The URL can be used to link to this page

274531 WHITE - CITV CI.ERK PINK - FINANCE r� ' t`� CANARV -DEPARTMENT GITY OF SAINT PAUL F le ci1N0• �1�..,� � GLUE -r MAVOR r .- rdindnce Ordinance W�.� ��^ T Presented By � Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date An Ordinance amending Chapter 60 of the St. Paul Legislative Code pertaining to � zoning for the City of Saint Paul and the zoning maps thereof. WHEREAS, Pursuant to Minnesota Statutes, � 462. 357 and � 64.210 of the Legislative Code, Rollie Brown duly petitioned to rezone Lots 8 and 9, Block 5, Co11Ege Park, located on the south side of Carroll between Snelling and Fry Avenue from RT-1 to I-1 for the purpose of expanding Coope�ative Plating, the petition having been certified by the D�partment of Finance and Management Services on September 19, 1979, as having been con- sented to by at least 67� of thE owner5 of the area of the property to be rezoned, and further, having bEen eonsented �o by at least two-thirds of the owners of the property situated within 100 feet of the total contiguous descriptions of real estate held by the same owner or any party purchasing any such contiguous property within one year preceding the date,-of the p��ition; and . .._.:, WHEREA�, the current plan�,,�a:g committee on Nflvemlaer 1,- 1979, conducted a public hearing �for the purpose of con'si-ek�ring the re- zoning petition, and, pursuant to Section 107. 03 of the Administra- tive Code, submitted its recommendation to the Planning Commission; *"� and .�: , WHEREAS , the Planning Commission considered the rezoning petition at its meeting held on November 16, 1979, and submitted its recommendation to the City Council; and WHEREAS, Notice of a public hearing before the City Council on the said rezoning petition was duly published in the official newspaper of the City on December 26, 1979, and notices were duly mailed to each owner of affected property and property situated COU[VCILMEN Requested by Department of: Yeas Nays Butler In Favor Hozza Hunt Levine Against BY Maddox Showalter Tedesco Form Approv by i Attor Adopted by Council: Date Certified Passed by Council Secretary BY By Approved by Mayor: Date Approved by ayor r Submission to Council By By WHITE - CITV CLERK PINK - F�NANCE GITY OF SAINT PAUL Council /J CANARV - DEPARTMENT File NO. �� 1 BtUE � -rMAVOR ♦ , Ordindnce Ordinance N 0. 1 �(ill/T � Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date Page 2. wholly or partly within 350 feet of the property sought to be rezoned; and WHEREAS, a public hearing before the City Council, having been conducted on February 7, 1980 and February 21, 1980, where all interested persons were heard, and the Council having con- sidered all the facts and recommendations concerning the petition; now, therefore, THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN: Section 1. That the zoning map of the City of Saint Paul, Sheet No. 18, as incorporated by reference in Section 60.401 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code, as amended, is hereby further amended as follows: That property located on the south side of Carroll between Snelling and Fry Avenue, being more particu- larly described as Lots 8 and 9, Block 5, College Park, be and is hereby rezoned from RT-1 to I-l. Section 2 . This ordinance shall take effect and be in force thirty (30) days from and after its passage, approval and publication. COUIVCILMEIV Requested by Department of: Yeas McMAHON Nays � � In Favor Hunt-� Levine � Against BY Maddox Showalter �� APR 1 1980 Form Approved c� corn Adopted by Council: Date Certified P Cou il Secretar BY BY p � • App by Mayor: ` �`I�R App d�e by Ma for Sub ' sion t il By B Pi,�US}!ED APR 1 2 1980 . ,_��WH1�'E - CITV CLERK ' -� PIPIIZ'� - FINANCE ��.y �r � CANARV - DEPARTMENT CITY OF SAINT PAITL COUIICII �� / y.� BLUfi -MAVOR File �O. /'e ■ ��CD�1 � • ZC Ordinance N 0. Presented By Leonard W. Levine � + Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date ,. An Ordinance amending Chapter 60 of the St. Paul Legislative Code pertaining to zoning for the City of Saint Paul and e zoning maps thereof. WHEREAS, Pursu t to Minnesota Statutes, § 462.357 and � 64. 210 of the Legis ative Code, Rollie Brown duly petitioned to rezone Lots 8 and 9, Block 5, College Park, located on the south side of Carroll be ween Snelling and Macalester Avenue from RT-1 to I-1 for the rpose of expanding Cooperative Plating, the petition having been ce tified by the Department of Finance and Management Services on S tember 19, 1979, as having been con- sented to by at least 67% of e owners of the area of the property to be rezoned, and further, hav g been consented to by at least two-thirds of the owners of the operty situated within 100 feet , of the total contiguous descriptio s of real estate held by the same owner or any party purchasing y such contiguous property within one year preceding the date o the petition; and WHEREAS, the current planning comm tee on November 1, 1979, conducted a public hearing for the purpos of considering the re- zoning petition, and, pursuant to Section 7.03 of the Administra- tive Code, submitted its recommendation to t�ie Planning Commission that the petition be granted; and WHEREAS, the Planning Commission considered the rezoning petition at its meeting held on November 16, 1979� and recommended that the City Council approve the petition; and WHEREAS, Notice of a public hearing before the ity Council on the said rezoning petition was duly published in t e official newspaper of the City on December 26, 1979, and notice were duly ma.iled to each owner of affected property and property s uated COUl�1CILMEN Requested by Department of: Yeas Nays Butler In Favor Hozza Hunt Levine Against BY Maddox Showalter Tedesco Form Approved y C' Atto ey Adopted by Council: Date Certified Passed by Council Secretary BY By Approved by Mayor: Date Approved by ay for Submission to Council gy By WHITE - CITV CLERK 1 . • C N��Y - OIE�ARTMENT COUIIClI BLUE -MAYOR GITY OF SAINT PAITL File- NO. ��1 • Or indnce Ordinance N 0. Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date Page 2. wholly d� partly within 350 feet of the property sought to be rezoned; �.d '. WHEREAS�, a public hearing before the City Council, having been conducte on February 7, 1980 and February 21, 1980, where all interested ersons were heard, and the Council having con- sidered all the cts and recommendations concerning the petition; now, theref ore, THE COUNCIL OF THE CI Y OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN: � � ` Section 1. That the zoning ma.p of ._the City of Saint Paul, Sheet No. 18, as incorporated by reference in Section 60.401 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code, as amended, is hereby further amended as follows: That property located on the south side of Garroll between Snelling and Ma.calester Avenue, being more particularly described as Lots 8 and 9, Block 5, College Park, be and is hereby rezoned from RT-1 to I-1. Section 2. This ordinance shall take effect and be in force thirty (30) days from and after its passage, approval and publication. COUNCILMEIV Requested by Department f: Yeas Nays Butler In Favor Hozza Hunt ��` Levine Against BY Maddox Showalter Tedesco Form Approved b ity A torn Adopted by Council: Date Certified Passed by Council Secretary BY By Approved by Mayor: Date Approved by or r Submission to Council By By � , . '�, � 1st ��/ ` � 2nd ti� /�; � � Adopted �� < � / 3rd '� /` � �� Yeas Nays HOZZA HUNT LEVINE � MADDOX � ��"� McMAHOiV TIDESCO ' 1 PRES IDENT (SHOWALTIIt) � � �,�� o�s CITY OF SAINT PAUL �;�0 a� DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT m �iii'iiu� ;� �• ^ [�,F�}�,y�[''° DIVISION OF PLANNING ,�'Rt�� isa• °,S" I t w iM1�.� �nsm ¢:�y ,�,�e,;s,.,.25 West Fourth Street,Saint Paul,Minnesota,55102 GEORGE LATIMER 612-298-4151 MAYOR February 1 , 1980 Rose Mix, City Clerk Room 386 City Hall St. Paul , Minnesota 55102 RE: Zoning File No. 8526 - Rollie Brown Dear Madam: This letter is written in response to the petition of Rollie Brown to rezone from RT-1 (One and Two-Family Residential ) to I-1 (Light Industrial ) property located at 1602-1606 Carroll Avenue for the purpose of expanding Cooperative Plating. On November 1 , 1979, the Current Planning and Zoning Committee conducted a public hearing on this matter. Twelve letters from property owners within 350 ft. and a letter from District 13 were received in opposition; three persons spoke in opposition. Major concerns were increased noise, traffic, pollution; destruction of two houses; decreased property values; and encroach- ment of industry. The Committee recommended denial on a vote of 5-0 based on findings that the Comprehensive Plan and District 13 Plan designate the site as residential ; expanded industrial use would generate additional traffic on residential streets; permitted uses in the I-1 would be detrimental to adjacent residential use; the proposed rezoning could be considered spot zoning; the size of the site would require variances for development; and two existing single family homes would be destroyed. On November 16, 1979, the Planning Commission upheld the Committee's recommendation on a vote of 14-0. This matter is scheduled to be heard by the City Council on February 7, 1980. The Zoning Office has received thirty letters in opposition in anticipation of the Council hearing. Sincerely, �`�'�u.,u.a� Wl,�sia' Donna McNeally City Planner DM/mb Enc. �O . ' ``�C�nOP • I � � ��y � CITY OF SAINT PAUL �oR4 '� DEPARTMENT OF PL�1�11+F'�ID ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT �r uii'ii"i � {� �''' �• � ` �� 3.��r4..t_ -,,' " DIVISION OF PLANNING �se• ��''�II- 25 West Fourth Street,Saint Paul,Minnesota,55102 GEORGE LATIMER 612-298-4151 MAYOR December 31 , 1979 Rose Mix, City Clerk 386 City Hall St. Paul , Minnesota 55102 Re: Zoning File No. 8526 - Rollie Brown Dear Madam: This letter is written in response to the petition of Rollie Brown to rezone from RT-1 (One and two-family Residential ) to I-1 (Light industrial) property located at 1602-1606 Carroll Avenue for the purpose of expanding Cooperation Plating. On November l , 1979, the Current Planning and Zoning Comnittee conducted a public hearing on this matter. Twelve letters from property owners within 350 ft. and a letter from District 13 were received in opposi-tion; three persons spoke in opposition. Major concerns were increased noise, traffic, pollution; destruction of two houses; decreased property values; and encroach- ment of industry. The Committee recommended denial on a vote of 5-0 based on findings that the Comprehensive Plan and District 13 Plan designate the site as residential ; expanded industrial use would generate additional traffic on residential streets; permitted uses in the I-1 would be detrimental to adjacent residential use; the proposed rezoning could be considered spot zoning; the size of the site would require variances for development; and two existing single family homes would be destroyed. On November 16, 1979, the Planning Comnission upheld the Committee's recomnendation on a vote of 14-0. This matter is scheduled to be heard by the City Council on January 10, 1980. Sincerely, C��u Donna McNeally City Planner DM/cc Enc. O � '� �Q� � � . —.5 •�� tT'o, CITY OF SAINT PAUL rR04 � �; a DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT � Itl�ll�� o . ,,,�• " DIVISION OF PLANNING � .... 25 West Fourth Street,Seint Paul,Minnesota,55102 GEORGE LATIMER 612-298-4151 MAYOR February 19, 1980 Rose Mli x, Ci ty C1 erk Room 386, City Hall St. Paul , Minnesota 55102 RE: Zoning File No. 8526 - Rollie Brown Dear Madam: This letter is written in response to the petition of Rollie Brown to rezone from RT-1 (One and Two-Family Residential ) to I-1 (Light Industrial ) property located at 1602-1606 Carroll Avenue for the purpose of expanding Cooperative Plating. On November 1 , 1979, the Current Planning and Zoning Committee conducted a public hearing on this matter. Twelve letters from property owners within 350 feet and a letter from District 13 were received in opposition; three persons spoke in opposition. Major concerns were increased noise, traffic, pollution; destriction of two houses; decreased property values; and encroach- ment of industry. The Committee recomnended denial on a vote of 5-0 based on findings that the Comprehensive Plan and District 13 Plan designate the site as residential ; expanded industrial use would generate additional traffic on residential streets; permitted uses in the I-1 would be detrimental to adjacent residential use; the proposed rezoning could be considered spot zoning; the size of the site would require variances for development; and two existing single family homes would be destroyed. On November 16, 1979, the Planning Commission upheld the Comnittee's recommendation on a vote of 14-0. This matter was first heard by the City Council on February 7, 1980 and was laid over until February 21 ,1980. Sincerely, �� Donna McNeally City Planner DM/cc Enc. �O � � ��C� � � ��.....,,� .,. S NELLING . H AMLINE _ Cj OMMUNITY � '"�,, . Cj OUNCIL '°"'"„ 113 No. Ssratope. 