270629 WHITE - CI7V CLERK • COUI1C11 � ���
PINK - FINANCE GITY �OF SAINT PALTL �""�� ��
CANARV - DEPARTMENT
BLUE - MAYOR � Flle NO.
� -� uncil Resolution
Presented By
Referred To Committee: Date
Out of Committee By Date '
WHEREAS, "St. Paul Citizens for Huma.n Rights" is an organiza-
tion of gay men, lesbians, and others all of whom support human
rights for all persons regardless of sexual preference; and
WHEREAS, "St. Paul Citizens for Human Rights" has requested
an exemption for their members and contributors from the reporting
requirements of Chapter 382 of the St. Paul Legislative Code; and
WHEREAS, the reasons for which the exemption is requested is
set forth in a letter from their attorney, Scott F. Tilsen, which
is attached and tnade part of this resolution; and
WHEREAS, additional testimony was heard and affidavits pre-
sented at the License Committee on February 28, 1978; now, there-
fore, be it
, RESOLVED, by the Council of the City of Saint Paul that based
u�on the oral testimony, letters and affidavits a finding is ma.de
that there is a reasona.ble probability that disclosure would
expose some or all of the members of the "St. Pau1 Citizens for
Human Rights" to economic reprisals, loss of employment or threat
of physical coercion and that this has a restrictive effect on
their freedom of association; and, be it
FURTHER RESOLVED, that the "St. Paul Citizens for Human Rights"
is hereby exempted from the provisions of Chapter 382 of the St.
Paul Legislative Code which requires disclosure of identification
data of inembers and of each person whose contribution is worth
$5.00 or more and that all other provisions of Chapter 382 must be
adhered to in all respects by the "St. Paul Citizens for Human
Rights," and, be it
COUNCILMEN Requested by Department of:
Yeas Nays
[n Favor
_ __ Against BY --
Form Approved by City Attorney
Adopted by Council: Date
Certified Yassed by Council Secretary BY
By
Approved by iVlayor: Date _ Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
By _ _ ' BY
WHYTE — CI TV CLERK �� a
PINK — FINANCE
COUnCII �����;�
CANARV — DEPARTMENT G I TY OF SA I NT PAUL
BLUE — MAVOR File NO.
� ' Council Resolution
Presented By
Referred To Committee: Date
Out of Committee By Date
Page 2.
FURTHER RESOLVED, that this exemption is for the calendar
year 1978.
COUNCILMEN Requested by Department of:
Yeas Nays
Sutler �
Hozza [n Favor
Hunt �• � �
�evine � _ __ Against BY — —
Roedler
5�,��✓c-�,ter
Ts:ie�;-�
Adopte y Counci : Date — ��2 t978 Form Ap ro ed by City Attorney �
rtified ed by C cil SeFret ��
/'3•Q�
App o by Mavoc Date �A� 3 �g78 Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
BY - — BY
�u��►s�,�n ���1,�R 11 1978
,_��� I
. •
�
WHITE - C�TV CLERK
PINK - FINANCE G I TY OF .SA I NT PA lJ L COUflCIl �
CANARV - DEPARTMENT
BLUE - MAVOR File NO. I
����_ �� uncil Resolution �
Presented By ��`��
Referred To Committee: Date
Out of Committee Date
WHEREAS, t. Paul Citizens for Human Rights" is an organiza-
tion of gay men, lesbians, and others all of whom support human
rights for all p sons regardless of sexual preference, and
WHEREAS, "St. aul Citizens for Human Rights" has requested
an exemption for th 'r members and contributors from the reporting
requirements of Chap r 382 of the St. Paul Legislative Code,
and
WHEREAS, The reaso for which the exemption is requested is
set forth in a letter f ` their attorney, Scott F. Tilsen, which
is attached and made part, f this resolution, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, By the Counc'�. of the City of St. Paul that based
on these statements a findiri is ma.de that there is a reasonable
probability that disclosure v� ld expose some or all of the mem-
bers of the "St. Paul Citizens� or Human Rights" to economic re-
prisals, loss of employment or �� reat of physical coercien and
that this has a restrictive effe on their freedom of associa-
tion and be it further
RESOLVED, That the "St. Paul G�a izens for Human Rights" is '
hereby exempted from the pravisions '' Chapter 382 of the St. Paul '
Legislative Code which requires disc��o ure of iden tification data
of inembers and of each person whose cb.n ribution is worth $5.00
or more and that all other provisions b Chapter 382 must be
adhered to in all respects by the "St. 'Pa 1 Citizens for Human
Rights. "
- — • �
COUNCILMEN `
Yeas Nays Requested by Depart ent of:
Butler �
Hozza In Favor
Hunt
Levine _ __ Against BY ��
Roedler �
� Sylvester � '
Tedesco
Form Approved by City Attorney ;
Adopted by Council: Date — � !
