The URL can be used to link to this page

271826 � WHITE - UTV CIERK �� PINK - FINANCE GITY OF SAINT PAITL Council CANARV - OEPARTMENT File NO. BLUE - MAVOR l Resolution Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date WHEREAS , Leo A. Scheu applied to the City Council for a determination of the zoning district boundary for the east 6 feet of Lot 11, Block 1, Rothschild' s Addition, pursuant to Section 60. 402 (f) of the Zoning Ordinances of the City of Saint Paul; and WHEREAS, Said Section 60. 402 (f) provides that the Council, upon written application, may determine the exact boundary location of any intended zoning use district where, because due to scale, lack of detail, or illegibility of the zoning map, there is un- certainty, contradiction, or conflict as to the intended location of any district boundaries; and WHEREAS, Leo A. Scheu' s Lot 12 is currently zoned B-1 and has been used as a parking lot for a supermarket since September 1967, and Mr. Scheu states that the east 6 feet of the adjacent Lot 11 has also been used as a part of the parking lot; and WHEREAS, Prior to the adoption of the present zoning classification both Lots 11 and 12 were zoned for commercial, and the present zoning classification is RM-l; and WHEREAS, The Council, having heard from the applicant and having considered the report of staff, does hereby RESOLVE, That the Council of the City of Saint Paul, pursuant to the authority granted it by Section 60. 402 (f) of the Zoning Ordinances, and based upon the evidence considered, does hereby find and determine that the boundary line for the B-1 zone is up to and does include the east 6 feet of Lot 11, Block 1, Rothschild' s Addition. � COU[VCILMEN Yeas Nays Requested by Department of: ..� $�r In Favor Hozza 1 Hunt �J Levine __ Against BY ��4e�idcx.. Showalter_ � � �9�� Tede �� Adopted Counci Date Form Approved by ty Att ney Cer ied Ya- - by o il Sectetary BY t#ppro ;Navor: Dat _ � Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council By _ BY �UBLISNED SEP 3 � 197a , . . .;. � ` ,,. \�� ' . i • � , ; � , ' , ��. '. ' « . , , . . . . r . . . . . . r�. i . . .. . . . .. .. � . . . , . . . . � � ..f.. � .. . . / . . . . ,. _ . - . � . , � � Aug�t 8� 1978 . \ ; __ . � I 4 � � ,l�r. B�xsrord Carieon - � Direotor FL4aaeas � M�nagema�nt ,�ervicee , , �toam u3, c�ty Hal.l , , � �7eas F�r. Carlecr�: ' T�,, Tbe C�t,y Counefl rril�l held a Dubl.la bra�ciog oo Augwt 3�.� ],9'r8 �o - �sausi�,�3er � r�e�uuest of 3�so Sctwu Por a ?iap�qg Distari�Dt�.Hound�r� ��et�r� p�rtstia� atf+�etl,ng preyper�jr on t�he �.s'ide of Rs4dolph be��se� � . ' Ful�;ari & Ylew aad deecribed ae Lota 11 8� �2�„Hloak,l� �l.�ds Addi�'id�. ` ` i�i12 �non p�.�a�a� e�d nolitses o! he�a�iqg 't►� su�era�rdiog p�'ope�ty a�mere f't�i.• ; : ].o�air� t1�s avne 't�quiren�t�te as other sc�ing �ters. . • • . v� �� B' . Ro�s Mix � ' " : ;� � � � � � City C�.�rk " � � � � � � � , , � . . QajPianoi�8 8�at�', �o�iog`Sectioa , , . Sapsrr�isoar t�ode �a►fo�c�ent - , Aeo/sah , ' � . �' . f _ \ ' ,,, , !, . , � , , , . . , , , f \ � � 1 Y,. � � � ` _� x � �.� ��u �4 d y' '• �t Z � 'Y � �r F, � 4 x,' i � �I •�� I.�' i� F� \ n2 / � . � l-� � '� �# s� y . k . / , F � � �e! �/ ._{ �;� 1. � .1 ,i 1 ','t h��n� � 1 � y _ � �f /.,� � '� -} � R�� _ . v � `�.��5 � ��{+ � � f � � �` - �9 '�Y.y , � . . ` r� � . i } kf��9 � t h�� .� �A \k�� f - �.i � i � + ' '��f ��r-� 7 ,�� kl� t . � .. 1' 1 ��' j ... < f /( *� y . �.. . '.. ... . . ` . .. ., . � . .. : ' . �� ' �:. ,� ' . - . �. , ' - ..: ' � � �¢� .. ... � . , . , � . � -.. - '. .. . . .. , -� �-.. , � .�... .. ,.. � r � . . . 1 f 4 � � f: t i *rc 1 � � 4 ..j ' . �;� A .j � ; t �. � , t � . '� ��j y i '� i"f, tF � � � l.. � " Y 3= �f '� bi � �.`• • )i• , j " � Y ,!' ,i`y��', � �'i. : � x r � • � + t r� S '� J t �+� � }� / • �� ; ��`�� ir � �� w .r `� . ,� � •,�-�� } x:�� `- ' ` � . I.� ' �#' `�"` , 4 ''°. � � � f v;� y � �t t � ,, I , �,��!# '�� $ t. f f r s h � i.?+ f! ` '�` Y � t ,'� �'.1 t7'r L �. ) � F t �' - � # k 5 ^i t ` ' � r � , ' ? � �� I '%.` ' / -t . �V .. 4 ' �.l �'j � , � ��f�� .�� i �` g. 1 �� F�� ' �! F \ y A q 6� ��r ;TM j � � '�� _ j �� E` i � # ` ' . � ID � ��'! �. A � �' i�- � ° f .i � . M�� . . a� s+r �l. ' , . ` ,, ,� � . � � 6 i� 4 � '�r r , , ' , , , , ,� , � , ,, � •{: � �'� � � y 9f�qos'+�'r'r� �,�i' �`+1� �'Qi S� �."'� ��,s'� '� '��' ��kl��l� � � . , ; + ; c =+� ��l�?�� t.