8t. Paul, 68104 444-1085 October 29, 1979 . . Current Planning & Zoning Committee _ . _ 25 West Fouxth Street St. Paul, NIDT 55102 Re: Zoning File No. 8526 Zoning File Name Rollie Brown Property Location: 1602 & 1606 Carrol This property is located in a small residential area, which in the DISTRICT 13PL�N, Septernber, 1977, is refered to as the"Creative lighting" area. This area is bounded by I-94 on the North, Snelling Avenue on the East, and the Chicago, Milwaukee & St. Paul raiiroad on the South and West. There are only about 40 residential structures in this area, which occupy a bit more than half of the area of the above mentioned triangle. The remainder is occupied by light Industrial and businesses. This residential area has it5 share of trouble, mostly with I-94 cutting it off from other residential areas, but also with business expansion along Snelling Ave. , I-94, and Iglehart, Pierce, and Fry. Currently , there remains a fairly strong, well kept two and two third blocks of residential area. I fedr that if further Cutting away is done to this neighborhood, it won't be long before it eeases to exist. This is a tizne when energy costs make living in areas like the"creative lighting" area, more desireable. And it is also a time of home and rental shortages. In deciding this zoning issue, please look at the area as a whole, because this could certainly become a turning point for the remainder of the residential pro�erty. Thank yo '', ��`��--.\ �� L�� ` R. Carl Wolter Vice Chair � � � ��e C�� un�.ounr ♦.• r � . , � S,NELLING t"'�AMLINE : _ < Cj OMMUNiTY ; °?o,, . > Cj OUNCIL '""""'� 113 No. 8�r�topa, St. Paut, b6f04 " 84�-1085 October 29, 1979 . , '� �.� - .- - Current Planning & Zoning Committee ` � ; - 25 West Fourth Street St. Paul, MDT 55102 Re: Zoning File No. 8526 Zoning File Name Rollie Brown Property Location: 1602 & 1606 Carrol This property is located in a small residential area, which in the DISTRICT 13PLAN, September, 1977, is refered to as the"Creative lighting" area. This area is bounded by I-94 on the North, Snelling Avenue on the East, and the Chicago, Milwaukee & St. Paul raiiroad on the South and West. There are only about 40 residentiai structures in this area, which occupy a bit more than half of the area of the above mentioned triangle. The remainder is occupied by light Industrial and businesses. This residential area has its share of trouble, mostly with I-94 cutting it off from other residential areas, but also with business expansion along Snelling Ave. , I-94, and Iglehart, Pierce, and Fry. Currently , there remains a fairly strong, well kept two and two third blocks of residential area. I iear that if further Cutting away is done to this neighborhood, it won't be long before it ceases to exist. This is a time when energy costs make living in areas like the"creative lighting" area, more desireable. And it is also a time of home and rental shortages. In deciding this zoning issue, please look at the area as a whole, because this could certainly become a turning point for the remainder of the residential pro�erty. Thank Xo�, �.��.�,��,�';l �� R. Carl Wolter Vice Chair .- i c.� �y � , _ . � , . J __ . _ _� .:,, � _ �_ . , � �� – – �- . .- 7 09 - a/.. � ,;� � � I...__ � �' ____— 1 � �i � Nb� �� . n � � � � �� 4 �� I' '� a�, . � —�? � ! V' ' �- — � - 5 / /o --- �-_ � � � � by � � v, , � / �o � �, L ; - �0 �• . \�� cy • � ,, � � N '' �v � � /3Z.7S ' � E��____ � � . ; — — — . � � ��.�,�, .. � Iy, .� I . . ' � ,+ .� . � � �o� ,� . � � cw o . � . � � �, �� - I ,� � �zZZ3 � —,---� ---/ o __ isa.zs _--"' ---- ` ----=- - ------=- �°'=--=- - : ---------------�---�--------- - ---�-•- ' � l3Z73 I32.7�---- � -�; /7Z.ZS. �,,,: . � f/6 i�+----�ZZ.-�.�. �,,,�� j�►,+ %3Z.75 20; : l32.7S � � . � , 1 W � • r� � �°� � tt' - o`` � '�y � �tu . c � �V �..' � /� � �� '� ` ,,�\ � �,��{ � ' �v� hu , � ! � �• t � iZZZS � � .� � Q ,i;,�' �� , � �'� � `b; - �!�1 N1 ( � 1 c�N usS�ti� , �1 � .�� r - � . � . � � �, c�. ��►.� �r� , � � � J03.76 v,�i -`�. 7Q4 zo� /2ZZf 1, � _ %3�75 _/3Z.7S � � . i . . . . . . . , � ' n�/ °' � - � .- - � c �� Y .S7. . / j , . .. . . . �� , . . � ,y.a,. �.a� . . . • . . � . . ' . '.'Z� S �� ` �� _..-�::.,.--'" . 913. �,, . ;`. /2 Z_Z •a;� � U ia �3Z.7f � �ZQr /3 75� i � :y .. �i -` , R, ',i r� � 1}� +L t�1 � t�� '�.` 'f'� �N ` � � � � !v� -i � i �t.. �'Q i ' �� i r A l • ::� � �� 'b ? � . � � � � : �� \ i � i , '�. J ;� \ . ! /1_� +j t { � 1 �••-r, r� �•A , t -�� Iw. � �: - � - � - s � ' � �O�� .Sd N 0 D � N � `� • / �- • , . . .. • �, � �. � ' \ :�� t+� (�''t ;A `� i � � .• • Y. ;\.h�.y.,, �-I,�� • � I° � �>;a'; _. �,. - t - ��, -y� ` '� �' ._:;��:�::>�.�:_.�.:::��..: r� f --s � � , �• �:>:t �i::�i'::�::�.;:;;;i:.,.i:�:.ti�:�i; . . � ;icri' ��•+ x•>:�:,,`>.:•• %'(.•�'��x;� �' � .� {. .; ::;?>:;.:''i f��=''��{::'s%:�::��;�:^�:::".:::•:,y,,;�,..: �o.. � � . � `� ` �' EL � � � - / .� ��t � }��. � ::� 4�- ��"��`''�j�.�''� _ `O�x '� � . �.y ,.. .� �� :�:�:�.: ; : �C,�11 EAl �. \ :s�...:��;:�k.v�:;:., :.'�Q,j"�,,,' � �� mr' �' ``e: � .\ :.4.�� :-:t �:ti�.��.':':}:a!::i.i:{�TF��'�::::�: o '��-•--� ry� ' , . ' •} ':�1',�i•;i:::i � . �`i�s''ii. ${'( . �± � � r � �.1: • ?:#,j�i;::°:;?�:_i�ia: <: �' ,:•;:<c . 3. � i !_ .� � �.��':��,' ;�r:;;�'=' i i t �,J � � •. � ; �.ti�.�� ..�. � L .l�if,tr�/��-,,�S�,,L!��'C � � � � . . . , - � -- .. S? �� ; i:+ �. r":/ :..3+.�`'� � • . , ,. ( • .. �'�.....,:. ?: � : f � ;` ,{� �' � � � �;.�.�,.t�',.;'';��•: ` '� !r N .�, � � � . - ; � ..,.:�:�.:: �:� �� ; �� . � � _ eZ-t'� :�v w�n�Y � .. � � ,� ; �:;'�^i::::>:c:::�:�%:i: � ; :';�:y�:+�t ... .'`:f��.,::'� t . /'� / i � `�� ' ::�'i•`;:,'.''._.lt.'•••.i . ;{:. . ` . ^-� . , N . i \ � . �* , .• .. . � . �c `� . � ;' :,j%�-,^/'?ij}''�':}:j:�: :�w'.�','�'�''.' . •., ' i z 'V � j .�;:�w:�:.' �,. :.Y;'.<.'•,',•`'y,.• �y,r�%fi .�� . .::�':.`- � .�� . ' � �- �`� 1n,��L �/�� /��I �� :.: � �'�� s � �. _ 'r`::�.;.;.:. �:;,. � � �sr;_::`•':•>:: �:.::��:;:�:�:::::� �.� � r =•. ..:•.:::;::'>:.:<z� •,.�f�:.�,,....�.f..:: j ,, �'til � : �i, ?�:�Y> >� ''^ � N ; � - '' � i 4 .'''�� i; � � ��r��'��`:`{ ' �d �'�+�►j� � ' �'/� �, � � : ' - :�:�:._•,.'.,:;:.: ��,;;.��.. ��,.,,. ► �lf�_zi�� )' ! ?75 � ,,, -1 �:�:;�'-�� ._. ;2c, 3 b . 7Z.96 0 � , • *r N . . JZI So� . . :=.<. =:: ,�::_:>:;:`.:.......:..:.�:✓`� � t � _ _ -� i , .: t . - .: :;.:5._�,::_��f�� . . .�:. } � � � � � � � � , �� ^ , ' . i i � � � � t � � � ;(1 t �1 v, . , � . �1�� NO �; . �O �' ;�� , i •t1 t..� � ,d� ti V . • , ��i t. ' �± � � ' � ' ,�� e / �' ,� ► �.,� '�_ •: � � � ' ��i ',r-�— Q.A • v' _ .'__ ,' j: � ^: �y 3' . �: � .) . ��+ � ;(.� i �� "" Lj • b, l ( . . � ! . , QZ 6an. .1ZZS �Q � Q � ��6�e d..'r?ru '*=� �,. _ � _ J.. _ 1.�' lK7•i �� . .. � ..�°, • � -,..p.� � StGNED PETI TIpN, � ` -.. �� _:..._.r:.__-- -�'�'"� . o o . . >�'�:>:< ..�-�------ . . . . �.�. . . ... _ -_ . , . N . , ._ , ,. .. _ ..........:< � ,�-,.-_.� � , = . o - ^ • , _ - ''�'' .... r 1n : • � V •�-- � � �� , w: w _ • o p ~ . • � .. . �.� - � �. .� � � ,� � �y .. �___ -, - - --jf-��, .. -- -- - -- -_ _ _. _� -- --- :�.;-�_� - ==-- - - j- -- - - - - -. L-� z.33 -�• -1� e i°, t l`TI.�t �!o � �, �, -f o ,f'I.�t 1'� �l.�. M� ��1,7r •i o �. .r a .s n ¢Y. �y� . � b� �,► �'' ' d . �a , L � , �� h - , ��' . �`• �'` � tj � ��, a �• � n � ' • t,1 �� jl � o, - , � /�/ L� �{� �+ � Q . + y /� �. �.a ��' �� _1� t� cC� . �� tss�,. �� O � a� `a r ` � � . � h �. �I s ' — %� t . . o ' (,��/ / ` O \� � '� w. � S!•Zr .fr i;' w .ft•i.r -f�,,,l .fo �' r. .. .?a .I3 5�' u, . ---� � � "' � o � y!' 7� � , . � �`i,�. -,/�1"-'_'i:3,.j,.--�-'�' • � /\.�'.r' ! �L /:l3-)I_'.,.._ �. � �� • , t� �� +; ! t,. � t� ' K t� ♦ 1 ��.� . � ,� K� '�'o• � t�b � ' • � � � '� A/�I /0 9.L (—'.�' ` � _ n�'` � ' . � ,� w _ T • � � 1 �� = i z 3.=r . + . . ' �� ti �^ . -+. ;j � N . L � � . (y F ' _` � 7 09 � � - � r3/. / - � ' • f 1 - .. ' ,- - o` .�_� �. � � �A. " � ' . � � ' � . � ,� � N��'� � w = � . �. � W . �_� _ � _ 4 6 - � / /o � � --- -__ . . b p� b5 � +� c*+ �' 4 � � /� • �� l° � N " y � �- - N— - �� .. ! �'/ .� / I3Z.7S ? . �' . . � , ` �_�_._ � �_ , ia ,� . ( . . . � � � . � �oc �V�' � �t '�" p . � . � t •�_�__ /z�25--�-�-------- �•----��- --- /SB25 _--v� ----- ±v----�3z�.�---- �-°� ' ---!.�z�s---' ;� izzzs � w, . � . �i6 0� i7�'Zj. �fi �--- iu " �� - o. 4� A,� � %3Z.75 20. . %3�75 Q I� � � . .� � � `' : � - �- � � .. � ' ^' � �� ;�1+� .c�y.' it' ' �; � � iv � � ' 4�'�' �� ' - �1-�I M � �toN U.iSe ti� �i /22.25 � _� U r� ,A c� �" � �� • �� ' :,�' • �' �. �� N.�' �� '' _ . � � /03,76 v�j .�.� 7O¢ 20� a /2775 � � . /3�75_ /32.�3 �. � �- - . � . , � % -�� . - ` �- - �_- - � -� .�� r_ �� sr. / . . . . �, . _ . �„o,. � �i . - . ;Zo 3 • �:,.� . 913. t> � /Z 2Z �a;. � O 1ja �3Z.7S`_. .�Zo�%3 75 . , � :.�r�' ` _ . .` � i:� - .. � -'� . � . .e , +.. ., �y � i �� aS�r'�C� �`�`` �� s� ` � ! ► /�- ��`c ` �r� � �, ' r` � '� � 'O �O - � - ' � ��w '�`i� �- �q � � • � '1 � . � t ! �c �►OS� SON 6 � � �,,. � �--' ' . t N �j �� / � � . . t . , � _ � r'' �►p `` - � � � " �: �.; ` �. . �• � • � _ � � .� � �° � v ::::; ��:`��:::�'�:�>:�:.::��"� i_��.�sQ� . C.L��n�_'� � .� �. ;:::; �� ;r:>,f::,:;::>:::;:::�:; � j; � • . � "; ..• :::�::,,1's:'�. .::w,::��'��;�� ... i � ' ,� ,' � ,; •{::?:,:'::::�:<�:;.>'t €�:��'•'•.::;�:�::i�;�'::'::'i::<'';�:��•ri� �O � ' � '� � ; � ; :::>:'�::" � �. �� i': �L / � . ;�:�;::::�.:::::::�� <�`�:�:�:�:��:;�:;��::�:�� :�� ,` , �I'' : �C'��'� �� ':'`r> ;;�✓'�*;:i;'c :;,•;�:i; =•�::>:;�:•'.'��'?:;:'•;:�::�''::i�::-::�;' as.F t r_• � .� :il.,.;�;.::�. ob � � . . ,, (/ ,�� • � ::i�;:�::: ,: :: ..:�:;�';Gg::::;::;��;:��:�Y !:� ni'..—� ; 1` ' � _ V ! �j ::,��::.::�: ��'�' ;:,,-� ' ,�:.:� (`._, ' 1 . '�::v i}: } y:.::,:�'.•.;...� „: ' • • Y�,. _..� � . ' .:�::�<�::::�::�:.::::;<�:>�,: �:>�:��.��...��:s � L ,I�if;l/'�- S E,�L�� ._ . � _ , .�:.:,.::...:. .:�.:_� ..: . .. ... .:.: � � ,�P , /. . :.�..:�:::: . . . . �:`:`:: >:x'+':::::•;::..:..:;r •� �. i•'•. •.,*" r. ±:r. �k+``/.?� � � � � f . 3:•::�;•:::•::.::•• �-�^",�'"r.:�:..:•. 4 ,_- ;:�3�;�'`"`� �� '�.•;. :�r�.�..,�_ „1 N , 1 ;�.::.::; ::.� ��'��:�:�•::�:'. �;. ;.%�: � •� Q , J " `� . . I � �'"' :" � ;� � ; � fi��;, � ,�-f'D/!� � �l/V f7.N � � i � ; :�:r:::>:;:::=:�:�:::.:::�: : ;� �.,:: � >. ':�;._. � , - . � t .. ;:. .:. :,�:�;:.�»��.�:`'�'� �. �v � , � � �;:;:;:�"::::::;:�; �i�'�:::;,::;:?'�:..,.., f. � � �� '"�':� .:.r;..�•:::.. �' "' .... r�s"ifi`::.f,r�.:..r:; . �: -�' � r :� /� o� � :.:.: :: .:,;.<;�::�.:�.»��;i�::.��::<. - ._� �� : ��L��k � ..b ��; :::::>:::::::::::�. . :.. . .. . j . . � . _ ��F.:::::;::•�:::::;::;:�::'x.• ,:�:x�;:�;>�.��:� ��.� r �,U i. :tJ �::;�:<:::>::::::�::;;;:<•: `y� � .:.,,:�'�°'::.;.�' � N �1 . �' '• ' :�:'<� .��. .. ;i.`. � V 1`1 � � •o ;�:��:�;��:;�:�>::::;:;:.::�; .t...��::::>•��-��>�'•� �i � � � f (�1 � � ::.:•... •3:•';;';:�r;;::;:,`;:•�.:•::::.:�;•.�,,. ;p. Q./�� f ��-- - :�:��::>:;:<:::>`.7cs��t�:;:��;�x�'��:�'.�;:�'� , ` !l�_�� , ;ZO, /37._75 � i � � +�J..,.,t. �,••>� L �' _ 7Z.9� o . ' ::� o - - . : . - - . /ZI. 50 .. ......::�:...:...�..�Y:_:;::;�x;�� - --3 I :��;:;�� ;:;��:� �-�:<;::�:` : � i G' ;�:,�:.:.�,r:�'��. >,.�';<. .�i? � } . • }y}'•:'. .n�+ }:�� . . . I . � ''� ' i y ` . t ' .� �i r-- � . . ::�''�:a::.:�,>. ,, . ' p �\ l� t 4 � ; ;(� i .�Y �,,, ' t � �'. , . - �^i .. ' � .h `� � � �• � . ;R, � , ,.��n, . , � �.."�. �, a� �:� ^• ti ! �. � 4; �. � �.�. c1 ' � � �O �C'� . �� :m ` ,�i 7� p�A\� ' f•^' + , I _'__ : t "` � � f � � • ii,�; •' � � ' .� �� . � � ; ./' � � A� f i _ . _ ..�. . . ! . O.2 � 6 .17.Z5 �.O Q I ��• 66 ,�;�%r -�;l,J„ : 1 : .�.. _ �..��x 6 rr -6s.a � -_, •r?, o: . ... ` ..t°, � ; �. .D� � StGNED P�.T�TIbN, � -.... � . �_. __.----�'— -:__ o � o - :��:�� ---�------- . . . •`�. . ., . .�, . •- .........::::...... f--�-�------,—•------• .'�- - o _ � _ _ _ _ _ * . C� � `-x '!, '� . . y w � � � � � • ' � C.. - '� tJ . ... ?-� - �_�� ...� � .�. r—�f--'� .- �...�.. ._ �. _ �•_ _ �.. ._.._. �. .._.� :'�:�o-�.. ��= � ��.�.... �. :a.� ....� .� �.. � �. ... ,� 2.3z -I• -1� � o LG9 s.Z.t.r �10 . `•� .. -fo SI.�2r� ��L �1 �IJr .�o •• »� a .FO q� i i� l , � � i �. /y cn ., �.�, . ' �� b' ,�?j` d' � I � � ' � �3 f.• w - � � � ^\�1. p� ,• � n o . . . S S' � � � � t • a • ► � /� � � �`s' � � v � � . � V � o �"�°� tit - h �{ �� '� t� �: o � . � � � c s �. � -E-j �� J ?. � . _ + o w . � � � � � .. ;o,o � -r -►. ' S1•yr .r. ,~ .ft-�.r -f� -fc '• ., « .ao .�z � ' � ` a 'h °' ' `a ' �°; `a � 0 1 y` �i �� . � /�:.r' �s /�j•z,r- i`.7r � �g �.�3 T _' ,^ �► o � � r �1 • �,. c+� i ��i �°• . � � � . ' ` � � �� • }� A �. /0 9.� ` ! ;-��'' 4,,, - , �,; c�+ ' _ _ y �+ 1 � �' /T 3 2�/' . • � �• � o �v ° . . �. �j (,ti N . • � � . � • . N 1 i - . • � _ _ . _ ..�.�._ �_ . • . --° ...,�._.,.:... ..__ . ... .,.._ _. __ .f._ �< ti . . r , . , . � � � ► � � �' i r� � � �1 �`�, M, �+lf«�i„ �� ,q,. •a • • � �' *;.�' �. ��:;-�.. - C` �.- . .�� i,�. .: ...-� , '..;, y '•. ..?.>`�S,l l.�'tf . .. : .:. .�i,� t h, �M f�1'. — '�,,;'�'::l•�+�'�w��-"�"� �. � - .�. �. � �fi ; I ��* � a ��; �raia.w►�s �� 0 � � � � � S � � � � � � � � N �: ;,�,, ' � � ., � � i : r,��w�� {� • s • � � • s • • • • • • • • � ;�� • • • • � � ra • s V �;�. *: �_�. , �.::��, .� .� rr + ,;�.,�,� ''.�'�s-;`�,: �,: � r,„,,,. .��F.� �d.�. T �. � . �� ` }�rf�' � � �'� � � � � ��.. � � � ' . �� :� �;r � , � �_. �M f��' ��,... .s.��••• .� ��`� ��.�� ' ��1� �� a'. � 1� � ' �� r ` =:1 � �z �' S • • • � � .� � • • • ! • � � ��.�. ,�` yr�:�.t.,V'�' � � . . ,.:F � i =.i� r . �.. � r � � � •� � � � � „ . � t � �z�+�. ,. �� F}.�� _.. ..:t" S..�c.