The URL can be used to link to this page

272400 _. . __. WHITE - CITV CLERK �� ' PINK� - FINANCE GITY OF SAINT PAUL Council :�'i `�•. ..�;� � CANARV -DEPARTMENT BLUE - MAVOR File NO. 4 � • � � P �n�nce Ordinance N�. � , Presented By Referred To Committee: Date ' Qut of Commi,ttee By - Date , An Ordinance amending Chapter 60 of the St. Paul Legislative Code pertaining to � zoning for the City of Saint Paul and the zoning maps thereof. WHEREAS, Pursuant to Minnesota Statutes, $ 462. 357 and �S 64. 210 of the Legislative Code, Paul L. Gonia duly petitioned to rezone the north 50 feet of Lots 12 through 15, inclusive, Block 2, Birmingham' s Park, located on the south side of Sims Avenue between White Bear Avenue and Flandrau Street from R-4 (One-Family Residential) to RT-1 (Two-Family Residential) for the purpose of converting a single family dwelling into a duplex, the petition having been certified by the Department of Finance and Management Services on October 25, 1978 as having been consented to by at least 67� of the owners of the area of the property to be rezoned, and further, having been consented to by at least two-thirds of the owners of the property situated within 100 feet of the total contiguous descriptions of real estate held by the same owner or any party purchasing any such contiguous property within one year preceding the date of the petition; and WHEREAS, The current planning committee on November 16, 1978 conducted a public hearing for the purpose of considering the re- zoning petition, and, pursuant to Section 20. 03 of the Administra- tive Code, submitted its recommendation to the Planning Commission that the petition be granted; and WHEREAS, The Planning Commission considered the rezoning petition at its meeting held on November 17, 1978 and recommended that the City Council approve the petition; and COUIVCILMEN Requested by Department of: Yeas Nays Butler Hozza In Favor Hunt Levine A gai n s t BY Maddox Showalter Tedesco Form Approved }� City Attor�y Adopted by Council: Date Certified Passed by Council Secretary BY � � , By . , Approved by Mayor: Date Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council By By - _� ��, �.�� ,�; WHEREAS , Notice of a public hearing before the City Council on the said rezoning petition was duly published in the official newspaper of the City on December 9, 1978 and notices were duly mailed to each owner of affected property and property situated wholly or partly within 350 feet of the property sought to be re- zoned; and WHEREAS, A public hearing before the City Council, having been conducted on December 21, 1978 where all interested persons were heard, and the Council having considered all the facts and recommendations concerning the petition; now, therefore, THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN: Section l. That the zoning map of the City of Saint Paul, Sheet No. 15 , as incorporated by reference in Section 60. 401 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code, as amended, is hereby further amended as follows: That property located on the south side of Sims Avenue between White Bear Avenue and Flandrau Street, being more particularly described as the north 50 feet of Lots 12 through 15, inclusive, Block 2 , Birmingham' s Park, be and is hereby re- zoned from R-4 (One-Family Residential) to RT-1 (Two-Family Residential) . 2 . WHITE - CITV CLERK � �CANARV -DEP RTMENT COUIICII � j �'%'��, ��' Bl`E - MAVOR GITY OF SAINT PAZTL File NO. ��;� °' r � 0 rdindnce Ordinance N�. � ° .� Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date Section 2 . This ordinance shall take effect and be in force thirty (30) days from and after its passage, approval and publication. 3. COUIJCILMEIV Requested by Department of: Yeas Nays Butler Hozza [n Favor Hunt Levine Against BY Maddox Showalter Tedesco Form Approved by ity Attorney Adopted b ouncil: Date �a 6 � � Cer ' ied Pass y Council ecrEtar BY ' r � By � Ap by Mayor: D � Approved by Mayor or Submission to Council By By pl�LtSHED F�B 1 ? 1979 rf { 1� � � . .. �. � ��- ��- r. �,7� /�� ► �� t� � � -� *� L ,�i ..� �� i� � � , ��,. ,S �� '� '. .1� � � �, � � �F , � � � . � .�� 'f...� � : , : . �- ,. ,. , . . , , . . , � t . . � �' : ��;+/ i �'� � ? � �, . . ., .. , ,� ., .� . . „ ..- , .�]i: � .i�- ;i. .. .,:� ,� . . . .. � :. r . ..;� i :L: �� . - �� . �i '�¢ � } .. ' �� ,' �-� 4 .` � � . °.