272894 �
WHITE - CITV CLERK . � �y�
PII�,K� - FINANCE COUtICII �����
CANARV - CSEPARTMENT GITY OF SAINT PAUL �
BLUE - MAVOR Y ��
File N 0._ �-' �
�� Resolution
Presented By
Referred To , Committee: Date
Out of Committee BX Date
BE IT RE�50LVED, That the Council of the City of Saint Paul
hereby certif es and approves the action of the City af Saint Paul
Board of Appe�ls and Review pertaining to the following listed
property and �s shown by the Fxcerpted Minutes of said Board of
Appeals and Rleview, dated April 10+ 1979. and marked EXFiIBIT A, and
attached hereto and made a part hereof by reference:
DATE OF BOARD;
MINUTES CASE NO« PROPERTY APPELLANT
�
4/10/79 ' 10-79—H 265 Dayton Ave. Raymond P. Farrell
' (27 units)
BOARD ACTION:II Granted waiver of St. Paul Legi�lative Code, Section
, 54.13, pertaining to cellar occupancies, to pertnit
I continued use of four dwelling units more than 50,6
below grade, on condition that all sleeping rooms be
I provided with escape windows in conformance with
�', Uniforcn Building Code requirements.
Property Descpription: Dayton and Irvine's Addition, Block 69�
71 thru 82, 84, 85, part of Blocks 70,
83 and 87
S. 8 3/10 ft. of Lot I6 Ex. W. 10 ft.
Lot 34 and all of Lot 35, Block 82
-------------�-__________
4/10%79 , 17-79-H I120 Burne Ave. Gary H. Market
(3 units)
COU[VCILMEN Requested by Department of:
Yeas Nays
Butler � In Favor
Hozza I
Hunt I
Levine i _ __ Against BY --
Maddox
Showalter i
Tedesco Form Approved by City Attorney
Adopted by Council: Dat� — -`
Certified Passed by Council Secretary B�Q'�'v � ��' �+�`f 7�
By
t�pproved by Wlavor. Date � _ Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
BY - — BY
WHITE - CITV CLERK , ���](�/� S
PIN� - FINANCE �� CO�IIICIl I��� y
GANAR'/'- CEPARTMENT �I G I TY OF SA I NT PA�U L ��� � �
BLUE - MAVOR ,i File NO.
� Council Resolution
�
Presented By
Referred To ' Committee: Date
Out of Committee By I Date
I
BOARD ACTIONs � Granted waiver o� St. Paul Legislative Code, Section
'� 54,11, pertaining to requiremnent of bathroom facilities
within walls of dwelling unit, to permit ec�ntinued use
�� of rear first floor unit with bathroom facilities in
� basement, on conditian said bathroom be enclosed and
' mechanical ventilation be provided, and on further
� con�ition that all remaining violations lieted in
I Code Enforcement Divieion`s letter of 3/1/79 be
i co�racted.
;
Property Desc�ription: Suburban Hills
; E. 55 ft, of N. 125 ft. and the S. 7 tt.
of W. 57 50/100 ft. of N. 125 ft. of
Lot 4. Block 28
-------------�----__--------
and be it I
FIIRTfiER �tESOLVED, That the City Clerk is hereby authorizec7 ar�d
directed to tjransmit a copy of this resolution for recording to the
Ramsey County� Office of the Register of Deeds.
�
COUNCILMEN ��
Yeas Nays I � Requested by Department of:
Butler
��z, [n Favor
Hunt �
Levine � __ Against BY
Roedler
Sylvester '
Tedesco
� ,,'�Y 3 1979 Form Approved by City At!omey
Adopted by ncil: Da�e
Certifi Passed ouncil ar / �- �'�'`���' �'2`�?9
B
Appr v by Mavor. D t " Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
By BY
I�tis�.tS�ED M AY '12 �979
�
r , _� I � �� d' l
i - �
�e�.�Iw�,-; ``.��,4t�ri�ri�w.' ,
,�_ �,: �..,�_ `� ��
�
W �.I 4 �'� {
1
� I �
� �j P � , �
� f
� i ,
d� � �� `.,�"� � 3 ; STAT� OF MINN�SOTA )
� �� ±�„ Coun,ty o� Rambey ) ad.