�a" „ii'�l� �"Y... ... p,; „ �: =;-. ' �� :i /� s � �� : ,,: � ��; ,�� ; ` � .� ' � ,� s � �t. r . j.. •4.� �! . �a."�a. �p � .'1�..�.y,��' � �� Q -��'� �'` t ,`� ��{:�� . i/a�� , y".. ,.� � "�'` , �►� ��`°.�.�'�7�+�F!' � ;� 1� ,� � . ;�� `��; :�,�'t wo • w • • � � � � • . . � �_ �� . �;� ; ._ ��; - , �� c�: , • � • � • • a � • ��-�� C��;: • • • • i • • � � �'� �.i� - .__. , _ 0 : � � � O • • • ! � i • ! � • �,, � .. ��"n '� • • � • • i '�` � t � .� . .� � � . . � � � 1 : i � � • . � .� . � �/�� • . � . . . � . � � � , . � . � • ' . • ! • � • ' i • � • � + t � � • � � � � . . . . . : � • - � ' ' .., ��-i � . �1 . �.�� . �, ,,,� . -_,�� ,�.. , ��'�I�' • �;,�g� ,� ..�I ; . } , f , : �r.�.��.►�• �r . � �••�a�,,��n.�.� r�► Ir1A1 ' � � � � • • � � � � � � � 0 � � � � � S � �i � H ��i�.: r ��: � � �. �� ;r—�:, _ � " t. T , , _ ..`. u �•____ �. • s • �1 • � • • • • • • • • • �, ,,� =y • • • � i � • • • � Y :-- a.::�:° �, W � . Y ._ _ , � : �� - : . II■ �*� ��; ._4� � . :: M � • • • � ��ii ��► " � ;: • • � • • �'• .,� • t: .. �c �_ .t�._ ,� _ �,� ,, � - ! .., .- � t�.,� ;. �i ~� �� _.��„. t _ :--=r „ S , � r � r;. ■� I� `y: �.., !� • t � '�.. � a • • � � ,� � � • • • • • � . ,�� __---, rar .`�.. . ` . :� � • � ��,.�.ry�� -��: �� • � • . • • • 0 0 � � �� '� � ...� P � .� ..- �� M �.: �.;; � r 1'..!!► ti ,� `., , }; �_I , , ��li �!�� .�w :� . ! � /• ��t: �� a' , .�-:' �'��. -� ��►�� a�� ur� � • Y �Y�� ,��{ r��{ � ��'`�� ` ; � r - �,,,111�1�� A Z::� �~��..��,{'^.�.z��. + • � ��X � �.:�",a`a:= • � • � � � . � � � , • .�,� . {� � .r� � M� � - � . ;,. -� Ei�; ��' - �i�'. � • � ♦ • • • a • ` , t��:' • • • • � • • • � � �"'� �r.ai� � -_ - O • • ;° ..�;; C �o ` � • a � • ♦ � � • �r�` S " d � � � • s � � � � � � . - - . �� : �� r . � : . � . . ' ' � ��.�/. = . . � . . . . � � � � � . � . � i � � , � s � � � • � � � � • • • . . � � � • � ' � • . . - . . : � , - � . . . r . ----�-!' ROLL CALL UOTE - PL�PJNITa� COh1MISSION -- � DATE /l I . I �' �.. � � p �T ��.�-�-C....-E'� - • � 53 7 �s->°� -S �L� � ` 1 2 3 4 5 6 YES NO A* YES NO A* YES NO A* YES NO A* YES NO A* YES ��0 A* ANDERSON � ARMSTEAD � BRYAN COCHRANE FITzGI860N ( GtiA I S ,J '� HANGGI HUBER HYDUKE KARNS � � LANEGRE;�1 � � LEVY McGONE�L McGINIEY NELSON '� � '� NORTON f PANGAL SU��IMERS � TAYLOR � T08LER ✓ VAN HOEF TOTALS �� - /� - - �� 1� _. � f' Moti on 1 ..��,,;,,s �,., - Gcr�-�'-Q-J Moti on 4 �cvm�,-�,�.cz.-�-�- c��— Motion 2 /� - ,��_�_ Motion 5 Mo�io� 3 �� - Motion E � . . .---�-� ROLL CALL VOTE - PLf�P�NING COPIMISSION -- DATE // I �.. '. "` . � . O' 6 7 V �iC/...•��,/ . � . % . J 3 7 �5.5"0�e -� �� r `� 1 2 3 4 5 6 YES NO A* YES NO A* YES NO A* YES NO A* YES NO A* YES NO A�• ANDERSON � 1 ARMSTEAD � � BRYAN CQCHRANE FITzGI660N GItAIS ►� . � MANGGI HUBER � . - HYDUKE . KARNS ✓ ✓. '. LANEGRAN LEUY McDOtJELL ...� - . McGINLEY NELSON '� '� NORTON � � PANGAL SUt�IMERS � 7AYLOR ' T08LER ✓ VAN HOEF TOTALS ,� _ _ /� - - 1� - ' J� - � �� : Moti on 1 ,.��,�,,,.,�,.,.t�, - Gcr� Moti on 4 �c,vrn��- Moti on 2 /� - ,��,�,.� Moti on 5 Mo��on 3 �i - Motion 6 42.�t r.... - ;' : . ._ ,,: _� _.,. ' ZONING STAFF REPORT �`�� y � 8526 1 . APPLICANT: Rollie Brown DATE OF HEARING ��-1-79 2. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . CLASSIFICATION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . CURRENT PLANNING & ZONING COMMITTEE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS Rezoning � Variance ❑ • Special Condition Use ❑ Administrative Review ❑ Determination of Similar Use ❑ Other ❑ Change of Nonconforming Use ❑ Other ❑ 3. LOCATION: 1602 and 1606 Carroll (near the southwest corner of Snelling and Carroll� 4. LEGAL DESCRIPTION: Lots 8 and 9, Block 5, College Park Addition. _, 5. PRESENT ZONING: RT-1 ZONING CODE REFEREPJCE: Section 64.210 6. STAFF INVESTIGATION & REPORT: DATE 10-24-79 gy D.F. McNeally �� -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- , A. SUFFICIENCY: The application to rezone was filed on a consent petition subscribed and sworn to before a Notary P'ublic on 9-10-79; declared sufficient by the Finance Department on 9-19-79; and received in the Planning Office on 9-27-79. 22 parcels were eligible; 13 parcels were required; 15 were obtained. The petition stated the zoning categories RT-1 to I-1 , but did not state a purpose. . . B. PURPOSE: The applicant intends to rezone from RT-1 (1 and 2 family) to I-1 (light industrial ) in order to construct an addition to the existing Cooperative Plating Company located to the south across the alley. C. FRONTAGE AND AREA: This rectangular site is composed of two lots with a total of 80 foot frontage on Carroll and a depth of 122 feet. D. SITE AND AREA CONDITIONS: The site is occupied by two single family homes in good repair. Adjacent to the west and north are other single family homes fronting on Carroll . Rdjacent to the east is a building housing Local 2047 which is zoned B-3 as are those uses fronting on Snelling. To the south abutting across an alley is the existing Cooperative Plating Company which fronts on Iglehart. Snelling Avenue, a major thoroughfare, is one-half block to the east. The two lots in question comprise two of a total of 7 residentially zoned lots on the south side of Carroll Avenue. E. FINDINGS: 1. The 1963 Comprehensive La.n,c Use Plan des�gnated this site as a medium density . residential . 2. The site was previously zoned light industrial . Under the 1922 code, houses could be constructed in industrial zones. 3. The 1975 zoning ordinance designated the site as RT-1 , recognizing existing uses. 4. The District 13 Plan, adopted by the City Council , identifies this site as part of one of eight small residential areas in the district. These small resident�al areas are typically more easily penetrated than larger neighbarhoods by business expansion and parking lots; however, they serve an important function by providing both homeowner and rental housing at moderate cost. The District 13 Plan further states that "in order to conserve these small residential areas, special attention should be paid in zoning cases to creating stable residential edges." It would appear that this proposed industrial expansion would create an unstable situation on the south side of Carroll between Snelling and Fry. It would appear that this proposed rezoning represents a "nibbling away" effect. 5. The District 13 Plan also identifies this site as "block initiative areas" for the neighborhood Housing Services program. This means that if residents organize a concentration of rehab projects on a particular block, the Neighborhood Ho�sing Services would play a strong supporting role. 6. Carroll is not a truck route and expansion of this industrial use could generate more commercial traffic alo�;y this residential street. . , STAFF REPORT Rollie Brown #8526 7. Discussions with Public Works relative to a vacation of a portion of the alley between the existing Plating Company and these two lots in question in order for the applicant to expand his building acr�ss the existing alley have revealed that Public Works would not support such a vacation. Vacation of the entire alley from Snelling to Fry would result in an alley which is half industrial and half residential , preventing use by the industrial corporation. 8. Discussions relative to a vacation of a portion of Iglehart in order for expansion of the Plating Company to the south have occurred and the district planner and Public Works agree that this would be the better solution to the expansion needs. The intersection of Iglehart, the railroad,and Fry Street is one of the most dangerous in the district and this vacation could result in an alleviation of that danger. Ho�ever, the applicant has stated that he is interested in proceeding wit� the rezoning of the two lots on Carroll rather than the vacation of Iglehart. . r 9. There are a number of restrictions placed on irr�lustriaT property abutting residential property. These include a required side yard: setback equal to one and one-half times the height of the industrial building. Therefore, a typical 16 foot building would result in a required setback of 24 fee�. In this case the applicant would be restricted to a 32 foot building unless. he applied for an obtained a variance. The applicant must also meet the front yard setback of the blocic which is 25 feet or the average of the block. Off-street parking and loading is not permitted in these required yards. Off-street parking would also have to be provided. 10. Other permitted uses in the I-1 district include all the B-3 uses, automo5ile body shops and repair facilities and contractors yards. . Give�i the size of the parcel and its adjacent location to residential use it would appear that some of these permitted uses as well as the Plating Company could result in increased traffic, nc�ise and be generally detrimental to the residential qualit.y of Carroll . 11. The proposed reaoning could be considered spot zoning: it is not in accord with the Comprehensive Plan or the adopted District 13 Plan; there are na changing conditions in the area or apparent mistakes in the original zon7ng which warrant a change in the zoning; the area to be rezoned is small , two lots; the nermitted uses of the proposed I-1 are substantially different from the nrevailing residential uses fronting on Carroll ; the change to a less restricted district appears to be more to the advantage of a specific developer in this case than to the surrounding community. F. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Based on findings 1 through 11 above, staft recommends aenial of the rezoning request. , , . ._ " ZONING STAFF REPORT � ` �� r 8526 1 . APPLICANT: Rollie Brown DATE OF HEARING�1_1_79 2. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . CLASSIFICATION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . CURRENT PLANNING & ZONING COMMITTEE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS Rezoning � Variance ❑ Special Condition Use ❑ Administrative Review ❑ Determination of Similar Use ❑ Other ❑ Change of Nonconforming Use ❑ Other ❑ 3. LOCATION: 1602 and 1606 Carroll (near the southwest corner of Snelling and Carroll ) 4. LEGAL DESCRIPTION: Lots 8 and 9, Block 5, College Park Addition. 5. PRESENT ZONING: RT-1 ZONING CODE REFEREPdCE: Section 64.210 6. STAFF INVESTIGATION & REPORT: DATE 10-24-79 gy D.F. McNeally -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- A. SUFFICIENCY: The application to rezone was filed on a consent petition subscribed and sworn to before a Notary Public on 9-10-79; declared sufficient by the Finance Department on 9-19-79; and received in the Planning Office on 9-27-79. 22 parcels were eligible; 13 parcels were required; 15 were obtained. The petition stated the zoning categories RT-1 to I-1 , but did not state a purpose. B. PURPOSE: The applicant intends to rezone from RT-1 (1 and 2 family) to I-1 (light industrial ) in order to construct an addition to the existing Cooperative Plating Company located to the south across the alley. C. FRONTAGE AND AREA: This rectangular site is composed of two lots with a to�al of 80 foot frontage on Carroll and a depth of 122 feet. D. SITE AND AREA CONDITIONS: The site is occupied by two single family homes in good repair. Adjacent to the west and north are ather single family homes fronting on Carroll . Adjacent to the east is a building housing Local 2047 which is zoned B-3 as are those uses fronting on Snelling. To the south abutting across an alley is the existing Cooperative Plating Company which fronts on Iglehart. Snelling Avenue, a major thoroughfare, is one-half block to the east. The two lots in question comprise two of a total of 7 residentially zoned lots on the south side of Carroll Avenue. E. FINDINGS: ', . The 1963 ��mpreriensive Land Use p'.an dAei�nated this site as a medium �ensitu residential . 2. The site was previously zoned light industrial . Under the 1922 code, houses could be. constructed in industrial zones. 3. The 1975 zoning ordinance designated the site as RT-1 , recognizing existing uses. 4. The District 13 Plan, adopted by the City Council , identifies this site as part of one of eight small residential areas in the district. These small residential areas are typically more easily penetrated than larger neighborhoods by business expansion and parking lots; however, they serve an important function by pr�viding both homeowner and rental housing at moderate cost. The District 13 Plan further states that "in order to conserve these small residential areas, special attention should be paid in zoning cases to creating stable residential edges." It would appear that this proposed industrial expansion would create an unstable situation on the south side of Carroll between Snelling and Fry. It would appear that this proposed rezoning represents a "nibbling away" effect. 5. The District 13 Plan also identifies this site as "block initiative areas" for the neighborhood Housing Services program. This means that if residents organize a concentration of r�hab projects cn a �art;culu� �';ock, the ^l��grborhood iio�sir�g Serviees would play a strong supporting role. 6. Carroll is not a truck route and expansion of this indiastriai use could generate - more commercial traffic alonq this residential stre�t, /�_ _ �TAFF REPORT Rollie Brouln �8526 7. �1SCUSS�O�i.°, :.Ji�lh D�FJI�.• I,�..