272625 ! Y
� � �l'f`1� ��-�,
� $� °�,'�.C�
CITY OF ST.PAUL COUNCIL FILE NO. �'
FINAL ORDER � � '
� By�.�.,..�s.�-.,-.;�...P.�.� .T...;� �Ji,...
File Na 1��
In the Matte# of ��� �; �• � � ��. t0 �t1 �{t. �
co�ts�at� �t 4i�s �erw�i�wl1�, +e��t�i1� �t�r �d �uttt+�,
rf:d�ita +n �ars�rsa�►�r, �at�! Ii�� �, •t+� �ra�c
dra#�ap� lasil�t��s, w� all +��h�r:�re�c �%e�► �rd �e�iia�tE�t
to sa� ' ';i�pernr�nt. +t�tX Ihc���t� �iafl wd �-Oi13
rt�
under�dmi"ms.�i'��rder Ab approved
�����__ � ���
under Preliminary Order �� approved � } 3 ��
s
The Council of the City of Saint Paul has conducted a public hearing upon the above improvement, due notice
thereof having been given as prescribed by the City Charter; and
WHEREAS, The Council has heard all persons, objections and recommendations pertaining to said proposed improve-
ment and has fully considered the same; now, therefore, beroat
RESOLVED, That the Council of the City of Saint Paul does hereby order thafi the above-described improvement
be made, and the proper City officers are hereby directed and authorized to proceed with the improvement; and be it
FURTHER RESOLVED, That upon the completion�of said improvement, the proper City officers shall calculate
all expenses incurred therein and shall report the same to the City Council in accordance with Chapter 14 of the City Charter.
COUNCILMEN Adopte the uncil: Date � � 3 ��
Yeas Nays
�� ertified sed by�'1�ecreta � � 1 4 �g�
�� �In Favor
� Y
Levi ne t�
Nla�do�c Against � �L
Mavor
Schowalt�
�'edesc� PUBLCSHED MAR 1 7 1979
, �/ •
•. K •r..%� / '�Yt'��� . .
, � ��.
f ; `
��r �
a� � �,. ���
�'T"°�`�- CITY OF SAINT PAUL
'�r� �.+� '.'_..
'� .��� a; � DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORK5
',� iiii�ili�ii: ''
4
-� ^- DONALD E. NYGAARD, DIRECTOR
"" �' 234 City Hall,Saint Paul,Minnesota 55102
612-298-4241
GEORGE LATIMER
MAYOR
December 20, 1978
F����'''. ��"'"'�
Mr. Bernard J. Carlson
Di rector of Finance OEC 2 �( 1`�la
Room 109 City Hall
BU I LQ 1 NG ASSESSMENi' SEC1�tClv
DEPARTMENT OF FlNANCE
Attention• Paul Desch ANOMANAG�MENTSERVICES
Re: Improving CASE AVENUE - Arcade St. to Earl St.
City Projects P-0480A and V-0613
Dear S i r:
Will you please take the necessary steps to schedule a public hearing before the City
Council on the foliowing matter:
Improve Case Avenue from Arcade Street to Eart Street by constructing a bituminous
roadway, concrete curb and gutter, sidewalks as necessary, ornamental lighting system,
storm water drainage facilities and all other work necessary and incidental to said i�,,�'
i mp rovemen t. ' �,�,.���1�
� � l
The Engineer's estimate, including Engineering and Inspection is $206,900,'and wilt be�`
fi�anced with $195,600 Municipal State Aid funds and $11 ,300 P. t .A. funds.
Attached is a map and a plan of the proposed improvement.
Sincerely,
� ��
Donald E. Nyg d��/� �
Di rector of Publ ic Wodks4
DJD/JWD/ck
Attachments
. � - � �'�?����
=��``T'�°'a`�- CITY �F SAINT PAUL
_�r �,.� s'', .
