Loading...
01-1211Council File # p � _ \ y\\ :��::.�f iti;�i� CITY_ Presented By Refened To Committee: Date WHEREAS, Juan Rada dlbfa La Hacienda Restaurante applied for Malt On-Sale and Wine On-Sale licenses for the premises located at 2467 West 7`� Street; and 7 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 WHEREAS, the applicant was norified in writing on May 23, 2001 by the Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection that the applicant needed to submit 1) Liquor Liability Insurance, 2) a copy of a Property Lease/Purchase Agreement, Proof of Ownership or Bill of Sale, and 3) Federal and State Income Tas Returns for the past 3 years, 4) Site plan, and 5) a letter acknowledging requirement of food sales with beverage (malt and/or wine), in order for the license application to be processed; and WHEREAS, the applicant was sent a Notice Of Intent To Deny License Application by the City Attorney's Office, dated September 2Q 2001, for failing to submit the required docuxnentation; and WHEREAS, the necessary documentation has still not been received; now, therefore be it RESOLVED, that the Malt On-5ale and Wine On-Sale license application submitted by Juan Rada d/b/a La Hacienda Restaurante, for the premises at 2467 West 7"' Street is hereby denied for failing to submit the documentarion required for licensure. IZequested by Department of: Adoption Certified by Council Secretary ay �:..�� �- (�� Form Approved by City Attorn�� ( By: � � Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council BY� V \� c�- � F"�!. By: �_ 111 �iw -- �� — �1 / Approved by Mayor: Date RESOLUTION Green Sheet # I U 3�j00 SAINT PAUL, MINNE50TA ay: �j. j i �E� !/!/!�L Adopted by Council: Date o.p ."� 2-00� ��:- OFFICE oF LIEP Date: GREEN SHEET Roger Curtis, Director october il, 2ooi 266-9013 _ NO . 10 3 3 0 0 ��'� 1 BPARTt�NT DIR8CIDR 3 ITY COIINCIL � ZT4 ATTORNSY ITY Q.HRR xamaw� ust be on Council Agenda by: � ��' axxacrox ZN. & MGT. SVC. DIA. � ovember 7 2001 xox {ox usxsrairr) - OTAL # OR SIGNATQRS PAGSS 1 (CLIP ALL LOCATIOI3S FOR SIGP3ATiIRE} CTION REQUESTED: That the Malt On-Sale and Wine On-Sale license application ubmitted by Juan Rada d/b/a La Hacienda Restaurante, for the premises at 2467 West 7" Street be denied for failing to submit the documentation required for licensure. COMNISNDATIONS: APPROVE (A) OR REJHLT (R) BRSONAL 38&VICB CONTRACT3 DfU3T ANSii%R TH6 FOLLOSVIfiG: PLANNING COMMISSION CIVIL SERVICS COMMISSION 1. Has the person/fixm ever worked under a contract for this deparCment? CIH COMMITPES _ HUSINESS REVIEW COUNCZL YES NO STPFP _ Has this person/Eirm ever been a City employee? DISIRICT COVRT _ YES NO 3. Does this pexson/firm possess a skill not nozmally possessed by any PORTS WfiICH CoIIxCIL OBJSCTIVB? Current City employee? YBS NO lain all YBS aaewers on a separata sheec and attach. .INITIATING PROBLEM, ISSUE, OPPORTUNITY {Who, What, Tr7Y��en, Where, Why):The applicant as notified in writing on May 23, 2001 by LIEP that the applicant needed to submit roof of liquor liability insurance, a copy of a property lease/purchase agreement/proof of ownership or bill of sale, federal and state income tax returns £or the past three years, a site plan and a letter acknowledging requirement of food sales with beverage (malt and/or wine) in order for the license application to e pracessed. Mr. Rada failed to provide any of the above information. VANPAGES IF APPROVED: ISADVANPAGES IF APPROVED: ISADVANTAGES IF NO`P APPROVED: Malt and Wine On-Sale license applicants will no longer provide information to the city for determination as to whether or not they should receive their licenses. OTAL AMOUI3'P OF TRANSACTION S COSTjREVENUE BUDGETED YES NO FUNDING SOURCE ACTIVITY NUMBER FINANCIAL INFORMATION: (EXPLAIN) �' arch ��nt�P ! �, . / OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY Clayfon M. Ro6irsson, Jr., Ciry Attorney � \ ^�a.\\ CITY OF SAINT PAUL CtviZDivisian Norm Coleman, Mnyor 400 Ciry Hall Telephone: 651 26687f0 IiWesiKelloggBlvd. Facsimile:65l298-5619 Saint Pau1, Minnuota 55102 i October 10, 2001 NOTICE OF COUNCIL MEETING 7uan Rada La Hacienda Restaurante 2467 W. 7"' Street Saint Paul, Minnesota 55116 RE: Application for malt on-sale and wine on-sale licenses at 2467 W. 7` Street License ID #: 19980009120 Dear Mr. Rada: Please take notice that this matter has been set on the Consent Agenda for the Council meeting scheduled for 3:30 p.m., Wednesday, November 7, 2001 in the City Council Chambers, Third Floor, Saint Paul City Hall and Ramsey County Courthouse. Enclosed are copies of the proposed resolution and other documents which will be presented to the City Council for their consideration. This is an uncontested matter, in that the facts concerning your failure to submit the required documentation for the processing of your license application have not been denied. The recommendation of the license office will be for the denial oFyour license application. If you have any questions, please