�LS Y'O�dtl��° tn a y��atinn nf 4 r�v�ti�n n�F th� d��C�jt between the existing Plating Company and these two lots in question in order far the ' applicant to expand his builu�ing acrnss the existing alley have revealed that Public Works would not support such a vacation. Vacation of the entire a11ey from Snelling t� Fry would result in an alley which is half industrial and half resider,tial , preventing use by the industrial cor��ration. 8. Discussions relative to a vacation of a portion of Iglehart in order fc�r expansion of the Plating Company to the south have occurred and the district planner and Public t.Jorks agree that this would be the better solution to the expansion needs. The intersection of Iglehart, the railroad,and Fry Street is one of the most dangerous in the district and this vacation could result in an alleviation of that danger. However, the applicant has stated that he is interested in pr�ceeding with the rezoning of the two lots on Carroll rather than the vacatiun of Iglehart. 9. There are a number of restrictions placed on industrial property abutting residential property. These include a reqGired side yard setback equal to one and one-ha.lf times the height of the industrial building. Therefore, a typical 16 faot bui�ding would result in a required setback of 24 feet. In this case the applicant would be restricted to a 32 foot building unless he apnlied for an obtained a variance. The applicant must also meet the front yard setback of the block which is 25 feet ar the average of the block. Off-street parking and loading is not permitted in these required yards. Off-street parking would also have to be provided. 10. Other permitted uses in the I-1 district include all the B-3 uses , a�tomo�ile body shops and repair faciiitZe� and contractors yards. aiven the size of the parcel and its adjacent location to residential use it would appear that some of these. permitted uses as well as the Plating Comnany could result in increased traffic, nc�ise and be gener�lly detrimental to the residential quality of Carrall. 11 . The proposed rezoning could be considered spot zoning: it is not in accord with the Comprehensive Plan or the adc�pted District 13 Plan; there are nn changinq conditions in the area or apparent mistakes in the original zoning which warrant a change in the zoning; the area to be rezoned is small , two 1ots ; the permitted uses of the proposed I-1 are substantially different from the prevailing residential uses fronting on Carroll ; the change to a less restricted district appears to be more to the advantage of a specific developer in this case than to the surroundtng community. � F. STAFF Rr.COP1MEiVGAi'IGN: 6ased on finaings 1 °crrcug�� 11 above, staff �•ecomi��ends denial of the rezoning request. , f ' � �� . i �� `f-� #� � �� i _ . , . . _: � �t. � � . . ,�so. �.� �—�c—79 CITY OF SAINT PAUL, t4IMlESOTA PETITION TO AMENO CHAPTERS 60 thru 64 OF THE LEGISLATIVE (ZONING) COQ� Np , - -�-^��ng ai�1 be considered by the City of 5sint . °^r^�'� si�ning t�12 MINUTES OF THE CURRENT p�qNNIPvG qNp ZONING CO . IN CITY COUNCIL CNAME�ERS, ST. PqUL MMITTEE h1EETIr�G '� T PRE-- SENT-= hh�eS• Ka rns and su��p�rs , ' MINNESOTA, ON P�OVEP1GER � , �y�g � Pianning and Zoning Comrnittee• ' Messrs. Bryan, Lev � Ms. Wendy Lane and Mr, ' Mr• �erome Se Y and Par�yal c,f the Current Enforcement; Mmes. R�chard An1e of 9a> > Assista►�t City Attc�rney; , McNeally and Hanson of e Divisi�n of Housing and Quildir� AB'S�_ the Planning Divisioi�. 9 Code Mrs. McGinley and Mr. Lanegran. The meeting was chaired by James Bryan, Cha�r ROLLIE BROWN (#8526 : man. and 1606 � A petitTOn to rezone from RT-� tu I_� Carroll for the expansion of Cooperativ e Pl�ting. Property at ]602 The petittoner was present. There was op osi � Ms. McNeally shawed slides of th� p t�on present at the hearing. denial of the rezor�ing request. S�te and reviewed the staff report re One letter was received from the commending opPosition. Snelling_Hamline Community Council stat ' Twelve letters were received from residents W� �n9 their opposition to the rezoning request. ��h1n 350 feet also statin Rollie Brown 9 their this � owner of the propert t�dt pt�hadtbeenschanged�taer�id y' Stated that before not realize until he wentetu9se11 (�h��9p�r`��nance, sldential. � rop�r�y David Brown of T151 Park Ave. zoned industrial and there ' Mahtomedi were no ' eXp�a1ned that this area was not create any more additional Problems. He felt that this rezonin to expand. PerhapS the neiyhboPhoodeneeds ��r area, pr�viously Platin The cit g WUU1d g about what the e inforrnation fromhCood a>>0w businesses Y intend to do in the area. Victor Rosenbloom P�rative put up a sma) � bu�1dana9er of Cooper�ative Platirj Any trucks wou)d use jg °n the site, comp]etel g' eXp�a�ned that the glehart. Y separate from their y pian to Mrs. present building. Hueller of 1601 Carrol ) in the area and also tear � stated she felt that trucks on the alley line and thisuPreates taeet w�uld create rnore noise also was concerned about Pavement. The present buildin biind corner at Carroll and Igleharts �ocated Property values going down. Florence Felix of She in the area. 1613 Carroll stated her concern about truck traffic and noise Mrs. Don Haman of 1625 Carrol) stated the hous and they could be resold for sin le famil 9 es on the site are in good conditi�n Hearin no f Y residences. 9 urther testimony, P1r. Bryan closed the publi Mr. Levy made a motion to den � hearir�g, 11 of the staff report. Mrs,y �he rezoning request based on findin S � the rezoning Was Summers seconded the motiun. � �r�rough passed with a ro) 1 ca11 vote of � The motion to deny Submitted by; 5 to 0. a-�- �/`, Approved by: onna F. McNea,�y �__ ,� Notary Pubia.c, ..s....--. y,��? Z ��—"�� - - � E.'$ Rr� �n� r�. Srly cotnmission expires ��,,,°1 � f ` ' "r�i�n ",,�, • � LJ ��.: L�� _ P�TITION TO AMENO CEiApTERS� 60 thru 64 OF 'THE LEGZSLATIVE (ZO*1ZMG) COD� � , ' , . Note: Before the petitioner's proposal for rezoning Wi�I. be considered by the City of Sai�t Paul, property owners must consent to the proposed change. Before signing the petition which is a statement to thot ef�ect, the signer should be aware ef u��a ger- mitted under the. new classificatfon. For further information about the rezoning c�f property, call the Zoning Section of the City Planning Office, 298-4154. TO TH� HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL pa,te: c/o the City Clerk, Room 386 City Hall City of Saint Paul, Minaesota , Section 64.210 of St. Paul's Zoning Ordinance states that 67y of property owners within tne area to be considered must consent to the proposed rezoning. Section 462.357(5) of Minnesota Statutes states that 2/3 of property owners within 100 feet of the land proposed for rezoning must give written consent before the City shall consider the proposal. However, when the owner of said property has owned for any time in the past year additional real estate contiguou= to the land proposed for rezoning, 2/3 of the property owners within 100 feet of this larger package of property must give written consent. Pursuant to Section 64.210 of the St. Paul Zo�ing Ord�nance and Section 462.357(5) of Minnesota Statutes, we, the undersigned, own property within 100 feet of the petitioner's land and hereby petition your Honorable Body to rezone the following described property: (legal description & street address) J.,�-f-S `�� `t, r,,i��l: Si Co l��R� l��'-r 1� � �L�da Carroll °F 1 6p fa La rro /� J fzam��J Distri�t to .1 � District, for the pu��pOSe of i*�stalling, canstructing and/or aperatiag the followinq: (descxibe briefly the proposed faci.lity) RECORD OWDIER SIGNF1TiJRE ZAT BLOCK ADDITION Subject roperty: /� /� ��Pa�. I�✓�, ,� s" C'vI/� � �,- , ., �- ' �� s ,� '/ � a ,. ✓�. � ' , /O �. .. r��c C �� . A,:� ,�� .� �— �G G� (�� n - -- f. fl C � %��.��. � �-- -< :. /G'e a /fP�:0.4� r�' _ � ( S��S C�if F�o�!�c �✓F �v =��`� � � '' � � State of Mirulesota) ' � �s � County af Ramsey ) : c.. _ _ . -- - - __. _ __ _ ___ _.__ __- --- ---- - _- _- _-- _--s �� ;� �-� ' ' .,� .,o � � C'o�l � . � G... /�� ,. �� 1 r'•_- ---- . , �. )�'.�l /� ., • � /� �. - ;'� - • - �� //? G - • \�� - � � _ rr ', _, � �� ^�'� �_ �_�1'-'�x.,�' - -� I, ' --- )))i � /� I - I � b / � /_ �r J!�� • �J 4��!!�- �� . . � . � \. . . �+� � } � �13 ) _ � // –� rr �• �'S '� f.%�c� L v r= --- � /� 7' �` � 'lo o/ C=/��Q �o s�,c ft d� 2 .— ----_ !� � .. ., �G � ��.A it'%�C�� ;�r',� ' � - r J% /�� /`>� =�`- r/✓`E .2 ° .� , -- �_ - �� /'i �'�`L�.L ,�'t / �r 4 s� ---�-�-- � ---�-----�-- . ' i �Y_ , _ � , t � �- � , � � - � J �� , • CITY OF SAINT PAUL, cRZrtraFso�A � PETITION TO AMEND CHAPTERS 60 thrtt 64 OF THE LEGISLATIVG (ZONIIVG) GOL�E Note: T�e signer should appris� himself of the usps �ermitted under the new classi-- fication before signing this petiiion. For further informatian about tne rezoning of property, call the Board of Zoning Office at 298-4151. (Please type or print} bate: TO ."'iHE HOI�iORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL c/o� the City Clerk, Room 386 City .Hall City of Saint Paul, Minnesota Pursuant to Section 64.06 of the Legislative Code an$ Minnesota` Statute 462.357(5) , we, the undersigned owners of two-thirds of the several descriptions of real estate situated within 100 feet of the total contiguous descriptions of real estate helu by the owner of the real estate to b� re2onEd or by any party who has pu�chased o� is piirchasing any such contiguous property within one il� year preceding the date of. this oetition, such property including the property to be rezoned, hereby acquiesc'�; ar:d we, tY►e owners of 50$ or more of the £rontage to be reclassified, petition ,your �r�narable �,,� Bc�.3y to rezone the f llowing des ibed property: (legal description and street addrsss) d�°�v`fi �:2e� �' ° ��. ��D� �-tQ /�o� ��c�� from ,��%/ District to � > District, for th� purpose of installing, constructing and/or operating the following: (descrire briefly the proposed facility) RECORD OWNER SIGPtATURE LOT BLOCR ADDITION Sub'ect ropert�: , . �'�t' t-s � .l ' � c3— � l� o � �r, . �,� �- �� •, ,. ,, `� /g s << .. ,, « �� /9 � �� « <� Y �' �(3 ✓� /r l�. /..- � �. �:� << �, ` . �� n( � �� •. C r• !� /f� �� „ . ' !i e o inneso a ) ss County of Ramsey ) �v �. L /�E .�RoG�tl/�/ being first duly sworn, deposes and stat�s that he is i.he psrson who circulated the within petition consisting o ages; that the pa�ties described above are the owners respectively of the lots a immediat�ly following each narae; that each of the parties descri.bed above is the owner of property which is within 100 feet from any property owned by affiant or sold �y affiant withi.n one {1� year preceding the date of this petition which is contiguous to the property above described; fihat none of the parties described a'�ove has purchased or is purchasing property from af:iiant'cantiguous to the above described property within one il) year of the date of this petition; that this petition was siqned �hy each of said owners in the presence of this affiant, and that the signatures above are the true and correct signatuYes of each ar.d all of the parties so described, , Subscribed and sworn to before me Adc'tress: /G D G ��, �.WQ1 Telephone No.. ( %�/ t� or b�Jr this��Y of / r1' 7 � _ Approz*ed as to form 5-27-73 ' �� `bjcfice o£ the City Attorney �.'7 � .�otary Public, Ramsey Coiin�ty, ,Mi,izzx. '. ' � riy commission expires � , �„ -�'' ` � . l: . .... .r.. .. ..`�..��V-JVVZ2 _... . � � � •. ' ` ��0 • • , , "`��T�rt�,L� CITY OF SAINT PAUL '�`` •�''i�� ''� i: '• •� OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK :o a; :� uu�m�i ,: ;� �n �nn ^� ''�• = BUREAU OF RECORDS '�,,p ,�� ; �1^��""OC``` 386 City Hall,Saint Paul,Minnesota 55102 GEORGE LATIMER 612-298-4231 MAYOR J�Y 31, 1979 Mr. Bernard Carlson �irector, Finance & Managemeat Services Room 113, City Ha11 St. Paul, Minnesota Dear Sir: The Couttcil referred to you for check a$ to sufficiency, the attach�d petition to rezone Lots 8 and 9, Block 5, College Park Addition a� 16�2 and 1606 Carroll Av�enue. Very truly yours, � �'T Rose Mix City CZerk � Attach. ABO:la :. � R��EI�EO q�G_ -� �. � � OFF�CE 2 19�g O. I f{ ANp M N M�NTNOF�lnFrrOR A��MENT S�R�� \� / � rc�S �� r � � �: � � � � �_:: �o r •� � I • � � .. • � . � • t ~ , ` � . ,. ' s . � STATE OF MINNESOTA ) � . ) •' COUN'PY OF RAMSEY ) ss. ) ! CITY OF SAINT PAUL ) , • .. � ��/�� f Gj/�/ , being first duly sworn, deposes and states that he is the owner of the property �o be rezoned, or has authority to lawfully bind the owner of the property to be � rezoned, which is described as follows: � � OT $ � ��OG�(' coll�G� �� that affiant does not have any legal or equitable interest in, is not in the act of purchasing, nor has he purchased or sold within one (1) yeaz preceding the date of the attached petition any :Land contiguous t:, t:�e p�oper�y �cu6::t � to be rezoned as described above, except (NONE) (SEE ATTACHED); that affiant i ' � understands the word "contiguous" as used herein to mean parcels of property sharing a co�on boundary at any point without regard to the presence of public i �� thoroughfares. � "!/-�� vl ' N0�!'ARY PUBLIC, RAMSEY COUNZ'Y, MZNN. ,.�-�� r,7i+, < - . . � � '�. e. s i�o�� 5 1535. � • �� . . �N.^Mh/'•`�M!