The URL can be used to link to this page

270993 WHITE - CITV CLERK COUI1C11 I"�y��;,; PINK - FINANCE GITY� OF �SAINT PAUL �CANARV - DEPARTMENT /'+ i � $,) � . � BLUE� - MAVOR File NO. l Resolution Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date BE IT RESOLVED, That the Council of the City of Saint Paul hereby ratifies and approves the action of the City of Saint Paul Board of Appeals and Review pertaining to the following listed prop- erty and as shown by the Excerpted Minutes of said Board of Appeals and Review, dated March 28, 1978, and marked EXHIBIT A, and attached hereto and made a part hereof by reference: DATE OF BOARD . �- MINLTTES CASE NO. PROPERTY APPELLANT' 3/28/78 52-77-B 67 E. Eighth St. Harkins Bowling, Inc. (vacant commercial) BOARD ACTION: Granted deferment of fee payments under the Vacant � Building Registration Ordinance of the Saint Paul Legislative Code until such time as the building be sold, at which time all accumulated fees shall become due and payable. Propertv Descr3.ption: Roberts and Randalls Addition Lot 1, Part of Lot 2 NEly of Extended SWly Line of Lot 6 and Ex SEly 26 Ft. for St. Lots 6, 7, and 8, Block 13 COUNC[LMEN Yeas Nays Requested by Department of:_ [n Favor _ __ Against BY -- Form Approved by City Attorney Adopted by Council: Date Certified Passed by Council Secretary BY �' _'�_78 sy Approved by ;Nayor. Date ' _ Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council By _ _ _ sy � , ��5��`� • -' C...i''L.✓ ._.i 2• DATE OF BOARD MINUTES CASE NO. PROPERTY APPELLANT 3/28/78 02-78-H 1137-39 University Ave. Clarence A. Lindeke (six units) BOARD ACTION: Granted variance of Saint Paul Legislative Code re- quirement:_ pertaining to location of bathroom for Apt. #3 for the lifetime of the structure. Property Description: Sanborn' s Midway Addition Lot 21, Block 8 -------------------- 3/28/78 04-78-H 1056 E. Third St. Donald A. Anderson (three units) BOARD ACTION: Granted waiver of Saint Paul Legislative Code, Section 54.13, pertaining to basement occupancy, on condition that window area be enlarged and approved type of window be installed which would be suitable for use as an emergency exit. Property Description: Leffmann' s Subdivision E 12 Ft. of Lot 2 and All of Lot l, Block 86 -------------------- 3/28/78 05-78-B 345 Wabasha Virgil Doerfler Doerfler Square Bldg. (14� units plus commercial) BOARD ACTION: Granted waiver of Saint Paul Legislative Code require- ment pertaining to standby power generation for ele- vators, as stated in the Minnesota $Ia�. Code, Chapter 88, in section applicable to this classification of building. Property Description: City of St. Paul, Blocks 3 through 12, 17 through 26, and 31 through 39 SEly 1/6 of Lots 1 and 2, and Al1 of Lots 11 and 12, Block 21 -------------------- WH17E - CITV CLERK � - PINK - FINANCE COUIICII �'��.+`^��.=i''�i� .`CANARV - DEPARTMENT G I TY OF SA I�NT PAU L t � BLU,E - MAVOR . Flle NO• ti Council Resolution Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date 3. and be it � FURTHER RESOLVED, That the City Clerk is hereby authorized and directed to transmit a copy of this resolution for recording to the Ramsey County Office of the Register of Deeds. COU[VC[LMEN Requested by Department of: Yeas ,$�,;.f� Nays HOZl3 �+unt In Favor Leiived�e� d � � _ __ Against BY — �tye�ee Adopted by Council: Date _ �'� �' 19�8 Form Approved by City Attorney Certified P-s by Council ,e ret B� O�'�' �'�D"�8 By, Appr ed Mavor: Date Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council By BY pUBI{SHED .N1A'� 1 � t9� . . � � XKt �31 � 1� - . t ' -2- 3/28/78 - ��er`��o-''No. 138 requested that his case be rescheduled to the April lI Board meeting, since