�� ' atu� ` '� ��w, "�l�M�l{�W��'�� c.~ �� ; �+�°�r�� ? +�i��4��y��i i' � C, �. - ( : ; , : , �.• �}� �. � � ' �� '�l;. �, � I J v�i� � - . � t'` ��' � . . � . ��. c:v.�r t " �': ' ,.. ` . . : ! ,�y d -a � _ .. -�, a� ?�4.`7,:, i � � x gr�� ' � + �, ' y "� �/ i 'Er'� �y � : r � � f ' f . �� j�: ¢ !� � �� `�� - � . . ' .. "�� ' f } ��'1�� ,. . . �� , .,. .. � ��.. '��s. � � _ ��-. 1 .� - . . . � �, :�.t � � ��, �t �'9� �� { �� 4 7 `� f ' � �� / � ,� 6 k � � a , f' � � . . J � - .��.. . �, +` „ � . � " �Fd L � y t } ' 4 - .. fi: �� , � .f . ` . .! ,!; ` y f t� f� � � �: . i t . 4:> i� � -, � P �'� J � ls-.) � u�z ' ' 'k e; �a�- i�� . ' � � y � � t ' F _ . . ._ `,� J �J! � ��e^ r6 �� (y j � i� Y _.� . . i �", . ',,j _ � ` ' ' �� a :_ � ' . ' ✓, �� \i. , � g '#�K < � �� ' .�. . . _ _ c�� '� '�1� ''� �,`-: r� � � � { £� � �. , � . .� ,�: . '( .� � , . .� ` f.� � - .. . +�' . � .,..-. a .. _, > � ;� b�r)�+` t ; ^ � � i �� i � ' �i: i � < ; M a"�`, ' 1F-, � t �tP ' � . �}[ �. : t � ' 2 �` {� � ,�.M1 _ .. . . . .__ .. . .� ..� �_ , _t.- ._ . ., . � ., ,. ., . , ..r.r.�, z_ ... ��._,�u,� . ��,.a.l"»�s,�. � ...,�,. .�514,i,r... � ., � � �. - � � __ i �� '��_�;� v . ��TY o,. CITY OF SAINT PAUL �'�� `�= DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT y� . L � b•••:.�7.•. '� . t ��i� �b ,�� ^� DIVISION OF PLANNING �.� 421 Wabasha Street,Saint Paul,Minnesota,55102 612-298-4151 George Latimer Mayor July 26, 1978 Rose Mix, City Clerk 386 City Hall St. Paul , Minn. 55102 Re: Zoning File No. 8316 - Leo Scheu Dear Madam: Zoning District Boundary Interpretation Enclosed is the Planning Staff report and recomnendation on the above referenced zoning district boundary interpretation. This is in response to the City Council request of June 13, 1978. Sincerely, Edward J. War Senior City P ner EJW/gf Enc. cc: Glenn Erickson, Zoning Administrator �-�.�,�� • '•• ' . ,��,��-�� PIANNING NOARD STAFF REPOItT JUIy 25, �978 Plat Map 9 8316 1. APYLICANT'S NAME . LEO SCHEU 6577 2, CLASSIFICATION . � Amendment � Appeal � Permit � Other 3. PURPOSE . Zoriing District Boundary Interpretation 4. LOCATION . North side of Randolph between Fulton & View 5. LEGAL DESCRIPTION : Lots 11 & 12, Block 1 , Rothschilds Addition 6. PRESENT 20NING: RM=1 7 . PURSUANT TO Zoning Code Chapter: 60 Section: 402 Peragraph: �f� 8. STAFF INVESTIGATION & REPORT: Date: 7-25-78 �y; EJW A. PURPOSE: The purpose of this report is to provide a staff recommendation for the C�ty Countil on the interpretation of a zoning district boundary concerning Leo Scheu. Mr. Scheu requests interpreting the existing zoning district boundary line between Lots 11 and 12 to include the east 6 ft. of Lot 11 with Lot 12 in a B-1 zone. B. FRONTA�E & AREA: 1 . Lot 11 , Block 1 , Rothschilds Addition, has 37.1 ft. frontage on Randolph and is 111 .8 ft. deep, for a total area of 4,148 sq. ft. 2. An existing house on said Lot 11 (805 Randolph) has as its legal description "the east 6 ft. of Lot 10 and all of Lot 11 , Block 1 , Rothschilds Addition. " This house and property, therefore, has 43.� ft. frontage on Randolph and is 111 .8 ft, deep, for a total area of 4,819 sq. ft. 3. Lot 12, Block 1 , Rothschilds Addition, has 38.1 ft. frontage on Randolph and is 111 .8 ft. deep, for a total area of 4,260 sq. ft. C. SITE CONDITIONS: An older, well-kept, sin le family home occupies Lot 11 and the east 6 ft. of Lot 10 Rothschilds Addition �see "B" above). An asphalt parking lot occupies all of Lot 12 and, according to Mr. Leo Scheu, the east 6 ft. of Lot 11 Rothschilds Addition. A single family house borders the subject properties on the west and Dannekers Super Market borders on the east. D. AREA CONDITIONS: The area is characterized by single family homes with some multi- family and commercial uses along Randolph. E. ZONiNG DISTRICT BOUNDARY INTERPRETATION: Section 60.402(f) states: "Where unzoned property may exist, or where, due to the scale, lack of detail , or illegibility of the Zoning Map, there is any uncertainty, contradiction, or confliction as to the intended location of any district boundaries shown thereon, interpretation concerning the exact location of the district boundary iines shall be determined by the City Council , upon written application, or upon the Council 's own motion following review and recomnendation by the Board of Zoning Appeals." In this case Mr. Scheu has made written application to interpret a zoning district boundar,y. ' . , LEO SCHEU Page 2 F. FINDINGS: 1 . The north side of Randolph between Fulton and View was zoned "Commercial" under the 1922 zoning ordinance. 