`M/• Juf y��, ��'�� . � • , + � r '`� - CITY OF ST. PAUL DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE AND MANAGEMENT SERVICES ASSESSMENT DIVISION 113 CITY HALL ST.PAUL,MINNESOTA 55102 August 13, 1979 To the Council City of St. Paul I have checked the attached petition of Rollie Brown filed in the matter of rezoning, Lots 8 and 9, Block 5, College Park Addition, from an RT-1 to an I-1 district and find that said petition is insufficient. Yours very truly, � � Bernard J. Carlson - Director Re: X2365 cc: Building Department Zoning Board File Parcels eligible - 22 Parcels needed - 15 Parcels signed - 7 � . . , , . , r . , . � � ,r' : ,, �; .. . , ' - + , � , � . �, � � . • ' . i ' . � . , . • � _ �6�5* ,1l�� 19�9 , - ,. . � . � _ . !�. 1�0�]�1 I�ra�n . �s t�u ��.. � � st. 'Pau].,�.N�t�eaota 55� � �.�� . . � . . . . � . . . . . . . .. � . R�5 ' R�t Peti��;oa x.o reabne Lo#a 8 �nd 9, Col.l�gi Park :AdsL�. , ; � Dear SS�r s \ : �. ,. � . : � The �ba'w«r�fe.r�►d xec� �rrt�cl �QSnffi.o�.effit by � Dirto'�c�r � , , , � oP �'imanc� 8a Mcuea�e.a�er�t 5otrrlo�a Dept. : � � . 1. � . . . . . . . , , 4 ' : �! p6Lrlt3.oci 7j.e Y��I811�b3.� f�x' rettircr�]aa�ion at t�l6 C1�y c��.' $�• Faul''s C3.�tg.:�lartz aP�'i�i :bt�t.�86�,;�ty Hail. . ` _ . � , r -��, �„�, �� , , . . . _ z . ` � , Ro� -M�c . , . � , . �� rg� � ,: �`� � � . . , � � � , , �. � , - ; , �- • A!�:ln • ' - � . . ,, _ t . . , ' i ; � � � � . � . . ,. , . _ �� _ , . � � � ,t � � , a , . { i . . , , ; , _ , � � ' . � i . . . _ _ �� ' . `4 ' CiTY Or 5T. Pa�.iL � � . : , DFP�R3,4S��1]' OF �I�IAN�� A\D �ti1A�AG�MEtiT SxPV10E5 � t►ssfsstiiE,�r�ivisiov , 113 CtiY HAII Si.P�UI,h11.VNE50?A ii10? � December 21, 197�3 . .�. . - City Clerk � 386 City Hall File X2365 Page 1 St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 Zoning File 8526 - iEee Council of the City of St. Pau1 will hold a publ.ic hearing in Lhe Cou-�cil Cha.-�bers of the City Hall and CQurt �Zouse (third floor) �t � � 10-00 a_ri. on January 10,� 1}80 on the: Petition of Rollie Brown to rezone from an RT-1 :district to an I-1 . • - ` - district the property at 1602-1606 Carroll Avenue. This property . � , is located on the south side of Carroll Avenue between Snelling and ' Macalester Avenues, and is legally described at: Lots 8 and 9, ' � Block 5, College Park. � If }ou �,-ould like further infor�ation about this hearing, coatact the Curre� Ylau:iiao Section of the Planning Board, Rm: 1202 Citp �:all A�:ie:c=298-415�. �."aile the City Chaxter xequixes that we notify, yoa of the hearing, we t,�ant to � he].p Sou to leaxn fully about any icaprovenent that could affect you oz your co�tr_i*�j. Therefore, I sincerely Y�ope.you can attend this tiear?ng, so thz� .. . ;_ you can r•lake your views about it kno��m to the City Co�ncil, whether ror or - . �oairtst_ � � � - � J_ WILLIAM DOtiOV?ujT � . VALIIATIO�i AND ASSESSi'IE�iT E\GIi+�.E� � � , , � 4 ; , , ' , ��. . ' CITY OF ST. PAUL � ` DEPARTMENT Of fINANCE AND MANAGEMENT SERVICES ASSESSMENT DIVISION 113 CITY HALL ST.PAUL,MINNESOTA 55102 September 19, 1979 To the Council City of St. Paul I have rechecked the attached petition of Rollie Brown ffled in the matter of rezoning, Lots 8 and 9, Block 5, College P�rk Addition, from an RT-1 district to an I-1 district, and find that said petition if sufficient. Yours very truly, � �ntiL1.��1, �� Bernard J. Carlson - Director Re: X2365 CC: Building Department Zoning Board File parcels eligible - 22 parcels needed - 15 parcels signed - 15 �� / �� 2,6 January 3, 1980 � -r ,��°'��. �� Current Planning & Zoning Committee ;� 5 � , 25 West Fourth Street St. Paul , Minnesota 55102 Dear Sir: Subject: Zoning File No. 8526 Zoning File Name - Rollie Brown Address : 1602-1606 Carroll Avenue (Near S.W. Corner Snelling/Carroll ) Lot 8 8� 9, 61ock 5, College Park Addition. Reason: As a home owner in a residential area, I maintain that W� dre being discriminated against b,y continued violations of the residential code by the following industrial and business establishments : Norman Chemical Co. Tempel Motors, Inc. Creative Lighting Nicholson Co. Vickers Gas Station Adeco Mfg. Co. Kline Oldsmobile Lot Local #2047 Cooperative Plating The above mentioned, in some instances. has contributed to our discomfort; noise and dirt pollution and a serious parking problem. We have had more than our share of these frustrating situations due to the trains, fire engines, trucks and car transports. The latter doinq a good job of tearing up our streets that are maintained through our tax dollar. I am not in favor of rezoning from RT-1 to I-1 to expand the existing Cqoperative Plating Building and/or provide parking for Cooperative Plating. Yq�rs Very Truly� � � �� I ,,; ,;.1 !, � `��' L'_ i:i] j� � �' �, �J � � , �� .Ll�_Y r`t.-`,' :,� '`''1/�7f '� ., �y•� _ ,oli.i . � , ,. '�..1 � i January 3, 1980 Current Planning & Zoning Committee 25 West Fourth Street S�. Paul , Minnesota 55102 Dear Sir: Subject: Zoning File Mo. 8526 Zoning File Name - Rollie Brown Address ; 1602-1606 Carroll Avenue (Near S.W. Corner Snelling/Carroll ) Lot 8 & 9, Block 5, College Park Addition. Reason: As a home owner in a residential area, I maintain that we are being discriminated against b,y continued violations of the residential Cpde by th� following industrial and business establishments : Norman Chemical Co. Tempel Motors, Inc. Creative Liqhting Nicholson Co. - Vickers Gas Station Adeco Mfg. Co. Kline Oldsmobile Lot Local #2047 Cooperative Plating The above mentioned, in some instances, has contributed to our discomfort; noise and dirt pollution and a serious parking problem. We have had more �han our share of these frustrating situations due to the trains , fire en�ines, trucks and car transports. The latter doing a good job of tearing up our stre�ts that are maintained through our tax dollar. I am not in favor of rezoning from RT-1 to I-1 to expand the existing CooperatiV� Plating Building and/or provide parking for Cooperative Plating. Ypurs Very Truly, ��.�a ��a.�..��-.. � b � I G� . January 3, 1980 �,.-� ./�%1��.��.�� ---___. a Current Pl ann i ng & Zoni ng Commi ttee ��'i;,( ;"�?/' � � � 25 West Fourth Street St. Paul . Minnesota 55102 � ' �.�.��i_r u�.l�C�C ; ;�� Dear Sir: Subject: Zoning File Mo. 8526 Zoning File Name - Rollie Brown Address ; 1602-1606 Carroll Avenue (Near S.W. Corner Snelling/Carroll ) Lot 8 & 9, Block 5, College Park Addition. Reason: As a home owner in a residential area, I maintain that we are being discriminated against b,y continued violations of the residential code by the following industrial and business establishments: Norman Chemical Co. Tempel Motors, Inc. Creative Lighting Nicholson Co. Vickers Gas Station Adeco Mfg. Co. Kline Oldsmobile Lot local #2047 Cooperative Plating The above mentioned, in some instances, has contributed to our discomfort; noise and dirt pollution and a serious parking problem. We have had more than our share of these frustrating situations due to the trains , fire engines, trucks and car transports. The latter doing a good job of tearing up our streets that are maintained through our tax dollar. I am not in favor of rezoning from RT-1 to I-1 to expand the existing Cooperative Plating Building and/or provide parking for Cooperative Plating. Yours V�ry Truly, I I Cu�'2.�.��^�-C� ' i `�'1� 1��g- a� ! (D�� L�fi��'�-GC �G�l�-� , l�� G��v �S�d �jL . r 1 C�C�� 4 January 3, 1980 Current Planning & Zoning Committee 25 West Fourth Street St. Paul , Minnesota 55102 Dear Sir: Subject: Zoning File Mo. 8526 Zoning File Name - Rollie Brown Address : 1602-1606 Carroll Avenue (Near S.W. Corner Snelling/Carroll ) Lot 8 & 9, Block 5, College Park Addition. Reason: As a home owner in a residential area, I maintain that we are being discriminated against b,y continued violat�ons of the residential cpde by the following industrial and business establishments: Norman Chemical Co. Tempel Motors, Inc. Creative Lighting Nicholson Co. Vickers Gas Station Adeco Mfg. Co. Kline Oldsmobile Lot Local #2047 Cooperative Plating The above mentioned, in some instances� has contributed to our discomfort; noise and dirt pollution and a serious parking problem. We have had more than our share of these frustrating situations due to the trains , fire engines, trucks and car transports. The latter doing a good job of tearing up our streets that are maintained through our tax dollar. I am not in favor of rezoning from RT-1 to I-1 to expand the existing Cooperative Plating Building and/or provide parking for Cooperative Plating. Y�urs Very Truly, / L. � � � ��,..°�G�v� . .. . :� . • , . , � ., + - January 3, 1980 :� ' ; � �AN 141�30 Current Planning & Zoning Committee , � 2� West Fourth Street ' � . � � St� Paul . Minnesota 55102 � D�ar Sir: Subject: Zoning File No. 8526 . . Zoning File Name - Rollie Brown �° Address : 1602-1606 Carroll Avenue (Near S.W. . Corner Snelling/Carroll � L'ot 8 & 9. Block 5, College Park Addition. ' Reason: As a home owner in a residential area� I maintain that We are being discriminated against by continued violations of the residential cqde by the following industrial and business establishments: Norman Chemical Co. Tempel Motors. Inc. Creative Lighting Nicholson Co. Vickers Gas Station Adeco Mfg. Co. Kline Oldsnwbile Lot Local �f2047 Cooperative Plating The above mentioned� in some instances, has contributed to our discomfort; noise and dirt pollution and a serious parking problem. We have had more than our share of these frustrating situations due to the trains, fire engin�s, trucks and car transports. The latter doing a good �ob of tearing up our streets that are maintained through our tax dollar. I am not in favor of rezoning from RT-1 to I-1 to expand the existing Coqperative Plating Building and/or provide parking for Cooperative Plating. Yours Very Truly. �. �' � . ti2 - � .z c5l-,; 1�2�c��1�r,�� ,�. ��2�.�.,� � �� (�rr��11 s�� F'au�, /ti1lU .,�� . � . � � January 3� 1980 � :' ' � ,iAlv 141�0 . ,. . Current Planning & Zoning Committee , . 25 West Fourth Street � . St. Paul . Minnesota 55102 ! Dedr Sir: Subject: Zoning File No. 8526 . Zoning File Name - Rollie Brown � : _ . � � . Address: 1602-1606 Carroll Avenue (Near S.W. Corner Snelling/Carro]1 ) L'ot 8 & 9� Block 5, College Park � Addition. ' Reason: As a home owner in a residential area, I maintain that . we are being discriminated against by continued violations of the residential � code by the following industrial and business establishments: Norman Chemical Co. Tempel Motors, Inc. Creative Lighting Nicholson Co. Uickers Gas Station Adeco Mfg. Co. Kline Oldsmobile Lot Local #2047 Cooperative Plating The above mentioned, in some instances, has contributed to our discomfort; � noise and dirt pollution and a serious parking problem. We have had more . than our share of these frustrating situations due to the trains, fire , �ngines, truckS and car transports. The latter doing a good �ob of tearing ; up our sti^eets that are maintained through our tax dollar. I dm not in favor of rezoning from RT-1 to I-1 to expand the existing �qoperative Plating Building and/or provide parking for Cooperative Plating. , Yours Yery Truly� . ,, �. ; , � � ��j ' ,�, m��P�t� � ��z��.�, � �� (�t,rr;�l l s�� F'a ct�, �llU : .. . .;�Yi: i�loM"YF,Y�. . . ,, - � � • January 3, 1980 Current Planning & Zoning Committee 25 West Fourth Street St. Paul , Minnesota 55102 Dear Sir: Subject: Zoning File Mo. 8526 Zoning File Name - Rollie Brown Address: 1602-1606 Carroll Avenue (Near S.W. Corner Snelling/Carroll ) Lot 8 & 9, Block 5, College Park Addition. Reason: As a home owner in a residential area, I maintain that we are being discriminated against by continued violations of the residential Code by the following industrial and business establishments: Norman Chemical Co. Tempel Motors, Inc. Creative Lighting Nicholson Co. Vickers Gas Station Adeco Mfg. Co. Kline Oldsmobile Lot Local #2047 Gooperative Plating The dbove mentioned, in some instances. has contributed to our discomfort; noise and dirt pollution and a serious parking problem. �e have had more than our share of these frustrating situations due to the trains, fire engines, trucks and car transports. The latter doinq a good �ob of tearing up our streets that are maintained through our tax dollar. I am nqt in favor of rezoning from RT-1 to I-1 to expand the existing Cooperative Plating Building and/or provide parking for Cooperative Plating. Yours Very Truly, i � � � C �t�� . : :�: . ; ; � � , . - , . January 3, 1980 Current Planning & Zoning Comrnittee 25 West Fourth Street St. Paul . Minnesota 55102 Dear Sir: Subject: Zoning File Mo. 8526 Zoning File Name - Rollie Brown Address : 1602-1606 Carroll Avenue (Near S.W. Corner Snelling/Carroll ) Lot 8 & 9, Block 5, College Park � Addition. Reason: As a home owner in a residential area, I maintain that we are being discriminated against b,y continued violations of the residential COde by the following industrial and business establishments : Norman Chemical Co. Tempel Motors, Inc. Creative Lighting Nicholson Co. Vickers Gas Station Adeco Mfg. Co. Kline Oldsmobile Lat Local �2047 Cooperative Plating The dbove mentioned, in some instances. has contributed to our discomfort; noise and dirt pollution and a serious parking problem. We have had more than our share of these frustrating situations due to the trains, fire engines, trucks and car transports. The latter doing a good job of tearing up pur str�ets th�t are maintained through our tax dollar. I �m �ot in favor of rezoning from RT-1 to I-1 to expand the existing Cqoperatjve Plattng Building and/or provide parking for Cooperative Plating. Y4urs Very Truly, � ' "' ` 1 i ` �►c�l ` ` �"�.t L /p;r�,jz �t i2'1�'�� .'