he could not be present at today' s meeting. In Case No. 06- 78-H, 729 Thomas , A�pellant Gertrude Suiek had withdrawn her appeal . eASE N0. PROPERTY APPELLANT 52- 77-B 67 E. 8th St . Harkins Bowling, Inc. (vacant commercial building) by Eric Steneroden SUBJECT: � ea� uest waiver of quarterly fees under the Vacant Building Reaistratian Ordinance because of fin ancial hardship. Ntatter is before Board to consider Assistant City Attorney' s recommendations on action of Board taken at me�ting of 1/10/78. Prior Hearing 1/10/78: Board granted �aaiver of fees until such time as building is sold, pending opinion and recommendations of City Attorney' s Oifice as to feasibility and legality of such action. APPEARANCE: None PROCEEDINGS: Chairman tivozniak reviewed the action of the Board taken at the Jan . 10 , 1978, meeting, at which time a tentative deferment of the fees was granted, pending an opinion from Assistant City Attorney Robert Straughn as to the best way to handle the matter. The chairman noted the letter from Attorney Straughn in response . Attorney Straughn stated that it would be proper to defer fee �aymen�s until such �ir�e as the building might be sold, provided there �as some record of it on the deed so that a prospective buyer would be aware of the fees payable to the city. Steve Roy asked if he should continue billing the corporation or just accumulate the amounts due at each quarter. Chairman j�Tozniak replied that the fees should be accumulated on the books . Attorney Straughn said there was no provision for deferment af fees �beyond one year under the Vacant Building Ordinance. BOARD ACTIO\: Chairman {�lozniak moved that payment of the c{uarterly fees under the Vacant Building Ordinance be deferred until such time as the building is sold, at which time all fees shall become due and payable, and th at this action be recorded by the Register of Deeds . Mr. Glassman seconded. MOTION CARRIED AND SO ORDERED. THE VOTE: �yes - 4 Nayes - 0 Abstentions - Q - - - - - - -- --- - - - - - - - - -- - -- - - -- - - -- - - - - -- - --- ---- ---- -- -- - ---- --- - - -- --- -- 3/28/78 - Meeting No. I38 � - MINUTES OF THE MEETI`G ST. P�:UL BOARD OF APPEALS ?l�;D REVIE�� . Tuesday, March 28, I978 City Council Committee Roam 707 City Hall and Court House 1 : 30 p.m. I�fEMBERS PRESENT: D.D. Wozniak, Chairma� �styr B. Peake �on Glassman LeRoy Coleman MEMBERS ABSENT: David Heider �rthur Tieso Ja;nes Voigt . AGENCIES PRESENT: De�artment of Communitv Services - Division of Hous ing an Bui ing o e En orcement : Glenn Erickson Sam Blue Frank Staffenson Alice Bi j j ani Steve Roy Fire Prevention Bureau: Dan Norrgran City Attorney' s Office Robert Straughn . OTHERS PRESENT: Donald Anderson Debra Avoles Clarence A. Lindeke �airgil Doerfler Sylvester McDonough STAFF PRESENT: Patricia Moxness The meeting was called to order at 1 : 45 p.m. bV Chairman D.D. Wozniak. The minutes of the meeting of January I0 , 19?8, were approved as mailed out to the members . The chairman informed the members that two cases on the agenda would nat be heard. In Case 03- 78-H, 852 Ashland, Apnellant Daniel Butler had .� " �� i �� • � � r�+Ft �� , � , � � � STAT� OF MINN�SOTA ) • Co un ty o S Ram.�e y 1 a.�. CITy d� SAINT PAUL ) � I . .. . .. . . Rose Mix . . .. . . . . . . . . . . .Cf#!� C.e21tf't � � , . . . . . . . . . .. . . . � . • o� �'he C.i.ty o� Sa,i,wt Pau.e, Mi.nne.ao�a, do heneby ce�c,t,i.�y �Gi.a,t � � I have compcviced �'h.e a�t.ached copy o� Counc.i..Q F-i,ee No.??0993„ a � � a.b adop�ed 6y �he Ci.ty Counc,i.e .. . . . . . �Y. ?:. . . . . . . . . . . 19.78. � �` � and appnoved by �he Mayon . . . . .. . . .. .. May. 3:.. . . . . . . .. . 19. 78. � �,, w.