-` ' _`� � DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS
° .,�� �= �"i�
,.. iiii':i�,ii �' � ` '�: _
�.►
' : "_ -f� ��---��, � . DONALD E. NYGAARD, DIRECTOR
� isa• .• ;: ..
b. � 234 City Hall,Saint Paui,Minnesota 55102
GEORGE LATIMER '' 612-299-4241
MAYOR
January 2, 1�7� ���'�,-..���s�.,,-�
�
JA N 4 1979
ASSESSMEN7 SECTI4N
DEPARTMENT OF FINqNCE
AND MANAGEMENT SERVtCES
Mr. Bernard J. Carlson
Director of Finance
Room 109 City Halt
BUILDING
Attention: Paul Desch
Re: Case Ave. improvements - Arcade St. to Earl St.
City Project P-0480A and V-0613
Dear Sir:
On December 20, 1978, we requested that you set a hearing on Case Avenue improvements.
We gave an Engineers estimate of $206,900. This figure did not include the ornamental
lighting system.
The lighting system (including Engineering and Inspection) is estimated at $29,600,
and will be financed by CDBG Year V funds. We are anticipating HUQ approval of these
funds on or about June 1 , 1979•
Yours very truly,
Gt�/��,.�..
John W. Davis
P.W. Tech IV
JWO/ck
�C�
� '?" y � i � ' �'• � � � .
�}_ "•� ' � I � � •� y : j i � •'~\� � �. � � �, y �� �^. � I � t '
.- . �} �� '
.t r� ��# , Z a�' i �• � � ; IZ I � � j i �. � � 1 ; ' y 1��, .� � y� y i- ' , �.
«t ' o� ' f 0 � Q, � • �� � • I �-Jf � . • •
•!: �;�� � ?y'� I : � T �I I, , r R �� ' n�o.. .. �a; � � ,�,^ 1 4i C `�••. -'��.+. .0` � ► � � .
"�., �` , � 1 . �� � � Q., ' � � . 'Ir ;3 � , . � !: . . ��
� o�• h (' 4 ,� y w °y O ' • / 1 �, i • �� . �y . •. II
. �yy �4: � � � . � .. .r F 4 2 i � �: 1 a .� � i . �� 1 � • '� " � , '� �i = .
r��� . • . -r • . . . � i � � . . ,E � � { �
' Ti .'.. V � ;1 .ia'_',r�y.� \ y '�.iIi, r.. ii. � . nw• / � . _
" i - � � �.. . . * a � e � �` � • ° . ;' 1 .� � r 4 � S
` �. �..� . i_ . , i � -�'T� .M .MY' tM . �
i �'�ti. � . � • • . : � I I �. � ,�' . •�• . 1 '. r � •� t � =.'_�f'._2.
�y� ��
� I'� . b: . �'�I ^�1 � �w5 � e�o , '`f,9' �'�:Zi 2 � ` . :*- � ,' _�i. +. ` i .1� �
.1 � .. '`` �.!�`,°��hINIY`hly��M � �•lY�. l �`� '' `��� .��� 1� ���� � _� . i2 • � ? tl 2
frt� � � N f.! .�:"' "' '� t ,�. '. • ' •s_ •R iw
:'} �`� -. y�� ' I ..15 � •• . 7r1Y3 $` '•'}' • ...r.`bs � �� ,:..• �.Y:a.w '` � �r� .."LS �
r:, i� � � w . ti s � . . . . ,. ♦.w � .
•r �'� � i ' . Y.r•,.I. y I ynl �"'�A. I. i I. .r�v! 1.�� n.w �. iW,.��l,a:•. ssr �.�.� iro� iw
' f.: �r;' r ' 1 !f I � 1 !� � �f t i � W ' . ��.. � M; ' • .
�tl � "-►'
i �,ti �^Y4'i.;ri i. .I I�lalvl.* � �..I. ..I..�•i�l.j.�: a �� : t" � �. ,, , 4f+` ` � R � 2
� � i ti 1 � � ' � 1�" _ ; _ ` � _ ! ` !'