� • � January 3, 1980 Current Planning & Zoning Committee 25 West Fourth Street St. Paul , Minnesota 55102 Dear Sir: Subject: Zoning File Plo. 8526 Zoning File Name - Rollie Brown Address : 1602-1606 Carroll Avenue (Near S.W. Corner Snelling/Carroll ) Lot 8 & 9, Block 5, College Park Addition. Reason: As a home owner in a residential area, I maintain that we are being discriminated against b,y continued violations of the residential code by the following industrial and business establishments : Narman Chemical Co. Tempel Motors, Inc. �reative Lighting Nicholson Co. Vickers Gas Station Adeco Mfg. Co. Kline Oldsmobile Lot Local #2047 Cooperative Plating Th� dbove mentioned, in some instances, has contributed to our discomfort; nois� and dirt pollution and a serious parking problem. We have had more thdn our share of these frustrating situations due to the trains, fire engines, trucks and car transports. The latter doing a good job of tearing up our streets that are maintained through our tax dollar. I am not in favor of rezoning from RT-1 to I-1 to expand the existing Cqoperative Plating Building and/or provide parking for Cooperative Plating. Yqurs V�ry Truly, . �/ tiG�-iG�� ✓- � ��2��--�.y �� `L�-e- , l�� Y� �S� d � � January 3, 1980 ,- �"� � ��{�� - �.__ , Current Planning � Zoning Committee (_,`��(/�� , � 25 West Fourth Street St. Paul , Minnesota 55102 ) � /�y �" �'`�'Y't.1�.!� � 1. Dear Sir: Subject: Zoning File No. 8526 � Zoning File Name - Rollie Brown Address: 1602-1606 Carroll Avenue (Near S.W. Corner Snelling/Carroll ) Lot 8 & 9, Block 5, College Park Addition. Reason: As a home owner in a residential area, I maintain that we are being discriminated against b,y continued violations of the residential code by the following industrial and business establishments: Norman Chemical Co. Tempel Motors, Inc. Creative Lighting Nicholson Co. Vickers Gas Station Adeco Mfg. Co. Kline Oldsmobile Lot Local �2047 Cooperative Plating The above mentioned, in some instances, has contributed to our discomfort; noi5e and dirt pollution and a serious parking problem. We have had more thdn our share of these frustrating situations due to the trains , fire en�ines, trucks and car transports. The latter doing a good job of tearing up our streets that are maintained through our tax dollar. I �m not in favor of rezoning from RT-1 to I-1 to expand the existing CpoperatiVe Plating Building and/or provide parking for Cooperative Plating. Yours Very Truly, I i ��..wvd�:a� � i ~�-� 1��- a� January 3, 1980 Current Planning & Zoning Committee 25 West Fourth Street St. Paul , Minnesota 551.02 Dear Sir: Subject: Zoning File No. 8526 Zoning File Name - Rollie Brown Address; 1602-1606 Carroll Avenue (Near S.W. Corner Snelling/Carroll ) Lot 8 & 9, Block 5, College Park Addition. Reason: As a home owner in a residential area, I maintain that We are being discriminated against b,y continued violations of the residential Code by the following industrial and business establishments: Norman Chemical Co. Tempel Motors, Inc. Creat�ve Lighting Nicholson Co. Vickers Gas Station Adeco Mfg. Co. Kline Oldsmobile Lot Local #2047 Cooperative Plating The above mentioned, in some instances, has contributed to our discomfort; noise and dirt pollution and a serious parking problem. We have had more than our share of these frustrating situations due to the trains, fire engines, trucks and car transports. The latter doing a good job of tearing up pur streets that are maintained through our tax dollar. I am not in favor of rezoning from RT-1 to I-1 to expand the existing Cooperativ� Plating Building and/or provide parking for Cooperative Plating. Yours Ve�y Truly, . '/ " `�� (J�v�iv�•.� �J..�.,,.�--a� I � .� � G� . January 3, 1980 � - Current Planning & Zoning Committee � 25 West Fourth Street St. Paul , Minnesota 55102 Dear Sir: Subject: Zoning File No. 8526 Zoning File Name - Rollie Brown Address : 1602-1606 Carroll Avenue (Near S.W. Corner Snelling/Carroll ) Lot 8 & 9, Block 5, College Park Addition. Reason: As a home owner in a residential area, I maintain that we are being discriminated against b,y continued violations of the residential code by the following industrial and business establishments: Norman Chemical Co. Tempel Motors, Inc. Creative Liqhting Nicholson Co. Vickers Gas Station Adeco Mfg. Co. Kline Oldsmobile Lot Local #2047 Cooperative Plating The above mentioned, in some instances, has contributed to our discomfort; noise and dirt pollution and a serious parking problem. We have had more than our share of these frustrating situations due to the trains, fire engines, trucks and car transports. The latter doing a good job of tearing up our Streets that are maintained through our tax dollar. I am not in favor of rezoning from RT-1 to I-1 to expand the existing Cooperative Plating Building and/or provide parking for Cooperative Plating. Yo,urs Very Truly, � � �� '4 _�: :,''. /.r� �r t . � '�' � (1 �� f��/ ,,;; �� . � ; 1 j'� ; ,,; ,�irt� ' � , ��, 4 , . , '. � ��:��'��. January 3, 1980 Current Planning & Zoning Committee 25 West Fourth Street St. Paul . Minnesota 55102 Dedr Sir: Subject: Zoning File �lo. 8526 Zoning File Name - Rollie Brown Address : 1602-1606 Carroll Avenue (Near S.W. Corner Snelling/Carroll ) Lot 8 & 9, Block 5, College Park Addition. Reason: As a home owner in a residential area, I maintain that we are being discriminated against b,y continued violations of the residential Code by the following industrial and business establishments: Norman Chemical Co. Tempel Motors, Inc. Creative Lighting Nicholson Co. Vickers Gas Station Adeco Mfg. Co. Kline Oldsmobile Lot Local #2047 Cooperative Plating The dbove mentioned, in some instances, has contributed to our discomfort; ngise and dirt pollution and a serious parking problem. We have had more than our share of these frustrating situations due to the trains , fire en�ines, trucks and car transports. The latter doing a good job of tearing up oulr streets that are maintained through our tax dollar. I am not in favor of rezoning from RT-1 to I-1 to expand the existing CQOperative Plating Building and/or provide parking for Cooperative Plating. Yours Very Truly, '➢�, , ��'h,� . �� ( � �o o J (.° C�.t.� , � January 3, 1980 Cu�rent Planning & Zoning Committee 25 West Fourth Street S�. Paul , Minnesota 55102 Qear Sir: Subject: Zoning File �lo. 8526 Zoning File Name - Rollie Brown Address : 1602-1606 Carroll Avenue (Near S.W. Corner Snelling/Carroll ) Lot 8 & 9, Block 5, College Park Addition. Reason: As a home owner in a residential area, I maintain that We are being discriminated against b,y continued violations of the residential cpde by the following industrial and business establishments: Norman Chemical Co. Tempel Motors, Inc. Creative Lighting Nicholson Co. Vickers Gas Station Adeco Mfg. Co. Kline Oldsmobile Lot Local #2047 �ooperative Plating The above mentioned, in some instances, has contributed to our discomfort; n0ise and dirt pollution and a serious parking problem. We have had more than our share of these frustrating situations due to the trains, fire engines, trucks and car transports. The latter doinq a good job of tearing up our Streets that are maintained through our tax dollar. I am not in favor of rezoning from RT-1 to I-1 to expand the existing Cooperative Plating Building and/or provide parking for Cooperative Plating. YourS Ve y Truly� . � • s January 3, 1980 Current Planning & Zoning Committee 25 West Fourth Street St. Paul . Minnesota 55102 Dear Sir: Subject: Zoning File No. 8526 Zoning File Name - Rollie Brown Address : 1602-1606 Carroll Avenue (Near S.W. Corner Snelling/Carroll ) Lot 8 & 9, Block 5, College Park Addition. Reason: As a home owner in a residential area, I maintain that We are being discriminated against by continued violations of the residential Code by the following industrial and business establishments: Norman Chemical Co. Tempel Motors, Inc. Creative Liqhting Nicholson Co. Vickers Gas Station Adeco Mfg. Co. Kline Oldsmobile Lot Local #2047 Cooperative Plating The above mentioned, in some instances, has contributed to our discomfort; noise and dirt pollution and a serious parking problem. We have had more than our share of these frustrating s�tua io ue to the trains, fire engines, trucks and car transports, The latter doing a good job of tearing up our streets that are maintained through our tax dollar. I dm not in favor of rezoning from RT-1 to I-1 to expand the existing Co�perative Plating Building and/or provide parking for Cooperative Plating. Yqurs Very Truly. �,� , �.0"r, b. ��.,�,n�w,..� - l�a S C�.u,�-t.¢. Q+�-�- . �� .�,�.C� �- � 0..��. t¢�.,.� �.w �-�+.c.�,. � �.w y�,.o df. ��.�,_. � � ol 5�- � he�-�-• w-A,�.e :�-�� e.��.� ,Q�-�- ��- c�-�. .t�i.�- ��c.� h-a.t�.e� � ,�,1,bS,-,t�✓ �.,) V�.�..r._ Cl.�-�.un . �,..el.n� �a,tJC. �°�-�-- �-�-- �`��.c"1 � /7��..� !J f� �p�o c�.. �-o-✓n.�- S•�"a'"d,.�d� ,.�. �;.. a�.a..w- �,�..:�_�d� �d�- �-a-�-� °�- a-�- °�^d�. U • , `�j,�5t5 ;to NF1..ocl.e.�a�.� ��-cr,�w �l.e.e,¢.Q,� � �� /l��o-....�-,.d ;�,C.a- c�.t.�.� � ,2��+.� -t^�oCc�y � � 0 0 �d pCt,41a...L .c.,su.t� �u'�,�C'�✓t' � 5-�-�t�j �°�' 1.��-c.r �a-�--<-- `�v� :i+� . � � � � � (J �J�,� - �� ..�.�... January 3, 1980 Current Planning & Zoning Committee 25 West Fourth Street St. Paul , Minnesota 55102 Dear Sir: Subject: Zoning File PJo. 8526 Zoning File Name - Rollie Brown Address : 1602-1606 Carroll Avenue (Near S.W. Corner Snelling/Carroll ) Lot 8 & 9, Block 5, College Park Addition. Reason: As a home owner in a residential area, I maintain that we are being discriminated against b,y continued violations of the residential Code by the following industrial and business establishments: Norman Chemical .Co. Tempel Motors, Inc. Creative Lighting Nicholson Co. Yickers Gas Station Adeco Mfg. Co. Kline Oldsmobile Lot Local #2047 Cooperative Plating The above mentioned� in some instances, has contributed to our discomfort; noise and dirt pollution and a serious parking problem. We have had more than our share of these frustrating situations due to the trains, fire engines, trucks and car transports. The latter doing a good �ob of tearing up our streets that are maintained through our tax dollar. � I �m not in favor of rezoning from RT-1 to I-1 to expand the existing Cqqperative Plating Building and/or provide parking for Cooperative Plating. Yo�rs V�ry Truly, C �� d� � � ��- . . , - . ��,�� January 3, 1980 Cu�^rent Planning & Zoning Committee 25 West Fourth Street St. Paul , Minnesota 55102 Dear Sir: Subject: Zoning File �lo. 8526 Zoning File Name - Rollie Brown Address : 1602-1606 Carroll Avenue (Near S.W. Corner Snelling/Carroll ) Lot 8 & 9, Block 5, College Park Addition. Reason: As a home owner in a residential area, I maintain that we �re being discriminated against b,y continued violations of the residential code by the following industrial and business establishments : Norman Chemical Co. Tempel Motors, Inc. Creative Lighting Nicholson Co. Vickers Gas Station Adeco Mfg. Co. Kline Oldsmobile Lot Local �2047 Cooperative Plating The above mentioned, in some instances, has contributed to our discomfort; noise dnd dirt pollution and a serious parking problem. We have had more than our share of these frustrating situations due to the trains , fire engines, trucks and car transports. The latter doing a good job of tearing up our Streets that are maintained through our tax dollar. I am not in favor of rezoning from RT-1 to I-1 to expand the existing Cooperative Plating Building and/or provide parking for Cooperative Plating. Yours Very Truly, ��, , ��a�,,� . �� l ��, J l�01 �°Q C��,�t , � . � January 3� 1980 Current Planning & Zoning Committee 25 West Fourth Street St, Paul . Minnesota 55102 ,..4,y�.. . _ . . January 3, �ggp Current Planning & Zoning Committee 25 West Fourth Street St. Paul , Minnesota 55102 Dear Sir: Subject: Zoning File No. 8526 Zoning File Name - Rollie Brown Address : 1602-1606 Carroll Avenue (Near S.W. Corner Snelling/Carroll ) Lot 8 & 9, 61ock 5, College Park Addition. Reason: As a home owner in a residential area, I maintain that we are being discriminated against b,y continued violations of the residential code by the following industrial and business establishments : Norman Chemical .Co. Tempel Motors, Inc. Creative Lighting Nicholson Co. Uickers Gas Station Adeco Mfg. Co. Kline Oldsmobile Lot Local #2047 Caoperative Plating The above mentioned, in some instances, has contributed to our discomfort• noise and dirt pollution and a serious parkin than our share of these frustrating situations duebtomthewtrains,hfi�re�re� engines, trucks and car transports. The latter doing a good �ob of tearin up our streets that are maintained through our tax dollar. 9 I �m not in favor of rezoning from RT-1 to I-1 to expand the existin Gooperative Plating Building and/or provide parking for Coo erati 9 P ve Plat�ng. Yours Very Truly, � � �� c � !� �� — . , , � . • , ` \ ;� �� January 3, 1980 �G �'�' �\, �, �^; t `� �� ,,,� ,�o �a� �� . ,;.� �t,�'�`�J`�MG�e`'°�+ Current Planning & Zoning Committee .