�th �'he oni.g�.na.0 �'he�ceo� on g.i.P.e �,n my o��.i.ce. � � � � .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .� � . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . � . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . .. . , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . � . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . � . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . _ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . � l . • • • • • • • • • • • • • � • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • � • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •� • • • • • • • � • • • • • • • � • • • • • • � � • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • � • • • • • • • • • • • • � • • • • • � • • • •• • • � • i � • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • � • • • • • • • • • • • � • • • � • • • • � �• • • • • • � I bwr�heJc ce�c.ti�y �'h.a.t �cci,d copy .i.b a �.ue and co�cne.c,t copc ,"�:;. �� , %. o b d cu.d o�u.g�.na.2 and �di.e who.2e �'h.e�ceo�. ��,�' u ..; ��; w� $.� wITN�SS my hand and �'h.e dea.e a� �he Cc.ty a� Sa,i,n� Pau,e, �: ,.3;. � � � � ;A S ;�{"� r `,� �:` µi.nn. �'.�u.a . .. .12t1� . day o� . . . . . . 1`�a„v. . . . . . .. . . . .A.�. 19.78. . . e �`f i �' a T 1� _ . M f(F°� y.p. �� ,:, r, ;. � , � f � � i :;�.�„ ` ,�' ( d ;,.<��" >� ,�,?;e. �`;�- . .. . . . .. . . . . .. . . . . .. .. . . . . . . . . . . � c�ty eh.Fz. 5 .s ' (;. .. /� j� � � '�,:� � :N i.1. � WMITE - LIT�' CLEpK PINI( FINA"'CE � ' COUIICII N��ED�TMENT (� ITY OF SAINT I�AUL �� ,P� �pVOR , File N0. $��' � l Resolution Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date BE IT RESOLVED, That the Council of the City of Saint Paul � hereby ratifies and approves the action of the City of Saint Paul (� Board of Appeals and Review pertaining to the following listed prop- C^ erty and • as shown by the Excerpted Minutes of said Board of Appeals � and Review, dated March 28, 1978, and marked EXHIBIT A, and attached r� hereto and made a parf hereof by reference: e DATE OF BOARD . �- MINUTES CASE N0. PROPERTY APPELLANT' 3/28/78 52-77-B 67 E. Eighth St. . Harkins Bowling, Inc. (vacant commercial) BOARD ACTION: Granted deferment of fee payments under the Vacant • Building Registration Ordinance of the Saint Paul • Legislative Code until such time as the building be sold, at which time all accumulated fees shall become due and payable. , Property Description: Roberts and Randalls Addition Lot 1, Part of Lot 2 NEly of Extended SWly Line of Lot 6 and Ex SEly 26 Ft. for St. Lots 6; 7, and 8, Block 13 � ------------------- COUNCILMEN Requested by Department of: Yeas Nays In Favor Against BY Form Approved by City Attorney Adopted by Council: Date Cert�fied Passed by Council Secretary By 0�1�' —'�°�78 B}� Approved by :Vlavor. Date ' Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council By� _ By •� ��'�,� � . � . � ,� ,.'�?�'�'-7�� ' - � 2. H !� ;� C'y' DATE OF BOARD � MINUTES CASE NO. PROPERTY APPELLANT �. 3/28/78 02-78-H 1137-39 University Ave. Clarence A. Lindeke (six units) BOARD ACTION: Granted variance of Saint Paul Legislative Code re- quirement pertaining to location of bathroom for Apt. #3 for the lifetime of the structure. Propertv Description: Sanborn' s Midway Addition Lot 21, Block 8 -------------------- 3/28/78 04-78-H 1056 E. Third St. Donald A. Anderson (three units) BOARD ACTION: Granted waiver of Saint Paul Legislative Code, Section 54.13, pertaining to basement occupancy, on condition that window area be enlarged and approved type of window be installed which would be suitable for use as an emergency exit. Propertv Description: Leffmann' s Subdivision E 12 Ft. of Lot 2 and All of