'` t ' , , , ; , • ,. . . r �
. 'u.4:`- p „ ' ' :. rr �, � wa, �w� �r. � 1 1 � �1 • '�' a° , '+ i� �
; � ' t � 1 e I � . � ' '
�r � � �i . 7 � • �• ' $ � �
�,� �} ,C� � w .l ' I ' ry i ' �� ' � � ' ,�,.. • .....� ' � ,�� • F.• � !i �. •' � _ '; �
.. i. g ^ � � E � i ' 1 ����u:� Z ,� � � ti ►.n
� ��x ♦�jw� �l ♦ , ,���• � I : � �= W'. � ' Pii: \,1 \ . Rti, , � y. !
;.#.f; + „ � ti � 1 �� ��••. «.. ; ,� � �1 Y
�' "�'�. f w�( • • .,,� +. I •w . ^ ` ; � ' ' " ,� • t
� h, t�^' . .` � (`' ..� , � ` ^ o � . �� • o t Q
,? .�. - M « . :I ' � I =n ` � ; . � . 1', ` �. .i� :� �.: . !, . -
.��... . �� .1 �' �I 2 � I � '+ I � � ;` .' M� � . �, � ._ J1 �. _ "�
,. � z �... . , '�"•, ,
; t'�" � • � .. � � I . Q° , •a .� ; �:., �.q, r . � 2
i;. * ' v �� • n . � � e' �eV , . w,n � � ` � �1 , ; � _ r��a�l {{
z , � � I h •� y I. _ � ;V1 h �� ` , �`` � . \. � y• '\ . � � ` a
. $Q'�e t .� -: � � ` t O •y � . � ; r». s l ..w �
� .T+� � � ;. �. 't y I• � � ; � 1 � .�: � 1 . � - . •c s ° {� �
O '6�I��.1 , � q, � : 1 � �° I 1,_ ; � ' .. ,1, , ' ��. "w �'�• 4:,��a !� I
�.••` (�� � � s � %�1 � =' � � r�i��' . . � :¢ . ; in� t�
�ir'>;. ,��,, �'�"i - I a� y � : Gti � .� � . �
' �� �V . �.:�1,F.wl�. ol �� l � �t 9S. r � , , . �" �.�• !�'� .
� �:' . ar q w in. (/�' . 1 � � ••�w��•..:.. �y;� �
��. � �:..t' � ° • �9 i '7; _' SS]+w ID 7N a -. .. 1 �, � '
•�.��r� . . �. r .•��. � �i (f'M �N '0� n.'a rwn�� � iii.Y.r •� TS
-, � ��,�5..-�`Iw��l.'I~I�Iw-I'M1'�w+�l:�:;�i•�~i.I� � M.� & s : ,J�'� ~ i3 � �+�,i�` ��,�: `i!.t.• 'j.i.w�y� � .s... .
�•° _� � .
� }�. � 3�,��i I � • I • �• � • � - �w i a a ` .o.. • • I.''r . w:wn�•.M` � .��� � , o �`.r - ��
: 3"� /�� °, '�.y,,. e ir »3ssn� abe ; t , ` � s�. � ?,' -
�` 1��[ �o .l+il �� Ir • ` . I� . � . � . iw ��r�n;sla: � • .� ar « �«; x� . i . �� •r«�w�, �` �� . ;i'�d� . 7� r�
.: ti. b �. ,a
�* � I�(�� w • I ♦ .I;.. ` • � wi4 � x � ��� '" •�. � 8 . � �� � , L � s. j ,L�1 � `� ; :�Y.�. J'� .
� . . � _ � � , ��;� � " � , - : _ - �
� ��_� vw ' �•.���r ' � . 1 M�4 r w w ; ' - • ' . . '�w� .�, � I.a ��nrrw�w �`. � . •y ?.:'. •
��: �o ��� �-� .� � � �I: E ; . ; _ , � � ;�;� ;N : �; : , . � r�, �� ; ,� - �e
t ~+.� �+ ' 4 � � • � I�'. ' ; ; �.� • n �Q . j I � y . . ; � � ��. - �N � . • r�'�-.