�\�tp`a 25 West Fourth Street S�. Paul . Minnesota 55102 f)ear Sir: Subject: Zoning File No. 8526 Zoning File Name - Rollie Brown Address : 1602-1606 Carroll Avenue (Near S.W. Corner Snelling/Carroll ) � Lot 8 & 9, Block 5, College Park Addition. Reason: As a home owner in a residential area, I maintain that WQ ,�re being discriminated against b,y continued violations of the residential Gpde by the following industrial and business establishments: Norman Chemical Co. Tempel Motors, Inc. Creative Liqhting Nicholson Co. .� Vickers Gas Station Adeco Mfg. Co. Kline Oldsmobile Lot Local #2047 Cooperative Plating The above mentioned, in some instances, has contributed to our discomfort; noise and dirt pollution and a serious parking problem. We have had r�ore than pur share of these frustrating situations due to the trains, fire �ngines, trucks and car transports. The latter doing a good �ob af tearing u� our streets that are maintained through our tax dollar. � am not in favor of rezoning from RT-1 to I-1 to expand the existing Gooperd�tiVe Plating Building and/or provide parking for Cooperative Plating. Yours Very Truly, ��,r�`: ��-1i�� — �� L= �Z�/.��/ � . I�Q Gpt+�DRD�4 � , January 3, 1980 Current Planning & Zoning Committee 25 West Fourth Street St. Paul , Minnesota 55102 Dear Sir: Subject: Zoning File No. 8526 Zoning File Name - Rollie Brown Address : 1602-1606 Carroll Avenue (Near S.W. Corner Snelling/Carroll ) Lot 8 & 9, Block 5, College Park Addition. Reason: As a home owner in a residential area, I maintain that we are being discriminated against b,y continued violations of the residential Code by th� following industrial and business establishments: Norman Chemical Co. Tempel Motors� Inc. Creative Lighting Nicholson Co. Vickers Gas Station Adeco Mfg. Co. Kline Oldsmobile Lot Local #2047 Cooperative Plating The above mentioned, in some instances, has contributed to our discomfort; noise and dirt pollution and a serious parking problem. We have had more than our share of these frustrating situations due to the trains, fire Qngines, trucks and car transports. The latter doing a good job of tearing up our streets that are maintained through our tax dollar. I dm not in favor of rezoning from RT-1 to I-1 to expand the existing C�pperatiVe Plating Building and/or provide parking for Cooperative Plating. YpurS Very Truly� � � �6/L4�'�G�1 f.`"i1.. r�� d- (?i - l -' � � 1 ��'.�t.<<;�. �.�-C:�_ . � L', y, ' January 3, 1980 Current Planning & Zoning Committee 25 West Fourth Street St. Paul , Minnesota 55102 Dedr Sir: Subject: Zoning File �Jo. 8526 Zoning File Name - Rollie Brown Address : 1602-1606 Carroll Avenue (Near S.W. Corner Snelling/Carroll ) Lot 8 & 9, Block 5, College Park Addition. Reason: As a home owner in a residential area, I maintain that WQ dre being discriminated against b,y continued violations of the residential COde by the following industrial and business establishments: Norman Chemical Co. Tempel Motors, Inc. Creative Liqhting Nicholson Co. Vickers Gas Station Adeco Mfg. Co. Kline Oldsmobile Lot Local #2047 Cooperative Plating The above mentioned, in some instances. has contributed to our discomfort; nGise and dirt pallution and a serious parking problem. We have had more thdn our share of these frustrating situations due to the trains , fire �n�ines, trucks and car transports, The latter doing a good job of tearing up our str�ets that are maintained through our tax dollar. I am not in favor of rezoning from RT-1 to I-1 to expand the existing Cppperative Plating Building and/or provide parking for Cooperative Plating. Yqyrs Very Truly. -�,- . � � . .��-�-�' � � / � �.�.-�-�-,�-,,`.�.(.� ' ..° �dnuary 3, 1980 Current Planning & Zoning Committee 25 West Fourth Street S�. Pdul , Minnesota 55102 R�ar Sir: Subject: Zoning File Mo. 8526 Zoning File Name - Rollie Brown Address : 1602-1606 Carroll Avenue (Near S.W. Corner Snelling/Carroll ) Lot 8 & 9, Block 5, College Park Addition. Reason: As a home owner in a residential area, I maintain that we ,�re being discriminated against by continued violations of the residential +COde by the following industrial and business establishments: Norman Chemical Co. Tempel Motors, Inc. Creative Liqhting Nicholson Co. ; Vickers Gas Station Adeco Mfg. Co. Kline 4ldsmobile Lot Local #2047 Coqperative Plating Th� �bav� mentioned, in some instances, has contributed to our discomfort; noi�� nd dirt pollution and a serious parking problem. We have had more � th,�rt our share of these frustrating situations due to the trains, fire en��nes, trucks and car transports. The latter doing a good job of tearing � 1��► p4�r s�r�ets that are maintained through our tax dollar. , I ,�►� not in favor of rezoning from RT-1 to I-1 to expand the existing Cpp�erative Plating Building and/or provide parking for Cooperative Plating. Yq�r� Very Truly, , � �I , /�Zrv / �+ � � � -� � January 3, 1980 Current Planning & Zoning Committee 25 West Fourth Street St. Paul , Minnesota 55102 De�r Sir: Subject: Zoning File Plo. 8526 Zoning File Name - Rollie Brown Address : 1602-1606 Carroll Avenue (Near S.W. Corner Snelling/Carroll ) Lot 8 & 9, Block 5, College Park Addition. Reason: As a home owner in a residential area, I maintain that W� �re being discriminated against b,y continued violations of the residential cOdB by the following industrial and business establishments : Norman Chemical Co. Tempel Motors. Inc. Creative Lighting Nicholson Co. Vickers Gas Station Adeco Mfg. Co. Kline Oldsmobile Lot Local #2047 Cooperative Plating The abay� mentioned, in some instances. has contributed to our discomfort; noise and dirt pollution and a serious parking problem. We have had more than our share of these frustrating situations due to the trains, fire engin�s, trucks and car transports. The latter doing a good job of tearing up Our Streets that are maintained through our tax dollar. I �m not in favor of rezoning from RT-1 to I-1 to expand the existing CoOper�tive Plating Building and/or provide parking for Cooperative Plating. Yours Very Truly. .� �t 1 !�-C�� .-r ;: �- c-� /6� � �' ' _.t��i:.'�-Cf�_ _ / J ` �, � ,� , .�' `�'t� �°°� t{ ' _ Gzd f ��`��v�„ ' ,� ��'��,,. adnUary 3, 1980 � `' � �` � � �� Y � , a�� , � �`NG �,�. ��'� �'�"n� Gur'rent Pldnning & Zoning Committee ;\�,�pa��' Y5 West Fourth Street St. Paul . Minnesota 55102 � t�ar Sir: Subject: Zoning File No. 8526 � Zoning File Name - Rollie Brown �f ' � : " � Address: 1602-1606 Carroll Avenue (Near S.W. ..�, a `�� J��;��;� � � Corner Snel l ing/Carrol l ) � '� Lot 8 & 9, Block 5, College Park �� " Addition. ' if' ,: Reason: As a home owner in a residential area, I maintain that 1�� are b�ing discriminated against by continued violations of the residential k k .��de b,� the fallowing industrial and business establishments: .. �e,�'y:-_. . i`;`'}, Norman Chemical Co. Tempel Motors, Inc. .= k �� Creative Lighting Nicholson Co. ..�. .� Vickers Gas Station Adeco Mfg. Co. '" Kline Oldsmobile Lot Local #2047 . Cooperative Plating �h� �bove tnentioned, in some instances, has contributed to our discomfort; noise and dirt pollution and a serious parking problem. We have had more � , �b�1 our sh�are of these frustrating situations due to the trains, fire �,@r��in�s, t�'ucks and car transports. The latter doing a good job of tearing a .4�p��our s�r��ts that are maintained through our tax dollar. «;.. ,�,.� � not 1n fdvor of rezoning from RT-1 to I-1 to expand the existing � `�q��ra�iy� Plating Building and/or provide parking fior Cooperativs Pla�ing. � � ° <Yg�irs Very Truly� i { � �� l,��-�.��-�� G - �- .� �3��,, Z�.��/ ��V. ... � �� , ;.}r ; . • .,•� �� •A'� �'. g� � 7�� `� t p , ' . �''� '�. a.�� . . . � '� � },{ �g �� K `� °t� ,.� ��, ;I . - � . �ff. �y �$.y��y u� . . � � �: �r �I : . . i�'. � �� ', . p�a� y ��'' .. Y;_ . F„` t✓' �.y� ° ' . �i �x � k, � ' `''' �_; , �,y:,: r ; ' ; f ,' xu� ,�',?!' � � , � � �c..� ,�� ...� � ' , February 19, 1g80 � � '�' F11.ED � ;, �'�E� [��: 1;� 1 G :,' "' j � � f� i F� � , i Cit�T Council ct7Y CLE'RK's CFFICE � 347 City Hall �� '�Ui, t�ti��W. � i ;': St. Pau i,�:innesota 102 ,� , 55 r � i Dea_� P�iembers, � j' .�s a citizen and a t�,xpayer, I feel I have the right to �rro- ' ' tect the value of my property, my health and my welfa-re. ;, � ; � � '�' Cooperative Platin� is very definitely a threat to all of i �� the above-mentioned. The buildin� is alrea�y too close to �. I our home. If Coopera�ive Platin.� builds on Ca�rr_o1l�venue, ; ' the thrzat to residentiGl prop�;rty value, health and �vel�'are i ' ' will be r�agnified, heapin� misery and fright upon the residents. ': � �!' Cooperative Platin�; should never have been allovred to build on ` I Igleh�,�^t Avenue in the first place, a.nd age-old residents here , I� do not recall having any choice in the matter. Tne nei�hbors i �' do not w�.n.t Cooperative Platin� to remain because tney have {� �!; be�;n c�.reless about pollution and trie buildin� is terribly � � "j u��attractive. Anyone v�ho thinks that sueh a building could i ! �'; enhG.n.ce the nei;hborhood is thinkin� ag��.inst the wind. � I In the event that Coo�erative Platin� �ov�s to Blaine, which I _ � doubt very much, he can still put 30 men to �vork - then someone I �' ` else v�rill purchase the existing building �.n,t� put 60 - 70 more � men to work. �i: f � If industry forces Merriam Park residents to move, then all f ' the businesses in the Tv:errid,m Park and Tv7idway are�,s will suffer. � ; ; �'� It stands to reason; why r�a.�>e several families miserable when � .1 ;� nothin� �reat i:� being accomplished?. I � � Very Truly Yours, �` � ;�,. i' ' , t� ��L+�o. �O ; I ; . �i � (v 6� (.., ��C . , _ � �'; ,, I , ; , t ''li ,,; �, ilI i , ;�, � ��f i !t� � , ; i ::� �j�!; , I i. � � iI ' �:. . :�. ... ��: '� . . 1, ii� I February 1 , 1980 '�. � {�L�.�,4�"� . ��t'p � �"` � � City Council ��"� �� R om 347 Cit Hall o y St. Paul , Minnesota 55102 Subject: Zoning File No. 8526 Zoning File Name - Rollie Brown � ' Address: 1602-1606 Carroll Avenue Lot 8 & 9, Block 5, College Park Addition Dear Members: �I Ora behalf of many neighbors who are greatly opposed to rezoning Lots 8 & 9, Block 5, I , College Park Addition from RT-1 district to I-1 district, I would like to present '� t4 you two valid reasons why Cooperative Plating should not be allowed to erect an additional building on the site of 1602-1606 Carroll Avenue. First, new young families have started to move into this block of old established , residents. They feel fortunate to have found a good home to buy th�t was within their means - the same way we felt some twenty odd years ago when we bought our ' house on Carroll Avenue. Not too far down the road, more young people will be ' occupying several of these homes, which, including Mr. Rollie Brown's property, are sound, well-kept livable homes. Houses are now at a premium. We need homes. Secondly, from past experience with other business places in this district, we ' neighbors have combated harmful environmental and health hazard problems. There are six widows, five in this block alone, who are very distressed over the proposed rezoning. They feel more secure living in a residential neighborhood. Three of these widows are in the eiqhties. Neighbors, who use the same alley as Cooperative Plating, have reported to me some of the problems they have had with Cooperative Plating: � ' 1 . Illegal parking in the alley along the side of Cooperative Plating, making it ' extremely difficult to get in or out of their garages. One neighbor accidently , backed into one Cooperative Plating employee's car. He knew he was illegally parked, but he told the woman that it was okay because the car was old anyway. 2. Waste water running out of a spout at the top of Cooperative Plating constantly , keeping the alley wet. In the winter, the water freezes in the alley, building ', up in the low spots to one and a half to two feet thick with ice. This build- , up of ice cause deep ruts which makes it impossible to use the alley. When the ice sealed off one neighbor's garage doors, the police were called. It was at this time the police noticed the seriousness of the problem. ' i ! i i ' The �clice sternly w�..rne� Coo�erative Platin� about the condi- �'� ' , tion of th�: alley and that th�y ��rere �o allovr ten feet access � for th� fire en�;ines. To this day they are in. violation. ,;; , ��„ '!' 3 ,' Cooper�.tive Platin� �.lso put some cherr�ical on the flat roof of ; ;� said building to melt the snovr. It v�as a foamy type substG.nce � , th�,t oozed out a spout at thu top of the building, ran down the � , ,, side cf the building, forrninz�; d deep rut vrhich ran about 5G - 75 ' feet down to th� T-alley. Some titnes this substc:.nce w�s �oeach � ' color, other ti�aes green.. The city �va.s c�:lled by one of the � � nei�hbors. The city took i�rompt eff�ctiv� action. � 4� .�� nei�hbor said she planted a �;arden at thL rear of her back z �rd - �he whol� ��arden died due to sor�.e white pawc�er-li�e sub- J � �II st�.nce which apparently had blovan c�ff th� to�; of tne cher�ically- i' lac:ened rocf of Coo�erative Plating. This same substance could I' ' ; be responsible fcr speckled, h�,rd-to-clean windows which were �' reported to nze b;yr neighbors. � i; 5 ,. .y previous o�vner attributed th� dea.th of her do� to the che:�iici ;; �il�= treated water t'r�at flo��ved from the roof of Cooperative Plat- ! in�. 