274442 WHITE - CITV CLERK
B�,�E F� „oR E GITY OF SAINT �AUL Council �����+�i
CANARV - DEPARTMENT
Cl�.y A�`�ny/RHZ File N 0. ��
� UCouncil Resolution
RETURN COP'Y TO L TIO
Presented By �
Referred To , Committee: Date
Out of Committee By Date
RESOLUTION APPROVING SETTLEMENT OF EMINENT DOMAIN
LITIGATION ARISING FROM WIDENING OF AALE STREET.
WHEREAS, on December 2, 1975, the Council of the City of Saint
Paul adopted a Final Order In Condemnation, Council File No. 268009
as amended by Council File No. 270482 adopted January 31, 1978,
which Orders authorized the acquisition of the following described
property located� within the City of Saint Paul:
Except the South 60 feet, the West 20 feet of Lot 14,
and except the South 60 feet, Lot 15; and the South
60 feet of the West 30 feet of Lot 13 and the South
60 feet of Lots 14 and 15; and, all of Lots 16 and 17;
all in Block 1, Michel' s Subdivision of Block 4 ,
Stinsons Division; and
WHEREAS, on June 21, 1978, the City of Saint Paul initiated
eminent domain proceedings in Ramsey County District Court to condemn
said property for the purpose of widen�.rr�g Dal� Stxe�t �between ;�i an
Buren and Minnehaha, the case being entitled City of Saint Paul
v. Robert G. Rosen, et al. , Court File No. 428413; and
WHEREAS, on November 16, 1978, the Court appointed Commissioners
filed their Award for the taking of Parcel "C" therein, in the sum
of $58,000. 00, whereupon Respondent filed an Appeal of said Award,
and in response, the City filed its Cross-Appeal; and
WHEREAS, City, according to Minnesota law, has paid to
Respondent Anthony Podgorski the Commissioner's Award as to
Parcel "C" , or $58,000. 00, by Court deposit; and
COUNCILMEN Requested by Department of:
Yeas Nays
8utler Fina and 1�nagement Services
Hozza In Favor �J
Hunt D�rector
Levine __ Against BY
Maddox �
Showalter
Tedesco Form prove by ttorne
Adopted by Council: Date ,
Certified Passed by Council Secretary �Y' ������� � ������
gy.
Approved by 1Navor: Date _ Approved by Mayor for Submi ion to Council
sy By ��� ��a�v�'vl�
M�HITE - C�TV CLERK COUIICIl `�.���'���
PINK - F�NANCE GITY OF SAINT PAUL `"'-'
CANARV - DEPARTMENT File NO•
BLUE - MAVOR �
RET�IRN COPY TO VpLUATIOPT StJREAU . .
ouncil Resolution
Presented By . ` ,
Referred To Committee: Date
Out of Committee By Date
-2-
WHEREAS, Respondent has contacted the City seeking settle-
ment of said matter, and Respondent has, after negotiations,
offered to settle the matter and dismiss its appeal for the
Commissioners' Award of $58,000.00 plus $1,500.00; and
WHEREAS, the Office of the City Attorney has reviewed
the offer, the file and the evidence in detail in preparation
for jury trial, and now recommends that this settlement offer
be accepted.
NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Council of the
City of Saint Paul hereby approves settlement of the pending
eminent domain litigation entitled City of Saint Paul v.
Robert G. Rosen, et al. , Court File No. 428418 as to Parcel
"C" therein with Respondent` Anthony Podgorski, for $1�.500.00
in excess of the A�ard of the Court appointed Commissioners
of $58,000.00, and that as a result thereof, Respondent shall
dismiss its appeal of said Award. It is provided that this
settlement be paid from Fund No. PIR 60000.711-000 (L-7835), to be
reimbuxsed from M.S.A. Fund.s.
COUNCILMEN
Yeas Na s Requested by Department of:
Mc�N y �
��, [n Favor F��' � and Mana ment Services
�nt
Levine _ O __ Against B — Direc�or
Maddox
Showalter
Tedesco (�[B � 4 ',�80 Form A ve by Cit Attorney
Adopted by Council: Date ��� f/��� �� � '
`� �.�C�li�.-f a ����
Certified Vass b ouncil S etary BY'
By C1���� �� ,�
� � �
f�pp d y �Navor: Da FEB i 9 19$0 Approved by Mayor for Submission to Counci
By _ — — BY
�lj�t,iSNED MAR 1 ig80
. � "�e a' "T`�.,-'p;.'T'"'°y����` �y °"'�"" '�.5...� �.-^^^a�^s -.a° 7mm"�•.�"zsG.�fA�!�;im-�r'ii€«�rt.^p'�.�v',�
_ ��`� �� `�+� ��.� ��� •
� +
y� • .. . :.�..t' ��8�� , k u�
���RT�CN Cl' AY�I�SINIST�.�TIV�;' ///y���R��,
�`��U i � ■n�u irnr�ui�r�r`�.r�.w��r�i r���. s •
}�� �o�tF�2.�1�,.,�,,,,._ANn �;c.�� ' �����. „t`
,. - � �: � � �����
" ��� �>>
� .�� �` �.� �� � � ' � fk�
�a = . ��� lg� `� � ,; �`�
,. , .