Certified Passed by Council Secretary BY ;
By . �
Appro��ed by ;Vlayor: Date Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council j
gy BY �
;t� �.. ; .., .��:r��.�,.-a.-.�, ,�� � '
WHITE - CITV�CLERK �.y,_ ' � ��
.P.INK � - FINANCE � ` - � COIlIICll �
C�AP7ARV - DEPARTMENT GITY OF �AINT F��L � �
BLUE - MAVOR . F11E NO. -
�-.����;� y�F��-� un�il Resolution � -
�� �� �
Presented By _
5.
Referred To �" Committee: Date
, ,�
Out of Committee � Date
4
;�
�= 1�;� �it. gaa4l C�ti� !�e �s ��' #as sn +aa�udis�
� 'ts+o� att � aMat�, la�isnss au►d otr�a�'� al?► t�!' td�oie so�vs't � ,
�i+�i�ts fs�r a�l �as �d��rar +c� ,r�aa�1 ya�rl�rs�aw�s, aad
�, "ftt.�' a�tl �Cilis�s i�oar IIm�sa �t3+��s" �ta
�a �3+oa� l�oac #b�t � aa�! e�ats3b�al�►ss �ma #�r r�pawc#.3aq
b o� �oc .3s2 0� !�r St,. l�ct1 3.�gr3��at�.i�►�r t�od*�:
� ��
-� '
,�
t�s� � r�sr�i�s l+a�c �► th+� +aawpt#+Oa �s �� t�
� s�t � i�t t 1.�rtt�oc fi�3�' att�'�,� �� !. 'tfla�� �L3�►
is a�d a�d s�ds �+a� #�!s :a�alat�, ,a�r ��t� �r it� '
�
�� �► t� �� �# t� �itt o! St�.� �1 �t i�aMd
� � tnss� a�Ea#�ra�s a t#,�d i� �a�r l�at !1� is s s�so�Dt+� �
pe+e�#33l� #ia! Aia�3.oalasi� �s se�r ae� ai� � tl�r ar�
b�ucs a►� � '"�t� l�s1 C��fsw�ns �'�` � RlqqLts• fia► a�odao�i+a �
pc�an3�s,� �,�ass o! �i�� a�r �is�rat o� ph�r�s� �or�� a�t!
tb�at � �r a �s#ri�cr�l.� afl�t oa�e t6ei= � of a��abi�a�► .
t� a�sd br it L'�a��l�ac �
, �,
�tLtt�D, ?!lraat t'�we "!'t�« �� Cf �o►s' ��: �h�" #s °
� tmrtpt�l�ca� `t� p�cr��rlr3+a�r a��� �2 v� t�► �. �,t
�r �oda w�3�h r�a�c�s od! l�stt.it�oafi�,a�r �
a�' �ir�r� a�d oE � �so� � aora�;irib�tl� #s ��e►�r�t i3,��
�'n: _.: � tl�� sli ot�ie' �r'�,r�s LR�Cdtp�c . �� a�t bs
y _ � �S s1I s��tfi� � �S �'s�► �a� C�t�s�t �at,.�r�t
:,�t � -, :
, ,
:�
;,
COUNCILMEN Requested by Departm�nt of:
Yeas Nays
Butler
Hozza In Favor
Hunt
Levine Against BY
Roedler .
Sylvester
Tedesco :
Form Approved by City Attorney
Adopted by Council: ` Date .
Certified Passed by Council Secretary BY
sy �
Approved by Mayor: Date Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
�BY By
. y.��'. ;R . • �ITY O�+' ►5A3N� PAUL
. .'lA' f d 1�-"> > . y . .
y�• ,�
L � L OFFICE OF THE CIT`t' COIII�TGiL
� ��� �: ����
. � :� 1 �:� ���
;�� } , -_'y.. ,�=�� .
� - �` � Dat e : February 28, 1978
;
COM � ITTEE REP4RT
T0 : Soin# P�aul Ci�y Council
FRON1 � Commi�te� on L�GISLATZON
David Hozza , chairman, makes the foilov�ring .
report on C. F. �] Ordrna�ce
i.
Q Resolutfon .
� OthQr
"[� ("j'L,E : A resoluti on exempting the St. Paul `'it izens for
Human 1'�i�hts from certain disclosure requirements
in Chapter 382 of the Le�,isla�ive Code.
� .
The Le�LSlation L"ommittee, meetin� as a committee of
the whole, voted unanimously to approve the resolution
• grantin�; an exemption to the St. �aul Citizens -for
Human Rights, after making several amendments to the
resolution.