2. The 1975 zoning ordinance attempted to recognize existing uses in determining zoning districts. 3. Since the block was divided by residential and corronercial uses existing at the time of the 1975 zoning ordinance, the block was divided into RM-1 and B-1 zones. 4. The City approved construction of a parking lot for Danneckers in September 1967 (Zoning File #6577), showing bituminous surfacing on the east 2'-6" of Lot 11 . 5. There is no basis to interpret the zoning district boundary to include the east 6 ft. of Lot 11 . G. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Staff's recommendation, based on Findings 2-5 above, is that the zoning district boundary line in question be interpreted as follows: That the east 2'-6" of Lot 11 , Block 1 , Rothschilds Addition be included in the existing B-1 zone on the north side of Randolph between Fulton and View. H. OTHER ��J�dSIDERATIONS: ? . The proposed sale of the east 6 ft. of Lot 10 and all of Lot 11 except ±nR easterly 6 ft. (805 Randolph) would be contrary to Section 5' .102(c)(1 ) �hich requires that a lot or parcel "shall not be d��vided or sub�+iv�c�ed and pa�^t of a lot or parcel shall not be conveyed unless and urt�� a�? lots or parcels created by division, by subdivision, or by conveyance �f nart of a lot or parcel shall meet the requirements of Sect�on &1 .101 to 61 .104, Schedule of Regulations." The applicant's proposed subdivision of this lot would not meet the requirements of this ;P�±��n 5ecause it would create a lot with less than the minimum requireG �� ft. frontage. Sale of the east 6 ft. of Lot 10 and all of Lot 1 �. ��cept the east 2' -6" would leave a 40'-7" wide lot and therefore wo¢.�ld not violate Section 61 .102(c)(1 ). 2. T�e portion of the parking lot covering the easterly 2' -6" of Lot ?� �s a lega� nonconforming use and can continue as a parking lot as long as any owner of that piece of land so desires if the Council interprets the zon�ng distr�ct boundary as falling on the lot line separating Lots 11 and 12. �i I a � �• � �� 1�I�� • Cj4'.rS) �js"�j /��s177r�JI7/ IY ��.�...v.�rwr.�w• _..,�.� """"��t. ....��/!1' ' � I�`� .�/ ��t.1l' �� G�...r� � E....��4.�Etilgt,.i..LL1 ��G �- p?�-r rn =_� �71� /j. .,... . � (. •p n• ,� r 1.,�n�i P'�---�?� ��';_� r�_r��, � �. '- �� '� , ��...�y,, ��:�¢�;q� , .,�.. - rr•,�. - - - - ��--�--___..._ __ �-, v--'� r:.J �.�.LY.1�,�; . `�,� ;'.".��.�(� ..I7 .�i}�. ,`��_ _.—.1 ��iy�►000 ♦/Rn � . Y�A _.,Yf. _ , �� , /' •��•�. � �,�, •��• ' � ' Iy/; � � � •�� l__._.-- �� ' /'� / �' �� •�•.• ��_�� ... -. '� ./ �� , _ _�� . _ � ._ _ . . . . � _ ' • ��•p~IIM�1�� 1 � --- f�AKL *.e -�-- v �o •�N�i��.�r • �1I't `� -� i �^[ �.. �� - �1^Gj��r��1�' • .�sin��`'!eY - "�,,'. `r i [ �[�.� •� ,�.� � �P"�� ••�y•��C:.. w� . '�iL�+'/✓~.>/ i7 /,, ��r �Y,.�. �� ;,�' ! fLll .i :,,�'� �ir�k:��.��• _�. ._ � �. - �� / ;� " ��rr��•�•r�• � i� ///� . . � . � � t ��/ �,' ' + ••��U�r+r. � � r� �n;.,4��;��f•�•��r.•r�. .��)�ol a!!iLl. � , ' .-R .air.r�.,.. �� •r� � •'.�`}ti�1 ��►I� ��U��1. ��i. �' -1 ( ,�l '1 r �A• • / �� i��ii � I 1 � •�� •�• �• •��r��• •� ' � � �' ;i.- � � ' �I � I � . i •�• ��r •• ��A1r�� Y�♦ •r��r��. ' _.�s! ' 4.r � � I I � . _�:• • ::• ••��• t��. h�r.yr.`�s /�/�7' n 17•.�. � � _.. r�j •• '�••`I1Y��r��O+�r�/��• r � ___. � •• �• •• •1►�r• •�r�i��'�I / �� _. •�• •• � �.if"' .� �, L�...' � �• � � •• r• •r• •��rr/, � ,,.,;--.,. �- .,, ; , : , � ' � . .. �.. •. ........y �� %�'�lY 7 � � �, �� •��• �• ��. •��• , �, �L[.r�� '.iYy' �'�� ' •��.. •• �• i��r�� ..1.... 1..Gi n:i� -- , •�+wr• �• � +' L ..t � .�� "--��v Q .,�ri � /*-.�17 ;�r%�� ,,;�--- -- Ir i�I +• � ,. �' ��,,. •'�•1 � � M + :i..:•..'�:"�r •s i�:�• � -.± r� �� •�.••��••�...•� Q � lG:: , �__.. �.: .� 4�l.i� •�..��.��v•�.��.�� •.' �T / �'� �� , � �; •��M��r�w � Q ��'1�''' '�'��,� ??7'1� � i. � •��H��' o � � �t. `� ��' ,,»tiy�y� f •��wvs��' ��I �.,.;. � u �.,:4a .......»,...... s .s.... r��• 5 �� ` '�/, iI �7 �f/ • •. ./�1 / •��• r-;,f� p:?31y`',9}��""!'�'=� � . ...•.•.��...•.• � ♦ ---- rlG:..� '� �1/i �i� � •��• •��r��• . � „"��.. i7• 7 r �� . •��• �! %�ae..,�`,� , /.�.��,' ` . �7� /� tG� • •��r��• 1 ;'% � •��• � l /. �i � • •M��r�►�• , .