call me at 266-8710. Very truly yours, � �u�� �„�� Virginia� Palmer AssisYant Ciry Attorney cc: Nancy Anderson, Assistant Coimcil Secretary Christine Rozek, LIEP UNCONTESTED LICENSE MATTER � l -� 3-�\ Licensee Name: Address; Council Date: Juan Rada d/b/a La Hacienda Restaurante 2467 West 7"' Street November 7, 2001 Violation: Failure to submit the following documents required for Mait On-Safe and Wine On-Sale licensure: 1) Liquor Liability Insurance; 2) Copy of the Lease or Purchase Agreement, - Proof of Ownership or Bill of Sale; 3) Site Plan; 4) Federal and State Income Tax Returns for the past 3 years; 5) Letter acknowledging requirement of food sales with beverage (malt and/or wine). Place: 2467 West 7 Street - Proposed Licensed Premises Recommendation of Assistant City Attorney on behalf of client, Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection: Denial of License Application For Malt On-Sale and Wine On- Sale Licenses Attachments: 1. Proposed resolution 2. Notice of Intent to Deny License Application 3. License Information Report 4. Two 5/23/01 letters from Christine Rozek to applicant 5. licensing information CITY OF SAINT PAUL Norm Colemrsn, Mayor September 20, 2001 OFFIC' = THE CITY ATTOIL�IEY CfnyTOn �L„ _.obinson, Jn, CityAnorrtey civitDirision 400 Ciry Ka[l 15 ii'estKelloggBlvd Saint PneJ, .bfinnesoln 55l0? a, -��.�� Telephone: 651266-8710 Fncsimi[e: 651298-56l9 NOTICE OF INTENT TO DENY LICEIvSE APPLICATION Juan Rada La Hacienda Restaurante 2467 W. 7`" Street Saint Paul, Minnesota 55116 RE: Application for malt on-sale and wine on-sale licenses at 2467 W. 7` Street License ID #: 19980009120 Deat Mr. Rada: The Office of License Inspections and Environmental Protection (LIEP) has recommended denial of the application for the above-referenced licenses. The basis for the recommendation is as follows: On May 23, 2001, a letter was sent to you by the Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection advising you that your application for wine and malt on-sale licenses had been pending since February and the appiication «•as stiil incomplete. You were asked to submit a copy of your lease agreement or proof of ownership of the property, federal and state income taxes for the last three years, a site glan, liquor liability iasurance and a letter acknowledging the requirement of food sales with the sale of wine and beer. You were given until May 30, Z001 to submit the necessary information or withdraw your application. To date you have neither submitted the information nor withdrawn �•our application. If you do not dispute the above facts, please send me a letter with a statement to that effect. The matter will then be scheduled for a hearing before the Saint Paul City Council to determine what penalty, if any, to impose. You will have an opportunity to appear before the Council and make a statement on your own behal£ The recommendation from the licensin� office is for the denial of your license application. Page 2 Juan Rada September 20, 2001 D� -1��� On the other hand, if you wish to dispute the above facts, you are entitled to an evidentiary hearing before an administrative law jud�e. If you wish to have such a hearing, please send a letter stating that you are contesting the facts. You will then be sent a"Notice of Hearin�" with the date, time and place for the hearin�, the name of the administrative law jud�e, and an explanation of the procedures. In either case, please let me know in writing no later than Monday, October 1, 2001, how you would like to proceed. If you have not contacted me by Monday, October i, 2001, I will assume that you are not contesting the facts. I will then schedule this matter for the St. Paul City Council and have it place on the Consent Agenda during rvhich no public discussion is allowed and the recommended penalty will be imposed. If you have questions about these options, please feel free to contact me at 266-8710 to discuss them. Sincerely, �/ �-�� �� Virginia D. Palmer Assistant City Attorney cc: Christine Rozek, LIEP o � - �a.�� STATE OF MINNESOTA ) ) ss. COUNTY OF RAMSEY ) AE'FIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL JOANNE G. CLEMENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes and says that on September 24, 2001, she served the attached NOTICE OF INTENT TO DENY LICENSE APPLICATION on the following named person by placing a true and correct copy thereof in an envelope addressed as £ollows: Juan Rada La Hacienda Restaurante 2467 W. 7 Street St. Paul, MN. 55116 (which is the last known address o£ said person) depositing the same, with postage prepaid, in the UnitecLS.�ates mails at St. Paul, Minnesota. / \ _ . , G. Subscribed and sworn to before me o� -�a�� � � 0 x M W � N O { � N d U t4 � N O- N 9 � O C d � C O R � L M�. C d N C d u J N � � N U � J � r C N � N O E N � Q m F- C � � N C 7 U � J � � � O O N � O Q � j N {Z � I� O U � J � � N � N � N N = � � � Q 1� � (O c- N L� � H W � I � Q j � Z � U �; m Q ;o = I J � �� IZ 0 � c l a 4 � 7 V C 7 O V � N N � W N C N � E 7 Z U O � m U C � 3 N c d TI C � Ui C � �' C N � � � Z N � M O t N a �., y � N � N � C �� m � � � F- � � � � _ n � � N 0 d � a N 0 N� d � � � � � @ � c� � 3 � 0 �= J N � Q O N� O � � a m „ L in E .