273747 M�HITE - CITY CLERK Ayi� ►�Ji.�� ww
PINK - FINANCE COURCIl. •D� /�� /A�
'ANARY - DEPARTMENT I TY OF SA I NT PAUL � �� f ��
�LUE I't- MAVOR {�{9� 0 0 j �
File N 0.
- C ncil Resolution
Presented By �
Referred To Committee: Date
Out of Committee By Date
WHEREAS, The Council of the City of Saint Paul at a public
hearing held on August 22, 1979, and continued to September 12,
1979, considered testimony relevant to the renewal of the
Secondhand Dealer' s License issued to David Doepner, d/b/a
East Side Appliances, 1080 Earl Street; and
WHEREAS, The licensee appeared together with his attorney,
A. Keith Hanzel; and
WHEREAS, Testimony was presented by concerned neighbors,
the Police Department, and the applicant; and
WHEREAS, The attorney for the applicant was afforded an
opportunity to cross-examine all witnesses; and
WHEREAS, Evidence was presented that the licensee was
storing refrigerators and washing ma.chines outside of the
enclosed limits of the appliance store; and
WHEREAS, Evidence was presented that the licensed establish-
ment was a gathering place for young adults; and
WHEREAS, Evidence was presented concerning confrontations
between the young adults who gather at the licensed premises and
neighborhood residents; and
WHEREAS, The members of the Council agreed that evidence
justified a renewal of the license with conditions; now, therefore,
be it
COUNC[LMEN Requested by Department of:
Yeas Nays
In Favor
_ __ Against BY
Form A d y City tt
Adopted by Council: Date
Certified Passed by Council Secretary BY
gy.
Approved by 1Qavor: Date _ Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
By _ _ _ By
WHI7E - CITV CLERK
PINK - FINANCE 1 �
CANARV - DEPARTMENT GITY OF �SAINT PAUL COUI1C11 ,� � • � �
j3LUE��- MAVOR � ��
File N 0.
Council Resolution
Presented By
Referred To Committee: Date
Out of Committee By Date
2.
RESOLVED BY THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL, That the
Secondhand Dealer' s License issued to David Doepner, d/b/a East
Side Appliances at 1080 Earl Street, is hereby renewed, subject
to the following conditions:
1, That the licensee shall not store appliances outside
of the enclosed limits of the building located at
1080 Earl Street or the detached storage shed; and
2. That the licensee shall conduct the licensed business
in the manner for which it is intended, to-wit:
The repair, display and offering for sale of
used appliances, and for no other purpose and
the licensee shall, in conducting said business,
do so in a lawful and peaceful manner;
and
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, That the License Inspector is instructed
to report back to the Council in 90 days, whether the licensee has
complied with the conditions set forth above or the ordinances of the
City of Saint Paul; and, be it
FINALLY RESOLVED, That upon the report of the License Inspector
the Council shall determine whether a hearing should be scheduled to
consider renewal or revocation of the license.
Yeas �MC ahon E Na s Requested by Department of:
Y
Hozza
� In Favor
Levine �
Maddox _ __ Against BY — --
Showa
T esco
Ado ed by Counc : Date $�p � 5 1979 Form Appr b City A or
ertified sed by Co cil Secretary BY
/A v d by Ylavor: D e ���6 1979 Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
By
Pust,��KE� 0 CT 6 1979
�� � �7� 7 �7
..a.o�.�wi.,���
_��'��?• �.°� CITY OF SAINT PAUL
=�•` :;'��_,,
�• •= OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK
:� �:
;,+ iiii'iii'n ��
<:• - BUREAU OF RECORDS
`���, �...
''�+n.�n,,,,.��'��� 386 Cily Hall,Saint Paul,Minnesota 55102
GEORGE LATIMER 612-298-4231
MAYOR
September 13, 1979
Mr. Ed Starr
City Attorney
Room 647, City Hall
St. Paul, Minnesota
Dear Sir:
The City Council requests that you confer with the License
Inspector and the attorney for Mr. Doepner and prepare a
resolution granting the Second Hand Dealer General License
application at 1080 Earl Street, sub�ect to conditions on:
1 - Behavior of persons in and around location.
2 - Storage
3 - A condition pertaining to the son of the applicant
living in the upstairs apartment.
4 - A 90-day license provision.
Very truly yours,
Rose Mix
City Clerk
ABO:la
cc: Mr. Carchedi, License Inspector
�O
. � .
t �
, , ; :�. ' O .•
_.`.. .. �. �
1075 Arcade
. � Saint Paul, Minneaota 55106
' July 30, 1979
�-
- � Councilman David Hozza
- :z;T. �* Preaident
Saint Paul City Council
�= ,:'. � 7th Floor - City Hall .