6. Childr�n have been seen splashir��; arld running barefoot through r"s , this "river" of che:,:ically treated w�,ter durin;; w�.rm we�ther. i 7�. Cooperative Pl�,ting works 24-hcurs a day, five days �. v�eek. �;; '; During thE daf we have to contend with the rumblin;�, noisy trucks. ' � - The darkness of ni�ht, which is the restful climax of a bus;� day, ;; is shatt�red by glwrin� bri�;ht li�hts boltin� from several l�.r�;e shadeless windows. r I� � � ��,; ' �. Cooperative Pla�ing buildin�, drith its gray cement block exterior, � leaves muc� to be desired. Its drab appea•rance is condusive to .,��, '"' obscene vrords squirted out of musturd bottles by teenagers leaving ,, the �ed Barn restaurant on C�rroll and Sne�lin� .�venues, �which h�.s t ; been the case Nvi�L� the Union buildin� at 1598 Carroll. The Union ` �.1 o has had several break-ins - resultin � in the owner �i.avin to �, s s g ; ", cement up a rear window by which the illegal entries were made. ' � klsa, teena�ers would carry their food from Red B�.m and sit along the foundation of the Union, leavin;� their mess of paper cups, nap- '� � �I� kins, straws, etc. behind. } - �; � � � I�uis is a residential district ai�d we neighbors war�.t to keep it this ! ` W�y. In �.ddition to the support of approximately sixteen cr seventeen '� n�i�hbors, ��e have the backing of Merriam P�,rk Comr.iunity Center and the ; ; N�eighborhood Housing Service. �id T�iis letter is in lieu of the fact that P�Ir. Rollie Brown has acquired ! 'a,�. �ttorney, postponed the ori�inal meetin�; on Jar�.uary 10 to February ! 7 � and that he has made a personal visit at the City Council Chambers b;�„�tween these above-mentioned dates, rvhich we, as a �roup, could not do. � ,i; � Vnery Truly Yours, �I:! � ;,' �?Z-t.� ��.... �t--� ( /.� ��J � ' <,�c/ `�� , � i �I; / C'��-�.�-�-�� CC-:�� iu-=� ' I i� ' ' IAi ��.- f " �i .J_� � _� / � _ 1 .. . .► , � . ♦ ' ./.�/ .�► ��J ., .i , i � � � � ► �� ► i ' � � ,�/.►�,! .`J L�. � � / l � � I � � _ i r � i � � i � � � � � � � / f �l.�� .�� _ �� ..� . . _ �!�l .�� .�1. �� .�i�. �. �� ,/ � ! _ i . ._ . '1 .i ► !J ► r I , � � � . ; � � ` � / r `� i , � � �� . i ._ % i�� 1r ./_ ► � / ,I � .i I i � I , � I l � / �I .I. . �' � . s� � � r /�� . � / � � / ' ' ./. J I .►�� I � � ,I, I�t _ ��I � i i �.!l � ; - _ ' - � - � �� l�. , � •!.�. � . . �. ! � � . � i � - ��/1 ;J . ; 1� ��'�� , � /�� I � � . �� i �� . � f t I , l �� r' � , ' ' � .. ! �� ► ,.� 1 ► /� �, , .� .� � _� / . � .i : - �� ,� • ' � � �► � O� ' I iI � � I� �I �t � � � . i � ,�J .► �1 •.� . � . , _ � � f� � o , i i� �_. � � � I % f .�►J ..��.�..� . 1� I ��► I .. ii. � � 1. .�� . ��. .u►. ..� � � � / Ju .� � _. _..» _� ,.�,..r � . ! 1 . , �..� . • • � r �i / � , . �� • , �, i _ . ► � � � I !.�. _� .r�� ! .�.� /�� _. i .� t �_�J�� .�. ' ' � . �� , � / � ' � / , �.1� .� _�� / ll. �J .' � ► �� . .'�► I �' . � / � .I�./_l �� L ► � � �� - J1. I . ./. �/ � � � � / � / i � '' �/• �/__ �� .�. • ' I.,J►.�` ��,� . . ..r�► _ �►� �_�.�./ ' 1 i � I� 1�1 i■ �/.'��1 �.i_�I_� ��I. / .� �11�� . �, ..�.l�l� /r/ I11� �� / � � � � / I1. �1 �'1 .��. � � ► UI � - -�. ��i � 1 � �;�. ... �� . . _- ..�.�� - � � j .r,. �..' .► . ._<_ �� _; �. _ �r�,�/.i� �rl• � � /. ��.►�► �J' ,!,_ L� �� ;, 1. l�'� /L. .� ./��. ( � /� � t ` � � � �.II .I� I�. ,�1�i:� � , _ � �LJ � � __�j>I ri, � • / ' _ `�� /� �` _I� '�1 � . _i _ I, �( �./ I. ��/ ./t/, �.�'L� " - +. . / 1 .��1 �' ✓/�'�� !� �, .11 I I � / / � • . •� � L�. _.� � .► . � .� �r �.��/. ..� I� . _ ` � � � I / � �:.�1�1_ . 9 . . . .� � �► . � � .:.1 �,.:1�► .' 1 � . , � j ' � .I �`� . � - �i � � � � � . ��:�/��.. �:� . ?��;,t �. �;; Y ;�:� , ., ', a k ��.> � �i '�,� � e�� Y �;_ ,a. �'� � ' � ,aG'� ''� r � .� i -�k�;�� r Y ;�"8� � r. . �- �� r' 3.. �'` ,�y ��' — .4Pfa�� ` :Y�.ou{ � q� � . ._ . ':�: . ��' � ��R. �,�*=�`'� x�Q �.::��r.:''.. �' / q•.�.. i � > �;T� '� �y�..�}� �� 1Y , . 4FY �f1� i Y{.�'t� '� ` �J hKr��'�:.. � y��r�'\ ' �Vqr� � �2'�w`� if'�'�,�, ��.,�' ' 1�,.: iCL;. 3<,�(�,;s � �� , , t �j�:��: '$�� i. II � - A � r- '_l�e ao�tf► � ; ( �� .` Tlre Cp has 8�tec1: �Y �9 A � r� ��r;p..,. PosbY! � �� ,1;'��:..�� I� � ' � ,rj ��s„ �)� ,� 1,_�i h_. �'8. . .>! .Mk L4'�__-' ��f �� F�a � �a�+a.'tl,.' !.. STACKER & RAVICH ATTORNEYS AT LAW 1250 NORTHERN FEDERAL BUILDING CAPITAL CENTRE PLAZA ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA 55102 TELEPHONE <612� 222-1761 RALPH STACKER PAUL N.RAVICH STUART RADSOM M I N N EAPO LI S HOWARDG.STACKER January 9 � 190� JOEL C-MAURER 1500 MIDWEST PLAZA BUILDING ROBERTJ.TANSEY,JR. MINNEAPOLIS, MN 55402 STEVEN M. RUBIN GLENN R.AYRES TELEPHONE C612)330-3000 JAMES D.BATES WILLIAM E.DORIGAN DAVID L.BLACK LYMAN P. O.JOHNSON DAVID E.KIRKMAN MAX A.STACKER (1900-1971) OFCOUNSEL FRED SILVERSTEIN Mr. Albert Olson City Clerk Room 318 Ramsey County Courthouse St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 Re: Raleigh Brown - Petition for Rezoning Dear Mr. Olson: This is to confirm that our client, Mr. Rosenblum will pay the cost of mailing new notices in connection with the hearing on the petition for rezoning in the above-referenced matter and that we have notified the "opposition" that the hearing scheduled for January 10 has been continued until February 7, l�$0. Yours tri�ly, � �� t R. J� Tanse��, Jr. RJT:ljb cc. Mr. Victor Rosenblum � �� CI�TY OF SAINT PAUL � ,"T. o:°-�. � =��• �»* '-�"'; OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK � ��e :� . � %� IIi11111L .E . '+ " ��'L'' �< BUREAU Of RECORDS , , _ ,' �... 386 City Hall,Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102 J M+mn�„�...°''``_ . � . 612-298-4231 GEORCE LA7IMER !N^YOR January 8, 1980 N'.r. Bernard Carlson Director, Finance & Ma.nagement Services Room 113, City x�l� St. Paul, Minnesota Dea.r Sir: • , The �ity Cour_cil adopted a r�otion today concurring in the request ' of the attorney for petitioner and reschedulino from Janu2sy lOth, 19�0, to �ebruary 7, 1980, a public hearing to consider the ge�itio*� of Rollie Brown to rezone property at 1602-1h0o Carroll Avenue. (x2355) w'ill you please send notices to property owners advisin� then of the rescheduled hea_ring on February 7tn. Very truly yours, Rose Mix City t;lerk ABO:la cc: � Plannin� Staff, Zoning Section �O - ��"°'^�� C t�TY O F SA l NT PA U L =;:��T, 0,�,,, -• =''�• OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK >„ ,; :e .; . _� uu�rum ,; � �+ "" �p1 �� BUREAU OF RECORDS ,,. _ �°�� ••• 386 Cit Hail,Saint Paul,Minnesoia 55102 �"+mm�.....e�'�``` Y �� `'� 612-298-4231 GEORGE L/1TIMER , F„�� * �?,� MAYOR � � � � January 8, 1980 Mr. Bernard Carlson Director, Finance & Ma.nagement Services Room 113, City Hall St. Paul, Minnesota Dea.r Sir: The City Council adopted a r�otion today concurring in the request of the attorney for petitioner and rescheduling from January lOth, 19�, to February 7, 1980, a public hearing to consider the petition of Rollie Brown to rezone �roperty at 1602-160o Carroll Avenue. (x2365) Will you please send notices to property owners advising them of the rescheduled hearing on February 7th. � Very truly yours, Rose Mix Cit;,� Clerk ABO:la cc:J Planninj Staff, Zoning Section �O . . � � . . � . . � \' . . . . , . . . . ._� � 1 . .. . . ' ' . . .. . . ' . 3 ' . . � � A . �� . . �� .. , . .. . ' .. . ,� � � , � �'�� . , . �� — , � � , � �� ,� ; , . a � -- , , ; . , . � � � � � - , . ; - . , , - � - _ , \ . _ y, y � _ � - .� , ; � �ee�u.r,► 8, 1980 � �� _ � . �. ` Y ;rf ! , , �. _ lte.• H�ard C�►Tlaew ' ' ` ' ', � Dd�r�ctor, �,livae�w Ar lYm�trot 8�svia�s ' , � 1 ; Roca� 113, Cl#.,y Hall ', �', � SL. Paul� l�tl.on�so�a , � . �. .� •/ . . , � � �. }�rtt' $i!"i' , ',� T�e CiLy Ooa►r�eail adaptsd a rwtion �o�la�y e�o�urrtng:3�i �►t r�qw�t � n ; � of � s�Et�arne� !or peLitioa�r a;o�d , tr�e Ja�nu�ry lO�Yh, � . � �� , 19eo,-to l�ruar3► T, 19eo,. � �►u� �"'�8r �;o, 000sid�r tb. , � _ . p�t�iiion of koL'�.�e Braw�t. �o r� prq�rt�► at 1602-�606: Gsrroll• # Av�sao�ts. . (7t2�s�: Mil1 yc�u pl��tsa �e�atd �of.iQea to �p,��perty o�ners - " edvisias 'h.L� o� tlw rtt�dnlsd 3rarit�,B oes 1tib�t�irY T�. � � - - ¢ , - � � , ' Ver'Y ��Y �'�?'+�� , : � - � _ , .. r F' . .. � ' . � _�f-�'�� . . .. ' . � .. � • , � C1,ta► Cl�r'k , �, . , � � . ��- � � � �, � ` ,` �� , � � : . � - . 1 , . ' � co s "PLamiq;� Btai`l, Zooip6 8�atic� , _ , i $ � _ � � F. , � r : , 4 � . . � . , . . . .�. _ . ' ' � . . . � . . � . . 1 . . . . . ., � . � � . � ' - . . ' � ' . . 4' . � . . . . ' . � ' . � �. . . � i - .. �. '' .. . .. . � . . . . . . , � , . " ' . . ' . � i . ` .. \. . . � 'R� . � � � - . . . � ... , . . . . . . � � . . . ' � � , i � . . . � .. � .. . . � .. ' . . � , � • � �'� :1 . � � . . . . . ' .. . � � • . . . � - .. . ' . .. . . . . , .. . . ' . . ' � ,. � � -. '.. J . . . . " . . . � . . . �,�i 7�. . . � . . 1 . . . . � ' . . . . '� � � � . � ' . � . l � . . . _ � . . . . .� .. . . . . .. .. � � . . ' .. ' . . . ' � / . � . , . . .. . . . � � .,. . 4 � . . .. r. � . ' : � . . . . . . � �1.� � � . � . . . � ' . . . . . . . . . . . l . ' ��. . . µ. . � _ . . �. . . ' � . � . . �. . . � � � . . . . . � , . . ; � : . . . . . . . .. . . . . , .. � _ � . � . � ` :� � . . I, ., � . . . � . � . . . . . . . . ��.:� I. � . � .� .. . � . . . � � � . .. �. . �. . . . . � , . '. , . . . . ;� . STACKER & RAVICH ATTORNEYS AT LAW 1250 NORTHERIY FEDERAL 6UILDING `;' -} CAPITAL CENTRE PLAZA ST. PAUI., MINNESOTA 55102 TELEPHONE C612) 222-1761 RALPH STACKER PAUL H.RAVICH STUART RADSOM p MINNEAPOLIS HOWARD G.STACKER January 3� l�pQ JOEL C-MAURER 1500 MIDWEST PLAZA BUILDING ROBERTJ.TANSEY,JR. MINNEAPOLIS, MN 55402 � STEVEN M.RUBIN TELEPHONE<6�2)330-3000 GLENN R.AYRES � JAMES D.BATES � WILLIAM E.DORIGAN DAVID L.BLACK LYMAN P. Q.JOHNSON DAVID E.KIRKMAN MAX A.STACKER (1900-1971) OF COUNSEL . FRED SILVERSTEIN � Mr. Albert Olson City Clerk Ramsey County Courthouse -- St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 Re: Raleigh Brown - Petition for Rezoning Dear Mr. Olson: This is to confirm our conversation of today. As I mentioned, I was contacted today to represent Mr. Victor Rosenblum in connection with Mr. Raleigh Brown' s petition to rezone certain property in the City of St. Paul near the corner of Carroll Avenue and Snelling. Mr. Rosenblum has an option to purchase Mr. Brown' s property if the property can be rezoned. Mr. Rosen- blum wishes to expand his business, Co-operative Plating Company, by erecting a structure on the land which he proposes to purchase from Mr. Brown. I understand the petition is scheduled for hearing before the Council on January 10. I am writing to request that the matter be continued for approximately 30 days to permit out firm to become familiar with the situation. Moreover, I will be out of town both January 8 and January 10 and would be unable to appear on either day on behalf of the petition. I understand from our conversation that you will put my request for a continuance on the Council ' s agenda for Tuesday, January 8. I will ask one of the attorneys from my office to appear on January 8 should the Council have any questions. Yours truly, j � ,�� ..��"fL�?Cr- �. • ;------�, Z� '-� �-- R. J. Tansey, Jr. RJT:ljb � � . ' � � � _ ' , � i � - � � . ' . '� . , .. .. ' . . . . . � ' . � . ' � .i.. . . f ' d . , . ' . . . . . . � � . . �-. . . •. ,. . . . } . �.� � � � . . , . •. + . . � � , � .' � . . • �. . t ' � - ' . .. . � . � . � . . . ' . . - . . . •. i � . _ . , e , ' , , � - . / F:. . . . . � � . � , . . . . _ .. . / . I.. � ., i , � � ' � �- � . . . � . . � � . . s . . � . ' . . , . . � . . � . i � . .. � � , � . . .. ,.�. . . . � � . . . - �. � i � . � � . . ' . . . . � -.. � �I�:. � �. � . .. . . � ' � . ,� . . . �. .� . . . .. k�� " ' ' . � � � . . . � . ' . . �� - , " . � � • '�. , . . � - . .. .. , . , . � . . . . . . � . . � , . _ . � � � . . \ . . .. ., . . , ' . � .. . . . �. . . . . � � � . � . � .. . . . ' . � . +�� f. 1� �� ' � .. . . � � . y . . . . . . . . .. � . " . ` . . . .. . - , . . . . / . . _ � � . � .. � , . .' � . ' � Pl�o�ni� 8tstf, Ztuting- Sa�etion - , '; l�.th lrl,00r j Cit�r �13. At�wz ` ` � � �. Pr►t�il, Iin. . - . - ; - � ` D�ar Sirsa ' ' ' � , _ , � t Tht City �o'upcsil tioder�► laid ov�r tor L�c► `Meeks wttil ��rdary. 21�It, ` ± 1980� a hesriag on i� p�fii^Eian pt Ro111t�-H�vWU tc� �s� � HT*1. � _ ` t.o '2-1 propertY locat�d` �t 16o2-1ba6 +C�srrol2, al�a Lot. 8 arrd 9, . . � 81oQic g, Coll�ge I�t /Wdit�oar, xit.h �e m�d�t.�sding,#1�►t:,�artiss'� � R ' i � iqv�oi�d �i�ould aret duriag th� 3nt.�rir'p�riod �r�pQ �his: ' , propo�e►1. � � � Y . � , , ' ' �,ti� . ,.,.,-.-; , , � , i " 'Vsi'Y �Y 3!"onra) . �--, ; , . . : . � j ' � �� , ' . � . . � / . . . . I . � - ' � . . . ' . . . . ' . � . - � , _ . . . . .. . i'PJI�` . � .. . l-�-��; - . . . ; . . . . . ' . . 1 . . . � . ' � . . • ��, . . . . . . ' . �.��f_�I� ��. . � . . ��r . . .. . ` . ' ,- � ,. .. . ! . ` , .. � ' � �' �� ' � � F. . , h . . . , J . .. . . . ' � � . . . . . . . � . , .. '. �. i . ,f.... . � t . . �i�� . . � ' . ,. � . . . . . . . . . . . ' .. �I;. . , . . . _ , . . . . � . . . � . �, . . � - � , .. ' � � � . � � . � , . � . r . . ; . , ` f , . , . .: � . � �. � . ; - , - �I - ' ` . � k . , ' ` . / : i \ , • �k„ — ' ` ' k . . � ,ti ., _ �E � � � : � � � , � f ' , . - , �" j ' � � . � ! , � , , , � . � . . � _ � � . , � . . � �