1li•�AfA44 l L'lJr-�G'r17 1 7' ��?� i� ( lj.�" t�tyT4=, ,��/�/ � .�f' �%�1E'i�t-" /.s i.a ��,�- � . �; , � � � • _ /� c�< <;i✓ .f�'G��_ Ti�.�..✓ ..- _:;r .'� .�3�i� v�.� � t:�.:��i� vc..��.y l�.s�.�� �C��i���.E'.-ln� ; ��_o,�;� ��'-�c �y �fUfu,v.��� y'� � t�i.� � ,a.� c�it/ T�E' ��-� �<c,�'�v�.� v �" �. G+J�/ /TC .�.?'�.�7 i�' '� �v,� /l� i i�/Ju�-,�/.0 .�r'.� .��'/�'c , , � .5r-. ��c��� .1 " (�v�� !�i u ,,. � �� /�:q fi�` �u,� ��; ;!� t�J tC 1�. �.n�/ Q 1.��s /`�/'�.�:�'Us.a � : ' (I r�k��r . � � �p `° � � �j G C ' C7u.JNr�D �;�U,�r��Rf � C oiran� ��Y r� : � y �',l/ ,�/ �� : j - - ,vD o . , _ ./� .���- :r��.� c:. ��NN�:r��N� � �"=-� -- 3 t _ �1 ;� �,p.:3�'�.. 3 .� �io j _ . ..��� ,7�.� � ,,,�r � .t, ��o � , /I/�1 � ,�,�.�.x.� ,�s-,3i� — � �.��y�s �,�, ..���� �� � � �' ��r,C �.-2.�t�� � 7�} -l�7`%� �•� �i�/,�� �3S-C Aao �6��'c7: � � # , ,.� . ,�� ��c, � y, � ' jS� �� v 1 4 '� � �`�P� ���. ���t C � . `�� ` _ .�f�' /�� �� U. . �-�1 1.�s� �►�' � � _ � , . ...�..�.__--_.---�--�-- .,R . * ��� ` '�,.� �:�� ��:,� � �:�� � 8�� ��� � :w ; �',. 'A ..,._, _,..�._ __ .. _ --�..�..:,:w�---"'" « ���{� . . . , . � .. i....�q�.,�r-swr�}MIyM+V..irw.... . . . . . �. . . . i. � ., . . 4.. ��5.. .,�.. � � � . . . ' . , ... ' . �� 7i. ' . � .. . u . . . ' . � . . � , : . . , ' r . . . , . ,, . , . . . . . f;,,� , i� 1 ` � ,'' , � � y...� / ' � �.. �st . �����l.c.� .� � c�.,� ����� � ��q. ,� , � �t.� �, - . . . .. . . � .� 1 NP�G��MINNP.".HAHw_AvL NIJC . . � ' � '�4��Gs"„•+': ,��G�.q�,.� . ,. bT. PAU6.. MINME50TA �5ti1}B ' i j . , I i . , . . . . �. � ' . .1��4,RPNONR''�7iils�.ylti414 . . . , , .. . . .��. �,..' ' C L.Ur�G�i l ] 1 T� �7� �.1 � - �, � 1 t , �j C'�v I� L.- c /t/� , ' , , , , , , : l.._ �.._�, � � ' � . r� f,��,:?� �_5 � A��- �:�;�• «,��, » ' � /-�GC� Ti�.�.,,./ � `.l�- .,� ,.C�G.'/�G �.��i✓ cr l_/ S�t'� ' .�G� '�'wc=G�/ /�,�".e1 ,, , :� �C C� is�t,�.�':1i✓ i � /"U�C�> >i�� ��s/ ����u.v.�� � .�� , � . i�i.2 � .�.� C��1/ �%�E .:���" �''C�iv�r�� U /-- ���� �r� �'�.� ,� ,%a ��,� ��� ,��.�,�,��,� ,�,� �-��� : . , . . � S7': �.�,��✓L� �,rL �Lc%;,� l.r/.���c t) � /�.�l�,� .. 1��� LJ C.7J�C� I'�i Qn/ D ' J/�/�,.5 ��[� �'DS� L . ; �/�u�s , ' . � ��fDI�L ' H��� • ., . t � DG�N C �'� ,f' . .�J/�"/I1�N� � _ � �� -'�/j c _ :y? �, ,f.. 4:.�,;�,.�, C-3.�....�.�.. ���;C:�1��i�" ;�.,�.,•`.,.K,,.,�.�,,� <�2cc �.�' Pk'L'i ,.�L: .�'�� ��,�"; C;., j..� �,:>,n,., ,,., �.,.1��..,x�.►.� �a� �'C ` �y � R s �,� v��t �..� , tnc��� � ��'-c�'' >- /f i y ��'�►r�t. c��n���,�,; �2 3 _._._.__�_�__._.._._....._._.__ - . . . .. , ��v rrl �.: 1 �i�S 1`�1'h�l,a �� � � '-j r �`�. �,►a���c.�,"`' r ., : ..r, . , _ .._M_____... ..__-_._.__._.__... ..� ."�,�e� �,� ��`'1..:.-�c- t'�;:�c fo�,�� � �' � �/ �'� �'ls::� ����:�.�-1 r._..,L !'?`f;� i�o r�tn.:,-�'.ch 1z c:r .� ���`I � ': Il,j, 1,' c(--.• � � i ... i. [ C'.l. c� L�t � " �� ��P L .��a.�� �" - 1 .t �>� L , `` -- __.—;_- ._. . : __ F��.E �Sa _ � ���iI�C� . ,}� _ .� .� - ; , �.r�� . _�_..�,�,�....- i §� i. � � . .. �� . � . / ; t,,�l • � t"; i j , s'' � j . 4�►«' �� C4 J�J-4�'-�C.• � �� . *N �� � ���'�(�`!�►�..�.'��� ���'�7�,, �, ,� .�."� + •F �,. `�':r � ` �� ��.