'i �".:,� ('�) O . � � R � � Y 7�.� • I • � • . � � � i: �1 :� i a, . � ;� � 1 � �� $ �, i ` � :{;� �� ..
4. � �
i �:. "" w z �f�-,� � I w • � • � ` 1 . � , I , I 'r' '� � ! : ; ' i � i I , « : � �` : �s. ,a
+ m � � 6 . � • I I �. I HI � ..i . I . ` { l .� �t -`.
�,�` • Vw, c. �� ls p 1 SS]N�l10 $e : ^ ...:_._.� . ; ; �� `'�._�--�-
�"k�� W � Iw w i � • � � i � i �a 'n �. r • . �w �� u. � - � t , ~j�.,��> •
� //1 :' t � � � I I I.A l V � � ! � � � . ' � . . �. � : _ '+a;�!-�
. V13i;�N�! ' �'�`.N.'�w�•� y �' I � Ig�alI : � ; l , ' ~ �! . • ~$ � � , I ^ ! ' � ~ � " 31� ,� ,� .��:�_
��� 1 �w� �w� • �wl�«Iy � •�' � I • � I I .I i - • . :i.' i� . �. �n �y � � • !w.i .n..�. �na �. L_3!":+'_ ��"l�'
:t: � ��`�:X [S : +. • . . �, •1S72►O! :':' 4� �, � ` ' g c, ' xs M1
�:' �Y � NW' . . 3 � i, ' M� , I � �
• J.0 s • 'S: r�� ��n -sii w; r�i � �... � r L�( 'N�v ' 1T��rTA����;
x (l• . �31,� i cr,: . 7 � •- i • .. � Y^� _ �. •� ;e : a' 't..c'� i '; -- x
rK.� � � ; .� .� i. .•i ;.; ' r� � , II , � - �` ! � ' ';'$�, . i � , � �.. .ot z
►� �.,j Gti=• 'r�l e , i I ( v ; W j• � R' . . J !� '; ;■ p ,
r� ` ; '���c• 9 ..r `� e � ,� � �. .i � i �I '1 � r �,� � 1 �� � � 6%
7/'1 -1 . ti ! � 1 � I y � I 1 �� i� ! �
+ lJ1 � i � �� �` �n' � I � I L I e "n I � '+ � ' +. �/ � � �� � �
.q+� e ' i� ' w � `, f � � � , ^..�� i � .� a . � •�r.�•t w«� '� '�/ � i� �� ~ 1 �
.���� ti ;� y ; �7 � � � �. (. ,� . . i .I Z, •+; •�' ..► .1 u • � . .
. �l O M . I � , I I O � i �� f`� ; .t ; , ..
� .- : ;j. . _ � . . :, � �., • -. . .
•��''� w • W � '� �-' � i � � 4 �' i � . '" � l 1 � � h �
�-.�' ��� yQ I. 9. .i ; �f � i I � � 3 I : : ��J� i � . � �� �T 1 �� � s {" �
'�'' 1 �` f. � �' ^ Vf � ' ' I � 1 I � .1 � '� :�P� ; I, � i �
: � V"�J � � t. .. � O I � . .I � 1 y � 3�• a � . �( ! �r�I� � � � . � +
' �1� � �
� w j .I ' �x'. �•N :�! y� i i w (� Q � t I � ti ��: � �1 ;� � !� C }, � �
�• � i . ::� � i ` � ;, w !� Q � � ..J1. .1 J ..I ' U� � h � � �
�. � ' ' , x; �.� Ii � i� . � I � �, , _ L 4� _ "` � �; ' _
�. � � ." >o•� ; ; I :e � � i ► ; I � `: ';� �;: ':�:•'; :! � � � 1• ` ' _
� „ �,� � �_ �� . �' �. .,� ,� � t, . �
S- - � �i' ' r I I• a . 2 . � ( � :
. °��.+ . � , I �- • L' � h ` "1 � I I _ 1 ..V ' . � .'�; y : 1: It � '
3 � .�`r . �t�`,.i" ,« �! � � I 1 ^ � �; . �,_ �.r� .b_ � . � , (r i � ; � �1 � ,.