V
F CTTy F NT PAIIL
0 SAI )
.� �M ,
�� ' ������ � ���i��� �� Rose Mix •��
r�.' '
I. . . . . . . .. . . . . . .. . . . . . .. . . .. . . . . . . .. . . .. . . . C.ee�cfz
` ` � :� � _� _ o� �'h.e C.i ty o� Scu,n,t Pau.e, M,i.nne.�oxa, do heneby centi.�y xha.t
;
` � . � . ~ ' 272894
-. -� I have compcviced �'h.e a�',ta.ched copy o� Counc,i.e �-i,e.e No. . . .. . . . ..
� �sr�t�uNw :�
;� � a.e adop�ed by �he Ci.ty Counai.e. ...M�:y.3: . . . . .. .. . . . . . . . 19.:9 ..
, ,�,
jI
,II: �, and appnoved by �h.e Mayon . . . . .. . .May.4: . . .. .. .. . . . . .. . 19.79..
� .
. . . .
w.i.#'h o�u. .cna,e �'h.elr.ea on .i.e .cn m
�'h.e e o �,ce.
9 6 � y �6�
.. . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . .
f
1
�`v��� •� � � • • � � � � • • • • • • •• • • • � • • • • • � • • • � • • • • • • • � • • •• •• • • • • • •• • � • • • •• • �
• • • • •• • � � � • • � • • • • � • � � �• • • • � � • • • � • • • � • • • � • • • • • • • • • • • • • � • • � • • • ••
�.
• � • • � • • • • � • � • • • • • � � • • � �� • • • • • • � � • • � • • • • � • • • • • • • • � • • • � �� • • � � • • •
.
y� �i • • � • • • • � • • • • • • • • � � • • • � • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • � � • • • • � � • • • • • � • • • • • • • � •
.'�' "R i�'�:3�
x<_ 'r' '��, .��
F� - � . � • • . .. • • . . . . • . • . . . . . • • . • • . . . • . . . • . • . . • . . . . . •. . . . • . . • .. • .. . .• .
r
�
��L - . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
r�l
�
O . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . • . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . .. . . . . . . . .
C� . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. .. . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . .. .. .. . .. . .
C
. � ' . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . • . . . . . . . . • . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . .
I �cvr�'he�c ce�r.ti.�y �'hcc,t dcr,i.d copy .i�s a �'Jcu.e and co�vr.eat copy
� ! o� da,i,d an,i.g.i.n.a.2 and �h.e who.2e �'h.viceo�.
wI TN�SS m y ha.v�.d and �'h.e d ea.2 0� �he Ci.ty a� Scu.v�t Pa.u,�,
� - � <'�� ����
�:: ' M.i.nn. �h.id 14th da.y o� MaY. . . .A �. 19 79. . .
. .. . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . .
, .��i _
` c.-: ,
£,`' dn� �� �
� � k"'�� � � � • • . • • • • • • • • • . • , • •• . • •• •. • • •. • • • • • • . .
'� . l�l-""7 1.�..Q��•
� 3iZ � i.i �. � u roT�. ;�
�
i
- ; �Xf7lI,(3�� � 4/10/79 - Meeting No . I49
� � ' � ������
. MINUTES OF THE MEETING .
ST. PAUL BOARD OF APPEALS �, REVIEW
� Tuesday, April 10, 1979
City Council Committee Room 707
Ci,ty Hall and Court House
1 : 30 p .m.
MEMBERS PRESENT: D.D. Wazniak, Chairman Ron Glassman
� Arthur Tieso James Voigt
Estyr B. Peake LeRoy Coleman
ABSENT: David Heider
AGENCIES PRESENT: Community Services Dept. - Division of Housing
and Building Code Enforcement
• Alice Bijjani
OTHERS PRESENT: Ray Farrell
' Gary Market
Bill Holberg
Ron Wagner (District 4 Community Organizer)
STAFF PRESENT: ' Patricia Moxness
.