� � 8aiat Ps�ul; Minneeote 55102
`�;��a:�;` �° � .
�. . - �ear Counailaian Hozza:
�, ,
.� � - In s letter deted June 15 directed to you the Dietrict 5 Planning -
�� G,onncil addr�ased their eoac�rne regarding a busiaess located at
� , 1Q80 Earl Street. Some of the concerna that were �oiced to the
- �ouacil by reaidente residing near the busineas were: 1)The problem -
_ `* ��` oi aethetica witb aa applis�aoe store, etc., when the majority of
x:°.
, - the area is reaidential; 2) Appliances stored outside. This is
in direot violation oi their aecondhand dealer'e license; 3) The
a�•thod oY loe�diag e�nd unloading equipment - obstructs traffic flow
aad the aidewalke for pedeatrians.
�In fai�neae to the ownere ot the appliance Etore, a meeting wae
(� . calltd by the District 5 pl.anaia8 Council in late June to provide
.:�,� 1 , ,�2#,em tlie epportuaity to reepoad to these concerne. A follow-up
���-�� feetiag was held on July 17 and from commente ms�de by, residents
�und Council members who_had over the paat month visited the site
;��: � on mors�than one occasion fe3t that an efiort ha.d been mad
�:�=:�: � aompa.y rrith aome of the concerns expressed. Ve seriously. wever,
` '� if this elea►a-up wae c�one in good faith or merely in eu�t���:ipation
'..'L^'t.. - .� . .
�'�'� oY the Auguet 1 renewal af their license. .
:,:s, -
; We would, therefore� at thia time� wish to reaffirm our aupport of
r�'� � � thia aeigbborhood by again aaking that the City rs-zone thia
��L�,�t ' property to residential.
� Sincerel
. Y•
� � /
�..��`./—J_��/ ,/�.n '��f'`'� lv-
Doug For�rg %•�l'! ,�
� President �
DF/8v
cc: City Council Repreeentativea
�Q Joe Carchedi
:�'
. �
- TYPE OF CALL DATE
Thefts :
1060 Earl Street 3-g-�g
1063 Earl Street 5-24-79
1028 Magnolia Street 6-g-�g
1076 Magnolia Street 8-16-79
Accidents :
1063 Earl Street 6-22-79
Landlord-Neighbor Trouble :
1095 Magnolia Street g-1g-79
Domestic :
1073 Earl Street 1-28-79
Burglary:
1080 Earl Street 8-31-79
1090 Earl Street 6-22-�g
1075 Magnolia Street 12-22-��'
Disorderly Boys :
1080 Earl Street 6-15-79
1013 Magnolia Street 7-17-79
1045 Magnolia Street 7-18-79
1083 Magnolia Street 8-18-79
1083 Magnolia Street 8-22-7g
1095 Magnolia Street 6-25-79
Investigate:
1080 Earl Street 6-15-79
1084 Earl Street 6-16-79
1033 Magnolia Street 4-18-79
1083 Magnolia Street 8-18-79
1083 Magnolia Street 1-10-79
1113 Magnolia Street 12-13-78
. , ,
. • '
• TYPE OF CALL DATE
Traffic Violation:
1084 Earl Street 5-5-79
1076 Magnolia Street 2-8-79
Forgery:
1090 Earl Street 8-21-79
1090 Earl Street 6-10-79
Malicious Destruction of Property:
1090 Earl Street 6-20-79
1090 Earl Street 1-30-79
1091 Magnolia Street 8-3-79
Alarms :
1090 Earl Street 3-5-79
Animal Bites :
1017 Magnolia Street 7-22-79
Deaths:
1076 Magnolia Street 4-1-79
Assaults :
1083 Magnolia Street 8-21-79
1084 Magnolia Street 8-22-79
1092 Magnolia Street 5-5-79
Peeper-Prowler:
1092 Magnolia Street 4-28-79
CALLS - MONTH OF YEAR:
1979 - January 3 1979 - July 3
" February 1 " August 10
" March 2
" April 3 1978 - December 2
" May 3
" June 9
. ' ' '
LOCATION NO. OF CALLS DISPOSITION
Earl Street
1060 1 Report
1063 2 G.O.A. - Report
1073 1 Advised
1080 3 Assisted-Advised-Service not Rea.
1084 2 Assisted - Advised
1090 6 Assisted - P.dvised - (4) Reports
Magnolia Street
1013 1 G.O.A.