:� S �� .« .1"� . '� � t ( �_�.��. '.
- t �' ..•+��. . 15 I d100N3W :1 � .' ►', ; F • �rwwiwr-..
r : ..y i �:�.�t !w ' �,_�y.. ` P 7.r��'...r, y w 1,..'�n' w! �; � . .3 I ' '+ � : 'u.
, k� � I �_- � � ' � !t �
..;,.,'. � C w' ��-�• W� ; � ; � � ti , � � � ti � � •� � • � 1 � + • � E
Y' . O � � � � I �' •y ,� � . I ~ I � ^ � '1 . . • � '/'' I � � �� $ ..
.l; I p � I I , .� , O � '
�_ � " .oc { I• � y � !• � � � l l: J j r:
y •� �1. � _i I \ . \ � `1 !� 1 � � • \ � 1. i .. �-' �
1 . � I I �' d' � I � 1 ' '1 '' . 7 1 � � � �t
� ; .i :�, .N� ` � .� ( ;. + 1 I ' s' � � � i a ; r;,i �,F ,� 1 l t a .
. • � F?' .. • .I ' � I ` � I f ^ � ' ' I �� � �- .
. y •.3 �- � � 1 .j �p � (
I i . � / �
2 ~ . w 1r� ~ .� � �! ��}' �� � � ' �t' ....' ;,� � `� � I -t � .
� o'y„ '� ,�i' � j{ +^. � i I I. Q � �st .I � I. 4 � „ � �y M ��I� , �p `S�J I � � C` - •
'i�� Y ; � ,I� _ ' .f I..� �� ; i. . � e �.,,; . ••� r � , }..; a: l ; E S -
%t • � �; � :.�. Y I J« �I � �. y l ! .r' .. .,� I � ` i ' ;�4 . ' i � . � � � .
,y:�. . ��� � � (:� � � 4 s •7 i � t':�• � � , :
- � _ � � � � � 1 � � t ; * . « 7 i � ��.�--
�'•� � 1 : '�:- 2 . .. I � � ` " � - �f1 1 ?� v � � E � -
.� . I . � 5 = � . , � j ti �:
��,�,. � 2 .� ��,. , � — . � ,� � �.--t -{ � , � � tt � : , .
1:. � i�y . .3 j �y � I ` � � �j ' � � i S � 4� ' ;
�a� w � � i�.: '. ' . 1� w 17 ^' D ` � �� � R � � �
.Ay' _..� �+..P,�t�-'..'+�'•t�'_l } i`� .r .. �n .,a i�. .;'-' . �.. J , t�� ' I�A..�...... ... . �J�..1..� � � _ '_ � .abr
�'r.�.l.�•�'f5-!• �a � � .1�..�
�.:. !•j : a -i;- rt_•._-._._•_�.�..!. ......�._ , �,�,. 301yOiY1►.:._. ..«....t r--�-,-- 4j =
, . . . �w...i'�wr' . ...'�:- ��� �°i'�1 �n' .iwr_:N•:�a 1"N:!'�.''i^^ti'.�~?��� w ('!�'�+.(,l�►��,1`IN'`IN' 'L '.���. ' � �+
. , , :N _�`t_'^
� �; . �����
i "• ' • Summary of Engineering Recommendations �
��.'�~ '
Report Prepared - December 5, 1978 �� ��
Publ ic Hearing - �`-�
� � _
ADVISABILITY AND DESIRABILITY
PROJ�CT: .
