Loading...
271438 WHI7E - CITV CLERK [�►►►���.+++��� g PINK - FINANCE GITY OF SAINT PAITL COUIICII ���1^�M� CANARY - DEPARTMENT - BLUE - MAVOR File NO. ncil Resolution . Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date BE IT RESOLVED, That the Council of the City of Saint Paul hereby ratifies and approves the action of the City of Saint Paul Board of Appeals and Review pertaining to the following listed property, as shown by the Excerpted Minutes of said Board of Appeals and Review dated June 13, 1978, attached hereto as EXHIBIT A, and by reference made a part hereof: DATE OF BOARD MINUTES CASE NO. PROPERTY APPELLANT 6/13/78 18-78-H 24 South St. Albans Ronald D. Soderberg Street (seven units) BOARD ACTION: Pursuant to Section 55.02 .(b) of the St. Paul Legis- lative Code, granted variance of Section 54.13 (g) to permit occupancy with the existing windows of one dwelling unit partially below grade wherein the sill height of such windows is 51 inches above the floor. Property Description: Summit Park Addition S 110 Ft. of Lots 12 and 13, Block 1 and, be it FURTHER RESOLVED, That the City Clerk is hereby authorized and directed to transmit a copy of this resolution for recording to the Ramsey County Recorder. COUIVCILMEN Requested by Department of: Yeas Nays � Butler ►�� In Favor Hunt � L�evine M�� - � __ Against BY — ShowdbC Tb� Adopted by Council: Date JUL � � �g7g Form Approved by City Attorney Certified as' y Council eta BY By ' Appr :Vlayoc Date — �(,�L � 4 ���� Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council gy, — By RUBLISHED JUL ZZ ���� . � � 1 �3 � � � STAT� OF MINNFSOTA 1 t-� t� Cow�,ty o� Ramaey ) aa. � CITy OF SAINT PAUL ) � Rose Mix . . .. �� I, � . ..• • ... .. ��.• •..• • .. • � �• •. • • .• •. .. ..Cc�'.� :'� � o� #he C.i,ty o� Sa.i.n.t Pa.u,C, M.i.nne,�o�a, da heneb y cent,i.�y �'ha� � 271438 _,A � I ha.ve corrq�a�ced �'he a�.tuched copy o� Caunc,i.e F.i.ee No.. .. . ,,, � �` � a.a a.dop�ed 6y �he Ci.ty Couxc,i.Z JulY. 13:. . . 19.78. ::�,u .. . . ... . . . .. .. U� Zo and appnoved by fihe Mayon .. .... . . .. .. . July. 14:. .. .. .. . 19. ?$. ��� �'6 �" �' w�i.th �he on,i,g�.na,� �'heh.eo� on �.i,Ce �.n my o��.i.ce. "'� J � ... ... .. .. .. . .. . . . .. . . •. .. . . .. ... . .. . . . . . . . . . .. . •. . . . . . . . . . . .. . �. . . . . � . . . . . . .. . . . � • . . .. • . . . .. . .. ... . . . .. . � .. .. . . . . . . . . ... . . .. .. . • . . . . .. . . . . . � . .. . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . .. . . . . . .... . .. . . . . . . .. . .. . . . .. .. . • . . . . .. . . .•.• . . . .. • .. . . .. . . .. . . . .. . . . .. . .. . . . . . . . . . .. . .. ... • .. . . . . . • . . .•. • . .. . . • .. . . •. . . .. . . . . . . .. .. . . . . . . . . . . . . • . . . .w• . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . •• . .. .. . .. . . . .. . .. .. . .. . .. . . . . . .. _ .. . . . . . . . . . . . .. .. . . . . .. . . . .. . .. . . . .. .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. .. . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. • . .. . . . . . ... . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . .. . .. . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . .. .. .. . .. . .. . . . . . . . . . •. . . . . • . . • . . .. . . .. . . .. . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . I �u�r,the�c eelr.t,i.�y �h.cr,t ea,i.d capy ,i,a a �c.ue and cafvr.ec.t eop� y o� d cci.d an,i,g.i.na.e and �he who.�e �'heJceo�. � � ' � WITN�SS my hand and �'he a ea.0 o� zh.e Ci�y o� Scu.wt Pa.u,C, � ���- � � � � 24th . , . �`�`� � Minn. �h,i.6 . .. . . . . . . day a� J .Y.. . . . . .. . .A.�. 19. .$. . ��� , ; ,���,� � ul 7 •..�.... .,; - �-- ,. '1 G��- .�� . .. .. .. .. . . ... . .... . .. . . .. .. .... . . . . . . . � �. i v" � L � , , F 'v � ' n� ' 'i , ,��_ti � � , �. � � � � � c � � � _ � � � � ` p � � �: � �� 9 LN U � ,• , � KG, N *' � � �t_. i'�. + C C f�"� Q ,4 �t,i R�" / P � N ��� � .. �� .0 U g � v �'.,2 , a ` Ll I � C` m � w fS3 11 t^ ��� `/ � ,,� O ' � �,,:� 'ti V O '� 0 � N Y C � �� T"{ � '� i � r°�-. p -o l:� �� Q< '_ � oC � c °� �w :W . � � �; � v— Z7 p .t�.+ � `� ♦�; O N � �� >, "'1 � z `�� • � �.i w � F z � O � D � ` �' U �� � � Fz � � � � � � o � :� r � � m .s � o o� � N �, � .. � �- � , u; �.,, .� o -� �' �, � _ / � o � o a� rn � -o � V cn = a� .--i Rs ... F-- a v "� � N O G� e> c� A ` N� Q � � OC � L'il'_ C� - -- - � �' ., : -_; z z �nr o3HSnana .._ :�� �g - .tg ii�uno� ol uoissiwqns �o; �oeSeW �Sq pano�ddy �`�` � ` -1f1i` aled :�one�� .� > >ddy ��� tg ,�g , ela (��uao�j�.C� �tir. p�iJil�a� �Sau�oa�F! �;�� �9 Pano�ddy wio3 a�eQ :�►�unoJ .�y paidoptl . e,c�t £ t �nr �•t ,�,��g ,�a ;su�e�d - xo�QM - � WM� . 3unH Jone3 ui � �aoH �a�ng s.Ce N sea,� :30 �uaw>>edaQ �Cq pa�sanbag N�W�IJNf10� ' •�ap.zo�ag �C�uno� �asu� ac� o� buip.zooa.z .zo� uoz�nTosa.z si� �o �do� � �.iuisu��� o� pa��aiTp puE pazi�ou�nE �qa.zau si x.zat� d�i� aq� ��qs 'Q�A'IOS� 2i�HS2III3 . �i aq 'pu� � t x�oTS '£T PuE ZT s�o'I 30 '�3 Ott S uoi�ipprd X�pd �T�S :uoi� t.z�saQ ��a o�a •�ooj� au� anoq� sau�ui TS si sr�opuzr� q�ns �o �ubiaq Ttis ar.� u-raaaqM apE�b MOjaQ �CjjEt�.I2CT �TLI[l buiTZaMp auo �o SMOptITM bui�sixa aLj'� [�TM �I�utdn��o �iuuad o� (b) £Z•�S uoi��ag �o aouei�En pa�uE�zb 'apo� ant�ET -sibaZ TnEd '�S a� �o (Q)� ZO'SS uoi�.�ag o� �u�ns�nd =NOIS��i �iOg � (s�iun uanas) �aa��g b�zaq�apog •Q pt2uog sttQqT� •�g �nog �iZ H-8L-8T 8L/£t/9 s�azz�aa�a asx�aoxa •ort �s� s�snHiw Q2i�dOS 30 �S�'Q :�oa�au ���d Q ap�iu a�ua.za�aa �q pu� '� ylgl�� sE o�a�au paq���.�.� '8L6T •'6T aunr pa�Qp Maina� pu2 stEadd� �o p.zQOg pt�s �o sa�nuiy,i pa�d.za�x� ac� �q uMOus s� '��aado.zd pa�sij butMOTjo� a� o� buiuis�.zad Mainag pu� st2add� 3o p.z�og jnEa �ui2g �o �I�t� .a� �o uoi��� au� sano�dd� pu� sai�i�E� �iqa�aq � ZnEa �u-rEg �o �I�i� a� �o Tz�uno� a�. �EuS 'Q�A'IOS32i SI �S � � � n a;ea 6g aa�iTwwo� �o ;np (�, � �) aiea :aa�i►mwo� oZ pa»a�a� �(g pa�uasa�d . � uoz�n1osa� 1i�u ���M� •QN iJ nio3 zn��� .L� Ids '�� �.Lj � a�t3a - iNawia�+ j, � • 3�NVNi��- HH3l� All� - , " 6/13/78 - �Ieeting Mo. I41 MINUTES OF THE �1EETING ST. PAUL BOARD OF APPF.ALS Ai�D RE�TIEW Tuesday, June 13, 1978 City Council Committee Raom 7Q7 • City Hall and Court House - 1 : 30 p .m. MEMBERS PRESENT: Arthur Tieso, Acting Chairman Ron Glassman Estyr Peake David Heider MEMBERS ABSENT: D. D. Wozniak, Chairman LeRoy Coleman James Voigt AGENCIES PRESENT: Department of Community Serviees - Division of Housing and Bu�l 1ng Code Enforcement: Alice Bi j j ani Arnie Beyer Gerald Kern City Attorney' s Office Robert Straughn St . Paul Bureau of Environmental Health William McCausland OTHERS PRESENT: Bill Fabec