Loading...
275816 WFIIT6 - CITY CLERK � 1 PINK - FINANCE ���1 CANARI� - DEPARTMENT COUIICII �ti�o � BLUE - MAYOR G I T Y O F S A I N T� PA LT L File N O. � ou 'l Resolution Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date BE TT RESOLUED, That the Cotmcil o� the City of Sa.int Paul hereby certifies and approv�es the action of the City of Saint Paul Board of Appeals and Review perta.inin� to the follaw- in,g listed property and as shown by the Excerpted. Minutes of said Board of Appeals and Re- vi.ew, da.tes September 9, 1980, and marked EXHIBIT A, and attached hereto and ma.de a part hereof by reference: I]ATE OF BOARD MI1.VU7.�'.S CASE N0. PROPER7.'Y APPELIANT 9/8/80 34-80-H 951 W. 7th St. Michael Rc�ach (14 tmits) BQARD ACTION: Gran.ted variance of St. Paul Legislative Code, Sectian 54.11, pertaininig to bathroam facilities, to permit occupancy of six apartr�n.ts where 2� baths are shared, � conditian that ane additianal shawer or tub facility be inGtalled, sa.id occupancy to be limited to one persan per tmit. Property Description: Stinson's Subdivisian of Block 25 of Stinsan, Brawn and Ra�nsey's Additian � Lots 10 and 11, Block 25 -------------------------------- 9/9/80 37-80-H 1281-83 Sherburne Av�e. Marv�n Koenig, Jr. (t�a� Lmits) BOARD ACTION: Gran.ted variances of St. Paul Legisla.tiv�e Code, Section 54.13, perta.inin� to ceiling height and occupancy of sleeping roams more than 50% belaw gracle, on canditian tha.t a secand sta.irway fram fisst floor to base��n.t be installed and that appellant co�nply with code require�ents in all other respects. Froperty Descriptian: Syndica.te No. 5 Additian I.ot 30, Block 26 --------------------------------- COUNCILMEN Yeas Nays Requestgd by Department of: Hunt Levine [n Favor Maddox McMahon B snowaiter __ Against Y — Tedesco Wilson Form Approved by City Attorney Adopted by Council: Date — �,; - Certified Passed by Counc.il Secretary B9"� - ����� �� ' �`" ' �� By Approved by ;Nayor: Date _ Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council By _ – BY WHITE - CITY CLERK PINK - FINANCE 2r75�16 CANARY''- DEPARTMENT G I TY O F SA I NT PA U L COUtIC1I � BLUE - MAYOR File N . " Council Resolution Presented By _ � Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date and be it FUR'IHm RESOLVED, That the City Clerk is hereby authorized and directed to transznit a copy of this resolutian for recording to the Ramsey Co�ty Office of the Register of Deeds. . -2- COU(VCILME[V Requestgd by Department of: Yeas Nays -iinnl. ���e � [n Favor nnad� �' snowaker __ Against BY Tedesco wlson Adopted-by Council: � Date OCT 1 6 1980 Form Approved by City Attorney C tified P• •- by Co Se�`retary �V d l, � A ved by :14ayor: � Cj 2 � 1�� Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council /� - By �� 0 C T 2 5 1980 . , � , ����.s -6- 9/9�80 - Meeting No. I65 � - - L� I-� C3 I T X I � CASE N0. PROPERTY APPELI�ANT � 34- 80-H 951 tiV. 7th St. ]�iichaeT Raach (14 units - rooming house) ' SUBJECT : ec{t�st waiver of St. Paul Heal.th Dept. ' s as~der to remove stoves and refrigerators from six• units : APPEARANCE: Michael Roach Naomi Neimann� care�aker ��m. McCausland K�sidents o� affected ui23_'�s PROCEEDINGS : Mr. Roach said he felt zt was unr.easonable �:o he ordex�d to remov�e t�ie stov�s and refrigerators . T-ie explained ��at since he bought the building in January, 1978, he had completed a Iong ].ist �f repairs and had vacated four units that Iacked a t�rindo�r tha.t could be - used as a second means of egress in an