� 1, h , , .. , f :, �. ., � . . . � f ; ... '/ � . ry... � ' i:� . �:� .H� `, � � t ��i� . � ' ,f 7� �� ,�� 'i'�j� �3 _ � .1�- _ '( �4 d` (e i . i 1 y ry . }��}t � I[ f Ly , . � , � � � Z. � j_ �� t� '"� ; � � +��' ��'�� ; � . � +„ 9� � . , \ b t ' ./ ' ',', 1+� ,t�. 1 / , `l �'� �.�.�^1 �t�.. .� - i . . . .i,l� k > � � {• �� Y . _ ' � t ,{� , f � i-Q��'1A��y� � 1 � _ Y { ,. }3 .��t, :�<��Fl�t, .��!!'�!r� . � : .. � � t F � � `� h � �' { � �+k7.��! r;�� '' `Y � n '� � ��.'•�r '��; � � �� . �` ` J ��'�� .��,��'�^ . ��. ��i• . F�� i ro �� ' M' , �' �' #�`'��` � � � �,,�� :�+��► '�-.�+� a�� +�►o+�� #±�o�'��, �� , . t��L��`� � �: ' ; . � <��i��,-�-`��,i�:�� !"� �'i;��.�� ,�� ^� � �L ��_ �� ' ` +, � `'�' ��r 1A�IrC"�y# fBi�E� IA��D. Y , � � � — � ��"�� t r, •'� �'. 'k• ��' .. . ,��Y�y ` ��, ... t�� s��' � � j t � �' � ,� � � � a i - .'� ... - _. � � .�'� � �� i� . � � .�6 '�� .,�y r ,y' ' '� � r. �'�� . ` � , �' , - .. , , . . . • ., ' ` . � ,. , r.> l � � �� ,�. � :�'t�' y .. ,,± ^ -, y x r, , , e . � ;,� ,, , _ , 1' �,: ` ,' ' _ `� _ �� , •S � ..,� � ' ' '. , � , � ` �^ � � r „ "! � Y i � �'� ` ; � �. ,', ; i ' ,.1 � ¢3`. � � . . ��' . �'ti , , . , 4 1; ' ` ' = � , ?' ` .} , . , . , . . . ,_ , . .: , • . . .. >� , ., - � ' ` ' � �, � � . } , � ,� �� - �� , � r�s ' '.� � ,�, ;� ,1` '' '` � :; , , !,, .; t�� . �. . , ,. , . , , .,, , � �.,.� �. .. ... , � . ; • � �;a`r�i=� � w+��,TY o',', CITY OF SAINT PAUL . � DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT � ._ ,+ DtVI510N OF PL/1NNING �+ �° 421 Wabasha Street,Saint Paul,Minnesow,55102 ••• 612-298-�151 George Latimer . Mayor December 13, 1978 � Rose Mix, City Clerk 386 City Hall St. Paul , Minn. 55102 Dear Madam: This letter is written in response to the petition of Paul L. Gonia to rezone property located on the south side of Simms between White Bear and Flandrau from R-4 (Single Family) to RT-1 (Two-Family) , in order to convert a single family dwelling into a duplex located at 726 Sims. This matter was heard before the Current Planning & Zoning Committee on November 16, 1978. There was no opposition. Staff recomnended approval of the rezoning request and the Current Planning & Zoning Comnittee also recommended approval on a vote. of 7 to 0 based on the findings that the property was formerly zoned A Residence; the Comprehensive Land Use Plan identifies the site as appropriate for two-family use; the site adjoins no other zoning district; the subject lot exceeds the RT-1 square footage requirements and maximizing the use of the structure is in keeping with energy conservation. On November 17, 1978 the Planning Comnission unanimously confirmed the determin- ation of the Current Planning & Zoning Committee to approve the rezoning. The City Council has scheduled a public hearing on this matter for December 21 , 1978. Sincerely, � �� onna F. McNeally . City Planner DFM/gf Enc. Zoning File No. 8378 . , . r ' . � � b, � ' MINUTES OF THE CURRENT PLANNING AND ZONING C(IMMITTEE NOVERMBER 16, 1978 IN CITY COUNCIL CHAMBERS, SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA PRESENT: Mmes. McGinley, Karns and Sumners, Messrs. Bryan, Pangal , Levy and Fitzgibbon of the Current Planning and Zoning Committee; Mr. Jerome Segal , Assistant City Attorney; Mr. Richard Amey of the Division of Housing and Building Code Enforcement; Mmes. I�Neall, and Fox, and Mr. Warn of the Planning Staff. ABSENT: 0 The meeting was chaired by James Bryan, the chairman: PAUL L. GONIA (#8378): An application to rezone from R-4 (Single Family Residential ) to - �wo�ami'Ty Residential ) property located at 1726 Sims. The applicant was present. There was no opposition present at the hearing. Ed Warn showed slides of the subject site and reviewed the staff report with a staff recommendation of approval of the rezoning request. He also noted two letters of support from Frank & June Boyer, 929 Flandrau, and Raymond & Marilyn Whebbe, 1706 Sims Ave. Mr. Gonia said he was satisfied with the staff report and had nothing to add. There being no further testimony, Mr. Bryan then closed the public hearing. Jean McGinley moved to recommend approval of the rezoning request based on Findings 1 through 6 of the staff report. Her moti.on was seconded by Joseph Pangal and passed on a 7 to 0 roll call vote. Submitted by: Approv�d by: ! �. ..�• � . .. _. .., � �(1 . . ��.