Lot l, Block 86 -------------------- 3/28/78 05-78-B 345 Wabasha Virgil Doerfler Doerfler Square Bldg. (149 units plus commercial) BOARD ACTION: Granted waiver of Saint Paul Legislative Code require- ment pertaining to standby power generation for ele- , vators, as stated in the Minnesota BIdg. Code, Chapter 88, in section applicable to this classification of building. Propertv Description: City of St. Paul, Blocks 3 through 12, 17 through 26, and 31 through 39 SEly 1/6 of Lots 1 and 2, and All of Lots 11 and 12, Block 21 -------------------- � �ITV CLERK . � �'- { . _��gEP�T ENT GITY OF SAINT PAUL %- Council �� . � -","""oR File NO. � s ..f � Council Resolution Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date e1 3. � � � and be it � � � FURTHER RESOLVED, That the City Clerk is hereby authorized and directed to transmit a copy of this resolution for recording to the Ramsey County Office of the Register of Deeds. COUIVCILMEN Requested by Department of: �Yeas ,�„f�� Nays Noua t+unc In Favor Levine 'R0°'d+� � � Against BY �i+�st �tleses Adopted by Council: Date �Y �' �9T8 Form Approved by City Attorney Certified P•s. by Counc.il ,e ret B�t �.�-78 By Appr ed Mavor: Date _ Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council By By N ♦ �c -�- 3/28/78 - Meetina vo. I38 � �'�� CASE N0. PROPERTY APPELLANT 02- 78-H 1137- 39 University Ave . Clarence Lindeke (six units) dba The Cherokee Co. SUBJECT: Request waiver of St. Paul Legislative Code provision requiring that bathroom be located within walls of �it (Apt. #4 only) ; an d also, request waiver of requirement of second means of egress from third floor apartments , since alternate me ans is available, although not strictly in code compliance, because of financial hardship. APPEARANCE: Clarence A. Lin deke PROCEEDINGS : Mr. Lindeke told the Board that the building inspector had suggested replacemen� of the two third floor bathroom windows with either doors or lower windo��s , and then constructing a stairway leading from these exits to the ground. Mr. Lindeke explained that at present there was a ladder leading from a third floor window down to the second flaor. A similar ladder could be built from a third floor bedroom windaw to the roof of a norch which reached to the second floor. He felt this was a reasonable substitute for the more expensive construction the inspector had described. Alice Bijjani stated that a stairway was required leading to the ground level and it had to be accessible to all third flovr units . If replace- ment windows were installed instead of doors in the 3rd floor bathrooms , they should be a type that swings outward for ease of exit in an emergency. Mr. Lindeke said he would like to have a time extension beyon d the May 10, 1978, deadline listed in the letter from the Housin g Code Division. The carpenter who normally i�orked for him had suffered a heart attack, and Mr. Lindeke wanted to consult him about the project and learn whether he would be well enau�h to do the work or whether Mr. Lindeke would have to find another t�orkman. Ms. Bij j ani explained that if Mr. Lindeke brought in some plans that met code requirements , the Housing Code agency could give him a six month' s extension to complete the work. BOARD ACTION: Mr. Glassman moved to grant an extension of time to August 10 , I978, .I . • � -5- 3/28/78 - Meeting �a. 138 . � BOARD ACTION (con�i�ued) : for construction oi an approved second means of egress far anartments located on the third floor. Mrs . Peake seconded. MOTION CARRIED AND SO ORDERED, THE VOTE : Ayps - 4 Nayes - 0 Abstentions - 0 :�ir. Lindeke stated t:�at he was also requesting a waiver on the bathroom location for Apt . =3 on