. Improve CASE AVENUE from Arcade Street to Earl Street by constructing a
bituminous roadway, concrete curb and gutter, sidewalks as necessary,
ornamental lighting system, storm water drainage facilities� and all other
work necessary and incidental to said improvement. City Projects P-048Q
and V-0613. . �
EXISTING CONDITIONS:
Case Avenue is a minor arterial , and is on the Municipal State Aid System.
There is no curbing from Arcade to Forest. From Forest to Earl there is
concrete curbing in fair to poor condition. The roadway is an oiled surface
and varies in width from 30' to 44' .
The sidewalks are in fair to good condition and we. are planning only a smali
percentage of replacement.
Most of the Elms on this street have been removed and new trees planted by
the City Forestry Department.
Present street lighting is located on N.S.P. poles. Lights are widely spaced
and light tevels are inadequate.
PROPOSED IMPROVEMENTS:
Since this street is considered a collector street, the proposed construction
would be heavier than a residential street and somewhat wider. The proposed
width for the entire length of the project is 36' with parking banrted on one
side of the street. .
Only that walk which is badly broken or tree heaved will be reconstructed.
Al1 driveways witl be reconstructed where existing drives �xist. All
existing house outwalks will be reconstructed. Boulevards will be regraded
and sodded f rom curb to sidewalks and an energy efficient sodium vapor
lighting system will be installed.
ALTERNATES: �
The width of the roadway could be increased to 44' and this would allow parking
on both sides of the street. Widening to a 44' roadway in a 60' right-of-way
would reduce the boulevard to 3' and in areas of 6' sidewalk, it would be
reduced to 2' . This narrow boulevard would require the removal of all trees.
Do nothing - the riding surface would remain quite rough and the boulevards
would continue to erode where curbing does not exist.
F .
e �
� '
� � �
� �" � � � . -2- �'������
t�r
, �` �����
POSITIVE BENEFITS: r..
Complete improvement of the public right-of-way will greatty enhance and add
to the quality and character of the neighborh�od.
ADVERSE EFFECTS:
Minor disruption to the area during construction is the only conceivable
adverse effect. Most h�mes in the construction area are serviced by public
alleys which should help to minimize the inconvenience.
SPECIAL CONSIDERATIONS:
Ornamental lighting will not be done with the roadH�ay construction. A separate
contract will be awarded for this item in an attempt to obtain better unit
costs. Construction of all work will be properly coordinated however.
Public Involvement: On September lg, 1978, a public informationat meeting
was held in conjunction with the Dis.trict 5 Council meeting. Most of the
residents at this meeting preferred the 36' width and the District Council
motioned and approved the 36' width as proposed by the Department of Public �
Works. �
TIME SCHEDULE:
If this project is approved, construction could begin in the Spring of 1979
and be completed within 60 days.
COST ESTIMATE AND FINANCING: COST MSA PIA CD YR. 5
Paving, curbing, walk, etc. $203,000 $188,200 $14,800
Ornamental Lighting 29,600 $29,600
SGJRCE OF ADDITIOiJAL i�lF�'?MATIOiJ. � '
For additional information, contact the project engineer, Tom Kuhfeld at 29$-5311 •
. RECOMMENDATION:
The Department of Public Works strongly feeis that this is a worthwhile project
and the Engineering Recommentaion is for approval of the order.
Respectfully submitted,
Donald E. Nygaard
Director of Public Works
� �
�
�=
- 6�� 'n ����
. � `� �^�
�e . R
-� � �--� �
� , � � ��-�
' i �nt o�ras�F>� �
. t.. :y. d�t#��..
�,� �'-t�— ;c��'��
��
;v� .
� .. '.i= i_ ,
��
I � i
�
��'�� � i�j...
,,�'s
I I.!i II I;�p�.....
.;
-'"::�X:,-,
��.
•�
�
��
�
�i''i
I P �
�
T
+ .
4 � � d
11
c