� � � �� � � `�� � � Yr � �.f}a + `.: � ��� `. ,a1 7* i Yi. J� '4 . � . � � . ;. r aaL�' ��t +� � y�'nf , , 17fl!C: MIh{N���MMN I�}�.V�wi�B ' _� i �L..� .c x n § � �Y f.T. t'iA►t�.lL. MINN�.'6�?T�1 [iC.71�1Q � �„�. �����; ,,. r Tc�cv►+�aNR'��!�•�Ao�w �,� �h ��,¢":. � ,� : �, �j r;a ry; . x" i r. ' � . ,�,� ,• 4 /cl �r�G';1 ]� 1� T :'7 7 �( ' t� f��,[= �c��✓ ` ,'���`� 4� �;f t �� . . . . . . .�.� . .. � -�^+.v.'.t• t�y }�''��'- . 4��k ,,,f� � �fy�/�aL /.'� � /�� ,/-.�r�iL�l' !,..!�✓� / � �/5�/ / �.�w� . l . � � .,., : . � ��! I�:.�J4/ . �L . y f t '.(x 't :if ,.`� ,L�cr✓'/L !.�//✓ � l,(..,'�C f'� •���'L�`L� /�.S ,f7 M , , J � / , . ,7 �� � �+` ��� /./�A �l A�'�w'�!✓/ / �r!»J/C /� ��X� �y 1'� uc , t, G�/L:V.aL L .Y'S ' '`' , �9 � � 1 �/ ,.�^- �^ ,r^ � / . a �; j j,� ,� !!'.�. �..I^�.�.1 �/L/. !,f�1F. . ..�'J L" L�. . /r/.V�L /ti � (� / � '� / t s ; �k ,�l.�//-� /l� .C3��::� i� /�.lV..> � 7 i.k1/.�z/,�4-.�/.0 �/,r� ..'�G'c= �?. <r ; , . , � � � :��.' . i'.r�G,�L..� ,,,,� ��[/r� � �r.�t t� ,✓�/�,�/�% /�,J � y , y �� �. ��.�i r"c r, ,o..�./ � �.�"'�,��.s '.t�ic�'v �'r�s,q ,�. . ';. � + � / �i � .�� , �� ..� . . ' .�/\ 4!��J - . . k���fA�� ,.�� � Q 4�,��.1�s : ,�.�c��v�R' ��,� . � � � . OGUi1l�l3 �� o f' ,� _y. b „.. ,,.... . .. . .. .. . � � . . . . c`'�`''/ ��7�C� ' i�. � � .�'`,d. ?o�Gu ' .�� �3 ,"-���'y y g �',� ,.�„ . °�; � � � � ;.� _ _ � ��;,,,� ('' �.�� � i Y ,�.�.�.,,�!�.'.�..�..... '�",�s=a���� , 'J��� ::�-��,. -x� . _ ��� ; �, .. , , _,..� . �_ . �.F„ti,-'f-LrrL.:t�..P' �, ������l� '�,/�':" f� �", �C..,qt� f�L� .�.;�i(. �.,�.'a:�., /,�.Z,�_� v�/ "`---' --�--- .. ,� � t,.a.�,..�� ,t ' J[Q� `� r .?d . G ;� ,. � . , ,. " �/ � . . . , . . . . . ��.. . . , ._ . � .. ,� 5 ... . ' . . ... . .. . �.��+,� �.. . . . . . . .f..�...+».�,.,,�, . �.... � . . . . � � . �.. »._.... ..._.......,. . . . . . . . � . . .........�.., 1 . :�� ' � . . .� ........,.... .. . .... .. ... ���,-�_, . ' . . � . . . . . . :?.�i � . . .� - . . .. . . � � . . .j.� . . . ' . . , . . S� I� . . . , "'"'s'�"^�'�..�.-+.. .�........_.�.. .. - . . . -.�..... ...._...._._...�...�........ ... �, . . . . _,..__...._«........ . .. -.,..: ....,._ .....�._...__.""_ a, -....� ••-----•-----.•-.-�.___._ �,,`-.;. .4 .. � 4. :•. " � . .. .. . . . ��.� �' � . � � . .. � � . 4 ' . . . .. . . � , �". . � �/5,.. ' . . , � � � • S , �, . � � � . . . ' . .. � . y . s R f� � y:.� : .. . . . . . . . ��,(. �. . . • . . �'h . , � � . . . . . ' . , 4 '.:,':' . . � . , iZ+"'.. , �w,` �:: ' . ��,A� � � ;t. • ;¢.��_ ',.F; . . }�s. g,;�'` ,;�k �� �; ' r�`; • � ��r � �: , � . � �, ' , ���� �� F��,� �; ti..,..�..._-�..._.... _ .a.�....�.......�.�� i h l 4/ �,��,fr o_ � � " ' '� , ' . + . �� . . . . . . . . . . . . �� � ��a� � �� �.; ������ � � �e�a9o. . .e`.�� a�ea���� ,, ��.���f . . . . . . . . . . . . . d . p. . . . . •�•r:���:n r� �ir, ,s- � . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . �, p. �,�.�- -� . � � � ��i' ' : �� ��� � �� a�� �� � t �� ������ ' � ��e �S � � l��e��� �.��� '' • � • • • • • Y � ♦ • • • • • • � • • • • • • • • • � • ( � , , ...r.����� �. . .`1 C� 37t?'3'�1!�T�':. �Pl�� • • • • • ^• • • • •� • •�i i • � • �� . •�• • .��.���� • �� .�. . .