� `f' � ,i� Edward J. W � James �Bryan, Chairman r' , , , - . � , � • � CITY OF SAINT PAUL DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE AND MANAGEMENT SERVICES DIVISION OF ASSESSMENTS AND VALUATIONS + October 25, 1978 To the Council City of St. Paul Gentlemen: I have checked the attached petition of Paul L. Gonia f iled in the matter of rezoning, � The north 50 feet of Lots 12, 13, 14, and 15, Block 2, Birmingham's Park. The property is located on the south side of Sims Avenue between White Bear Avenue and Flandrau Street, from R-4 to RT-1 for the purpose of raising the southeast part of the roof to construct a small upper-floor apartment, and find that said petition is sufficient. Yours very truly, Bernard J. Carlson - Director • Department of Finance and Management Services , �� ' �� -�.��: �►, . Re: X2190 cc: Building Department Zoning Board File Parcels Eligible - 15 Parcels Needed - 10 Parcels Signed - 11 ' � �� '�� ,. �_ _ LL . .. _y.:.�_..__ . Telephone612/298-5241 113 City Hall, Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102 ( . . � • � � • � • + � 1 I � �a� V . �n � e W � , ,� s �' �. , �Y/.� �p'� `o7.s �y,-/ .,� � _ l,l� 2 /�f'�i°•.�.y/�.�r� �A :y , -�,r,:�-�•�,�,� _ _ --_ ._ _ _ __. , � A�to _ �QV�tn _____ _ _. _ ghoP 1 - - . �tTor Off _ . _ �P�-, _ - _ __ L eT. ,°rprt's. _ _ _ . _ -----_ __ --- _ _-- - - � _ ._ ___. _ _ 0��` --- ----_ . ��. _ -- - -- -- -�---_ _ . �e - __ _ _ � ; _: � J � O _ _ .. � . _ . a . . . ..=, - _ _ _ --�h' -- ----- ._--- =- ----____ _ _ --- ------._ — ---------- ---__ ---__ _____--- _ ♦ � y�, , _ ___ _. _ _�_'-- ---�- ------__ __ !��' _-- --� _- --- --- --- �- _ __ _ � � � �� __ .___ _ . � __ .-; _ _� ---- --- -- .__-- -� ------____ _�. M• � ___-- _ - - �- - -�--- ___ _ _ _ ____ ---- -- ---- -— -- �--- � � � v ..__.__.__....__. _.._' . _ _�.. ________._... ..___ .. !. ... _. _'___._ . ..___._ _ _'_��_ __ _.. . ... ... . �� . P ` __ __ __ _______ __ _ ___ _. ___ _ _ _ _ ______ _ _ _ .______ ._ _ _ '�h' Q - -- ___ _ _ _� --- _ - -- --_ _---_ ._ __ _ _ ___ �� -- - _. , _ __ -- ___ _---- - - - ___ _ _ _ - - ------ -- --- _ '�� . �� 1y ---. _ ��± . _ - --- . __ _ �_._ __ _--- _ __ --_ ._.____ ._ --- -- -- J� � p, 0 _ - - - - __ --.--- - ----- --_ __ ___ _-- - -- _ __ __ _ _ __-- - --___ _ ___ ------ ------ ---- -- _ _ _ __ Q VI VA lit � --- __-_ __ ___ ... ---____._ _ � -- - - -----_ ---- -------------- -- - �t� --- - -----_ _._- ------- _�__._ __ _ _ __ _ --_ _ � - • . _ _ -- - -.------- --- ---- ----.--_ _ _-- - _ __. -- - --- - �.�--�Q.n��. _- -_ _._ . 17ZG 5�►�s �v : "' � /��C..�� - -. f� � � !"4►y '"�a ;�i+K ' ,� _ . O�� A� � /,_ �a4�,T, o� , CITY OF SAINT PAUL � DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT � i O � -- �' DIVISION OF PLANNING �' ^c 421 Wabasha Street,Saint Paul,Minnesota,55102 ... 612-298-4151 George Latimer Mayor December 13, 1978 Rose Mix, City Clerk 386 City Hall St. Paul , Minn. 55102 Dear Madam: � This letter is written in response to the petition of Paul L. Gonia to rezone property located on the south side of Simms between White Bear and Flandrau from R-4 (Single Family) to RT-1 (Two-Family) , in order to convert a single family dwelling into a duplex located at 726 Sims. This matter was heard before the Current Planning & Zoning Committee on November 16, 1978. There was no opposition. Staff recommended approval of the rezoning request and the Current Planning & Zoning Committee also recommended approval on a vote. of 7 to 0 based on the findings that the property was formerly zoned A Residence; the Comprehensive Land Use Plan identifies the site as appropriate for two-family use; the site adjoins no other zoning district; the subject lot exceeds the RT-1 square footage requirements and maximizing the use of the structure is in keeping with energy conservation. On November 17, 1978 the Planning Commission unanimously confirmed the determin- ation of the Current Planning & Zoning Corrnnittee to approve the rezoning. The City Council has scheduled a public hearing on this matter for December 21 , 1978. Sincerely, � W�-�� onna F. McNeally . City Planner DFM/gf Enc. Zoning File No. 8378 . , �+� ' ' .r _' ' ' MINUTES OF THE CURRENT PLANNING AND ZONING COMMITTEE NOVERMBER 16, 1978 IN CITY COUNCIL CHAMBERS, SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA PRESENT: Mmes. McGinley, Karns and Summers, Messrs. Bryan, Pangal , Levy and Fitzgibbon of the Current Planning and Zoning Committee; Mr. Jerome Segal , Assistant City Attorney; Mr. Richard Amey of the Division of Housing and Building Code Enforcement; Mmes. I�CNeall; and Fox, and Mr. Warn of the Planning Staff. ABSENT: 0 The meeting was chaired by