,
: (The vote iaas s ix in favor, none against ; Roedle� was al�sent �
� .
CITY HALL SEVEN7H FLOOR SAINT PAUL, MINNESUTA SSI02 -
' . . . "G��J . . ' - . � . � . � �� ..
rt ` �' ° � s" ,�'" :`�,^' v �- '�. .x `�! �r �•u�,� �� s,-a, ,� �y�'���,
_ _ �Y N .� L"�1at 5 '.¢�,A
�` � ��+�. �
k _'�-'a' `� � C � '��
T., � '�`,� S'{ h- �.; $'nte.� ,�ye� �''Y #'F
�� � � • � � ���� ��� � � .� S ����
rk�.' -� � � � ^� ` ,,�'�z �,.��. �.� '' ,�
y � . ..
.;y� . � Wilfl r � �: •� � }� 4� . ,y..
� -r � 'a, �. Y�
� 2 � ,f ,��� �
t .�'a� „� s ..n�` `�,� '� ~ '� r` -t � �,'°` u: wx.,-
' �� � � ff s,. �5�
�'� ., 'S i � ..� "}: :��.
� � -�'L� ��e��` - ��...�i'��"r��r r =2 �.t �;,, �!- .L
¢ ',' y� �.. �y �r"��""�t�
� �.. � 4 . )' ,-L� 'YS r d}n'C.'v'y�
y� �}� � S �� 4£ } _ i'^ y.�'
� y�?i�'ik���.� ' .>'c ` � �"' � k3 '.
�r� ��"+ .l. ''�.1 t �..em- dT t
� �� � 'r _y $�. ��q'� ,z�
e �g `'� 3 ��
����< �+'�.A �K� � �a 4 -��'r � �
� r � „�+ f� �, � �i. v r
,: �, . „ �. ^ ,
• ,. -.
m � i_ � <
, . ,.:. .�- '�
�`�+`_ �'i . z .t a.vt��,h
'� �� w'�c�+t z r
yK _ � a '�����:r � � '
i _" - �w�T*x ! ,,F '� `��'� �'�
� �# ` �� ��`���`�r ��:G�.�t� ' " `��"``� , ����
� ��i����'�r �,'�:� �.�;'.�`i�'a� �� �� �. � �F =t
°c, � `t ' �y tir ;� ,�.'� . � i - �
� �.�,� r���.� �'.�.A4r :_:a � � _ 1, ��,ai. _ ;�y �?,
�- � �
.
,�
� `�• ��c I. °�'�''��.�;� ,�, a i, �+. �, n r '�
'� - . � � � ', �-.
� ;�"�B� -��3E�'� y���C` .�G `�?� � -� :�'� ��
� :. i�` ` �i�,�rW.�:�� �-"�'`'i�.,� �� � k R�t ,�} �'�
�tT•f "s:�� '.'� f ,.�ia����� `� - 7 �� � h..� }`, .
��^ " ?�'" ` ����+!`��� W� ��� k ) 'Y$�iaa" � y�._
PN i� � r d �
� ����+t�����'�� � ��s _. �
4 r -_fi ' } Y' ��'�� � '�.
x ��='�t-���''�1��` �,s t •r ' y 4 � � � �rz� �k,�� ,i�,
f 1 '� � �. x ��.
t � ' , � .�'
£' _ n _ . .. _ � � �. } .. k �sr a � .� '
�� � +��,�.76.'�taa� �ww�. ��f � #E�Y�r�' � ,._..�� 6(�� � �'S. `vfi� !
� ,`��``�� � ,.�,�+�i, j � ��'��#�y��C +� �.� ���� � �My,�,. '� € �. � �� "���� e hY,;
'#�A�� �7 �PY. ���M�'�.� ��� LJ��.�l t A'r�y� � 3_ ..' _ � A `a�.
S 1 � � e? { `e l LS
t � ; � ' Z " dF•n`�:a�
� ��. ... Z . '
Y "t
� ( ., " ' v .'�� f ,"`^"-� : � 4 e+k,., , �%-,
�� , .._ � ', � E�1
��'`� �RIA�� � a�k�,,. ' ���� } � t �
$ ,�'� a#�
� � t t ' : x : �- s r > > � '
� � � . k � . ,: � k a #�` , t; , �}
} ,� e "�`
�'� �z , ����i+`i� �' 4 5:��J ��e�- �1�� u� ,��' '�� � � � �k� �' �
�� .� �*a �:� � ,
� _ � -
�,� , .- . - s
,� �` y y . , i 't�.. �` �` t� �;,�"�
.� � . ���l�� ��i' �� ��� ��1�.��� ���F�i�a ,��� � + �$��4�"�.��� ,� �s"4���� ��rRy�`3H.,`.