��r- �l / ' ��'l/yi � ` " •��• ,., ,,,, l� � ' ,;j/� .. .. � . � . . . . '/� Lc�J ! � � r �y! � �s� ' Y ��/ � � � �� , ��r�%�'l�„' �� %/�y� ✓ s� '% •��• • � , ' • � ' � �[(�y „�,.,.,,,,, 'i �i�/ • � � /f • GCGl��i.f�GL�L�GkYYir� i" / . '�•• •�� / r /,�'�Y• • y ,�,i.!�' � ,�� :-i%�/`L � � . • ��o� h 4 �f%��5%�� ' ..:.�:�t'.k'/i.:% ; '7,� � • S•S � ,\'�y '�` _� ♦"/ �` r.. �. / 1 --. �'� � ;;, ',, , �N A �� . .. � %% � I � �� Vr- • ... . �i... .it� r��'„''�� i �t . � /� V •��• " /� ci,rr ti,wirs _ _ ,�,,....• �E`;'� .� ,�' ._• _ .. �. _ �► ,uu,�• r"f i �� •�••�i��i�� _ " ' _- � �� w�� / •��N�� ^�� .�-� .:.::,. ........... C�TY F . ..____...� Q SAINT PAUl. �; ...... .............. .... .................. �/� . �•• •��.��w��arwr�• N O � V � O . .. .................... �,� RDINANC E . �� •.��r�.�•��r•o�r• •��r��r��r��rr• � •��r��Ml��• ., �•....................... � A U G., I-.9 2 2 (+I��.•+�wr��.��M��M • ••«��r� ` +j� •�rr��w��• ♦ /� . ��/ t .��.��Z• •��.r�rrs• � /�/ ��e�r�e�r��o�� ir��.�r�.�.��r��• � • •0��r1��r •• ................:�. ; DlSTRICT . ..................�.. � �� ....... .......... .. . , S ��r��11��1�+��• •� � . .......,r,........... .��..-. .�� •� •y.��.v •• .:c..'` "'"~'""=wy •=�=' ' A�� R E S I D E N C E D I S T R I C T .. ......... r ��J•f�.•�••.• �" •�i. :� ' .��•�:./ •��.+• •�.� • • �� 2•.+� .•.�„ d PUBLIC PROPERTIES : .�;:•...►•.•. �.....�. 1 , .��...�--l� ��i�ii� � 11 11 •�=�� ---�--�- �' B R E S I� D E N C E D I S T R I C T �, ...y— .�y �, � � � _ u�n- - � "cia �RESIDENCE DISTRIGT N O R T H COMMERCIAL OISTRICT � LIGHT INDUSTRY ~ T I O! S R GT ...... �""' HEAVY INDUSTRY DISTRICT ...�.� . . . , . _..,-.,,..,,,. � ,_.. ... .... .� _ � - - - - -- - -^ - - , � . � O �* v `^ �.., p 'U a � • Q N k ��" L r I " ( » , • ^ v� � ` • � m ro s � � �: t z �x ` . . r � ` Fr'vcc w�vo N oy�7 � Z !� � _ ' ,_ ; � ^ I � �.. �-- �.... �N � � I � . • . � � ~ i � 6iTi+M.uoos sviW�� t •..;\ z � ��.,� �. N z � , • � o� � � � � � �-' � i IG L � �, ; �„� A� v� 0�c� .� Qe .o � w—�• '�bv � � � • O • 1 . _ V � — _ ._. _ �Cicl /iA�rT'iN� _... � _ p � \ � � • � �...�_ = � n J, m i � ^`� �` n � � .•\: d � r A{ � J� � m P� � I � yn � o .- r � J�� ..' -�t . � ` � � \ �. z � .o � �, . I} � a' D .� o, ?- '° „ p �t ! � p � � � � � ��W (1 A n � � = D I �� . � � C � �( I I ..�ra � r r i i O �r � O � n cS(- D � � --! f — _ N _ �D � �° ~ .... _ � ..� � ^ _ o , -� I `^ _ . _. � � N N � � -�- � �Q-- —3 � � � � � � � � � � � � � � tn riJ r,� ,- -9 -( C r' a � Tr p �,�-- _� � r' p rn • �1 D i. � v � yo Z v ... -� tl Cl O _D ( � "� � ^� ' , • � ,� ,:.; r i :` =7 � ' � � N � ._ '=� � s � N O j �' � � � � � � o i ; . o � � I � C � '� � �- � � �� rn �" ' � n J�`- . � � � � �� _� rJr�� \ Z.., �. �.--i �• - Ci. . Z � G� '�'� � � ` � � � � � ^R � � d � �v Q � ° i�'+v � �� " :F% n ; m � � cr � � ' �w�' � ;�� Cj ��: „q � 1 � � r �� .;� � � � r„ �j, a � � ,` :�; . . Tri � � � 4 •° ��- _k � i . �v' . a f'T1 ��c`� � � � �+ ` -o � �� d 'n , • , � �� t �.- N � N '� A � / � i-= y (l"If � �� V i 0 l__. � , . V r� I �► �w S�"• � . . . � . :, � .� f� r s�-rz� �s �� TY �,, CITY OF SAINT PAUL "a� '% OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK � ,, ., 0 , '».�' , �',� �° BUREAU OF RECORDS ... 386 City Hall,Saint Paul,Minnesota 55102 George Latimer 612-298-4231 Mayor .--- `� __ f ,r ;,, r �: � ;�. �_��, `� �; i 1� � � Z-. `P « ,...;,�-? �� f (�" :�� :� ' � � June 13, 1978 Planniag Staff, Zoning Section . Grace Building , St. Paul, Minnesota Dear Sir: The City Council today received an application of Mr. Leo Scheu bq his Attorney Bernard N. Litman requesting an interpretation concerning the location of a zoning district line for property on Randolph Avenue between Fulton and View and the matter was referred to the Zoning Staff for recommendation. Ve truly yours, �r�� Rose Mix City Clerk Attach. � ABO:dcr cc: Mr. Glenn Erickson, Zoning Administrator � -�� u � � �� ,, � :`; 197g »;�ttVG 8��►RD GIT��P Q uL�Mi�7n�,;:�:a �� jQ� � CITY OF ST. PAUL D�PARTMENT �F F�{VANCE AND MANAGfMENT SERVICES � ,"��,�,� ASSfSSMfNT DIVISi�N 713 CITY HAIL ST,PAUL,MINI�ESOTA 55102 August 18, 1978 File X2133, Page Zoning File 8316 The Council of the City of St. Paul will hold a public hearing in the Council Chambers of the City Hall and Court House (third floor) at 10:00 a.m. on August 31, 1978 on the: REQUEST of Leo Scheu for a Zoning District Boundary Interpretation affecting property on the north side of Randolph between