1017 1 Report
1028 1 Report
1033 1 Advised
1045 1 Advised
1075 1 Advised
1076 3 (3) Reports
1083 5 Advised-G.O.A.-Unfounded- (2) �?F�
1084 1 Report
1091 1 Report
1092 2 Advised - G.O.A.
1095 2 Advised - G.O.A.
1113 1 Assisted
TOTAL - 36
Dispositions :
Reports - 15
Advised - 10
Assisted - 4
Gone on Arrival - 5
Services not Required - 1
Unfounded - 1
, , :: T —
. .
. r _ �
. : , , � � r'-,._, .r��� ,.� L f.1 �
'. , i , T � ;� ,
s: . _ , _ _ � _
_ � . � ; -
, . � . , f .
, '' , j � � .
� , ,
i ' `, , � - ,
,. , ,
- � ,.
, , . � � ;
, �
• _ ,� , i , '
/. , � - � , � :
. , ' �� .
. � �� ,
,` ' , : i �ti� �
. t �'fi
� v�
. - s��� as, �srs, �,,�
� , � � + -�
,- ; _
. . � , ,
,. _ .
, _ ,
- . ; , , � � . ;
rYr. 3�ph r�rer�sas - , . ;�
L�t+a�nee It»ip��r : . : , �
� .2�?9, Ci�}i 8e�1 � � f�,
, .,
" St. IRa�a�l.. Mit�sc►�a ` - ;
, . _ r
DQ's� Sfr s � � � � _
� �
; �: , . ;
r '4RttSt!#�d i3 �t 1�O�g Of A t'BBOIt3!#t�t &dcs'ptEUd,'�ay th�e C1�y �im�31 �OdBy, .C,F. Nd.
' 2737+��, .r�inggChe Se��� �iani�t U�alers La.c�ee 2�auect r� b�d �Dosprier at
1Q6Q �r�: Str� st���t -to a�rtaiu co!�di�i��i.. .��a C�C� C,�+ail r�q�uests ti�t' '
\ yo�er �ap�c� b� pl,acra oA a Wad�da� ,�gascta faa 94 dsys `rith th� prog�r b�igh- ' ,
� bo�rhood �oata�ta to bo �tifl...i. � _ . :
� " _�
,, , Ve:9 tretil,Y Y��. � �
� . % r
R,oee M'�.at . - .
; , Gity Clark , '
_
, a�ta�h�st . . , _
. ,r .
� ABOls�� : , � �
- . . . . . . _ . . � .. �. � . . . , . . . , . . . i. . .
� , � � . . . . . . . . . .. � - . . . _, .
. . . . .�. . . • . . , . . .. �- . ' i
� � � .. ' . . � . ' �. . . f� �. i ,. ' ' , .
t . .. . . . . . . ' . . . . , . . .
. . . � . �i . . , . ,, .
� � . ,. , � � .. . , ' . . . . . . . . : .. • . � �.(. .
� � . � .. . ' . . . - � ; . � � i . . � . . . ' � .. .�
.. � .. . � . .. . . � . - I � . � . .. � . ' . . � ' . .
. �� � � � � � " ' . . . , ' ' � . . . ' . � . � �
. ' � .� . � , ' � . � . ' . ' ' . � . ' ., , 1
, . � � , i . . ' ,, . ' . . , . . " . . � , . .. . . . � . ... ... .. . �
� � ������ �
,� �.i �? ri � �
ALTERNATIVE COUNCSL RESOLUTION
RESOLVED BY THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF ST. PAUL, That the
Secondhand Dealer's License issued to David Doepner, d/b/a/ East
Side Appliances at 1080 Earl Street, is hereby renewed, subject
to the following conditions:
I. That the licensee shall not store appliances outside
the building located at 10&0 Ear1 Street or a detached
covera�e�storage shed; and
2. That the licensee shall conduct the licensed business
in the manner for which it is intended, to-wit:
The repair, display and offering for sale of
used appliances , and for no other purpose and
the licensee, employees, and others, shall, during
all hours, conduct themselves in a lawful and
peaceful manner;
and 3. That the licensee shall maintain the building including
the upstairs rental unit in conformance with all
applicable code standards .
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, That the License Inspector, is
instructed to report back to the Gouncil every 90 days, whether
the licensee ,has complied with the conditions set forth above
or the ordinances of the City of St. Paul and specifically to
determine if conditions have existed which constitute a public
nuisance or permitting publ�c nuisance as defined in Minnesota
Statutes 609. 74 to 609.745; and, be it �
FINALLY RESQLVED, That upon the report of the License Inspector
the Council shall determine whether a hearing should be scheduled
to consider renewal or xevocation of the license.