� a c� �� �� m U V N U ' �6 � f6 '6 � O p . a �c � a�� �c F m�� �'3� E� a� o y Q N a � y O y O N � ��m c� 52 ° � V N�� O�(6 � w,6 � J 6�9 . S, C � "6 . 0 � � C �p � � C N(6 V N E N U � fn �r �� C N p) '6 N E O ry � W_ � m r �� � �3 3 L p� U �a���� �0 3�Yw� ca�Na��a�id �_° a�-a�co ���a m c E o`o � m m a�-o� c_ o a� o w E V- .� m� � m'm V- (6 O� � V C C V C� t6 fl.it y'� T� Q �� N N{j, j� U U U U �� @ U V a �� N G N L L z d��aqr��� o(� � C � � N N�� W p� U O p � O O O 3 O�- Z Z� 00'00� � � N7��NN�p NN@N�m00� O '�p � � V N w V� N N dQ' N N � N �� O�� 6) Q 0 011� I� O. Q tn M .�- L O O4-. (000 (pC,) 00 ��- U C N �=� o�-�a�� � � 0 Q x M W O � p N � O d V N 0) J N a c 0 � O a � C O w � � L w L d N C N U J h J � � N p� N G � 'a V � J a m C O N � Q � F- N � � N � N � U J � � O O N O N e- s 'o E o �- � N z �, N � U p� _I � � m � N ~ N� N = "6 �- � � tD Qn.- � � N � � � F � W � N a N Z Z U m Q � _ J m � Q � O z � O a � U C 7 O U � d m � Q X lA1 C `m � � 7 Z U O Q � U C ( � y C d, � m� Z �� `I oi U� U� @ � N C N a � � Z N C � O � L N a �„ y � N � N � c J � m � I '� � ;� � i � I � V � � x h ti V N O 4� 0 3 N� 3 � C � E � G � G 3 m C O ;] N �O_ > > U7 a O N� O C G � t6 � L y � � N U -p a1 � d N N (6 (6 C N C c U' „ � (0 V V� (6"� - S pa O . Q ` C C� N d � C �".' m�° �'3� E= o� o t�n � d a � O N O N � � U� c c 2 0 C � c6 � p � p C u> U w Q� O�� C(6 � J fA C C S N N� N E� � O O U d U i CQW- N� p C� 47 'O d E O 47 � W'o �� � N N � 3 L ��— U ��o � v d� a�o 3�Yw d C�NN �� "�O�'O�(D a� ��a m c � c oa�pv,� oo��J�.�m p(0 O O � V C C V G E(0 Q.# U'� �� � i� N N Q� O V N N Z "��amrc�ic {p �� C � LL LL W o � . 3oy N� yo o� o0 0�- Zz O U� O O� O O� O L � �O�C" MP�'J CV w V� N N d� CV N"' N@ L O r V� N� O�� N 0 0 N U 0 0 ��-' U C N � N � � — \a.�� � � 0 X M � � N O M � N U � R 1 N a � 0 � 0 Q m � c O .� E L W c N C d � J � � � m � � � c�i � � � a N N � F - m N � c �O U � J j > � O N O � O � j N Z N O V p�i J � � N � �n ~ �� � -`o � Qn� �� N � � � H � w � N � �z N z W Q U m = � Q J � � Q m p Z O � d a � � U C 7 O U N a� m � a w m c s � 7 � U O a U c m � C � � ZI � [6 � 0 U U C [ � C d � � z N O M � N a M N � � � c � m � � � W � F � � � 2 � n � V N � � � d U y 3 d � c R � c � 'o � N�' V � N N C o �� � 3 L � w-� v�j � d O N� O p Uj C O �� � L y � - N U "6 p� � N N N (6 U N � (6'� U'� � � (6 - U. � . � � @ O Q t_ C C N N L L G � N��O Q3r � �� � ga� Uo ,� o y om 4 C � (n 4- � 0 C= � U� Q� O� m � W �� 6�4 C�'� N N� C E d � O 0 N� � C��"�O N V N Li.l - O � y � �� p> � ,'p � � L N 3 3 L O�= CJ °.�o y� � � � 0 3��t,� � C p- N N"6 N d L� '�6 �'6 C(D N a� - omc rn C� O d`� N E O O @� J �, 6 cD 0(0 O O`� � V C C U C E f0 O_# U'����_� ywfl.��VUU ' � (6 V a �� (6�Q N L.0 Z v'Q �HOJ ?� � �dmp�t�t�� oU . o a���W °a�i�0000 003o�"—'ZZ� O i, O p•.. 00'60 L� � N��(6NN�p NNCN�m00� Nw ��NN U R� NN � N�LOO� L U N��. O. Q ( 0 l6 � c- Efl O�� N 00 (�6U 00 E�- U C N.-!!� CI'TY OF SAIN'f PAUL Norm Coleman, Mayor Vfay 23, 2001 m 29980009I20 Suan Rada La Hacienda Restuarante 2402 Benson Ave St Paul VIlV 55116 OFr'ICH C; LICSIQSE, INSPSCTIONS AND E?`JVIRONMENT,aL PROTEC?':ON Tj \ — \?.\l Roger Czvtis, Director JAWRYPROFESSIONALBUILDING Zetephons: 65i-?66-9090 350 SG Peter Streel, Suite 300 Fao'imile: 651-166-9l24 Saint Pm�l, Minnuat¢ 5�102-I510 Web: www cistpauLmn.us/lie� Re: New License Application at 2467 7`� S�eet West Dear Applicant: Our records indicate that your license application #19980009120 for malt and wine on sale has been pending in our o�ce since Februazy. At this time, your business license has not been issued because the following requirements have not been met: • Copy of your Properry Lease/Purchase Agreement, Proof of Ownership or Bill of Sale • Federal and State Income Tax Returns for the past 3 yeazs • Liquar Liability Insuzance ' • Site plan • Letter aclrnowledging requirement of food sales with beverage (malt and/or wine) If you are selling beer and/or wine, you are doing so without a valid City of Saint Paul license and will be subject to adverse acfion and penalries. Please let us lmow, in writing, before Wednesday, May 30, 2001 whether or not you intend to continue with this application or wish to permanendy withdraw. After Wednesday, May 30, this office will begin the administrative hearing process to deny your license request. You have the opportunity to appeal the City's decision through this proceeding. If you have any questions regazding this acrion, please contact Corinne at (651) 266-9106. Sincere� , � �. �� Christine A. Rozek LIEP Deputy Director :C�7\:7t�7 OFFICE Gr' LICE?YSE, INSPECTTONS AA*D E�ii VIROi�IMENTAL PROTECI'fON � �_���� Roger Cunis, Director CITY OF SAINT PAUL Nam Coleman, Mayar LOWRYPROFESSION�ILBUILDING Telephone: 65Z-?66-9090 350 St. Puer Street, Suite 