Fulton and View and described as Lots 11 and 12, Slock 1, Rothschilds Addition. A favorable ruling would place Dannecker's parking lot • in a B-1 zone. If you would like further information about Chis hearing, contact the Curreirt Planni.no Section of the Planning Board, 421 Wabasha Street or telephone 298-4154. While the City Charter requires that we notify you of the heari.ng, we want to help you to learn fully about any improvement that could affect you o� your community. Therefore, I sincerely hope you can atL-end this :�earir_g, so that you can make your views about it known to the City Council, whether for or � against. - J. WILLIAM.DONOVAN VALUATION AND ASSESSMENT ENGINEER . ... ,... ,.-....�, ... . �y .=:.�d�.. .;�..M�.;a�.:r'{S!A�'U:��I�e$4F1�-�'�t��?�'��:�d�!4.'!�'!��'3.�„ie�.�r,.:�i�'�`J'�t,hi'yiliY.�° , r`�` r�.G•u.�. p . . !r�' �. i �;Y/'a�.;i rT� :;a:�...� . � .' . , . . . . . � � . - . . . . . . . . � .� ... ." , . . .. . . . . .. � ::�� . .•. _. . .� .. . . � . .� � . � ,� P . ,,. .� . . , . . ,. . , .. . � . . � ... � . � � �� Q. . .. . . . . . . . . . � �. . . ��r ��Tr o,, 7, CITY OF �AINT PAUI� � � DEPARTMENT QF PLANNING AND �CON4MIC D�VELQPMENT . O� '� . . . . . . . . . +� � ,. ,.�� DIV1510N OF PLANI�ING �•• 421 Wabasha Street,Saint Paul,Mi�nesota,55102 612-298�A151 George Latimer Mayo► Mr. Bernard N. Li:tman Attorney at Law 1p44 Minnesota Bldg. St. Paul , MN 55101 Dear Mr. Litman: Re: Zonin F'ile No. 8316 - leo A. Scheu oning D str�ct oun ary Interpretation Enclosed is a copy of tf►e City Council Resolution wF�ich interprets the zoning district boundary line six feet westerly of tfie tot li'ne separating Lot 11 and Lot 12, Block l , of Rothscfiilds Addition. Tfiis is in accordance with your request which was received June 15, 1978. Please note that this resolution only �'nterprets tFie locatl'on o� t[�e zoning district boundary between an RM-1 zone and a B-1 zone. Tfi�s reso�ut�`on d4es not in any way make legal any sale which would creat� a lot of less tfian 4a feet i'n width. Sale of any land in this area i's a separate questi�on and i'f your cli'ent intends to su6- divide or convey any lots sucFi ta6t a noncor�form�"ng lot will 6e created, please be advi sed that i t wi l l requi�re a var�,ance oP tFie s�tri�ct regul at�'ons of t�ie Zoning Ordinance for any sale to 6e legal. Enclosed is a copy of tf�e Board af Zon�'ng Appeals Rules of Procedure wbich describes the method for applying for a variance. �f ,you fiave an� furtfier questions, please contact me at 298-4154. Sincerely, Edward J. Warn Senior City P1 nner EDJ/da Enc. cc: City Attorney City Clerk Owner of 805 Randolph St. ��c� � - .. . sn w �� 7 F t7�a��r M� 7^ � � �u� r: tNw ,,� a�NwMGa ,, i ,' s f�= `��k�„��'�!i x��" -'� N�S�,�i��b. q �';�.r'•.;;t','�� r,"�t'��'�� S'`"K`,""•,�'�'r"� '�x � , 1 �y'�'�1Ni��1P�w'�EP�;;R�TMfi.NT.�,.. ��'`� �' ti`Rw.i,. W +!'.� 1 t� t -n�t�,fru! �?� � .�ak:5 yta .,� �� dr t4� �� i �'��, 1 � ��I:UE '►�.l�MAYQi��, 4� �� A i 5,xxys fi �-7�', X � .�gh ,�'�Y�`'` � i � ��.��y� q?C�� J�� t�� 4�.� � � a�,,�''�F�w � ,�tf"`" '� ��.�f �� 4.,in4 �f�`��k�'a� �;, ��1�� .?, .� ' 1`'i ��.��'�'.n�: O 7 � ,� �P .�.i � ��'r °a"} u !� i di.: f �i,� �n '�" r .. . � . � � ��I7�e�� .:��'�'+� F�xa1 t I '��R x.S T li'� , �'p� j�'�t pg�°A-��.+ ,' , , � '� } � � �n.t'�. ,��.�' 1., i" d"1{�A y,�'..�'. �[@$'�71f� �y � +� � � c,' � ��.r, �� ,i._r d� ��P ,�s � ! a' t. Y�� ', �.. . . ��e- ro•z {i�- � �� , ' , : �� ' .i� i . : . . - ..:� . . .� . � • r . ��: . � . � " �': � ,.� +. r � ' � . . . ,•�...� .r..,ei.� � � '� . �( '.:� ��'�. �d 7 ' Referred To .� �:�� ' ''r; .� t _ Out of Committee By _ .� •. � �.�� ,� „ ��At� � � � ,tE, .r � � � ;�: wLi�R�AS. l.eo �, �x ' c�t�=siaatiou ot tb� ��q� �' � ��` �� i'o�c a o! Lot 11, Slaak 1, Rath�ah,ild•s ,11�� b�� ' �� i` f� . . 60.�02(!� os the Svdia prdia�n �`�, ` �':` � �� ':. 9 ea�a� '+a►,�, �, �`��' �� r � ^�. M�. $aid S�ctioa i0.t@Z«,� p�''�M1� << . . � � +Mrittea sp�lieatian, � � �1� , , , oi� an in � '�� '�< �Iet Y � ac�aainq use d;,�,��,,�, �►,. �?��vlt ,.. . � �►accicc ot deta3,1, oz i].lo �'a�°�� ! � : • �. rtainlY. �tr�dicst3,onibD�� # `�� .� ,.r �►�'� aay diatri+at hawa�dar�.e�f � -�' ��° �' .,,, =� ��fop ' , w�718. Lao 11. � �`� � ,.; , . Sv�t�tt s �rtt �$ �a; �4� s�OiYd s••1 � � � agaa� aas a pas�cia,q 1�►t lG�ar a a� �'�' �967, and Mir. Se��e� sta�t�s tb�et !