James Bryan, the chairman. PAUL L. GONIA (#8378�_ An application to rezone from R-4 (Single Family Residential ) to - wo Fami y esidential ) property located at 1126 Sims. The applicant was present. There was no �opposition present at the hearing. Ed Warn showed slides of the subject site and reviewed the staff report with a staff recomnendation of� approval of the rezoning request. He also noted two letters of support from Frank & June Boyer, 929 Flandrau, and Raymond & Marilyn Whebbe, 1706 Sims Ave. Mr. Gonia said he was satisfied with the staff report and had nothing to add. There being no further testimony, Mr. Bryan then closed the public hearing. Jean McGinley moved to recommend approval of the rezoni�g request based on Findings 1 through 6 of the staff report. Her motion was seconded by Joseph Pangal and passed on a 7 to 0 roll call vote. Submitted by: Approved by: . , � � . i� , . i �� = �,/ � Edward J. W James Bryan, Chairman �. . - , . ��i . �- .� � CITY OF SAINT PAUL DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE AND MANAGEMENT SERVICES DIVISION OF ASSESSMENTS AND VALUATIONS + October 25, 1978 To the Council City of St. Paul Gentlemen: " I have checked the attached petition of Paul L. Gonia filed in the matter of rezoning, ' The north 50 feet of• Lots 12, 13, 14, and 15, Block 2, Birmingham's Park. The property is located on the south side of Sims Avenue between White Bear Avenue and Flandrau Street, from R-4 to RT-1 for the purpose of raising the southeast part of the roof to construct a small upper-floor apartment, and find that said petition is sufficient. Yours very truly, Bernard J. Carlson - Director � Department of Finance and Management Services .� �.�� , J�� Re: X2190 cc: Building Department Zoning Board File Parcels Eligible - 15 Parcels Needed - 10 Parcels Signed - 11 � �� ,��9�� ... Telephone 612/298-5241 113 City Hall, Saint Pau (, Minnesota 55102 .� _._ .. '- . � � �"�`��'��'� . . • � � . - � • ` ' r . ^ �/1 �fie ��ar ve . W �i- �]� � y f � ��'' /� , / `+'-i � �,� o !i0'/.t /jn+��s��ji Z J/��`��/FI`� e'�S�IP �� /`":��w.'<-�;,r -rr _._ _ ._ _ � _ ''---- ____- — A�r� V�� g h o P �� 1 - �tTor O f f- _ _ _ _ fF P1• _ _ L °T' _ , �►PTs._ _ __ __ - --- _ . __ ____ ____ ---. __ _--- _ _ ---- �� , �e♦ �` -- , , -- ____ ___ ____ - -- _ _ _ ---- - -_ _ _ _. __ _ OJ� � . QJ -_ _-- -._ _ __- -..------ _ _.__ _. . -- - _._... .-- - ____. _�� _ _. _. _ __ : � ___ ._._ _ ..- —__ .__ .,;: .• �., ' _.___ ___ _-- - !�b• -- --- ---------=---- _____ _� ��__ __ _��_-- -�- --- ------- ---- _ _ � � �� .: _ __ _ _ --�- __ -- ---�- -------__ . �_��' - ____-- �� ~ � -------- ______ � S� � _ � � �' � __ _.____ _ - -- - - -- _.--- -- --- ---- -- .- '� - - -------- � �- -- - ------- --- '��• � _ _ _ - _ .__ _- -_ _ ---- ___ �C �� ---- _. __ ---,�--- __ __ ,� .,. ____ __ _ - ---- _ __--__ --- �. _ _ _ __�_ __ ___ .� __--- � @' ,. _- - - __ _ _ . '�h' _ __�_ --_ _ --- ° -__-__ _ ___ _____ �� ___ ____ _ _ .______ _ __._._ ______ __ _ ___ _ _ _ _ ___ ______- ___ __ ______ _ 'C�� _ _.�►� __ _ �� - - --- - -- - - - _ __- - ___ ---- _ -- _._. ��____ a� - 9J� _ _____ --__ _ -, -____ _ _. ___ �- t a v► �a u - _ S r.- ___ ___ _ _____ _ _ _ --- - __. �_ �_ � _ _ _ __ _ _ --------- - _ . - - - _ �`+ _ _-----._ __ _ __ ___ ____ _ __ --_ - _ __ _ o�t _ _ _ . _ --- ___ ___ _- ____ _ _ _ _ _ ___- - __ ._ __ �,��--_GQ��_ _- . - � �ZL s�►�s �� . � �y� � • ��• � •� ' 1 L� • ' �J`�' � • . . M STATE OF MINNESOTA ) �� COUNTY OF RAMSEY ) ss. ) CITY OF SAINT PAUL ) Paul L. �onia , being first duly sworn, deposes and states that he is the owner of the property to be rezoned, or has authority to lawfully bind the owner of the property to be rezoned, which is described as follows: Birminghams Park Add. Ex. S. 50 ft. Lot 12 and N. 1/2 o s , an 1 B1. 2 '�,. ..;�, �n : � that affiant does not have any legal or equitable itrt� res , is not in the ��'��, � act of purchasing, nor has he purchased or sold with'in one (1) year preceding the date of the attached petition any land contiguous to the property sought to be rezoned as described above, except (NONE) (SEE ATTACHED) ; that affiant understands the word "contiguous" as used herein to mean parcels of property sharing a common boundary at any point without regard to the presence of public thoroughfares. • � /'/( � . 1 NORARY C, RAMSEY COUNTY, MINN. � �,�aa.�.�aaA�3p.�.r"s,.�r C"�� c��l,�n^�ua�,�a��u.ft , r1 � Y J �°�CG� � ' �},�+�� '"f G�,�riinn. i �'F �,,� N , 'b � . s� �� ''�`�l�`•� �. ,., 1 `J3 <r�rEb � ��.