emexgen.cy. There z,rere 2',. hath- rooms shared by 14 persons . He introduced Mxs. Neimann, who hacl been caretaker of the building for 39 yeaxs . He saa.cl a7.I. the tenants of t;hE� rooms in question had come with him taday ancl would Ue ��a.17_ing to 2�tt�st to the cleanliness and comfort of their raoms� A11 were men between the age of 60 and 85, and some had special dietary needsg t�rhi.ch made �he i�div�.dual cooking facilities important to th�m. Mr. McCausland said that apparently the buil:d_a��g Iiad heen operatec� as it was today for many previous years with no objectiuns �ram authar5t3_cs . It had been noted, hoi�ever, at an inspectiax� �nacie July 7.0 , Z980 , and at w�:s felt that the situation should receive s�me a�tent-a.on sa:i-�ce it. was � being aperated in violation of health ancl housing codes. He fel.t no serious objections ta continuing the eurre�it mannex af. c�gexation, t�ut also felt it should be clarified. Ms . Bij jani said,from her understanding, vaha� was needed Zoras a varianr.e on the shared baths . She suggested that one additianal shoiv�x ox t:tih facility would be advisable. Mr. McCausland said this would satisfy state eodP requixements , a�.t:haugh � the city code is more stringent. Chairman ti'Vozniak commented that occupancy of each uni'C should probab�y be restricted to one person. Mre Roach said thi.s would be no problem, that there never had been more than one person pex unit. _ �_ 9/9/80 - Meeting No. 165 � . � � � � � � �� �� � � � c BOARD ACTION : Mr. Tieso moved to grant a� variance of Section 54. 11 , pertaining to bathroomaredilirovided�onEradditionalnshowersfacility be where bathrooms are sh , p added to the existing ersonllebaunitomsUnder thesencond�tionst cookpngcy be restricted to one p P facilities niay remain in the units . Mr. Gausman secanded. 1�10TION CARRIED AND SO ORDERED. Na es - 0 Abstentions - Q THE VOTE : Ayes - 4 Y � 9/9/80 - Meeting No. I65 • , . MINUTES OF THE I�iEETING ST. PAUL BOARD OF APPEALS F� REVIEW Tuesday, September 9 , 1980 City Council Committee Room 707 City Hall and Court House 1 : 30 p .m. 1�1EMBERS PRESENT: D.D. tiVozniak, Chairman Arthur Tieso A. Wali Naibi Glenn Gausmann � ABSENT: Estyx B. Peake Thomas Reiter Ron Glassman AGENCIES PRESENT: Community Services Dep� e - Divisa_on. af. Iiousa_n.g snf Buil.ding Code Enforcement Alice Bijjani . Earl Conley � � � Department of Public I�ea2th 6Yi11iam McCausland OTHERS PRESENT: G. Jurgensen Debbie Johannsen H. Wifal navicl Ries Joe Cochrane Ray Gust:a.fson � _ Bruce Margan Mrs . Ray GusY.a.f.son Ge Lee Arthu�° Bredy Don J. Sax�on Robc:r.i: Kerchr�ff Nzck S�eich.�n �.W. Pef:erson Naomi: N�emann rcl Ro1�in�tte Joe KaFi�aski Jim CaGaram M. Roach � R�,fieri: �7. Fc�le� A1ice Fo1ey M��~t].e ltogers � Marvin E. Koeni�g�, Jx°. STAFF PRESENT: Patricia Moxness � _ The meeting was called to order at 1 :45 p.m. The minutes of the meeting of August 12 , �980s wexe approved as mai.].ed out to -the board membexs. The following cases r��rere removed from the agenda: � (1) Case No. 23- 80-H, 773 E. 6th St. , Don J. Saxton - AppeaS: of zoning status pending. Matter was continued to October meeting. � ,�,_�. ._ ._.._�,__._..w�..�....__......._.�.____.._r_�.....___._._....__..______._.._.�.-�-r.-r- , - 8- 9/9/80 - rseetin� No. 7 b5 � � ��5��� CASE N0. PROPERTY APPELLANT 37-80-H 12 81= 83 S�erburnz , Maxvin Koe�7 a.�;s Jr. (two units) � . SUBJECT: Request variances of Sections 54. 13 (a} , 54. �:3(g) , and 5�. l�(a� , pertaining to ceiling hei.ght, basement occupancy; an.d la.