300 Facsimile: 65b266-9124 Saint P¢ul, Minnerot¢ i5101-I570 Web: wknv.cistpauLmrt.us/liep Mazch 23, 2001 19980009120 Juan Rada La Hacienda Restaurante 2402 Benson Ave St Paul MN 55116 Re: New License Application at 2467 7`� Street West Deaz Applicant: This letter is to formally norify you of documentarion our o�ce still requires in order to complete your application. Your license application for Malt On Sale (Strong) and Wine On Sale license located at 2467 7`� Street West can not be processed until our office receives the following: • Copy of your Properry Lease/Purchase Agreement, Proof of Ownership or Bill of Sale • Federal and State Income Tas Returns for the past 3 years • Liquor Liability Insurance • Letter aclmowledging requirement of food sales with beverage (Vlalt and/or Wine) • Site plan Insurance certificates, lease agreemeats/Bill of Sale, site plans, Articles of Incorporation, signed condition affidavits, and lists may be faxed to our affice at (651) 266-9124. A self- addressed City of Saint Paul envelope is also enclosed for your convenience. We must obtain the required paperwork/payment before we can complete processing your application. At this t3me, your license has not been issued; therefore, you are not authorized to serve Malt or Wine in the City of Saint Paul. You will not receive your license until all information and/or payments aze received in our office. If you have any questions, please contact Corinne at (651) 266-9106. Sincerely, l�i�Z� �. J� Chrisrine A. Rozek � LIEP Deputy Director CAR/caa licensg Group Comments Text licensee: �UAN RADA DBA: Lp HACIENDA RESTAURANTE License#: �ggg0008120 07/2S/2001 OS-\a\\ 07/28/2007 To CAO for adverse adioo. CAR 07f28Y2001 Documents never received for wine and beer application. LIEP recommends denial of the pending application. CAR 05/232007 letter sent for requirements not met. caa 03232001 letter sent for dowmentation stiil required for new maft and wine app. pa 17/2�/2000 Per Juan Rada who came into our office, he wants to change his DBA from Latin Lover to La Hacienda Restaurente, nothing else has changed. KRD 2-10-00 NSF check paid in fuII.ES 7-11-00 NSF check #7696 rec'd for 5450.00. Total amount due is $465.00.ES ��� .�(\r,'t;o �uo�-c.�- (�J � `t� C�� (�,�.c�;.�., �' �-r� O \ - \a\\ Atltlress � ��see, CoMac[ � L'cense ( Cartlholder, � Type' C� property (� Liceitsee t' LMofficial t' AIl �treet tl 467 Street Name' TH StreM Type: <Alb "'" Direahort Wib �v UnR#: r Cdy <Allx ; _fud�J�;a` ?'�.,`:: ��p _i"X:-y�,=,''. �.'.`' "-'`''�a'h �:"r}c'. vre.;. ,4'� '�af ���P: � Res[eurerRCB)-moACtrvs 4censeFrrcAed 12R317945 12R3R0012487 JNneOnSele fPendng _ _�04720R�Q7 04R020022467 � � -\�\\ , r , ��d. �`� �""�'. A"a iE�+' �censee�luMlRaon — stre '�� �°� �'�� �� DBA AHAqENDARESTAURA13iE - Stre Licenu � Licensee , Lic. TVPes � Inwrance l BaM , RequiremerSS l SYre r Propedy (` Licensee t' Unofficial 7mjeG FadldffiOr. ASUNCION, CORP➢ilE Dire� Street #: 467 Ativerse Adion Comm � Street Name TFI C Street TYPe: ST Dvection /V — ' Undlnt. �— UndF: �-- , Cdy. T PAUL License G roup �ommeMs ; 5[ffie: � Lp: 5511 fi 523f1001 letter serd for reqwremeMS not met cae � � 323R001 IetteY serG for tlocumentation still requiretl for �g�� ew malt anC wine apP. caa � Dist Ccuncl: r 1 R7 f1000 Per Juen Ratla who came irito our oftice, he — __ ertstoc t ; Licensee: AN RADA Licensee 721(1000 Per Juan ftatle wha came irRO our � DBA A HALIENDA RESTAUftANTE ���� fice. he werdsto chenge his DBA from - ���=�? � Sales Tax Itl: 561978 Bus Phone: 651) 6993213 �n Laverta Le flacientla Restaurarrte, - �+.aoanee.q.e e.r van ;� £ � 7 � - �.. � � �: MaR On Sale (SYrongJ , C � 04R0f2007 7 0420f1002 N� $445 00( i Restaurarrt(B)-morethanl2seats R ��2/23n998 � 1223R007 �N � $4`..0.00� � . _' " _'___ ' " ,�, ' � Nhne On Sale C = 041102001 : 04202002 N $i �385A� J � '- '_'_'_"-_"'_'__"___'_ """ ' ;License# 80008720 SeveChenaestoF+NOrv1J �–ra�. : .��.��1 r.x<r��_y 2d67 ... <.e � ..... V,��,ga� .-�_ o�-�a�� - TYPf R��tl �tyg¢�,�°P���8��7�':) u�r.iac�Nuv��vwa Stre. DBA A HACIENDA RE< Stre ��cense Ucensee � Lic. Types � Insurence l Bantl � RequiremerAS l SIre Licensee Neme' UAN R4DA Dire� DBA' A HAGENDA RESTAUR4NTE Unrt Sales Tax Itl 567978 NorvProfR r Worker's Comp: ONOi9000 AA CoMrac[ Rec'tl� Or00N000 AA Training Rec'd Oi00ii)000 � M1Y eSA Fee CNlectetl ONOA7000 Discourrt Rec'd r _�' . Pr6�sM{.�, Qther A enc l�censes Fnar�crel F1old Reasons �Jtie�l R��k°': -�-, "p t '"y�' �z.._i[ct`rve Dele „ � NSF N 01111R000 To " 1?1231f JUAN BUSINES: JUkN MARING _ ____� JUAN _ , ^ �HOME PS �..c; ,R 4 �p' tl -(4� i a"� e Nig» vt x ^?"}� �� . e .! �5..'`� r '�.� µ N� 't x�ti„k q ffi�. ���[QAFSY�fw�!['��� . Save Chenges to Hisiory r' -Meil License Ta: — ����'��' !: Meil To CoMact i3213 ; C License Adtlress „_ N _ r �Mail Invoice To: — -� C•� Maii To CoMaet ;,p.,t,,:a�+�:� � �' Licerise Atldress -` ' BeckgrowH Check Required � i 'License# 80009120 <� �,� ' .—r...