�� ' - y L�+�y I -^:r�.y!y>�.i . Iw��Y[1��t1�f1" ,4t ::.�: ':�tir YF.. ` . . , , . N`� C1TY ar ST. �AUL �' 'i�rPaR�fMfNT L�� !1{A�lC� AND MANAGEMEN3 5£RV1C�S ASSESSME�iT DIVISION ,�, 113 CITY HALL 5T.PAUL,h11:�ItiE507A ii702 ��°N9��i,,� f_ � �.:� December 1, 1978 � File X2190, Page Zoning File 8378 The Council of the City of St. Paul will hold a put�lic hearing in the Council Chambers of the City Hall and Court House (third floor) at 10:00 a.m. on December 21, 1978 on the: Petition of Paul L. Gonia to REZONE from R-4 to RT-1 the property at 1726 Sims Avenue on the south side of Sims Avenue between White Bear Avenue and Flandrau Street, described as: the north 50 feet of Lots 12, 13, 14 and 15, Block 2, Birmingham's Park. If you would like further informatioa about this hearing, contact the Curreirt Planning Section of the Plannimg Board, 421 Wabasha Street or telephone 298-4154. While the City Charter requires that we notify you of the hearing, we want to help you to learn fully about any improvement that could affect you or yovr community. Therefore, I sincerely hope you can attend this hearing, so that you can make youx views about it known t� rhe City Counc;.l, whether for or � - against. J. WILLIAM DONOVAN VALUATION AND ASSESSMENT E�:GINEER � . ��# iGi< �I�i,ll.= I �� `�t° .t' r�y' '~�; .� y �� . t I1 },.�Y'. &� ��1 i.:�Y rl��, n ;� _ � _ , . . � r ' CITY OF SAIIVT PAUL, MINPdFSOTA ��+��,'��D� � • � PETITION TO AMEND CHAPTERS 60 thrtt 64 OF THE LEGISLATTVE (�3NIIVG) COL�� : Note: T�e signer should apprise himself of the us�s �ermitted under the new classi•- fication before signing tnis petizian. For further informatiQn about the rezoning of property, call the Board o£ Zoning Office at 298-4151._ (Please type or print} Date: TO �i HE HOI30RABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNC IL e/o the City Clerk, Room 386 City .Ha11 City of Saint Paul, Minnesota Pursuant to Section 64.06 of the Legislative Code and Minnesata Statute 462.35?(5} , we, the undersigned owners of two-thirds of the several descriptions of real estate situated within 100 feet of the total contiguous descriptions of real estate hela by the owne.r of the real estate ta be rezonEd or by any party who h3s purchased oz is purchasing any such contiguous property within one (1) year preceding th� date af this oetition, such property includinq the property to be rezoned, hereby acquiesc�; ar:d we, tY�e owners of 50$ or more of the frontage to be reclassified, petition .your Honora.kal� B�.3y to rezone the followinq described property: (legal deseription and street address)�� I�a(o S�nns I� . so �-t. � l.�s �a , �3 , ly �- 1�, ��e a, ��r►ry:��l�a.�s , from - � District to '�� District, for the purpose af installing, constructing and/or operatinq the following- S� ,po.�'� (describe briefly the proposed facility) /�.�-� �a c,o�S'�'�'� SV��u�.�e,�p�� .�Q��,a�. U oU lf �. RECORA OWNER SIGAIATURE LOT BLOCR ADDITI� Subject Property: v y� S;w.s 9� f �� 0�- , �� as . i�a9 _ ` i��7 � 0� . . 73 or� � ' ra-� ��Q t`l l s O�se. �.� � State of Minnesota) �� } ss County of Ramsey ) �f}1�1 � �o Ni,4 beinq first duly sworn, deposes and states that he is the psrson who circulated the within petition consisting of a, pages; that the parties described above are the owners respectively of the lots placed immediately follawing each narae; that each of the paxties descri.bed above is the owner of property which is within 100 feet from any property owned by affiant or sold by affiant withi.n one (la year preceding thg date of this petition which is contiguous to the property above described; that none of tYie parties described above has pu�chased or i.s vurchasing property from af�iant'cantiguous to the� above described property within one {1) year of the date of }his petition; that this petition was signed by each of said owners in the � presence of this affiant, and that the signatures above are the true and eorrect signatures of each ar.d all of the parties so� descr' � � � / �Z lo ��•�-i c �ve • Subscribed and sworn to before me Adc3ress: // ,/ Telephone No. �7T ^��`�� thir.•%1�� day of� I�7� _. � ` Appro�•ed as to form 8-27-73 O�fice of fihe City Attorney i3otary Public, Ramsey County,� Miiin. riy commission expires��'�+�'�w�`!''� " :,^^ � . ��Q-.s�r . ,� r,�,�� ,� r,�. , � �•r �� c i .:� f- " t,. �� . , ��, . , , ;:.. :,. ;� �" �, �„ i,.:a tia�. F.�; . _ _x '`�.,,.:-• � , i:.;.3 „r± p � ,.