�ht and venYi.I.a° _ tion, respectively, to permit occupancy af sl.eeping xooms mor.e than . 50% below gi•ade , i,�here ceiling height is below m�_nimum, and lighf. and ventilation is below the rec�uired 10 0 of fl.aor axeas t�ecause of. �inancial considerations . � APPEARANCE : Marvin Koenig, Jr. Alice Bijjani � PROCEEDINGS : Chairman tiNozniak called the board� s attention to a l.etter rom District Eleven Coalition, dated 9/3/80 , objecting to the gran�ing of any variances on this property. 1�1r. Koenig said he had talked to some of the members of the coalition to let them knoi�r what he intended to do to improve his pronerty. He said -9- 9/9/80 - Meeting No. I65 ' � �`�j�� � � there had been some favorable reaction , but evidently not enough members ti�ere so persuaded. He explained that he had applied for perrnits to remodel �yhat he had thought was an existing basement apartment . Permits had been issued and he started work, and to date had spen't about �8,000. Then he learned that he would need a change of zoning status to operate three units . He had gone before the Zoning Board and his appeal had been denied, so he could only operate as a duplex. In order. to reeover some of his investment, he decided to change the basement unit to three bed- rooms and add them to the first floor two-bedroom apartment, thereby making it a five-bedroom apartment, with th� possibility of chargi.ng � higher rent. his. Bijjani said there had been a misunderstanding as to ��hat Mr. t:oenig planned to do at the time the building permit was issued. Othexwise, he might have been advised against the project and have avoided spenda.ng his money on it. ° - Dir. Koenig said all he �vanted to do was to improve the existing a}�axt- ment. He had pulled a permit to add another entrance to improve the safety of tenants . The unit was vacant at the time he bot�gh't the propFrtx, but he had assumed it had been rented in the past because it had a kitc:hen and was laid out as an apartment . The seller had not specifical7.y sold the property as a three-unit building, but neither had he said a� was not . Mr. Koenig said he had just thought it needed upgrading� to make it a rentable unit , but had since learned otherwise . He ha.d �;one to all hzs neighbors prior to his appeal to the Zoni.ng Board to aT7ocv� a third unit and had obtained signatures of all agreei.ng to his plan, so he felt sure there would be no objection from �hem i.f. he i��ere alloti��d y to use the space as bedrooms . Ms . Bijjani said some members of the district were concerned �ha�Y 1�'fr. Koenig might be attempting to circumvent the zoning 1aw by renta.il,�; our the bedrooms separately, while claiming to make them part of tlxe firsL floor unit. HotJever, it would be illegal ta rent ta mar� 'chan fc�tzr unrelated persons in a duplex zane. A discussion of ineans of eseape from basement level_ sleepa.iig roams t��-oY�ght a suggestion from Ms. Bijjani that an additional stair�aa.y he provided. bir. Koenig agreed that this was needed and 'said �here t�as a space f:o install it. �Zs . Bij j ani pointed out several violations that r.equ�.xed at 4entzon i� � the basement was to be used for living space , such as the need far larger windows . Mr. Koen�g said he was aware of this , but he had �o �ind aut fixst ��thc�the�- it could be used at all before he snent more money. He said he was �v�all.in� to do whatever necessary and asked that an insnector come� aut and advise _ him exactly what should be done ,if allowed to use the space. Thexe ���exe two things that could not be done , one , exposing the other �c1S�lll�ylt: SSc'2� � y and, two, lowering the floor. BOARD ACTION: Mr. Tieso moved to grant variances of Sections 5�1. 