--.. -;� � .,::.: 3 Rems Found � ?Qb'7 7 2467 7' � Council File # p � _ \ y\\ :��::.�f iti;�i� CITY_ Presented By Refened To Committee: Date WHEREAS, Juan Rada dlbfa La Hacienda Restaurante applied for Malt On-Sale and Wine On-Sale licenses for the premises located at 2467 West 7`� Street; and 7 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 WHEREAS, the applicant was norified in writing on May 23, 2001 by the Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection that the applicant needed to submit 1) Liquor Liability Insurance, 2) a copy of a Property Lease/Purchase Agreement, Proof of Ownership or Bill of Sale, and 3) Federal and State Income Tas Returns for the past 3 years, 4) Site plan, and 5) a letter acknowledging requirement of food sales with beverage (malt and/or wine), in order for the license application to be processed; and WHEREAS, the applicant was sent a Notice Of Intent To Deny License Application by the City Attorney's Office, dated September 2Q 2001, for failing to submit the required docuxnentation; and WHEREAS, the necessary documentation has still not been received; now, therefore be it RESOLVED, that the Malt On-5ale and Wine On-Sale license application submitted by Juan Rada d/b/a La Hacienda Restaurante, for the premises at 2467 West 7"' Street is hereby denied for failing to submit the documentarion required for licensure. IZequested by Department of: Adoption Certified by Council Secretary ay �:..�� �- (�� Form Approved by City Attorn�� ( By: � � Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council BY� V \� c�- � F"�!. By: �_ 111 �iw -- �� — �1 / Approved by Mayor: Date RESOLUTION Green Sheet # I U 3�j00 SAINT PAUL, MINNE50TA ay: �j. j i �E� !/!/!�L Adopted by Council: Date o.p ."� 2-00� ��:- OFFICE oF LIEP Date: GREEN SHEET Roger Curtis, Director october il, 2ooi 266-9013 _ NO . 10 3 3 0 0 ��'� 1 BPARTt�NT DIR8CIDR 3 ITY COIINCIL � ZT4 ATTORNSY ITY Q.HRR xamaw� ust be on Council Agenda by: � ��' axxacrox ZN. & MGT. SVC. DIA. � ovember 7 2001 xox {ox usxsrairr) - OTAL # OR SIGNATQRS PAGSS 1 (CLIP ALL LOCATIOI3S FOR SIGP3ATiIRE} CTION REQUESTED: That the Malt On-Sale and Wine On-Sale license application ubmitted by Juan Rada d/b/a La Hacienda Restaurante, for the premises at 2467 West 7" Street be denied for failing to submit the documentation required for licensure. COMNISNDATIONS: APPROVE (A) OR REJHLT (R) BRSONAL 38&VICB CONTRACT3 DfU3T ANSii%R TH6 FOLLOSVIfiG: PLANNING COMMISSION CIVIL SERVICS COMMISSION 1. Has the person/fixm ever worked under a contract for this deparCment? CIH COMMITPES _ HUSINESS REVIEW COUNCZL YES NO STPFP _ Has this person/Eirm ever been a City employee? DISIRICT COVRT _ YES NO 3. Does this pexson/firm possess a skill not nozmally possessed by any PORTS WfiICH CoIIxCIL OBJSCTIVB? Current City employee? YBS NO lain all YBS aaewers on a separata sheec and attach. .INITIATING PROBLEM, ISSUE, OPPORTUNITY {Who, What, Tr7Y��en, Where, Why):The applicant as notified in writing on May 23, 2001 by LIEP that the applicant needed to submit roof of liquor liability insurance, a copy of a property lease/purchase agreement/proof of ownership or bill of sale, federal and state income tax returns £or the past three years, a site plan and a letter acknowledging requirement of food sales with beverage (malt and/or wine) in order for the license application to e pracessed. Mr. Rada failed to provide any of the above information. VANPAGES IF APPROVED: ISADVANPAGES IF APPROVED: ISADVANTAGES IF NO`P APPROVED: Malt and Wine On-Sale license applicants will no longer provide information to the city for determination as to whether or not they should receive their licenses. OTAL AMOUI3'P OF TRANSACTION S COSTjREVENUE BUDGETED YES NO FUNDING SOURCE ACTIVITY NUMBER FINANCIAL INFORMATION: (EXPLAIN) �' arch ��nt�P ! �, . / OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY Clayfon M. Ro6irsson, Jr., Ciry Attorney � \ ^�a.\\ CITY OF SAINT PAUL CtviZDivisian Norm Coleman, Mnyor 400 Ciry Hall Telephone: 651 26687f0 IiWesiKelloggBlvd. Facsimile:65l298-5619 Saint Pau1, Minnuota 55102 i October 10, 2001 NOTICE OF COUNCIL MEETING 7uan Rada La Hacienda Restaurante 2467 W. 7"' Street Saint Paul, Minnesota 55116 RE: Application for malt on-sale and wine on-sale licenses at 2467 W. 7` Street License ID #: 19980009120 Dear Mr. Rada: Please take notice that this matter has been set on the Consent Agenda for the Council meeting scheduled for 3:30 p.m., Wednesday, November 7, 2001 in the City Council Chambers, Third Floor, Saint Paul City Hall and Ramsey County Courthouse. Enclosed are copies of the proposed resolution and other documents which will be presented to the City Council for their consideration. This is an uncontested matter, in that the facts concerning your failure to submit the required documentation for the processing of your license application have not been denied. The recommendation of the license office will be for the denial oFyour license application. If you have any questions, please