�. � � i�i:!i .�.1 i.f 1�.!. . . � . . ,. . . �� ' l � .. . , � "" �,^ , � •�' ` ' . . .' r CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MIM�ESOTA PETITION TO 11MEN0 Cli11FTERS 60 thYU 64 OF THE LEGISIJITZVE (ZONING) GODE No[e: Before the petitioner's proposal for rezoning wi�1 be considered by the City of Saint Paul� property ownera must consent to the proposed change. Before signing the petition which is a statement to that effect, the signer should be aware of uses per- mitted under the new classification. For further information about the rezoning,of , property, call the Zoning Section of the City Planning Office, 298-4154. TO THE HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL p,ata• c/o the City Clerk, Room 386 City Hall City of Saint Paul, Minnesota Section 64.210 of St. Paul's Zoning Ordinance states that 67Z of property owners within the area to be considered must consent to the proposed rezoning. Section 462.357(S) of Minnesota Statutes atates that 2/3 of property ownera within 100 feet of the land proposed for rezoning must give written consent befofe the City shall consider the proposal. However, when the owner of said property has owned� for any time in the past year additional real estate contiguou: to the land proposed for rezoning, 2/3 of the property owners within 100 feet of this larger package of property must give writtEn consent. Pursuant to Section 64.210 of the St. Paul Zoning Ordinance and Section 462.357(5) of Minnesota Statutes, we, the undersigned, own property within 100 feet of the petitioner's land and hereby petition your Honorable Body to rezone [he following described property: (legal description & street address) H�i.rminghams Park Add. Ex. S. 50 ft. Lot 12 and N. 1/� L•ots 13, 14 & 15 B1. 2 1726 Sims Ave., St.Paul,Mn. lro� '��4 District to �T�'� District, for the purpose of installinq, constructinq and/or operatinq the followinq: (describe briefl�r the proposed facility) Raise �:.E. part of roof to construct sma11 upper-f�oor apartment. RECORD OWNER SIGNATtJRE IAT BIACK ADDITION Subject Property: �� 9 8 Flandrau St. �� 939 Flandrau St. � � ��.�4 Sims Ave. ' �4 1734 Sims Ave. ► 9�8 Flandrau St. _ ------ ---- ------- -- — _ -- _----- _ __ __ — ---��_�-�/__�= ------------- -- --'�%�----_ -' __ ��`'--------- __ _ __ . _y��__ __ _��t'�t,� _. --- -- _ /� _ ._ _ _ _ . _ __ _ - --_ - YViYSaY�:rv .__-_._—_—_.____— ... ... . . . _ ._.. ..._ . . . ��r_______._._vaj..Va _" ._.... .._..._ ' .__. ..��_ r�� ____ _._�� .��v �� -_ . - __s.=�- J each nameJ that each of the parties described above is the owner of property which is within 100 feet fram any property owned by affiant or sold by affiant within one tl) + year precedinq the date of this pet3tion which is contiguous to the property above desczibedj that none of the parties described above has purchased or is purchasinq property from atfiant contiguous to the above described property within one (1) year of the date of this petitioni that this petition was signed by each of said owners in the presence of thig affiarit, and that the signatures above are the true and correct sic�natures of each and all of the parties so described. . � Subscribed and sworn to before me Address: 1726 Sims Ave. St.Paul,Nin. � " � ' Telephone No. 774-1495 this�day of �<<,�-u,-�� ,. � '�f�� • Approved as to form 10-27-76 - Office of the City Rtto_-ney X�.�.��i�i'.�atl,wv�.�i;�:.�.�,/,�/�,�,{;.w1dil.�..9�/AAiElk1A X Notary Public, Ramsey County, Min�. rtr�,_3,� rn,q�:�� . woo�^��!� :!y Commisslon explze9 -� �'€��i,,�',�,�p NctaryF�b;i;,,.Ram:eyC�.,Ninn. �s ��q� P.4Y Ci::.�7ri�S;:;��i EXPiHES ' f c�. i�, 1:i33 �y �(�i�")iiiti �I.r`::'�'iYfriifTYi'}�SF'}�V� , v X L �` :,,. � � . � ...,_ ,,.:� �,.:� � �p j L l , , N �,.. �,,: � _ � I , I l,� . L � .� -w✓- �'' �' �!� 0�0 -� � ��. 0�� I � � �� . .f" �� " AMES AVE. � , � ,. . � . ,,: ,¢�'r' •:-=�%" � .- �/�y�'��, ' -" , y�- �I � � � � y / `\ j � r ♦ • ✓� � C � �� . �. /' � �� O , ' �_. - � � � '� � �� ,�' � � " � � ' � � �.�.�, � ; , �� PS �� _ � � � i � � � �� 7� 'Q,i - � �, � I � / � � I � /� \ -- V `: A �ViV�V�V�� i - -� � � /O . %• � G . � � \ R C / O' , , E , o, , .� , � , �, �. � ; � j i ; � - - E3 . A ��,� � pi C� OO � � , v v I v� t_---- - l � I ' � I i---- ` "`J 1_ i_ _ 1. ��_ _ v � -- - T_ _. � _ I I I � ��, � iv � -� AMES O O O, O bI Oi � �O�O � O �0000 O S- 38 T ' i i �O 'O m i i2 ' � i2 i2 i2 � � O O O d � Oi0�O:C , � � � F . � , ' i ,. v , � T � . L . .i 1_J_�v l_ .1_ 1_1_�L1..