� �;+� 6 �i�w1�� of�,� �t�a�c' x.o�t lI i�u�s al�o ba�� naed As a �` �!'��'� � : Pawr� �' ,� �� :�� . Prior #o th� a�op�,an qu�,r ♦� . . , both Lots il aad lx wu+� san�d it� ��''� � alas�ili�tl��, clasaifiv�stio� �.a R!�-1 s aad '' � t�t �k sp��g �. �lta Couoaf l, ha�t�q �, : ba.viAg aop�i+c�tred �' �� t� :a1�+liaan� and ' th� s+e�ort o! �#,�t, �� R880�Vt�. s�t th� Conncil o;E ti�e �#tp o! Sa�t �anl, to tlas authozi'tY 9r+�ted it b� 6emtiatl 64.4�9��f� Q! tye ��ant ffne�aad��a �°""°� �� th+� .via� �ssi�, ye '� �r+� that th� boa� � t� aaa dooe '�Y ti�a for tl�e 8-1 s��eu�1� it�cl� the �ast 6 ��t ot Lot 3.1.; Bloc�t 1, �othaa�31d'a Ad�it3cui. ---- COUNCILMEN ' �'eas NayS Requested by Depa,rtment of: — � � (n Favor Hunt : � Qf -_ A gai ns t ,, By ----_ Showalter , Tedesco dopted by Council: Date �� ,� �� Form A ' pprov@d by ty.Att ne�r. j ertified Y�ssed by Council Secretary `� �� ,�1 By a By f, . �pr�ved by Mavor: Date �:F� � 5 '� A�' oved b y ,. " -�'---�_ R�', y Ma or for Submission to Couacil $y --T---____ —____- 4Y t � � 4y � . . , � . f 5 �. /�� 4 � b � /'� ��• �.'�� . `�k�� .. — � � � .. "'�a.►✓`� .i�� .s- � �� , "�} . . � . . , ;. � � � . 1 A .. �l .�' �� :t''$; . . :.. T[ S �.� �'' . . . ' .� � '',� i z� I '3N .. , . . . � / i '} 1 �� ` � . . .�. . l ' ��. L M1 � s �j ' , ,� t , / '. � \� � t �� ;, � ' , 1 �','� ' i f�'. `� �' � }�. f: - ,� . �, f� �; . . . , � . , _ r � . �� J / � y; `� _ � . .. - ' '� .. . - i�a � . �� . . .`,r ��. ; .f. � � " # � ' f, ; j � -,. - / ' � �� .�im� �5,� .�9"�`� �. ' .e 1 . ri' 4 . - ! . . � � . �� j.� � �. .l � �✓ � � � p� � . 7. � i' . � � < . . " ' - - � * £ �, ,� �,.��i„� ��Qf� �.3�� '�,,��c�. ` . �` y ';p ��i �'�,� '�� , � _ �' � , i: � 't`�+" �!^$�� ' � �' E. o �' � � � �� '. .�� ► C��!" '��3� �ii�� Aq�i'�M�d � +��i�it� s#'�� b�► 1t� �;�. � � ,�"Itot'�+�r,�r 8� �t. t•��en, �w��g at=:�at'�i�xp�f��r ,�,�. '� � ; �-; '3�It�� +�'� a ,�`d�sd�et !� �� +�t�i ��.br�#t�,� { �. ,.F � '1M��o� a�:�r: +r�.-�a aac��rr�:+�►�►s:an��i�trid ee,� � ��. '� �� it�'�-�fR.� . ; '�hM'�fl�;-�1��' �S �z , . � , . ,. , : , , �: 5 , � � - _, � � � . �: . � , � , .� � � - , � " �. �� . , . ; �; � . , Q��r �a%tai�r �she,' � ` �r �� ' � ,: '`' ,f � ' � . , . .. . r� / ' � {� . , * j/ ��, � ' � . � �..��/ \ .� � ' � �t�f� - / \' ,I1, � _ , � . .. � � . � �✓ I � ,.� `�� . . l' .. \ '-1 r^ �, � . ��r '�`��a .. _ . . � .t . � *4 ' .,, .�� ,.. � .�.. , . . � � '�, �/E� �'} i�-��OR� ��i�'��S�t��Q�' � � . , , �3 r.� � . �. � .: .�. ,�, 1 . ' � : k. � �, .. ' � � .f \ � t.� � 1I� �� ' ' F� , � � . . � � / � � t i .. ' ' . . ' . F� ' i . .. .�.f ,� :�� . � , �- � _ .. i � -� . . . f . �..-. _ - .� . _ -'' .�� . , . .�� . ' �*'� . t:� . . .. ... . . � � . � t` . �%, � . . . `� ' . . .. , � � - .. , � �+ :.� .�'� . / . .- � f F � ""�� . . � - � E � 1 ' Y � 1 / f {{ ...� . _ .. _ ' � _ °, � < • � , I . .<<� . . ( . �� ' . . ' . . � d 14 ��$.�' l � � � i . i �,.£,:_ . . . . . . . . .. . .. ... , � .. '4 .. . . . . , ......, ..� ,.a. i.. .. � . _.. � � • ' ~ '� � Office: 224•8941 Residence: 699-7597 BERNARD N. LITMAN ATTORNEY AT LAW 1044 Minnesota Building Saint Paul, Minnesota 55101 June 8, 1978 Honorable Members of the City Council of the City of Saint Paul C ity Hall St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 Gentlemen: Enclosed herewith is Application for Interpretation Concerning the location of a zoning district. Will you kindly refer this to the Cit.y Council f or further action. Very truly urs, ��- BERNARD N. LITMAN BNL:er EYic. � r {' , ^ � � ' r� ' � _-:� APPLICATION FOR INTERPRETATION CONCERNING THE LOCATION OF ZONING DISTRICT T0: THE HONORABLE MEMBERS OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUZ c/o City Clerk City Hall St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 Gentlemen: Tne undersigned is hereby respectfully requesting an interpretation as to the location of the North-South boundary line dividing the RM-1 district from the B-1 district between Randolph Avenue to the North line running in a Northerly direction to the alley dividing the block between Fulton Street and View Street. Your attention is called to the confusion which nas resulted from the location of this line for the following reasons: The undersigned is the owner in fee simple of Lot 12, Block 1, Rothscnild�s Subdivision of Part of Block 3�. of Stinson, Brown and Ramsey�s Addition to St. Paul� Minnesota. This lot may be found on