call me at 266-8710. Very truly yours, � �u�� �„�� Virginia� Palmer AssisYant Ciry Attorney cc: Nancy Anderson, Assistant Coimcil Secretary Christine Rozek, LIEP UNCONTESTED LICENSE MATTER � l -� 3-�\ Licensee Name: Address; Council Date: Juan Rada d/b/a La Hacienda Restaurante 2467 West 7"' Street November 7, 2001 Violation: Failure to submit the following documents required for Mait On-Safe and Wine On-Sale licensure: 1) Liquor Liability Insurance; 2) Copy of the Lease or Purchase Agreement, - Proof of Ownership or Bill of Sale; 3) Site Plan; 4) Federal and State Income Tax Returns for the past 3 years; 5) Letter acknowledging requirement of food sales with beverage (malt and/or wine). Place: 2467 West 7 Street - Proposed Licensed Premises Recommendation of Assistant City Attorney on behalf of client, Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection: Denial of License Application For Malt On-Sale and Wine On- Sale Licenses Attachments: 1. Proposed resolution 2. Notice of Intent to Deny License Application 3. License Information Report 4. Two 5/23/01 letters from Christine Rozek to applicant 5. licensing information CITY OF SAINT PAUL Norm Colemrsn, Mayor September 20, 2001 OFFIC' = THE CITY ATTOIL�IEY CfnyTOn �L„ _.obinson, Jn, CityAnorrtey civitDirision 400 Ciry Ka[l 15 ii'estKelloggBlvd Saint PneJ, .bfinnesoln 55l0? a, -��.�� Telephone: 651266-8710 Fncsimi[e: 651298-56l9 NOTICE OF INTENT TO DENY LICEIvSE APPLICATION Juan Rada La Hacienda Restaurante 2467 W. 7`" Street Saint Paul, Minnesota 55116 RE: Application for malt on-sale and wine on-sale licenses at 2467 W. 7` Street License ID #: 19980009120 Deat Mr. Rada: The Office of License Inspections and Environmental Protection (LIEP) has recommended denial of the application for the above-referenced licenses. The basis for the recommendation is as follows: On May 23, 2001, a letter was sent to you by the Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection advising you that your application for wine and malt on-sale licenses had been pending since February and the appiication «•as stiil incomplete. You were asked to submit a copy of your lease agreement or proof of ownership of the property, federal and state income taxes for the last three years, a site glan, liquor liability iasurance and a letter acknowledging the requirement of food sales with the sale of wine and beer. You were given until May 30, Z001 to submit the necessary information or withdraw your application. To date you have neither submitted the information nor withdrawn �•our application. If you do not dispute the above facts, please send me a letter with a statement to that effect. The matter will then be scheduled for a hearing before the Saint Paul City Council to determine what penalty, if any, to impose. You will have an opportunity to appear before the Council and make a statement on your own behal£ The recommendation from the licensin� office is for the denial of your license application. Page 2 Juan Rada September 20, 2001 D� -1��� On the other hand, if you wish to dispute the above facts, you are entitled to an evidentiary hearing before an administrative law jud�e. If you wish to have such a hearing, please send a letter stating that you are contesting the facts. You will then be sent a"Notice of Hearin�" with the date, time and place for the hearin�, the name of the administrative law jud�e, and an explanation of the procedures. In either case, please let me know in writing no later than Monday, October 1, 2001, how you would like to proceed. If you have not contacted me by Monday, October i, 2001, I will assume that you are not contesting the facts. I will then schedule this matter for the St. Paul City Council and have it place on the Consent Agenda during rvhich no public discussion is allowed and the recommended penalty will be imposed. If you have questions about these options, please feel free to contact me at 266-8710 to discuss them. Sincerely, �/ �-�� �� Virginia D. Palmer Assistant City Attorney cc: Christine Rozek, LIEP o � - �a.�� STATE OF MINNESOTA ) ) ss. COUNTY OF RAMSEY ) AE'FIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL JOANNE G. CLEMENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes and says that on September 24, 2001, she served the attached NOTICE OF INTENT TO DENY LICENSE APPLICATION on the following named person by placing a true and correct copy thereof in an envelope addressed as £ollows: Juan Rada La Hacienda Restaurante 2467 W. 7 Street St. Paul, MN. 55116 (which is the last known address o£ said person) depositing the same, with postage prepaid, in the UnitecLS.�ates mails at St. Paul, Minnesota. / \ _ . , G. Subscribed and sworn to before me o� -�a�� � � 0 x M W � N O { � N d U t4 � N O- N 9 � O C d � C O R � L M�. C d N C d u J N � � N U � J � r C N � N O E N � Q m F- C � � N C 7 U � J � � � O O N � O Q � j N {Z � I� O U � J � � N � N � N N = � � � Q 1� � (O c- N L� � H W � I � Q j � Z � U �; m Q ;o = I J � �� IZ 0 � c l a 4 � 7 V C 7 O V � N N � W N C N � E 7 Z U O � m U C � 3 N c d TI C � Ui C � �' C N � � � Z N � M O t N a �., y � N � N � C �� m � � � F- � � � � _ n � � N 0 d � a N 0 N� d � � � � � @ � c� � 3 � 0 �= J N � Q O N� O � � a m „ L in E .