the second floor. The bath was located off the common hallway outside the walls of the unit, but was use d only by the tenants of. Apt . #;, �ho had a key and kept it locked. To change the location of the door to open into the kitchen would require two movements of plumbing. Ms . Bijjani asked 'naw far the bathroom door t�as from the ap artment door. �ir. Lindeke said it was about three feet aiaay, and Ms . Bi�jani indicated that her agency would not object to a continuation of this arrangement. BOARD ACTION: Mr. Glassman moved to grant a waiver of code rec{uirements pertaining to the location of the bathroom for Apt. 3 for the lifetime of the structure , said waiver to be recorded by the Register of Deeds . Chairman Wozniak seconded. MOTION CARRIED �'SD SO ORDERED. THE VOTE: Ayes - 4 Nayes - 0 Absten tions - 0 --- - -- --- - - - -- - -- -- --- --- - --- ---- - - -- - - - -- -- - -------- -- -- -- ------ - ---- - 3/28/78 - Meeting No. I38 � ' MI\UTES OF THE ME�TING ST. PAUL BO�RD OF APPEALS AND REVIE�d Tuesday, biarch 28, I978 City Council Committee Roam 707 � City Hall and Court House 1 : 30 p.m. MEMBE�S PRESENT: D. D. �ti`ozniak, Chairman Estyr B. Peake Ron Glassman LeRoy Coleman MEMBERS ABSENT: David Heider Arthur Tieso James Voigt AGENCIES PRESENT: Department of Communit Services - Division of ousing an Buil ing o e n orcement : Glenn Erickson Sam Blue Frank Staffenson Alice Bij j ani Steve Roy Fire Prevention Bureau: Dan �Vorrgran City Attorney' s Office Robert Straughn :OTHER.S PRESENT: Donald �nderson Debra �voles Clarence A. Lindeke Virgil Doerfler Sylves ter ?�icDonough STAF� PRESENT: Patricia '�So�mess The Meeting was called to order at 1 : 45 p.m. by Chairman D.D. Wazniak. The ninutes of the meeting of January 10, I978, were anprove d as mailed out to the members . The chairman informed the mer�bers that two cases on the agen da would �ot be heard. In Case 03- 78-H, 852 Ashland, Appellant Daniel Butler had � ' ' -5- 3/28/78 - Meeting ti'o. I38 ��'��'� '� "' ,i' -J -- - - - - -- - - ---- - - - - --- - ---- �- - ----- -- --- ---- -- ------- -- -- - - -- ----- -- - - - CASE N0. PROPERTY . �� APPELLANT 04-78-H 1056 E. Third St. Donald A. Anderson (three units) SUBJE CT: Request waiver of St. Paul Legislative Code, Section 54. 13, pertainin g to basement occupancy, because loss of income would constitute financial hardship. APPEARA�'�CE : Donald A. Anderson PROCEEDINGS: Frank Staffenson reported that the basement unit had two standard cellar-type windows , which made then unsuitable for use as an er�ergency exit. Pdr. Anderson said he was willing to install larger windows and window wells outside if this was all that ��as necessary to obtain a certificate of occupancy on a unit more than 50% below grade. Ms . Bijjani reQuested that if the Board should grant a variance from the 50o below grade restriction, it be on condition that proper-size windows be provided. � , . 3/28/78 - Meeting ZFa. I38 '� MINUTES OF THE t�ETI�G ST. PAUL BOARD 0'= �PPEALS AND REYIEEV Tuesday, '�farch 28, 1978 City Cou.ncil Conmittee Room 707 � City Hall and Court House I : 30 p.m. A7EMBERS P?.rSE\T: D.D. Woznian, C�airman Es tyr B. Pe a;e Ron Glassman LeRoy Coleman MEMBERS �SL�iT: David Heider Arthur Tieso - James tioigt AGENCIES PRESE:VT: Department of Commu.nit Services - Division of ousing an Buil ing o e En orcement: Glenn Erickson Sam Blue - Frank Staffenson Alice Bi j j ani Steve Roy Fire Prevention Bureau: Dan Norrgran City Attornev' s Office Robert Strauahn - ..OTHERS PRESEVT: Donald Anderson Debra Avoles Clarence A. Lindeke - Virgil Doerfler Sylvester :�±cDonough STAFF PRESE�;T: Patricia l�1oxn�ss The meetino has called to order at 1 : 45 p.m. by