- � l , - - i - - r---- - - -7 T. . -� ---r- T - � , -, - - r- , � �o� � p , _ � _� � ,-_ � _� , � ; � , . '�; i vpp � rt r0 12 � � i2 � � � iv� �000000� O�C / -. r • ��000�o'o;o'oo_�_ ao � � � d o �0000 �oo�o'c , m i i � � i I i � � T T � �" � �- I I � � F � p p' p ; p ; p � p 00 � O o4 O O oo �0000pp�o'O � r � ►i0 0 !O O d I b O� ; �U , O �O� 4 � � � �O ��. , % I i i ' � � I i ; � � � I i � ; "F' i I ,; � '� � I i I I �O I I � ( i m I G I � i; L_��_��_1_1__1�11_1 _�_ ^r--_r _r-_ T � � # i �O � � � I I ` � i � � � , � � (� � I , � , I I I i � � �d � ; '`-�' �o;o' o m o� i m o) �d o 0 0 0 0 o a b q i � ,' �' '„' oio;o � TI LL O �oio 0 oj '�; � o O o o a p o _-fl- oG o;o 0 0 0�010�0� t I � � I � v v� •� � I I v v - , i , � �__� i i I ; ' I I � I �V ' ! � I iO� � i f �.� 1_ �__�__L� _L. � � .1_ 1 -- L -1- -�--:__.l ;�-`T--r-�� G ,, , t � � � ; i ; ; � ; � ' ' I t . ' � � ' , ��0; ' C� �O O� Q �� ,i O O O 04 f + •o � , �O O Oi0'O+Oi( E. S E T'}� _ _ � , — AKtA MI�1F' APPLICANT PAUL L. soN�A LEGEND —� -� ZONING DISTRICT BOUNDARY PURPOSE Rezone from R-4 to RT-1 �� SUBJECT PROPERTY O ONE FAMILY PLANIWNG DISTRICT 8378 �• TWO FAMILY FILE N0. • ��_ �� _ f�-�-� MULTIPLE FAMILY � - DATE �_ �8 � � � COMMERCIAL SCALE � I"* 200� NORTH � �� NOUSTRIAL MAP NO. SAINT PAU PLANNING 80AR0 ' V VACANT I� . � ' . � ZONING STAFF REPORT -�1 : APPLICANT: PAUL L. GONIA DATE OF HEARING: Nov. 16, 1978 2. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . CLASSIFICATION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . CURRENT PLANNING & ZONING COMMITTEE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS ezoning � Variance ❑ Special Condition Use Administrative Review ❑ Determination of Similar Use ❑ Other ❑ Change of Nonconforming Use ❑ Other ❑ 3. LOCATION: 1726 Sims Avenue (South side of Sims between White Bear Avenue & Flandrau) 4. LEGAL D�SCRIPTION: North 50 ft. of Lots 12, 13, 14 and 15, Block 2, Birmingham Park Addn. 5. PRESENT ZONING: R-4 ZONING CODE REFERENCE: 64.210 6. STAFF INVESTIGATION & REPORT: DATE 11/8/78 gy JM/EJW �l��iifii�ii7iiiisii=tsilsiiss�s�if�f�tsiii��!!l��laaltSli�iiilSaa/�si�i�ialiiiiafitsiiiti A. SUFFICIENCY: The application was filed on a consent form petition subscribed and sworn to be o�re a notary public on Oct. 23, 1978, and received in the Planning Office November 1 , 1978. 6. PURPOSE: The applicant requests a rezoning of his property from R-4 to RT-1 in order to m fy his single family dwelling into a duplex by raising the southeast pqrtion of his roof to construct a small upper floor apartment. C. FRONTAGE & AREA: This corner site has 160 ft. frontage on Sims and 50 ft. side rontage on andrau, for a total area of 8,000 sq. ft. D. SITE CONDITIONS: This corner lot contains a 1� story single family dwelling with a detac e -car garage. Duplexes abut the site on the south and east. E. AREA CONDITIONS: The surrounding land to the east, south and west consists primarily o s ng e am y homes and duplexes . Seven 12 unit apartment buildings occupy the block to the north. White Bear Avenue, a comnercial strip, lies 1 block to the east. FINDINGS: 1 . The property was forrr�rly zoned an "A" residential district permitting both single family and duplex residential dwellings . 2. The 1963 Comprehensive Land Use Plan identifies the site as one appropriate for one and two family residences. 3. The site directly adjoins no other zoning district; however, much of the north side of Sims between Flandrau and White Bear is zoned RM-2. There is a large RT-1 zone one block north of the applicant's parcel along the north side of Case Avenue (see map) . 4. The applicant's lot area of 8,000 sq. ft. exceeds the RT-1 requirement of 6,000 sq. ft. 5. Duplexes presently adjoin applicant's property on the south and east (these are non- conforming uses.) 6. Maximizing the use of an existing structure is in keeping with energy conservation. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Based on the findings above, staff recommends approval of this rezoning request. _ ,, _.�._ , i �;� � p�0'O' C��O O OI O O � �•- ri _ �` u � ' ' f�:��_% AMES =�>✓�,- AVE. . � .. � .. �-.. ,. .�-� ,+ '� '� , � �,- '!.r' .: _w'' � i � ,� , \ j � --� . ..r ( ��1 , ..� `�'� /� • Q � 1 . . � , � , , a ,k - � v � a -a �...�.-=--�lr'T � i ' � ,� � '9 � ,-' � , � � PS _� �� ' "'� � � i , � � � /O �1� 'O,�� t � , r_ � � s ,o V V \ ;ViVI �/�V�i `� i - � • i � G � � \ R C E °� � , , .�- � � o� �, ..