.
i98Q
� ��
. , _ " ��� ��{' ,
: ��.wa� �,
Z'�i: l�f��t GECR�GE Z�1T� �r��`�
; � �#�����r
� �� � __ • � � ' *� . .. .. � �-< k�fp7�� ts
�r .� �,.: �eJ►tidvs�ts �9� �f �! ���i�� �l M'��,�{�� '�����"��� �' -
� � x � - � i �:�i 'ya k t:^}�,�i��� a:
'�`�• �, ' � ��i �l�: 7'ilY �������'� +� �'+��F i�, 1 s � ��, � #�`a�k��e" :` `�.}��.��t "�..s
y i ��y r � �;�rr ��Ur �C a,,?+a�cy,.� '' � '� i i.l„'y�� �.s�.�'i.1 � .� ,
� ,•��i���i�'�f "'�����' 7 1 fj t° �: 7 > � �j"�'�iS f '3r n t� fo,„ s.K+r4 3 er y xw�� -.
V �P�S������i� f s�.d���"i.. } dC� 4�"1'r i ., �t ,• �-.i ?�e} a�
w�'-, ` �r a x ��.t� f 3� '�.a� + t -n t "x�
� ...: , _�. �I �: '. '.. � it-� a �',� ��� � ,�
.f• f
.,+ i = �r t,.�' � �i��'�
. �R k ur .�` t .a;r 'rxi a `',`�,w��4y�'�, 1 {���,�"' �*ti�•t
�' e . r h'� { �'�� ih t� ' t ' f����tiK�? r: ;1 ���'�
� _ r x a "t� $! ,j""� � ,.?},� �a .
:� �.�,a ar ; :N� � �{ �n�ts�. .� �� ��r'� �,
rc . t.
� �� K
, ` ` � _ ,
+ � 1�, 4
. . . .�, .�. , ,'. ,,' ' - .p,�+y �xi
,� . . . .•� , . � .
,_ .
, � , - i. .. ."- + �i e
r A' "�'� <
� J �l 'A''� � f 'At € 1 +0
. . r , � . . -. ,Sy:S I`
� . i''""'k»� ,. a.'a
_ . �� ,� a.� . 1 `,��+�pt��.
.�R2 ��� _ � ��� ���� ��
� ;.�
� . - , . . . , ..'` ,. ,,. , � � ..
b�!' 't1�e �I�a,' Ewl 't�1C a'�'��let� �t+@'BE��Ci�:+�q, �u�` �� � "� �' �� � � � .
.. s �f� � ��'w'!',�s'� 2� >
I r t
� ; � � x���
_ r� �a �„� r .
� ' �;�. � �� �, ��� � �.
` � t ,�
� . • h s -�y :•i
. �� � � 3 ��$, �
�. ' �,
� �x���
j1�. . .,,e , x' � �'�' ' ,
. � . � F� }!r.,' ..
� .• .:. . .., �. . ' " . . . .,�'_. y
ir �
.
� ;..'. . ,� . rT
.
�
. ..i . . ., - s �4�{� -
' �j�y s.�'F#�:'. .
i � t�
�
. {r� . . . . . ,. ru � �:
. .. t��: . . . ��i�+' �{
.. �� 1 -.. 4 `.
� T m fkA�P'�
� i . . . ,� . ' ' ...., - . ��
, x
' :� .� � � ��.,Ary.4�
t
y� f
y ,1� �x
�� . .. ..L },t k t };�.� tw
� . .. .. .. , . . . ... � .r�.. ��:
�.�o �.��+a� FoR �=s ae�rzox:
��.�
� �
s t �t �,5c�o.c�v to �r: �at�► roa�o�rs�d. .�:s � a�.�rs �e ���, ,r��� --����
� e. `�
T'hia e�aqt� tw�ti� i�aclr�tte all e�+�atts; .fa��t, ��.s �d, �1� �� ' r ' �:,t
wi � ,
" � t.e�nd s�►ti.r�e►ctiva ot a�.l. a�ges. Pay�ie� c�f �4-�,�0.c�.;�]:d be p.i.AB � .
. � � � . , � , � �
. �T l�n� 6ot�a.7u-c� f�-7s35)� to b. r��bur�e���. �.a�«I�t t�r�t. : ,�
. _ .
. , -
: , .. ; - �
, � : =_ - ,
�
, _
� :;
. . �,.
. . . �..{ � . � , . . . , � . �. . .. . . .. .. � . � 4r r�;
.. . �i . . �� .. � ... .. � . . . . .. .. .. , . . .
- � . . . . . � � . - - � � � . � . �� , . . . .. , � � . . . � -
,
�_ , - . . , . � ,
. . . . .. � - � . . � . � . . . � � . . .� -� � . � � '€'.
. `� . .. . . . . _ . - . . .. � . . . .. _. . . , .. �.
.• � . . `A g,,
, �i.1�a !a� a;�p��s1 snd ai'b�i,ssicm tc� City Ca�aall. ��`
.
� _, ,
� , - ,�
_�: V _ -�;