� ee��t���y'��'�: :�����.� ;,�.��� ai�r ���€�:, �`� ' :�� �,���s �� �� �� `
�> �� A ��, � � ���
�g � ���
�c�v�� y � �- � � ��g.
�� � ��fi' �'QiC��*T.��� �� �C`;�'s�► ������� f�� � � `� �`� �� �'��� 2 y.�. ''���
� .^ ���i������.'� �' � ����Y� �ii,� 5/� ��� �� t *k.�° �i.�'��a��+.�b ).ti+k�{a�'»�7�
"�``` ,r��rr���a.�ar,� �+���� +�� ;��1����rrer€t ±�r �t.�r���� °e�.� ��`���� ' ��''Y �'z r`s r : �$�}`.
� # 1` k-
,,¢,, .�... ?� , : : �`��R',�y?�a :��'��7� W�:
�� ° `. �r����r�•a.:� r ,;. . {� `��t i '���r"j4 �a '�,�'�,'�'�.'"�'�
�� �4 .' t ;� s .� ..,, � :� �_. ,=i� s�, �.�{ � �s.� x's>y ��t Y"�� '?`��.tp
� �-, ,l�' �..���r��.� �, �`#'�.'�$+�.::d't�" ;�3.���:��:� ';�'�� �'� ��i� a r �,��ix ���`"��,��
�`�.�� I�:�t #��.�`,��i� .�XQ:� ��i. �� ��� +��:.+Ei�� ��`� . �� .� ��r;kT Y"r .y�a�y���.�.�;
*' _ .�'��� ;��` �'�: ,�iE�� 8 �'�+�(�'`�&??��eb '�l��s�'��� �i��� � '�� '�z .' "u'��s�
�
�- � � � � s, a � � � .�, �.�,�P:
������ � �;���' ����� ��c' ��� �
s . �y�. ' � x � � r �
, „` "� �`°� ,� � � ��"�i
� �.k ����'�A��F�"� �}�tai '".�. +i��:���YIr���R� �,.����JY�� ^F�/t�S�,+��,V�'��^�� t ��,ss ^S � k "N. t -3
� �� #��+�/'w������ ����F�i"`�^'' ��,� :f�, .tZ��t ..r � .s ,�� l� ��.� '� �� � +�
A` d I,t;�n
�p�,, �y��fi �} ! . � .V �kM� '"�''�` R1„
�����"���w9�±..�+ '.��R'i� � ���?Q.A� �..� .` -L '+`.tw'4n .'k'+��}:>,�\ , ��c�n k'.�,.,�� ��4+��"` � ���`!�
_ i .�,� , � 'w -.>i t ��A X�k' �. �"
Y'_. � � ,.�, . .. �., -.,. . _ � ' 1 � $ ' ,� f : g ''�C: �'�
,y�j y� '} "� "•.��
�� �� �.+'�1�'R�'�?`�ra�::�.. � ..�- '�"�^���� �z�; � �p � � € #d��' f�3AFX;
i �`r� �{
�, 1G�/� �ir�"����'� � '� ��'�x � '�+# ��'.y � � :
f �. 4 �� E
��� � �• � °�'� �'1 ;��� � ��'� t M�� �� .� '�'�.rt ��
y �,.. : . ;� T � ..�.-�,�. �. z fi � `4 �
� � ����•j'JY+4�:�t�''�. , � �,..� - ' ; � � �
_ � � � � �' : �� � „�
� :..� W�8 ,�° 1�t��� �t# �`3� '� :.�A,�,� �� �� � � � . ` �� ����,' �t �
� .;�rp�e�.r ��i�`� �'t'k�' � '� �� � � �� fr , '� ���� '�� �
, a� , x F ;� � r� '��` r
Y
�a wy ,,. -�x �
: , "r �,a.��, v�,t
���s .�5. � t•:. h� 4"b '� F a Y � p��6
A . t Sy3 ,� � . '� � "� h� ',
� :,{ . t �,"�` Q ' -. Y„�y 3 i
W:.. } � y�' _ Y kc �t ,k k a,�, ,: j ; S q� .(`'T
•. r. � F b ,�y't O'� y,�t A`tU��
. v� . � "`� "�a.. .e.�.: .���.�x _.s�...,.. z............ . .... ... .... . . .s�:�.�. � , 3.J� �aa.4. , a .�.e.. „.3.�.t..�:'i....2� �.
_ � 4 Y
�.:
` ° .. _ '� �_:1,_Y„a v w 1.... . ... -:3'-_ ._ ,..�e._. .. . x.�, ..� . , ..z. _ „_ . ,_. . �.... . ..__ ' _