� a c� �� �� m U V N U ' �6 � f6 '6 � O p . a �c � a�� �c F m�� �'3� E� a� o y Q N a � y O y O N � ��m c� 52 ° � V N�� O�(6 � w,6 � J 6�9 . S, C � "6 . 0 � � C �p � � C N(6 V N E N U � fn �r �� C N p) '6 N E O ry � W_ � m r �� � �3 3 L p� U �a���� �0 3�Yw� ca�Na��a�id �_° a�-a�co ���a m c E o`o � m m a�-o� c_ o a� o w E V- .� m� � m'm V- (6 O� � V C C V C� t6 fl.it y'� T� Q �� N N{j, j� U U U U �� @ U V a �� N G N L L z d��aqr��� o(� � C � � N N�� W p� U O p � O O O 3 O�- Z Z� 00'00� � � N7��NN�p NN@N�m00� O '�p � � V N w V� N N dQ' N N � N �� O�� 6) Q 0 011� I� O. Q tn M .�- L O O4-. (000 (pC,) 00 ��- U C N �=� o�-�a�� � � 0 Q x M W O � p N � O d V N 0) J N a c 0 � O a � C O w � � L w L d N C N U J h J � � N p� N G � 'a V � J a m C O N � Q � F- N � � N � N � U J � � O O N O N e- s 'o E o �- � N z �, N � U p� _I � � m � N ~ N� N = "6 �- � � tD Qn.- � � N � � � F � W � N a N Z Z U m Q � _ J m � Q � O z � O a � U C 7 O U � d m � Q X lA1 C `m � � 7 Z U O Q � U C ( � y C d, � m� Z �� `I oi U� U� @ � N C N a � � Z N C � O � L N a �„ y � N � N � c J � m � I '� � ;� � i � I � V � � x h ti V N O 4� 0 3 N� 3 � C � E � G � G 3 m C O ;] N �O_ > > U7 a O N� O C G � t6 � L y � � N U -p a1 � d N N (6 (6 C N C c U' „ � (0 V V� (6"� - S pa O . Q ` C C� N d � C �".' m�° �'3� E= o� o t�n � d a � O N O N � � U� c c 2 0 C � c6 � p � p C u> U w Q� O�� C(6 � J fA C C S N N� N E� � O O U d U i CQW- N� p C� 47 'O d E O 47 � W'o �� � N N � 3 L ��— U ��o � v d� a�o 3�Yw d C�NN �� "�O�'O�(D a� ��a m c � c oa�pv,� oo��J�.�m p(0 O O � V C C V G E(0 Q.# U'� �� � i� N N Q� O V N N Z "��amrc�ic {p �� C � LL LL W o � . 3oy N� yo o� o0 0�- Zz O U� O O� O O� O L � �O�C" MP�'J CV w V� N N d� CV N"' N@ L O r V� N� O�� N 0 0 N U 0 0 ��-' U C N � N � � — \a.�� � � 0 X M � � N O M � N U � R 1 N a � 0 � 0 Q m � c O .� E L W c N C d � J � � � m � � � c�i � � � a N N � F - m N � c �O U � J j > � O N O � O � j N Z N O V p�i J � � N � �n ~ �� � -`o � Qn� �� N � � � H � w � N � �z N z W Q U m = � Q J � � Q m p Z O � d a � � U C 7 O U N a� m � a w m c s � 7 � U O a U c m � C � � ZI � [6 � 0 U U C [ � C d � � z N O M � N a M N � � � c � m � � � W � F � � � 2 � n � V N � � � d U y 3 d � c R � c � 'o � N�' V � N N C o �� � 3 L � w-� v�j � d O N� O p Uj C O �� � L y � - N U "6 p� � N N N (6 U N � (6'� U'� � � (6 - U. � . � � @ O Q t_ C C N N L L G � N��O Q3r � �� � ga� Uo ,� o y om 4 C � (n 4- � 0 C= � U� Q� O� m � W �� 6�4 C�'� N N� C E d � O 0 N� � C��"�O N V N Li.l - O � y � �� p> � ,'p � � L N 3 3 L O�= CJ °.�o y� � � � 0 3��t,� � C p- N N"6 N d L� '�6 �'6 C(D N a� - omc rn C� O d`� N E O O @� J �, 6 cD 0(0 O O`� � V C C U C E f0 O_# U'����_� ywfl.��VUU ' � (6 V a �� (6�Q N L.0 Z v'Q �HOJ ?� � �dmp�t�t�� oU . o a���W °a�i�0000 003o�"—'ZZ� O i, O p•.. 00'60 L� � N��(6NN�p NNCN�m00� Nw ��NN U R� NN � N�LOO� L U N��. O. Q ( 0 l6 � c- Efl O�� N 00 (�6U 00 E�- U C N.-!!� CI'TY OF SAIN'f PAUL Norm Coleman, Mayor Vfay 23, 2001 m 29980009I20 Suan Rada La Hacienda Restuarante 2402 Benson Ave St Paul VIlV 55116 OFr'ICH C; LICSIQSE, INSPSCTIONS AND E?`JVIRONMENT,aL PROTEC?':ON Tj \ — \?.\l Roger Czvtis, Director JAWRYPROFESSIONALBUILDING Zetephons: 65i-?66-9090 350 SG Peter Streel, Suite 300 Fao'imile: 651-166-9l24 Saint Pm�l, Minnuat¢ 5�102-I510 Web: www cistpauLmn.us/lie� Re: New License Application at 2467 7`� S�eet West Dear Applicant: Our records indicate that your license application #19980009120 for malt and wine on sale has been pending in our o�ce since Februazy. At this time, your business license has not been issued because the following requirements have not been met: • Copy of your Properry Lease/Purchase Agreement, Proof of Ownership or Bill of Sale • Federal and State Income Tax Returns for the past 3 yeazs • Liquar Liability Insuzance ' • Site plan • Letter aclrnowledging requirement of food sales with beverage (malt and/or wine) If you are selling beer and/or wine, you are doing so without a valid City of Saint Paul license and will be subject to adverse acfion and penalries. Please let us lmow, in writing, before Wednesday, May 30, 2001 whether or not you intend to continue with this application or wish to permanendy withdraw. After Wednesday, May 30, this office will begin the administrative hearing process to deny your license request. You have the opportunity to appeal the City's decision through this proceeding. If you have any questions regazding this acrion, please contact Corinne at (651) 266-9106. Sincere� , � �. �� Christine A. Rozek LIEP Deputy Director :C�7\:7t�7 OFFICE Gr' LICE?YSE, INSPECTTONS AA*D E�ii VIROi�IMENTAL PROTECI'fON � �_���� Roger Cunis, Director CITY OF SAINT PAUL Nam Coleman, Mayar LOWRYPROFESSION�ILBUILDING Telephone: 65Z-?66-9090 350 St. Puer Street, Suite 300 