� �t ' � � � ' �,: � � � L _ _ Q � ��Q / 0i �� ' .o 'o � � � � � ; � �j �i v- - • � � i ; I � r-v-- .`_...J 1 � _ 1_ , - -1__J ' ,, i r_r� _� , I 1 I � i � � -'� AMES I I ; � O '0000�� 000, O ¢I Oi � O;C O S- 38 , � ,o ,o o ��2 � ��2 �2 �2 � • o 0 o a � a�o,o;c , I � � � � F � , ,, `• v vi '� V I I i � - . i , i. . -� 1 .1. �_ 1 1_._L�_L � - -�-1-L-1 - - - - , - 1 - _ T_ . _� _; _ __ I-- � � � � � i T � m IOI � pl � � ;�_ . �;�; ��oo � -r 70 ,2 � � ,2 � � � �"� b00000� o�c . / S — r . . : �,o'o 0 0'0.0'0�0 ! -� a o� � ` � , � d m lo 0 olo; 'o o:o 'c . , � � ; , ;r.; � . , _ - ' � , _� � O O' p ; p � O O O ' 00 � O 00 000 O oOOO�ooip�po Oc � ►'O ' 0 +O�O d � b O� ' , O �O' � � � ¢ i�� V ' i . � � i � , ! i � � � ( � � � � � �• ; ;i � �.� j t � � I �' �O I I � � i m ' � I I � i; L._��_1�1_� _i_ I i ; 1 I I i �--� -r--r j-- T-T '�'�' ' � � � � � � � � I� I j I I I � � � � �d � ! � � � i i � r o;o' o m o� i m o� �d o o� o 0 0 0� a b q i � � ,' �' �„� ojo;o � �'I 11. R o 'o;o�o�o� ��' I o O o�o a p o �-o- oG o�o 0 0 0�0 0�0; � ; � ; �� •�• � � � � � �� -t-- _ � , ; , , � � __ I I � � � i � , � ; � 1 � �1– I I I �/ r , p� 1-� 1- i-- --�- _1_ 1 _ L_1 �--�--1 -��-- �---r � t �� ' . � . � � � , � �) + j � ; � Q ; , ' ' '�� I � �O O� � O O I O O O ► ! •o � �O O Oi0 0�O�1 Q 17 �� E. S E T __ _ . , � AKtA MAt' APPLICANT PAUL L. GoN�A ' LEGEND — -- ZONING DISTRICT 80UNDARY PURPOSE Rezone from R-4 to RT-1 � SUBJECT PROPERTY � ' O ONE fAMiLY P�ANNING DISTRICT 8378 ¢• TWO FAMILY FILE N0. • ��_ �6 _ f,�� Q,r MULTIPLE FAMILY � - OATE � • � � COMMERCIAL SCALE � I"= 200' NORTH � �� NDUSTRIAL MAP N0. SAINT PAUI. PLANNING 00AR0 ' V �VACANT I� , • . , , ZONING STAFF REPORT , � . APPLICANT: PAUL L. GONIA DATE OF HEARING: Nov. 16, 1978 2. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . CLASSIFICATION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . CURRENT PLANNING & ZONING COMMITTEE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS ezoning L�] Variance ❑ Special Condition Use ❑ Administrative Review ❑ Determination of Similar Use ❑ Other ❑ Change of Nonconforming Use ❑ Other ❑ 3. LOCATION: 1726 Sims Avenue (South side of Sims between White Bear Avenue & Flandrau) 4. LEGAL D�SCRIPTION: North 50 ft. of Lots 12, 13, 14 and 15, Block 2, Birmingham Park Addn. 5. PRESENT ZONING: R-4 ZONING CODE REFERENCE: 64.210 6. STAFF INVESTIGATION & REPORT: DATE >>�8��$ BY JM/EJW �xnrzassaa:aas:�a�a=ssasa�aassssss=�a�sa�s:ssssaasa�sa�ass�s��s�a�ssasass�asss�as�sas:sa:sa A. SUFFICIENCY: The application was filed on a consent form petition subscribed and sworn to before a notary public on Oct. 23, 1978, and received in the Planning Office November 1 , 1978. B. PURPOSE: The applicant requests a rezoning of his property from R-4 to RT-1 in order to�mo ��fy his single family dwelling into a duplex by raising the southeast portion of his roof to construct a small upper floor apartment. � C. FRONTAGE & AREA: This corner site has 160 ft. frontage on Sims and 50 ft. side rontage on andrau, for a total area of 8,000 sq. ft. D. SITE CONDITIONS: This corner lot contains a 1� story single family dwelling with a detac e -car garage. Duplexes abut the site on the south and east. E. AREA CONDITIONS: The surrounding land to the east, south and west consists primarily o s ng e am y homes and duplexes. Seven 12 unit apartment buildings occupy the block to the north. White Bear Avenue, a comnercial strip, lies 1 block to the east. FINDINGS: 1 . The property was formerly zoned an "A" residential district permitting both single family and duplex residential dwellings. 2. The 1963 Comprehensive Land Use Plan identifies the site as one appropriate for one and two family residences. 3. The site directly adjoins no other zoning district; however, much of the north side of Sims between Flandrau and White Bear is zoned RM-2. There is a large RT-1 zone one block north of the applicant's parcel along the north side of Case Avenue (see map) . 4. The applicant's lot area of 8,000 sq. ft. exceeds the RT-1 requirement of 6,000 sq. ft. 5. Duplexes presently adjoin applicant's property on the south and east (these are non- conforming uses.) 6. Maximizing the use of an existing structure is in keeping with energy conservation. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Based on the findings above, staff recommends approval of this rezoning request. ! . ti . � lst � � 2nd _/ � — �_ 3rd �/ =Adopted � . Yeas Na�'S BUTLER HITNT ��, �� LEVINE MADDOR SHOWALTER ' - TEDESCO PRESTDENT (HOZZA)