the zoning map as being on Ra.ndolph Avenue between Fulton and View Streets approximately in the middle of the block. E�ca.mination of the zoning ma.p indicates that the lot is located in a B-1 use district for business purposes. The lot has been used as a parking lot for part of the facilities for Danneckers Super Market. The lot nas been used in this ma.nner for approximately nine years. Prior to the adoption of the existing zoning law on August 28, 1975, the lot was previously zoned for use in a commercial use district. For approxi.mately the same period of time the owner of Lot 11, Block 1, Rotnscnild�s Subdivision of Part of Block 3Lt, Stinson, Brown and Ramsey�s Addition to St. t'aul, which adjoins Lot 12 on the Westerly side, ha.s permitted the undersigned to utilize the easterly 6 feet of said I�ot 11 also as a part of the parking lot facility. During all of said times, all of the parking lot t'acility was zoned t'or commercial use. The present owner of Lot 11 also is the owner of the easterly 6 feet of Lot 10 of Block 1, Rothschild�s Subdivision of Yart of Block 34 of Stinson, Brown and :�amsey�s Addition to ,St. Yaul and it is contemplated that the present owner Danneckers Super Market, Inc. of said �,ot 11 would convey to the undersigned said easterly 6 feet of said I,ot 11 in order to retain that portion as part of the paxking lot facility. It appears that the South Ha1f of the block between Vi�w and Fulton on Randolph has been divided so that the part lying West of the line th.at runs through I�ot 11 is now rezoned from commercial to an RM-1 use district. Lot 11 and #,�e ea�°b:�'se�� yot 10 as presently constituted does not conform with the RM zoning for the reason that it does not contain 5,000 squa.re feet permitted for a single fami7.y dwelling nouse and does not conta.in 10,000 square feet permitted in connection with the RM classification. The line is so drawn as to be entirely on Lot 11. r � � `� • � . a. ' t I r T0: THE HONORABLE MENBERS OF THE PAGE 2. CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL The undersigned believes that when this line was drawn, the fact that the easterly b feet of Lot 11 was used for commercial purposes was unknown to any of the parties involved in redrafting the zoning laws. We also believe that a eommon sense construction would place that line at least 6 feet West of the easterly boundary line of Lot 11 so that the parking lot facility would not be confronted with ha.ving a 6 foot strip belonging to a different use district. Because of this uncer�ainty, the undersigned respectfully requests an interpreta.tion concerning the exa.et location of existing boundary lines pursuant to Section 60.402 of the zoning code of St. Paul, such interpretation to esta,blish the boundary line of said Lot 11. That no other property will be aft'ected by such interpretation. Respectfully submitted: <��X -�o L!i• � , ��-P�i�/ MR. LEO A. SCHE� 1793 Lilac Lane Mendota Heights, Minnesota. 55118 � . �� °�°�.�-, , BERNARD N. LIT�A'N � � ��--�� Attorney at Law -�-*� , 10lt1� Minnesota Building �� St. Paul, Minnesota 55101 � Y .�. . ,- . . � � i : , , . ,. . ► APPLICATION FOR INTERYRETATION CONCgtNING T� � LOCATION OF ZONING DISTRICT ! ► I T0: THE HONQRABLE MEMRERS QF T1� CITY COUNCIL � QF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL � c/o City Clerk � City Hall ' St. raul, Minnesota 55102 � � t Gentlemen: r . � Tne undersigned is nereby respectfully requesting an interpretation � as to the location of the North-South boundary line dividing the RM-1 district fram the B-•1 district between Randolpn Avenue to the North � line running in a Northerly direction to the alley dividing the block between Fulton Street and View Street. Your attention is called to the confusion which nas resulted fram the location of this line for the following reasons: The undersigned is the owner in fee si.m�le of Lot 12, B1ock 1, Rothscnild�s Subdivision of Part of Block 31t of Stinson, Bro�wn and Ramsey�s Addition to St. Paul, Minnesota. This lot may be found on the zoning map as being on Randolph Avenue between Fulton and View Streets approximately irr the middle of the block. F.xamination of the zoning map indicates that the lot is located in a B-1 use district for business purposes. The lot has been used as a parking lot f or part of the facilities for Danneckers Super A4arket. The lot nas been used in