Chairman D.D. i�tiozniak_ The minut°s of the meeting of Januarv I0, 1978, �rere anpra�ed as mailed out to the �embers . � The chairnan informed the members that tcro cases on the agenda would not be heard. in Case 03- 78-H, 852 as:�land, Appellartt Daniel Butler had _ i � ` -6- 3/28/78 - Meeting No. 138 ' � , �'��'� ! Attorney Straughn left the meeting at this time. Sa� Blue, Gienn Erickson, and Dan Norrgran joined the meeting. � CASE N0. PROPE RTY APPELLANT 05- 78-B 345 Wab asha Virgil Doerfler ' Doerfler Sc{uare (formerly t the Lowry Hotel) (149 units , plus commercial} SUBJECT: Request waiver of St. Paul Legislative Code requireme�t pertaining to emergency standby electric generation for elevators, because of high cost and because other safety measures make it unnec�ssary. APPEARANCE: Virgil Doerfler, Sylvester �icDonough PROCEEDINGS : City Architect Glenn Erickson explained that the bui.lding was over 75 ft. in height which, if it were new cons�ruction, wc�uld put it in the classification of a high-rise structure . This class of building rec{uires a standby power generator for a fire pump and for the elevator. Street pressures in the water mains are insufficien� to deliver water in required volu�e at the to.p, so there has to be a pump to accomplish this . This is being installed and is very costly, but to add the standby generation, which would also require an on-site fuel supply and other items , would add a great deal more to the e xpense. As for the elevator system, the height of the building req�i res that at le as t one elevator have standby power. He said that Mr. Doerfler had agreed to a long list of fire-safety rec{uirements which the Code Enforcement Division had b rought to his attention and in every respect h ad been most cooperative . However, he hesitated over the s�andhy generation of power for tne elevators reQuired by the code . Assistant Fire �farshal Dan Norrgran related that a �heck had been made with Northern States Power as to the reliability of the power supply. NSP had given it a high rating, as the downtown are�a did not have overhead wires to cause a problem. In regard to st�.dby power for the fire pump, it was desirable to have it, but not absolutely necessary. If the fire pu�p should lose power, the Fire Depart�ent can bypass the pump, using the Fire Department pumper instead to p�ip water into the system. He explained that there are connections an the outside of the building to support that system. Also , the building is not so high that there would be insufficient gressure to pump water to the top floor. . � ; - 7- 3/28/78 - Meeting No. 138 ~ ?�ir. '�orrgran said in this case a standby generator does not have as great significance as it might have in some buildings . iir. Glassman said it ap�eared the main problem was standby power for the elevator. �ir. Erickson agreed with this statement . He said Chanter 88 of the Fire Code states that when there is a change made in an elevator, the type of drive , speed of o�eration, etc. , all other snecificatians must be brought up to a certain level spelled out b� the code. Since i�ir. Doerfler is installing two new high-speed, self-controlled elevators , standby generation is also reauired. �ir. Doerfler stated that the additional cost iaould be about $40,UQQ . bir. Erickson said that , aside from the cost of the generator itself, it has to be installed in a two-hour fire-rated room, it has to be ventilate� there has to be a fuel supply, and there have to be transfer switches to �ake the automatic transfer of power. San Blue note d that Mr. Doerfler, in listi.ng the fire-safety items he had agreed to do, had not included the sprinkler system in the basement. Mr. Doerfler