�� .� R�.. ��M������ : __. _ , ,�i�����m� ��. � ���r� � � . . . . . . . ._.. . .��. .� . y �.r VY�I�;V'i� � • ��/ • � �I ' �����Y� Y� �i: � . . �r. , L �as�� ��� ,r�r-�,. �r � . . . . . . . . '� c nn r .^ n � .� rn +� -�. l�G�O o0 . . . . . �q��. .` �•�'rr. . . .������-�� -� . . . . . . .�^ �; � .,., M . � � �ql�iG��� � .�a[����r����Mr �,�R� �O�C�� �e �������i� �l����� 16� 4 �� � . . . . • • • • . • • . . • . • • . . . . . . . . . . . . . • . . . . . ����������r i��sr LI��� :��I . . . � � . . . . . . . �. . . .� � � •�. . . . . • Y • • • • • • • • • • �I��������� �� • 00 � . . . ;. . . .� � ����� s� �o� a� � � . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . �c i�����d� �� � r . :n�.�.� :u� 00 0� � . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . q . . . . . . . . . . . . .� . . �.�. � . q�qQ������M � � • -.1 c`� . ppA� . . . . . . . . . . . . . . i�i����A�d� � � - . . . . . . . . . . . r. . � ` N :��T::�'.�' :l�l.� � �� • ��..d���Li��L�. . ���� ' ������ � . . . . . . . . . .. . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . � . . . .���• �r� . � . . . . � . . . . . . . . . . . . .�,. . . �. .� . . . . .i . . . . . . . -. � � ���. . . . . . . . . .� � . . . . �.:9:►::� ��:��'�:� / � �� �[�; • � � w •�� •• • • u • • • � � • �' �• • • • •-������� • • • • ♦ • • • ���� � � ��,� ' • • • • � • • • • • • • • • � ����� � �� � � Y • • � • • • • � • .• • • � • • • • • � • • � ����� • • • • • • • • • • • • • � � Y rI�1�� �.. �. _ M • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • / • • • • � • • • • • • • • • .• • \ • • • • • •' • • w � ! • • • • • • • • • � • • • • • • • • ���.,., �I �-��• • • • M • • • • • • • Y • • • • p �• • • • • • • • • • • • • + � , Vr � .� • • • • • • •~ • • • • • • • • • • • • •� • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • � e • • • • • • • • • • � • . • . . • f . . ., . . . .y . . . . . . . . . �.�.. . . . .�y�y , . / 7��/:1 � • I � � . � �. . .Jr. .� .�. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . � �i • . � ���� � ���� � . . .. . o . . . . � . . . . � . . . . . .��.'i— r��� � . . . . . � . . . . . . . . �`, . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . � . . . . .. . ,.r . ������ �� . . . .� . . . . , . . . . . . . . � � . , .�•T�T,�r'L� _ . - ,. . . . . . . . . . . . ��� . . . . . . � . . . • � ' - . . �'����, - - w�_. � . . _ �iN�lt � �111� � � . - . , - � � � • � : � � . - � � � � � � � �//�/. ' • � . � � � � . � � • � - � � � �. • � � • ' � • ' • � � ' • • � � � ' : • � � � � � _ � • � � C . • � � • 1�7�/�—AfRd�vit of S�rria!� M�il. (��vb�d H72) ��ADY-MARCUUS CO. ST.►AUL,MINN. a ` ��a�c of �innc�ora, -- ss. cou���y o/ ..._..Ram��y . ...___._ ' • ponna McNeal Ty 6e:ng �rst duly sworn, deposes and says ...- -��-�......... .....•-------�-� -.. ......_ ---- -- --- -----.._. ........ _ - - --...... ............. � -- -.-.....------.......-- that on._...--••----------------M�y-.18--.--..... , 19......7..8, .......She served the attached.-.---.-1"eSO�Ut�Ot1 - ---•-----•-•-•-----------••---•----------•-----�---------------------••- _._...-�.............................. � -_ __ -. � -- -... _upor� - -------.Matt..Morel l i .... - ----��---_....