.
_ i
,
CASE N0. PROPERTY APPEL,LANT
10- 79-H 265 Dayton Ave . Raymond P. Farrell
•. (27 units)
�
` -2- 4/IO/79 - Meeting No . I49
� �
� . �
SUBJECT: Request waiver of St . Paul Legislative Code , Section 54 . 1�,
� perta n g to occupancy of units more than 50% below grade , and waiver
of certain electrical re�uirements , as designated in Certificate o£
dccupancy letter of 1/6/79, because of economic considerations .
Previous Hearing 3/13/79: Case continued to April meeting.
APPEARANCE : Raymond P. Farrell
PROCEEDINGS : Mr. �arrell said the four basement apartments were in use
iri 1 w en he purchased the building. . He had expanded Apt . #4 in 296I,
having obtained a building permit for the construction. In the recent :
Certificate of Occupancy inspection, the city inspector had advised
- that fire walls and door closers in the boiler room were required, and
that a larger window, suitable for use as an emergency exit, was needed
in one of the base'ment units . Mr. Farrell said he was willing to comnly
� with these requirements and that he needed the income from the units to
make operation of the building feasible .
Alice Bijjani exnlained that the only question before the Board was
whether or not to 'waive the re�uirement that prohibited occupancy of any
' unit more than S0� below grade . She said if the Board granted such a
waiver, the Code �nforcement Division reauested there be a stipulation
that all sleeping rooms in the below grade apartments be provided with
an escape window in conformance with Uniform Building Code specifications .
BOARD ACTION: Mr. Tieso moved that a waiver of St . Paul Legislative Code,
Section 54 . 13, pe�taining to basement occunancies , be granted, on condition
that all sleeping' rooms in four basement anartments be provided wi�h
escape windows in conformance to Uniform Building Code requireme�ts in
, any apartment where such means of egress is not already provided. Mrs .
Peake seconded. MOTION CARRIED AI�iD SO ORDERED.
- THE VOTE : Aye,'s - 6 Nayes - 0 Abstentions - 0
.
,
i
i
� � -2- 4/10/79 - Meeting No . 149
t
2�2�q�
� CASE N0. PROPERTY APPELLANT
' 17- 79-H 1120 Burns Ave . Gary H. Market
(3 units)
SUBJECT: Request waiver of certain requirements of St . Paul Legislative
Gode pertaini.ng �o bathroom location, and electrical and structural
: repairs, as designated in letter of 3/1/79 from Code Enforcement Division,
' because of pract�cal difficulty and economic considerations .
APPEAR.ANCE : Gary H. Market
. PROCEEDIN GS : Mr. Market stated that his pronerty had one second floor
� unit and two first floor units . The violations cited by the city applied
primarily to the rear first floor apartment, where the bathroom facilities
werelocated in the basement. The unit rented for $145 a month, and the
present tenant had agreed to make several of the repairs listed in the
. city' s letter i�a exchange for two months ' rent . Mr. Market said he could
not find out what was wrong with the stairway support post listed as
inadequate , and' the rear norch, found in violation because of broken
window panes and a roof leak, was never intended to be part of the rental
, �
-3- 4/IQ/79 - Meeting No. I49
', - '
unit, having alway5 served as a storage shed. That had been reroofed
in recent years , and he felt if there was a leak, it was only because of
: the unusually hard winter in which many other property owners had exper-
ienced similar problems , in spite of sound roofs . However, the tenant " �
who was to make thC repairs continuecl to complain to Mr. D�arket about `
various conditions , which resulted in some disagreement between them.-°
After an unlawful detainer action, the tenant agreed to repair the kitchen
ceiling light and the broken window panes on the rear porch . The only
item on the city' s list that A�r. Market was appealing concerned the
basement batliroom, ; and he asked that he be permitted to retain it for
the exclusive use of the rear first floor apartment . He said he was
willing to enclose it for privacy and install a mechanical. ventilator�.'