Curtis M. Lilleboe Kenne th An de rs on Frank Hughes STAFF PRESENT : Patricia Mo�cness The meeting was called to order at 1 : 50 p.m. by Acting Chairman Tieso . The minutes of the meeting of May 9 , 1978, were approved as mailed out to the Board members . Chairman Tieso called attention to the response of the Mayor to the Board' s inc{uiry regarding rehabilitation funding sources for non-owner- occupied apartment buildings . It was noted that a program tiaas being prepared for this type of project, with a target date sometime after October of 1978, under the federal 312 program. In his letter, the Nlayor said the city had a non-owner occupied reh�.b program funded with federal Community Development funds in the past , but it had not EXl4!l3/T 1 � '—"" - - 6/13/7 8 - Me����� 2'4 l, . ectively used, probably due to too stringent ui . e suggested that t e some ' or the Rehab Advisory Committee meetinas ' a e ln e ue which will d ure policy . No action was taken on this suggestion . C�SE �10. PROPER`FY �PPELLANT 18- 78-H 24 So . St . Albans Ronald D. Soderberg (6 condominiums - one • apartment) SUBJECT: Rec{uest waiver of St. Paul Legislative Code, Section 54. 13 (g) , so as to permit occup ancy of unit more than 50% below grade, because of fin ancial considerations . APPEARANCE : Bill Fabec PROCEEDINGS : Mr. Fabec stated that Mr. Soderberg had purchased the property a out a year ago and had completely renovated the b uildin g, creatin g six condominium units and one basement apartment . To make ownership feasible , the owners ' association owned the basement apart- ment, using the rental income to defray building maintenance costs . The apartment was up to code in every way except for the windows , which were three inches too high from the floar to comply with code . Inspector Arnie Beyer said that his department had no objection to the granting of a variance on this requirement. BOARD ACTION: Mr. Glassman moved that a variance be granted on the requirement in Chapter 54 . 13 (g) , pertaining to window height in base- ment occupancies. Chairman Tieso seconded. MOTION CARRIED AND SO ORDERED. THF VOTE : Ayes - 4 Nayes - 0 Abstentions - 0 ,,. N0. PROPERTY APPELLA'�T 19- 78-H 473 Wabasha Kenneth Anderso 13 units) SUBJECT: Request waiver of Health Depa ent rest ' ctions on occup ancy of Rooms A and #2 , pertaining to nat ight rec{uirements , because city building inspector and fire rs both had approved occupancy. Inabzlity to rent units would nstztute - ancial hardship. APPEARANCE : Kenneth rson PROCEEDINGS : M Anderson said there were four apartmen whose source of natural 1 ' t was derived from a skylight at the top of an djacent air shaf two on the third floor and two on the second. It was e t�ao u ' s on second which the Health Department found, in their opin t e lacking in adequate na�ural light, although the building inspector . , „ _ . _ . - , a . . , , : - . —�:MZ . � , �.. ; , _ . . - _ . . . . ' � ���.�,��� .� 4 �1�� . .,. �.. ,�� � ' �� � . .'. i ' . . . . � . . .. .. � .. . . ,. . .� .. . . .. �_ i . I . . . . . . . � •. . . �,.. . ....., a . . . � . . � .'. . , {y, . . i . . }' .. ,. . . , . . - ,. .r . � .. ,� . ., .'� ��.. .�, . ' . - . . , � / y d , . . � ` . � . .. � . � . � te� , , � � . • � , � .Xk ' ' _ � � �� , , �... � - � , ' � �� � E�� � , . . �;� , , � , � , , _ , . _ . .! � a .. ' ' - � .. . . � � . .. _ f 1�x � . .. . . � 4,� . . .. . . _ . . . . � . � �;: , , . . :. - ..