-�------•....................�-----�-•--•-••---••---------------------._........... attorneY�-- lor........... . ...._- ._ ...._ __ _ _ - - -- ..... _. ... - -�- �- -- ....__.........- ...-------�- --------��-�--�--�------------...-------------�-bY placing a true and eo�reet eopy thereof in an enaelope addressed as follows: Matt Morelli , 418 Johnson Pkwy, St Paul , MN 55106 (which is the last known add�ess oJ said attorney) and depositing the same, with postage prepaid, in the United States mails ae---�---�--� - �--��---.......St._Paul- --� - ------ - �-- -- -, Minnesota. Su6scribed ond sworn to beJore me this... .1_8th_.._ ._ . s��� doy,q�. - �---,�............ .......MaY.. - --> >s....78. ---- �-� -- - --f - - -......�....!!.!rc�...._. - ------------•-�-------�- --•---------- � N�AAA�A6►�i,�AAAAAAAA�i�AAAilAAAA� �+� �U�OIE A. rOX � 3 ..�';; Ndlft��Y NUBIIG hii;J:+E;,;,l<< � • . � '�ll�� haMSEV COUN�y , s �y�nmm ti:on Expi�P< ,,., ,� A •--..........--- --.....-•--•---•-••--�-•- •• -•............. ............ ••-••----- NOZCfy Iii'I � k�rv w'b'd'v�W tl'�a�wd�b�r�r��wn�tl'G`�G\�v�w�V G�GG'!�Y"kt ,e�n?-. — ----- _ ... .an city of saint paul board of zoning appeals resolution zoning file number 8279 (��te May 16, ]978 WHCREAS, Mat�t Morelli has applied for a variance from the strict application of the provisions of Sections 61 .103(a) and 62.103(m)(3)(e) of the Saint Paul Legislative Code pertaining to building setback and parking requirements in a B-2 zoning district; and WHEREAS, the Saint Paul Board of Zoning Appeals conducted a public hearing on April 18, 1978 pursuant to said appeal in accordance with the requirements of Section 64.203a of the Legislative Code; and WHEREAS, the Saint Paul Board of Zoning Appeals, based upon evidence presented at the public hearing, as substantially reflected in the minutes attached hereto as Exhibit A, made the following findings of fact: l . Strict application of the regulations would result in peculiar or practical difficulties, or exceptional undue hardship to the owner by reason of the exceptional narrowness of the property. 2. Granting the variance could be done without substantial detriment to the public good and wit.hout impairing the intenc of the Ordinance. 3. Granting the variance would not impair an adequate supply of light and air to adjacent property. 4. The request is not based primarily on a desire to increase the value or income potential of the property. NOW, TNEREFORE, BE IT RESOLUED by the Saint Paul Board of Zoning Appeals that the provisions of Section 61 .103(a) be hereby varied by 21 feet to allow construction of a new restaurant, Section 61 .103(a) be hereby varied by 30 feet to allow construction of off-street parking adjacent to the property line, and Section 62.103(m)(3)(e) by hereby varied by 8 parking spaces, in accordance with the application for variance (Exhibit B) attached hereto. moved by Peterson Decislons of the Board of Zoning seco nded b Benshoof Appeals are final subject to appeal �/ _ to the City Council within 30 days ! in favor _ .�` � by anyone affected by the decision. � against �_