this manner for approximately nine years. Prior to the adoption of the existing zoning law on August 28, 1975, the lot was previously zoned for use in a commerci.al use district. For approximately the same period of time the owner oi' Lot 11, Block 1, Rotnscnild�s Subdivision of Yart of 31ock 34, Stinson, Brown and Ramsey�s Addition to St. t'aul, j,rhich adjoins Lot 12 on the Westerly 5ide, has permitted tne unders igned to utilize the easterly 6 feet of said Lot 11 also as a part of the parking lot facility. During all of said times, all of the parking lot 3"acility was zoned 2'or commercial use. The �resent own�x Q#' �,ot 11 also is the owner of tne easterly 6 feet of Lot 10 of Block l, Rothschild�s Subdivis ion of rart of Block 3�t of Stinson, Brown and Ra,msey�s Addition to St. Yaul and it is contemplated that the present awner Danneckers Super Nlarket, Inc. of said Lot 11 would convey to the undersigned said easterly 6 feet of said Lot 11 in order to retain that portion as part of the parking lot facility. It appears that the Sout�h Half of the block between Vi�w and Fulton on 13andolph has been divided so tha.t the part lying West of the line tnat runs through Lot 11 is now rezoned from commercial to an RM-1 use district. Lot 11 and the eaeter�y 6 ieet �of Lot 10 as presently constituted does not conform with the 1�I zoning for the reason that it does not contain 5,000 squa.re feet permitted for a single family dwelling house and does not contain 10,000 squa.re feet permitted in connection With the RM classif ication. The line is so drawn as to be entirely on Lot 11. ;p� r :,�: { � � � ; , !n� lC 'Ir� i!' ( �Yf �� ijj; �i..�i� � ,_ lyTL , L� Y h'Lrlie�ri�i`j tS�.;f`il;l� `x,int �'�,��, ., .. , . , . ;� • . .- , . *`�""`""�'�► � _ � .�,, . � T0: THE H�IORABLE MF.I�BERS OF THE PAGE 2. CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT rAUL Tne undersigned believes that when this line Was drawn� the fact that the easterly b feet of Lot 11 was used for commerci.al purposes was unknown to any of the paxties involved in redrafting the zoning laws. We also believe that a common sense construct'fon would place that line at least 6 feet West of the easterly boundary line of Lot 11 so that the parking lot facility Would not be confronted �it� having a 6 foot strip belonging to a different use district. Because of this uncertainty, the undersigned respectfully requests an interpretation concerning the exact location of existing boundary lines pursuant to Section 60.1t02 of the zoniqg code of St. Paul, such interpretation to establish tha boundary line of said Lot 11. That no other property will be afi'ected by such interpretation. Nespectfully submitted: � --�" �'��' _ �' -� ( ��-ut' Mft. LEO A. SCHED 1793 Lilac Lan�e Mendota Heights, Minnesota 55118 �� . � � . :-, :., ,�,` . .�. ..� , , . r � _�',�--t�-•._� BERATARD N. LI'1'!(A'N • 'r�:� � . ;' - ,`� Attorney at Law - '�: ..;, . � �....,_; . �.�.: . -_ . ,:�.. 1011l4 Minnesota Builditig � St. Paul, Minnesota 55101 .��°�e �� 'l r� � G�� ,L ,,� ��. ;, � `� f; 'rf; ;,�, ,., ��- �f�j; C/rY �Ulw ? t� jyT� •.�: .5�;;��/y'�F�;jr.•'., ;� 7 y { . • ` '!,� ` / '��: `�'�� . ,��';�� ' • • • I � • • • � � � � � � :�,,�., � � . , . � ` r , , � �� • • • � • • • • � • . �' �!� • . �,; � • : �.� �':7 • . , , . -. , . �• .1 • Dt7��i • • o -� �i,•�r �i • `:,� • • • !, • � J � • • • . • i • • � • • � . ' ., : , . � . ; ; � . . . _ . � , ao • • ,. � c•�, �, �cs� . • . . t' � ' � � �.� � . . • • • • • ! �'� • • • • , . • � . � �� Q�7 � , • . , . , � � . '' � � � • • �� M � • • • � • • • • • • • • • � • � �,� - - u � � � % �'-- ,� , � , , • � ' • e e • • � � • • • � � � �� u �� • • • • a . • . . .- -- � : , � . . . i i�s�;� • • • • • • • • • • • . • • • • • � • • • ' • • • � � � ,� � r�•l �' � • � ~ • - • .,= � • � . . . . . . . . . . . � . . . . . . . . le�.�� p � . .�. � � � . � • • �� • • • • • � s • • • • • � • � • • • • � � • • • • • • • �� , ,/' i_ �� • „ 't�'i _ - �� '�b � � �� . � �, .� . . . . . . . . . . . . . . � ' �� ' . . . . . . � �' .�� .9 ' , . . , i r. � '� / �1 • • • • • • • • • � • • • • • • • • � • • ,I� / '� • � � �'�� •� Z. � '� �� :D � •� ,,•• ^' ► � . . . . . . . . . . . . . �+ . . . . . .�, �,� e�. �, . . � � � � \ •�� .I�I:r L�� . " � ! " � � � � • � : • � � ' . i ♦ i/// � . ' • , ♦ r � 1 � t � i � � � � � :■ �.. .. • • � i � r • • � • . � . . �. � • • • ' . • � k