Facsimile: 65b266-9124 Saint P¢ul, Minnerot¢ i5101-I570 Web: wknv.cistpauLmrt.us/liep Mazch 23, 2001 19980009120 Juan Rada La Hacienda Restaurante 2402 Benson Ave St Paul MN 55116 Re: New License Application at 2467 7`� Street West Deaz Applicant: This letter is to formally norify you of documentarion our o�ce still requires in order to complete your application. Your license application for Malt On Sale (Strong) and Wine On Sale license located at 2467 7`� Street West can not be processed until our office receives the following: • Copy of your Properry Lease/Purchase Agreement, Proof of Ownership or Bill of Sale • Federal and State Income Tas Returns for the past 3 years • Liquor Liability Insurance • Letter aclmowledging requirement of food sales with beverage (Vlalt and/or Wine) • Site plan Insurance certificates, lease agreemeats/Bill of Sale, site plans, Articles of Incorporation, signed condition affidavits, and lists may be faxed to our affice at (651) 266-9124. A self- addressed City of Saint Paul envelope is also enclosed for your convenience. We must obtain the required paperwork/payment before we can complete processing your application. At this t3me, your license has not been issued; therefore, you are not authorized to serve Malt or Wine in the City of Saint Paul. You will not receive your license until all information and/or payments aze received in our office. If you have any questions, please contact Corinne at (651) 266-9106. Sincerely, l�i�Z� �. J� Chrisrine A. Rozek � LIEP Deputy Director CAR/caa licensg Group Comments Text licensee: �UAN RADA DBA: Lp HACIENDA RESTAURANTE License#: �ggg0008120 07/2S/2001 OS-\a\\ 07/28/2007 To CAO for adverse adioo. CAR 07f28Y2001 Documents never received for wine and beer application. LIEP recommends denial of the pending application. CAR 05/232007 letter sent for requirements not met. caa 03232001 letter sent for dowmentation stiil required for new maft and wine app. pa 17/2�/2000 Per Juan Rada who came into our office, he wants to change his DBA from Latin Lover to La Hacienda Restaurente, nothing else has changed. KRD 2-10-00 NSF check paid in fuII.ES 7-11-00 NSF check #7696 rec'd for 5450.00. Total amount due is $465.00.ES ��� .�(\r,'t;o �uo�-c.�- (�J � `t� C�� (�,�.c�;.�., �' �-r� O \ - \a\\ Atltlress � ��see, CoMac[ � L'cense ( Cartlholder, � Type' C� property (� Liceitsee t' LMofficial t' AIl �treet tl 467 Street Name' TH StreM Type: <Alb "'" Direahort Wib �v UnR#: r Cdy <Allx ; _fud�J�;a` ?'�.,`:: ��p _i"X:-y�,=,''. �.'.`' "-'`''�a'h �:"r}c'. vre.;. ,4'� '�af ���P: � Res[eurerRCB)-moACtrvs 4censeFrrcAed 12R317945 12R3R0012487 JNneOnSele fPendng _ _�04720R�Q7 04R020022467 � � -\�\\ , r , ��d. �`� �""�'. A"a iE�+' �censee�luMlRaon — stre '�� �°� �'�� �� DBA AHAqENDARESTAURA13iE - Stre Licenu � Licensee , Lic. TVPes � Inwrance l BaM , RequiremerSS l SYre r Propedy (` Licensee t' Unofficial 7mjeG FadldffiOr. ASUNCION, CORP➢ilE Dire� Street #: 467 Ativerse Adion Comm � Street Name TFI C Street TYPe: ST Dvection /V — ' Undlnt. �— UndF: �-- , Cdy. T PAUL License G roup �ommeMs ; 5[ffie: � Lp: 5511 fi 523f1001 letter serd for reqwremeMS not met cae � � 323R001 IetteY serG for tlocumentation still requiretl for �g�� ew malt anC wine apP. caa � Dist Ccuncl: r 1 R7 f1000 Per Juen Ratla who came irito our oftice, he — __ ertstoc t ; Licensee: AN RADA Licensee 721(1000 Per Juan ftatle wha came irRO our � DBA A HALIENDA RESTAUftANTE ���� fice. he werdsto chenge his DBA from - ���=�? � Sales Tax Itl: 561978 Bus Phone: 651) 6993213 �n Laverta Le flacientla Restaurarrte, - �+.aoanee.q.e e.r van ;� £ � 7 � - �.. � � �: MaR On Sale (SYrongJ , C � 04R0f2007 7 0420f1002 N� $445 00( i Restaurarrt(B)-morethanl2seats R ��2/23n998 � 1223R007 �N � $4`..0.00� � . _' " _'___ ' " ,�, ' � Nhne On Sale C = 041102001 : 04202002 N $i �385A� J � '- '_'_'_"-_"'_'__"___'_ """ ' ;License# 80008720 SeveChenaestoF+NOrv1J �–ra�. : .��.��1 r.x<r��_y 2d67 ... <.e � ..... V,��,ga� .-�_ o�-�a�� - TYPf R��tl �tyg¢�,�°P���8��7�':) u�r.iac�Nuv��vwa Stre. DBA A HACIENDA RE< Stre ��cense Ucensee � Lic. Types � Insurence l Bantl � RequiremerAS l SIre Licensee Neme' UAN R4DA Dire� DBA' A HAGENDA RESTAUR4NTE Unrt Sales Tax Itl 567978 NorvProfR r Worker's Comp: ONOi9000 AA CoMrac[ Rec'tl� Or00N000 AA Training Rec'd Oi00ii)000 � M1Y eSA Fee CNlectetl ONOA7000 Discourrt Rec'd r _�' . Pr6�sM{.�, Qther A enc l�censes Fnar�crel F1old Reasons �Jtie�l R��k°': -�-, "p t '"y�' �z.._i[ct`rve Dele „ � NSF N 01111R000 To " 1?1231f JUAN BUSINES: JUkN MARING _ ____� JUAN _ , ^ �HOME PS �..c; ,R 4 �p' tl -(4� i a"� e Nig» vt x ^?"}� �� . e .! �5..'`� r '�.� µ N� 't x�ti„k q ffi�. ���[QAFSY�fw�!['��� . Save Chenges to Hisiory r' -Meil License Ta: — ����'��' !: Meil To CoMact i3213 ; C License Adtlress „_ N _ r �Mail Invoice To: — -� C•� Maii To CoMaet ;,p.,t,,:a�+�:� � �' Licerise Atldress -` ' BeckgrowH Check Required � i 'License# 80009120 <� �,� ' .—r...--.. -;� � .,::.: 3 Rems Found � ?Qb'7 7 2467 7' �