� . . � . . i. .. � . - : �.- �. . . . . . . -. . , `. � -. . . . , . '� , . . .' �. ..�.. . . . . . . , ... - - ::} \ . . .. .. � `F`k r . . . ' ' . ,' _ . '.: ' ' . . " . � ,� �,'. . , ' \ � . . _ / \ � ^' � � _ ^ - ' � ' . . . ,\� .�F. _ \ � �S� .1' . . .. �� ... � -f `y�y . � � � .. � . I�. Y+'{ .. . � . . , .. � . . . � 1 .. . . ` _ ., r. � . . ., .. .. _ . - , . . . . ,. . ,. y! . �el�► �l4, I!T# " � � � - _ ".�� _ � , . r � � � +� . , . . . , , j<.;; . , , . , � , ; , . , , , , , : � " ��tit�t� i� ;�s ` � � Adp�► ��. t����._ �' � , ' r ` � ' S�ir �`�« �!'Mir�O�� r{ , . �` ��'t _ , . '� � � . � , ;°', :� :, , , �"�'���!#� �� '�r� ��#c�'�•`�'k �QI�l� ��l1�`� f;����w�' � a ' ' ��� #�p7► o�`' C�#. � �. �714�:>-�i�p�ed b�f'�, #R�.t�1' C��. � ' _ , ,. er�+ �! ��, �l�8. �`� . , , . . > . � �, K fi�� � ��� `����►� _ � , . � .. . � . _ ,,, . , ,. -; , � ��� . . � 1��� - ;� � " � .. . , � .. . '�� 4�� b . - * 1 . .. . . � �� ��"'. . . . r '. . �. .. . ' . . ' - '' . .� . . . . . • . �. . . �: �{ ��1� , � . � y � s�+ . . !� . ... .. . . � - l I './ . . . . . . ..* � .V '.+ , .. ..� . <4���. . . . ' � - - . . .. .- - ' ,� �/ ., � . ` . . . ,� , . .. . � :' : . . .. . , . �-' Y,:�. . . . � . � ' . .. ' ,. :. .. .. .. . . .. . �' . .. � . . : .. .�...� .�.� . . R 1'. , ..'. � � ' '. � . . ' . . . . . I. .�_ �. . . :. � � k - , . .�� ' - . � ., .�. �. . - , �:. . . . . . �t , . . � � . - . �. . � :�':.: y. • . . .. .. � �� , - . , � �� �� . . ' , , i V � ,� . . 6 , � ' . _ . � � ��'. . .. . . . . .. . ' . . . . . . .. . *�' - . � � .I - i . .. , � . ._ . . . . . � r. ' ... , . � .' . .. .�.' . , ' '• . T� _ . ' a .� f� ' � S•Y-•' .,;• . �' .�..,:.. +. . . . � ''_.. . ;'-. �,�. � � -�� . ;. � :. . ` . . f i.{ . . , .. . ,. �.. ..... � .. . . � . . . . - .' „ " . � - � . . . . _�_' ' " . ' " �� . .. _ . � . . ..,-,. • .���e .-. . . . , � .. . . . � , .. . . . � .. ' �- . - � . � . . ,.,. . . . . ,�. .� .,., .. , .,, . .. i . ... .� �. � � ' . �. , - . �..� �. ' . .. ' .: .� . � . . � -: .. ,. . .. . � ' . . . ...- �" ) � , { .': . . � . - . . . � � .. - ' � . . t i3 . , ... . . . _ .. . . . � . . . . . . � .. �'. . - . ". �,. . . � . '� � . �.. ..� � :... -�� '' . .� . . �: �.. ' : � . �. . .. �, �.' . ;� ' .. . . .., .::, . ..� i .' . . .,. ... � .. . �:. , '..� . :.. .. . � . .�. . � . �:�'. n �� � � . � - ' � A � � . . ' � -' _ t� \ . . _ . . . �. � � . .. , .. �:\ i� . v�r '� ' . _ ' _ ' .', ' . , � . ��✓�.."� �-. . . � �. �: . . :. , : ..; . �' , �. ,;.. .. . . .�:. ... . . .'.. • " 1 �' y ! . �,� P y - . � ;.. • . . , -- - �' ' � . . � � � .i ' �. ' �. " � .:� ki� .� .�\ . ,. . . - .'.' .♦. . .'. � � . . . . � ". � . , . , � ♦�_ri .. . . . . . . � . ' . _� ;. � .- ., i. ... .: \,.1 , " 'i . . . .. ... .. ' .. . .. �. , � . ' j: { � , . , '. ., :.�.I �. , � .. . :. �, .. .. . � _ . .: � _ , . '- ... �. . .._ �f� , 1. � . � . � . . . . . _ ' ,, '. �. , � .. , : r. � . . . �" . . . . , � . '. ..' - . -. . . . � . . , . . , ;. ... �:.. . , ,.. �. ..� � --.. t... � �::�:� '��. ?�. . �� � . � , , � �/. ' ,_,I � zk� . . ' . ' . ' . � �4i � ....; :-.� '� �. �,: .�' . ' . . ; � .. - �� . • . .. . . . .. . .. ` ,. . .. l . . . . � . . . . .. . . , Y,.. .