13(a) and 54. 13�, pertaining to ceiling height and occupaney of rooms more than SO% below grade , respectively, on condition that all remaini.ng code requirements are met, and that an additional stair��ray be i.nstalled from the first floor to the sleeping room area of the basement. rir. Gaus- man seconded. MOTION CARRIED AND SO ORDERED. � THE_VOTE_ _ _ __ ___Ayes___3_ __ __ __Nayes___0_ ________Abstentions ___1_ (Naibi)__ The meeting adjourned at 4 :30 p.m. - 9/9/80 -- Meeting No. 165 . MINUTES OF THE NIEETING . ST. PAUL BOARD OF APPEALS �, REVIEW Tuesday, September 9 , 1980 City Council Committee Room 707 City Hall and Court House 1: 30 p .m. b4E1�1BERS PRESENT: D.D. l�Vozniak, Chairman Arthur Tieso A. Wali Naibi - Glenn Gausmann � ABSENT: Estyr B. Peake Thomas Reiter Ron Glassman AGENCTES PRESENT: CQmmunity Services Dep� . -� A1.visa.on of Housin.g snf Building Code Enforcemen� Alice Bij j ani Ear1 Conley � � Department of Public Heal.th 1��Tilliam McCausland OTHERS PRESENT: G. Jurgensen Debba.e Joh annsen H. Wifal David Ri es � Joe Cochrane �2ay Gustafson � . Bruce Morgan Mrs . Ray Gustaf.son Ge Lee l�xthu.�� Rredy Don J. Sax�on �t�bex�i� I:Prcha�� Ni.ck S�ei�chen S.tiV. l'c i:ersan Naomi Nie�mann __ rd Rc�bi.ne-Ltc .7oe �Kabroski Ja.m Cacar�m M. RoacTi lZobert. �T. ���1ey Alice Faley M}rxtle RogE;xs � Marvi.n E. Koenig, Jx°. � STAFF PRESENT: Patricia Moxness _ The meeting was called to order at 1 :45 pm�p The minutes of the meeting of August 12 , 1984 , were appravecl as ma�.�ed out to the board members. The following cases were removed from the agencta:: (1) Case No. 23- 80-H, 773 E. 6th St. , Don Jo Saxton - �ppeal of zanin g status pending. Matter was continued to October meet:ing. � * �'� � � I , � �., G8 STATF OF -MINNFSOTA ) � � County o� Ram.aey ) aa. . � CT TY OF SAI NT PA(IL ) � t`� Rose Mix .�� �p� t�j I. . . . . . . .: . .. . ... .. . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . o� #he Ci.ty o� Scun.t Pa.u.e, M,i.nne.bo-t.a, do heneby ce�c.t,i.�y #hcLt I have compcuced #he a.ttnched copy o� Counc,i.e F�.e No.??5816, . , , a.a Qdop�ed 6y �'he City Counc,i.0 .. . . . oct j .�F�, . . .. . . . . . . . I9.80. .. and appnoved by �he Mayon . . . . . . . . .. oct; .20, . . .. .. .. .. . 19.8�). . . uu#h. #he o�c.i_g.i.r�a.e �h.eneo� on S.i.Ce .i.n my o��.i.ce. � . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . .. . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . o .. . . . . .. . w . � � . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .� � . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . o . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ...: . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . cu � c�a V . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. O . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. .. . . . . . . . . . ... . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . ' I �cvc.the�c cPJc.t�i.sy #ha.t aa,i.d copy .i..a a #�u�e and co�ec.t coPy , ._.,. o� acud on.i.g�.na.e and #he who.�e #he�c.eoS. .� i �u: ` WI7NFSS m y hand and..the a e.a.L o� �he Ci.ty o� Scu.n.t Pau.e, ,�;�,�,, - . � ` M,i.nn. .t1u.d -21st dQy . . . oct. . . . . . . . ..a.v. l9. $9. .. . . .. . . . - • . �,< - ;:� � . . , :.,:� - �.� . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . , C i.ty e�fz. r� - � 1 g � 27 � o a. � � — � WHITE � CITY CLERK COUi1C1I � ����� PINK '� FI�IANCE ' CANARY -�'� DEPARTMENT G I Ty pi''� SA I N T I�A IT L BLU[� � MAYOR FIIC N O. � V�ouncil Resolution -- ��� � - � � - - Presented By � .. .-- __.._ . --. _ _ __. ._ _ . Referred To . Committee: Date � Out of Committee By' ' Date 1► - - - � B� IT RF.9(�'�, �at l3�B Q�adl O� Lt� C3tp a� Si3at Patil �by o� and epp�D�t�es � tbe act�ian af th� City o�' Saf:� Paal Baa�+d o� Ap�eala and �Osv3e�r pr��g to t�e fnilo�r �J ing listed S���ty �d as s�a bp Li�e F�cezpt�d �a c�f a�aiRl Ho�nrd of !►ppeals ea�d Rs- � vLev, datx+s bember 9, L9�80, aad m�Oed �IT A, �cl �ec�ed �reba aod'mr3e a pszt h�e�f bp s�es�os: I�TE CF H(3�RD I� CASE NC3. P� A�'�[tdi@T 9/8/8U 34-6t1-H 9M51 iT. 7tit St. � , �el Roach � �I � r . K:� . • BQARD AL'I'I(�: � Varia�cx of St. P�su2 Le�a�ZatitR t'kxks, 9eeti3On 54.11., tA yaLY.�+oo,m f�•t��rf�►�, to pe.rnit o�cp af si�c a�rt�entn �te 2� s�e �, aa �tfat ti�t aRZS add#t��anal ���er o� #�nb £e�cilit� t�e install�d, eai�d ooci�.y t�o i�e iirnLt�e�d ta me persaa per unit. . pyc�vpe�t,y Descri�tf�: Stfaaoa's S�t�diviai� oF B1xk ZS of S�Insm, Br�an ax�d B�ey's �diti,an Lat$ i0 aod 11, B�I�oc3c ZS � - ....._ �`____-----�---� . 9j9/80 37-80-H L281.-�83 �b�br�n�e 1�e. Harrvin Roe�ig. Jr. . t� �) �� , Ba1� AC12�t+3: �nr�ed v�s cf St. PauY. I�egi.slative (bde, Secti+� 54.�3, Pes'tainin� t�o c�iliug��� a�d ocra��scy of sl� ioo�m4 �are th�t St�� bel.�v be i�A*�pd � gpq�el2.aut�1���� �ts ia� �c�ec�• , ----- - ---- - :. �3� �tinc: Sy�d�ba i;b:�5 l�ddit3�ao►=- - , - - Int 30, Byo�dc Z6 = �. _:_��-.: =. �_ �..�_.,..,.e.. COUNCILMEN ' Yeas Nays Requestgd by Department of: Hunt Levine In Favor Maddox McMahon sno�ite. Against BY Tedesco w Ison Form Approved by City Attorney Adopted b�� Council: Date -._.. Certif�ed P�tised by Council Secretary By�t��f'�- -__�1��'t � ,..-` �f B� `����' Approved by Mavor: Date Approved by Mayor for Submission to Councii B}• ____ _ __ __.. _--.. _ _ ---- ---- ----- Y -------- -- —-- �� WHITE .• FIAANCERK ♦ 1 ��( _ L V , P�~K T`' COUDCII CANARY" -� DEPARTMENT (� I TS� O F SA I � T 1 �U L ��� V.i BL.Ug ~, MAVOR _, . � - F1Ie N O. ' . . . . - -' ''� - --- --------- -- J� -� � - �Council R esolution Presenied By ', ;,: Referred To �"�+.Committee: Date t�_'���.F<<:. Out of Committee By Date � ��� �: � '..d �q�- � �and be it ^� a- - � F� i�.9fI.�H3, 3hst tbe t�ty �'Le�c 3s besebgr ac�orimad � 8trmc�0ed to �t O a copy of �Ms sr.e�l�sti,on t� reoasd�,g tio tbe �a�ey tl�aty �ffioe o� t�e �gisteoc o� `'� De+eds• 2- COUNCILMEN Yeas Nays �,.- ' Requestgd by Depactment of: _� Levine � In Favor Maddox � �CT B sno�iter A gai n s t Y Tedesco Wilson OCT 1 6 1g$Q Form Approved by City Attorney Adopted hv Council: , Date - — Certi(ied P��tied by Council Secretary °Y-"� ``j�"' �� �~r � � � 't� �, � ✓�----. "��T'�G' 0 j�g0 Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council Approved by 11avor. Date —_�• _-- B� ------_ _----- —--._— _------ BY ------- — - ! 1 � \� ' • . .t ` W � � � D � � s O y . . � (R Q v � � �, �' � o -�-I n � �n 3 �o ro' vi c m Q, .+ o � � � i� (n � —h � ..�F � 0 ` �� � Z' m O � � O �. � O � 4 � � "'� � c� � _ a' n =.r` p n�7i z � ' \��"' �: � 1 � 9�1 �, .� o `� f- z � �-C z o � - ,_.,. 3 m � (� � O z p �i '�- � �' (� �f � � Q � �' � �� r`� C� a c; '� ^.. T ''� '�G �O . i� �J � �� � �' � _�. �o c�i D � � '� O � N �;� �7 � �. � � � , C� C� e.J - � =: � � , �''� � (p � v v � � e! � Q- h ,y.. 7 � O ,-+ � C y C �' • � � � � �� _� � � \ 1 e; � 1C ` ... . t� �_ yi .y 1A 11 3.