pointed out tW0 other areas which were sprinklered as well, the tobacco shop and the bar and restaurant . He said the building itself is fireproof, even the fire wallswere cement. He reported that the elevators work on a separate power from the rest of the building, so if the power goes out in the building, the elevators continue to work on their own. There was also emergency lighting, supplied by battery pac�, �in case there should be a loss of power affecting the elevators . BO_`,�?D ACTION: Chairman Wozniak moved that a waiver be granted from the requirement of standby power generation for the elevators . Mr. Glassman seconded. ri0TI0V CARRIED AND SO ORDERED. THE VOTE : Ayes - 4 Nayes - 0 Abstentions - 0 -- -- -- - -- -- -- - - -- -- ---- -- -- -- -- - -- - -- ---- -- -- ---- -- -- -- -- ---- -- ---- - -- The meeting adjourned at 3: 05 p.m. � • A 3/28�78 - Meeting \o. 138 w,�' MINUTES OF THE ?��ETTNG ST. PAUL BOARD Or �PPEALS A:�ID REVIEN Tuesday, '�iarch 28, 1978 City Council Co�nittee Room 707 � City Hall and Court House 1 : 30 �.m. biEMBERS PRESE\T: D.D. iVozniak, Chairman Estyr B. Peake Ron Glass man LeRoy Coleman ME1�iBERS ABSEtiT: David Heider Arthur Tieso James Voigt - AGENCIES PRESENT: �De_��artment of Com.munity Services - Division of -F�ousing and�ui� in� ode �n orcement : Glenn Erickson Sam Blue Frank Staffenson Alice Bi j j ani Steve Roy . Fire Prevention Bureau: Dan Norrgran City Attornev' s Office Robert Straugh� - ..OTHERS PRESEVT: Donald Anderson Debra Avoles Clarence A. Lindeke � Virgil Doerfler Sylvester A1cDonough STAFF PRESEVT: Patricia Moxizess ' The meeting was called to order at I : 45 p.m. by Chairman D.D. ��ozniak. The minutes of the meeting of Januarv I0, 1978, were approved as �nailed out to the me^bers . � The chairman informed the members that two cases on the agenda would not he heard. In Case 03- 78-H, 852 Ashland, Appellant Daniel Butler had _ 4 'i ", , ` �. ;F, �. � ' { r , .. .- ��`i�� i',. r �.,r ,'. `3 � - ! ' ' r. � � � � • � �� ,. , . . =, 4, �. ,r . � � � � � � ' . _ � � f` �.� • � � ' � � � � � � � �� , � � � .�. — � ' � '.� r � �`�j�. � .. � . . � . : ' �. � ,. .. * �. ,Mi . _ . . � � � � . .. . . � �" -�gg,�" • _ � � , ' � . '� �� _ .� ' . . , �� ` — i, f �� ,t�, 1+�7��, , s � � � , . ,,. . . ;: . . . . . � . ,. �►' . ��{ , , . , �, ;'� - " . � . �. . , -�_ � . , � ,� , � � . � _ ,; ��, . ��. . � �ig�,,s!t,s�r �p#�-�lt�d� . ` . � � � ° _ ` ,. `�'�. ��ao�e�t,��3,�_ �t�►��,� �� r ., � • � � , . . � , � -'� . ��S+�c �'� �ssoti� � �; s , , , . ,. �,, . . � , • : �� , �� 1�D� � ' \ �} . . . . , . Et; - ' . . , . - � b��a�hsd !o�` i� l�i� iiir a ' . , �E ' �� '� �� +� ; � , S. , ; r '�.�:� �'�'�� i�l�. � � �"' c .�, ��i1. i'� �, �� aY ,_ • � . ,. , , . ; , ,.., � � . �;' - 4�MS'� �01+�" �rs:' , , , , �� . � . �. . . . . ,�; . ' . � , -. ' ,, y} ; i.. . - . , . - �<- � '�O#i �� r ; ; , . .� , . , �, . - � �. - �,� � � �� , , , - , - �t � 7. Jw; � � � . - . � � . • y ,. � ' �i � , . . � . � r . � . . � � � .. : .. . . � . � . .. .. . . � . , . . . - j, . . . . . , . . . - sr �� g . ' , �.� � .. � .. \ �` . 1 ' +� , . ." i _ . „ , , �' �, .� � .' .. � . _ � . •.. � . � � . +��,��' .�. � , . � . .�� '- ' . ' . ., . . . . ', . '� . . ' � . - . � . . .. ti � , , — M� . , , .. , , . y . , . , � , .. . ; . �. � � �;N , - _ 4 , . , , , . _;� . � � ��. - � . , , . . . . , �<., . _ . ,,,..: � e _ � ; ,�� ' , +. - . � r• � . . . _ - � .. - ' _ . � � i n � � .. . _ • � . y'� 1� / �a , , � �� , . �' � � , �' ,w� . � ��.. , , ' . -� ' � � � . , �. . . . . � .. �.. a k�,.� . �.� .. , ... . . . . . . �� +;4 i _ / . �. ; , ., , .- � � z ;. � �, • ` _ ' � .. , • rX, ,� , �.: �: �_ , . , . _ . .. . _ . ... -