He had in recent years installed a separate bathroom in the front first
floor apartment, but there was no space available to do so in the rear
unit .
Mr. Market also said he had just sold the property and, as part of th�
_ selling agreement, he had agreed to appeal for a waiver on the question
of the basement bathroom.
Alice Bijjani stated that there was a possible problem with zoning, that
. three apartments might be illegal under the zoning code . She suggested
this be checked be;fore the owner proceeded with the exnense of enclosing
the basement bathroom.
- On the basis of certain facts involving how long the three units had be.en
in existence, as explained by Mr. Market, Ms . Bijjani said it was clear
: that the property would be eligible for a legal non-conforming status
designation under the zoning code .__, Such a status iaould need the aunroval
of housing and building code officials and would depend on Mr. Market
proving hardshin, but Ms . Bijjani said she did not anticipate any problem
in getting approval .
BOARD ACTION : Chairman �liozniak moved that a waiver be granted to permit
: use o t e athroom facilities in the basement for the rear dwelling unit
on the first floox, on condition that the bathroom be enclosed for privacy
� and adequate ventilation be provided, and on furthex condition that all
� remaining violations listed in the city's letter af 3/1/79 be corrected.
. b4r. Glassman seconded. Ni0TI0N CARRIED AND SO ORDERED.
; THE VOTE : Ayes - 6 Nayes - 0 Abstentions - 0
;
;
.
' 4/10/79 - 1�4eeting No . 149
- , > .
' MI:VUTES OF THE MEETING
� S'T. PAUL BOARD OF APPEALS F� REVIEW � ,_
; Tuesday, April 10, 1979
City Council Committee Room 707 -
City Hall and Court House
1 : 30 p .m.
,
MEMBERS PRESENT: D.D. Wozniak, Chairman Ron Glassman �
Arthur Tieso James Voigt
Estyr B. Peake LeRoy Coleman
ABSENT: David Heider �
,
� AGENCIES PRESENT: Community Services Dept. - Division of Housing
and Building Code Enforcement
Alice Bijjani •
OTHERS PRESENT: Ray Farrell
Gary Market
. Bill Holberg
Ron Wagner (District 4 Community Organizer)
STAFF PRESENT: Patricia Moxness
� � . .. � . . . � . . . � . ' . ��, • ��. ' , . .�� �i
' . 1
.. � . � . . . / � . . .- . . , . . _ . � . .
.. . �� � � , � . . . . . � . . � . . ' �� . .
� � . � . / • , . � � � . � .. . . . .� � :. .. . . . . . . . . - �_.
. , . ' . . , . . ` . , . . � . ' _ . , . .
. . . ... . . � . . . �
.;t,. . . � . � .' . . � . . . . � . . � ' .
'♦ . .. � , . � . � . . . ' . . , � .. . ' � . . <.
� . . ,. . . I. . ' . � . . � ,+ .. . .
. . I . . � ' . �. . . . . � , . - . . � � , . .
_ . i��a;� 14", ;14?9 � �
. , .
- ,
- , . ,
, _ :tcr;ist�r £ Dfled, � � .
. � 1�t i�lbcr Citv �tall , , .
S�. Paul, ;Sinaesotn ' . ,
, � ; ,
. D�rzr �i.r: .
, ,
, .
� Attac;iQd or filizis; ��` your. 'off.xce f� a certifi�� cogy of '
. C.F. No. . i2�k, �dopted b;r tl�� C�Lp Cou�ciZ o#i 2L3p, 4, 1'�7�. ,
. , , ;
V�ry truly pours, � • •
, ` i .
, " Rose l�in �
' r it� Cle�k . �
� A�tech. '
cicX `,
' • � �
. ;
I
' , � : ,� 1
, � .. i t •
, _ •
y
' , ,
, r
% �
,
� i , _ ,
� . , �
: , �
� ' i
�- '